Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Get That Job! The Quick & Complete Guide To A Winning Interview
Get That Job! The Quick & Complete Guide To A Winning Interview
Thea Kelley
Asked what we do best, few of us would say "doing a great job interview."
Yet this is one of the most highly rewarded abilities in life. Skillful interviewing can be the determining
factor in how soon you start getting that new paycheck – and whether you land your dream job or have
to settle for something less.
This book will help you master this crucial skill so that you get the job and the career you want.
Get the job by being well prepared and being yourself.
Some people go into interviews thinking "I'll just be myself," but they're winging it, so it isn't their best
self that the interviewer sees and hears. Others prepare by the cookie-cutter approach, memorizing
answers recommended by experts and coming across as stiff and insincere.
My approach is based on authenticity and strategy, the "yin and yang" that work together for a
convincing interview. You'll be authentic – honest and natural – while being strategic in presenting what
the employer needs to know about the value you can bring to their organization.
You'll learn how to authentically and strategically use every aspect of the interview – from the first
handshake to the last question and answer – to stand out and get the job.
What are your challenges?
Most job seekers face difficulties in interviewing. This book will explore issues like these:
"I'm not comfortable with talking about myself and 'tooting my own horn.' "
"I haven't interviewed in a long time (or ever)."
"I have trouble with certain questions, like 'Tell me about yourself' and questions about weaknesses."
"I tend to ramble. I start talking and don't know when to stop."
"I get so nervous, sometimes I go blank and forget what question I'm answering."
"I have a negative issue in my work history and I don't know what to say about it."
"I can't think of a story or example when I need one."
"I don't know what I'm doing wrong – I'm just not getting offers."
This book will provide strategies to overcome obstacles like these, and more.
In Section One – First Things First: Preparing Your Core Messages – you'll build confidence and clarity
by identifying your key selling points and learning how to proactively emphasize those throughout the
interview. Your answers will become more relevant, compelling and convincing.
In Section Two – Questions: Answering and Asking – you'll gain strategies for handling any question
that may come your way, plus specific tips on dozens of the most common questions. You'll also learn to
ask insightful and well-targeted questions that help you assess the job and impress the interviewer.
In Section Three – Nailing the Nonverbals – you'll polish the unspoken aspects of your presentation,
including body language and clothes, and learn techniques for eliminating nervousness and self-doubt.
We'll also explore how to stand out through effective use of "interview extras" like portfolios and
presentations.
In Section Four – Know What to Expect – you'll get familiar with 12 different types of interviews and
how to succeed in all of them. We'll also clear up some misunderstandings about references to make
sure you sail smoothly from the final interview into an offer.
Finally, in Section Five – Happy Endings and Great Beginnings – you'll learn to conclude the interview
effectively and follow up strongly, reinforcing the positive brand you've built up through the interview.
You'll also get prepared to juggle offers, negotiate for the pay and working conditions you want and
ensure a smooth transition into your new job!
This book is quick to read. Preparing to be the winner of a competitive interview process, on the other
hand, takes time. So start now.
An interview can happen anytime. If you've sent out a single resume, or simply have a strong profile on
LinkedIn, you could be called for a phone screening any day now. Recruiters like to take a casual tone in
these "conversations," but don't be lulled: it's an interview. Even in-person interviews can happen on
very short notice.
Work your way through these five sections and you'll be well equipped to stand out from other
applicants and get the offer. So let's get started and get you ready.
Section One
First Things First: Preparing Your Core
Messages
CHAPTER 1
What Makes You Stand Out? Your REV Points
Section Two
Questions: Answering and Asking
CHAPTER 5
How to Answer Any Interview Question
Wise men speak because they have something to say; fools because they have to say something.
– Plato
Answer Authentically and Strategically
Authenticity and strategy could almost be called the "yin and yang" of good interviewing – except that
they aren't opposites. The opposite of authenticity is phoniness, and the opposite of strategy is
randomness, or carelessness.
Many job candidates fail to be strategic. They may interview in an honest and straightforward way, but
without being clear what messages they're trying to communicate or how their answers are going to get
them the job (or not).
Being strategic means asking yourself "How is this question an opportunity to sell my abilities? Keep
your eyes on the prize! This will make your answers more compelling and relevant.
Even "negative" sounding questions like "What is your weakness?" are an opportunity to sell yourself by
showing that you are self-aware, realistic about your limitations and always striving to improve.
Being strategic means proactively taking responsibility for making sure your message comes across. Let's
say you've got some great stories prepared, but nothing the interviewer says gives you an opportunity
to bring them up. Make your own opportunity. Say something like "Speaking of X, may I tell you about
…?" or "(Name), we haven't talked about X, but there's something important I wanted to say about that,
if we have a moment…"
Being strategic also includes planning out answers to some of the more crucial or tricky questions you
may be asked.
Other candidates don't come across as being authentic. They give "right" answers that reflect what
they think the interviewer wants to hear, but the answers sound "canned" and insincere. Maybe they
found these "right" answers in a book. Or they thought up their own answers, but they've memorized
them, word for word, like a speech. This kind of presentation doesn't build trust, nor does it
demonstrate good communication skills. And it's boring!
In mock interviews I often hear candidates struggling to give a perfect answer that has very little
connection to what's true for them. I ask them, "Okay, forget about the interview version for now. Just
between you and me, what's the plain answer?"
You might think of this as your "best-friend answer" – one with no caution or polish, just the blunt truth.
Usually this spontaneous answer, or at least part of it, contains the core of a perfectly good interview
answer. It will probably need some pruning and polishing, but in the end, you'll be more authentic and
believable than if you had gone straight for the safe and perfect, by-the-book answer.
No discussion of authenticity is complete without a word about lying. As we all know, people sometimes
lie about their qualifications. In the short run it may get them the job, but it may result in termination if
the lie is discovered – and quite possibly, far-reaching damage to their reputations. Even if the lie is
never discovered, they live in fear and must hide their secret from everyone they work with. This is not
necessary. There's invariably a better way to address tricky issues such as a long career gap, having been
fired, a negative work incident or even a criminal record. (Some of these will be covered in Chapter 7,
Common But Not Easy.)
Be both authentic and strategic in your interviewing and let the interviewer see the best of who you
really are.
Know What the Interviewer Is Looking for
There are three unspoken questions an interviewer has about you, which you can think of as the Three
C's of Interviewing. (The following is derived from a model developed by the outplacement firm Lee
Hecht Harrison.) The three C's are Competence, Compatibility with the company culture, and Chemistry.
Competence: Of course, the interviewer wants to make sure you can do the job, and do it well. This is
what we all tend to think the whole interview is about: whether the candidate has the necessary
experience, technical skills and soft skills. But actually there's more.
Compatibility with the company culture: They also want to make sure you'll work well in this particular
environment, especially if it's quite different from the organizations you've worked in before. For
example, some organizations are very hard-driving and competitive, while others are more
collaborative; some are very hierarchical and formal, while others are more open and want everyone to
be a leader. Show the employer that you understand and appreciate their company culture and will
work well within it. If you have more experience with that type of culture than your resume indicates,
clarify that.
Chemistry: Last but not least, they want a sense that you'll "click" with the boss and team members and
that they'll enjoy spending a big chunk of their waking hours with you, day after day. Don't
underestimate or forget the importance of liking and being liked by the people you're meeting – all of
them, including the receptionist, shuttle driver and so on. Much of this comes down to everyday things
like friendly chitchat, showing an interest in people, active listening, and body language such as a firm
handshake, eye contact and a warm smile. In many cases, chemistry is even more important than
competence.
Understand Before You Answer
We've all been taught in school to answer quickly, but answering instantly in an interview can give the
impression that you're not taking the question seriously, or that you have your answers memorized.
Answering too quickly can also lead to the embarrassing experience of realizing, in the middle of your
answer, that you've forgotten the question. So pause for a moment – usually two to five seconds is
about right – and repeat the question silently to yourself. If the question is long or complex, repeat it
aloud to ensure you've got it right.
While you're at it, make sure you fully understand the question. Is it a behavioral question, requiring you
to tell a story? Make sure you tell one. Does the question have multiple parts? Get ready to answer
them all.
Is the question vague or unclear? Ask for clarification if necessary. "I'd love to answer that, and before I
do, could you just clarify for me which aspect of…" This is skillful communication – and it will enable you
to give a more relevant answer.
There's another major advantage in asking questions related to what's being discussed: it makes the
interview feel more like a dialogue or conversation, and less like an interrogation. That makes it more
enjoyable – and a person who enjoyed their conversation with you is more likely to want to work with
you.
Listen Between the Lines
Think about what the employer is trying to find out with each question. Usually it's straightforward, as in
"Tell me about your experience with (technique or task)." On the other hand, a question about your
boss is indirect: it's really a question about you, and whether you're easy to manage, and whether you
speak respectfully of others even when they're not present.
Be Specific and Concrete
Question: "What's your management style?" Answer: "I'm fair, my door is always open, and I coach my
team to excel and help them move up."
This answer sounds trite, uninteresting and vague. It neither informs nor persuades! Why not? Because
it lacks the specific details that would make it real and convincing. What do you mean by "fair"? Can you
give an example? Do you have a special philosophy or motto about coaching? Can you tell a story about
a team member whose career you helped transform?
Use Sound Bites
Public figures use sound bites – short, memorable phrases and slogans – because they are easily
remembered when more wordy, generic language has been forgotten. Of course, you can't always speak
in sound bites – it would be difficult and just plain weird – but as you think about your answers, watch
for the kinds of short, expressive language that we all come across every day.
One candidate told me her motto at work is "Have fun, but get it done!" That's a memorable phrase.
Another told me he created a bit of software that caused a teammate in a staff meeting to say "That's
the coolest thing I've ever seen!" It's not Shakespeare, but it packs a punch. Look for "sound bites" like
these in your LinkedIn recommendations and performance reviews. Memorize them – they are quotes,
after all – and sprinkle them into your interviews.
Keep It Positive
Never volunteer a negative about yourself, such as confessing to a weakness when the interviewer hasn't
asked about your weaknesses.
Don't say what you didn't like about any past job, unless asked to do so.
Don't badmouth your former boss, co-workers or company. This is one of the surest ways to destroy your
chances at a job interview.
Occasionally, a story about your own accomplishments might unavoidably mention challenges created by
others: a co-worker not pulling their own weight, or an underperforming employee you managed. Be very
tactful, respectful, objective and brief about the behavior. Preserve this person's reputation by omitting
any information that would allow anyone to identify them.
Handle Negatives Skillfully
Sometimes you have to address a negative, as when you're asked a question about your weaknesses,
mistakes and failures, or why you left (or were fired from) past jobs. These questions can actually be
opportunities to demonstrate strengths such as transparency, resilience, and learning valuable lessons
from experience.
To handle these type of questions effectively, follow these pointers:
• Plan and practice your answers. Planning your talking points is always smart, and these
questions may even justify an exception to my warning about scripting exact language. And do
practice with someone – a peer or an interview coach.
• Use the "sandwich" technique: surround the negatives with positives. "Why did I leave Positive
Promotions? I loved my work there, and I played a key role in many major wins, such as (maybe
three ultra-brief examples), which I can tell you more about today. Then I was diagnosed with
Ravel Syndrome, and I had to take a year off to recover my health. Last month my doctor said
I'm fully recovered and should be fine from now on. I feel great and I've been attending
conferences and reading a lot to refresh my skills while looking for the right opportunity. I'm
very excited about this opening."
• Keep the negative part brief. See the example above, where the reason for leaving the job takes
up only one-fifth of the answer. It can be hard to be brief about something you have strong
feelings about. Questions like "Tell me about a difficult person you had to work with" or "Why
do you want to leave your job?" present a strong temptation to kvetch and commiserate,
particularly when your interviewer has the natural empathy we often see among human
resources folks. Resist that urge firmly.
• Set your feelings aside and speak in an emotionally neutral manner. This may require that you
work through those feelings ahead of time. Try journaling, talking to a trusted friend, reading
self-help books or getting professional help. As every pro athlete or performer knows, state of
mind is crucial to success.
• Don't create negative sound bites. As author Jeff Haden has written, "Interviewers will only
remember a few sound bites, especially negative ones. Don't say, 'I've never been in charge of
training.' Say, 'I did not fill that specific role, but I have trained dozens of new hires and created
several training guides.'" Rather than saying "I haven't" or "I can't," tell them what you have
done and can do.
Know that the Interviewer Wants You to Succeed
Good news! The interviewer would like nothing better than to be wowed by you, to know that his
problem – lacking an employee – is about to be solved. Begin thinking of the interviewer as a future
colleague who thinks highly of your skills, and with whom you'll soon have a friendly and productive
working relationship.
Be Concise
Long-winded, wandering answers can be a deal-breaker. Employers don't want to hire people who
ramble on and don't get to the point, or who don't leave enough air space for others to talk – especially
themselves!
How long should your answers be? Telling a complex and important story, such as "the accomplishment
you're most proud of," may warrant two minutes, or even a bit more. But most interview questions can
– and should – be answered in less than a minute.
Does answering in less than 60 seconds sound difficult? Have you found yourself rambling in past
interviews, unsure when or how to finish your answer? The next chapter will help you make a great
impression keeping all of your answers concise and to the point.
CHAPTER 6
How to Speak Concisely
If it takes a lot of words to say what you have in mind, give it more thought.
– Author Dennis Roth
“Begin at the beginning," the King said, very gravely, "and go on till you come to the end: then stop.”
― Lewis Carroll's Alice in Wonderland
One of the most common ways to fail a job interview is to give long, wandering answers to the
interviewer's questions. You need them to be excited about you – not overwhelmed or bored.
