Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Water Crisis Final Report
Water Crisis Final Report
Group Members:
Ayesha Asghar, 150
Sajid Ali,158
OmaimahIrfan, 132
RameenAther, 185
ZainabWaseem, 175
ShifaAmjad, 141
RamishNadeem, 166
Table of Contents
Introduction………………………………………………………………1
Early History……………………………………………………………..1
Origin of Water Issue…………………………………………………….2
Indus Water Treaty and its conflict……………………………………….2
Causes of Water Shortage………………………………………………3
Impacts of water shortage………………………………………………4
Construction of dams……………………………………………………5
a. Mangla Dam………………………………………………………5
b. Tarbela Dam…………………………………………………………6
c. Kalabagh Dam………………………………………………………7
Water usage by different sectors………………………………………….8
Water availability in dams………………………………………………9
Misuse of water resources………………………………………………10
Steps taken by the Government…………………………………………10
Using water effectively and efficiently………………………………….15
Water conservation strategies………………………………………….16
Pakistan is running dry………………………………………………..17
Conclusion……………………………………………………………..17
References
Introduction:
If we look at a satellite picture of Pakistan and Sindh, it is quite clear that the River
Indus is a pivotal water source for Sindh as it is the only source of freshwater that
sustains the people, and the economy of Sindh. Indus is the longest river of the
Subcontinent, about1900 miles long. The Indus river system comprises of seven rivers
including the River Indus itself.
The five rivers of Punjab – Bias, Sutluj, Ravi, Chanab, and Jehlem discharge in Indus at
MithanKot and the Kabul River at Attock. Present water crises that have engulfed
Pakistan are not so much a result of general water shortage, as some would want us to
believe. As a matter of fact, these crises are a result of never ending greed and
mismanagement of the water resources by the powers that governed Pakistan. This
presentation will talk about the origin of the water issue, the effects it is leaving on the
economy, and the steps that we can take to solve this problem.
Early History:
Basically, the water issue is between Sindh and Punjab which are the provinces of
Pakistan. This issue is not necessarily of recent origin, and arose when the British
occupied parts of Sindh in the nineteenth century.
The issue came to notice in 1901, when the Indian Irrigation Commission prohibited
Punjab from taking even a drop of water from Indus without the approval of Sindh.
In 1919, the then government of India issued the Cotton Committee report; where in,
it prohibited Punjab from undertaking any projects until Sukkur barrage was completed
and water needs of Sindh were determined.
In 1925, Lord Reading, the British Viceroy of India, rejected Punjab’s request for Thal
canal from Indus.
In 1937; however, the Anderson Commission allowed Punjab to withdraw 775 cusecs
of water on experimental basis from Indus for Thal canal. This happened even with the
absence of Thal canal, and clearly constituted a direct violation of the viceroy’s orders
of 1925.
In 1939, Sindh lodged a formal complaint to the government against Punjab, under the
Government of India Act of 1935.
Consequently, in1941, the Roy Commission recognized that injustice was being done
in Sindh and recommended construction of two new barrages in Sindh on Indus, and
ordered Punjab to pay 20 million Rupees of the construction cost of these barrages to
make up for Sindh’s losses, done by Punjab.
Under the guidance of the Roy Commission, a committee comprising of the chief
engineers of Punjab and Sindh came out with an agreement in 1945, known as “Sindh-
Punjab Agreement.” It resolved the distribution of the waters of all Indus basin rivers
between Punjab and Sindh. This agreement recognized Sindh’s supremacy over the
Indus River, and let the other provinces know that no action, involving River Indus,
could be taken without Sindh’s consent.
1
Origin of the Water Issue:
In 1947 Lord Mountbatten, the Viceroy of the Subcontinent, realized the dire need of
a separate homeland for Muslims and Hindus, declared that power would be
transferred from the British to the Indians by June of the same year. The increasing
tensions even after partition did not end just there. Neither have they ended after the
three wars, the neighboring nations, Pakistan and India, have fought within a time
frame of 30 years after their independence.
At the time of partition, the distribution of assets was not done equally, which created
huge problems for Pakistan. What was left unnoticed at that time was that India had
full control over that one resource without which human life would cease to exist-
water.
