Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Point: A Classification
Point: A Classification
Point of View
Research on Unstable Coronary Syndromes
Unstable Angina
A Classification
Eugene Braunwald, MD
T he establishment of a prognosis and the "intermediate coronary syndrome"4-7; the term most
approach to the treatment of many diseases frequently used now, "unstable angina," was used by
is aided greatly by a logical classification. Fowler8 and Conti et a19 in 1971. This large number of
For example, classification of a wide variety of designations, as well as the lack of a clear, agreed-
neoplasms by anatomic extent, microscopic appear- upon definition, reflects the ambiguity that has con-
ance, and the presence of special markers now tinued to be associated with this "catch-all" syn-
forms the basis for selecting appropriate therapy. In drome. Unstable angina probably consists of a number
cardiology, the classification of patients with acute of conditions, all characterized by severe transient
myocardial infarction and congestive heart failure myocardial ischemia.10-13
has been of enormous value in following the prog- Unstable angina is very common and often quite
ress and in selecting therapy of individual patients serious; it is responsible for more than 750,000
and in comparing the outcome of similar patients hospitalizations annually in the United States14 and
treated at different locations and at different times. thus ranks among the most frequent causes of hos-
The purpose of this article is to provide a classifi- pitalization in this country. More than 70,000 of
cation of unstable angina. This classification is these hospitalized patients develop myocardial
designed to facilitate communication about these infarction,13 and some die suddenly.15 An unknown,
patients, to aid in the decision regarding diagnostic
Downloaded from http://ahajournals.org by on July 4, 2019
nary vasoconstriction18 and activation of platelets27 together under the broad umbrella of unstable angina
and of the clotting system10 may occur during and be pectoris. These patients can be described by using
of pathogenetic importance in unstable angina. Cor- information obtained not only from the clinical
onary thrombi causing variable degrees of coronary examination and routine electrocardiogram but also
obstruction may develop and regress rapidly, from a variety of specialized tests, including coro-
reflecting the opposing actions of the hemostatic and nary arteriography, left ventriculography, continu-
fibrinolytic systems. Platelet emboli may cause ously recorded (Holter) electrocardiography, and
arrhythmias and sudden death in these patients.28 perfusion scintigraphy. Characterization of patients
Unstable angina occurring soon after acute myocar- by all of these methods can lead to the classification
dial infarction is particularly dangerous, often her- of unstable angina into an almost infinite number of
subgroups. Such fine classification is almost as
Downloaded from http://ahajournals.org by on July 4, 2019
alds infarct extension, and is associated with a high useless to the clinician as is the lumping of all
incidence of recurrent events29-32; the latter also patients into a single category.
occur more frequently in patients whose episodes of To separate patients with unstable angina into a
chest pain are accompanied by transient electrocar- manageable number of meaningful and easily under-
diographic changes of ischemia.33-38 stood subgroups based on the severity, the pre-
Considerable efforts are also underway to improve sumed precipitating cause, and the presence of
the treatment of unstable angina, and a variety of electrocardiographic changes, a clinical classifica-
therapeutic approaches are being actively used and tion of this condition is proposed (Table 1). This
investigated. In addition to anti-ischemic pharma- classification focuses on three important aspects of
cologic agents (nitrates, ,3-adrenergic blockers, and unstable angina: 1) the severity of the clinical man-
calcium antagonists), therapeutic options include ifestations, 2) the clinical circumstances in which
anticoagulants, antiplatelet aggregating agents, unstable angina occurs, and 3) whether or not the
thromboxane synthesis inhibitors, thromboxane symptomatic ischemic episodes are accompanied
receptor blockers, thrombolytic agents, percutane- by transient electrocardiographic changes. The clas-
ous transluminal angioplasty, and coronary artery sification can be made before obtaining the above-
bypass surgery.1"'39-48 New methods of revascular- mentioned specialized laboratory tests, and once
ization, such as coronary atherectomy, balloon angio- the tests are performed, the results may then be
plasty with stents, and laser angioplasty, are being used to supplement the clinical information and the
actively investigated. These modes of therapy are standard electrocardiogram. This classification of
being tested in various combinations and sequences, unstable angina is based on two premises: 1) the
and a major challenge will be to select individual patient's symptoms are actually caused by myocar-
patients with unstable angina for various treatment dial ischemia, and 2) in patients with prolonged
options. ischemia, the diagnosis of acute myocardial infarc-
One impediment to obtaining a clearer understand- tion is excluded by electrocardiography or serum
ing of the natural history of unstable angina and to enzyme determinations. Often, this exclusion must
evaluating therapeutic strategies is the heteroge- be retrospective.
