Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PM Meets Jaitley After He Opts Out of Cabinet: Indigooptsfor Pratt&Whitney Rival, Dealsoon
PM Meets Jaitley After He Opts Out of Cabinet: Indigooptsfor Pratt&Whitney Rival, Dealsoon
me/TheHindu_Zone_official
THURSDAY, 30 MAY 2019
34 pages in 2 sections www.business-standard.com
MUMBAI (CITY)
~8.00
VOLUME XXIII NUMBER 205
INDICES FALL ON
PROFIT BOOKING,
GLOBAL CUES
PM meets Jaitley after IndiGo opts for
Pratt&Whitney
he opts out of Cabinet
SENSEX Snapping their
39,800
39,502.1 39,700 three-day
P
(FY19)* (FY14)
Bond yields rally in May rime Minister Narendra Modi met
Arun Jaitley at the latter’s residence
on rate cut hopes on Wednesday evening, hours after CPI INFLATION (In%YoY)
Since the beginning of May, the 10-year
bond yields have fallen 28 basis points
the outgoing finance minister
requested that he should not be given any
2.9 8.3 ARINDAM MAJUMDER
New Delhi, 29 May POWERING
(FY19 end) (FY14 end)
(bps), as investors factor in sharp rate
cuts by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI)
responsibility for now and be allowed time off
due to his ill health.
THE FLIGHT
IndiGo, the largest customer of Airbus’ Marketshare of engine
FISCAL DEFICIT (As%ofGDP)
after the Bharatiya Janata Party’s Though there was no official announce- fuel-efficient A320neo family aircraft manufacturers for
resounding victory in the polls. Most of ment on the outcome of the meeting, which 3.4 4.4 with Pratt & Whitney (P&W) engines, is
A320neo familyaircraft
the movement in yields has come after lasted about 20 minutes, Modi is learnt to have (FY19) ** (FY14) learnt to have decided on rival CFM
the exit poll results, as foreign portfolio requested Jaitley to reconsider his decision. It International for LEAP1-A engines. The Market share (in %)
investors also increased their is not known if Jaitley agreed to stay on in the CURRENT ACCOUNT DEFICIT airline is looking at an order for 280 air- CFM International
investments in the Indian bonds. The government. However, the buzz in political (As%ofGDP) craft. IndiGo’s move to shift to CFM, a 39
10-year bond yields closed at 7.13 per
cent, 2 bps lower than its previous close.
circles is that Jaitley could hold the post of a
Cabinet minister without portfolio. If that hap-
2.6 1.7 50:50 joint venture between the US’ Unannounced
General Electric and French engine mak- 32
(First9months (FY14)
pens, the country will have a new finance min- ofFY19) er Safran, follows a series of issues, Pratt & Whitney
ister, and the names of Piyush Goyal and including the grounding of planes due to 29
ECONOMY & PUBLIC AFFAIRS P4 Nirmala Sitharaman are doing the rounds. FOREX RESERVES (In$billion) trouble with P&W engines. Note: Unannounced means the
India to battle it out with The new council of ministers will be sworn in
on Thursday. 411.9 304.2 IndiGo’s deal with CFM could be airline hasn’t yet opted for the
announced during the Paris Air Show to
type of engine
US, UK to tax digital firms Earlier in the day, Jaitley tweeted a letter he (FY19 end ) (FY14 end) Figures are as of Nov 2018
be held from June 17 to 23, sources in Source: FlightGlobal
India will press for widening the scope had written to Modi, ending days of fervent * Second advance estimates
the know said. The deal is valued at
of permanent establishment (PE) to tax speculation regarding his health. “I am writing ** Revised estimates $8.12 billion, according to the listed price.
digital enterprises such as Google, to you formally to request you that I should be Sources: MoSPI, RBI, Controller But airlines pay far less than what the listed price is.
Facebook, Microsoft, and Netflix at the allowed a reasonable time for myself, my treat- General of Accounts IndiGo’s decision to go for CFM is seen as a big blow for P&W’s
Organisation for Economic Co-operation ment and my health and therefore, not be a geared turbo fan engine programme, which is the only other option
and Development (OECD) Base Erosion part of any responsibility, for the present, in GOURMET TO TROUBLESHOOTER FM P6 besides CFM’s LEAP1-A for the A320neo family.
and Profit Shifting (BEPS) Inclusive the new government,” he said. Charles Soret, a CFM spokesperson, while refusing to respond to
Framework meeting next month. “During the last eighteen months, I have campaign, I would in future, like to keep away Jaitley has undergone a bariatric surgery, a queries on the deal citing client confidentiality, said the engine mak-
had some serious health challenges… After from any responsibility,” he wrote to the PM . kidney transplant and a surgery in the er was looking to strengthen its position in the Indian subcontinent
the campaign had concluded and you were Jaitley said while doctors had enabled him United States to remove soft tissue cancer in by winning customers for the LEAP engine. “As of today, 57 LEAP-
BACK PAGE P24 leaving for Kedarnath, I had orally informed to come out of most of his health concerns, he his left leg. Currently, he is said to be under- powered aircraft are operated by Indian airlines and several hun-
China ready to hit back you that even though I was able to discharge
the responsibilities assigned to me during the
would need time to recover.
Since becoming finance minister in 2014,
going chemotherapy. dreds of LEAP engines will be delivered in the coming years to
cover the needs of Indian market,” Soret said.
at US with rare earths Turn to Page 21 > Turn to Page 21 >
DEBASIS MOHAPATRA
Bengaluru, 29 May powersunderCGST
ON Engineering major Larsen & AASHISH ARYAN while granting anticipatory bail
SPECIALS
THURSDAY Toubro (L&T) is behind New Delhi, 29 May to a person accused of evading
schedule in the launch of its CGST, asked the government to
PRIVATE EQUITY:
open offer for the sharehold-
ers of information technology MAHARASHTRA’S PLAN The Supreme Court on file an FIR and only then pro-
Wednesday agreed to hear the ceed with the arrest.
TO BE DROUGHT-FREE
II, 2 > company Mindtree. government’s plea seeking clar- The HC had directed that
More hits It has already exceeded the ifications on powers the accused could
than misses in
Ratan Tata’s
start-up bets
timeline fixed
Securities and Exchange
under
110 ~121.10 CLOSE 116.55 115 ~116.55 CLOSE 83.80 80 ~404.40 CLOSE 83.80 80 ~83.80 CLOSE 1,865 ~2,052.60 CLOSE
May 2019 May May May 2019 May May May 2019 May May May 2019 May May May 2019 May May
* OVER PREVIOUS CLOSE 22 28 29 2.63% UP* 22 28 29 13.70% DOWN* 22 28 29 5.37% DOWN* 22 28 29 12.53% DOWN* 22 28 29 4.42% UP*
> .
IN BRIEF
Cognizant to offer higher salary Tower firms’ top line woes to REPORT CARD
Goenka: Passenger
to entry-level engineers
IT major Cognizant, which has close
to 200,000 employees in India, will
continue despite 4G switch vehicle sales will
outdoSiamforecast
offer over 18 per cent higher pay
packages to entry-level engineers
joining next year, according to in-
SOHINI DAS & ROMITA MAJUMDAR
Mumbai, 29 May
TOWER RENTALS CONTINUE TO DECLINE
dustry sources. Engineering stud-
T
ents graduating in June 2020 will see the offer made by the US- elcos’ focus on densification of 4G Rental per tower Growth rate SHALLY SETH MOHILE
based company increase from ~3.38 lakh per annum to ~4 lakh, network is unlikely to result in bet- 800 8 Mumbai, 29 May
they said. IT companies are slated to visit campuses around ter top line for tower companies, a 7
August-September this year to present offer letters for next year. recent CRISIL report has suggested. 665 652 Amid slowing sales and poor
Confirming the salary increase, a Cognizant spokesperson said As telcos stress on densification of 4G, 600 668 4 buying sentiment, Pawan
the company already offers higher packages for employees with the replacement of 2G and 3G base trans- 601 630 Goenka, managing director,
"premium" skills in digital technologies. “In line with that, we ceiver station (BTS) or signal transmit- 548 563 Mahindra & Mahindra (M&M),
have decided to increase the compensation of entry-level engi- ters with 4G will slow down the net BTS 400 -2 0 is hopeful that passenger vehi-
neering graduates, as digital technologies have become an inte- additions to about 155,000 in FY20 from
715 cle sales in India in the ongoing
gral part of engineering curricula in progressive institutions from 275,000 in FY19. financial year may do better
where we recruit talent,” the spokesperson said. PTI< The number of BTS per tower is, how- 200 -4 than what the auto industry
ever, expected to increase marginally to body has projected.
3.85 this fiscal compared with 3.67 in FY19 Goenka expects the newly M&M on Wednesday reported
0 -8
T-Series becomes Jaypee case: Lenders on increased loading by telcos to increase
their capacity per site. This will support FY13 FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17 FY18 FY19E FY20P
elected government to take
aggressive steps to boost con-
a 16 per cent decline in its net
profit for the fourth quarter
first channel to put 5 riders to NBCC existing coverage during high traffic and E: Estimated; P: Projected; (Rentals in ~ '000 crore) Source: CRISIL Research sumption and expedite refor- ended March 31 at ~969 crore
cross 100mn users for considering bid congestion, CRISIL said in a note shared ms after a strong mandate the
with Business Standard. rulingBJPhasgotintherecent- India advanced 3.27 per cent in
BhushanKumar-ledmusic LenderstoJaypeeInfratechhave Hetal Gandhi, research director, For instance, the recent merger of half of FY18, owing to tenancy losses. ly concluded Lok Sabha elec- 2018-19, the slowest in four
labelT-Serieshasbecomethe askedNBCCtosweetenitsbidto CRISIL, said this loading results in a dis- Vodafone and Idea resulted in over The Indus Towers-Bharti Infratel tions. “The industry will do bet- years. As a run-up to the imple-
firsteverYouTubechannelto acquirethedebt-ladenrealty count to telcos (which need to pay just 57,000 tenancy losses. Moreover, reduc- merger, expected to be completed by late ter than the Society of Indian mentation of the Bharat Stage
crossthe100-millionsubscriber firmandhavedemandedthat 10-15 per cent of rent). This reduces the tion of around 21,000 tenancies is 2019, is set to create the world’s second- Automobile Manufacturers’ (BS)-VI emission norms, the
mark.Indoingso,ithasalso thepublicsectorfirmshould potential for higher top line of tower firms. expected in the first half of FY20. While largest mobile tower operator, with over (Siam) forecast,” he said at the biggest unknown is the extent
pulledaheadofYouTuber offer1,426acresinsteadof950 Telecom operators are pushing con- exit penalties are expected to partially 163,000 towers and 36 per cent tower company’s annual press meet. to which pre-buying will take
PewDiePie'schannels,and acresbesidestakingonusof sumers to shift to 4G network as it allows offset the revenue loss, the impact of ten- market share in India. Post-merger, the Uncertainty ahead of the elec- place and inventory planning.
becomesolidifieditspositionas gettingapprovalsfromincome them to offer more data services which ancy losses is expected to spill over to industry will have three large players tions, liquidity issues, and a Meanwhile, like most the other
themostsubscribedchannelon taxanddevelopmentauthor- convert to higher revenue. FY20 as well. controlling over 70 per cent of the tower prediction of below-normal manufacturers such as Maruti
theplatform.Tilllastmonth, ities.Accordingtothedirectionof Going forward, loaded sites are “The telecom sector is moving market. monsoon, among other factors, Suzuki India and Tata Motors,
SwedishYouTubecelebrityFelix theNationalCompanyLawApp- expected to account for a higher propor- towards an oligopolistic structure, with Meanwhile, with telecom operators had prompted the industry M&M too will discontinue its
ArvidUlfKjellberg'schannel ellateTribunal,lendersare tion of incremental tenancies. In addi- three players accounting for more than divesting tower assets, the industry is body to forecast a moderate 1.2-litre turbo diesel engine
PewDiePieandT-Serieslocked negotiatingwiththeNBCConthe tion, rentals may come under pressure 90 per cent market share. This will pose expected to the shift to pure-play inde- 3-5 per cent growth for passen- with the transition to BS-VI.
