Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Harmonics: Let's Get Physic-Al!
Harmonics: Let's Get Physic-Al!
Harmonics: Let's Get Physic-Al!
Well, that’s because it means such different things to different people. Is it is a voice
quality, or is a particular set of notes? Could it be a gear change or the area between
chest voice and head voice? Here’s one definition from about.com
“about a 50/50 split in resonance”.
What does that mean? How do I split my resonance?
I can’t answer either of those questions without yawning, or starting the entire post
again having got nowhere. Instead let’s cover mixed voice in the acoustic sense,
which is just one way to attempt to describe this ambiguous little blighter. I will
absolutely post something on the vocal fold story of mixed voice soon, but that’s
another ball game altogether!
Harmonics
Let’s get our head around harmonics for a sec. Stay awake…
Our vocal folds begin to make sound by interrupting the airflow that leaves our
lungs. This interruption causes pressure to build up underneath the vocals, which
causes them to vibrate as the air eventually bursts through. For the record, this
pressure build up and vibration thing happens in a fraction of a second.
The speed of vocal fold vibration is determined by the vocal fold’s tension, which is
adjusted by the muscle in our larynx when we sing higher or lower. You exercise this
tension-changing ability every time you sing a melody and speak expressively so it’s
not a very technical thing. We just do it, although extreme pitches and tensions are
what we have trouble with mostly. That’s where teachers come in to help out.
ARE YOU STILL WITH ME???
As the vocal folds vibrate in singing, they are constantly parting and colliding, many
times per second, in a constant cycle. As they collide, their mucosal covering also
vibrates as a result of the collision. In a better description, the covering ripples like a
kind of vocal jelly. Those ripples allow little puffs of air through at varying speeds.
These little puffs send vibrations though the air molecules in our throat and mouth,
and eventually into the outside world. Our ears are the receivers for that signal, and
therefore we have sound waves!
So, in essence, harmonics are sound waves created by these little puffs of air in each
vibration of the vocal folds. The amount of vocal fold vibrations that happen in one
second is decoded by our ears and brains as the pitch. This measurement is known as
the frequency, displayed as Hertz (Hz). If we sing an A4, that equates to 440Hz. That
is, 440 vibrations per second!
Back to the puffs of air that create harmonics, because they come from the same
event (IE, vocal fold vibration/collision) our brain decodes these extra parts of the
sound wave as the tone colour of the note being sung. Because the puffs of air ripple
so much faster than the vocal fold vibration, they send off much higher frequency
elements in the sound wave. Up to thousands of vibrations per second and beyond.
To summarise harmonics…
It’s such a b*tch to grasp harmonics. It’s essentially lots of different pitches being
created at the same time, from the same source, but we only hear one consolidated
sound! On saying that, it’s lucky we only hear one. It saves us from being
overwhelmed by this barrage of individual sound waves. Instead, we just hear two
things: the amount of vibrations per second (the pitch) + the harmonics generated in
that vibration (the tone colour). Thanks brain!
Moving on from harmonics, we need to march on into spaces and resonance…
The boost
If only this was about chocolate 🙂 But alas… back to physics
The thing about spaces is that they preferentially reinforce sound waves, making
them more intense. This is purely because spaces can change how sound waves
travel through the air in them. Their size also changes how and when these waves
reflect around in the space. A bit like how a room, and what it’s made of, can change
how long an echo bounces around the walls for. As you’ve probably guessed it, if you
were to scream into a wardrobe it wouldn’t be very resonant.
Don’t ask why I scream into my wardrobe.
Larger spaces boost lower frequency vibrations, and hence lower pitches and
harmonics. Smaller spaces reinforce higher frequency vibrations, and hence higher
pitches and harmonics. In singing, a larger space would be considered as the throat
and our lower notes may feel like the resonate there. A smaller space would be the
mouth, and that space is capable of resonating much higher pitches.
