Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Optimisation Mix Design and Suppress The Alkali Silica Reaction
Optimisation Mix Design and Suppress The Alkali Silica Reaction
AZIRA SALIM
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
CONTENTS i - iii
LIST OF FIGURES iv
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction 1
1.2 Background Of Study 2
1.3 Problem Statement 3
1.4 Research Importance 4
1.5 Objectives 4
1.6 Scope Of Works 5
2.1 Introduction 6
2.2 Alkali Silica Reaction (ASR) 7-8
2.3 Mechanism of ASR 8 - 10
2.4 Ground Granulated Blast-Furnace Slag (GGBS) 10 - 12
2.5 Factors Affecting ASR 12
2.5.1 The Effect of Admixtures in Controlling ASR 13
2.5.2 The Effect of Different Percentage Admixtures in Controlling
ASR 13 - 15
2.5.3 The Effect of Different Water Cement Ratio Admixtures in
Controlling ASR 15 - 16
2.6 Effects on Compressive Strength 16 - 19
2.7 Effects on Workability (Slump Test) 19 - 20
CHAPTER 3 METHODOLOGY
3.1 Overview 21
3.2 Flow Chart of the Methodology 22
3.3 Material Preparation 23
ii
3.3.1 Slag 23
3.3.2 Water 23
3.3.3 Portland cement 24
3.3.4 Aggregate 24
3.3.5 Sand 24
3.4 Mix Design 25
3.5 Mix Description 26
3.6 Mix Proportion 26 - 27
3.7 Number of Samples 28
3.8 Lab Testing 29 - 32
3.8.1 Accelerated Mortar Bar Test (AMBT) ASTM C 1260 29 - 30
3.8.2 Compressive Strength Test ASTM C 109 30 - 32
3.8.3 Slump Test for Concrete Mix (ASTM C143, C172) 32
4.1 Overview 33
4.2 AMBT 33 - 34
4.3 Slump Test 34
4.4 Comprehensive Strength of Mortar Cube 35
4.5 Comprehensive Strength of Concrete Cube 35
5.1 Overview 36
5.2 The Importance of Planning Work Done 36
5.3 Milestones and Dates 37
5.4 Project Schedule 38
CHAPTER 6 CONCLUSION
6.1 Introduction 39
6.2 The Advantages Of Using Slag As Part Of Replacement By Cement 39 - 40
6.2.1 Reduced Energy 40
6.2.2 Reduced Greenhouse Gas Emissions 40
6.2.3 Reduced Virgin Raw Material 40
REFERENCES 41 – 42
iii
LIST OF TABLE
TABLE PAGE
LIST OF FIGURE
FIGURE PAGE
2.1 ASR Site Under a Microscope in Thin Section: Expanding Chert Sand
Particle 9
2.2 ASR Gel Deposit in a Crack Remove From The Reaction Site,
iv
2.3 The Three-Phase CaO-SiO2-Al2O3 Diagram 11
Including Condensed Silicafume (CSF), Fly Ash (FA), and Slag (GBFS) 13
2.6 Influence Of Palm Oil Fuel Ash On The Expansion Of Mortar Bars 14
Concrete Mixtures 15
Cementitious Material 17
2.11 Relationship Between The Slag Percent And The Slump Of Concrete
v
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction
Problems in existing building concrete are often identified by term such as damage or
deleterious of concrete. One of the damage is existing concrete building due to alkali silica
reaction (ASR). It also called the “cancer of concrete”. Generally, the story of Alkali-Silica
Reaction (ASR) in concrete commenced with the discovery in California in 1940 (Gunnar M.
Idorn, 1997). Damage due to ASR in concrete is become common phenomenon throughout
the world. Alkali-Silica Reaction (ASR) is a chemical reaction between the alkalis in portland
cement and certain siliceous aggregates. These aggregates, when placed in a highly alkaline
solution and in the presence of water and calcium, will expand and a gel will begin to form.
As the aggregate particle expands, it causes the concrete to crack. As the concrete
deteriorates, more water enters to fuel the reaction. This cycle continues until the concrete
1
ASR is a chemical reaction between the reactive silica contained in the aggregates
and the alkalis (Na2O and K2O) within the cement paste (Jan Lindgard, 2012). The result is
an alkali-silicate gel that absorbs water and increases in volume. If the gel is confined by the
cement paste, it builds up pressure as it grows causing internal stresses that eventually
could cause serious expansion and cracking in concrete that resulting in major structural
problems. There are some methods to prevent or minimize ASR deterioration with avoiding
use of reactive aggregates, limiting the alkali content of cement, and incorporation of
The best way to minimize expansion due to ASR is the incorporation of pozzolans in
admixtures.There are two types admixtures. There are chemical admixtures and mineral
admixtures. These mineral admixtures with pozzolona characteristics are added to the
certain amount.
There are various problems involving concrete structures. One of them is Alkali Silica
Reaction (ASR). It is resulted from the reaction between alkalies (sodium and potassium) in
portland cement and certain siliceous rocks or minerals, such as opaline chert, strained
quartz, and acidic volcanic glass, present in some aggregates. It has been known to cause
structural damages.
