Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jurnal Bayi 4 PDF
Jurnal Bayi 4 PDF
Original Article
Abstract
Background: Literature abounds of the positive impacts of Family-Centered Nursing Care on the outcome of
paediatric care. However, despite the near-universal adoption of Family-Centered Care in paediatric hospitals, there
is paucity of literature on what forms Family centered nursing care in the paediatric population in Nigeria.
Aims: This study examined paediatric parents (PP) and nurses’ perceptions of Family – Centered Nursing care
behaviors to be most and least important.
Methodology: A descriptive design was used, University College Hospital, Ibadan and Massy Street Children
Hospital, Lagos State, South-West Nigeria were the study settings. Purposive sampling technique was adopted to
select 323 parents while simple random sampling used to recruit 176 nurses who participated in the study. A
modified Family Centered Care Scale (FCCS) was used for data collection. Data was analyzed using descriptive
statistics, t- test and multiple regression.
Results: The Family Centered nurse-caring behaviours mostly perceived as caring by the peadiatric parents was
“Use my suggestions about how to care for your child ( 4.46 ± 1.496) while nurses perceived “Parents are given
detail explanations about changes they could be expected from their condition (4.48 ± 0.985) as the most important.
Age (p = 0.03), education (p = 0.02) influenced peadiatric parents perception of Family centered nursing care
behaviors and length of hospital stay (p = 0.96) did not influence it. Nurses age (0.08) did not influence their
perception of Family centered nursing care behaviors but years of peadiatric experience (0.02) influenced it. There
was no statistical significant difference in the peadiatric Parents and Nurses perception Family centered nursing care
behaviors (p = 0.90).
Conclusions: Peadiatric parents and nurses perceived these items to be important for FCNC. Therefore, these should
be incorporated into nursing practice and nursing education in Nigeria in providing sense of care.
Keywords: Peadiatric parents, Nurses, perception, Family centered care, Family centered nursing care behaviors,
Family centered care scale
www.internationaljournalofcaringsciences.org
International Journal of Caring Sciences January– April 2017 Volume 10 | Issue 1| Page 68
www.internationaljournalofcaringsciences.org
International Journal of Caring Sciences January– April 2017 Volume 10 | Issue 1| Page 69
conducted a study on patients' and professional and very important. For the focus of this study, the
nurses' perceptions of important nurse caring instrument was back translated into Yoruba
behaviors important in making them feel cared for. language which is a major language spoke in the
However, studies on paediatric patients’ perception study setting and from Yoruba language back to
of nurse caring behaviour have been conducted in English language.
some Western nations including Nigeria (Pelander,
Face and content validity was determined by a
Leino-Kilpi, & Katajisto, 2007; Adereti etal
team of peadiatric nurses and five parents of
(2014). In Nigeria, there is paucity as regards what
hospitalized children. A pilot study was conducted
constitute family centered nursing care behaviors
with 20 peadiatric parents in a hospital different
for parents of hospitalized children and nurses
from the study setting to ensure internal
working in peadiatric units. Therefore, this study
consistency and reliability of the English
was aimed at identifying those nursing activities
instrument and translated versions. The result was
that are important for Family Centered Nursing
cronbach’s alpha value of 0.94 for the English
Care (FCNC) by the paediatric parents and nurses.
instrument and 0.93 for the Yoruba instrument.
