Seasonal Trend in The Soybean Market

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

Seasonal Trend in the Soybean Market

Ricardo Da Costa
ricardof_da_costa@hotmail.com

Abstract knowledge provides a very rough but useful, yearly


One hundred years of historical price records for roadmap for producers, traders and analysts indicating
soybeans were analyzed in order to find its seasonal them when to expect high or low prices.
trend. The months when most/least highs and lows are
reached were registered and analyzed to gain 2.1. Data sets and chart types
understanding of the seasonal behavior of the market.
W.D. Gann’s findings on this subject were verified. The In order to find a reliable commodity market seasonal
soybean market showed a well-defined seasonal trend behavior it is necessary to include in the study price
with highs and lows in each of the four seasons. The records going back as far as possible. In this particular
months of May, June and July had a greater probability case of study the data set has a time span of 100 years,
of extreme high prices. The month of October is the month going back to 1913 when soybean prices began to be
when most extreme low prices were reached. These recorded. Only monthly swing data was available from
results should serve as reference for when to expect highs 1913 to 1936 when futures trading began in soybeans [2].
and lows and for how long a typical move should last. The From 1936 to 1954 May soybean futures data is used [3].
analyst should then be able to know when to expect rallies These two data sets were available and used by Gann.
and reactions, tops and bottoms. From 1969 to the present time, cash prices recorded at
central Illinois are used [4]. This last data set was chosen
because it is more consistent over time, it doesn’t contain
1. Introduction artificial gaps due to contract roll-overs and it represents
the market close to its most elemental form [5].
Going over past price records W.D. Gann observed In the case of May soybean futures and the more recent
that agricultural commodity prices follow a seasonal cash prices at central Illinois, 2-month swing charts are
pattern [1]. Some commodities have a more consistent used in the study. This was done to filter minor moves
and reliable pattern than others; however, all of them and keep only relevant tops and bottoms in the study.
follow a yearly cyclical behavior.
A seasonal trend analysis is performed on the soybean 3. Soybeans seasonal monthly lows
market employing the same data Gann used along with
more recent price records. The present study confirmed By going over past records it is possible to see in
and expanded Gann’s results. Additionally, it was found which months the soybean market is more likely to reach
that the soybean market has a very well defined and extreme low prices. Just as important, it is to know which
consistent seasonal behavior. This knowledge proves to months are less likely to have market bottoms.
be useful for market analysts, who in conjunction with Additionally, it is useful to have an idea of the expected
geometry and cycle analysis can carry out more accurate behavior of the market after an extreme low is reached in
predictions. a particular month.

2. Seasonal trend 3.1. Months when most lows are reached


Each agricultural product has a particular crop cycle of Figure 1 is a bar chart containing the percentage of
planting, growing and harvesting. This cycle is directly times the soybean market has reached an extreme high or
related to seasonal changes. In consequence, agricultural low price in each calendar month of the year. It is the
commodities are quite dependent on weather conditions result of the analysis of the data sets described in the
and its fluctuations. previous section. In view of the fact that agricultural
For this reason, agricultural products display a yearly commodity markets display a seasonal behavior, the
seasonal behavior. Generally, each commodity market upper part of Figure 1 can be considered as the probability
will behave following a particular yearly pattern, making of reaching a top in each month, while the lower part of
tops or bottoms in similar months each year. This
30%

25%

20% 17%
15% 11%
11% 11%
8% 9%
10% 7% 8% 7%
4% 5%
5% 3%

0%

-5% -2%
-5% -4%
-5% -5% -5%
-10% -8% -7% -7%
-11% -12%
-15%

-20%

-25%

-30% -28%
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec

Figure 1
Percentages of times the soybean market reaches tops and bottoms in each calendar month of the year.

