Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TRS
TRS
SUMMARY
This paper analyses the influence of operating variables on flue gas emissions containing total reduced sulfur (TRS) from
a dissolving tank and a recovery boiler. Two pulp mills in Chile provided data to allow this study to be conducted. First,
at Lincacel plant, emissions from the dissolving tank vent gas scrubber were studied. Then at the Valdivia plant, the
influence of different operating variables on TRS emissions from the recovery boiler were analysed using a multivariate
statistical analysis for TRS emissions. In this analysis it was observed that variables affecting the boiler furnace
temperature were strongly correlated with changes in the TRS emissions.
INTRODUCTION the base of the recovery boiler which contains mainly sodium
sulfide and sodium carbonate. The smelt droplets are dissolved
As technology advances, newer equipment in the chemical in weak white liquor to produce green liquor. To avoid explosions
recovery area is allowing operation with low TRS emissions. in the dissolving tank during the dissolution process, steam jets
However, older mills close to urban centres still face problems are used to break the flow of smelt coming out of the boiler
with odorous emissions (1). In Kraft pulp mills, odour is caused before it reaches the white liquor (4). This steam atomization,
mainly by reduced sulfur compounds (total reduced sulfur - which pulverizes the smelt into small droplets, together with the
TRS): methyl mercaptan (MM) - CH3SCH, dimethyl sulfide smelt dissolution generates gases in the dissolving tank.
(DMS) - CH3SCH3, dimethyl disulfide (DMDS) - CH3S2CH3 This paper has two objectives: to identify the sources of TRS
and hydrogen sulfide - H2S. MM, DMS, DMDS and H2S are emissions from the dissolving tank vent gas scrubbers in the
formed in the pulping process of wood; while SO2 and H2S are Lincacel plant and to evaluate the impact of boiler operating
mainly formed in the recovery boiler (2). TRS combined with conditions on the TRS emissions from the recovery boiler at the
air and water, plus varying amounts of vaporous methanol and Valdivia plant, both located in Chile.
turpentine, are collectively known as non-condensable gases
(NCG). NCG originates in many areas of the mill. There are STUDY BACKGROUND
basically two types of NCG: concentrated NCG (CNCG) and Chilean Supreme Decree, number 167 of 1999, from the
diluted NCG (DNCG) (3). Secretary General of the Presidency of the Republic of Chile
There are two approaches to reducing odours: one involves the regulates the level of TRS emissions from the recovery boiler’s
elimination of TRS by thermal oxidation, usually performed dissolving tank. This standard decrees that it is inappropriate if
through combustion of NCG and DNCG in lime kilns, power 5% of the TRS values measured per year are greater than 16.8 mg
boilers, recovery boilers or dedicated incinerators. The other H2S / kg DS. A control measurement of TRS emissions from the
approach is to use vent gas scrubbers, where diluted gases MM, dissolving tank should be carried out at least once annually. This
H2S and other NCG are contacted with water and / or white standard also decrees that in the combustion of black liquor in the
liquor sprayed on the washers. recovery boiler, TRS in the flue gas should not exceed 5 ppmv,
Although vent scrubbers are very effective in removing NCG measured on a dry basis and corrected to 8% oxygen (5).
