Designer Babies Presentation Rubric
0 1
Presentation informs
audience on the correct
science behind designer
babies
Points x2
Presentation has adequate
evidence to support the
groups stance (to pass or not stance on the issue
pass the law)
Points x2
Presentation includes the
other side of the argument
and links it back to their
original stance (rebuttal)
Presentation looks appealing
to the eye and has enough
information for audience to
make an educated decision
Presentation was given in a
2-3 4
The presentation The presentation The presentation gives The presentation gives
does not include touches on the science some information about a thorough explanation
anything about the of designer babies, but the science of designer of the science behind
science of designer nothing is explained babies, but there is not designer babies
babies enough or some of the
science is wrong
The presentation The presentation The presentation make The presentation makes
does not make a makes a stance but a clear stance and there a clear stance with
there is not enough is some evidence to adequate evidence to
evidence to back up back up their claim, but back up their claim
why the group took a not enough or some
stance evidence is incorrect
The presentation The presentation may The presentation The presentation
does not include the quickly touch on the touches on the other includes the other side
other side of the other side of the side of the argument of the argument and
argument argument but it is not and there is effort to link successfully links it back
linked back to the it back to their original to their original stance
original stance stance, however it may
not be completely
successful
The presentation is The presentation is The presentation is Presentation looks
extremely sloppy sloppy or there not pleasing to the eye and appealing to the eye
and there not enough information for there is some and has enough
enough information an audience member information but not quite information for audience
for an audience to make an educated enough for an audience to make an educated
member to make an decision member to make an decision
educated decision educated decision
It was impossible to The presentation was Presentation was given Presentation was given
professional manner
(appropriate eye connect,
dialect, volume and equal
participation of group
members)
understand the very unprofessional in a semi-professional in a professional
presentation with little eye contact, manner with a few minor manner
inappropriate volume problems with eye
and/or group members contact, dialect, volume
did not participate and equal participation
equally of group members

Presentation is free of
grammar errors and all
sources are cited
12+ grammar errors 9-12 grammar errors 3-9 grammar errors 1-3 grammar errors
Sources are not Sources are not Most sources are All sources are credible
cited credible and cited credible and all are cited and cited correctly
incorrectly correctly

You made an adequate Groupmates averaged Groupmates averaged a Groupmates averaged a

contribution to the group a 1 for your 2-3 for your contribution 4 for your contribution
(rated by group members) contribution

If you have an issue with X

your score from your
groupmates bring it to my
attention and I will determine
the final score
https://docs.google.com/doc
ument/d/1PaDqnoHMR5KG
Y7wWJ1p3Mvlk2RQFuA85r
LEGClnpwek/edit?
usp=sharing

Total Points: ___________ /44