Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Economist Explains
The Economist Explains
"#$ÿ&'()(*+,-ÿ$./01+),
234ÿ67898:;<=ÿ4>?@A;9<
BCDÿFCGHÿIJKLMÿNGLHCOÿPJGÿKLPGOLGPQ
RSTUÿWXTUÿTUYÿZ[Y\Tÿ]S[Y^\__ÿ\`aÿTUYÿZX_aY`ÿbUSY_a
opqÿstuvuwxyzÿq{|}~xvy
c?dÿee9fÿeghijÿklÿ6mnm
ÿ
ÿÿ
ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ
ÿ
ÿ
ÿÿ
¡ÿÿÿÿ¢£ÿÿÿÿ¤¥ÿ¦ÿÿ§
ÿ̈©ªÿÿ«
ÿÿ¢
«ÿÿ¢ÿ«
ÿÿ¬£ÿ
ÿ
ÿ§
ÿ«
ÿÿÿ¥ÿ
¦¤ÿÿÿÿ®ª®ÿÿ
«¤ÿ£ÿ¦¤ÿ«
ÿÿÿ¬
ÿ
¯
ÿ¬ÿ¤
ÿÿÿ¤ÿ¯¤ÿÿ
ÿÿ¤ÿ
ÿ
¢ÿ«£ÿ
1199988
8188
1245 1401251898
8 51!
012312456 789ÿ8
ÿÿ
8ÿÿÿÿÿ88
ÿ
"#$ÿ&'()*ÿ&#$+ÿ,"ÿ-'.$/ÿ"'ÿ,+"$(+$"ÿ0--$//1ÿ02"$(ÿ3(0+ÿ0+*ÿ4560ÿ7"#'58#ÿ"#,/ÿ(0+9,+8ÿ$:-)5*$/
"#'/$ÿ;)0-$/1ÿ/5-#ÿ0/ÿ<'("#ÿ='($01ÿ&#$($ÿ'(*,+0(>ÿ;$';)$ÿ0($ÿ+'"ÿ0))'&$*ÿ"'ÿ5/$ÿ"#$ÿ,+"$(+$"
0"ÿ0))?@ÿA'&ÿ*'$/ÿ4#,+0ÿ-$+/'(ÿ"#$ÿ,+"$(+$"B
C#$ÿ4#,+$/$ÿ-$+"(0)ÿ8'D$(+.$+"ÿ#0/ÿ"&'ÿ.0,+ÿ&0>/ÿ'2ÿ-'+"(')),+8ÿ�"ÿ,"/ÿ-,",E$+/ÿ/$$ÿ'+ÿ"#$
&$6Fÿ"#$ÿG($0"ÿH,($&0))1ÿ0/ÿ,"ÿ,/ÿ-0))$*ÿ6>ÿ2'($,8+$(/1ÿ&#,-#ÿ,/ÿ0ÿ/>/"$.ÿ'2ÿ),.,",+8ÿ0--$//ÿ"'
2'($,8+ÿ&$6/,"$/ÿ&#,-#ÿ/"0("$*ÿ,+ÿ"#$ÿ)0"$ÿIJJK/1ÿ0+*ÿ"#$ÿG')*$+ÿL#,$)*1ÿ0ÿ/>/"$.ÿ2'(ÿ*'.$/",-
/5(D$,))0+-$ÿ/$"ÿ5;ÿ,+ÿIJJMÿ6>ÿ"#$ÿN,+,/"(>ÿ'2ÿO56),-ÿL$-5(,">@ÿL$;0(0"$ÿ8'D$(+.$+"
*$;0(".$+"/1ÿ0)'+8ÿ&,"#ÿ)'-0)ÿ0+*ÿ;('D,+-,0)ÿ0*.,+,/"(0",'+/1ÿ0)/'ÿ#0D$ÿ"#$,(ÿ'&+ÿ.'+,"'(,+8
/>/"$./@ÿ4#,+0ÿ6$80+ÿ6>ÿ6)'-9,+8ÿ0ÿ),/"ÿ'2ÿ2'($,8+ÿ&$6/,"$/1ÿ,+-)5*,+8ÿP',-$ÿ'2ÿQ.$(,-01
