Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cdi1 Fundamentals of Criminal Investigation
Cdi1 Fundamentals of Criminal Investigation
Other Terminologies
Motive - It refers to reason that impels a person to commit criminal act for definite result.
Intent - It is the accomplishment of the criminal act.
Inductive Reasoning - It forms a general conclusion after further investigation and evidence gathering.
Deductive Reasoning - It forms a general conclusion prior to having a complete explanation based on facts.
Passive Effect - the criminal may bring away something with him from the crime scene.
Active Effect - the criminal might have left something on the crime scene.
Cold Case - It is a dormant case where a suspect or witness has the luxury or ample time to mull over the ramifications of the case and to put their alibi or
defense or otherwise form subjective impression of the case.
Hot Case - It is the violation of law has just been unearthed or discovered and the suspects or the witnesses to the case are still emotionally upset or excited.
INVESTIGATOR/PROBER – is the key figure in the crime investigation who is charged with the duty of carrying on the threefold aims of crime investigation.
His/her primary job is to discover whether or not an offense has been committed under the law, after determining what specific offense has been committed.
Qualities of good investigator:
1. The ability to persevere or stick to task despite of the monotony and the many obstacles which surrounds it.
2. He must have certain abilities and an intelligence which would enable him to acquire information easily and readily and to
use this information truthfully.
3. He must be honest. He must be incorruptible and must possess personal integrity.
4. He must have understanding (weaknesses and strength) of the people and the environment where he/she lives.
5. He must have a keen power of observation and accurate description.
2. Legality - That the evidence should be gathered in the manner prescribed by the Constitution, existing laws, “jurisprudence rules and regulations such as:
a. 1987 Constitution
b. R.A. 7438
c. Rules on Criminal Procedure
d. Supreme Court ruling as: “Just been committed” “fruits of poisonous tree” etc.
B. Accounts or Testimonies of Witnesses – accuracy of the identification by eyewitness accounts would depend on the following factors:
1. Ability to remember the distinct appearance of the subject.
2. Prevailing conditions of observation and visibility when the crime was committed.
3. Lapse of time in the identification process.
C. Circumstantial Evidence - It is the identification established indirectly by proving other facts or circumstances from which the identity of the perpetrator
can be inferred. This evidence is sufficient to produce conviction when:
1. there are more than one circumstances
2. the facts from which the inferences derived are proven
3. the combination of all the circumstances is such as to produce a conviction beyond reasonable doubt
MODUS OPERANDI
Major General Llewely Atcherly devises the first modus operandi file. It is a human nature that personal habit and mannerism do not change easily but
remains with the individual for years. It signifies the method of operation or the distinct manner of how crimes are committed by known criminals. It includes
nature of stolen property, description, observation at the scene, motive, time and peculiarities.
Physical Evidence - It comprises all objects and materials in connection with an investigation that are instrumental in discovering the facts. It can
prove that the crime has been committed or establish by element of the crime, establish the identity of the suspect, exonerate the innocent, corroborate the
victim’s testimony; lead to admission or confession; more reliable than the statement of witness; and provide useful information.
Kinds of Physical Evidence
1. Corpus Delicti – objects or substance which are essential parts of the body of the crime.
2. Associative Evidence – it links the suspect to the crime scene or offense.
3. Trace Evidence – articles that can establish the physical contact of suspect with the victim to probe his physical presence in the crime scene.
4. Indirect/circumstantial evidence - evidence which tends to incriminate a person such as footprints found at the scene.
The Photographer’s Note - Notes are valuable not only as an aid to an accurate recall of events to be testified to in court, but also to furnish the raw material
needed in the written formal report of the case. A different notebook/photo log should be used for each separate case and it should be kept permanently in a
safe place.
Photo Log:
-Name of the photographer - Date photos were taken
- Name of the logger - Type of investigation
- Case number - Time photo taken
- Date of incident - Location of photo Click me for sample crime scene photos
Types of Measurements
1. TRIANGULAR COORDINATES
2. RECTANGULAR COORDINATES
3. BASELINE COORDINATES
Types of Sketch
1. Rough – made by the prober at the crime scene. No scale proportion is ignored and everything is approximated. It is to be used as a basis of the finished
sketch.
