Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BATCH: 2016-2019 Vels University, Pallavaram - Chennai Moot Court - 2019
BATCH: 2016-2019 Vels University, Pallavaram - Chennai Moot Court - 2019
VS
Union of Sindiya
Vs
1. Union of Sindiya
… Respondent
TABLE OF CONTENTS
B) INDEX OF AUTHORITIES
Case Laws ……………………………….6
Books …………………………................6
Legal Database ………………………….... 6
Articles &Reports ………………………….......... 7
PRAYER ……………………………………………………34
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
¶ Para
DC Deccan Land
Art Article
Edn Edition
HC High Court
SC Supreme Court
Ors Others
Memorial on behalf of the Respondent
5
& And
p. Page No
v. Versus
INDEX OF AUTHORITIES
CASE LAWS
BOOKS
www.indiankanoon.com
www.legalservice.com
www.manupatra.com
www.scconline.com
www.sci.gov.in
www.legalservicesindia.com
www.supremecourtcases.com
STATEMENT OF JURISDICTION
STATEMENT OF FACTS
democracy in the globe. The government of Union of Sindiya has based and run
like country India. The Court’s system in Union of Sindiya follows strict system
of hierarchy.
2. In recent past the Supreme Court of Union of Sindiya has delivered its
judgment on the issue relating to the Right to life with human dignity which
includes the smoothening of the process of dying in case of terminally ill patient
or a person in persistent vegetative state with no hope for recovery. In the light
of this ruling and direction by the Supreme Court of Union of Sindiya, several
petitions were filed by the people in various High Courts of the State and
In an incident, Mrs. Swagatha from the province of Coastal Pradesh had filed an
application seeking for permission from the High Court to end the life of her
child who is suffering with inherited blood disorder called Thalassemia. In the
High Court of Deccan Land, this is one of the High Courts in the Union of
Along with the above application is several other petitions were filed in various
facilitate to end their life. These incidents were reported in local newspapers.
Responding to the news the Deccan Land based NGOby the name "Citizens'
Union for Human Rights" filed a PIL in the Supreme Court of Union of Sindiya.
STATEMENT OF ISSUES
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENTS
to take away the life of anyone who is a child, whoever they are.” Parents and
guardians will pressure minors in more or less subtle ways into making
euthanasia decisions to find relief from their own emotional or financial needs.
ARGUMENTS IN ADVANCE
Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 also incidentally deals with the issue at hand.
UnderSection 20A read with Section 33(m) of the Act of 1956, the Medical
Council of India may prescribe the standards of professional conduct and
etiquette and a code of ethics for medical practitioners. Exercising these powers,
the Medical Council of India has recently amended 27the code of medical ethics
for medical practitioners. Thereunder the act of euthanasia has been classified as
unethical except in cases where the life support system is used only to continue
the cardio-pulmonary actions of the body. Only in such cases, subject to the
certification by the team of doctors, life support systems may be removed. If
physicians and nurses become associated with killing people then trust which is
the basis of the healing contract will be eroded and slowly disintegrate.
afflictions cause people to suffer through extreme physical pain in their last
days, and euthanasia may seem like a compassionate way of ending this pain.
Other patients may request euthanasia to avoid the weakness and loss of mental
faculties that some diseases cause, and many feel these wishes should be
respected. But euthanasia also seems to contradict one of the most basic
principles of morality, which is that killing is wrong. Viewed from a traditional
Judeo-Christian point of view, euthanasia ismurder and a blatant violation of the
biblical commandment “Thou shalt not kill”. From asecular perspective, one of
the principal purposes of law is to uphold the sanctity of humanlife. Euthanasia
is so controversial because it pits the plight of suffering, dying
individualsagainst religious beliefs, legal tradition, and, in the case of physician-
assisted death, medicalethics. So, there is a need for consideration of settled law
and guidelines with respect to right to end life with human dignity.
It is submitted that the parents have no right to seek the state’s assistance to end
the life of their child if in case all the effort made by them have failed to save
the life of their child, particularly the failure of the state in recognizing
advanced medical directives. It is not the duty of the state to end the life of the
citizens.
Constitutional Provisions for Children:
Article 21 guarantees personal liberty and due process of law to one and
all.
Article 45 of the Directive Principles of State Policy provides for free and
compulsory education for all children until their complete the age of 14.
