Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Guy Fawkes Night: 1 Origins and History in England
Guy Fawkes Night: 1 Origins and History in England
Guy Fawkes Night: 1 Origins and History in England
“Fifth of November” redirects here. For the date, see 5 large organised events, centred on a bonfire and extrav-
November. agant firework displays.
Guy Fawkes Night, also known as Guy Fawkes Day,
Settlers exported Guy Fawkes Night to overseas colonies,
including some in North America, where it was known
as Pope Day. Those festivities died out with the onset
of the American Revolution. Claims that Guy Fawkes
Night was a Protestant replacement for older customs like
Samhain are disputed, although another old celebration,
Halloween, has lately increased in popularity, and accord-
ing to some writers, may threaten the continued obser-
vance of 5 November.
1
2 1 ORIGINS AND HISTORY IN ENGLAND
ber arrest of Guy Fawkes, caught guarding a cache of son, the future Charles I, married the Catholic Henrietta
explosives placed beneath the House of Lords, James’s Maria of France. Puritans reacted to the marriage
Council allowed the public to celebrate the king’s sur- by issuing a new prayer to warn against rebellion and
vival with bonfires, so long as they were “without any Catholicism, and on 5 November that year, effigies of
danger or disorder”.[1] This made 1605 the first year the pope and the devil were burnt, the earliest such
the plot’s failure was celebrated.[2] The following Jan- report of this practice and the beginning of centuries
uary, days before the surviving conspirators were exe- of tradition.[nb 1][14] During Charles’s reign Gunpowder
cuted, Parliament passed the Observance of 5th Novem- Treason Day became increasingly partisan. Between
ber Act, commonly known as the “Thanksgiving Act”. 1629 and 1640 he ruled without Parliament, and he
It was proposed by a Puritan Member of Parliament, seemed to support Arminianism, regarded by Puritans
Edward Montagu, who suggested that the king’s apparent like Henry Burton as a step toward Catholicism. By 1636,
deliverance by divine intervention deserved some mea- under the leadership of the Arminian Archbishop of Can-
sure of official recognition, and kept 5 November free terbury William Laud, the English church was trying to
as a day of thanksgiving while in theory making atten- use 5 November to denounce all seditious practices, and
dance at Church mandatory.[3] A new form of service was not just popery.[15] Puritans went on the defensive, some
also added to the Church of England's Book of Common pressing for further reformation of the Church.[9]
Prayer, for use on that date.[4]
Little is known about the earliest celebrations. In settle-
ments such as Carlisle, Norwich and Nottingham, corpo-
rations provided music and artillery salutes. Canterbury
celebrated 5 November 1607 with 106 pounds of gun-
powder and 14 pounds of match, and three years later
food and drink was provided for local dignitaries, as well
as music, explosions and a parade by the local militia.