Water that reaches the two nations comes from the Himalayan glaciers which pass
through the part of the Kashmir, controlled by India. Pakistan’s government was
seriously concerned about this matter. In order to solve this problem, the Inter-
Dominion Accord of 1948 was signed between the two countries. According to this
accord, India would release water into Pakistan for which it would receive regular
payments.
The people of Pakistan were unhappy about it, and their concerns proved valid when
in 1948 Pakistan’s water supplies were cut off by India. This led the leaders of the
nation to take this matter to the International Court of Justice but India was always
hesitant towards solving this issue.
It was on September 19, 1960 that a deal was signed between the then Indian Prime
Minister Jawaharlal Nehru and Ayub Khan, the President of Pakistan. It was termed as
the Indus Water Treaty according to which, control of water from the western rivers
of Indus, Jhelum and Chenab was handed over to Pakistan and India would have
complete access to the waters from Sutlej, Beas and Ravi, the eastern waterways.
2
Causes of water crises in Pakistan?
According to the UNO Report, Pakistan is at the 7th position in the list of countries,
which are facing water crisis. Presently, Pakistan has a surface water of 153 MAF and
underground water resources of only 24 MAF and Pakistan may face water shortage
during the year, 2025. The causes of water crisis in Pakistan are as follows:
1. Fewer downpours
The Water Cycle maintain the flow of water in an environment. The hydrological
cycle depends upon evaporation but due to high contamination of water bodies
including, oceans, rivers, and seas the process is affected badly. The contribution of
rainfall to crops is 5% to 10%. Cutting of large areas of jungle according to UN report
in Pakistan from 7000 to 9000 hectares jungle is removed yearly and now it is only
5% instead of 25 % of total land.
4. Urbanization/Industrialization
Growing urban-industrial use of water is also another important factor. The Khanpur
Dam constructed for urban water supply to twin cities of Islamabad and Rawalpindi is
becoming inadequate even before its supply could be started, population has increased
exponentially.
5. Population Explosion:
The global population in 2006 was 6.7 billion, which is increasing at a rate of 78
million/year that has reached 7.13 billion now. It has been predicted that the
population will reach up to 10.9billion by the year 2050. Among all this total
population, 90% growth rate occurs in developing countries like Pakistan. Increase in
population will put an enormous pressure on water use. Pakistan is 6th most populous
nation in the world with 19.6million population growing at a rate of 1.52% by the
year 2014. This clearly shows that if the population keeps on increasing at the same
rate, we would eventually run out of water to fulfill everyone’s needs.
3
Impact of shortage of water:
1. Impact on Economy / Society
Agriculture is the backbone of our country. If there is shortage of water then
the country should be prepared for facing problems economically as well as
socially. According to the estimates of federal government, the agriculture
sector would suffer a loss of about Rs. 90 billion because of drought. Since
agriculture has always been a major source of supporting the crippled
economy, it has a vital role to play particularly in terms of food security and
employment majority of the population. The adverse effects of water shortage
on agriculture would have a negative effect on the economy of Pakistan.
2. Food Security
Less water means less agricultural yields and to fulfill the food requirements
of the nation we will be dependent to other countries. Import of food
commodities from other countries will result in more expenditure.
3. Livestock Problems
Raising livestock is the main source of livelihood of rural areas. It is also an
important economic activity, which contributes 9.7% of GDP, will be affected
due to shortage of water.
4. Decrease in Exports:
Pakistan bring home a healthy amount of foreign exchange, owing to its
agricultural products, which can be affected due to water shortage. The major
crops of Pakistan include wheat, rice, maize, millets, sugar cane, pulses,
cotton, and oil seeds. Pakistan grows long grain Basmati rice, in the plains of
north Punjab. Some of the best varieties of fruits are grown in Pakistan that
include mangoes, apples, oranges, peaches, plums etc But the water shortage
in the present situation can put enormous reduction in the mentioned
productions and put impact on economy of the country.
5. Health
In many developing countries people are forced to drink unhygienic water
from the flowing streams, which are usually contaminated with toxic
chemicals. This gives birth to many water borne diseases, as a result of which
many people die. Lack of quality water results in sanitation issues. Clinics,
educational institutes, and many other places used by the public are left with
very little water for cleaning purposes.
