Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Seminar Report Final
Seminar Report Final
A
Seminar Report
On
“IMPLEMENTATION OF VERTICAL
FARMING”
BACHELOR OF ENGINEERING
IN
THIRD YEAR MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
Submitted By
MANISH SUNIL CHANDRE
University, Pune.
Date:
Place: PCET’s, PCCOER, Pune.
Submitted by
MANISH SUNIL CHANDRE
Is approved for the degree of Bachelor of Engineering (Third Year
Mechanical Engineering) of Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune.
Examiners:
1. _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _
2. _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _
Date:
I am thankful to my family for their whole hearted blessings are always for
me support and constant encouragement towards the fulfillment of the work.
I wish to record the help extended to be my friends in all possible ways and
active support and constant encouragement.
VF - Vertical Farming
TF - Traditional Farming
Eg – for example
i.e – that is
ABSTRACT
The pursuit of urban agriculture as part of a city’s green infrastructure is often a challenge,
particularly within compact cities, where there is a limited amount of space between buildings for
urban farming and gardening. Instead, such high-rise urban developments present often under-
utilized spaces on the vertical surfaces of buildings. Development of new type of farming
technique is required over the traditional farming technique so as to fulfill the increasing demand
for food. Land based cultivation has been able to suffice food demand till now, but with increasing
scarcity of land, water and other resources an improvised and efficient way of farming needs to be
implemented. With the world population over 7.6 billion as of 2017 and expected to reach 9.5
billion by 2050, there is going to be manifold increase for food production demand. Vertical
In this report the technical design and economic analysis of a Vertical Farm (VF), a high-rise
building used for the cultivation of food crops, is presented. Vertical Farms are posited as a
potential solution regarding the global food demand by allowing increased crop growth per land
area. A Vertical Farm offers the possibility of cultivating crops year-round in an optimized,
the technical and economic feasibility which eventually determine whether Vertical Farms will be
built. However, until now, no study has been performed to determine the actual production costs
1.1 HISTORY
In 1915, American geologist Gilbert Ellis Bailey used the concept of tall multi-story
buildings for indoor cultivation. One of the earliest drawings of a tall building that
cultivates food was published in Life Magazine in 1909. The reproduced drawings feature
vertically stacked homesteads set amidst a farming landscape. This proposal can be seen
in Rem Koolhaas’s Delirious New York. Koolhaas wrote that this 1909 theorem is 'The
Skyscraper as Utopian device for the production of unlimited numbers of virgin sites on a
metropolitan location'
we have been growing various food products. With the advancement in technology the farming
practice has improved a lot by using cultivating tools, modern machinery, etc. but the farming
technique used is the same(refer fig1). Currently, there is approximately 800 million hectares
(equal to the size of Brazil) of land which is designated to soil-based farming globally, which
constitutes about 38 % of the total global land area. Out of all the fresh water reserves 70% of fresh
water is used for traditional irrigation itself. The rise of urban agriculture as an important form of
green infrastructure has accompanied global efforts to increase the sustainability and resilience of
cities in recent years. Due to the increasing food demand, there is a need for utilizing more arable
land for farming as swell as intensifying farming efforts that would affect global agriculture
production. A new method that could potentially meet this demand, is by designing and developing
vertical farms. In theory, Vertical Farming (VF) is an agricultural technique involving large-scale
food production in high-rise buildings that enables fast growth and planned production by
controlling environmental conditions and nutrient solutions to crops based on hydroponics, using
engineering and natural sciences, and has multiple applications in both society and the
environment. Currently designed Vertical Farms having an area of 1 acre produce 10 acre
Vertical farming is the practice of producing food and medicine in vertically stacked layers,
vertically inclined surfaces and/or integrated in other structures (such as in a skyscraper, used
warehouse, or shipping container). The modern ideas of vertical farming use indoor farming
factors can be controlled. These facilities utilize artificial control of light, environmental control
(humidity, temperature, gases...) and fertigation. Some vertical farms use techniques similar
Recently, producing sustainable food in cities has garnered much interest and attention in many
academic and practical fields. At present, these farms are largely growing and produce different
types of crops inside cities such as China, Holland, South Korea, Japan, Canada, Italy, U.S,
Singapore, United Arab Emirates, and England. Because the plants will be grown indoors by
controlled environment agricultural techniques, then changing of seasons will have no effect on
the crops. It is obvious the various amount and types of products determined the VF is not just
happening, it is prospering at multiple cities with different regional characteristics around the
world.