Even less is known of how the occasion was first com-
memorated by the general public, although records indi-
cate that in Protestant Dorchester a sermon was read, the
church bells rung, and bonfires and fireworks lit.[5]
local population; proceedings were concerned more with abolished, and in March 1859 the Anniversary Days Ob-
the settling of old arguments and general mayhem, than servance Act repealed the Observance of 5th Novem-
any historical reminiscences.[33] Similar problems arose ber Act.[40][41][42] As the authorities dealt with the worst
in Exeter, originally the scene of more traditional cele- excesses, public decorum was gradually restored. The
brations. In 1831 an effigy was burnt of the new Bishop sale of fireworks was restricted,[43] and the Guildford
of Exeter Henry Phillpotts, a High Church Anglican and “guys” were neutralized in 1865, although this was too
High Tory who opposed Parliamentary reform, and who late for one constable, who died of his wounds.[37] Vi-
was also suspected of being involved in “creeping pop- olence continued in Exeter for some years, peaking in
ery”. A local ban on fireworks in 1843 was largely ig- 1867, when incensed by rising food prices and banned
nored, and attempts by the authorities to suppress the cel- from firing their customary bonfire, a mob was twice
ebrations resulted in violent protests and several injured in one night driven from Cathedral Close by armed in-
constables.[34] fantry. Further riots occurred in 1879, but there were no
more bonfires in Cathedral Close after 1894.[44][45] Else-
where, sporadic instances of public disorder persisted late
into the 20th century, accompanied by large numbers of
firework-related accidents, but a national Firework Code
and improved public safety has in most cases brought an
end to such things.[46]
Reporting on the same topic, in 2012 the BBC’s Tom de Zealand and Canada.[65] Although initially the com-
Castella concluded: memoration was paid scant attention, the arrest of two
boys caught lighting bonfires on 5 November 1662 in
It’s probably not a case of Bonfire Night de- Boston suggests, in historian James Sharpe’s view, that
cline, but rather a shift in priorities ... there are “an underground tradition of commemorating the Fifth
new trends in the bonfire ritual. Guy Fawkes existed”.[66] In parts of North America it was known as
masks have proved popular and some of the Pope Day, celebrated mainly in colonial New England,
more quirky bonfire societies have replaced the but also as far south as Charleston. In Boston, founded in
Guy with effigies of celebrities in the news – in- 1630 by Puritan settlers led by John Winthrop, an early
cluding Lance Armstrong and Mario Balotelli celebration was held in 1685, the same year that James
– and even politicians. The emphasis has II assumed the throne. Fifty years later, again in Boston,
moved. The bonfire with a Guy on top – in- a local minister wrote “a Great number of people went
deed the whole story of the Gunpowder Plot over to Dorchester neck where at night they made a Great
– has been marginalised. But the spectacle Bonfire and plaid off many fireworks”, although the day
remains. [63] ended in tragedy when “4 young men coming home in
a Canoe were all Drowned.” Ten years later the raucous
celebrations were the cause of considerable annoyance to
Another celebration involving fireworks, the five-day
the upper classes and a special Riot Act was passed, to
Hindu festival of Diwali (normally observed between
prevent “riotous tumultuous and disorderly assemblies of
mid-October and November), in 2010 began on 5
more than three persons, all or any of them armed with
November. This led The Independent to comment on the
Sticks, Clubs or any kind of weapons, or disguised with
similarities between the two, its reporter Kevin Rawlin-
vizards, or painted or discolored faces, on in any man-
son wondering “which fireworks will burn brightest”.[64]
ner disguised, having any kind of imagery or pageantry,
in any street, lane, or place in Boston.” With inadequate