In Malaysia, ASR has been one of the problem happening on the concrete (A. S. M.
Abdul Awal, 1997) . This may lead to expansion and destruction of the concrete. ASR is a
chemical reaction between reactive silica contained in aggregate and alkalis (Na2O and K2O)
2
in a mixture of cement paste (Jan Lindgard, 2012). The result is alkali-silicate gel that
absorbs water and will increase the volume of concrete. If the gel is confined by cement
paste, it builds pressure as it grows finally causing internal stress can produce cracks in
concrete. However, the most factor affecting ASR must be present are reactive silica from
the aggregates. The second most factor affecting ASR is high-alkali (pH) pore solution. The
third most affecting is the sufficient moisture. If one of these conditions is absent, ASR
The one of the best way to avoid ASR is by adding or replacing part of cement at
certain amount with various pozzolans. Pozzolanic materials are widely used as
by cement is more better than adding by cement to purpose green technology. The
increasing use of concrete with strength properties and high durability cause pozzolana
Concrete is the most widely used building material in the world because of its beauty,
strength and durability, among other benefits. Concrete is used in nearly every type of
construction, including homes, buildings, roads, bridges, airports and subways, just to name
a few. And in an era of an increase the construction of concrete structures, it requires the
use a lot of cement in construction of concrete structure. Among the entire energy intensive
Management for the Seas of East Asia, 2012). CO2 emissions from cement manufacturing are
produced as cement is calcined to produce calcium oxide. Approximately 0.5 metric tons of
carbon is released for each metric ton of cement production (Partnerships in Environmental
3
Management for the Seas of East Asia, 2012). Then, the amount of CO2 produced during
worldwide has contributed to the greenhouse effect and scarcity of materials and energy
sources. It show that the earth is scarce of natural fuel and the increasing cost of burning
source. in addition, it should has alternative method about the increasing demand of cement
Generally, dealing with ASR in existing concrete is a much more difficult task,
because the ingredients that keep the reaction going are already built into the structure.
Furthermore, cost repairing ASR in existing concrete takes cost a lot of money.
The research is to investigate the optimisation mix design and suppress the ASR. The
replacement has any improvement in compressive strength. Other than that, to mitigate use
throughout of the world, the alternative way to reduce use of cement will be use also as
4
1.5 Objectives
The aim of this study is to investigates the optimisation of concrete design mix to suppress
alkali silica reaction in concrete. To achieve this aim, the following objectives of this study
percentage.
i. To determine compressive strength mortar bar and concrete that containing slag at
strength of mortar bars and concrete cubes where ordinary portland cement (OPC) was
replaced 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50% and 60% by Ground granulated blast-furnace slag
(GGBS). The plain mortar compose of cement, water, and fine aggregate were considered as
a control mix without replacing cement by slag at different percentage. For plain concrete
sample compose of cement, sand, water and coarse aggregate as a control mix without
cement where the material testing involve of Accelerated Mortar Bar Test ASTM C 1260,
Slump Test, Compressive Strength Test ASTM C 109 and Compressive Strength BS1881-116.
Meanwhile, material testing done on compressive strength test at two types which are on
5
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
This chapter will mainly review about the effect of alkali silica reaction (ASR) when slag
suppressing ASR expansion. Research studied and reviewed back using journals, books and
other resources that related to this research to gain the understanding about the problems,
process and result which might be useful during implementation of the study. Various aspect
of effect of alkali silica reaction when admixtures being replace by cement including the
mechanism of alkali silica reaction , effect of expansion on mortar and compressive strength
of mortar will be discussed based on the information gathered mainly through desk study.
Past studies and researches are also discussed in this chapter with more attention
given to expansion due to alkali silica reaction. This chapter also will review about various
percantage replacement by cement effecting on mortar expansion all around the world from
6
2.2 Alkali Silica Reaction (ASR)
According to James A. Farny (1997), there are 3 types of alkali-aggregate reaction, namely:
- Alkali-silicon reaction: Reaction between alkali in concrete and active silicon dioxide in
aggregate
aggregate
He also stated that alkali silica reaction (ASR) in concrete was identified the chemical
discovered by California in 1940 investigated by Idorn (1997). It also called the cancer of
concrete. Damage due to ASR in concrete is become common phenomenon throughout the
world. ASR is a chemical reaction between the reactive silica contained in the aggregates
and the alkalis (Na2O and K2O) within the cement paste. Initially, alkali hydroxide, mainly
from the cement, react with susceptible siliceous components within aggregate particles, in
the presence of moisture, to form an alkali-silica gel. Subsequently, this gel can absorb
further moisture, swelling in the process and imposing expansive stresses on the enveloping
concrete. Water can be absorbed by the gel water is not used in the cement hydration
reaction, free water from rain, tide, river, or water condensed from the air humidity. James
A. Farny (1997) defined in general, the reaction can be concluded has two-step process,
Step 1:
7
Step 2:
generated by the swelling. Once that pressure is larger than the tensile strength of the
concrete, cracks occur leading to additional water migration or absorption and additional gel
swelling
ASR in concrete, and especially ASR leading to damage, is rarely inevitable and
According to Josee (2001), the decisive parameters was identified for the course of the ASR
in concrete:
According to Chiara (1995), most researchers agree that the main of ASR is the
reaction between certain forms of silica present in the aggregates and the hydroxide ions
(OH-) in the pore water of concrete. In brief, their theory suggested that alkali and calcium
hydroxide in solution the pore liquid penetrated by diffusion into siliceous aggregate
particles, and there transformed the interior mineral structure into an alkali-silica gel
compound. In case of a high alkali to calcium ion ratio, the gel would become an alkali-rich
“unlimitedly swelling gel”, and thus cause expansive pressure in the reacting aggregate
particle. With a low alkali to calcium ion ratio, the gel would become calcium enriched and
non swelling.