the chart indicates the probability of reaching a bottom in 3.3. Market behavior after monthly lows
each month of the year.
From Figure 1 it can be seen that most seasonal lows It is useful to have knowledge of the expected market
are made in the months of October (28%), November behavior after soybeans makes extreme low prices in each
(12%) and February (11%). Together, these three months month of the year.
comprise 51% of all lows in the soybean market. While reviewing these results, it is of utmost
This means that when the market is running according importance to remember that the soybean market follows
to seasonal trend, the analyst will expect seasonal bottoms a seasonal trend. Not all months have the same probability
and a change in trend in the months of October or of reaching a bottom and show a change of trend.
November, and later in February. Appendix A contains a series of charts with relevant
graphical information regarding this section.
3.2. Months when least lows are reached
3.3.1. January lows. When low prices are made in the
Figure 1 shows that June (2%), July (4%) and May month of January, the market most likely rallies until
(5%) are the months when the least number of lows are February (25%) and July (25%). Second on importance
made. These are typically seasonal high months for are the months of April (17%) and May (17%) as possible
soybeans. swing tops after a January low.
This does not mean that extreme low prices can’t be This means that the market will rally for only one
reached in those months; however that is not the expected month and then react strongly; otherwise prices will
market behavior. When the market is running according continue to go up until the seasonal high months.
to seasonal trend the analyst will not anticipate bottoms
around the summer months, which are seasonal high 3.3.2. February lows. February is an important month
months. for soybean bottoms. When extreme low prices are
reached in February prices typically rally until May (29%)
and April (25%). This suggests that after a February
bottom, the market is expected to rally from one to three
months before any important reaction takes place.
It is important to mention that in 100 years there has two months into October (18%) and November (45%).
never been a July swing top after a February bottom. This Second on importance for a swing top after a September
indicates that if the market doesn’t reacts in June, the next bottoms is January (18%).
month to look for a possible swing top is August.
This description agrees with Gann’s analysis [1]: 3.3.10. October lows. October is the month when most
seasonal lows are made. According to past records, after
“…If Lows were reached in January and February, the market bottoms in October it will most likely rally for
according to seasonal trend, then you would watch the three to four months until January (20%) or February
Highs in May, June and July and, if the crop was very (14%), which together comprise 34% of the cases.
short and the market running against seasonal trend, you In some instances, the market will not react for seven
would expect Highs in October.” to nine months until the seasonal months for highs are
“…therefore, the early part of the year you would reached in May (10%), June (10%) and July (18%), which
expect the most Lows to be made, but from March to June together are 38% of the cases.
there had been no extreme Lows for the year made; According to Gann after October bottoms [1]:
therefore, during this period you should be careful of
being short, and expect the market to advance to seasonal “October is the record month for Lows…[and] during
Highs in May, June or July.” the months of November and December, 5 Lows have
been made. Therefore, you should expect Soy Beans
3.3.3. March lows. If a market bottom is made in the to…[make] Lows from October to January, and some
month of March, prices will mostly rally for three months years as late as February. When they follow the seasonal
until June (38%) or July (25%), when seasonal highs are trend they advance from February to May, and possibly
made. from June to July. During the Summer, if it looks like a
large crop, prices may work lower during August and
3.3.4. April lows. When extreme low prices are September, but if there was a crop scare during these
reached in April, the market generally rallies for three months an advance would take place.”
months until July (50%) or one to two months until May
(33%). 3.3.11. November lows. Together with October and
February, the month of November is important for market
3.3.5. May lows. May is not a month for seasonal bottoms. When soybeans reaches extreme low prices in
lows. However, after a May low the market has only November the market typically rallies two or three
rallied into the June (50%) or July (50%) tops. months into February (20%) and January (10%), which
add up to 30% of the cases.
3.3.6. June lows. June is the month with least seasonal However, according to past records, the most likely
lows in soybeans recorded history. After a June low, behavior after a November bottom is to rally for five to
prices go up for two or three months into August (67%) or six months until May (35%) or June (15%), which
September (33%) which are seasonal months for tops or together comprise 50% of the instances. In this case,
secondary tops. swing tops are not to be expected in the month of July
(5%), even if this is the month for high prices.
3.3.7. July lows. July is not a month for seasonal lows.
Nevertheless, going against the seasonal trend, after a July 3.3.12. December lows. According to seasonal
bottom the market will most likely rally for five months behavior, after a bottom in the month of December,
until December (38%) of or seven to eight months until soybeans are expected to rally until January (29%) and
