Professional Documents
Culture Documents
International Food Science and Technology
International Food Science and Technology
International http://fst.sagepub.com/
Published by:
http://www.sagepublications.com
On behalf of:
Additional services and information for Food Science and Technology International can be found at:
Subscriptions: http://fst.sagepub.com/subscriptions
Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav
Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav
Citations: http://fst.sagepub.com/content/6/3/243.refs.html
What is This?
Instituto del Frío (CSIC). Ciudad Universitaria s/n, Madrid 28040, Spain
Vacuum packed hake muscle subjected to 400 MPa (three 5-min cycles) at 7 °C proved to be more
stable chilled temperatures (2-3 °C), and sensorially acceptable, until 43 days of storage in com-
at
parison with the nine days for the non-pressurized hake. The lot pressurized at 400 MPa had the
appearance of cooked muscle. The microbial load was initially reduced by two log units by pressur-
ization at 400 MPa. Trimethylamine nitrogen (TMA-N) values were also very low. Pressurization had
no effect on dimethylamine nitrogen (DMA-N) production. The lot pressurized at 400 MPa showed
slower increase in drip loss from day 15 of storage. In the lot subjected to 200 MPa (three 5-min
cycles) at 7 °C, which retained the appearance of raw fish, microorganisms were one log unit lower
than in the non-pressurized sample and TMA-N was lower. In conclusion, the chilled shelf life was
prolonged by about one week in the lot pressurized at 200 MPa and about two weeks in the lot
pressurized at 400 MPa.
Keywords: hake, shelf life, chilling, high pressure, storage, vacuum packaging
La presurizaci6n increment6 notablemente la vida util del musculo de merluza almacenado en
refrigeraci6n (2-3 °C). El lote presurizado a 400 MPa (tres ciclos de cinco minutos) a 7°C result6 ser el
-
mas estable a temperaturas de refrigeraci6n, y aceptable desde el punto de vista sensorial hasta los 43
dias de almacenamiento, tiempo muy superior a los 9 dias en los que se descart6 el lote sin presurizar.
El lote presurizado tenia la apariencia de musculo cocido. La carga microbiana (ufc/g) se redujo
inicialmente en dos unidades logaritmicas con el tratamiento a 400 Mpa, asimismo se obtuvieron valores
muy bajos en nitr6geno de trimetilamina (N-TMA). La presurizad6n no tuvo ningun efecto sobre la
producci6n de nitr6geno de dimetilamina (N-DMA). El lote presurizado a 400 MPa mostr6 unos valores
de exudado por debajo de los demas lotes a partir de los 15 dias de conservaci6n. El lote presurizado a
200 MPa (tres ciclos de cinco minutos) a 7 °C, que conserv6 una apariencia de pescado crudo, present6
una reducci6n de microorganismos de una unidad logaritmica y una menor cantidad en N-TMA en
relaci6n con el lote testigo sin presurizar. En conclusi6n, los lotes presurizados a 200 MPa y 400 MPa
mostraron un incremento de la vida util de aproximadamente una y dos semanas, respectivamente.
Palabras clave: merluza, vida util, refrigeraci6n, altas presiones, almacenamiento, envasado a vacio
temperature 115 °C) ready for high pressure treatment ity’, very fresh and unfresh fish were tested by the panel
and storage at chilled temperature (2.0-3.0 °C). Two dif- at the same time as the samples. Lots scoring less than 4
ferent packs with approximately 300-350 g of muscle in for any sensory parameter were rejected.
each bag were pressurized simultaneously.