8
The reactive silica contained in the aggregates and the alkalis (Na2O and K2O) within
the cement paste give the result of an Alkali-silicate gel. This gel can absorb further
moisture, after that swelling in the process and imposing expansive stresses on the
enveloping concrete. According to the John Newman (2003), in view of the relatively low
tensile strength of concrete matrix, these expanding sites generates radiating microcracks
like the Figure 2.1. The alkali silica gel is able to imbibe considerable quantities of water,
then the viscosity is reduced and the reaction product becomes able to migrate into the
Figure 2.1 : ASR site under a microscope in thin section: expanding chert sand
9
Figure 2.2: ASR gel deposit in a crack remove from the reaction site, under a
cement and certain siliceous aggregates. Three components, reactive silica from the
aggregates, sufficient alkalis and sufficient moisture, are required in order for ASR to cause
damage to concrete structures. From the few studies found in the literature, it appears that
ASR may be affected by some of factors governing ASR are as described below.
Generally, alkali aggregate reaction involves two main types of aggregates, which are
rapid and slow/late alkali reactive aggregates (John Newman, 2003). Rapid alkali reaction
aggregates will react by dissolution to form alkali silca gel at both surfaces of the reactive
particles and inside particles. For slow/late alkali reactive aggregate, the reaction initiates at
original cracks, in homogenities or grain boundaries, which act as pathway for the alkaline
10
pore solution. Therefore, only certain parts of reactive particles should be considered as
alkali reactive and minimal gel formation is produced. However, the gels are capable of
separating the grain boundaries and leading to expansion of aggregate, and the resulting
Besides that, smaller particles will have a much higher specific surface area compared
to coarser particles. Hence, smaller particles will react quicker. However, the alkali reaction is
most damaging for certain rock typaes when the reactive rocks occur in particular size range.
Both natural aggregates, eroded to present size by natural agents, and crushed aggregates,
obtained by a deliberated fragmentation of rocks are used in concrete. The physical factors
and chemical factors might to a certain degree, differ between these types of aggregates.
This also will introduce some possible in differences the alkali reactivity of these dinstinctive
types of aggregates.
The environment plays a crucial role in ASR expansion and damages of structures by
governing the availability of external moisture and ambient temperature. Without the
presence of sufficient moisture the damaging effect of ASR will not occur. This effects may
be greater in thinner elements where the interaction between external environment and
internal conditions are greater, assuming a moist condition. In larger members even in dry
environments, internal moisture will usually be retained, while the outer portions will dry.
Mark Gavin Alexander(2005) stated that this results in expansive reaction occuring internally
but not in the outer zone, giving surfaces cracking while the interior of the member may
appear uncracked.
11
ASR may also be caused or exacerbated by external sources of moisture such as
structure, leading to localised zones of ASR damage. Conditions promoting cyclic moisture
Figure 2.3: Cracking of core due to internal ASR and external drying (Mark Gavin
Alexander, 2005)
The primary source of alkalis in the pore solution is cement or binder, which contains
metal alkalis -sodium and potassium hydroxide (Idorn, 1997). Other sources of alkalis in
concrete can be the environment such as marine or chemical admixtures usually containing
sodium. Idorn(1997) mention that alkali sometimes derive from the aggregate themselves,
for examples alkali containing minerals such as feldspar which react with the calcium
hydroxide released by cement hydration. The alkali contribution from aggregates, though
The presence alkali from Portland cement also one of components required for ASR.
When cement is mixed with water the alkali suphates go rapidly into the liquid phase
converting to alkali hydroxide which increase the concentrations of alkali in the pore water
12
solution encourage greater swelling capacities in the gel (John Newman, 2003). The
concentration of sodium and potassium compounds and hydroxyl ions is dependent on the
quantity of sodium and potassium compounds in the anhydrous Portland cement. The
hydroxyl ion concentration in the pore solution of concrete made with high alkali cement
Mineral admixtures are known to be effective ways to mitigate ASR expansion. The
optimum method for minimizing the potential for expansion due to ASR in concrete is to
replace a portion of the Portland cement by admixtures. These admixtures include fly ash,
silica fume, ground granulated blast-furnace slag and so on. The use of admixtures can
provide the most realistic advantages to the nature of concrete to improve durability and
controlling ASR expansion, there are still some aspects of the reaction mechanism of
admixtures and their effects are not well understood. Aiqin Wang (2008) summed up the
mechanism have three basics factors from chemical effect. There are the acidity of mineral
admixture, the more the active acidic oxide of mineral admixture and the less its basic oxide,
the better the inhibiting effect. Second, the basicity of cement, about 20% Ca(OH) will yield
after Portland cement hydrated. Thus, a large quantity mineral admixtures must be added.