4
7. Water constraints for population
Due to drought and more dependency on ground water for irrigation, the water
table will go down and this will cause water constraints for population.
According to ICOLD, dams with height above the foundation greater than 15 meters
(49 ft) are known as large dams. Mangla and Tarbela Dam are the two operational
large dams in Pakistan. Further information about the dams is given below:
Mangla Dam:
The Mangla dam project was conceived as a multipurpose project in the 1950s, and its
initial investment and feasibility studies were concluded in 1958. It was the first dam
to be built as a part of the Indus Basin Project as per the Indus water treaty signed
between India and Pakistan in 1960.
The construction of Mangla dam was started in March 1963, and took a little more
than 4 years to complete in June, 1967. It cost $ 434.505 million and was funded by
the World Bank and Asian Development Bank. The dam was constructed without the
consent of local people under the first military dictator of Pakistan, Gen. Ayub Khan,
5
on the disputed territory of Jammu Kashmir. There were large-scale protests even
then, but they were crushed as per the military orders. Local people claim that even
today, after a lapse of 40 years, some 10 thousand families out of those who were
displaced for the building of the dam have still not been compensated.
The main dam was 10,300 feet long and 380 feet high above the riverbed with a
reservoir of 97.7 square miles. In 1974, its generation capacity was increased by
commissioning two more units each of 100 MW. In 1981, the power generation
capacity was further enhanced by installing the identical units of equal strengths.
In 2001, General Musharraf announced that the height of the Mangla dam will be
raised to increase its live storage capacity and maximize the hydropower potential of
river Jhelum. In 2003, the Mangla Dam Raising Project (MDRP) was signed to raise
the height of the Mangla reservoir from 1,202 feet to 1,252 feet, giving it an increased
capacity of 3.1 million acre feet (MAF) of water.
The dam was constructed without the consent of local people under the first military
dictator of Pakistan, Gen. Ayub Khan, on the disputed territory of Jammu Kashmir.
There were large-scale protests even then, but they were crushed as per the military
orders. Local people claim that even today, after a lapse of 40 years, some 10
thousand families out of those who were displaced for the building of the dam have
still not been compensated.
The advantages of the Mangla dam, which includes cheap electricity, irrigation
facilities and prevention from flooding is enjoyed by the rest of Pakistan, whereas the
people who live in the immediate upstream of the dam, bear the environmental costs,
which include disappearance of the fertile agriculture land, submergence of two of the
district´s market towns- Mirpur and Chaomukh, and hindrance in transport and
communication. Despite these frequent protests, rightful compensations have not been
provided.
In November 2012, the United States of America announced a grant of $150 million
dollars for the expansion of the Mangla Dam power plant. In March 2014, United
States through USAID signed another $72 million project for refurbishing and
upgrading the dam.
Tarbela Dam:
Originally constructed in 1974, under the government of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, the
Tarbela Dam is the world’s largest earth- and rock-filled structure. Its existing
hydropower facilities supply about 16% of the electricity generated in Pakistan. The
primary purpose of the Tarbela Dam Project was to regulate the flows of the Indus
River for irrigation use.
Currently, there are several expansion plans in store for the Tarbela plant. The World
Bank is financing the Tarbela Fourth Extension Project to increase the dam stability to
produce more electricity. The financial institution argues the fact that the country’s
6
need for energy is increasing and that widespread blackouts might lead to major
problems. USAID and US government are also using the same argument for
co-financing the Tarbela project
Affected communities in the Indus delta have been actively protesting the devastating
impacts of the existing water development projects; the Tarbela dam caused itself the
displacement of at least 100,000 people; many of them have not been properly
compensated nor resettled.
Kalabagh Dam :
Sindh’s viewpoint:
Sindh is the only province to strongly oppose KBD. Sindh supports its argument by
stating that by virtue of its name and history of water rights of the province, Indus
River belongs exclusively to Sindh. Therefore, claiming the construction of dams,
Tarbela and Mangla and now KBD actions of theft of water at the irrigation cost of
Sindh.
