Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2019 Utility Solar Energy Market Snapshot in The US (SEIA) - Energy Transition in Rooftop Solar
2019 Utility Solar Energy Market Snapshot in The US (SEIA) - Energy Transition in Rooftop Solar
Solar Market
Snapshot
JUNE 2019
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT
TABLE OF CONTENTS
BACKGROUND.................................................................................................................................................................5 SOLAR CUSTOMER PROGRAMS............................................................................................................................. 20
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY...................................................................................................................................................6 COMMUNITY SOLAR POLICIES................................................................................................................................ 21
§§ National Market......................................................................................................................................................6 §§ Encouraging Low-Income Customer Participation................................................................................. 21
§§ Industry Trends ......................................................................................................................................................6 PURPA IMPLEMENTATION RULES......................................................................................................................... 22
§§ Flexible Solar............................................................................................................................................................6 NET METERING SUCCESSOR TARIFFS................................................................................................................... 23
SEPA’S SOLAR TOP 10 UTILITY RANKINGS.............................................................................................................7 FLEXIBLE SOLAR........................................................................................................................................................... 24
NATIONAL SOLAR MARKET.........................................................................................................................................8 §§ Advanced Inverter Functionality.................................................................................................................... 25
RESIDENTIAL SOLAR MARKET....................................................................................................................................9 §§ Smart Contracts and Programs..................................................................................................................... 26
§§ Markets Driving Residential Solar................................................................................................................. 10 §§ Solar Plus Storage............................................................................................................................................... 27
NON-RESIDENTIAL SOLAR MARKET...................................................................................................................... 11 APPENDIX A: 2018 SOLAR CAPACITY BY STATE AND SELECT TERRITORIES (MW-AC)......................... 28
§§ Corporate Renewables on the Rise.............................................................................................................. 12 APPENDIX B: TOP 10................................................................................................................................................... 29
UTILITY-SUPPLY SOLAR MARKET............................................................................................................................ 13 APPENDIX C: SURVEY PARTICIPANTS.................................................................................................................... 31
UTILITY-SUPPLY SOLAR SHINES IN NEW MARKETS......................................................................................... 14 §§ Federal/Generation & Transmission Utilities............................................................................................ 31
§§ State Spotlight: The Sunshine State.............................................................................................................. 15 §§ Distribution Utilities............................................................................................................................................ 31
SOLAR MARKETS BY UTILITY TYPE ........................................................................................................................ 16
§§ Investor-Owned Utilities................................................................................................................................... 17
§§ Cooperative Utilities........................................................................................................................................... 18
§§ Public Power Utilities......................................................................................................................................... 19
LIST OF TABLES
TABLE 1: TOP 10 UTILITIES BY ANNUAL SOLAR CAPACITY (MW-AC)............................................................7 TABLE 7: SOLAR CAPACITY BY STATE AND TERRITORY.................................................................................. 28
TABLE 2: TOP 10 UTILITIES BY ANNUAL SOLAR W/C-AC...................................................................................7 TABLE 8: TOP 10 UTILITIES BY ANNUAL SOLAR CAPACITY (MW-AC)......................................................... 29
TABLE 3: ANNUAL RESIDENTIAL SOLAR DEPLOYMENT BY DEPLOYMENT TYPE (MW-AC) .................9 TABLE 9: TOP 10 UTILITIES BY ANNUAL SOLAR W/C-AC................................................................................ 29
TABLE 4: ANNUAL NON-RESIDENTIAL SOLAR DEPLOYMENT BY DEPLOYMENT TYPE (MW-AC)..... 11 TABLE 10: TOP UTILITIES BY CUMULATIVE SOLAR CAPACITY (MW).......................................................... 30
TABLE 5: ANNUAL UTILITY-SUPPLY SOLAR DEPLOYMENT BY DEPLOYMENT TYPE (MW-AC).......... 13 TABLE 11: TOP 10 UTILITIES BY CUMULATIVE W/C......................................................................................... 30
TABLE 6: LOW-INCOME COMMUNITY SOLAR PROVISIONS......................................................................... 21
LIST OF FIGURES
FIGURE 1: 2018 ANNUAL SOLAR CAPACITY (MW-AC)........................................................................................6 FIGURE 15: 2018 ANNUAL COOPERATIVE CAPACITY (MW-AC).................................................................... 18
FIGURE 2: 2008-2018 ANNUAL SOLAR CAPACITY ADDED BY SECTOR (MW-AC)......................................8 FIGURE 16: 2015-2018 ANNUAL COOPERATIVE CAPACITY BY SECTOR................................................... 18
FIGURE 3: 2018 ANNUAL RESIDENTIAL CAPACITY (MW-AC)............................................................................9 FIGURE 17: 2018 ANNUAL PUBLIC POWER CAPACITY (MW-AC) ................................................................ 19
