Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Modelling of Small Wind Power Plant With Savonius-Darrieus Rotor in The PSCAD
Modelling of Small Wind Power Plant With Savonius-Darrieus Rotor in The PSCAD
Abstract—The paper focuses on the creation of a mathematical a shaft with a gearbox, generator, controllers and more. The
model of a small wind power plant with a vertical axis of rotation use of partial description is derived, however, from the
with a Savonius-Darrieus rotor within the PSCAD. The paper concept of the wind power source and its actual construction.
describes the principle of a wind energy source and it brings basic The requirement to all models of the wind power source is that
data about this technology and specifies individual parameters and the conversion of the kinetic energy of wind into the
their mutual relations that are needed for mathematical simulation. mechanical energy must be expressed.
The paper also presents the results of simulations of the created
mathematical model and assesses the overall generated energy for an Generally there are two basic concepts of wind turbines used
average and above-the-average windy day in a chosen area. primarily for electric power generation. One features turbines
with a horizontal spin axis (HAWT), where the rotation axis is
Keywords—wind power plant; mathematical model; aerody- parallel to the wind direction. The other concept is represented by
namic model; VAWT; Savonius rotor; Darrieus rotor; power curve; wind turbines with a vertical spin axis (VAWT) which is
PSCAD. perpendicular to the wind direction [3]. HAWTs are more cost
effective than VAWTs [4]. Due to HAWTs design, rotors can
I. INTRODUCTION reach greater heights and thereby also utilize more favourable
velocities of wind. The advantages of VAWTs concept including
The wind energy source is a plant which through a wind independence of wind directions and effective use of variable air
turbine converts the kinetic energy of wind into the mechanical flow [5]. Wind turbines can further be divided according to
energy or further into the electrical energy. Kinetics of a solid operational statuses during which the rotor operates at constant or
body is based on the fact that the mass of the body is constant. variable speed [4]. In the constant speed mode the turbine rotor
The output of wind energy source strongly depends on weather revolves at invariable angular speed regardless to the wind
conditions, in particular on the direction and velocity of wind. variability. As the rotor speed under specific conditions must be
Wind is a moving air, therefore it must be seen as a fluid whose restricted, the turbine does not run effectively, as it does not fully
density and velocity can change [1], which also affect the use the wind energy potential at all velocities. The rotor angular
mathematical description of the conversion of the kinetic energy velocity is mostly selected based on the frequency of the grid to
of wind into the mechanical energy. One possible method of which the wind power plant is connected. It implies that turbines
modelling a wind energy source is described in [2]. It is a power with a constant speed generate less power at lower wind
description of a particular wind source. The model can provide velocities than turbines with variable speeds for which pro-
only an electric power generated by a wind power plant. The
portional dependency is taken into account [4]. The advantage of
power curve enables to assign a power value to a corresponding
this solution is the reduction of the financial cost of power
velocity of wind. The aforementioned model makes it possible to
electronics, such as inverters and controllers [5]. Wind turbines
analyse its power potential, without the knowledge of other
with a constant speed use one or two fixed speeds [6]. Ref. [6]
electrical and mechanical quantities. When using this approach,
presents that a wind power plant with variable speeds and a
however, it is important to correctly model the power curve of a
permanent magnet generator without a gearbox generates 5 % to
wind power plant so that it fully captures the different operating
10 % more power than a wind power plant with two fixed speeds
modes. It is also necessary to take into account the wind turbine
and an asynchronous generator with a gearbox, and 10 % to 15 %
dynamics, due to the rotor torque and the steps performed by
more when one fixed speed is considered.