Vertical farms comes in different shapes and sizes they are classified in two major types as:
All vertical farms use one of these three soil- free systems for providing nutrients to plants:
Hydroponic
Aeroponic
Aquaponics
Majorly Vertical Farming is done by using Hydroponic method. It involves growing plant in
nutrient solution that is free of soil. Plants roots are submerged in nutrient solution which is
Mainly terrestrial plants are grown with the help of this type of farming. Two main techniques is
used sub irrigation and top irrigation .these irrigation is done with the help of reservoirs. Most of
the reservoirs are made up of plastic, woods, vegetable solids. The containers should exclude light
Nowadays, rapid development of country gives an effect to agriculture because land of agriculture
was destroyed in order to make new building and residential area. Vertical hydroponics provides
an intelligent solution to gardeners that have limited horizontal space and for gardeners that want
to maximize their yield. They are mostly suited to that do not grow very tall, and can be used
effectively on walls, fences, balconies, and for higher density growth in small yards. The usage of
chemical pesticide can be dangerous for the people. It possibly avoided when we practice
aquaponics system. The advantages of this method of farming can be further exploited by large
scale production of crops. The controlled growing conditions will reduce the use of chemical
pesticide.
OBJECTIVES
1 Being a fully enclosed and climate controlled environment obtain reliable harvests
4 Low water usage with recycling and reduced washing and processing.
8 Reduce carbon footprint as less fossil fuel burning machines are required
With the turn of the millennium we have heard, read and spoken so much about sustainability, eco-
friendliness and carbon footprints, but what have we really learnt? What do we really know about
the topic? Sometimes companies seem to drape their products and services in a pseudo green veil,
without really taking the time to explain to the customers what is so eco-friendly about this offer
compared to any other. Most of the time this is just a clever marketing scam to attract more
customers. But how can we distinguish these faux green products from the genuine ones? I ask
myself how businesses accept or even contemplate the idea of planned obsolescence, how
consumerism has completely changed the way things are designed, produced and disposed of. How
is it that we give greater value to economic growth, rather than human and environmental well-
being? We have reached a critical point in history, where finally the consequences of our past
actions are starting to materialize in front of us: high concentrations of toxins and harmful
chemicals are accumulating in the water that we drink, temperature levels around the globe are
rising exponentially, natural resources are disappearing at a shocking rate and we are consuming
The industrial revolution certainly brought with it many benefits for mankind, such as modern
medicine, the invention of automated machinery and an immense range of new materials, but it
has also lead us to the current environmental crisis that each day torments world leaders and global
campaigning organizations alike. Is it possible for us to become truly aware of these issues and
change the course of our actions before the option is no longer available? The purpose of this study
is to raise awareness on the topic of Sustainability and Urban Farming, in order to actively involve
people and encourage them to be more environmentally-conscious. The aim of this study is to
stimulate the curiosity of the users and educate them in a noninvasive manner, while respecting
the surrounding space and public privacy. The goal is to establish regenerative ecosystems on
water, food, materials, energy and economy. I have looked into existing technologies such as
Vertical Gardening, Living Machines and Rain Water Harvesting as a source of inspiration for the
final concept. The optimistic goal was to find a way to bring city dwellers closer to nature and at
the same time protect the natural environment that surrounds urban settlements. The main notion
that I wanted to convey is that being less bad is not good enough.
Fig 3: Functional Breakdown for Vertical Farm
Approach to Study:
The whole purpose of this project is to create a better standard of urban life through the
establishment of more green areas dedicated to harvesting healthy food that requires minimum
transport. The creation of leisure gardens in the city would reduce the urban heat island effect,
absorb excess CO2 emissions, reduce noise levels, restore habitat to the suburbs, manage storm
water, provide educational and recreational public activities, and reclaim forgotten real estate. By
growing its own greens the city would go from being a parasitic consumption machine, to a self-
4 sustaining ecosystem. The creation of these green oases would offer jobs to the increasing
amount of unemployed farmers migrating from the countryside to the city, a relaxing getaway
from the stresses of a long working day, a possibility for disabled citizens to take part in social
activities and the elderly to feel useful and interact with people that share the same interests.
