Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 19

WXYZ U[\]^ _Z`\b[Y\ZbV _dX\Zf W[Zfhj\jV 3V k lmnkoq knstkmu

Moral Standards in Business Environment or


How is Corporate Ethics Possible?
I  I
  I
D    #$%  
B -B!" 
"i'( &
E((
Abstract. ) (
+ ,  (.,
   (,
$ ( (
( *'
( 
, 
( (
e/   
' 
0 ((
,   ( %
(( ,   (
  ("%( 

,",
 *  % , ( 
 
r  (  ( 
  ( ,  "
+    ((,  
 1, ,
(2'
1(( )
+,2    
ep34567898/: 
( 
 ,  (.
,    
 
( (     , "   ((    
( +   (" ;, 2'B,(

( (  . (   (( , ,    ' )   %
 ,  ("% . ((
" (
(     " 
  (g
, "   ,  ( ec
( ,   +(    
( %
1 (,( 2%1c ((,( , 2% 
(" ((
/' E( ( , " + ( ,  
,
!, ,
,   ( ,   
 ((,
( , "
  " 
fi  ("%
 + '
(   *  %" %( ' 
  , ,     (" 
 ((%
Keywords: , ,
,,%  ((
(% " %
+, (
ep34567898/% (% 
(
(,  (% ( ( , ( , % ( ,% (
( ,%
Introduction
U<=>??@ ACAF@GHA >JFAA< KL>K KLA >MMANK>HMA GO >HP KLA >PLAFAHMA KG QGF>?
FAR=SFAQAHK< S< KLA MGHPSKSGH GO OF=SKO=? MG??>TGF>KSGH >QGHJ NAGN?AV T=K KLA
>H<aAF KG KLA R=A<KSGH GO aLAKLAF SK S< NG<<ST?A >HP HAMA<<>F@ KG L>CA > QGF>?
11 I  I
 I

p       p        !
  pp    !     ! !  !p! 
pc " !  #   !!#   p   
fi    !    r#    p$  
 !    fl c u p       
  !! fl!    r# !  
   !  a ur#        #
   p   fi!       
p    !  #     p 
p  !     !p! !    
  p  p       !
 !  ! c

The ethical view of social institutions


The sphere of moral action1

App!      pp!$  #     p 


p  #         # 
 !    !   ppm !  sc#c  
p  p %c "    !!  p !
    # pp   p   #   
  #        p  !!   p
     pm # p     !c " 
# !#   s     #   !
   # p%      !fi! 
fl    ! !   #    ! 
  c "     !     ## $
  p  p ! p#      
&  p  !!   p     
 !  r!    ! !    # !
 #    ! c e   ! ! 
m     ! , #     
#!!     !  fi      c
N   #  !          
!  $ c#c '#(  ' ( p '(
   pm     ) ! 

* + -./0-/2 -3/ -4567 48 -369 9:;9/7-64< 6< => 9-:26/9 9/?/.0@ -6=/9 BC<D?0.6EF.G<>6 HJJKL HM*EHOK
0<2 C<D?0.6EF.G<>6 HJJPL *JQE*HPRL 0774.26<D@>L -3/ 84@@4S6<D -.06< 48 -34:D3- 69 =49-@> -3/
./6-/.0-64< 48 => 8:.-3/. 62/09T
M   
       111

s  s     ! " #   
i$ %s  ss & s'(   s!  !  iss "
    i    s(    s( s
  iims  !! s$
T)#   i* s!s  s   ( 
isi! s"!  s  si     s  s
 ss i  s(  s   s)  #s
 s s    !! "  ( s s$ o s  
 fis  i si )#   !  s s 
! #   s i#!   s#!  )"#(
    i isi!(  s    
i  s   s & is!   ")s  %
S+,( -#  .)( si !   s  /s T!(
%s Ao!  0+# 2s'$ T#   " "!s(   
 is s  s "s ! s s #s(
#!( s  s3 !    ss( (
si !( ss  #s(     s$
.#sL  s #  s s#! s
s   s  "( # s ss   ss
#  (    iis    " #   4)
"s  #w &5,'$ 6# s iss   ( si ! si(
as  #s is   i  s s$ o  (
 s   ## s#(  " is  
# (  " s  "!    s 
iss   s#   s s  s   "Lis
  3#$ Ts "!    ii  #   s
  is  si  #ss     ss
 i !   )#  #$

