Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Predictors of Asian American Adolescents' Suicide Attempts: A Latent Class Regression Analysis
Predictors of Asian American Adolescents' Suicide Attempts: A Latent Class Regression Analysis
DOI 10.1007/s10964-011-9701-3
EMPIRICAL RESEARCH
Received: 19 May 2011 / Accepted: 19 July 2011 / Published online: 5 August 2011
Ó Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2011
123
1454 J Youth Adolescence (2011) 40:1453–1464
The literature on factors associated with suicide-related interpersonal relationships in Asian cultures (Markus and
outcomes among Asian American adolescents is charac- Kitayama 1991), the deleterious consequences of thwarted
terized by several limitations. First, most studies have belongingness may be a pernicious suicide risk for Asian
focused on replicating suicide risk factors identified in the American adolescents. Conversely, a sense of belonging-
general US population (e.g., Else et al. 2009; Nishimura ness to a valued social group may be a salient protective
et al. 2005), without paying adequate attention to how these factor. Support for Joiner’s (2005) theory was found in a
factors might vary across subgroups of Asian American recent study showing that a combination of perceived
adolescents (e.g., highly acculturated vs. less acculturated burdensomeness and thwarted belongingness was associ-
Asian American adolescents). Indeed, studies have shown ated with elevated levels of suicidal ideation among Asian
that Asian American adolescents’ psychosocial adjustment American college students (Wong et al. 2011b). In sum, a
varied as a function of acculturation (Hahm et al. 2003; focus on interpersonal needs may be particularly relevant
Willgerodt and Thompson 2006). Second, from a meth- to the study of Asian Americans’ suicide-related outcomes.
odological perspective, studies on Asian American ado- Guided by Joiner’s (2005) interpersonal-psychological
lescents’ suicide-related outcomes tend to rely on small theory, we investigated, in this study, the influence of three
samples [e.g., from a community mental health center (e.g., indicators of belongingness—family, peer, and school
Lau et al. 2002) or from a few schools in a particular city relationships—on Asian American adolescents’ suicide
(e.g., Cho and Haslam 2009)]. Consequently, it is unclear attempts. We focused on these three indicators because
whether the findings from these studies are a function of a they have been found in prior research to be associated
local setting or are generalizable to Asian American ado- with suicide-related outcomes (Kidd et al. 2006; Perkins
lescents in general. and Hartless 2002). Several studies have documented the
Moreover, no known study has employed a longitudinal relevance of family-related variables to suicide-related
research design in the study of Asian Americans’ suicidal outcomes among adolescents (Kidd et al. 2006) as well as
behavior, thus limiting researchers’ ability to draw infer- in Asian American communities. Wong et al. (2011a)
ences about the temporal order of the link between risk and found that, among Asian American college students, living
protective factors and suicide-related outcomes. Finally, with a family member was uniquely associated with lower
one criticism of the empirical literature on Asian Ameri- rates of suicidal ideation, after controlling for demographic
cans’ suicide-related outcomes, including research on and mental health variables. In a recent national study of
Asian American adolescents, is that it has consisted mainly Asian American adults (Wong et al. in press), family
of atheoretical studies that have not been grounded in cohesion was associated with reduced rates of suicidal
suicidology theories (Wong et al. 2011b). To summarize, ideation. Conversely, problems in Asian American ado-
our review of the literature on Asian American adoles- lescents’ relationship with their parents have been impli-
cents’ suicide-related outcomes revealed several empirical, cated as a risk factor for suicide-related outcomes (Cho and
methodological, and theoretical limitations, which we Haslam 2009; Lau et al. 2002). Collectively, these studies
sought to address in this study. suggest that strong family relationships may be an impor-
tant protective factor against Asian American adolescents’
Joiner’s Interpersonal-Psychological Theory suicide-related outcomes.
Peer and school-related variables have also been shown to
Against this backdrop, we used Joiner’s (2005) inter- be associated with US adolescents’ suicide-related outcomes
personal-psychological theory of suicidal behavior as the (Perkins and Hartless 2002). A recent study of Korean
main theoretical basis for our study. Joiner posited that American high school adolescents found that perceived
suicidal desire is engendered primarily by the thwarting of social support from a friend of a different ethnicity was
one’s basic interpersonal needs. In particular, suicidal negatively related to suicidal ideation (Cho and Haslam
desire develops as a result of a sense of thwarted belong- 2009). Although no known study has examined the link
ingness and perceived burdensomeness to others. This between school relationships and suicide-related outcomes
theory may be particularly applicable to Asian American among Asian American adolescents, one study found that
communities because its emphasis on unmet interpersonal attitudes toward school and teachers were significantly and
needs is congruent with Asian cultural norms that empha- negatively related to depression among Chinese American
size the centrality of interpersonal relationships (Wong and adolescents, but not among European American adolescents
Poon 2010). Indeed, research has consistently found that (Zhou et al. 2003). The authors theorized that because
Asian Americans demonstrated higher levels of interde- Chinese culture strongly emphasizes the importance of
pendent self-construals than White Americans (Lam and education, Chinese Americans’ experience of alienation
Zane 2004; Okazaki 2000; Singelis 1994). Because one’s from schools had a more devastating impact on their well-
well-being is viewed as strongly linked to one’s being as compared with European Americans.