The mineral admixtures not only react to alkali, but also remove a large quantity of mineral
admixtures of Ca(OH)2 to make basicity of hydrated compund reduce. Only so the expansion
of ASR can be inhibited effectively. And the last one is the course of reaction. If the content
mineral admixtures is larger and Ca(OH)2 in hardened cement paste is limited, there will be
13
some unreacted microparticles. These microparticle have stronger acidity and can retain
alkali.
Figure 2.4: ASR expansion versus dosage for various mineral admixtures
including condensed silicafume (CSF), fly ash (FA), and slag (GBFS). (James A.
F,1997)
The effect of pozzolanic materials on expansion due to ASR has been known to
depend on their alkali content, calcium content, pozzolanicity and fineness (A. S. M. Abdul
Awal, 1997). Figure 2.6 show that the graphs of expansion of mortar bars, plotted against
time, in which various amounts of POFA was being replaced OPC. It is evident from the
figure that a reduction in expansion occurred with an increase in the amount of ash content.
14
Figure 2.5: Influence of palm oil fuel ash on the expansion of mortar bars (A. S.
ASR was first reported (John Newman, 2003). In concrete the GGBS slag will react with
calcium hydroxides from the hydrated cement and form cementitious products. The
hydration of slag, in a mixture of Portland cement and water, which was initiated by the n
alkaline solution was prepared by early hydration of Portland cement. The slag hydration
directly activated by the heat of hydration of Portland cement reaction with water (Idorn,
1997). It obviously that the efficiency of the slag cement depends on the nature of the slag
cement, the reactivity on aggregate and the alkali content of portland cement. In most
cases, 50% slag cement was sufficient for controlling damaging expansion in concrete with
15
Hoogan (1981) concluded that after two years of observation, the slag cement
blends were found to be effective in reducing expansion, but the reduction was less than
that found with the low-alkali cement. When used in combination with high-alkali cement,
blends of 50% slag cement appear to be effective in reducing the potential of ASR.
Figure 2.6: Various Slag Replacements On The Expansion Of Mortar Bars (Hogan,
Et Al., 1981)
Basically the use of GGBS in concrete is beneficial for the following reasons:
- It represents a large potential energy savings. Melting in the blast furnace process
in effect until the chemical energy stored in GGBS for subsequent activation
- The heat was made productive because the activation of the slag during the
Portland cement hydration consumed some of its heat hydration, and thereby
16
- The alkali hydroxide activation made concrete with GGBS containing resistant to
harmful ASR with reactive aggregates, and reduce the permeability of hardened
Roy et al. (1983) discovered that the concrete will have a great effect on strength at
the temperature at which concrete is cured , particularly at early ages. Concrete containing
slag is found to respond very well under elevated temperature curing conditions. The
proportion of the slag cement on mortar used affects the strength gain as show in Figure
2.9. From the Figure 2.9, obviously when highly active slag cement have been used, the
greatest 28-day strengths are found with blends as high 65% slag cement.
17
Roy et al. (1983) also summarizes that the early age strength development of
conditions ,GGBS mortars gain strength more slowly than Portland cement mortars. The rate
of strength gain is generally inversely proportional to the fraction of slag cement used in the
There are not many researchers discussed about on the effects compressive strength
researchers discuss the compressive strength gain characteristics of concrete containing slag
Through some research done by several researchers, it is found that the concrete
made with cement replacement by slag provides higher compressive strength compared with
18
The results obtained from testing compressive strength done by Hogan (1981)
slag powder. In general increasing the CaO content of the slag results an increase in
compressive strength. From study it can be concluded that as the percentage of slag
replacement increase, the strength tends to increase also. However early strength
development due to may be slower than plain Portland cement due to lower the lower
and even 7 days may be tend to be lower using slag–cement combinations, particularly at
19
CHAPTER 3
METHODOLOGY
3.1 Overview
This chapter briefly discussed about how the research being carried out in order to achieve
the objectives. The types of material needed in this research as well as their specification
and description were listed and detailed. Laboratory tests which related to the research were
conducted. Materials were firstly prepared , such as in the research, Ground Granulated Blast
Furnace Slag (GGBS) were collected. Other materials such as cement, water and coarse
aggregate also prepared as well before laboratory works were commerced. Test were
conducted once all the samples are ready. Data or results collected from tests were taken fur
further analysis.
20
3.2 Flow Chart of the Methodology
Figure 3.1 illustrated the step by steps procedures which were conducted in this
research from the initial stage until the testing was completed.