Pressure was applied by a hydrostatic pressure unit Drip and cooking loss measurements
(Gec Alsthom ACB 900 HP, Type ACIP model 665,
Nantes, France). Pressures of 200 MPa (lot P1 ) and 400 Drip loss and cooking loss were measured throughout
MPa (lot P2) were applied in three 5-min cycles at 30 s the storage period. Drip loss was measured as the dif-
intervals at a temperature of 7 °C, as measured by a ference between muscle weight at the outset of storage
thermocouple inside the vessel when the desired pres- and at the time of analysis after draining off the released
sure was reached. Following pressurization (not includ- liquid. Cooking loss was measured after placing samples
ing control, lot T), all lots were kept in a cold store in in boiling water for 5 min. Cooking loss was calculated
their separate packs for the entire storage period. Peri- as the difference between muscle weight before and af-
odic analyses were performed during this time period. ter heat treatment following removal of exudate once
Downloaded from fst.sagepub.com at CARLETON UNIV on July 6, 2014
245
the samples had cooled to room temperature. Both types Immediately following pressurization at 200 and 400
of loss were expressed as percentages. Analyses were MPa, the high initial microbial load of samples on re-
performed in duplicate from different packs. ception log units (cfu / g)) was 1 and 2 log units lower,
(6
respectively (Figure 1). Pressure-dependent reduction
Statistical alT~ljl/SIS -
of microorganisms has been described by other authors,
who found that inactivation increased with pressure
Analysis of variance and regression analysis were per- (Cheftel, 1995). The evolution of counts was similar in
formed using an SAS program (SAS Institute Inc, Cary, all three lots up to 12 days of storage, but the lot pres-
NC, USA).. surized at 400 MPa presented significantly lower val-
ues than the others, except
at day 12. All lots exhibited
latency from day 0 to day of storage probably due to
5
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION high pressure and vacuum, thereafter the microbial load
began to increase. The control lot (unpressurized) pre-
Experiments at different pressures produced two types sented counts of over 101 cfu / g on day 9 of storage,
of product: one having a cooked appearance following when it was rejected by the sensory panel. Considering
pressurizing at 400 MPa (lot P2), and another having a that at day 0 of storage, the hake had been five days in
fresh appearance after pressurizing at 200 MPa (lot P1 ). ice between capture and arrival at the laboratory, these
As noted by Ohshima et al. (1993) and by Ashie and values are very similar to those of Sumner and Gorczyca
Simpson (1996) high pressure can induce modifications (1981) in Merluccius capel1sis at day 14 of chilled stor-
in the appearance of fish muscle, which generally be- age. When lots PI and P2 were rejected by the panel,
comes whiter the higher the pressure. The mechanism the counts were over 8 log units (cfu / g). According to
involved in color change is, however, still unclear even Olafsd6ttir et al. (1997), total aerobic microorganism
though pressure-induced denaturation of heme com- counts in the range 10’-108 cfu / g are typical for fish
pounds like metmyoglobin have been shown to cause products at the time of rejection. Possible hazards of the
spectral shifts in such compounds (Zipp and Kauzmann, vacuum packed products are: (i) the growth of patho-
1973; Gibson and Carey, 1977). genic vegetative forms such as Clostridium botulinum,
Immediately after pressurization both pressurized chiefly those non-proteolytic strains (B or E) that can
and control lots had similar scores in general appear- produce botulin toxin without fish spoiling (Phillips,
ance, odor and flavor (Table 1). During chilled storage 1996); and (ii) the growth of pathogenic microorganisms
the pressurized lots (PI and P2) scored higher than the like Salmonella spp. and Listeria monocytogel1es (Anony-
control in all sensory parameters. The control lot was mous, 1991). Proper processing will minimize these
rejected after nine days of storage due to low scoring in risks, and at a storage temperature below 3 °C, as in the
all three parameters, whereas the pressurized lots (PI present study, it is essential to prevent the growth of
and P2) were respectively rejected between 15 and 22, Clostridium botuli1Zum (Cann, 1988; Baldratti et al., 1989;
or 36 and 43 days. Gibbs et al., 1994; Garren ef nl., 1995; Reddy et al., 1995)
Table 1. Sensory analysis of hake during chilled storage. T: Control. P1: Pressurized lot at 200 MPa in three 5-minute
cycles at 7 °C. P2: Pressurized lot at 400 MPa in three 5-minute cycles at 7 °C.