123
J Youth Adolescence (2011) 40:1453–1464 1455
Person-Oriented Framework gender expectations for boys and girls in schools, among
peers, and at home (Pessar 2003). This may be particularly
Although Joiner’s (2005) interpersonal-psychological the- true for racial and ethnic minority girls, including Asian
ory is potentially relevant to the study of Asian American American girls (Suarez-Orozco and Qin 2006). Compared
adolescents’ suicidal attempts, one limitation of this theory to their male counterparts, Asian American girls tend to
is that it may not fully take into account the complex ways in experience stricter parental control over their schooling
which diverse groups of adolescents demonstrate different activities and social lives, more familial obligations (e.g.,
profiles of risk and protective factors for suicide-related taking care of younger siblings), and greater parental
outcomes. In contrast, there is growing acceptance of a expectations to retain Asian cultural traditions (Fuligni et al.
holistic, interactionistic view of individuals within the field 2002; Qin 2009). Additionally, Asian American girls may
of child and adolescent development (Bergman et al. 2006; face gendered social pressures in school (e.g., wearing
Bergman and Magnusson 1997; Van Horn et al. 2009; fashionable clothes and showing an interest in boys) that are
Weaver and Kim 2008). This person-oriented framework antithetical to the cultural values of their parents, which
focuses on individuals as the unit of analysis in research and emphasizes modesty and more conservative dating attitudes
can be contrasted with a variable-oriented research frame- (Qin 2009). Accordingly, high levels of peer and school
work which focuses on variables as the main unit of analysis relationships could, ironically, engender stress for Asian
(Bergman and Magnusson 1997). The person-oriented American girls via parental disapproval or internalized guilt
framework emphasizes the heterogeneity of child and ado- because they may reflect activities that conflict with tradi-
lescent development and the need to understand how diverse tional Asian parental expectations. Although there are no
subgroups of children and adolescents differ on the basis of a known studies on gender differences in the predictors of
constellation of characteristics (von Eye and Bogat 2006). Asian American adolescents’ suicide-related outcomes, one
Moreover, such an analysis dovetails with the basic eco- study of adolescents’ suicide attempts in Oregon found
logical premise that the influence of the environment on differential gender effects; specifically, family support
children and adolescents differ on the basis of multiple negatively predicted suicide attempts among girls, whereas
characteristics, such as gender and culture (e.g., Bronfen- support from friends negatively predicted suicide attempts
brenner 1979, Van Horn et al. 2009). among boys (Lewinsohn et al. 2001). Based on the fore-
The person-oriented framework may be particularly rele- going literature review, we surmised that peer and school
vant to our study because there are theoretical and empirical relationships would not be protective factors against suicide
reasons to suggest that Joiner’s (2005) theory would not be attempts for Asian American girls as compared to their male
universally applicable to Asian American adolescents; counterparts.
indeed, there might be subgroups of Asian American adoles- Following the example of previous developmental
cents who demonstrate different patterns of risk and protective research (Van Horn et al. 2009), we used latent class
factors associated with suicide attempts. In particular, previ- regression (also known as regression mixture models) to
ous research has suggested that the effects of predictors of test a person-oriented approach to understanding suicide
suicide-related outcomes vary as a function of participants’ attempts among Asian American adolescents. Latent class
gender and acculturation. With regard to acculturation, Lau regression combines the strengths of cluster analysis and
et al. (2002) found that parent–child conflict was more regression models by testing, within a single analysis, dif-
strongly associated with suicide-related outcomes among less ferential relationships between predictor and outcome vari-
acculturated Asian Americans than among highly accultur- ables across several latent classes (Wedel and DeSarbo
ated Asian Americans. In the same vein, Wong et al. (in press) 1994). Participants who are classified in the same latent class
showed that family cohesion was a protective factor against tend to be similar to one another in terms of the associations
suicidal ideation among Asian American adults with low between predictor and outcome variables. Consistent with
levels of language acculturation (i.e., English proficiency) but growing acceptance of the person-oriented framework (e.g.,
not among those with greater language acculturation. Applied Weaver and Kim 2008), latent class regression has been
to our study, strong family relationships might be a less rele- increasingly applied in diverse areas of child and adolescent
vant protective factor for highly acculturated Asian American research; such research includes the study of differential
adolescents because they might be more concerned about environmental influences on children’s cognitive behavior
individuating from their families and are therefore less (Bouwmeester et al. 2004) and academic outcomes (Van
affected by the degree to which their family members feel Horn et al. 2009), as well as differential risk and protective
connected to one another (cf. Lau et al. 2002). factors for marijuana use (Reboussin et al. 2007) and suicide-
In addition to acculturation, gender has been identified as related outcomes among adolescents (Jiang et al. 2010).
a powerful influence on racial and ethnic minority adoles- Latent class regression confers several methodological
cents’ psychosocial functioning because of conflicting benefits as compared to conventional regression methods.