Materials Preparation:
- Cement
- Ground granulated blast furnace slag (GGBS)
- Aggregate
- Sand
- Water
Date Analysis
Report
21
3.3 Material Preparation
Slag was used as cement replacement about 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, 50%, and 60%
from the cement. The slag was stored in dry place such as concrete lab. The chemical
SiO2 37.6
Al2O3 3.3
Fe2O3 0.4
CaO 17.6
MgO 11.2
SO3 1.94
Na2O 0.22
K2O 0.34
3.3.2 Water
Water taken from pipe water of School of Engineering and Information Technology
Concrete Lab. Water use in making samples shall be clean, fresh and free from impurities.
22
3.3.3 Portland cement
Type I portland cement (Ordinary Portland Cement) was used as binder. The cement
was stored in dry place such as concrete lab. The chemical composition of the cement is
Table 3.2 Chemical Compostition of OPC (A. S. M. Abdul Awal, The Effectiveness of
Palm Oil Fuel Ash in Preventing Expansion Due to Alkali Silca Reaction, 1997)
SiO2 20.2
Al2O3 5.7
Fe2O3 3.0
CaO 62.5
MgO 2.6
SO3 1.8
Na2O 0.16
K2O 0.87
3.3.4 Aggregates
Type of aggregate used is reactive aggregate. Reactive aggregate used in this study was
aggregate obtained from Sabah. Coarse aggregate predominantly retained on the No. 4
(4.75 mm) sieve or that portion of an aggregate retained on the No. 4 (4.75 mm).
23
3.3.5 Sand
Type of sand used in this study was river sand obtained from Sabah. For fine aggregate, fine
aggregate passing the No. 50(300 µm) sieve will be used for this study.
Table 3.3 Description of Mix Ids for Different Percentage Replacement of ordinary
Portland cement.
CEMENT
A0
Design mix was set up in order to prepare the mixtures that show the quantities of
each materials in the mortar bar samples used for the test during the research. In this study,
the mixture proportion for aggregate and cement ratio was 1:2.25 for mortar samples.. This
24
means that 1 part of the cement mix with the 2.25 part of the aggregate and the
water/cement ratio is 0.47. Meanwhile, the design mix was taken from the standard ASTM
C1260 requirements for a batch of 3 mortar bar. For concrete samples, the mixture
proportion for cement, sand and coarse aggregate is 1:1.16:2.25. This means that 1 part of
the cement mix with the 1.16 part of the sand and the coarse aggregate 2.25. The
water/cement ratio remains same is 0.47. Initially, controlled mortar sample which contains
only ordinary Portland cement, aggregate and water was casted. For controlled concrete
sample are containing ordinary Portland cement, sand , coarse aggregate and water was
casted. Then, the mortar and concrete samples with different percentage of cement
replacement were casted as well. The mixture proportions of mortar samples for slag as
replacement of ordinary Portland cement is given in table 3.6. Meanwhile, the mixture
proportions of concrete samples for slag as replacement of ordinary Portland cement is given
in table 3.7.
Table 3.4 Mix Design for Mortar Bars and Mortar Cubes
MATERIAL RATIO
Cement 1
Water 0.47
MATERIAL RATIO
Cement 1
Sand 1.16
25
Table 3.6 : Design Mix Proportion of Samples With Slag Replacement By Cement
Design Mix Proportion of Samples With Slag Replacement By Cement for AMBT
Mix Id Weight, g
Portland Cement Slag Water Aggregate
A0 (Control) 440 0 206.8 990
A10 396 44 206.8 990
A20 352 88 206.8 990
A30 308 132 206.8 990
A40 264 176 206.8 990
A50 220 220 206.8 990
A60 176 264 206.8 990
Design Mix Proportion of Samples With Slag Replacement By Cement for Mortar
Compressive Strength
Mix Id Weight, g
Portland Cement Slag Water Aggregate
A0 (Control) 314.3 0 147.7 707.2
A10 282.9 31.4 147.7 707.2
A20 251.4 62.9 147.7 707.2
A30 220.0 94.3 147.7 707.2
A40 188.6 125.7 147.7 707.2
A50 157.15 157.15 147.7 707.2
A60 188.6 125.7 147.7 707.2
26
Table 3.7 : Design Mix Proportion of Samples With Slag Replacement By Cement
Mix Id Weight, g
Coarse
Cement Slag Water Aggregate Sand
A0 2514.3 0 1181.7 5657.2 2916.6
A10 2262.9 251.4 1181.7 5657.2 2916.6
A20 2011.4 502.9 1181.7 5657.2 2916.6
A30 1760.0 754.3 1181.7 5657.2 2916.6
A40 1508.6 1005.7 1181.7 5657.2 2916.6
A50 1257.15 1257.15 1181.7 5657.2 2916.6
A60 1005.7 1508.6 1181.7 5657.2 2916.6
Day day
3 7 28 3 7 28
A0 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
A10 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
A20 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
A30 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
A40 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
A50 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
A60 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
27
Total = 21 Total = 63 Total = 63
SUBTOTAL =147
Objective:
This test to determine the change length or mortar bar by AMBT . For this research, the
control expansion that can be determined using the 14-day expansion limit.