Methodology
Procedure for data collection
A descriptive design was used for this study. The
Data was collected between January and June
study was conducted in the peadiatric units of two
2015. Ethical approval was taken from the ethical
tertiary hospitals in Southwest, Nigeria. The
and review committees of University College
hospitals are University College Hospital, Ibadan
Hospital, Ibadan and Massy Street Children
and Massy Street Children Hospital, Ibadan. Using
Hospital. Written and oral informed consent to
purposive sampling technique for peadiatric
participate in the study was further obtained from
parents, the sample size was 323peadiatric parents
parents who agreed to participate in the study. The
or guardian from a total population of 607 children
informed consent emphasized that participation
admitted per month. Subjects are parents or
was voluntary and confidentiality guaranteed. The
guardian of hospitalized children between age’s 1-
participant were asked to rate the items on the
14years. Allocation of sample frame is
scale perceived to be important for FCNC using a
proportional in between the wards. Peadiatric
five point likert scale of 1= not all important, to 5=
parents/guardian was purposively selected based
very important. The principal investigator and two
on the following inclusion criteria: (1) biological
research assistants helped to read and fill the
parents or guardian of the sick child (2) persons
responses for respondents who could neither read
directly responsible for the care and wellbeing of
nor write in English or Yoruba language, for those
the child and provides consistent care (3) the sick
who could read they were given the questionnaire
child who must have been hospitalized for at least
to fill. These questionnaires were filled between 15
one week. Utilizing simple random sampling for
to 45minutes. The questionnaire were retrieved the
nurses, the sample size is 176 nurses who are have
same day and examined if they were properly
been working for not less than six months in the
filled.
selected peadiatric units.
Data Analysis
Instrument for data collection
The data were analysed using SPSS software
The instrument for data collection was a modified
version 21.0. Each item on the questionnaire was
Family Centered Care Scale developed by Curley,
first coded for statistical analysis from 1 for the not
Hunsberger & Harris (2013). The instrument
all important to 5 for the very important and their
consists of 20 items adapted from the original
mean scores and standard deviations were
instrument to accommodate the subjects, study
calculated to find the most important and least
settings and objectives of the study. The
important Family centered nursing care behaviors.
modification of the instrument was made by
The items with the highest mean were identified as
consultant peadiatrician, senior nurse lecturers,
most important family centered nursing care
peadiatric nurses and statistician. Each item was
behaviors while the items with the lowest mean
rated on a 5-point likert scale of not all important,
scores were identified as the least important family
less important, important, moderately important
www.internationaljournalofcaringsciences.org
International Journal of Caring Sciences January– April 2017 Volume 10 | Issue 1| Page 70
centered nursing care behaviors. The t -test while “ Parents are allowed to request how they
analysis of variables was used to compare want to participate in child care (4.07 ± 1.023) was
peadiatric parents and nurses’ scores on each item rated the last.
to determine any difference in their perception of
Analyzing the list of the most important items, the
family centered nursing behaviours. Regression
peadiatric parents and nurses agreed on 7 out of the
analysis was used to determine the effect of socio
10 most important items. The seven items were;
demographic variables on peadiatric parents and
“Suggestions are used about how to care for their
nurses’ perception of family centered nursing
child”, “convinced your child is well- cared for”,
behavior.
“Explain about changes you could expect in your
Results child’s condition”, “Figure out how you can be
most helpful to your child”, “Participate actively in
Socio-Demographic Characteristics of Subjects
the care of your child”, “Are treated as a valued
The ages of peadiatric parents/guardian ranged team member when planning their child’s nursing
from 18 to 55years with mean of 29.72 ± 5.89. care”, “Are asked to relate things about their child
There were 92.9% mother/female guardians. Only that the nurse should know”.
48% had primary school education while 36.8%
Utilizing multiple regression (Table 3), there was
had secondary school education. The nurses’ age
no significant influence of age , level of education
ranged from 20- 52years with mean of
and length of hospital stay on peadiatric parents
(34.81±7.99). The nurses’ ages were between 20-
perception of Family Centered Nursing behavior
52years with mean of (34.81±7.99). Only 96.6%
(F=2.058 p=0.106). The nurses’ age and years of
were females, 77.8% had diploma in nursing
peadiatric experience significantly influenced their
qualification while 22.2% had bachelor degree in
perception of Family Centered Nursing behavior
nursing. Their years of peadiatrics experience
(F=11.167 p=0.00). There was no significant
ranged from 1to 12years with mean of 4.25 ±3.11
difference between the perception of peadiatric
(table 1).
parents’ and nurses on Family Centered Nursing
Family Centered Nursing Care Behaviors behavior (t= 0.014, P=0.90).
