Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MDMA-Assistive Psychotherapy As Treatment For PTSD
MDMA-Assistive Psychotherapy As Treatment For PTSD
Psychotherapy as
Treatment
for PTSDD
By:
Noah Carlin
The Feasibility of MDMA-Assistive Psychotherapy as Treatment for
Posttraumatic Stress Disorder in Veterans
Noah Carlin
Department of English
Florida State University
ISC 4404, Section 002
April 09, 2019
Word Count: 3,302
Cover Photograph: U.S. Air Force photo by Master Sgt. Kevin Milliken
Table of Contents
ii
List of Figures
Figures
Figure 1: Prolonged Exposure Therapy Image ................................................................................2
Figure 2: CPT Treatment Structures ................................................................................................4
Figure 3: RU Pharmacotherapy Recommendations .........................................................................5
Figure 4: RU Pharmacotherapy Recommendations .........................................................................6
Figure 5: MAPS Phase II Clinical Trial Dose .................................................................................7
Figure 6: MAPS MDMA-Assistive Psychotherapy Treatment Structure .......................................8
Figure 7: MAPS MDMA-Assistive Psychotherapy Phase II Clinical Trial Results .......................9
Figure 8: Long-Term Results ...........................................................................................................9
iii
Executive Summary
According to the Department of Defense/ Veterans Affairs, veteran suicide rates have been
steadily rising since 2005—with more than 6,000 suicides committed per year since 2008. These
are just the reported cases; there are thousands more veterans living with PTSD and struggling
everyday to manage symptoms of the disorder. Until recently, psychotherapy and
pharmacotherapy have been the only available treatment options for PTSD.
Pharmacotherapy
If MAPS Phase III trials go as projected, and MDMA-assistive psychotherapy is approved by the
FDA for prescription, there are still several socioeconomic hurdles to jump through before the
treatment becomes a viable option for a large, diverse population. However, based on strong
statistical evidence emerging from MAPS Phase I and II trials, MDMA-assistive psychotherapy
has enormous therapeutic potential in the treatment of PTSD, and should be considered as
treatment—especially for veterans—in the near-future.
iv
1 Introduction
“I did not want to get close to my new babies for fear I may get deployed again. A big piece of
me wanted to go back to battle because the battlefield made sense; coming home to emails,
memorandums and unit “politics” did not. I also knew that if I went back, a bigger piece of me
did not want to come back home again.” – U.S. Army Chaplain (Maj.) Carlos C. Huerta
For tens of thousands of veterans, the horrors of war pale in comparison to what happens when
they finally return home from the war-zone. Soldiers have been conditioned to the high-strung
anxieties of battle and grown physiologically used to dealing with very traumatic events on a
daily basis. When they return home where danger isn’t lurking around every corner and things
are far slower and safer, they often experience intense feelings of disillusionment, paranoia,
frustration, fear, and alienation. These feelings mimic the kinds of hair-trigger reactions soldiers
are expected to have in a fire-fight, but that serve no practical purpose once back at home.
I am referring to the symptoms associated with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). If not
properly addressed, these issues can spiral into intense psychosocial issues manifesting in any
number of debilitating and horrific ways.
According to data collected by the Department of Veteran Affairs, there’s been a steady increase
in veteran suicide rates since 2005—with more than 6,000 committed per year since 2008
(Department of Defense/VA). PTSD is the biggest contributing factor to this increase. This is a
problem not just for those afflicted with PTSD, but for the rest of American society as well.
Without proper treatment, PTSD can render veterans unable for reintroduction as productive
members of society, and creates a need for them to be cared for in ways they cannot handle on
their own. The scope of this report is to glimpse a recent method of treatment with far higher
success rates than current models have yielded: looking at MDMA-Assistive Psychotherapy as a
treatment option for people suffering from PTSD.
This report utilizes peer-reviewed studies about recovery rates for PTSD patients treated with
Processing Therapy, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, pharmacotherapy, and MDMA-assistive
psychotherapy. The goal is not to demonize any particular method of treatment, rather it is to
analyze therapeutic potential to see if there is a confluence of treatment available that would
alleviate the hardships for those currently afflicted with PTSD.
1
2 Current Treatment Options
For those currently living with PTSD, there are a few available treatment options that require
long-term commitment for the patient, physicians and therapists involved in treatment process.
Popular options include Prolonged Exposure Therapy (PE), Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
(CBT), pharmaceutical intervention, and often involve a confluence of therapy and
pharmaceuticals before patients see results.