FIGURE 4: TOP UTILITIES BY CUMULATIVE RESIDENTIAL CAPACITY (MW-AC)..........................................9 FIGURE 18: 2015-2018 ANNUAL PUBLIC POWER CAPACITY BY SECTOR................................................. 19
FIGURE 5: 2015 - 2018 RESIDENTIAL CUSTOMER ACCOUNT SOLAR PENETRATION........................... 10 FIGURE 19: 2018 UTILITY RESIDENTIAL VS. NON-RESIDENTIAL CUSTOMER
FIGURE 6: 2018 ANNUAL NON-RESIDENTIAL CAPACITY (MW-AC)............................................................. 11 PROGRAM COMPARISON......................................................................................................................................... 20
FIGURE 7: TOP UTILITIES BY CUMULATIVE NON-RESIDENTIAL CAPACITY (MW-AC)............................ 11 FIGURE 20: STATE COMMUNITY SOLAR POLICIES........................................................................................... 21
FIGURE 8: 2018 ANNUAL UTILITY-SUPPLY CAPACITY (MW-AC)................................................................... 13 FIGURE 21: STATES CONSIDERING CHANGES TO PURPA IMPLEMENTATION....................................... 22
FIGURE 9: TOP UTILITIES BY CUMULATIVE UTILITY-SUPPLY CAPACITY (MW-AC) ................................ 13 FIGURE 22: 2018 CUMULATIVE CAPACITY (MW-AC)........................................................................................ 24
FIGURE 10: NEW UTILITY-SUPPLY MARKETS BY CAPACITY (MW-AC)......................................................... 14 FIGURE 23: 2018 UTILITY INTEREST IN ADVANCED INVERTER FUNCTIONALITIES............................... 25
FIGURE 11: INVESTOR-OWNED ELECTRIC UTILITIES: APPROXIMATE FIGURE 24: POTENTIAL ANCILLARY SERVICES CREATED BY RENEWABLE
SERVICE TERRITORIES................................................................................................................................................ 15 DISPATCHABLE GENERATION................................................................................................................................. 26
FIGURE 12: 2015-2018 ANNUAL CAPACITY BREAKDOWN............................................................................ 16 FIGURE 25: 2018 UTILITY RESIDENTIAL VS. NON-RESIDENTIAL SOLAR+STORAGE
TRENDS COMPARISON.............................................................................................................................................. 27
FIGURE 13: 2018 ANNUAL IOU CAPACITY (MW-AC)........................................................................................ 17
FIGURE 14: 2015-2018 ANNUAL IOU CAPACITY BY SECTOR........................................................................ 17
Background
The Smart Electric Power Alliance (SEPA) began surveying electric utilities annually SEPA reports solar data in AC format as it is a more accurate accounting of the
in 2007 to track the capacity of interconnected solar power. The yearly survey and amount of solar that is interconnected to the grid. At times, SEPA collected data
subsequent Snapshot reports provide critical insights into the U.S. solar market, is submitted as raw data in direct current (DC). In those cases SEPA derates3 the
with a particular focus on utility-scale development. capacity to AC format to track the actual solar capacity injected to the grid.
The 2019 Utility Solar Market Snapshot results are based on data reported from For purposes of analysis, SEPA has aggregated or supplemented survey data with
participating utilities. The participating utilities represent slightly more than additional information to fine tune accuracy. These sources include cumulative
108 million customer accounts, or approximately 74% of all customer accounts net metering data from Form 861 and 861M from the U.S. Energy Information
throughout the United States and 71% of all MWhs sold in 2018.1 Administration (EIA), solar project level data from EIA’s Form 860 and 860M, and
information from our data provider Energy Acuity. SEPA has verified the accuracy of
SURVEY METHODOLOGY AND SCOPE survey information through contacts at utilities, previous data submissions, and
SEPA conducted its annual Utility Survey between January and March 2019, using an external sources.
online survey platform. More than 500 participating utilities2 throughout the United
States and its territories provided data on solar installations either interconnected
to their systems or procured under power purchase agreements (PPAs) between
January 1 and December 31, 2018.
SEPA encouraged participation through direct outreach to key contacts at utilities,
and through partner organizations’ listservs and newsletters. Utilities with service
territories in multiple states reported data from each state separately.
Unless explicitly stated, all solar data in this document is reported in watts (W),
kilowatts (kW), megawatts (MW), and gigawatts (GW) of alternating current (AC).
FLEXIBLE SOLAR
ALASKA HAWAII DISTRICT OF AMERICAN GUAM PUERTO RICO &
COLUMBIA SAMOA U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS nnSolar has established itself as a mainstream generation technology, and grid
Source: Smart Electric Power Alliance, 2019 operators are beginning to tap into expanded capabilities. Solar can be operated
as a flexible resource through three approaches: Advanced Inverter Functionality,
Smart Contracts, and Solar Plus Storage (see pages 24 - 27).
MW = Megawatts-ac
SEPA | 2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT 6
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT
TABLE 1: TOP 10 UTILITIES BY ANNUAL SOLAR CAPACITY (MW-AC) TABLE 2: TOP 10 UTILITIES BY ANNUAL SOLAR W/C-AC
1 PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC California 630.0 1 REEDY CREEK IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT Florida 35,936.4
2 FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY Florida 626.8 2 GEORGETOWN UTILITY SYSTEMS Texas 6,048.7
3 SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON California 440.7 3 VILLAGE ELECTRIC UTILITY - BREWSTER Ohio 1,980.9
4 DUKE ENERGY PROGRESS North Carolina 436.3 4 DOMINION ENERGY NORTH CAROLINA North Carolina 1,768.2
5 NORTHERN STATES POWER MINNESOTA (XCEL) Minnesota 269.4 5 BOLIVAR ENERGY AUTHORITY Tennessee 1,482.8
6 DOMINION ENERGY NORTH CAROLINA North Carolina 213.1 6 MIDDLETON ELECTRIC LIGHT DEPARTMENT Massachusetts 1,358.9
7 AUSTIN ENERGY Texas 192.9 7 CHICKASAW ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE, INC. Tennessee 829.1
8 SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC California 185.3 8 KAUA'I ISLAND UTILITY COOPERATIVE Hawaii 637.9
9 TAMPA ELECTRIC COMPANY Florida 155.1 9 DENTON MUNICIPAL ELECTRIC Texas 595.3
Source: Smart Electric Power Alliance, 2019. Source: Smart Electric Power Alliance, 2019.
MW = Megawatts-ac
SEPA | 2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT 7
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT
MARKETS DRIVING RESIDENTIAL SOLAR FIGURE 5: 2015 - 2018 RESIDENTIAL CUSTOMER ACCOUNT SOLAR PENETRATION
First adopter markets have begun to mature, reaching significant levels of
penetration in some utility service territories. Given these maturing markets, 20%
emerging markets will be essential for continued market growth of the residential
sector.
