Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Psychoactive Medicines Use in The Elderly - Study Proposal
Psychoactive Medicines Use in The Elderly - Study Proposal
Psychoactive Medicines Use in The Elderly - Study Proposal
Research Proposal
Psychoactive medicines are substances that can alter mood, thought processes, or
behaviour by causing sedation, hypnosis and muscle relaxation [1-3]. Some of these
medicines are approved to treat anxiety, insomnia, depression and other related central
nervous system diseases. Examples of psychoactive medicines with sedative properties
that are approved for treatments are antipsychotics (chlorpromazine and thioridazine),
hypnotics and sedatives (alprazolam and amobarbital), anxiolytics (clonazepam and
diazepam) and anti-epileptics (gabapentin and lamotrigine).
Studies have shown that psychoactive medicines with sedative properties can
cause adverse effects such as fall [4]. Fall is one of the major public health problems
among elderly people and is the leading cause of injury and death [5-7]. In one study
undertaken in Netherlands, approximately 30% to 70% of nursing home residents fall at
least once a year [8]. Although there are various factors that led to falls, medication use is
one of the important risk factors for falls in elderly people and is considered as
potentially modifiable risk factors [6, 10].
Studies have shown that psychoactive medicines are commonly prescribed for the
elderly [6]. In one meta-analysis study, it is stated that the multiple use of psychoactive
medicine increases risk of falls that resulting in hospitalisation [11]. There are limited
information regarding the use of psychoactive medicines and its association with falls in
Malaysian elderly. The only study that was undertaken in Malaysia is to determine the
fall risk factors among Malaysian older adults [5].This study found that the strongest
predictor that contributed to the high level of fall risk was medical condition (OR 10.63;
95% CI 1.617- 69.950) instead of medication (OR 0.609; 95% CI 0.221 – 1.682). The
study however did not investigate types of medications that lead to fall risk among the
elderly. Thus, this study is an attempt to identify the association between use of
psychoactive medicines and risk of falls among elderly in Malaysia.
2|Page
Literature Review
Geriatrics/Elderly
Elderly is an age group of people that is not easy to define precisely [12]. Older
people or older adult is sometimes preferred but is equally imprecise and > 65 is the age
often used. In developed country, the elderly is at the age of 65 and over because the
economic status, education and health status is higher compared to developing country
[13]. Meanwhile, the age of elderly in developing country such as Malaysia is 60.
Geriatrics and gerontology refer to fields of study related to aging and older
adulthood [14]. Geriatrics is the branch of medicine specializing in the medical care and
treatment of the diseases and health problems of older adults. Gerontology is the study of
the biological, behavioral, and social phenomena that occur from the point of maturity to
old age. In other terms, geriatrics applied to the study of the disease-related aspects of
aging, while gerontology refers to the study of healthy older adults.
3|Page
Geriatric Health
The elderly is unique and not same as the young people. This is because they
often have multiple medical problems, different patterns of disease presentation, often
slower response to treatment and requirements for social support [18]. “Geriatric Giants”
is a term created by Bernard Isaacs, is refers to the principal chronic disabilities of old
age that impact on physical, mental and social domains of older adults [19]. The other
term which is also known as 5 I’s are the expression for incontinence, immobility,
instability, intellectual impairment and iatrogenic. There are actually a lot more I’s such
as infection, impotence, impaired vision and hearing as well as insomnia.
Instability (Falls)
The definitions of falls are varying between studies and there is no specific
operational definition of fall yet [20, 21]. Most studies characterised the fall to be
‘unintentional’ and in the form of contact with the ground and most studies have also
excluded falls caused by road accidents and violence [20]. As stated in WHO Global
Report on Falls Prevention in Older Age 2008, falls are generally defined as
“inadvertently coming to rest on the ground, floor or other lower level, excluding
intentional change in position to rest in furniture, wall or other objects” [21]. Other
4|Page
definition by Kellogg International Work Group, a fall is an “event which results in a
person coming to rest inadvertently on the ground and other than a consequence of the
following: loss of consciousness, sudden onset of paralysis, or epileptic seizure” [22].
Besides, falls are coded as E880-E888 in International Classification of Disease-9 (ICD-
9), and as W00-W19 in ICD-10, which include a wide range of falls including those on
the same level, upper level, and other unspecified falls [21, 23].