Identified by Peadiatric Parents and Nurses
Discussion
Table 2 shows family centered nursing behavior
This study explored peadiatric parents and nurses
highly rated by peadiatric parents/guardian
perception of family centered nursing care
perceived as very important were “Use my
behaviors. The strength of the study included the
suggestions about how to care for your child ( 4.46
use of matched parent and staff instruments that
± 1.496) ,“ Feel well- cared for (4.42 ± 0.879),
allowed for direct comparisons of family centered
“Explain about changes you could expect in your
nursing care behavior perceptions. The ranking of
child’s condition (4.40± 0.958), “ Figure out how
the most important Family centered nursing care
you can be most helpful to your child (4.38±
behaviours by the peadiatric parents and nurses
0.845) and “Given an opportunity in taking a break
revealed that “Suggestions are used about how to
from your child’s room (3.51±1.479) as least
care for their child”, “convinced your child is
important.
well- cared for”, “Explain about changes you
Nurses rated the following family centered nursing could expect in your child’s condition”, “Figure
care behaviors as the most important “ Parents out how you can be most helpful to your child”,
are given detail explanations about changes they “Participate actively in the care of your child”,
could be expected from their condition (4.48 ± “Are treated as a valued team member when
0.985), “ Parents are treated as a valued team planning their child’s nursing care” were
member when planning their child’s nursing care( considered very important. This finding is similar
4.33 ± 0.910) “ Parents are help to figure out how with the study of Curley etal (2013), who reported
they can be most helpful to their child (4.31 ± parents rated the same items as important for
0.956) “ Parents are given explanations on how to FCNC.
respond to child behavior and emotional reaction
related to illness and hospitalization (4.30 ± 1.038)
www.internationaljournalofcaringsciences.org
International Journal of Caring Sciences January– April 2017 Volume 10 | Issue 1| Page 71
www.internationaljournalofcaringsciences.org
International Journal of Caring Sciences January– April 2017 Volume 10 | Issue 1| Page 72
Table 2: Paediatric Parents' and Nurses’ Ranking of the 10 Most Important Family
Centered Nursing Care Behaviors
ITEMS MEAN/SD ITEMS NURSES MEAN/SD
PARENTS N=176
N=323
Use my suggestions about how to 4.46±1.496 Are given detail explanations 4.48±0.985
care for your child. about changes they could expect
from their child’s condition
Convinced your child is well- 4.42±0.879 Are treated as a valued team 4.33±0.910
cared for member when planning their
child’s nursing care.
Explain about changes you could 4.40±0.158 Are helped to figure out how they 4.31±0.956
expect in your child’s condition can be most helpful to their child
Figure out how you can be most 4.38±0.845 Are given explanations on how to 4.30±1.038
helpful to your child respond to child’s behavior and
emotional reactions related to illness
and hospitalization
Confident in caring for my sick 4.38±0.804 Are helped to be of the opinion 4.30±1.113
child their child is well cared for
Provide information as regards 4.38±0.867 Are asked to relate things about 4.29±0.856
your child’s condition and their child that the nurse should
medical history know
Given the opeadiatric 4.37±0.856 Are allowed to feel important in 4.26±1.073
parentsortunity to participate in child’s care
your child’s care
Participate actively in the care of 4.37±0.833 Are well cared for 4.25±1.149
your child
Informed about the importance of 4.36±1.011 Are welcomed 4.23±O.912
collaborative care
Involved in making key decisions 4.33±0.946 Suggestions are used about how to 4.23±1.165
in the care of your child care for their child
www.internationaljournalofcaringsciences.org
International Journal of Caring Sciences January– April 2017 Volume 10 | Issue 1| Page 73
Table 3: Paired sample T-test of Paediatric Parents and Nurses Perception of Family Centered
Nursing Care Behaviours.
VARIABLES MEAN SD± df t-cal P value
Table 4: Socio- demographic Variables and Paediatric Parents and Nurses Perception of Family
Centered Nursing Care Behaviours.
