6 cooling systems f
‘@
of the past INTERNATIONAL
Pere at ea uitlas
become very
primitive when
adapted to
today’s modern
7 bE)
engines...
Electric Fan's technology
leader Roger Clemente
has new ideas for
“cooling off” modern
heat producers.
e International Review of
dustrial Vehicle Design
+ See page 188
Reprinted from a feature article in
IVT '98 (Industrial Vehicle Technology)
Magazine.INDUSTRIAL VEHICLE TECHNOLOGY ’98
Cooling
concepts
on the horizon
Modern off-highway vehicles place an overwhelming demand for
advanced design cooling systems that can ensure maximum
operating efficiency. Such complex systems must be able to
effectively cool a number of different fluids. The use of electric
and hydrat
fan assemblies on traditional heat exchangers
will provide an effective alternative in the design of cooling
‘systems that will reduce noise and emissions and increase
overall performance
Roger Clemente
he cooling systems ofthe past
‘become very primitive when adapted
to toay’s modem engines, since
anufacturers are now required 10
design complicated cooling systems to control
the temperature of many figs, including
water, of freon, charged airand even diesel
fuel Such sophisticated cooling requirements
n Engineenng, USA
can phe an overwhelming demand on all ypes
lof eleven fan ystems, including on/off
assembles, since they can consume up (0 15,
pet cent of the engine's avaiable horsepower
‘when operating at high peak loads
Another drawback that they reduce
‘overall performance and efficiency, because
such fn assemblies have great dificuly in
correctly monitoring and maintaining the
‘multiple operating temperature levels of
radiator when combined with the many other
diferent rypes of heat exchangers necessary’ to
support other engine functions. Obviously
each assembly has ts own unigue cooling
requirements For example, a airconditioning
‘condenser may requir fn operation wile
other systems do not. It sno longer practical
to use a singe fan system to property coo! an
assortment of heat exchangers that are
grouped together.
For many years, these traditional systems
found on both stationary and mobile applicINDUSTRIAL VEHICLE TECHNOLOGY ’98
These assembles, which operate only when,
necessary, from the 12 oF 24V electrical sy-
tem, have proven their mei inthe aftermae
ket and are now rapidly gaining gecogntion
from various manufacturer,
The advantages of electric fs ae
‘numerous, When wsed on many-aixlary
applications, elec fans can provide
auditional allow to prevent overheating
supplement the existing beitdriven fan as
‘new means to control unacceptable noise
levels and ai in the redesign ofthe engine
ccompartnent by relocating heat exchangers,
(On select primary cooling applications
lect fans with an adequate capacity may
Ee oe ako be used 10 replace the conventional belt
tions have remained virally system (Figure 2). Moston toad vehicles
unchanged and are now considered to that benefit from ram aircooling can
be very ineficient anda costly compo accept such modifications provided
they have engines under 400hp and that
the temperiture levels fall appropri
systems, including wate, oi and charged
‘ent 9 mainttn, More importantly
they restrict the overall design ofthe
vehicle of machine since the fin must
be attache! direct tothe engine
Heltrven fn systems, commonly
alr, a5 well as airconditioning head
pressure are monitored. In addition, other
types of offhighway or stationary vehicles
‘with engines up to 100hp can be adapted
found on mos mobile appa
fnchading on-oad vehicles, are required
‘only $10 10 percent ofthe time when
tormake use of electric fans for primary
cooling provided they have adequate
aero capcty, since ach fan con
fding, moving at slow speeds or cim’>
fing step grades. A other times, the for
‘ward movement ofthe vehicle at
sponds in exces of 2030mph iy Gage ee dai be us aie
mate eter
sow hough
prope opera emperre On
fol installations rely on many ential
torto maintain factors including gross vehicle weight
and proper raitor core size
Going hydraulic
Hydraulic fans are designed for extremely
ital cooling applications that are
‘commonly found on both stationary and
and industal applications they create
puckaging restrictions, which may
result in noise abatement issues.
