ûý õ #

#
<$<6'334#
#
#
#
#
:(67(51#),71(66#
#
#
#
6WHSKDQLH# /DURFTXH# SUHSDUHG# WKLV# FDVH# XQGHU# WKH# VXSHUYLVLRQ# RI# 3URIHVVRU# -RKQ# +D\ZRRG0)DUPHU# VROHO\# WR#
SURYLGH# PDWHULDO# IRU# FODVV# GLVFXVVLRQ1# # 7KH# DXWKRUV# GR# QRW# LQWHQG# WR# LOOXVWUDWH# HLWKHU# HIIHFWLYH# RU# LQHIIHFWLYH#
KDQGOLQJ# RI# D# PDQDJHULDO# VLWXDWLRQ1# # 7KH# DXWKRUV# PD\# KDYH# GLVJXLVHG# FHUWDLQ# QDPHV# DQG# RWKHU# LGHQWLI\LQJ#
LQIRUPDWLRQ#WR#SURWHFW#FRQILGHQWLDOLW\1#
#
,YH\# 0DQDJHPHQW# 6HUYLFHV# SURKLELWV# DQ\# IRUP# RI# UHSURGXFWLRQ/# VWRUDJH# RU# WUDQVPLWWDO# ZLWKRXW# LWV# ZULWWHQ#
SHUPLVVLRQ1# # 7KLV# PDWHULDO# LV# QRW# FRYHUHG# XQGHU# DXWKRUL]DWLRQ# IURP# &DQ&RS\# RU# DQ\# UHSURGXFWLRQ# ULJKWV#
RUJDQL]DWLRQ1# # 7R# RUGHU# FRSLHV# RU# UHTXHVW# SHUPLVVLRQ# WR# UHSURGXFH# PDWHULDOV/# FRQWDFW# ,YH\# 3XEOLVKLQJ/# ,YH\#
0DQDJHPHQW# 6HUYLFHV/# F2R# 5LFKDUG# ,YH\# 6FKRRO# RI# %XVLQHVV/# 7KH# 8QLYHUVLW\# RI# :HVWHUQ# 2QWDULR/# /RQGRQ/#
2QWDULR/#&DQDGD/#19$#6.:>#SKRQH#+84<,#9940653;>#ID[#+84<,#99406;;5>#H0PDLO#FDVHV#LYH\1XZR1FD1#
#
&RS\ULJKW##‹##4<<6/#,YH\#0DQDJHPHQW#6HUYLFHV# 9HUVLRQ=#+$,#5335035045#
#
#
#
,Q# 0DUFK# 4<<5# $QGUHD# 6DXHUV/# )LWQHVV# 8QLW# &RRUGLQDWRU# DW# 7KH# 8QLYHUVLW\# RI#
:HVWHUQ#2QWDULR/#GHVFULEHG#KHU#H[SHULHQFH#LQ#ILWQHVV=#
#
,Q#HLJKW#\HDUV/#PDQ\#WKLQJV#KDYH#FKDQJHG1#$V#DQ#DHURELFV#LQVWUXFWRU#
LQ# 4<;8/# ,# ZDV# H[SHFWHG# WR# WHDFK# WKH# VDPH# FODVVHV# DV# WKH# QH[W#
LQVWUXFWRU# HYHU\# WLPH1# 7KDW¶V#ZKDW# SHRSOH# ZDQWHG1# 1RZ# SHRSOH#²#
PDQDJHUV/# LQVWUXFWRUV/# DQG# SDUWLFLSDQWV# ²# DUH# FKDQJLQJ# WKHLU#
H[SHFWDWLRQV# RI# ZKDW# D# ILWQHVV# FODVV# VKRXOG# EH1# 7KH\# UHDOL]H# LW¶V#
EHQHILFLDO#WR#KDYH#GLIIHUHQW#FODVV#W\SHV#DQG#VW\OHV#RI#LQVWUXFWLRQ1#7KH#
SDUWLFLSDQWV#GR#H[SUHVV#FRQFHUQ#IRU#WKH#ORVV#RI#D#JUHDW#ROG#ZRUNRXW1#
#
:LWK# WKRVH# WKRXJKWV# LQ# PLQG/# DQG# WKH# UHVXOWV# RI# D# UHFHQW# VXUYH\/# 8QGHUVWDQGLQJ#
2XU#3DUWLFLSDQWV#%HWWHU/#LQ#KDQG/#$QGUHD#ZRQGHUHG#KRZ#WR#LPSURYH#WKH#TXDOLW\#RI#
WKH# DHURELFV# SURJUDP1# $QGUHD# LGHQWLILHG# WKUHH# DUHDV# QHHGLQJ# LPSURYHPHQW=# WKH#
VXLWDELOLW\# RI# WKH# FODVVHV/# WKH# QXPEHU# RI# FODVVHV/# DQG# WKH# HIILFLHQF\# RI# SURJUDP#
DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ1#
#
#
7+(#),71(66#029(0(17#
#
7HOHYLVLRQ#H[HUFLVH#SURJUDPV#ILUVW#EHFDPH#SRSXODU#LQ#WKH#4<:3V#EXW#LW#WRRN#DQRWKHU#
GHFDGH#IRU#µDHURELF#GDQFH¶#WR#JDLQ#IDYRXU1#7KH#4<;3V#VDZ#WHOHYLVLRQ#SURJUDPV#VXFK#
DV#'DQFHUVL]H#DQG#7KH#53#0LQXWH#:RUNRXW/#DQG#KRPH#H[HUFLVH#YLGHRV#VXFK#DV#-DQH#
3DJH#5# <$<6'334#
#
#
)RQGD¶V#:RUNRXW/#JDLQ#SRSXODULW\1#:LWK#DQ#LQFUHDVLQJ#QXPEHU#RI#ZRUNLQJ#ZRPHQ#
ZDQWLQJ#WR#ORRN#DQG#IHHO#EHWWHU/#DHURELFV#EHFDPH#PRUH#SRSXODU1#
#
,Q# WKH# EHJLQQLQJ/# DHURELFV# VKRZHG# OLWWOH# FRQFHUQ# IRU# WKH# VDIHW\# RI# PRYHPHQWV1#
6SRUWV#GRFWRUV# DQG# ILWQHVV# VSHFLDOLVWV# ZHUH#VORZ# WR# DGPLW#WKDW# DHURELFV# ZDV# PRUH#
WKDQ#D#SDVVLQJ#IDG1#6XEVHTXHQW#UHVHDUFK#LQWR#DHURELF#PRYHPHQW#UHVXOWHG#LQ#PDQ\/#
RIWHQ#GLIIHULQJ/#OLVWV#RI#JRRG#DQG#EDG#H[HUFLVHV1#$HURELFV#SDUWLFLSDQWV#RI#WKH#4<<3V#
KDG#WKH#RSSRUWXQLW\#WR#EH#EHWWHU#LQIRUPHG#WKDQ#WKHLU#HDUOLHU#FRXQWHUSDUWV1#+RZHYHU/#