Interestingly, vowels change the shape of both our throat and mouth. So, these
spaces are capable of being many different sizes! That means they are also capable
of resonating many different frequencies. Oh the wonder of it!
The bridge/passaggio
I’ve already banged on about the throat being able to resonate lower pitches, which
is significant here. Certain harmonic energy in our voice becomes too high for the
throat to resonate. It’s just too big and suited to low notes!
If we keep raising pitch, we will reach the point where this energy stops being
resonated and doesn’t contribute to our tone colour anymore. We can feel and hear
that as it happens. You’ll know the place… around E4/F4 for guys and A4/B4 for girls,
singing an UH vowel.
Provided you’re not massively straining, this transition will be felt subtly, but
obviously, without a big break or crack.
I know what you’re thinking though…
“But I’m not resonated anymore… waaaaaaaaaah”
You are, but it’s just not the harmonic energy that was bouncing in the throat.
There’s plenty of other harmonic energy knocking around in the other spaces of the
vocal tract that contribute to your sound. Otherwise, you’d be completely inaudible!
We just feel the one described above much more distinctly, so we have latched on to
it.
We always have the vowel on our side too. Because vowels change the shape of the
throat and mouth, they are very useful tools for adjusting which pitches and
harmonics we can resonate. That’s why some vowels are impossible to sing high up,
and some help us negotiate the passaggio.
Is that it???
Pretty much. Entering the acoustic world of mixed register basically boils down to:
Certain pitches and harmonic energy getting too high for the throat space to
resonate, so acoustic energy changes.
No mixing in sight, really. Because there’s no mixing, the teaching industry is
beginning to avoid the term ‘mix’ because it is so misleading.
This is on a strictly ‘need to know’ basis
I usually battle with myself when writing articles like this. I think to myself, probably
like many voice teachers reading this:
“Who honestly gives a sh*t about physics???”
Or the more polite version:
“Actually how useful is it knowing this?”
For teachers who want a better understanding of how voice works and a good BS
meter for taking in new material, I feel it’s essential to dig into science. It also helps
teachers avoid unhelpful or inappropriate vowel choices. That makes getting to the
end game much quicker for everyone.
When I sing I don’t think much about this at all, granted. But many of the tools that
got me where I am today were based on this knowledge.
For singers and enthusiasts, it could muddy the waters to know all this stuff. You’re
in serious danger of analysis paralysis! My view is that you are better off
experiencing it with someone trained to create a scenario where you can. That way
you can name it whatever you want. Mixed voice, monkey voice or “my god I can’t
feel a thing” voice. Please take this information as purely a geeky indulgence without
losing sight of the instinctive, experiential nature of singing training.
It doesn’t stop there…
All of that up there is about resonance, but there’s another massive chapter in the
mixing myth; the vocal folds. This is the theory that the vocal folds themselves can
create a mixed setting, which is aside from resonance. Stay tuned for that article,
which will be coming soon once I’ve recovered from this one 🙂
Training
There are a number of vocal exercises any singer can do that will strengthen both
low and high notes and allow seamless transition between the two. This process is
also known as learning to mix registers. When working on mixing registers, the most
important point to keep in mind is that every person’s register breaks are unique;
some of these exercises will be more effective for you than others.
Yawn-Sighs
The yawn-sigh is exactly what it sounds like, mixing high tones from a yawn down to
a gentle, low sigh. Starting from the very top note you can hit, "swoosh" down to the
very bottom note with an exaggerated sigh. Slide your voice down the scale as slowly
as possible, especially during transitions in which your voice often breaks. Chances
are, one of these awkward "bumps" in your voice is an indicator that you are not
hitting every single pitch from the top to the bottom.
Repeat this process multiple times, sliding slower in challenged sections each time.
Male singers should take special care between the falsetto (highest pitched) notes
and the head voice (the next octave down). Female singers, conversely, should focus
on the transition from baritone to bass transitions.
The Grunt
The grunt exercise focuses on the vibrations your vocal cords make in your body, and
just like the name suggests does so through a series of guttural grunting sounds.