In 2018, San Diego Gas and Electric (SDG&E), Southern California Edison (SCE), and 15
Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) deployed 740.6 MW of residential solar, representing
39.1% of all residential solar deployed in 2018. Over the last three years, these
three utilities and Arizona Public Service are the only utilities nationwide that have
interconnected more than 100 MW of residential solar energy to the grid each year. 10
California was not the only sustained residential market seen in 2018. In Hawaii,
continued residential deployment by Hawaiian Electric Company resulted in
penetrations reaching 18.9% of its residential customer accounts.
5
United Power (CO) led all cooperatives with 5.9 MW of residential solar installed in
2018, bringing its total residential solar deployed since 2015 to 15.5 MW, and reaching
residential penetration of 4.4%.
0
2015 2016 2017 2018
EMERGING RESIDENTIAL MARKETS
ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE HAWAII ELECTRIC LIGHT COMPANY HAWAIIAN ELECTRIC
nnFlorida interconnected 85.8 MW of residential solar in 2018, a 56.9% increase PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC KAUAI ISLAND UTILITY COOPERATIVE
over 2017. Since 2016, the state has interconnected 176 MW of residential solar, UNITED POWER, INC
representing 76.1% of Florida’s cumulative residential solar capacity. Source: Smart Electric Power Alliance, 2019
HIGHLIGHTS
500
373.9
438.0
202.7
259.8
128.8
0 77.2
OREGON SOUTH CAROLINA MINNESOTA TEXAS FLORIDA
UTILITY-SUPPLY CAPACITY ADDED IN 2018 CUMULATIVE UTILITY-SUPPLY CAPACITY
MW = Megawatts-ac
SEPA | 2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT 14
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT
STATE SPOTLIGHT: THE SUNSHINE STATE FIGURE 11: INVESTOR-OWNED ELECTRIC UTILITIES: APPROXIMATE SERVICE TERRITORIES
In the state of Florida, 876.2 MW of utility-supply solar were interconnected in
2018—a more than 200% increase in Florida’s total installed utility-supply capacity
from 2017. Florida Power and Light, Tampa Electric Company and Duke Energy Florida
are all actively deploying and planning for large utility-supply solar projects
to economically meet future generation needs as a result of falling PV prices.
nnFlorida Power & Light Company interconnected 597.5 MW of utility-owned solar in
2018, with an additional 298 MW planned for interconnection in 2019. FPL expects
more than 4 GW of solar coming online by the end of 2027.10
nnTampa Electric Company interconnected 144.8 MW of utility-owned solar in 2018,
and expects to add 600 MW of utility-scale solar by 2020.11
nnDuke Energy Florida interconnected 74.9 MW of utility-owned solar in 2018 and has FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY
committed to adding 700 MW of utility-supply solar by 2023.12 TAMPA ELECTRIC COMPANY
DUKE ENERGY FLORIDA
PUBLIC POWER UTILITIES
GULF POWER COMPANY
Orlando Utilities Commission and the Florida Municipal Power Agency (FMPA) are FLORIDA PUBLIC UTILITIES CORPORATION
partnering on the construction of three 74.5 MW solar farms that will be operational
in mid-2020 and will provide cost-effective renewable energy to their customers.13
10 “Ten Year Power Plant Site Plan 2018-2027”. FPL, 2018. https://www.fpl.com/company/pdf/10-year-site-plan.pdf Source: Florida Public Service Commission
11 “Tampa Electric Company Ten Year Site Plan” .TECO, 2018. http://www.psc.state.fl.us/Files/PDF/Utilities/Electricgas/
TenYearSitePlans/2018/Tampa%20Electric%20Company.pdf
12 Duke Energy Florida LLC Ten Year Site Plan”. DEF, 2018. http://www.psc.state.fl.us/Files/PDF/Utilities/Electricgas/TenYearSitePlans/2018/Duke%20Energy%20Florida.pdf
13 “2019 Orlando Utilities Commission Ten-Year Site Plan”. OUC, 2019: 2-7. http://www.psc.state.fl.us/Files/PDF/Utilities/Electricgas/TenYearSitePlans/2019/Orlando%20Utilities%20Commission.pdf
MW = Megawatts-ac
SEPA | 2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT 15
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT
continued to experience
the largest capacity growth
In Texas, public power utilities Austin Energy and
4,000 in Texas, which accounted
Georgetown Utility Systems ranked in SEPA’s Top
for 50% of municipal solar
10 list for annual solar capacity. Between the two
capacity interconnected to the
utilities, 346.9 MW were interconnected to the grid
2,000 grid in 2018.
in 2018, accounting for 68.1% of the solar capacity
added throughout the entire state.
