Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Protection Coordination Report: Camerich Paper Private LTD
Protection Coordination Report: Camerich Paper Private LTD
1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 3
2 Reference Documents 4
3 Device Details 5
4 Single Line Diagram 6
5 Short Circuit Current Details 8
6 Setting Calculation for Transformers 13
7 Stabilising Resistance calculation 15
8 Setting Data for Control and Relay Panels 17
9 Setting Data for 11 kV Boards 22
10 Setting Data for 415V MCCs 37
11 Time Current Characterstics Curves 39
Executive Summary
Introduction
Project: CAMERICH PAPER PRIVATE LTD,MORBI,GUJARAT,INDIA,363641
Electrical Contractor: SIEMENS INDIA LTD, MUMBAI
ElectricalDistribution System 66/11kV Distribution system
Power System Data
Max Source Fault level (assumed) 3000 MVA sec at 66 kV
The short circuit currents at various busbars are calculated based on the above
assumptions. Calculated Short circuit currents are tabulated in the report and also
shown in the SLD.
Selectivity of relays and circuit breakers were worked out based on the cable size
and flow of short circuit currents.
Time current characterstic curves are generated for every path and verified .
Conclusion
Settings for each device,short circuit currents at every busbars,detailed
calculations for the settings are given in the following pages. No deviation is
observed and the interuupting capacities of the devices are above the calculated
short circuit currents .
Reference Documents/Drawings
Sl.No File ref Drawing title Rev Drawing No
1 CAMERICH PAPERS SLD- R1-Layout1 Over all SLD 0 (1) g71001-K0100-S3100 SH1 OF1
2 GTP - 7.5 MVA.pdf Technical Data Sheets for Power Transformer and OLTC 0 DOC NO.: ELE-01
3 Third Submission_Camerich_70 0606-100 11kV Switchboard (Expandable Type)-66 kV SS 1 70 0606/01-02 item 100
4 Third Submission_Camerich_70 0606-200 11kV Switchboard (Expandable Type)-SS2 1 70 0606/01-02 item 200
5 Third Submission_Camerich_70 0606-300 11kV Switchboard (Expandable Type)-SS3 1 70 0606/01-02 item 300
6 Type A- 66Kv C&R panel for feeder- GETCO end Single Line Diagram for 66kV Control & Relay Panel for 1 14 17 124-5A
Feeder
7 Type B- 66Kv C&R panel for feeder Single Line Diagram for 66kV Control & Relay Panel for 1 14 17 124-5B
Feeder
8 Type C- 66Kv C&R panel for Trafo with Diiff Prot. Single Line Diagram for 66kV Control & Relay Panel for 1 14 17 124-5C
Transformer
Device Details
2-Winding Transformers
Details of Equipment kVA rating High Low voltage Percentage Low High Grounding Vector Type of Supply Variation on
Voltage side Impedance winding winding Mode Group Cooling Primary side
side
Transformer TR 7500 66000 11000 8.70 Star Delta Direct Dyn11 ONAN -10% to +10% tapping
range
Transformer TR2 3000 11000 433 7.50 Star Delta Direct Dyn11 ONAN -5% to +5% tapping range
Transformer TR3 3000 11000 433 7.50 Star Delta Direct Dyn11 ONAN -5% to +5% tapping range
Transformer TR4 3000 11000 433 7.50 Star Delta Direct Dyn11 ONAN -5% to +5% tapping range
Transformer TR5 3000 11000 433 7.50 Star Delta Direct Dyn11 ONAN -5% to +5% tapping range
3-Winding Transformers
Details of Equipment kVA rating High Low voltage Low voltage Low High Low winding Vector Type of Supply Variation on
Voltage side1 in Volts side2 in winding winding 2 Group Cooling Primary side
side IN Volts 1
Volts