PE typically includes 8-12 sessions lasting 1.5 hours, supplemented with two hours of daily self-
practice and phone contact between sessions. (Powch, 2011) Within the context of therapeutic
guidance, the trauma survivor approaches the trauma memory long and often enough to
emotionally process the trauma and experience a reduction in anxiety and fear-responses so that
new learning pathways can be built to better understand the trauma, the fear-response, and
eventually to disassociate the trauma from the fear-response. (Foa and Kozak 1986)
2
PE has been shown to be one of the most effective treatments for PTSD in individuals that are
able to stick with the regimen co-created by the therapist and patient to effectively treat the
disorder: “Recovery rates in psychotherapy randomized clinical trials can reach 70–80% among
individuals who complete treatment…. However, dropout plagues virtually every treatment trial,
leading to average recovery rates in intent-to-treat analyses of only around 40%.” (Hog et. al.,
2014)
Treatment drop-outs occur due to a wide array of factors: from patients feeling like they can
manage on their own, to work interference, related mental illness, lack of therapeutic benefit,
insufficient time, stigma, etc. (Najavits, 2015)
3
CPT typically includes 12
weekly sessions consisting
of cognitive therapy and
exposure therapy that
focuses on learning new
skills to challenge
assimilated and over-
accommodated beliefs
surrounding the trauma
memory. (Watkins et. al.,
2018) Within the context of
therapeutic guidance, the
trauma survivor learns about
the psychoeducational tools
required to appropriately
reframe and approach the
traumatic memory, and how
to utilize those tools to
Figure 2: CPT Treatment Structures. Source: Dept. of Veterans Affairs Medical updated cognitive structure.
Center. The goal is to equip the
patient with the necessary
knowledge to alter their maladaptive beliefs and replace them with adaptive, accommodated
beliefs. (Watkins et. al., 2018) Although CPT was introduced as trauma therapy for rape victims,
it has shown to be equally effective across all types of trauma populations.
Treatment drop-outs are also an issue for CPT, especially due to the long duration of time in the
entire recovery process. Drop-outs occur due to a wide array of factors: from patients feeling like
they can manage on their own, to work interference, related mental illness, lack of therapeutic
benefit, insufficient time, stigma, etc. (Najavits, 2015)
2.3 Pharmacotherapy
Along with regular psychotherapy, there are many people who opt for a pharmaceutical
approach. However, this is more often than not recommended in conjunction with some form of
trauma psychotherapy. Pharmacotherapy alone is generally not recommended; pharmaceutical
medications can potentially alleviate several prominent symptoms of PTSD, they do not address
the psychological root of the trauma. (Watkins et. al., 2018) Among the types of drugs
prescribed to treat PTSD, some common ones are:
Antidepressants:
o Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors (SSRIs); Selective
Norepinephrine Reuptake Inhibitors (SNRIs); Monoamine Oxidase
Inhibitors (MAOIs)
4
Antipsychotics and A-typical Antipsychotics
Benzodiazepines:
o Alprazolam (Xanax), Diazepam (Valium), Clonazepam (Klonopin)
Antidepressants in particular have been shown to mitigate several symptoms of PTSD, and have
proven to assist with the treatment of PTSD in randomized-controlled trials when compared to
placebo. (Sullivan and Neria, 2009)
Antipsychotics have not proven as well on their own: “Overall there is little empirical evidence
supporting use of atypical antipsychotics as monotherapy in PTSD, and data on use as an
augmentation strategy to SSRIs is equivocal.” (Sullivan and Neria, 2009)
Benzodiazepines have had surprisingly few studies conducted regarding their effectiveness in the
treatment of PTSD. In fact, in the one study I could find the authors concluded that, “Symptoms
specific to PTSD were not significantly altered.” (Braun, et al.)
5
Figure 4: Pharmacological medication recommendations for pharmacotherapy treatment of PTSD according to
Neuroscience research at Rutgers University. Source: Brain Alliance of New Jersey, 2016
The danger with some of these medications is even when they are effective, they rarely produce
zero side effects. According to Harvard Health online medical journal, among the most common
antidepressant side effects are sexual problems, weight gain, feeling emotionally numb/distant,
increased feelings of sadness, caring less about other people, and suicidal thoughts. (Harvard
Health, 2019)
Apart from side effects, these medications can be toxic if they’re mixed improperly, if they’re
combined with alcohol or other recreational drugs, and when they’re not taken in proper
intervals—which is especially dangerous, as stopping cold-turkey dramatically increases the risk
for suicide.