Most interview questions can and should be answered in less than a minute. Others, especially where
you're telling a story, may take two minutes or more. An answer longer than five minutes is probably a
mistake.
Be concise. You've heard that before, but it's not as easy as it sounds. How can you do it?
Know What You Need to Say
The main cause of rambling is a lack of clarity about where you're going in your answer. In Chapter 1 you
saw that identifying the Situation, Actions, Obstacles and Results in your SOAR story can help you cover
the key points efficiently, like checking items off a list. And in Chapter 3 you saw how a talking-points
outline can help you prepare a clear and concise answer to "Tell me about yourself."
Other common questions can be treated in the same way. Plan your answers by noting your talking
points, then timing yourself as you use them to run through your answer aloud. After going through this
process multiple times over a period of days, you're likely to find yourself being more concise even on
answers you haven't prepared!
Know How to End
Sometimes we ramble because we're looking for an ending – something to tie up your answer neatly,
like "…and they all lived happily ever after," or "…and that's how they saved the world." Interview
answers can actually end in a similar way!
Here are four ways to end your statements:
1. Results. If you're telling a story you can end with the impact and benefits of your work: "This
new program increased revenues 20% and became the model for similar efforts in five other
divisions."
2. Referring back to the interviewer's question. "So that's how I'd describe my management
style."
3. Relating what you've said to the job/company you're interviewing for. "Have you had similar
situations here?" or "Does that sound like a strategy that could work here?"
4. A question: "Is there anything more you'd like to know about what I've just said?"
As you prepare answers, make a point of practicing each of these four types of endings, so that you get
in the habit of using them.
Still "Going Long"?
Here are two practice techniques that are bound to make a difference.
• Give too-concise answers (yes! actually too short!), followed by a question like: "Would you like
more detail in any area of that?"
•
Once you've practiced lots of too-short answers, you can then make your way back towards a
perfect "Goldilocks Zone" where your answers are not too short, not too long, but just right.
• "Bottom line" your answers. In other words, when you find you're rambling, interrupt yourself
with one of these phrases:
o "To get straight to the bottom line…"
o "And the essence of this story is…"
o "To make a long story short…"
…And then get straight to the point.
By now you're probably itching to get your hands on some specific interview questions. In the next
chapter we'll look at many of the most common questions, with tips for answering them in a way that
shows you at your best.
CHAPTER 7
Common But Not Easy: Questions You'll Need to Answer
First learn the meaning of what you say, and then speak.
– Epictetus
The trouble with talking too fast is you may say something you haven't thought of yet.
– Ann Landers
We all know many jobs are being replaced by automation these days; even by robots. But if you're
interviewing for a job, it means the employer doesn't want a robot. Interviewers are sick of robotic,
"canned" answers candidates have read in books. So instead of feeding you readymade answers, I'm
going to help you think through and prepare your own answers – ones that are both authentic and
strategic.
"Tell me about yourself."
This question is so important it has a chapter all to itself. If you haven't already read and worked with
Chapter 3, now is the time.
"What is your greatest strength?"
Think about those key selling points you identified in Chapter 1. What's at the top of that list? It should
be a strength that has all the REV factors: one that is Relevant, Exceptional and Verifiable. Illustrate your
point with a story.
"Why should we hire you?"
Focus on your key selling points and how they relate to the organization and its needs. This may be very
similar to your answer to "Tell me about yourself," but say it a different way, using different examples.
"Tell me about the accomplishment you are most proud of."
If you've done your work with Chapter 2, you have plenty of SOAR stories to choose from in answering
this question. Your answer may be taken as a reflection not only of your skills but also what makes you
proud – in other words, what you find valuable and motivating. Make sure your choice is highly relevant
to the job you're interviewing for.
"Why do you want this job?"
What is it about the role, the product, the mission and/or the organization that excites you? List these
things in your mind. Your answer should be built upon the items that are central to doing the job, the
things that will motivate you on a day-to-day basis, especially that the role is a good fit for your interests
and skills, and that you love the product or believe in the mission. You can also add, as a secondary
reason, that you feel like you'll be compatible with the company culture or that you've heard it's a great
place to work. Avoid emphasizing that you're excited about the money, the location or the hours.
"What's your ideal work environment?"
First, ask yourself why the interviewer is asking this question. Are they planning to go out of their way to
make sure you have the ideal work environment? No? So why are they asking?
Once you think about it, you undoubtedly realize that they're trying to find out (a) whether their
environment is similar to what you're looking for, and (b) whether you're reasonable and flexible in your
expectations.
Focus your answer on common, reasonable factors that will motivate you to do your best – like a team
environment, open sharing of information, or a focus on customer satisfaction. Don't talk about
preferences that are more self-focused such as amenities or benefits, or superficial items such as the
appearance of the office. And make it clear that you do not require ideal circumstances and can perform
excellently under a wide range of conditions.
"Where do you see yourself in five years?"
Why are they asking you this?
For one thing, they want to know whether the job aligns with your goals, and thus whether you'll stick
around. They may also be hoping you have some ambition. Ambitious people often make better
employees. They're more motivated, and they may work harder and smarter. They make a point of
growing their abilities.
On the other hand, those who come in with their eye on a higher position and view the current role only
as a stepping stone may be impatient and lack commitment to the tasks at hand.
So give an answer that combines a desire to grow, on the one hand, with realism, patience and
commitment on the other.
Before the interview, see if you can find information about paths to advancement from within the
position. If the only position you can advance to is that of the person you're interviewing with, proceed
with care! He probably won't like the idea that you have your eye on his job, so just talk about growing
and taking on more responsibility.
In most cases you won't have much information, in which case it's safest to start with a general answer
followed by a question, like this:
"Over the next few years I see myself building my skills, taking on more responsibility and moving up, if
it's appropriate. Can you tell me about how others have advanced from this role?"
Note: Although the question often includes the phrase "five years," you don't have to be that precise in
your answer. More open-ended terms like "over the next several years" may be best.
"Why do you want to leave your current job?"
Some reasons are easy to talk about:
• You like your current job, and are only interviewing because you saw another opportunity too
exciting to resist.
• You are successful in your current job but wish to make a career change that your current
company can't offer you – e.g., a shift into a different industry.
• There is no path for advancement from your current role.
• You need to relocate to a different city or state, and your current company can't transfer you.
It's trickier if you're leaving because of a problem – that the company is poorly managed, your boss is
difficult, or such.
It's ironic that while the number one reason most people quit jobs is because of their bosses, that is the
last reason you can safely talk about in an interview. Likewise, it's poor practice to criticize your current
company, especially if you would be revealing issues that are not publicly known.
As with "Why did you leave your past job," take a look at all the reasons you might want to leave, and
focus on reasons that present you in a good light.
"Why did you leave your job?"
If you left and immediately started a new job, this is easy: you left for a better opportunity (or what you
thought was a better opportunity, if it didn’t work out).
But leaving without a new job lined up is generally a red flag, so this question is tricky.
The key is this: although one reason may dominate in your mind – probably the most emotional one,
such as a personality conflict or issue with the boss – usually there are more reasons. List them all on a
piece of paper. Then see which of these reasons makes the best impression.
Example:
Joe quit his job for the following reasons: (1) his boss was a micromanager, (2) the company, a hospital,
had toxic office politics, (3) the circumstances made it difficult or impossible to move up into a better
department, (4) he couldn't stay until he found a new job because the job left him no time or energy for
job search, and (5) he also had an itch to move into the pharmaceutical industry.
Reasons 1 and 2 are a minefield that would be hard to discuss without presenting himself as a
complainer who badmouths his former employer. But he doesn't need to go there; he can build a
truthful answer out of reasons 3-5:
"While Bayworth Hospital is a great institution in terms of patient care, and I had three excellent years
there, with strong accomplishments like the ones we've discussed, there really wasn't a path upward for
me there any more (reason #3). It was time to leave and pursue my longtime interest in pharmaceutical
companies (#5) like this one. The job was intensely demanding and it didn't leave me the energy to
conduct a search. (#4) So I gave notice, helped the department make a smooth transition, and then left
to devote myself to a full-time process of transitioning into doing what I'm most passionate about."
Why does this answer work? Because it's true, tactful, brief (30 seconds) and focused on the positive.
It's also a great example of the "sandwich technique": surrounding a negative (the fact that he left) with
positives (his respect for the hospital in certain ways, his accomplishments and his passion for the
current opportunity).
What if Joe had been fired?
In a past chapter I said "Never volunteer a negative." Joe doesn't need to say he was fired, unless
specifically asked (see the next question). His answer could be the same as above, with a slightly
different ending:
"…It was time to leave and pursue my longtime interest in pharmaceutical companies like this one. Since
then I've devoted myself to a full-time process of transitioning into doing what I'm most passionate
about."
Because this subject is emotionally charged for Joe, he would be wise to rehearse this answer with great
care.
Joe also needs to be prepared for the likelihood the interviewer will ask additional questions that will
reveal that he was fired.
"Have you been fired? What happened?"
First of all, realize that having been fired is probably more of a big deal to you than it is to the
prospective employer.
Keep your answer short and sweet: brief and emotionally neutral.
Here are some effective ways people have explained being fired:
• I was a valued member of the team, as I've described, for five years. Then a new manager came
in (or there was a reorganization, or the company was bought) and a large percentage of the
staff and leadership were let go, including me. The new manager then filled the team with
people he had worked with at a past company. The silver lining is that now I'm able to interview
for this exciting new opportunity.
• Looking back, I've realized the job and I weren't really a good fit. I was successful with (aspects
that are similar to the job you're interviewing for), but not as strong on (parts that are different).
I'm much better suited to a position like the one we're talking about today.
• Although I did accomplish many milestones in that role, I realize I also made some mistakes. It's
been a learning experience for me. What I learned was … and I took that learning with me to my
next role, where I was much more successful. For example …
Notice how these answers begin and end with something positive, with the negative sandwiched in
between. You can use this "sandwich" technique whenever you need to address something negative.
Whatever you say, it is important to say it without radiating anger, fear or shame. Work on your state
of mind if you need to, perhaps with the aid of self-help books or counseling.
Don't take having been fired too seriously or personally. "Good people get fired every day," according to
Tim Sackett, who runs a staffing agency. (Interesting surname, considering his occupation and the topic
of his blog post!) "They get fired for making bad decisions. They get fired for pissing off the wrong
person. They get fired because they didn’t fit your culture. They get fired because of bad job fit." Or
because of office politics.
Many of the most successful people in the world have been fired: Steve Jobs was fired from Apple, then
returned years later. Oprah Winfrey, Walt Disney, Lee Iacocca, J.K. Rowling and Thomas Edison all got
the boot. Look up "successful people who have been fired" online. You'll see that the list goes on and
on. You're in good company.
Note: Being fired is not the same as being laid off. If your position was eliminated as part of a staff
reduction, your answer is easier. You can say something like, "A business decision was made to
eliminate a number of positions" – state how many, if it's a reasonably large number – "including mine."
Surround this brief statement with positives as in the examples above.
"What is your greatest weakness?"
In most cases, the interviewer isn't just asking this to find out if there's a weakness that would disqualify
you. They're even more interested in finding out whether you're self-aware and willing to openly discuss
your shortcomings, which would indicate that you probably take feedback well. They want to hear that
you are committed to continually improving your skills.
With that in mind, try talking about…
…a weakness that's closely connected to one of your greatest strengths. For example, if you're
great at relationship-building and that's crucial to the job you're applying for, you might mention
that you sometimes spend more time listening to a client or co-worker than you intended to.
(But if it really isn't a weakness at all, it will sound evasive and insincere, so pick something else.)
…an "elephant in the room" weakness that's already very noticeable to the employer – such as
having less experience than they would prefer, or a thick accent – so you have nothing to lose by
bringing it up.
…a weakness you have largely overcome or that you compensate for very successfully.
No matter what weakness you bring up, keep it brief and spend more time talking about how you're
overcoming it than about what a problem it is. And avoid words like "weakness" and "problem" in your
answer. Use more positive words like "challenge," "growing edge" and "area where I'm growing."
Of course, don't bring up a weakness that would cause them to seriously doubt you can do the job.
Realize that certain answers – especially "I'm a perfectionist" and "I work too hard" – have been used so
often they've become clichés and should be avoided, unless you can put a fresh spin on them.
"What's one area / three areas where your boss wants you to
improve?"
This is similar to the question above, and can be approached similarly, but with an even more positive
spin, since they're not actually asking for a negative. You can talk about things you do well but would like
to do even better, or a skill that's so cutting-edge that only a really committed professional would be
concerned about it. And I've heard people succeed with approaches more frank and transparent than
this, as long as the issue they mention is not major and good progress is being made.
"Why is there a gap in your employment?"
Employers tend to assume that everyone wants to be employed continually. If you weren't, they may
wonder what the problem was. They may imagine a serious physical or mental illness such as cancer,
major depression or alcohol/drug abuse. Or maybe that you lost your job and were unable to find a new
one after many months. If other employers passed you up for a year, they may feel reluctant to take a
chance on you.
First, address how the gap started. Read the tips under "Why did you leave your job?" or "Have you
been fired?" above. If the situation is not likely to recur, explain why – for example, that you were caring
for an ill family member who has now recovered or for whom other caregivers have been secured.
Talk about any positive activities you were engaged in, such as travel, education or volunteer work. You
want to show that you're energetic and like to work, learn and grow.
If you are unemployed and haven't worked in several months, I recommend you start participating in
updating your skills, doing pro bono work and/or consulting now – don't put it off! – and mention those
activities in your interviews.
"Tell me about a major mistake you made."
As with the "weakness" questions, the intention here is to see whether you are open to admitting,
taking responsibility for and learning from your mistakes. No one wants employees who will sweep their
mistakes under the rug or blame them on others. They also want to hear that you clean up after yourself
where possible, going the extra mile to make things right.
