Ultra-Compact Switchable Microstrip Band-Pass Filter - Low-Pass Filter With Improved Characteristics

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 5

2. S. Seok and J.

Kim, Design, Fabrication, and Characterization of a


Wideband 60GHz Bandpass Filter Based Flexible PerMX polymer
Substrate, IEEE Trans Compon Packaging Manufacturing Technol 3
(2013), 1384–1389.
3. H.-L. Kao, F.-H. Chu, and C.-L. Tseng, Hairpin Bandpass Filter on
Liquid Crystal Polymer Substrate using Inkjet-Printed Technology,
IEEE MTT-S International Microwave Symposium, Seattle, WA,
2013, pp. 1–4.
4. H.-L. Kao, C.-L. Cho, and L.-C. Chang, Inkjet-Printed Inter digital
Coupled Line Filter on Liquid Crystal Polymer Substrate, IEEE
Electron Device Lett 34 (2013), 1584–1586.
5. J.-S. Kim, J.-Y. Lee, and G.-B. Lee, A Novel Flexible Filter with Figure 1 Traditional dual mode BPF
Enhanced Coupling Effect using Mixed Coupling, 2010 Asia-Pacific
Microwave Conference, 2010, pp. 1150–1153. and higher cost. In the present work, a novel filter configuration
is proposed which overcomes the problem of large dimension,
C 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
V complex fabrication, and higher cost and is also capable of real-
izing two filter configurations, the BPF and the LPF.
In this work, a common compact filter section is utilized to
ULTRA-COMPACT SWITCHABLE realize both BPF and LPF operation employing the switches.
MICROSTRIP BAND-PASS FILTER– The planar structure provides easier fabrication and lower cost.
LOW-PASS FILTER WITH IMPROVED As common section is utilized for both BPF and LPF operation,
CHARACTERISTICS miniaturization is achieved automatically. In the proposed filter
Prashant Kumar Singh, Anjini Kumar Tiwary, and Nisha Gupta configurations, the “ON” mode of RF switch is realized by con-
Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, Birla necting conducting pads and “OFF” mode by removing the con-
Institute of Technology, Mesra, Ranchi 835 215, Jharkhand, India; ducting pads at the switching position. The proposed filter
Corresponding author: prashantkrsingh@bitmesra.ac.in performs as BPF when all switches are in OFF mode and as
LPF with all switches are in ON mode. The BPF is designed for
Received 7 June 2016 wireless local area network (WLAN) (5.15–5.35 GHz) applica-
tion while the LPF is designed for 3 GHz as 3 dB cut-off fre-
ABSTRACT: A novel, ultra-compact switchable microstrip band-pass quency, which can select various bands such as GSM 900, GSM
filter–low-pass filter (BPF–LPF) showing wide stop band and good 1800, GPS, and WLAN operating around 2.4 GHz etc. The wid-
attenuation characteristics is proposed in this paper. Both BPF and LPF
er stop band is achieved extending up to 12 GHz showing an
operation utilizes a common geometrical filter section, and individual
filter operation is realized by means of the switches operated in “ON” insertion loss (S21) below 220 dB in out-of-band (stop band)
or “OFF” mode. The proposed filter is designed for the dual mode BPF region for both filter operation.
for wireless local area network (5.15–5.35 GHz) application with all
four switches in OFF condition and for the LPF at 3 GHz cut-off fre-
2. SWITCHABLE BPF–LPF
quency with all switches in ON condition. The insertion loss (S21) in the
stop band region is below 220 dB extending up to 12 GHz for both the The microstrip filter configurations are printed on the Rogers
filters. The proposed reconfigurable filter is ultra-compact having the (RO3010) substrate of relative dielectric constant (er) as 10.2,
circuit size of only 5.952 mm 3 8 mm 5 47.616 mm2. The simulation thickness (h) as 0.635 mm, and loss tangent (tan d) as 0.0022.
result is validated experimentally. V
C 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
The filter configurations are simulated using full wave method
Microwave Opt Technol Lett 59:197–201, 2017; View this article online of moments (MoM)-based simulation software tool IE3D by
at wileyonlinelibrary.com. DOI 10.1002/mop.30262
Zeland.
Key words: microstrip switchable filter; radial stub; band-pass filter;
low-pass filter; wireless local area network