February (25%). February (21%). Otherwise, the market will continue up
for five to seven months for a swing top in the month of
3.3.8. August lows. According to seasonal trend, after June (21%). This suggests that if extreme low prices are
the tops of June/July soybeans generally decline into an reached in December, an initial rally will only last for a
August bottom when a rally follows, most of the time into month or two until a correction is due. If not, the market
late August or September (15%). However, it is also will continue to go up until the summer months.
probable that the market will rally for seven to eight
months until March (23%), which is not a month for 4. Soybeans seasonal monthly highs
seasonal highs. Second on importance for a swing top
after an August low are the months of November (15%) From past price records it is possible to see in which
and December (15%), rallying for three months. months the soybean market is more likely to reach
extreme high prices. It is important as well, to know
3.3.9. September lows. When low prices are reached which months are less likely to have market tops.
in September, the market most likely will rally for one or Furthermore, knowing the expected behavior of the
market after an extreme top is reached in a particular market will decline for eight months until October (40%)
month is also of interest. or for two months into a March bottom (20%). This
indicates that if after a top in February the market doesn’t
4.1. Months when most highs are reached reacts in March, it will most likely decline to an October
bottom.
Figure 1 shows that most seasonal highs are made in
the months of July (17%), January (11%), May (11%) and 4.3.3. March highs. The month of March is not a
June (11%). Together, these four months comprise 50% month for seasonal highs, nevertheless when extreme high
of all highs recorded. prices are reached in that month the market will probably
This suggests that when the market is running decline for one or two months until May (50%), which is
according to seasonal trend, the analyst will expect not a month for seasonal lows.
seasonal tops and a change in trend in the months of
January then May, June and July. 4.3.4. April highs. When tops are made in April the
market declines for four to six months until October
4.2. Months when least highs are reached (42%) or less probable August (25%). August bottoms
generally come after the summer tops as the beginning of
Figure 1 shows that March (4%), October (4%) and a rally until the secondary tops of August-September.
December (5%) are the months when the least number of
tops are made. Notice that October is a month for most 4.3.5. May highs. May is an important month for tops
seasonal lows. in the soybean market. In this case, the market is
The fact that these months are not seasonal month for following seasonal trend with a decline lasting between
tops in soybeans does not mean that extreme high prices two to five months ending in October (42%), August
can’t be reached in those months. There are exceptions (21%) or September (21%). These three months comprise
and years when the market runs opposite seasonal trend. 84% of the bottoms made after a May top.
But when the market is running according to seasonal
trend the analyst will not expect tops around March, 4.3.6. June highs. June is another important month for
October or December. tops. After soybeans has reached extreme high prices in
June, the market will most likely decline for four to five
months into October (44%) or November (17%). This
4.3. Market behavior after monthly highs suggest that after June tops the market will most likely
decline directly into the seasonal lows of October-
In addition to the knowledge of when to expect a
November without any important rally.
market top according to seasonal behavior, it is useful to
anticipate for how long a decline will last after a top.
4.3.7. July highs. July is the month when most
Seeing as October is such an important month for
seasonal tops are made. From past records, after extreme
bottoms, a great number of declines are finished in this
prices are reached in July, the market will decline for only
month
one month until August (23%). Otherwise it will decline
It is important to keep in mind that the soybean market
for three to five months into October (23%) or November
follows a seasonal trend. Not all months have the same
(17%) bottoms.
probability of reaching a top. Appendix B contains a
This indicates that it is very likely that after a July top
series of charts with relevant graphical information
the market will decline until August and rally, making a
regarding this section.
secondary top in late August or September. Else, the
market will decline into the seasonal low months of
4.3.1. January highs. January is an important month
October or November.
for soybean tops. When the market tops in January the
most important month for a market bottom is October
4.3.8. August highs. After high prices are reached in
(33%) after an eight to nine months decline. Second in
August the market will most probably decline for one to
importance is a two to three month decline until March
three months until October (46%) or September (23%).
(20%) and April (20%).
This suggests that after a top in January the market will
4.3.9. September highs. Together with August, the
most likely decline for most part of the year until October,
tops in September are generally secondary tops. From
the seasonal month for bottoms. But a rally could be
these tops, the market typically declines for one to two
expected between March and April.
months until October (60%) and November (30%), which
are seasonal month for extreme low prices.
4.3.2. February highs. Similarly to the month of
January, when high prices are reached in February, the
18%

