Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chen2007 PDF
Chen2007 PDF
Chen2007 PDF
Abstract
A passive direct methanol fuel cell (DMFC) with its cathode current collector made of porous metal foam was investigated experimentally. The
measured polarization curves, constant-current discharging behavior and EIS spectra showed that the passive DMFC having the porous current
collector yielded much higher and much more stable performance than did the cell having the conventional perforated-plate current collector with
high methanol concentration operation. It was demonstrated that the improved performance for the porous current collector was attributed to: (i)
the enhanced oxygen transport on the cathode as a result of a larger specific transport area, (ii) the increased operating temperature as a result of
the lower effective thermal conductivity of the porous structure, and (iii) the faster water removal as a result of the capillary action in the porous
structure, The experimental results also revealed that the porous current collector with a smaller pore size yielded higher performance as a result
of the lower cell resistance.
© 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Fuel cell; Passive DMFC; Metal foam; Effective thermal conductivity; Cell performance; Oxygen transport
1. Introduction and compact systems but also makes it possible to eliminate the
parasitic power losses for powering ancillary devices required in
The high energy density of liquid methanol as well as sim- active DMFCs. Because of these advantages, the passive DMFC
ple and compact power systems make the direct methanol fuel has received much more attention. Chen and Yang [10] inves-
cells (DMFC) a promising power source for portable electronic tigated the effect of operating conditions on the power density
devices. Over the past decade, extensive efforts [1–8] have been of an air-breathing DMFC. Liu et al. [11] studied sintered stain-
made to the study of the DMFC with the fuel fed by a liquid less steel fiber felt as the gas diffusion layer in an air-breathing
pump and oxidant fed by a gas compressor. In order to make the DMFC. The effect of methanol concentration was also studied
DMFC more competitive with conventional battery technolo- in this work. Kim et al. [12] fabricated and tested a single cell
gies, however, it is essential to eliminate some auxiliary devices and monopolar DMFC stack operating under passive and air-
such as liquid pumps and gas fans/blowers so that the overall breathing conditions. Shimizu et al. [13] reported their activities
DMFC system becomes much simpler and much more com- regarding the research and development of DMFCs that oper-
pact. For this reason, the concept of a passive DMFC without ated passively at room temperature. Park et al. [15] reported the
external pumps and other ancillary devices has been proposed optimal methanol solution appeared at 4.0 M in passive DMFCs.
and studied [9–18]. A typical passive-feed DMFC consists of a Kho et al. [17] investigated the variation in the open circuit volt-
fuel reservoir, an anode current collector, a membrane electrode age (OCV) and the cell temperature with time as a consequence
assembly (MEA), and a cathode current collector. Methanol is of the methanol crossover.
introduced to the active layer primarily by diffusion without any The previous studies have indicated that the passive DMFC
external means of liquid transport and oxygen is taken passively usually has to be operated with higher methanol concentration,
from the ambient air without any means of air movement. This as the methanol transport from a built-in fuel reservoir to the
type of passive DMFCs not only offers the advantage of simple anode catalyst layer in this type of passive fuel cell relies on
diffusion. Since there is plenty of room up to pure methanol,
methanol transport on the anode is actually not a problem.
∗ Corresponding author. Tel.: +852 2358 8647; fax: +852 2358 1543. Rather, higher methanol concentration offers the advantage of
E-mail address: metzhao@ust.hk (T.S. Zhao). increasing the energy density of the fuel cell, provided that the
0013-4686/$ – see front matter © 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.electacta.2006.12.015
4318 R. Chen, T.S. Zhao / Electrochimica Acta 52 (2007) 4317–4324
rate of methanol crossover can effectively be reduced. In con- As a consequence, the cell having this type of porous current
trast, the problem of mass transport of oxygen and water on collector yielded significantly higher performance and much
the cathode is more challenging, as this type of fuel cell oper- more stable operation than did the cell having the conventional
ates on the air-breathing mode and there is no external means perforated-plate current collector.
