Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Article On SS 3.output PDF
Article On SS 3.output PDF
Article On SS 3.output PDF
“Synopsis on SS 3”
“Chahat Jain”
Check at:
http://vinodkothari.com/staff-
publications.html
for more write ups.
Copyright:
This write up is the property of Vinod Kothari & Company and no part of it can be copied,
reproduced or distributed in any manner.
Disclaimer:
This write up is intended to initiate academic debate on a pertinent question. It is not intended
to be a professional advice and should not be relied upon for real life facts.
“Synopsis on SS 3”
Article
Preamble
This Standard is issued by the Institute of Company Secretaries of India in November
2017 in relation to declaration and payment of dividend and matters related thereto.
The Standard is recommendatory & applicability of this standard is Voluntary to every
company and specifically exempts company limited by guarantee not having share capital
and does not deal with Dividend, if any, declared by companies under liquidation and is
effective from 1st January, 2018.
Detailed Tabular analysis of the Standard with the Provisions of the Companies Act, 2013
and Listing Regulations along with remarks if any, is mentioned below:
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
1 “Dividend” means a distribution As per clause 35 of Section 2, No conflict SS 3 clearly spells
of any sums to Members out of Dividend includes any interim out what is
profits dividend Dividend, Final
and wherever permitted out of Dividend and
free reserves available for the No specific definition for Interim Dividend
purpose. Preference Shareholder and whereas there is no
Shareholder specific definitions
“Final Dividend” means the for the same in the
Dividend recommended by the Act.
Board of Directors and declared
by the Members at an Annual
General Meeting. SS also terms out
Preference
“Interim Dividend” means the Shareholder and
Dividend declared by the Board Shareholder
of
Directors.
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
a holder of such shares which
carry a preferential right, in
respect of payment of Dividend,
of a fixed amount or an amount
calculated at a fixed rate and in
respect of capital, to repayment
of capital.
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
(c) Payment of Dividend
declared in the current or (c) Payment of
previous financial year(s), or Dividend declared
(d) Repayment of any term in the current or
loan to a bank or financial previous financial
institution or interest thereon, year(s), or
till such time the default is
subsisting. (d) Repayment of
No Dividend shall be declared any term loan to a
by the company during bank or financial
the extended time, if any, institution or
granted by the interest thereon,
Tribunal/Courtfor repayment till such time the
of above liabilities. default is subsisting.
In addition to the
above, SS 3 also
specifies that No
Dividend shall be
declared by the
company during the
extended time, if
any, granted by the
Tribunal/Court for
repayment of above
liabilities.
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
prior to incorporation of the
company.
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
(a) The rate of Dividend the following conditions: Company in which
declared by the company shall (a) The rate of Dividend the entire paid up
not exceed the average of the declared by the company shall share capital is held
rates at which Dividend was not exceed the average of the by the Central
declared by it in the three rates at which Dividend was Government or
financial years immediately declared by it in the three State
preceding the financial year of financial years immediately Government(s) or
declaration of Dividend. This preceding the financial year of jointly by both to
shall not be applicable where a declaration of Dividend. This comply with the
company has not declared any shall not be applicable where said requirement of
Dividend in each of the three a company has not declared SS 3.
preceding financial years. any Dividend in each of the
(b) Total withdrawal from the three preceding financial It is the matter of
accumulated profits shall not years. inconsistency, as the
exceed one tenth of the sum of (b) Total withdrawal from the Act and rule is not
the paid up share capital and accumulated profits shall not providing any
free reserves of the company as exceed one tenth of the sum of exemption to the
per the latest audited financial the paid up share capital and above-mentioned
statements. (c) The amount so free reserves of the company company as
withdrawn shall first be utilised as per the latest audited mentioned in SS 3,
to set off the losses, if any, financial statements. the Act will prevail.
incurred in the financial year in (c) The amount so withdrawn
which Dividend in respect of shall first be utilised to set off
equity shares is proposed to be the losses, if any, incurred in
declared. the financial year in which
(d) The balance of Free Dividend in respect of equity
Reserves after such withdrawal shares is proposed to be
shall not fall below 15% of the declared.
paid up share capital of the (d) The balance of Free
company as per the latest Reserves after such
audited financial statements. withdrawal shall not fall
below 15% of the paid up
The above conditions shall not share capital of the company
apply to a Government as per the latest audited
Company in which the entire financial statements.
paid up share capital is held by
the Central Government or
“Synopsis on SS 3”
Article
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
State Government(s) or jointly
by both.
But the SS 3
prohibits the
declaration of
Interim Dividend
out of reserves.
However, the SS 3
here is more
stringent, it should
be followed.
“Synopsis on SS 3”
Article
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
Therefore, it is
recommendable to
declare any
dividend
unconditionally and
all the requisite
approvals should be
taken prior to the
“Synopsis on SS 3”
Article
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
declaration.