The corporation as subject of philosophical inquiry

P    !!  s  iims  s ) i   i


 $ T i s  i* s #,  iss
sifi #s(        #i  ii s s 3 s
 ) i   ,$ T #, s!s   ) s
ss ! i* is   i  "  isi
  ss  i!  i $ %#  %*
O (  L  T 7  Psi!  -sss  /#
U s!( is   s isi ass 8 9 )s
 iis  is  : 2"  s is   
   #s " )  i: 9 #s   i
11 I  I
 I

a a   a   a       
as a  s  s   !"  aa
a  a   a# "as "s s a
" c $a   a a a a a a aa a 
as # a a ! a   "   ac r 
!"a #"a   "%   a a as   
a&a# a a  a   a#   a "s 
ac '  !a(a a#    a  "! a
 a a  a  "!  a   !"a
 p a $a" ))* c + +"(as    'a
 oaa!s + a +   ,#  -a!s
as a./ 0" !a(a a# "s #s #a"s
#" a # +"(a ))1 c vs . - p2 3a a 4
B2 oa  a./ 0a a 0a 5a# a 0 3a a
oa 1MM6s 11* c 7  8" "   a   a a 
 at a#     aa  a     a.!
s " #  a 8"  a   a   
at aa  a     aa  a a2

Difficulties in building out corporate ethics


Corporate (business) ethics and economical education

r  a #" a a a  a #  9a 
a  a ##  a !# " a# a#  a 
a"s 22 a # a"   a  #2 5#s 
  a  #"   a  a" a a  "
9a    a a a   a s
  a  a" a #a   a
#2 :"s   9# a       #"a
 a! a        "  as
  a" a  a#  .  i!; a a2
S" a a a "  #a   a " 
a! a  (  a"  a! a a 
.  " a a a    a  a  a a #
aa    a #   a aa <2 =  "s
a !a " fi  !s   a "a a a! 
a a a a9a # a aa aa a
as #s a  a a "    !
"a  # " aa! a 9a  a "" "
M 

 
  11

ee e e  e   !"   # $ %&'# !'#&


a!a ! e # ee '& a e  e ae 
a!!  e a e ! 'a
I e ()t* e',  & " e +), e e!  ! e  e
  # e# $ e %&  $'e  #ee # e e &
#e e# ee$, -'  .e$e / # 0 %e 2'  !'#e# 
e '#  a e #ee # $'e e#'  3e#e e &fi 
e'! ee#  e fie!#  eae& aee a#' # fi  !
 %e,  aa  a#'e# &! '$  ! #  &e  '#e #&
e   ! $ %&'#  e e #', e  a!e e# e
h  4
4 #e!  $e& e ! e5a!   aa!e ee e
$  #e  e  e' #e!    e  e  e#
! $ e!fi  e ! ee #, eee, a  $ #  #e
   efie! ee e  e!#e6 ee ! a#e#    
e e#  $e&  #e 'a  e " e #efie! ae  &e 
aepe! e# aae  # a e ea$!  p e !  'e,
# "e   ee  & & afi -'   e!#e # 7!'&
ee !    #  'a %e,  aa    # e#  s'e !&
e e "   e %&, '     #e &e  '$e 
  &e #ee   e & e  %e  !'e  e a  es'  e
! es'ee  e ae ! 'e, e  fie# e " " 
 %& #e $ e!pee o/ # 2'  ())8, 19 7!'& e
$e ee# ' #  a   e  #e !! fl'ee# $'e
ee  ea$!e  e e &! &e  '$e    &e !
 # ' &e'! ea$!e, e!fi a e &e e  e
" e "#epae # " # , e a! #e    e e#' 
  $e e$'%e#  !e   e #e a' ! i e!!e' ! a!  
   !  fi# aae !e e  e h  4
4 #e! e  e
!' "  e e# $ c$e # :e$e! # ; & 7 3ee, #&
 "e a e :'aee   a !  !'e e,< " e5!'e!
e!e 'a e # e& ##' !  #a,   '!e# e!,
e e    e ! $eefi   $e e e#  ! $ ##' ! e #
efie, $'  e ! $ #& '!e #&  ' " ee# "
e"  ee  %e ae o:e$e! # 3ee ())v, ()v9
I "e  %e  ! e a$!  ', , e e #&  "
 a ! e5   ! $e ' !#  !&e 'e, e   e e

= A >?@>BCD E@ F?GBCH AJ K>HLNCBDBO P?QBR COESB TE@@BO B>?@?NEGDUG Q??V ?@ WXYZ[X\Z]^_


]`bZX\Z]^ Xdf gj^`bkXblm THE>H OBREBG LC?@ DHB nGGLNCDE?@ DHnD DHB B@DEOB DOnqE@r n@q
E@qLGDOEnR G?>EBDu EG >nGD E@D? B>?@?NE> N?RqG n@q EG ?w n@ B>?@?NE> @nDLOB E@ nRR EDG qBDnERGm
GDnODE@r wO?N EDG QnGBG DHO?LrH EDG GLGDnE@E@r GDOL>DLOB n@q LC D? EDG GEr@nR GuGDBNJ xHLGm ED EG
nQ?LD n G?>EBDu THBOB nRR nGGBGGNB@DGm COESBG n@q OBDOEQLDE?@G nOB ByCOBGGBq E@ fi@n@>EnR DBONGJ
11 I  I
 I

f f  fi e  fi s  f  e
    s  d  e   f
       f    e
s s  i     i ffi     
   e      
   i sa! "    d 
 d    f  f   i !
Tf     i i  i si  se 
  f  s     
 c    s e e s   
i f s  ! T    
 f      s  i f    is
   i s   ! m f  
  s    #     
 i  si d f  se f  ! $
    f   e     e f is
 ifi i f     f  % f 
  &i  ' ()) a!