3 MDMA-Assistive Psychotherapy
MDMA (3-4 Methylenedioxymethamphetamine) is a psychoactive stimulant developed by
MERCK pharmaceuticals in 1912. MDMA experienced brief therapeutic use in the 1950s and
60s. However, responding to an outbreak in recreational usage, the DEA parked it the list of
controlled substances as a Schedule-I drug in 1985. Until recently, the only evidence supporting
MDMA has been largely anecdotal, as it has not been researched or deemed appropriate for
medical use.
6
In 2010, MAPS (Multidisciplinary Association for Psychedelic Studies) began researching the
therapeutic potential of MDMA-assistive psychotherapy in controlled trials on a group of
volunteers diagnosed with PTSD. MDMA is used as only part of the healing process, and works
to enhance the effectiveness of typical psychotherapy for those receiving treatment for PTSD.
Figure 5: Therapeutic dose of MDMA for MAPS Phase II Clinical Trials. Source: MAPS, 2014
Regular pharmacotherapy requires long-term daily medicating that will often numb the
symptoms of PTSD without addressing the disorder directly; MDMA-assistive psychotherapy
treatment lasts only 10 weeks, directly addresses the psychological root of the disorder, and
allows the patient to encounter the trauma-memory without the cognitive fear-response
associated with the traumatic event.
7
3.1 Maps Phase I & II Clinical Trials
Figure 6: MAPS MDMA-Assistive Psychotherapy Treatment Structure and Results. Source: MAPS, 2014
The most recent Phase II Clinical trials, which ended in 2016, were conducted in this manner:
Subjects were administered either MDMA or placebo during two, eight-hour sessions conducted
3-5 weeks apart, along with weekly psychotherapy sessions. The subjects administered MDMA
or placebo had been living with PTSD for upwards of 20 years. The results between the placebo-
groups and the MDMA-administered group are extremely promising. (MAPS, 2019)
8
After three psychotherapy sessions with MAPS therapists, the treatment-resistant placebo-control
group experienced a 23% success rate in the treatment of PTSD symptoms two-months post-
treatment. The MDMA-administered group experienced a 61% success rate in PTSD symptoms
two-months post treatment. A full year after treatment, the MDMA-administered group reported
a 68% recovery rate. 3.8 years post-treatment, the MDMA-administered group continues to
report that the benefits of MDMA-assistive psychotherapy have been maintained over time.
(Hausfield, 2019)
Figure 7: MAPS MDMA-Assistive Psychotherapy Treatment Phase II Clinical Trial Results. Source: MAPS, 2016
Despite the Phase II trials being conducted with only a few hundred participants, the results are
undeniably promising. They show that given the proper therapeutic setting, guidance, and
education, MDMA-assistive psychotherapy is a safe and incredibly effective treatment option for
those healthy enough to participate.
9
According to MAPS website, “Phase 3 trials will take place at 14 research sites in the U.S.,
Canada, and Israel. Participants in the main portion of the trial will be randomized to receive
three sessions of either MDMA or placebo in conjunction with psychotherapy over a 12-week
treatment period, along with non-drug preparatory and integration sessions (three each).”
(MAPS, 2019) The Phase III trials follow similarly from the Phase II trials, except this time with
three doses of MDMA being administered three to five weeks apart. (MAPS, 2019)
If the results from Phase III trials mimic the results from Phase I and II, we could easily start
seeing MDMA-assistive psychotherapy being prescribed by the early 2020s.
So far, the challenges stem from what happens after MDMA-assistive psychotherapy is approved
for prescription. Because MPAS is the only organization this close to gaining FDA approval,
they will hold all the cards as to how efficient the progression of MDMA-assistive therapy into
the socioeconomic zeitgeist will be. If clinics are to begin to pop up around the United States,
there need to be enough MAPS-trained therapists to supplement them, and because this treatment
is so new and specialized, it is also going to be expensive. According to MAPS founder Rick
Doblin, Phase III MDMA treatment protocols call for twelve sober therapy sessions, with three
MDMA sessions; a total between 42-60 hours of treatment. (Hausfield, 2019) It’s projected that
initial costs for treatment with MDMA-assistive psychotherapy could run around $15,000.