hornstobecomethemost latter’sbidtoacquireJaypee during contract renewals as telcos have challenges for tower firms and put pres- pendent tower firms from the operator- ger vehicle sales in 2019-20. Small-capacity diesel engine
subscribedchannel.Thetwo Infratechandcompletestuck higher bargaining power, Gandhi felt. sure on rent revenue per tower as the led model. “The government will have ‘will be too expensive’ to meet
havebeenplayingmusicalcha- housingprojectscomprisingover This is because telcos’ return on cap- number of tenants per tower would go Telecom sector debt remains elevated to turn the curve on demand,” the new norms and expected
irsforthetopspot.TheSwedish 20,000units.TheIDBI-ledlend- ital employed (RoCE) is less than around down. Also, the stressed financial con- due to high network investments and said Goenka, pointing out that to disappear from the market,
YouTuberevenreleased‘diss ers’consortiumhaswrittento 2 per cent, compared with tower compa- dition of debt-ridden telecom incum- spectrum price. CRISIL Research esti- growth in India’s passenger said Goenka.
tracks’makingfunofand NBCCsayingitsbidwouldbe nies’ RoCE, which is as high as 19-20 per bents will restrain any material hike in mates the total debt to be ~4.3 trillion as vehicle market has been taper- M&M on Wednesday repo-
throwingshadeatT-Series,and considered“favourably”ifthe cent. After a decline of about 7 per cent in rentals, at least over the medium term. of March 2019. ing off over the past five years rted a 16-per cent decline in its
manybelievethattheact firmmeetsitsfiveconditions. PTI< fiscal 2019, CRISIL Research expects the In addition, though the towers added Thus, telcos are resorting to measures due to frequent pace of regula- net profit for the fourth quarter
instigatedBollywoodfansacross rent revenue per tower to remain under by Bharat Sanchar Nigam and Reliance such as selling standalone towers or tory changes. ended March 31 at ~969 crore.
theglobetorallyinsupportofT- pressure and decline by another 2-3 per Jio account for a considerable share of reducing stake in existing tower sub- Rajan Wadhera, president, Revenue for the period rose 4.7
Series'channel. BS REPORTER< Cholamandalam cent in FY20. captive towers, the revenue from this sidiaries, to pare debt. For instance, Siam, and president-automo- per cent to ~13,808 crore over a
Investment raises Tower companies are already hit by does not flow to the industry,” Gandhi Vodafone and Idea, last year, sold 20,000 tive sector at M&M, said the year ago. On the back of weak
tenancy losses. Consolidation in the tele- added. standalone towers to American Tower industry lobby has made a rep- tractor volumes, margins dec-
FASTags can now be $222 million com industry has changed the dynamics A look at tower rentals in the past 12 Company (ATC) for around ~7,800 crore. resentation to the government lined to 13.5 per cent, from 15.1
purchased online InternationalFinanceCorpora- of tower firms. The latter reported mas- quarters indicate a stabilising trend till Also, Bharti Airtel had raised over ~12,000 to cut the goods and services a year ago. The company has
tion(IFC)hasanchoredadebt sive tenancy losses over the past one and the first half of FY18 and then a drop for crore through multiple rounds of stake tax rate on passenger vehicles recommended a dividend of
through Amazon investmentroundof$222mill- half years. the first time in five years in the second sale in Bharti Infratel. to 18 per cent, from the current ~8.5 (170 per cent) per ordinary
FASTagsarenowavailableone- ion(~1,550crore)intoChola- 28 per cent. (equity) share of the face value
commerceplatformAmazonto mandalamInvestmentand Passenger vehicle sales in of ~5 each.
furtherpromotedigitalpayment FinanceCompany.Themoney
oftollforseamlesstraffic,the
governmentsaidonWednes-
day.FASTagisareloadabletag,
willhelpMurugappaGroup’s
non-bankfinancingentityto
expandcreditaccessformicro
India Tourism may start working Cadila Healthcare net down 22%
.
MUMBAI | THURSDAY, 30 MAY 2019 COMPANIES 3 <
T
he Permanent Court of the source agreed to have the we would look to systematically has come down from ~4,300 Lodha’s Palava project. has assets that it could sell to
Arbitration in Singapore arbitration in Singapore, filed a bring down our single borrower crore as of September-end 2018 Lodha has been facing improve its liquidity position,
has rejected India’s argu- plea in 2017 saying the arbitra- exposure to Lodha Developers. to ~3,800 crore in December rough weather in recent uncertainty remains around the
ment that the court does not tion court in Singapore does not In line with that focus, ~1,000 2018, Khushru Jijina, managing months. Two rating firms — company’s ability to execute
have the jurisdiction to rule on have the authority to rule on the crorewillbereducedwithinthis director, Piramal Capital & Moody’s and Fitch — have these asset sales in a timely
a case brought against India by case for many reasons, includ- quarter itself,” a Piramal Housing Finance, said in a downgraded their outlook on manner and at values that
Japan’s Nissan Motor, accord- ing that it was a tax-related mat- spokespersonsaid.“Inaddition, recent conference call. Lodha Developers back to back would be sufficient to address
ing to two people and docu- ter outside the purview of the we have also received prepay- Piramal had a loan book of in the recent weeks. the liquidity needs.
ments reviewed by Reuters. CEPA with Japan.
If India had won the plea, The international tribu-
the entire case would have been
thrown out, said one of the peo-
THE STORY SO FAR nal, in a 140-page order dated
April 29, denied India’s objec-
ple who has direct knowledge | Nissan has sent legal | India argued that court tions, saying it has the
of the matter, adding that the notice to the Indian does not have jurisdiction authority to rule on the mat-
Indian government is now like- govt in 2016 | If India would have ter and would hold the final
ly to file an appeal with | It claimed $720 mn in won, the case would be hearing in February 2020
Singapore’s Supreme Court. after submission of evidence
unpaid dues, damages thrown out
Nissan sent a legal notice to and arguments from both
India in 2016 claiming more sides. The order has not pre-
than ~5,000 crore ($720 million) set up a car manufacturing for alleged violation of a viously been reported.
in a dispute over incentives it plant in the southern state. Comprehensive Economic Nissan said it “continues to
said were due from Tamil Nadu The Japanese car maker Partnership Agreement (CEPA) work with the government to
as part of a 2008 agreement to brought the case against India the country has with Japan. The resolve this matter”. REUTERS
“It is certain that they (Congress, JDS) will go home “Post-election ground analysis revealed “I did not start the controversy... I had said
fighting each other. We are 105 (MLAs), we are two big reasons. First, the atmosphere in that eloquence of silence is difficult but far
ready to wait. Let them work efficiently or resign the country rubbed off on Delhi as well. more desirable to see the elections through
and go. By creating an atmosphere of confusion Second, people saw this poll as a Modi instead of creating ill-timed controversies.
and loot, they cannot be forgiven“ and Rahul fight, and voted accordingly” This is what I had said and I stand by that”
B S YEDDYURAPPA, Leader of Opposition, Karnataka Legislative Assembly ARVIND KEJRIWAL, Delhi chief minister SUNIL ARORA, Chief Election Commissioner
>
I
ndia will press for widen-
on banks for failing to meet ing the scope of perma- Since the beginning of May,
-2,601.1 20,000
lending targets of farm loans, nent establishment to tax 10-year bond yields have fall-
especially crop loans, in the however, 23 per cent higher digital enterprises such as en 28 basis points, as investors 1,040.0
state that is reeling from agri- than that in FY18. At present, Google, Facebook, Microsoft, factor in sharp rate cuts by the
culture distress. there is no legal arrangement and Netflix at the Organisation Reserve Bank of India (RBI) 10,000
He rubbished claims by for levying fine on lenders for for Economic Co-operation after the ruling BJP’s resound-
banks that they could not failing to meet loan targets. and Development (OECD) ing victory at the polls.
meet crop-loan targets due to SLBC Maharashtra’s convener Base Erosion and Profit Most of the movement in 0
draught conditions. “There bank, Bank of Maharashtra, Shifting (BEPS) Inclusive yields have come after the exit
are widespread complaints will be writing to bank chiefs Framework meeting in June. poll results, as foreign portfolio
from farmers about problems on the thrust on meeting FY20 With G24 backing, it will investors also increased their -10,000
in getting money (loans),” lending targets. “There has to fight it out with the US and the investments in Indian bonds. Jan ‘19 May ‘19
Fadnavis said while address- be accountability for perfor- UK to push through its ‘signif- The 10-year bond yields closed Till May 27, 2019
ing State Level Bankers’ Com- mance (targets) in banks with icant economic presence’ pro- at 7.13 per cent, two basis
mittee (SLBC), Maharashtra. respect to the farm sector. The posal at the OECD, as 128 points lower than the previous INDIA 10-YEAR
The crop-loan target for state government is paying counties sit together to put in close, but considering that the
FY19 was ~58,324 crore for banks amounts that have place a multilateral instru- yields were at 7.41 per cent at G-SEC YIELD (%)
Maharashtra, but actual dis- been waived off. Decisions ment to bring these compa- the end of April, the move-
bursements were at ~31,231 taken at top levels do not seem nies into the tax net. ment is pretty sharp. 7.80
crore. So the lenders met 54 to be percolating to people In its representation, India package. The OECD report on Therefore, India’s proposal tors for determining corporate The bond market expects 7.37
per cent of crop-loan target in working at bank branch lev- has pitched for ‘significant the subject will be finalised in of the significant economic profits attributable in a tax at least 25 basis points cut in 7.60
FY19. The disbursement was, els,” Fadnavis said. economic presence’ principle, 2020. India has the backing of presence will establish the jurisdiction. According to the the June 6 policy, but it is
arguing that permanent estab- 28 countries of G24. nexus between remote and US’ ‘marketing intangibles’ divided on if the stance would
lishment should not only At present, when a non-res- digital engagement of non-res- principle proposal, the current be changed to accommoda- 7.40
require a fixed place of busi- ident business supplies goods ident businesses with Indian tax allocation rules would tive. While most economists
IN BRIEF ness and that the definition of and services, its profits may be consumers, providing a basis change, so that the market expect a cut, some are advo- 7.20
‘nexus’ needs to be changed, taxed attributable to the oper- for taxation of the income. jurisdiction (where users are cating a pause in the policy. 7.13
India moves to 43rd US rules out sanction to give more taxing rights to ations in that country, based In the Budget last year, the located) would be entitled to “The bond market has 7.00
in competitiveness; exemptions from market-driven economies, or
developing nations. The US,
on its ‘fixed place of
business’ or perma- India has pitched
government pro-
posed that the
tax some or all of the ‘non-rou-
tine’ income properly associ-
baked in a rate cut of 25 basis
points, if the stance also
Dec ‘18 May ‘19
Sources: Sebi (NSDL), Bloomberg
Singapore tops chart Iranian oil import meanwhile, is pressing for tax- nent establishment, for ‘significant number of Indian ated with such intangibles, changes with that, there will compiled by BS Research Bureau
ing digital economy through according to the tax economic presence’, users and a revenue while ‘routine’ income would be a movement of another five
India has moved up one place to The US has ruled out giving any the ‘marketing intangibles’ treaty. The defini- arguing that threshold should be continue to be allocated, based basis points. If there is no rate fear that the growth prospects
rank 43rd most competitive exemption from its punitive principle and the UK through tion of permanent permanent used to tax the busi- on existing transfer pricing cut though, there will be a of the world’s largest economy
economy in the world on the sanctions to countries, a ‘user-base’ principle. establishment is establishment ness profits of non- principles. Marketing intangi- chaos,” said Harihar may not be as robust as was
back of its robust economic including India, for buying oil “We are seeking changes in primarily based on should not only resident digital bles include brand, trade Krishnamurthy, head of trea- expected before. US-China
growth, while Singapore has from Iran, saying America's the digital economy taxation a fixed place of busi- require a fixed companies derived name, customer data, cus- sury at First Rand Bank. trade tensions are dragging
toppled the US to grab the top maximum pressure campaign rules. The definition of nexus ness, and also place of business from Indian con- tomer relationships, and cus- Devendra Dash, head of global growth, which is reflect-
position, a global study showed. was working and the Trump needs to be changed from hav- includes service or sumers. However, it tomer lists. risk at AU Small Finance ed in the softer oil prices.
Singapore has moved up to the administration remains ing a fixed place of business to construction activi- will require amend- However, India feels that Bank, said if the yields climb Despite Iran sanctions, oil
top, from the third position last “unwavering” in its tough having a significant economic ties carried out beyond specif- ment of each double taxation the US’ proposal may not be up on no rate cut, it will soon prices are trading at $68 a bar-
year, while the US has slipped to policy on Tehran. PTI< presence. This should give us ic duration, existence of a avoidance agreement partner, feasible, as it will be very diffi- start falling as the market is rel, from $74 earlier this year.
the third place in the 2019 more taxing rights. The US’ dependent agent, and collec- making it challenging. Hence, cult to compute income, con- pretty convinced that sooner At the same time, a significant
edition of the IMD World
Competitiveness Rankings. PTI<
Modi united India proposal of marketing intan-
gibles is too complicated to
tion of insurance premiums. a multilateral instrument will
However, such a business be a better option.
sidering the volume of data
required for the purpose.
or later there will be rate cuts.