2. Finished – made primarily for courtroom presentation. All elements of sketching must be present.
Rules for Sketching
1. Never forget to determine the direction of the compass. Draw it on the sketch.
2. Control measurements. Do not rely on others to give them.
3. Do not draw things where are clearly irrelevant to the case.
4. Never rely on memory to make corrections at the station, or any other place removed from the scene of the crime.
5. The scale must be drawn on the sketch. If the camera has been used, mark its position on the sketch.
THE CRIME SCENE SEARCH - The Search for physical evidence is done using the accepted methods of search depending upon the actual location to be
searched. A Crime Scene Search could only be started after it has been photographed and sketched. There is no hard and fast rule as to the specific method of
search to be employed. Situation will decide as to what method is to be employed. Any method is correct but the search must be orderly, optimistic and
thorough. The main objective of crime scene search is to systematically look for physical evidence that may prove useful in establishing that a crime has been
committed.
Recognition of Physical Evidence At the crime scene, the prober must exercise keen observation and extreme care in his search for these physical evidence.
The success of the case will depend heavily on how the prober conducts himself in handling those pieces of evidence. He has to do his job well at “proper time”
and “proper place”. Proper time refers to when he is right there in the scene and proper place refers to him being right there at the scene.
The Chain of Custody The establishment of the identity and the number of persons who handle evidence between the time of commission of the offense to
the ultimate disposal of the case.
B. INTERROGATION It refers to the elicitation of information from an individual who refuses to provide information.
Limitation on Interrogation Section 12 of Bill of Rights of the 1987 Constitution providing the suspect/person under custodial investigation the
right to remain silent. ***Remedy – Waiver of Section 12 which must be signed in the presence of counsel.
Rules in Questioning:
1. One question at a time – multiple questions are confusing
2. Avoiding implied answer – suggesting answer defeats the purpose of interrogation.
3. Simplicity of the questions – long, complicated and legalistic questions are confusing and irritating which may cause embarrassment and resentment.
4. Saving Faces – embarrassing situation on the subject by ridicule to the stupidity, poor judgment and other deficiencies should be avoided.
5. Yes and No Questions – do not insist on a yes or no answer that will result to inaccurate answers and prevent flow of information.
6. Positive Attitude – a positive way of questioning and approach should be employed.
CUSTODIAL INVESTIGATION Republic Act 7438 – an act defining certain rights of persons arrested detained or under custodial investigation as well as
duties of the arresting, detaining, and investigating officers, and providing penalties for violations thereof.
Rights of Persons Arrested, Detained or Under Custodial Investigation
1. Any person arrested, detained or under custodial investigation shall at all times be assisted by counsel.
2. Inform the subject in a language known to and understood by him, of his rights to remain silent and to have a competent and independent
counsel, preferably of his own choice. If such person cannot afford the services of his own counsel, he must be provided with a competent and
independent counsel by investigating officer.
3. Custodial investigation report shall be reduced to writing by the investigating officer, provided that before such report is signed, or thumb-
marked if the person arrested or detained does not know how to read and write, it shall be read and adequately explained to him by the counsel
or by the assisting counsel provided by the investigating officer in the language or dialect known to such arrested or detained person, otherwise
such investigation report shall be null and void and of no effect whatsoever.
4. Any extra judicial confession made by a person arrested, detained or under custodial investigation shall in be writing and signed by such person
in the presence of his counsel or in the latter’s absence, upon a valid waiver, and in the presence any of the parents, elder brothers or sisters, his
spouse, the municipal mayor, municipal judge, district school supervisor, or priest/minister of the gospel as chosen by him; otherwise such
extrajudicial confession shall be inadmissible as evidence in any proceeding.
5. Any waiver by a person arrested or detained under the provisions of Art. 125 of the Revised Penal Code, or under custodial investigation, shall be
in writing and signed by such person in the presence of counsel, otherwise the waiver shall be null and void and of no effect.