0
2015 2016 2017 2018
INVESTOR OWNED UTILITY SUPPLY INVESTOR OWNED NON-RESIDENTIAL INVESTOR OWNED RESIDENTIAL
COOPERATIVE UTILITY SUPPLY COOPERATIVE NON-RESIDENTIAL COOPERATIVE RESIDENTIAL
MUNICIPAL UTILITY SUPPLY MUNICIPAL NON-RESIDENTIAL MUNICIPAL RESIDENTIAL
MW = Megawatts-ac
SEPA | 2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT 16
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT
INVESTOR-OWNED UTILITIES
FIGURE 13: 2018 ANNUAL IOU CAPACITY (MW-AC) FIGURE 14: 2015-2018 ANNUAL IOU CAPACITY BY SECTOR
MEGAWATT-AC
5,000 UTILITY SUPPLY
4,000 NON-RESIDENTIAL
1, ME RESIDENTIAL
62 T E N 3,000
8. RE E T
7
M D: 2,000
W
RE 1,000
S
1, IDE :
66 N PPA 11 MW 0
5. T I
1 AL 2, 4 2015 2016 2017 2018
M :
W Source: Smart Electric Power Alliance, 2019
MERCHANT POWER:
163.4 MW
COOPERATIVE UTILITIES
FIGURE 15: 2018 ANNUAL COOPERATIVE CAPACITY (MW-AC) FIGURE 16: 2015-2018 ANNUAL COOPERATIVE CAPACITY BY SECTOR
MEGAWATT-AC
UTILITY SUPPLY
250
NON-RESIDENTIAL
200
M RESIDENTIAL
E N 150
32 TER ET
.1 ED
M : 100
W
RE 50
SI :
DE PPA 0 MW 0
3 4 NT 4 6. 2015 2016 2017 2018
.0 I A
M L: Source: Smart Electric Power Alliance, 2019
W
UPPLY:
TOTAL:
UTILIT Y S 2018 was a slow year for cooperative solar
58.0 MW CUMULATIVE CAPACITY:
127.5 MW 1,112.9 MW deployment, compared with 2017. However,
UTILITY-OWNED:
Hawaii and Texas continue to lead cooperative
2.5 MW nnResidential: 364.2 MW solar deployment in terms of capacity. In Hawaii,
35 N T I A N -
MWL:
U T NE W
SO
MERCHANT
W
OW.0 M
I L I D:
POWER:
TY
0.0 MW
-
NET
METERED:
9.0 MW
UTILITY-OWNED: 2,000
1.2 MW
35.2 MW
TARIFF:
SOL A R
1,500
MEGAWATT-AC
UTILITY SUPPLY
NON-RESIDENTIAL
1,000
RESIDENTIAL
M 79
E T .8
1
N D:
ER MW
ET
E
500
RE
SI 16
DE . 2
0
2
Solar Customer Programs FIGURE 19: 2018 UTILITY RESIDENTIAL VS. NON-RESIDENTIAL CUSTOMER PROGRAM
COMPARISON
Customer programs remain an ideal way for utilities to engage with their customers 100%
and offer them the opportunity to invest in solar. Across the country, utilities are
pursuing these programs and according to the over 140 respondents to our customer
80
programs section, utilities are more interested in encouraging both residential and
non-residential solar adoption through solar incentives, green tariffs, and community
solar programs. 60
RESIDENTIAL
RESIDENTIAL
RESIDENTIAL
RESIDENTIAL
RESIDENTIAL
RESIDENTIAL
NON-RESIDENTIAL
NON-RESIDENTIAL
NON-RESIDENTIAL
NON-RESIDENTIAL
NON-RESIDENTIAL
improve the accessibility of solar to lower-income households through attractive
financing.14, 15
NC CLEAN ENERGY
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT TECHNOLOGY CENTER
10% of program capacity and 10% of each project’s capacity are reserved for
CONNECTICUT
low-income customers or service organizations
NC CLEAN ENERGY
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT TECHNOLOGY CENTER
NC CLEAN ENERGY
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT TECHNOLOGY CENTER
MW = Megawatts-ac
SEPA | 2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT 23
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT
Flexible Solar
In 2018, solar was again among the top three most deployed generating resources
in the country.17 As the cost of solar PV technology continues to decline, continued FIGURE 22: 2018 CUMULATIVE CAPACITY (MW-AC)
growth of both national and regional solar markets is expected, especially as states,
municipalities, utilities and corporations use solar to meet increasingly aggressive
decarbonization goals.
However, as solar PV only generates power when the sun shines, it is not a perfect
generating resource. Despite the inherent intermittency, with the appropriate MEGAWATTS
communications, solar PV can be operated as a dispatchable resource because 21,000+
it is an inverter-based generating resource. In other words, solar PV is capable of 1,600-3,999
altering the amount and type of electricity that it is interjecting to the grid almost 800-1,599
instantaneously—even allowing the resource to provide ancillary services to the grid. 400-799
As higher penetrations of solar are achieved, grid operators will find that solar’s value 100-399
substantially increases if it is dispatchable. 0.1-99
0
Flexible solar can be achieved through three main approaches:
nnAdvanced Inverter Functionality
nnSmart Contracts
nnSolar Plus Storage
17 “Preliminary Monthly Electric Generator Inventory” U.S. Energy Information Administration, 2019. https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/eia860m/
MW = Megawatts-ac
SEPA | 2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT 24
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT
20
18 “Unlocking Advanced Inverter Functionality: Roadmap to a future of utility engagement and ownership”. SEPA, 2014. https://
sepapower.org/resource/unlocking-advanced-inverter-functionality
19 “Owning and Leveraging Advanced Inverters.” SEPA, 2014. https://sepapower.org/media-item/owning-and-leveraging-advanced-
0 inverters/
RAMP RATE EXPANDED RANDOMIZED CURTAILMENT VOLTAGE 20 “IEEE 1547-2018-IEEE Standard for Interconnection and Interoperability of Distributed Energy Resources with Associated Electric
CONTROL FREQUENCY RECONNECT SUPPORT Power Systems Interfaces”. IEEE, 2018. https://standards.ieee.org/standard/1547-2018.html
AND VOLTAGE
RIDE THROUGH 21 “Rule 21 Interconnection”. CPUC, 2019. http://www.cpuc.ca.gov/Rule21/
FULLY IMPLEMENTED PILOTING PLANNING INTERESTED NO INTEREST 22 “Customer Renewable Programs: Standard Interconnection Agreement”. Hawaiian Electric Company, 2019. https://www.
hawaiianelectric.com/products-and-services/customer-renewable-programs/standard-interconnection
Source: Smart Electric Power Alliance, 2019. N = 156 23 “The Value of Dispatchability: Unleashing Grid Flexible Solar”. SEPA, 2019. https://sepapower.org/media-item/the-value-of-.
dispatchability-unleashing-grid-flexible-solar/
MW = Megawatts-ac
SEPA | 2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT 25
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT
PRODUCTION (KW)
customers at a fixed rate for exported solar power, incentivizing the consumption
4,000
of power generated on-site. A second iteration of the grid-supply option is the
Customer Grid Supply+ Program (CGS+) program.24 Under this program, new
3,000
solar PV customers install a system on-site that will only export energy to the grid.
