Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 5400160637227631067 PDF
2 5400160637227631067 PDF
DOI 10.1007/s00276-016-1629-6
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
123
Surg Radiol Anat
hypothesis, maybe some anatomical variations change or from the ENT Department, in a secondary care unit, for
reinforce the increasing tendency of tinnitus or the per- temporal bone CT between September 2014 and May 2015.
ception of tinnitus. Among them, patients with a tinnitus complaint were
Imaging aims to find out a potentially treatable etiology extracted for further analysis of their CT scans by three
in tinnitus patients. In pulsatile tinnitus patients, which experienced radiologists (BK, NY, GG). Patients with prior
constitute 1 % of all tinnitus group, some vascular or ear surgery, acoustic schwannoma, meningioma, a history
anatomic variations also have been detected in temporal of or findings of otitis media, hearing loss, and other pos-
bone computed tomography (CT), including jugular bulb sible causes of tinnitus (otosclerosis, hypertension, diabetes
anomalies (jugular vein asymmetry, a high jugular bulb, a mellitus, anxiety, depression, ototoxic medications, etc.)
dehiscent jugular bulb [1], an aberrant internal carotid were excluded. A total of 70 patients met the inclusion
artery (ICA), dehiscent carotid canal [1], sigmoid sinus criteria and the type and localization of tinnitus were noted
(SS) dehiscence/diverticulum [5–7] or petrous bone for each. As a control group, an additional 70 patients were
pneumatization (PBP) [8]. selected from consecutive paranasal sinus CT scans cov-
In daily head and neck radiology practice, we come ering the temporal bone without any otological, clinical, or
across varying grades of bulging of the SS. Laterally swing radiological findings. Ethical approval of the study was
of SS has a closer contact with posterior mastoid cells obtained from the ethics committee of our institution.
while medial swing of SS leads proximity to the semicir-
cular canal and endolymphatic sac [9]. CT examination protocol
The skull of the posterior fossa hosts many valveless
veins passing through calvarial apertures for the drainage Temporal bone CT studies without a contrast agent were
of the posterior fossa sinuses. Mastoid emissary vein obtained using a 64 detector-row scanner (LightSpeed
(MEV) is one of them, which connects SS to the posterior VCT, GE Medical Systems, Milwaukee, WI, USA) with a
auricular or occipital vein via the mastoid foramen. The standard temporal bone CT protocol, a setting tube voltage
diameter and number of MEV vary from patient to patient of 130 kVp, a tube current of 100–350 mA, a slice thick-
[10]. MEV enlargement was presented as a cause of pul- ness 0.625 mm, a reconstruction increment 1 mm, a scan
satile tinnitus in two distinct cases in the literature [11–13]. field of view (FOV) of 25 cm and a matrix of 512 9 512
As far as we know, the occurrence and significance of with high-resolution bone algorithm. Coronal reformatted
MEV and the bulging SS through the posterior mastoid images were created from isometric axial volume data.
have not been detected. Paranasal sinus CT studies were obtained from the same
The main goal of this study was to reveal any associa- scanner without a contrast agent.
tion between the grade of SS bulging and MEV enlarge-
ment in patients with tinnitus. The secondary goal was to Image evaluation and analysis
ascertain the incidence and significance of vascular
abnormalities in these patients. Images were retrospectively evaluated by a consensus of
We retrospectively analyzed the temporal bone CT of three experienced professionals. Images were reviewed for
patients presenting with tinnitus to determine the grade of finding those where tinnitus was previously attributed: SS
the bulging SS into the posterior mastoid by measuring the dehiscence/diverticulum, high jugular bulb, dehiscent
diameter of the SS curve. We also compared the diameter jugular bulb, aberrant ICA, carotid canal dehiscence, and
of MEV between patients with or without tinnitus. We also PBP.
detected CT findings on temporal bone of those whowere A high riding jugular bulb was defined as the position of
previously associated with tinnitus, such as the asymmetric the upper jugular vein (jugular bulb) being higher than the
jugular vein, SS dehiscence/diverticulum, the high jugular floor of the internal acoustic canal level [9]. A dehiscent
bulb, the dehiscent jugular bulb, the aberrant ICA, carotid jugular bulb was defined as the absence of dense bony
canal dehiscence and PBP. We then compared the inci- septa between the tympanic cavity and the jugular bulb [9].
