Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Senior Project Paper
Senior Project Paper
Designer Without the Price: How Counterfeit and Knock Off Products Affect The Economy and
Designers
Reagan N. Bonniwell
Abstract
This paper talks about the controversial topic of counterfeit and knock off products of
designer and high end brands. The author begins by explaining the difference between
counterfeit and knock offs and the trouble many individuals and stores go through everyday if
they are caught with these products. The author also explains the negative and positive impacts
on the companies and economy due to the sales of these fake products. There are many ways
authorities and companies can prevent people from going to jail or being sued for producing
counterfeits and knock offs. Finally, the author talks about many recent cases that involved retail
stores being sued for trademark and copyright infringement, and health problems people have
Imagine you’re walking through the streets of New York City and you come across
amazing deals on your favorite designer products. People come up to you offering Chanel bags,
Gucci belts, or Tiffany jewelry for around the price of $60. You may think they’re real, you may
think they’re not, but what you may not know is that these products are illegal. The prices of
these products too good to be true because they are not actually made by designers, but criminals
overseas. Counterfeiting is when a product is made that looks exactly the same as a well known
brand. The product is considered to be a counterfeit once the name or logo of another brand is
placed onto the product. The production and selling of counterfeit products is illegal, and if an
individual is caught making or selling the products, they can be charged and prosecuted.
Counterfeiting has been an issue for many years that has just recently started to be investigated.
Clothing and accessories are not the only thing that can be counterfeited. Many high end makeup
products are starting to be copied as well. Counterfeit products are very controversial because
some may not affect the consumer in any way, but some have been known to cause health
problems. It is very difficult for authorities to catch people who make and sell counterfeit
products. While there are some people getting charged and sentenced for adding a brand’s name
to a similar looking product, there are people getting around the law by making products that are
knock offs. Knock offs are products that look similar or include similar aspects to a designer
product, but it does not have the designer’s logo on it. There are still legal issues the producers of
knock offs have to get around, such as trademark laws. Companies will sue other companies for
trademark infringement if they feel one of their products has been copied. Another legal issue
companies struggle with is copyright infringement. Sales of counterfeit and knock off products
DESIGNER WITHOUT THE PRICE 4
do not only affect the designers directly, but it affects the economy as well. While the economy
and designers are getting affected negatively, there are also benefits to counterfeits and knock
offs being sold. Counterfeit products of designer brands hinders designers and their company by
selling products with their logo or similar looking products, which reduces the sales and profit
Many designers around the world are experiencing a decrease in their sales due to the
production and buying of counterfeit and knock off products. Consumers look at a variety of
factors when choosing between designer and knock off products such as price, uniqueness, and
quality. Counterfeits and knock offs are being sold at a much lower price, which consumers tend
to gravitate towards. Another major factor that determines whether designers will be successful
in sales is whether their product is unique or not. If there are products being sold that look
exactly like theirs and has their logo on it, that means there are more of the same products all
around and people are less likely to buy the designer’s if they can get it at a cheaper price. Some
producers of counterfeits may also make and sell the same product recently after it has been
released in designer stores and this can negatively affect the sales of designers (Muller, 2013).
However, if there a large gap between the time the designer starts selling their product and the
time the counterfeit is sold, profits made by designers are less likely to be affected (Muller,
2013). If the product is in high demand and is on trend, they are most likely going to buy the
product that is less expensive. Over the years, the quality of counterfeit items have improved
dramatically. They used to fall apart shortly after purchasing them, or you could tell the
DESIGNER WITHOUT THE PRICE 5
difference between the material or fabric used. Today, the stitching and material used for bags,
belts, and many other products look very similar, if not exactly the same, as the designer product
Production and sales of counterfeit goods helps promote the design of the designer
product. If someone who is able to afford the designer sees the counterfeit product, they are most
likely going to buy the real product and not the fake one. Even if the costumer ends up buying
the counterfeit, they are still advertising the brand when others see them with the product
(Sprigman, 2012). Even though there are jobs being lost for the high end companies, there are
also jobs being created overseas. Individuals in other countries are struggling to find jobs to
support their families, and this gives them the opportunity to work in a factory or selling the
The United States is not the only country that is being affected by the sales of counterfeit
products. Countries all over the world are experiencing a decline in their economy due to the
production and sales of counterfeits. The sales of counterfeits has led to the sales in Europe to go
down by nearly ten percent (Bain, 2015). There is a decrease in need for certain jobs like
manufacturing and retail in many countries. If sales of counterfeits start to increase, designers
may have to let go of a few of their workers because they are not able to pay them since the
profit they are making is low. This starts a ripple effect in the economy. If an individual loses
their job, they are are going to focus their spending on necessities and are less likely to spend a
DESIGNER WITHOUT THE PRICE 6
lot of money on things they do not need. Businesses are negatively affected if people are losing
their jobs because fewer products are being bought, which means their profit is decreasing as
well (Bain, 2015). The government is being affected by the sales of counterfeits as well.