Bonds from big corporates
section in the market is
expecting the gross domestic
like no PM in work for developing countries, connection with the local New Delhi has said that “Most developing countries are also showing some signs product (GDP) numbers for
FinMin may look at decades: TIME article while the UK’s user-base prin- economy, in terms of a fixed there is a need to rework the don’t have that capacity to dis- of easing, at least in the short- the last quarter to come at
ciple is too basic. We need a place of business, does not international tax framework tinguish routine and non-rou- er tenure. The corporate below 6 per cent. That may
10-yr tax holiday on Weeks after TIME magazine broader proposal,” said a gov- exist in the case of remotely or regarding nexus and profit tine profit or identify and put bonds had remained elevated drag the annual GDP growth
builders’ rental profits featured Narendra Modi on the ernment official. digitally delivered goods and allocation rules. These should a value to intangibles of an even when government bond rate to just about 7 per cent, or
cover of its international The Inclusive Framework services. India has argued that take into account value creat- enterprise,” said another offi- yields were falling. After the even below that. The RBI in
The finance ministry may look at edition with a controversial brings together over 125 coun- today a non-resident can par- ed within the supply chain, cial. He added that UK’s user- election results, though, some that case will have to chip in
a 10-year tax holiday for headline, it has now run an tries and jurisdictions to col- ticipate in the economic affairs representing the contribution based principle only talks of the corporate bond yields with rate cuts, said bond deal-
developers on profits earned article that says no PM has laborate on the impl- of a jurisdiction without being of supply side, along with con- about one part of the digital have fallen 15-20 basis points, ers. The landslide victory of
from rental housing as it looks to united India in decades the ementation of the BEPS physically present there. tribution of demand-side fac- economy, making it restrictive. following the fall in rates by the NDA government has att-
revive investment and boost a way he has done. The article government bonds. As yields racted foreign investors, look-
slowing economy, sources said. titled Modi Has United India fall, prices of bonds rise. ing for an avenue to invest. In
In a recent meeting with senior Like No Prime Minister in State Bank of India’s chief May so far, FPIs have bought
finance ministry officials, realtors
have been asked to suggest steps
to address challenges faced by
Decades is written by Manoj
Ladwa, founder of the India Inc
Group, a London-based media
NCLAT prods IL&FS amber firms to pay economic advisor Soumy-
akanti Ghosh expects the six-
member monetary policy
~1,040 crore in Indian debt.
Krishnamurthy, the sys-
tem liquidity deficit being at
the sector. PTI< organisation. PTI< AASHISH ARYAN companies to service the debt debts in accordance with the and red, based on their finan- committee to cut rates by 50 ~25,000 crore, from nearly
New Delhi, 29 May on a “proportionate basis”, the February 11 order of the appel- cial health and ability to ser- basis points in the June policy, ~60,000-70,000 crore a month
Modi to host West Coast Paper Mills The National Company Law
two-judge Bench said. The oth- late tribunal, in which it had
er firm of the allowed firms un-
vice debt obligations to secu-
red and unsecured creditors.
but Goldman Sachs’ Prachi
Mishra and Andrew Tilton
ago, and the RBI’s indication
to provide enough liquidity in
China’s Xi for to buy International Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) IL&FS, which der the green cat- The appellate tribunal also sees rates to remain stable in the system through open mar-
informal summit Paper APPM said on Wednesday if the may be classified Other IL&FS egory to start asked the government to pro- June as the RBI waits for past ket operations has buoyed the
Infrastructure Leasing & Fina- green in the firms, which are servicing debt vide an updated report on the rate cuts to be passed by banks bond market sentiment.
West Coast Paper Mills has ncial Services (IL&FS) compa- future can service re-classified under within the reso- classification process of all to the customers first. “The government is
Prime Minister Narendra Modi entered into a pact to buy 51-60 nies placed under the amber their debt obliga- the green category, lution framewo- IL&FS group companies. So Whatever be the expecta- expected to front-load its
will host Chinese President Xi per cent in International Paper category could not be reclas- tion automatical- can automatically rk under the far, 55 companies have been tions, there are solid reasons spending, and that would cre-
Jinping this year for an informal APPM, a subsidiary of US-based sified into the green category ly. The new board start servicing supervision of placed under the green cate- why the bond yields are falling ate additional liquidity, which
summit, an Indian foreign min- International Paper, for ~275 a by the next date of hearing on of directors of their debts retired Supreme gory and 13 have been placed in India. Globally, yields have is positive for bonds,” said
istry spokesman said, after me- share, which works out to July 12, the appellate tribunal IL&FS can permit Court Judge under the amber category. softened, led by an inversion Krishnamurthy.
eting several times over the past ~557.8-656.2 crore. It will also will pass orders asking such such firms to ser- Justice D K Jain, A total of 82 companies in US yield curve. The US 10- However, it is highly
year to try to defuse tension. The make an open offer to companies to service 100 per vice their obligations to lenders, the NCLAT said on Wednesday. have been placed under the year yields have fallen below unlikely that the 10-year
two held their first informal su- International Paper APPM's cent debt obligations of the a two-member Bench led by The new board at IL&FS red category, while 11 are yet the three-month yield and yields can fall below 7 per
mmit in Wuhan in April 2018 and non-promoter shareholders, provident and pension funds. Chairperson Justice S J had classified IL&FS group to be classified, the counsel overall, the yields have cent, considering the heavy
then Xi had accepted Modi's who have a 25 per cent stake in For other lenders, the Mukhopadhaya said. companies into three cate- appearing for the new board fallen 5-6 basis points across supply of government bonds,
invitation to come to India. PTI< the firm. BS REPORTER< NCLAT may ask the amber Such firms will service their gories, namely green, amber, of IL&FS said. the curve. This gives rise to the according to bond dealers.
T
he Reserve Bank of in ceremony of the council of minis- June 1946 amid the raging riots of the merce and become a chartered police, he opted for arrest in 1974 and
India (RBI) on Wednes- ters, nothing could be bigger than this. Partition, they decided to stay on in accountant instead: that was a profes- was locked up for 19 months.
day constituted a task As Finance Minister (2014-19), his India and moved to Delhi in a house sion much in demand those days. During his stint in jail, Jaitley devel-
force on the development of contribution was political much more abandoned by a Muslim family and That is why Jaitley joined SRCC, oped a taste for good food. “One of my
secondary market for corpo- than economic. After a two-term declared evacuee property. considered a top of the senior colleagues described me as both
rate loans. In India, banks sell tenure of the United Progressive His family are Brahmins line business school. a gourmet and a glutton,” he had told
their stressed loans to the asset Alliance (UPA) when L K Advani from Punjab. As elsewhere He could hardly have Business Standard. During the 19
reconstruction firms, but has seemed loath to leave the spotlight and in India, in Punjab too, the Jaitley has known how useful the months in jail, he got a first class in his
practically no other alterna- the BJP seemed to be staring at a polit- caste had little land but nurtured skill of reading a bal- second year of law and decided to make
tive. However, globally, there ical dead end, Jaitley was one of those placed a tremendous pre- professional ance sheet would be in law his career.
is a healthy corporate loan who pushed and propelled Narendra mium on education. talent, the future. Between 1977 and 1979, he came
market where banks can off- Modi centre-stage, edging out his for- Opportunities did not exist protected it and By this time, Jaitley close to many stalwarts of the JP move-
load their stressed assets and mer mentor. Little wonder then, that for exalted university edu- pushed it to its had already become an ment. He was also put on the Janata
those get traded. Credit Def- RBI breather for NBFCs not only was he given the most impor- cation. But school teaching, full growth
potential
activist of the Akhil Party’s national executive. In 1980 elec-
ault Swaps against these loans The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) on Wednesday extended the tant portfolio in the Modi government law and science were con- Bharatiya Vidyarthi tions, the Janata Party was defeated
also get developed as a result. relaxation given to the NBFCs on minimum holding period — finance — but his protégés, Piyush sidered respected streams. Parishad (ABVP), the resoundingly. By then, Jaitley had
“A vibrant, deep and liquid of their secutised assets, for loans above 5 years, till Goyal, Nirmala Sitharaman, Prakash Jaitley’s seven uncles were youth wing of the already bid temporary adieu to politics
secondary market for debt December. The relaxation was first offered at the end of Javdekar, Ravishankar Prasad and educated by his grandmother at a time Bharatiya Jana Sangh. He had contest- and decided to concentrate on his legal
would go a long way in November last year for six months. BS REPORTER many others, also got important posi- it was both expensive and hard to edu- ed the local college union elections and career and left the ABVP.
increasing the efficiencies of tions. cate. So the extended family grew up ABVP was trying to persuade him to Jail taught him something: a
the debt market in general and His friends and followers in govern- to value good grades, but more than contest the Delhi University Students’ strong bias in favour of strengthening
would aid in resolution of
stressed assets in particular. A
well-developed secondary
RBI panel for mortgage ment reflect a conviction he has held
all his life: the talent available in politics
is inversely proportional to the power
that, contributed to educate each oth- Union (DUSU) election.
er. All the brothers helped to fund the In 1974-75, this counted as an act of
education of one of them who trained subversion. Indira Gandhi was the
existing institutions, reform and rec-
tification rather than abolition. But
most of all, Jaitley has stuck to one
market for debt would also aid
in transparent price discovery
securitisation market politicians wield. Because parties are
— mostly — deficient in internal
as a psychiatrist in the UK, studying in Prime Minister, but around her, all she
England to become an FRCS. But most- saw was people threatening her author-
principle throughout his life: never,
ever, to be a political activist who lives
of the inherent riskiness of the democracy, people coming into politics ly, they studied and practised law. ity and trying to undermine it. A well without the means or the income
debt being traded,” the RBI SUBRATA PANDA of originators and investors. are subject to no quality control. Jaitley studied in a missionary to live well.
said in a statement. Mumbai, 29 May The RBI has asked the They form political parties that school — St Xavier’s — and while in “There are people who change par-
In April policy, the RBI had committee to also suggest have no quality control systems. These school, although he opted for the sci- ties to save the roof over their heads.
suggested composition of To develop the housing measures for facilitating sec- parties became one-person operations ence stream believing ultimately that The political system does not pay you
such a committee. The terms finance securitisation market ondary market trading in at best; and caste-driven set ups at engineering was what he wanted to enough to live properly. Salaries are
of the committee, which in India, the Reserve Bank of mortgage securitisation instr- worst. Caste provides legitimacy to study, he joined the Bachelor of not enough to maintain the standard
should submit its report by the India (RBI) on Wednesday uments, such as broadening anti-social behaviour through bogus Commerce programme at Sri Ram of living you get used to. Most politi-
end of August, would be to formed a committee to review investor base, and strengthen- kinship appeals. Naturally, gover- College of Commerce (SRCC) under cians have learnt the art of living well
suggest required policies for the existing state of mortgage ing market infrastructure. nance-related issues get a short shrift. Delhi University. without working. I haven’t,” he said,
facilitating development of securitisation and suggest Moreover, it has been Caste is a peculiar problem in India This was the India of the Nehru- “and I never will”.
secondary market in corporate ways to develop the market tasked to analyse the inter- and it provides an additional twist in Indira era, of big dams, abolition of Law and politics taught him a lot.
loans, including loan transac- further under the chairman- linkages between securitisa- the tale. Criminals in politics are privy purse and bank nationalisation. But when Vajpayee became Prime
tion platform for stressed ship of Harsh Vardhan, senior tion and other related defended through caste appeals. It was also the time of extended famine Minister, his appointment as minis-
assets, creation of a loan con- advisor, Bain & Co. financial market instruments Jaitley has never been against affirma- in East Pakistan (later Bangladesh) ter for information and broadcasting
tract registry, its ownership The committee has been and suggest policy interven- tive action-type of politics, only its fall- rationing in India (remember the con- (for a short period), disinvestment
structure and related protocols asked to submit its report by tions to leverage these inter- out — the rise of caste-based parties, troversy over whether Sanjay and and law prepared him for the
such as standardisation of the end of August 2019. linkages. which seem to have no superstructure Menaka Gandhi’s wedding was consis- Finance Ministry in 2014. Most peo-
loan information, independ- The newly appointed com- The mandate of the com- of governance or ethics driving it. “I tent with the Guest Control Order?). ple forget that he was the only per-
ent validation and data access. mittee has been mandated to mittee also requires them to am totally opposed to non-ideological But poverty and hunger per- son whom Modi appointed a
The task force would examine the existing structure evaluate the role of various politics,” he told Business Standard in sisted in India. Locked minister despite losing
design the market structure for mortgage-backed securiti- counterparties, including the an interview a few years ago. as the country was in the Lok Sabha election
for loan sales/auctions, includ- sation transactions in India, servicers, trustees, rating Because of this conviction, Jaitley the non-aligned- in a Modi wave.
ing online platforms and the including legal, tax, valuation agencies in the securitisation has nurtured professional talent, pro- but-sympathetic- What Pranab
related trading and transac- and accounting-related issues. process, and suggest meas- tected it and pushed it to its full growth to-the-Soviet Mukherjee was to
tion reporting infrastructure. It has also been asked to sug- ures required, if any, to potential. Union syn- UPA, Jaitley has
gest necessary modifications address the key structural, This is because he has seen his own drome, entre- been to NDA.