#5.0+R(,8#"/ÿ'(80+,/0",'+/ÿ0+*ÿ/'.$ÿ2'($,8+ÿ+$&/;0;$(/@ÿS5"ÿ,"/ÿT)"$(/ÿ#0D$ÿ/,+-$ÿ6$-'.$
.'($ÿ/';#,/",-0"$*ÿ0+*ÿ-0+ÿ+'&ÿ/$)$-",D$)>ÿ6)'-9ÿ/;$-,T-ÿ;08$/ÿ&,"#,+ÿ2'($,8+ÿ&$6/,"$/1
(0"#$(ÿ"#0+ÿ.09,+8ÿ"#$ÿ$+",($ÿ/,"$ÿ,+0--$//,6)$@ÿC#$>ÿ-0+ÿ0)/'ÿ6)'-9ÿ;0(",-5)0(ÿ"$(./ÿ&#$+
"#$>ÿ0($ÿ5/$*ÿ,+ÿ/$0(-#ÿU5$(,$/ÿ'(ÿ,+/"0+"ÿ.$//08$/@ÿG''8)$ÿ,/ÿ+'"ÿ6)'-9$*ÿ$+",($)>Vÿ,+/"$0*1
5/$(/ÿ&#'ÿ/$0(-#ÿ2'(ÿ60++$*ÿ9$>&'(*/ÿ0($ÿ6)'-9$*ÿ2('.ÿG''8)$ÿ2'(ÿJKÿ/$-'+*/1ÿ"#'58#ÿ'"#$(
&$6/,"$/ÿ($.0,+ÿ0D0,)06)$@ÿ4#,+0W/ÿ.0+>ÿ,+"$(+$"ÿ-'.;0+,$/ÿ0($ÿ($85)0()>ÿ,//5$*ÿ&,"#ÿ),/"/ÿ'2
($/"(,-"$*ÿ9$>&'(*/1ÿ0+*ÿ'2"$+ÿ-$+/'(ÿ6)'8ÿ;'/"/ÿ0+*ÿ'"#$(ÿ-'+"$+"ÿ;($R$.;",D$)>ÿ"'ÿ0D',*
"('56)$ÿ&,"#ÿ"#$ÿ05"#'(,",$/@ÿ3+ÿ0))ÿ"#$($ÿ0($ÿ"#'58#"ÿ"'ÿ6$ÿ0('5+*ÿIKK1KKKÿ;$';)$1ÿ$.;)'>$*
6'"#ÿ6>ÿ"#$ÿ/"0"$ÿ0+*ÿ6>ÿ;(,D0"$ÿ-'.;0+,$/1ÿ;'),-,+8ÿ4#,+0W/ÿ,+"$(+$"ÿ0('5+*ÿ"#$ÿ-)'-9@ÿL,+-$
XKKYÿ"#$ÿ/"0"$ÿ#0/ÿ0)/'ÿ;0,*ÿ;$';)$1ÿ9+'&+ÿ0/ÿ"#$ÿZYKÿ4$+"ÿO0(">Z1ÿ"'ÿ;'/"ÿ;('R8'D$(+.$+"
.$//08$/ÿ0+*ÿ/"$$(ÿ'+),+$ÿ-'+D$(/0",'+/ÿ0&0>ÿ2('.ÿ/$+/,",D$ÿ"';,-/@
[\]ÿ_`aÿbcdefÿg\hie\]]\a
j;8(0*$ÿ>'5(ÿ,+6':ÿ0+*ÿ8$"ÿ'5(ÿk0,)>ÿk,/;0"-#ÿ0+*ÿl*,"'(W/ÿO,-9/@
ÿ
mnÿoÿ89
4#,+0W/ÿ-(,"$(,0ÿ2'(ÿ-$+/'(,+8ÿ"#$ÿ,+"$(+$"ÿ0($ÿ/),8#")>ÿ.'($ÿ/56")$ÿ"#0+ÿ2'($,8+$(/ÿ'2"$+
0//5.$@ÿ3+ÿ$//$+-$ÿ,"ÿ0;;),$/ÿ"#$ÿ(5)$/ÿ"#0"ÿ#0D$ÿ;($D0,)$*ÿ/,+-$ÿ"#$ÿC,0+0+.$+ÿLU50($