DV#LQ#DQ\#QHZ#ILHOG/#WKHUH#ZHUH#QR#XQLYHUVDOO\#DFFHSWHG#VWDQGDUGV#RI#JRRG#SUDFWLFH1#
#
#
5(&5($7,21#$7#7+(#81,9(56,7<#2)#:(67(51#217$5,2#
#
7KH# 8QLYHUVLW\# RI# :HVWHUQ# 2QWDULR# +8:2# RU# :HVWHUQ,# ZDV# ORFDWHG# LQ# /RQGRQ/#
2QWDULR/#DSSUR[LPDWHO\#533#NLORPHWUHV#VRXWKZHVW#RI#7RURQWR/#2QWDULR1#7KH#8:2#
FRPPXQLW\#FRPSULVHG#DERXW#58/833#IXOO0#DQG#SDUW0WLPH#VWXGHQWV/#IDFXOW\/#DQG#VWDII1#
#
8:2#VWXGHQWV#SDLG#D#PDQGDWRU\#UHFUHDWLRQ#IHH#+'65#IRU#IXOO0WLPH#VWXGHQWV#LQ#4<<4#
±#4<<5,1#)DFXOW\#DQG#VWDII#SDLG#PHPEHUVKLS#IHHV#IRU#DFFHVV#WR#UHFUHDWLRQ#IDFLOLWLHV1#
5HFUHDWLRQ#ZDV#PDQDJHG#E\#&DPSXV#5HFUHDWLRQ#DQG#ZDV#GLYLGHG#LQWR#VHYHQ#XQLWV1#
7KH# ILWQHVV# XQLW# EXGJHW# SURYLGHG# IXQGV# IRU# D# VHW# QXPEHU# RI# WHDFKLQJ# KRXUV/# VWDII#
WUDLQLQJ/#DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ/#VXSSOLHV/#DQG#HTXLSPHQW1#$FFRUGLQJ#WR#$QGUHD=#
#
:LWK# UHGXFHG# IXQGV# IRU# VWDII# WUDLQLQJ# DQG# KLULQJ# DGPLQLVWUDWLYH#
DVVLVWDQWV/# PDLQWDLQLQJ# DQG# LPSURYLQJ# WKH# TXDOLW\# RI# SURJUDPPLQJ#
ZLOO#EH#D#FKDOOHQJH$#,Q#RUGHU#WR#SUHYHQW#UHGXFWLRQV#LQ#WKH#QXPEHU#RI#
FODVVHV/#ZH#DUH#QRW#DGYHUWLVLQJ1#
#
#
)LWQHVV#DW#:HVWHUQ#
#
8:2#ILUVW#LQWURGXFHG#DHURELFV#FODVVHV#LQ#4<::±4<:;#ZKHQ#WZR#FODVVHV#ZHUH#KHOG#
HDFK#ZHHNGD\#LQ#WKH#8QLYHUVLW\#&RPPXQLW\#&HQWUH#+8&&,1#7KH#QXPEHUV#LQFUHDVHG#
DV# IROORZV=# 4<;5±4<;6/# IRXU# FODVVHV># 4<;8±4<;9/# HLJKW# FODVVHV># 4<;;±4<;</# 44#
FODVVHV1#,Q#4<<4±4<<5#WKH#ILWQHVV#SURJUDP#DGGHG#WZR#VWHS#DHURELFV#FODVVHV#GDLO\#WR#
LWV#SRUWIROLR1#7KH#VL]H#RI#WKHVH#FODVVHV#ZDV#OLPLWHG#EHFDXVH#RQO\#5;#VWHS#ER[HV#ZHUH#
DYDLODEOH1# 7KH\# DOVR# GLIIHUHG# IURP# WKH# RWKHU# ILWQHVV# FODVVHV# LQ# WKDW# WKH# ILWQHVV#
SURJUDP# FKDUJHG# SDUWLFLSDQWV# D# IHH# SHU# YLVLW1# ,Q# DGGLWLRQ# WR# DHURELFV# FODVVHV/#
&DPSXV#5HFUHDWLRQ# PHPEHUV# FRXOG# DOVR#LPSURYH# WKHLU# ILWQHVV# E\# SDUWLFLSDWLQJ# LQ#
DTXDELFV#FODVVHV#+VLPLODU#WR#DHURELFV/#EXW#LQ#WKH#ZDWHU,1#([KLELW#4#SUHVHQWV#WKH#FODVV#
VFKHGXOH#IRU#DHURELFV#DQG#DTXDELFV#FODVVHV#DW#8:21#
#
&DPSXV#5HFUHDWLRQ¶V#ILWQHVV#SURJUDP#VKDUHG#XQLYHUVLW\#DWKOHWLF#IDFLOLWLHV#ZLWK#WKH#
)DFXOW\# RI# .LQHVLRORJ\¶V# YDUVLW\# VSRUWV# DQG# RWKHU# DFDGHPLF# DQG# QRQ0DFDGHPLF#
JURXSV1# 2I# 94# WRWDO# DHURELFV# FODVVHV# SHU# ZHHN/# 79# ZHUH# KHOG# LQ# WKH# ODUJH# 8&&#
3DJH#6# <$<6'334#
#
#
*\PQDVLXP/#ZKLFK#KDG#D#ZHOO0FXVKLRQHG#IORRU#DQG#D#QHZ#VRXQG#V\VWHP1#7KH#RWKHU#
48#FODVVHV#ZHUH#KHOG#LQ#RWKHU#FDPSXV#EXLOGLQJV1#)URP#$QGUHD¶V#SRLQW#RI#YLHZ/#WKH#
IDFLOLWLHV# ZHUH# QRW# SHUIHFW1# 7KH# 8&&# URRI# OHDNHG/# DQG# WKH# FODVVHV# LQ# $OWKRXVH#
&ROOHJH#DQG#$OXPQL#+DOO#XVHG#PXFK0KDQGOHG#SRUWDEOH#WDSH#SOD\HUV1#$QGUHD#RIWHQ#
TXHVWLRQHG# WKH# SUDFWLFDOLW\# WR# WKH# SDUWLFLSDQWV/# LQVWUXFWRUV/# DQG# DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ>#
KRZHYHU/# VKH# REVHUYHG/# ³6PDOO# FODVVHV# DW# RXW0RI0WKH0ZD\# SODFHV# VXLW# VRPH#
SDUWLFLSDQWV1´#
#
&DPSXV#5HFUHDWLRQ/#HVSHFLDOO\#WKH#ILWQHVV#SURJUDP/#SODQQHG#WR#XVH#D#QHZ/#VPDOOHU/#
PXOWL0SXUSRVH# URRP# E\# -DQXDU\# 4<<7# ZKHQ# DQ# DGGLWLRQ# WR# WKH# FXUUHQW# 8&&# ZDV#
VFKHGXOHG#IRU#FRPSOHWLRQ1#7KH#QHZ#URRP#ZRXOG#DOOHYLDWH#WKH#FRQIOLFWV#RI#VKDULQJ#
IDFLOLWLHV#ZLWK#RWKHU#DFWLYLWLHV/#EXW#ZRXOG#QRW#DFFRPPRGDWH#WKH#ODUJH#QRRQ/#7#S1P1/#