9 2.2 As per Section 102(2) No Conflict The dividend
Dividend shall be declared only declaration of dividend is an recommended by
at an Annual General Meeting. ordinary business to be the Board of
transacted at the annual directors in the
Dividend shall relate to a general meeting. Board’s Report must
financial year and shall be be ‘declared’ at the
declared by the Members at the annual general
Annual General Meeting of the meeting of the
company after adoption of the company. This
financial statements of the constitutes an item
company. of ordinary business
to be transacted at
Members may declare a lower every annual
rate of Dividend than the rate general meeting.
recommended by the Board but
have no power to increase the
amount or rate of Dividend In the case of
recommended by the Board. Maharani Lalita
Rajya Laxmi v.
The Members may also decide Indian Motor Co.
not to declare the Dividend (Hazaribagh) Ltd.
recommended by the Board. The (1962) final
Dividend, if declared, should be dividend for any
disclosed on per share basis financial year can be
declared and paid
only when the
balance sheet and
profit and loss
account are
presented to the
shareholders at the
annual general
meeting, and the
shareholders after
consideration of the
amount
“Synopsis on SS 3”
Article
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
recommended by
the directors
approve the same or
such lesser amount
as may appear to
them to be
reasonable and
proper. It is thus
prerogative of the
board of directors to
recommend the
amount of dividend
to be distributed
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
Central Jute Mills,
that the declaration
of dividend is
business of annual
general meeting.
Dividend cannot be
declared
retrospectively with
reference to the
previous years, the
accounts of which
are closed at the
annual general
meeting held for
those years.
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
thereon before
submission to the
board for approval.
12 2.5 Subsection 5 of section 123 of No Conflict Deemed Dividend is
Distribution of discount coupons the Act, prohibits payment of defined in Section
to all the Shareholders shall not dividend in any manner 2(22)(e) of the
be treated as deemed Dividend. otherwise than by cash. So, a Income Tax Act
company can pay dividend 1961.
only in cash, not in kind. The concept of
Deemed Dividend
As per second proviso of sub treats specified set
section 5, any dividend of payments made
payable in cash may be paid by closely held
by cheque or warrant or in companies by way
any electronic mode to the of loans or advances
shareholder entitled to the to certain
payment of the dividend. shareholders of the
company or to the
concerns/companie
s in which
shareholders have
substantial interest.
Any payment is
made by way of loan
or advance, the
recipient of the loan
or advance will be
liable to be taxed on
the received amount
as a dividend, to the
extent to which the
company has
accumulated profits,
under the deeming
provisions of section
2(22)(e)
“Synopsis on SS 3”
Article
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
As distribution of
discount coupon is
out of preview of
Section 2(22)(e), it
will not be treated
as deemed dividend.
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
transferred to the Unpaid Where any instrument of to it providing till
Dividend Account. transfer of shares has been the ownership of
delivered to any company for shares are in
Members may authorise the registration and the transfer abeyance or till it is
company in writing to pay the of such shares has not been not registered, the
Dividend to the transferee registered by the company, it dividend accruing
specified in the instrument of shall, notwithstanding out of those shares
transfer and the company shall anything contained in any shall be transferred
act upon such authorisation. other provision of this Act,— to Unpaid dividend
However, where such account.
instrument is not valid for any (a) transfer the dividend in
reason, the company shall not relation to such shares to the Section 124 also
act upon such authorisation and Unpaid Dividend Account specifies that the
intimate the concerned Member referred to in section 124 dividend not paid or
accordingly. unless the company is claimed will be
authorised by the registered transferred to
In case of shares which have not holder of such shares in Unpaid dividend
been transferred because the writing to pay such dividend account.
ownership thereof is in dispute, to the transferee specified in
or where specific prohibitory such instrument of transfer;
orders have been passed by a and (b) keep in abeyance in
court or statutory authority, relation to such shares, any
Dividend should be kept in offer of rights shares under
abeyance and be transferred to clause (a) of subsection (1) of
the Unpaid Dividend Account, as section 62 and any issue of
and when it becomes due. fully paid-up bonus shares in
pursuance of first proviso to
sub-section (5) of section 123
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
the Central Government or State State
Government(s) or jointly by Government(s) or
both or by one or more jointly by both or by
Government Company. one or more
Government
Company.
