Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Blue or Red The Effects of Colour On The Emotions of Chinese People
Blue or Red The Effects of Colour On The Emotions of Chinese People
Two experiments were performed to examine the effects of red and blue on the emotional pleasure of Chinese
people. Experiment 1 explored the effects of the ‘physical’ colours red and blue on emotion, and the results
showed that red induced positive and negative emotion, while blue only induced positive emotion. Experiment
2 further explored the effects of the ‘verbal’ colours red and blue on emotion, and the results showed that red
induced only positive emotion, while blue induced neither positive nor negative emotion. The findings indicate
that the influence of colour on emotion is rooted in both natural and social associations. For Chinese, the
associations between blue and positive emotion, and red and negative emotion, were natural associations;
however, the associations between red and positive emotion were social associations. Moreover, physical
colour and verbal colour stimuli induced emotions by activating different mechanisms: physical colour
induced emotions via both natural and social associations, whereas verbal colour induced emotions via social
associations.
Colour plays a key role in influencing the minds and behav- Colour theorists believe that colour influences minds and
iours of both animals and humans. A large amount of behaviours mainly via learned associations. When people
research has been done to investigate the effects of colour frequently encounter situations where different colours are
on emotion, and most has focused on red and blue. accompanied by particular objects or experiences, they form
According to Mehrabian and Russell (1974), emotion specific associations to those colours (Baldwin & Meunier,
has three dimensions, including arousal, dominance, and 1999). Learned association theory has been proven by the
pleasure. On the arousal dimension, most studies that used studies in the colour behaviour field (Elliot, Maier, Moller,
physiological measures (e.g. galvanic skin response, elec- Friedman & Meinhardt, 2007; Elliot, Maier, Binser,
troencephalograph) have generally shown that long- Friedman & Pekrun, 2009; Mehta & Zhu, 2009). In a recent
wavelength colours (e.g. red and yellow) are more arousing report by Mehta and Zhu (2009), it is proven that red can
than short-wavelength colours (e.g. blue and green) induce primarily avoidance motivation via learned associa-
(Arsenault, Hebert & Dubois, 2012; Gerard, 1958; Kuller, tions with blood and warning, etc., and then enhanced per-
Mikellides & Janssens, 2009; Wilson, 1966). On the domi- formance on a detail-oriented task; whereas blue can induce
nance dimension, research shows that compared with blue, primarily approach motivation via learned associations with
red can enhance the dominance of animals and humans, sky and ocean, etc., and then enhanced performance on a
especially in competition (Healey, Uller & Olsson, 2007; creative task. This study, first of all, proves that it is via
Hill & Barton, 2005; Pryke & Griffith, 2006). However, on learned associations that the colours induce specific motiva-
the pleasure dimension, the results are conflicting. Some tions. Moreover, they give us an important implication that
studies show that red can induce more positive emotion learned associations should include both natural and social
than blue (Choungourian, 1968; Garth & Collado, 1921; associations (Moller et al., 2009). Natural associations refer
Gesche, 1927; Hevner, 1935; Pastoureau, 2001). Other to the learned associations between colour and meanings
studies, however, find that blue can induce more positive formed in the biological environment during a species’
emotion than red (Camgoz, Yener & Guvenc, 2002; Gerend evolution (e.g. the link between blue and sky). By contrast,
& Tricia, 2009; Hurlbert & Ling, 2007; Manav, 2007; social associations refer to the learned associations between
Moller, Elliot & Maier, 2009; Sascha, 2009; Spielberger, colour and meanings formed in the socio-cultural environ-
Gorsuch & Lushene, 1970; Valdez & Mehrabian, 1994; ment during the individual’s development (e.g. the link
Wogalter, Conzola & Smith-Jackson, 2002). between red and victory).
