Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ieee PDF
Ieee PDF
ABSTRACT
This paper deal with influence of the existence of the epoxy spacer on the transmission
rate of partial discharge (PD) induced electromagnetic (EM) wave propagating through
T-Branch of 66 kV GIS model tank. The partial discharge sources are a particle on the
conductor and a free particle on the tank. PD induced EM wave was measured by ultra
high frequency (UHF) sensors and observed by the oscilloscope and the spectrum
analyzer. A low pass filtering (LPF) process for the cut off frequency of TE11 mode was
used to eliminate the higher order mode above TE11 of the detected signal. In addition,
a high pass filtering (HPF) process for the cut-off frequency of TE11 mode was used to
eliminate the lower frequency component below TE11 of the detected signal. We
discussed the effects of the T-branch and the effect of the existence of the epoxy spacer
on the peak to peak amplitude Vpp of the propagating EM wave before and after the
LPF and HPF processing. We compared the transmission rate (TR) of the propagating
EM wave before and after LPF and HPF processing through T-branch in straight
direction (TRS) with TR of EM wave before and after the LPF and HPF processing
turning at a right angle at the T-branch (TRT) in the presence and in the absence of the
epoxy spacer. The results showed that the transmission rate (TR) of EM wave in the
presence of the spacer was generally lower than one without spacer. TR of a particle on
the conductor was higher than TR of a particle on the tank. TRT was larger than TRS.
It was found that TR of low frequency component (TRLF) of EM wave signal was
higher than TR of high frequency component (TRHF) with and without epoxy spacer.
Index Terms — GIS, T-branch, spacer, electromagnetic wave, transmission rate
B A PD without spacer
40
-2 35
Particle on the 30
Time (10ns/div)
Time (10ns/div)
conductor
wave
2
UHFB 25
EM wave strength
20
Electromagnetic
0
50
Transmission Rate
-2 15
40
Time (10ns/div) 10
Time (10ns/div) 30
(%)
15.82% 17.83% 5
UHFC
EM wave strength (V)
2 20
0
0 10 UHF B UHF C UHF B UHF C
-2 0
Particle on the Conductor Free Particle on the Tank
Time (10ns/div) UHFB UHFC
Time (10ns/div)
a b Figure 6. Resume of propagation properties of EM wave measured with each
UHF sensor (66 kV T-branch model GIS WOS and WS, PD source: HVP and
FPT).
Figure 4. Propagation properties of EM wave measured with each UHF
sensor (66 kV model GIS WS, PD source: HVP).
spacer WS reduces TR to less than 20% for HVP and to about
4 10% for FPT. It means that the presence of spacer WS reduces
wave strength (V)
-2
C of FPT. TR of propagating EM wave through T-branch in
-4
Time
Time (10ns/div)
(10ns/div) Particle on the straight direction (TRS) is smaller with that TR of EM wave
4 conductor turning at a right angle at the T-branch (TRT).
UHFB
EM wave strength
2
While the details are explained later, these waveforms
0
50
largely depend on how TEM mode and TE mode are
Electromagnetic
39.51% 42.83%
Transmission Rate
-2
40 superimposed, and how EM wave are reflected at the terminal
-4
Time (10ns/div)
Time (10ns/div) 30 of GIS tank [9-12]. For this reason the amplitude varies
(%)
4
20 depending on the size and configuration of GIS, even for the
EM wave strength (V)
UHFC
2
10 same discharge. Therefore, it is unreasonable to simply
0
0
discuss the attenuation of only the amplitude value of the EM
-2
0.2
UHFB peak of the first wave Vpp of propagating EM wave after the
0.0 LPF processing. As for the low frequency component, the
transmission rate of TEM waves detected with UHF-B and
-0.2
UHF-C is almost same value in the absence of the spacer. In
Time (10ns/div) the presence of the spacer, the transmission rate of low
frequency component detected with UHF C was higher than
EM wave strength (V)
EM wave strength (V)
0.2
UHFC that with UHF B.
