Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Library of Congress
Library of Congress
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Library of Congress is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Quarterly
Journal of the Library of Congress.
http://www.jstor.org
at the American
Filmmaking
and
Mutoscope Biograph
1900-1906
Company
by Paul C. Spehr
In the hope of casting a clearer light upon film been the office of the Magic Introduction Com?
production from 1900 through 1906, a period pany, owned by Bernard Koopman, who, in 1895,
that antedates trade press coverage, it occurred joined Henry Marvin, Herman Casler of Syra?
to me that there was a need to study specific cuse, and Thomas Edison's former employee
examples. What follows is based on the American W. K. L. Dickson in forming the K. M. C. D.
and Biograph Company Company, which soon became the American
Mutoscope production
logs, which survive in the library of the Museum Mutoscope Company. Although the company
of Modern Art inNew York and are available in was originally formed to produce movies on flip
the Library of Congress on microfilm; on Kemp cards for the
Mutoscope machines, it soon turned
Niver's compilation of the Biograph Company's to producing films for projection in theaters as
bulletins;1 and on my viewing, over a long period, well. This led the firm into conflict with the larger
of many Biograph films, some of which survive in and more dominant Edison Company?
the Library's Paper Print Collection. The produc? America's earliest major motion picture pro?
tion logs provide a chronological pattern of film ducer. Edison met this competition with a patent
production by
one of the most important of the suit designed to restrict projection of the films.
early American film companies. My study con? In this early movie market, the competitive war
centrated on the firm's production volume and was continually on two fronts?the
waged legal
were with the suits involving interpretation of the
frequency, the proportion of its films that one,
entertainment, the length of its films, the shoot? patent laws, and the more direct one, whereby
ing locations, and the films' makers.
In 1900 the American Mutoscope and Bio
graph Company had a rooftop studio in New Paul on
C. Spehr, who has written and lectured extensively
York City at 841 Broadway, the Hackett-Carhart film, is assistant chief of the Motion Picture, Broadcast?
early
building, near Union Square. The building had ing, and Recorded Sound Division of the Library.
principles.2 The Edison Company's role as plain? In order to get a perspective on production in
tiff in the patent suits in which they appear as the 1900, it is necessary to consider the situation in
aggressor tends to confirm the company's image 1899. The rooftop in New York City which was
as a conservative and possessive business con? the company's shooting stage had some inherent
and Bio in the winter. If itwas
glomerate. The American Mutoscope limitations, particularly
graph Company, which we will call by its later cold, stormy, or even gray and overcast, the
name, the Biograph Company, has always rooftop became unusable since controlled, con?
seemed the more adventuresome and oppor? sistent, strong light was vital for production.
tunistic of the early companies.3 It appears to The last productions of 1899 were shot in
have augmented itsoutput of travel, religion, and November by operator Francis S. Armitage.
classical literature films, the staples of the conser? The titles include: The Make-Up Thief, A Warm
vative early filmmakers, with sex, drama, comedy, Baby and a Cold Duck, Fougere,* The Foster
and sensational productions, thereby laying the Mother,* and Pity theBlind. They were relatively
groundwork for the imaginative creativity of short films, twenty-five to fiftyfeet in length and
D. W. Griffith and his followers. scarcely a minute in running time. During
Today's scholars have access to sources which November and December of 1899, a number of
were not available to earlier researchers who actuality films were shot outside of New York
stereotyped aspects of this period. The survival City?eleven titles in Honolulu and the Philip?
of the Biograph Company's handwritten, daily pines by an operator named Raymond Acker
production logbooks, in which filming activity man, and another series along the Union Pacific
was recorded in roughly chronological order, Railway line.
provides unique information. About 40 percent The roof studio was not used again until Jan?
of these logged films survive, many in the Li? uary 18, 1900, when Wallace McCutcheon shot
Print Collection, and now scholars Necessary Qualifications of a Typewriter and The
brary's Paper
can view them. Perfect Woman Wanted Her Picture in the Al?
