This rubric evaluates student reflective writing prompts in 5 areas on a scale of 1 to 5:
1. Depth of reflection on the writing prompt and subject matter. Higher scores demonstrate a thorough understanding while lower scores show little understanding.
2. Use of textual evidence and historical context from sources to support claims. Stronger responses use specific examples while weaker ones use incomplete or vague examples.
3. Language use in terms of style, voice, awareness of audience and purpose, and sentence variation. More advanced responses use sophisticated, precise language while basic responses may use vague language.
4. Conventions of spelling, grammar, and punctuation. Higher scores exhibit control with few errors even in complex writing, whereas
This rubric evaluates student reflective writing prompts in 5 areas on a scale of 1 to 5:
1. Depth of reflection on the writing prompt and subject matter. Higher scores demonstrate a thorough understanding while lower scores show little understanding.
2. Use of textual evidence and historical context from sources to support claims. Stronger responses use specific examples while weaker ones use incomplete or vague examples.
3. Language use in terms of style, voice, awareness of audience and purpose, and sentence variation. More advanced responses use sophisticated, precise language while basic responses may use vague language.
4. Conventions of spelling, grammar, and punctuation. Higher scores exhibit control with few errors even in complex writing, whereas
This rubric evaluates student reflective writing prompts in 5 areas on a scale of 1 to 5:
1. Depth of reflection on the writing prompt and subject matter. Higher scores demonstrate a thorough understanding while lower scores show little understanding.
2. Use of textual evidence and historical context from sources to support claims. Stronger responses use specific examples while weaker ones use incomplete or vague examples.
3. Language use in terms of style, voice, awareness of audience and purpose, and sentence variation. More advanced responses use sophisticated, precise language while basic responses may use vague language.
4. Conventions of spelling, grammar, and punctuation. Higher scores exhibit control with few errors even in complex writing, whereas
5 4 3 2 1 Depth of Demonstrate a Demonstrate a Demonstrate a Demonstrate a Demonstrate little or reflection conscious and thoughtful basic limited no understanding of thorough understanding understanding understanding the writing prompt understanding of of the writing of the writing of the writing and subject matter. the writing prompt prompt and the prompt and the prompt and This reflection needs and the subject subject matter. subject matter. subject matter. revision. matter. This reflection This reflection can needs revision. be used as an example for other students. Use of textual Use specific and Use relevant Use examples Use incomplete No examples from evidence and convincing examples from from the text to or vaguely the text are used and historical examples from the the texts studied support most developed claims made in your context texts studied to to support claims in your examples to own writing are support claims in claims in your writing with only partially unsupported and your own writing, own writing, some support claims irrelevant to the making insightful making connections with no topic at hand. and applicable applicable made between connections connections connections texts. made between between texts. between texts. texts. Language use Use stylistically Use language Use basic but Use language Use language that is sophisticated that is fluent and appropriate that is vague or unsuitable for the language that is original, with language, with a imprecise for audience and precise and evident a sense basic sense of the audience or purpose, with little engaging, with of voice, voice, some purpose, with or no awareness of notable sense of awareness of awareness of little sense of sentence structure. voice, awareness of audience and audience and voice, and a audience and purpose, and the purpose and limited purpose, and ability to vary some attempt to awareness of varied sentence sentence vary sentence how to vary structure. structure. structure. sentence structure. Conventions Demonstrate Demonstrate Demonstrate Demonstrate Demonstrate little or control of the control of the partial control of limited control of no control of the conventions with conventions, the conventions, the conventions, conventions, making essentially no exhibiting exhibiting exhibiting comprehension almost errors, even with occasional occasional frequent errors impossible. sophisticated errors only errors that do that make language. when using not hinder comprehension sophisticated comprehension. difficult. language.
Vuong-Dac-Rubrics-SSR Writing/Adapted from “Reflective Writing Rubric” readwritethink.org