0.0
3.3 HIGH PASS FILTERING (HPF) PROCESS
-0.2
To discuss TE mode component of EM waves, the HPF
Time (10ns/div) process was undertaken for measured EM waveform, with
setting the cutoff frequency fc (LPF) of LPF at 700 MHz.
Figure 7. Propagating TEM mode component of PD-induced EM wave
extracted by LPF process (500 MHz, 66 kV model GIS WS, PD source: HVP). Figures 10 shows the waveforms undergoing the HPF process
with fc (HPF) = 700 MHz for the results given in Figure 4. In
this case, it is found that the signal intensity of UHF-C is
(V)
0.20
larger than that of UHF-B.
strength (V)
UHFA
wavestrength
0.10
0.00
Figure 11 shows the TR characteristics of the TE mode
component of EM wave obtained with each UHF sensor in
EMwave
-0.10
GIS WS and WOS. It can be seen that TR of TE mode
EM
-0.20
Time (10ns/div)
decreases significantly in WS. It was found that TRT was
larger than TRS after the HPF processing in WS and WOS.
(V)
0.2
strength (V)
wavestrength
0.0
UHFA
wavestrength
0.10
EMwave
-0.1 0.00
EMwave
EM
-0.2 -0.10
EM
(V)
0.2
strength (V)
strength (V)
wavestrength
UHFC UHFB
wavestrength
0.1 0.1
0.0
0.0
EMwave
-0.1
wave
-0.1
EM
-0.2
EMEM
Time (10ns/div)
-0.2
0.2
(V)
strength (V)
Time (10ns/div)
UHFC
wavestrength
0.1
0.0
wave
-0.1
Figure 8. Propagating TEM mode component of PD-induced EM wave
EMEM
-0.2
extracted by LPF process (500 MHz, 66 kV model GIS WOS, PD source: Time (10ns/div)
HVP). Figure 10. Propagating TE mode component of PD-induced EM wave
extracted by HPF process (700 MHz, 66 kV model GIS WS, PD source: HVP).
without spacer
80 45
with spacer without spacer
70 40
Transmission Rate (%)
with spacer
Transmission Rate (%)
35
60
30
50
25
40
20
30
15
20
10
10
5
0 0
UHF B UHF C UHF B UHF C UHF B UHF C
Particle on the Conductor Free Particle on the
Particle on the Conductor Tank
Figure 9. Transmission rate of TEM mode component of PD-induced EM Figure 11. Transmission rate of TE mode component of PD-induced EM
wave extracted by LPF process (500 MHz) for each UHF sensor against UHF- wave extracted by HPF process (700 MHz,) for each UHF sensor against
A (66 kV model GIS). UHF-A as function of Vpp value (66 kV model GIS).
3.4 FREQUENCY SPECTRUM OF PD INDUCED EM HVP and 70% for FPT. It is thus considered that large part of
WAVE TEM mode component of EM wave propagates through the
Figure 12 shows frequency spectrum of PD induced EM spacer, while TE mode component of EM wave is dominantly
wave for HVP in GIS WS and WOS measured at UHF A, B, reflected by the spacer.
and C for the comparison. When it is divided in the EM wave The experimental results of the frequency spectrum of EM
mode, it becomes the TEM mode, the TE11 mode, the TE21 wave in Figure 12 supports these results on the variation of the
mode, the TE31 mode, and TE41 mode from the left. The transmission rates. It is found from Figure 11 that the intensity
effect of the spacer is observed. It is shown that the high of high frequency component above the cut-off frequency (TE
frequency component of EM wave in WS is lower than that in mode) in WS was lower than that in WOS. The EM wave
WOS. The intensity of the high frequency component in UHF from FPT was attenuated by the spacer more than the EM
A is growing due to reflection of EM wave by the spacer. wave from HVC because the high frequency component
Moreover, the PD induced EM wave attenuates by the occupies more in the tank side than in the center side of GIS
difference of the transmission rate of the spacer in UHF B and tank. Since the high frequency component was reflected by the
UHF C. spacer it results in higher attenuation for EM wave originated
from FPT.