regulating elements. According to [2] the response of a wind
turbine can be reflected by a moderately attenuated system of a
second order. The model of a wind power plant can be generally Although the vertical axis wind power plants can not
divided into individual partial mathematical descriptions compete with HAWT plants by their power output, especially
characterizing e.g. a wind turbine, the hybrid VAWT (i.e. Savonius-Darrieus rotor) plants with
variable speeds still have a considerable potential for use
This research paper has been carried out in the Centre for Research and
Utilization of Renewable Energy (CVVOZE). Authors gratefully acknowledge
mainly in common urban areas where small hybrid energy
financial support from the Ministry of Education, Youth and Sports of the Czech systems are being newly developed. Regarding to a small
Republic under NPU I programme (project No. LO1210) and from the Technology hybrid wind plant it is appropriate to perform a mathematical
Agency of the Czech Republic (project No. TA04021490). simulation just through partial descriptions within the PSCAD,
978-1-5090-0908-4/16/$31.00 c 2016 IEEE
dm
which will enable specification of individual mutual links in dt
greater detail. Considering the individual links in conjunction where
1
is the air mass flow rate (kg·s− ), A is the area
with the PSCAD then also offers progressive options for
analysing dynamic behaviour of the finite mathematical model. 2 3
swept by the rotor (m ), ρ is the air density (kg·m− ) and vR is the
1
wind velocity at the rotor (m·s− ).
II. THEORY BASICS The density of air can be calculated using the ideal gas law,
expressed as a function of temperature and pressure [3]. Both
In this paper, a wind turbine aerodynamic model is ex- temperature and pressure vary with elevation and decrease
pressed with a method which uses a homogeneous disc and
control volume. An overview of the methods usable in the with increasing elevation, respectively. Hence site location is
development of an aerodynamic model including details is important as elevation has major effect on power generated
contained in [7]. For schematic representation see Fig. 1. as a result of air density and [1] considers the following
relation
− 0.297 (2)
area 2
area 3
ρ = ρ0 · e 3.048 h ,
area 0 area 1
p v 3
v0 = v 1 where ρ0 is the air density in zero elevation (in kg·m− ) and h
2
is site elevation (in m). At high elevations the air density
wind flow
wind flow
v1 v
corrections can be important. Fig. 1 also shows the
3
p
p0 T 3
ȡ
A0 A1 A2 A
developments of the static pressure and the velocity associated
freestream upstream p
3 to the axial force exerted by the actuator disc (i.e. turbine
2
rotor). The pressure increases from its freestream value p0 to a
downstream
actuator disk value p1 in front of the rotor. Behind the rotor the pressure
wake drops to value p2 and then gradually recovers in the wake to
the freestream value. The disc also acts as a drag device
Fig. 1. One-dimensional flow through an actuator disc representing ideal wind slowing the velocity from the freestream velocity v0 far
turbine: the velocity is dash line (- - -), the pressure is dot-and-dash line (– · upstream of the rotor to vR at the rotor and to v3 in the wake.
–), the lateral boundary of the stream control volume is dotted line (· · ·)
On the other hand, [1] expresses the relation by means of the where Pg is the output electric power of the generator (W),
Tem is the electromagnetic torque (N·m) and ωg is the angular
velocities directly 1
velocity of the generator magnetic flux (rad·s− ). According
v3 2 v3 v3 3 to [14] the following expression relates to the differential of
CP = 1 + the angular velocity of a ideal generator
−
v0 v0 − v0 , (13)
2 dω = 1 (Tm − Tem) , (21)
v3
where v0 presents the tip speed ratio of the wind turnine and dt J
according to [1], [9]–[11] it can be also expressed as 2
where J is the moment of the inertia (kg·m ). By modification
λ = v3 =ω · R , (14) of the preceding equation (19) a torque can be expressed with
v the power coefficient
0 v
−1 2
where ω is the angular velocity of the turbine (rad·s ) and Tm = ρ · AR · R · v · CP (22)
R is the radius of the wind turbine rotor (m). Previous (12) 2·λ
and (13) inform that the power coefficient is not a constant Considering that principally different generator designs exist,
because it is a function of the tip speed ratio. Moreover it is specific features of a particular solution must be respected
the most important parameter, especially in the case of power and taken into account within the mathematical model of
regulation [1]. Its curve is typically used for regulation of a generator. The basic model of an asynchronous generator
the active power of the wind power source and it presents is presented by [9]. A detailed model of a three-phase asyn-
reference curve [12]. Furthermore, the torque coefficient can chronous generator and its interrelations is included in [15].
be determined as Another model of an asynchronous generator is described
CP = CT · λ, (15) by [16], where also models of a drive train and gearbox
are presented which also consider a coefficient of attenuation not be oriented in the direction of wind velocity. Table I shows
and rigidity. The mathematical description of a synchronous general parameters of combined wind turbine.
permanent magnet generator is provided e.g. in [11].