Customers are credited annually with export credits while the utility has the ability 2,000
to operate and dispatch those systems, taking advantage of advanced inverter
functionality, to optimize the grid. 1,000
Utility-scale: For most solar power purchase agreements, curtailment is an inherent
risk. However, contracts can be designed to mitigate that risk. This is emerging in 0
HE1
HE2
HE3
HE4
HE19
HE5
HE6
HE20
HE21
HE7
HE8
HE9
HE10
HE11
HE12
HE13
HE14
HE15
HE16
HE17
HE18
HE22
HE23
HE24
regions with higher solar penetration. SEPA’s 2016 report, Proactive Solutions to
Curtailment Risks, discussed potential contract structures including energy and HOURS
capacity PPAs, time-of-day price caps, and a dispatchable contract that SPINNING RESERVES POTENTIAL PRODUCTION SIGNALED PRODUCTION
can be used for spinning reserves.25 Dispatchable contracts are depicted in Figure 24. Source: SEPA & ScottMadden, 2016
24 “Smart Export Program”. State of Hawaii Public Utilities Commission, 2017. https://puc.hawaii.gov/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Hawaii_PUC_Smart-Export_CGS_Fact_Sheets_FINAL.pdf
25 “Proactive Solutions to Curtailment Risks”. SEPA and ScottMadden, 2016 https://sepapower.org/resource/proactive-solutions-curtailment-risks-identifying-new-contract-structures-utility-scale-renewables/
MW = Megawatts-ac
SEPA | 2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT 26
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT
SOLAR PLUS STORAGE FIGURE 25: 2018 UTILITY RESIDENTIAL VS. NON-RESIDENTIAL SOLAR+STORAGE TRENDS
COMPARISON
The third way of making solar flexible is to co-locate it with an inherently flexible
100
resource such as energy storage. The emerging trend of solar + storage was captured
in SEPA’s 2018 Utility Energy Storage Market Snapshot,26 which documented 80
capabilities, use cases and flagship deployments. The coupling of solar and storage FULLY IMPLEMENTED
is an ideal match. 60 PILOTING
PLANNING
Customer-sited: The second offer for new solar PV customers in Hawaii, after the 40 INTERESTED
2015 changes,27 was self supply. This option credited solar PV customers nothing for NO INTEREST
20
exporting solar to the grid, requiring a solar + storage system to be financially viable.
The second iteration of this program was the Smart Export program28 launched in 0
RESIDENTIAL NON-RESIDENTIAL
2017. The program requires a solar + storage system and takes the self-supply concept
Source: Smart Electric Power Alliance, 2019. N = 157
a step further. Customers receive a fixed credit for energy exported outside the 9am
to 4pm window and receive no credits for energy exported within that window.
SOLAR PLUS PUMPED HYDROPOWER ENERGY STORAGE
Utility-scale: Earlier in 2018, Hawaiian Electric Companies (HECO) announced the
approval29 of six solar-plus-battery storage projects that will provide 247 MW of solar In an effort to meet its aggressive renewable energy goals, Kauai Island Utility
and 1 GWh of battery storage. Like Kauai Island Utility Cooperative’s solar + storage Cooperative (KIUC), has deployed a number of energy storage technologies to make
projects (see callout box), each HECO system has roughly a 1:1 ratio of battery solar dispatchable—most notably its solar + battery storage systems. In 2018, the
storage energy capacity (MWh) to solar generation, making the solar generation utility executed a contract for the design, engineering, and construction of a solar
fully dispatchable. plus pumped hydropower project that will use solar energy to pump water up to
Utilities are taking notice of the potential for solar + storage programs to align a reservoir during the day and release it through a turbine when power is needed.
customer investment in DERs with grid needs. The project alone is expected to provide 15% of the island’s energy needs.
2018 ANNUAL 2018 CUMULATIVE 2018 ANNUAL 2018 CUMULATIVE 2018 ANNUAL 2018 CUMULATIVE
STATES STATES STATES
CAPACITY CAPACITY CAPACITY CAPACITY CAPACITY CAPACITY
Appendix B: Top 10
TABLE 8: TOP 10 UTILITIES BY ANNUAL SOLAR CAPACITY (MW-AC) TABLE 9: TOP 10 UTILITIES BY ANNUAL SOLAR W/C-AC
1 PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC California 630.0 1 REEDY CREEK IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT Florida 35,936.4
2 FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT CO. Florida 626.8 2 GEORGETOWN UTILITY SYSTEMS Texas 6,048.7
3 SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON California 440.7 3 VILLAGE ELECTRIC UTILITY - BREWSTER Ohio 1,980.9
4 DUKE ENERGY PROGRESS North Carolina 436.3 4 DOMINION ENERGY NORTH CAROLINA North Carolina 1,768.2
5 NORTHERN STATES POWER MINNESOTA (XCEL) Minnesota 269.4 5 BOLIVAR ENERGY AUTHORITY Tennessee 1,482.8
6 DOMINION ENERGY NORTH CAROLINA North Carolina 213.1 6 MIDDLETON ELECTRIC LIGHT DEPARTMENT Massachusetts 1,358.9
7 AUSTIN ENERGY Texas 192.9 7 CHICKASAW ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE, INC. Tennessee 829.1
8 SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC California 185.3 8 KAUA’I ISLAND UTILITY COOPERATIVE Hawaii 637.9
9 TAMPA ELECTRIC COMPANY Florida 155.1 9 DENTON MUNICIPAL ELECTRIC Texas 595.3
Source: Smart Electric Power Alliance, 2019. Source: Smart Electric Power Alliance, 2019.
