Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hypertension and The Kidney-An Overview: Eberhard Ritz, MD, FRCP, and Danilo Fliser, MD
Hypertension and The Kidney-An Overview: Eberhard Ritz, MD, FRCP, and Danilo Fliser, MD
Hypertension and The Kidney-An Overview: Eberhard Ritz, MD, FRCP, and Danilo Fliser, MD
• The kidney plays a major role in the genesis of any type of hypertension, as demonstrated by experiments which
show that hypertension can be "transplanted" when the kidney itself is transplanted. Hypertension is common in
patients with renal disease, and may occur even at normal glomerular filtration rates. The mechanisms that promote
hypertension and are involved in renal disease comprise both activation of pressor mechanisms and failure of depressor
mechanisms, the latter having been considerably less well studied. The major pressor mechanisms are an abnormal
pressure-natriuresis relationship and inappropriate activity of the renin-angiotensin system.
© 1993 by the National Kidney Foundation, Inc.
INDEX WORDS: Renal hypertension; renal salt excretion; renin-angiotensin system; medullolipins; nitric oxide.
American Journal of Kidney Diseases, Vol 21, No 6, Suppl 3 (June), 1993: pp 3-9 3
4 RITZ AND FLISER
180
tients with type I diabetes and nephropathy,
higher blood pressures were found in the parents
170 Boys GIrls
of these patients. 12 Furthermore, higher rates of
Na+,Li+-countertransport (a putative marker for
160 primary hypertension) were observed in diabetic
patients with nephropathy compared with those
150 without.
c;
:I:
E
Pursuing a similar line of thought, we mea-
§.
~ 140
sured blood pressure in parents of patients with
~
~
biopsy-confirmed primary chronic glomerulo-
nephritis and parents of matched controls, ie,
i 130
visitors to the emergency department of a surgical
!
CI) clinicY As shown in Table 1, hypertension was
120
of considerably greater prevalence in the parents
of patients with glomerulonephritis, which may
110
indicate that a genetic predisposition to hyper-
tension also may increase the risk of nondiabetic
100 renal disease.
90
WHAT IS THE NORMAL BLOOD PRESSURE
At
presentatIOn
After complete
remiSSion
At
presentation
After complete
remission
FOR A PATIENT WITH A DISEASED KIDNEY?
%lyear
75 R",Q.85
The reasons why the diseased kidney is so
2p=02% uniquely susceptible to even minor increments
in blood pressure are undoubtedly complex. One
50 major mechanism is illustrated in Fig 3. In the
\
Mlcroalbuminuna
diseased kidney preglomerular vessels, including
the afferent arterioles, are dilated and autoregu-
25
lation is lost.' 9 ,20 This implies that a higher pro-
portion of systemic blood pressure will be trans-
125 mitted to the glomerular vascular bed, causing
. 115
glomerular capillary hypertension, which is one
. factor in the initiation and perpetuation of glo-
-25
I 1.0 merular damage.
.. To make an informed choice of antihyperten-
ProteinUria
/
....... ....... vasodilatation
vascular risk at diastolic pressures lower than 70 '...............
mm Hg. Furthermore, Knowler et al 18 studied ...... _--------
diabetic Pima Indians and found that the risk of
retinopathy increased with rising blood pressure,
even in the normotensive range. The weight of
such evidence may force us to redefine the con- Systemic pressure Glomerular pressure
120
THE RENIN-ANGIOTENSIN SYSTEM
t-----------------------t
Oi
J:
E
g
110 The recognition that renin promotes hyper-
~ tension goes back to the classical experiments of
i 100
Tigerstedt and Bergmann and the demonstration
"~ f------------------------~ of its release from the ischemic kidney by Gold-
.
go-
o
~ 80
blatt. However, subtle abnormalities of the renin-
angiotensin system (RAS) have been recognized
50 200
only recently in patients with no gross elevation
Urinary sodium excretion (mmol/day) in PRA, ie, in the absence of renal artery stenosis
or other renovascular pathology.
