Laney 1967

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

The maxillary denture: its palatal relief and

posterior palatal seal

William R. Laney, DDS, MS Anatomic considerations


Juan B. Gonzalez, DDS, MS, Rochester, Minn.
To determine the location and extent of palatal re­
The delineation of areas for palatal relief and pos­ lief and posterior palatal seal, a superficial evalu­
terior palatal seal is the responsibility of the den­ ation o f the potential denture foundation is suc­
tist who constructs the prosthesis. This phase of ceeded by a more detailed examination. Bone of
denture construction is extremely important to the the maxillas, palate, and alveolar ridge has peri­
success of the restoration and the health of the pa­ osteal attachments and a mucosal covering with a
tient. Palatal reliefs should be minimal, and mas­ varying distribution of connective and glandular
ticatory stresses should be distributed adequately tissue elements. Palpation normally reveals firm
over as wide an area as is feasible. The posterior and dense tissues of the residual ridge and tissues
palatal seal should be properly placed to enhance of limited elasticity over the anterior part of the
border seal and increase stability. hard palate, where the rugae appear as irregular
elevations. Substantial vertical pressure can be ap­
plied in the latter area without eliciting pain. How­
Inflammatory, necrotic, and premalignant tissue ever, prolonged horizontal shifting of the denture
changes generally are not precipitated without base readily irritates the irregular mucosal surface.
cause. The resin denture base of a relatively inert Anteriorly, on the median palatine suture, lies
material is seldom the immediate etiologic factor. the anterior palatine foramen indicated by the in­
Anatomic structures supporting the denture base cisive papilla. Traumatic forces applied to this re­
constantly respond to local stresses and systemic gion may induce paresthesia, pain, or a burning
disorders, and the normal maxillary denture sensation since the nasopalatine vessels and nerves
foundation can withstand local functional stresses underlie the mucosa near the papilla.
transmitted by the denture base. However, to con­ In its anteroposterior extent, the median pala­
struct a complete prosthesis efficiently for the tine suture can vary from a midline depression to
edentulous maxillas, one must be cpgnizant of the an extensive undercut torus. The suture usually is
anatomic and physiologic limitations of each pa­ covered with a relatively thin mucoperiosteum.
tient and plan the restoration accordingly. Laterally from the midline to the alveolar pro­
The delineation of areas for palatal relief and cess, the thickness of the submucosa increases.
posterior palatal seal is not a laboratory obliga­ Fat cells are profusely interspersed in the super­
tion; it is the responsibility of the dentist who con­ ficial tissues between the deep layers o f the oral
structs the prosthesis. To assign the laboratory mucosa and the palatine glands. Pendleton1’2 ob­
technician this responsibility is a breach of the pa­ served that the palatine glands may contribute to
tient’s faith in the diagnostic ability of his den­ the mechanical function performed by the adipose
tist; the success of the prosthesis may depend on tissue. These glands are of equal importance as
these simple but critical procedures. buffers to the shock of forces transmitted to the