MW = Megawatts-ac
SEPA | 2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT 29
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT
TABLE 10: TOP UTILITIES BY CUMULATIVE SOLAR CAPACITY (MW) TABLE 11: TOP 10 UTILITIES BY CUMULATIVE W/C
1 SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON California 7,786.1 1 REEDY CREEK IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT Florida 35,936.4
2 PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC California 7,648.0 2 DOMINION ENERGY NORTH CAROLINA North Carolina 7,126.3
3 SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC California 2,329.4 3 GEORGETOWN UTILITY SYSTEMS Texas 6,048.7
4 DUKE ENERGY PROGRESS North Carolina 2,324.0 4 VILLAGE ELECTRIC UTILITY - BREWSTER Ohio 2,881.4
5 LOS ANGELES DEPT OF WATER AND POWER California 1,371.6 5 KAUA’I ISLAND UTILITY COOPERATIVE Hawaii 2,876.1
6 ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE Arizona 1,355.2 6 PICKWICK ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE Tennessee 2,783.8
8 PUBLIC SERVICE ELECTRIC & GAS New Jersey 1,088.5 8 VILLAGE OF MINSTER Ohio 1,997.3
9 MASSACHUSETTS ELECTRIC CO. Massachusetts 1,061.7 9 DUKE ENERGY PROGRESS North Carolina 1,671.9
10 FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT CO. Florida 949.1 10 MIDDLETON ELECTRIC LIGHT DEPARTMENT Massachusetts 1,653.7
Source: Smart Electric Power Alliance, 2019. Source: Smart Electric Power Alliance, 2019.
MW = Megawatts-ac
SEPA | 2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT 30
2019 UTILITY SOLAR MARKET SNAPSHOT
DISTRIBUTION UTILITIES
4-County Electric Power Alliant Energy - Wisconsin Appalachian Power Company - Barry Electric Cooperative Blue Ridge Mountain Electric
Association Altamaha Electric Membership West Virginia Barton County Electric Co-op, Inc. Membership Corporation -
A&N Electric Cooperative Corporation Arab Electric Cooperative Inc. Georgia
Beaches Energy Services
AEP Ohio Ameren Illinois Arizona Public Service Blue Ridge Mountain Electric
Belmont Light
Membership Corporation -
AEP Texas Ameren Missouri Athens Utility Board Benton County Electric System North Carolina
Aiken Electric Cooperative, Inc. American Samoa Power Atlantic City Electric Company Berkeley Electric Cooperative, Inc. Bolivar Energy Authority
Albertville Municipal Utilities Authority Austin Energy Big Bend Electric Cooperative, Boscobel Utilities
Board Amicalola Electric Membership Austin Utilities Inc.
Corporation Bowling Green Municipal Utilities
Alcorn County Electric Power Avista Utilities - Idaho Black River Electric Cooperative,
Association Anaheim Public Utilities Braintree Electric Light
Avista Utilities - Washington Inc.
Department
Alger-Delta Co-op Electric Anza Electric Cooperative Black River Falls Municipal
Baltimore Gas & Electric BrightRidge
Association Appalachian Electric Cooperative Utilities
Baraga Electric Utility Bristol Tennessee Essential
Algoma Utilities Appalachian Power Company - Blue Ridge Electric Cooperative
BARC Electric Cooperative Services - Tennessee
Alliant Energy - Iowa Virginia
Bristol Tennessee Essential Central Electric Power City of Crystal Falls City of Russellville Colquitt Electric Membership
Solutions - Virginia Association City of Dayton City of Shelbyville Corporation
Bristol Virginia Utilities Central Georgia Electric City of Evansville City of St. Charles Colton Electric Utility
Broad River Electric Cooperative, Membership Corporation Columbia Power System
City of Fort Collins City of Starke
Inc. Central Hudson Gas & Electric Columbus Water and Light
City of Fort Meade City of Stoughton
Brodhead Water & Light Cherryland Electric Cooperative, Commonwealth Edison
City of Fremont City of Sturgeon Bay
Commission Inc. Company
City of Gladstone City of Tallahassee
Brownsville Utility Department Chickasaw Electric Cooperative, Concord Municipal Light Board
Inc. City of Green Cove Springs City of Tupelo Light & Water
Caney Fork Electric Cooperative Connecticut Light & Power
Inc. Chugach Electric Association City of Harrisonburg City of Westby
Consolidated Edison Company
Canoochee Electric Membership Citizens Electric Company City of Holyoke City Utilities of Springfield -
of New York, Inc.
Corporation City of Independence Missouri
City of Aberdeen Consolidated Electric
Carroll County Electric City of Leesburg Clark Public Utilities
City of Alcoa Cooperative
Department City of Lenoir Clarksville Department of
City of Athens Consumers Energy
Carroll Electric Membership Electricity dba CDE Lightband
City of Banning City of Maquoketa Consumers Power, Inc.
Cooperative Clarksville Light & Water
City of Benton City of Naperville Cookeville Electric Department
Cedar Falls Utility Company
City of Bessemer Utilities City of Negaunee Cookson Hills Electric
Cedarburg Light & Water Utility Cleveland Utilities
City of Bowling Green City of Newberry - Florida Cooperative, Inc.
Central Electric Cooperative, Inc. Coastal Electric Cooperative
City of Bushnell City of Ocala CoServ Electric
- Oklahoma Coastal Electric Cooperative, Inc.
