Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

THE CITY OF BUFFALO

The City of Buffalo Zoning Board of Appeals 901 City Hall

Minutes  April 17, 2019 Buffalo, NY 14202


http://www.city-buffalo.com
James Lewis

Regular OSP Conference Room 2:00 PM


901 City Hall, 65 Niagara Sq,, Buffalo, NY 14202

I. Call to Order

The meeting was called to order at 2:05 PM by Chairman James A. Lewis


Attendee Name Present Absent Late Arrived
Bernice Radle   
Thomas Dearing   
Janice McKinnie   
James Hornung Jr   
James A. Lewis   

II. Minutes Approval


1. Zoning Board of Appeals - Regular - Mar 20, 2019 2:00 PM

RESULT: ACCEPTED [UNANIMOUS]


MOVER: Janice McKinnie
SECONDER: James Hornung Jr
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing

III. Public Hearings


1. 47 East Amherst Street - Erect Building; in Excess of Building Height and Parking Not
Permitted in Corner Side Yards. N-2E Zone . Section 496-3.2.11.E(A), and -8.3.3.A.

RESULT: CLOSED PUBLIC HEARING [UNANIMOUS]


MOVER: James A. Lewis, Chairman
SECONDER: Bernice Radle
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
47 East Amherst Street - Erect Building; in Excess of Building Height and Parking Not Permitted
in Corner Side Yards. N-2E Zone . Section 496-3.2.11.E(A), and -8.3.3.A.

Board approved variances for "In excess of building height" and "Parking not
permitted in corner side yards".

Generated 4/18/2019 11:34 AM


Regular Wednesday, April 17, 2019 2:00 PM

RESULT: APPROVE VARIANCE [UNANIMOUS]


MOVER: James Hornung Jr
SECONDER: Janice McKinnie
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
2. 11 Norway Park - Permit Parking Pad; Parking Not Permitted in Front Yard. N-3R Zone.
Section 496-8.3.3.A.2.

RESULT: CLOSED PUBLIC HEARING [UNANIMOUS]


MOVER: Bernice Radle
SECONDER: Janice McKinnie
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
11 Norway Park - Permit Parking Pad; Parking Not Permitted in Front Yard. N-3R Zone. Section
496-8.3.3.A.2.

Board denied the variance for "Parking pad not permitted in front yard" for the
following reasons:
* Applicant currently has a driveway
* No evidence provided for the need of a parking pad
RESULT: DENY VARIANCE [UNANIMOUS]
MOVER: Janice McKinnie
SECONDER: Bernice Radle
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
3. 58 Goodyear Avenue - Combine Lots and Erect Garage; in Excess of Lot Width and
Garage Must be Set Back at Least 20 Feet from Front Facade of Principal Building. N-4-
30 Zone. Section 496-3.2.6.(CB), and -6.2.2.Q.1.

RESULT: CLOSED PUBLIC HEARING [UNANIMOUS]


MOVER: Janice McKinnie
SECONDER: Bernice Radle
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
58 Goodyear Avenue - Combine Lots and Erect Garage; in Excess of Lot Width and Garage Must
be Set Back at Least 20 Feet from Front Facade of Principal Building. N-4-30 Zone.
Section 496-3.2.6.(CB), and -6.2.2.Q.1.

Board approved variances for "In excess of lot width", and "Garage must be set
back at least 20 feet from front facade of principal structure".

2|Page
Regular Wednesday, April 17, 2019 2:00 PM

RESULT: APPROVE VARIANCE [UNANIMOUS]


MOVER: Janice McKinnie
SECONDER: James Hornung Jr
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
4. 41 Chandler Street - Erect Addition; in Excess of Front Yard Setback, Parking Not
Permitted in Front Yard, and Accessory Structure Not Permitted in Front Yard. N-1S
Zone. Section 496-3.2.7.D(A), -8.3.3.A, and -6.2.1.D.3.

RESULT: CLOSED PUBLIC HEARING [UNANIMOUS]


MOVER: Janice McKinnie
SECONDER: Bernice Radle
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
41 Chandler Street - Erect Addition; in Excess of Front Yard Setback, Parking Not Permitted in
Front Yard, and Accessory Structure Not Permitted in Front Yard. N-1S Zone. Section
496-3.2.7.D(A), -8.3.3.A, and -6.2.1.D.3.

Negative Declaration Adopted


Board approved variances for "In excess of front yard setback", and "Accessory
structure not permitted in front yard".
RESULT: APPROVE VARIANCE [UNANIMOUS]
MOVER: James Hornung Jr
SECONDER: Bernice Radle
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
41 Chandler Street - Erect Addition; in Excess of Front Yard Setback, Parking Not Permitted in
Front Yard, and Accessory Structure Not Permitted in Front Yard. N-1S Zone. Section
496-3.2.7.D(A), -8.3.3.A, and -6.2.1.D.3.