Procedure:
1. Each mold in the moist cabinet or room had been placimmediately after molds have
28
2. The specimens have been removed from the moulds and their lengths were
measured.
3. After the first measurements of their lengths, pure water been putted at 80oC for a
period of 24 h.
4. The containers had been removed from the water bath one at a time. The time
elapsed between removal and return of the specimens to the water bath shall not
exceed 10 min.
5. The bars one time have been removed from the water and their surface had been
dried with a towel paying particular attention to the two metal gage stud.
6. The zero reading had been taken of each bar immediately after drying the bar is in
7. The process of drying and reading using a length comparator have been completed.
8. After reading, the specimen on a towel is abandoned until comparatory readings have
been taken on the remainder of the bars. All specimens made had been placed with
each aggregate sample in a container with sufficient 1N NaOH, at 80oC for the
samples to be totally immersed. The 40g of the NaOH was diluted with 900mL of
10. According to ASTM C 1260 (2005) expansion, 16 days after casting can be classified
between 0.10 % and 0.20 %. Mortar bar consider as non-detrimental when the
percentage of expansion is less than 0.10 %. Table 3.9 showed the interpretation of
Table 3.9 Interpretation of the Test AMBT Result (ASTM C1260 3005)
29
Percentage of Expansion Classification
Objective:
Compressive strength test used to determine the compressive strength of mortar cubes
samples. The objectives for this study was focuses on the performance of compressive
strength of mortar. Compressive strength test will be performed at the age of 3 days, 7 days
Procedure:
1. A thin layer of mineral oil was applied to the inside surface the mold. The excess oil
2. After mixing the mortar, the mold was filled with mortar to a depth about 1-in. The
mortar in the entire cube compartments was tamped 32 times in about 10s in four
rounds, each round to be at right angles to the other. The compartment was filled
with the remaining mortar and was tamped as specied for the first layer.
30
3. The cubes were smoothed off by drawing the flat side of the trowel across them with
the leading edge slightly raised. The mortar was cut off to a plane surface flushed
with the top of the mold by drawing the straight edge of the trowel across.
4. Mortar cube were cured under normal condition which the specimen was stored at
room temperature for 24h and was covered with the plastic sheet. The specimen in
the mold were transferred and immersed into the water tank for curing purpose.
5. The specimen kept in the water for 7, 14 and 28 days. They were tested immediately
after removal from the curing tank. The specimen was wiped to a surface dry
condition.
6. Then, the compression load was applied to the mortar cubes surface using
7. The compressive strength of all specimens and the average value had been
FMax / A
Where :
P = Compressive Strength
A = Cross-Sectional Area
Objective:
31
Procedure:
1. The internal surface of the mould is cleaned and damped with water.
2. The mould is placed on a smooth, horizontal, rigid and non-absorbent surface free
3. The mold is filled with concrete in three layers, each about 1/3 of the height of the
mold.
5. After the top layer has tamped, cut the concrete at the top of the molds with tamping
6. The mould is removed from the concrete by rising it vertically, slowly, and carefully
7. After the mould is removed, immediately measure the slump to the nearest 5mm.
Objective:
Compressive strength test used to determine the compressive strength of concrete cubes
samples. The objectives for this study was focuses on the performance of compressive
strength of concrete. Compressive strength test will be performed at the age of 3 days, 7
Procedure:
32
8. A thin layer of mineral oil was applied to the inside surface the mold. The excess oil
9. After mixing the concrete, the mold was filled with concrete to a depth about 1-in.
The concrete in the entire cube compartments was tamped 32 times in about 10s in
four rounds, each round to be at right angles to the other. The compartment was
filled with the remaining concrete and was tamped as specied for the first layer.
10. The cubes were smoothed off by drawing the flat side of the trowel across them with
the leading edge slightly raised. The mortar was cut off to a plane surface flushed
with the top of the mold by drawing the straight edge of the trowel across.
11. Concrete cube were cured under normal condition which the specimen was stored at
room temperature for 24h and was covered with the plastic sheet. The specimen in
the mold were transferred and immersed into the water tank for curing purpose.
12. The specimen kept in the water for 7, 14 and 28 days. They were tested immediately
after removal from the curing tank. The specimen was wiped to a surface dry
condition.
13. Then, the compression load was applied to the concrete cubes surface using
14. The compressive strength of all specimens and the average value had been
FMax / A
Where :
P = Compressive Strength
A = Cross-Sectional Area
33
CHAPTER 4
EXPECTED RESULT
4.1 Introduction
The preliminary study has been conducted through previous research.The expected result
and observation obtained from journal that have same conducted testing was discussed.
expansion of mortar bar using slag as replacement of cement for reduce ASR. Meanwhile,
the expected result of compressive strength of mortar and concrete, and slump test also will
be discuss.
previous research done by Hoogan (1981) after two years observation when 50% GGBS was
replaced appear to be effective in reducing the potential of ASR. His research stated that
that the efficiency of slag cement depends on the nature of the slag cement, the reactivity of
the aggregate, and the alkali content of the portland cement. It also expected that the slag
34
For the expected result, influence slag in expansion bars will be similar to J. S Lumley
(1992) research. The different on type of testing which are their use ASTM C227 that take
4.3 Workability
improves the workability of the concrete and allowing for a small reduction in the water
content due to higher smoothness of GGBS particles and increase in paste volume of
concrete. When GGBS is used as replacement for Portland cement in a mix , it normally acts
as water reducing-agent. According to Hisham (2009), it is clear that the use of slag reduced
the workability of concrete. Hisham (2009) stated that replacement ratios up to 50% have
only marginal effect on the workability and the concrete can still be classified as concrete of
medium workability.