"On a software project I managed, a certain manager didn't come to the regular meetings until the final
one where everyone was supposed to sign off. There, at the last minute, he objected to a great new
feature the team was excited about. Later I realized how I could have countered that objection, but at
the time it caught me by surprise, I didn't make a good case for it, and the feature was left off. What I
learned for the future was to always make sure the key stakeholders are involved early, and that's what
I've done since then. Anyway, I worked hard to ensure that the new feature would be in the next release
– and it was!"
"What would you look to accomplish in the first 30/60/90 days?"
This question is typically asked of sales, managerial and executive candidates, among others. It tends to
occur late in the interview process. Preparing a written plan to present is a good idea, as described in
Chapter 11, "Something Extra." If other candidates don't do this and you do, you'll stand out.
Your plan should demonstrate that you have learned from your previous interviews with this company,
done additional homework and understand the company and its priorities, that you will get up to speed
quickly, put in extra time, respect and learn from those who have been there longer, and add value soon
after hire.
"Tell me how you handled a difficult situation."
This is a behavioral interview question; it requires you to tell a story. The employer is hoping the story
will show that you have skills and strengths like resourcefulness, creative problem solving ability,
emotional intelligence, resilience, team leadership skills, diplomacy, staying calm and rational under
pressure, and possibly technical skills as well.
Avoid using an example where you were the cause of the difficulty! At the same time, don't blame
anybody else. Remember to be tactful; don't "talk down" your past company, boss or co-workers.
As in any story, make sure you include the successful results, which in this case might be that you
prevented or at least reduced the damage that could have occurred, and that you maintained morale
and good relationships. Point out how you learned from the situation and implemented measures to
prevent future occurrences.
"Give me an example of a time you had to deal with an angry customer
or client."
Most of us have dealt skillfully with an angry customer, or an upset co-worker, or a very anxious client.
What many of us have trouble doing is explaining how we did it. Often our people skills are somewhat
unconscious; we may have "helped the person calm down" but we don't know how.
If you've ever had formal training in handling difficult interactions – for example, in customer service
training – review that in your mind and apply the concepts and language to the incident you're
remembering. This will help you describe it, as well as demonstrating that you have tools for such
situations.
If you don't have such training, review the situation carefully in your memory. What did you say or do
that worked? Did telling the person "Calm down" help? (Usually it doesn't.) Did listening help? (Usually it
does.) What else did you say or do?
What was the outcome? Try to say more than just "He calmed down and was pleased." What did you
specifically observe that tells you he was pleased? Did he stop yelling and thank you, renew his
subscription, give you a "10" in a survey later, write a letter to your manager?
Show empathy for the customer in the way you tell this story. If you don't feel any empathy for them,
dig deeper – or tell a different story.
"Tell me about a time when you went above and beyond
requirements."
Companies want employees and leaders who consistently go above and beyond. If you're having trouble
thinking of examples, think of various projects and situations in which you excelled and showed great
dedication, and ask yourself whether everything you did was really required.
Sometimes going above and beyond means taking the lead. One recent graduate told the story of a
school project on which the work was delayed due to a conflict between team members. She took the
initiative to assign each team member a role and tasks that fit their individual abilities. As a result, the
project was completed on time and received an excellent grade.
"What do you know about our company?"
This is where you need to have done some research, preferably going beyond simply skimming the
website. Show that you know not only the basics of the company history, leadership, products and
culture, but also understand its competitive position, financial condition, challenges and opportunities,
and recent news coverage.
Common related questions are "Who is our CEO?" and "Who are our competitors?"
"What are your salary expectations?"
Answering this question too specifically can lose you a lot of money, or an opportunity. Naming a figure
that's too low can result in a lower offer, or even loss of the opportunity if your answer creates doubt
about your value. A figure that's too high can immediately disqualify you.
This is one of the few questions where formulaic, memorized verbiage may be the best approach.
First, as soon as you apply for a job make sure you understand the range of typical salaries for the
position and geographic area, because this may be one of the first questions you will be asked in a
phone screen, which could happen at any time.
You can research salaries via websites like Salary, Payscale, Glassdoor, Indeed, CareerOneStop,
JobSearchIntelligence, via a simple Google search, and sometimes via word of mouth. Use more than
one source, since a broader range may give you more negotiating flexibility.
When the question is asked, respond with "Can you tell me what range you have budgeted for the
position?"
If they tell you a range, say something like, "That seems like a reasonable ballpark. I'm sure once we
agree I'm the right person for the job, we'll be able to agree on a salary that's fair."
If they won't state their range and put the question back onto you, say something like, "I've done some
research and I'm seeing salaries anywhere from X to Y. I'm sure once we agree I'm the right person for
the job we'll be able to agree on a salary that's fair."
"How much are/were you making at your current/previous job?"
There are a couple of options here. You can decline to state, saying something like "I'd rather learn more
about the position and how well I fit what you're looking for, before we discuss salary issues," or "It
would be difficult to compare my last salary with this position for several reasons, including that I don't
have enough information about your whole package. I'm sure we can agree on compensation."
If you will be changing careers or industries, you might point out that this makes your current/recent
salary less relevant.
On the other hand, if your salary has been very similar to what you expect you would be offered – or if it
appears you won't be considered without providing the information – it might be best to just go ahead
and give them the information. If your current salary is low, include the value of any bonuses and perks
in the figure you give.
"How is your search going? Have you been having other interviews?"
There are two reasons they might be asking.
On the one hand, they may be wondering whether you're about to accept another offer. A safe answer
is something like, "I've been meeting with other people and discussing various opportunities, but
nothing is concrete yet."
On the other hand, if you have been unemployed for more than a few months, they may wonder
whether there's some reason you aren't getting hired. They may be leery of taking a chance on someone
who has been passed over by many other companies.
It's usually best to avoid identifying the other companies you've interviewed with, since they see their
hiring activities as confidential. Instead refer to them generically, for example as "a few Tier One tech
companies" or "several small design firms."
"Tell me about a time you disagreed with your boss."
Most managers would like their staff to speak up in a constructive way when they disagree with
directives. After all, they have their hands more closely on the work and may know something the boss
doesn't. The best answer here would involve a congenial disagreement in which both parties had good
reasons for their opinions, you communicated yours tactfully and factually, and your input led to a
better solution. It would also be acceptable if the boss didn't act on your input, as long as the story
shows you accepting the decision in a professional and fully engaged manner.
If the disagreement resolved in your favor, make sure you don't sound smug about it!
"What's your availability?" or "How soon could you start?"
If you're unemployed and would like to start work immediately, you can say so, but avoid sounding like
you're desperate for a paycheck ASAP! If you'd prefer a later date, say something like "I'm quite
available and I'd be happy to discuss a start date that works for both of us, once we agree that my
abilities and the role are a good fit."
If you're currently employed, it's reasonable to state that you'll need to give at least two weeks' notice.
Since the interviewer would hope for the same consideration when you leave, he will probably respect
this.
If you think some negotiation may be needed on this point, keep the discussion general and don't make
a commitment. The best time to negotiate is after they've offered you the job.
"What motivates you / gets you up in the morning / makes you excited
about Mondays?"
If you can't say "excited about Mondays" with a straight face, don't use that phrase in your answer! But
do show passion for the specific challenges and rewards of the work itself – solving problems (such as?),
collaborating and learning from team members (say more!), achieving goals (like what?), making a
difference (how?) – rather than vague generalities like "working with people" or peripheral issues like
the pay or benefits.
"How do you handle conflict at work? Please give an example."
Conflict is inevitable when two or more people are working together. Employers want to know that you
can resolve conflicts – whether between you and someone else, or between two others – in a
constructive way.
Most examples involve talking things over with the parties involved, but many interviewees are too
vague, saying "We talked it over and resolved the issue."
Say a bit more, illustrating the communication and interpersonal skills you used. What happened in that
conversation? Did you try to understand the other person's point of view? What questions did you ask?
How did you listen to the answers? What did you learn from the other person that helped you resolve the
problem? Did you express empathy, offer ideas, or what? And as in any story, be specific about the
beneficial outcomes.
Other candidates make an even worse mistake, choosing a situation they still feel emotional about and
getting emotionally "hooked" into ranting on about how bad the situation was and the awful things
people did or said. Choose an example that you're sure you can describe in a completely calm and even-
handed manner.
"Tell me about a time you had to work with someone you didn't like,
or who didn't like you."
First of all, don't reinforce an image of yourself as someone who dislikes or is disliked by others. Reframe
it as a situation where it was a challenge to work effectively with this person.
This question requires you to say something negative about a co-worker, which is generally a no-no in
interviews. So be tactful by not giving any information that could identify who this person is.
Take an emotionally neutral tone. Resist the urge to kvetch, even if the interviewer encourages it by
offering you sympathy.
Avoid characterizing the co-worker in judgmental terms like "Nothing was ever right as far as he was
concerned" or "She wasn't a team player." Instead, describe the specific behavior objectively: "He would
often make negative comments about team members" or "We needed her to provide a report every
Monday, but it usually wasn't done until mid-week."
Be very brief about the difficult behavior, focusing primarily on what you did to make the best of the
situation and how well it turned out. Treat this as a SOAR story, emphasizing the positive results.
"What would your boss / direct reports / teammates say about you?"
Of course you want your answer to support your key selling points and other relevant skills and
strengths. The trick is not just to put the desired words into these people's mouths, but actually ask
yourself how they would say it. This can lead to interesting quotes or turns of phrase that show that
you're authentically answering the question that has been asked.
"What are your boss's strengths and weaknesses?"
Of course, this question is not really about your boss. It's about you: what kind of relationship you tend
to have with your manager; whether you're easy to manage.
Name a few of your manager's strengths – and even if they're a terrible boss, find something to
wholeheartedly admire.
Good grief, do they really expect you to talk about your bosses' weaknesses? It's a test. Don't take the
bait! After praising a few strengths, say "I'd rather not comment on any weaknesses." If you think highly
of your boss, close by saying so.
But don't rave about how great your boss is. That's a little like telling a date how much you adored your
ex!
"What's the last book you read for fun?"
Let's assume the interviewer isn't being nosy, but just wants to get to know you better as a person.
Name any book you've read within the last couple of months that supports your brand – or at least
presents you as an intelligent person. If you don't read books – as many people don't, these days –
mention something you read online, such as a blog.
"What are your co-worker pet peeves?" or "What makes you
uncomfortable in the workplace?"
Don't use the word "pet peeve" in your response, lest it sound like you cherish your annoyances. Choose
something that would displease anyone, such as co-workers who don't pull their own weight. Because
this is a negative, sandwich it between positives.
"I'm generally very focused on my own work. Of course, like anyone I don't like to see team members
not pulling their own weight. As an individual contributor it isn't my place to come down on that kind of
thing, but if it's affecting my work I'll generally talk it over with them and see if we can resolve any issues
that are getting in the way. For example…"
"What question haven't I asked you, that I should have?"
A question like this is a nice opportunity. What would you like to say that hasn't been covered yet? Do
you have a great story you haven't had a chance to tell? Smile and say something like "Well, I'd love to
tell you about…" Or if you're stumped, say "Actually, you've been very complete! I do have some
questions for you. Is it time for that?"
The questions we've looked at so far have been quite normal – you might say, vanilla. Let's get into
some of the more complex flavors – maybe a bit more nutty, maybe more of a, shall we say, rocky road.
CHAPTER 8
Quirky Questions: Puzzling, Stressful, Off-the-Wall or Illegal
Why is a raven like a writing desk?
– The Mad Hatter, in Lewis Carroll's Alice in Wonderland
The questions in this chapter are – mercifully – less common than the ones we've discussed previously.
But let's make sure you're prepared for whatever comes your way.
Off-the-wall
Let's start with the friendlier questions we'll encounter in this chapter, the odd inquiries like "If you
could have any superpower, what power would you choose, and why?" or "What would the title of your
debut album be?"
These kinds of questions are intended to give insight into your personality and values. They also test
whether you react flexibly to the unexpected.
As silly as you may find these questions, answer pleasantly and try to make your answer relevant. For
example, if you're interviewing for a job where managing people is key, you might say "It's important to
me to understand my team – what motivates them, what they know and don't know, and what their
concerns are. So mind-reading might be useful. But I think I'd rather just talk to them!"
Puzzles
Puzzle questions may sound similarly odd, like "Why are manhole covers round?" or "How many golf
balls will fit into a Boeing 747?" But the difference is that these questions may actually have right
answers, or at least smarter and less-smart ones.
In the early 2000s, tech companies like Microsoft and Google led a trend in using this type of question to
try to assess candidates' intelligence and creative problem-solving skills. Although the approach has lost
some popularity in recent years, due to doubts about whether it works, you may still be asked this type
of question.
To handle puzzle questions:
• Don't rush into answering. Start problem-solving out loud. Ask questions, if appropriate.
• If the first answer that comes to mind seems too easy, rethink it. There may be a trick to it.
• On the other hand, an apparently complex problem may be simpler than it appears. If it seems
to involve higher math, look for an easier solution.
• If you're stuck, examine your assumptions, one by one.
• If there seems to be no one right answer, great! That gives you the opportunity to develop a
uniquely creative, memorable one.
Are you wondering about the quote at the top of the chapter? How a raven is like a writing desk? Lewis
Carroll answered his own question many years after Alice in Wonderland was published: "Because it can
produce a few notes, though they are very flat; and it is 'nevar' put with the wrong end in front!"
("Nevar" is "raven" spelled backwards.)
Intentionally Stressful
These questions might be asked in order to see how you react to uncomfortable and unexpected
situations, and whether you're able to stay cool and deal with difficult people.