123
1456 J Youth Adolescence (2011) 40:1453–1464
For one, unlike conventional regression methods which outcomes (Lau et al. 2002; Lewinsohn et al. 2001), we
assume that all individuals belong to a single population, expected that our latent class regression would identify at
latent class regression relaxes the assumption of population least two latent classes of participants that differ from each
homogeneity to allow for parameter differences across other in terms of gender and acculturation. Guided by
unobserved subpopulations (Ding 2006). Additionally, Joiner’s (2005) theory on the protective nature of
conventional regression methods rely on interaction terms belongingness, our first hypothesis predicted that in the
to test differential effects (i.e., whether the effects of one latent class with the most number of participants, family,
variable on another are consistent across a population). school, and peer relationships would all be protective
However, the testing of interaction terms are typically factors predicting lower rates of suicide attempts. On the
confined to only two- or three-way interactions and require basis of our foregoing literature review on acculturation
separate interaction terms for each specific interaction (e.g., Lau et al. 2002), our second hypothesis predicted
effect, thus limiting its ability to identify complex patterns that compared to less acculturated participants, highly
of differential effects (Van Horn et al. 2009). In contrast, acculturated participants would have greater odds of being
latent class regression does not rely on interaction effects in a latent class in which family relationships were not a
and can provide a global evaluation of differential effects significant protective factor against suicide attempts. In
based on complex patterns of associations between pre- light of our earlier review of the literature on gender (Fu-
dictor and outcome variables that vary across subgroups ligni et al. 2002; Lewinsohn et al. 2001; Qin 2009), our
(Van Horn et al. 2009; Wedel and DeSarbo 1994). Simply third hypothesis stated that compared to Asian American
put, latent class regression is particularly well-suited to boys, Asian American girls would have lower odds of
address research questions from a person-oriented frame- being in a latent class in which peer relationships and
work (Bergman and Magnusson 1997). school relationships were protective factors against suicide
attempts.
Research Hypotheses
123
J Youth Adolescence (2011) 40:1453–1464 1457
123
1458 J Youth Adolescence (2011) 40:1453–1464
Following Hahm et al. (2003), participants in group The means, standard deviations, and intercorrelations of
(c) were considered more acculturated than group (b) due the main measures are presented in Table 1. At the bivar-
to previous research indicating that language is a more iate level, family relationships were the only indicator of
accurate indicator of acculturation than place of birth belongingness that was significantly and negatively asso-
(Phinney 1990). Evidence for the predictive validity of ciated with Wave 2 suicide attempts.
this acculturation measure was demonstrated through a
positive association with greater alcohol use among Asian Main Analyses
American adolescents in Hahm et al.’s (2003) study.
The results of the model fit for 1–4-class models are pre-
Statistical Analyses sented in Table 2. The 2-class model was a significantly
better fit to the data than the 1-class model, and the 3-class
For our latent class logistic regression analysis, we used model was a significantly better fit to the data than the
Latent Gold 4.5 (Vermunt and Magidson 2008), which can 2-class model. However, the 4-class model was not sig-
handle skewed dichotomous outcomes and take into nificantly different from the 3-class model (p = .074).
account the cluster sampling, probability sampling weights, Moreover, among the four models, the 3-class model had
and stratification of the Add Health data. Wave 2 suicide the lowest AIC values. Accordingly, we concluded that the
attempt was the dichotomous outcome variable. The pre- 3-class model was the optimal and most parsimonious
dictor variables were Wave 1 family, school, and peer representation of the data. Classes 1–3 consisted of 57%
relationships, depressive symptoms, suicidal ideation, and (n = 547), 32% (n = 310), and 11% (n = 102) of partic-
suicide attempts. Since our focus was on the differential ipants, respectively.