Counterfeit products are not taxed since they are being sold under the table, which hurts the
government (FindLaw, 2018). Counterfeit products are made overseas in factories where child
labor is promoted and is not illegal. While people of all ages work in these factories, they hire
children in order to keep the number of workers high, which allows production to go by quicker
Counterfeit products are being produced overseas in countries that are not fully
developed. Individuals in other countries, that are still developing or not developed at all, are
struggling to find jobs to support their families, and this gives them the opportunity to work in a
factory or selling the product on the streets all around the world. The individuals who are
working in these factories are experiencing poor working conditions and get paid a very small
amount (Shepherd, 2016). When consumers buy counterfeit products, they are contributing to the
money these workers are making in order to provide for themselves and their families. Poor labor
conditions is not something many people want to support, but these workers need to make money
somehow. The sales of counterfeits and knock offs shows the public what is in high demand and
China is the known to be the most popular country to make counterfeit goods. All the
products sold in the United States and other countries come from China. The products they sell
DESIGNER WITHOUT THE PRICE 7
vary from shoes,which is the most produced product, designer clothes, jewelry, and other
accessories. They are able to find loopholes around the laws, like copyright, and are able to keep
it under wraps from the law enforcements. They make it hard for the authorities to catch them in
the action of selling the products, which is why the cost of investigations are so expensive. With
their skills of being able to keep under the radar and making a large amount of sales, they are
able to make approximately two billion each year. As the year goes on, it said that their sales and
profit should increase by 25 percent (Proquest, 2009). China is also very successful because they
sell through countries that lack strong security, like Syria, and countries that are big in trading,
Legal Implications
Trademark Laws
Trademark laws are used by individuals and companies to keep their logos and symbols
safe from other people using them on their products. If an individual is infringing on someone’s
trademark, that means they most likely produced a counterfeit product. This can get people into
some financial and legal troubles if they are caught by the authorities or sued by a company. If
someone is sued for trademark infringement that means they must go to court and argue their
case on why they believe they were not infringing. Many companies will try and make a
Getting a trademark on a product is a long process that takes three steps. First, companies
have to make sure the thing they want to trademark is unique to them and not generic. Next, the
companies have to file a form through the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office and pay $375.
Lastly, the trademark office has to make sure the trademark is not already taken or there isn’t
DESIGNER WITHOUT THE PRICE 8
else like it that isn’t trademarked. The process could take up to a year if the file was filled out
correctly, but if it isn’t filled out correctly, it could take longer than a year (C. Herrick, personal
Copyright Laws
Copyright laws keep an individual’s work safe from being copied by another person. It is
very similar to trademark laws, however the only difference is that copyright laws apply to
artwork. This can still apply to designer companies because they will copyright their designs and
art to make sure other people do not use it without the owner getting compensation. Many people
and companies get into legal trouble because they will print someone’s artwork onto their
There was an artist who had experienced copyright infringement in the past when Hot
Topic took one of her art designs and included them on their products. While her designs were
not completely copyrighted yet, she was in the middle of the process and still is able to sue for
infringement. She recently is experiencing copyright infringement again when she discovered
another store, Zara, had used her work on some of their products as well. When she goes to court
with these stores she will sue them and have the chance of getting compensation from the sales
sentencing and fines vary based on the amount of times they have been prosecuted for the same
thing in the past or the number of counterfeit products they are found with. For the first offense,
the sentencing can be up to a maximum of ten years in prison. The individual can be fined up to
DESIGNER WITHOUT THE PRICE 9
two million dollars. A second offense can lead to twenty years in prison and a fine of five million
Federal Authorities
Catching people who produce and sell counterfeit goods is very difficult for authorities
and expensive. Being able to point out counterfeit products is difficult for many reasons. One
main reason it is difficult to spot fake designer products is that the quality has improved. Along
with the improved production of the products, the packaging has improved as well. For example,
the box a fake Gucci belt comes in looks exactly like the box a real one would come in. Since the
quality of counterfeits have improved and they look exactly like the real product, people buying
these products are not going to turn in the seller. Another factor is that the products are made
overseas and once they are shipped out and received in other countries they are difficult to track.
The factories overseas lack good security, which is used to make sure that the products being
made are legal. Lastly, counterfeit products are not only sold on the streets around the world.