According to Hogan (1981), the greater solid volume and higher fineness of slag
allow more coarse aggregate to be used without a loss of workability. This often reduces the
stickiness of the mix. The reduction in workability is attributed to the fact that the sand has
been replaced by a finer and a more absorbing material. The higher the percentage of the
fines, the less the workability. Moreover, the slag particles have more angular shapes when
It is expected that compressive strength of mortar will be increased with age and
35
The expectation supported by Cahit (2012) discovered that an increase in the
replacement level of GGBS increased compressive strength of the mortars. As expected, the
compressive strength increased with age, and depending on the acceleration in the
activation reactions, the compressive strength values increased with an increase in the Na
content in the mix for a constant replacement level of GGBS. On the other hand, an increase
in the replacement level of GGBS increased compressive strength of the mortars for a
constant.
It supported by Md. Moinul Islam (2011) that the optimum use of slag in the mortar
is observed to be 40% of cement. Slag mortars with 40% cement replacement shows 19%
higher compressive strength than OPC mortar after 180 days curing.
It is expected that the result of compressive strength of concrete cube when higher
to plain concrete. The strength of concrete at a given age and the rate of strength
development are depends upon the type and characteristics mix proportion of the slag in
concrete. This shows that the pozzolanic reactivity of GGBS contributes to the rate of gain of
It supported by Hogan (1981) that found that the concrete made with cement
replacement by slag provides higher compressive strength compared with plain Portland
cement concrete. This is due to increasing the CaO content of the slag results an increase in
compressive strength.
36
CHAPTER 5
5.1 Overview
In this chapter about summary overview the progress work already done and planning future
work. The gantt chart containing progress work done and planning future work that different
by their colour.
Projects and tasks may appear to be endless and they very well could be without a work
plan. A work plan is an important tool for identifying tasks of a project, setting deadlines and
37
5.3 Milestones and Dates
The milestone shows the important activities that will be carried out in planning future work.
No Milestone Date
concrete cubes)
replaced by cement
by cement
38
5.4 Project Schedule
There are prepare an implementation plan that will guide activities in future work. The project schedule described here:
Details/ Sep-2012 Oct-2012 Nov-2013 Dis-2013 Jan-2013 Feb-2013 Mar-2013 Apr-2013 May-2013
Weeks 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
Collecting
Journal
Study FYP 1
1)Introduction
2)Literature
3)Methodology
Sample
preparation
Lab Testing
Analysis Data
Documentati
on
39
CHAPTER 6
CONCLUSION
6.1 Introduction
In this chapter, discusses the advantages of using slag as part of replacement by cement in
the actual building. The effect of admixtures investigated alkali silica reaction will be judged
either meet the objectives set out at the beginning of its development or not. In addition,
Ever since the alkali-silica reaction was discovered, researchers have reported on the
1995). Effective mineral admixtures include slag. The slag in concrete helps in mitigating the
expansions caused by alkali silica reactions. Other than that, there are also have advantages
which are;
40
6.2.1 Reduced Energy
produce cement) and lessened pressure on natural resources (such as reduction in water
consumption).
Portland cement, the major component of concrete, is used to bind the materials that
make up concrete. The production per tonne of portland cement contributes about one ton
materials such as fly ash or slag GGBF will be replaced with portland cement to reduce CO2
emissions. Use of high volume slag as a replacement of cement, in any construction work,
provides lower impact on environment (reduced CO2 emission) and judicious use of
resources (energy conservation, use of by-product etc.). The use of materials in concrete not
only help reduce greenhouse gas emissions but results in environmentally friendly concrete
that has excellent long-term strength and durability characteristics, and often more
Using a mineral admixtures of concrete can avoiding ASR damage. This is also
economical because in some raw material for making concrete where use of cement content
can be reduced. Use of slag reduces the amount of cement content as well as heat of
hydration in a mortar mix. Thus, the construction work with slag concrete becomes
41
economical and also environmentally safe. Furthermore, it also reduce cementitious material
Slag is a by-product of iron produced in a blast furnace. Molten slag the non-metallic
minerals remaining after the iron is removed is tapped from the blast furnace. At this point,
slag can either become a waste, a construction aggregate or a hydraulic cement. It not only
considered a recycled material, but it can also significantly reduce energy consumption and
42
REFERENCE
A. S. M. Abdul Awal, M. Warid Hussin. 1997. The Effectiveness of Palm Oil Fuel Ash in
Preventing Expansion Due to Alkali Silca Reaction. Cement and Concrete Composites.