1. INTRODUCTION
The multifunctionality, wide out-of-band rejection and miniaturi-
zation are the most essential features of modern microwave/
wireless communication system. The traditional methods to
design microstrip filters are well documented [1]. Switchable
multifunctional BPFs [2–7] and band reject filters [8,9] have
been studied extensively in the past. Multifunctionality can be
achieved by diplexers or incorporating switches in the filters.
The diplexers are often employed in the design for band-pass
filter–low-pass filter (BPF–LPF) operation [10,11]. These
diplexers utilize two different sections for both LPF and BPF
resulting into larger dimension. The switchable BPF–LPF is
designed by merging the two output ports of the diplexer and
applying switches [12]. Again, the dimension is large as two dif-
ferent sections are utilized for the two different filter operations,
only output ports are merged. The compactness can be achieved
by using the low temperature cofired ceramic (LTCC) technolo-
gy [13]. However, this results in complex fabrication procedure Figure 2 Modified dual mode BPF

DOI 10.1002/mop MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 59, No. 1, January 2017 197
TABLE 1 Filter Dimension Analogy Between Dual Mode BPF
and Modified Dual Mode BPF

Dimensional Parameters

Radial Angle
kg/2 line kg/4 line (deg) Radius
Figure 1 la lb h ro
Figure 2 2(l21l31l4) (l51l61l7) h ro

2.1. Modified Dual Mode BPF for WLAN Application


Initially the synthesis of BPF is discussed in this section fol-
lowed by transformation of the BPF into the LPF by switching
mechanism to realize a switchable filter. A dual mode BPF, can
be realized using dual mode resonator consisting of half wave-
Figure 4 Simulated mode frequencies and transmission zero (fz) loca-
length (kg/2) transmission line centrally loaded with a radial tion. [Color figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
stub [14], as shown in Figure 1. The microstrip line of length
kg/2 can be folded conveniently to realize a compact filter con-
figuration. The modified compact dual mode BPF is shown in study is being carried out and simulations are extended further
Figure 2. The analogy between the dimensions of the conven- by changing the radii of radial stub while keeping all other
tional and modified filter configurations are listed in Table 1. parameters constant to obtain the mode frequencies and trans-
The line Y-Y0 in Figures 1 and 2 is the axis of symmetry. mission zero location against ro, as shown in Figure 4. It is clear
The modified dual mode BPF is designed for WLAN band that with the change in ro, mode I frequency and transmission
(5.15–5.35 GHz). The compactness is achieved by folding the zero (fz) location get changed, while Mode II frequency location
open ended kg/2 transmission line and parallel coupled input/ does not change effectively. This analysis shows that Mode I
output (I/O) kg/4 transmission lines, as elaborated in Table 1. and fz depend on the parameters of radial stub, while Mode II
The dimensional parameter of 50 X line is shown by l1 3 w1. depends on the parameters of open ended transmission line. The
The radius and spanning angle of the radial stub are ro and h, radial stub can be seen as a series combination of inductor (Lr)
respectively. The length of open ended transmission line can be and capacitor (Cr) [15]. The resonant frequency of series LC cir-
determined as: cuit can be calculated as:

c c 1
fc 5 pffiffiffiffiffi 5 pffiffiffiffiffi (1) fz 5 pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi (2)
kg ere 4ðl2 1l3 1l4 Þ ere 2p Lr Cr