resources, however, Boston’s authorities were powerless
2 In other countries to enforce the Act. In the 1740s gang violence became
common, with groups of Boston residents battling for the
honour of burning the pope’s effigy. But by the mid-
1760s these riots had subsided, and as colonial Amer-
ica moved towards revolution, the class rivalries featured
during Pope Day gave way to anti-British sentiment.[67]
In author Alfred Young’s view, Pope Day provided the
“scaffolding, symbolism, and leadership” for resistance
to the Stamp Act in 1764-1765, forgoing previous gang
rivalries in favour of unified resistance to Britain.[68]
The passage in 1774 of the Quebec Act, which guaran-
teed French Canadians free practice of Catholicism in
the Province of Quebec, provoked complaints from some
Americans that the British were introducing “Popish prin-
ciples and French law”.[69] Such fears were bolstered by
opposition from the Church in Europe to American in-
dependence, threatening a revival of Pope Day.[70] Com-
menting in 1775, George Washington was less than im-
pressed by the thought of any such resurrections, forbid-
ding any under his command from participating:[71]
fence of the general Liberty of America: At [4] Edward L. Bond, Spreading the gospel in colonial Virginia
such a juncture, and in such Circumstances, to (Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, 2005), p. 93
be insulting their Religion, is so monstrous, as
[5] Sharpe 2005, p. 87
not to be suffered or excused; indeed instead of
offering the most remote insult, it is our duty [6] Fraser 2005, p. 352
to address public thanks to these our Brethren,
as to them we are so much indebted for every [7] Sharpe 2005, p. 88
late happy Success over the common Enemy in [8] Sharpe 2005, pp. 88–89
Canada.[72]
[9] Cressy 1992, p. 73
Generally, following Washington’s complaint, American [10] Hutton 2001, pp. 394–395
colonists stopped observing Pope Day, although accord-
ing to The Bostonian Society some citizens of Boston cel- [11] Cressy 1992, pp. 83–84
ebrated it on one final occasion, in 1776.[73] The tradi-
[12] Fraser 2005, pp. 356–357
tion continued in Salem as late as 1817,[74] and was still
observed in Portsmouth, New Hampshire, in 1892.[75] [13] Nicholls, Mark, “The Gunpowder Plot”, Oxford Dictio-
In the late 18th century, effigies of prominent figures nary of National Biography (Oxford University Press), re-
such as two Prime Ministers of Great Britain, the Earl trieved 4 November 2010 (subscription or UK public li-
of Bute and Lord North, and the American traitor Gen- brary membership required)
eral Benedict Arnold, were also burnt.[76] In the 1880s
[14] Sharpe 2005, p. 89
bonfires were still being lit in some New England coastal
towns, although no longer to commemorate the failure [15] Sharpe 2005, p. 90
of the Gunpowder Plot. In the area around New York,
stacks of barrels were burnt on election day eve, which [16] Hutton 2001, p. 395
after 1845 was a Tuesday early in November.[77] [17] Cressy 1992, p. 74
[3] Sharpe 2005, pp. 78–79 [33] Cressy 1992, pp. 76–79
8 4 REFERENCES
[34] Sharpe 2005, pp. 157–159 [64] Rawlinson, Kevin (5 November 2010), Guy Fawkes vs Di-
wali: Battle of Bonfire Night, independent.co.uk, retrieved
[35] Sharpe 2005, pp. 114–115 22 March 2011
[36] Sharpe 2005, pp. 110–111 [65] Sharpe 2005, p. 192
[37] Hutton 2001, p. 401 [66] Sharpe 2005, p. 142
[39] Sharpe 2005, p. 159 [68] Young 1999, pp. 24, 93–94
[62] Cannadine, David (4 November 2005), Halloween v Guy • Fraser, Antonia (2005) [1996], The Gunpowder
Fawkes Day, news.bbc.co.uk, archived from the original Plot, London: Phoenix, ISBN 0-7538-1401-3
on 12 November 2010, retrieved 7 November 2010
• Fuchs, Lawrence H. (1990), The American kalei-
[63] de Castella, Tom (6 November 2012), Has Halloween now doscope: race, ethnicity, and the civic culture, Mid-
dampened Bonfire Night?, bbc.co.uk, retrieved 6 Novem- dletown, Connecticut: Wesleyan University Press,
ber 2012 ISBN 0-8195-6250-5
9
• Hutton, Ronald (2001), The stations of the sun: a Fawkes Day at Fresh Creek, Andros Island, Ba-