16 5.3 As per Section 123(5) No No Conflict SS 3 has defined the
Dividend shall be paid in cash dividend shall be paid by a means for the
and not in kind. Dividend company in respect of any payment of
payable in cash may be paid share therein except to the dividend. It brings
through payable at par cheque registered shareholder of such out more clarity
or warrant or in any electronic share or to his order or to his where the Act is
mode of payment approved by banker and shall not be compendiary.
the Reserve Bank of India. To payable except in cash:
curb the practices of fraudulent Regulation 12 of
encashment of Dividend, the Provided further that any LODR states that the
company shall endeavour to pay dividend payable in cash may listed entity shall
Dividend directly to the bank be paid by cheque or warrant use any of the
accounts of the Members or in any electronic mode to electronic mode of
through any one of the the shareholder entitled to the payment facility
electronic modes specified by payment of the dividend. approved by the
the Reserve Bank of India viz. Reserve Bank of
electronic clearing services India, in the manner
(local, regional or national), specified in
direct credit, real time gross Schedule I, for the
settlement, national electronic payment of the
funds transfer etc. Where following:
Dividend is remitted through (a) dividends;
electronic mode, the company (b) interest;
shall send to the Member, a (c) redemption or
statement in writing showing repayment
the amount of Dividend paid. amounts:
Where payment of Dividend is
not possible through any Provided that where
electronic mode, such Dividend it is not possible to
shall be paid by way of cheque use electronic mode
payable at par or Dividend of payment,
“Synopsis on SS 3”
Article
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
warrant. ‗payable-at-par‘
warrants or cheques
The cheque or warrant shall be may be issued:
sent to the registered address of
the Member and, in the case of Provided further
joint holders, to the registered that where the
address of the Member named amount payable as
first in the Register of Members dividend exceeds
or to such person or to such one thousand and
address as the Member or the five hundred rupees,
joint holders have directed, in the ‗payable-at-par‘
writing. warrants or cheques
When payment is made by shall be sent by
Dividend warrant, the name of speed post.
the bank and account number, if
available, shall be mentioned in
the warrant after the name. In
case these are not available,
address of the Member shall be
printed after the name.
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
compliance if the declaration of
Dividend is announced in the
local language in one local
newspaper of wide circulation
and announcement of the said
declaration is also displayed on
the notice board of the Nidhis for
at least three months
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
18 5.5 No such provision No conflict The SS 3 in this
A duplicate Dividend cheque or matter is much
warrant shall be issued only similar to provisions
after obtaining requisite of Section 46 of the
indemnity/ declaration from the Act and rule 6 of the
concerned Member and after Companies (Share
ascertaining the encashment Capital &
status of the original Dividend Debenture) Rules
cheque or warrant. 2014.
In case of defaced, torn or
decrepit Dividend cheque or
warrant, a duplicate instrument
may be issued on surrender of
such defaced, torn or decrepit
instrument to the company.
In case of non-receipt of
Dividend warrant by the
Shareholder and if the same is
not returned undelivered to the
company, a duplicate warrant
may be issued by the company
after verifying the encashment
status.
Particulars of every duplicate
Dividend cheque or warrant
issued as aforesaid shall be
entered in a Register of
Duplicate Dividend Warrants
kept for the purpose, indicating
the name of the person to whom
the instrument is issued, the
number and amount of the
instrument in lieu of which the
duplicate instrument is issued
and the number & date of issue
of such duplicate instrument.
“Synopsis on SS 3”
Article
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
19 5.6 No related Provision No Conflict SS 3 prescribes the
The Dividend cheque or warrant matter to be written
shall be accompanied by a on the Dividend
statement in writing showing cheque or warrant.
the amount of Dividend paid,
Folio no./DP ID and Client ID
nos., number of shares held by
the concerned Member as on the
record date, amount paid up on
each share and the financial year
to which the Dividend pertains.
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
In the case of listed companies,
calls in arrears or any other sum
due from a Member in relation
to the shares of the company,
may be adjusted against the
Dividend payable to him after
giving such notice, as may be
required.
In the case of other companies, if
the Articles so provide , any
other sums due from a Member,
in a capacity other than as a
Member, may also be adjusted
against the Dividend payable to
him.
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
(b) It shall maintain record
consisting of name, last known (5) The amount may also be
address, amount, Folio no., DP ID remitted by Electronic Fund
/ Client ID no., certificate Transfer in such manner, as
number, beneficiary details etc. may be specified by the
of the persons in respect of Central Government.
whom unclaimed or unpaid
Dividend is transferred to the (6) (a) On receipt of the
Fund. statement, the Authority shall
enter the details of such
(c) It shall not transfer any receipt in a Register
Dividend to the Fund where maintained physically or
there is a specific order of Court electronically by it in respect
or Tribunal or any other of each company every year,
statutory authority restraining and reconcile the amount so
such transfer. It shall furnish remitted and collected, with
details of such unpaid Dividend the concerned designated
to the IEPF Authority in the bank on monthly basis.
prescribed form within thirty
days from the end of the (b) Each designated bank
financial year. shall furnish an abstract of
such receipts during the
(d) It shall file with the IEPF month to the Authority within
Authority within thirty days of seven days after the close of
the end of each financial year, a every month.