As in the colour behaviour field, colour should also influ-
Correspondence: Lei Mo and Siyun Shu, Department of Psychol- ence emotion through both natural and social associations
ogy, South China Normal University, Guangzhou, 510631 China. (Gerend & Tricia, 2009). Based on this theory, we propose
Email: molei@scnu.edu.cn, and shusybao@163.com that the reason the influence of colour on arousal (or domi-
Received 22 July 2012; accepted 13 August 2013. nance) is consistent in multiple research types among
© 2014 Wiley Publishing Asia Pty Ltd with the Asian Association of Social Psychology and the Japanese Group Dynamics Association
Effects of colour on emotion 153
different species and cultures is because the associations positive emotions in Chinese due to its positive associations
between colour and arousal (or dominance) are natural, in the natural environment (Mehta & Zhu, 2009). So our
not social. During evolution, specific colour carries consist- first hypothesis is that red could induce both positive and
ent emotional arousal (or dominance) in the biological negative emotions in Chinese, while blue could only induce
environment for both human beings and animals. For positive emotions in Chinese. Furthermore, according to
example, red is a signal for attention (higher arousal) and previous studies, because of the linguistic and abstract fea-
power (higher dominance). Therefore, although research tures, verbal colour stimulus is a better reflection of social
objects vary from human to animals, culture to culture, and culture than physical colour stimulus. It was more affected
research methods vary from behavioural to physiological, by the socio-cultural environment and less, or even not at
the results of colour and arousal (or dominance) are con- all, by the biological environment (Harba & Grant, 1970;
sistent (Moller et al., 2009). In this case we further suggest Williams & Tucker, 1971). Thus, we further hypothesize
that the reason the influence of colour on pleasure is still that the verbal colour stimulus ‘red’ could only induce
controversial is because the associations between colour positive emotions in Chinese people. To test the above
and pleasure are not only natural but also social. Thus, we hypotheses, two experiments were performed to investigate
further propose that the conflicting findings of previous the effects of red and blue on Chinese emotions. Experi-
studies on pleasure dimension might result from the differ- ment 1 explored the different effects of red and blue on their
ent cultural backgrounds of the participants. In previous emotional pleasure; and Experiment 2 further explored the
studies, participants were American, Mexican, Philippine, influence of the verbal colour stimuli ‘red’ and ‘blue’ on
Turkish, Roman, Kuwaiti, American Indian, and German, their emotional pleasure.
etc. The results show that the Mexican, Philippine, Roman,
Kuwaiti and American Indian participants preferred
red, and red could activate their positive emotions Experiment 1
(Choungourian, 1968; Garth & Collado, 1921; Gesche,
1927; Pastoureau, 2001), while the American, German, and Method
Turkish participants preferred blue, and blue could invoke
Experiment 1 aimed to investigate the effects of blue and
their positive emotions (Camgoz et al., 2002; Gerend &
red on the emotional pleasure of Chinese people.1 It is
Tricia, 2009; Hurlbert & Ling, 2007; Moller et al., 2009;
also worth noting that the experimental purposes of most
Sascha, 2009; Spielberger et al., 1970; Valdez &
previous studies were so obvious that participants could
Mehrabian, 1994; Wogalter et al., 2002). According to pre-
guess what was expected. However, according to learned
vious research, red is a respectful colour in the Mexican,
association theory, the activation of colour associations on
Philippine, and American Indian cultures, and it is com-
emotion always occurs automatically and unconsciously
monly used in national flags, totems, and daily decorations
(Bargh, 1990). In order to avoid the above problem, an
(Garth & Collado, 1921; Gesche, 1927). However, it does
implicit task and a priming paradigm were used in this
not have such meanings in America, Germany, and Turkey.
study. During the experiment, the task was to ask the par-
Blue is generally preferred to red by American, British and
ticipants to judge whether the word was true or not. But
German adults (Camgoz et al., 2002; Gerend & Tricia,
the real purpose of the experiment was to investigate
2009; Hurlbert & Ling, 2007; Moller et al., 2009; Sascha,
whether positive (or negative) emotion words were
2009; Spielberger et al., 1970; Valdez & Mehrabian, 1994;
responded to faster than neutral ones in red (or blue)
Wogalter et al., 2002). However, blue is ranked among
colour priming conditions. According to the logic of the
the least preferred colours in Rome owing to the historical
priming paradigm, reactions are typically faster when the
reason that blue was adored by Rome’s archenemies, the
target stimulus is preceded by a semantically or percep-
Celts (Pastoureau, 2001). Therefore, same colour can
tually related priming stimulus (Angela, Steinhauer &
carry different meanings in different socio-cultural
Frisch, 1999). Thus, faster reactions for target stimuli
environments.