DQG#8#S1P1#FODVVHV/#ZKLFK#ZRXOG#UHTXLUH#WKH#FRQWLQXHG#XVH#RI#WKH#8&&#*\P1#
#
#
0DQDJLQJ#WKH#)LWQHVV#3URJUDP#
#
$QGUHD# KDG# EHHQ# LQYROYHG# ZLWK# &DPSXV# 5HFUHDWLRQ# VLQFH# 4<;6/# ILUVW# DV# D#
SDUWLFLSDQW/# WKHQ# LQ# 4<;8/# SDUW0WLPH# DV# DQ# DHURELFV# LQVWUXFWRU# DQG# ORFNHU# URRP#
DWWHQGDQW1# 8SRQ# JUDGXDWLRQ# IURP#:HVWHUQ# ZLWK# DQ# +RQRXUV# %DFKHORU# RI#3K\VLFDO#
(GXFDWLRQ4# LQ# 4<;;/# VKH# VHFXUHG# WKH# SRVLWLRQ# RI# /RFNHU# 5RRP# 6XSHUYLVRU1# 6LQFH#
-XQH# 4<<3/# $QGUHD# KDG#KHOG# ERWK#WKLV# DQG# WKH# )LWQHVV# 8QLW# &RRUGLQDWRU# SRVLWLRQ1#
%\#4<<5#VKH#VSHQW#;3#SHU#FHQW#RI#KHU#WLPH#RQ#ILWQHVV1#
#
,QVWUXFWRUV#ZHUH#LPSRUWDQW#LQ#PDQDJLQJ#WKH#ILWQHVV#SURJUDP1#7KH#)LWQHVV#3URJUDP#
3ODQQLQJ# &RPPLWWHH# ZDV# D# JURXS# RI# ILYH# LQVWUXFWRUV# ZKR# DFWHG# DV# DVVLVWDQWV# WR#
$QGUHD1#,Q#6HSWHPEHU#4<<5#WKH#DGPLQLVWUDWLYH#VWUXFWXUH#ZDV#VFKHGXOHG#WR#FKDQJH/#
HIIHFWLYHO\# UHGXFLQJ# $QGUHD¶V# DVVLVWDQWV# WR# WKUHH=# $VVLVWDQW# 6WDII# &RRUGLQDWRU/#
$VVLVWDQW#3URJUDP#'HYHORSHU#DQG#5HVHDUFKHU/#DQG#$VVLVWDQW#3URJUDP#3URPRWHU1##
#
7KH#)LWQHVV#3ODQQLQJ#&RPPLWWHH#RIIHUHG#$QGUHD#XVHIXO#IHHGEDFN/#LGHDV/#RSLQLRQV/#
DQG# PRVW# LPSRUWDQWO\/# LPSOHPHQWDWLRQ1# 7KH# RWKHU# LQVWUXFWRUV# DOVR# SURYLGHG#
ZHOFRPHG# IHHGEDFN1# ,Q# 1RYHPEHU# DQG# 0DUFK/# HDFK# LQVWUXFWRU# UHFHLYHG# D#
TXHVWLRQQDLUH# VHHNLQJ# KLV# RU# KHU# IHHOLQJV# WRZDUG# WKH# ILWQHVV# SURJUDP# DQG# LWV#
DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ1#
#
#
:HVWHUQ#$HURELFV#,QVWUXFWRUV#
#
&DPSXV# 5HFUHDWLRQ# KDG# DERXW# 63# DHURELFV# LQVWUXFWRUV># DERXW# :8# SHU# FHQW# ZHUH#
VWXGHQWV1#(DFK#LQVWUXFWRU#ZDV#FHUWLILHG#LQ#ILWQHVV#LQVWUXFWLRQ#DV#ZHOO#DV#LQ#ILUVW#DLG#
DQG# FDUGLRSXOPRQDU\# UHVXVFLWDWLRQ# +&35,1# 0RVW# LQVWUXFWRUV# WDXJKW# WKUHH# RU# IRXU#
FODVVHV#HDFK#ZHHN#DW#:HVWHUQ>#PDQ\#DOVR#WDXJKW#DW#RWKHU#ILWQHVV#FOXEV/#HLWKHU#RQ#WKH#
VLGH#RU#GXULQJ#WKH#VXPPHU1#
###########################################################
4
,Q#4<<4#WKLV#GHJUHH#ZDV#UHQDPHG#+RQRXUV#%DFKHORU#RI#.LQHVLRORJ\1#
3DJH#7# <$<6'334#
#
#
,Q#4<<4±4<<5/#&DPSXV#5HFUHDWLRQ#SDLG#LWV#QHZ#LQVWUXFWRUV#'<188#SHU#KRXU#DQG#LWV#
UHWXUQLQJ# LQVWUXFWRUV# '43143# SHU# KRXU/# DQG# JDYH# WKHP# IUHH# DFFHVV# WR# ORFNHU# URRP#
VHUYLFHV1# &RPSHQVDWLRQ# FRYHUHG# WHDFKLQJ# WLPH# DQG# WUDLQLQJ# EXW# QRW# FODVV#
SUHSDUDWLRQ# DQG# GHVLJQ/# WKH# FRVW# RI# PXVLF/# RU# VWDII# GHYHORSPHQW# WKURXJK# RXWVLGH#
ZRUNVKRSV# DQG# OLWHUDWXUH1# 7KH# SD\# UDWHV# ZHUH# ORZHU# WKDQ# WKRVH# RI# PDQ\# RWKHU#
2QWDULR#XQLYHUVLWLHV1##
#
%HFDXVH# PDQ\# &DPSXV# 5HFUHDWLRQ# VWDII# ZHUH# VWXGHQWV/# \HDUO\# WXUQRYHU# RI#
LQVWUXFWRUV# ZDV# KLJK1# 7KH# SURJUDP# UHFUXLWHG# DV# PDQ\# DV# 48# LQVWUXFWRUV# HDFK#
DXWXPQ/#DQG#DGGHG#VHYHUDO#RWKHUV#WKURXJK#WKH#\HDU1#$QGUHD#HYDOXDWHG#DQ#DHURELFV#
FODVV# OHG# E\# HDFK# FDQGLGDWH# DQG# DOVR# DVVHVVHG# KLV# RU# KHU# SHUVRQDO# VXLWDELOLW\1#
$QGUHD# WULHG# WR# MXGJH# ERWK# SOHDVDQWQHVV# DQG# RSHQQHVV# WR# IHHGEDFN1# 7KLV# ODWWHU#
IDFWRU#ZDV#FRQVLGHUHG#LPSRUWDQW#DV#WKH#LQVWUXFWRU#FRXOG#H[SHFW#WR#KHDU#ERWK#SRVLWLYH#
DQG#QHJDWLYH#FULWLFLVP#WKURXJKRXW#KLV#RU#KHU#WHDFKLQJ#FDUHHU1#
#
$QGUHD#KDG#QHYHU#ILUHG#DQ#LQVWUXFWRU/#DOWKRXJK#WZR#KDG#UHVLJQHG#EHIRUH#VKH#KDG#WR#