statement in the prescribed
format containing the details of (c) The company shall
the unclaimed or unpaid maintain record consisting of
Dividend due to be transferred name, last known address,
to the Fund in the next financial amount, folio number or
year. client ID, certificate number,
beneficiary details etc. of the
(e) Within thirty days of closure persons in respect of whom
of financial statements for a unpaid or unclaimed amount
financial year, the company shall has remained unpaid or
furnish another statement to the unclaimed for a period of
IEPF Authority stating therein seven years and has been
“Synopsis on SS 3”
Article
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
reasons for deviation, if any, transferred to the Fund and
between the unclaimed or the Authority shall have the
unpaid Dividend detailed in the powers to inspect such
earlier statement under (d) records
above and the actual Dividend
transferred to the Fund.
Any claimant of unpaid or
unclaimed Dividend transferred
to the fund, shall be entitled to
apply for refund from the
Investor Education and
Protection Fund, after following
the prescribed procedure
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
96 of the Act, separately remained unpaid or
furnish and upload on its own unclaimed for 7
website and also on website of consecutive years,
Authority or any other the provisions of the
website as may be specified by Standard provides
the Government, a statement for giving notice to
or information through Form the Members before
No. IEPF 2, separately for each transferring any
year, containing following unclaimed or unpaid
information, namely:- dividend to the
(a) the names and last known IEPF.
addresses of the persons
entitled to receive the sum; Thus, the provision
(b)the nature of amount; of the Standard
(c) the amount to which each seems to be
person is entitled; cumbersome for
(d)the due date for transfer companies to follow
into the Investor Education requiring them to
and Protection Fund; and give notice every
(e) such other information as year before
may be considered relevant transferring any
for the purposes. unpaid or unclaimed
dividend to the
IEPF.
24 6.5 Proviso to Section 124(6) No Conflict SS 3 is similar to IEP
Before transfer of such shares to provides that any claimant of Rules 2016 in the
the Fund, the company shall shares transferred above shall matter of
send individual notice to the be entitled to claim the transferring fund to
concerned Members at least transfer of shares from IEPF account.
three months in advance at his Investor Education and
latest available address Protection Fund in
registered with the company accordance with such
giving details of the Members procedure and on submission
and the shares due for transfer of such documents as may be
to the Fund. prescribed.
Such details shall also be
uploaded on the website of the Also to refer Rule 6 of
“Synopsis on SS 3”
Article
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
company, if any. Investor Education and
Protection Fund Authority
A notice shall also be (Accounting, Audit, Transfer
simultaneously published in and Refund) Rules, 2016
leading newspapers in English
and regional language having
wide circulation in the place
where the registered office of the
company is situated, informing
the concerned Members that the
names of such Shareholders
whose shares are due for transfer
and their folio number or DP ID -
Client ID are available on
company website duly
mentioning the website address.
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
25 8. No related provisions - SS 3 prescribes for
Preservation of Dividend preservation of
Cheques, Warrants and Dividend dividend cheques,
Registers warrents and
dividend registers
8.1 Dividend cheques or which should be
warrants returned by the Bank, adopted by the
after payment thereof, and the companies
Dividend Registers shall be
preserved by the company for a
period of eight years.
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
Shareholders for the financial recommended for
year and the related amount of the year, including
Dividend per share. Arrears of interim dividends :
fixed cumulative Dividend on (i) amount of
preference shares shall also be dividend distributed
disclosed separately. or proposed for
distribution per
9.2 The Balance Sheet of the share; the amounts
company shall also disclose in respect of
under the head ‘Current different classes of
Liabilities and Provisions’, the shares shall be
amount lying in the Unpaid distinguished and
Dividend Account together with the nominal values
interest accrued thereon, if any. of shares shall also
be indicated;
9.3 The amount of Interim
Dividend, if any, paid during the (ii) where dividend
financial year and final Dividend is paid or proposed
recommended by the Board of to be paid pro-rata
directors shall be disclosed in for shares allotted
the Board’s Report. during the year, the
date of allotment
9.4 The Annual Report of the and number of
company shall disclose the total shares allotted, pro-
amount lying in the Unpaid rata amount of
Dividend Account of the dividend per share
company in respect of the last and the aggregate
seven years and when such amount of dividend
unpaid Dividend is due for paid or proposed to
transfer to the Fund. The be paid on pro-rata
amount of Dividend, if any, basis.
transferred by the company to
the Investor Education and
Protection Fund during the year
shall also be disclosed.
S.No Relevant Para under SS 3 Provision under Companies Whether any Remarks
Act 2013 conflict
between the
Act,
Regulations
and SS
ensure compliance with the set out under
requirement covered under Annexure A are
Annexure A same as in LODR.
No additional
requirement.
Also read our article Secretarial Standards 3 – a voluntary guideline for companies!