MODEL T P Beta F P
MODEL T P Beta F P
These findings supports that of Harbaugh, about changes they could expect from their
Tomlinson & Kirschbaum (2004) who conducted child’s condition” as the most important nursing
a qualitative study to assess parents’ perception of behavior important for FCNC. This is in line with
nurses’ caregiving behaviors in peaditaric Omari, Abualrub & Ayasreh(2013) who
intensive care unit. Parents reported nurses conducted a study on perceptions of patients and
engaged in nurturing and vigilant behavior, nurses towards nurse caring behaviors in coronary
namely showing affection, caring, watching and care units in Jordan. They reported patients in
protecting. Melo etal (2014) reported critical care units perceived physical and technical
communication and mutual understanding was behaviors as most important caring behaviors
emphasized by primary caregivers as very whereas nurses perceived teaching behaviors as
important for Family Centered Care. the most important. Findings from this study also
revealed there is no significant difference between
Also, findings in this study revealed that nurses
the perception of peadiatric parents’ and nurses’
ranked” Parents are given detail explanations
www.internationaljournalofcaringsciences.org
International Journal of Caring Sciences January– April 2017 Volume 10 | Issue 1| Page 74
on Family centered nursing care behaviors. This that nurses included in the study were those that
could be due to the nurses’ educational base, have been working for not less than 6months in
where informed consent and educating parents of the selected peadiatric units.
patho-physiology of disease conditions take a
These findings provide concrete information as
significant part. Frequency analysis (table 2) also
regards the Family Centered Nursing Care
demonstrated marked concordance between
behaviors, the parents of hospitalized children
peadiatric parents and nurses in prioritizing how
would like to experience and caring behaviors
important these items are for FCNC. Seven nurse
nurses perceived as important for family centered
caring behaviors were ranked among the ten most
care, they should include in their daily practice.
important behaviours. Adereti etal, (2014)
For effective implementation of Family Centered
reported there is no significant difference in the
Nursing Care among the peadiatric settings, there
peadiatrics patients and primary caregiver
is need for nurses and healthcare professionals to
perception of nurse caring behaviors. This also
take cognizance of the nurse caring behaviors
supported by Stuart & Melling (2014) who
important to parents of hospitalized children.
reported parents and nurses had similar
Interventions should be initiated in the hospitals
perceptions of task allocation in Family Centered
to help nurses meet the caring expectations for
Care. This is in constrast with the study of Gill,
parents of hospitalized children in order to be in
Pascoe, Monterosso, Young , Burr, Tanner &
tune with their needs. There is need for further
Shields (2014) who compared parents and
studies in the implementation of FCC among the
hospital staff perception of Family Centered Care
peadiatric population in Nigeria.
in two Australian tertiary peadiatric hospital,
findings revealed that both parents and staff Acknowledgements
responses were different. Kimble etal (2003) I would like to thank all parents of hospitalized
indicated that regardless of the patients age or the children and nurses who participated in the study.
severity of their illness, parents and patients alike
share the same perception regarding which Research Setting
nursing behaviours are the most indicative of their University College Hospital, Ibadan, info@uch-
sense of caring. ibadan.org,ng and Massy Street Children
The second hypothesis generated for this study Hospital, Lagos, Nigeria, +23412631979.
revealed there is statistical differences in the
perception of Family Centered Nursing Care References
behavior by age and level of education but length Adereti, S.C., Olaogun, A.A., Olagunju, E.O. and
of hospital stay did not influence it. This finding Afolabi, K.E., 2014. Paediatric Patients and
could be because most parents had a previous Primary Care Givers' Perception of Nurse-Caring
experience in the hospital with other siblings of Behaviour in South Western Nigeria. International
the sick child. Kam etal (2008) reported that age Journal of Caring Sciences, 7(2), p.610.
and length of stay did not explain the differences Bruce, B., Letourneau, N., Ritchie, J., Larocque, S.,
between the responses of parents of hospitalized Dennis, C. and Elliott, M.R., 2002. A multisite study
children with sickle cell disease who perceived of health professionals’ perceptions and practices of
family-centered care. Journal of Family Nursing,
their child’s care as of lower quality than parents
8(4), pp.408-429.
of children with cancer. This differs from the Curley, M.A., Hunsberger, M. and Harris, S.K., 2013.
study of Commodari(2010) who reported that Psychometric evaluation of the family-
length of hospital stay and age influenced the centered care scale for pediatric acute care
respondents perception of stress and level of nursing. Nursing research, 62(3), pp.160-168.