DVN#WKHP#WR#OHDYH1#$QGUHD#EHOLHYHG#WKDW#VKH#FRXOG#KHOS#LQVWUXFWRUV#WR#LPSURYH#DQG#
ZRUN#RQ#WKHLU#WHDFKLQJ#VNLOOV#WKURXJK#FRQVWUXFWLYH#FULWLFLVP/#UDWKHU#WKDQ#KDYLQJ#WR#
ILUH# WKHP1# ,QVWUXFWRUV# ZKR# ZHUH# QRW# SHUIRUPLQJ# DGHTXDWHO\# XVXDOO\# ZLWKGUHZ#
YROXQWDULO\1##
#
%RWK# QHZ# DQG# UHWXUQLQJ# LQVWUXFWRUV# WRRN# SDUW# LQ# 6HSWHPEHU# RULHQWDWLRQ/# VWDII#
PHHWLQJV/# ZRUNVKRSV/# DQG# VHOI0LPSURYHPHQW# JURXSV1# (LJKW# KRXUV# RI# RULHQWDWLRQ#
WRRN# WKH# VWDII# WKURXJK#WKH#RUJDQL]DWLRQ#RI#&DPSXV# 5HFUHDWLRQ/# DQ#LQWURGXFWLRQ#WR#
RWKHU# LQVWUXFWRUV/# MRE# GHVFULSWLRQV/# VDIHW\# SURFHGXUHV/# DQG# RWKHU# UHOHYDQW#
LQIRUPDWLRQ1#6WDII#PHHWLQJV/#KHOG#HYHU\#WZR#WR#WKUHH#PRQWKV/#NHSW#LQVWUXFWRUV#XS0WR0
GDWH#RQ#FXUUHQW#HYHQWV# DQG#FRQFHUQV1#:LOOLQJ#LQVWUXFWRUV# RUJDQL]HG# DQG#SUHVHQWHG#
ZRUNVKRSV#DQG#VHOI0LPSURYHPHQW#VHVVLRQV/#ZKLFK#ZHUH#GHYRWHG#WR#GLVFXVVLQJ#DQG#
GHPRQVWUDWLQJ#QHZ#WHDFKLQJ#PHWKRGV#DQG#LVVXHV1##
#
#
352*5$00,1*#&+$//(1*(6#
#
3OHDVLQJ#3DUWLFLSDQWV#
#
$QGUHD#FODVVLILHG#SDUWLFLSDQWV#LQWR#WZR#W\SHV=#
#
xý WKRVH#LQWHUHVWHG#LQ#DFKLHYLQJ#RU#PDLQWDLQLQJ#ILWQHVV#
xý WKRVH#LQWHUHVWHG#LQ#VRFLDOL]LQJ#
#
0RVW# IDFXOW\# DQG# VWDII# VHHPHG#WR# EH#LQ# WKH# ILUVW# FDWHJRU\/# ZKHUHDV# VWXGHQWV# ZHUH#
JHQHUDOO\#LQ#ERWK1#
#
)LWQHVV#FODVVHV#GLIIHUHG#IURP#VSRUWV#LQ#JHQHUDO/#EHFDXVH#PDQ\#SDUWLFLSDQWV#DWWHQGHG#
WKH# FODVV#IRU#D#VFKHGXOHG#83# PLQXWHV#RI#µFDORULH0EXUQLQJ1¶#$#JRRG# FDUGLRYDVFXODU#
3DJH#8# <$<6'334#
#
#
ZRUNRXW# DQG# VLW0XSV# ZHUH# WKH# PRVW# SRSXODU# FRPSRQHQWV# RI# D# ILWQHVV# FODVV1# %XW/#
ZKDW# ZDV# D# JRRG# ZRUNRXW"# :LWK# SDUWLFLSDQWV# DW# PDQ\# GLIIHUHQW# OHYHOV# RI# ILWQHVV/#
WKLV#ZDV#D#GLIILFXOW#TXHVWLRQ#WR#DQVZHU1#$QGUHD#GLYLGHG#FODVVHV#LQWR#WKUHH#OHYHOV#RI#
LQWHQVLW\/# GHSHQGLQJ#RQ#WKH#GXUDWLRQ#RI#WKH# FDUGLRYDVFXODU#ZRUNRXW=#JHQHUDO# OHYHO#
+45# FODVVHV# SHU# ZHHN,/# LQWHUPHGLDWH# +4<# FODVVHV,/# DQG# DGYDQFHG# +48# FODVVHV,1# 7KH#
UHPDLQLQJ#48#FODVVHV#SHU#ZHHN#ZHUH#GHYRWHG#WR#VSHFLDO#WRSLFV=#VWUHWFK#DQG#VWUHQJWK/#
RU#VWHS1#
#
#
:KDW#LV#D#*RRG#:RUNRXW"#
#
7KH#LQWHQVLW\#LVVXH#ZDV#RQO\#EHJLQQLQJ#WR#VXUIDFH1#,Q#$QGUHD¶V#YLHZ=#
#
6LQFH# LW# LV# YLUWXDOO\# LPSRVVLEOH# WR# PHDVXUH# LQWHQVLW\/# WKH# SURJUDP#
UHOLHV# RQ# WKH# LQVWUXFWRU¶V# VHQVH# RI# LQWHQVLW\1# :LWK# WKH# SKHQRPHQDO#
UDQJH# RI# DELOLWLHV# DPRQJ# LQGLYLGXDOV# ²# ERWK# SDUWLFLSDQWV# DQG#
LQVWUXFWRUV#²#DQG#GDLO\#YDULDWLRQ/#WKLV#SURYHV#WR#EH#D#SUREOHP1#
#
2QH#LQVWUXFWRU#FLWHG#YLVXDO#LQWHQVLW\#DV#DQ#DSSURSULDWH#PHDVXUH#RI#D#JRRG#ZRUNRXW1#
6KH# IHOW# WKDW# LI# SDUWLFLSDQWV# VDZ# WKH# LQVWUXFWRU# ZRUNLQJ# KDUG/# DQG# VDZ# HDFK# RWKHU#
VZHDWLQJ/# WKHQ# WKH\# EHOLHYHG# WKDW# WKH\# ZHUH# JHWWLQJ# D# JRRG# ZRUNRXW1# 6RPH#
LQVWUXFWRUV#DWWHPSWHG#WR#PHDVXUH#SDUWLFLSDQWV¶#LPSUHVVLRQV#RI#FODVV#LQWHQVLW\#GXULQJ#
FDUGLRYDVFXODU#H[HUFLVH#E\#DVNLQJ#WKHP#WR#FODS#WKHLU#KDQGV#LI#WKH\#IHOW#JRRG1#
#
$QGUHD# IUHTXHQWO\# GLVFXVVHG# TXDOLW\# ZLWK# LQVWUXFWRUV1# (DFK# KDG# KLV# RU# KHU# RZQ#
RSLQLRQ# RI# ZKDW# FRQVWLWXWHG# D# JRRG# ILWQHVV# FODVV1# $QGUHD# UHFDOOHG# WKH# IROORZLQJ#
W\SLFDO#FRPPHQWV=#
#
xý D#JRRG#ZRUNRXW#
xý WKH#ULJKW#LQWHQVLW\#