Value perception differences in private life and business management

A    is  i s    


is     d   e 
s *  e  is    +  
   +   i  f  
 i     es   e  #e 
 fl    c    
#    ! me   f     
   i   s    is
   e     f  d 
i  +  b b* e  + es     #
i  s  f     i 
i  ia    f ! T fl f    s
  fl    A %&,  f  i
 e      # s e  i f
 e  fl f  s f  c d  f
i  ffi    i  b* ())1 (-1a! A
  s ff  e fi     
b*      e ,    s
D   . f ,s ffi e f  e
 fi ff   f  e  s    /.)!
M 

 
  11

C      !     "


w# #  #  #  $%& '&#  &" %$" fi"
e" " " " #%#"  % " "
 fi" #" "  " " "   , %& 
 a( %) * # #  % #  w## +   #
 + w #     # $w  # $
e w# # %"   # w c %$" # # #
 & w# #  #   # % $%&  t%
  fi$ &#  & w## #  v &&% " 
# #   v   %% # #   # ) -e"
# #  #   $%& # # #  %  
v#&" % &# $%& # # v% v     & 
# "      &  % " w $"
.&  w$ c " $  %vv) / w 
%" # #   #  fi$   &&% 
w# #   v &v.&%  v %% ) 0# &
+  –&2 v  + w #c      
#  3 # w   w#$  #
  &  $&%   $%& # v # $
"  #  # ) 4#% $&% $%& %&  &# 
#" %$"   " t&" # %    $%&
w &"  fi" w" $  &$) 5$%
&# #2# & w & #  %  $v%
   # #& $%& v$  $ %"  # #
  &%% v     & v 
    %$%" w#  #w %% %     
#& $%&  # $ %$)

“Bounded” ethicality in corporate environments

C     %$%    # $%& w# #c 
# %(   # $ %$    # $%& & w##
# % w# c       %  #
 % $   w# # ) 0#   # e%
 #  #  #   &% $ %  " # % %
.& w#& " &%c w#"   " # v$
#  % &fi%%" &v    v& fi 
 & &%) 0# # v(%   % v & v#
v & %   ' "  (  
" ," w##       %  %
  #  &"  v #  %% 6b  
11 I  I
 I

rr”   ! ,b"## $%r” &'' () *   !


 '  ' s+-(). '” * / ' * +0
H2 3(+ 456 7 8+   9: ;6(  8+  <===>? @+. !
+ !  2+* + !   &' +(+ + ** 'A' +  -
* .+   * *+ +0 +  (  ! &  ) 2+* ,2+*
' !” /+ 2! +' 2+> &' & &' + :( &' +'
 /+> *    &' 0+   +(! (. '+&
 (+* &''  +(2  &' ' + ! (  :
' ? e' 2+ (+ '+(   ! '+& 2! H-
G+. G(  ' + +0 @+ B p$CC + /G(
<==  <1DE<<=>   '*( s 0-(.(” 2 ! ??  ! ' 
+ ! +.6. ' .+   2 2! ' .' .+    &'  +
 *2  +  'A' *  i* 2! ' *(? F+ + ! '+
 ( * *' *( 2*  + 'A' ! +0 ,+ +”
 + * + ' '(+! +0 'A' (+  /*'  ) +0 '(+!
2&  2+ J*.(   fi *>?
@ '+*.' : '+& ' +-()  0i* ! +( 
+(  2! ' +( :! +0 ' *  2! ' +&' (.  +0
+ 00 + ) +   ,*2+( ”K + 2+'  ( +0
:2  + !   ( +0 ' ! ' :+ ,*2+( ” 
' *'(? L  +((+ ! )+& ' ' ++'! ' 2 +.
 @+ B * ' +. +  *+ +0 '++. (+. +fl.
(+0   !  *+ +0  2+ 2  0+ ' +. *
 '! ) + +* '  +0 ,.++ 0”? e' 2 ! +0 ,
&o Mp$>  ' 2 0+ +.6. '  + +0 00
) +0 * (+. '(   &' 0 *+ ++. '+?
e'* ! *+* r Mp$(+> &'+  + ! * 0+(  (+ +
+0 &  2! ' +& &  2+ ,2. +  !” '+ ! *
&'' + ' .' + * ' . *(?
V*  (++   *  +(+ 0* +0 0+(
 +0 ' ! ! ,” + ++. *( ,' .”?
L  ' ! *  + ! 0+* +  +   ( ++
 + &''   ' :  +0  *  ( ! ' : 
&'' + ' 0* fi ( +0 'A' *+ &''     &''
+. + 'A' ,* +0 0”  :2  0+( '(A'? L '  +
,*2+( ” + *+  2    &+*  ( ' ' + + +
2 *&+'! +0 'A' +  ?? 2!+  'A' *+   0-*+ 'A
' 0   ++  'A' +*   *. +  ( (.
'A' 0- ? F'  ' s2+* ' !” '+(+   !
N OP QRSP TSUPWSXUYPRZ[\ ]^P _`WPa`Z TRcPWQWdW_f\ _RZ TQUgWQWdW_f\h XU^jP[k W_YRQcj`P`k
W_S^XfiYW`_P W_ `PaWYUj P`ZQSl
M 