More on business-standard.com to address the requirements fiduciary and servicer risks. growth being nurtured by his seniors preneurs
A
powerful business tycoon being a deconstruction of the event throws up flight raised an alarm that Goyal and his did not stop him when he was leaving industrialists, who are under the scan-
deplaned and stopped from fly- is that there was no lookout circular for wife, with unpaid dues of more than the country and that he had no clue ner. In that backdrop, the lookout circu- that actor and fellow MP Hema Malini
ing out of the country could any the Goyals but it may have been in the ~8,500 crore, were leaving the country. there was a lookout circular against lar against the Goyals is just a beginning, was also present at the meeting.
day be a scene from a racy thriller. But making. That’s why the immigration, Functionaries in the SFIO, under the him. In that case too, the immigration despite the mystery of the immigration Without wasting time, he clicked a
the dramatic sequence of events leading which had no evidence of a lookout cir- Ministry of Corporate Affairs, later clarified probably didn’t catch the name right giving them an all clear. selfie with the actor in the background.
The selfie went viral in no time. When
he returned to Indore and local leaders
asked him about the picture, an
I
n January 2004, Australia commis- Studies conducted by the World Bank, seats in Tamil
sioned what is regarded as one of which is funding the Eastern DFC with Nadu in the just
the most difficult railway lines to be a loan of $2.360 billion, and Japan concluded Lok
ever built in the world — across the International Cooperation Agency, Sabha election.
inhospitable terrain from Alice Spring which offering ~38,722 crore for the But the party is
in the north to the deepwater port of Western DFC, traffic flow is set to reach hopeful of getting
Darwin in the south. Around the same 264 MT for eastern corridor and 284 MT a plum post in the
time, the Railway Board in India, head- for the western corridor in 20 years. to-be-formed
ed by Chairman R K Singh, was working
on pulling off a similar feat with a ded-
The corridor is a massive logistical
exercise for the Railways. So far, the
FREIGHT National Democratic Alliance (NDA)
government at the centre, said minister
icated track for freight to speed up traf-
fic flow.
Dedicated Freight Corridor Corporation
of India (DFCCIL) — a special purpose
MOVEMENT Kadambur Raju. OP Raveendranath
(pictured), son of state Deputy Chief
The project was shelved after initial vehicle for the project incorporated in Total Distance: Minister and AIADMK coordinator O
deliberations citing cost effectiveness, 2006 — has awarded all contracts for
Maximum speed: Panneerselvam, is the only winner from
Land acquired:
but was given a fresh lease of life in
2006. But since it received the final go-
construction to begin, except for sys-
tem contracts for Khurja-Dadri and
3,560 km 100 Kmph 98.5 % the party and he is known to share a
warm relationship with the Bharatiya
ahead, the Dedicated Freight Khurja-Ludhiana sections of Janata Party leadership at the centre. All
Corridor (DFC) has been the eastern corridor. eyes, therefore, are on the 39-year-old.
stumbling over hurdles — Land acquisition was ini- Eastern Dedicated Freight Western Dedicated
from land acquisition issues tially a big hurdle but by
INVESTMENT
Corridor: Freight Corridor:
to cost escalation and delay
in implementation.
February this year, nearly
98.5 per cent of the land has LUDHIANA TO DANKUNI JAWAHARLAL NEHRU TOTAL ~ 81,459 CRORE Physical Coming soon: Chambers’ PC
Nearly a decade and a half been acquired — except for 1,856 Kms Of this, 538 PORT TERMINAL (JNPT)
Expenditure incurred so far: progress:
43,000 crore 55 %
later, however, DFC may the Sonnagar to Dankuni Kms from Sonnagar to TO DADRI
finally see the light of day section, which is in the pro-
Dankuni are under PPP 1,504 Kms Over ~
with the Narendra Modi gov- cess of being acquired,
ernment planning to com- according to a senior DFC-
plete it by December 2021, CIL official.
ahead of India’s 75th But the construction 2015 pegged it at ~81,459 crore — fac- on time. “Though started work in 2007, All these projects are important to
Independence day in 2022. work is only half way through and toring in price escalation and interest the DFCs were initially expected to be increase the Railways' freight and pas-
According to multiple sources close meeting the target is a race against during construction. on track by 2011. However, due to senger traffic as well to help it compete
to the development, completion of time. On August 15 last year, the “DFC was initially conceptualised speeding up of work in last three years, efficiently with other means of trans-
Eastern and Western Dedicated Freight Railways had conducted its first suc- with a lower axle load, which was later we will be able to deliver it by December port. The DFC, for instance, will not just
corridors by 2021 will be one of the key cessful trial run of the western corridor increased to a heavier 32.5 tonnes sub- 2021,” said another official. increase the freight volume, but also
priorities of the Modi government dur- covering a 190-km stretch from Ateli structure axle load and superstructure What's of concern though is that land increase the average pace of freight traf-
ing its second tenure. “The western and to Phulera. This was followed by two with axle load of 25 tonnes, that natu- acquisition woes and project delays are fic in the country. According to the Not many remember that the various
eastern dedicated freight corridors, more trials between Badan and Khurja rally increased the cost of the project. not rare for the Railways. According to Railways, the average speed in DFC will business chambers did not hold the
covering 3,360 km of track across nine (194 km of the eastern corridor in In addition to this, cost of land, available data, at least 505 projects — be around 75 kmph, compared to the traditional press conferences (PCs) by
states, are vital to increase the total traf- November) and Madar and change of scope of the project and including 263 doubling of lines, 185 new existing 25 kmph. One advantage for their incoming presidents this year. The
fic of the Railways by at least 144 mil- Kishangarh Balawas (306 km on the some other technical requirements lines and 57 gauge conversion — are consumers will be the cost effective- appointments were over by April but
lion tonne (mt) by 2022,” said an official eastern corridor). also added to the cost,” said R under various stages of execution. Of ness, as it is expected to cut the unit the PCs had been postponed to ensure
close to developments. The delay has of course not been Sivadasan, former finance commis- this, several projects are facing a cost cost of transport by at least 40 per cent. they are heard by the new government.
In a strategic vision document pre- without consequences for the Railways. sioner with the railways. overrun — owing to issues like acquisi- DFCCIL also expects savings of 457 MT Wait for the announcements about
pared in March, the Railways’ has set a Though the initial cost of the project After the renewed focus, the tion of land, shifting of utilities and of CO2 emission over a period of 30 those PCs soon.
target to increase its share in the coun- was ~28,181 crore, a revised estimate in Railways seem confident of finishing it delay in various statutory clearances. years, once the project is on track.
M
any Indian startups, their capabilities — recall how “other things changing”. He has made a marginal cost of funds based lending rate,
designed on Silicon Valley Napoleon invaded Russia foolishly in static assumption rather than a dynamic has not facilitated the desired level of
principles, appear to be aim- 1812 when he famously said that product experience emerges with fawning reviews, so did the pink press. assumption. What will change is that the transmission so far. Besides the reasons
ing to destroy the enemy and to grab Impossible is a word found only in a effectiveness. A technique known as Patanjali has lost its way amidst its own rich will become richer at a much faster narrated by the writer that are posing hur-
the prize of winner takes all. In the pro- fool's dictionary. Such an arrogant and TRIZ is used by experts. competitor obsession. rate than the poor. Thomas Piketty, in his dles in effective transmission of monetary
cess, they are drowning in a dangerous self-preening leader would be least An institution that is competitor- It is not only companies, but other famous book, Capital in the Twenty-First policy, one major risk that banks face is
ocean of swirling losses. I cannot aware of the effect of power on his or focused to a fault comes through as institutions as well that should avoid Century, has proved this thesis. The most the “mismatch risk” — between its assets
understand why so many Indian uni- her behaviour. self-preening and over-confident, competitor-obsession. Among politi- quoted Piketty theory is, "... that no one, and liabilities. The writer is correct in say-
corns are eulogised for business savvy As argued in some writings (Mark especially when a firm has enjoyed a cal parties, history suggests that if to my knowledge, has questioned: that 60 ing there is a need to address the inherent
and growth even though they incur Bonchek and Gene Corfield, Harvard winning spree. During the onslaught communications to the voter ooze per cent of the increase in US national compulsions that stop banks from passing
every year a loss of three to four times Business Review, April 28, 2016), cus- of Nirma on Hindustan Unilever’s with self-praise and obsessive derision income in the 30 years after 1977 went to on rate cut benefits to borrowers.
their revenue. tomers are individuals, who are sort of detergent business from 1970s to mid- of the competition, unexpected just the top 1 per cent of earners. The only Saagar Soni Gandhinagar
Commenting on Silicon Valley, The tiny enterprises. Individually, con- 1980s, there were many internal dis- results can emerge. As examples, section of the US population that has
Letters can be mailed, faxed or e-mailed to:
Economist (April 20, 2019) reported sumers are changing faster than the cussions about the unfair tactics of the recall the self-preening behaviour of done better than the top 1 per cent is the The Editor, Business Standard
that 12 or so American unicorns that company; their needs are quite liquid, competitor. When the company waded the then ruling political parties that top 10th of that 1 per cent. The top 100th Nehru House, 4 Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg
have listed are likely to post combined and they are concerned with the ser- from ankle-deep into hip-deep hot lost elections in India in 1977 of the 1 per cent have done best of all". So New Delhi 110 002
losses of $14 billion for the last year, vice that suits them, not with the ser- water, a spirited chairman and vice- (Congress) and in 2004 (Bharatiya the average man will never ever catch up Fax: (011) 23720201 · E-mail: letters@bsmail.in
with cumulative losses of $49 billion. vice provider or the technology. chairman (Ashok Ganguly and Susim Janata Party); think of the superbly with the rich MPs. All letters must have a postal address and telephone
number
The poster boy startup for stupidity in Changing consumer preference is the Datta) massively aligned the company confident Yahya Khan before the Sukumar Mukhopadhyay via email
funding and management preoccupa- reason why getting a management’s back to consumer-focus, creating Pakistani elections of 1970, resulting
tion with valuations is Theranos. eye off consumer-orientation produces Wheel. Wheel detergent played a car- in the East Pakistan revolt.
Among well-established companies, unintended consequences. dinal role in restoring the company’s Arrogant, self-centered, competitor
> HAMBONE
Xerox's inability to read emerging con- Modern design thinking lays great focus and became a valuable brand for obsession is more than likely to fail —
sumer needs has been well document- emphasis on the role of empathy. This HLL over time. whether a company, a political party
ed as a case of losing focus. is quite foundational and requires you Patanjali Ayurved started with huge or any other institution.
Cycles of human folly have played to put yourself in the hearts of people bluster, captured through the personal
out for centuries, so why would people and experience the feelings of the oth- image of Baba Ramdev. It was highly The writer is a corporate advisor and
not continue withe their foolish acts? er person. When the voice of the prod- competitor-focused. The company distinguished professor of IIT Kharagpur.