UHFA
UHFA
-20 UHF
BGN A
BGN spacer
The experimental results indicate that TR of propagating
(dBm)
-40
No spacer EM wave after HPF processing through T-branch in straight
EM wave
-60
BGN direction (TRS) was lower than one through T-branch in
wave intensity
-80
0 1 2 3 turning at a right angle direction (TRT) in both WS and WOS.
Frequency(GHz)
0 Frequency (GHz) With Analysis by LPF of EM wave revealed that TR of TEM
strength(dBm)
wave strength(dBm)
UHFB
UHFB
-20 UHFBGN B
BGN spacer mode of EM wave measured in straight direction (UHF B) and
-40 No spacer that in turning at right angle direction (UHF C) are almost
Electromagnetic
-60 BGN
direction at T-branch is caused by the difference in
EM
-80
0 1 2 3
Frequency(GHz) propagation of the high frequency component of EM wave.
0 Frequency (GHz)
EM wave strength(dBm)
UHFC
UHFC
UHF With The results are explained as follows. TEM mode propagates
-20 BGN C
BGN
spacer according to the travelling theory based on the distributed
-40
No spacer constant circuit with considering the characteristic impedance
-60
BGN of T-branch [12]. It means that the TEM mode propagates
-80
0 1 2 3 with the same intensity in the straight and turn right direction
689MHz Frequency(GHz)
Frequency (GHz) of T-branch. In other words, as shown in the Figure 13, TR is
Figure 12. Frequency spectrum of PD induced EM wave for HVP in GIS expressed as equation (1) where Z1 is the surge impedance of
WS and WOS measured at UHF A, B, and C. the 66 kV model GIS tank. The experimental result shown in
Figure 9 for T-branch type GIS shows that the average TR of
TEM mode of EM wave was 50% and 70% for both UHF-B
4 DISCUSSION and UHF-C with (WS) and without (WOS) the spacers,
respectively. Note that the relatively good agreement is
4.1 PROPAGATION PROPERTIES OF EMW obtained between the experimentally and theoretically derived
THROUGH SPACER TR for the TEM mode components. The discrepancy may be
Based on the experimental results, the propagation caused by the existence of the capacitance formed between the
properties of EM wave through spacer in T-branch 66 kV UHF coupler (disk shaped metal) and the flange of the GIS
model GIS is explained as follows. The existence of the spacer tank [9].
decreases the magnitude of EM wave and changes EM Z
waveform. As explained in chapter 3.1 the existence of the 2Z 2 2 1
t 2 2 ≒ 66.7 ・・・・ (1)
spacer reduces magnitude of original EM wave significantly,
Z1 Z 2 Z 3
that is, by 50% for HVP and 70% for FPT. Z1 1
2 ,
As shown in Figure 9, LPF process of EM wave gives
information that the existence of the spacer further reduces the
magnitude of TEM mode of EM wave with additional
reduction by 35% for HVP and 30% for FPT. It means that the
attenuation by spacer is caused more by the attenuation of
high frequency component of EM wave. As shown in Figure
11, HPF of EM wave confirms that the existence of the spacer
reduces magnitude of TE mode component about 60% for Figure 13. Equivalent circuit of T-branch for TEM mode component using
distributed constant network.