(positive emotion words) in specific priming conditions
But what about Chinese participants? Owing to the
(e.g. red) indicate that this priming condition (e.g. red)
unique cultural environment, red and blue should have dif-
can induce the corresponding inner mental state (positive
ferent effects on the emotions of Chinese people. Specifi-
emotion), which is consistent with the target stimuli (posi-
cally, red, because of its special value in the red-esteem
tive emotion words).
Chinese culture, and its pivotal status in dangerous warning
in the natural environment, should induce both positive and
Participants
negative emotions in Chinese participants (Huang, Huang
& Li, 1991; Hurlbert & Ling, 2007; Li, 1991, 2007). By Thirty-one (16 female, 15 male, mean age: 22 ± 2.5 years)
contrast, blue does not have special meaning or status in students from South China Normal University participated
Chinese culture. As a result, it is more likely to induce in the present study in exchange for ¥5. Participation was
© 2014 Wiley Publishing Asia Pty Ltd with the Asian Association of Social Psychology and the Japanese Group Dynamics Association
154 Tingting Wang et al.
restricted to individuals who were native Chinese speakers, These pictures were all approximately close to 0 (z-score) in
had normal or corrected-to-normal vision without colour the dimensions of arousal, pleasure, and dominance.
blindness or weakness.
(2) Experimental phase. At the start of each trial, a fixa-
Design and materials tion cross appeared at the centre of the screen for 500 ms,
followed by a colour square as a priming stimulus pre-
A 3 (pleasure: positive, neutral, and negative) × 2 (colours:
sented for 105 ms. After the priming stimulus disappeared,
red and blue) within-subject design was used. The priming
an affective word as the target stimulus was shown on the
stimuli were either blue or red squares, which measured
screen. Participants were asked to judge whether the word
2 cm × 2 cm. The HSL (hue, saturation, and lightness)
was a real word or a pseudo word by pressing ‘F’ or ‘J’,
values were as follows: red = 0, 240, 120; blue = 160, 240,
respectively. The target word was presented on the screen
and 120; these were adopted from Mehta and Zhu
until the participants pressed one of the buttons or until
(2009).
3000 ms had elapsed.
The target stimuli were two types of words: experimental
and dummy. For the experimental words, the stimuli were
(3) Post-test phase. After the experiment, participants
180 affective words chosen from the Chinese affective
received a questionnaire to examine whether they had
words system (Wang, Zhou & Lou, 2008), including 60
figured out the aim of the experiment. For the post-test
positive words (e.g. ‘success’ and ‘smile’, z-score above
questionnaire, participants were asked the following
0.85, M = 6.93, SD = 0.22), 60 neutral words (e.g. ‘floor’
question: ‘What do you think we were trying to test?’ Only
and ‘door’, z-score above 0.40 and below −0.40, M = 5.13,
if the participants mentioned colour and emotion at the
SD = 0.33), and 60 negative words (e.g. ‘failure’ and ‘idiot’,
same time, they were judged to have figured out the purpose
z-score below −1.06, M = 3.02, SD = 0.34). The Chinese
of study (Elliot, Maier, Moller, Friedman & Meinhardt,
affective words system is a standard system, which is based
2007).
on the three emotional dimensions (arousal, dominance,
and valence) carried in Chinese words, and has a good
‘test-retest’ reliability (all the dimensions are over 0.79) Results and discussion
(Wang, Zhou, & Lou, 2008). One-way ANOVA showed
One participant was excluded because he had guessed the
that the difference in the three types of words was signifi-
purpose of the experiment. Mean RTs (for accurate
cant in pleasure but not significant in arousal, dominance,
responses) and accuracy were submitted to a 3 (pleasure:
concreteness, words frequency, and initial word frequency.
positive vs neutral vs negative) × 2 (colour: red vs blue)
To make sure the three types of words were comparable, we
repeated measures ANOVA, respectively. For RTs, the
conducted a pilot study under the non-priming condition.
main effect of pleasure was significant, F(2,58) = 18.49,
The results indicate that there were no significant differ-
MSE = 1892.09, p < 0.05, ηp2 = 0.57. The main effect of
ences in either mean reaction times (RTs) or accuracy
colour was also significant, F(1,29) = 0.32, MSE =
among the three types of words (RTs: F(2,28) = 2.48,
1595.11, p < 0.05, ηp2 = 0.05. More importantly, the inter-
MSE = 499.18, p > 0.05, ηp2 = 0.15; accuracy: F(2,28) =
action between colour and pleasure was significant,
2.51, MSE = 0.001, p > 0.05, ηp2 = 0.15). The dummy
F(2,58) = 3.61, MSE = 1445.73, p < 0.05, ηp2 = 0.21.