xý VRFLDO#DWPRVSKHUH#
xý OLWWOH#PHQWDO#VWUDLQ#
xý YDULHW\#
xý D#JRRG/#VROLG/#VWUDLJKWIRUZDUG/#IXQ#FODVV#
#
7KH\# KDG# DQ# HTXDOO\# ZLGH# UDQJH# RI# RSLQLRQV# WR# GHVFULEH# WKH# FKDUDFWHULVWLFV# RI# D#
JRRG#DHURELFV#LQVWUXFWRU=#
#
xý SHUVRQDOLW\#DQG#DELOLW\#WR#WUDQVIHU#HQHUJ\#
xý D#UROH#PRGHO#
xý D# WHDFKHU# DQG# H[SODLQHU# UDWKHU# WKDQ# VRPHRQH# ZKR# MXVW# JRHV# WKURXJK# WKH#
PRYHPHQWV#
xý ZHOO0FKRUHRJUDSKHG/#LQIRUPDWLYH/#DQG#LQVSLULQJ#
xý HQWKXVLDVWLF#ZLWK#JRRG#UDSSRUW#
xý ILW#DQG#NQRZOHGJHDEOH#DERXW#VDIHW\#
3DJH#9# <$<6'334#
#
#
xý JRRG#FRPPXQLFDWLRQ#VNLOOV#DQG#WKH#DELOLW\#WR#ZRUN#ZHOO#ZLWK#PXVLF#
xý H[SHUWLVH#LQ#WHFKQLFDO#DVSHFWV#RI#WKH#FODVV#
#
#
6DIHW\#
#
%RWK# SDUWLFLSDQWV# DQG# LQVWUXFWRUV# ZHUH# FRQFHUQHG# ZLWK# JHWWLQJ# QRW# RQO\# D# JRRG#
ZRUNRXW/# EXW# DOVR# D#VDIH# RQH1# ,JQRUDQFH# FRXSOHG# ZLWK# DQ# DWWLWXGH# RI# µQR#SDLQ/# QR#
JDLQ¶# UHVXOWHG# LQ# SHRSOH# SXVKLQJ# WKHPVHOYHV# WRR# IDU/# RIWHQ# UHVXOWLQJ# LQ# VWUHVV#
LQMXULHV# RU# RYHUWLULQJ1# )XUWKHUPRUH/# FHUWLI\LQJ# ERGLHV# VXFK# DV# WKH# <0&$# QRZ#
IURZQHG# XSRQ# PDQ\# VWUHWFKHV# DQG# PRYHPHQWV# WKH\# KDG# SUHYLRXVO\# DFFHSWHG# RU#
HYHQ#UHFRPPHQGHG1#$QGUHD#H[SHFWHG#LQVWUXFWRUV#WR#NHHS#DEUHDVW#RI#GHYHORSPHQWV#
LQ#ILWQHVV1#
#
$FFRUGLQJ#WR#WKH# 2QWDULR# )LWQHVV#&RXQFLO¶V# VDIHW\# VWDQGDUGV/# WKH#RSWLPDO#VL]H# IRU#
DQ#DHURELFV#FODVV#ZDV#63#SDUWLFLSDQWV#SHU#LQVWUXFWRU1#$W#:HVWHUQ/#WKLV#JXLGHOLQH#ZDV#
EURNHQ#PRUH#RIWHQ#WKDQ#QRW#GXULQJ#WKH#44#D1P1/#QRRQ/#7#S1P1/#DQG#8#S1P1#FODVVHV1#
)RU# H[DPSOH/# FODVVHV# LQ# HDUO\# -DQXDU\# ZHUH# RIWHQ# DV# ODUJH# DV# 583# WR# 5:8# SHRSOH1#
7KH# UDWLR# RI# SDUWLFLSDQWV# WR# LQVWUXFWRUV# ZDV# ORZHUHG# WKURXJK# WHDP0WHDFKLQJ# DQG#
PRQLWRULQJ1#,QVWUXFWRUV/#XVXDOO\#WZR#SHU#FODVV/#PRQLWRUHG#WKH#PRUH#SRSXODU#FODVVHV1#
7ZR# VXFK# PRQLWRUV# ZRXOG# UHGXFH# WKH# SDUWLFLSDQW2LQVWUXFWRU# UDWLR# RI# D# 5730
SDUWLFLSDQW#FODVV#IURP#573=4#WR#;3=41#+RZHYHU/#PDQ\#RI#WKH#PRQLWRUV#FRPSODLQHG#
WKDW#ZDONLQJ#WKURXJK#D#FODVV#ZDWFKLQJ#SDUWLFLSDQWV#IRU#83#PLQXWHV#ZDV#ERULQJ1#
#
$QGUHD# FRQIURQWHG# RYHUFURZGLQJ# ZLWK# DQ# ³$WWHQGDQFH# ²# 0RGHUDWLRQ# DQG#
5HJXODULW\´#UHFRPPHQGDWLRQ#LQ#WKH#4<<4±4<<5#&DPSXV#5HFUHDWLRQ#%URFKXUH1#7KH#
EURFKXUH#VWDWHG=#
#
7KH# ILWQHVV# FODVV# VFKHGXOH# KDV# EHHQ# GHVLJQHG# WR# HQFRXUDJH#
SDUWLFLSDQWV#RI#DOO#ILWQHVV#OHYHOV#WR#DWWHQG#FODVVHV#RQ#D#UHJXODU#EDVLV#
RI#WKUHH#WLPHV#SHU#ZHHN#1#1#1#,W#PHHWV#WKH#QHHGV#RI#SDUWLFLSDQWV#ZKR#
DUH# QHZ# WR# ILWQHVV# DQG# WKRVH# ZKRVH# DYDLODELOLWLHV# DUH# OLPLWHG# WR#
OXQFK#KRXU#DQG#DIWHU0ZRUN#FODVVHV1#
#
$V# ZHOO/# $QGUHD# VLJQLILFDQWO\# LQFUHDVHG# WKH# QXPEHU# RI# ORZ# LPSDFW# DQG# KLJK0ORZ#
LPSDFW# FODVVHV# LQ# 4<<4±4<<5/# HVSHFLDOO\# WKRVH# DYDLODEOH# DW# SRSXODU# WLPHV1# 6KH#
REVHUYHG#UHGXFHG#DWWHQGDQFH#DW#SHDN0KRXU#FODVVHV#ZLWK#D#FRUUHVSRQGLQJ#LQFUHDVH#LQ#
DWWHQGDQFH# DW# RWKHU# FODVVHV1# 7KH# PRVW# VLJQLILFDQW# GHFOLQH# ZDV# LQ# -DQXDU\# 7# S1P1#
FODVVHV#ZKLFK#KDG#XS#WR#658#SDUWLFLSDQWV#LQ#4<<4#EXW#QR#PRUH#WKDQ#598#SDUWLFLSDQWV#
LQ#4<<51#
#
(DUOLHU/#$QGUHD#KDG#DWWHPSWHG#WR#FRQWURO#FODVV#VL]HV#E\#LVVXLQJ#D#OLPLWHG/#FRQWUROOHG#
QXPEHU# RI# VKRH# WDJV# IRU# HDFK# FODVV# RQ# D# ILUVW0FRPH0ILUVW0VHUYHG# EDVLV># VKH#