Here, fc is transmission pole generated by transmission line, c is The mode analysis is carried out to achieve the proper
speed of light in free space, kg is guided wavelength, and ere is band pass region and to design the modified dual mode BPF
effective dielectric constant. The simulation is performed under for WLAN application. The dimensional parameters of this
weak coupling condition to find the mode resonant characteristic BPF is obtained as l1 5 1.65 mm, w1 5 0.59 mm, w2 5 w3 5
of modified dual mode BPF as shown in Figure 3. The dimen- s 5 0.3 mm, l2 5 1.4685 mm, l3 5 1.9 mm, l4 5 2.736 mm,
sional parameters used are as l1 5 1.65 mm, w1 5 0.59 mm, l5 5 1.4685 mm, l6 5 1.5 mm, l7 5 1.6235 mm, h 5 135˚,
w2 5 w3 5 s 5 0.3 mm, l2 5 1.4685 mm, l3 5 1.9 mm, ro 5 2.957 mm, g 5 0.3 mm. Figure 5 presents the simulated
l4 5 2.736 mm, l5 5 0.5685 mm, l6 5 2.1 mm, l7 5 1.9235 mm, result of this BPF and Figure 6 shows enlarged view of the
h 5 135˚, ro 5 2.957 mm, and g 5 0.6 mm. Next, a parametric band pass region shown as inset in Figure 5.

Figure 3 Simulated mode resonant characteristic of modifed dual Figure 5 Simulation result of modified dual mode BPF (all four
mode BPF switches OFF). [Color figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]

198 MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 59, No. 1, January 2017 DOI 10.1002/mop
Figure 6 Enlarged view of inset in Figure 5. [Color figure can be
viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]

Figure 9 (a) Proposed switchable BPF–LPF with four switches. (b)


Equivalent circuit of proposed structure with all switches in ON condition

output ports of the transmission line using two more switches for
Figure 7 LPF transformed from dual mode BPF the purpose of widening the stop band region of the LPF. The
modified dual mode BPF can be switched to LPF by using two
switches as shown in Figure 7. The LPF is designed for 3 GHz
The simulation result depicts the required band width (BW) of cut-off frequency. In LPF section, the radial stub connected with
0.2 GHz (5.15–5.35 GHz) for WLAN and a good wide stop band coupled lines offers wide stop band characteristic [16,17]. How-
with insertion loss (S21) below 20 dB extending up to 12 GHz. ever, this has little effect on BPF characteristic.
When the two switches are in “ON” mode, the P and Q arms
2.2. BPF to LPF Transformation work as kg/4 resonator. This in turn creates extra transmission
To realize reconfigurable BPF–LPF configurations two switches zeroes in stop band region and enhances the stop band perfor-
are inserted at the two requisite locations in the designed BPF mance. The simulation result for this LPF is shown in Figure 8.
configuration. Two kg/4 resonators are also attached to the input/

Figure 8 Simulation result of LPF shown in Figure 7. [Color figure Figure 10 Simulation result of proposed reconfigurable filter in LPF
can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com] mode. [Color figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]

DOI 10.1002/mop MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 59, No. 1, January 2017 199
Figure 11 Fabricated prototype of proposed BPF. [Color figure can be
viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
Figure 13 Fabricated prototype of proposed LPF. [Color figure can be
viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
The simulation result shows stop band only up to 8 GHz. A fur-
ther widening of stop band can be achieved by introducing two
kg/4 resonators at 50 X line for 8 GHz as shown in Figure 9, characteristic. As the switch position is moved upward, the series
which is the final proposed switchable BPF–LPF filter with four inductance, Lb, increases and hence the cut-off frequency shifts
switches. The dimensional parameters of kg/4 resonators are towards lower band. The simulation result shown in Figure 10
l8 5 1.8 mm, w4 5 0.3 mm, w3 50.3 mm. These two resonators depicts the 3 dB cut-off frequency of 3 GHz having enhanced
are separated by a distance v 5 0.6 mm to minimize coupling. and wide stop band with five transmission zeroes at fz1, fz2, fz3,
Figure 9(a) depicts the proposed structure with all switches fz4, and fz5. The transmission zeros at fz1 and fz5 are due to the
in ON condition and its equivalent circuit model is shown in effect of radial stub and coupled lines, respectively. The transmis-
Figure 9(b). The simulation result for the proposed structure in sion zeros located at fz2 and fz4 can be controlled by the kg/4 res-
BPF mode (all switches OFF) is same as shown in Figure 5. onators P and Q, respectively, while located at fz3 can be
The simulation result of the proposed structure in LPF mode (all controlled by the additional kg/4 resonator connected in shunt
switches ON) is shown in Figure 10. with 50 X line towards left and right end. The insertion loss in
The calculation of equivalent circuit parameters, analysis, and stop band region is below 220 dB extending up to 12 GHz.
parametric study of radial stub connected with parallel coupled
line is well discussed [16,17]. The cut-off frequency can be 3. EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
changed by changing the radius of radial stub or by changing the The proposed BPF–LPF filter configuration is finally fabricated
length of coupled line or by changing the length of inductive line and tested. The testing is performed using PNA series vector
connected in series with 50 X line. The first two options change network analyzer. The reconfigurability aspect from band-pass
the characteristic of BPF. The length of inductive line can be mode to low-pass mode in the proposed configuration is realized
changed by changing the position of the switch (g 3 w3) in the using either connecting the conducting pad or by removing it
vertical upward direction, which does not affect the BPF completely, which can be replaced by RF switch such as PIN