Falls in elderly are a major health problem that can cause morbidity and mortality
[24]. It is expected that one in three persons over the age of 65 is likely to fall at least
once each year [25]. According to Ferri, the incidence of falls among community-
dwelling older adults is 30% to 40%. Two thirds of falls in the community are
preventable; 6% to 7% of these falls result in fracture. The incidence of falls for nursing
home and hospitalized older adults is three times the rate of community-dwelling older
adults. Over 50% of nursing home residents fall during their stay [23]. In another study
conducted by Rubenstein and Josephson, in community dwelling older adults, the annual
mean of falls is 34% (range 30-60%) and the incidence rate of falls is 0.7 per person per
year. Meanwhile, in institutionalized older adults, the annual mean of falls is 43% (range
16-75%) with the incidence rate of 1.4 falls per person per year in hospital setting [26].
Moreover, a study was conducted in primary care clinic in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia to
determine the prevalence and patterns of falls in community dwelling older people. A
total of 151 respondents showed that the prevalence of falls was 47% with 57% reported
experiencing recurrent falls [27].
5|Page
Multiple risk factors such as intrinsic and extrinsic factors contributed to the
increment of fall rates. The intrinsic factors can be such as medical condition, sensory
deficit, mobility limitation and age [5]. According to Todd C and Skelton D. (2004) in
their article entitled What are the main risk factors for falls amongst older people and
what are the most effective interventions to prevent these falls?, they mentioned the types
of medical conditions that predispose to risk of falls. They are circulatory disease,
chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), depression and arthritis. The prevalence
of fall increases with rising chronic disease burden. In addition, thyroid dysfunction,
diabetes and arthritis also increase risk of falls [33]. For the extrinsic factors which also
known as environmental hazards, the risk factors for falls are slippery flooring, poor
lighting as well as the unstable ground surface [5]. Medication use which can be
categorized as intrinsic factor [5] is an important risk factor for falls in older people [11].
Moreover, medication use is also considered as one of the most easily reversible risk
factors for falls [11] and medicines review is suggested in most guidelines for the
prevention of falls in elderly [8, 30].
According to a study that was conducted in the western country, about 38% of the
elderly consume prescribed medications. Elderly in community consumes about 4.5
medications while in the nursing homes setting, more than 7 medications are consumed
[18]. Usually, they have multiple co-morbidities and hence, more medications are
prescribed. The commonly prescribed drugs for elderly are non-steroidal anti-
inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), antihypertensives, and anticholinergics but antipsychotics
are the most prescribed. Table 1 below shows some drugs that contribute to risk of falls.
6|Page
7|Page
Table 1: Some Drugs That Contribute to Risk of Falls
Drugs Mechanism
Aminoglycosides Direct vestibular damage
Analgesics (especially opioids) Reduced alertness or slow central
processing
Antiarrhythmics Impaired cerebral perfusion
Anticholinergics Confusion/delirium
Antihypertensives (especially vasodilators) Impaired cerebral perfusion
Antipsychotics Extrapyramidal syndromes, other
antiadrenergic effects
Diuretics (especially when patients are Impaired cerebral perfusion
dehydrated)
Loop diuretics (high-dose) Direct vestibular damage
Psychoactive drugs (especially Reduced alertness or slow central
antidepressants, antipsychotics, and processing
benzodiazepines)
Another study which is conducted in the day clinic of the department of geriatric
medicine of the Academic Hospital Utrecht, Netherlands showed that short acting
benzodiazepines and hypnotics were the most common psychotropic medications
prescribed with 18.6% number of users [31]. This percentage was followed by
antidepressants with 18.3% number of users. The least percentage number of users was
3.0% which is for anti-dementia medications.
8|Page
Association between psychoactive medicines used and hospitalization for falls.
A similar result was observed when the data were analysed by dose, with the
highest risk being found for those taking three or more DDD per day (adjusted IRR 4.26,
95 % CI 2.75–6.58).The DDD is the assumed average maintenance dose per day for a
drug used for its main indication in adults [9].
9|Page
PROBLEM STATEMENT
As Malaysia will reach ageing population in 20 years ahead, there will be more
people aged 60 years and older [32]. Recognizing falls as a public health problem is still
low in developing countries. There is still lack of information and study regarding the use
of psychoactive medicines in elderly of this country and its association with falls. Hence,
this study is conducted as an attempt to provide the information regarding to both
statements. If the result shows is significant, the authorities or related personnel or body
can find solutions to encounter these problem.