People are now able to sell the products online through websites like Amazon and Ebay. This
allows them to stop selling and delete their account whenever they feel they may get caught.
They are also able to make new accounts to sell on if they delete their original account (Addison,
2018).
Recently, federal authorities have overcome the difficulties and found five people who
have been producing and selling counterfeit goods. They produced over 70 million dollars worth
of counterfeit Nike Air Jordans. The shoes would not have been considered counterfeit products
when they were originally made because they did not include the Nike or Jordan logo. However,
after the shoes went through customs, when being shipped from China, the logos were then
DESIGNER WITHOUT THE PRICE 10
added to shoes which makes them illegal (Sherman, 2018). Another issue involving an individual
selling counterfeit goods took place in Miami, Florida. A undercover detective discovered that a
man was selling counterfeits and kept them in the back of his store. He was selling brands like
Gucci and Louis Vuitton, over a six month period. The worth of the amount of products in the
back room are equivalent to a retail price of almost ten million dollars. The man was arrested and
In the court case Louis Vuitton Malletier v. Haute Diggity Dog, Louis Vuitton tried suing
Haute Diggity Dog for copyright infringement. Haute Diggity Dog is a company that sells
products for pets, such as dog beds, chew toys, and bags to carry the pets in. The product Louis
Vuitton had a problem with was a chew toy that included a design and pattern similar to one of
the designer’s bag. They also had an issue with the name of the toy, which is “Chewy Vuitton.”
This case was taken to the United States Court of Appeals, and they ruled in favor of Haute
Diggity Dog. The court said that company was not infringing Louis Vuitton’s copyrights in any
way. Also, the sale of the chew toy should not affect the sales of the designer bags in any way.
The chew toys are not counterfeit products that are being sold for a cheaper price. If anything, it
could promote the designer’s brand and possibly help their sales (Louis Vuitton Malletier v.
Forever 21
Forever 21 is a retail store that sells trendy clothing for an affordable price. Many of their
products are inspired by designer brands, which has gotten them in a lot of legal trouble over the
years. They have been sued multiple times for issues like trademark infringement. Their products
DESIGNER WITHOUT THE PRICE 11
are very controversial because they have details that are similar to designer brands, but they also
include details that make it unique. While they have been sued for trademark infringement, they
have fought back hard and requested the courts to dismiss some companies trademarks.
Forever 21 v. Gucci
Gucci had reached out to Forever 21 requesting them to stop using their stripe patterns,
like green-red-green. Forever 21 then took Gucci to court asking for the removal of Gucci’s
trademarks on the stripes. They argued that the stripes were generic and consumers do not
automatically associate them with Gucci. They also argued that the trademark was a monopoly
over the stripes. Gucci argued that Forever 21 was infringing on their trademark. The court ruled
in favor of Gucci, which allows them to keep their trademark on the stripes. However, Forever
21 is still able to sell products with similar stripe patterns because they have small details that are
Adidas v. Forever 21
Adidas is known for including three stripes on clothing and other products. Forever 21
has recently been producing garments like leggings with stripes along the side that mimic Adidas
products. Adidas had reached out to Forever 21 stating that they would sue the retail store.
Forever 21 requested the court to explain to Adidas that they were not impeding on any
trademark laws. Adidas then filed a lawsuit on Forever 21 for trademark infringement for the
stripes and argued that there were products, like leggings, that looked so similar to their products
that they could pass as counterfeits (The Fashion Law, 2017). Forever 21 is selling shoes that
include two gold stripes on the side and a gold heel, which is another product Adidas is suing
over because of the similarity to one of their products. Forever 21 then made a counter-suit
DESIGNER WITHOUT THE PRICE 12
arguing to the court that Adidas will sue anyone for trademark infringement for any number of
stripes on an article of clothing. However, they ended up dropping the counter-suit and settled
Puma v. Forever 21
Singer Rihanna came out with a line with Puma and released different style of shoes. One
of many styles that Forever 21 copied was a slide on with satin bows on top. Forever 21 makes
products that look similar, if not exactly the same, to appeal to the consumers looking for a less
expensive product. Puma sued Forever 21 for copyright infringement and design patent. The case
went to the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California (The Fashion Law, 2017).
Forever 21 argued that there are many companies that sell similar looking products. The court
ruled in favor of Forever 21 because there were small details on the shoes that were not included
and there were new details added to the design (Cohen-Nowak, 2017).