Figure 12 Comparison of simulation and measured result of proposed Figure 14 Comparison of simulation and measured results of proposed
BPF. [Color figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com] LPF. [Color figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]

200 MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 59, No. 1, January 2017 DOI 10.1002/mop
TABLE 2 Comparison of Results

LPF BPF

Cut-Off S21 in Pass Centre Minimal S21 in Attenuation in Stop Overall Circuit
Frequency (GHz) Band (dB) Frequency (GHz) Pass Band (dB) Band (dB/GHz) Size (mm2)
[10] 1.5 <0.25 2.4 2.42 >20/up to 6 >5400
Diplexer
[11] 0.6 <1 2.4 4.8 - >1500
Diplexer
[12] 1.5 <0.37 2.4 3.3 >15/up to 6 >5400
Reconfigurable
Proposed work 3 < 0.8 5.25 1.4 >20/up to 12 47.616

diode using proper biasing. Figure 11 shows the fabricated pro- 7. J. Mazloum, A. Jalali, and M. Ojaroudi, Miniaturized reconfigurable
posed filter structure without the conducting pads (all switches band-pass filter with electronically controllable for WIMAX/WLAN
OFF), which works as dual mode BPF for WLAN (5.15– applications, Microwave Opt Technol Lett 56 (2014), 509–512.
5.35 GHz) application. Figure 12 depicts the comparison of sim- 8. S. Pendharker, R.K. Shevgaonkar, and A.N. Chandorkar, Optically
controlled frequency reconfigurable band stop filter with multifrequen-
ulation and measured results of proposed BPF. A good agree-
cy switching, Microwave Opt Technol Lett 56 (2014), 1204–1211.
ment between the two is evident. 9. W.M. Fathelbab, Classes of reconfigurable band-reject filters realis-
Figure 13 shows the fabricated structure with conducting ing constant absolute bandwidth in two distinct states, IET Micro-
pads (all switches ON) connected at proper locations, which wave Antennas Propag 9 (2015), 989–1003.
realizes LPF characteristic for 3 GHz cut-off frequency and Fig- 10. P.H. Deng and J.T. Tsai, Design of microstrip lowpass-bandpass
ure 14 depicts the comparative simulation and measured result diplexer, IEEE Microwave Wireless Compon Lett 23 (2013), 332–334.
for this LPF. 11. M.H. Capstisk, Microstrip lowpass-bandpass diplexer topology, Elec-
Table 2 shows the comparison of the characteristics of some tron Lett 35 (1999), 1958–1960.
similar filter configurations available in literature and the pro- 12. P.H. Deng, J.T. Tsai, and R.C. Liu, Design of a switchable micro-
strip dual-band lowpass-bandpass filter, IEEE Microwave Wireless
posed filter. As seen, the proposed filter configuration outper-
Compon Lett 24 (2014), 599–601.
forms several other similar filter configurations reported earlier 13. D.H. Kim, D. Kim, J.C. Kim, J.C. Park, and C.D. Park, Design of
in the literature. Novelty is achieved in the sense that common selectable low- and bandpass filter for 2.4 GHz applications, Elec-
section is utilized for LPF operation in a lower band with all tron Lett 46 (2010), 1699–1700.
switches ON and BPF operation for WLAN band with all 14. L. Zhang, Z.Y. Yu, and S.G. Mo,Novel planar multimode bandpass fil-
switches OFF. As the common structure is utilized both in BPF ters with radial-line stubs, Prog Electromagn Res 101 (2010), 33–42.
and LPF configurations, compactness is achieved in twofolds. 15. P.K. Singh, A.K. Tiwary, and N. Gupta, Design of radial microstrip