neous nature of the syndrome and the lack of Classification
general agreement about its precise definition. Cur-
rently, a broad spectrum of patients with ischemic Severity
episodes varying widely in cause, severity, progno- Class L New onset severe or accelerated angina.
sis, and responsiveness to therapy are lumped Patients with new onset (<2 months in duration)
412 Circulation Vol 80, No 2, August 1989
exertional angina pectoris that is severe or frequent These three levels of treatment may be desig-
(>3 episodes/day) or patients with chronic stable nated by the subscripts 1, 2, and 3.
angina who develop accelerated angina (that is,
angina distinctly more frequent, severe, longer in Discussion
duration, or precipitated by distinctly less exertion This classification of unstable angina, which should
than previously) but who have not experienced pain be tested prospectively, permits the grading of
at rest during the preceding 2 months. patients with unstable angina from the mildest to
Class I. Angina at rest, subacute. Patients with the most severe condition. An example of the
one or more episodes of angina at rest during the mildest form would be a patient with chronic stable
preceding month but not within the preceding 48 angina who develops marked intensification of
hours. exertion-induced angina pectoris after blood loss
Class III. Angina at rest, acute. Patients with one and who has no ST segment or T wave changes
or more episodes of angina at rest within the pre- during angina. This patient would be in class IA
ceding 48 hours. without transient electrocardiographic changes (I,
In classes II and III, manifestations described in accelerated angina; A, secondary unstable angina).
class I may also occur. Unstable angina is no longer At the other end of the spectrum is the patient who
considered to be present when a patient has been experiences recurrent angina at rest with transient
asymptomatic or suffers angina that has been stable ST segment depressions several days after an acute
for more than 2 months. myocardial infarction. This patient would be in
class IIIC with transient electrocardiographic
Clinical Circumstances in Which Unstable changes (class III, angina at rest, acute; C, postin-
Angina Occurs farction unstable angina).
Class A. Secondary unstable angina. Patients in Unstable angina is a dynamic condition, and
whom unstable angina develops secondary to a patients may initially be in one class and move to
clearly identified condition extrinsic to the coronary another as the underlying disease changes or as
vascular bed that has intensified myocardial isch- response to treatment occurs. For example, a patient
emia. Such conditions reduce myocardial oxygen with the new onset of severe and frequent exer-
supply or increase myocardial oxygen demand and tional angina without an apparent provocative ex-
include anemia, fever, infection, hypotension, uncon- tracardiac condition is in class IB. If that patient
trolled hypertension, tachyarrhythmia, unusual emo- then developed an episode of angina at rest, he
Downloaded from http://ahajournals.org by on July 4, 2019
tional stress, thyrotoxicosis, and hypoxemia sec- would be in class IIIB. If no pain recurred for 48
ondary to respiratory failure. hours, he would be in class IIB.
Class B. Primary unstable angina. Patients who The classification of the intensity of treatment
develop unstable angina pectoris in the absence of may be used as follows. A patient with a history of
an extracardiac condition that has intensified isch- primary unstable angina at rest during convales-
emia, as in class A. cence from a myocardial infarction who is receiving
Class C. Postinfarction unstable angina. Patients no anti-ischemia therapy is in class 111C1. If epi-
who develop unstable angina within the first 2 weeks sodes of pain persist despite treatment with usual
after a documented acute myocardial infarction. doses of antianginal agents, the patient would
advance to 111C2; if during treatment with intrave-
Electrocardiographic Changes nous nitroglycerin the episodes disappeared for
more than 48 hours, the patient would be classified
If an electrocardiogram has been recorded during as IGC3.
an episode of chest pain, the presence or absence of Although the proposed classification of unstable
transient ST-T abnormalities is noted. (The pres- angina is clinical, it can be related to the underlying
ence of such abnormalities is associated with more disease. Angioscopic observations performed dur-
severe underlying disease.33-38) ing operation suggest a good correlation between
the presence of nonocclusive thrombi and the recent
Intensity of Treatment occurrence of angina at rest.25 Such thrombi usually
For research purposes, especially clinical trials, it undergo rapid spontaneous lysis and therefore
may be helpful also to classify patients by the inten- become less prevalent with the passage of time.