Sindh objects that their share of the Indus water will be curtailed as water from the
Kalabagh will go to irrigate farmlands in Punjab and NWFP, at their cost.
KPK’s viewpoint:
While the reservoir will be in KPK, the main electricity generating turbines will be in
Punjab. Therefore, Punjab would keep getting all the benefits. Even though Punjab
has not agreed to accept any royalties, KPK is afraid that it will face adverse
consequences, i.e. relocation of the people, being the most important one, about which
the government has not done much, in the past. KPK is also concerned, that most part
of the Nowshehra district would be submerged, thus affecting the lives of the people.
7
Baluchistan’s viewpoint:
Baluchistan has always been neglected by the governments of the past, who have
failed to uncap its natural resources. The Province fears that if the Kalabagh dam
project is put into action, Punjab would get all the luxuries, and dominate over the
entire country.
Out of 240.22 maf (million acre feet), 172.21 maf water is utilized for irrigation
purposes. In this the canal diversions is 105.23 maf; rainwater is 6.0 maf; ground
water is 41.30 and utility above rims is 5.28 maf.
(b) Domestic
Most of the rural and urban water is supplied from ground water through tube wells
and hand pumps except few cities like Karachi and Islamabad. Total urban and rural
estimated requirements is 10-15% of the surface water, out of which 80% return to the
system, however with degraded quality. Net consumption is normally about 2% of the
total water available.
(c) Industry
Water is also utilized in industries basically for cooling purposes and also in
manufacturing processes. This utility is almost 1%. Recent increase in generating
electricity through solar power has reduced the water usage for hydro power
generation. Most of the annual storage is utilized for irrigation and not for hydro
power.
8
Water availability and population:
Both population and water availability is inversely proportion to each other. In the
past few years’ population has doubled whereas the water availability has decreased
drastically due to misuse, and lack of storing capacity and other important factors.
Mangla reservoir is the second major storage of Pakistan. Due to siltation it has lost
9
13.2% of its storage and presently can store 4.636 maf of water. After the Mangla
powerhouse’s zero water indents due to water scarcity, Indus River System Authority
(IRSA) closed the water supply from Mangla Dam. Only 3.4 MAF water is available
in the reservoir of Mangla.
Provinces are receiving the following amounts of water:
About 20.3 million acres of land remains unutilized and needs to be irrigated, which
can only be done if Pakistan has the capacity to build more reservoirs thus regulating
the flow of water. It may come as a shock, however, that many Pakistanis are using at
least 10 times more water than the world’s average. The citizens of Pakistan,
connected through the Water and Sanitation Agency (WASA), receive around 100
million gallons every day, but they receive it almost free. Through WASA, the water
reaches around 100,000 households, or around 900,000 people. This makes an
average use of 100 gallons per person per day. The world’s average is 10 gallons per
day.
Owing to the absence of appropriate water user charges, citizens use too much water,
the water supply organization (WASA) remains poorly mismanaged, and ultimately
there are no funds for maintenance of infrastructure.
Policy Objectives:
1. To ensure water security at every level.
2. To minimize the risks arising from the expected increase in frequency and intensity
of extreme weather events such as floods, droughts and tropical storms.
3. To grow as many trees as one can to increase downpour.
10
Kachhi Canal Project
The project is expected to irrigate around “72,000 acres” of barren land in the Sui
tehsil area of Baluchistan and more than one million people will benefit from this
canal. The project is scheduled for three phases.
Agriculture which will take place through this canal will cater to the demand in
Baluchistan and some areas in South Punjab as well. These areas have very low
development but due to abundant water resources through Kacchi Canal agriculture
and cattle farming will be made more convenient. People of these areas could
generate large amount of income through these water resources. Moreover, other two
phases of this project are currently under construction.
11
National Water Policy, 2018
In the 37th meeting of the CCI, held on 24th April, 2018 former Prime Minister
ShahidKhaqanAbbasi approved the First National Water Policy along with a National
Water charter that was signed by the chief ministers of the four provinces. This has
been of extreme importance because the implementation of this policy kept being
delayed for many years, and now it was finally being put into action with the mutual
consensus of all the four provinces. In order to enforce this policy, a national level
institute “National Water Council” has been established, lead by Prime Minister of
Pakistan along with all Chief Ministers, Federal Minister of water resources, Finance
Minister, Power Minister and Minister of Planning and Development. According to
this Policy, 2 meetings of this council will be mandatory to call in a year.