On the other hand, analysis by HPF of EM wave results in [10] Masayuki Hikita, Shinya Ohtsuka, Genyo Ueta, Shigemitsu Okabe,
Toshihiro Hoshino and Shiro Maruyama. “Influence of Insulating Spacer
that TR of EM wave in straight direction (UHF B) is lower
Type on Propagation Properties of PD-induced Electromagnetic Wave in
than one in turning at right angle direction (UHF C). It is GIS”, IEEE Trans. Dielectr. Electr. Insul., Vol. 17, No.5, pp. 1642-1647,
already reported that TE mode components of EM waves can 2010.
be reflected at the L-shaped branch [11]. Similarly, it is [11] M. Hikita, S. Otsuka, J. Wada, S. Okabe, T. Hoshino, and S. Maruyama,
“Propagation Properties of PD-induced Electromagnetic Wave in 66 kV
thought that the existence of T-branch would make it difficult
GIS Model with L Branch Structure”, IEEE, Trans. Dielectr. Electr.
for high frequency components above TE mode of EM waves Insul., Vol.18, No.5, pp.1678-1685, October 2011.
to propagate. [12] M. Hikita, S. Otsuka, S. Okabe, G. Ueta, T. Hoshino, and S. Maruyama,
“Propagation Properties of PD-induced Electromagnetic Wave in GIS
Model Tank with T Branch Structure”, IEEE, Trans. Dielectr. Electr.
5 CONCLUSION Insul.,Vol.18, No.1, pp.256-263, 2011.
We investigated the influence of the existence of the epoxy
spacer on propagation properties of PD-induced EM wave
measured with UHF sensors in 66 kV model GIS. The results Umar Khayam (Non Member) was born in 1975. He
showed that the transmission rate (TR) of EM wave in the received B.Eng. (cum laude), M.Eng. degrees in
presence of the spacer was generally lower than that without electrical engineering from Bandung Institute of
Technology (ITB), Indonesia, in 1998 and 2000,
the spacer. TR for a particle on the conductor (HVP) was respectively. He received Doctor Degree in electrical
higher than TR for a particle on the tank (FPT). Transmission engineering from Kyushu Institute of Technology
rate at turn right of T branch (TRT) was larger than one at (KIT), Japan in 2008. He was a researcher at Hikita
Laboratory, KIT during 2008-2009 and 2010-2011.
straight direction (TRS). It was found that TR of low
Since 2008 he is a Lecturer at School of Electrical
frequency component (TRLF) of EMW signal was higher than Engineering and Informatics ITB. His research interest
TR of high frequency component (TRHF). It is considered that is partial discharge measurement and phenomena in electric power apparatus.
large part of TEM mode component of EM wave propagates
Masahiro Kozako is an Assistant Professor at
through the spacer, while TE mode component of EM wave is
Department of Electrical Engineering and Electronics,
dominantly reflected by the spacer. Kyusyu Institute of Technology. He was born on 13
August, 1974 in Tokyo. He received the B. Eng., M. Eng.,
and Dr. Eng. degrees in electrical engineering from
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Kyushu Institute of Technology in 1997, 1999, and 2002,
The authors would like to express special thanks to Mr. respectively. He worked at Waseda University for 3 years
Hajime Takada, Mr. Masayuki Hayashi, and Mr. Satoshi and at Kagoshima National College of Technology for 3
years. His research interests concern the development of new insulating
Yoshida of Kyushu Institute of Technology for their helping polymer nano-composite materials and the development of diagnostic
conduct experiments. technique of electric power apparatus. He is a member of the IEEJ and the
IEEE.