The candidate is generally not told this technique will be used. So if you find yourself hearing questions
like this, realize that it may be a test. First, smile and breathe. Think of it as an interesting challenge,
maybe even a sort of game, to stay utterly calm and professional and give the best possible answer.
• "What do you do that drives your boss crazy?"
(Answer that you don't do anything that drives your boss crazy, but you're always looking to
improve your skills.)
• "How would you evaluate me as an interviewer?"
(How about "Very cautiously"! Beyond that, the correct answer depends on the job you're
interviewing for.)
• "What's the worst thing you've heard about our company?"
(If something negative has appeared in the news or is well known, tactfully acknowledge what
you've seen and be prepared to discuss the issue and how you feel about it.)
Illegal
In a 2015 Harris poll, one out of five employers surveyed admitted to having unknowingly asked an
interview question that was illegal.
It is illegal not to hire candidates because of their race, color, sex, religion, national origin, birthplace,
age, disability or marital/family status. Questions that seek to draw out information about these
subjects are illegal.
In a 2016 article, Glassdoor.com listed the following examples:
• How old are you?
• When did you graduate?
• Are you married?
• Are you gay?
• Do you have children (or plan on having children)?
• Who will take care of your children while you’re at work?
• Is English your first language?
• Are you a U.S. citizen?
• What country are you from?
• Where were you/your parents born?
• What is your religion?
• Where do you go to church?
• What clubs or social organizations do you belong to?
• Do you have any disabilities?
• How is your health?
• How tall are you? How much do you weigh?
• Have you ever been arrested?
• If you’ve been in the military, were you honorably discharged?
I'm not an attorney, and nothing in this chapter is intended as legal advice. But I do have some
suggestions for handling such questions. Let's look at three options. You could:
A. Refuse to answer, perhaps pointing out that the question is illegal or that it's none of their
business.
B. Draw out the underlying concern, so that you can address it without providing the information.
C. Provide the information.
Let's say the interviewer asks, "Are you married?"
Option A: "That's illegal (or personal) and I'd rather not answer it." This answer will probably make the
interviewer feel criticized and embarrassed, destroying your rapport with them and making it unlikely
you'll be selected for the job. If you leave out the "illegal/personal" part and simply say "I'd rather not
answer that question," they may decide you're uncooperative or hiding something, so again you won't
get the job.
Option B is somewhat safer. You might say, "I'd be happy to answer that, if you could first tell me…"
or "May I ask what your concern is, or how that's relevant to the job?" The interviewer may respond
that they're wondering whether relocation will be a problem for your spouse, in which case you can
assure them there is no issue.
There is some risk in this approach, since it may jog the interviewer's memory that their question is
illegal or inappropriate. However, if you have a strategic reason not to provide the information, this may
be the best option.
If you already think you know why they're asking, you could just address the supposed concern: "I think
you may be concerned about whether relocation will be problem. I'd like to assure you there are no
issues about that."
Option C is often the best option. "Yes, I am married. If you're concerned about the relocation, I'd like
you to know I've discussed it with my husband, and he's totally on board. Living in Seattle would be a
great thing for both of us. Does that address your concern?"
What if they didn't ask an illegal question, but you want to bring up one of these issues – marital
status, health, etc. – on your own? You have every right to provide the information if you wish. Don't go
there without a good reason, because it may make interviewers anxious about the potential of a lawsuit.
Some of these items may be worth bringing up. For example, if you have a noticeable disability or health
issue, you may want to proactively assure the employer that it doesn't limit your ability to do an
excellent job.
In this chapter and the last, you've learned a lot about answering questions. But there's one absolutely
crucial question we haven't explored yet, and it's a question that's asked toward the end of nearly every
interview: "What questions do you have for me?"
First impressions are important, but so are endings. Failing to respond with several good questions can
shoot down even a high-flying interview as quickly as you can say "No."
What are the best (and worst) questions to ask? What else do you need to know? That's our next topic.
CHAPTER 9
Asking the Right Questions (& Not the Wrong Ones!)
Judge a man by his questions rather than his answers.
– Voltaire
As you know, you need to ask questions in an interview to help you decide whether you want the job.
But it's also true that asking good questions may be necessary to get the offer! Why?
First, employers prefer candidates who show an interest this way. A candidate who is not inquisitive can
seem not only unmotivated, but perhaps unintelligent and definitely unprepared.
The second reason is that asking questions – especially if you can do it earlier in the interview – can arm
you with information that helps you market yourself. The more you know about the employer’s
challenges, goals and environment, the better you can target your message.
What makes a question a good one?
A good question…
… Demonstrates communication skills, social savvy and good judgment.
… Shows you’re strongly interested in the job.
… Demonstrates that you’re thinking about how you can add value.
… Is usually not answerable with a "yes" or "no." Open-ended questions lead to a more friendly,
informative conversation.
… Is appropriate for your industry and level. An interviewer may expect very bold questions
from a corporate executive, but not from a clerical candidate.
… Is asked in the right tone, at the right time, of the right person. Some questions require
sensitive handling; for example, questions about the person who previously held the position.
… Sounds natural, not “canned” – even if you found the question on a list like this one!
… Shows that you’ve done some research on the company.
Do your homework before asking questions.
Researching the company thoroughly before the interview shows diligence and motivation. The
information you gain enables you to dispense with basic questions like "How long has the company been
in business?" and instead ask questions like, "I read in Forbes that this company is putting a new
emphasis on X. How has that affected this department?"
Examples of facts you should know about the company:
• Basics of company history, size and structure (is it a subsidiary, or part of a family of
companies?), mission, values and culture
• Products/services
• Company's market position and rank (Fortune 100/500? best/only/first of its kind?) and
competitors
• Recent organizational changes, other positions currently open that may affect you (for example,
your prospective manager's)
• Company's financial condition
• Trends in the industry
Where to find the information:
• The company's website, of course (and the site map may be a good place to start)
• News media and blogs
• Social media
• Directories like corporateinformation.com and hoovers.com/free
• Word of mouth
• Online discussion groups
If possible, use the company's product or service, and be prepared to talk about it. One candidate
contacted the company's user support department with a minor issue to see how they handled it.
How many questions should you ask?
This depends on the position, the interviewer’s preferences, how much time is available, and the
structure of the interview. Three good questions at the end might be enough for some interviews; for
others you might need to ask questions throughout the discussion and several at the end. Always
prepare at least 10, in case some of your questions are answered during the interview. (It's generally
appropriate to bring a written list and refer to it at the appropriate time.) Never get stuck with "Uh, no,
you've answered them already."
What questions should you not ask?
"Ask not what the employer can do for you, but what you can do for the employer.” Focus on the work
and the environment in which you’ll be doing it. Don’t ask about salary, benefits, vacation, flextime or
anything that may require negotiation – until after a firm offer is on the table (preferably in writing!).
It's also risky to ask the interviewer any personal questions, such as those about their family – even if
family pictures are on display on the interviewer's desk. Mentioning facts you've seen in their LinkedIn
profile should be okay – but be careful. Some people may feel self-conscious about the fact that you
looked them up online. (I know, that's not logical – but then, people often aren't logical.)
And of course, don't ask questions that you could easily have researched on your own.
What counter-question should you always be prepared for?
"Why do you ask?" Always be able to explain what you're seeking by answering a certain question – or
don't ask it.
What will you say after they answer your question?
Make it a conversation. Use your active listening skills and show that you "get it." Relate your own
background to their answers. For example, if their answer gives you insight into the company's needs,
say something about how you can help fulfill those needs.
Can you give me examples of good questions?
The following questions may be good, depending on your situation. Choose about 10 of them and adapt
them as necessary, based on the circumstances and your own communication style.
Are they “safe questions"? Not necessarily! That depends on the people involved, the industry, company
culture and how you ask – factors that I don't know as I write this. So use your best judgment.
About the company and the department:
(Many of these can be enhanced by referring to what you’ve found out through your research.)
• What potential growth areas are people most excited about here?
• How do you see this organization’s strengths and weaknesses compared to its competitors?
• How would you describe the company’s culture? If the company was a person, what kind of
person would it be?
• How does the company reward successful performance?
• What kind of person succeeds here?
• Why do people come to work here instead of for your competitors? Why do they stay?
• How does upper management view the role and importance of this department?
• What's ahead for this company in the next five years, and how does this department fit into
that?
• What is this department’s most urgent priority in the next (three or six) months?
• What have been the department's achievements in the last couple of years?
• What makes this department successful?
• What is the rhythm to the work here? Is there a time of year you're pulling all-nighters, or is it
consistent all year? Is it evenly spread throughout the week/month, or are there crunch days?
• What are the greatest strengths of this company? And since no company is perfect, what could
be improved upon?
About the manager (for clues about how you’ll like working with him/her):
• How did you join the company? What makes you stay?
• What do you most enjoy about your work with this organization?
• What keeps you awake at night?
• What are some good ideas you’ve gotten from your direct reports, and how did they make a
difference? (This may tell you how interested they are in such ideas, and whether they act on
them.)
• Will it be possible for me to meet my prospective co-workers during the interview process?
(Present this as a way to flesh out your understanding of the company culture and the work. If
the manager declines to have you meet the team, take it as a red flag.)
• What recognition or rewards have your direct reports received in the past year?
• What training and development have they received?
• How do you prefer to communicate with your team? Through email, phone, dropping in,
scheduled meetings?
• What are your goals for this position/department?
• How would you describe your management style? (This question is expected, and they will
probably have a well-rehearsed answer, but it's still worth asking.)
• What kind of person fits best with your management style? (This indirect question may elicit a
more revealing answer.)
• How will you and I work together to make me successful in this role?
About the position:
• Who does this position report to? When would I be meeting him or her?
• What would you consider to be the most important aspects of this job?
• What are the most crucial skills and strengths you want to see in the person hired for this
position?
• What would a very successful (next year) look like for this company, and how does this position
help achieve those goals?
• It can be hard to get funding to hire someone these days. Why does the company see this
position as crucial and worth the money?
• How would you describe a typical week/day in this position? A typical client or customer?
• What is the typical work week? Is overtime expected?
• Why is this position open?
• Is this a new position? If not, what did the previous employee move on to?
• What types of skills do you not already have onboard that you're looking to bring in with the
new hire?
About expectations and evaluation:
• Thinking back to people who've been in this position previously, what differentiated the ones
who were good from the ones who were really great?
• If you were to hire me now, and a year from now give me a stellar performance review, what
will I have done to earn it?
• What are the most immediate challenges I would be facing in this position?
• What would be the highest priority for the next six months?
• What are the performance expectations for this position in the first year?
• What were the major strengths of the last person who held this job, and is there anything you
would like to see the new employee do differently?
• How will my performance be reviewed, and when does that occur?
• What are the specific criteria upon which I would be evaluated?
About advancement:
• What are the career paths in this department?
• What are the opportunities for training and development within this position?
• Are lateral moves available to provide broader experience?
• Assuming I were successful in this role, what opportunities might there be for eventual
advancement?
• How much assistance are employees given in developing their careers here?
• Where have successful employees advanced to from this position?
About your strengths and weaknesses as a candidate:
(Ask these questions with care and with a smile, late in the interview process. They can yield very
valuable information, but can also make some interviewers nervous.)
• Now that we’ve talked a while, what do you see as my greatest strengths for this position?
• On the other hand, do you have any concerns, or is there anything you see as an area for
growth?
• Is there any reason you would not hire me for this position?
• If I could add/change anything about myself and my experience to make me a better fit for the
position and the company, what would it be?
About a question that you’re not sure how to respond to:
• Before I answer that, may I ask you…
About the next steps:
• What are the next steps in the process? (A very important question. You need to know what to
expect!)
• When should I expect to hear from you next?
• I’d like to give you a call next week to check in and offer any additional information that might
be helpful. Is there a good day for me to do that?
• What can I do to prove to you that I'm the right person for this job?
What else?
A question is a tool. Picking the right tools for the situation is important, and so is using them well.
Practice your questions as you practice other aspects of the interview. Then enjoy an interview that
feels like a stimulating conversation and shows you as a sharp, motivated professional.
Up to this point, we've focused on verbal communication, but some of the most important
communication takes place nonverbally: in your face, your gestures, your appearance, items you might
bring to the interview, and the nervousness or confidence you exude. The next three chapters will show
you how to master these aspects of interviewing. Let your actions speak as positively as your words.
Section Three
Nailing the Nonverbals
CHAPTER 10
More than Words Can Say: Body Language, Clothes and Other
Silent Messages
What you do speaks so loudly that I cannot hear what you say.
― Ralph Waldo Emerson
How do employers decide who to hire? A lot of it comes down to gut feelings, rapport, the "chemistry"
you read about in Chapter 5. And those gut feelings are largely based on nonverbals like body language,
listening, manners and appearance.
Much of this comes naturally, some of it you already know – like shaking hands, smiling and wearing an
appropriate outfit – but I'm sure you'll find a few surprises.
Body Language
It's commonly said that most of the communication in a conversation happens nonverbally. So you'll
want to get it right!
What are the biggest body language mistakes job seekers make? In a 2016 survey commissioned by
CareerBuilder, U.S. hiring managers named the following mistakes (listed in order of how many
managers mentioned each one):
• Failing to make eye contact. A full 67% of these managers reported they would be less likely to
hire someone who doesn't look them in the eye. Too little eye contact can make a candidate
seem insincere or insecure. Too much can feel domineering. If you make eye contact about 30-
60% of the time – less when talking, more when listening – you should make a good impression.
• Failing to smile. Two points in the interview definitely call for a smile, to show friendliness and
enthusiasm: at the beginning and the end. In between, smile when it feels natural to you, and
when the interviewer smiles. (Did you know you can smile too much in an interview? A recent
study by Northeastern University showed that too much smiling can give the impression you're
not taking the interview seriously. In my experience, however, most people are more likely to
not smile enough.)