There are 32 articles of NWP, they are stated as follows:
7. Providing food security and expanding water availability to help adapt to climate
change, population and other large-scale stresses.
9. Upgrading water sector information systems for improved asset management and
to derive evidence and data driven decision making.
12
11. Restoring and maintaining the health of the environment and water related eco
systems.
14. Security of benefit streams of the water related infrastructure for sustained
provision of services.
15. Promoting appropriate technologies for rain water harvesting in rural as well as
urban areas.
16. Regulating groundwater withdrawals for curbing over-abstraction and
promoting aquifer recharge.
17. Adequate water pricing (Abiana) for irrigation and proper operation and
maintenance of the irrigation system as well as other user sectors.
18. Promoting measures for long term sustainability of the Irrigation System.
22. Protection of wet lands and Ramsar Sites for the prevention of wild life, flora
and fauna.
23. Stoppage of further sea water intrusion into Sindh (upstream from coastline) for
the sustainability of coastal environment, flora and fauna and mangrove growth
including the use of skimming dug- wells in coastal areas.
26. Climate change impact assessment and adaptation for sustainable water
resources development and management.
27. Promoting research on water resources related issues of national importance and
building capacity/delineating roles and responsibilities of Federal research institutions
and promoting coordination among them.
13
28. Setting major national targets for the water sector including those for water
conservation, water storage, Irrigation, water treatment and drinking water. These
targets can be firmed up in consultation with the Provincial Governments and
reviewed periodically for inclusion in the 12th and 13th Five Year Plans and future
plans.
31. Effective implementation of the 1991 Water Apportionment Accord in letter and
spirit.
32. Rainwater management in plains where it cannot be disposed of or diverted to
the river.
On 7th September, Prime Minister Imran Khan announceda joint account of CJP and
PM fund for construction of dams and encouraged overseas Pakistanis to donate for
this cause. Due to all these efforts, and owing to the generosity of the Pakistani
people, the funds have mounted up to USD 52 million (i.e. PKR 6.9 billion)
approximately by end of third quarter of 2018.
On 9th September 2018 a WAPDA Official revealed that at least 12 billion dollars are
required to build DiamerBhasha Dam. 5 billion dollars are required to build
infrastructure while another 7 billion dollars are required for the power generation.
14
DiamerBhasha Dam will have long term benefits, as a water reservoir with
availability of about 6,400,000 acre feet, which can be used in irrigation during low
flow periods.
Others:
1. Under Punjab Saaf Pani Project, filtrations plants have been installed all over the
Punjab during the regime of CM Punjab Shahbaz Sharif (2008-2018).
3. About 250 mini and micro hydropower projects (MHPs) have become fully
operational and functional to save water and to be used be by people of hilly areas of
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa through community-based local institutional mechanisms.
6. Public Awareness About water is also being done on different social media forums.
Special Advertisements in this regard are also being putting on air on different
electronic media channels.
7. It will not be wrong to say that India blocks the water flow in Pakistan due to
which Pakistan faces a great loss in terms of agriculture and economy. In the recent
Past, Government of Pakistan tried to restart the negotiations with India but they
ended in vain. Having good relations with India is very beneficial for us in terms of
water and agriculture as our major sector of agriculture depends upon the water come
from the River Indus and its tributaries.
15
How can we conserve water, and use it efficiently and effectively?
1. Raising water rates to bring at par with the operation and maintenance cost:
Abiana rates should be raised to bring them at par with the cost required to operate
and maintain the water supply system. At the same time, regulatory policies are
needed to ensure sustainability of underground water resources.
16
1) adoption of integrated approach, rational resource use, and the introduction
of water efficient techniques
2) institutional strengthening, capacity building and human resource
development (HRD)
3) improving performance and utilization of local systems through better
planning, management and community participation
4) improving quality of life and easy access to water supply, especially for
women
5) improving sanitation through sewerage and drainage schemes
6) Promoting increased take up of household sanitation improving the
understanding of the linkages between hygiene and health through community
education campaigns, especially among the women and children.