The findings of the study will provide an evidence-based data regarding the
prevalence of use of psychoactive medicines in elderly and its association with falls in
Malaysia. Preventive measures can be taken if the result is significant. This can give a
contribution to the geriatric care in Malaysia.
Study Aim
The purpose of this study is to find out about psychoactive medicines and its
association with falls in elderly as medications related can be a potentially modifiable
risk factor for falls.
10 | P a g e
Objectives
Main Objective
Specific Objectives
11 | P a g e
METHODOLOGY
Sampling Method
Convenient sampling with completed medical record in 6 months (1st July 2015 –
31st December 2015) will be used in this study. The medical record contains all
information on the demographic profile, cause of hospitalisation and medications intake
for a single patient. Our sample would be geriatric patients who were admitted in the
geriatric ward for any diagnosis from 1st July 2015 until 31st December 2015. For a
patient who had more than one admission would be count as one sample. Our sample
would be based on number of patients but not number of admissions. We would count the
number of admission or hospitalisation as a separate event. Figure 1 shows how we
planned our design for selection of sample of an individual patient.
12 | P a g e
Sample size determination
Sample size = Z2 x (p) x [(1-p) / C2] where,
Z = Z value (e.g.: 1.96 for 95% confidence interval)
P = percentage picking a choice, expressed as a decimal (0.5 used for sample size
needed)
C = confidence interval
Sample Size = [(1.96)2 x (0.5) x (1-0.5)] / (0.05)2 = 384.16
Corrected sample size for finite population = Sample Size / [1 + (SS – 1) / Estimated
Population]
= 384.16/ (1 + (384.16 – 1) / 200)
= 131.75
≈ 132
The actual value of the estimated population will be obtained from Geriatric
Department of Hospital Tuanku Ja’far.
Inclusion criteria:
1. Hospitalized patient who is > 60 years old.
2. Completed medical record in 6 months (from 1st July 2015 until 1st December
2015) including demographic profile, cause of hospitalization and medications
intake.
3. Patient who is admitted to Geriatric Ward in Hospital Tuanku Ja’far.
13 | P a g e
14 | P a g e
These patients will be excluded from further analysis.
Exclusion criteria:
1. Hospitalized patient who is < 60 years old.
2. Incomplete medical record in 6 months (from 1st July 2015 until 1st December
2015) including demographic profile, cause of hospitalization and medications
intake.
3. Elective hospitalization for surgery and investigation.
Patient Involvement
Data Extraction
All relevant data will be collected from the medical record unit. These data
include patient’s demographic profile, reason for hospitalisation and all prescription
medication. All of this data will be recorded in a Data Collection Form that is attached in
Appendix A.
15 | P a g e
16 | P a g e
Data Analysis
There would be few limitations on this study. Firstly would be the sample
selection. We only choose patients who were admitted in the geriatric ward, although we
notice that some elderly patients who had fall might be admitted to orthopaedic ward as
well as medical ward. This is a preliminary study of medications and medical conditions
that could lead to fall in geriatric patients. Future study will be expended to include
geriatric patients in other wards.
Secondly, we only choose patients who are hospitalised only and not the one who
also fall at the community or in the nursing homes or their own home. This is because, in
this study we are dealing with severe cases of fall only and we assume that persons who
fall and not being admitted to the hospital might have mild or moderate fall severity. It
might be impossible to identify all elderly people who fall at homes without actually
17 | P a g e
going to hospital. Hence, the outcome of this study might underestimate the real situation
which will fall under limitation of this study.
All aspects of the study protocol will be reviewed and authorized by National
Medical Research Register (NMRR)and Clinical Research Centre (CRC) Hospital
Tuanku Ja’far, Malaysia.
Month Feb March April May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb
‘16 ‘16 ‘16 ‘16 ‘16 ‘16 ‘16 ‘16 ‘16 ‘16 ‘16 ‘17 ‘17
Activity
Choosing
research
topic
Meeting
with
supervisor
Literature
review
Research
proposal
Ethics
approval &
permission
for data
collection
Research
proposal
presentation
Data
collection
Data
analysis
Thesis
writing
Viva
presentation
Preparing
manuscript
for
publications
18 | P a g e
Appendix A
A. Demographic Data
1. Patient’s age
2. Gender o Male
o Female
3. Ethnicity o Malay
o Chinese
o Indian
o Others:
4. Nationality o Malaysian
o Others:
5. Date of admission o ___ / ___ / 2015
6. Date of discharge o ___ / ___ / 2015
7. Days in the ward o ___ days
8. Reason of hospitalisation
(current)