On the flip side, there are magnificent uct, the voice of the system and the pretended to be in national service, During his career, he was a director of Tata
startups that invested heavily, incurred voice of the process are all heard and about to blast MNCs off their prof- Sons and a vice chairman of Hindustan
losses but built up unbelievably valu- together, then an infinitely superior it-sucking ways. Equity analysts wrote Unilever. Email: rgopal@themindworks.me
>
OPINION 9
STAY INFORMED THROUGH THE DAY @ WWW.BUSINESS-STANDARD.COM
Disciplining NBFCs
It’s about high-quality jobs
RBI’s draft rules will help reboot the sector We need millions of high-quality jobs to become a developed nation
ILLUSTRATION: BINAY SINHA
I
he Reserve Bank of India’s (RBI’s) proposal to introduce liquidity buffers n earlier articles, “It’s about jobs” (Business
Water woes the way a factory is organised inherently develops things that make people modern. An intensive train-
the individual. People work to a manufacturing ing programme teaches everything from hospitality
schedule; this teaches planning. One sees a direct domain skills to the soft skills essential to success
tourism Czar with the power to work across min-
istries and state governments to attract 80 million
annual tourists to India in the term of this govern-
Crop diversification is the need of the hour connection between work and output — so it isn’t in a luxury resort. In the eight years since Shillim ment. The alternative could condemn us, in
luck that delivers results but learning and using opened, hundreds of lives have been transformed, Trotsky’s words, to the ash heap of history.
aryana’s decision to incentivise diversion of cropland from water-
H
skills. That fosters efficacy. Any decent factory has and with it the fortunes of their families in the next
guzzling paddy to less water-consuming crops like maize, pulses and a focus on efficiency — that directly connects using generation. The writer is co-chairman of Forbes Marshall, past
others is a welcome step towards mitigating the high-water footprint time productively to output. Change is the norm in Shillim needs to become India writ large. Tourism president of CII, and chairman of the Centre for Technology,
of its agriculture. Widespread rice cultivation is deemed the chief factories, so new experience is valued. Technology is our greatest untapped opportunity. No country Innovation and Economic Research (CTIER)
is all around one, making the individual more pro- can match us in the combination of architectural Email: ndforbes@forbesmarshall.com
cause of rapid decline in groundwater in nearly 75 per cent of the state. Paddy,
especially non-Basmati paddy, has not been the traditional crop of this inherently
water-stressed state. It was introduced chiefly to meet the needs of the other
Pluralism lives
food-deficit regions, most of which are now growing enough rice on their own.
Haryana, therefore, need not expend its scarce water on cultivating non-Basmati
rice, each kilogram of which takes a massive 3,000 to 3,500 litres of water to
grow. The sops mooted to spur changes in cropping pattern include ~2,000 per
providing bijli, paani, schools and health to the
L
utyens’ liberals and sundry “sickular” ana- paign, in case you missed the memo) made no
acre as cash, free seeds of the alternative crops, full reimbursement of crop insur- lysts have been dumbfounded by the election urban poor, Bihar and Odisha on development, sense at all. Ill-conceived warnings of Muslims
ance premium and assured procurement of the output at the minimum support results that handed Narendra Modi’s West Bengal on protecting land rights (until being killed en-masse if the BJP came to power
prices fixed by the Centre. Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) an unanticipated Mamata Banerjee inexplicably opted for communal even as the Congress offered soft Hindutva imagery
Haryana, indeed, is not the only state that needs crop diversification of this majority in the Lok Sabha. The elite intellectual appeasement), and Chhattisgarh, MP and via multiple temple visits only confused the signals
kind to ensure sustainable use of water. Its adjoining areas of Punjab, western discourse since then has eddied around the xeno- Rajasthan on widespread farmer unrest, to offer for the average voter. Although it is possible to
phobic and communal content of the campaign, some examples. debate the wisdom or otherwise of the income sup-
Uttar Pradesh and eastern Rajasthan, as also parts of southern states like Andhra
which appears to have trumped the myriad non- Mr Modi’s 2014 majority owed much to the non- port programme NYAY, it came far too late and
Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka and Maharashtra, need to modify their cropping achievements of Mr Modi’s 2014 promises. So casteist, job-creating development plank on which was poorly propagated. The irony is that the
systems to conserve water. Though, arguably, fiscal incentives-based crop diver- should we pronounce the funeral oration for plural, he campaigned convincingly and energetically. His Congress has an entrenched grassroots organisa-
sification can worsen the already strained state finances, this burden would seem inclusive India? vision of a red-tape— and corruption-free India, of tion and capable state satraps that Mr Gandhi did
trivial when weighed against the consequences of inaction on this front. Going The past five years offer clues to why the answer efficient administration with plentiful jobs and a not leverage judiciously. His performance has only
by the reckoning of the National Institute for Transforming India (NITI) Aayog, can as well be no. fast-growing economy — a stark served to validate Mr Modi’s sneers at the inade-
Critics of Mr Modi have attribut- contrast to the tired, venal alliance quate “dynast”.
the lives and livelihood of millions of Indians are in jeopardy due to water depri-
ed his almost single-handed victory in power — encouraged many vot- In contrast, Messrs Modi and Shah had some-
vation. About 600 million people are already facing high to extremely high water to his undoubted charisma, money ers steeped in India’s foundational thing Mr Gandhi, two decades younger, lacked: the
stress and 200,000 of them die every year due to inadequate access to it. The power, youthful muscle power and values to press the button next to zealots’ vitality to mobilise the people and craft a
consequential economic losses are anticipated by the NITI Aayog to mount to a command over the national broad- the lotus symbol. narrative that is guaranteed to resonate when times
worth around 6 per cent of the gross domestic product (GDP) by 2050. casting apparatus. All these advan- Thus, presented with an ener- are bad. Generating fear of an inchoate Other —
Moreover, with business as usual, the demand of water is projected to surge tages multiplied from 2014 onwards getic, credible competing vision Pakistan, Islamic terrorists, issues that it single-
— in fact, Mr Modi’s All India Radio of progress that is not necessarily handedly revived in Jammu & Kashmir after a
to twice the availability by as early as 2030. The water level in about 54 per cent talk show Mann Ki Baat was consid- predicated on religion and nation- decade of relative peace — is a handy alibi when
of wells across the country is receding at a worrisome pace due to withdrawals ered a potent electoral tool. Yet his alism, it is just as possible for elec- an economy stagnates and foreign investors seek
exceeding the annual recharge. Worse still, the quality of nearly 70 per cent of party lost eight seats in Lok Sabha torates to respond positively. It is other pastures. Mr Modi’s detractors compare him
the available water is rather poor, thanks to rampant contamination, rendering bypolls and several key state elec- SWOT easy to forget now that at the start with Indira Gandhi in his authoritarianism and dis-
it unfit for domestic uses and, in some cases, even for irrigation. Unsurprisingly, tions in the past five years. In the of 2019, Mr Modi’s poor perfor- regard for institutions and constitutional norms.
India ranks 120 among 122 countries in the global water quality index. 20-odd Assembly polls since then, KANIKA DATTA mance on the economic front had His regime’s similarities with West Bengal’s defunct
non-BJP parties won almost as often raised prospect of a comeback but Left Front are also striking. Just as the Left Front’s
The potential advantages of crop diversification, on the other hand, can be many. as the BJP, though the exigencies of power politics with a significantly reduced number of seats. That success with land redistribution rooted its three
Apart from saving water, it can stave off the demand for power and diesel needed for induced two of them to tie up subsequently with the Congress was unable to offer voters a credible decades in power, the initial triumphs of schemes
running irrigation equipment. Besides, it can help improve environment by cutting the saffron party and the party broke ground in nationwide alternative vision at all had as much to such as Jan Dhan and Ujjwala exposed the aam
down emissions of greenhouse gases like methane and nitrous oxide which are the north-east. do with the oblique nature of its campaign when aadmi outside Gujarat to Mr Modi’s capabilities.
spewed routinely from the flooded paddy fields and the smoke generated by burning For evidence recall: The Assembly elections of compared with Mr Modi and Amit Shah subliminal Just as the Left Front found a useful recruiting base
Delhi and Bihar (2015), Odisha (in 2014 and 2019), messaging. among unemployed youth — the result of its own
paddy stubbles. Most importantly, inclusion of legumes (pulses) in the cropping sys-
West Bengal (in 2016) and the Big Three of 2018 in Rahul Gandhi’s distance from the aam aadmi anti-industry policies — record youth unemploy-
tems can restore soil health by fixing nitrogen into it, thus diminishing the fertiliser Chhattisgarh, Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan, the way of thinking caused him to focus on issues that ment provided Mr Modi with a large cohort of polit-
requirement of the subsequent crops. It is, therefore, imperative to economise the UP Assembly by-elections in Gorakhpur and have little resonance for them. Whether Mr Modi ical foot soldiers.
use of water in agriculture through measures like crop diversifications, strict regulation Phulpur in 2018. made money on the Rafale deal (especially when Mr Modi, in permanent campaign mode, is plan-
of groundwater extraction and pricing water in accordance with its scarcity value. The Hindutva tide was no weaker then than it there was no evidence of this) is irrelevant when ning his strategies for various elections in 2020. Time
is today. But all of these wins came on the back of livelihoods are at stake. Mr Gandhi’s mawkish big for his secular opponents to get their act together
down-to-earth bread-and-butter issues: Delhi on message of Love (as against the BJP’s hate cam- asap, you would think.
P
rime Minister Narendra Modi will authors Anirban Ganguly and Shiwanand The book provides, for the benefit of its lore, Arvind Ghose, later known as Sri externed him from Gujarat in 2010. experience had been a transformative one;
take the oath of office for his sec- Dwivedi, both associated with a BJP think readers, “selected video links with QR Aurobindo, visited the family once and it In September 2010, Mr Shah was on his willpower and resolve had strength-
ond term, with his council of min- tank, the Syama Prasad Mookerjee codes” of 15 of Mr Shah’s speeches. There still preserves the chair that saint sat on. his first visit to Varanasi. One evening he ened,” the authors write.
isters, on Thursday. There is anticipation Research Foundation, are effusive in their is a separate eight-page section titled “Amit The authors say Mr Shah’s family was rich joined the Ganga aarti and had an Is it too much to ask of a prestigious
that Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) presi- praise of the BJP’s “Chanakya” as a master Shah’s Thoughts”. These include Mr Shah’s but prepared him for a life of hard work. epiphany. “Shah felt strange ripples rising international publisher such as
dent Amit Shah would be a member of political strategist. praise of khadi, his simple lifestyle, com- While his sisters would go to school in a within himself, these were waves of Bloomsbury to come up with biographies
the cabinet committee on security, repris- The book, the authors state in the intro- mitment to “garib kalyan”, or welfare of horse-drawn carriage, Mr Shah had to walk thoughts, of a deep inward rumination that are a tad more dispassionate?
ing his role as home minister, a portfolio duction, is an attempt at recording the story the poor, his paeans to India’s cultural her- to the school. of which he had no inkling, it was in a
he held in Gujarat when Mr Modi was of Mr Shah’s years at the BJP’s helm “relying itage and so on. Shah started his political work as a 13- state of being which he had never expe- AMIT SHAH AND THE MARCH OF BJP
chief minister. on authentic sources, material and infor- More interesting are some of the per- year-old in 1977 when he stuck posters for rienced before,” the authors write.
Mr Shah has had a meteoric rise in mation” since most of the available material sonal details. Janata Party candidates from Mehsana, “Certain questions began haunting him:
Anirban Ganguly &
national politics. In mid-2010, Mr Shah on the man is based “on speculations, sur- The chapter, “Rising Through the Maniben Patel, the daughter of Sardar Why is this immortal city in such a state of Shiwanand Dwivedi
spent time in jail in the Sohrabuddin mises and assumptions” by people, they Ranks”, has details on Mr Shah’s ancestral Vallabhbhai Patel. Later, he joined the Akhil degeneration? Is the lap of Mother Ganga Bloomsbury; 296 pages, ~399
>
MUMBAI | THURSDAY, 30 MAY 2019 ECONOMY & PUBLIC AFFAIRS 19
N
ational Housing Bank (NHB) latory instructions in the pipeline in a ~10,000 crore in FY20 from
on Wednesday directed big- bid to give comfort to the market, sale of non-core assets, rights
ger housing finance compa- lenders, analysts and investors, follow- issue and expected write-
nies (HFCs) to appoint a chief risk offi- ing last year’s default by the backs from two large
cer (CRO) in a bid to improve risk Infrastructure Leasing & Financial accounts undergoing insol-
management practices. Services, which led to the reporting of vency proceedings.
“While the boards of HFCs should a series of defaults by other players in The lender is expecting a
strive to follow best practices in risk the NBFC and HFC space, dampening write-back of ~4,000 crore
management, it has been decided that market sentiments. from Essar Steel and
HFCs with asset size of more than The instructions may ask HFCs to Bhushan Power and Steel
~5,000 crore shall appoint a CRO with maintain adequate funds in case of a which are undergoing reso-
clearly specified role and responsibil- crisis situation. HFCs may also be lution under the Insolvency
ities,” NHB said in a circular dated asked to submit their asset-liability and Bankruptcy Code. erstwhile headquarters, situ- the current financial year.