Start this exercise by placing your hand on your chest and making a sustained
grunting sound—if it suits you, feel free to imitate a gorilla! If you're feeling
vibrations in your chest, this means you're creating these notes with your chest
voice.
Now raise your pitch slowly and imitate the low grunt again. The higher the pitch
goes, the harder it will be for you to feel the vibrations in your chest. Work on
adjusting tone and vibration in the higher registers because once you do, that means
you've successfully combined the high and low registers of your voice.
Once you are satisfied with the transition between those two notes, take a deep
breath. Then, sing the last note you ended on and again slur up to the next pitch,
taking all the time you need to get there seamlessly. Once you have reached the top
of the scale, you can either repeat these steps or move on to the next technique.
Portamento
Portamento is an Italian word which literally means, “to carry the voice,” but most
refer to these warm-ups as slides. Much like slurring up the scale, portamento relies
on an in-depth understanding of the pitches and tones between notes. In
portamento, you begin by choosing a vowel sound, creating a note with it, then
buzzing your lips throughout the exercise. Unlike slurring, though, portamento asks
that you slide from high to low and vice versa.
Through this, you can learn to mix and connect registers. By sliding from either the
top to the bottom of your voice or vice versa, you are able to work on specific
transitions between them. It is best to pick two pitches, one above and one below
the break you are experiencing, and slide between the two over and over. Through
repetition and a keen ear, you should be able to rid yourself of those vocal "bumps."
Messa di Voce
Messa di Voce literally translates to "placing of voice," and in the warm-up refers to
singing a certain pitch in crescendo then decrescendo. Singing soft-to-loud and then
loud-to-soft on one pitch teaches you to sing that particular note in both registers.
Because this is a particularly difficult exercise, be sure to start on a pitch you are
comfortable singing. You can pick any syllable or vowel to practice on, but most
music teachers will start you off with "la."
The point of Messa di Voce is to allow you to gauge the power of specific pitches
within your vocal range. Once you have an understanding of your strengths and
weaknesses at opposite ends of the scale, you can more easily transition between
high and low notes you sing well.
Octave Leaps
An octave consists of eight notes, so an octave leap means leaping 8 notes at a time,
essentially hitting the same note at a higher or lower octave. To adjust for your vocal
crack, it is best to pick a note above or below (whichever you are more comfortable
singing) the note where your voice is wont to crack. Sing the note then leap up or
down one octave wherein you will have sung both registers once you've completed
the task.
Octave leaps are different from slides in that instead of gliding through all the notes
between, you directly jump from singing a lower note to the same note an octave
higher. Your goal here is to seek a fluid transition without "scooping." Though it is
challenging, finding a balance between smoothness and excessive scooping is
necessary for a beautiful singing voice.
Yawn
Yawns are wonderful tools to open up the back of the throat, adding warmth and
loudness to the voice. The best use of the yawn is to breathe deeply as if about to
yawn and attempt to sing with that same feeling. The soft palate should be lifted and
back of the throat feels as if an egg is stuck in it. Lower notes are easier to sing with
an open throat, so start by singing a single pitch in a lower register. Note the open
feeling. Now sing a five-note scale from top to bottom, 5-4-3-2-1 or sol-fa-mi-re-
do with the same open feeling. Higher notes should be as open as lower notes, but
require more point as described in more detail under “Hum.”
Hum
Humming accesses the natural brightness of the voice, which nasopharynx resonance
contributes. You may also concentrate on singing in the mask of the voice for the
same effect. This type of resonance is particularly important in order to sing high
notes easily and to help low notes project. Start by humming on a pitch high for you.
Note the buzzing feeling on the bridge of the nose. Now open the mouth into an ‘ah,’
while continuing the feeling of a hum. Are your high notes easier to sing? If so, then
you are doing the exercise right.