Fig 4. Relationship between urinary sodium excretion
and mean arterial pressure in controls (open circles) and Autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease
in patients with autosomal dominant polycystic kidney (ADPKD) is a useful paradigm to illustrate how
disease (closed circles) on the seventh day of low (20 inappropriate activity of the RAS may contribute
mmol/d) and high (200 mmol/d) sodium intake. Controls
and patients on the low sodium diet had significantly to blood pressure elevation in renal disease de-
different baseline blood pressures. In addition, the slope spite PRA levels that are within the normal range.
of the urinary sodium-blood pressure relationship was Early investigators27 ,28 who studied patients with
significantly different. (Reprinted with permission of
Current SCience. 23 ) ADPKD measured PRA levels within the normal
range and concluded that the RAS was not related
to the elevation of blood pressure. More recently,
experiments showed that activation of extrarenal however, higher post-captopril PRAS29 and higher
pressor mechanisms persistently failed to increase basal PRAs have been found in juvenile subjects
blood pressure unless the pressure-natriuresis re- with ADPKD when compared with appropriate
lationship was reset to higher blood pressure controls, ie, patients with primary hypertension
levels. who were matched for blood pressure. 30 This
There is good evidence for sodium retention finding points to an inappropriate activity of the
in patients with renal failure. 22 Furthermore, even RAS, which is further supported by a comparison
in incipient renal failure, the pressure-natriuresis of angiotensin II levels with the number of an-
relationship may be shifted to the right and blood giotensin II receptors on thrombocytes. 31 As
pressure may become sensitive to both salt and shown in Table 2, although patients with
volume, as shown in Fig 4. 23 ADPKD had substantially higher blood pressures,
It has been more difficult to provide evidence angiotensin II levels, the number of angiotensin
for abnormal renal handling of sodium in subjects II receptors on the platelets were not as low as
with primary hypertension. In early studies, a would be expected, suggesting inappropriate ac-
lowish exchangeable sodium, if anything, was tivity of the RAS. Activation of the RAS also
noted in patients with primary hypertension. 24 could be demonstrated by immunostaining of the
More recently, however, several investigators
have documented increased sodium sensitivity Table 2. Inappropriate Angiotensin II Levels
in Autosomal Dominant Polycystic
of blood pressure in a proportion of patients with Kidney Disease (ADPKD) Patients
primary hypertension 25 and even in young nor-
motensive individuals who were genetically pre- Angiotensin II
Mean Artenal Angiotensin II Receptors
disposed to primary hypertension. 7 The mecha- Pressure Concentration (Sites!
nism(s) through which the kidney is prevented (mmHg) (fmol!mL) Platelet)
kidneys for renin. 32 The number of angiotensin pertensive than in normotensive patients. This
II receptors on the platelets correlates closely with indicates that PRA is too high relative to sodium
the acute pressor response to angiotensin II in- and to blood pressure.
fusion, as shown previously in our laboratory. The activity of the RAS depends on the type
The potential functional relevance of inappro- of underlying renal disease, being particularly
priate activation of the RAS is illustrated by the high in patients with nephangiosclerosis and glo-
observation that angiotensin converting enzyme merulonephritis. 36 It is excessive in a minority of
inhibition selectively increases renal plasma flow uremic patients whose blood pressure does not
in patients with ADPKD, but not in controls,33 respond to loss of volume, and it is these patients
suggesting angiotensin II-mediated renal cortical who in the past required bilateral nephrectomy3?
vasoconstriction. Since renal vasoconstriction and who today benefit particularly from angio-
alters renal sodium excretion, the two hyperten- tensin converting enzyme inhibitors.
sinogenic phenomena (an abnormal pressure-
natriuresis relationship and inappropriate acti- THE SYMPATHETIC NERVOUS SYSTEM
vation of the RAS) may be interrelated and may The kidney is the origin of, and the target for,
mutually amplify each other. sympathetic efferent and afferent nerve traffic. 33
A wide range of PRA values is found in indi- Afferent nerve traffic is stimulated by intrarenal
viduals with primary hypertension, although the mechanoreceptors and chemoreceptors, while ef-
median PRA lies well within the normal range. ferent sympathetic nerve traffic modulates renal
More recently, intemephron heterogeneity with renin release and renal vascular resistance and
respect to the activity of the renal renin system directly modulates tubular transport of sodium.
