Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Comparative Analysis of Abrahamic Religions:Judaism, Christianity and Islamintroduction
Comparative Analysis of Abrahamic Religions:Judaism, Christianity and Islamintroduction
ORIGINS
Judaism, Christianity and Islam were known for being one of the largest religions in
theworld (Largest Religions, 2017). These three religions has been stimulated good,
healthy andmoral behavior for the society and the mankind. Moreover, Judaism,
Christianity and Islam are very closely related in their origins, beliefs and scriptures.
They are also closely related in theirmoral and ethical beliefs, as well as their views of
the individual and social life (The AbrahamicFaith, n.d.), and these religions was
founded Abraham.Abraham became the most influential person in the history. The three
largestmonotheistic religions found their beginnings in him. According to the Genesis
17, Godappeared in front of him and then promise that he will be the father of many
nations. God promised to Abraham, that he will
have a lot of descendants as many as the stars in the sky. Inthe present, over 3 billion
people in the modern world cite Abraham as their "spiritual father" oftheir religion
(Encyclopedia of Biography, 2004).Before God appeared in front of Abraham, he was
originally named as Abram, son ofTerah (Genesis 17:5). Abraham is estimated to have
been born 2,166 years before Jesus in oraround the Mesopotamian, city of Ur
–
modern day Iraq
–
(Mufti, 2015) after which he and hisfamily moved to Harran
–
modern day Israel (Genesis 11:31). Incidentally, Abraham was camefrom a polytheistic
family, who served many gods.
And it was happened that Abraham’s father,
Terah was an idol maker. In the Jewish tradition called
Midrash
(a Hebrew word which means'interpretation' and relates to the way readings or biblical
verses are understood), there are anumber of stories about Abraham smashing his
father's idols when he realises that there can beonly one God of heaven and earth
(Religions, 2009). The Koran tells of a time when Abramconfronts his father about his
idol worship and is condemned to burn in a furnace by
King Nimrod of Babylon, but God protected him (Encyclopedia of Biography, 2004). Abr
ahammarried Sarai, later named as Sarah (Genesis 17:15) and entered a lifelong
partnership with her.By the time that Abraham and family moved to Harran, including
the neighboring countries andcities, was a land devoted to polytheism (Encyclopedia of
Biography, 2004) 4Terah lived 205 years and died in Harran (Genesis 11:32). Then
Abraham and his wife became very wealthy in livestock and silver and gold as they left
their native country and went toCanaan, the promised land of God (Genesis 13:2,
13:14-17). Eventually, Abraham and Sarah aregrowing old, and Abraham asked the
God that who will inherit all the wealth that he got. Godreplied that his son who is his
own flesh and blood shall be his heir (Genesis 15:4). Sarah knewthat she was past the
age where a woman can bear a child, so she suggest and let his husband,Abraham
sleep with her Egyptian slave, Hagar. In accordance with the laws of the time,
femaleslaves were the property of the wife and therefore any children they bore were
also the propertyof their mistress (The First Other Woman, 2016). Hagar bore Abraham
a son, which she namedhim as Ishmael, who according to the Islam and Christians, he
is the ancestors of the Arabs oralso known as the Ishmaelites (Genesis 16). Eventually,
God promised Abraham and Sarah ason, despite of their old ages, and they will name it
Isaac which means “laugh” signifiesAbraham’s joy on having a son
and circumcised him on his eighth day. According to theJudaism, Isaac was the
ancestor of the Jewish people. Thus, the conflict between Arabs and Jewscan be seen
as a form of sibling rivalry (Rich, 2011).
1.1 Origin of Judaism
Isaac was the second son of Abraham, and he was also the subject of the tenth and
mostdifficult test of Abraham's faith. In Islamic interpretation, Ishmael is the son in the
story(Encyclopedia of Biography, 2004). Either way, God commanded Abraham to
sacrifice Isaac (orIshmael) as a burnt offering (Who are the Jews, n.d.), (Genesis 22). In
Jewish tradition, the process that Abraham did to his son, was the
Akeidah
It is founded on the life, teachings,death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ, and those
who fo
llow him are called "Christians”
(Christianity, n.d.).Christianity originated with Jesus of Nazareth, a Jewish prophet and
teacher
who probably came to believe he was the Son of God and certainly was regarded as su
ch by hisdisciples (Guisepi, n.d.). It was the time of Augustus when he preached the
Jewish people ofIsrael. Jesus taught his morality based on love and humility. He is also
considered an important prophet in Muslim tradition and the precursor of Prophet
Muhammad (Violatti, 2013).It was around 40 B.C. to 1 B.C. where Herod was the king
of Judea, the angel of God,Gabriel was sent to the city of Galilee, in Nazareth. Gabriel
visited a virgin named Mary and toldher that she would be conceive a son, that she will
name as Jesus (Luke 1:26-38). According toGabriel, the Holy Spirit will come upon her
and the power of the most high will overshadow her.Mary accepted and the angel left.