Sing the Vowel ‘E’
The tongue is high in the back of the mouth and out of the throat when singing ‘e,’ or
in IPA ‘i’ as in “feed.” For many, the ‘e,’ is their first introduction to nasal resonance.
Listen for the ringing sound of efficient resonance as you sing it on a five-note
scale going up and down (1-2-3-4-5-4-3-2-1 or do-re-mi-fa-sol-fa-mi-re-do). Allow
yourself to sound excessively nasal two or three times as you sing it if you are
struggling to hear a difference. For some students, the overdone version of the
exercise is beautiful singing. Having someone with a well-trained ear listen to you
explore your voice as you sing these exercises will help you make needed changes.
Ningy
‘N’ and ‘ng’ are nasal consonants requiring a large amount of buzzing in the nose.
Singing them in combination with vowels requires singers to add a brighter
resonance from the ‘n’ and ‘ng’ into the vowel. Since singers often lose this “ring” to
the voice when going down the scale, I like to sing it on 5-5-4-4-3-3-2-2-1-1 or sol,
sol, fa, fa, mi, mi, re, re, do, do. The first 5 or sol is ‘ning’ and the second is ‘y,’ the
same applies to the other repeated scale notes. You may also change the last vowel
to improve other vowels. Variations include Ninga (ah as in father), Ninge (e as in
aid), Ningo (oh as in ode), ningoo (ooh as in food).
New (njʊ)
Sing new with a slightly more open vowel, as in ‘book.’ This word combines the
brighter resonance of ‘nj’ with ‘ʊ,’ which opens the back of the throat for a warmer
quality. Both male and female voices should sing the word in lower and middle
registers, as the vowel is often open in higher registers and more brightness is
required. I suggest singing it on a descending chordal pattern 5-3-1. As the pattern
makes finding a half step higher easier to find than a half step lower, start in the
lowest part of your voice and work your way up to the middle of your voice.
Vowel Tuning
Singers often have a favorite vowel they resonate or sound best singing. On one
single tone sing your favorite vowel and then switch to another vowel of your choice.
While singing the second vowel, try to keep the qualities of the first. The five
main vowels in English in IPA or International Phonetic Alphabet transcription are: ‘ɑ’
as in fog, ‘e’ as in ate, ‘i’ as in see, ‘o’ as in ode, ‘u’ as in too, ‘I’ as in pit, ‘ɛ’ as in
thread, ‘ʌ’ as in up, ‘ə’ as in could, ‘a’ as in pat, ‘ʊ’ as in book, and ‘ᴐ’ as in pot. If your
favorite vowel is ‘i’ as in “feed,” then try these combos: i-ɑ, i-e, i-o, i-u, i-I, i-ɛ, i-ʌ, i-ə,
i-a, i-ʊ, and i-ᴐ. I use the same scale as for the exercise using ningy: 5-5-4-4-3-3-2-2-1-
1 or sol, sol, fa, fa, mi, mi, re, re, do, do. The first scale degree gets one vowel and the
second gets the other.
Large Skips
Practicing large skips helps singers find consistency throughout the range of their
voice. In this exercise, it encourages an open throat as you ascend the scale. This is
accomplished by keeping a neutral larynx position and relaxed throat when singing
high. The exercise is 1-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1 or do-do-ti-la-sol-fa-mi-re-do. Sing the first
note long enough to notice the feeling of the mouth, tongue, jaw, and throat. When
skipping up an octave, keep the feeling as best you can. It may take some practice
but will improve your upper range tremendously. Be sure to keep the same
sensation and engagement as you go down the scale.
Resonance Training
Reed instruments are loud enough to be heard over an entire string orchestra
because of their efficient use of resonance. But remove their small wood piece called
a reed, and the instrument loses its ability to project. Similarly, the voice can also be
heard over an orchestra, even a full one with added brass and reed instruments.
Take away the vocal cords and the voice’s ability to make sound is greatly reduced.