-(0-9*'&+ÿ'2ÿIJMJFÿ*'ÿ+'"ÿp$';0(*,/$ÿ/'-,0)ÿ/"06,),">1ÿ*'ÿ+'"ÿ'(80+,/$ÿ0+*ÿ*'ÿ+'"ÿ"#($0"$+ÿ"#$
;0(">@ÿQ--'(*,+8)>1ÿ-(,",-,/.ÿ'2ÿ.,*R(0+9,+8ÿ'q-,0)/ÿ,/ÿ"')$(0"$*1ÿ;0(",-5)0()>ÿ,2ÿ,"ÿ,/ÿ,+ÿ9$$;,+8
&,"#ÿ"#$ÿ8'D$(+.$+"W/ÿ0+",R-'((5;",'+ÿ*(,D$@ÿS5"ÿ0""0-9/ÿ'+ÿ"#$ÿ/$+,'(ÿ)$0*$(/#,;ÿ0($ÿ/&,2")>
($.'D$*ÿ7;('.;",+8ÿ4#,+$/$ÿ,+"$(+$"ÿ5/$(/ÿ"'ÿ($2$(ÿ"'ÿ/$+,'(ÿT85($/ÿ5/,+8ÿ+,-9+0.$/ÿ'(
-'*$*ÿ)0+8508$1ÿ,+ÿ0+ÿ$r'("ÿ"'ÿ/"0>ÿ0#$0*ÿ'2ÿ"#$ÿ-$+/'(/?@ÿC#$ÿ.'/"ÿ6(5"0)ÿ($/"(,-",'+/ÿ0($
1199988
8188
1245 1401251898
8 21!
012312456 789ÿ8
ÿÿ
8ÿÿÿÿÿ88
ÿ
2334567ÿ9:ÿ2;<ÿ3:=9ÿ9>29ÿ?244=ÿ@:Aÿ:B5;6ÿ3A:96=9=ÿ:Aÿ76C:;=9A295:;=D6E6;ÿ@:Aÿ3A:FG:E6A;C6;9
?2H=6=IÿJ>6ÿ?6;=:A=>53ÿ=<=96CK=ÿC25;ÿG:24ÿ5=ÿ9:ÿ3A6E6;9ÿ9>6ÿ5;96A;69ÿ@A:CÿL65;GÿH=67ÿ9:ÿ?:F
:A75;296ÿ:Aÿ:AG2;5=6ÿA624FM:A47ÿ3:4595?24ÿ2?95E59<IÿN;ÿ6O9A6C6ÿ?2=6=Pÿ5;96A;69ÿ2??6==ÿC2<ÿL6ÿ?H9
:Qÿ249:G69>6APÿ2=ÿ>2336;67ÿ@:Aÿ96;ÿC:;9>=ÿ5;ÿRSSTPÿ2@96AÿA5:9=ÿ5;ÿU5;V52;GPÿ2ÿA6C:96ÿ;:A9>F
M6=96A;ÿA6G5:;I ¯°±²±ÿ ÿ¡¢ÿ£¤ÿ¥
¤ÿ¦§ÿ¨ÿ«¤ÿ§³¤´ÿ©ÿª«¬ÿ£
N;ÿ=>:A9PÿW>5;2ÿ5=ÿ>2E5;Gÿ59ÿL:9>ÿM2<=Xÿ59ÿ5=ÿ244:M5;Gÿ59=ÿ?595Y6;=ÿ9:ÿL6;6Z9ÿ@A:Cÿ9>6ÿ=:?524ÿ2;7
?:CC6A?524ÿ2=36?9=ÿ:@ÿ9>6ÿ5;96A6 ;69ÿ9@HPÿ4M>
4ÿ2??54
66
==ÿ3ÿ9:42ÿb?c5d;ÿfGgÿh=i9hAjk
5?l9mÿ4E55C5
2ÿ3A95=;ÿ:9P;ÿ59=ÿH=6ÿ@:Aÿ3:4595?24ÿ2?95E5=CI
[9>6Aÿ2H9>:A592A52;ÿG:E6A;C6;9:=;ÿ4?5:;6;ÿ2=;577ÿ6:HAÿÿA2W>
ÿ2335;
A9 5 ?