TABLE I. GENERAL PARAMETERS OF WIND TURBINE WITH
SAVONIUS-DARRIEUS ROTOR [17]
III. THE CREATED MODEL
Symbol Parameter Value Unit
The created model describes DS-300 wind power plant vin cut-in wind speed < 3.0 m·s−
1
1
with Savonius-Darrieus rotor. The model consists of two main vout cut-out wind speed 15.5 m·s−
1
vn rated wind speed 13.5 m·s−
modules representing both three-phase AC synchronous d diameter of the shaft 14 mm
generator with inset NdFeB permanent magnet rotor (PMSG)
sh
m weight of the rotor 25 kg
and Darrieus-Savonius rotors which are combined by
installing the Savonius rotor inside the rotational closed space The preceding text describes two principally different ro-
of the Darrieus rotor. Fig. 2 shows created model in PSCAD. tors used in a hybrid power plant. A Savonius rotor works
mech_spd
according to the resistance principle, as opposed to the lift
mech. spd principle that a Darrieus rotor is based on. Fig. 4 illustrates
Wind Source
Mean Turbine individual forces and their distribution in these types of rotor.
Vw trq torque
Ramp wind spd W
wind spd Te PMSG A Load
N(Į)
el. torque Te
V
T (Į) . v drag
Ɏ v ș
- Ȧ RDar R Į
Fig. 2. Model of a small wind power plant in PSCAD
Į T
lift N
Ȧ Ȧ
Previous Fig. 2 also shows other used modules and com- v v
ponents in model, e.g. source signal of wind speed, measuring
and display elements etc. These are provided by components
from main library of PSCAD. Proposals of a wind turbine and
synchronous generator are described in more detail below. Fig. 4. General schematic of rotor cross sections and considered forces
A. Wind turbine
The combination of these two types of rotor makes it
The Savonius rotor consists of two horizontal circular possible to operate a power plant within a broad range of wind
discs, between which there are two S-blades vertically velocity with high efficiency. This construction of rotor does
mounted. In the middle the blades are set in an opposite not require adjustment of blades in response to a wind
direction toward to each other, so part of wind coming from direction, which reduces its maintenance requirements. As this
the back of the momentarily passive blade is directed at the is a combined wind power plant, whose construction does not
front of the active blade. Rotor blades are conceived with the enable a blade adjustment, also the power coefficient does not
aim of the resulting momentum to revolve the turbine consider a change in angular direction. The created
counterclockwise. The turbine contains a two-stage Savonius mathematical model uses the empirical expression of the
rotor, where the rotor stages are turned toward each other by power coefficient and internal layout of constructed model is
ninety degrees. The aspect ratio of Savonius rotor αSav is 1.94 shown in Fig. 5.
and its overlap ratio βSav is 0.39. The height of the Savonius
rotor HSav is 660 mm. Fig. 3 shows design concept and size of , #2 , !
&' "#
"
"#
600
1000 330
"
120 ° "$
&
330
3
170 ()*
+ , +& , +-&./ '
Ø 220 ! "
# # * 0 01
Fig. 3. Front view and top view of hybrid vertical axis wind turbine with "#
Savonius-Darrieus rotor / "
axis. The shape of the blades should reduce the effects of "$
350 340
power. Because of the wind turbine is VAWT and full variable rated power error
0.525 %
speed, the generator works as vertical one without gearbox.
Power of wind powerplant
300 310
The rotor is salient pole type and it has 8 projected pole pairs. 250 280 13.4 13.6 13.8
26.133 %
100 10
Symbol Parameter Value Unit
Ω 5.7 5.9 6.1 6.3
Rs stator resistance 0.3528
Φ flux in the stator windings 0.03 Wb 50
4 2
J moment of inertia 5.2·10− kg·m 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
5 −1
F viscous friction coefficient 3.035·10− N·m·s·rad
f frequency 40 Hz 0
−1
Wind speed (m⋅s )
The design of poles leads to the longitudinal inductance Ld Fig. 6. Power curve of modelled DS-300 small wind power plant
and the transverse inductance Lq are not significant different.