1182
denser tissues at the residual ridges and the mid­ pterygomandibular raphe. Prominent superior at­
line of the palate by the prosthesis. The anterior tachments of the raphe to the maxillary tuberosity
palatine nerves and descending palatine vessels behave as active frenums and may affect border
leave the greater palatine foramens at the postero­ seal. Frequently active in this region is the tendon
lateral angles of the hard palate. If the jaw has of the tensor palati muscle, which is protected by
been edentulous for some time with subsequent a bursa as it rounds the hook of the hamular pro­
resorption, these structures may be superficial in cess. Although in instances of prominent tuberosi­
their anterior course. In the average patient, suf­ ties, its medial extension onto the lateral palate
ficient protection is afforded by a normal distribu­ may be affected by vertical tendinous slips of the
tion of glandular and adipose tissue. However, in internal pterygoid muscle, the hamular notch is a
instances of extreme resorption, spinous processes relatively passive region for maintaining adequate
of bone near these foramens may require mechan­ seal.
ical relief or surgical removal.
A comparative study of the elasticity and dis-
placeability of the mucosa covering the residual Clinical aspects
ridge, the median palatine suture, the zygomatic
process, and the neutral zone between the pala­ Palatal relief may be needed to compensate for
tine suture and ridge enables one to determine differential characteristics of the hard and soft tis­
more efficiently the outline and depth of the pala­ sues of the maxillary denture foundation by arti­
tal relief that may be needed in the denture base. ficial means. Basal and alveolar bone differ in
The region providing the opportunity for the structure and physiology and consequently in re­
posterior palatal seal is a relatively inconspicuous sistance to stress. Unequal, uncompensated re­
maze of integrated anatomic structures. Although sorption of the alveolar ridges may result in a rock-
the posterior border contact of the complete den­
ture essentially resembles the peripheral contacts,
the tissues of thè soft palate have some character­
istics different from those of other border tissues.
Oversimplification in classifying throat forms
causes many dentists to think of palatal movement
as hingelike. However, a wide range of three-di-
mensional functional movements in speaking and
swallowing actually affects posterior border exten­
sion. Relatively far removed from their bony at­
tachment at the posterior border of the hard pal­
ate, the muscles providing noticeable movements
of the soft palate seem to interfere most with pos­
terior border adaptation about 3 to 5 mm. lateral
from the midline. Movement at the vibrating line
in the midline involves a thin, firm, tendonlike
band, the palatine aponeurosis, which supports
the palatal muscles, strengthens the palate, and
attaches anteriorly to the posterior border of the
horizontal palatine plate. Because action of this
band is vigorous, palatal reliefs extended too far
posteriorly may contribute to seal leakage or ir­
ritation of the mucosa. Essentially, the posterior
border of the maxillary denture is borne by the
palatine aponeurosis.
The hamular notch is formed by the pterygoid
hamulus, the pyramidal process of the palatine
bone, and the maxillary tuberosity. This trough is
the lateral indication for completing the posterior Fig. 1 ■ Typical m idpalatal configurations. L ittle hor­
izontal hard area, top; average hard area w ith some ver­
palatal seal; it contains collagenous tissue, and its tica l projection, m iddle, and hard area exaggerated w ith
ease of displacement relates to the action of the torus palatinus, bottom .

Laney—Gonzalez: THE MAXILLARY DENTURE ■ 1183


Fig. 2 ■ Examples o f stereotyped tin fo il palatal relie fs com m only placed in laboratory w ith o u t ade­
quate exam ination and diagnosis.

ing of the prosthesis on more resistant regions physiologically impossible to bring the entire im­
with proportionately decreased retention and sta­ pression surface of the denture base in contact with
bility. Soft tissue depth, elasticity, and displace- the anatomic foundation uniformly in all function­
ability vary from patient to patient, and compen­ al situations. From an adequate survey of the en­
sation for these differences, as well as for ultimate tire stress-bearing base, however, selection of a
settling of the base, may also be needed. Vital minimal area for needed palatal relief can be
nerve and blood supplies must not be curtailed. made. Reliefs placed arbitrarily are generally too
Consequently, relief is provided for comfort, more extensive, and they needlessly sacrifice desirable
efficient distribution of stress, and a more lasting stress-bearing surface (Fig. 2). Liberally consider­
retention of the prosthesis. ing those surfaces that would offer resistance to
Mechanical justification for palatal relief has masticating force as stress bearing, the arbitrary
been cited.3 Shrinkage of acrylic resin during cur­ relief shown on the »left (Fig. 2) used about 18
ing causes premature palatal contact. Furthermore, percent of the total bearing surface available; the
one theory says that impression materials are un­ relief area of the specimen shown in the center
der greater pressure in the region of the palatal covered 13 percent, and that of the specimen
vault, causing the impression surface to have an shown on the right covered 21 percent of the de­
exaggerated contour. sirable surface for stress distribution.
The median palatine suture, called “the hard Palatal relief design cannot be stereotyped
area” by Swenson,4 varies in vertical and horizon­ without loss of efficiency because most maxillary
tal dimensions. Cross sections of average maxillas dentures do not need relief. Moreover, extensive
are in one of three general categories (Fig. ij. The relief areas weaken complete acrylic resin maxil­
prominence and extent of the hard area can easily lary prostheses and, unless occlusal compensation
be palpated with a ball burnisher or other similar is made, midline fracture may result. Lammie5 in­
blunt instrument. However, when selecting the dicated that reliefs should always be of minimal
area for palatal relief, the depth and ease of dis­ extension and thickness since the use of unneces­
placement of the mucosa covering the lateral, ante­ sary relief areas serves only to reduce retention
rior, and posterior palatal areas, the residual ridge, through causing air inclusions in the salivary film.
and the zygomatic process are examined and com­ Rather than overrelieve the palatal portion of the
pared with that covering the hard area. The loca­ denture to compensate for resorptive changes, it
tion and structure of the anterior and posterior is more desirable to maintain the tissue surface of
palatine foramens are also considered for possible the denture properly adapted to the mucosa by
relief. periodically relining or replacing the denture base.
Unfortunately, the area usually needing relief Various methods of incorporating palatal relief
is near the center of the stress-bearing area of the into the maxillary prosthesis can be used. Tilton6
complete maxillary prosthesis. Thus the problem has successfully used several methods to provide
of sacrificing stress-bearing area and retentive seal automatic relief in the impression: soft wax in the
surface for palatal relief and stability arises. By relieved final impression; soft plaster or paste in
use of predetermined relief (Fig. 2), it is almost the relieved final impression with an escape hole;