Volume 1 of the Biograph On 23 /Had to Leave a
logbooks begins together. January Happy
April 15, 1899, with production number 935. Home for You* and Caught were shot. No more
Each production is recorded in sequence by films were made until March, when four titles
number, date, subject (often the release title), were shot. In the meantime forty actuality films
were received and processed by the company, all
shooting location, the name of the operator (as
the cameraman-filmmaker was usually called at shot outdoors in Philadelphia (two), Cincinnati
the time), the date the negative was developed, (two), Chicago (three), Canada (thirteen, by Ar?
and occasionally some production or release in? thur Marvin), and the Philippines (by Raymond
formation. Later entries include the length of the Ackerman).
original, the "corrected" length, the date shot, the During 1900 the company made 374 films?
date developed, the speed at which the camera 166 were actuality films, 194 were entertain?
was cranked, occasional quality evaluations, and a ment, and 14 were of undetermined nature.
note recording whether it was produced for Five men worked as operators during this time.
Mutoscope (flip-card machine), Biograph (pro? Ackerman, who was in Hawaii and the Philip?
jection), or both. pines at the beginning of the year, returned to
I have classified filmed dance or vaudeville the West Coast in September. Francis S. Armi?
acts as entertainments. Inevitably, I had tomake tage, G. W. "Billy" Bitzer, Arthur Marvin, and
some arbitrary decisions regarding what should
be categorized as entertainment, so my statistics
should be regarded as proportional rather than *Film titles followed by
an asterisk are in the Library's Paper
absolute. There were also certain subjects that Print Collection.
probable that the midwinter production lull, ac? out as a creative achievement. The
Library has
counts for this interlude of creative experi? copies of many of these films.
mentation in technical achievements. During this period productions continued to
These three were the only entertainment be short, twenty-five to fifty feet of 35mm film,
productions made by the company until April less than a minute of running time. By now the
15, 1901; only two were done during April and majority of the entertainment films were broad
seven during May. It was a very slow year for comedies patterned after burlesque routines.
new entertainment productions at the Biograph They were repetitive and predictable. The
Company. Only forty-nine entertainment pro? number of comedies produced outnumbered
ductions were made all year (in contrast to 185 the melodramas.
the year before) and twenty-nine of them were In 1903 Bitzer and Bonine continued as
made during June, including a five-part Ten operators. Armitage and McCutcheon returned
*
Nights in a Bar-Room. Eight were made during to work and were joined by A. E. Weed and a
July, and then New York production was shut San Francisco photographer, Herbert J. Miles.
down until May 1902. During the year production jumped from 187
During 1901 Biograph continued to employ to 496 titles, and the company moved from the
and McCutcheon as
Armitage, Bitzer, Marvin, rooftop studio on Broadway to a converted
camera
operators. Cameramen Robert K. brownstone at 11 East Fourteenth Street (about
Bonine and James Congdon were added to the a block away). This
building was made famous
staff. Bonine made a trip to Hawaii, Japan, and by D. W. Griffith, Lillian Gish, Blanche Sweet,
China. The year's production of new films fo? Mack Sennett, and other members of the Bio
cused on actuality production, 286 titles. There graph Stock Company. Films produced on
were seventeen films of uncertain type. Major March 26 and 27 and April 1 are marked in the
attention was given to the Pan American Exposi? log as made in the studio, the first such indica?
tion in Buffalo and the assassination and funeral tions. The first title so listed is For the Upper
of President McKinley. Crust. April was, however, a period of light pro?
During 1902 the staff of operators was re? duction, with only seven films made during the
duced to Bitzer, Bonine, Congdon, and Marvin. month, so the beginning of new studio produc?
Production for the year dropped from 352 to tion was rather hesitant.
