Professional Documents
Culture Documents
No Load Performance Study of 1200 KV Indian Uhvac Transmission System
No Load Performance Study of 1200 KV Indian Uhvac Transmission System
No Load Performance Study of 1200 KV Indian Uhvac Transmission System
Review Article
ISSN 2397-7264
No-load performance study of 1200 kV Indian Received on 3rd July 2016
Revised on 1st October 2016
UHVAC transmission system Accepted on 1st October 2016
doi: 10.1049/hve.2016.0036
www.ietdl.org
Abstract: Major load centres of India are located at northern part and western–southern part of country, whereas most of
the generating units are concentrated at eastern and North-eastern parts. Economic transmission of bulk power over a
long distance is a basic requirement for which ultra-high voltage AC (UHVAC) transmission system is identified as a
feasible solution resulting in reduced transmission loss and reduced corridor width (right of way), protection of
precious flora and fauna. For this, Powergrid Corporation of India along with Central Power Research Institute had
made a call for indigenous development of UHVAC technology. As a result, 1200 kV UHVAC National Test Station is
developed in India at Bina. One 400/1200 kV bay is successfully charged, along with one 1200 kV single circuit and one
1200 kV double-circuit test transmission line. This study deals with the study of on-site acceptance test such as sweep
frequency response analysis, frequency-domain spectroscopy (FDS), along with inrush current measurement, voltage
withstand test, corona measurement, thermo-vision scanning conducted on-site at no load, to ensure the performance
of transmission system. A brief review of technical studies related to UHVAC technology developed throughout the
World is also presented. The power transmission at 1200 kV is a feasible and viable option but further research is
required in this area to make UHV transmission a global success.
Table 2 T&D and AT&C losses (%) [2] Table 6 LIWV and SIWV of IEC TC28: insulation coordination
Loss Year 2010–2011 2011–2012 2012–2013 2013–2014 Highest voltage, kV 1100 1200
T&D losses 23.97 23.65 23.04 21.46 (P) Standard LIWV 1950, 2100, 250, 2100, 2250, 2400,
AT&C losses 26.35 26.63 25.38 22.70 (P) 2400, 2550 2550, 2700
Standard SIWV 1425, 1550, 1675, 1800 1675, 1800, 1950
(phase to Earth)
Note: As per PFC for utilities selling directly to consumers, P: provisional
Table 3 Highest power frequency voltage Um (kilovolts) of various UHV Table 8 summarises analytical results of DC time constants
projects world wide calculated using various tower designs with different
multi-sub-conductor bundle used in different projects. The
Project Italy Russia Japan China India
constants were obtained by a ratio of positive-sequence inductance
Um, kV 1050 1200 1100 1100 1200
to positive-sequence resistance of the lines. Special case time
constants, in excess of the standard value of 45 ms, were added in
the International Electro-technical Commission (IEC) 62271-100
based on a survey conducted by CIGRE WG 13.04. The special
case time constant is 75 ms for rated voltages 550 kV and above
Table 4 Specification of MOSAs characteristics for UHV systems
which corresponds to the medium value of the constants, surveyed
Italy Russia Japan China India for 800 kV lines.
Surveys of network conditions for capacitive current switching:
rated voltage 750 kV 800 kV 826 kV 828 kV 850 kV Capacitive current switching under normal service and 1LG
switching impulse – 1570 kV 1400 kV 1400 kV 1500 kV conditions was evaluated according to practical conditions of a
protection level 1.6 pu 1.6 pu 1.56 pu 1.53 pu
(30/60 µs) at 2 kA at 2.8 kA at 1.0 kA transmission tower, multi-sub-conductor bundle, normal current
lightning impulse 1750 kV 1764 kV 1620 kV 1620 kV 1700 kV and line length. Typical tower designs and network conditions
protection level were investigated by working group (WG) A3.22 and are
(8/20 µs)at 20 kA 2.04 pu 1.8 pu 1.8 pu 1.8 pu 1.74 pu summarised in Table 9.
at 15 kA
Fig. 2 shows typical voltage and current behaviour in the case of
capacitive current switching under 1LG conditions based on
Table 8 DC time constant of short-circuit currents in EHV/UHV 1200 kV single-circuit transmission lines of 400 km length in India.
transmission lines The breaking current is 1474 Arms (14% larger as compared with
normal condition) and the maximum TRV peak is 2454 kV (10%
Maximum voltage, kV Conductors DC time constant, ms
higher as compared with normal condition) which corresponds to a
Size, mm2 Bundle voltage factor of 1.25. Fig. 3 shows the initial part of TRV in the
case of capacitive current switching for no load 1200 kV line
Canada, 765 686 4 75 breaking in India. The ITRV is suppressed within a few
USA, 800 572 6 89 milliseconds and the transient does not exceed 1/4 cycle (5 ms)
South Africa, 800 428 6 67 after the interruption.