HYHQWXDOO\# HOLPLQDWHG# WKLV# V\VWHP# ZKHQ# LW# ZDV# FOHDU# WKDW# LW# KDG# IDLOHG1# %HFDXVH#
SDUWLFLSDQWV#SLFNHG#XS#WKHLU#WDJV#LQ#DGYDQFH#EXW#GLG#QRW#DOZD\V#DWWHQG/#VRPH#SHDN0
3DJH#:# <$<6'334#
#
#
KRXU# FODVVHV# ZHUH# TXLWH# HPSW\# PXFK# WR# WKH# DQQR\DQFH# RI# ZRXOG0EH# SDUWLFLSDQWV#
ZKR#KDG#EHHQ#XQDEOH#WR#JHW#D#WDJ1##
#
#
3DUWLFLSDQWV¶#&RPSODLQWV#
#
$QGUHD# UHFHLYHG# D# ZLGH#UDQJH# RI# FRPSODLQWV/# PDQ\# YHU\# JHQHUDO/# H1J1/# ³WKDW#7=33#
FODVV#ZDV#%$'1´#7KH#PRVW#FRPPRQ#FRQFHUQ#ZDV#WKH#KLJK#YROXPH#OHYHO#RI#PXVLF#
SOD\HG#E\#WKH#LQVWUXFWRUV1#7KLV#IDFWRU#ZDV#GLIILFXOW#WR#FRQWURO1#,QVWUXFWRUV#KDG#WKHLU#
RZQ# WDSHV/# DOO# RI# ZKLFK# ZHUH# UHFRUGHG# DW# GLIIHUHQW# OHYHOV1# $QGUHD# IUHTXHQWO\#
UHPLQGHG# LQVWUXFWRUV# RI# WKH# QHHG# WR# WXUQ# GRZQ# WKHLU# PXVLF1# $QGUHD# WROG#
FRPSODLQLQJ#SDUWLFLSDQWV=#
#
3HUVRQDO#RSLQLRQV#RI#YROXPH#ZRUN#EHWWHU#ZKHQ#WKH\#FRPH#IURP#WKH#
SDUWLFLSDQW1# 2WKHUZLVH/# LW¶V# µMXVW# $QGUHD# FRPSODLQLQJ# DERXW# WKH#
PXVLF#YROXPHV#DJDLQ1¶#
#
&DPSXV#5HFUHDWLRQ#H[SHFWHG#WR#DFTXLUH#D#GHFLEHO#PHWHU#IRU#WKH#8&&#*\P#E\#-XQH#
4<<51#
#
$QGUHD# UDUHO\# DGGUHVVHG# RWKHU# FRPSODLQWV# UHJDUGLQJ# LQVWUXFWRUV/# FODVVHV/# DQG# WKH#
)LWQHVV#3URJUDP1#6KH#EHOLHYHG#WKDW#VKH#GLG#QRW#KDYH#WKH#WLPH# QRU# WKH# SDWLHQFH#WR#
GHDO#ZLWK#WKHP1#+RZHYHU/#VKH#ZDV#ZRUNLQJ#RQ#D#SDUWLFLSDQW#IHHGEDFN#ERDUG#ZKLFK#
ZRXOG# EH# SODFHG# RXWVLGH# WKH# ORFNHU# URRPV# QHDU# WKH# 8&&# *\P1# 6LPLODU# EXOOHWLQ#
ERDUGV/# LQFRUSRUDWLQJ# VLPSOH# FRPSODLQW0FRPSOLPHQW0FULWLFLVP# FDUGV/# KDG# EHHQ#
VXFFHVVIXOO\# LPSOHPHQWHG# LQ# ERWK# &DPSXV# 5HFUHDWLRQ¶V# ZHLJKW# URRP# DQG# ORFNHU#
URRP#DUHDV1#
#
#
3URJUDP#&KDQJHV#
#
&DPSXV# 5HFUHDWLRQ# GLVWULEXWHG# EURFKXUHV# LQ# $SULO# IRU# WKH# 0D\# WR# $XJXVW#
SURJUDPV/#DQG#LQ#$XJXVW#IRU#6HSWHPEHU#WR#$SULO#SURJUDPV1#7KH#EURFKXUH¶V#VHYHUDO#
SDJHV#LQFOXGHG#WLPHV#DQG#ORFDWLRQV#IRU#DOO#LQWUDPXUDO#VSRUWV/#SRRO#DFWLYLWLHV/#GURS0LQ#
VSRUWV/#VSRUWV#FOXEV/#DQG#ILWQHVV#FODVVHV1#$QGUHD#VSHQW#D#VXEVWDQWLDO#DPRXQW#RI#WLPH#
IURP#1RYHPEHU#WR#0DUFK#SODQQLQJ#WKH#ILWQHVV#SURJUDP#IRU#WKH#XSFRPLQJ#\HDU1#6KH#
GHYHORSHG#GLIIHUHQW#ILWQHVV#FODVV#VFKHGXOHV#WR#VXLW#WKH#H[SHFWHG#GHPDQGV#IRU#FODVVHV#
GXULQJ#WKH#IROORZLQJ#SHULRGV=#
#
xý WKH#ILUVW#WZR#ZHHNV#EDFN#WR#VFKRRO#
xý KROLGD\V#
xý 0D\#WR#-XQH#,QWHUVHVVLRQ#
xý 6HSWHPEHU#WR#$SULO#
xý H[DP#WLPHV#
xý -XO\#WR#$XJXVW#
3DJH#;# <$<6'334#
#
#
%HFDXVH# $QGUHD#KDG# QR#DGYHUWLVLQJ# EXGJHW/# VFKHGXOH# FKDQJHV# DIWHU#WKH# IDFW# ZHUH#
YHU\# GLIILFXOW# WR# FRPPXQLFDWH># WKXV/# VKH# NHSW# SURJUDP# FKDQJHV# WR# DQ# DEVROXWH#
PLQLPXP1#
#
#
0$,17$,1,1*#48$/,7<#,16758&7,21#
#
'XULQJ# WKH#DXWXPQ#VFKRRO#WHUP/#$QGUHD# PRQLWRUHG# ILYH#WR# VL[# FODVVHV# HDFK#ZHHN#
DQG#JDYH#IHHGEDFN#SRVLWLYHO\#WR#WKH#LQVWUXFWRU#DV#VRRQ#DV#WKH#VHVVLRQ#ZDV#RYHU1#
#
$QGUHD#KDG#SODQQHG#WR#HYDOXDWH#WKH#LQVWUXFWRUV#WZLFH#GXULQJ#WKH#4<<4±4<<5#VFKRRO#
\HDU1#+RZHYHU/#EHFDXVH#WKH#HYDOXDWLRQ#SURFHVV#SURYHG#WR#EH#WRR#WLPH0FRQVXPLQJ/#
VKH#FRPSOHWHG#RQO\#WKH#ILUVW#HYDOXDWLRQ#LQ#2FWREHU01RYHPEHU#4<<41#7KH#HYDOXDWLRQ#
SURFHVV# SURFHHGHG# DV# IROORZV=# $QGUHD# LQIRUPHG# HDFK# LQVWUXFWRU# ZKLFK# FODVV# VKH#