187 titles. Production of entertainment films The earlier part of the year had seen a burst
continued at about the same level, 52 (49 in of documentary production. In February
1901). Once again, production of entertainment Bonine shot thirty short films at the National
films was restricted to the warm months of May Cash Register Company in Dayton, Ohio, ap?
on a commission from the company.
through August. The drop in production coin? parently
cides with the period when the Biograph Com? Certainly one of the earliest "sponsored" films, it
pany began tomake massive copyright registra? recorded factory production, employees' ac?
tions for previously produced subjects. This tivities, and the management of the company.
burst of copyrighting was probably the result of Unfortunately, the film has not survived.
a favorable court decision in the long continu? In March forty documentary films were re?
ing suit with the Edison Company. For the first corded, more than twenty-five of them shot in
time the company could distribute films for pro? the Yukon (probably photographed earlier, but
jection, augmenting itsMutoscope distribution. recorded in New York inMarch).
The production patterns for the year reflect a In June entertainment film production began
rather conservative, unadventurous
approach
to in earnest when twenty-nine titles were made (as
event of to ten the previous month). In July
production. The major documentary opposed
the year was Prince Henry of Prussia's visit to thirty-two were made, twenty-one in August,
the United States. There were so few new ven? thirty-eight in September, and forty-four inOc?
tures on the dramatic side that a series of seven tober. While production dropped to eleven in
films featuring the newly popular comic strip November, thirty-seven titles were made in De?
characters "Foxy Grandpa and the Boys," with cember. The indoor facilities in the new studio
stage actor Joseph Hart playing the lead, stands clearly put at least a partial end to the seasonal
nature of the company's output. this clearly indicates a significant change in pro?
At the same time, documentary production duction patterns.
was also flourishing, spurred on by the produc? October of 1903 brought the first long enter?
tion of films in groups or series. In August tainment releases?The American Soldier in Love
twenty-four films on the U.S. Postal service were and War* in three short parts, Kit Carson* in
shot in Washington, D.C., and its environs thirteen parts, and The Pioneers in six parts. The
(including Westminster, Maryland) by oper? latter two were made in the Adirondacks in Sep?
ator A. E. Weed. Also in August, Bitzer shot tember by Wallace McCutcheon. At this time,
twelve films on the U. S. S. Kearsarge, which Biograph was following the lead of the rival
was on Oyster Bay, New York, near Theodore Edison Company, which had released several
Roosevelt's home. In August and September successful longer films (about one reel each),
Francis S. Armitage shot forty-one films in the including Jack and the Beanstalk* (June 1902),
West and Southwest for the U.S. Department of Life of an American Fireman* (January 1903), and
the Interior. While these films could be viewed Uncle Tom's Cabin* (July 1903), soon to be fol?
individually, they also had a continuity of sub? lowed by A Railroad Romance (Route of thePhoebe
ject and, perhaps, some sequential order. Since Snow)* (October 1903) and The Great Train Rob?
some of these "series" were up to an hour bery* (December 1903).
long,
Dobson; Weed did not work during 1905. sonal" Columns, on August 23 and 24, 1904, at almost the same
locations (Grant's Tomb and Englewood, New Jersey.). From the
At least one long film a month was produced
Niver Collection.
throughout the year as were a number of
shorter films of Mutoscope length. The number
of actuality films declined dramatically, from
105 in 1904 (268 in 1903) to 43. The average
length increased. The number of entertainment
films, 104, was the same as the previous year. By
194
1900 166 14 374
49 1901 286 17 352
52 1902 117 18 187
225
1903 5496
266
104
1904 5214
105
104
1905 9156
43
46 1906 _52 15 113
774 Total 1,035 83 1,892
NOTES
1. Kemp R. Niver, comp., Biograph Bulletins, 1896-1908, suits, the Edison Company was some Vitagraph
purchasing
ed. Bebe Bergsten (Los Angeles: Locare Research films to expand its sales catalog.
Group,
3. The name was changed to the Biograph
1971). company's
2. Other existed, particularly the Vitagraph Company in 1909.
competitors
of America, but they were not yet a serious threat; 4. The in the logbook is not always clear,
Company handwriting
however, their time would come. At the time of these early but it appears to indicate Marvin for this production.