 
  11

m      m !" m   !


 !  a # !sm     $ % fi $a a
!s!!c ! &$!c ' !#( )
 d * +4 , - a
  a $ a   a m !"  a m!  
% "   !    a fi!   a
m a  $a . %!/ % a '! /!(  am ,

Prerequisites for building out corporate ethics


- c  a  !  a ! O "mc   a
%!  $ %  !m $a a %/ m p!
   $  !!$0 $a  a  O  
a a m  mcm  !  a %!  c 
a t% &  fi!!   m a m! %! ,,   /
 a m!   a $ m! %c % a "oc a &!!
c m! c, 2!! $    aca fi! /! a 
a c!oc m!    m  a  / am !!%
– m! a c a m%    % /!/   a m
 a a &  $aa $ $a  / am !!% 
a c a "  a   m!  c!o c – a$/
    c   "  a ! m! / 
% /! m%! )!+   !   a !! % !,
B!c    a  & ! !     !%
m / a m  mc m  / !   t  
a   co! /! m,

Ethical company management

2a    !  c $a a m$&    /
 m! fl – % a $ / m!s!!  – %
a O!  m  mcm, 3a t! $&c   $!
m! !&   a$ a mc m a &$!c  a /! 
c!  a  a t $& a$ a mc  mm 

5 I6 7898:;<=> ?6@;<A<;@8@?C6 D<?>@C@E; 9;>?F68@;9 E?G; @H?> @H8@ A;<>C6 JHC KH8> 8EE @H; 68@L<8E
A<;<;NL?>?@;> 869 F?P@> PC< @H?> :C<8E G6CJE;9F;Q 8 :86 JHC ?> 8RE;Q J?@H <;:8<G8RE; >G?EEQ @C F;@
@H; :C>@ CL@ CP 86S >?@L8@?C6Q JHC ?> 8RE; @C @L<6 ;T;<S@H?6F @C H?> 89T86@8F; 869 fi69> 8 J8S CL@
CP ;T;<S >?@L8@?C6U VL@ @H?> 68@L<8E WCL6@;<A8<@ @C XYZ[\]^_^ ?> WH8<8W@;<?`;9 RS @H; P8W@ @H8@ @H;
9;?6C> ?> bW8A8RE; CP 86S@H?6F=e H; L>;> H?> >G?EE> @C 86S AL<AC>; 869 ?> J?@HCL@ ?6H?R?@?C6U f; ?>
g\]h gZ]i]^U D69 ?@ ?> :C<; @H86 8WW?9;6@8E @H8@ >LWH 8 A;<>C6 ?> F?T;6 8 68:; @H8@ 8E>C :;86>
b@;<<?RE;=U ‘C@H?6F ?> >C @;<<?RE;Q >C L6W866SQ >C 8AA8EE?6FQ 8> @H; ;j;<W?>; CP R<?EE?86@ @8E;6@> PC<
;T?Ek l7898:;< nqqrQ unqvU
11 I  I
 I

a  a   a   aa a   
a a a  aa a fi  d a ! a
 s "a # $ %&' $ (aa ) a )a
*())+ !  a , as     -  a a a . /
   a   aa  ad ) as  a  
 s a a $  .a aa  $ as a a  a .
  a.. . $ a  $a.d n as
 $.    .$. as aa a a
  as s asa   $ a -  $ a
.  s  $raa  a a.sd
( aa a  a .  $ a a a 
!  .$. a – !   a fi  . a
 .   a    .a. .  ar
 ad m$raa   aa.  s  aa $ ,
  a a-  . a   ar. - $ a
 a   a sd '  a $    – $ a
$a - a a  a fi    d n $a
a a.s    .a.s a - – a 
as  a   a  a $  ad 0's  a a
fi  a.  $/$  /  a  –   
2 *"a 3445 1!3+d
'$ .  a a.  O. a $ aa a  a a a
a   $ a  a a, as   a
as a a   a- $$   a s a
a  $ . aa ad n  s 6a #a
   a $ a   a a  fi
a  a .   a, a    fi
c $raa $r.a a a as a
a -d )  a as a   a  
 a a$a aa- s a    .  a
s a $ $ . a  a $ .a
as a   .s a sd n  fias
.a a a a a   s a a $ aaa
as a . a a . $ .s a. ad ). s
as $ –a $rfi a $ra a $ra
 $ ..  a a  a fia . O. a
as a s  aas  a .as   a
a  ra   a a7aa 
  $ a $r.a asd %s as a a -
 s fi a  aas  .a  a a-. $
 a  a   a .O   a a   
M 