dence of all these entities with a control group. ICA dehiscence was defined as a lack of cortical cov-
ering of the internal carotid artery in the horizontal portion
of the petrous carotid canal segment near to the petrous
Materials and methods bone [14]. The asymmetric jugular vein and transverse
sinus were defined as being a unilaterally larger internal
Patient population jugular vein in continuity with a transverse sinus [15]. PBP
was determined as the air density within the anterior part of
In this study, we retrospectively browsed medical reports the petrous bone accepting the anterior wall of the ICA as
of patients who were referred to the Radiology Department an imaginary oblique border line [8]. SS dehiscence was
123
Surg Radiol Anat
Statistical analysis
Fig. 2 Mastoid emissary vein enlargement on right side in a 40-year-
We performed all statistical analyses using SPSS statistics old male with left sided tinnitus
22 (IBM, Armonk/NY, USA). In our cohort, the Mann–
Whitney U test and Pearson correlation analysis were
performed. p values below 0.05 were considered mean age of 42.1. Gender distribution in the tinnitus group
significant. was 36 (51.4 %) male and 34 (48.6 %) female; in control
group the distribution was 45 (64.3 %) male and 25
(35.7 %) female. The ‘‘side’’ of tinnitus was left in 40 %,
Results right in 32.9 %, and bilateral in 27.1 % of patients. The
type of tinnitus was subjective and nonpulsatile overall.
This study consisted of 70 tinnitus and 70 control The frequencies of the appearance of the asymmetric
patients—a total of 140 patients overall. The age distri- jugular vein, the high riding jugular bulb, jugular vein
bution of all the patients ranged from 10 to 73 years with a dehiscence, PBP, MEV enlargement are demonstrated in
Table 1.
The mean MEV widths in the whole group were
2.32 ± 0.79 mm on the right side and 2.23 ± 0.76 mm on
the left; in the control group 2.28 ± 0.76 mm on the right
side and 1.96 ± 0.58 mm on the left; in the tinnitus group
2.34 ± 0.82 mm on the right side and 2.36 ± 0.81 mm on
the left. MEV diameters and SS curve mean diameters are
shown in Table 2. In both the tinnitus patient group and the
control group, there was no evidence of SS
dehiscence/diverticulum.
The gender balance was the same in each group;
however, the average age in the control group was
younger than that of the tinnitus group. No significant
difference was noted between the two groups in terms of
jugular vein asymmetry, the diameters of SS curve on
each side, and the diameters of MEV on the right side
(Table 2). The diameters of MEV on the left side were
significantly higher in the tinnitus patient group than in
the control group.
Carotid canal dehiscence was significantly higher in the
tinnitus group (p = 0.043). High riding jugular bulbs were
Fig. 1 Displaying measurement of sigmoid sinus bulging; dashed
line indicates borders of the curve on the bone. Thick yellow line is detected more frequently in patient group (p = 0.005).
depth of curve on mastoid bone (color figure online) PBP was not significantly strong, but it was lower in the
123
Surg Radiol Anat
MEV (mm) 2.36 ± 0.82 2.34 ± 0.81 2.28 ± 0.76 1.96 ± 0.58
SS curve (mm) 6.32 5.02 5.88 4.99
MEV mastoid emissary vein, SS sigmoid sinus
tinnitus patient group than in the control group tinnitus compromise some neural theories, including
(p = 0.049). spontaneous firing of neurons due to temporal synchrony
Tinnitus was present on the left side more frequently in [2]. Different types of tinnitus may be explained by dif-
older patients according to the correlation analyses ferent mechanisms in the ear or the brain [2]. We have the
[rho(r) 0.299; p = 0.012]. There were four female tinnitus hypothesis that in some tinnitus patients, blood flow within
patients with carotid canal dehiscence; two were on the left the vessels around the temporal bone, including mastoid or
side and two were bilateral. The left asymmetric jugular temporal parts, may increase the perception of tinnitus
vein was correlated with left-sided tinnitus (r 0.254; even in nonpulsatile forms. In this study, we evaluated
p = 0.034). The side of tinnitus and the asymmetric tinnitus patients to assess if there was any association with
jugular vein were correlated (r 0.254; p = 0.034). vascular abnormalities of the temporal bone in CT, which
have been mentioned before as a cause of pulsatile tinnitus.