Crash program for cleaning of water channels including canals, water courses
and distributaries
Regulating ground water by issuance of licenses to check overdraft of aquifer.
Better water management for increasing cropping intensity with riverine area.
Technical land demolishing, surge irrigation, high irrigation efficiency
technology including drip and sprinkler.
Strengthening of institutional capacity building by improving financial
sustainability.
Better and more efficient use of funds.
To exploit the uncultivated lands for irrigation purpose,
Storage of flood water during Monsoon season by construction of a series of
small dams/reservoirs on the barren lands and Barani areas of Northern
Punjab, NWFP and Balochistan.
Launching of incentive based upon public campaign emphasizing conservation
of water at all levels.
Pakistan could run dry by 2025 as its water shortage has reached an alarming level.
The governments of the past have remained negligent towards this issue that can
cause a serious threat to the stability of the country. According to a recent report by
International Monetary Fund (IMF),Pakistan ranks third in the world among countries
facing acute water shortage. UNDP (United Nations Development Program) works in
about 170 countries helps countries to develop policies, in order to ensure their
17
stability and the well being of its citizens. Reports by UNDPand the Pakistan Council
of Research in Water Resources (PCRWR) also warn the authorities that Pakistan will
reach absolute water scarcity by 2025.
It is not the first time that development and research organizations have warned our
country about a problem that is even more dangerous than terrorism, because this
problem puts the lives of the individuals at stake.
Conclusion
The importance of water cannot be ignored. With the rapid growth of population and
increased use of water, its supply is not meeting its demand over the time. Water use
practices in the country are not in accordance with water conservation and quality
requirements. Most of the water is polluted and unhygienic for drinking purpose both
for human and animals. There is a need to analyze the existing water resources and
recommending comprehensive conservation and management strategy in view of
catering the planning requirements for the future. In order to overcome the burning
issue confronted with water requirements for agriculture and energy there is a
pressing need to construct some new mega dams which could serve the larger interest
of the people of Pakistan and their coming generations for accruing the mutual
benefits on the basis of equity and justice. Every year due to floods a lot of water
flows down towards sea and its inundation causes huge and irreparable losses to
human lives, property and assets of public and private sectors. For overcoming such
disasters, we need to construct small and flood dams at different sites. Moreover, there
is a need to switch the irrigation from traditional system to the directions of “Blue
Revolution” which could meet the challenge of water shortages and water losses to a
greater extent. The proper lining of the canal system could also reduce water losses
and in this way water could be economized and used for alternative purposes.
References:
http://www.cssforum.com.pk/css-compulsory-subjects/pakistan-affairs/13283-res
ervoirs-dams-pakistan.html
18
https://ejatlas.org/conflict/tarbela-dam-pakistan
https://www.thenewsteller.com/other/top-10-biggest-dams-in-pakistan-here-is-the
-list/26529/
https://nation.com.pk/26-Mar-2016/mangla-dam-past-present-future
https://www.dawn.com/news/1293604
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/275964934_An_overview_on_emerging
_water_scarcity_in_Pakistan_its_causes_impacts_and_remedial_measures
https://nation.com.pk/31-Oct-2018/pak-seeks-assistance-from-swiss-govt-to-recov
er-wealth-stashed-abroad
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/313077771_A_Classification_of_Rainfa
ll_Regions_in_Pakistan
ttps://www.researchgate.net/profile/Sabir_Hussain7/publication/313077771_A_C
lassification_of_Rainfall_Regions_in_Pakistan/links/544848640cf22b3c14e30bcc/
A-Classification-of-Rainfall-Regions-in-Pakistan
http://insider.pk/national/67-years-unresolved-water-crisis/
http://www.commonlii.org/in/other/treaties/INTSer/1948/
https://waterinfo.net.pk/sites/default/files/knowledge/An%20Overview%20of%2
0the%20History%20and%20Impacts%20of%20the%20Water%20Issue%20in
%20Pakistan.PDF
http://www.academia.edu/10614581/Difficulties_and_problems_faced_in_establis
hment_of_Pakistan
https://www.quora.com/What-were-the-early-problems-of-Pakistan
19