To the best of the knowledge of the authors, this type of planar band pass filter with wide stop-band characteristics for GPS applica-
reconfigurable BPF–LPF filter is not reported earlier. tion, Prog Electromagn Res C 59 (2015), 127–134.
16. P.K. Singh, A.K. Tiwary, and N. Gupta, Design and development of
radial stub low-pass filter with improved characteristics, In: 10th Inter-
4. CONCLUSION
national Conference on Microwave Antennas Propagation and Remote
A novel planar reconfigurable BPF–LPF filter is proposed pos- Sensing (ICMARS-2014), Jodhpur, India, Dec. 2014, pp. 13–16.
sessing ultra-compact circuit size of only 47.616 mm2. The basic 17. K. Ma and K.S. Yeo, New ultra-wide stopband low-pass filter using
structure of the filter is common to both the configurations while transformed radial stubs, IEEE Trans Microwave Theory Tech 59
reconfigurability is achieved by means of the switches. In both (2011), 604–611.
the cases the out-of-band (stop band) characteristic is very good
and insertion loss is below 220 dB extending up to 12 GHz. The C 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
V
BPF is designed for WLAN (5.15–5.35 GHz) application and the
LPF is designed for 3 GHz cut-off frequency. The simulation and STABILITY OF COAXIAL CABLE
experimental results are in good agreement.
TRANSMISSION AND MEASUREMENT
REFERENCES
SYSTEM USING OPTICAL FIBER LINK
TECHNOLOGIES
1. J.-S. Hong and M.J. Lancaster, Microstrip filters for rf/microwave
applications, Wiley, New York, 2001. Yuanfeng She,1 Michitaka Ameya,1 Masanobu Hirose,1
2. D. Psychogiou and D. Peroulis, Reconfigurable bandpass filter with Satoru Kurokawa,1 Jiro Hirokawa,2 and Makoto Ando2
1
center frequency and bandwidth control, Microwave Opt Technol Electromagnetic Fields Section, National Metrology Institute of
Lett 55 (2013), 2745–2750. Japan (NMIJ), National institute of advanced industrial science and
3. X.M. Zhao, Q.Y. Wu, X.J. Liu, and X.W. Shi, Compact varactor- technology (AIST), Tsukuba, Ibaraki 3058563, Japan; Corresponding
tuned dual-mode filter with center frequency and bandwidth control, author: yuanfeng.she@aist.co.jp
2
Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Tokyo Institute
Microwave Opt Technol Lett 58 (2016), 803–806.
of Technology, Mekuro-ku, Tokyo 1528552, Japan
4. P.H. Deng and J.H. Jheng, A switched reconfigurable high-isolation
dual-band bandpass filter, IEEE Microwave Wireless Compon Lett
21 (2011), 71–73. Received 7 June 2016
5. B. Lui, F. Wei, and X. Shi, Switchable bandpass filter with two-state
frequency responses, Electron Lett 47 (2011), 40–41. ABSTRACT: This article measured the stability of the transmission of
6. Z.H. Chen and Q.X. Chu, Dual-band reconfigurable bandpass filter the coaxial cable and introduced a measurement system using the opti-
with independently controlled passbands and constant absolute band- cal fiber link technologies in the millimeter-wave band. The radiation
widths, IEEE Microwave Wireless Compon Lett 26 (2016), 92–94. patterns of two antennas have been measured by the proposed optical

DOI 10.1002/mop MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 59, No. 1, January 2017 201

You might also like