Therefore the creation of unbalanced magnetic reluctance
paths for the flux and consequence asymmetry in flux
distribution within generator is not significant. Individual Fig. 6 and following comments also reveal achieved accu-
inductances have been determined by [19]. racy of model for parameters specified above. The reference
curve is based on approximation of measured data of real wind
power plant in Brno University of Technology. The deficiency
IV. THE RESULTS of created PSCAD model is expressed by the relative error of
its power curve, therefore some parts of power curves are
According to [20] a number of studies dealing with the highlighted in detail in Fig. 6. At nominal wind speed (i.e.
1 1
problems of wind power sources use average wind velocity 13.5 m·s− ) the relative error is 0.525 %. From 11.5 m·s− to
values as their basis. The created mathematical model in 1
15.5 m·s− the accuracy of model is remained fairly static
combination with actual measured data of wind velocity is 1
also used for additional assessment of a hybrid power plant below approximate relative error of 1 %. Between 7.5 m·s−
1
operation. The power plant is located in the city of Brno, the and 11.5 m·s− , the decrease in the relative error is slow linear
1
Czech Republic, at a height of 25 m above the ground. and its pace is from 20.663 % at 7.5 m·s− to 0.904 % at 11.5
According to [21] an average wind velocity at a height of 100 1
m·s− . The lowest accuracy is achieved in range of wind
1 1 1 1
m above the ground ranges from 2.5 m·s− to 5.0 m·s− in this speeds from 3.0 m·s− to 7.5 m·s− where the relative errors
1
location. On recalculation of 4 m·s− according to [22] an reach approximately 20 % with maximum peak of 26.133 % at
−1
average velocity at a height of 25 m above the ground then 6 m·s .
V. CONCLUSION [10] J. Zhang, M. Cheng, Z. Chen, and X. Fu, “Pitch angle control for
variable speed wind turbines,” in Electric Utility Deregulation and
The paper informs that the simulation of combined wind Restructuring and Power Technologies, 2008. DRPT 2008. Third
power plant is a wide issue because a lot of interrelations has In-ternational Conference on, April 2008, pp. 2691–2696.
to be considered and determined. Based on empirical [11] B. S. Borowy and Z. M. Salameh, “Dynamic response of a stand-alone
approach, the individual empirical coefficients ci has been wind energy conversion system with battery energy storage to a wind
adjusted to match the power curve defined by measurement. gust,” Energy Conversion, IEEE Transactions on, vol. 12, pp. 73–
78, March 1997.
The accuracy of the power coefficient Cp (λ) in range of cut-in
[12] A. Perdana, O. Carlson, and J. Persson, “Dynamic response of grid
and cut-off wind speeds of wind turbine is given by used connected wind turbine with doubly fed induction generator during
polynomial. Moreover, because of the combined wind turbine, disturbances,” in Nordic workshop on power and industrial
adequate method of determination of coefficients ci is needed electronics, March 2004, pp. 1–6.
to achieve better accuracy of model. Therefore, the whole [13] M. Ptacek, “The definition of input parameters for modelling of
range of wind speed has to be divided into several separated energetic subsystems,” EPJ Web of Conferences, vol. 54, pp. 02
sections and then the sets of the coefficients has to be 002.1– 02 002.8, June 2013.
determined for each section individually. The improved [14] R. Gagnon, G. Sybille, S. Bernard, D. Pare,´ S. Casoria, and C. Larose,
mathematical model can be also used in finding a new locality, “Modeling and real-time simulation of a doubly-fed induction generator
better suited for a wind plant operation. Wind speed driven by a wind turbine,” in International Conference on Power
measurements then can be replaced by the wind characteristics Systems Transients IPST’05, June 2005.
and functions which describe the probability distribution, e.g. [15] T. Petru,˚ “Modeling of wind turbines for power system studies,” Ph.D.
using the Weibull or Gamma distribution. dissertation, Chalmers University of Technology, 2003.
ˇ
[16] V. Sant´ın, “Simulace jevu˚ zpusoben˚ych´ pˇripojovan´´ım a provozem
REFERENCES vetrnˇych´ elektraren´ a farem,” Ph.D. dissertation, Zapado´ceskˇa´
univerzita v Plzni, Kvetenˇ 2012.