I began the early phases of my research by reading and writing about the topic of Sustainability
and focusing on different aspects of this vast field. This gave me a general picture from which I
was able to properly segregate. After reading Dr. Dickson Despommier’s The Vertical Farm I
decided to work with the growing movement of urban agriculture, for the same reasons that were
stated above. The topic fascinated me, but I felt like I knew little or nothing about it. I began doing
case studies on existing examples of vertical gardens, automated farming, hydro-, aero-, and
aquaponics, Living Machines, Window Farming, Guerilla Gardening, and all sorts of other new
My research continued with case studies of relevant examples in which urban spaces had been
repurposed or used in a more practical manner. I examined the work of a group of architects from
the late 60s who focused on sustainability through projects involving green design and interaction
with the public. SITE architects base their work on communication systems, the natural sciences
and energy conservation in order to create a new architectural language that connects with the user
in a deeper way. A notion of stimulating the interest of the user, in the same way that SITE’s aim
was to make people think about the meaning of a certain architectural choice or element is
necessary. The goal was to not go unnoticed and this was achieved by bring conceptual architecture
into the suburban areas. Although the aesthetics were questionable but attitude and intention of
buildings like the Rainforest Showroom in Hialeah Florida are still admired in which nature is the
central theme. The building is seen as an intricate part of the landscape and therefore must give
Although just a concept, one of SITE’s most interesting proposal was the experimental High-Rise
Housing, which consisted of a structure of about twenty stories that would be located in the densely
populated city center. The building would include stores, parking spaces and housing for mixed
income residents. These houses would be grouped in a neighborhood like manner on the various
floors, which in turn would be supported by a matrix of steel beams and concrete. A central
elevator provides access to the individual houses, gardens, and interior streets. The purpose of the
experimental High-Rise Housing was to question the tradition of monotonous and faceless multi-
story buildings, which characterized the rationalistic architecture of the Twentieth Century,
causing the city’s inhabitants to hide behind bland and expressionless facades. “As an alternative,
the High-rise of Homes offers residents a unique opportunity to achieve an individual statement of
identity. The purpose is to shift the premises for aesthetic evaluation in high-rise buildings away
from orthodox design continuity, in favor of the artistic merits of collage architecture, based on
land comes an imminent and inevitable problem: How will we feed all of these people in a
sustainable way, without using up the earth’s resources? Experts believe we will reach a world
population of over 9 billion before the year 2050. If we were to rely on traditional agriculture that
would require adding cropland the size of Brazil to the existing farmland, which summed up is
already the size of the entire continent of South America. We are losing 1 percent of our topsoil
per year, due to traditional agriculture methods. These methods are unsustainable because they
focus on extracting as much as possible from the land, without giving back the precious nutrients
that the soil requires in order to support crop growth. Another disadvantage of traditional
agriculture is the fact that it requires vast amounts of space, water and natural sunlight. This, along
with the increase in demand, forces farmers to resort to petrochemical fertilizers, which contribute
even more to the destruction of farmlands. Eliminating crop diversity in favor of monoculture
crops drastically reduces the amount of beneficial insects, therefore increasing crop vulnerability
to pests and requiring the use of pesticides. A large amount of the sprayed pesticide runs off into
the groundwater and ends up polluting water sources. The yield to energy input ratio of such a
process is extremely low and inefficient, making agriculture one of the major contributors to global
warming.
Many organizations, scientists and private companies are working to find sustainable solutions to
these problems. Thanks to them we now have advanced technologies such as hydroponics which
produces much higher yields than traditional agriculture, using up to 99 percent less water without
the need for soil and making use of space in a three-dimensional way. Because the nutrients are
provided directly through the water, which stays in the system and can be reused, no pollution is
released into the environment. Another advantage is that crops can be grown indoors, thereby
providing year-round cycles that are not dependent on seasonal weather patterns.
CASE STUDY
By Lauren Rothman
A century ago, Newark, New Jersey's Ironbound neighborhood was a bustling center of industry,
home to factories that mixed up Benjamin Moore paint, brewed Ballantine beer, and, of course,
manufactured the steel and other metals from which the district takes its name. Today, most of
the area's industry has dried up, and many of the former factory sites have been converted into
modern homes and apartments. But the neighborhood stands to regain some of its productive
past with the arrival of AeroFarms, a ten-year-old aeroponics company that's moving into a huge
former steel factory to grow level upon level of quick-to-mature, sustainable greens and herbs.