 
  11

h   h  ! "#  "  h$ 


 a  fi n !  !   h h h %&
2''( () ha $$ n!a ! "hnh a ! a !*
!  h   n#!o
F  nn hn $" h ! + hn n $n
h t nhn   h n $!     na
 "h  n  ! h   n  "h n  n
hn $! n h  h +"# "h "hnh h n $n
 h n + h nn  # no ," F
+  h p i$a - .! /nh   +
h .! 0!  3! + 4 ,hn  "  5 /"
   h ! 6  h !a  D  7
8 9
:
L   9
7 h n t nhn  +  na n $!
$" %F  /" 2''v)o ;h+ h    !h 
h +! "hnh # h  !  + +! a h<h n!n
h =     a a n!n *+ !
 ! h $!   ! h"  a h   n $! + h
nn !  a n h nh + $ $ 
 + !    a h " n$ao 0
n $!   c!   $  h 
 nn h  a   ! t  ht n$a  hn o
;h ! !nh  n!n$ ! h   n + 
"  !ha  !  " " + h  + h $a
+  " $!  hn n   a  fina nn h
t $!o s   h<h  h   ! h na n
$!  ! +  ! >n  h n na + h nno
;h ! nhn  $ h  h  $  !ht
 "hnh  h ! + $ a + ! hn 6n hn
na  n! h "     hn #o ?;h
 # !a h h n + h n h ++n + t
n  h %#h)  ! h" n   
 n "a " h$ ++n  t nhn  h nhn + h@
%F  /" 2''v A)o ;h  h $a  "ha hn na
t n$a   $$ ah * "ha ha "a h#
  + n a  "ha ha    ! + hno
s h" h  $   nn "h h nn hnt
 h +" n  nB hn na  
! >n   n # +  $ "h a n! 
h n!a  "a n!o snn  h nh ha fi
!nh na n $!   "hnh ! a n !
h hn ! + h nao ;h+ h ! n c!  h
1  I 
I
I

c  c   c     c c c   c
b b  !    c   c  c  b
 c o  c  cc   b    c. "  !
 c  c      c c  b 
 c   c   ofic b  c  
  c c  ! c    c  
t  cc  #$o %! 1&'.

Tools in building out corporate ethics


"  b  !        b  c c
o   cm  !  c     o  
c s c  o c!     c
 c     m      om !
    b    c c c c   
    c. "      c   o
c !  ! c    ! ( )   
cc      *cc   b c   
c! b !  fi  +,-,/0 2340205 #6  7'!  c
v282,4 #6c     c 9  o   c
9c7'   c +, v/:;8 #6    ! cco 
c    !   cc   9  c  
cco      c b 7'. a    o 
b t  cc < =   cc c c  c   
*co b        9   co 
 9     o  o   cb  
    w #( ) 1! >>'7
"   c   c c!    ? 
o #c*o'  c  c b  c
      @tw!  cc   b
 c. A  cc  b o  c  
c c c  b c b  c c c. a 
b o  @w   c. Ao !   
b  b  ! c ! !  ! c! c
c ! fic  ! b  cco   !   
   o   b c  !  . a b    o 
 c B!   .
$     b c b    o *!
  c  !     c c   c   
 c   c    c t #    
M 