• Playing with something on the table. This is distracting, drawing attention to your nervousness.
• Fidgeting in your seat. This, too, draws attention to nervousness.
• Bad posture. Slouching can communicate a lack of motivation, interest and respect.
• Crossing your arms over your chest. This communicates defensiveness.
• Playing with your hair or touching your face. If you tend to play with your long hair, tie it back.
And did you know that touching the mouth or nose is sometimes associated with lying?
• Weak handshake. A full, firm handshake feels welcoming and confident.
• Too many hand gestures. This was mentioned by only 11% of those surveyed. Please don't take
this to mean you must never talk with your hands in interviews. A good rule of thumb is to do it
about as much as the interviewer does.
• Too-strong handshake. Don't ignore this because it's at the bottom of the list. This writer has
often felt a bit intimidated – or physically uncomfortable – with powerful handshakes. Be
sensitive to the gender and size of the person you're shaking hands with!
Most of us display some of these behaviors in interviews, and we may be unaware of it. It's a very good
idea to shoot a video of yourself in a mock interview and take a good look at your body language.
What about your voice?
Another reason to video yourself is to check for these common vocal mannerisms. You may have one of
these issues without being aware of it.
• Uptalk. A seemingly increasing number of people, especially Millennials, tend to end their
sentences with an upward inflection, as if asking a question or seeking confirmation. Surveys
show many people find it annoying. Practice making your sentences end on a confident,
definite, downward inflection.
• Vocal fry. This is the low-pitched, creaky sound that many people, especially young women, are
using these days, probably as a result of emulating celebrities like Kim Kardashian, Britney
Spears or the Meredith Gray character on the TV show Gray's Anatomy. Overuse of vocal fry can
not only be annoying but damaging to the vocal cords.
• Extremes: speaking too softly, too loudly, too slowly or too rapidly. If you tend toward any of
these extremes, strive for moderation!
• Singsong or monotone. The Free Dictionary defines singsong speech as "A tediously repetitive
rising and falling inflection of the voice." Equally tedious is the monotone, in which the voice
drones on without any change in pitch. If you have either of these habits, try to bring more
natural variety into the inflections and rhythms of your speaking. Listen to skilled public
speakers for examples.
• Overuse of vocal fillers such as saying "uh," "you know," "like," or smacking the lips at the
beginning or ending of statements. Wikipedia defines "filler" as a sound or word that is spoken
to signal that you're pausing to think without giving the impression that you've finished
speaking. Even the best speakers use fillers occasionally, but a statement with multiple fillers is
like clothing littered with lint or pet hair. It's unattractive and diminishes your credibility. To
overcome this:
o Become aware of it. You can't fix it if you don't know you're doing it. Record yourself, or
do a mock interview with a friend or coach and have them point out every filler.
o Replace fillers with silent pauses. The purpose of a filler is to give you a chance to think.
Practice just pausing. And maybe slow down a bit.
o Make eye contact, or look at your notes if you're in a phone interview. You're more
likely to use a filler when staring blankly.
o Try aversion therapy. You could put a rubber band around your wrist and snap it every
time you use a filler. Or practice with a friend and ask them to make a loud noise or
make you start over every time you use a filler.
Create rapport by mirroring body language.
Next time you're in a coffee shop, observe two friends who are enjoying a conversation. They will
naturally mimic each other's body language, speech patterns and vocabulary without being conscious of
it. For example, they'll both take a sip of coffee at the same moment. This unconscious mirroring is both
a cause and a result of rapport, and it helps the individuals feel more connected to each other, as if
they're "on the same wavelength."
Although mirroring is usually unconscious, you can help it along intentionally. Don't be too obvious or
exact about it, especially if the interviewer's gesture is not one that you as a candidate should imitate.
For example, if the interviewer leans way back in his chair, you might just lean back the slightest bit –
the effect is just as good.
Practice mirroring with friends first. Don't try it in interviews until you know you can make it look
natural.
Listening
If you want to sound smart, listen. The more you understand the employer's interests and concerns, the
better you can address them.
If you want the interviewer to like and trust you, listen to her. We all crave being listened to. And
managers want employees who listen well. Listen actively. Look like you're listening. Say something
occasionally that shows you've understood.
We've all heard and read so much about listening, yet we don't do it very well. Why not? Stephen Covey
put it well: "Most people don't listen with the intent to understand. They listen with the intent to reply."
If we're busy thinking about what we're going to say next, we aren't giving the interviewer our full
attention.
By the time you read this chapter, you've probably spent many hours preparing what you're going to say
in your interviews. So when the interviewer is talking, trust your preparation. Let go of thinking about
what you'll say. Give your undivided attention to the interviewer so that the relationship, and the
dialogue, can fully develop in the moment.
Note-taking
Just like any other nonverbal behavior, taking notes sends a message about you. Asking politely if you
may take notes, then quickly jotting down the occasional fact or detail, sends the message that you're
well organized and make a point of keeping track of information given to you.
On the other hand, continually taking notes may raise questions: whether you're really listening, whether
you have a problem with memory, whether you're able to think on your feet.
Laboring to take notes in full sentences, word for word, looks inefficient. Learn how to take fast,
abbreviated notes. It's a skill that will serve you for the rest of your life.
Manners
An interview is more formal than most day-to-day situations, so watch your manners from the moment
you're within eyeshot of the building until you've left the area afterwards.
Here are some fine points you may not have thought of:
• Arriving more than 15 minutes early is awkward for everyone involved. It's great to get to the
area far in advance to be sure you won't be late, but wait in a coffee shop or in your car until the
last few minutes. Use the extra time to review your notes, do relaxation exercises or visualize a
successful interview.
• Wait to be offered a seat before sitting down, or at least until others have taken their seats.
• Don't place personal items on the interview table, other than a notepad and pen. Place your
briefcase or purse on the seat next to you, or on the floor under your chair.
• As of 2017, taking notes on an electronic device at an interview is generally frowned upon. Cell
phones are taboo, and note-taking on a laptop is too obtrusive, too audible, and creates a feeling
of a barrier between you and the interviewer. "The jury is still out" regarding use of other devices
such as tablets.
• About cell phones: It's not enough to turn the phone off. It must be out of sight to eliminate even
the appearance that you might take a call during the interview.
• When leaving the interview, if possible stop in the outer office and thank the person who greeted
you when you arrived.
And a word about names: Most people like to hear their own name, so use it when shaking hands at the
beginning and end of the interview, and maybe once or twice in between. So, will it be "John" or "Mr.
Jones"?
The etiquette on this is changing, and not everyone agrees on it. In the Harvard Business Review in 2011,
communication and leadership consultant Jodi Glickman wrote, "Addressing people by their first name is
now the norm in corporate America," but later in the same article she wrote, " It may be counterintuitive
to look a powerful CEO in the face for the first time and call them boldly by their first name. And it may be
hard as that CEO to swallow it."
One common view is that it's best to follow the interviewer's cues: if they call you by your first name,
reply in the same way. Others say it's better to address the interviewer as Mr. or Ms. (or another title
they prefer, if you have any way of knowing that) until they specifically invite you to use their first name.
Since there is no one definitive answer, we each have to use our own best judgment.
Appearance
Before you ever answer "Tell me about yourself," you have already told the interviewer how you feel
about yourself and the opportunity. You've told them how much respect you have, or don't have, for
them and their company. You've told them whether you understand their world – whether you "get it."
All of that is instantly communicated by your outfit and grooming.
Over thousands of years of evolution, human beings have evolved to make snap judgments. Our hunter-
gatherer ancestors faced life-and-death struggles routinely, whether from huge animals or other people.
Those who could quickly size up an adversary with reasonable accuracy, survived and reproduced.
We still make those instant judgments, based on body language and appearance. It may not be very
enlightened, but it's how we are.
If that doesn't seem fair, or if you dislike business clothes and prefer to do the bare minimum to play the
game, believe me, I sympathize. Personally, I look and feel better in jeans than in a suit. Nevertheless,
those who play the game well, win. Besides, knowing you're perfectly attired can be a huge boost to your
confidence.
So here are the recommended moves in this appearance game.
Interview attire in the vast majority of workplaces is conservative. The advice below is geared towards
that majority, but realize that the rules are different according to the job, industry and region. If you're
interviewing for a job in a "creative" field such as advertising or fashion, for example, you'll want to look
more creatively stylish than if you're interviewing at a financial firm.
As a general rule, interview attire should be a step up from the way you would dress on the job.
• If the workplace is casual (let's say, the jeans and T-shirts of Silicon Valley software engineers):
For the interview, dress in "business casual." This is a deceptive term, because business casual is
not what most of us would call casual. For men, business casual means slacks with a crease, an
open collared shirt (no tie) and maybe a blazer. For women, it's similar except you have the
option of replacing the slacks with a knee-length skirt, and the shirt with a blouse. Both men and
women should wear closed-toe business shoes.
• If business casual is the standard daily attire (as in many offices today): Wear a suit to the
interview – preferably blue or gray, with closed toe dress shoes, and if you're a man put on a tie.
• If you'll be wearing a suit on the job every day: Clearly that's what you'll be wearing to the
interview!
When in doubt, ask the recruiter who scheduled the interview for their advice about what to wear.
It's best to carry only one item: a briefcase or portfolio to hold your resumes, notepad and so on. For a
woman to carry both a briefcase and a purse may give a disorganized impression; better to use a smaller
purse that will fit inside your briefcase.
What about self-expression? It's great to be real and interesting and let people know who you are. To
express your personality while still radiating impeccable professionalism can be a challenge, but if you can
pull it off, all the better! But do avoid loud colors or anything startling, eccentric, sexy or otherwise
distracting. Keep the focus on your professional self.
Groom for success. For hair, neat and tidy is essential. If your hair is long, pulling it back or up may be the
best way to ensure it looks businesslike. For women, light makeup is best and looks more professional
than going without. For men, a clean-shaven look is best, despite the current popularity of "designer
stubble" and beards.
Both sexes should avoid using any scented personal care products, especially perfumes and colognes,
since many people have unpleasant physical reactions to these.
Hygiene must be flawless, of course. Avoid strong-smelling foods, coffee and alcohol, which can leave
unwelcome smells. If you smoke, do everything you can to prevent tobacco smell on your clothes, hair,
hands or breath.
As of this writing in 2017, tattoos and piercings (other than women's pierced ears) are still considered
beyond the pale for most interviews. If you can't cover all your tats with clothing, there are makeup
products such as DermaBlend designed to hide them.
Look right, sound right and nail all your nonverbals so you're sending a consistent message in every
medium: that you're the best person for the job.
Appropriate clothes and nonverbals are a must – but often it's what's not required that really makes
you stand out. What can you bring to the interview to not just tell, but show your value to the employer?
CHAPTER 11
Something Extra: Portfolios, Presentations and Plans
Tell me and I forget, show me and I may remember, involve me and I learn.
– paraphrase of ancient Chinese proverb
Prove it.
– anonymous (Who hasn't said this?)
There are no traffic jams along the extra mile.
– Zig Ziglar
You're at the interview to educate – to memorably teach the employer about your value. And it's well
known that people remember information better when it includes visuals.
You're also there to persuade. Don't just claim you have certain skills and qualities. Look for ways to
offer evidence.
And you're there to stand out. So look for opportunities to offer something extra that the other
candidates might not.
Used correctly, "extras" such as portfolios, presentations and 30/60/90-day plans can help you educate,
persuade and stand out in the interviewer's mind.
Portfolios aren't just for artists.
Portfolios – whether online or physical – aren't just for "creative" professionals like graphic designers
and copywriters. If the quality of your work can be demonstrated by several of the following items,
consider assembling them into a binder or computerized presentation.
You might include:
It's perfectly normal to be nervous about job interviews. But if you get so anxious that your voice shakes,
you can't stop fidgeting or you find it hard to think clearly, that's a problem. Fortunately, there's a lot
you can do about it.
Too often we feel like we have no control over our anxieties, no way to consciously cultivate confidence.
Abundant research shows this is just not true. In this chapter you'll learn several ways to calm your
nerves and feel confident.
Psychoanalyst Anna Freud wrote, "I was always looking outside myself for strength and confidence, but
it comes from within. It is there all the time." The following practical tips and techniques can help you
find that inner confidence. Experiment – find out which of these tools work best for you, and then use
them!
Breathing and Other Relaxation Techniques
Psychologist Fritz Perls once said, "Fear is excitement without the breath." This may be an
oversimplification, but some of your nervousness may actually be excitement about the opportunity. Your
excitement is an asset, since it shows you're passionate about the job.
So appreciate your excitement, and then breathe to release the anxiety. Easier said than done?
Here are a couple of quick, easy breathing exercises from a Harvard Medical School blog. Try them right
now.
Breathing with a peaceful phrase:
1. While sitting comfortably, take a slow deep breath, quietly saying to yourself "I am" as you
breathe in and "at peace" as you breathe out.
2. Repeat slowly two or three times.
3. Feel your entire body let go into the support of your chair.
Abdominal breathing:
1. Place your hand just beneath your navel so you can feel the gentle rise and fall of your belly as
you breathe.
2. Breathe in. Pause for a count of three.
3. Breathe out. Pause for a count of three.
4. Continue like this for one minute.
Notice how you feel before and after doing these exercises.
You can also use your imagination to help you relax. Try these techniques and see which one works best
for you.
Color visualization:
1. Think of a color that you find relaxing.
2. As you breathe slowly and deeply, imagine that you're breathing that color into various areas of
your body. Feel the color bringing relaxation wherever it goes.
Rubber bands visualization:
1. Focus on a tense area such as your neck or shoulders, and imagine that the area is made of taut
rubber bands stretched in between pegs.
