Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cellulitis in Obesity: Adverse Outcomes Affected by Increases in Body Mass Index
Cellulitis in Obesity: Adverse Outcomes Affected by Increases in Body Mass Index
net/publication/275667773
CITATIONS READS
7 292
5 authors, including:
Kurt B Angstman
Mayo Clinic - Rochester
87 PUBLICATIONS 597 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Kurt B Angstman on 13 January 2018.
Original Research
Journal of Primary Care & Community Health
Abstract
Purpose: Cellulitis in obese patients is associated with increased rates of treatment failure compared to those with
normal body mass index (BMI); however, patients have not been extensively studied in the outpatient environment or
stratified based on range of obesity and associated risk factors. This study looked at antibiotic dosing and treatment
failure in the obese population from the primary care perspective and accounts for BMI range, weight, comorbid diabetes,
and tobacco use. Methods: This study was a retrospective chart review of 637 adult primary care patients designed to
evaluate rates of treatment failure of outpatient cellulitis among patients of varying BMI. Treatment failure was defined as
(a) hospital admission for intravenous antibiotics, (b) prolonged antibiotic course, or (c) requiring a different antibiotic after
initial course. Results: Adverse outcomes were not statistically significant between normal BMI and those with BMI ≥40
kg/m2. A subset of patients with a BMI ≥50 kg/m2 was noted to have approximately twice the rate of adverse outcomes
as the normal BMI group. While controlling for age, gender, race, diagnosis of diabetes mellitus, and tobacco use, a BMI of
≥50 kg/m2 and a weight ≥120 kg was associated with adverse outcomes with an odds ratio of 2.440 (95% CI, 1.260-4.724;
P = .008) and 2.246 (95% CI, 1.154-4.369; P = .017), respectively. Conclusions: Patients with cellulitis weighing >120kg
or with a BMI ≥50 kg/m2 were at greatest risk for treatment failure in the outpatient setting, even when controlling for
comorbid diabetes and tobacco use. As morbid obesity continues to become more prevalent, it becomes imperative that
primary care physicians have better antibiotic dosing guidelines to account for the physiologic effects of obesity to minimize
the risk of increased morbidity, health care costs, and antibiotic resistance.
Keywords
primary care, diabetes, tobacco use
agents including children, the elderly, and those with renal and race. Clinical data abstracted included height, weight,
and hepatic impairment. However, effectiveness data for BMI, recent tobacco use, comorbid diagnosis of diabetes,
those of higher than normal BMI are not required leading to antibiotic prescribed/ treatment methods used, and dosing.
underrepresentation of the obese population.5 For primary Any cellulitis case in which the patient was directly admit-
care providers, this is of particular concern, as they serve on ted to the hospital for treatment after being initially diag-
the frontline in administering antibiotics for most outpatient nosed was excluded from the analysis, as the focus of the
infections. Without appropriate data and guidelines to direct study was outpatient management of cellulitis. Medical
antibiotic treatment in the growing obese population, inad- records with an obvious error in documentation (usually
equate dosing is likely contributing to treatment failure, BMI) were also screened and removed.
unnecessary escalation to broader spectrum antibiotics, and Much of the data was retrieved using automated queries.
selection of resistant pathogens in obese patients. However, because of limitations of the program, the data
Cellulitis is one of the most common bacterial infections regarding each provider’s method or choice of treatment,
seen in the primary care setting, with an incidence that has including medication type, dose, and duration were manu-
increased from 8.6 million to 14.2 million from 1997 to ally abstracted by a family medicine resident and clinical
2005.6 From a recent retrospective analysis, both morbid research coordinator. The medical charts were also manu-
obesity and inadequate empiric antibiotic therapy were ally reviewed to determine smoking status within the previ-
independent risk factors for treatment failure in hospitalized ous 12 months.
patients with cellulitis (odds ratio 4.10, P = .02; and odds We compared a cohort of patients with BMIs at 40 kg/m2
ratio 9.25, P < .01, respectively).7 However, little is known and higher with a cohort of age-and gender-matched con-
about the relationship between specific BMI categories and trols having BMIs in the range of 18.5 to 25 kg/m2 at the
weight with treatment failure in patients with skin and soft time of their cellulitis diagnosis. The dependent variable
tissue infections. There is a need for more BMI-specific rec- was treatment failure as defined by (a) hospital admission
ommendations regarding antimicrobial dosing for patients for intravenous administration of antibiotics and (b) pro-
>120 kg and normal organ function; such recommendations longed therapy (defined as an extended course of the initial
might include modified dosing for beta-lactams, trime- antibiotic or a different antibiotic after initial course was
thoprim-sulfamethoxazole, and many intravenous antibiot- completed.