 
  1 1

p    ! "! p  ,#   
b $  b,%  #   ,#  b%   % #
s,. & s ,, #p  $  $'   p  
,  b   p% !  #ifl ,$#
 " ,$  o,%  ,#     p%
%   p% ,p "  s,. ( ,#
 b%  p%  b% ,,   s,  b 
,%  # ,$#.
F p!    b b,  ,$ ,   %  
p   # )p! ,! " ,#  ,# o,% 
" s,!   %   p% $ ,!
b! ,       p,% ! p,%!
 ,, ,,b. t#,    $ $#p  ,# p, 
b p   #b,% p   ,, b# !
#,  #!    ps b# p #,#. &!
b #,$  p% !   s   , p
$   ,p  p% #,# g*,,$ ++-! 1/012 .
D,p$  p #,#   i#$ p! " 
p ,  p,% b%  , p% $3 p,%! 
,p r  "  $#p  r #$  $',
#   #b, ! " , %  p#, pb,
p  b s  #       % p! #$
, $, p   p 4, $5 ,s 
,b, "%. a # p " p b% ( 67!
Lp D,p (#,! " #,,% ps b#  $,
, 4,b)5. e,b "   fi  ,#  p, #  p,)
pb, ,%   #, "p " $ b #$$ b% 
4,b)5 )p!   " fi$ # " #  4b)5 % . *%
,, !    fl)b, p   4,b)5! p,p  ,%
#p u$3 p! $  "   #  #  #
"! "  b ,   ,   ,b) " #,'!
"!   ,,%  b% #. e ,  " "  p,p'$
gu$ ++8! 801+ . 9#  u$3 #$    $# 
#pp   ,$# #,! b#     ,, s 
#, 0     p, ,'   ,  
,# $   p, ,  p  ),, ,   # 
0!     s",$   , $ ,s s
% p% $ b  , $!    ,b,%  
b d,5   ,p  , p #,# ,, b% ,! .
*% #   b b ,s!  b#,$ #  , p
#,#!  p%    $  #, 4, ,5! $
1 I  I
 I

w          ! 
   !    “"  “ ! 
    #  “$   !  !
f !    ““ f  “ # ! “#"!
 ft % & #  ' “  w 
      t“     ! ( 
         c  
f  #o   !  ) *+,+-. */+0 *+/ +2 .34*5 -6/
*+/ +2 *+6/7*.    "!  w  “  *+,-68 ,+94*8
-6/ *+,-68 ,+*/75 "!  ""  .-4646:5 c;<
==>o!   # " w#  w w #  
 “   % <    ““   “ f w 
  a “  " wa "    f " “
f! # f  .34*-9 e-9-6* 53. ,+.5    f 
""    “   f “" “"t'
'“ fi  ##   .34*-9 465,*.4+6 ?-7/4.46:@ f  “"! 
     w"  w  “"%

The unique style of corporate ethics regulations


Dff   f #t  w “ 
#"  " A B  ; C% E! w
“  # '“% A  #"  '“  " 
 “ # f f “ ! w   #
  fi  (     #% C
 '“!  f  wtaw   “!
"    f F+46:! w  "  w #
    w" cf fi f     # o!
 #  #“ " S465   w   "
“ f “     f SGH ?S85.0
G6J6/76:6 76/ H+/7K. 46 / L-.6M-e4.76:@! w  w
#   f  # !   “" 
  (  fw  f “% & ff  "  
 # fi f #" cf f!   “!
“   fw #“o!  w   
ff    # f   “%
A  w F+46:   " “  t
% C# ! " #  fi  cw! f  o w
#    “#  f  w   “"N
 “ % &  “ “ f  #  
M  



  1 

a  a    !" #$#$ %a$& ' #$!$" '( ' a !
$( ' '"  fl   $" #$#$ $a #  ##$"  !
a$! #$$ t%$a )($ %  fia*
T % %#$a  (# "  !fi   a #$a   

  '$a ' ##  !$  $a a !  #a $'     i% 


a%f" a #$# $   %#a f a !f   # $!
f  $%a %% a " a ! ( #$(! $ !(# '  $%a $$*
T % %#$a  #   #a$ (a+$ a a!  ,i% 
$a! - a$ #+ ' ($ fi a a  $" $a' a !  a
%a a'%   !# !  $% (a  #"  ' #   !(!am
#$ a !(#% "  i%  a$$  ' a  a (#  
a##  ' # %a a'$ .i  a ! / $ 002" 034* t'  a$
!  %  "   $  fa$ a a ! ' $ a  '(  
i%  $#$a $# f    #  a a !(#%  a !
#  a (a  a !( %#$a " '%af" a  a #$
 $$# o $$f" $# '  %#fm %a $'" #$ 
%#f ' !$ "  %#fm a a ! $f" a  a  ($ % 
#$ "  a( a   !!   !  *
T a$ !% a S5 67
8 S9 :  5 ;  
D<  := a  !fi ! a a$ $#$a (a* n($" a
%% a a $ (a #af a %#$a  $   %#a f"  
 S5 a% $& a& #a  !$ %a  !  $%a " a%f
a a% a$  # $ $% $a$  $a * b S5"  a
$'a >a a $$  a ! f $ ' a ! ##$ ' a%+(a*
/  %a a'$ a !  a% a$ $B f a ' ' a% %%$  a +
$'a >! %a $* ?#$a   a%  %a f !fi ! f %$
#$p* @%#f a$ ##!   '!  $ a%" $ f
a$ $  a(  a%* T" S5 !  a( a (a f%   %#a
  $ %#a f a !  $$  !(!a a($" ($"  $%% !
a $ $  #$#  #$a * T# ($! f  a $
a$ a  Baf .( ' Baf+$a! 4" !(#%  #$ .AT
#%>a   %#a f4" #$a a ! %% a . $(
+$& '  a (  fi !    4"    ' ' a% .f ! 
a$ % a $a$a $$ a ! #$!$ $a!  $$af4"  '+
$% #a$ $#* /f !  a( %  ! $" a %a a'$ a ! %#f
% fi ! $  $  #$a .i  a ! / $ 002" 0C4*
@a %#a fm  a %a a'%  a ! (a %% a a$
a #a$ a$a$"  %$ a f ' a$$ aaf $%  $a! a
f #$fi+$ ! f#  %#a " a !  %$ a $ a( a$
!$% ! f a d#a  a ! a##$a $f '  $ (a* T
 $#" a #a a   $   '(   %#a  
1  I 
I
I