To the best of our knowledge, any study was held inter-
Discussion esting in all these vascular abnormalities previously related
pulsatile tinnitus, including asymmetric jugular vein, high
This study has demonstrated that in the nonpulsatile tin- riding jugular bulbus, dehiscent jugular bulbus, aberrant
nitus patient group with unexplained etiology, some vas- ICA, carotid canal dehiscence, SS diverticulum/
cular variations of the temporal bone, previously dehiscence.
mentioned as causes of pulsatile tinnitus, had a higher An asymmetric jugular vein is a vascular variation,
incidence than in the control group. In addition, MEV which commonly exists on the right side, apart from
enlargement, which has been previously associated with pathologic conditions such as dural arteriovenous fistulas
pulsatile tinnitus in the literature [10–13] was compared to and is accepted as being asymptomatic [1]. In our study,
the control group in our study. Left-sided MEV enlarge- although the frequency of dilation of the asymmetric
ment was significantly higher in the tinnitus patient group jugular vein did not differ between the tinnitus patient
(p = 0.029). We also evaluated PBP, which has been group (right side 26.4 %) and the control group (right side
suggested previously as an underlying cause of pulsatile 23.6 %), the existence of left asymmetric jugular vein
tinnitus. Our results demonstrated a significant lower fre- dilatation was well correlated in patients with left-sided
quency of PBP, which is contrary to previous results [8]. tinnitus (p \ 0.05). In older patients, asymmetric jugular
The quantification of SS bulging into the mastoid bone by vein dilation was seen more frequently on the left side.
measuring the SS curve (Fig. 1) revealed an insignificant Jugular bulb anomalies have been stated among the causes
change between the groups in the current study. of pulsatile tinnitus [1]. The incidence of a high riding
Tinnitus is a very complex symptom and has a hetero- jugular bulb in the normal population was reported as
geneous etiology. Pathophysiological mechanisms of 6–28 % and the incidence of a dehiscent jugular bulb
123
Surg Radiol Anat
Fig. 3 High riding jugular bulb (arrow) is visible at mid portion level
of internal acoustic canal in a 44-year-old men with right sided
tinnitus
123
Surg Radiol Anat
MEV has a bidirectional flow, displaying the compensatory Acknowledgments The article is not supported by any
role between intracranial and extracranial vasculature. As organizations.
far as we know, the relationship between tinnitus and MEV
has not been studied except for case reports [5, 11–13]. In
References
the current study, for the first time, we compared the
incidence of MEV enlargement between a nonpulsatile 1. Davis A, El Rafaie A (2000) Epidemiology of tinnitus. In: Tyler
tinnitus group and a control group. In the literature, RS (ed) Tinnitus hand book. Singular, Thompson Learning, San
diameters of MEVs range from 1.1 to 5.6 mm (with a Diego, pp 1–23
median of 3.5 mm) and 60 % of patients had MEV smaller 2. Baguley D, McFerran D, Hall D (2013) Tinnitus. Lancet
382(9904):1600–1607
than 2 mm [11, 12]. In this study, we accepted MEV larger 3. Nondahl DM, Cruickshanks KJ, Huang G-H et al (2011) Tinnitus
than 1.5 mm as enlargement. Accordingly, left MEV and its risk factors in the Beaver Dam offspring study. Int J
enlargement was correlated with age and was mostly seen Audiol 50:313–320
in older patients (r = -2.90; p \ 0.05). Right MEV 4. Madani G, Connor SE (2009) Imaging in pulsatile tinnitus. Clin
Radiol 64:319–328
enlargement was common in patients with jugular vein 5. Zhao P, Lv H, Dong C, Niu Y, Xian J, Wang Z (2016) CT
asymmetry on the left, thus explaining the compensation of evaluation of sigmoid plate dehiscence causing pulsatile tinnitus.
contralateral dural sinus drainage by MEV. On the left Eur Radiol 26(1):9–14
side, MEV enlargement was significantly higher in the 6. Grewal AK, Kim HY, Comstock RH, Berkowitz F, Kim HJ, Jay
AK (2014) Clinical presentation and imaging findings in patients
tinnitus patient group compared with the control group with pulsatile tinnitus and sigmoid sinus diverticulum/dehis-
(p = 0.029). cence. Otol Neurotol 35(1):16–21
There are some limitations in our study. First, our study 7. Zhaohui L, Cheng D, Xiao W, Xiaoyi H, Pengfei Z, Han L, Qing
population was not composed of pulsatile tinnitus patients L, Zhenchang W (2015) Association between idiopathic
intracranial hypertension and sigmoid sinus dehiscence/divertic-
probably due to lower number of patients in study group ulum with pulsatile tinnitus: a retrospective imaging study.