This scenario that was happened to Mary was agreed to the
bible verse (John 3:16) which says “
For God so loved the world that he gave his one and onlySon, that whoever believes in
him shall not perish but have eternal life
”
.Jesus was born in a stable, where shepherds visited him. Later, a star guided men
fromthe East to the young child (Birth of Jesus, n.d.). Christians believed that there is a
star came in the middle of the night that led to the wise men to the place where Jesus
was born. According tothe Jewish tradition, when a star came up above the night sky,
they believe that there wasactually a new born king.Jesus was around 30 years old
when he started to preach word in the kingdom of Judea,which the God sent him to do.
Jesus chose 12 men that would help him do his work that later hemade them his
apostles. As Jesus claimed that he is divine, he made a lot of miracles such asfeeding a
thousand of people by just a few small fishes and few loaves of bread, healed the
sickand even raised the dead, and a lot more just to prove that he himself was the
God.Jesus won a lot of followers, mostly the poor, and made them believe that the
Judgment Day
was near, whereby the God will judge all the sinners to the everlasting hell, and reward
whowere righteous with immortality.Initially, Christian converts were Jewish by birth and
followed the basic Jewish law(Weiner, 2017). Jews believes that there will be the
messiah who will come down to earth.
Messiah
came from the Hebrew word meaning the
“Annointed one”
and
Christ
or
Christos
isthe Greek equivalent of it (Messiah, n.d.)
.
MORALITY
It was believed that religions were made for the morality for all the people
emerged.Morality was the basis of the religions. This is why the role of the religions was
to make peaceand mold the mankind into a righteous people based on morals and
ethics. Merriam-WebsterDictionary (n.d.) defined morality as a moral discourse and a
system of moral conduct.Currently, all religions nowadays established on the earth have
their own holy scriptures.Holy scriptures are the sacred texts written over a couple of
decades, collected which made by
people who’s inspired by their supreme deities or gods. Eventually, these Holy S
criptures areused by the adherents of a religion as their source of moral code or
morality. Therefore, Judaism,Christianity and Islam; the Abrahamic Religions has a
morality to follows as well.
1.1 Judaism: TANAKH and Talmud
Judaism doesn’t only have one Holy Scripture that their adherents follow as their moral
code. Moreover, after the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE and the
subsequent exile,sacrifices became impossible and Jewish religious life turned to study
of the scriptures and prayer in the synagogue. Study of Torah and other Jewish texts
has been central to religious lifeever since (ReligionFacts, 2016).The first Holy
Scriptures that Judaism has was the TANAKH, whose name is an acronymof
Torah, Nev’
im
and
Ketuvim
It consists of the same books as the Christian Old Testament,although in a slightly
different order and with other minor differences (ReligionFacts, 2016).
Torah
includes the first five books of the Pentateuch. The
Bereishit
(Genesis),
Shemot
(Exodus),
Vayikra
(Leviticus),
Bambidbar
(Numbers), and the
D’varim
(Deutronomy) (Judaism: Holy Scriptures n.d.). Torah is derived from a root that was
used in the realm of archery or yareh.Yareh means to shoot an arrow in order to hit a
mark. The mark or target, of course, was theobject
is the Holy Scripture used by the Muslims, the adherents of Islam.Muslims claimed that
Quran was the truth and the word of God. According to the Islamic beliefs,Quran was
written by
Allah
–
the God, himself (Radical Truth, 2016) and verbally revealed to theMuhammad through
his Archangel Gabriel. Although Muhammad was an illiterate prophet ofGod, the
revelations on his lifetime was written and collected into one official copy in 633 C.E,one
year after his death and presented in 653 C.E into to the third caliph, Uthman ibn
Affan(New World Encyclopedia, 2016).Quran was the primary source of morality of the
Islam. It deals with all the subjects
which concern human beings: wisdom, doctrine, worship, transactions, law…etc., but its
basic
theme is the relationship between God and His creatures. At the same time, it provides
guidelinesand detailed teachings for a just society, proper human conduct, and an
equitable economicsystem (Splendid Arabia, 2017).Except to the belief that it was
written by Allah, himself, Muslims also believed that itwas a guide to all
Al-muttaqoon
–
which means righteous people or who the people who fear andlove Allah (Surah Al-
Baqarah, Verse 2). Muslims also acknowledge the Jewish and theChristians, as they
also compromise to their Holy books, TANAKH or Old Testament and
the New Testament. However, muslims believes that new versions of the said books wa
s corruptedso that some of the verses in Quran contradicts the teaching of the said holy
books.