Agriculture who developed the company's low-waste, high-yield growing system. Aeroponics is
both soilless and sunless, and can be thought of as next-level hydroponics: Instead of utilizing
gallon upon gallon of water to grow plants, AeroFarms' system sprays plants with a nutrient-rich
mist. Seeds are sown, germinated, and grown on reusable sheets of fabric, which are stretched
out over trays that are stacked vertically and will fill 69,000 square feet of space in the Newark
factory. LED lights stand in for the sun, and their strength is adjusted according to the plants'
maturity.
Marc Oshima, AeroFarms' chief marketing officer, says these combined factors make the
productive than a hydroponic greenhouse," he says. "We use over 95 percent less water than
"Even versus a hydroponic grower, we're able to use less water and less nutrients, and also have
a much faster growing process," Oshima continues. "We can take that exact same seed that, out
in the field, would take 30 to 45 days to grow, and we can grow it in 12 to 16 days. We're talking
about between 22 and 30 crop turns a year; out in the field, you're lucky if you can get three crop
turns." Aeroponics can be used to grow any type of produce, Oshima says, but over the years
AeroFarms has zeroed in on shortstemmed leafy greens, in order to maximize the amount of
trays that can be stacked up inside the vertical farm. (Plants like tomatoes and peppers, for
example, grow too tall to be efficiently stacked.) The Newark farm will grow hundreds of
varieties, Oshima says, and even conventional growers have taken note.
Fig 5: World’s largest Vertical Farm in New Jersey
1. Xiao Ping Songa, Hugh T.W. Tana, Puay Yok Tan – “Assessment of light adequacy for
vertical farming in a tropical city”
Methodology - Study was to evaluate the spatio-temporal characteristics of PAR for growing leafy
vegetables at high-rise vertical spaces, using tropical Singapore as a case-study location. Chinese
cabbage and lettuce were grown & correlate with naturally grown ones. Leaf photosynthetic
responses were measured using an open-flow CO2 gas exchange system (LI 6400, Li-Cor Inc.,
Lincoln, Nebraska, USA) fitted with the standard leaf chamber, CO2 injector system and red/blue
LED light source (6400–02 B LED). Measurements were made upon the maturation of each crop
type, within the edible phase of the growing period. Measurements were taken for the youngest
mature leaves of three different individuals per crop type from 0800−1700 h. To derive the light
response curve, stepwise changes made in PPFD were made in the following order: 250, 100, 50,
25, 250, 500, 750, 1000, 1500, 2000, 2500 μmol m−2 s −1 . In order to create stable measurement
conditions, measurements were made under a block temperature of 28 °C, constant CO2 level of
360 μmol mol−1 , and an air-flow rate adjusted between 300 and 500 μmol s−1 to reduce the effect
of humidity on measurement error. Leaves were allowed to acclimatize for 2–5 min at each PPFD
Conclusion - Survey of PAR conditions along the façades of public housing apartment buildings
with basic linear & L- shaped configurations show that PAR increased gradually with building
height, but remains highly influenced by façade orientation and building forms. Chinese cabbage,
and lettuce require moderate amounts of light. The result suggested that building façades that
experience a minimum of half-day direct insolation will support the growth of vegetables that
seedling production as well as on vegetable crop production was studied. Crop management
recommendations were made for Quebec growers and nowadays all lettuce growers use
supplemental lighting.
Conclusion - The photosynthetic yield of HPS Lamps was found to be 34% more than natural
lighting. Energy consumption per kg of crop produced and carbon dioxide release into
environment reduced on use of HPS Lamps. The intercropping system under supplemental lighting
is promising for year round production of vegetables. However for such an energy and capital
3. Ahmad Mohammadi Ghehsareh, Samira Khosravan & Ali Asghar Shahabi – “The
soilless culture”
Methodology - This study was conducted to analyze use of different nutrients on the growth of
cucumber. A total of 3 Nutrient solution were tested on identically growing cucumber under a
media mixture of Cocopeat and Perlite. Plant height, stem diameter, intensity of leaf color, leaf
area index, stiffness of fruit tissue, yield of fruits, dry matter weight were measured in every
treatment of nutrient solution. (Refer fig 6 for composition of different nutrient solutions).