May 29, adding that the CRO will act management data on a weekly basis. “For FY20, we are looking ated at Bhikaji Cama Place in In FY19, its recovery more
independently to “ensure highest “The move to appoint CROs will to raise ~10,000 crore. We are South Delhi, to the income than doubled to ~20,000 crore
standards of risk management.” put a deeper glare on the HFC sector. expecting ~1,000 crore from tax department. The deal is from ~9,666 crore in FY18. The
The circular added that the board HFCs may have to maintain adequate funds in case of a crisis and to submit their Many HFCs have approached the sale of non-core assets, in the final stage. bank narrowed its loss by
of HFCs should put in place policies to asset-liability management data weekly PHOTO: ISTOCK NHB, demanding tightening of regu- ~4,000 crore write-back It is also planning to raise nearly 65 per cent to ~4,750
“safeguard the independence of the lations on them in a bid to boost mar- (from) two accounts (Essar ~400 crore by selling some crore during the fourth quar-
CRO” who should report directly to the Finance, Tata Capital, GIC Housing ture withdrawals of its deposits, with ket sentiments,” said a senior finance Steel and Bhushan Power and real estate properties.Mehta ter of fiscal ended March 2019.
managing director and chief executive Finance, PNB Housing Finance, immediate effect, in order to reorganise ministry official. Steel) and ~5,000 crore from said the lender would raise Its net loss was at ~13,417 crore
officer. Indiabulls Housing Finance, and its liability management. The official said that HFCs are markets,” the bank’s manag- ~5,000 crore through rights in the same quarter of FY18.
The circular will cover top 15 HFCs Dewan Housing Finance (DHFL), The move follows a similar direction complaining of a liquidity crunch and ing director and CEO Sunil issue or qualified institution- Gross NPAs improved to
controlling 95 per cent of the business, among others. given by the Reserve Bank of India a a tight regulation on HFCs may ‘gen- Mehta told reporters. al placement (QIP) route. 15.50 per cent from 18.38 per
including Housing Development Recently, the liquidity-starved few days back to appoint a CRO in a erate confidence among market play- The bank expects to raise The bank has set a recov- cent at the end of
Finance Corporation, LIC Housing DHFL had said it won’t allow prema- non-banking financial company ers to invest in them’. ~600 crore from sale of its ery target of ~20,000 crore in March 2018.
BJP’s claims of political minister Narendra Modi Ji. It ing the BJP but now they have started Biju Janata Dal (BJD) presi-
was my plan to accept the coming to us,” Dilip Ghosh, the state’s dent Naveen Patnaik took
violence by members of constitutional invitation and president of the BJP, who won in the oath as Odisha chief minister
TMC; Mamata refutes attend the oath-taking
ceremony. However, in the
Lok Sabha elections, claimed.
Last month, in one of his campaigns
for the fifth straight term on
Wednesday.
last one hour, I am seeing in this state, Modi had claimed that This made him the third
AVISHEK RAKSHIT media reports that the BJP is Banerjee is losing her hold in West chief minister after Jyoti Basu
Kolkata, 29 May claiming 54 people have been Bengal as 40 MLAs from her party are (West Bengal) and Pawan
murdered in political in touch with him and they will desert Kumar Chamling (Sikkim) to
Bengal Chief Minister Mamata violence in Bengal. the TMC once the BJP wins. In response, achieve the rare feat.
Banerjee has decided not to attend This is completely TMC leader Derek O’Brien had claimed State Governor Ganeshi Lal
Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s swear- untrue. I am that not even a councillor will jump ship. administered the oath of office
ing-in on Thursday. She had earlier said sorry, Narendra The Lok Sabha election results came and secrecy to Patnaik and his
she would attend the event as “consti- Modi Ji, this has as a blow to Banerjee and the TMC, as new council of 20 ministers –
tutional duty and courtesy”. Her U-turn compelled me the party lost its hold on entire northern 11 of Cabinet rank and 10 as
comes after the BJP’s claim of political not to attend the West Bengal and tribal areas of the west- ministers of state (MoS).
violence in Bengal, which she has refut- ceremony” ern part of the state. Its seat count The portfolios were allocat-
ed. She had skipped the ceremony in reduced from 34 in 2014 to 22. On the ed swiftly after the swearing-
2014 as well. MAMATA other hand, the BJP increased its tally in closed. Patnaik will addi-
“Congratulations, new prime min- BANERJEE from two in 2014 elections to 18. tionally oversee home, general Secretariat employees greet CM Naveen Patnaik in Bhubaneswar on Wednesday PHOTO: PTI
ister Narendra Modi Ji. It was my plan Bengal CM administration and public
to accept the Constitutional invitation grievances as well as any other ily welfare. Tukuni Sahu, blew away the Modi wave and leader of the House, the chief
and attend the oath-taking ceremony.
However, in the last one hour, I am see- an “august occasion to celebrate
Doesn't matter if department not assigned to
other ministers.
Patnaik’s lone female col-
league in the Cabinet, has
transcended the anti-incum-
bency factor.
minister will be present during
the occasion.
ing media reports that the BJP is claim- democracy” and it should not be used some opportunist Niranjan Pujari, former bagged the ministry of women Patnaik will not attend the So, Patnaik will not be able
ing 54 people have been murdered in to “score political points”. The 2019 Lok speaker of the state Assembly, and child development & swearing-in ceremony of to visit Delhi to attend the
political violence in Bengal. This is Sabha elections witnessed a pitched MLAs join BJP: TMC is the new minister for finance Mission Shakti. Prime Minister Narendra swearing-in ceremony of the
completely untrue”, her statement on battle between the BJP and the TMC, & excise. Prafulla Mallick Patnaik led his BJD to a Modi in Delhi on Thursday, prime minister and his council
a social media platform said. not only via the democratic process of The TMC leadership on Wednesday retains his old portfolio of steel thumping victory in the 2019 officials said. of ministers, an official com-
It added, “So, I am sorry, Narendra polling, but numerous incidents of vio- shrugged off party MLAs joining the & mines along with works. elections, winning 112 of the The newly elected mem- munication issued by the
Modi Ji, this has compelled me not to lence and voter intimidation. BJP, saying it “doesn't matter” if some New entrant Naba Kishore Das 146 Assembly constituencies bers of the 16th Vidhan Sabha Chief Minister's Office said on
attend the ceremony”. Political observers like Biswanath “opportunist” legislators switch will look after health and fam- polled. His immense mandate will take oath on Thursday. As Wednesday.
Banerjee affirmed, “There have Chakraborty noted that at least four loyalties. It also claimed some among
been no political murders in Bengal. people were casualties of political vio- those who had joined the saffron
These deaths may have occurred due
to enmity, family quarrels and other
lence during the polls while the entire
poll season saw 12 people getting killed
party had been threatened to do so.
"It doesn't matter if one or two Odisha govt starts disbursements under KALIA scheme
disputes; nothing related to politics. in political violence. In another devel- opportunist MLAs switchover to the
There is no record with us”. Modi, in opment, another TMC MLA, Manirul BJP. Some are opportunist and some PRESS TRUST OF INDIA our first cabinet meeting, the target of KALIA benefi- released to about 840,000
his address in Varanasi, on Tuesday, Islam and party leaders — Gadadhar are being forced to join by using threat Bhubaneswar, 29 May the fund release under ciaries to 7.5 million farm farm families under the
had claimed that BJP workers are being Hazra, Mohd Asif Iqbal and Nimai Das and intimidation," senior TMC leader KALIA scheme starts with families from 4.2 million Krushak Assistance for
killed in the state for their ideology. – joined the saffron party on Tapas Roy said. Roy's comment came The Biju Janata Dal (BJD) immediate effect, and about families. Livelihood and Income
According to reports, the BJP has invit- Wednesday after two MLAs and over 50 after TMC MLA Monirul Islam joined the government on Wednesday 2.5 million additional fami- “This is 3.3 million more Augmentation (KALIA)
ed kin of BJP workers, who allegedly councillors from the TMC camp had BJP earlier on Wednesday. Two other started disbursement of lies will be assisted in a than the existing benefici- scheme. Patnaik had earlier
lost their lives in political violence in crossed over to the BJP. A CPI(M) MLA legislators, including Subhrangshu funds to farmers under the weeks’ time,” Patnaik told ary families,” the chief min- assured his government, on
Bengal, as special invitees, in Modi’s had also defected. Roy, and over 50 councillors, had KALIA scheme. reporters here. ister said. the first day of taking oath,
oath-taking ceremony. “There are many in the TMC who joined the BJP on Tuesday. PTI “As part of our commit- He also said the first cab- On Wednesday, the first will release funds under the
Banerjee said such a ceremony was wants to join the BJP. They know that ment to farmers, today in inet meeting has increased instalment of ~5,000 was KALIA scheme.
Modi2.0must
metric form of identification is almost
always built into the access controls. So
employees authenticate themselves
enhancetech
either through a fingerprint or a retina
scan or facial recognition or a combi-
nation of these. This is done so that
prowess
no unauthorised person can enter the
building in case an ID card gets stolen.
Again, if there is a security breach
because an employee has not adhered
to the processes, stringent protocols India’s effort at improv-
are in place. Extensive logs are main- ing competitiveness
tained for all activities and video sur- has been so far focused
veillance tapes are available to pin- on ease of doing busi-
point the exact source of the breach. ness. The government
Besides, there are regular audits, hasbeenmakingefforts
as frequent as once every six months, to improve the environ-
to ensure that the protocols are being ment for approvals
followed. while enhancing physi-
Simple rules like no tailgating are cal infrastructure. In its
important in a data centre because of second term, the NDA
the criticality of the data stored on the KRANTI NATION government, led by
premises. There is also under-vehicle Prime Minister
surveillance cameras set up on the PRANJAL SHARMA Narendra Modi, should
Data fortress
ground to check vehicles from bring- now target improving
ing in anything that could pose a India'stechnologicalcompetitiveness.Intheeraofthe
threat to the data centre. fourth industrial revolution, mere tinkering with
existing government procedures will not enhance its
Environment control economic competitiveness.
Apart from the human element, the A large part of national competitiveness derives
environment inside a data centre is from its ability to create and deploy technology for
Datacentres,whichstorecriticaldataofhundredsofmillions also tightly controlled to ensure
smooth operation at all times. The
development, welfare and industrial activity.
According to the IMD Digital Competitiveness
of Indians, have multiple and rigorous layers of security. main building that houses the storage
equipment is usually made of higher
report, the ranking of India improved from 56 to 48
between 2014 and 2018. Lausanne based business
Neha Alawadhi gives the lowdown reinforcement and can withstand
earthquakes measuring up to nine on
school IMD says “the objective of the digital com-
petitiveness ranking is to assess the extent to which
the Richter scale. The power supply is a country adopts and explores digital technologies
T
he Noida branch of CtrlS, a in managing data centres in the coun- veillance of people and equipment to tained for a proper back-up. We have taken from two or more different leading to transformation in government practices,
data centre company based try, have several layers of physical choosing the right materials for the systems that help monitor this and sources so as to minimise the down- business models and society in general.”
in Hyderabad, stands tall on security and contingency measures to building that contains the servers that they trigger an automatic response, time in case of power failures. The linkage between technological and overall
a busy highway. The ensure that the data of hundreds or store data, these facilities are truly informing the person in charge Air quality is another critical aspect competitiveness is very high. Countries that tend to
unmarked building has 24X7 video millions of users remains safe. state-of-the-art. through SMS alerts that action needs that impacts the performance of a data invest in their technological prowess improve their
surveillance through multiple cam- With more and more organisations A data centre essentially looks like to be taken,” says an executive at one of centre.“TheairqualityinDelhiandNCR overall competitiveness. While earlier, the invest-
eras, including one on the roof that choosing to trust data centres with a library, with rows upon rows of India’s largest data centres who does isabigproblemasthedatacentreequip- ment was mostly in physical machines, factories and
scans the perimeter surrounded by 15- their most critical data, these firms are metallic shelves that house thousands not wish to be named. ment can corrode faster with toxins like industrial products, now the shift is towards smart
feet-high walls with barbed, electrified taking every measure possible to of servers which look like DVD players A camera control room with feeds sulphur and nitrogen present in the air. solutions. In many ways, it is easier for developing
wires on top. The walls are crash-rated ensure that none of their system or stacked one on top of the other. The from over a 100 cameras is also part of Hence, we have a chemical filtration countries to adopt artificial intelligence (AI)-based
to guard against a vehicle ramming subsystem ever goes down. humming machines with their glow- the set-up. The room has bulletproof capability at the facility itself,” says an solutions that enhance productivity and efficiency for
into the facility. US-based cybersecurity firm Palo ing connection lights look a bit eerie. glass on the door and windows. A com- executive at one of the data centres. business and government. “Countries that rank high
Needless to say, getting into the Alto Networks defines But every single aspect bination of low-light cameras, pan-tilt- In fact, data centres have been in technological aspects tend to rank high in overall
high-security building is no cakewalk. a data centre as “a facil- of the server rooms is zoom cameras and standard fixed experiencing a rapid rate of hardware competitiveness,” says Dr Jose Caballero, senior econ-
You are frisked and your identity and ity that centralises an Data centres use building controlled, monitored cameras are used and footage from failures due to sulphur bearing gases. omist at IMD.