(             
e  !  "     #  
  e s $ %  &  '") $   * 
"%  '  '  " (#    ,,"
 #    % $ (  c   #  
 fi* r   "% T+ -./0 2+.3 I454657.468% !
  !     ,"% ,   #s 9  # 
  #,  !*i! :  !  !   %
 !         " "s
;   ; &" <% ,   68a= 64/ 7==7.4=%>
  "      s 9 T6/74? @+65
fi 374p738/ 3.fi5 56t74?  ,  ,      
 "% !  A#     #%   
 " !  !     !  #,"% ss  #
   "       s $   %  "
    "  fi    %   
#   ,# #%    !   ,# #  ," 
 " , ,"% ,# "  ,  !     !
"       # ,   "    # 
     i! ,# ,"    #s ; l &
  "  "   H6/ .B 68a=   ,  
re # E  # #%  #  " 
#% !  v  C# " "    D l
 !        #  , #fis ;
i   ! , " , #    #  
,# #   " !  #  %    !
 ! #    ,     #  # 
    !        #   ! 
e  !s 9  !%   c # #  %
 " !     ! ,"  #  
($  D F i  !%   !% e" # # , 
  ##  ,#      ##    G 
J1 #%     #,  KK   !i 
!  w   r%  !  ! D   c *
  %   % ,#    # %  
 %    %  " !s 9
KK %  # !      i ,# 
1LM    "%   KKJ "    N)’   ,#" 

O P QRSURV WX YZR [W\] ^ZW_ R`ZUbdf gdhdjRgRh` Vdk _QRkRh`R\ Uh dh RdQfURQ k`m\] nohjSqQU
uQxh]U yzz{|} QRf]Uhj m_Wh `ZR \d`d QRjdQ\Uhj `ZR ]RdQ yzz~ _QRkRh`R\ Wh `ZR bWg_dh]k
VR€_djR
M  



  1 

c   c   ! " # $   
  t  %  #  c##    #% # c$ fi$& #
ca# '# %$ ()c ( %$#  *  c%##&
O *  #  ()c ### '#  *$$ **
 *  c$ t   ' c#n 'c   # 
t  #%%$ * t  ! " c$ (### cc#&
#  cc$# c ( '  c#  ($  flc 
%# t# (  t$#   cc# * #v$# ' v 
 c   **c (  c% *n   %$ *
 c c$  '# c$ #c%# # '$$& +%$t
 c c$ c$ #t  (%  $#    #cfic
#$# '$$ *   t$ sc#t %$ c## '
 #  * #  $t (  c c %$#  
a# *  c * c#& #n  c$ t *  cn
c$t #  ##c $vn c ( t # c#ct 
# $ ( cc% '#6 #   cc% c
t   ##%## *  c# *  c %$#
 (  a$$ & # *c# n '%n t$ **
#()c    *  c#  *  c$ t $c#
* #c   #  '  %#  *$ %$ #c
* % c& # #   c. ( #  t ) 
*  fcc($, * %# c#n #c '% # cc($ 
% *  cn   ( cc($n *fic  % #$t 
t# *  &

Corporate ethics and ethical thinking


I # * ### cct  c %$# t%t  cn # '$$ # 
 *  c$ t $ n  ' *  c #
 s% t  cn '%n %   c# *  *%($ c#n
c #   tn   ct # n $# ( 
$#n   c# c$ c& l#t # #  $#c$ ##n
(% $$& - c$ c c %  %#$$ cfi v'$t
'c w c t#  # w '$ # c  % $ c# 
#  #c  '   p$c cc$# c$ ( ' #   c$$
t  't  * $$ ##($ c#& # # $    *c  
c$ c #  $  #($#t *c#n (   c#t c