ics. Many recommendations may be based on the available Student’s t test was used for statistical analysis of the
pharmacokinetic properties of the drug and the frequency continuous variable. Categorical data were analyzed with
and severity of known toxicities rather than published chi-square testing. Multiple logistic regression modeling
research studies. for the clinical outcome of an adverse outcome of either
For adult patients diagnosed with cellulitis in the pri- hospitalization or prolonged treatment within 30 days of the
mary care setting, we hypothesized that an increased BMI diagnosis of cellulitis as an outpatient was performed while
would correlate with adverse outcomes (specifically, pro- retaining all independent variables studied. Statistical sig-
longed antibiotic course, escalation of antibiotic choice, or nificance was set at P < .05. Calculations were performed
hospitalization for intravenous administration of antibiot- on MedCalc software (www.medcalc.org, version 14.10.2).
ics). Since other factors such as the diagnosis of diabetes
and tobacco use may be confounding issues, these condi-
tions will specifically be controlled for in this study. With a
Results
recent (2014) institutional guideline suggesting increased Of the 637 patients in the study cohort, 393 (61.7%) were of
doses for antibiotics in patients weighing more than 120 kg, a BMI ≥40.0 kg/m2 and 244 (38.3%) were of normal BMI.
we used weight in a secondary analysis. Between the 2 groups of patients, those with a normal BMI
were younger, more likely white women without diabetes
and weigh less than 120 kg (Table 1). There was no differ-
Methods ence between the 2 groups of patients with regard to tobacco
This was a retrospective study involving primary care use, which ranged from 16.5% to 19.1%. Overall, adverse
patients within a Mayo Clinic setting located in the Midwest. outcomes were not statistically significant between the
All patients who had a primary diagnosis of cellulitis from groups, with almost 1 in 5 patients experiencing either a
June 2008 through June 2013 were identified using ICD-9 prolonged therapy or hospitalization for their cellulitis.
(International Classification of Diseases, ninth revision) While hospitalizations were approximately 1 in 20 from
codes. After approval by the organization’s institutional each group; approximately 20% (range 17.9% to 19.6%)
review board, adult patients were screened and only those required prolonged or altered therapy.
having given prior research authorization were included. With subgroup analysis of the BMI ≥40 kg/m2 group, the
Data were collected using both automated and manual pro- patients with a BMI of 40 to 50 kg/m2 had similar adverse
cesses. Demographic data recorded included age, gender, events compared with patients with a normal BMI; while
Theofiles et al 235
Table 1. Demographics and Clinical Factors by Body Mass Index (BMI; Normal vs ≥40 kg/m2) of Primary Care Patients Diagnosed
With Cellulitis as an Outpatient, by Variable.
30.00% 28.60%
25.00%
15.00%
10.00%
5.00%
0.00%
18.5-25 (N=244) 40-50 (N=322) 50-60 (N=57) >60 (N=14)
Figure 1. Percentage of adverse events (either hospitalization or prolonged therapy) for outpatient patients diagnosed with cellulitis,
by body mass index (BMI) category.
the patients with a BMI ≥50 kg/m2 were noted to have ≥50 kg/m2 and 244 patients with a normal BMI (N = 315)
almost twice the rate of adverse outcomes as the normal while retaining all the demographic variables, a BMI of ≥50
BMI group and the subgroup of patients with a BMI of ≥40 kg/m2 was associated with an odds ratio of 2.440 (95% CI,
to <50 kg/m2 (Figure 1). These 71 patients with “super obe- 1.260-4.724; P = .008) and weight >120 kg was associated
sity” were almost all more than a weight of 120 kg (98.6%) with an odds ratio of 2.246 (95% CI, 1.154-4.369; P = .017;
and had a much higher incidence of diabetes when com- Table 3). Age, gender, race, the diagnosis of diabetes mel-
pared with the patients with normal BMI (40.8% vs 4.9%, litus, or the use of tobacco were not associated with a wors-
P < .001; Table 2). Adverse outcomes were noted in 33.8% ening outcome of cellulitis, when controlling for all other
of these patients compared with 17.9% of the normal BMI variables for either model.
patients. There were no demographic statistically signifi-
cant differences noted between these 2 groups of patients
for age, gender, race, or tobacco use.