2. Now imagine the pegs are released and the rubber bands go limp. Feel the relief.
Whatever technique you prefer, practice it often and enjoy it. Make it part of your everyday life so it
comes naturally to you when you need it – like in the waiting area right before an interview.
Growing Your Confidence
If you're like most people, your level of confidence changes fluidly from day to day, and even from
minute to minute. The good new is this: if it's so fluid, that means it's changeable and you can change it
intentionally.
Here are several ways to feel more confident in your job search:
Act the way you want to feel. As you practice for interviews, and in the interview itself, do and say
everything as if you were confident. You'll begin to actually feel that way. Use confident language: "I'm
confident" or "I'm convinced" rather than "I think" or "I feel." Avoid saying you "tried to" do this or that.
As Yoda said in The Empire Strikes Back, "Do not try. Do. Or do not. There is no try."
Use power poses. Here's a great example of how "acting the way you want to feel" works. Research
done at Harvard University has shown that adopting a confident pose for only two minutes alters a
person's hormone balance, making them feel more confident. Try the "Wonder Woman" or "Superman"
pose – stand up straight with your legs apart and your hands on your hips for two minutes. You might
combine this with a breathing exercise such as those above and get multiple benefits at one time.
Yoga and martial arts include many poses that radiate confidence and strength, while encouraging deep
breathing and improving posture. Many people have experienced increased confidence as a result of
these practices.
Exercise. Countless job seekers have found that an exercise habit boosts confidence. Regular exercise
brings energy, well-being, a sense of accomplishment and a feeling of control over one's body and mind,
not to mention a healthier appearance. If your work ethic says "I don't have time," think of it as an
investment in your career success.
Don't believe everything you think. Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is a very successful approach to
feeling better by changing your thoughts. If you're feeling bad about yourself it's probably because of
something you're thinking. Practice disputing those thoughts and replacing them with realistically
positive ones. For example, when you catch yourself thinking "I'm no good at interviewing," replace that
thought with "I'm improving my interview skills and I will get an offer."
Here are some examples:
Negative Positive
I can't do this. I can do this. I'm working on it and increasing my skills.
Somebody else will get the job, not I was selected out of many applicants for this interview. The
me. interviewer is very interested in me. There are good reasons to
hire me.
I always blow it. I've made mistakes in past interviews, but the past doesn't
determine the future. I have new skills. The next interview will
be a whole different story.
I hate interviewing. I can find things to enjoy about interviewing. It can be an
enjoyable conversation. I can see the interviewer and me really
hitting it off.
The interviewer will be trying to make The interviewer is anxious to fill the position and hopes I'm the
me fail. one. She'd love to be very impressed by me.
The interviewer has all the power. I'm The interviewer has needs, hopes and probably anxieties
the only nervous one. about this process. He's a person, just like me. In a way, we're
in the same boat.
The beliefs above are just examples. If these positive statements don't feel right to you – maybe they're
too optimistic for where you're at right now, or not optimistic enough – make up your own.
Trying to block out the negative thoughts doesn't usually work. Instead, just compassionately notice
them and then replace them. This work takes patience – doing it once isn't enough – but every bit adds
up.
Use Mental Imagery. It is well known that top performers in the arts, athletics and other fields use
mental imagery, also known as creative visualization, to build their skills and set up the mental
conditions for success. The idea is to experience, in your imagination, the way you want to feel, think,
speak and act during your next interview. On some level, your brain stores this experience as learning,
almost as if you had participated in a real, highly successful interview. Naturally, this prepares you for a
confident and effective performance in the real world. This isn't magic; it's supported by scientific
research. (You can look up "motor imagery" on Wikipedia.)
First relax, using any relaxation technique that works for you. Then, vividly imagine going through a very
successful interview, feeling confident from start to finish. If you start to feel tense or worried, use your
technique again to bring back calm and confidence before you continue. Be sure to give your "mental
movie" a happy ending!
Do this for a few minutes every day. If you find it hard to concentrate on your imagery, work with a
coach or therapist who has skills in guided visualization. Ask them to make you a recording you can
listen to again and again. (This is part of the service I offer to my coaching clients, and it can be done
remotely.)
Start a kudos file. Gather up or write down any praise you've received about your work, whether it was
as casual as a comment or as formal as a performance review or LinkedIn recommendation. (If you don't
have LinkedIn recommendations, ask several people to give you one!) Look through these things when
you need a boost.
If you haven't kept any of the compliments or recognition you've received in the past, make a point of
doing so from now on.
If your past experience was in environments where little praise or recognition is given, I empathize with
you! Many managers and companies fail to see the importance of recognizing good work. Visualize your
current job search landing you in a more supportive situation!
Last but certainly not least, confidence comes from being prepared. Really practice what you learn
from the various chapters of this book. Get thoroughly ready. If you've been "winging it" until now, you
may be quite surprised at the difference this makes.
Confidence is contagious! Let your confidence in yourself convince the interviewer.
Part of being prepared is knowing what to expect. Interview formats vary widely, from a recorded video
session to the "firing line" pressures of a formal panel interview, and each comes with its own challenges.
You may love surprises on your birthday, but probably not in interviewing! The next chapter will help you
adapt confidently to different types of interviews.
Section Four
Know What to Expect
CHAPTER 13
Twelve Types of Interviews
Expect the unexpected, and whenever possible be the unexpected.
– Lynda Barry
The classic one-on-one, in-person meeting is only one of the many forms an interview can take. You may
encounter a range of formats, from recorded interviews to meal interviews and more. Each type of
interview has its own challenges and opportunities. This chapter will help you understand how to succeed
with all of them.
How do you know the format of your upcoming interview? Usually, the human resources person who
schedules the interview will tell you if it's not just a traditional one-on-one. If it's not clear, ask. For
example, if they tell you you'll be meeting with five people at once, ask "So it's a panel interview?" (And
ask for each person's name and role, too.)
Phone Screening
A screening can be a lot like a "pop quiz," occurring when you least expect it. Don't be caught off guard.
As soon as you've sent a resume, get ready.
First of all, make sure you have a clear, professional voicemail greeting that includes your name. Don't
make a recruiter wonder whether their confidential message will be heard by the right person.
When you hear that voice saying "I'm calling about the opening at X Company," you don't want to be
struggling to remember "Which job was that? What did I tell them about myself?" Make sure the
following information is instantly available near the phone, or in your purse or briefcase.
• Job announcements you've applied to recently
• Resumes and cover letters
• Your REV Intro outline, unless you have it memorized
• Appointment calendar, if you don't use your cell phone for this
• Notepad and pen
The recruiter may be anxious to "talk for a few minutes right now" even though it's not a good time for
you. If there are several good candidates available, asking to reschedule may put you at a disadvantage.
But if it's really a bad time, it may be better to say "Can we talk a bit later, maybe in 15 minutes?" – rather
than interview badly because you just woke up or are about to go into another important meeting.
Along with general questions like "Tell me about yourself" and "Why are you interested in this job?", you
may be asked about your current/past salary or your salary expectations. See Chapters 3 and 7 for help
with these questions.
One advantage of a phone interview is that you can refer to notes if you need to, such as your REV Intro
outline or SOAR stories list. Spread the notes out in front of you so you don't need to handle them, to
avoid rustling noises.
You might think body language is unimportant in a phone interview, but actually the interviewer can hear
whether you're smiling. To help you remember to smile, draw a smiley face on your notes. And sit up
straight or stand up, which makes your voice sound more energetic.
One on One, Face to Face
This is the classic interview format. Typically longer than a phone screening, an in-person interview may
be a half hour, an hour or even longer (which is usually a good sign).
You can learn a lot from physically being there in the office. Look around and pay attention for clues
about the company culture and what it's like working there. Be friendly, but not too chatty, with the
receptionist and whoever else you encounter.
Panel Interview
Panel interviews are also sometimes known as committee or departmental interviews. They are often
very firmly structured as to the questions asked, order of the questions, and even the seating
arrangements.
These interviews can feel very artificial and "stiff." But look at it this way: the interviewers probably don't
enjoy it either. Let that thought give you a feeling of empathy toward them! Be gracious, put them at
ease, and you may end up making yourself feel more relaxed as well.
Address all of the interviewers as you answer each question, not just the person who asked. Strive for a
friendly rapport with everyone, including the least friendly person, and especially the decision maker.
Write down the name and role of each person present. (Do this in advance if possible.) Arrange the
names on your notepad in the same way that the people are arranged in the room – Brenda on the left,
Carlo on the right, etc. Ask for business cards so you'll have contact information to follow up with
everyone individually.
Group Interview
The term "group interview" can mean different things, but what we'll focus on here is a process where
multiple candidates interact together in a round-table discussion or small-group exercise.
This format allows interviewers to observe interpersonal skills such as teamwork, leadership, and helping
to facilitate the stated goals of the exercise.
It's a balancing act: demonstrate your skills without taking over; collaborate with people who may also be
your competitors – as you might do on the job, if you were competing with teammates for a promotion
while still working together for a common goal.
Sometimes "group interview" simply means meeting with more than one person at a time, for example
the hiring manager plus a few team members. As in a panel interview, use eye contact to include
everyone in your answers, and of course give extra attention to the person who may become your boss.
Behavioral Interview
A behavioral interview, also known as a performance-based interview, is one where most of the questions
will start with language like "Tell me about a time when…" and require you to tell a specific story from
your work experience.
The theory is that a person's behavior in the past is the best predictor of how they will perform if hired.
So, as emphasized in Chapter 2 and throughout this book, it's important to develop a written list of
success stories.
You won't necessarily be told "This will be a behavioral interview," since performance-based interviewing
is used, at least to some extent, in most interviews.
Sequential or All-day Interview
Multiple interview rounds are increasingly common. When they're crammed into one day it can be
overwhelming.
Keeping your energy up is one of the challenges here. If you're among those of us who don't function well
without frequent fuel, ask when there will be breaks in the interviewing and bring food. If time permits, a
quick walk around the block may help refresh you between meetings.
Varying the stories you tell is important. Interviewers may compare notes later, and you don't want them
to discover you told the exact same stories every time, as if that's all you have to say.
Don't let all the interviews blur together in your mind. If possible, take a few notes between meetings:
questions that were asked, stories you told, what you learned about each interviewer. This will help you
write smart, personalized thank-you notes later.
Meal Interview
It may not be called an interview, but a meal with your prospective boss and/or teammates can have a
strong effect on your candidacy, so prepare as you would for an interview. In addition, if you know the
name of the restaurant in advance, look up the menu online and plan your order beforehand.
Eat very little so that you're free to talk. Avoid alcoholic beverages, even if the boss is drinking. Keep your
phone switched off and out of sight. Be nice to your server.
Meal interviews tend to include more small talk than most. One good conversation strategy is to ask the
others how they came to join the company and what they enjoy most about their work there. But follow
the lead of the boss: if he sticks to business, do likewise.
And of course, be on your best behavior as to conversational topics and table manners – even if others
break the rules.
Video Interview
Most employers use video interviewing at times, but many people find it a bit unnatural and
uncomfortable. If you can help make the experience feel more engaging and enjoyable for yourself and
others, you will certainly stand out.
Video interviews may be either two-way or asynchronous. In a two-way call, you're communicating in
realtime, perhaps via Skype, Google Hangouts or GoToMeeting. In an asynchronous interview you'll
record your responses for company employees to view later.
To ensure you'll use the technology smoothly and without stress, try it out ahead of time. If you have
technical difficulties during the interview, notify the interviewer immediately.
How you look is very important, and lighting is the key. Check yourself through your computer's Photo
Booth or Crazy Cam application, or through a camera or even in a mirror. Look into the camera often to
create the effect of eye contact.
Case Interview
Case interviews are used in filling roles that require problem solving and analytical skills especially
management consulting and positions that require an MBA.
In a case interview, you would be presented with a problem scenario similar to those you would
encounter on the job and asked to develop a solution. Candidates often spend many hours and days
preparing for case interviews. Entire books have been devoted to advice on answering them effectively,
and there are many sample cases and good how-to resources online.
Many of these resources are on the websites of consulting firms like Accenture and McKinsey and
Company. Here are a few tips from these sites:
• Practice many cases ahead of time, especially with others, and get feedback on how you're
doing.
• Understand that the interviewer doesn't expect to hear a perfect solution; in many cases it
would take a whole team to do that.
• Listen carefully. Interviewers may give you tips and clues.
• Don't jump into answering right away. Take a minute to think about the case, ask questions and
plan your answer.
• Show your thought processes. Use a whiteboard if one is available. The interviewer is interested
in how you approach, structure and communicate your answer.
Stress Interview
In the "Common Questions" chapter I listed several "stress questions" that are intended to test
interviewees ability to perform effectively under uncomfortable circumstances or with difficult people.
In addition to questions like "How would you rate me as an interviewer?", the interview may be
designed to be stressful in other ways as well.
Stress tactics may include asking you the same question repeatedly, as if your answer was inadequate or
they don't believe you. They may sigh, frown continually, avoid eye contact, interrupt or act as if they're
not listening. They may act hostile or rushed.
It may be hard to tell whether the interviewer always acts this way – a serious concern if they will be
your manager – or whether it's just an interview technique. One tip-off is if the interviewer's manner
suddenly changes at the end, becoming more friendly.
The key to success in this type of interview is to stay calm and respond with impeccable professionalism.
Don't take the behavior personally. View the situation as an interesting challenge. Remember to smile –
it may actually make you feel better as well as demonstrate your unflappability.
If the stress tactics are extreme, you may want to ask in a pleasant tone whether you are being tested
for your ability to handle stress, and whether that indicates that the position is typically very stressful.