The Government of India adopted National Policy for Children in 1974 and
there was a shift of focus from child welfare to child development. The policy
was intended to ensure effective services for children in the areas of education,
health, nutrition and recreation with special emphasis on the weaker sections of
society. The Government of India has taken a number of measures related to
child rights protection and child development in India. The Ministry of Women
and Child Development was established on a full-fledged basis.
The National Plan of Action for Children (NPA) was prepared by the
Government of India under the title ‘A Commitment to the Child’ with a focus
on various target groups of vulnerable children and called for improved
protection of these children. The plan was indeed an outcome of an inter-sector,
inter-department coordination and covered areas of health, nutrition, water and
sanitation, education, children in need of care and protection, girl child
adolescent girls, children and environment, women advocacy and people’s
participation, resources monitoring and evaluation.
The National Plan of Action for the Girl Child was formulated during
1991-2000 by the Government of India in order to ensure the survival and
protection of the girl child, safe motherhood, overall development of the girl
child and special protection for vulnerable girl children in need of care and
protection. The vulnerable groups of children included – street children,
orphaned, abandoned and destitute children, working children, abused children,
children who are victims of commercial sexual exploitation and trafficking,
children engaging in substance abuse, children in conflict and disaster
situations, children in families at-risk, differently able children, mentally ill
children, HIV/AIDS affected / infected children and juveniles in conflict with
the law.
The National Charter for Children (2003), National Plan of Action for
Children (2005) and enforcement of the National Commissions for
Protection of Child Rights Act (2006) were formulated and established with a
view to protect the interest of children in India. The National Plan of Action was
mainly responsible for a comprehensive study of child abuse and initiation of
the amendment of law on child marriage. The Prohibition of Child Marriage Bill
(2006) enhanced the punishment for those who were involved in child abuse
and child marriage activities.
In this case, the petitioner seeks for a Mandamus directing the first respondent
to take necessary action to admit his wife, namely, Sumathi, aged 33 years in
the second respondent Hospital and provide treatment to his wife till her
recovery in second respondent Hospital at Government cost or direct the
respondents to terminate the life of petitioner's wife by mercy killing.
So the state shall not assistance to end the life of their child if in case all the
efforts made by them have failed to save the life of their child, particularly the
failure of the state in recognizing advanced medical directives. The State shall
protect the life of the child till them life.
and alcohol. Why should we let them make decisions about matters of life and
death?
2. Argument from Capability of Discernment. For a euthanasia request to be
granted an assessment is required that the minor is capable of discernment. But
minors are not capable of discernment.
3. Argument from Pressure. Parents and guardians will pressure minors in
more or less subtle ways into making euthanasia decisions to find relief from
their own emotional or financial needs.
4. Argument from Sensitivity. A minor will opt for euthanasia due to her
sensitivity, i.e. her desire to satisfy expectations from parents who can no longer
bear the situation.
5. Argument from Sufficient Palliative Care. Euthanasia for minors is
unnecessary: Physical suffering at the end of life can always be made bearable
by means of palliative care; Requests for euthanasia come about due to poor
palliative care.
In Sudheswari v state of Assam a three year old child was killed by her
mother and among the defences stated by her, one was that the little child had
been done to death because she was suffering from illness badly and that the
accused could not bear the trouble of looking after her and thus the court was
asked to decide whether mercy killing was an exception to murder available in
India. The court in case clearly held that euthanasia is not an exception to the
offence of murder.Thus in a country like India it is very likely that people will
abuse this law if all kinds of euthanasia becomes legal.
The state is under the obligation to take care of the aged in case of the failure to
their and all others alternatives. The state shall provide the help to all the
citizens, including child and aged persons.
The problems of the elderly in India were not serious in the past because the
numbers were small and the elderly were provided with social protection by
their family members. But owing to relatively recent socio-economic changes,
ageing of the population is emerging as a problem that requires consideration
before it becomes critical. However family and relatives still play a dominant
role in providing economic and social security for the elderly. But still the
majority of elderly need social, economic and health support.
Over the years, the government has launched various schemes and policies for
elderly persons. These policies and schemes are meant to promote the health,
well-being and independence of elderly people around the country.
CONSTITUTIONAL PROVISIONS:
of state policy, we need to understand the meaning of each word i.e. Directive +
principle + state + policy which suggest that these are the principles that direct
the state when it makes policies for its people. These DPSPs act as a guideline
for the state and are needed to be taken into consideration while coming up with
any new law but a citizen cannot compel the state to follow DPSPs.