Transformer TR1 3000 11000 433 433 Star Star Delta YYD ONAN -5% to +5% tapping range
SIEMENS INDIA LTD
CAMERICH PAPER PRIVATE LTD
mm m
m
mm
mmm
m m
m
m m
mm
mmm
m
mmm
m m m m
mm mmm
m m
mmm mmm
m m m m m m m
m
mm
: :: :::: :
:
: :: : ::
m mmmm m mmmm m m :: : ::
: :
: :: :::::::::
SIEMENS INDIA LTD
CAMERICH PAPER PRIVATE LTD
yy y y
yyyyy
yyy
yyy
y
y y
y y
yy
yyyyy
y
yyyyy
yyy
y y y y
yy yy
yyyy yyyyy
y y
yyyyy yyyyy
yyy yyy
y y y y y y y
y
yy
y yy
y y yy
y y y yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
y yyyy yyyyyyy yyyyyyyyyyyy yyyyyyyyyy yyyyy y
y y yyyy
y yyy y yyy y y y y
y yy
yy y yy
yy y y :
: :
: :: :::: :
:
: :: : ::
yyy yyy yyy yyy :: : ::
: :
: :: :::::::::
Short Circuit Detailed Report ,(Minimum Source fault 1500 MVA sec)
3P Fault - IEC60909 Method at the Following Times
Bus Name Pre Fault Initial Peak Short 0.5 Cycle 1 Cycle 3 Cycle 5 cycle Std
Voltage in Symmetrical Circuit Current Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical
Volts SC Current in in Amps SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in
Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps
GRID 66000 13122 37113 13122 13122 13122 13122 13122
11kV BD_66kV SS 11000 4263 11221 4263 4263 4263 4263 4263
11kV BD SS1 11000 4251 11174 4251 4251 4251 4251 4251
11kV BD SS2 11000 4251 11174 4251 4251 4251 4251 4251
MCC-1 415 38524 98066 38524 38524 38524 38524 38524
MCC-2 415 38524 98066 38524 38524 38524 38524 38524
MCC-3 415 38524 98066 38524 38524 38524 38524 38524
MCC-4 415 38524 98066 38524 38524 38524 38524 38524
DRIVE PNL-1 415 35162 61379 35162 35162 35162 35162 35162
DRIVE PNL-2 415 35162 61379 35162 35162 35162 35162 35162
LL Fault - IEC60909 Method at the Following Times
Bus Name Pre Fault Initial Peak Short 0.5 Cycle 1 Cycle 3 Cycle 5 cycle Std
Voltage in Symmetrical Circuit Current Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical
Volts SC Current in in Amps SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in
Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps
GRID 66000 13122 37113 13122 13122 13122 13122 13122
11kV BD_66kV SS 11000 3718 9779 3718 3718 3718 3718 3718
11kV BD SS1 11000 3708 9738 3708 3708 3708 3708 3708
11kV BD SS2 11000 3708 9738 3708 3708 3708 3708 3708
MCC-1 415 33441 85128 33441 33441 33441 33441 33441
MCC-2 415 33441 85128 33441 33441 33441 33441 33441
MCC-3 415 33441 85128 33441 33441 33441 33441 33441
MCC-4 415 33441 85128 33441 33441 33441 33441 33441
DRIVE PNL-1 415 30501 53221 30501 30501 30501 30501 30501
DRIVE PNL-2 415 30501 53221 30501 30501 30501 30501 30501
LG Fault - IEC60909 Method at the Following Times
Bus Name Pre Fault Initial Peak Short 0.5 Cycle 1 Cycle 3 Cycle 5 cycle Std
Voltage in Symmetrical Circuit Current Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical
Volts SC Current in in Amps SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in
Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps
GRID 66000 13122 37113 13122 13122 13122 13122 13122
11kV BD_66kV SS 11000 5408 14204 5408 5408 5408 5408 5408
11kV BD SS1 11000 5388 14131 5388 5388 5388 5388 5388
11kV BD SS2 11000 5383 14116 5383 5383 5383 5383 5383
DRIVE PNL-1 415 39972 72733 39972 39972 39972 39972 39972
MCC-1 415 38258 89277 38258 38258 38258 38258 38258
MCC-2 415 38258 89277 38258 38258 38258 38258 38258
MCC-3 415 38258 89277 38258 38258 38258 38258 38258
MCC-4 415 38258 89277 38258 38258 38258 38258 38258