1184 ■ JADA, Vol. 75, Nov. 1967


an indelible pencil and reseating the impression.
The pencil line is transferred to the impression,
and a groove is cut along the center of the recorded
area to a depth corresponding to the hardness and
prominence of the area. The scraping is decreased
gradually from the midline to the border of the
relief area.
Rather than provide a space in the denture base
for palatal relief, resilient material may be pro­
cessed with the acrylic resin to provide a yielding,
but contacting, surface8 (Fig. 3).
Tinfoil cut and sealed to the cast over the de­
sired area is a commonly used laboratory proce­
dure for providing relief. A somewhat typical hard
Fig. 3 ■ R elief area fille d w ith heat-cured silicone area might be relieved as shown in Figure 4. How­
rubber.
ever, a routine relief of several layers of 60-gauge
brushing on soft plaster through a large relief hole tinfoil, for example, placed in the same pattern
in the impression for metal base (when there are without a careful examination suggests inefficient
large tori palatini), and syringe-injection technic. diagnosis and planning. When the patient is ex­
When a compound tray is used, a relief can al­ amined, the cast is marked for extent and depth
so be accomplished by making a trough in the re­ of palatal relief. For the average patient, a palatal
gions of the midpalatine suture and incisive papil­ relief of more than two or three thicknesses of
la. As the compound tray is reheated and seated 0.0025-inch foil is probably excessive. If the use
in the mouth, pressure is relieved in these regions of foil for relief is the selected procedure, a vari­
since the material can flow into the trough. This able laminated thickness should be provided for
trough also provides a space for the relief of hy­ each patient (Fig. 4, right). Keeping the greatest
draulic pressure developed when the final impres­ depth over the hardest and most prominent areas,
sion is made.7 the top layer or layers are lapped and burnished
Swenson4 suggested a procedure for system­ to the cast. The relief border must blend smoothly
atically scraping the final impression which in­ with the adjacent base to maintain good seal and
volves marking of the hard area in the mouth with prevent retention of food debris and saliva.

Fig. 4 ■ Hard area (left) adequately relieved w ith tin fo il (right) by prosthodontist. Thorough mouth
exam ination resulted in design shown here.

Laney—Gonzalez: THE MAXILLARY DENTURE ■ 1185


Fig. 5 a P osterior palatal seal in wax on fin a l im pression (le ft) and seal area created by scraping
m aster cast to predeterm ined o u tlin e and depth (right).