Article 47 of the constitution of India provides that the state shall regard the
raising of the level of nutrition and the standard of living of its people and
improvement of public health as among its primary duties.
Entry 24 in list III of schedule VII of constitution of India deals with the welfare
of labour, including conditions of work, provident funds, liability for workmen’s
compensation, invalidity and old age pension and maternity benefits. Further,
item 9 of the state list and item 20, 23 and 24 of concurrent list relates to old age
pension, social security and social insurance, and economic and social planning.
The right of parents, without any means, to be supported by their children
having sufficient means has been recognized by section 125(1) (d) of the Code
of Criminal Procedure 1973, and section 20 (1 & 3) of the Hindu Adoption and
Maintenance Act, 1956.
Memorial on behalf of the Respondent
25
LEGISLATIONS:
The Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 was
enacted in December 2007, to ensure need based maintenance for parents and
senior citizens and their welfare. Section 19 of the Maintenance and Welfare of
Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 envisages provision of at least one old
age home for indigent senior citizens with a capacity of 150 persons in every
district of the country. The objectives of the Act are:
The Act was enacted on 31st December 2007. It accords prime responsibility for
the maintenance of parents on their children, grand children or even relatives
who may possibly inherit the property of a senior citizen. It also calls upon the
state to provide facilities for poor and destitute older persons. The Act has to be
brought into force by individual State Government. Himachal Pradesh is the
first state and Punjab is the fifth state where old parents can legally stake claim
to financial aid from their grown-up children for their survival and a denial
would invite a prison term. As on 03.02.2010, the Act had been notified by 22
states and all UTs.
Several initiative steps for various policies and programmes for the elderly have
been taken by the government. Some of them have been:
A National Council for Older Persons (NCOP) was constituted in 1999 under
the chairpersonship of the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment to
operationalize the National Policy on Older Persons. The NCOP is the highest
body to advise the Government in the formulation and implementation of policy
and programmes for the elderly. The basic objectives of this council are to:
provide a nodal point at the national level for redressing the grievances of
older persons which are of an individual nature provide lobby for
concessions, rebates and discounts for older persons both with the
Government as well as with the corporate sector.
Memorial on behalf of the Respondent
29
Work as a nodal point at the national level for redressing the grievances
of elderly people.
Undertake any other work or activity in the best interest of elderly people.
The council was re-constituted in 2005 and met at least once every year.
At present there are 50 members in it, comprising representatives of
Central and State Governments, NGO’s, citizens’ group, retired persons’
associations, and experts in the fields of law, social welfare and medicine.
Providing disability and hearing aids for the elderly people. The
eligibility criteria for beneficiaries of some important projects supported
under IPOP Scheme are:
Respite care homes and continuous care homes – for elderly persons who
are seriously ill and require continuous nursing care and respite
Mobile Medicare units – for older persons living in slums, rural and
inaccessible areas where proper health facilities are not available. The scheme
has been revised in April, 2008. Besides an increase in amount of financial
assistance for existing projects, Governments/Panchayati Raj institutions/local
bodies have been made eligible for getting financial assistance.
Convergence with National Rural Health Mission, AYUSH and other line
departments like Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment.
Help Age India has sponsored the construction and maintenance of old age
homes in India. These homes cater to the needs of those elderly who are unable
to live by themselves and for those who have been abandoned by the family or
are neglected and uncapped for by their children. These old age homes provide
and cater to the various needs of the elderly so that they can spend the
“evenings of their lives” with dignity and respect and not feel a burden to the
society. There are over 800 old age homes all over India and nearly half of them
are being sponsored and funded by Help Age India. Besides old age homes,
Help Age India also supports day care centres where the elderly come for a few
hours every day or on certain days of the week and spend some time together.
These centres combat the loneliness they face and create a sense of “we feeling”
among them. In some of the centres being supported by Help Age India in rural
areas they are also places where the income generating activities are conducted.
So, there are many provisions in Sindhiya to protect the aged person. State shall
provide all the helps to the aged person till them life.
PRAYER
Therefore, in the light of facts of the case, issues raised, arguments advanced
and authorities cited this Hon’ble Court may be pleased to adjudge and declare
that:
And pass any other order in favour of the respondent that it may deem fit in the
submitted.