to enhance oxygen transport and water removal. As a result, the
passive fuel cell frequently operates under the oxygen-starving 2. Experimental
and water-flooding conditions. In addition, it was recently found
that passive DMFCs operate at near room temperature and it 2.1. Membrane and electrode assembly (MEA)
is important to increase the cell operating temperature so that
electrochemical kinetics of both methanol oxidation and oxy- A pretreated Nafion 115 membrane with a thickness of
gen reduction reactions can be improved [18,19]. In summary, 125 m was employed in this work. The pretreatment proce-
on the constraint without any external means of air movement, it dures included boiling the membrane in 5 vol.% H2 O2 , washing
is critical to design and optimize the architecture of the passive in DI water, boiling in 0.5 M H2 SO4 and washing in DI water for
DMFC to ensure higher oxygen transfer and water removal rates 1 h in turn. The pretreated membranes were kept in the DI water
as well as a higher cell operating temperature. prior to the fabrication of MEAs. Single-side ELAT electrodes
The cathode current collector is one of the key components from ETEK were used in both anode and cathode, where carbon
of the passive DMFC, which not only collects the electric cur- cloth (E-TEK, Type A) were used as the backing support layer
rent but also offers the passages for oxygen and water transport. with 30 wt% PTFE wet-proofing treatment. The catalyst load-
Furthermore, since in the passive DMFC, the heat generated ing on the anode side was 4.0 mg/cm2 with PtRu black (1:1 a/o),
within the cell is predominately lost from the cathode current while the catalyst loading on the cathode side was 2.0 mg/cm2
collector, it is essential to employ a material with low effective using 40 wt% Pt on Vulcan XC-72. Furthermore, 0.8 mg/cm2 dry
thermal conductivity as the cathode current collector such that Nafion® ionomer was coated onto the surface of each electrode.
the heat loss can be lowered and the cell can be operated at a Finally, MEA with an active area of 4.0 cm2 were fabricated
higher temperature to achieve better performance. Therefore, in by hot pressing at 135 ◦ C and 4 MPa for 3.0 min. More detailed
the passive DMFC, the cathode current collector must have high information about the MEA fabrication can be found elsewhere
electric conductivity, good mechanical strength, more uniform [20].
transport area and low effective thermal conductivity. In this
work, a passive DMFC with its cathode current collector made 2.2. Single cell fixture
of porous metal foam was investigated experimentally. We show
that this type of porous current collector can not only provide a As shown in Fig. 1, the MEA mentioned above was sand-
higher oxygen transfer rate and a more effective water removal wiched between an anode and a cathode current collector. The
rate, but also can render a higher cell operating temperature. entire cell setup was then held together between an anode and a
cathode fixture, both of which were made of transparent organic collectors, as shown in Fig. 2, were fabricated and tested. One
glass. A 5.0 mL methanol solution reservoir was built in the was the conventional perforated-plate current collector made
anode fixture. Methanol was transferred into the catalyst layer of a 316L stainless steel plate, while the other was the porous
from the built-in reservoir, while oxygen, from the surrounding current collector made of a Ni–Cr alloy metal foam plate of
air, was transferred into the cathode catalyst layer through the 1.0 mm in thickness. The Ni–Cr alloy metal foam supplied by
opening of the cathode fixture. The cell temperature was mea- the RECEMAT® International offers over 95% porosity and
sured by a thermocouple (Type T), which was installed on the the estimated average pore diameter of 0.4 mm. A plurality of
outer surface of the anode gas diffusion layer. The anode cur- 2.6 mm-circular holes was drilled in both the current collectors,
rent collector was made of a perforated 316L stainless steel plate serving as the passages of fuel and oxidant, which resulted in an
of 1.5 mm in thickness. Two different types of cathode current open ratio of 47.8%. A 200 nm platinum layer was sputtered onto
the surface of the perforated-plate and porous current collectors
to reduce the contact resistance with the electrodes.
Fig. 5. Nyquist plots of passive DMFC impedance spectra. Cell voltage: 0.30 V; Fig. 6. Transient discharging voltage at a constant-current density (80 mA cm−2 )
anode: 4.0 M methanol; cathode: room temperature: 22.4 ◦ C, relative humidity: with a start from the cell to be fueled with methanol solutions between different
75%. cathode current collectors. Anode: 4.0 M methanol; cathode: room temperature:
22.6 ◦ C, relative humidity: 71%.