DRIVE PNL-2 415 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
LLG Fault - IEC60909 Method at the Following Times
Bus Name Pre Fault Initial Peak Short 0.5 Cycle 1 Cycle 3 Cycle 5 cycle Std
Voltage in Symmetrical Circuit Current Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical
Volts SC Current in in Amps SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in
Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps
GRID 66000 13603 38476 13603 13603 13603 13603 13603
11kV BD_66kV SS 11000 5189 13639 5189 5189 5189 5189 5189
11kV BD SS1 11000 5169 13566 5169 5169 5169 5169 5169
11kV BD SS2 11000 5164 13551 5164 5164 5164 5164 5164
DRIVE PNL-1 415 42546 76284 42546 42546 42546 42546 42546
MCC-1 415 41270 101135 41270 41270 41270 41270 41270
MCC-2 415 41270 101135 41270 41270 41270 41270 41270
MCC-3 415 41270 101135 41270 41270 41270 41270 41270
MCC-4 415 41270 101135 41270 41270 41270 41270 41270
DRIVE PNL-2 415 30501 53221 30501 30501 30501 30501 30501
y
y yyy
yy y y
yyyyy
yyy
yyy
y
y y
y y
yy
yyyyy
y
yyyyy
yyy
y y y y
yy yy
yyyy yyyyy
y y
yyyyy yyyyy
yyy yyy
y y y y y y y
y
yy
y yy
y y yy
y y y yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
y yyyy yyyyyyy yyyyyyyyyyyy y yyyyyyyy yyyyy y
y y yyyy
y yyy y yyy y y y y
y yy
yy y yy
yy y y :
: :
: :: :::: :
:
: :: : ::
yyy yyy yyy yyy :: : ::
: :
: :: :::::::::
Short Circuit Detailed Report ,(Maximum Source fault 3000 MVA sec)
3P Fault - IEC60909 Method at the Following Times
Bus Name Pre Fault Initial Peak Short 0.5 Cycle 1 Cycle 3 Cycle 5 cycle Std
Voltage in Symmetrical Circuit Current Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical
Volts SC Current in in Amps SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in
Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps
GRID 66000 26243 74227 26243 26243 26243 26243 26243
11kV BD_66kV SS 11000 4381 11490 4381 4381 4381 4381 4381
11kV BD SS1 11000 4368 11441 4368 4368 4368 4368 4368
11kV BD SS2 11000 4368 11441 4368 4368 4368 4368 4368
MCC-1 415 38865 98934 38865 38865 38865 38865 38865
MCC-2 415 38865 98934 38865 38865 38865 38865 38865
MCC-3 415 38865 98934 38865 38865 38865 38865 38865
MCC-4 415 38865 98934 38865 38865 38865 38865 38865
DRIVE PNL-1 415 35376 61658 35376 35376 35376 35376 35376
DRIVE PNL-2 415 35376 61658 35376 35376 35376 35376 35376
LL Fault - IEC60909 Method at the Following Times
Bus Name Pre Fault Initial Peak Short 0.5 Cycle 1 Cycle 3 Cycle 5 cycle Std
Voltage in Symmetrical Circuit Current Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical
Volts SC Current in in Amps SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in
Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps
GRID 66000 26243 74227 26243 26243 26243 26243 26243
11kV BD_66kV SS 11000 3808 9983 3808 3808 3808 3808 3808
11kV BD SS1 11000 3797 9940 3797 3797 3797 3797 3797
11kV BD SS2 11000 3797 9940 3797 3797 3797 3797 3797
MCC-1 415 33698 85781 33698 33698 33698 33698 33698
MCC-2 415 33698 85781 33698 33698 33698 33698 33698
MCC-3 415 33698 85781 33698 33698 33698 33698 33698
MCC-4 415 33698 85781 33698 33698 33698 33698 33698
DRIVE PNL-1 415 30662 53430 30662 30662 30662 30662 30662
DRIVE PNL-2 415 30662 53430 30662 30662 30662 30662 30662
LG Fault - IEC60909 Method at the Following Times
Bus Name Pre Fault Initial Peak Short 0.5 Cycle 1 Cycle 3 Cycle 5 cycle Std