Discussion
Using a logistic regression analysis for presence of an In this study, we determined rates of treatment failure in
adverse outcome within 30 days of the diagnosis of outpa- patients initially diagnosed with cellulitis in the outpatient
tient cellulitis in the cohorts of the 71 patients with BMI setting with a particular emphasis on specific ranges of
236 Journal of Primary Care & Community Health 6(4)
Table 2. Demographics and Clinical Factors by Body Mass Index (BMI; Normal vs ≥50 kg/m2) of Primary Care Patients Diagnosed
With Cellulitis as an Outpatient, by Variable.
Table 3. Odds Ratios for Adverse (Either Prolonged Treatment or Hospitalization) Event Within 30 Days of Diagnosis of Cellulitis
(for Normal Body Mass Index [BMI] Patients vs BMI ≥50 kg/m2) by BMI or Weight, by Variable (N = 315).
obesity, including morbid obesity (BMI 40-50 kg/m2) and the fastest rates. From a period of 2000 to 2005, self-
super obesity (BMI ≥50 kg/m2). We were surprised to see reported BMI higher than 40 kg/m2 increased by 50% with
minimal differences in the rates of prolonged antibiotic BMI >50 kg/m2 increasing by 75%, approximately 3 times
therapy and hospitalizations between normal BMI and the the rate of moderate obesity.8 Based on obesity trends in
BMI 40 to 50 kg/m2 cohort; however, the rates of adverse Pennsylvania school children from 2007 to 2011, Lohrmann
outcomes in the BMI ≥50 kg/m2 cohort was quite marked et al9 project the prevalence of overweight, obesity, and
and independent from other studied variables including age, extreme high obesity of Pennsylvania school children to be
gender, comorbid diabetes, and tobacco use. It was observed 16%, 6.6%, and 23% by 2031, lending additional evidence
that most patients within this latter group had a weight of that morbid and severe obesity are surpassing general trends
>120 kg, suggesting a weight at which concerns for inade- in moderate obesity. As clinically severe obesity continues
quate antibiotic therapy should be triggered. This study to become a significant portion of the nation’s weight distri-
adds to the knowledge base of outpatient treatment for cel- bution, we will undoubtedly see more clinically relevant
lulitis in patients with obesity, by controlling for the poten- ramifications especially in terms of drug dosing.
tial confounding factors of diabetes mellitus and tobacco From a pharmacologic standpoint, differences in drug
use. Also, the significant change in adverse events at BMIs metabolism among obese individuals have drawn signifi-
≥50 kg/m2 vs BMI of 40 to 50 kg/m2 was intriguing, as prior cant attention over the past decade and are well described in
studies have not subcategorized BMIs >40 kg/m2. the literature, although clinical evidence has lagged behind.