[1] A. W. Manyonge, R. M. Ochieng, F. N. Onyango, and J. M. Shichikha, ˇ
“Mathematical modelling of wind turbine in a wind energy conversion [17] D. Topolanek´ and J. Slezinger. System´ male´ vetrnˇe´ elektrarny´ s axialn´´ı osou
system: Power coefficient analysis,” Applied Mathematical rotace. popis meˇˇr´ıc´ıho systemu´ a parametru˚ vetrnˇe´ elektrarny´. [on-line].
Sciences, vol. 6, no. 91, pp. 4527 – 4536, 2012. Vysoke´ ucenˇ´ı technicke´ v Brneˇ. [cit. 10.02.2016]. 24 p. Available on:
http://www.ueen.feec.vutbr.cz/cz/index.php/laboratore/vtesavonius.
[2] M. Khan and M. Iqbal, “Dynamic modeling and simulation of a small
wind-fuel cell hybrid energy system,” Renewable Energy, vol. 30, no. [18] N. Bianchi, S. Bolognani, E. Fornasiero, M. Morandin, and G. Pavesi,
3, pp. 421–439, 2005. “Optimal drive and machine sizing for a self starting, vertical axis, low
[3] D. P. Kothari, K. C. Signal, and R. Ranjan, Renewable Energy Sources power wind generator,” in Energy Conference and Exhibition
And Emerging Technologies. Prentice-Hall Of India Pvt. Limited, (ENERGYCON), 2012 IEEE International, Sept 2012, pp. 178–183.
October 2009. [19] J. Michaliczek, “Synchronn´ı generator´ s permanentn´ımi magnety a aktivn
[4] K. E. Johnson, Adaptive Torque Control of Variable Speed Wind ´ım usmerˇnovaˇcem,”ˇ Ph.D. dissertation, Vysoke´ ucenˇ´ı technicke´ v
Turbines. Technical Report. NREL/TP-500-36265, August 2004. Brne,ˇ Fakulta elektrotechniky a komunikacnˇ´ıch technologi´ı, 2013, 70 s.
[5] A. M. Biadgo, A. Simonovic, D. Komarov, and S. Stupar, “Numerical Vedouc´ı diplomove´ prace´ Ing. Ondˇrej V´ıtek, Ph.D.
and analytical investigation of vertical axis wind turbine,” FME Trans- [20] A. Altunkaynak, T. Erdik, I. Dabanli, and Z. Sen, “Theoretical deriva-
actions, vol. 41, pp. 49 – 58, 2013. tion of wind power probability distribution function and applications,”
[6] H. Vihrial¨a,¨ “Control of variable spe win turbine,” Ph.D. dissertation, Applied Energy, vol. 92, pp. 809 – 814, April 2012.
Tampere University of Technology, November 2002. ´ atmosfery´ ˇ Vetrnˇa´ energie. vetrnˇa´
[21] Ustav fyziky AV CR, v. v. i. (2009)
[7] M. Hansen, Aerodynamics of Wind Turbines. Earthscan, 2008. mapa. pole prum˚ernˇe´ rychlosti vetruˇ ve vy´sceˇ 100 m nad
[8] K. Busawon, L. Dodson, and M. Jovanovic, “Estimation of the power povrchem. [online]. [cit. 10.02.2016]. Available on:
coefficient in a wind conversion system,” in Decision and Control, http://www.ufa.cas.cz/vetrna-energie.
2005 and 2005 European Control Conference. CDC-ECC ’05.
[22] P. Mastny,´ J. Drapela,´ J. Macha´cek,ˇ M. Pta´cek,ˇ T. Radil, Luka´sˇ Bartosˇ´ık,
44th IEEE Conference on, Dec 2005, pp. 3450–3455. T. Pavelka, and S. Misˇak,´ Obnovitelne´ zdroje elektricke´ energie. Praha,
ˇ ˇ
[9] A. El-Sattar, N. Saad, and M. Shams El-Dein, “Dynamic response of doubly Ceska´ republika: Ceske´ vysoke´ ucenˇ´ı technicke´ v Praze, Prosinec
fed induction generator variable speed wind turbine under fault,” Electric 2011, vol. 1.
Power Systems Research, vol. 78, pp. 1240–1246, July 2008.