The processed base can be relieved with hand­ tini, and the phonation of “ah” by the patient in­
piece and bur. Pressure indicator pastes have made dicate its location. If these signs fail to indicate a
this approach effective. distinct line of movement, instructing the patient
Although it is clinically used, the vacuum- to blow air through the nose while holding his
chamber principle has lost support. Atmospheric nostrils closed will force the palate downward.
pressure and an emergency vacuum help retain However, this procedure may denote a line in
the complete maxillary denture; however, palatal front of the desired functional position. In locating
lesions are seen frequently under these chambers the vibrating line, the dentist seeks to determine
and in overrelieved areas. A so-called vacuum, the posterior border extension of the denture and
equivalent to at least 10 mm. of mercury and main­ to note the depth and rate of palatal movement.
tained under the denture for a time, probably In selecting an area for an efficient posterior pala­
could result in tissue proliferation tending to fill tal seal, one considers movable tissues along the
the space. However, the beaded, hyperemic pro­ entire extent of the vibrating line. Since the Class
jections— called “chronic inflammatory papillary I static throat usually has minimal three-dimen­
hyperplasia” by Fisher and Rashid9— probably sional movement, it is most advantageous for pos­
result from tissue irritation secondary to excessive terior extension and placement of the posterior
retention of food debris and stagnant oral secre­ palatal seal.
tions under or around poor-fitting denture bases. The selection of the seal area further involves
Such inflammatory lesions have progressed to ma­ palpation to determine the depth and displace­
lignancy.10 Some authors 1112 think that a predis­ ment of less movable tissues. Generally, a lip­
posing factor is present as a major etiologic agent shaped area, with the widest portions directed
in patients with inflammatory hyperplasia. anteriorly over the posterolateral glandular re­
The posterior palatal seal, described by Neil,13 gions of the palate, is most advantageous for ob­
compensates for dimensional changes incurred in taining a good seal. A single or double beaded-
processing acrylic resins, thereby enhancing bor­ line tissue placement may result in loss of seal in
der seal. The portion o f the denture on the soft the lateral palatal areas where functional depth
tissue adjacent to the vibrating line must be physi­ and width are variable. Pendleton1 has shown
ologically compatible with the tissues at rest and that the width of the seal area may range from 1
in action. to 12 mm. anteroposteriorly. However, the widest
Since the determination of the posterior palatal portion of the seal seldom extends more than 6
seal area is a clinical and not a laboratory proce­ mm. clinically since greater width could result in
dure, the dentist should analyze the form of the loss of adaptation at the posterior border. Posteri­
throat at rest and in action. In examining palatal or palatal seal depth ranges from about 1 to 4 mm.
function, it is advantageous to first note the vi­ The general rule is to note the total possible dis­
brating line. The hamular notches, the fovea pala­ placement of these tissues and then to make the
1186 ■ JADA, Vol. 75, Nov. 1967
maximal depth not more than two thirds of this tention of the denture and to give the patient
displacement.13 maximal comfort.
The seal generally is provided while one makes The posterior palatal seal is an essential feature
the impression or subsequently by scraping the in the retention of the complete maxillary pros­
cast. Regardless o f the technic used, the posterior thesis. When properly paced, it enhances border
extension of the denture base should be deter­ seal and increases stability.
mined in the mouth. If the seal is to be added dur­ An American Dental Association Bulletin14
ing the impression, mouth temperature wax is an contained this pertinent passage:
excellent medium provided it is carefully placed
and allowed to flow properly (Fig. 5, left). The When the dentist carries out the various professional
trimmed posterior limit of the seal may need to be procedures involved in the design of a prosthetic