has been suggested by Laragh. 34 This novel con- A role for the sympathetic nervous system in the
cept also may provide a conceptual framework genesis of blood pressure elevation in models of
to accommodate the co-existence of ischemic and renal hypertension is suggested by observations
overperfused nephrons, as is frequently found in that selective renal denervation abrogated or de-
chronic renal disease. layed the onset of blood pressure elevation in dif-
Animal experiments provide further evidence ferent models of renal hypertension. 38
for an important role of the renal renin system In the past, the sympathetic nervous system
in the long-term regulation of blood pressure in was not thought to be a major contributor to the
situations in which renal disease is not present. genesis of renal hypertension. However, this view
In the conscious, chronically instrumented dog, is now known to be incorrect. Norepinephrine
long-term regulation of blood pressure correlated levels are elevated in patients with renal failure,
strongly with the renal autoregulatory threshold but this finding is difficult to interpret because
for renin secretion, ie, the critical level of mean re-uptake of norepinephrine is diminished. Fur-
pressure in the renal artery below which renin thermore, the increase in vascular resistance in
secretion was stimulated. 35 response to norepinephrine is impaired in the
More definite evidence for overtly inappro- vasculature of uremic animals. 39 Nevertheless,
priate activity of the RAS has been obtained in sympathetic overactivity appears to playa major
patients with renal failure. 22 ,36 To correctly in- role in the maintenance of elevated blood pres-
terpret PRA, it must be remembered that a re- sure. Schohn et al40 found that sympathetic
ciprocal relationship exists between renin secre- blockade with debrisoquine dramatically reduced
tion and arterial pressure so that PRA should be blood pressure in hypertensive uremic patients.
close to zero in the hypertensive renal patient. McGrath et al41 carried this one step further and
Apart from blood pressure, an expanded sodium studied the effect of total autonomic blockade
space also will suppress the RAS. In the study by using atropine and beta- and alpha-adrenoceptor
Weidmann et al,36 the relationship between ex- blockers. Total autonomic blockade dramatically
changeable sodium and PRA was compared in lowered blood pressure and total peripheral re-
normal subjects and in normotensive and hy- sistance in hypertensive patients on dialysis, ir-
pertensive uremic subjects. It was found that at respective of whether they were on a low- or high-
any given level of exchangeable sodium, PRA was salt diet. The relationship between sympathetic
higher in uremic subjects, and more so in hy- overactivity and increased blood pressure gains
8 RITZ AND FLiSER
further credence from the microneurographic ultrafiltration. Nevertheless, in view of the above
studies of Victor et al,42 who demonstrated in- experiments, one would anticipate hypertension
creased efferent sympathetic nerve traffic in ure- in diseases that destroy the renal medulla. Indeed,
mic patients. in analgesic abusers, who suffer from papillary
destruction, we have noted a high prevalence of
THE CIRCULATING INHIBITORS OF hypertension (over 80%), even when the serum
NITRIC OXIDE SYNTHESIS creatinine level was below 1.1 mg/dL. 49
An entirely new perspective was opened up by REFERENCES
the findings of Vallance et al,43 who identified a
1. Bright R: The Symptoms and Cure of Disease. London,
derivative of L-arginine, asymmetric dimethylar-
UK, Longman, Rees, Orme, Brown and Green, 1827
ginine, in the circulation of uremic animals. This 2. Rettig R, Stauss H, Folberth Ch, Ganten D, Waldherr
compound competitively inhibits the synthesis R, Unger T: Hypertension transmitted by kidneys from stroke-
of nitric oxide from L-arginine and, when given prone spontaneously hypertensive rats. Am J Physiol 257:
to guinea pigs, increased blood pressure dose de- FI97-F203, 1989
3. Curtis JJ, Luke RG, Dustan HP, Kashgarian M, Whel-
pendently and over prolonged periods of time.