This may lead people to believe the secret to loud sound lies within the vocal cords,
but resonance is the true secret to vocal volume. In addition, carefully choosing what
overtones are amplified will create a beautiful, balanced vocal tone incorporating
both warmth and brightness.
What Is Resonance?
Resonance amplifies sound. It also adjusts the color and timbre of the voice by
intensifying certain vocal qualities over others. In other words, some resonators
make the tone quality of the singer warm and others bright. All increase the overall
volume. Vocal cords start sound. And like a well-designed recital hall, the body
reflects and increases the sound. Learning to create the best, most efficient space for
resonance begins with learning about the main resonance chambers of the human
body that singers have an influence over.
Integrate Resonators
Though you may focus on one area of the pharynx over another as you familiarize
yourself with resonance, professionals use all the spaces to resonate. Combining
both bright and warm qualities makes a voice interesting and brings out its natural
uniqueness. Avoid imitating other singers as your voice may be entirely different
than theirs. Though you may successfully sound like someone by altering your
resonance chambers, doing so does not help you reach your fullest vocal potential.
Over-focus on one area of the pharynx is detrimental. For instance, focusing on the
laryngopharynx alone can make a singer sound swallowed or too dark. The
oropharynx is so diverse that fixating on it causes inconsistent sound going back and
forth from loud and soft. Too much nasopharynx resonance makes singers overly
bright. Using the entire pharyngeal cavity throughout the range of your voice will
provide balance in volume and timbre. Dr. Clayne Robison, a prominent voice coach
in Utah, expressed integration of resonance as a “crusty banana” with two black
ends.
One black end represents nasopharynx resonance and the other represents
laryngopharynx resonance. The analogy represents the two being on opposite sides
and also provides a somewhat tubular shape similar to the inside of the throat to
visualize. When looked at this way, the center of the banana represents the
oropharynx between the two extremes. Learn to use the entire pharynx as you sing
and the result is lovely, loud, long-lasting, and laudable.
Controlling Vibrato
A beautiful vibrato indicates healthy singing. If you employ proper singing technique,
then you just have it. However, a skilled singer has considerable control over their
vibrato. They can sing without it or increase vibrato speed and intensity at will. Some
unattractive vibratos can also be remedied with training and effort.
Tremolo may also be caused by controlling the pitch of vibrato as in a fast trill. A
habit of that nature takes time to stop, but will often go away on its own by paying
attention to breathing techniques. For some, simply learning to slow down and relax
their emotions may be needed. Singers often sing with faster vibratos during
heightened moments of music, but the variation is heard as beautiful. If you suspect
emotions are involved, focus on portraying the words of the text to a trusted family
member or a friend rather than trying to impress someone. Physically, the
diaphragm will stay lower and more flexible when calm.
Finding breath threshold, or the moment when the vocal cords resist air pressure
with the most effort possible without tension is imperative for those with a wobble.
Singing with a brighter, lighter tone may help. In addition, the general techniques of
breath support should be reviewed. Because a wobble is produced by a more
labored production which usually gets worse as a phrase progresses, practicing vocal
onsets will help. A vocal onset is simply the start of tone. Practice it by singing ‘ah’
for a moment on any pitch of your choice, stop, take a deep breath, and sing it again.
Repeat this over and over attempting to create an ease in the tone that will
eventually roll over to harder phrases.
Vocal Onset
The first sound produced during the singing process is the most important. It has
little to do with first impressions and everything to do with getting a good start to
the phrase. There are three basic ways one can initiate vocal tone: aspirated, glottal,
and coordinated. Learning about the different types of vocal onsets is one of the first
steps to achieving an easy, free, and engaging vocal quality.
Coordinated Onset
The hardest to achieve and most important to develop is the coordinated onset. The
vocal cords close with the initial sound producing a quiet onset as in the vowel, “ah.”
This onset is somewhere between the glottal attack where the vocal cords close
before starting the sound and the breathy onset where the vocal cords close after
initiating sound. The name “coordinated,” appropriately refers to the need to
synchronize and prepare all aspects of initial sound in order to achieve the best tone
including breath, vocal cords, and resonant chambers.