effects of the three indicators of belongingness, Wave 1 The parameter estimates for the 3-class latent class regres-
depressive symptoms, suicidal ideation, and suicide sion are shown in Table 3. Across the three latent classes, the
attempts were control variables constrained to be class three indicators of belongingness differed significantly in their
independent. We selected the optimal number of latent influence on Wave 2 suicide attempts (Wald = 36.08,
classes by comparing the relative fit of the models via the p \ .001 for family relationships, Wald = 45.02, p \ .001 for
model fit likelihood ratio chi-square statistic (L2) and school relationships, and Wald = 41.70, p \ .001 for peer
Akaike information criterion (AIC) values. The lower the relationships). Wave 1 depressive symptoms and suicide
L2 and AIC estimates, the better the model fits the data. attempts significantly and positively predicted Wave 2 suicide
attempts. In support of our first hypothesis, the majority of
participants were in Class 1, in which stronger family, school,
Results and peer relationships all significantly predicted lower rates of
Wave 2 suicide attempts. Because all three indicators of
Preliminary Analyses belongingness were protective factors against suicide attempts,
we labeled Class 1 Protective Relationships Class. In Class 2,
Multiple imputation (through the use of five imputed family and peer relationships did not significantly predict Wave
datasets) was used to handle missing data (Schafer 1999). 2 suicide attempts. However, stronger school relationships
123
J Youth Adolescence (2011) 40:1453–1464 1459
Table 2 Model fit statistics for four latent class models gender and acculturation. These findings are summarized in
Model AIC L 2 2
L difference
Table 5. A logistic regression model with class member-
ship predicting Wave 2 suicide attempts was significant,
1-class model 276.36 262.36 v2(2) = 26.14, p \ .001, Nagelkerke R2 = .11. Class
2-class model 257.64 227.64 34.73* membership significantly predicted Wave 2 suicide
3-class model 235.84 189.84 37.79* attempts. Class 1 had significantly lower odds of Wave 2
4-class model 237.54 175.54 14.31 suicide attempts than Class 2 and Class 3, but Class 2 did
2 2
L difference refers to the difference between the L value for a not differ significantly from Class 3 in the odds of Wave 2
particular model and that of the preceding model (e.g., 2-class model suicide attempts. These findings indicate that among the
vs. 1-class model) three latent classes, Class 1 (Protective Relationships
* p \ .01 Class) participants had the lowest rate of suicide attempts.
To test the link between gender and acculturation and
significantly predicted higher rates of suicide attempts. Given class membership, we used a multinomial logistic regres-
that none of the three indicators of belongingness were pro- sion with class membership (Class 1 vs. Class 2 vs. Class 3)
tective factors and school relationships appeared to be a risk as the outcome variable (see Table 5). The model pre-
factor, we labeled Class 2 Non-Protective Relationships Class. dicting class membership was significant, v2(4) = 691.08,
Class 3 was similar to Class 1 in that stronger family and school p \ .001, Nagelkerke R2 = .61. Our second hypothesis
relationships significantly predicted lower rates of suicide predicted that highly acculturated participants would have
attempts. However, stronger peer relationships significantly greater odds of being in a latent class in which family
predicted higher rates of suicide attempts. Because peer rela- relationships were not a significant protective factor against
tionships were a risk factor, whereas family and school rela- suicide attempts. We found that less acculturated partici-
tionships were protective factors, we labeled Class 3 Mixed pants had greater odds of being in Class 3 (Mixed Rela-
Relationships Class. tionships Class) than in Classes 1 and 2. In contrast, highly
To examine differences among the latent classes on the acculturated participants had greater odds of being in Class
main study measures related to our research questions, we 2 (Non-Protective Relationships Class) than in the other
used ANOVAs and chi-square for continuous and dichot- two latent classes. This finding provides support for our
omous measures, respectively (see Table 4). The latent second hypothesis, given that among the three latent clas-
classes did not differ significantly in the levels of family, ses, Class 2 was the only one in which family relationships
school, and peer relationships [F(2, 956) B 1.64, p C .194 were not significantly related to suicide attempts.
for all three measures]. In contrast, we found significant Our third hypothesis predicted that Asian American girls
differences among the latent classes in their levels of would have lower odds of being in a latent class in which
acculturation, [F(2, 956) = 184.91, p \ .001], Wave 2 peer and school relationships were protective factors
suicide attempts [v2(2) = 25.19, p \ .001], and gender against suicide attempts. This hypothesis received some
[v2(2) = 199.98, p \ .001]. support. Compared to boys, girls had lower odds of being
Next, we explored the specific nature of the associations in Class 1 (the only latent class in which peer relationships
between class membership and Wave 2 suicide attempts, were a protective factor) than in Class 3. Moreover, girls
Family relationships -4.45 1.23 .01* .29 .26 1.33 -3.16 .64 .04*
School relationships -4.66 .97 .01* 1.35 .30 3.87* -2.27 .87 .10*
Peer relationships -5.51 1.63 .004* -.98 .95 .37 8.24 1.89 3,778.94*
Depressive symptoms 1.07 .30 2.92* 1.07 .30 2.92* 1.07 .30 2.92*
Suicidal ideation 0.47 .32 1.60 0.47 .32 1.60 0.47 .32 1.60
Suicide attempt 1.86 .51 6.41* 1.86 .51 6.41* 1.86 .51 6.41*
Suicidal ideation: 0 no ideation, 1 ideation; suicide attempt: 0 no attempt, 1 attempt. All predictor variables were assessed at Wave 1
* p \ .001
123
1460 J Youth Adolescence (2011) 40:1453–1464
Table 4 Group comparisons among latent classes on the main study Discussion
measures
Measures Class 1 57% Class 2 32% Class 3 11% Although suicide-related outcomes among Asian American
(n = 547) (n = 310) (n = 102) adolescents are a serious public health problem in the United
States, research in this area has been relatively sparse com-
M (SD)
pared to other racial/ethnic groups (Goldston et al. 2008).