sity of treatment as follows: 1) unstable angina Thrombolytic or anticoagulant therapy may there-
occurring in the absence of or with minimal antiangi- fore be of great value in patients in class III, of less
nal therapy; 2) unstable angina occurring in the value in class II, and of little value in class I. The
presence of appropriate therapy for chronic stable precipitation of unstable angina by changes in con-
angina (the administration of conventional oral doses ditions extrinsic to the coronary artery bed that
of antianginal drugs, i.e., ,3-adrenergic blockers, long- have intensified ischemia (class A) is compatible
acting nitrates, and calcium antagonists); and 3) with fixed, severe coronary obstruction, and the
unstable angina occurring in the presence of maxi- presence of a fissured plaque or thrombus need not
mally tolerated doses of all three categories of anti- be presumed (but cannot, of course, be excluded).
ischemic drugs, including intravenous nitroglycerin.49 Unstable angina secondary to an increase in myo-
Braunwald Classification of Unstable Angina 413
cardial oxygen needs or abnormal coronary vaso- 16. Harper RW, Kennedy G, DeSanctis RW, Hutter AM: The
constriction generally responds to bed rest, mild incidence and pattern of angina prior to acute myocardial
infarction: A study of 577 cases.Am Heart J 1979;97:178-183
sedation, and vigorous treatment with multiple anti- 17. Fuster V, Badimon L, Cohen M, Ambrose JA, Badimon JJ,
ischemic drugs; failure to respond to such vigorous Chesebro J: Insights into the pathogenesis of acute ischemic
therapy suggests total or subtotal coronary occlu- syndromes. Circulation 1988;6:1213-1220
sion, sometimes by a thrombus. 18. Maseri A: Pathogenetic classifications of unstable angina as
It is hoped that this classification will aid in the a guideline to individual patient management and prognosis.
Am J Med 1986;80(Suppl 4C):48-55
clear description of and communication about 19. Moise A, Theroux P, Taeymans Y, Descoings B, Lesper-
patients with unstable angina, in the elucidation of ance J, Waters DD, Pelletier GB, Bourassa M: Unstable
the natural history and prognosis of the various angina and progression of coronary atherosclerosis. N Engl
subgroups, in the precise definition of patients JMed 1983;309:685-689
selected for clinical trials so that therapy can be 20. Ambrose JA, Winters SL, Arora RR, Eng A, Ricco A,
Gorlin R, Fuster V: Angiographic evolution of coronary
evaluated in comparable patients, and ultimately in artery morphology in unstable angina. JAm Coll Cardiol
the development of treatment regimens that are 1986;7:472-478
appropriate for each subgroup. 21. Holmes DR Jr, Hartzler GO, Smith HC, Fuster V: Coronary
artery thrombosis in patients with unstable angina. Br Heart
Acknowledgments J 1981;45:411-416
22. Vetrovec GW, Cowley MJ, Overton H, Richardson DW:
The aid of a number of colleagues who reviewed Intracoronary thrombus in syndromes of unstable myocar-
this manuscript is gratefully acknowledged. Partic- dial ischemia. Am Heart J 1981;102:1202-1208
ularly valuable suggestions were made by Drs. C.R. 23. Capone G, Wolf NM, Meyer B, Meister SG: Frequency of
Conti, S. Epstein, V. Fuster, L. Goldman, R. intracoronary filling defects by angiography in angina pecto-
Gorlin, S. Gottlieb, R. Helfant, A. Maseri, R. Ross, ris at rest. Am J Cardiol 1985;56:403-406
24. Gotoh K, Katoh K, Fukui S, Hamano Y, Minamino T:
and T. Ryan. Angiographic visualization of coronary thrombus during
anginal attack in unstable angina (abstract). Circulation
References 1985;72(suppl III):III-112
1. Wearn JT: Thrombosis of the coronary arteries, with infarc- 25. Sherman CT, Litvack F, Grundfest ME, Lee M, Hickey A,
tion of the heart. Am JMed Sci 1923;165:250-276 Chaux A, Kass R, Blanche C, Matloff J, Morgenstern L,
2. Sampson JJ, Eliaser M Jr: The diagnosis of impending acute Ganz W, Swan HJC, Forrester J: Coronary angioscopy in