Tongue Position
The tongue can have the biggest influence on your vocal sound. It influences the
shape and length of the vocal tract affecting your ability to resonate. It also affects
your ability to enunciate the text of songs. Learning to control the tongue is
particularly difficult because one must coordinate its eight muscles all at once.
Posture training
Stradivari violins are known for their unsurpassed craftsmanship and quality of
sound. The process of creating one involves painstakingly carving the wood so that
the violin is thickest in the center. This shape has proven to give the violin a beautiful
sound. The same time and energy is spent in the design and creation of all great
instruments.
As a singer, your body is the instrument. Just like carving a violin, you can change the
shape of your body in a way that improves tone quality. No surgery is involved; all
you have to do is learn how to have good posture.
On the other hand, you may overcorrect a slumped stance and cause additional
problems. A neck that is too far back or a chest too high causes tension. Be careful
not to overdo it while you practice correct singing posture.
The Alexander Technique is a tool singers can learn for maintaining good posture
while moving. The technique teaches you to use deep postural muscles rather than
actively engaging superficial muscles. The best way to learn the Alexander Technique
is to hire a certified therapist. You will learn to move with the least amount of effort,
so you can save your energy for singing.
Breathing
Breathing well is the most important aspect of successful singing. Not only do you
have to use your diaphragm while singing, but you have to steal time between
phrases to take breaths, take them quickly, make sure they are silent, and do all that
naturally and without tension. Though some people find breathing natural, others
have to consciously practice each aspect of breathing until it is thoroughly engrained
into their bodies.
Low
Diaphragmatic Breathing. :The first step to fantastic breathing while singing is taking
a deep breath using the diaphragm. Your diaphragm is located between the lungs
and stomach and splits you in half vertically. It descends down as you take in a low
breath, pushing the stomach out. Inhaling low is also mandatory in order to properly
support your tone.
No Shoulder Movement
Holding your hands up in a "T" will make it harder for you to lift your chest during
breathing, forcing the breathe down. Photo © Katrina SchmidtUnder no
circumstance should the shoulders rise while you inhale for singing, even if your
stomach goes out and diaphragm extends. There is a muscle that connects the larynx
or Adam’s apple to your shoulders, and if they rise, so does your larynx. This narrows
the space in the back of your throat and you may feel like choking. Low breaths are
especially important when you sing high, because the larynx can rise anyway when
beginning singers have not learned to shorten the vocal chords to create higher
pitches.
Stomach Out
Photo © Katrina SchmidtSome people breathe backwards. They inhale when the
tummy goes in, and exhales as it goes out. Though it may feel right to them, the
lungs need room to expand to take in air. Either you need to raise the shoulders,
lower the diaphragm, or do a combination of both in order to do so. Pushing the
stomach in during inhalation does not create space for the lungs to fill. Even though
it feels right, it is a bad habit that can be broken with time and diligence.
Quiet
for air can ruin the beauty of your singing. The sound between phrases is not only
distracting, but taking a quiet breath requires you to lift the soft palate and create
space in the back of the throat. Since both are required for good singing, you set
yourself up for a beautiful, open, and well projected tone while you sing.
Quick
Gasping or pretending to be surprised or shocked causes you to take a quick low
breath. Photo © Katrina SchmidtWhen you first learn to breathe low, your breaths
take a bit longer. There is nothing wrong with a slow, low breath when you have
time. But many times a quicker breath is required when you sing. Most people find
that if they practice a ‘surprise breath,’ they easily learn how to quickly take air in.
Just gasp as in shock and open your throat as you do so, in order to make a quick and
silent breath.
Planned
Breathing between phrases can be a challenge, whether the song is fast or slow. Fast
songs tend to require quicker, shallower breaths and slow ones tend to require
deeper breaths that take a bit more time. Either way, you will need to steel time
from the ends of phrases in order to start each new phrase on time.