City of Chickamauga City of Okolona Coweta-Fayette Electric
Central Electric Cooperative, Inc. Cobb Electric Membership
City of Oxford Membership Corporation
- Oregon City of Clewiston Corporation
City of Richland Center CPS Energy
City of Clinton
Cuba City Light & Water Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC - Emerald People’s Utility District Fort Loudoun Electric Guam Power Authority
Cullman Electric Cooperative, South Carolina Empire Electric Association - Cooperative Guntersville Electric Board
Inc. Duke Energy Indiana Colorado Fort Payne Improvement Habersham Electric Membership
Cullman Power Board Duke Energy Ohio Inc. - Empire Electric Association - Authority Corporation
Cumberland Electric Member Kentucky Utah Fort Pierce Utilities Authority Hagerstown Light Department
Corporation Duke Energy Ohio Inc. - Ohio Etowah Utilities Fulton Electric System Harriman Utility Board
Dayton Power & Light Duke Energy Progress - North Excelsior Electric Membership Gainesville Regional Utilities Hart Electric Member
Decatur Utilities Carolina Corporation Gallatin Department of Electricity Corporation
Delaware Electric Cooperative Duke Energy Progress - South Fairfield Electric Cooperative, Inc. Georgetown Utility Systems Hartford Electric
Carolina Farmers Electric Cooperative,
Delmarva Power - Delaware Georgia Power Company Havana Power & Light Company
Duquesne Light Company Inc.
Delmarva Power- Maryland Gibson Electric Members Hawaii Electric Light Company
Eagle River Light & Water Fayetteville Public Utilities Corporation - Kentucky
Denton Municipal Electric Hawaiian Electric Company
Department Fitchburg Gas and Electric Light
Detroit Edison Gibson Electric Members Heber Light & Power
East Mississippi Electric Power Company Corporation - Tennessee
Dickson Electric Department Association Hickman Electric Plant Board
Flathead Electric Cooperative Glasgow Electric Plant Board
Diverse Power Incorporated Easton Utilities Hickman Electric System
Flint Energies Glendale Water & Power
Dominion Energy North Carolina Edisto Electric Cooperative, Inc. Holston Electric Cooperative, Inc.
Florence Utilities Grady Electric Membership
Dominion Energy Virginia El Paso Electric Hopkinsville Electric System
Florence Utility Commission Corporation
Duck River Electric Membership Electric Power Board of Horry Electric Cooperative
Florida Power & Light Company Green Mountain Power
Corporation Chattanooga - Georgia Humboldt Utilities
Florida Public Utilities Corporation
Duke Energy (FL) Electric Power Board of Huntsville Utilities - Alabama
Forked Deer Electric Greeneville Power & Light
Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC - Chattanooga - Tennessee System Huntsville Utilities - Tennessee
Cooperative, Inc.
North Carolina Elizabethton Electric System GreyStone Power Corporation Hustisford Utilities
Imperial Irrigation District Jersey Central Power & Light Lake Mills Light & Water Louisville Gas & Electric Metropolitan Edison Company
Indian Electric Cooperative, Inc. Joe Wheeler Electric Lake Region Electric Loveland Water and Power Mid-Carolina Electric Co-op Inc.
Indiana Michigan Power - Membership Corporation Cooperative, Inc. Lynches River Electric Middle Georgia Electric Member
Indiana Juneau Utilities Laurens Electric Cooperative Cooperative, Inc. Corporation
Indiana Michigan Power - Kansas City Power & Light - Lawrenceburg Utility Systems Magic Valley Electric Middle Tennessee Electric
Michigan Kansas Lewisburg Electric System Cooperative, Inc. Membership Corporation
Indianapolis Power & Light Kansas City Power & Light - Lexington Electric System Marlboro Electric Cooperative, Middleton Electric Light
Company (AES) Missouri Inc. Department
Liberty Utilities
Irwin Electric Membership Kansas City Power & Light Marshall-De Kalb Electric Milan Department of Public
Lincoln Electric System
Corporation Greater Missouri Operations Cooperative Utilities
Linn County Rural Electric
Jackson Electric Member Kauai Island Utility Cooperative Marshfield Utilities Mitchell Electric Member
Cooperative Association
Corporation Kaukauna Utilities Maryville Electric Department Corporation
Little Ocmulgee Electric
Jackson Energy Authority Kennebunk Light & Power Massachusetts Electric Company Monongahela Power Company
Membership Corporation
Jacksonville Electric Authority District Maui Electric Company Monroe County Electric Power
Little River Electric Cooperative
Jamestown Board of Public Kentucky Power Company Association
Lodi Electric Utility Mayfield Electric & Water System
Utilities Keys Energy Services Morristown Utility Commission
Lodi Utilities McMinnville Electric System
Jefferson Electric Member Kingsport Power Company Mount Horeb Utility
Longmont Power & Medina Electric Co-op, Inc.
Corporation Mount Pleasant Power System
Kissimmee Utility Authority Communications Memphis Light, Gas and Water
Jefferson Utilities Mountain Electric Cooperative -
Kit Carson Electric Cooperative, Los Angeles Dept of Water and Division
Jellico Electric and Water Inc. North Carolina
Power Menasha Electric & Water
Systems - Kentucky Mountain Electric Cooperative -
Knoxville Utility Board Loudon Utilities Utilities
Jellico Electric and Water Tennessee
Lafollette Utilities Board Louisville Electric System Meriwether Lewis Electric
Systems - Tennessee
Cooperative
Murfreesboro Electric North East Mississippi Electric Northest Oklahoma Electric Otero County Electric Planters Electric Membership
Department Power Association Cooperative, Inc. Cooperative, Inc. Corporation
Murray Electric System North Georgia Electric Member Northwest Rural Public Power Ozark Electric Co-op Inc. Plateau Electric Cooperative
Muscle Shoals Electric Board Corporation District Pacific Gas & Electric Plumas-Sierra Rural Electric
Nashville Electric Service Northcentral Mississippi Electric Norway Department of Power & PacifiCorp - California Cooperative
Power Association Light Plymouth Utilities
Natchez Trace Electric Power PacifiCorp - Idaho
Association Northern Neck Electric NSTAR Potomac Edison Company -
PacifiCorp - Oregon
Cooperative, Inc. NV Energy Maryland
Navajo Tribal Utility Authority PacifiCorp - Utah
Northern States Power Oak Ridge Electric Department Potomac Edison Company -
Nebraska Public Power District PacifiCorp - Washington
Minnesota (Xcel) Virginia
New Albany Light, Gas & Water Ocmulgee Electric Membership
Northern States Power PacifiCorp - Wyoming
Corporation Potomac Edison Company -
New Braunfels Utilities Minnesota (Xcel) - Colorado Palmetto Electric Cooperative
Oconee Electric Membership West Virginia
New Holstein Utilities Northern States Power Paris Board of Public Utilities
Corporation Potomac Electric Power
New London Utilities Minnesota (Xcel) - North Dakota PECO Energy Company Company - District of Columbia
Oconomowoc Utilities
New Richmond Utilities Northern States Power Pedernales Electric Cooperative, Potomac Electric Power
Oconto Falls Municipal Electric
Newberry Electric Cooperative Minnesota (Xcel) - South Dakota Inc. Company - Maryland
Utility
New-Mac Electric Cooperative, Northern States Power Texas Pee Dee Electric Co-op, Inc. Poudre Valley Rural Electric
Ohio Edison Company
Inc. (Xcel) - New Mexico Association, Inc.