ZRXOG#HYDOXDWH1#'XULQJ#WKH#FODVV/#VKH#VDW#DW#WKH#VLGH#WR#REVHUYH1#6KH#JDYH#IHHGEDFN#
WR# WKH# LQVWUXFWRU# DW# WKH# HQG# RI# WKH# FODVV# RQ# KHU# SHUFHSWLRQV# RI# WKH# LQVWUXFWRU¶V#
VWUHQJWKV#DQG#ZHDNQHVVHV#LQ#WKH#IROORZLQJ#DUHDV=#
#
xý DGHTXDWH#VWUHWFKLQJ#
xý LQWHQVLW\#DQG#W\SH#RI#PRYHPHQWV#
xý VDIHW\#
xý YHUEDO#DQG#YLVXDO#FXHV#
#
$QGUHD# DYRLGHG# MXGJLQJ# WKH# XVH# RI# PXVLF# DQG# IORZ# RI# PRYHPHQW# EHFDXVH# VKH#
EHOLHYHG# WKDW# VKH# KDG# LQVXIILFLHQW# UHOHYDQW# NQRZOHGJH# WR# DVVHVV# WKHVH# DUHDV#
SURSHUO\1#
#
7KH# LQVWUXFWRUV# KDG# GLIIHUHQW# RSLQLRQV# RQ# WKH# DPRXQW# RI# IHHGEDFN# WKH\# UHFHLYHG1#
0DQ\# QHZ# LQVWUXFWRUV# EHOLHYHG# WKDW# $QGUHD# JDYH# WKHP# DGHTXDWH# IHHGEDFN1#
+RZHYHU/# VRPH# H[SHULHQFHG# LQVWUXFWRUV# EHOLHYHG# WKDW# WKH\# UHFHLYHG# YHU\# OLWWOH#
IHHGEDFN# RWKHU# WKDQ# WKH# FODVV# HYDOXDWLRQV1# ,Q# RQH# LQVWUXFWRU¶V# ZRUGV/# ³,# GR# JHW#
WHFKQLFDO#IHHGEDFN#IURP#$QGUHD/#EXW#,#GRQ¶W#IHHO#WKDW#VKH#FDQ#RIIHU#DOO#WKDW#,#QHHG1´#
7ZLFH/# WKLV# LQVWUXFWRU# KDG# DVNHG# RWKHU# KLJKO\0WUDLQHG# LQVWUXFWRUV# WR# FRPH# WR# KHU#
FODVV#DQG#HYDOXDWH#LW1#7KH\#SLQSRLQWHG#XVHIXO#DQG#VSHFLILF#DUHDV#IRU#KHU#WR#LPSURYH#
RQ1# $QRWKHU# LQVWUXFWRU# IHOW#WKDW#VKH#NQHZ#ZKDW#SDUWLFLSDQWV# ZDQWHG#RXW# RI#D# FODVV#
EHFDXVH#VKH#SDUWLFLSDWHG#LQ#RWKHU#LQVWUXFWRUV¶#DHURELFV#FODVVHV/#DQG#WKHUHIRUH#ZDV#LQ#
D#SRVLWLRQ#WR#NQRZ#ZKDW#SDUWLFLSDQWV#ZDQWHG1#
#
7KH#ODUJHVW#DPRXQW#RI#IHHGEDFN#FDPH#GLUHFWO\#IURP#SDUWLFLSDQWV1#6RPH#LQVWUXFWRUV#
UHFHLYHG#WZR#WR#WKUHH#FRPPHQWV#HDFK#ZHHN#IURP#WKHLU#SDUWLFLSDQWV1#7KLV#IHHGEDFN#
ZDV#JHQHUDOO\#SRVLWLYH>#SDUWLFLSDQWV#ZHUH#UHOXFWDQW#WR#FULWLFL]H#WKH#LQVWUXFWRU#IDFH0
WR0IDFH1# 2WKHU# LQVWUXFWRUV# VWDWHG# WKDW# WKH\# UHFHLYHG# OLWWOH# RU# QR# IHHGEDFN# IURP#
SDUWLFLSDQWV1#
#
3DJH#<# <$<6'334#
#
#
$QGUHD# GHYHORSHG# D# )LWQHVV# ,QVWUXFWRU# +DQGERRN# IRU# 4<<3±4<<41# +RZHYHU/# IHZ#
LQVWUXFWRUV#UHFHLYHG#FRSLHV#EHFDXVH#$QGUHD#EHOLHYHG#WKDW#LW#ZDV#WRR#GLVRUJDQL]HG#WR#
EH# XVHIXO1# 1R# VLPLODU# KDQGERRN# ZDV# PDGH# DYDLODEOH# LQ# 4<<4±4<<5/# DOWKRXJK# WKH#
$VVLVWDQW# 6WDII# &RRUGLQDWRU# ZDV# GHYHORSLQJ# DQ# HDVLHU0WR0UHDG# YHUVLRQ# IRU# 4<<5±
4<<61##
#
#
81'(567$1',1*#285#3$57,&,3$176#%(77(5#
#
,Q# WKH# DXWXPQ# RI# 4<<4# $QGUHD# GHYHORSHG# D# TXHVWLRQQDLUH# ZKLFK# VKH# FDOOHG#
8QGHUVWDQGLQJ#RXU#3DUWLFLSDQWV#%HWWHU#+VHH#([KLELW#5,1#$QGUHD#LQWHQGHG#WR#XVH#WKLV#
LQVWUXPHQW# WR# VXUYH\# SDUWLFLSDQWV# DQQXDOO\1# 6KH# EHOLHYHG# WKDW# WKH# VXUYH\# ZDV# DQ#
H[FHOOHQW# ZD\# WR# REWDLQ# IHHGEDFN# IURP# SDUWLFLSDQWV# RQ# WKHLU# H[SHFWDWLRQV# RI# D#
µTXDOLW\¶#DHURELFV#FODVV1# 6KH#DOVR#WKRXJKW#WKDW# WKH# VXUYH\#ZRXOG# HQDEOH#KHU#WR#OHW#
SDUWLFLSDQWV# NQRZ# KRZ# VKH# HYDOXDWHG# FODVVHV# DQG# LQVWUXFWRUV1# $# TXHVWLRQ# OLNH#
³:KDW# FULWHULD# GR# \RX# WKLQN# DUH# PRVW# LPSRUWDQW# IRU# JRRG# FODVV# OHDGHUVKLS"´# ZDV#
VXSSRVHG#WR#LQIRUP#WKH#SDUWLFLSDQW#WKDW#$QGUHD#H[SHFWHG#HQWKXVLDVP/#YHUEDO#FXHV/#
DQG# RWKHU# TXDOLWLHV# IURP# D# JRRG# DHURELFV# FODVV1# 7KH# VXUYH\# ZRXOG# DOVR# VHUYH# WR#
HGXFDWH#WKH#QHZFRPHU#RU#DQ\#RWKHU#SDUWLFLSDQW#ZKR#NQHZ#OLWWOH#DERXW#WKH#UHTXLUHG#
FRPSRQHQWV#RI#D#FODVV1#
#
)URP# 1RYHPEHU# 53# WR# 1RYHPEHU# 59/# EHIRUH# VWDUWLQJ# KLV# RU# KHU# FODVV/# HDFK#