=ÿ:2AK
46 = ÿ
@
ÿ=ÿ
=
A 6
52
G3
6
;3
I
ÿHA3:ÿ92:ÿ?
6>
;Vÿ :2<ÿC:764ÿ9:ÿL6ÿ6CH42967IÿJ>6A6ÿ5=
;:ÿ7:HL9ÿ9>29ÿC5?A:L4:G=ÿ=H?>ÿ2=ÿ\5;2ÿ]65L:Pÿ9>6ÿW>5;6=6ÿ6^H5E246;9ÿ:@ÿJM5996APÿ>2E6ÿG5E6;
9>6ÿ3HL45?ÿ2ÿ;6MÿE:5?6ÿM59>ÿM>5?>ÿ9:ÿ76C2 ;7 ÿÿ C:
ÿ¡A 6¢ÿ2ÿ£?
¤?
:ÿ¥H ;92L5459<ÿ @A:Cÿ:_?524=ÿ:;ÿ5==H6=
=H?>ÿ2=ÿ?:AAH395:;Pÿ@::7ÿ=2@69<ÿ2;7ÿ25Aÿ3:44H95:;Iÿ̀H9ÿ=:ÿ@2Aÿ9>6ÿG:E6A;C6;9ÿ>2=ÿC2;2G67ÿ9:
3A6E6;9ÿ9>6ÿ5;96A;69ÿL65;GÿH=67ÿ9:ÿ?2C3 ¦§ÿ2¨5G
ÿ©;ÿªÿ @«:A¬ÿ
LA :27ÿ¤
ÿ̈ 6A§ÿ3«®:4595?24ÿ?>2;G6IÿN;7667PÿL<
3A:E575;Gÿ36:346ÿM59>ÿ2;ÿ:H9469ÿ9:ÿE6;9ÿ9>65Aÿ?:;?6A;=ÿ2;7ÿG5E5;Gÿ9>6ÿ544H=5:;ÿ:@ÿ3HL45?ÿ76L296P
9>6ÿ5;96A;69ÿC2<ÿ6E6;ÿL6ÿ7642<5;Gÿ9>6ÿA275?24ÿ?>2;G6=ÿ9>29ÿW>5;2ÿ;667=I
aÿ]>29ÿ64=6ÿ=>:H47ÿbcdÿfghihjklmÿ6O3425;nÿ\6;7ÿH=ÿ<:HAÿ=HGG6=95:;=I
opqrstÿvttwÿxytÿwtzv{
wpzÿ|}v~pstÿxytÿvxp
69ÿ5;?5=5E6ÿ2;24<=5=ÿ:;ÿ9>6ÿ5==H6=ÿ9>29ÿC2996AIÿ]>69>6Aÿ<:HÿA627ÿ62?>ÿ5==H6ÿ?:E6A
9:ÿ?:E6APÿ45=96;ÿ9:ÿ9>6ÿ2H75:ÿ67595:;ÿ:AÿG:ÿL6>5;7ÿ9>6ÿ>62745;6=ÿ:;ÿ<:HAÿ3>:;6Pÿ95C6
M59>ÿbcdÿfghihjklmÿ5=ÿ24M2<=ÿM644ÿ=36;9I
ÿÿÿÿ ÿ
"#$ÿ&'()(*+,-ÿ$./01+),
1199988
8188
1245 1401251898
8 1!