Beauty
Counterfeit products are not strictly accessories and clothes. Many high end makeup
brands are being turned into counterfeit products. However, the difference is the quality is
nowhere near the quality of the real product. These products are not as pigmented and have
caused health problems due to the ingredients used to make it. There have been animal feces and
bacteria found in the counterfeit products. Consumers have been experiencing bad reactions like
rashes, to the ingredients put in these products. The people who sell the products are getting
away with it because the products are either being sold online through fake websites and other
websites like Ebay and Amazon. Also, there are streets around the world that are known for
selling counterfeit makeup, but the authorities have not done anything about it (Robin, 20180 .
DESIGNER WITHOUT THE PRICE 13
Kylie Jenner released lip kits in 2016 and has expanded to selling other makeup products.
Since she has made such a large profit, many people have started making counterfeit products
from her line in hopes of making a lot of money. Kylie reached out to her fans and buyers of her
products on twitter to let them know that they could only purchase her products through her
website. If any products were being sold on other websites like Amazon that meant they were
fake. The counterfeit products are being made with products that are causing negative reactions.
One woman who bought a fake lip kit experienced a swollen face and blistering lips.
When McLaughlin woke up the next morning, she was struggling to breathe and the
lower half of her face was dramatically swollen."I lost all feeling around the bottom of
my face, and my lips continued to grow bigger from when I first saw them," McLaughlin
told Belfast Live, which originally published images of the counterfeit products affect on
her lips. "It was the scariest experience ever."McLaughlin's family, including her
21-year-old sister, Bronagh, rushed her to the hospital. "We took her to [Royal Victoria
Hospital] on Saturday morning and they took her in straight away and got her seen to as
soon as possible. They gave her extremely strong antibiotic cream for her lips and some
antihistamines," said Bronagh, who wants to help her sister spread awareness about the
potential dangers of counterfeit cosmetics. Bronagh is focused less on how the counterfeit
lipstick affected her sister's appearance and more on how seriously it could have affected
her health. "My aunt is a nurse and she said that if she [Rachael} wasn't young and didn't
have such a strong immune system you wouldn't know what could have happened,"
Bronagh said, urging people not to purchase unverified makeup products (Robin, 2018).
DESIGNER WITHOUT THE PRICE 14
James Charles, a famous youtuber and beauty guru, has experienced similar problems as
Kylie Jenner. He recently came out with a eyeshadow palette in late 2018 and people are already
producing and selling counterfeit palettes. Days after finding out about the fake palettes being
sold, he uploaded a video on youtube of him using one that he had bought. Since the counterfeit
makeup products are not as similar to the actual product like clothing and accessories are, there
are details that prove the products are counterfeit. There were minor mistakes on the packaging
and the names of the color eyeshadows were different. As he tested the products he noticed that
some of the shades were not even close to what the shades included in the real palette looked
like. He did a tutorial using both palettes, using one on each eye. There was clearly a difference
in how they applied to the lids of his eyes. The pigmentation was not as noticeable as the colors
used on his eye from his palette. Since the counterfeit palette has just recently come out, there
has not been any complaints about reactions from using the product. Only time can tell whether
or not there will be any health problems after using the product consistently. James did mention
that him and his legal team will be finding a way to take down anyone selling these fake palette
These counterfeit makeup products are not only hurting Kylie Jenner and James Charles’s
sales but they are hurting the people using it and their self-esteem. Beauty products are made to
enhance girls’ features and make them feel insecure about any blemishes. Counterfeit makeup
products are doing the complete opposite by causing reactions and other health problems. Kylie
and James are not the only people whose products have been copied. High end brands like Urban
Decay and NARS are going through the same thing. Those counterfeit products also include
DESIGNER WITHOUT THE PRICE 15
ingredients that are not meant to be put on the skin and can cause irritation and other health
Conclusion
Counterfeiting designer brands has been a problem for a while but has increased over the
years. It has gotten harder for authorities to pick out the differences between real products and
the counterfeits because the quality has improved. Many people have gotten away with
producing and selling counterfeit products because the security at customs is very lenient. If the
security becomes stricter it may be easier for authorities to catch people in the act and stop them
before they are able to sell the products. This issued does not only need to be solved for the
purpose of helping designers, but in order to keep those safe from the harmful ingredients used
when making some products. Stricter security would also keep the sales of counterfeit products
from hurting the economy and the risk of people losing their jobs. Another major issue is retail
stores selling products that look very similar to designers but do not include the designer’s logo
on it. These stores have a better chance of not getting into legal trouble, however there are still
some stores who do end up getting sued for trademark or copyright infringement. Their court
cases are now precedents for any similar cases that happen in the future.