coronary artery occlusion. Am Heart J 1937;13:675 -686
patients with unstable angina pectoris. N Engl J Med 1986;
315:913-919
3. Feil H: Preliminary pain in coronary thrombosis. Am J Med 26. Falk E: Plaque rupture with severe pre-existing stenosis
Downloaded from http://ahajournals.org by on July 4, 2019
35. Sclarovsky S, Davidson E, Lewin RF, Strasberg B, Arditti toris: Results of a randomized double-blind, placebo-
A, Agmon J: Unstable angina pectoris evolving to acute controlled trial. Am J Cardiol 1988;62:368-371
myocardial infarction: Significance of ECG changes during 43. de Zwaan C, Bar FW, Janssen JHA, de Swart HB, Vermeer
chest pain. Am Heart J 1986;112:459- 462 F, Wellens HJJ: Effects of thrombolytic therapy on unstable
36. Sclarovsky S, Davidson E, Strasberg B, Lewin RF, Arditti angina: Clinical and angiographic results. JAm Coll Cardiol
A, Wurtzel M, Agmon J: Unstable angina: The significance 1988; 12:301- 309
of ST segment elevation or depression in patients without 44. Williams DO, Riley RS, Singh AK, Gerwitz H, Most AS:
evidence of increased myocardial oxygen demand. Am Heart Evaluation of the role of coronary angioplasty in patients
J 1986;112:463-467 with unstable angina pectoris. Am Heart J 1981;102:1- 90
37. Plotnick GD, Greene HL, Carliner NH, Becker LC, Fisher 45. De Feyter PJ, Suryapranata H, Serruys PW, Beatt K, van
ML: Clinical indicators of left main coronary artery disease Domburg R, van den Brand M, Tijssen JJ, Azar AJ, Hugen-
in unstable angina. Ann Intern Med 1979;91:149-153 holtz PG: Coronary angioplasty for unstable angina: Imme-
38. Papapietro SE, Niess GS, Paine TD, Mantle JA, Rackley diate and late results in 200 consecutive patients with iden-
CE, Russell RO, Rogers WJ: Transient electrocardiographic
changes in patients with unstable angina: Relation to coro- tification of risk factors for unfavorable early and late
nary arterial anatomy. Am J Cardiol 1980;46:28-33 outcome. JAm Coll Cardiol 1988;12:324-333
39. Lewis HD, Davis JW, Archibald DG, Steinke WE, Smith- 46. Favaloro RG, Effier DB, Cheanvechai C, Quint RA, Sones
erman TC, Doherty JE III, Schnaper HW, LeWinter MM, FM Jr: Acute coronary insufficiency (impending myocardial
Linares E, Pouget JM, Sabharwal SC, Chester E, DeMots infarction and myocardial infarction). Am J Cardiol 1971;
H: Protective effects of aspirin against acute myocardial 28:598-607
infarction and death in men with unstable angina. N Engl J 47. Unstable Angina Pectoris Study Group: Unstable angina
Med 1983;309:396-403 pectoris: National cooperative study group to compare sur-
40. Theroux P, Ouimet H, McCans J, Latour JG, Joly P, Levy gical and medical therapy: II. In-hospital experience and
G, Pelletier E, Juneau M, Stasiak J, DeGruise P, Pellitier initial follow-up results in patients with one, two and three
GB, Rinzler D, Waters DD: Aspirin, heparin, or both to treat vessel disease. Am J Cardiol 1978;42:839-848
acute unstable angina. N Engl J Med 1988;319:1105 -11 11 48. Luchi RJ, Scott SM, Deupree RH, and the Principal Inves-
41. Gold HK, Johns JA, Leinbach RC, Yasuda T, Grossbard E, tigators and Their Associates of Veterans Administration
Zusman R, Collen D: A randomized, blinded, placebo- Cooperative Study No. 28: Comparison of medical and
controlled trial of recombinant human tissue-type plasmino- surgical treatment for unstable angina pectoris. N Engl J
gen activator in patients with unstable angina pectoris. Med 1987;316:977-984
Circulation 1987;75:1192-1199 49. Curfman GD, Heinsimer JA, Lozner EC, Ho-Leung F:
42. Topol EJ, Nicklas JM, Kander NH, Walton JA, Ellis SG, Intravenous nitroglycerin in the treatment of spontaneous
Gorman L, Pitt B: Coronary revascularization after intrave- angina pectoris: A prospective, randomized trial. Circula-
nous tissue plasminogen activator for unstable angina pec- tion 1983;67:276-282
Circulation 1989;80:410-414
Downloaded from http://ahajournals.org by on July 4, 2019