9. Diagnosis
19 | P a g e
12. History of fall o Yes. Specify: ……………….
(within 10 years) o No
13. History of confusion o Yes. Specify: ……………….
(within 1 year) o No
14. History of fracture o Yes. Specify: ……………….
(within 10 years) o No
15. Social/Family history
20 | P a g e
Appendix B
N02A Opioids
N02AA Natural opium alkaloids N02AE Oripavine derivatives
N02AA01 Morphine N02AE01 Buprenorphine
N02AA02 Opium
N02AA03 Hydromorphone
N02AA04 Nicomorphine
N02AA05 Oxycodone
N02AA08 Dihydrocodeine
N02AA10 Papaveretum
N02AA51 Morphine, combinations
N02AA55 Oxycodone, combinations
N02AA58 Dihydrocodeine, combinations
N02AA59 Codeine, combinations
excluding psycholeptics
N02AA79 Codeine, combinations with
psycholeptics
22 | P a g e
N03A Antiepileptics
N03AA Barbiturates and derivatives N03AE Benzodiazepine derivatives
N03AA01 Methylphenobarbital N03AE01 Clonazepam
N03AA02 Phenobarbital
N03AA03 Primidone
N03AA04 Barbexaclone
N03AA30 Metharbital
23 | P a g e
N04 Anti-Parkinson Medicines
N04AA Tertiary amines N04BB Adamantane derivatives
N04AA01 Trihexyphenidyl N04BB01 Amantadine
N04AA02 Biperiden
N04AA03 Metixene
N04AA04 Procyclidine
N04AA05 Profenamine
N04AA08 Dexetimide
N04AA09 Phenglutarimide
N04AA10 Mazaticol
N04AA11 Bornaprine
N04AA12 Tropatepine
24 | P a g e
N05A Antipsychotics
N05AA Phenothiazines with aliphatic N05AF Thioxanthene derivative
sidechain N05AF01 Flupentixol
N05AA01 Chlorpromazine N05AF02 Clopenthixol
N05AA02 Levomepromazine N05AF03 Chlorprothixene
N05AA03 Promazine N05AF04 Thiothixene
N05AA04 Acepromazine N05AF05 Zuclopenthixol
N05AA05 Triflupromazine
N05AA06 Cyamemazine
N05AA07 Chlorproethazine
25 | P a g e
N05AE Indole derivatives N05AX Other antipsychotics
N05AE01 Oxypertine N05AX07 Prothipendyl
N05AE02 Molindone N05AX08 Risperidone
N05AE03 Sertindole N05AX10 Mosapramine
N05AE04 Ziprasidone N05AX11 Zotepine
N05AE05 Lurasidone N05AX12 Aripiprazole
N05AX13 Paliperidone
N05AX14 Iloperidone
N05AX15 Cariprazine
N05AX16 Brexpiprazole
26 | P a g e
N05B Anxiolytics
N05BA Benzodiazepine derivatives N05BD Dibenzobicyclooctadiene
N05BA01 Diazepam derivatives
N05BA02 Chlordiazepoxide N05BD01 Benzoctamine
N05BA03 Medazepam
N05BA04 Oxazepam
N05BA05 Potassium clorazepate
N05BA06 Lorazepam
N05BA07 Adinazolam
N05BA08 Bromazepam
N05BA09 Clobazam
N05BA10 Ketazolam
N05BA11 Prazepam
N05BA12 Alprazolam
N05BA13 Halazepam
N05BA14 Pinazepam
N05BA15 Camazepam
N05BA16 Nordazepam
N05BA17 Fludiazepam
N05BA18 Ethyl loflazepate
N05BA19 Etizolam
N05BA21 Clotiazepam
N05BA22 Cloxazolam
N05BA23 Tofisopam
N05BA56 Lorazepam, combinations
27 | P a g e
N05C Hypnotics and sedatives
N05CA Barbiturates, plain N05CF Benzodiazepine related drugs
N05CA01 Pentobarbital N05CF01 Zopiclone
N05CA02 Amobarbital N05CF02 Zolpidem
N05CA03 Butobarbital N05CF03 Zaleplon
N05CA04 Barbital N05CF04 Eszopiclone
N05CA05 Aprobarbital
N05CA06 Secobarbital
N05CA07 Talbutal
N05CA08 Vinylbital
N05CA09 Vinbarbital
N05CA10 Cyclobarbital
N05CA11 Heptabarbital
N05CA12 Reposal
N05CA15 Methohexital
N05CA16 Hexobarbital
N05CA19 Thiopental
N05CA20 Ethallobarbital
N05CA21 Allobarbital
N05CA22 Proxibarbal
28 | P a g e
N05CD Benzodiazepine derivatives N05CX Hypnotics and sedatives in