Brazil, 800 603 4 88
China, 800 400 6 75 Table 10 summarises the results of capacitive current switching
Russia, 1200 400 8 91 under normal service and 1LG conditions. For line-charging
Italy, 1050 520 8 100 current switching by circuit breakers with rated voltages 800, 1100
China 1100 500 8 120 and 1200 kV, the capacitive voltage factor (kc) is covered by, or is
Japan, 1100 810 8 150
India, 1200 774 8 100 close to, 1.2 under normal service conditions and is <1.3 under
1LG fault conditions.
Fig. 2 Analytical results of no load 1200 kV line breaking with 1LG condition (India) [1]
800 kV South Africa 50 440 969 801 1559 1392 1009 901 1703 1520
765 kV Canada 60 210 491 472 1442 1388 487 469 1575 1517
400 1000 867 1465 1289 1015 880 1627 1411
800 kV Korea 60 39 94 93 1569 1567 92 92 1639 1636
155 378 369 1577 1542 382 374 1659 1624
800 kV USA 60 300 815 753 1527 1413 889 822 1688 1410
800 kV Brazil 60 266 643 606 1485 1400 670 632 1629 1535
331 817 745 1526 1392 860 784 1638 1489
1100 kV Japan 50 210 665 647 2187 2131 686 668 2321 2276
250 798 768 2188 2107 85 796 2343 2259
1100 kV China pilot 50 281 850 812 2082 1987 877 897 2253 2063
358 1105 1024 2090 1938 1151 1143 2292 2030
1100 kV China 50 151 443 434 2115 2076 450 446 2203 2177
future 327 994 925 2149 1999 1025 962 2234 2105
1200 kV India 50 400 1293 1175 2225 2021 1474 1339 2454 2229
(i) On completion of successful pre-commissioning tests, After successful charging of the first bay, commissioning tests
equipments are being charged successively from January 2012 were carried out to ensure its performance to confirm the integrity
onwards. of equipment and system in grid.
4.1 Inrush-current of transformers particle count measurement and Tan ∂ are planned on a monthly
basis. Thermograph imaging, partial discharge measurement by
Inrush currents were recorded by waveform recorder at the moment ulta-high-frequency method, noise level measurement and neutral
of charging of the 1200 kV system as shown in Fig. 5. The leakage current measurement are scheduled with 6 months interval.
inrush-current values recorded from 400 kV side are 1.16, 1.16 dissolved gas analysis (DGA) monitoring and bushing capacitance
and 2.71 kA for R, Y and B phases, respectively [9]. and Tan delta measurement are scheduled on half yearly and yearly
During the operation & maintenance (O&M) period, tests planned basis, respectively. To check the ageing of insulation furan
on the transformers are monitoring of winding and oil temperature measurement and frequency-domain spectroscopy (FDS) will be
and earthing leakage current measurement on tank on weekly basis. carried out on regular intervals. In near future, a comprehensive
Breakdown voltage test, moisture content measurement (ppm), online monitoring system is going to be installed to monitor the
transformers continuously. Corona performance was assessed from
the corona images taken from camera.
Sweep frequency response analysis (SFRA) was carried out to
assess the mechanical integrity of transformer. Comparison of SFRA
results obtained from one transformer from factory and site are
depicted in Fig. 6. The matching of the signatures confirms that no
mechanical damage happened during transportation and installation.
FDS is carried out transformers to measure the moisture content of
the pressboard and paper insulation used in transformer. In FDS, the
tan ∂ value of the insulation system was measured over a range of
frequency from 0.0001 to 1000 Hz [9].
The obtained response curve is shown in Fig. 7.
The analysis of the above curve at National Test Station Bina
revealed that the moisture content is only 0.2%, which is well
below the acceptable level of 0.5%.
Figs. 8 and 9 show the photographic images of 1200 kV UHV line
(both single and double circuits) and a typical 400/1200 kV
autotransformer of National Test Station Bina, India.
Winding and oil temperature measurement: Being working at no load,
transformer has not indicated any undue temperature rise. Thermo-vision
scanning of all equipments, hardware, clamps and connectors: thermal
images of UHVAC transmission system accessories were taken. It was
found that performance of all parts is within safe limits. Vector group
test was carried out after forming three-phase bank with the help of
three single-phase transformers. Voltage withstand test gave
satisfactory result. The voltage profile for 3 days observation period
from 30th May to 3rd June 2012 is shown in Fig. 10.