REFERENCES Masayuki Hikita (M’97-SM’98) was born in 1953. He
[1] M. D. Judd, O. Farish, and B.F. Hampton, “The Excitation of UHF received the B.S., M.S. and Dr. degrees in electrical
Signals by Partial Discharges in GIS”, IEEE Trans. Dielectr. Electr. engineering from Nagoya University, Japan, in 1977,
Insul., Vol. 3, pp.213-228, 1996. 1979, and 1982, respectively. He was assistant Professor,
[2] T. Hoshino, H. Koyama, S. Maruyama, and M. Hanai, "Comparison of Lecture, and Associate Professor at Nagoya University in
Sensitivity between UHF Method and IEC 60270 for On-site Calibration 1982, 1989, and 1992, respectively. Since 1996, he has
in Various GIS," IEEE Trans. Power Delivery, vol. 21, no. 4, pp. 1948- been a professor of Department of Electrical Engineering,
1953, Oct. 2006. Kyushu Institute of Technology. He was Visiting Scientist
[3] S.M.Hoek, U.Riechert, T.Streh, S.Tenbohlen and K. Feser, “A New at the High Voltage Laboratory in MIT, USA, from 1985 to 1987. Dr. Hikita
Procedure for Partial Discharge Localization in Gas-Insulated has been interested in the development of diagnostic technique of electric
Switchgears in Frequency Domain”, in Proc. 14th ISH, No.G-05,2005. power apparatus and insulation system of power electronics device and
[4] S.M. Hoek, M. Koch and M. Heindl: “Propagation Mechanisms of PD apparatus. He is a member of the Japan Society of Applied Physics and the
Pulses for UHF and Traditional Electrical Measurements”, Proceedings IEEJ.
of the 2010 International Conference on Condition Monitoring and
Diagnosis, No. C2-2 2010. Toshihiro Hoshino (M’02) was born in Aichi, Japan, on October 30, 1971.
[5] M. Hanai, F. Endo, S. Okabe, T. Kato, H. Hama, and M. Nagao, “New He received his B.S., M.S., and Ph.D. in electrical engineering from Nagoya
development for detecting partial discharge using an UHF method and University in 1995, 1997, and 1999, respectively. He joined Toshiba
its application to power apparatus in Japan,” CIGRE Session 2006. Corporation in 1999. After temporarily being a member of TMT&D
[6] S. Okabe, S. Kaneko, M. Yoshimura, H. Muto, C. Nishida and M. Corporation, he is now with the high-voltage technology group of Toshiba
Kamei, “Partial Discharge Diagnosis Method Using Electromagnetic Corporation. He has been engaged in research on insulation diagnosis of GIS
Wave Mode Transformation in Gas Insulated Switchgear”, IEEE Trans. and high-voltage insulation technology. Dr. Hoshino is a member of IEEE and
Dielectr. Electr. Insul., Vol. 14, No. 3, pp.702-709, June 2007. IEE of Japan.
[7] M. Yoshimura, H. Muto, C. Nishida, M. Kamei, S. Okabe and S.
Kaneko, “Propagation Properties of Electromagnetic Wave through T- Shiro Maruyama received his B.S. and M.S. degree in electrical and
branch in GIS”, IEEE Trans. Dielectr. Electr. Insul., Vol. 14, No. 2, electronics engineering from Nagoya University, Nagoya, Japan in 1980 and
pp.328-333, April 2007. 1982 respectively. He joined Toshiba Corporation in 1982. After temporarily
[8] A. J. Reid, and M. D. Judd, “High Bandwidth Measurement of Partial being a member of TMT&D Corporation, he is now with the monitoring
Discharge Pulses in SF6,” Paper No. G-012, 14th ISH, 2005. systems design section of Toshiba Corporation. He has been engaged in the
[9] Masayuki Hikita, Shinya Ohtsuka, Shigemitsu Okabe, Junichi Wada, development and design of monitoring and diagnostic system for high-voltage
Toshihiro Hoshino and Shiro Maruyama. “Influence of Disconnecting gas-insulated substations. Mr. Maruyama is a member of CIGRE and IEE of
Part on Propagation Properties of PD-induced Electromagnetic Wave in Japan.
Model GIS”, IEEE Trans. Dielectr. Electr. Insul., Vol. 17, No.6, pp.
1731-1737, 2010.
Junichi Wada received the B.S. and M.S. degrees from
Tokyo Denki University in 2004 and 2006, respectively.
He joined Tokyo Electric Power Company in 2006.
Currently, he is a researcher at the High Voltage &
Insulation Group of R&D Center and mainly engaged in
research on insulation characteristics of GIS.