N05CD01 Flurazepam combination, excluding barbiturates
N05CD02 Nitrazepam N05CX01 Meprobamate, combinations
N05CD03 Flunitrazepam N05CX02 Methaqualone, combinations
N05CD04 Estazolam N05CX03 Methylpentynol, combinations
N05CD05 Triazolam N05CX04 Clomethiazole, combinations
N05CD06 Lormetazepam N05CX05 Emepronium, combinations
N05CD07 Temazepam N05CX06 Dipiperonylaminoethanol,
N05CD08 Midazolam combinations
N05CD09 Brotizolam
N05CD10 Quazepam
N05CD11 Loprazolam
N05CD12 Doxefazepam
N05CD13 Cinolazepam
29 | P a g e
N06A Antidepressants
N06AA Nonselective monoamine N06AG Monoamine oxidase A inhibitors
reuptake inhibitors N06AG02 Moclobemide
N06AA01 Desipramine N06AG03 Toloxatone
N06AA02 Imipramine
N06AA03 Imipramine oxide
N06AA04 Clomipramine
N06AA05 Opipramol
N06AA06 Trimipramine
N06AA07 Lofepramine
N06AA08 Dibenzepin
N06AA09 Amitriptyline
N06AA10 Nortriptyline
N06AA11 Protriptyline
N06AA12 Doxepin
N06AA13 Iprindole
N06AA14 Melitracen
N06AA15 Butriptyline
N06AA16 Dosulepin
N06AA17 Amoxapine
N06AA18 Dimetacrine
N06AA19 Amineptine
N06AA21 Maprotiline
N06AA23 Quinupramine
31 | P a g e
References
33 | P a g e
24. Grundstrom, A. C., Guse, C. E., & Layde, P. M. (2012). Risk factors for falls and
fall-related injuries in adults 85 years of age and older. Archives of gerontology
and geriatrics, 54(3), 421-428.
25. Tinetti, M. E. (2003). Preventing falls in elderly persons. New England journal of
medicine, 348(1), 42-49.
26. Rubenstein, L. Z., & Josephson, K. R. (2002). The epidemiology of falls and
syncope. Clinics in geriatric medicine, 18(2), 141-158.
27. Stevens, J. A., Corso, P. S., Finkelstein, E. A., & Miller, T. R. (2006). The costs
of fatal and non-fatal falls among older adults. Injury prevention,12(5), 290-295.
28. Huang, A. R., Mallet, L., Rochefort, C. M., Eguale, T., Buckeridge, D. L., &
Tamblyn, R. (2012). Medication-related falls in the elderly. Drugs & aging,29(5),
359-376.
29. Sazlina, S. G., Krishnan, R., Shamsul, A. S., Zaiton, A., & Visvanathan, R.
(2008). Prevalence of falls among older people attending a primary care clinic in
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Jurnal Kesihatan Masyarakat, 14(1), 11-16.
30. Clinical practice guideline for the assessment and prevention of falls in older
people: Guidelines commissioned by the National Institute for Clinical Excellence
(NICE). (2004). London: Royal College of Nursing.
31. Strien, A. M., Koek, H. L., Marum, R. J., &Emmelot-Vonk, M. H. (2013).
Psychotropic medications, including short acting benzodiazepines, strongly
increase the frequency of falls in elderly. Maturitas,74(4), 357-362.
32. Malaysia Population Ageing: Can We “Live Long and Prosper ... (n.d.). Retrieved
March 13, 2016, from http://www.establishmentpost.com/malaysia-population-
ageing-can-live-long-prosper/
33. Todd C, Skelton D. (2004) What are the main risk factors for falls among older
people and what are the most effective interventions to prevent these falls?
Copenhagen, WHO Regional Office for Europe (Health Evidence Network report;
http://www.euro.who.int/document/E82552.pdf, accessed 10th June 2016).
34 | P a g e