extracted from secondary care unite. Pulsatile tinnitus Neuroradiology (Epub ahead of print)
patients are known to be the patient group who reveal bony 8. Sözen E, Çelebi I, Uçal YO, Coşkun BU (2013) Is there a rela-
variations including SS dehiscence or/diverticulum some tionship between subjective pulsatile tinnitus and petrous bone
pneumatization? J Craniofac Surg 24(2):461–463
of which can be reconstructed surgically. In a recent study 9. Schuknecht HR (1993) Pathology of the ear, 2nd edn. Lea and
by Zhao et al. they found out that some anatomic changes Febiger, Philadelphia
including dominant venous flow, high jugular bulbus, 10. Chauhan NS, Sharma YP, Bhagra T, Sud B (2011) Persistence of
transverse sinus stenosis and intracranial hypertension were multiple emissary veins of posterior fossa with unusual origin of
left petrosquamosal sinus from mastoid emissary. Surg Radiol
more frequent in pulsatile tinnitus side, and suggested that Anat 33(9):827–831
they should participate the perception of pulsatile tinnitus 11. Forte V, Turner A, Liu P (1989) Objective tinnitus associated
[5]. They compared pulsatile tinnitus patients with healthy with abnormal mastoid emissary vein. J Otolaryngol 18:232–235
controls in their study [5]. Large series are needed to 12. Lambert PR, Cantrell RW (1986) Objective tinnitus in associa-
tion with an abnormal posterior condylar emissary vein. Am J
compare both pulsatile and nonpulsatile tinnitus with Otol 7:204–207
healthy controls. Second, this is a retrospective study; 13. Lee SH, Kim SS, Sung KY, Nam EC (2013) Pulsatile tinnitus
medical records were obtained from the hospital informa- caused by a dilated mastoid emissary vein. J Korean Med Sci
tion system. Third, the control group was not age matched. 28(4):628–630
14. Lo WWM, Solti-Bohman LG, McElveen JT (1985) Aberrant
Fourth, the control group was selected from patients who carotid artery: radiologic diagnosis with emphasis on high-reso-
had paranasal sinus CT performed, which acted as an lution computed tomography. RadioGraphics 5:985–993
internal bias during interpretation of images. 15. Dietz RR, Davis WL, Harnsberger HR, JacobsJM Blatter DD
(1994) MR imaging and MR angiography in the evaluation of
pulsatile tinnitus. Am J Neuroradiol 15:879–889
16. Eisenman DJ (2011) Sinus wall reconstruction for sigmoid sinus
Conclusion diverticulum and dehiscence: a standardized surgical procedure for
a range of radiographic findings. Otol Neurotol 32(7):1116–1119
According to the results of the current study, patients com- 17. Pekçevik Y, Pekçevik R (2014) Why should we report posterior
fossa emissary veins? Diagn Interv Radiol 20(1):78–81
plained of subjective nonpulsatile tinnitus with unknown 18. Krishnan A, Mattox DE, Fountain AJ et al (2006) CT arteriog-
etiology, some temporal bone vascular variations, including raphy and venography in pulsatile tinnitus: preliminary results.
a high riding jugular bulb, dehiscent carotid canal, left-sided AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 27:1635–1683
MEV enlargement and PBP as a nonvascular variation, 19. Remley KB, Coit WE, Harnsberger HR et al (1990) Pulsatile
tinnitus and the vascular tympanic membrane: CT, MR, and
seemed to have an association with tinnitus. Further studies angiographic findings. Radiology 174:383–389
comparing all of these entities between pulsatile and non- 20. Sonmez G, Basekim CC, Ozturk E et al (2007) Imaging of pul-
pulsatile groups and healthy controls are needed. satile tinnitus: a review of 74 patients. Clin Imaging 31:102–108
123
Surg Radiol Anat
21. Henriksen SD, KindtMW Pedersen CB et al (2000) Pseudoa- 24. Schoeff S, Nicholas B, Mukherjee S, Kesser BW (2014) Imaging
neurysm of lateral internal carotid artery in the middle ear. Int J prevalence of sigmoid sinus dehiscence among patients with and
Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 52(2):163–167 without pulsatile tinnitus. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 150(5):
22. Jen A, Sanelli PC, Banthia V et al (2004) Relationship of petrous 841–846
temporal bone pneumatization to the eustachian tube lumen. 25. Gologorsky Y, Meyer SA, Post AF, Winn HR, Patel AB, Bed-
Laryngoscope 114(4):656–660 erson JBD (2009) Novel surgical treatment of a transverse-sig-
23. Virapongse C, Sarwar M, Bhimani S et al (1985) Computed moid sinus aneurysm presenting as pulsatile tinnitus: technical
tomography of temporal bone pneumatization: 1. Normal pattern case report. Neurosurgery 64(2):E393–E394 (discussion E394)
and morphology. Am J Roentgenol 145(3):473–481
123