bag rigorously checked. You are organisation’s IT oper- automation to manage and maintained — right these is typically stored for a mini- CtrlS says it has deployed an air filtra- TheIMDWorldCompetitivenessReport2019bears
required to put on disposable over- ations and equipment, every system in the down to the air you mum of 90 days. This can be handed tion and purification technology that out the importance of
shoes as you walk in. Inside the build- as well as where it building such as video breathe or the amount over to customers if needed. removes gaseous contaminants and technological prowess.
ing, too, access is rigidly controlled. stores, manages, and surveillance, fire alarm of light you see. particulates and inhibits corrosion. In the era of the Singaporeranks1st intech-
Even employees don’t have access to disseminates its data. systems, generators and Data centres use The human element Every effort is also made to keep fourth industrial nological infrastructure
every part of the facility — not all Data centres house a smoke detectors. And all building automation to One of the biggest challenges of manag- dust to a bare minimum. “Dust has to revolution, mere while topping the overall
employees are allowed on all floors. network’s most critical these are monitored manage every system in ing physical security at a data centre is be kept low. Sticking paints are often tinkering with ranking, the USA is 6th in
The core of the building, the data cen- systems and are vital to through a single the building such as getting people to follow the processes, used on the floor, so the dust sticks to existing technology, Sweden is 5th,
tre itself, is also protected by multiple the continuity of daily dashboard console video surveillance, fire says Nitin Mishra, senior vice president the paint. The air conditioners also government Denmark is 7th and
layers of security. You are body- operations”. alarm systems, water and chief product officer at Netmagic, have high quality filters to ensure that procedures will Switzerland is 8th. They
scanned before you enter. Nothing gets A typical multi-lay- leak detectors, genera- an NTT Communications company. dust does not circulate in the air,” says not enhance rank 3rd, 9th, 8th and 4th
in from outside — not even a pen. er security protocol in a data centre tors, smoke detectors and so on. And Though data centres are increasingly Netmagic’s Mishra. India’s economic (respectively) in overall
Data centres and their security in would be: Main gate security, a physi- all these are monitored through a sin- becoming non-labour intensive facili- According to Data Foundry, a data competitiveness competitiveness.
India have been in the limelight ever cal scan by security personnel, turn- gle dashboard console. The lights in ties,thehumanelementcontinuestobe centre company based in Austin, India’s overall level has
since the conversation intensified stile entry, a scanner for bags or equip- the building are usually kept low to important. For example, even the build- Texas, “If not kept under control, air- improvedmarginallyto43from44outof63countries
recently around the localisation of data ment, door access, another turnstile, conserve energy. ingautomationdashboardsaremanned borne contaminants in data centres ranked. Within the sub-factors India ranks at the bot-
of Indian users. Companies like CtrlS, frisking, and a biometrics-based “The battery used in the server at all times of the day. cause a variety of problems from tom at 63 for education. However it has better rank-
Netmagic and Tata Communications, access. It’s no different inside the rooms is a critical resource. A mini- Along with digital access cards for impaired power efficiency to equip- ing in technological infrastructure (28) and scientific
which are among the biggest names building. From round-the-clock sur- mum level of charge has to be main- different levels of employees, a bio- ment failure.” infrastructure (36). This means that while India has
the ability, it has not been able to develop its strengths
because of weak foundations in education.
"Technological infrastructure is closely related
to the scientific infrastructure and education.
ALGO RHYTHM Therefore, to improve in the technological sub-fac-
Fintechs ushering in digital disruption across Coporate banks face key challenges on multiple fronts tor, countries need to increase not only, for example,
DISRUPTORS
Dr Caballero says. "It is also necessary to develop
Rupeeseed share of corporate (Letter of undertaking) Competition from high levels of knowledge transfer between companies
Capital float
Market lending revenues to Rising customer Fintechs: Disruption in and universities to ensure knowledge spill-overs,
Corporate banks in India face ICres IBSFINtech overall banking expectations: business model across and to strengthen the quality of education."
greater degree of disruption today Indoinventing
Lendingkart SME revenues Increasing the banking AI is now an important medium for delivering
than even before, thanks to the
NeoGrowth
Treasury Treasury Line Increasing credit and expectations of ecosystem through
government and business solutions. The need for
mushrooming of new age digital lending understanding data science has extended to near-
banking platforms and fintech Power2SME Treasury Press fraud risks: Growing sophistication and digital offerings ly all professions in the world.
companies. With no legacy system Key facts and figures The Indian education systems is still divided by
to drag them, these new age silos that prevent students from blending skills for
KredX
companies with their asset light
KrypC
Billing 300 45% of India corpo- return on capital
below hurdle rate
between top quartile
and bottom quartile
specific objectives. AI and data science are needed
by doctors, engineers, but also town planners and
models use different tenets of Casfe rate banks showed
digital technologies to keep them (6%) in FY’18 banks tax officers. Accountants and human resource man-
M1 fonePaisa declining profits in agers need to understand data science as do dairy
agile and keep the business model FY’18
transparent to service the digital
ROUTE.com
Trade
Cash Giddh 10% difference in 2.7% increase in gross businesses and retail salesforce.
management An overhaul of the education system will allow
savvy customers effectively. In their SimplyFI Invoicera (Trade) 64% of india corpo- pre-tax returns on
regulatory capital
non-performing assets
from FY’17 to FY’18 students and professionals to go beyond the labels
2019 report Unlocking Success in TallyX numberz rate banks had of science and arts studies. In today’s world every-
Corporate Banking through body has to understand basic technology.
Digital, Boston Consulting Group Key facts and figures Options before corporate banks to survive in the game Improvement in ease of doing business is nec-
and SWIFT India have pointed out Develop Drive operational Leverage Big Data and advanced essary for the country but not sufficient. India has
that corporate banks need to ride $960m 42% yearly 1260 India fintech start- productised solutions excellence by digitising analytics to transform their
to benchmark itself on technology to assess its com-
the digital wave by leveraging Big investment in growth in fintech ups founded between petitiveness. Dr Caballero sums it up well,
for clients across their front-end channels topline through a mix of pricing, “Education is at the core of the technological and
Data and analytics among several India fintechs investments in 2015-2018 (second highest priority sectors and back-office processes selling and retention algorithms scientific infrastructures. To sustain India’s tech-
other digital tools in order to thrive in 2018 2018 vs 2017 globally)
Note: Coporate banks refers to those banks that offer banking services. Hurdle rate refers to the repo rate of 6%, nological and scientific performance, therefore,
in this environment. Source: BCG Research, FIDAC survey 2018 (Covering 30+ Indian banks including public and private sector banks) education needs to be strengthened.”
NEW CHOICES that manages user responses. Since The company claims that that was acquired by media firm the emotional impact it has had on the
everything happens in real-time, often BrainBaazi, which was launched in PocketAces in 2018. “A smartphone’s community is something we did not
QuizTime
with as many as 50,000 concurrent February 2018, has got over 10 million hallmark is interactivity and this has anticipate. People are playing it in
users, the games depend heavily on a downloads on the Android, with every not been exploited to its potential thus groups, with friends in hostels, playing
scalable and high-bandwidth cloud user playing the quiz at least eight times far,” says Anirudh Pandita, co-founder it at workplaces. I have heard that some
infrastructure. in a month. of PocketAces, which produces web companies have office happy hours
A slew of online games such as BrainBaazi, Loco Take BaaziNow, the gaming app
from Times Internet. “BaaziNow takes
“Our team envisaged what mobile
video entertainment could be with real
series and viral videos.
Like BrainBaazi, Loco has also got
around Loco. In the evening, people are
playing with their families.
and Trivia Live are bringing the joys of quizzing the online gaming phenomenon to the
next level with live games such as
participation from people via their
mobile phones,” says Sinha. BrainBaazi
over 10 million downloads on Android,
with as many as 60,000 concurrent
Interestingly, our biggest winners on
the app are from tier 2 towns in
to your mobile phone, reports Yuvraj Malik BrainBaazi, PollBaazi and BingoBaazi
that engage users across India. Our
beams its live quiz at 8.30 pm every day
and disburses cash prizes worth
users at times.
“The extent of Loco’s success and
Jharkhand and Bihar or towns like
Lucknow,” says Pandita.
intuitive user interface has a strong ~50,000 to the winners. PayTm, too, has a quiz game called
I
ndia loves quiz shows. You only have integrations. focus on integrating gaming and BrainBaazi’s biggest competitor is Trivia Live, which streams at 9 pm every
to look at the phenomenal success of Another big draw of these online interactive entertainment. This has Loco, a Mumbai- day with ~63,000 worth of prize money
Kaun Banega Crorepati, a show host- brain-teasers is that they promise real helped achieve some great results in a based startup on offer. Trivia Live is part of a gamut of
ed by Bollywood legend Amitabh cash rewards if you win. With PayTm short period,” says Gautam Sinha, chief internet games offerings from
Bachchan, to be convinced of that fact. In integrated across all such platforms, the executive officer, Times Internet. Gamepind, a joint venture between
another era, legions of school kids sat rewards are transferred to the users’ Paytm and Alibaba. In August 2018,
glued to the hugely popular Bournvita digital wallets. Alibaba-owned gaming company
Quiz Contest, which used to air on the Here’s how it works. A live quiz is “People are playing it in groups, AGTech Holdings and Paytm
radio before it reinvented itself for tele- beamed on the app at a set time of the with friends in hostels, playing invested $16 million to launch
vision. And now, in this age of the inter- day; a show host on live video talks to the it at workplaces. I have Gamepind.
net, a bunch of startups and app compa- audience and asks questions; the heard that some Also crowding the field are
nies are bringing the joys of quizzing to questions as well as the answer options companies have office such independent apps as
Indians on their mobile phones. appear over the video as text; the user happy hours around Loco. Qureka Quiz, launched by a
BrainBaazi, Loco, Qureka Quiz, IQ has to click on the correct option; if In the evening, people are startup called
Live and Trivia Live are just some of the correct, the next question is presented playing with their CoolBoots Media, and
apps that you can dip into if you feel like and so it goes on, till a wrong answer is families. Interestingly, IQ Live, which does a
engaging in a spot of quizzing. Their selected. If the user answers incorrectly, our biggest winners on the quiz show hosted by TV
USP? Unlike quiz shows on television, he or she can still stay on and watch the app are from tier 2 towns in Personality Rohit Roy.
where you are more of a spectator, you rest of the quiz. A typical quiz has 10 to 20 Jharkhand and Bihar or towns They largely follow the
can be an active participant in these questions, and runs for 20 to 30 minutes. like Lucknow” same model with minor
shows. This is made possible by a From a tech point of view, the online ANIRUDH PANDITA, tweaks.
combination of innovative game-play, quiz is nothing but a live-stream with Clearly, the Indian quiz
Co-founder of PocketAces
faster mobile internet speeds, live graphics being fired over it in real-time enthusiast is now spoilt for
stream technology and digital payment and supported by a game-play software choice.
.
MUMBAI | THURSDAY, 30 MAY 2019 BRAND WORLD 21 <
Ethnic fashion
of the GI tag for the embroi-
dered work says that GI tag-
ging and monitoring is a com-
plex and expensive process. It
took five years to get it done
I
t was a routine promotion Zaheda Mulla, a lawyer who
by one of the big online worked towards GI tagging the
ethnic-wear retailers, but Toda embroidery, believes that
one that went horribly wrong. there is a lot that can be done.
Even as it drew the attention People need to come togeth-
of the growing tribe of ethnic er and commit to a solution said
fashion enthusiasts, as it was Mulla. India could learn from
meant to, the ad also set off how the EU protects its food,
the alarm bells among the wine and cheese GIs, she said.