367-372. Retrieved 10 Oktober 2012, from http://www.sciencedirect.com
Aiqin Wang, J.N, Chengzhi Zhang. 2008. The mechanism of the effect of mineral admixtures
on the expansion of alkali-silica reaction. Journal of Wuhan University of Technology,
Volume 23, Issue 3, pp 376-380. SpringerLink. Retrieved 15 Oktober 2012, from
http://www.springerlink.com
ASTM C109. 2005. Compressive Strength of Mortar. Annual Book of ASTM Standards 2005,
Volume 04.02, ASTM international, 100 Bar Harbour Drive, Conshocken PA 19428-
3959.
ASTM C1260-01. 2005. Standard Test Method for potential alkali reactivity of aggregate
(Mortar-Bar Method). Annual Book of ASTM Standards 2005, Volume 04.02, ASTM
international, 100 Bar Harbour Drive, Conshocken PA 19428-3959.
ASTM C143. Slump Test for Concrete Mix. ASTM International Standards Worldwide.
Retrieved 29 October 2012, from http://www.astm.org
Atul Dubey, Dr. R. Chandak, Prof. R.K.Yadav. 2012. Effect of blast furnace slag powder on
compressive strength of concrete. International Journal of Scientific & Engineering
Research, Volume 3, Issue 8. Retrieved 11 November 2012, from
http://www.ijser.org
Cahit Bilim, Cengiz Duran Atis. 2012. Alkali activation of mortars containing different
replacement levels of ground granulated blast furnace slag. Construction and Building
Materials 28: 708–712. Retrieved 11 October 2012, from
http://www.sciencedirect.com
Chiara F. Ferraris. 1995. Alkali Silica Reaction and High Performance Concrete. Building and
Fire Research Laboratory National Institute of Standard and Technology. Retrieved 14
Oktober 2012, from http://fire.nist.gov
D.S Lane, C. Ozyildirim. 1995. Preventive measures for alkali silica reactions (binary and
ternary system). Cement and Concrete Research 1281-1288. Retrieved 10 November
2012, from http://www.sciencedirect.com
Donald W.L. 1981. Durability Of Slag Cement Concretes. National Slag Association. Retrieved
15 October 2012, from http://www.nationalslag.org
Donald W.L. 1982. Blast-Furnace Slag as a Mineral Admixture for Concrete. Concrete
Construction. Retrieved 14 October 2012, from http://www.concreteconstruction.net
43
George J.Z. Xu1, Daniel F. Watt1, Peter P. Hudec2. 1995. Effectiveness of mineral admixtures
in reducing ASR expansion. Cement and Concrete Research, Volume 25, Issue 6,
Pages 1225–1236. Retrieved 13 October 2012, from http://www.sciencedirect.com
Hisham Qasrawi *, Faisal Shalabi, Ibrahim Asi. 2009. Use of low CaO unprocessed steel slag
in concrete as fine aggregate. Construction and Building Materials, 23: 1118–1125.
Retrieved 30 November 2012, from http://www.sciencedirect.com.
Hogan, F. J., and Meusel, J. W., 1981, “Evaluation for Durability and Strength Development
of a Ground Granulated Blast-Furnace Slag,” Cement, Concrete, and Aggregates,
Volume 3, No. 1, pp. 40-52. Retrieved 11 November 2012, from
http://www.astm.com
J. S. Lumley. 1992. The Asr Expansion Of Concrete Prisms Made From Cements Partially
Replaced By Ground Granulated Blastfurnace Slag. Construction and Building
Materials, Volume 7, Issue 2, pp 95-99. Retrieved 15 Oktober 2012, from
http://www.sciencedirect.com
James A.Farny and Steven H. Kosmatha. 1997. Diagnosis and Control of Alkali Aggregate
Reactions in Concrete. Concrete Information. Retrieved 15 Oktober 2012, from
http://www.nebrconcagg.com
Jan Lindgard, Ozge Andic-Cakir, Isabel Fernandes, Terje F. Ronning. 2012. Alkali–silica
reactions (ASR): Literature revi ew on parameters influencing laboratory performance
testing. Cement and Concrete Composites 223–243. Retrieved 1 october 2012, from
http://www.sciencedirect.com
Mark Gavin Alexander, S.M. 2005. Aggregates In Concrete. New York: Taylor and Francis
Group.
Md. Moinul Islam, Dr.Md.Saiful Islam, Md. Aftabur Rahman and Amrita Das. 2011. Strength
Behavior Of Mortar Using Slag As Partial Replacement Of Cement. Science and
Technology, Volume 3. Retrieved 13 October 2012, from
http://www.banglajol.info/index.php/index
Partnerships in Environmental Management for the Seas of East Asia. 2012. Earthtrends.
Retrieved 15 December 2012, from http://earthtrends.wri.org
Roy, D. M., and Idorn, G. M., ―Hydration, Structure, and Properties of Blast Furnace Slag
Cements, Mortars, and Concrete,‖ Proceedings, ACI JOURNAL V. 79, No. 6, Nov.-
Dec. 1983, pp. 445-457
44
Slag Cement in Concrete and Mortar. Reported by ACI Committee 233
45