If the interviewer's behavior makes you uncertain whether you want the job, set that thought aside and
think about it after you leave. If you make a hasty negative decision during the interview you may regret
it later when you weigh the factors more calmly.
Job Fair
Standing at a company's booth, you chat with a company representative for maybe five minutes, hand
them your resume and the encounter ends. Unbeknownst to you, after you leave they write a note on
the resume that determines whether you will be contacted for a phone screening or a more formal
interview.
Was this five-minute conversation an interview? You bet it was!
Here's what you need to do to succeed in these mini-interviews:
• Dress as you would for any interview.
• Be knowledgeable about the company and any suitable open positions listed on their website.
• Show enthusiasm and passion.
• Don't give the impression their company is just one random stop, or that you're applying
everywhere. If you're applying at other booths nearby, don't be obvious about it. It looks better
to approach a booth from elsewhere in the fair, as if you've gone out of your way.
Testing and Projects
As hiring processes become increasingly rigorous, testing at interviews has become more common and
diverse, including written tests of basic skills such as writing or math, job skills, personality, management
style and so on. Testing of skills in using Microsoft Word, Excel or workplace equipment are common.
You may be asked to work your way through an in-box or prepare and deliver a presentation. Find out as
much as possible about any tests that will be required. Study, and take practice tests online, even for
personality tests.
If required to take a drug test, be aware that false positive results can occur if you have recently taken
certain medicines, such as ibuprofen, cold and allergy remedies, diet pills or sleeping aids, or eaten
foods containing poppy seeds or hemp.
Work projects may include assignments of actual work typical of the job, such as redesigning a website,
writing or reviewing software code, or planning a social media campaign. You may be asked to do the
work on the spot or at home.
Job seekers are sometimes suspicious of take-home projects and other lengthy assignments, and not
necessarily without cause. While in most cases the assignments are honestly intended only to test the
applicant's skills, some employers have gone on to profit from applicants' ideas or work. How can you
protect yourself from such practices? There is no simple answer.
When asked to complete a very time-consuming project, consider how seriously the company is
interested in you and how much you want the job. Research their reputation. Ask for an estimate of the
time required or how much detail is expected; in some cases a fully useable product may not be
required. In some cases job seekers have brought along a simple mutual nondisclosure agreement
(NDA). If the employer refuses to sign, that may be a red flag.
Knowing what to expect will help you to shine in any interview format and avoid stressful surprises.
The next chapter will help you avoid unpleasant surprises in another area: references. Who might the
employer talk to, what will they say – and what can you do about it?
CHAPTER 14
Five Dangerous Myths about References
Unless a reviewer has the courage to give you unqualified praise, I say ignore the bastard.
– John Steinbeck
If only the management of references was as simple as the breezy quotation at the top of this page.
At some point in the interview process you'll be asked for a list of people who can provide a reference,
and toward the end of the process the employer will probably check these references – and they might
not stop there.
The common fallacies discussed below can derail your progress toward the offer you've worked so hard
to capture. Ignore them at your peril!
Myth #1:
Employers will only contact people from the list you provide.
Many employers will contact other people as well. It's neither illegal nor particularly difficult for them to
do so. They can find your past managers and co-workers via social media, websites, online directories
and word of mouth. They may even find people at companies you haven't listed on your resume or
application.
Myth #2:
Past employers can legally only give out your title, dates of
employment and most recent salary.
Many companies do have company policies forbidding employees from giving out additional
information, but that doesn't mean it's against the law. And does everybody follow company policy
anyway? Don't count on it.
Myth #3:
There's nothing you can do about bad references.
First, you need to know whether bad references are occurring. If you're not sure, hire a reference
checking firm like Allison & Taylor to do a reference check for you. It's not expensive.
If you suspect that a certain individual may be giving you a negative reference, pluck up your nerve and
reach out to him to talk it over, preferably in person. The purpose here is to listen to his point of view,
acknowledge that there may have been difficulties in the past, and explain how you've learned and
grown since then. Appeal to his sympathy and point out that you need a chance to get a new start. Ask
whether he would be willing to emphasize the positive aspects of your past work, or at least to avoid
commenting.
If talking to him doesn't work, consider sending a firm "cease and desist" letter to someone higher up in
the company. Name the person giving the negative references and ask that the reference be limited to
the job title and dates of employment. Usually this will solve the problem. For more clout, it may be
helpful to have the letter come from an attorney.
Myth #4:
Once someone has agreed to give you a reference, all you need to do
is put them on the list and give it to the employer.
Actually, there are many ways that could go wrong. Help ensure successful outcomes by working with
your reference people as follows:
1. Ask each person if they're willing to provide a reference before you give out their name. Ask
them what they would say. If they seem uncomfortable, or if you have any sense that they
would give faint praise, thank them politely anyway. But don't put them on your list.
2. Inform them each time you give out their name. Let them know who they will be hearing from
and the nature of the job. It's no good having them rave about your management skills if you're
interviewing for an individual contributor role.
3. Help them target their comments. Suggest specific skills, projects or accomplishments to
mention. Send this information in an email so they can easily refer to it when needed. Don't
expect them to keep your job search at top of mind.
4. Make sure they'll be available – and not on vacation, for example. If an employer leaves a
message and fails to hear back, they may assume the worst: that the person is uncomfortable
talking about you.
5. Ask them to respond as quickly as possible. Employers may take the speed of the response as
an indication of how eager the person is (or isn't) to sing your praises.
6. Check in later to verify that the conversation happened and how it went. You may learn
something important about the employer, what they're looking for and what impresses or
concerns them about you.
Myth #5:
It's fine to present your references before you are asked for them.
Don't wear out a good reference on employers who are not seriously interested in hiring you. As a
courtesy to your reference providers, offer their names and contact information only when required.
If you want to have contacts vouching for you earlier in the process – which is often extremely helpful –
ask instead for a letter of recommendation, a LinkedIn recommendation, or, if your contact has a
relationship with the employer, a phone call to put in a good word.
We're now in the last laps of the interview process, and it's a crucial time. Last impressions can be
almost as important as first ones. How will you conclude your interview in a way that leaves a highly
persuasive image of you in the interviewer's mind?
Section Five
Happy Endings –
and Great Beginnings
CHAPTER 15
Ending on the Right Note
Finally, in conclusion, let me say just this.
– Peter Sellers
Too often, interviewees end an interview by saying what Peter Sellers did in the quote above: basically
nothing! Well, okay, nearly everybody remembers to say "Thank you." That's a good start. But why
waste one of the key moments of interview "air time"?
Why is it key? Because people tend to remember what came first, and what came last. So rise above the
mumble-and-stumble exits of your competitors by preparing a closing statement that reinforces your
positive image, your brand and your key selling points.
Here's what you want to accomplish:
1. Convey appreciation for the interview.
2. Leave your REV points clearly fixed in the interviewer's mind.
3. Express enthusiastic interest in the job.
Once the interviewer has finished with his questions and answered yours, it's time. Before you get up to
leave, make a brief closing statement that nails these three objectives.
Appreciation
Obviously, it's only polite to thank the interviewers for taking the time to meet with you. Show special
appreciation for anything extra the interviewer has done, such as coming in early or staying late for the
interview, taking you to lunch or giving you a tour of the office.
"Michael, thank you so much for meeting with me today. I've really enjoyed talking with
you. And thanks for taking the time to show me around. I'm very glad I was able to meet
Raj and Irene. I've gotten a great impression of the whole team."
REV Points Revisited
At the beginning of the interview you answered the "Tell me about yourself" inquiry with an introduction
that emphasized your REV (Relevant, Exceptional and Verifiable) selling points, the top factors you
thought would make you stand out to the interviewer as the right person to hire. At that time, you didn’t
know for sure what the interviewer would consider most crucial. To some extent, it was guesswork.
By the end of the interview you may know better. Maybe the interviewer's eyes lit up about some of your
REV Points more than others. Maybe the job matches your skills in a way you hadn't realized before. So
update your key selling points into a very brief statement of the great fit between you and this job.
Here's an example based on Denise, the sales manager mentioned early in the book:
"From what you've described about your plans, my ability to capitalize on change and
deliver results quickly fits really well with your goal of expanding into your new global
markets. And I was excited to discover today that you need the new hire to build a larger
team, because as I've said, I did hire and lead a very successful new team at Top Tier,
and I'm sure I can drive equally strong results for you here."
Expressing Interest / Asking for the Job
One of the pet peeves of interviewers is when the applicant leaves the interview without expressing a
strong interest in the job. Don't make the mistake of thinking they'll assume you're interested. For all
they know, you may have changed your mind based on something you heard during the meeting.
If there will be an additional round of interviews, make it clear you're excited about meeting again.
If this is the last interview, say you want the job, even if you're not sure you do. You can always decline
later, but don't shut the door prematurely by seeming unenthusiastic.
Asking for the job might sound like this:
"I know I can deliver what you're looking for, and the role is ideal for me. I'd really like to
work with you and your team."
Depending on what has been said about the next steps, you may want to follow that with one of these
questions:
"What's the next step?"
"I'm looking forward to hearing from you."
"Have I given you all the information you need to offer me the job?"
"Is there anything else I can do to make you completely confident that I'm the right
candidate?"
"On a scale of one to ten, how do you think I'd do in this job? … Is there anything I could
do to make that a ten?"
Notice that those last two questions invite the interviewer to give you an evaluation of your suitability
for the job (but not your interviewing skills – don't expect them to play career coach!). If you receive a
candid response, the feedback may create an opportunity to address any negatives that could get in the
way of an offer – or give you a heads-up that it's time to move on to other opportunities.
Brevity and Confidence
Putting together the appreciation, REV Points and enthusiastically asking for the job, the complete
closing statement presented above takes about 60 seconds. It is important to keep this statement brief
and not hold the interviewer hostage with a lengthy speech at this point.
It's also crucial to make this statement with body language that projects confidence and enthusiasm. In
general, that's likely to mean sitting up straight, leaning in slightly and smiling, especially when you say
your last words and as you shake hands before leaving.
Realize that in asking for the job you are actually offering something of great value: your abilities, time
and dedication. You're offering your ongoing partnership and commitment. Allow yourself to rest in the
dignity and power of that truth.
Whether this was a preliminary interview or the last, your next step is to follow up as strategically as
you interviewed. And as with your closing statement, it's more than just a "thank you."
CHAPTER 16
Following Up to Stand Out
Motivation will almost always beat mere talent.
– Norman Ralph Augustine
In a close race between candidates with roughly equal qualifications, often the deciding factor is the
motivation and enthusiasm shown by the candidate. Maybe that's why one in five hiring managers say
they would be less likely to hire a candidate who didn't send a "thank you" message.
So just sending the message puts you a step ahead. And what about doing it really well?
Note-taking for Smart Follow-up
Whether or not you take notes during your interviews, make time to do so immediately afterwards.
Before you go home, while the interview is fresh in your mind, sit in your car or in a coffee shop and note
the following:
• Names and roles of all the people you met
• Facts you learned about the job, the company and the industry
• Stories you told, or didn't get around to telling
• Any other topics that were discussed, whether job-related or chitchat
• Which of your qualifications and accomplishments they seemed most pleased about
• Any resistance or concerns they seemed to have
• Information about next steps in the process
These notes will be a big help in crafting intelligent, customized follow-up messages (as well as preparing
for the next interview).
Beyond "Thank You"
The term "thank you letter" is a bit misleading. Even aside from demonstrating enthusiasm and good
manners, your post-interview follow-up message can actually accomplish several important goals.
1. Confirm that you're still interested. It's very important to an employer to know whether you're
still a candidate. For all the employer knows, you may have changed your mind after the
interview.
2. Show appreciation and warmth. Say "thank you" again. Mention something you enjoyed about
speaking with them, or something that impressed you about the office. Maybe make a friendly
reference to some item of chitchat. "Thanks for making time to meet with me in the middle of
your rush project. I hope that's going well today."
3. Remind them why you're the right person for the job. Yes, you just (hopefully) made that clear
in your interview yesterday, but maybe you were one of three interviewees that day and four
earlier in the week, all of whom are beginning to blur together in the employer's mind. If you
feel like you're repeating your message too much, find a new way to say it.
4. If necessary, correct any omissions, misimpressions or other issues. Did you misstate some
facts out of nervousness? Did your external recruiter give you some feedback on a concern the
employer expressed to her? Sometimes it can be helpful to address it in your follow-up
message. But make sure you don't come across as defensive or call attention to a misstep that
the interviewer may not have even noticed.
5. Continue the conversation. What story or qualification did you not get a chance to bring up at
the time? What could you add about some industry trend or company project that was
discussed at the interview? Research it. Maybe there's an interesting link you can send.
Can you accomplish all of these things in one letter? Probably not, given that it needs to be brief – no
more than a few short paragraphs. You might save some of these ideas for later follow-ups.
How, Who and When?
Is it better to send an email, a formal letter or a handwritten note? Consider your industry first. In a
conservative industry like finance or law, a hardcopy letter would be appropriate, or a handwritten note
card could add a gracious personal touch. In IT or software, on the other hand, an email would better fit
the culture.
Who should you send the follow-up to? Everyone who interviewed you, preferably as separate,
personalized messages.
How soon after the interview? Very promptly, especially if a decision is expected soon. Ideally, time
your first follow-up message to arrive by the next day.
Staying at Top of Mind
Interview processes can stretch out for many weeks (even months). You need to stay on the decision
maker's radar screen. If you're the only candidate who keeps in touch, great – you'll be seen as the one
who really wants the job. So it can be effective to drop the hiring manager a note or a phone call
(perhaps varying your method of approach) on a regular basis until the decision is made.
Will this be viewed as "pestering"? It will if you keep asking about the decision they haven't made yet.
Instead, focus on being helpful – for example, asking whether they need any further information – and
continuing the conversation.