Okefenoke Rural Electric Pennsylvania Electric Company
Newport Utilities Board Northern States Power Texas Powell Valley Electric
Membership Corporation Pennsylvania Power Company
(Xcel) - Texas Cooperative - Tennessee
Niagara Mohawk Power Omaha Public Power District Pennyrile Rural Electric
Corporation Northern States Power Powell Valley Electric
Orlando Utilities Commission Cooperative
Wisconsin (Xcel) - Michigan Cooperative - Virginia
North Alabama Electric Co-op Pickwick Electric Cooperative
Northern States Power Osage Valley Electric Co-op Assn.
PPL Electric Utilities Company
Wisconsin (Xcel) - Wisconsin
Prentiss County Electric Power Ripley Power and Light Sequachee Valley Electric Southwest Tennessee Electric Tarrant Electric Department
Association River Falls Municipal Utilities Cooperative Membership Corporation Tennessee Valley Electric
Preston Public Utilities Riverside Public Utilities Sevier County Electric System Southwestern Electric Power Cooperative
Commission Sheffield Utilities Company - Arkansas The Illuminating Company
Rochelle Municipal Utilities
PSEG Long Island Shrewsbury Electric & Cable Southwestern Electric Power The Narragansett Electric
Rock Hill Utilities
Public Service Company of New Operations Company - Louisiana Company
Rockwood Electric Utility
Mexico Slash Pine Electric Membership Southwestern Electric Power The Potomac Edison Company
Roseville Electric Company - Texas
Public Service Company of Corporation Three Notch Electric
Oklahoma Sac-Osage Electric Cooperative, Sparta Electric & Public Works
Slinger Utilities Membership Corporation
Inc.
Public Service Electric & Gas Smithville Electric System Springfield Department of Tippah Electric Power
Sacramento Municipal Utility Electricity
Public Utility District No. 1 of Snapping Shoals Electric Association
District
Benton County Membership Corporation Starkville Electric System Tishomingo County Electric
Salt River Project
Puget Sound Energy Snohomish County Public Utility Sterling Municipal Light Power Association
San Diego Gas & Electric Department
Pulaski Electric System District Toledo Edison Company
Sand Mountain Electric Sulphur Springs Valley Electric
Randolph Electric Membership Southern California Edison Tombigbee Electric Power
Cooperative Cooperative
Corporation Southern Carolina Electric & Gas Association
Santee Cooper Sumter Electric Member
Rappahannock Electric Southern Maryland Electric Town of Erwin
Cooperative Santee Electric Cooperative Corporation
Cooperative, Inc. Town of Murphy
Rayle Electric Membership Satilla Rural Electric Membership Sun Prairie Utilities
Southern Rivers Energy Town of Stowe
Corporation Corporation Sweetwater Utilities Board
Southside Electric Co-op, Inc. Trenton Light & Water
Reedsburg Utility Commission Sawnee Electric Membership Tallahatchie Valley Electric Power
Southwest Electric Cooperative, Department
Corporation Association
Reedy Creek Improvement Inc. Trico Electric Cooperative, Inc.
District Seattle City Light Tampa Electric Company
Tri-County Elec Member Turlock Irrigation District Vermont Electric Cooperative Warren Rural Electric West Kentucky Rural Electric
Corporation - Georgia Tuscumbia Electricity Village Electric Utility - Brewster Cooperative Corporation Cooperative Corporation -
Tri-County Electric Cooperative Department Washington Electric Cooperative Tennessee
Village of Arcade
Tri-County Electric Membership Two Rivers Water & Light Washington Electric West Pennsylvania Power
Village of Bergen
Corporation - Kentucky Membership Corporation Company
Union City Electric System Village of L’Anse
Tri-County Electric Membership Waterloo Light & Water Westar Energy
United Cooperative Services, Inc. Village of Minster
Corporation - Tennessee Commission Western Massachusetts Electric
United Power, Inc. Village of Muscoda
Tri-State Electric Member Waupun Utilities Company d/b/a Eversource
Unitil Energy Systems Village of New Glarus Energy
Corporation - Georgia Weakley County Municipal
UNS Electric, Inc. Village of Prairie Du Sac Wheeling Power Company
Tri-State Electric Member Electric System
Corporation - North Carolina Upper Cumberland Electric Village of Waunakee White River Valley El Co-op Inc.
West Kentucky Rural Electric
Membership Corporation
Tri-State Electric Member Vineland Municipal Utilities Cooperative Corporation - Whitehall Electric Utility
Corporation - Tennessee Upson Electric Membership Kentucky
Volunteer Electric Cooperative Winchester Utilities
Corporation
Tucson Electric Power Walton Electric Member York Electric Cooperative, Inc.
Vectren Corporation
Tullahoma Utilities Board Corporation