from the gas streams, some do not achieve the expected In the period of 2008 to 2009, a series of TRS measurements in
performance. In this study, the scrubbers installed at the the dissolving tank were made at the Lincacel plant. Some of
dissolving tank connected to a recovery boiler presented such the values were above 16.8 milligrams of H2S per kilogram of
problem. The dissolving tank receives the smelt drained from dry solids and these values led to an investigation to determine
66 Appita
PEER REVIEWED
changes in the operating variables of the dissolving tank. High al (7) and Danko (8) the largest emissions of H2S comes from
values were also the motivating factor for having an analysis of green and white liquors. Also, the causticity has less influence
TRS emissions done in the recovery boiler at Valdivia plant (5). on the emissions of TRS than sulfidity. The emissions of H 2S
The dissolving tank system and the recovery boiler at Lincacel from the smelt atomization with steam usually occur from the
plant were built in 1993.The scrubber has four shower heads reactions of sodium sulfide (Na2S) smelt with water vapour and
placed in a specific arrangement at the same height from which CO2, through the reactions [1] and [2]:
the weak white liquor or water is sprayed. Each shower head
contains a series of nozzles that atomizes water or weak white Na2S + 2 H22ļ+2S(g) + 2 NaOH [1]
liquor through a circulation pump. The dissolving tank from this
plant can also receive streams from other stages of the process Na2S + H2O + CO2ļ+2S(g) + Na2CO3 [2]
containing contaminated condensate that can come from the
evaporation, causticizing and the pulping systems. Their results showed that at a low partial pressure of O2, the
The recovery boiler at Valdivia plant was built in 2003. The partial pressure of H2S depends on the partial pressure of water
boiler is designed to burn 3,100 tons of dry solids per day, vapour and CO2. For a partial pressure of CO2 in the flue gas of
producing 457 tons per hour of steam at a pressure of 86 bars 0.4% and low oxygen concentrations, the concentration of H 2S
and temperature of 486 °C. In this boiler there is the possibility at equilibrium was calculated to be approximately 700 ppm at
of burning alternative fuels as well as fuel oil. In addition, 1000 K and less for the temperatures lower than 1000 K.
the boiler burns methanol and non-condensable gases from Another important category to be analysed is the emissions
the digesters and evaporators. of organic sulfur compounds such as MM and DMS which
can enter the dissolving tank through the condensate from
TRS EMISSIONS the causticizing and evaporation areas. The condensate from
The main sources of TRS emissions from the chimneys of the evaporation usually contains methanol (CH3OH) and this can be
dissolving tank can be divided into three main categories: (i) found in emissions from the dissolving tank as well. Kymäläinen
TRS emissions from green liquor and weak wash, (ii) emissions et al. (9) found emissions at concentrations of 50 ppm in the
of H2S from the smelt atomization with steam jets, and (iii) dissolving tank. In addition, methanol often reacts with H 2S in
emissions of methyl mercaptan (6). According to Frederick et the gas phase to produce MM. According to Ziolek et al. (10),
the alkaline environment that favours this reaction is typically
catalysed by sodium and carbonate ions.
In boiler emissions, the main controlling factor in vaporization
of compounds containing sulfur and sodium is the temperature
in the furnace. According to Hupa (11), the concentration of
sodium-containing compounds in the gas phase increases with
increasing temperature, while emission of sulfur-containing
compounds decrease with temperature increase.
Besides temperature, the ratio of the concentrations of sulfur and
sodium in the black liquor will also influence the composition
of compounds containing sulfur and sodium present in the gas
stream. The average molar ratio of sulfur to sodium can vary
in the range from 0.8 to 1.5 in the recovery boiler combustion
gases. This ratio is lower at higher furnace temperature.
As the gases rise to the top of the furnace and combustion is
completed, several chemical reactions occur leading to the
formation of recovery boiler ashes. As a result, the boiler flue
gas composition is affected in different ways. In the case of
a hot bed in the bottom of the boiler, ash production is larger
68 Appita
PEER REVIEWED
minutes of June 2010. For the last two categories the data was
extracted at intervals of 5 minutes from the DSC (Distributed
Control System). After the removal of inconsistent data, a
study was conducted to find possible correlations among the 72
operational variables (Fig 1 and Table 1) and the TRS emission.
The Inferator program, developed by Oliveira (12) using Matlab
at the Federal University of Minas Gerais, was used to analyse
the operational variables that influence the emissions of TRS
in the recovery boiler of Valdivia plant. This program uses
multivariate linear regression techniques including principal
components regression, partial least squares, neural networks
with multi-layers perception type, and radial basis to evaluate
the datasets fed into the program.
Initially, the data was extracted from the DCS and stored in
Fig. 3. TRS Emissions during Black Liquor Gun Replacement.