Todas, a tribe that lives in They set prohibitive fines for
the Nilgiri mountains of even the slightest infringement
Tamil Nadu. and she added, in India it
Surprised to see a should be mandatory for retail-
retailer promote their ers selling ethnic wear to give
trademark black and credit to the crafts people and
red embroidery work source from authorised
(pohor) without any users of the GI tag.
acknowledgement However most people
of its GI tagged ori- said that the task of mon-
gins and worse still, itoring and implement-
labelling it wrongly, the com- ing GI tags is daunting.
munity fought back with legal Even if one focuses just on
notices with help from a group (Left) A pouch embroidered in the Toda the handloom sector, a posi-
of lawyers, NGOs and local community’s trademark black-and-red tion paper released by FICCI
artisans and store owners. So embroidery that is at the centre of the dispute earlier this year showed that in
far the retailers have main- India, nearly 27.83 lakh hand-
tained a standard denial, say- it investigates the matter. across communities. loom households are engaged
ing there has been no wrong- The GI tag is held As David researched the in weaving and allied activities,
doing on their part. But many jointly by Pompuhar (the story she found that the por- out of which 87 per cent are
sense trouble ahead for retail- Tamil Nadu Handicrafts tals were selling a Toda in rural areas. The diversity
ers, especially those that have Development Corporation), embroidered saree for any- and spread is staggering,
mushroomed online and are Keystone Foundation (an NGO where between ~2,500-3000 retailers said.
positioning themselves as pur- working in the Nilgiris) and the while the authentic product However some attempts are
veyors of an authentic Indian Toda Nalavaazhvu Sangam (a costs closer to ~7,000. The underway. Amazon India,
product. body of Toda artisans and a huge discrepancy in prices led according to the position paper,
The two retailers under fire non-Toda dentist based in people to investigate further is keen to promote the Indian
in this case are Reliance Coonoor). Priti David who and they discovered that Handloom Brand and
Trends, for its fashion label worked on the story for People’s retailers were passing off Handloom Mark products on
Siyahi and the e-commerce Archive of Rural India (PARI) machine printed work as the its marketplace. It has
portal Tjori. Both have been says that it is unfortunate that real deal, instead of sourcing launched Weavesmart, an e-
accused of misleading con- crafts people make the most authentic hand-embroidered commerce store for handlooms
sumers and violating the rights beautiful things, but they are work from the community. in India that currently has
of the GI tag holders. While the most disenfranchised. It is While the legal notices can more than 3,000 weavers in its
Reliance Trends refused to not just one embroidery style act as a deterrent, what hap- network and more than 20,000
respond to questions sent for or a single tribe that is facing pens next? Mathew John, products. This could encourage
this story, Tjori said it was tak- the brunt of blatant misuse, the founder-CEO of Keystone other retail brands too to wear
ing down the products while story runs a similar course Foundation who is joint holder their ethnicity on their sleeve.
less than 3 per cent in March 2019 against However, the firm is yet to get a green sig-
Jaitley... over 8 per cent in the same month five years
ago. The retail food and beverages inflation
nal from Sebi. L&T group chairman A M
Naik had said last week they expected to
He took leave from the ministry twice in rate was 8.61 per cent five years ago, which launch the offer within 10 days. Some
the past 13 months and could not present came down to 0.66 per cent in March 2019. legal experts said the 55-day timeline was
the 2019-20 interim Budget. A source told During his stint as FM, Jaitley played a not sacrosanct, pointing to earlier
Business Standard that chemotherapy had key role in building a consensus to get the instances. "Failure in sticking to this dead-
left him weak and he needed some months constitution amendment Bill on the GST line is not any breach of provisions, as the
off to recover. He has been advised relative passed in Parliament. Then, the GST laws offer is still under examination," a
isolation to avoid infection. “Call it rest and were passed in Parliament and respective Mumbai-based corporate lawyer said.
recuperation. He needs it,” the person said. state assemblies to enable the introduction
Shortly after Jaitley tweeted the letter,
reactions started coming in. “Wish Arun
of the new indirect tax from July 1, 2017.
After that, 34 meetings of the GST Council, CGST...
Jaitley ji speedy recovery. Despite political chaired by the FM, have taken place and To support its stand, it had cited an order
differences, I have always found him to be all decisions, including rate cuts, were tak- passed by the Telangana HC, which had
affectionate,” tweeted Delhi CM Arvind en by a consensus. The other big achieve- refused to provide any interim relief to the
Kejriwal. “I wish you a speedy return to ments were the enactment of the petitioner and upheld the powers of the
good health. A salute to your grace in Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, merger commissioner of CGST to arrest. The order
requesting a break from Cabinet. Your col- of associate banks and Bharatiya Mahila was later upheld by SC on May 27.
laborative skills will, I’m sure, be emulated Bank with State Bank of India, merger of As the two HCs had taken differing
by your successor,” tweeted Mahindra Dena Bank and Vijaya Bank with Bank of views in similar cases, the government
group Chairman Anand Mahindra. Baroda, and enactment of the Fugitive approached the SC and sought that it
Over the last week, there has been Economic Offenders Act, among others. should settle the issue of powers of arrest.
intense speculation about his health. In its order on Wednesday, the SC clar-
Reports said he had been admitted to the ified that if HCs were to entertain such cas-
AIIMS, New Delhi, for a day. A day after
the election results, Jaitley met the five sec- IndiGo... es, they “will keep in mind” that the top
court had on May 27 agreed with the
retaries of the finance ministry and senior IndiGo, with 50 per cent share of domestic Telangana HC order upholding the powers
officials at his residence. On Sunday, RBI aviation market, is the largest customer for of the GST commissioner to arrest an
Governor Shaktikanta Das visited him. A320neo family with an order book of 430 accused without filing an FIR under CGST
The next FM will be facing a tough chal- aircraft. It chosen P&W for the first 150 air- laws. Though the SC asked HCs not to
lenge to push up economic growth amid craft of which 85 have been delivered. interfere at this stage, it did not set aside
resource crunch. GDP growth is officially IndiGo refused to comment. Bombay HC’s order granting interim relief.
projected to come down to 7 per cent in Since induction in 2016, P&W engines The favourable interim relief granted by
2018-19, the lowest in the first tenure of the have faced issues primarily due to design the Bombay HC will continue to protect
Modi government. While there are flaws. Problems stretched from long engine taxpayers until the matter is finally decided
demands of a stimulus package to perk up start-up times, problems with seal of the by the three-judge Bench of the SC, said
subdued private investments and sagging engine and durability issues with the tur- Abhishek A Rastogi, partner at Khaitan &
demand, the government does not have bine blades. The situation became complex Co, who represented the accused.
money to give it. The Centre's fiscal deficit in March 2018 when DGCA grounded 11 In its plea, the government has claimed
overshot the FY19 target by 34 per cent till A320neos including eight of IndiGo. to have noticed a trend of “short-circuiting
February. However, under Jaitley, inflation Induction of IndiGo’s long-range the procedure established by law by indi-
has been benign. The CPI inflation rate was A321neos, for foreign routes, were delayed viduals being investigated for economic
as P&W has been retrofitting the offences by filing writ petitions, challeng-
engines with more durable tur- ing the constitutional validity of every pro-
> BS SUDOKU # 2756 bine blades. P&W didn’t com- vision”. Apart from the interim orders, the
ment on the issue. However, the government has challenged before the SC
company during its first-quarter certain observations made by the HC. One
earnings call in April had said such observation is that the CGST officers
shipments engines had more are not police officers and must first file an
than doubled year on year in Q1. FIR before making arrests. The govern-
“Pratt’s GTF engine has been ment, however, pleads that CGST officers
fantastic, reducing fuel burn by acting under the CGST Act, 2017, cannot
almost 16 per cent. But A320neo be compelled to register an FIR.
operators feel the stabilisation
period has taken far longer than
promised. Airlines will naturally High interest payments...
explore if there is an option,” said Firms borrowed at an interest rate of 9.04
a source. Airline executives said per cent (on average) during H2FY19
in such deals, manufactures com- against 8.85 per cent a year ago. On the
pete by giving lucrative offers. brighter side, the interest rate was down
“This is a binary competition by 24 bps on a sequential basis from the
where the airline has to choose highs of H1FY19. One bps is one-hundredth
either P&W or CFM. With IndiGo of a per cent. Firms’ inventory was up 12.9
being a bulk customer, CFM must per cent YoY during H2FY19, outpacing the
SOLUTION TO #2755 Very easy have given them a very lucrative top line growth for the second consecutive
« offer,” the executive said.
Philippe Couteaux, executive
half-yearly period. In the same period, their
receivables were up 12.8 per cent. In com-
Solution
vice-president, sales and market- parison, firms’ total fixed assets (invest-
tomorrow ing at CFM, had earlier indicated ment in plant and machinery) was up 9.7
HOW TO PLAY it was in talks with IndiGo. per cent during H2FY19. The rise in inven-
tory and receivables was most prominent
Fill in the grid so
that every row,
every column
L&T... in sectors such as automobiles and power
utilities. This, analysts say, corresponds
Queries to L&T and Mindtree with the changes in demand conditions in
and every 3x3
went unanswered. The open the respective industries.
box contains
the digits 1 to 9 offer was to be launched on May
14 and completed on May 27. More on business-standard.com
W
ith the one-and-a-half-month- cricketing history with the opponent. newspaper warned the US the US is highly integrat-
REVENUE long ICC World Cup 2019 taking Star’s on-ground activities involve the on Wednesday that the ed and highly comple-
off on Thursday in England and theme #LeJayenge. In the first phase of country was ready to use mentary, and there are no
~1,800cr Wales, there is plenty of time for brands to this campaign, auto drivers in multiple rare earths to strike back in winners in a trade war,
~700cr 2019 get on to the advertising wagon for the
most-watched sport in the country. And,
cities held up placards stating ‘LeJayenge’,
inviting passengers to ride with them. The
their bitter trade war, say-
ing in an extremely strong-
it said.
2015 Star India is pulling out all stops to ensure second phase will begin in Mumbai on ly worded commentary Oil slumps to lowest
audiences remain interested in the rather June 5 — the day India begins their World “don't say we didn’t since March
long World Cup season. Reports suggest Cup game against South Africa. On the warn you”. Oil joined a selloff for global
LANGUAGES 6 that Star India, the official broadcaster of day, BEST buses will provide free rides President Xi Jinping's equities as escalating trade
all International Cricket Council (ICC) across three prime routes in Mumbai. visit to a rare earths plant hostilities between the US
OF TELECAST 2015 events, could rake in as much as Star Sports also has an extensive pro- last week fuelled specula- and China stoked fears about
(Bengali, Tamil,
~1,800 crore from this year’s World Cup, grammingstrategy,includingregionallan- tion that China would use growth, while Opec and its
Malayalam,
against ~700 crore in the last season. guage feeds, to ensure the tournament’s its dominant position as a A man works at the site of a rare earth metals mine at allies vacillated about their
Kannada,
Gautam Thakar, CEO, Star Sports, reach expands. “One of the learnings from supplier of rare earths for Nancheng county, Jiangxi province, China FILE PHOTO next steps.
English, Hindi)
said: “We have in place a 360-degree the IPL is that we aim to carry forward leverage in the trade war. As of 10.50 pm IST, Brent
7 marketing plan starting with the core
thematic#CricketKaCrown, astheWorld
going deeply regional. We will have a big
opening for the tournament as well as
Rare earths are a group remarks from the editor of “Will rare earths become
of 17 chemical elements influential paper the Global a counter weapon for China
Crude was trading at $69.19
per barrel. Futures slumped
2015
(English, Hindi, Cup is regarded as the most prestigious India’s opening by telecasting the match- used in everything from Times on Twitter late on to hit back against the pres- as much as 3.8 per cent in
Tamil, Telugu, prize in world cricket. Bringing the com- es on some movie channels,” Thakar said. high-tech consumer elec- Tuesday. In a commentary sure the US has put on for no New York, putting them on
Kannada, Bengali, petitive element that every country holds The tourney’s and India’s first match- tronics to military headline “US, don't under- reason at all? The answer is track for their worst month-
Malayalam) during this tournament, the campaign es will be telecast on Star India’s general equipment. estimate China’s ability to no mystery,” it said. ly loss since December.
showcases the very nucleus of the sport entertainment channels like Maa Movies, While China has so far strike back”, the ruling “Undoubtedly, the US The plunge followed sug-
LANGUAGES
OF TELECAST 5
and how every team is going to England to Vijay Super, Jalsha Movies, Suvarna Plus, not explicitly said it will Communist Party's official side wants to use the prod- gestions in Chinese media
get their hands on the Crown of Cricket.” and Asianet Plus, along with sports chan- restrict rare earths exports People's Daily noted the ucts made by China's that the nation could restrict
2015 While a promo few weeks ago showed nels.Therestofthematches,includingthe to the US, Chinese media “uncomfortable” depend- exported rare earths to rare-earth exports critical to
each country gearing up for the India-Pakistan tie will be telecast on mul- has strongly implied this ence on rare earths from counter and suppress the US defense, energy and
15* tournament, Star Sports
released specific commer-
tiple channels across the Star network.
The network has roped in experts like
will happen, including China of the US. China's development. The electronics industries.
2019
cials. For example, the kick- Sachin Tendulkar for surround shows. It
off match on May 30 is being has planned shows like Fab 15, which
*Only first match and first
India match on 15
promoted through a creative
that draws on the insight that
focuses on the Indian squad, and Follow
the Blues, which provides off-the-field US drops India from Pakistan extends airspace
closure till June 15
channels. Rest will be
neither country has ever won insights into the teams.
currency watchlist
telecast on 10 channels