Family relationships 3.96 (.70) 3.94 (.70) 4.08 (.74)
Limitations in the extant empirical literature include a rela-
School relationships 2.82 (.74) 2.77 (.81) 2.88 (.66)
tive lack of emphasis on suicidology theory and subgroup
Peer relationships .53 (.27) .54 (.26) .49 (.25)
differences among Asian American adolescents, a tendency
Acculturation 1.97 (1.18) 2.32 (.96) .04 (.28)
to rely on small, local samples, and the use of cross-sectional
Frequencies (n)
research designs (e.g., Cho and Haslam 2009; Else et al.
W2 suicide attempt 4 18 8
2009; Lau et al. 2002; Nishimura et al. 2005). Against this
Gender: girls/boys 215/322 240/70 5/97
backdrop, our study breaks new ground in being the first
W2 Wave 2. Class 1 Protective Relationships Class, Class 2 known suicidology study to focus exclusively on a national
Non-Protective Relationships Class, Class 3 Mixed Relationships sample of Asian American adolescents through the use of a
Class. With the exception of Wave 2 suicide attempt, all other vari-
ables were examined at Wave 1
longitudinal research design. Guided by Joiner’s (2005)
interpersonal-psychological theory of suicidal behavior
and the person-oriented framework in developmental
Table 5 Binary and multinomial logistic regression analyses
research (Bergman and Magnusson 1997), we assessed the
optimal number of latent classes that explained the associ-
Outcome OR 95% CI ations between family, school, and peer relationships and
Binary logistic regression subsequent suicide attempts among Asian American
Wave 2 suicide attempt adolescents.
C1 (vs. C3) .09* .03, .29 Results from our latent class regression analysis uncov-
C2 (vs. C3) .72 .31, 1.72 ered a 3-class model. Across the three latent classes, the three
C2 (vs. C1) 8.37* 2.81, 24.96 Wave 1 indicators of belongingness exerted significantly
Multinomial logistic regression different effects on Wave 2 suicide attempts, after control-
C2 (vs. C1) ling for Wave 1 depressive symptoms, suicidal ideation, and
Gender .12* .09, .18
suicide attempts. The majority of participants (57%) were in
Acculturation 1.76* 1.52, 2.05
the Protective Relationships Class, which demonstrated the
lowest rate of suicide attempts as compared with the other
C3 (vs. C1)
two latent classes. These findings also provide support for
Gender 155.99* 52.30, 465.27
our first hypothesis, given that this was the only latent class in
Acculturation .01* .003, .03
which family, school, and peer relationships were all pro-
C2 (vs. C3)
tective factors predicting lower odds of subsequent suicide
Gender .001* .0003, .002
attempts. Moreover, these findings align with Joiner’s (2005)
Acculturation 208.90* 64.32, 678.55
interpersonal-psychological theory, which proposes that a
C1 Class 1 (Protective Relationships Class), C2 Class 2 (Non-Protective sense of belongingness to a valued social group is a salient
Relationships Class), C3 Class 3 (Mixed Relationships Class), Gender: protective factor against suicidal desire. Slightly less than a
0 girl, 1 boy, OR odds ratio. For the multinomial logistic regression,
OR [ 1.00 indicates that boys and more acculturated participants had third of participants were in the Non-Protective Relation-
greater odds of being in a particular class versus the other class listed in ships Class—in this latent class, family and peer relation-
parentheses; OR \ 1.00 indicates that girls and less acculturated par- ships did not significantly predict subsequent suicide
ticipants had greater odds of being in a particular class versus the other attempts. However, participants who reported stronger
class listed in parentheses
school relationships had higher rates of suicide attempts,
* p \ .001
suggesting that school relationships were a risk factor for this
latent class. Eleven percent of participants were in the Mixed
had lower odds of being in the two latent classes in which Relationships Class. In this latent class, family and school
school relationships were protective factors (i.e., Class 1 relationships predicted lower rates of suicide attempts, but
and Class 3) as compared to Class 2. Put differently, girls peer relationships were a risk factor predicting higher rates of
had higher odds of being in Class 2 (Non-Protective suicide attempts.