Apart from UHV transformer testing, on-site testing of major
equipments and switchgears was also done. Tan delta and capacitance
measurement of 1200 kV circuit breaker was done along with dew
point measurement of SF6 gas. Operating timings of circuit breaker
were measured including pre-insertion resistor timings. Dynamic
contact resistance measurement was also conducted for 1200 kV dead
tank type gas insulated switchgeat (GIS) circuit breakers. On-site
testing of 1200 kV knee type isolator, 1200 kV capacitive voltage
transformers and 850 kV SAs were also done. Various protection
systems of transformer: namely, differential, restricted Earth fault, over
Fig. 9 A single-phase 400/1200 kV autotransformer at the site [8] current, over excitation etc. were also checked [10].
Mr. H.K. Agarwal et.al. share the approach and experience they substation equipment up to 1200 kV’, December 2008, ISBN: 978-2 85873-049-0
underwent through their paper ‘Design & development of 1200 kV 2 Executive summary: ‘Power Sector August 2015’, Government of India, Central
Electricity Authority, New Delhi. Available at http://www.cea.nic.in/reports/
transmission line & sub-station insulator hardware fittings, clamps & monthly/executivesummary/2015/exe_summary-08.pdf
connectors’ [11] in which shop floor manufacturing facilities are 3 Daochun, H., Yinbiao, S., Jiangjun, R., et al.: ‘Ultra high voltage transmission in
discussed along with steel forging, aluminium casting, corona China: developments, current status and future prospects’, Proc. IEEE, 2009, 97,
control/grading ring tube bending and testing facilities. Calculation (3), pp. 555–583
4 Powergrid: ‘Proc. of the Brainstorming Session on Development of 1200 kV
was done for conductor surface voltage gradient for line and UHVAC Transmission System’, oorganized by POWERGRID in association
sub-station and both the values were found to be well below with ABB, AREVA, BHEL, CROMPTON GREAVES, SIEMENS., Hotel Taj,
negative corona onset value of 20 kV/cm. Studies were conducted New Delhi, 16–17 January 2008
to determine voltage distribution along insulator string with 5 Tiwari, R.K., Gupta, S.K., Singh, R.K., et al.: ‘Bharat heavy electricals limited’.
octagonal bundle conductor for 700 and 1100 mm ring diameters Critical Technical Aspects during Design, Manufacturing and Testing of India’s
First 1200 kV UHVAC Transformer. CIGRE 2012, Bhopal, 2012, pp. A2–112
outer corona control/grading rings. Voltage distribution pattern on 6 Agrawal, S.K., Tamoli, D.P., De Bhowmick, B.N., et al.: ‘1200 kV National Test
whole string and near HV end indicated in Fig. 11. Station: taking Indian power system to next orbit, 21, rue d’Artois, F-75008 PARIS
1200 kV UHVAC Indigenous Development New Delhi, 2013
7 Central Board of Irrigation and Power New Delhi, 2013, Water and Energy
5 Conclusion international, vol 70, no. (1 and 4) ISSN No. 09744711
8 Jha, I.S., Agrawal, S.K., De Bhowmick, B.N., et al.: ‘India’s powergrid R&D
No-load performance analysis is carried out and it is found that all efforts. Transmission and distribution world magazine’, January 2013. Available
at http://www.tdworld.com/transmission/indias-powergrid-rd-efforts, downloaded
the major equipments and accessories are working safely. The on 03 July 2016
India’s first 1200 kV UHVAC test station has opened new avenues 9 Shirasaka, Y., Kobayashi, T., Li, G., et al.: ‘Reliability of UHV transformers, on
for the research to make UHVAC transmission a global success. behalf of CIGRE SC A2, AG A2.5 (UHV AC & DC transformers) session 1.1,
From the above comparative study of UHVAC system of many transformers, New Delhi, 2013
10 Sundaran, A., Rao, S.B.R., Suresh Kumar, B.N.V.R.C., et al.: ‘Establishment of
countries, the conclusion can be drawn that the power transmission 1200 kV National Test Station in India CIGRE science and Engineering, 2016,
at 1200 kV is a feasible and viable option. 4, pp. 6–11
11 Design & development of 1200 kV transmission line & sub-station insulator
hardware fittings, clamps & connectors, article has released at April 2013 issue
6 References of ‘Engineering Review’ journal. Available at http://supremeco.com/design-
development-of-1200-kv-transmission-line-sub-station-insulator-hardware-
1 CIGRÉ Brochure 362 WG A3.22: ‘Technical requirements for substation fittings-clamps-connectors-article-has-released-at-april-2013-issue-of-engineering-
equipment exceeding 800 kV – field experience and technical specifications of review-journal/, downloaded on 30 September 2016 website
Satyadharma Bharti received degree of B.E. he is Associate Professor in the Department of Electrical
Electrical Engineering in 1990, and Master Engineering, Rungta College of Engineering & Technology Bhilai.
of Technology in 2007. He is Pursuing His research interests include High voltage Engineering, Electrical
Ph.D. from CSVTU, Bhilai, India. Currently, Machines and Power system.