Tabla 1. An~lisis sensorial durante el almacenamiento de la merluza en refrigeraci6n. T: Lote control. P1: Lote
presurizado a 200 MPa en tres ciclos de 5 minutos cada una a 7 °C. P2: Lote presurizado a 400 MPa en tres ciclos
de 5 minutos cada uno a 7°C.
conservaci6n de la merluza en refrigeraci6n. (*) Control. In summary, pressurization prolonged the shelf life
(0) Lote sometido a 200 MPa a 7 °C (P1 ). (A) Lote of chilled hake, whether pressurized at 200 MPa and
sometido a 400 MPa a 7 °C (P2). retaining the appearance of fresh fish, or pressurized at
Downloaded from fst.sagepub.com at CARLETON UNIV on July 6, 2014
248
Anonymous. (1991). The Microbiological Status of Some Mail Or- Chemistry 252: 4098-4101.
der Foods. London, UK: MAFF. Gill T.A. and Paulson T. (1982). Localization, characterization
Ashie I.N.A. and Simpson B.K. (1996). Application of high and partial purification of TMAO-ase. Comparative Biochem-
hydrostatic pressure to control enzyme related fresh sea- istry and Physiology 71B: 49-56.
Downloaded from fst.sagepub.com at CARLETON UNIV on July 6, 2014
49
Gola S., Maggi A., Carpi G., Pirazzoli P., Incerti I. and Rovere NFI (1991).
A Manual Of Standard Methods for Measuring and Speci-
P. (1996). High pressure treated shrimp cream: microbio- fying the Properties of Surimi. Lanier T.C., Hart K. and Martin
logical, chemical and sensorial shelf-life evaluation at re- R.E. (eds). Washington, DC: National Fisheries Institute.
frigeration temperature. In: th 26 Western European Fish Tech- Ohmori T., Shigehisa T., Taji S. and Hayashi R. (1991). Effect
nologist’ Association (WEFTA) Meeting. September 22-26, of high pressure on the protease activities in meat. Agricul-
1996. Gdynia, Polonia. tural and Biological Chemistry 55: 1253-1257.
González-Sotelo M.C. (1991). Thesis: Modificaciones del Ohshima T., Ushio H. and Koizumi C. (1993). High-pressure
músculo de merluza (Merluccius merluccius) durante su processing of fish and fish products. Trends in Food Science
conservación en estado congelado. Universidad de Santiago and Technology November (4): 370-375.
de Compostela, Facultad de Biologia. Ólafsdóttir G., Martinsdótirr E., Oehlenschläger J., Dalgaard
Hayakawa Y., Kanno T., Yoshima K. and Fujio Y. (1994). Oscil- P., Jensen B., Undeland I., Mackie M.I., Henehan G., Nielsen
latory compared with continuous high pressure steriliza- J. and Nilsen H. (1997). Methods to evaluate fish freshness
tion on Bacillus stearothermophilus Journal
spores. of Food Sci- in research and industry. Trends in Food Science and Technol-
ence. 59: 164-167.
ogy 8: 258-265.
Heremans K. (1992). From living systems to biomolecules. In: Phillips C.A. (1996). Review: modified atmosphere packag-
Balny C., Hayashi R., Heremans K. and Masson P. (eds), ing and its effects on the microbiological quality safety of
High Pressure and Biotechnology. Colloque INSERM. Vol. 224. produce. International Journal of Food Science and Tecnology 3:
Paris: John Libbey Eurotext Ltd. pp. 37-44. 463-479.
Hurtado J.L., Montero P. and Borderias J. (1998). Effect of high Reddy N.R., Paradis A., Roman M.G., Solomon H.M. and
pressure on muscle of octopus (Octopus vulgaris). In: IV th Rhodehamel E.J. (1995). Toxin development by Clostridium
Joint Meeting of Japanese and European Seminars on High Pres- botulinum in modified atmosphere-packaged fresh tilapia
sure Bioscience and Biotechnology. 30 August-3 September, fillets during storage. Journal of Food Science 61 (3): 632-635.