0123122
456344 56278 5 789ÿ8
ÿÿ
8ÿÿÿÿÿ88
ÿ
"#$ÿ&&'(ÿ&)*+,ÿ-.ÿ/010
9:;<:ÿ>?@<ÿABC>:C>
¢£¤¥¦§¤̈©ÿ*&ÿ}}zÿW$ÿ*&
DEFGHÿJKLÿNOPQPRSTU W$ÿzYZ'ÿ[#ÿWÿ}'ªW.ÿ ÿ{$Y~X}zÿ$}}
HÿGÿÿHFÿJKLÿNOPQPRSTUÿÿH
FÿÿFGÿÿFÿÿGÿHFÿF
ÿHÿ
[-z~$Y-}ÿ*&ÿ}}zÿW$ÿ*&
VWWXY'Zÿ[#
\]^]_`abÿdefgh]giÿ̀ajkghÿ_lfÿmja^hÿ]dÿnjjo]gi
pRLqSOrÿrQsÿtKSQrÿrqLÿOPRRSUUSQuÿvrTUÿTwRTÿUPÿUKLSqÿrqRLsÿxPqOLT
"ÿyY$[zÿ{|Y(ÿyYWX}'~}
lfÿnj^`ÿjk_naf`ÿ]gÿjgijÿ]dÿif__]giÿmjadf
{$X}-.
1199988
8188
1245 1401251898
8 01!
012312456 789ÿ8
ÿÿ
8ÿÿÿÿÿ88
ÿ
nopqrrsturÿwtoxÿyozs{
#$%&'()%*ÿ®¯ÿZGG°QÿKTLÿ±®¯
TLÿQN²UÿaRÿHTÿGU³TYÿJÿMLHNOPGQÿKLGG
ÿÿÿÿÿ|LMQSa
Q ÿ¡¢ÿ£¤¢¥¦
¥¢¥ÿ¥§ÿ¤ÿ££ÿ}¤ÿx ¢{¨ÿ
¥~ÿ£sÿz
ÿ
ÿt¥p©{ÿªoÿyo{pÿ{oqp{yÿu{wÿsuo{puy
«ÿ¤¢ÿ
¤pÿ
¬
ptu{
a`QOLǸGÿ®¯ÿZGG°QÿKTLÿ±®¯
N²UÿaRÿJÿMLHNOPGQÿRGLÿSTUHV
|_
5**-ÿ$-62/*6
#)70ÿ$-ÿ/,ÿ7*/ÿ8,(*ÿ9(,8ÿ:;<ÿ>?@A@BCDE
FGHÿJÿKLGGÿMLHNOPGQÿRGLÿSTUHVWÿXMNPYÿUGZQPGHHGLQÿMUXÿSTLG[
ÿ
\]ÿ^
_`TaHÿbcdÿfghihjklm
1199988
8188
1245 1401251898
8 !1"
012312456 789ÿ8
ÿÿ
8ÿÿÿÿÿ88
ÿ
"#$%&'()% *%+&(,')
-.&%%&) /%#(.ÿ-%,'&%
pqrstuvrwmÿFDÿB%%9)ÿ43&ÿnFD
1%&2)ÿ34ÿ5)% 3&ÿ)(;,ÿl+ÿ'3ÿ%,x368&ÿ(
o$ÿ.
.&7'8(7:%)ÿ4&%%
-339(%ÿ63:(78 IJKÿMNOOÿPQQJRRÿKSÿTUV/.
ÿXYZ,[.Z;\] ^_ÿ̀3a9P(ÿ%b)cadKe
%ÿ-3
SdOadJÿPdfÿSNcÿPbbRÿScÿRagdÿNbÿKSÿJdhSi
"77%))(<(:('8 jÿPcKaQOJ/3
RÿM#cJ%J&k,ÿ=:.$%&8ÿ='.'%2%,'
=l<)7&(<%mÿFDÿB%%9)ÿ43&ÿnFD
-3+8&(;>'ÿ?ÿ1>%ÿ@73,32()'ÿA%B)+.+%&ÿC(2('%#ÿDEFGHÿ"::ÿ&(;>')ÿ&%)%&$%#H
=(;,ÿl+mÿoÿ.&'(7:%)ÿ+%&ÿ23,'>
1199988 8188 1245 1401251898 8 !1!