Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Esthetic Failures in Fixed Partial Dentures: Vnvmadhav
Esthetic Failures in Fixed Partial Dentures: Vnvmadhav
V N V Madhav1*
1. Dr, M.D.S. (Prosthodontics), Reader, Department of Prosthodontics, Bharati Vidyapeeth Dental College and Hospital, Pune, India.
Abstract
Esthetic dentistry encompasses those procedures designed to enhance and improve form and
appearance of the maxillofacial region. Esthetic dentistry procedures are performed on both hard
and soft tissue to correct either subjectively or objectively, patient perceived deformities.
Perceptions of esthetic deformities or needs are highly subjective. In this article an effort has
been made to outline the possible esthetic errors which occur in the absence of careful treatment
planning during the fabrication of fixed partial denture procedure.
(J Int Dent Med Res 2010; 3: (3), pp. 146-153 )
irregularities occur, particularly on the labial To these three dimensions, and within the
surface. At the first glance one sees horizontal field of dentistry, we must add a fourth one which
depressions. Vertical lines become visible with would include all of the chromatic features that
more careful observation, so that a pattern of personalize the tooth apart from its average
very fine, slightly displaced rectangles is seen. color, and which are fundamental for the repro-
The older a tooth becomes, the less duction of the color of a tooth.
prominent these structure become. Millions of lip
movements in the same direction lead to Gingival Esthetics
formation of large smoothed regions between Factors Affecting Gingival Esthetics:
which few structured zones are retained. Enamel The morphology and dimension of supracrestal
tears, abrasions, discoloration, incisal edge periodontal tissues undoubtedly represent the
irregularities, bright spots, and band-shaped most important parameters to be taken into
shade variations are not the only consideration in designing a fixed prosthesis28.
characterizations that must be evaluated.
Cervical erosions and fine lines that The Esthetic Width; As the supracrestal
separate the clinical crown and the root, which connective tissue attachment is resected during
may result from simple aging or from oral tooth preparation, so should the esthetic width be
hygiene procedures, must also be evaluated. respected when designing the prosthetic
framework, a distinct space is necessary
Color between the coronal border of the gingiva and
Nature of Color: When we talk about the cervical margin of the framework to provide
color, we are making reference to a sensation adequate room for the application of specific
which is captured by our eyes. The human eye is shoulder porcelain.
an organ specialized in the reception of images
obtained from an electromagnetic radiation that The Umbrella Effect; A careful analysis of
we refer to as light, and which actually clinically relevant optical phenomena should
corresponds to a narrow segment of the entire always include the effect produced by the lips,
spectrum, situated between the 400 and 800 nm particularly the upper lip, because this feature will
wavelengths approximately, and which we significantly influence the interaction of light with
perceive as the so-called “colors of the rainbow”. the teeth and their supporting tissues. When the
Radiations below these wavelengths are lips are retracted, the apical extension of the
not visible to the human eye, and are referred to framework generally will not have a strong impact
as ultraviolet; those which are situated above on the optical behavior of the crown, because the
these wavelengths are not visible either, and are light can be directly distributed into the tissues.
referred to as infrared. When the upper lip is in its normal
There are generally three accepted position, however, the difference becomes
dimensions of color: significant, because direct penetration of light into
Hue, tonality: this indicates the feature which the surrounding periodontal tissues is prevented.
is normally referred to as color, directly related In contrast, an adequately reduced framework
to the wavelength of the observed luminous does not demonstrate the so-called umbrella
radiation observed (e.g. red, green, blue, effect.
yellow…).
Value, luminosity: this expresses the amount Esthetic Smile
of light that makes up the color under study, The smile is expressed by muscular
and would be like the black and white image action around the lips in the inferior third of the
of the observed object, corresponding to the face by a brightening of the eyes. The pleasing
tonalities of grey ranging from a maximum smile is one of our special forms of nonverbal
value, white, and a minimum value, black. communication, and it expresses joy.
Chroma, saturation: this refers to the amount
of dye that the color contains, the chromatic The elements that effect in an esthetic
brightness that we observe. This dimension smile are;
refers to the different dilutions of the base The upper lip position
color we are starting from. The upper lip curvature
The parallelism of the anterior incisal curve The property of light source to influence color of
with the lower lip objects is called “color rendition”. There are three
The relationship between the maxillary main illuminants within any dental practice:
anterior teeth natural, incandescent and fluorescent.
The number of teeth displayed in a smile Natural sunlight is itself variable with light
appearing blue at noon when the sun has fewer
The most attractive smiles have nearly atmospheres to penetrate and red/orange during
perfect harmony between the arcs of curvature of the morning and evening. Incandescent lighting
the incisal edges of the maxillary incisor and the is predominantly red/yellow and lacking in blue
upper border of the lower lip, and the upper lip while fluorescent lighting is high in blue tones
can be at the height of the gingival margin of the and low in red. There are special that are
maxillary central incisor. It was found that in an color corrected to emit light with a more uniform
attractive smile, the full shape of the maxillary distribution of color that can be utilized. Initial
anterior teeth was displayed between the upper shade selection should be initially made with be
and power lip. The upper lip curved upward or matched under different lights to avoid
was straight, the maxillary anterior incisal curve metamerism (the phenomenon that occurs when
was parallel to the lower lip, and the teeth were shades appear to match under one lighting
displayed to the first molar. condition and not another).