Board approved with conditions the variance for "Parking not permitted in front
yard".
Condition:
*Parking for handicap spaces only
RESULT: APPROVE VARIANCE W/COND [UNANIMOUS]
MOVER: Janice McKinnie
SECONDER: Bernice Radle
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
5. 2090 Elmwood Avenue - Erect Addition; Deficient in Ground Floor Transparency D.S.
Zone. Section 496-4.4.6.(A).

3|Page
Regular Wednesday, April 17, 2019 2:00 PM

RESULT: CLOSED PUBLIC HEARING [UNANIMOUS]


MOVER: Janice McKinnie
SECONDER: Bernice Radle
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
2090 Elmwood Avenue - Erect Addition; Deficient in Ground Floor Transparency D.S. Zone.
Section 496-4.4.6.(A).

Negative Declaration Adopted


Board approved variance for "Deficient in ground floor front facade
transparency".
RESULT: APPROVE VARIANCE [UNANIMOUS]
MOVER: James Hornung Jr
SECONDER: Janice McKinnie
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
6. 65 Northland Avenue - Erect Building; in Excess of Residential Density. N-3R Zone.
Section 496-3.2.1.E.

RESULT: CLOSED PUBLIC HEARING [UNANIMOUS]


MOVER: James Hornung Jr
SECONDER: Janice McKinnie
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
65 Northland Avenue - Erect Building; in Excess of Residential Density. N-3R Zone. Section 496-
3.2.1.E.

Negative Declaration Adopted


Board approved variance for "In excess of residential density".
RESULT: APPROVE VARIANCE [3 TO 0]
MOVER: Janice McKinnie
SECONDER: James Hornung Jr
AYES: Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A. Lewis
ABSTAIN: Bernice Radle
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
7. 894 Kenmore Avenue - Construct Parking Lot; Parking Not Permitted in Interior Side
Yard. N-3E Zone. Section 496-8.3.3.A.

4|Page
Regular Wednesday, April 17, 2019 2:00 PM

RESULT: TABLED [UNANIMOUS]

Next: 5/15/2019 2:00 PM


MOVER: Bernice Radle
SECONDER: Janice McKinnie
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
8. 312 Normal Avenue - Combine Lots; in Excess of Lot Width. N-2R Zone. Section 496-
11.534.A.1 or -3.2.6.C(B).

RESULT: CLOSED PUBLIC HEARING [UNANIMOUS]


MOVER: Janice McKinnie
SECONDER: James Hornung Jr
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
312 Normal Avenue - Combine Lots; in Excess of Lot Width. N-2R Zone. Section 496-11.534.A.1
or -3.2.6.C(B).

Board approved variance for "In excess of lot width".


RESULT: APPROVE VARIANCE [UNANIMOUS]
MOVER: James Hornung Jr
SECONDER: Bernice Radle
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
9. 201 Ellicott – Erect commercial & residential buildings; BLDG 1: deficient building hgt, in
excess of front setback (Ellicott/Oak), deficient build-to % (Oak), in excess of interior side
setback, deficient front transparency (Oak), deficient corner side transparency, excess
fence hgt, refuse not allowed in front yard, parking not permitted interior side, loading
area not permitted front facade; BLDG. 2: excess front setback (Ellicott/Oak); deficient
ground story height, and excess fence hgt N1C

RESULT: TABLED [UNANIMOUS]

Next: 5/15/2019 2:00 PM


MOVER: Bernice Radle
SECONDER: Janice McKinnie
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
10. 1020 Elmwood Avenue - Erect Building; No More Than Two Lots May be Combined for
New Construction in Elmwood Village, and in Excess of Building Height. N-2C Zone.
Section 496-3.2.1.J.3.E(A), and -3.2.5.E(A).

5|Page
Regular Wednesday, April 17, 2019 2:00 PM

RESULT: CLOSED PUBLIC HEARING [UNANIMOUS]


MOVER: Janice McKinnie
SECONDER: Bernice Radle
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing
1020 Elmwood Avenue - Erect Building; No More Than Two Lots May be Combined for New
Construction in Elmwood Village, and in Excess of Building Height. N-2C Zone. Section
496-3.2.1.J.3.E(A), and -3.2.5.E(A).

Negative Declaration Adopted


Board approved with conditions variances for "No more than two lots may be
combined for new construction in the Elmwood Village" and "In excess of
building height".
Condition:
*Include the stepback from the front facade at a depth equal to the height of the
4th floor
RESULT: APPROVE VARIANCE W/COND [UNANIMOUS]
MOVER: James Hornung Jr
SECONDER: Bernice Radle
AYES: Bernice Radle, Janice McKinnie, James Hornung Jr, James A.
Lewis
ABSENT: Thomas Dearing

IV. Adjournment

The meeting was closed at 5:25 PM

________________________
City Clerk

6|Page

You might also like