PURPOSE
“The Lord works out everything to its purpose…”
–
Proverbs 16:4Everything that has created by God has their own purpose. The objects
that an individualinteracts, those events that people join regularly, the guy that one
person met the other day and alot more phenomena.
There is always an answer to the question “why” therefore, every
thingreally happens for a reason.In a society, every aspect of it has its purpose. The
government was established for therulers to manage their constituents, businesses for
the country to increase the economic growth,education for the people to understand
how society really work and mankind for them to touchthe every aspect. In smaller
scale, an individual has its own purpose. Maybe to met another andget married, and
later on build a family, which is also the smallest unit of the society. In thefamily, the
mother, the father and every member of it has their own purpose. And if happens
thatvery one aspect of it was gone or removed, it will never be the same at all. Same
thing goes whenit comes in religions.Religions have also their own purposes. Although
nowadays, religions with or withoutthe same god, debate on which religion is more
useful and truthful. The main purpose of areligion is to build the moral code among the
people. Its role was to spread the peace and preventviolence. It was the one who
teaches the mankind to be righteous, as for they believe on supremedeities. For
instance, imagine a happy complete family was in an outing and the father suddenly
died. The complete family wasn’t completed at all. It will never be the same family as
it
was before. Eventually, maybe the daughter will have a lifetime effect as she grows into
heradulthood. The same goes with religion. Without religion, or the belief that there is a
divine who watches on how people act whether they make sins or not, a society will
never be in peace anymore, as there is no source of moral code.For every religions
established on earth has their own purposes as well. Moreover, theirown belief system
has been the reason why religions should stand still on the existence of earth.Therefore,
Judaism, Christianity and Islam, the Abrahamic religions have it too.These Abrahamic
Religions have their similarities in terms to their purpose. Although,they are built in
different times and started with different people, the purposes of theseestablished
religions have their common. The underlying common of these religions is
forthemankind to be aware that there is a God who watches them. People need to know
that the human
being is all part of God’s plan, and they need to abide all
of His commandment. Moreover, thesereligions were built as guidance for the humanity
as they teach that a man should worship God.
1.1 Judaism’s Purpose
Judaism was the basis of Christian and Islam religion. Therefore, the purpose of
thisreligion is broad and may also touch the purposes of the other religion (Eron, n.d).
The purposeof Judaism was to let God enter the world of mankind and as they believed
that the world ofmankind was part of his own creation (Genesis 1).According the Jewish
belief, every time they fulfill a Mitzvah -which means command- itcreates an awareness
of God and every time they study Torah, God's presence is manifest inworld (Shapiro,
2017). Moreover, it was part of their belief that whenever they study the Torah,God
accomplished one of his missions for the humanity.
1.2 Christianity’s Purpose
It was believed that the Christian religion was the continuation of the Jewish beliefs.
Itwas started when Jesus was born, as they were believed that He was the Messiah that
the Jewish people waited for a long time. Therefore, Christians also claimed that the
purpose of the Judaismwas also their purpose as well, however, they since there was
an additional to their beliefs whenJesus Christ did his earthly missions.According to the
Christians, they established their religion for them to make discipleshipas what Jesus
Christ did on his earthly missions. The goal of the Christian community is to belike
Christ, as they believe that He is a God and transformed into a righteous man. When
Christ became man and lived on earth, he endured all of the same trials, pains, and per
secutions thatman suffers in order to prove himself as a perfect example for us.
Therefore, one of the primary purposes of Christian discipleship is to emulate the
character of Christ (Following Jesus, 2017).
When Archangel Gabriel visited Muhammad, and verbally recited the word of Allah
tohim, Muhammad started preaching on what he had learned from it and established
the Islamreligion. Islam religion was built as a reminder or guidance to all Muslims, the
adherents ofIslam, the people who believe in Allah
–
the one and only supreme God. It was believed thatIslam religion leads the people to
the straight path to their God."Thee alone we worship; Thee alone we ask for help.
Show us the straight path." (Sura1:5-6, The Holy Qur'an).