sharpened on the cast, since palatal movement device, he visualizes something much deeper and
has a tendency to round the wax border and re­ more complex than mere pencil marking of a stone
duce adaptation. or plaster cast made from an impression of the
mouth. When he completes prosthetic treatment,
If the seal is to be cut into the cast, the posterior
he has done far more than restore some missing
extension may be established on the trial base­
teeth, he has restored a vital physiological function
plate by transfer of an indelible pencil line. This important not only to the dental health but to the
line is then etched on the cast. If the anterior seal general health of the patient. The serious threat to
limit has been determined by palpation, a line is public health which could develop by placing these
sketched on the cast corresponding to these find­ responsibilities in the hands of the unqualified is
ings. From the depth of the posterior cut, the cast obvious.
is scraped in a tapering manner to blend into the
remaining cast surface at the anterior line (Fig. 5,
right). Careful placement o f the seal is necessary
to prevent pressure atrophy of involved tissues. Doctors Laney and Gonzalez are at th e Mayo
C lin ic and Mayo Foundation, Section of D entistry
Furthermore, an excessive depth of seal may cause and Oral Surgery, Rochester, M inn., 55901.
a rocking of the prosthesis on the hard palate, es­
pecially at the midline.
1. Pendleton E. C. M in ute anatom y o f the so ft pal­
ate from th e view point o f th e denture prosthetist. Bur
44:13 A pril, 1944.
Conclusion 2. Pendleton, E. C. Anatom y of the face and mouth
from th e sta n dp o in t o f the denture prosthetist. JADA
33:219 Feb., 1946.
Each digital and visual examination of the eden­ 3. Campbell, R. L. R elief cham bers in com plete den­
tulous maxilla should reveal pertinent anatomic tures. J Prosth Dent 11:230 M arch-April, 1961.
and physiologic relationships vital to the success 4. Swenson, M. G. Com plete dentures, ed. 3. St.
Louis, C. V. Mosby Co. 1963.
of the proposed prosthesis. From a review of 5. Lammie, G. A. Retention of com plete dentures.
these considerations, the determination of areas JADA 55:502 Oct., 1957.
for more efficient palatal relief and posterior 6. T ilto n , G. E. M inim um pressure com plete den­
tu re im pression technique. J. Prosth Dent 6:6 Jan., 1956.
palatal seal can be made. In essence, the dentist 7. Kingery, R. H. Graduate com plete d e nture lec­
attempts to balance three static surfaces of the tu re notes. U niversity of M ichigan, 1961-1963.
denture base against one dynamic tissue surface. 8. Gonzalez, J. B., and Laney, W. R. R esilient ma­
te ria ls fo r denture prostheses. J Prosth Dent 16:438 May-
The impression surface, the depressed surface for June, 1966.
palatal relief, and the raised surface for the pos­ 9. Fisher, A. K., and Rashid, P. J. Inflam m atory pa­
terior palatal seal must be maintained in har­ p illa ry hyperplasia of the palatal mucosa. Oral Surg 5:
191 Feb., 1952.
monious adaptation to the changing anatomic 10. Robinson, H. B. G. Neoplasms and “ precancerous”
base. This phase of denture construction is of lesions o f th e oral regions. Dent Clin N Amer Nov., 1957,
such importance to the success of the restoration p. 621-626.
11. Yrastorza, J..A . In fla m m a tory pa p illa ry hyperplasia
and health of the patient that it must be consid­ o f th e palate. J Oral Surg Anesth Hosp Dent Serv 21:330
ered a clinical and not a laboratory procedure. July, 1963.
To ensure prosthesis efficiency and oral health, 12. Guernsey, L. H. Reactive in fla m m a to ry papillary
hyperplasia o f th e palate. Oral Surg. 20:814 Dec., 1965.
palatal reliefs should be minimal. Regardless of 13. Neil, E. Full denture practice. Nashville, Tenn­
the technic used to incorporate needed relief into essee, M arshall and Bruce, 1932, p. 13-14; 47-51; 72-77.
the denture base, the ultimate goal is to distribute 14. Am erican Dental Association. The d e n tis t’s re­
lations w ith the laboratory cra ft—a review o f his legal and
the masticatory stresses adequately over as wide ethical responsibilities. Chicago, Am erican Dental Asso­
an area as is feasible, to provide more lasting re­ cia tio n Inform ation B u lle tin . December, 1957, p. 3.

Laney-G onzalez: THE MAXILLARY DENTURE ■ 1187

You might also like