Relationships Class), the only latent class in which stronger Among the three indicators of belongingness, family
school relationships predicted higher rates of suicide relationships appeared to be a relatively salient protective
attempts. factor against suicide attempts because it was a protective
123
J Youth Adolescence (2011) 40:1453–1464 1461
factor in two latent classes and the only indicator of close friends may feel culturally marginalized because they
belongingness that was not a significant risk factor in any are potentially more acculturated than their parents, but
of the latent classes. These results dovetail with previous less acculturated than their friends (Chao and Tseng 2002).
scholarship identifying the importance of family processes Alternatively, less acculturated participants may experi-
as a factor associated with suicide-related outcomes among ence cognitive dissonance because of the different cultural
adolescents (Kidd et al. 2006) and in Asian American messages they receive from their family and peers (Tadmor
communities (Cho and Haslam 2009; Lau et al. 2002; and Tetlock 2006). Spending more time with peers can
Wong et al. 2011a, in press; Wong and Poon 2010). reinforce this awareness of cultural differences, thereby
Because the family is viewed as one’s main source of self- increasing their experience of acculturative stress and
esteem in many Asian American cultures (Inman and Yeh vulnerability to suicide attempts.
2007), strong family relationships might provide Asian Our third hypothesis predicted that girls would have
American adolescents with a sense of security that buffers lower odds of being in a latent class in which peer rela-
against suicide attempts. tionships and school relationships were protective factors
Although Joiner’s (2005) theory on the protective nature against suicide attempts. We found some support for this
of belongingness appears to apply to the majority of our hypothesis. Compared to boys, girls had lower odds of
participants (i.e., those in the Protective Relationships being in the Protective Relationships Class than in the
Class), there was a minority of participants in the other two Mixed Attachment Class; the Protective Relationships
latent classes for whom peer relationships and school Class was the only latent class in which peer relationships
relationships were potential risk factors. These findings significantly and negatively predicted suicide attempts.
challenge the universal applicability of Joiner’s (2005) Additionally, girls had lower odds of being in the two
interpersonal-psychological theory of suicidal behavior. latent classes in which school relationships were protective
What follows is a discussion of how differences in gender factors (Protective Relationships Class and the Mixed
and acculturation might explain the differential effects of Relationships Class) as compared to the Non-Protective
family, school, and peer relationships on suicide attempts Relationships Class. In other words, compared to boys,
across latent classes, including the counter-intuitive find- girls had higher odds of being in the Non-Protective
ings that school and peer relationships were risk factors in Relationships Class, the only latent class in which stronger
two latent classes. school relationships predicted higher rates of suicide
In support of our second hypothesis, we found that attempts. These findings are somewhat consistent with
highly acculturated participants had greater odds of being those of Lewinsohn et al. (2001), who also found that the
in the Non-Protective Relationships Class than in the other effects of family support and peer support on suicide
two latent classes. Among the three latent classes, the Non- attempts differed between adolescent boys and girls.
Protective Relationships Class was the only latent class in Moreover, the emergence of school relationships as a risk
which family relationships were not a significant protective factor in the Non-Protective Relationships Class might
factor against suicide attempts. These findings dovetail reflect Asian American girls’ experience of acculturative
with those of previous studies showing that family vari- stress. Compared to their male counterparts, Asian Amer-
ables were less strongly associated with suicide-related ican girls tend to experience stricter parental control over
outcomes among highly acculturated Asian Americans as their schooling activities and social lives, more familial
compared to less acculturated Asian Americans (Lau et al. obligations, and greater parental expectations to retain
2002; Wong et al. in press). Family relationships might be Asian cultural traditions (Fuligni et al. 2002; Qin 2009). On
a less relevant protective factor for highly acculturated the other hand, Asian American girls also face gendered
Asian American adolescents because they might be more social pressures in school (e.g., wearing fashionable clothes
concerned about individuating from their families and are and showing an interest in boys) that are antithetical to the
therefore less affected by the degree to which their family cultural values of their parents (Qin 2009). Accordingly,
members feel connected to one another (cf. Lau et al. high levels of connectedness to school could, ironically,
2002). engender parental disapproval or internalized guilt for
Additionally, less acculturated participants had greater some Asian American girls because they may reflect
odds of being in the Mixed Relationships Class than in the activities that conflict with traditional Asian parental
other two latent classes. The distinctive feature of the expectations.
Mixed Relationships Class is that peer relationships were a
risk factor for suicide attempts. Perhaps this finding reflects Strengths and Limitations
the psychosocial stressors that less acculturated Asian
American adolescents experience. Less acculturated Asian Several strengths in our study were notable. The Add
American adolescents who spend a lot of time with their Health dataset enabled us to use a large, nationally-
123
1462 J Youth Adolescence (2011) 40:1453–1464
representative sample of Asian American adolescents as Asian American adolescents would be to strengthen Asian
well as a longitudinal research design. We were also able to American parent–child relationships (Leong et al. 2011;
use measures with prior validity evidence in Asian Amer- Wong et al. 2011c). Interventions may include family
ican adolescent samples because the Add Health data have therapy and psychoeducational classes to bridge intergen-
been used in several published studies (e.g., Crosnoe and erational cultural gaps between Asian American parents
Elder 2004; Hahm et al. 2003; Willgerodt 2008). Further- and children (Kim 2003; Ying 2009). For instance, family
more, our use of latent class regression is a methodological therapists and educators can help Asian American families
strength. Our bivariate analyses found that only one of the view parent–child conflicts as an acculturative stressor
three indicators of belongingness—family relationships— confronting the entire family rather than as a problem
was significantly and negatively related to Wave 2 suicide associated with a specific member of the family (Kim
attempts. In contrast, because latent class regression is not 2003). However, a one-size-fits-all approach to the pre-
bound by the assumption of population homogeneity in vention of suicide-related outcomes may be problematic;
traditional regression methods (Ding 2006), we were able for some Asian American adolescents, stronger school and
to identify distinct subgroups, each of whom demonstrated peer relationships may be risk factors for suicide attempts.