DESIGNER WITHOUT THE PRICE 16
References
Addison, G. (2018, June 26). Top 5 reasons why counterfeit goods are getting
https://www.ipwatchdog.com/2018/06/26/
top-5-reasons-counterfeit-goods-getting-harder-spot/id=98645/
Bain, M. (2015, July 22). Fakes are costing Europe's fashion industry 10% of its
sales and thousands of jobs. Retrieved November 18, 2018, from Quartz
website: https://qz.com/460932/
fakes-are-costing-europes-fashion-industry-10-of-its-sales-and-thousands-of-jobs/
Batchelor, A. (2018, January 24). Man accused of selling counterfeit goods out
https://www.local10.com/news/crime/
man-accused-of-selling-counterfeit-goods-out-of-back-room-at-west-miami-store
Bell, B. (2016, July 15). What's wrong with buying fake luxury goods. BBC.
Cartwright, J. (2016, December 2). What every designer needs to know about
https://eyeondesign.aiga.org/
what-young-designers-need-to-know-about-copyright-law/
Charles, J. (2018, December 18). I bought a FAKE James Charles palette [Video
Volume%20107/Issue%20No.%206/vol107_no6_c1_cohen-nowak.pdf
Fernandez, C. (2017, November 7). Gucci wins latest rounds in legal battle with
news-bites/gucci-wins-latest-round-in-legal-battle-with-forever-21
Gucci sues Forever 21 for trademark infringement. (2017, August 10). CBS News.
gucci-sues-forever-21-trademark-infringement-bomber-jacket/
Gucci sues Forever 21 for trademark infringement. (2017, August 10). CBS News.
gucci-sues-forever-21-trademark-infringement-bomber-jacket/
Jackson, A. (2018, April 15). Police find animal waste in counterfeit makeup--
so it's not such a bargain after all. CNN News. Retrieved from
https://www.cnn.com/2018/04/15/health/counterfeit-makeup-seizure-lapd-trnd/
index.html
Louis Vuitton Malletier v. Haute Diggity Dog, LLC, No. 06-2267 (4th Cir. ).
scholar_case?case=4935710713295512983&q=counterfeit+products+of+designer+brands+&
hl=en&as_sdt=6,47
the-short-and-long-term-impacts-of-fashion-knockoffs-on-original-items/
Nowadays, counterfeit goods are "almost identical" to the real thing. (2018, May
24). Retrieved November 24, 2018, from The Fashion Law website:
http://www.thefashionlaw.com/home/
counterfeit-goods-are-almost-identical-the-the-real-thing
Phau, I., & Teah, M. (2009). Devil wears (counterfeit) prada: A study of antecedents and
Pithers, E. (2017, June 8). Forging ahead. Retrieved November 18, 2018, from
fake-designer-goods-counterfeit-pieces
Puma files patent, copyright, trade dress suit against Forever 21 over Rihanna
shoes. (2017, April 3). Retrieved December 10, 2018, from The Fashion Law
website: http://www.thefashionlaw.com/home/
puma-files-design-patent-copyright-trade-dress-suit-against-forever-21-over-rihan
na-footwear
Raustiala, K., & Sprigman, C. (2012, September 5). Why knockoffs can help build
http://freakonomics.com/2012/09/05/why-knockoffs-can-help-a-strong-brand/
https://consumer.findlaw.com/consumer-transactions/
buying-counterfeit-goods-laws-and-resources.html
Robbins, L. (2018, August 16). Investigators seize fake luxury goods worth half
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/16/nyregion/fake-luxury-goods-handbags.html
Robin, M. (2018, February 14). Woman says a counterfeit Kylie Cosmetic lip kit
caused this horrifying allergic reaction. Retrieved December 21, 2018, from
counterfeit-kylie-cosmetics-lip-kit-allergic-reaction
Shepherd, W. (2016, March 9). 7 great things about buying counterfeit. Retrieved
supply-chain/7-great-things-about-buying-counterfeits
Sherman, T. (2018, August 7). They allegedly imported $70M of fake Nike Air
Jordans. Then the feds dunked on them. Retrieved November 25, 2018, from
they_allegedly_imported_70m_of_fake_nike_air_jordans_then_the_feds_dunked_on_them
.html
Suokas, J. (2016, April 18). China is the world's biggest producer of fake
china-worlds-biggest-producer-fake-goods-oecd-says
A timeline of the ugly battle between Adidas v. Forever 21. (2017, July 21).
http://www.thefashionlaw.com/home/
a-timeline-of-the-ugly-legal-battle-between-adidas-v-forever-21
Updated: Adidas has filed suit against Forever 21, amidst existing strife
between the two. (2017, July 18). Retrieved December 14, 2018, from The
adidas-has-filed-suit-against-forever-21-amidst-existing-strife-between-the-two