words were 180 pseudo words (e.g., ‘冰现’). Both of the
Planned t-tests on simple effects suggested that, for the red
experimental words and dummy words were repeated
condition, positive words were responded to significantly
twice, so each of the subjects completed 720 trials. All
faster than negative (p < 0.05) and neutral words (p < 0.05),
stimuli were presented randomly.
while negative words were responded to significantly
faster than neutral words (p < 0.05); for the blue con-
Procedure
dition, positive words were responded to significantly
Computers with Intel Pentium V processors were used. The faster than negative words (p < 0.05) and neutral words
screen resolution was 1024 × 768, the screen lightness was (p < 0.05) (see Fig. 1). For accuracy, no significant effects
100, the screen contrast was 50, and the colour temperature were found.
was 6500 K. Each participant completed the experiment The results of Experiment 1 showed that in the red colour
independently in separate rooms, with a viewing distance of condition, both the reactions to positive and negative words
60 cm. They were asked to complete the three following were faster than to neutral words, while in the blue condi-
procedural phases in sequence: tion only the reactions to positive words were faster than
neutral words. The present findings support our first
(1) Adaptation phase. Eight affective pictures chosen from hypothesis that red can induce both positive and negative
the Chinese Affective Picture System (Bai, Ma, Huang & emotions in Chinese people, while blue can only induce
Luo, 2005) were each presented on the screen for 2 seconds. positive emotions in Chinese people.
© 2014 Wiley Publishing Asia Pty Ltd with the Asian Association of Social Psychology and the Japanese Group Dynamics Association
Effects of colour on emotion 155
Procedure
The procedure was completely identical to that of
Experiment 1.
© 2014 Wiley Publishing Asia Pty Ltd with the Asian Association of Social Psychology and the Japanese Group Dynamics Association
156 Tingting Wang et al.
© 2014 Wiley Publishing Asia Pty Ltd with the Asian Association of Social Psychology and the Japanese Group Dynamics Association
Effects of colour on emotion 157
© 2014 Wiley Publishing Asia Pty Ltd with the Asian Association of Social Psychology and the Japanese Group Dynamics Association
158 Tingting Wang et al.
Pryke, S. R. & Griffith, S. C. (2006). Red Spielberger, C. D., Gorsuch, R. L. & Lushene, chimpanzees. Journal of Comparative Psy-
dominates black: Agonistic signaling among R. E. (1970). Manual for the State–Trait chology, 122, 213–219.
head morphs in the colour polymorphic Anxiety Inventory. Palo Alto, CA: Consult- Williams, J. & Tucker, R. (1971). Changes in
Gouldian finch. Proceedings of the Royal ing Psychologists Press. the connotations of color names among
Society B, 273, 949–957. Valdez, P. & Mehrabian, A. (1994). Effects negroes and Caucasians. Journal of
Russell, J. A. & Mehrabian, A. (1974). Distin- of color on emotions. Journal of Experimen- Personality and Social Psychology, 19,
guishing anger and anxiety in terms of tal Psychology: General, 123, 394– 222–228.
emotional response factors. Journal of 409. Wilson, G. D. (1966). Arousal properties of red
Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 42, Wang, Y. N., Zhou, L. M. & Lou, Y. J. (2008). versus green. Perceptual and Motor Skills,
79–83. The pilot establishment and evaluation of 23, 942–949.
Sascha, F. (2009). Early and late tempro-spatial Chinese affective words system. Chinese Wogalter, M. S., Conzola, V. C. &
effects of contextual interference during Mental Health Journal, 22 (8), 608–612. Smith-Jackson, T. L. (2002). Research-based
perceptions of facial effect. International Wells, D. L., McDonald, C. L. & Ringland, J. guidelines for warning design and evalua-
Journal of Psychophysiology, 74, 1–13. E. (2008). Color preferences in gorillas and tion. Applied Ergonomic, 33, 219–230.
© 2014 Wiley Publishing Asia Pty Ltd with the Asian Association of Social Psychology and the Japanese Group Dynamics Association
Copyright of Asian Journal of Social Psychology is the property of Wiley-Blackwell and its
content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the
copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email
articles for individual use.