16% 15%

14%

12%
10%
10%
10% 9%
8%
8%
8%
8% 7%
7%
6%
6%
6%
5%
4%

2%

0%
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec

Figure 2
Percentages of times the soybean market changes trend in each month of the year.

4.3.10. October highs. From Figure 1 it is clear that in is also important to know the months in which trend
100 years October is the month when the least number of changes are least likely to take place.
tops have been reached in soybeans. This is a seasonal
month for low prices. When this happens, the market is 5.1. Months when most trend changes are
running opposite seasonal trend and it declines until June expected
(40%) or January (20%) and February (20%). June is not
a month for seasonal lows, but this scenario indicates that Figure 2 is a bar chart showing the percentage of times
the market is running opposite seasonal trend, making a trend change occurred in each month of the year. It
tops in seasonal low months and bottoms in seasonal high shows that the months of October (15%), July (10%) and
months. February (10%) are the months when it is more likely to
have a trend change in the soybean market.
4.3.11. November highs. The tops reached in It is not coincidence that these months are those when
November are generally followed by a decline of one to a change in trend is most likely to take place, because
two months until February (36%) and January (27%), October and February are seasonal months for lows and
which are months for seasonal lows. July is the seasonal month for highs. Nonetheless, from
Figure 1 February is also a month when some seasonal
4.3.12. December highs. Together with November, highs could be expected. This means that those months
December highs are sometimes tops after an October deserve more attention and the analyst should be prepared
bottom. From these months, the market declines for one for a possible trend change in them.
or four months into the early part of the year until
February (43%) or April (29%), then resuming the
5.2. Months when least trend changes are
uptrend.
expected
5. Soybeans seasonal trend changes Figure 2 shows that a change in trend is not to be
expected in the months of March (5%), April (6%) and
It is valuable to investigate from past records the December (6%). This suggests that the market will
months in which trend changes are most likely to occur, continue with its current trend during those months, and
regardless if the market tops or bottoms. Additionally, it any rally or reaction will most likely be short lived;
mainly in March, when it is very unlikely to have a
change in trend.

6. Soybeans average seasonal behavior


Figure 3 is a composite of soybeans seasonal trend
using a sum of normalized averages of the yearly
behavior of the market. This was performed using
MATLAB programing software and daily cash data [4],
from 1970 to 2013, a time span of 43 complete years.
It is possible to arrive to a composite by performing
the following three steps:

 Isolate each year’s market price action and


normalizing it.
 Adding together all normalized yearly data
day-by-day.
 Performing a final normalization.
Figure 3
The result from these operations is a very rough Soybeans seasonal trend
composite or average behavior of the market in a year’s
time; in other words, a seasonal trend. 7. Summary
The method employed here to construct the results
shown on Figure 3 was more complex, but it follows the A study on the seasonal behavior of the soybean
above mentioned steps in its core. market was presented. The initial approach was to follow
The seasonal trend from Figure 3 agrees with the Gann’s methodology. It consisted in researching past
findings of previous sections. At first sight it shows history to observe the months when it was most probable
seasonal bottoms in October and highs in June and July. to find lows and highs. It also incorporated the months
By blending the above results with those from Figure 3, a when it was least probable to find lows and highs and the
typical seasonal behavior for soybeans can be described in months when a change in trend was most and least likely
the following manner: to occur.
This method was expanded by analyzing what is the
 An uptrend begins with lows in October or most probable behavior of the market after a bottom or
November. top is made in any given month. Additionally, a seasonal
 A rally until November-December or trend curve was derived using daily cash prices.
January-February tops. The results verify Gann’s findings on the subject. The
 A reaction until January or February bottoms. soybean market follows a very definite seasonal pattern.
 A final rally until the summer tops from May This knowledge should give an idea or serve as reference
to July. From here a downtrend begins. of when to expect highs and lows and for how long a
 A reaction into early August lows. typical move should last. The analyst should then be able
 A rally until late August or September to know when to expect rallies and reactions, tops and
secondary tops. bottoms. With the aid of cycle and geometry analysis
 A downtrend returning to the lows of October market predictions should be more accurate and trades
or November. should be more profitable and less stressful.

This describes the general yearly behavior of the 8. Bibliography


soybean market when it is running according to seasonal
trend. According to this study, the soybean market makes [1] W. Gann, How to make profits trading in
a top and bottom in each one of the four seasons of the commodities, Pomeroy, WA: Library of Gann
year. publishing Co.Inc., 1942.
[2] B. Gould, "Prices Received for Soybeans," 2014.
[Online]. Available:
http://future.aae.wisc.edu/data/monthly_values/by_are
a/2051?tab=feed.
[3] Bradley F. Cowan, "Stock Market Geometry," 2014. twelve, San Diego, CA: Stock Market Geometry,
[Online]. Available: http://www.cycle-trader.com/. 1995.
[4] Illinois Department of Agriculture-USDA,
"GX_GR113, Illinois Grain Prices in Country
Elevators," [Online]. Available:
http://www.ams.usda.gov/mnreports/gx_gr113.txt.
[Accessed 25 03 2013].
[5] B. F. Cowan, Market science volume I: Square of
Appendix A

Monthly Highs from Monthly Highs from Monthly Highs from March
January Lows February Lows Lows
38%
25% 25% 29%
25%
25%
17%17%