Fig. 7. Comparison in cell operating temperatures at constant-discharging con- Fig. 8. Transient discharging voltage at a constant-current density (80 mA cm−2 )
dition between different cathode current collectors. Anode: 4.0 M methanol; with the active methanol feed between different cathode current collectors.
cathode: room temperature: 22.6 ◦ C, relative humidity: 71%. Temperature: 30 ◦ C; anode: 4.0 M methanol, 1.0 mL min−1 ; cathode: room tem-
perature: 21.8 ◦ C, relative humidity: 63%.
transport in the porous plate as the result of the larger specific discharging voltage at a constant-current density of 80 mA cm−2
mass transfer area and the faster water removal rate due to the between the cell with the porous current collector and the cell
capillary action in such a porous structure. It is also noticed from with the perforated-pate current collector under the condition of
Fig. 6 that the perforated-plate current collector exhibited signif- the cathode air-breathing operation but the active methanol feed
icant fluctuations during the discharge period, mainly because is compared in Fig. 8. It is seen that although the perforated-plate
of the periodic buildup and removal of liquid water in this type current collector yielded higher voltage in the initial period, but
of current collector. In contrast, the cell with the porous current the porous current collector exhibited substantially higher volt-
collector discharged much more stably. ages during the remaining discharge period. This proves that
It should be mentioned that the methanol consumption due the improved performance using the porous current collector is
to the electrochemical reaction and methanol crossover caused a because of the enhanced oxygen transport as a result of the larger
decrease in methanol concentration in the fuel reservoir. There- specific mass transfer area and the faster water removal rate due
fore, the discharging behaviors for both the current collectors to the capillary action in such a porous structure. In addition,
shown in Fig. 6 were actually caused by the combined effect of the comparison between Figs. 6 and 8 indicates that the active
the time-dependent methanol concentration, oxygen transport methanol feed operation yielded much more stable cell perfor-
and cell operating temperature. In order to further demonstrate mance than did the passive operation. This fact indicates that the
the improved performance using the porous current collector was time-dependent methanol concentration is one of the reasons for
due to the enhanced mass transport of oxygen instead of other instability in the passive DMFC. Moreover, it is also clear from
factors, we tested the same DMFC with methanol solution sup- Figs. 6 and 8 that the passive methanol feed operation yielded
plied by a pump while keeping the cathode at the air-breathing much better cell performance than did the active operation. This
operation mode and maintaining a fixed cell operating temper- is because the temperature in the active methanol feed mode was
ature. To this end, the anode current collector for the passive maintained at 30 ◦ C, whereas the operating temperature of the
operation mode was replaced by a current collector made of a passive methanol feed mode was higher. This fact implies that
316L stainless steel plate with a thickness of 1.0 mm, in which the temperature effect is a key factor affecting the performance
a single serpentine flow field, consisting of a flow channel with of the passive DMFC.
a cross-sectional area of 1.0 mm × 1.0 mm, was formed. Simi- In this work, we also tested the passive DMFC using the
larly, to reduce the contact resistance between the anode current porous current collector with and without drilled holes by the
collector and electrode, a 200 nm platinum layer was sputtered long-term operation with a start from the cell to be fueled with
onto the surface of the anode current collector. The methanol 5.0 mL methanol solution at 4.0 M. The cell performance is com-
solution with 4.0 M was supplied with the flow rate controlled pared in Fig. 9. It is seen that the passive DMFC using the porous
by a digital HPLC micro-pump (Series III). To ensure that all current collector without holes showed almost the same perfor-
the experiments were performed with the same mass transfer mance as the cell with drilled holes. This reveals that the porous
rate of methanol and with the same heat removal rate from structure can provide the sufficient oxygen transfer rate in the
the cell by the methanol stream, methanol was supplied at a passive DMFC as a result of a larger specific transport area and
flow rate of 1.0 mL min−1 . The cell operating temperature was the faster water removal rate due to the capillary action in such
controlled at 30 ◦ C by a temperature controller. The transient a porous structure. This fact also indicates that there is no need
R. Chen, T.S. Zhao / Electrochimica Acta 52 (2007) 4317–4324 4323
Acknowledgements
[14] G.G. Park, T.H. Yang, Y.G. Yoon, W.Y. Lee, C.S. Kim, Int. J. Hydrogen [18] J.G. Liu, T.S. Zhao, R. Chen, C.W. Wong, Electrochem. Commun. 7 (2005)
Energy 28 (2003) 645. 288.
[15] J. Han, E.S. Park, J. Power Sources 112 (2002) 477. [19] R. Chen, T.S. Zhao, J. Power Sources 152 (2005) 122.
[16] B.K. Kho, I.H. Oh, S.A. Hong, H.Y. Ha, Electrochim. Acta 50 (2004) 781. [20] H. Yang, T.S. Zhao, Q. Ye, J. Power Sources 139 (2005) 79.
[17] B.K. Kho, B. Bae, M.A. Scibioh, J. Lee, H.Y. Ha, J. Power Sources 142 [21] J.T. Mueller, P.M. Urban, J. Power Sources 75 (1998) 139.
(2005) 50.