history of the ritual year in Britain (reprinted, illus- hamas, Man (Royal Anthropological Institute of
trated ed.), Oxford: Oxford University Press, ISBN Great Britain and Ireland, hosted at jstor.org) 58:
0-19-285448-8 114–115, JSTOR 2796328
• Kaufman, Jason Andrew (2009), The origins of • A short history of Guy Fawkes celebrations: Ether-
Canadian and American political differences, Mas- ington, Jim (1993), Lewes Bonfire Night, Seaford:
sachusetts: Harvard University Press, ISBN 0-674- SB Publications, ISBN 1-85770-050-3
03136-9
• Gardiner, Samuel Rawson (2009), History of Eng-
• Opie, Iona and Peter (1961), The Language and land from the Accession of James I. to the Outbreak
Lore of Schoolchildren, Oxford: Clarendon Press of the Civil War 1603–1642 (8), BiblioBazaar, LLC,
ISBN 1-115-26650-0
• Pratt, Lynda (2006), Robert Southey and the contexts
of English Romanticism, Hampshire: Ashgate Pub- • An online newspaper report bemoaning the de-
lishing Ltd, ISBN 0-7546-3046-3 clining popularity of Guy Fawkes effigies in 20th-
century England: Letts, Quentin (5 November
• Rogers, Nicholas (2003), Halloween: From Pagan 2009), Where have all the Guys gone? QUENTIN
Ritual to Party Night, Oxford: Oxford University LETTS'S nostalgia for the fantastic Bonfire Night
Press, ISBN 0-19-516896-8 effigies of yesteryear, dailymail.co.uk, retrieved 11
• Sharpe, J. A. (2005), Remember, remember: a cul- November 2010
tural history of Guy Fawkes Day, London: Harvard
• For comments regarding the observance of the cus-
University Press, ISBN 0-674-01935-0
tom in the Caribbean, see Newall, Venetia (Spring
• Tager, Jack (2001), Boston riots: three centuries of 1975), Black Britain: The Jamaicans and Their
social violence, Lebanon, New Hampshire: Univer- Folklore, Folklore (Taylor & Francis, Ltd. on behalf
sity Press of New England, ISBN 1-55553-461-9 of Folklore Enterprises, Ltd, hosted at jstor.org) 86
(1): 25–41, JSTOR 1259683
• Underdown, David (1987), Revel, riot, and rebellion:
popular politics and culture in England 1603–1660 • A study of the political and social changes that
(reprinted, illustrated ed.), Oxford: Oxford Univer- affected Guy Fawkes Night: Paz, D. G. (1990),
sity Press, ISBN 0-19-285193-4 Bonfire Night in Mid Victorian Northamptonshire:
the Politics of a Popular Revel, Historical Re-
• Young, Alfred F (1999), The shoemaker and the tea search 63 (152): 316–328, doi:10.1111/j.1468-
party memory and the American Revolution, Mas- 2281.1990.tb00892.x
sachusetts: Boston, ISBN 0807071420
6 External links
5 Further reading
• For information on Pope Day as it was observed in
Boston, see 5th of November in Boston, The Bosto-
nian Society
• For information on Bonfires in Newfoundland and
Labrador, see Bonfire Night, collections.mun.ca
• To read further on England’s tradition of Protes-
tant holidays, see Cressy, David (1989), Bonfires
and Bells: National Memory and the Protestant Cal-
endar in Elizabethan and Stuart England, Berkeley:
University of California Press, ISBN 0-520-06940-
4. Cressy covers the same topic in Cressy, David
(1994), “National Memory in Early Modern Eng-
land”, in John R. Gillis, Commemorations – The Pol-
itics of National Identity, Princeton: Princeton Uni-
versity Press, ISBN 0-691-02925-3
• For anecdotal evidence of the origins of Guy Fawkes
Night as celebrated in the Bahamas in the 1950s,
see Crowley, Daniel J. (July 1958), 158. Guy
10 7 TEXT AND IMAGE SOURCES, CONTRIBUTORS, AND LICENSES
7.2 Images
• File:6_november_bonfire_from_flickr_user_sjnikon.jpg Source: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c0/6_
november_bonfire_from_flickr_user_sjnikon.jpg License: CC-BY-2.0 Contributors: http://www.flickr.com/photos/kaisers0ze/
5162928832/ Original artist: SJNikon - Sam Roberts
• File:Calendar_icon.svg Source: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/dd/Calendar_icon.svg License: CC-BY-SA-3.0 Con-
tributors: Transferred from en.wikipedia; transferred to Commons by User:Lvova using CommonsHelper. Original artist: Original uploader
was Vystrix Nexoth at en.wikipedia
7.3 Content license 11