Voltage in Symmetrical Circuit Current Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical
Volts SC Current in in Amps SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in
Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps
GRID 66000 26243 74227 26243 26243 26243 26243 26243
11kV BD_66kV SS 11000 5516 14451 5516 5516 5516 5516 5516
11kV BD SS1 11000 5496 14376 5496 5496 5496 5496 5496
11kV BD SS2 11000 5491 14360 5491 5491 5491 5491 5491
DRIVE PNL-1 415 40147 72960 40147 40147 40147 40147 40147
MCC-1 415 38448 89623 38448 38448 38448 38448 38448
MCC-2 415 38448 89623 38448 38448 38448 38448 38448
MCC-3 415 38448 89623 38448 38448 38448 38448 38448
MCC-4 415 38448 89623 38448 38448 38448 38448 38448
DRIVE PNL-2 415 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
LLG Fault - IEC60909 Method at the Following Times
Bus Name Pre Fault Initial Peak Short 0.5 Cycle 1 Cycle 3 Cycle 5 cycle Std
Voltage in Symmetrical Circuit Current Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical Symmetrical
Volts SC Current in in Amps SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in SC Current in
Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps Amps
GRID 66000 27206 76952 27206 27206 27206 27206 27206
11kV BD_66kV SS 11000 5299 13887 5299 5299 5299 5299 5299
11kV BD SS1 11000 5278 13811 5278 5278 5278 5278 5278
11kV BD SS2 11000 5273 13795 5273 5273 5273 5273 5273
DRIVE PNL-1 415 42797 76615 42797 42797 42797 42797 42797
MCC-1 415 41547 101717 41547 41547 41547 41547 41547
MCC-2 415 41547 101717 41547 41547 41547 41547 41547
MCC-3 415 41547 101717 41547 41547 41547 41547 41547
MCC-4 415 41547 101717 41547 41547 41547 41547 41547
DRIVE PNL-2 415 30662 53430 30662 30662 30662 30662 30662
Setting Calculation for Power Transformer
66 kV 11kV
CTHV:75/1 CTLV:400/1
7.5 MVA
Transformer capacity PT 7500 kVA
Primary Voltage Vp 66 kV
Secondary Voltage Vs 11 kV
Transformer HV side CT details CTHV 75/1
Turns Ratio CTR1 75
Transformer LV side CT details CTLV 400/1
Turns Ratio 400
Percentage Impedance of Transformer Z 8.70%
Fault Current at 66 kV Bus 13120 A
Fault current at 11 kV Bus as per report 4263.00 A
Transformer Full Load HV side Primary Current at 0% tapping Ipfl 7500X 1000 )/ (1.732 Amps
X66x1000x1)
Transformer Full Load HV side Primary Current at -0% tapping 65.61 Amps
65.61 Amps
Transformer HV side CT Secondary Full Load Current Isfl 0.87
Measuring Tolerence 10.00 %
Transformer HV side Primary current setting 65.61x 1.10 Amps
IDMT setting at 66 kV side 72.17
CT secondary Current to the above 0.96
Setting proposed Ip 1
Curve Normal Inverse
Transformer Full Load LV side Primary Current Ipfl 7500 X 1000 )/ (1.732 Amps
X11x1000)
393.66 Amps
Measuring Tolerence 10.00 %
Transformer LV side Primary current setting 393.66*1.10 Amps
433.03
Transformer LV side CT Secondary Current setting 1.08
Setting proposed Ip 1.1
Curve Extreme Inverse
Fault current at 11 kV Bus as per report 4263.00 Amps
LV side CT current due to above fault current 10.66 Amps
HV side current due to fault at 11 kV bus 710.50 Amps
HV side CT Secondary current due to fault at 11 kV bus 9.47 Amps
HV side CT current due to fault at Transformer HV side 174.93 Amps
Setting proposed on HV side relay I>> 12.32 X In
Setting proposed on LV side relay I>> 9 x In
Setting Calculation for Transformer 2,3,4&5
11 kV 0.433kV
200/1 ACB:5000 A
3 MVA
Transformer capacity PT 3000 kVA
Primary Voltage Vp 11 kV