Conclusion - Comparison of means of cucumber fruit yield showed that there are no significant
difference between solutions No 3, 2 and 1. The results showed that No 3 nutrient solution had
most effect on the intensity of leaf color, stem diameter, plant height and leaf area index as
compared with other nutrient solutions during the growth season. No 2 nutrient solution had most
effect on the weight of plant dry matter, weight of fruit dry matter and stiffness of fruit tissue. The
height of cucumber plants in treatments had no significant difference. The comparison of stem
diameter means showed that No 3 and 2 nutrient solutions had significant difference at 5% level
with No 2 solution but it had not any significant difference with No 1 nutrient solution at 5% level.
The results showed that stiffness of fruit tissue in No 3 and 1 nutrient solution had not any
significant differences but between No 3 and 2 nutrient solutions had significant difference
Techniques”
Methodology - The paper discusses about the vertical farming structure, where it has to be
completely made off with advanced technology such as, hydroponic system, artificial lighting
Conclusion - The vertical farming system has various methodologies, it is an eco-friendly process,
and we can cultivate variety of crops all year around. Multiple crops can be cultivated in this
process and in occurrence of heavy rains crops being in an enclosed building possess no risk or
damage. Water can be recycled multiple times and used again as water is passed over hydroponics
system and the excess amount of water is collected and recycled. It is a fully eco-friendly technique
where new kinds of crops can also be developed easily in vertical farming system and the plants
or crops which are grown under vertical farming are free from pesticides and thus are pure, fresh,
Methodology - Dr. Dickson Despommier’s design was used as basis for this research. In this
design light is used to cultivate crops inside the building and water is pumped throughout the
building for hydroponic culture. Solar panels are placed on roof and on facades. Therefore using
this design energy flow demand and generation was quantified. The purpose of quantifying energy
demand was to test whether renewable energy sources would be able to provide such amount of
energy.
Conclusion - Lighting and water pumping throughout the building are the two main energy
demands. The feasibility and plausibility of the vertical farming concept from a socio technical
mixed method research perspective was examined. This includes developing multifunctional
designs with input from engineers, architects and vertical farming technology providers
simultaneously in order to help design future structures that can adapt to the 21st century needs,
developing pilot programs where real time data can be collected and analyzed in order to examine
where opportunities and barriers exist compared to conventional produce developing a large model
that can take more factors into account and conduct a techno economic study that incorporates
construction and maintenance costs. Vertical farming does hold potential in right circumstances.
Fig 7: Composition of Nutrient Solution as discussed in 3rd Research Paper
Some Effective Vertical Farms around the World:
We can conclude that even a little knowledge and awareness of VF can help food security and
viability greatly. New technologies such as aeroponic systems, insulation methods and pest free
plant growth has not only transformed the greenhouse industry but has also paved the way for new
forms of farming such as rooftop farming. In apartments and office buildings, creative climate
management technologies and natural light management technology helped to save energy and cut
down on greenhouse gas distribution These have all made local food production in highly
populated city areas possible, where more people require more food and their needs cannot be met
VF has got numerous advantages over traditional farming, which includes more efficiency,
adaptability, and environmental benefits, which is all made possible through carefully controlled
systems of VF. In VF, no waste or pollution is involved, it enjoys high levels of potentiality. All
the above-mentioned benefits in a single system seems rather unbelievable, but VF has made it
possible. If its use becomes common and widespread across the globe, the fear of starvation will
also disappear and detrimental climate change will slow down too. Practically all famous Vertical
Farms were situated in cities with more than 150,000 populations. Europe and North America have
the biggest part of sustainable food production, while in high density Asian cities, like Hong Kong
Tokyo and Kuala Lumpur, the focus seems to be on improving the sustainable food production
In addition, VF has provided new opportunities for architecture and urban designing. Urban
designers have attested to the importance of making cities green, healthy and safe. By combining
food production and architecture, VF helps to produce buildings capable of multiple functions.