different effects of family, peer, and school relationships Accordingly, educators and mental health professionals
on subsequent suicide attempts. need to tailor their interventions to address the psychoso-
Despite these strengths, several limitations in this study cial needs of specific Asian American subgroups (e.g.,
should be noted. First, although suicide attempts have been Asian American female adolescents or highly acculturated
shown to be a robust predictor of suicide deaths among Asian American adolescents). For instance, given our
adolescents (Spirito and Esposito-Smythers 2006), only a finding that less acculturated Asian American adolescents
small proportion of individuals who attempt suicide even- were more likely to be found in a latent class of partici-
tually die by suicide. Therefore, our findings cannot be pants in which peer relationships were a risk factor for
generalized to suicide deaths. Second, our research ques- suicide attempts, preventive interventions can focus on
tions were limited by the paucity of culture-related items in identifying and addressing problematic aspects of friend-
the Add Health questionnaires. Place of birth and language ships and strengthening healthy friendships among these
spoken at home do not fully capture the complexities of adolescents.
Asian Americans’ acculturative experiences. Future
research should use measures that reflect the multidimen-
sional and bilinear nature of Asian Americans’ cultural
Conclusions
experiences (Gim Chung et al. 2004). Third, we focused
only on gender and acculturation differences among the
The goal of this study was to identify subgroups of Asian
latent classes; future research should address other demo-
American adolescents who demonstrated different profiles
graphic differences, such as socioeconomic status and
in the influence of family, school, and peer relationships on
family structure. Fourth, the magnitude of the odds ratio in
suicide attempts. We found that across three latent classes,
the latent class regression should be interpreted cautiously.
these three indicators of belongingness exerted signifi-
Sparse data biases might have inflated the size of the odds
cantly different effects on Asian American adolescents’
ratio for some predictors (e.g., OR = 3,779 for peer rela-
suicide attempts. Our findings provide support for the
tionships in the Mixed Relationships Class) due to the low
person-oriented framework, which emphasizes a holistic
frequency of suicide attempts across the latent classes
and interactionistic view of adolescent development and
(Greenland et al. 2000). Finally, future research should
the importance of understanding how diverse groups of
identify the pathways through which school and peer
adolescents differ on the basis of a constellation of char-
relationships might increase the risk of suicide attempts for
acteristics (Bergman and Magnusson 1997; von Eye and
some Asian American adolescents. As earlier discussed,
Bogat 2006). From a prevention perspective, the main take-
acculturative stress might be a potential mediating variable
home message from our findings is the need for educators
that explains the link between school and peer relationships
and mental health professionals to tailor suicide-related
and suicide attempts.
prevention programs to address the unique developmental
needs of specific subgroups of Asian American adolescents
(e.g., Asian American girls). Overall, the findings of our
Practical Implications
study underscore the heterogeneity and complexities of
Asian American adolescent development.
Our findings present several practical implications. Given
the importance of family relationships as a protective factor Acknowledgments This study was funded by a grant provided by
in our study, a useful suicide-related prevention strategy for the Maris M. Proffitt and Mary Higgins Proffitt Endowment Grants.
123
J Youth Adolescence (2011) 40:1453–1464 1463
123
1464 J Youth Adolescence (2011) 40:1453–1464
Qin, D. B. (2009). Being ‘‘good’’ or being ‘‘popular’’: Gender and Willgerodt, M. A. (2008). Family and peer influences on adjustment
ethnic identity negotiations of Chinese immigrant adolescents. among Chinese, Filipino, and White youth. Nursing Research,
Journal of Adolescent Research, 24, 37–66. 57, 395–405.
Radloff, L. S. (1977). The CES-D scale: A self-report depression Willgerodt, M. A., & Thompson, E. A. (2006). Ethnic and genera-
scale for research in the general population. Applied Psycholog- tional influences on emotional distress and risk behaviors among
ical Measurement, 1, 385–401. Chinese and Filipino American adolescents. Research in Nursing
Reboussin, B. A., Hubbard, S., & Ialongo, N. S. (2007). Marijuana and Health, 29, 311–324.
use patterns among African-American middle-school students: A Wong, Y. J., Brownson, C., & Schwing, A. E. (2011a). Risk and
longitudinal latent class regression analysis. Drug and Alcohol protective factors associated with Asian American students’
Dependence, 90, 12–24. suicidal ideation: A multi-campus, national study. Journal of
Schafer, J. L. (1999). Multiple imputation: A primer. Statistical College Student Development, 52, 396–408.