University of Heidelberg, Germany. Ruiz-Capillas C. (1997). Thesis. Almacenamiento de merluza
Jensen M.H., Petersen A., Roge E.H. and Jepsen A. (1980). Stor- (Merluccius merluccius L.) refrigerada en atmósferas de
age of chilled cod under vacuum and at various concentra- concentraciones variables de CO 2 yO : estudio de indices de calidad
2
tions of carbon dioxide. In: Advances in Fish Science and Tech- convencionales, aminoácidos libres y aminas biógenas. Universidad
nology. Vol. 6. Lyngby, Denmark: Tech. Lab., Min. of Fisher- Complutense de Madrid, Facultad de Veterinaria.
ies, Tech. Univ. pp. 294-297. Shigehisa T., Ohmori T., Saito A., Taji S. and Hayashi R. (1991).
Joly A., Cotin P., Han-Ching L. and Ducastaing A. (1992). Tri- Effects of high hydrostatic pressure on characteristics of pork
methylamine N-oxide demethylase (TMAO-ase) of saithe slurries and inactivation of microorganisms associated with
(Pollachius virens) kidney: A study of some physicochemi- meat and meat products. International Journal of Food Micro-
cal and enzymatic properties. Journal of the Science of Food biology 12: 207-216.
and Agriculture 59: 261-267. Shoji T. and Saeki H. (1989). Processing and preservation of
Kavecansky J., Dannenberg A.J. and Zakim D. (1992). Effects fish meat by pressurization. In: Hayashi, R. (ed.), Use of High
of high presssure on the catalytic and regulatory properties Pressure in Food. Kyoto, Japan: San-ei Publ. pp. 75-87.
of UDP-glucuronosyltransferase in intact microsomes. Bio- Simpson R.K. and Gilmour A. (1997). The effect of high hy-
chemistry 31: 162-168. drostatic pressure on Listeria monocytogenes in phosphate-
Knorr D. (1994). Hydrostatic pressure treatment of food: mi- buffered saline and model food systems. Journal of Applied
crobiology. In: Gould G.N. (ed.), New Methods of Food Pres- Microbiology 83: 181-188.
ervation. London: Blackie Academic and Professional. pp. Smelt J.P.P.M. (1998). Recent advances in the microbiology of
159-175. high pressure processing. Trends in Food Science and Technol-
L6pez-Caballero M.E., Pérez-Mateos M., Montero P. and ogy 9: 152-158.
Borderias A.J. (1999). Conservación de ostras refrigeradas Styles M.F., Dallas G.H. and Farkas D.F. (1991). Response of
tratadas por alta presión. In: VII Congreso Nacional de Listeria monocytogenes and Vibrio parahaemolyticus to high
Acuicultura, Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain. May 1999. hydrostatic pressure. Journal of Food Science 56
(5):1404—1407.
Lundstrom R.C., Correia F.F. and Wilhelm K.A. (1981). Sumner J.L. and Gorczyca E. (1981). Effect of vacuum-pack-
Dimethylamine and formaldehyde production in fresh red aging on the shelf-life of fish held either in ice or at 4—6 °C.
hake (Urophysis chuss): the effect of packaging material oxy- Refrigeration Science and Technology (IIR) 4: 365—370.
gen permeability and cellular damage. International Insti- Tozawa H., Enokihara K. and Amano K. (1971). Proposed
tute of Refrigeration (Fish Symposium). Boston, MA, USA. modification of Dyer’s methods for trimethylamine deter-
pp. 457-465. mination in cod fish. In: Kreuzer (ed.), Fish Inspection and
Murakami T., Kimura I., Yamagishi T., Yamashita M., Sugimoto Quality Control. London: R. Fishing News Ltd.
M. and Satake M. (1992). Thawing of frozen fish by hydro- Yoshioka K. and Yamamoto T. (1998). Changes of ultrastruc-
static pressure. In: Balny C., Hayashi R., Heremans K. and ture and the physical properties of carp muscle by high pres-
Masson P. (eds), High Pressure and Biotechnology. Colloque surization. Fisheries Science 64
(1): 89-94.
INSERM. Vol. 224. Paris: John Libbey Eurotext Ltd. pp. 329- Zipp A. and Kauzmann W. (1973). Pressure denaturation of
331. metmyoglobin. Biochemistry 12: 4217-4228.