[1] Xiao Ping Songa,, Hugh T.W. Tana, Puay Yok Tanb , Urban Forestry & Urban Greening
volume 28, Assessment of light adequacy for vertical farming in a tropical city, 2018, Retrieved
from : https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1618 866717304156
[2] Dr. Martine Dorais, Canadian Greenhouse Conference, Use of Supplemental Lighting for
Vegetable Crop Production, 2003,
Retrieved from: https://www.agrireseau.net/legumesdeserre/Documents/ CGC
[3] Ahmad Mohammadi Ghehsareh, Samira Khosravan & Ali Asghar Shahabi, Journal of Plant
Breeding and Crop Science, The effect of different nutrient solutions on some growth indices of
greenhouse cucumber in soilless culture, 2011,
Retrieved from:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/268347123_The_effect_of_different_nutrient_solution
s_on_some_gr owth_indices_of_greenhouse_cucumber_in_soilless_cu lture
[5] Malek Al-Chalabi, Sustainable Cities and Society, Vertical Farming: Skyscraper
Sustainability, 2015,
Retrieved from: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2210670715000700
[6] Project Report by Daniel Philip Veenboer on Vertical Farming, Graduation Project in
Collaboration with Konstfack University College, 2012,
http://www.diva-portal.se/smash/get/diva2:530359/FULLTEXT01.pdf
[7] Fatemeh Kalantari, Osman Mohd Tahir, Raheleh Akbari Joni And Ezaz Fatemi, Journal of
Landscape Ecology. Opportunities And Challenges In Sustainability Of Vertical Farming: A
Review, June 2017,
Retrieved from:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/319248372_Opportunities_and_Challenges_in_Sustain
ability_of_Vertical_Farming_A_Review
[9] Steiner AA (1984). The universal nutrient solution, in Proceedings Sixth International
Congress of Soilless Culture, The Hague, The Netherlands. pp. 633-650.
[10] Marilou P. Pascual, Gina A. Lorenzo, Arneil G. Gabriel, Open Journal of Ecology, 2018, 8,
25-41, Vertical Farming Using Hydroponic System: Toward a Sustainable Onion Production in
Nueva Ecija, Philippines, 2018,
Retrieved from: https://www.scirp.org/Journal/PaperInformation.aspx?PaperID=81678
[11] Per Pinstrup-Andersen, Journal of Global Food Security, Is it time to take vertical indoor
farming seriously?, 2014,
Retrieved From: www.elsevier.com/locate/gfs
[12] Yap Shien Chin and Lukman Audahb, American Institute of Physics, AIP Conference Proceedings
1883, 020021, Vertical Farming Monitoring System Using the Internet of Things (IoT), 2017,
Retrieved from: : https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5002039
[13] Banerjee, Chirantan, 2014. Up, up and away! the economics of vertical farming. J. Agric. Stud. 2 (1).
Cox, Stan, 2016. Enough with the vertical farming fantasies: There are still too many unanswered questions
about the trendy practice.
Retrieved from: http://www.salon.com/2016/ 02/17.
[14] Devlin, Hannah, 2017. Plants modified to boost photosynthesis produce greater yields, study shows.
〈https://www.theguardian.com/science/2016/nov/17〉.
[15] Gabriel, A.G., Claudio, E.G. and Bolisay, F.A. (2017) Saving Dupinga Watershed in Gabaldon, Nueva
Ecija Philippines: Insights from Community Based Forest Management Model, Open Journal of Ecology,
Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.4236/oje.2017.72011
[16] Guanlao, A.H. (2011) House Bill No. 720; Urban Agriculture Act of 2013, Sixteenth Congress, First
Regular Session. Bagasina-Cabreara, C. (2011) Urban Agriculture Act of 2011. House of Representatives
(Congress), Quezon City
[17] White, J. (2010) Sky-Field: A Vertical Farming Solution for Urban New York. Architecture Theses,
Paper 40.
Retrieved from: http://docs.rwu.edu/archthese/40
[18] Tilman, D., Cassman, K., Matson, P., Naylor, R. and Polasky, S. (2002). Agricultural Sustainability
and Intensive Production Practices. Nature , 418, 671-677.
Retrieved From: https://doi.org/10.1038/nature01014
PAPER PUBLISHED COPY
PaperID: IJSRDV5I120383
Publishedin: Volume:5,Issue:12
PublicationDate: 01/03/2018
Page(s): 1056-1059
IJSRD - International Journal for Scientific Research & Development| Vol. 5, Issue 12, 2018
| ISSN (online): 2321-0613