Premolars are of lighter shade than canine failure, and thus increase the quality of
For premolar select contra-lateral premolar restorations.
When maxillary anteriors are missing, shade
of the mandibular anteriors are considered
In case of a non-vital tooth, cover it and select
the shade of the adjacent tooth.
Photograph teeth and tabs using different
lighting conditions to minimize metamerism,
e.g. flash (5500K) and natural daylight
(6500K). Table 1. Commercially Available Digital Shade
Photograph teeth at 1:1 ratio for detailed Guides.
characterizations.
Send digitized images and shade map to As a summary reasons for esthetic
ceramist. failures can be summarized as following.
Failure to identify patient expectations
Stump shade selection regarding esthetics
With the increasing use of all-ceramic Improper shade selection
restorations, it is important to communicate the Failure to transfer the shade to dental
prepared tooth or “stump” shade to the ceramist laboratory
so that they can build the restoration with the
Excessive metal thickness at incisal and
right opacity/translucency. It may be necessary
cervical region
as in to use a more opaque ceramic to block out
Thick opaque layer application
discoloration, e.g. an alumina- or zirconia based
Surface blistering ("chalky" appearance)
restoration may be a better choice than a glass-
based ceramic like Empress. Over glazing or too much smooth surface
Although no single shade guide or Metal exposure in connector, cervical and
combination of guides includes all of the color incisal regions
combinations that may be encountered in clinical Dark space in cervical third due to improper
practice, a reasonably high level of clinical color pontic selection (Anteriors)
matching has been achieved, which attests to the Failure to produce incisal and proximal
artistic skills of many dentists in selecting the translucency
best available shade and determining what color Improper contouring
modifications are necessary to further enhance Failure to harmonize contra-lateral tooth
the color match. morphology
1. Contour
Instrumental Shade Selection 2. Color
Given the great subjectivity that 3. Position
predominates all during the color measurement 4. Angulations
process in the clinic, a series of electronic Discoloration of facing
instruments designed to facilitate and make more
objective the process of color measurement have The contemporary restorative dentist has
recently been appearing on the market. The a host of options with which to help his or her
practitioner thus needs only to use these devices patients are treated. Many of these options are
in order to be able to indicate the tooth’s color in considerably less invasive than many of our
a more precise, reliable and repeatable way. conventional restorative therapies. Many patients
Knowledge of the correct use of the present for esthetic restorative treatment, and are
conventional color measurement systems is becoming increasingly sophisticated in their
becoming more and more important if we wish to expectations of the final results. Additionally,
satisfy present day esthetic demands. manufacturers are bringing a myriad of new
This, together with the gradual entry and products to the market, often accompanied by a
perfection of the electronic color meter systems, blizzard of information purported to demonstrate
will serve to reduce the possibilities of aesthetic the benefits and efficacy of these new products.
Careful evaluation of patient’s expectations and 6. Cho GC, Donovan TE, Chee WWL. Rational use of contemporary
all-ceramic crown systems. J Calif Dent Assoc 1998: 26: 113–
needs and proper choice of materials and 120.
techniques along with sound knowledge and skill 7. Donovan TE. Contemporary ceramic restorations: a comparative
of the operator can decrease the failures in the evaluation. Alpha Omegan 1988: 81: 57–64.
8. Lehner C, Studer S, Brodbeck U, Scharer P. Short-term results of
esthetic outcomes in fixed partial dentures. IPS-Empress full-porcelain crowns. J Prosthodont 1997: 6: 20–
30.
9. Malament KA. Considerations in posterior glass-ceramic
Conclusions restorations. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 1988: 8: 32–49.
10. McLean JW. New dental ceramics and esthetics. J Esthet Dent
Today’s dental restoration is consolidated 1995: 7: 141–149.
11. Probster L. Four-year clinical study of glass-infiltrated, sintered
around three mainstays: the use of non- metallic alumina crowns. J Oral Rehabil 1996: 23: 147–151.
materials, such as composite resins and 12. Rinke S, Huls A. Copy-milled aluminous core ceramic crowns: a
clinical report. J Prosthet Dent 1996: 76: 343–346.
ceramics; adhesion to dental structures; and the 13. Sorensen JA, Choi C, Fanuscu MI, Mito WT. IPS Empress
achievement of a natural cosmetic look. The level Crown system: three-year clinical trial results. J Calif Dent
of esthetic requirement and demand by patients Assoc 1998: 26: 130–136.