anxiety. Perception of FCNC behaviors of the Commodari, E., 2010. Children staying in hospital: a
nurses varied by years of peadiatric experience research on psychological stress of caregivers.
but age did not. Bruce (2002) reported there is no Italian journal of pediatrics, 36(1), p.1.
significant difference between years of peadiatric Foster, M., Whitehead, L. and Maybee, P., 2010.
experience and perceptions of necessary elements Parents’ and health professionals’ perceptions of
family centred care for children in hospital, in
of FCC. The reason for this may be due to the fact
www.internationaljournalofcaringsciences.org
International Journal of Caring Sciences January– April 2017 Volume 10 | Issue 1| Page 75
developed and developing countries: a review of the the healthcare provided to hospitalzed children.
literature. International journal of nursing studies, Revista latino-americana de enfermagem, 22(3),
47(9), pp.1184-1193. pp.432-439
Gill, F.J., Pascoe, E., Monterosso, L., Young, J., Burr, Omari, F.H., AbuAlRub, R. and Ayasreh, I.R., 2013.
C., Tanner, A. and Shields, L., 2014. Parent and Perceptions of patients and nurses towards nurse
staff perceptions of family-centered care in two caring behaviors in coronary care units in Jordan.
Australian children’s hospitals. European Journal Journal of clinical nursing, 22(21-22), pp.3183-
for Person Centered Healthcare, 1(2). 3191.
Harbaugh, b.l., Tomlinson, p.s. and Kirschbaum, m., Pelander, T., Leino-Kilpi, H. and Katajisto, J., 2007.
2004. Parents' perceptions of nurses' caregiving Quality of pediatric nursing care in Finland:
behaviors in the pediatric intensive care unit. Issues Children's perspective. Journal of Nursing Care
in comprehensive pediatric nursing, 27(3), pp.163- Quality, 22(2), pp.185-194/
178. Shields, L., Pratt, J. and Hunter, J., 2006. Family
Hockenberry, M.J. and Wilson, D., 2011. Wong's centred care: a review of qualitative studies. Journal
nursing care of infants and children: Mosby St. of clinical nursing, 15(10), pp.1317-1323.
Louis, MO. Stuart, M. and Melling, S., 2014. Understanding nurses’
Jeglinsky, I., Autti‐Rämö, I. and Brogren Carlberg, E., and parents’ perceptions of family-centred care:
2012. Two sides of the mirror: parents' and service Nursing children and young people, 26(7), pp.16-21.
providers' view on the family‐centredness of care for Tsironi, S., Bovaretos, N., Tsoumakas, K.,
children with cerebral palsy. Child: care, health and Giannakopoulou, M. and Matziou, V., 2012. Factors
development, 38(1), pp.79-86. affecting parental satisfaction in the neonatal
Jolley, J. and Shields, L., 2009. The evolution of family- intensive care unit. Journal of Neonatal Nursing,
centered care. Journal of pediatric nursing, 24(2), 18(5), pp.183-192.
pp.164-170. Vincent, C. and Davis, R., 2012. Patients and families
Kam, J., Panepinto, J.A., Brandow, A.M. and as safety experts. Canadian Medical Association
Brousseau, D.C., 2008. Parental perception of Journal, 184(1), pp.15-16
quality of hospital care for children with sickle cell Watson, J., 1998. Reflections Florence Nightingale and
disease. Wisconsin Medical Journal (WMJ), 107(3), the Enduring Legacy of Transpersonal Human
p.131 Caring. Journal of Holistic Nursing, 16(2), pp.292-
Kimble, L., 2003. Patients’Perceptions of Nurse Caring 294.
Behaviors in an Emergency Department. Marshall Zamanzadeh V., Azimzadeh R., Rahmani A., &
University. Valizadeh, L(2010) Oncology patients and
Melo, E.M.D.O.P., Ferreira, P.L., Lima, R.A.G.D. and professional nurse’s perceptions of important nurse
Mello, D.F.D., 2014. The involvement of parents in caring behaviours. BMC Nursing 10:1-14
www.internationaljournalofcaringsciences.org
Reproduced with permission of copyright owner.
Further reproduction prohibited without permission.