Secondary Voltage Vs 0.433 kV
Transformer HV side CT details CTHV 200/1
Turns Ratio CTR1 200
Transformer LV side ACB RATING 5000 A
Percentage Impedance of Transformer Z 7.50%
Fault Current at 11 kV Bus 4251 A
Fault current at 0.415kV Bus as per report 38524.00 A
Transformer Full Load HV side Primary Current at 0% tapping Ipfl 3000X 1000 )/ (1.732 Amps
X11x1000x1)
Transformer Full Load HV side Primary Current at -0% tapping 157.46 Amps
Relay reset ratio 0.95
Measuring Tolerence 10.00 %
Transformer HV side Primary current setting 157.46x 1.10/0.95 Amps
IDMT setting at 110 kV side 182.33
CT secondary Current to the above 0.91
Setting proposed Ip 1
Curve Extreme Inverse
Transformer Full Load LV side Primary Current Ipfl 3000 X 1000 )/ (1.732 Amps
X415)
4000.23 Amps
Relay reset ratio 0.95
Measuring Tolerence 10.00 %
Transformer LV side Primary current setting 4000.24*1.10/0.95 Amps
4631.85
Transformer LV side ACB Current setting 0.93
IDMT setting at 415V side 0.9
0.9
Fault current at 0.415 kV Bus as per report 38524.00 Amps
HV side current due to fault at 0.415 kV bus 1516.44 Amps
HV side CT Secondary current due to fault at 0.415 kV bus 7.58 Amps
Setting proposed for high set on HV side 9.86 Amps
Setting proposed on HV side relay I>> 10.00 X In
Setting proposed on LV side relay I>> 4 x In
Calculation for the Value of Stabilizing Resistor- TR for 11 kV side
Setting:
The setting volatge may be determined by:
VS = IF/n [Rct + 2RL + Ra ]
VS = Setting Voltage
IS = Setting Current
IF = Fault level in CT Primary
n = CT Ratio
Rct = Resistance of CT at operating temperature
RL = Lead resistance at operating temperature
Ra = Additional resistance due to relay,contact/connection resistance etc at operating temperature
The Full CT requirement is therefore : Class X, ratio N,CT resistance Rct and knee point voltage > 2 x Vs
11 kV side
Transformer Details
TRF Capacity = 7500 kVA
TRF Primary = 66000 volts
TRF Secondary = 11000 volts
CT Primary(n) 400 Amps
CT Secondary = 1 amps
TRF Impedance = 8.7 %
n = 400
CT Secondary wiring Length = 50 met
CT Secondary wiring size = 4 Sq.mm
Resistance of conductor = 4.61 ohms per km
CT resistance(RCT) = 5 ohms
CT magnitization current(Im) = 4 mA
Fault level in CT Primary: Not taking source fault into account 4524.82 Amps
66 kV side
Transformer Details
TRF Capacity = 7500 kVA
TRF Primary = 66000 volts
TRF Secondary = 11000 volts
CT Primary(n) 75 Amps
CT Secondary = 1 amps
TRF Impedance = 8.7 %
n = 75
CT Secondary wiring Length = 50 met
CT Secondary wiring size = 4 Sq.mm
Resistance of conductor = 4.61 ohms per km
CT resistance(RCT) = 5 ohms
CT magnitization current(Im) = 4 mA
Fault level in CT Primary: Not taking source fault into account 754.14 Amps
IF Secondary = 10.06 Amps
RL= CT Secondary wiring Length x Resistance of Conductor per meter 0.2305 ohms
Additional Resistance: Ra=0.01 ohms 0.01
Vs=If/n (Rct+2RL+Ra) 55.01 volts
Knee point voltage must be in excess of 2 x Vs 110.02 volts
V kn 110.02 volts
10% Percent setting
Required Loop Resistance value
Rs=Vs/Is
Is=10 % 10
Is= 0.1 Amps 0.1 Amps
Vs= 55.01 volts
Rs= 550.12 ohms
Relay VA burden= VA 1
2 1 ohms
Relay resistance= VA/Is
Rstab=Rs-Relay resistance 549.12 Ohms
rounded off to 550 ohms
SIEMENS INDIA LTD
CAMERICH PAPER PRIVATE LTD
ooooo o
o
$
)
)))
))
))
)
))
))
))
))))
)))
)
$))$))) )))
)
)
)
))
)))
))$
))$
)))))
))))
$
)))
)))
) )
)
)))
)))*
))
))
)
)
))