How often should you follow up? It depends on the circumstances, including the nature of the job. If
you're pursuing a role as a manager, sales rep or project manager, for example, persistence and
assertiveness are expected of you. If you've interviewed for a technical role, your approach can be more
low-key. But don't let the decision maker forget about you.
If you feel this is too forward, you can basically ask for permission during the final interview. "May I
check in with an email or phone call at some point to see if you need any other information?"
The moment you're offered a job can be a mini-whirlwind of excitement joy, relief, nervousness, you
name it. You may be tempted to scream "YES!" – quickly, before they can change their mind!
Many a job seeker has done exactly that, only to think later, "I sure wish I had thought about …
(negotiating the starting date, the salary, leaving early on Tuesdays? the potential offer from that other
company?) … before I said yes."
Do yourself a favor. Have a plan for handling this important turning point in your career.
Buying Yourself Some Time to Think
When you receive the offer, chances are that one of the following will be true for you:
• Certain aspects of the offer – maybe salary, the start date or the work schedule – could be
better, and you have no reason to think the employer won't negotiate.
• You have been interviewing elsewhere and may be close to an offer from another company.
• You're not entirely sure this job is the right one. You have questions in your mind, such as:
Is this company financially stable? Any chance of layoffs in the next year or two?
Is this the right company culture for me?
Is there anything about the work schedule, the commute or the working conditions that's
going to get old fast?
What effect would this job have on my long-term career path?
Can I live on this salary?
Will I need to relocate? Will my family and I be happy in the new place?
Can I afford to wait for a better opportunity?
If so, I suggest you give an answer like this:
"This is a very exciting offer! I so appreciate it! Of course, it's a very important decision,
so I'd like to give it some careful thought. How soon do you need my answer?"
If you plan to negotiate, ask for a meeting:
"Is there a time tomorrow when we could meet to discuss the details of the offer?"
Whether you agree on giving an answer by Thursday, or meeting tomorrow at 1 pm to discuss
details, immediately send an email confirming what has been agreed.
Confirm, Confirm, Confirm
We've all heard that it's important to get a written offer letter (and to make sure all the details are as
agreed). But that's not the only point that needs to be confirmed in writing.
Opportunities have been lost because both parties were not clear about the next steps. "We didn't hear
back from you (within the timeframe we assumed you understood), so we had to move on." Whether
you're asking for time to think, for an answer to a question, or for an opportunity to discuss (negotiate)
details of the offer, make sure the next step is confirmed in writing.
Keep a pleasant tone about it. You're simply being thorough and professional for the benefit of all
concerned.
Will You Negotiate?
Not all job offers can be negotiated. Entry-level and some public sector job offers are commonly
(although not always) non-negotiable, and some corporations have a policy of not negotiating certain
aspects of the job, such as salary. But most employers expect some negotiation to occur – more than
80% according to a survey by Salary.com.
If you have never negotiated a job offer before, or are not sure you can, here are some reasons to
consider taking the leap:
• You'll probably end up with a better offer if you negotiate. Salary increases of $5K are very
common not to mention other perks.
• It's not just about your initial salary. Future raises will be based on a percentage of the salary
you obtain now. The salary of future job offers will be influenced by it.
• Assertiveness and negotiation may be on-the-job skills. Why not demonstrate them now?
• They may expect it and respect you more for it. Negotiating shows that you believe in your
value.
• It is highly unlikely they will withdraw the offer. As long as you communicate clearly, get
agreements in writing, and take a positive and reasonable approach throughout the process,
there is little risk. It would be highly unprofessional for an employer to withdraw an offer just
because you made a reasonable effort to negotiate.
• You're going to feel very empowered once you do it!
What Can Be Negotiated?
Salary isn't everything. It's actually a good idea to negotiate on more than one aspect of the package.
That way, if they can't meet your request in one area, they're likely to make it up to you on something
else.
Salary and Benefits:
• Base salary
• Timing of first salary review
• Signing bonus
• Annual/quarterly bonuses
• Stock options and other equity grants
• Health benefits (type and level of benefits, effective date)
• Retirement / termination pay (pension plans, severance packages)
• Tuition reimbursement
• Sick days / personal time off (PTO)
• Vacations (amount of, or the fact that you already have something scheduled)
• Relocation assistance, including reimbursement for house-hunting trips (with spouse or partner)
before start date
• Employee discounts
• Company car
• Mileage reimbursement
• Expense account
• Executive options such as: reimbursement of benefits lost by leaving another employer,
additional pensions/insurance, nonqualified deferred compensation plans (NQDCs),
supplemental executive retirement plans (SERPs), first class business travel, special parking, etc.
Other:
• Start date
• Hours, flexible work schedules
• Telecommuting
• Job title when starting
• Higher title after a specified time period
• Job responsibilities
Negotiating Tactics
Negotiating is an art, and many articles and books have been written offering various, sometimes
conflicting approaches. It's beyond the scope of this book to add to that discussion. However, I will offer
a few key points.
• It's best to have a firm, written offer of employment before beginning to negotiate the details.
• Do some research so you know what you're worth in the marketplace.
• Know your walk-away point, the lowest offer you would accept.
• Nurture good relationships throughout the process.
• Negotiate with the same positive attitude, respect and ethics the employer wants to see on the
job.
• Look for win-win solutions, and realize that it's truly in both parties' interests to craft a package
that will keep you happy.
• Focus on interests and needs rather than hard-and-fast positions. Be open to alternative ways of
addressing your interests.
• Realize that the negotiation may not be completed in one meeting. It's a process.
Juggling Two or More Offers
Let's say you get an offer at Company #1, but you have also interviewed at Company #2 and may be
close to an attractive offer there as well. What can you do?
Tell Company #2 you have a firm offer elsewhere, and ask whether they can accelerate the process.
Politely decline to state the specifics of the offer, such as salary; that information is confidential to
Company #1. (You can tell them Company #1's name if it seems helpful.)
Meanwhile, negotiate for time at Company #1. Taking up to a week to accept an offer is not unusual;
even longer for senior positions or if a relocation is involved. If they're in a hurry, express understanding
about their situation while being assertive about what you need. It's an important decision, after all. Let
them know you have another offer – or impending offer – that you need to consider, but make sure they
understand you are equally (or more) interested in their offer.
When you finally choose which job to accept, inform both parties verbally and in writing. Maintain a
positive relationship with Company #2. You never know what opportunities may arise there in future, or
who they may talk to.
Be very skeptical of any counter-offer you might receive from your current employer. Staying in an
existing job because they sweetened the deal tends to turn out badly. Your company would see you as a
flight risk, so you'd probably be passed over for important projects and promotions. Your political clout
would disappear and you'd essentially be a lame duck. Worse, the counter-offer might be intended only
to keep you in place until they can find a replacement – at which time you'd be let go. Your other
opportunities, of course, would be long gone.
Once you accept an offer, should you turn it down if a better one comes along? Generally, no.
Withdrawing your acceptance is likely to cause very hard feelings. You would be breaking a promise upon
which the employer will have made plans, including ceasing to pursue other candidates. They may have
actually said "no" to their second-choice candidate, who may now be unavailable. If you've already
started at the job the inconvenience and expense to the employer can be significant. All of this can
permanently damage your reputation.
That said, there may be times when the damage could conceivably be worth it. Maybe the second job
offer is an absolute dream job that will take your career to a whole new level. Or maybe the job you
accepted has turned out to be very different than described, and/or there is something very wrong with
it and it clearly won't work out. In either of these cases, apologize to your employer, explain the
situation honestly and tactfully, and do anything in your power to help make it better.
Ending a job search, and starting a new job, is a significant turning point in life. The first thing to do is
to celebrate! Woo-hoo!
The second thing to do is give a little thought to career management. Unless you're sure this is the last
job you'll ever have in your life – which is rarely the case in today's world – you can do yourself a big
favor by making this transition in a manner that supports your future career growth. The final, brief
chapter will help you navigate this transition and launch yourself into a successful start in your new role.
CHAPTER 18
You've Got the Job! – a Moment for Career Management
Arriving at one goal is the starting point to another.
– John Dewey
From the moment you accept a new job to your first glowing performance review on the new job, career
transition can be a bit of a roller coaster ride – exciting, hectic, even stressful. You get caught up in the
whirlwind of that. But it's also an important moment for some conscious career management.
Managing Your Career
Career management means realizing that although your new job is at XYZ Inc., your real, lifetime
employer is You Inc., and you're the leader of that enterprise.
Once upon a time we could depend on our employers for financial security. Today, there is more
security to be had from a well-managed career than from any individual job. Likewise, your personal and
professional fulfillment are up to you.
This advice is nothing new, but since it's part of a paradigm shift – a change in our mindset as a culture –
we need to be reminded of it.
Managing "Me, Inc." through your job transition means you're in charge of:
• Product Development – You and your skills are the product. What do you want to learn while
you're in this job?
• Talent Development and Advancement – Do you want to advance within the company, or
beyond it? To what role(s)? How will you get there?
• Finance – If you've been unemployed, you may have become painfully aware that you can't
count on a steady income at all times in your life. What's your plan to create or replenish your
between-jobs fund?
• Marketing Communications – Your current campaign is ending successfully! And good career
marketing is ongoing.
Speaking of marketing communications, during this job search, did you find yourself thinking "I wish I
had done (X) before I needed to start looking for a new job"? Did you wish you had…
…Kept track of accomplishments and kudos on the job, as "resume material"?
…Taken home copies of your performance reviews?
…Kept your resume and LinkedIn profile updated?
…Built a network and stayed in touch?
…Stayed on better terms with past employers?
If so, plan on taking these steps as you go along, so next time it can all be easier and even more
successful!
Let's look at some specific actions that will support your career as you're leaving your old job and getting
ready to start your new one.
Giving Notice and Transitioning Out
Before giving notice, make sure you have the new job offer in writing, including the start date. If you
have any doubts whether that job will really be there – for example, if the company is undergoing
extreme turmoil – clarify that with your boss-to-be before you give notice. New jobs have been known
to vanish between the offer and the start date.
Gather resume-fodder details while you still can. Giving notice doesn't necessarily mean the company
will want you to stay, and you may suddenly lose access to your computer and hardcopy files. So before
giving notice, and without violating agreements or ethics, gather up information that may be helpful in
your next job search, such as copies of your performance reviews and details about your
accomplishments (how much you increased sales last year, etc.).
Be clear what's yours and what's theirs. Does your LinkedIn profile belong to you, even though your
employer helped you set it up and it's connected to your business email address? Do you own your
customer contacts or not? Disputes have arisen over these types of information.
Give notice verbally and in writing. Break the news to your supervisor first, in a private meeting, and
agree on how and when the announcement will be made to others. Then write an email or letter stating
briefly that you are resigning and when your last day will be. Stating why you are leaving is not
necessary, but do include appreciation and thanks, even – or especially! – if the vibes are not gloriously
warm.
How much notice should you give? Two weeks' notice is standard; offering less is generally considered
unprofessional. You might even want to offer more if leaving in two weeks would cause a hardship for
the team. But don't let it drag on and on. Your future is with the new company, so put that relationship
first. Also consider your own needs for rest and recuperation. You may need to negotiate with both
employers to get some time off in between. Enjoy some time off if you possibly can! Starting a new job
takes a lot of energy.
Go out on a positive note. Past employers and co-workers are VIPs in your career network for many
reasons – as sources of references, recommendations and information; for their influence on your
reputation; and hopefully even as friends. So treat them well. Be willing to train your replacement.
Create documentation for the next person in the role. Share all those tips nobody knows better than
you.
Replacing Job Search with Ongoing Career Communications
Continue and nurture relationships with the people you've met in your search. Share your good news
with everyone who helped you in any way. Maybe treat somebody to a meal to celebrate together and
show appreciation for their support. Don't be one of those people who only get in touch when they
want something.
Update and improve your LinkedIn profile now; this is the very best time to do it. A year or two from
now you may be looking at new opportunities, but spiffing up your profile at that point may arouse
suspicion. Doing it now is safer, and will also help you look good to new colleagues who may be curious
about you. Ask for recommendations from people at the job you're leaving, especially your former boss.
(Aren't you glad you were nice on your way out?) Add your new job, either right before you start or, if
you have any doubts about whether it will work out, after you've been on the job a little while. Don't put
it off too long.
File away notes for your next job search. If you've created various versions of your resume, gathered a
lot of useful information about companies and job titles, and so on, you may want to refer to these
items at some point in the future. Put them where you'll be able to find them.
On Your New Job
If you've read this book, I'm guessing you work hard – and strategically – for what you want, and that
you're also smart about seeking out new knowledge and outside expertise to support your efforts. These
qualities will serve you well in your new workplace.
Your first days and months on the job will be about forming relationships, learning, and making a point
of achieving early wins to quickly establish yourself as a valuable team member. All of that is beyond the
scope of this book, but much has been written by others about making a great first impression at your
new job and ensuring that the crucial first few months will be evaluated positively.
May your new job and your career be a rich source of everything you want from it, whether that be
exciting challenges and growth, making a difference, prosperity, security, camaraderie or appreciation. I
wish you "all of the above"!
You only live once, but if you do it right, once is enough.
– Mae West
If you have found this book helpful, would you please leave a review at one of the following sites?
Amazon
Barnes & Noble
iBooks
or
Kobo
Thank you very much!
About the Author and Interview Coaching
It's an honor to help people achieve their career goals, and I'm grateful for all I've learned from my
clients and students over the years.
I'm also deeply appreciative to my friend and colleague Irene Marshall for her generous attention and
wise comments on the draft, and to my discerning husband Eric Kampman, without whom this book
would contain way! too! many! exclamation points!
Last but certainly not least, I appreciate you who are reading this book. Please let me know what you
think.