Methods in Medical Research, 8, 3–15. Wong, Y. J., Koo, K., Tran, K. K., Chiu, Y.-C., & Mok, Y. (2011b).
Singelis, T. M. (1994). The measurement of independent and Asian American college students’ suicide ideation: A mixed-
interdependent self-construals. Personality and Social Psychol- methods study. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 58, 197–209.
ogy Bulletin, 20, 580–591. Wong, Y. J., & Poon, M.-L. (2010). Counseling Asian American men
Spirito, A., & Esposito-Smythers, C. (2006). Attempted and com- who demonstrate suicidal behavior. In W. M. Liu, D. Iwamoto,
pleted suicide in adolescence. Annual Review of Clinical & M. Chae (Eds.), Culturally responsive counseling with Asian
Psychology, 2, 237–266. American men (pp. 279–298). New York: Routledge.
Suarez-Orozco, C., & Qin, D. B. (2006). Gendered perspectives in Wong, Y. J., Tran, K. K., Schwing, A. E., Cao, L. H., Ho, P. P.-H., &
psychology: Immigrant origin youth. International Migration Nguyen, Q.-T. (2011c). Vietnamese American immigrant par-
Review, 40, 165–198. ents: A pilot parenting intervention. The Family Journal, 19,
Tadmor, C. T., & Tetlock, P. E. (2006). Biculturalism: A model of the 314–321.
effects of second-culture exposure on acculturation and integra- Wong, Y. J., Uhm, S. Y., & Li, P. (in press). Asian Americans’ family
tive. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 37, 173–190. cohesion and suicide ideation: Moderating and mediating effects.
Ueno, K. (2005). The effects of friendship networks on adolescent American Journal of Orthopsychiatry.
depressive symptoms. Social Science Research, 34, 484–510. Ying, Y. (2009). Strengthening Intergenerational/Intercultural Ties in
Ueno, K. (2009). Same-race friendships and school attachment: Immigrant Families (SITIF): A parenting intervention to bridge
Demonstrating the interaction between personal network and the Chinese American intergenerational acculturation gap. In N.
school composition. Sociological Forum, 24, 515–537. Trinh, Y. C. Rho, K. M. Sanders, & F. G. Lu (Eds.), Handbook
US Department of Health and Human Services. (2007). Health, of mental health in Asian Americans: Families, acculturation,
United States, 2007. Retrieved January 29, 2009, from and resilience (pp. 45–64). Totowa, NJ: Humana Press.
http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/hus/hus07.pdf. Zhou, Z., Peverly, S., Xin, T., Huang, A. S., & Wang, W. (2003).
Van Horn, M. L., Jaki, T., Masyn, K., Ramey, S. L., Smith, J. A., & School adjustment of first-generation Chinese-American adoles-
Antaramian, S. (2009). Assessing differential effects: Applying cents. Psychology in the Schools, 40, 71–84.
regression mixture models to identify variations in the influence
of family resources on academic achievement. Developmental
Psychology, 45, 1298–1313.
Vander Stoep, A., McCauley, E., Flynn, C., & Stone, A. (2009). Author Biographies
Thoughts of death and suicide in early adolescence. Suicide and
Life-Threatening Behavior, 39, 599–613. Y. Joel Wong is Assistant Professor in the Counseling and
Vermunt, J. K., & Magidson, J. (2008). Latent GOLD 4.5. Belmont, Educational Psychology Department at Indiana University Bloom-
MA: Statistical Innovations Inc. ington. Dr. Wong received his Ph.D. in counseling psychology from
von Eye, A., & Bogat, G. A. (2006). Person orientation–Concepts, the University of Texas at Austin. His research interests include Asian
results, and development. Merrill Palmer Quarterly, 52, 390–420. American mental health, especially suicide-related outcomes.
Weaver, S. R., & Kim, S. Y. (2008). A person-centered approach to
studying the linkages among parent-child differences in cultural Cara S. Maffini is a doctoral student at Indiana University
orientation, supportive parenting, and adolescent depressive Bloomington. Her areas of interest include Asian American adoles-
symptoms in Chinese American families. Journal of Youth and cent mental health, risk and protective factors associated with violent
Adolescence, 37, 36–49. behaviors, and identity development.
Wedel, M., & DeSarbo, W. S. (1994). A review of recent develop-
ments in latent class regression models. In R. P. Bagozzi (Ed.),
Advanced methods of marketing research (pp. 352–388). Cam-
bridge: Blackwell Publishers.
123