DESTINY
The role of the religion is to stop and prevent violence among the people, and
spread peace and let the humanity do righteous things instead by making them believe t
hat there is asupreme deity who watches them and judge all of them. However, most of
the people nowadaysare inspired and motivated to be actively involved in religious
activities by one reason; there reward after life.
Most of the religious beliefs emerged in different religions, believed that their
supreme being promised the humanity a reward after life. This has been the main and
central reason why people do good deeds and righteous works, and religions
stayed upright on the earth. AbrahamicReligions have this belief as well. Some
adherents from any of the Abrahamic religions believedthat the God that was mentioned
from the Holy Scriptures was the same to the God that is
In Judaism belief, the Torah didn’t much focused on what will happen if a human died.
However, because Judaism is primarily focused on life on earth and now rather than on
theafterlife, Judaism does not have much dogma about the afterlife, and leaves a great
deal of room
for personal opinion (Rich, T. 2011). It means it wasn’t literally stat
ed on the Torah on thedestiny that the human being will take if an individual died.
Nevertheless, Torah did mention several times the “gathered to their people” whenever
a
biblical character died, such as Abraham, Ishmael, Isaac, Jacob, Moses and King
Josiah (Genesis25:8, 25:17, 35:29, 49:33, Deuteronomy 32:50, II Kings 22:20). Jewish
tradition believed thatthere was actually a place where God made, intended only for all
the righteous souls, where theywill have their reunion together with their loved ones who
passed away. Furthermore, Torah also
did mentioned “cut off from his people”
where signifies that there was also a place for thewicked souls (Genesis 17:14, Exodus
31:14).Eventually, there are some portions of TANAKH where it was stated about
Olam Ha-ba
.Olam. It was the spiritual afterlife referred to in Hebrew as Olam Ha-Ba (oh-LAHM hah-
BAH), the World to Come, although this term is also used to refer to the messianic age.
The Olam Ha-Ba is another, higher state of being (Rich, T. 2011). In the Mishnah, Rabbi
Yaakov says: "Thisworld is like a lobby before the Olam Ha-Ba. Prepare yourself in the
lobby so that you may enterthe banquet hall." (Pirkei Avot 4:21) (mbloch, 2016). A
particularly righteous person will have agreater share in the Olam Ha-Ba than the
average person. In addition, a person can lose his sharethrough wicked actions (Rich,
T. 2011). It means that only a righteous person who can onlyexperience the Olam-haba
or the messianic age, while the people who are not, they will getnothing and just fade.
Janna (Paradise, Heaven) is called by eight names in the Qur'an: Jannatu al-Khuld,
Darulas-Salam, Darul al-Qarar, Jannatu al-`Adn, J annatu al-Ma`wa, Jannatu an-Na`im,
`Illiyin, and Jan n tu al-Ferdaus. Janna is the Arabic word for "garden (Ontario
Consultants on Religious Tolerance, 2005). Sura 2:82 did mentioned "
But those who have faith and work righteousness, they are companions of the Garden:
Therein shall they abide (For ever)"
it means that only the one who believe on Allah
–
the God, and the people who did righteous works are only the one s who will be
experienced the life afterdeath in Janna.Same as for the Christian beliefs, Muslims have
also believed to the idea of Hell. It wassure unfair if the wicked people or the sinner or
unbelievers of Allah will be treated the same ,and as per Allah, Himself, was there to
welcome the righteous ones (al-Q iya amah 22-23). That’s
why it was believed that Allah made a place for the sinners called
Jahannam.
The idea of the Second Coming of Jesus Christ was similar to idea of
Yawm Al-Quiyama.
It was the day that Muslims believed when all beings will be raised to life again and will
be judged by Allah -the God, himself, and faces their fates,
VIEWS ON WOMEN
Gender is a socially constructed definition of women and men (Swiss Agency, n.d.)
andthe feminism has been a major problem to the culture of religion. Feminism is
aninterdisciplinary approach to issues of equality and equity based on gender, gender
expression,gender identity, sex, and sexuality as understood through social theories
and political activism(EKU, 2016). Women have played an important role in the
development of various religionsaround the world from Hinduism to Christianity, and the
way in which women are treated inreligions such as Islam is still a
n area of debate for many (Women’s Library, 2007)
The relationship of the religion and the feminists is in a complicated way. There has
beenan issue that religions, in terms of women, are considered subordinate to men.
There is no doubtthat the rise in feminism during the second half of the 20th century had
a direct influence on theincreased number of women being allowed to become religious
leaders such as priests and bisho
ps (Women’s Library, 2007).
Submitted by:
HUMSS 11-Perseverance
Submitted to:
Teacher