Recent product developments
will provide OEMs with several new offhighway vehicles (Figures 4 and 5)
(On sich installations, the conventional ele
methods to ad design of complex
cooling systems. The combination of system on engines in exces of 1,000
sophisticated electsc o hydrate an Figure 2: Dual 21in diameter turbine electri fan can easily be replaced with hyaic fans
technology with elated heat exchanger is ‘ even although they do noc bene fom ram
conpoosas willuimayadibe engineer HI Olectric siecooting
in developing the necessary high performance The availabilty ofbtery operated electric Fundamental, this replacement will
Pacag oth TW atet were at fans ranging in size up to 30in in dkamerer with surpass previous orignal equipment
lengesand act new goals and andards forthe alow ratings in excess of 1,000efm can standards since it provides an improved
Necniery ws improve existing designs on many airy Peaee et ian eagetace tees
and primary cooling applications (Figure 1) remote mounting of hea exchangers, id
About Electric Fan Engineering ee eS
"Beco Fan Engineering was founded by Roger Cements in 1972. has become a leader provide more ai fow tana conventional
inponeeng and developing numerous patented coding component, whic include ‘ye, sce the speed ofthe fn can be
talte-operate turin elect fans, hyeralicaly ven ure yeu fae andthe
thera rxourmer/ertr ffl tanalor tan aon Ie ecegion or many
ius tats cling
1 Tha hat parte ts 03 shaped leone for cooling atonctbe egies
Pibvowiellis usec tstiw ste fate cod rest nen
Secestly developed end peered te tune hyrau tan gystem for heavy duty cooking
reeds
The fest to perfect and pant th use of turin electric an for onsoad tucks;
+ Amajr coneutant and supper to many Fortune 500 OEMs in adon tothe US mit
‘Tha nowtor ofthe ptarted thrral max wanrerwiner eet tanetreytem io conta the
Sea eie eerciloral of eel ck
«The only wore manufac oof larglamete 12 and 24 cootng tn
Figure 3: Battry-operated electric fan@
Figure 4 Turbine hydraulic fan assembly
ajusted by selecting the appropriate pump
and motor combination
‘On/off hydraulic fn assemblies have an
‘enginesdeven pump that energize a fn motor
‘when necessary The pump maybe bet driven,
tached w the accessory drive or have an elec
tre clutch mounted tot (Figure 8). The on/off
‘operation ofthe pump circuit ean be con
INDUSTRIAL VEHICLE TECHNOLOGY “98,
trl na uber of 29. The spl are
elect contol aves between the pump and
fam ora patented method that hasan lecc
tlc drety mounted tthe pnp. Ala
redetemined temperature the ist assembly
{pens solenoid valve enegzng the fn
tac a cont, the cod oem
geste chch wen nce, ring
the pump a openeoc, which inn enenpaes
the moor forthe fn, When a lower tempers:
ture reached signal sent oth systems
Stopping the fn, The ote cach pee
prefered been redncessinanance coms
thc nc component of the pomp tte
snip when neces
Depending onthe quantity, the economics
ofa pial yal em for 00h
tine sstem canbe very vorbl snc the
ost of major components approximately
‘st630,
2 mamacurer can combine elec or
yt a wth many flere ype of
tar exchngers owing engineer 12
cay eshapea vehicles tue by remote
touting sch semble ay fom
Congest ore to erative postions
Multifunctional heat
exchangers
om ype ofa (wed war fo
ple hae diferent cooing quirements. On
{pecia appliations,aiinctiona hex
repens ny be rege weet monitor
the prefened year round tempest vel
of ld Diesel for sane, tbe
heated inthe winter and cooled dng the
summer asa mens conto press,
Gop scan densty, which ar al ctl
Figure 8: Schematic showing turbine hydraulic fan operation
Figure 6: Thermal max summer/winter heat
transfer system
factor in governing emissions and engine
performance. In certain instances, the use of
climate controled ai produced by a vehicle
eating/airconditioning system wil allow an
assembly to do both.
‘One patented mulifunctional system
igure 6 curently svalale operates in the
following manger. A remote mount heat
‘exchanger is connected by ductwork t0 a
vehicle's cab compartment. As diese fuels