6. Any person arrested or detained or under custodial investigation shall be allowed visits by or conferences with any member of his immediate
family, or any medical doctor or priest or religious minister chosen by him or by any member of his immediate family or by his counsel, or by any
national non-governmental organization duly accredited by the Commission on Human Rights or by International non- governmental
organization duly accredited by the Office of the President. The person’s immediate family shall include his/her spouse, fiance or fiancee, parent
or child, brother or sister, grandparent or grandchild, uncle or aunt, nephew or niece and guardian or ward
DECISION
The Court overturned Miranda’s conviction, stating that police interrogations are, by their very nature, coercive and therefore deny suspects their
constitutional right against self- incrimination by “forcing” them to confess. Consequently, any person who has been arrested and placed in custody must be
informed of his or her right to be free from self-incrimination and be represented by counsel during any interrogation. In other words, suspects must be told
that they do not have to answer police questions. To accomplish this, the Court establish the Miranda warning which must be read prior to questioning of a
suspect in custody.
7. Taking Sworn Statements of the witnesses. The execution of a suspect’s “WAIVER” as stipulated in Art 125 of RPC shall always be done in the presence of
his chosen counsel or any independent counsel.
9. Preparation of reports and filing of Charges – The Investigator on Case shall submit the following:
a. Spot Report within 24 hours to higher headquarters
b. Progress Report
c. After Operation Report
d. Final report after the case is filed before the prosecutor office/court (Referral)
e. Accomplishment Report
TERMS TO PONDER
Admission - is a voluntary acknowledgment, confession, or concession of the existence of a fact or the truth of an allegation made by a party to the suit.
Associative Evidence - is evidence that ties a suspect to the crime scene, the victim,or some other bit of evidence. Fingerprints, footprints, hair, fibers, blood
and other bodily fluids, knives, bullets, guns, paint, and many other objects and substances,even soil, can link a suspect to the scene.
Bugging - is the act of concealing a miniature microphone in (a room or telephone) inorder to eavesdrop on or record some one's conversations secretly.
Burned - when an investigator has been exposed. The target has become aware that he is being watched.
Circumstantial Evidence - also known as indirect evidence. It is distinguished from direct evidence, which, if believed, proves the existence of a particular
fact without any inference or presumption required. Circumstantial evidence relates to a series of facts other than the particular fact sought to be
proved.
Confession - A confession in criminal investigation may be defined as an out-of-court statement by a suspect in which he or she voluntarily, knowingly and
intelligently acknowledges that he or she committed or participated in the commission of a crime.
Corpus Delicti - the facts and circumstances constituting a crime. Concrete evidence of a crime, such as a corpse.
Deposition - in Criminal Investigation,is a formal written statement, made for example by a witness to a crime or by the perpetrator of a crime.
Eavesdropping - is secretly or stealthily listening to the private conversation of others without their consent.
Ibid - is a latin word, it is the short for ibidem. It means in the same place. It is the term used to provide an end note or footnote citation or reference for a
source that was cited in the preceding end note or footnote.
Investigare - is a Latin word which means to track or trace by footprint and to study or examine closely.
Felony - a higher level crime usually punishable by more than one year in prison.
Jonathan Wild - was a London underworld figure during the 1600's notable for operating on both sides of the law, posing as a public-spirited crime fighter
entitled the "Thief-Taker General".He was a thief employed to catch a thief.
Loc. Cit. - is a footnote or end note term used to repeat the title and page number for a given work (and author).
Misdemeanor - a lower level crime, usually punishable by less than one year in prison.
Sit On - conduct a stakeout or stationary surveillance.
Tail - to conduct a moving surveillance.
Trace - means to find or discover by investigation.
US Secret Service - created on July 5, 1865. Original mission was to suppress the production and distribution of counterfeit currency. After the assassination
of President William McKinley in 1901, they took their role of presidential protection.
Wiretapping - is the practice of connecting a listening device to a telephone line to monitor conversations secretly.