13% 13% 13%13% 13%


8% 8% 8%
4% 4% 4%
Jul

Jul

Jul
May
Jun

Mar

May
Jun

May
Jun
Jan
Feb
Mar

Sep

Nov

Jan
Feb

Sep

Nov

Jan
Feb
Mar

Sep

Nov
Oct

Dec

Oct

Dec

Oct

Dec
Apr

Aug

Apr

Aug

Apr

Aug
Monthly Highs from April Monthly Highs from May Monthly Highs from June
Lows Lows Lows
67%
50% 50%50%

33%
33%

8% 8%
Jul

Jul

Jul
Feb
Mar

May
Jun

Sep

Feb
Mar

May
Jun

Sep

Feb
Mar

May
Jun

Sep
Jan

Oct
Nov
Dec

Jan

Oct
Nov
Dec

Jan

Oct
Nov
Dec
Apr

Aug

Apr

Aug

Apr

Aug
Monthly Highs from July Monthly Highs from Monthly Highs from
Lows August Lows September Lows
38% 23% 45%

25% 15% 15%15%

18% 18%
13% 13%13% 8% 8% 8% 8%
9% 9%
Jul

Jul

Jul
May

May
Mar

Jun

Nov

Jun

Nov

May
Jun

Nov
Jan
Feb

Sep

Feb
Mar

Sep

Feb
Mar

Sep
Oct

Dec

Jan

Oct

Dec

Jan

Oct

Dec
Apr

Aug

Apr

Aug

Apr

Aug

Monthly Highs from Monthly Highs from Monthly Highs from


October Lows November Lows December Lows
29%
35%
20%
18% 21% 21%
14%
20% 14%
10%10% 15%
8%
6% 6% 6% 10% 10% 7% 7%
2% 5% 5%
Jul

Jul

Jul
May
Jun

Nov

May
Jun

Nov

May
Jun

Nov
Feb
Mar

Sep

Feb
Mar

Sep

Feb
Mar

Sep
Jan

Oct

Dec

Jan

Oct

Dec

Jan

Oct

Dec
Apr

Aug

Apr

Aug

Apr

Aug
Appendix B

Monthly Lows from Monthly Lows from Monthly Lows from March
January Highs February Highs Highs

May

May

May
Mar

Mar

Mar
Nov

Nov

Nov
Aug

Aug

Aug
Dec

Dec

Dec
Feb

Sep

Feb

Sep

Feb

Sep
Apr

Apr

Apr
Oct

Oct

Oct
Jun

Jun

Jun
Jan

Jan

Jan
Jul

Jul

Jul
-7%-7% -7%-7%
-13% -17% -17% -17%
-13% -13% -20%
-20%
-20%

-40% -50%
-33%

Monthly Lows from April Monthly Lows from May Monthly Lows from June
Highs Highs Highs
May

May

May
Mar

Mar

Mar
Nov

Nov

Nov
Aug

Aug

Aug
Dec

Dec

Dec
Feb

Sep

Feb

Sep

Feb

Sep
Apr

Apr

Apr
Oct

Oct

Oct
Jun

Jun

Jun
Jan

Jan

Jan
Jul

Jul

Jul
-6% -6% -6%
-8% -8% -8% -8%
-11% -11%
-17% -17%
-21%
-21%
-25%

-42% -42%
-44%

Monthly Lows from July Monthly Lows from August Monthly Lows from
Highs Highs September Highs
May

May

May
Mar

Mar

Mar
Nov

Nov

Nov
Aug

Aug

Aug
Dec

Dec

Dec
Feb

Sep

Feb

Sep

Feb

Sep
Apr

Apr

Apr
Oct

Oct

Oct
Jun

Jun

Jun
Jan

Jan

Jan
Jul

Jul

Jul
-3%-3% -8% -8% -9% -9%
-7% -15%
-10%
-23% -27%
-13%
-17%

-23% -23% -46% -55%

Monthly Lows from Monthly Lows from Monthly Lows from


October Highs November Highs December Highs
May

May

May
Mar

Mar

Mar
Nov

Nov

Nov
Aug

Aug

Aug
Dec

Dec

Dec
Feb

Sep

Feb

Sep

Feb

Sep
Apr

Apr

Apr
Oct

Oct

Oct
Jun

Jun

Jun
Jan

Jan

Jan
Jul

Jul

Jul

-9% -9%
-14% -14%
-20%
-20% -20%
-18%
-29%
-27%
-40%
-43%
-36%

You might also like