With these findings in mind, current prevalence data In general, oral absorption may play a minor role in
have shown that the highest BMI groups are increasing at decreased drug concentrations due to delayed gastric
Theofiles et al 237
emptying commonly seen in obesity. Volume of distribution similar findings if we assessed clinical failure once patients
(Vd), however, is significantly altered in obesity compared reached the inpatient setting. These findings are also appli-
with normal-weight individuals. In terms of lipophilic anti- cable to the dosing of antibiotics for prophylaxis of recur-
biotics (eg, fluoroquinolones and macrolides), Vd is typi- rent cellulitis. The PATCH I trial found that BMI >33
cally increased in obesity due to increases in adipose tissue. kg/m2, lymphedema, and multiple previous episodes were
Additionally, Vd in hydrophilic antibiotics (eg, beta-lactams independent risk factors for failure of penicillin prophylaxis
and aminoglycosides) is also increased with water compris- and that the increased prophylaxis failure rate in obese
ing 30% of adipose tissue thus increasing lean body weight. patients may be linked to underdosing of penicillin for
Less is known about hepatic metabolism, although fatty BMI.14
infiltration of the liver and increased activity of the cyto- There were several limitations to this study with the
chrome P450 pathway has been implicated in altered most obvious being our reliance on the clinical diagnosis of
metabolism. Glomerular filtration rate has been shown to be cellulitis. Misdiagnosis of noninfectious conditions like sta-
increased in obese individuals if otherwise healthy. Those sis dermatitis as cellulitis is a common error, occurring as
with associated comorbidities such as hypertension and dia- often as 28% in a recent study performed at University of
betes can have significantly impaired renal function posing California Los Angeles Medical Center.15 This was mini-
risk for toxicity with increased antibiotic dosing.4,10,11 mized by excluding cases where there was a high degree of
Reaching target antimicrobial concentrations in obese diagnostic uncertainty, but again we relied on accurate and
individuals has proven to be complex and certainly warrants detailed charting to do this. In an attempt to keep our study
additional clinical investigation. However, a few general con- generalizable, we did not account for comorbid chronic
siderations have been recognized which are reflected in our medical conditions (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease,
institutional guidelines for antimicrobial dosing in obesity. In chronic kidney disease, cancer, etc),preexisting stasis der-
general, penicillins and cephalosporins are suggested to be matitis, chronic lymphedema, or immunocompromised sta-
used at the higher end of suggested dosage range because of tus which may have an impact on cellulitis outcomes and
the relatively low rate of toxicity and adverse effects.11 In a could be considered for a future analysis. We also may have
recent study looking at cefazolin concentrations in adipose tis- gleaned useful information from recording the mechanism
sue at surgical sites, cefazolin concentrations were shown to of infection, as bites and trauma can predispose to infection
be inversely proportional to BMI (r = −0.67, P < .001) with a of deeper structures that are more difficult to treat. There
significant proportion of obese and extremely obese not were also challenges in determining what defined prolonged
achieving minimal inhibitory concentrations for Gram- treatment. If patients were found to have an allergic reaction
negative rod coverage in adipose samples at 20% and 33.3%, to the medication initially prescribed, another medication
respectively.12 In a commonly cited study, Forse et al13 showed was often prescribed in its place, thus extending the dura-
that increasing cefazolin from 1 to 2 g resulted in 75% to tion by several doses and days. This example was not coded
100% increase in tissue concentrations and resulted in a sig- as a prolonged therapeutic treatment, however, not all medi-
nificant reduction in surgical site infections from 16.5% to cation changes were as well documented leading to possible
5.6%. Rather than using the higher end of dosage range for misinterpretation.
cephalosporins, our institutional guidelines as of July 2014, In addition, not all BMI categories were evaluated in this
simply recommend doubling the dose in patients weighing study. It was demonstrated in our study that there was no
greater than 120 kg with no known organ dysfunction. difference in the adverse outcomes noted between patients
Our findings support the recent update in our institu- with a normal BMI and those of a BMI of 40 to 50 kg/m2
tional guidelines directing providers to increase specific and that the difference in outcomes was only associated
antibiotics such as penicillins and cephalosporins in patients with those of a BMI >50 kg/m2 compared with a normal
weighing greater than 120 kg. Our data were collected from BMI. Our study was designed to compare those that would
clinical episodes spanning from 2008 to 2012, predating be eligible to require antibiotic dosing changes (BMI >40
these guidelines, with the vast majority of the patients kg/m2) and those who did not (BMI 18.5-25.0 kg/m2). Also,
included receiving cephalexin at standard dosing of 500 mg we did not determine the retrospective control of the
orally 3 to 4 times per day. It would be interesting to com- patient’s diabetes at the index by determining the most
pare future rates of treatment failure with the new guide- recent hemoglobin A1c. Diabetes control would be best
lines in place as well as rates of adherence among providers. determined by an A1c at index date or within two months
Our data assessed risk of treatment failure in the outpatient prior and we felt this would be best determined by a poten-
setting and cannot be generalized to the inpatient setting. tial prospective analysis of cellulitis in diabetic patients.
Another study showed weights of just 100 kg and BMI of Retrospective data may or may not have been available, and
>40 kg/m2 significantly associated with clinical failure in would have diminished the potential number of diabetic
hospitalized patients with cellulitis.7 We too may have had patients.
238 Journal of Primary Care & Community Health 6(4)