Microsoft Office Excel worksheets. The data was first collected
Dashed line indicates regulatory limit.
on 72 variables, (Table 1), in order to correlate these variables
with the TRS emissions from the boiler. Data of TRS emissions
with negative values that represents a failure of the measurement
system were eliminated. The Hampel identifier technique was
also used to detect and eliminate outliers.
Based on Pearson correlation coefficients R 2 and stepwise
regressions, the influence of each variable was quantified.
From this analysis, regression variables of each set of system
data were obtained to establish which variables had a key role
in TRS emissions in the categories of data evaluated. From
these regression variables, neural network models were built
in order to predict TRS emissions. Two models were tested -
neural multilayer perceptions and radial basis -, for each data set
evaluated. A general scheme of the recovery boiler at Valdivia
plant indicates some of the points where the values were Fig. 4. TRS Emissions during Black Liquor Gun Shutdown.
measured (Fig. 1). Dashed line indicates the regulatory limit
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION After rigorously surveying the dissolving tank inlet and outlet
streams, and carrying out a careful mass balance, it was found
DISSOLVING TANK MEASUREMENTS AT
that the sulfur-containing compounds and methanol were
LINCACEL PLANT entering the dissolving tank through contaminated condensate
The initial control steps taken in the Lincacel plant were used to produce the green and weak white liquor. Up to that point,
primarily based on literature studies which focused on the the changes in the scrubber washing media had not involved the
reduction of the amount of H2S released in the dissolving tank. removal of the condensates coming from the evaporation plant.
The literature suggested that reduction could be achieved by Only when these condensates were removed, was there a
lowering the gases vent and steam pressure at the shatter jets significant reduction in emission levels of TRS. Emissions that
and by using more efficient nozzles in the scrubber. were previously superior to 8.16 mg H2S / kg DS fell to levels in
However, the measurements done during the period of 2008 and the range from 2.8 to 4.5 mg H2S / kg DS. Because of this, it was
2009 indicated that these changes had had little or no effect. decided not to reuse the contaminated condensates as washing
media in the dissolving tank scrubbers.
Fig. 7. Variables affecting the TRS emissions for the dataset of Fig. 8. Prediction of TRS emission by best neural network model for
June 2010. the dataset of June 2010
and the problem was solved after some black liquor guns were flows of primary and secondary air, temperature and flow of non-
replaced. The second event was related to a trip problem in the condensable gases, black liquor dry solids, oxygen content, and
black liquor feeding pumps electrical circuit, what resulted in white liquor sulfidity. However these variables are not the same as
a shutdown of liquor input to the boiler. Auxiliary burners and those that were important for the data covering the entire year of
start-up burners were put into service until the problem was 2010. This possibly occurred because of the impact of the transient
fixed. TRS emissions during this period increased significantly events showed in Figures 2 to 4 that affected the influence of the
as shown in Figure 4. Finally, the third event involved a variables during this short period of time.
calibration of the TRS monitoring equipment, apparently not In total for June 2010, 24 regression variables that influence TRS
relating to real boiler emissions. emissions were found, which corresponded to 33% of the total
input variables. The variables that have higher correlations and
RECOVERY BOILER EMISSION MODELLING therefore more influence on TRS emissions are: primary air flow;
After the main operating variable data of the recovery boiler temperature of primary air; air pressure in the primary entrance
were collected, a databank covering the entire year of 2010 to boiler; lower secondary air temperature; upper secondary air
CONCLUSIONS
Traditionally TRS emissions are thought to come from low can lead to sharp increases in TRS emission for a variety of
furnace temperature or poor mixing. This study concluded reasons. Finally, regarding the TRS levels in the dissolving
that in yearly operation, the parameters related to high furnace tank vent scrubber gases, a careful material balance around the
temperature seemed to be the determining ones for TRS emission tank identified the source of the problem in the Lincacel plant.
in recovery boilers for long term evaluation. However over short This procedure helps to identify significant sources of sulfur-
problematic time intervals the transient operating condition containing streams that could be impacting the equipment.
72 Appita