LQVWUXFWRU# ZDV# VXSSRVHG# WR# LQYLWH# SDUWLFLSDQWV# WR# FRPSOHWH# WKH# VXUYH\1# 7KH#
SDUWLFLSDQW#FRXOG#ILOO#LQ#D#VXUYH\#EHIRUH#RU#DIWHU#WKH#DHURELFV#FODVV#ZLWK#WKH#SHQFLOV#
VXSSOLHG1#7KH#UHVSRQVH#UDWH#ZDV#PL[HG>#DV#PDQ\# DV#488# UHVSRQVHV# ZHUH#UHFHLYHG#
IURP#VRPH#FODVVHV#EXW#DV#IHZ#DV#RQH#UHVSRQVH#ZDV#UHFHLYHG#IURP#RWKHUV1#
#
([KLELW#6#SUHVHQWV#UDZ#GDWD#DQG#VWDWLVWLFV1#,W#ZDV#QRW#FOHDU#KRZ#UHSUHVHQWDWLYH#WKH#
VDPSOH# ZDV1# 7KH# SURJUDP# KDG# QR# LQIRUPDWLRQ# RQ# LWV# SDUWLFLSDQWV/# DOWKRXJK#
LQVWUXFWRUV#EHOLHYHG#WKDW#ZRPHQ#DFFRXQWHG#IRU#DV#PXFK#DV#<3#SHU#FHQW#RI#WKH#JURXS1#
1RW#DOO#VXUYH\#SDUWLFLSDQWV#DQVZHUHG#DOO#48#TXHVWLRQV1#$OVR/#VRPH#JDYH#PRUH#WKDQ#
RQH#UHVSRQVH#IRU#D#TXHVWLRQ1#
#
#
3UHYLRXV#6XUYH\V#
#
,Q# 'HFHPEHU# 4<<3# $QGUHD# KDG# XVHG# D# OHQJWK\# TXHVWLRQQDLUH# WR# VXUYH\# WKH#
DSSUR[LPDWHO\# 4/633# PHPEHUV# RI# 7KH# 8QLYHUVLW\# RI# :HVWHUQ# 2QWDULR# 6WDII#
$VVRFLDWLRQ# WR# GHWHUPLQH# ZKDW# LWV# PHPEHUV# ZDQWHG# IURP# :HVWHUQ¶V# ILWQHVV#
SURJUDP1#3LHUUH#9DQGHUZDOO/#D#NLQHVLRORJ\#VWXGHQW/#FRQVXOWHG#IRU#$QGUHD#UHJDUGLQJ#
WKLV#VXUYH\#DQG#LWV#UHVXOWV1#+H#UHSRUWHG=#
#
,W# LV# P\# IHHOLQJ# WKDW# 3XEOLFLW\# DQG# $GYHUWLVLQJ# LV# RQH# DUHD# ZKLFK#
QHHGV# D# JUHDW# GHDO# RI# LPSURYHPHQW# 1# 1# 1# 0DQ\# RI# WKH# UHVSRQGHQWV#
3DJH#43# <$<6'334#
#
#
VDLG#WKDW#WKH\#GLG#QRW#NQRZ#HQRXJK#DERXW#WKH#ILWQHVV#SURJUDP#DQG#
WKHUHIRUH#FRXOG#QRW#SDVV#MXGJPHQW#DERXW#WKH#VDLG#SURJUDP#1#1#1#
#
$W# WKH# 8&&# ZLFNHW# LWVHOI# WKHUH# VKRXOG# EH# PRUH# DWWUDFWLYH/# H\H0
FDWFKLQJ# LQIRUPDWLRQ# LQ# SODFH/# DV# RSSRVHG# WR# WKH# H[LVWLQJ# V\VWHP/#
ZKLFK#LV#RIWHQ#FRYHUHG#LQ#FKHDS#EULVWRO#ERDUG#VLJQV1#
#
$OWKRXJK# $QGUHD# GLG# QRW# HQDFW# WKHVH# VXJJHVWLRQV/# VKH# GLG# DFW# RQ# RWKHU# ILQGLQJV#
DERXW# FODVV# W\SHV# DQG# SURJUDP# PL[1# 7KLV# VXUYH\# ZDV# UHSHDWHG# LQ# 2FWREHU# 4<<4>#
([KLELW#7#VKRZV#WKH#UHVXOWV1#
#
#
&21&/86,21#
#
,Q# OLJKW# RI# WKH# FKDQJLQJ# GHPDQGV# IRU# ILWQHVV# FODVVHV# LQ# WKH# 4<<3V/# $QGUHD#
TXHVWLRQHG# WKH# TXDOLW\# RI# WKH# SURJUDP# DQG# LWV# DGPLQLVWUDWLRQ1# +RZ# VKRXOG# VKH#
PDQDJH#WKH#WUDGH0RII#EHWZHHQ#JLYLQJ#SDUWLFLSDQWV#ZKDW#WKH\#ZDQWHG#DQG#ZKDW#WKH\#
QHHGHG#IRU#ILWQHVV#DQG#VDIHW\"#+RZ#PDQ\#FODVVHV#VKRXOG#EH#KHOG"#+RZ#FRXOG#VKH#
PDQDJH# WKH#VL]H#RI# FODVVHV"#:HUH#VRPH#YHU\#ODUJH# RU# YHU\# VPDOO# FODVVHV#DFWXDOO\#
GHVLUDEOH"# :KLFK# WDVNV# FRXOG# $QGUHD# GHOHJDWH"# +RZ# FRXOG# VKH# HQVXUH# TXDOLW\# LI#
VKH#JDYH#XS#VRPH#PHDVXUH#RI#FRQWURO"#
#
#
3DJH#44# <$<6'334#
#
#
([KLELW#4#
#
(;&(537#)520#8:2#&$0386#5(&5($7,21#352*5$0#&$7$/2*8(/#)$//#)#:,17(5#4<<4#±#4<<5#
#

#
#
6RXUFH=#3K\VLFDO#5HFUHDWLRQ#DQG#,QWUDPXUDOV#3URJUDP#ILOHV1#
3DJH#45# <$<6'334#
#
#
([KLELW#5#
#
),71(66#3$57,&,3$17#6859(<#
#
#

#
3DJH#46# <$<6'334#
#
#
([KLELW#5#+FRQWLQXHG,#
#
#

#
#
6RXUFH=#3K\VLFDO#5HFUHDWLRQ#DQG#,QWUDPXUDOV#3URJUDP#ILOHV1#
#
3DJH#47# <$<6'334#
#
#
([KLELW#6#
#
6859(<#5(68/76#
#

#
#
6RXUFH=#3K\VLFDO#5HFUHDWLRQ#DQG#,QWUDPXUDOV#3URJUDP#ILOHV1#
3DJH#48# <$<6'334#
#
#
([KLELW#7#
#
5(68/76#2)#6859(<#2)#81,9(56,7<#2)#:(67(51#217$5,2#67$))#$662&,$7,21#0(0%(56#
#
#

#
#
6RXUFH=#3K\VLFDO#5HFUHDWLRQ#DQG#,QWUDPXUDOV#3URJUDP#ILOHV1#
#