(Hausfield, 2019)
5 Conclusion
10
Simply put, PTSD is a debilitating disorder affecting thousands of veterans in the United States,
that if left unchecked can lead to severe psychosocial issues and suicide. PTSD has high
healthcare costs and and current psychotherapy treatments like Prolonged Exposure Therapy and
Cognitive Processing Therapy have proven to be effective at treating the root psychological
trauma of PTSD, but often experience high patient drop-out rates. When it comes to long-term
treatment of the disorder, the effects of psychotherapy alone are not always reliable. Current
models also rely on pharmaceutical intervention, which is problematic on two levels: this keeps
the patient tethered to the drug, or rather to the pharmaceutical company, for (sometimes) the rest
of their life; the drugs used to treat PTSD are often effective at alleviating symptoms of the
disorder, but do not address the root psychological trauma whence the disorder stems. This
creates lots of new pharmaceutically-reliant patients, but a low number of those that actually
recover.
Due to compromising legislation, there hasn’t been much research on the therapeutic benefits of
MDMA since the 1960s; now all of that is rapidly changing. If MAPS Phase III clinical trial
results follow their projections, MDMA-assisted psychotherapy clinics could start opening
around the United States by the early 2020s. Upon FDA-approval for prescription, the initial
socioeconomic hurdle of making MDMA-Assisted Psychotherapy both affordable and accessible
to a diverse population of peoples will be the next big challenge. Large-scale socioeconomic
change does not happen overnight—especially when federal legislation is evolved. However,
with the majority of patients who received MDMA-assistive psychotherapy having recovered at
remarkable rates (and still rising post-treatment), I think MDMA-Assistive Psychotherapy is the
future for treating PTSD in the United States.
11
References
Brain Injury Alliance of New Jersey Follow. (2016, May 19). Neurobiology, Diagnosis &
Treatment of PTSD & TBI in Veterans. Retrieved from
https://www.slideshare.net/BrainInjuryAllianceo/neurobiology-diagnosis-treatment-of-
ptsd-tbi-in-veterans
Foa E. B., Kozak M. J. (1986). Emotional processing of fear: exposure to corrective information.
Psychol. Bull. 99, 20–35. 10.1037/0033-2909.99.1.20
Harvard Health Publishing. (2014, March). What are the real risks of antidepressants? Retrieved
from http://www.health.harvard.edu/newsletter_article/what-are-the-real-risks-of-
antidepressants.
Hausfield, R. (2019, February 15). The Future of MDMA: Phase 3 and Beyond. Retrieved from
https://www.psymposia.com/magazine/future-of-mdma-phase-3-and-beyond/
Hausfield, R. (2019, March 27). MDMA Expanded Access is almost here. What's it all about?
Retrieved from https://www.psymposia.com/magazine/mdma-expanded-access
Hoge CW, Grossman SH, Auchterlonie JL, Riviere LA, Milliken CS, Wilk JE. PTSD treatment
for soldiers after combat deployment: low utilization of mental health care and reasons
for dropout. Psychiatr Serv. 2014;65:997–1004. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.201300307.
Huerta, C. C. (2012, April 25). Leaving the battlefield: Soldier shares story of PTSD.
Retrieved from
https://www.army.mil/article/78562/leaving_the_battlefield_soldier_shares_story_of_ptsd
Institute of Medicine. 2012. Treatment for Posttraumatic Stress Disorder in Military and Veteran
Populations: Initial Assessment. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
https://doi.org/10.17226/13364.
12
Moving Beyond PTSD. (2013, May 08). Retrieved from
https://www.acc.af.mil/News/Features/Display/Article/203810/moving-beyond-ptsd-
help-is-available/
Najavits L. M. (2015). The problem of dropout from "gold standard" PTSD therapies.
F1000prime reports, 7, 43. doi:10.12703/P7-43
Powch, I. (n.d.). Irene Powch, Ph.D. Portland State University and Mental Illness Research,
Education and Clinical Center, Northwest June 16, ppt download. Retrieved from
https://slideplayer.com/slide/5760960//
Resick, P. A., & Schnicke, M. K. (1992). Cognitive processing therapy for sexual assault
victims. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 60(5), 748-756.
Stein DJ, Ipser JC, Seedat S. Pharmacotherapy for post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2006
Sullivan, G. M., & Neria, Y. (2009). Pharmacotherapy of PTSD: Current Status and
Controversies. Psychiatric annals, 39(6), 342–347. doi:10.3928/00485713-20090515-01
Watkins LE, Sprang KR, Rothbaum BO. Treating PTSD: A Review of Evidence-Based
Psychotherapy Interventions. Front Behav Neurosci. 2018;12:258. Published 2018 Nov
2. doi:10.3389/fnbeh.2018.00258
13