/ D023457 8053209 2: 2;47 <:=>50? >8:<077 <3@@:2 A0 >8:B4909 ;080C ;:E0B08F 7:=0 8050B3@2 72G9407
380 80H08809 4@ 2;0 H:55:E4@JK L8GN3@ 3@9 P;Q770@ RSTTUVF W<;@0A05 3@9 X40@082 RYUUZVF [@JB\84]
^8_@Q4 RYUUTV`
1  I 
I
I

v  v   v   v !  " #$  
""   m%&   " '$ ( m
 m" #  e)*+,- ./-02*.  &  " ' 
v  "m "v $ '  #"   '$!&
 p,+e*+,- /,- p34pp/3*e*/53  &  "  '  mv
 v  $m  "#"    $ #!&
$ ( m  /,- e,+)*56 ,50 ,+e*/5 /0--*56 5/e*/53
 &  "  ' ## (  $ $"7 ##
'  "    7#m '  v "$  v $
   "! r m # " $ m '   
$$ ##   v& 7m  ## '  i 
  m "f   ##8& m '  "   
$ d$mm   " $m & fim   ' vd#$m
v   $  i v8 v$  "&  ("
   ##& $  &   " ! t  (
 f   $a #" "& ' ' v   $
9 &  7m #v & &   ## &
    m fvdfi   "&  $ 
"   "#" "#   "d ##
 "&     & m  v  "v& 'v "
  ##   ' (   "m  " $
 v  m b#  " m ##  #v$ 
##  v$m  d$$  7m $  $ mv
"#& ' # $  $v    $v#"    

References
%"& B: ;& B& < t ==  J4065e *5 >,5,6*,- ?+*3*/5 >,@*56
ACD $! E' F7o G H K r
m"& L$ ==M Ne)*+,- O,03)*p
P4*-0*56 Q43e *5 R/p/,e*/53
 nS $! t"o ;L< b 9
T$"$& <v$& H& Em ==U V43*533 e)*+3W XY 0*3+433*/5 .*e)
Y-Z [-*2\] Ne)*+3 V*e3& ^ _# `v b# $ T!
#occ'''# ccd" d  v  G 1=&
=1M!
g"& L T$'$& r'& h == ?2-/p*56 Ne)*+,- O,03)*p
 L$ 9  ^# T '''#dm
–  v  B 1  =1M!
j$"& ;djm == Q4e) ,50 >e)/0  nS v$ $! h$ $
E' F7o ^"
M  



  1 

G    ! "#  $%& H




' ( ) * ) +,1
G$-#!% .! / 0!! 2# 3  4 3% 1,)  5  6-7 8 
6#66& H


'( ( 3J%79:;%J%7* 1< +11


=! 06  >  L 
? @A B C? D E
@D  F ED D
@@ D  4%!#8* I6$7 K 4J### $ I$#!%!8 N66#
P%6$O#
Q !!-*RR222#;J $JR;#R R;%!#8R=!ST/I/UN=VPI4IN
-$K 9 #! 8#!  3J 1 1<p
06W% 5%!% 1,,, X@ Y   ? D
MZA B ? D

Co  F MZ


 >  :% 0O! T;%%7 Q !!-*RR222--%OR
;%%7R! 6#R! lO$ ! 9 #! 8#!  3J 1 1<p
P%J[ P!% > 7## \ 1,, 5fl6!# $ 6##J# /! 6# # i!7
# %$ 6% 8J %[  #!%!O6 -O H  ]

MZ
,* 1<^+1^1
P%J[P!% 1> _J#!K%O[!6#6J###5%O[!#
8 8J# 8%!J# $ 8##& H`a(b c  MZd  D]
Q !!-*RR222 %92J$ROR! S_J#!SKS%O#! !9#!8#!
 3J 1 1<p I# --%$  e  F


? D
,* 1+ )
N6 ; /;% %$! 4%! 0%O I  V-!O ! 6#  ;J###
%O[!# e  F


? D
^<* <+ 11
fO8g%9h%j7 V%  /%"k6# m# "J"g6n q0%!7 $
6J6!rV*Ng$% .%"n Q$p* Ésot
tZ u ssott
C t]o
d od fidvfi owsxy zX

F { 
u {  X?Z  
F
? |  F B@@  E? 
@?]} )19 , 4J$-#!* ~% .$n
fO8g%9h%j7 V% ^  vZ
 €@tD v €oD v wd‚s
o 
o ƒ o  o‚ sds
s?d z Z  €@  €D 
B@@D?
 X  D  €@  F X  } 0%#8g#g% 7*
0!% .$n
fO8g%9h%j7 V% „ /! 6 ;J### #!!J!# =2 % ! 7 -##;&
e  F ?  ] F ' Z   € Z 
1<* 1+ 
fO8g%9h%j7 V% , O6 ! 6# K% ;J### V h# T 4$ h#
:"! T Q$#p ? D E
@D
` D]… D ]    1,+
4%* N-%O% †%O
!!O#! TJ$2O , E? 
@?
D? ‡
D? ZˆE? 
@? D
€
 Z 
 T$* 3  7 ‰ N# T!$
h# Tg#[n  B ws
?d  otŠ zD
`Mo Z ? D
}
4J$-#!* .##J! .$n

You might also like