14. Sozio RB, Riley EJ. The shrink-free ceramic crown. J Prosthet
in restorations has risen spectacularly in recent Dent 1983: 49: 182–187.
years, and this has made it necessary for dental 15. Wohlwend A, Scharer P. The Empress technique: a new
professionals to explore this field in order to technique for the fabrication of full ceramic crowns, inlays, and
veneers. Quintessence Int 1990: 16: 966–978.
satisfy the existing social demand in this area. 16. Wohlwend A, Strub JR, Scharer P. Metal-ceramic and all
The dental materials that are available porcelain restorations: current considerations. Int J Prosthodont
nowadays offer us the possibility of imitating the 1989: 2: 13–26.
17. Donovan TE, Adishian S, Prince J. The platinum bonded crown:
tooth’s natural esthetic look, so long as the right a simplified technique. J Prosthet Dent 1984: 51: 273–275.
one is chosen for a given situation. The first step 18. Kessler JC, Brooks TD, Keenan MP. The direct lift-off technique
for constructing porcelain margins. Quintessence Dent Technol
to achieving clinical success in esthetic dentistry 1986: 10: 145–150.
will therefore be to correctly identify the patient’s 19. Prince J, Donovan TE. The esthetic metal-ceramic margin: A
needs and to imitate tooth color with the material comparison of techniques. J Prosthet Dent 1983: 50: 185–192.
20. Prince J, Donovan TE, Presswood RG. The all-porcelain labial
that most closely matches, and to communicate margin for metal-ceramic restorations: a new concept. J
this information to the laboratory if the restoration Prosthet Dent 1983: 50: 793–806.
21. Toogood GD, Archibald JF. Technique for establishing
is to be carried out there. porcelain margins. J Prosthet Dent 1978: 40: 464–466.
Color measurement may seem to be a 22. Vryonis P. A simplified approach to the complete porcelain
minor element within the field of Restorative margin. J Prosthet Dent 1979: 42: 592–593.
23. Cho GC, Donovan TE, Chee WWL. Clinical experiences with
Dentistry, but its importance is essential, bonded porcelain laminate veneers. J Calif Dent Assoc 1998:
although not from the biological point of view. But 26: 121–127.
given the present day level of esthetic exigency, 24. Friedman MJ. The enamel-ceramic alternative: porcelain
veneers vs. metal-ceramic crowns. J Calif Dent Assoc 1992: 20:
a technically correct restoration can be a clinical 27–33.
failure if it fails to achieve the esthetic integration 25. Horn HR. Porcelain laminate veneers bonded to etched
the patient nowadays demands. enamel. Dent Clin North Am 1983: 27: 671–684.
26. Materdomini D, Friedman MJ. The contact lens effect
enhancing porcelain veneer esthetics. J Esthet Dent 1995: 7:
Declaration of Interest 99–103.
27. Lombardi Richard E: a method for classification of errors in
dental esthetics. J Prosthet dent. 1974; 32: 501-513.
The authors report no conflict of interest 28. Malament Kenneth A: Periodontics and Prosthodontics. Goals
and the article is not funded or supported by any and objectives and clinical reality. J Prosthet dent. 1992; 67:
259-263.
research grant. 29. Egger B. Der Status quo der Ästhetik. Quintessenz Zahntech
1997; 23:191–204.
30. Preston JD. Der gegenwärtige Entwicklungsstand der
References Farbbestimmung und Farbanpassung. Part I. Quintessenz
Zahntech 1985; 11:863–873.
1. Qualtrough AJ, Burke FJ, A look at dental esthetics, 31. Preston JD. Der gegenwärtige Entwicklungsstand der
Quintessence Int. 1994 Jan; 25(1):7-14. Farbbestimmung und Farbanpassung. Part II. Quintessenz
2. Jones DW. Development of dental ceramics. An historical Zahntech 1985; 11:957–965.
perspective. Dent Clin North Am 1985: 29: 621–644. 32. Clark BE. The color problem in dentistry. Dent Digest 1931:8.
3. Adair PJ, Grossman DG. The castable ceramic crown. Int J 33. Miller L. A scientific approach to shade matching. In: Preston
Periodontics Restorative Dent 1984: 4: 32–46. JD. Perspectives in Dental Ceramics. Proceedings of the Fourth
4. Andersson M, Oden A. A new all-ceramic crown, a dense International Symposium on Ceramics. Chicago: Quintessence,
sintered, high-purity alumina coping with porcelain. Acta Odontol 1988:193–208.
Scand 1993: 51: 59–64. 34. Miller L. Organizing color in dentistry. J Am Dent Assoc 1987;
5. Anusavice KJ. Recent developments in restorative dental 12(special issue):26E–40E.
ceramics. J Am Dent Assoc 1993: 124: 72–84. 35. Miller L. Shade matching. J Esthet Dent 1993; 5:143–153.