chel JD, Jones P, Diethelm A: Remission of hypertension
Cumulation of such hypertension-promoting after renal transplantation. N Engl J Med 309: 1009- 10 15, 1983
inhibitors of endothelium-derived relaxing factor 4. Bianchi G, Cusi D, Gatti M, Lupi G, Ferrari P, Barlassina
may explain the known prevalence and severity C, Picotti GB, Bracchi G, Colombo G, Govi D, Velis 0, Maz-
of hypertension in end-stage renal failure patients zei D: A renal abnormality as a possible cause of essential
hypertension. Lancet 1:173-177, 1979
and also may explain why prolonged duration of
5. Montanari A, Vallisa D, Ragni G: Abnormal renal re-
dialysis sessions will keep most patients normo- sponses to calcium entry blockade in normotensive offspring
tensive, even if they do not receive antihyperten- of hypertensive parents. Hypertension 12:498-505, 1988
sive medication. 44 6. Van Hooft IMS, Grobee DE, Derkx FHM: Renal he-
modynamics and the RAAS in normotensive subjects with
hypertensive and normotensive parents. N Engl J Med 324:
THE RENAL VASODEPRESSOR FACTORS 1305-1311, 1991
The genesis of hypertension in renal disease 7. Skraba1 F, Hamberger L, Gruber G: Hereditary sodium
sensitivity as a cause of primary hypertension. Klin Woch-
usually is interpreted in terms of renal activation
enschr 63:891-896, 1985
of pressor factors. However, this concept may be 8. Kiister S, Mehls 0, Seidel C, Ritz E: Blood pressure in
incomplete. Loss of renal depressor mechanisms minimal change and other types of nephrotic syndrome. Am
and failure to reduce blood pressure may consti- J Nephrol 10:76-80, 1990
tute a potentially important pathogenetic aspect 9. Rambausek M, Rhein C, Waldherr R, Goetz R, Heid-
land A, Ritz E: Hypertension in chronic idiopathic glomer-
of renal hypertension. Blood pressure-lowering
ulonephritis: Analysis of 311 biopsied patients. Eur J Clin
lipid substances can be extracted from the inter- Invest 19:176-180, 1989
stitial cells of the renal medulla,45 but, until re- 10. Danielson H, Kornerup HG, Olson J, Posborg B: Ar-
cently, it was not possible to confirm whether terial hypertension in chronic glomerulonephritis. An analysis
such substances affected blood pressure under of 3 10 cases. Clin Nephrol 19:284-290, 1983
11. Orofino L, Quereda C, Lamas S: Hypertension in pri-
physiologic circumstances.
mary glomerulonephritis: Analysis of 288 biopsied patients.
In elegant cross-perfusion experiments, Karls- Nephron 45:22-26, 1987
tram et al varied the perfusion pressure of the 12. Viberti GC, Keen H, Wisemann MJ: Raised arterial
isolated perfused rat kidney within the range of pressure in parents of proteinuric insulin dependent diabetics.
pressures occurring in vivo and noted a dose-de- BMJ 295:515-517,1987
13. Schmid M, Meyer S, Wegner R, Ritz E: Increased ge-
pendent decrease in blood pressure and natri-
uresis in the recipient rat. 46 ,47 This implies that
netic risk of hypertension in glomerulonephritis? Hypertension
8:573-577, 1990
depressor substances, presumably medullolipins, 14. Gruppo Italiano per la Studio della Nephrite Lupica
are released from the kidney with increasing renal (GISNEL): Lupus nephritis: Prognostic factors and probability
perfusion pressures. The concept of renoprival of maintaining life-supporting renal function 10 years after
hypertension48 (ie, hypertension as a consequence the diagnosis. Am J Kidney Dis 19:473-479, 1992
15. Mogensen CE: Risk factors and optimal blood pressure
ofloss of renal function) had found disfavor after level for insulin-dependent diabetic patients, in Andreucci VE,
it was shown that anephric individuals were ren- Fine LG (eds): International Yearbook of Nephrology. Lon-
dered normotensive by subtraction of volume via don, UK, Springer, 1992, pp 141-145
HYPERTENSION AND THE KIDNEY 9
16. Klahr S, Schreiner G, Ichikawa I: The progression of with incipient and advanced renal failure. Kidney Int 42: 1259-
renal disease. N Engl J Med 318:1657-1666, 1988 1265,1992
17. Janka HU, Warram JH, Rand LI, Krolewski AS: Risk 33. Di Bona GF: Neural control of renal function: Car-
factors for progression of background retinopathy in long- diovascular implications. Hypertension 13:539-548, 1989
standing IDDM. Diabetes 38:460-464, 1989 34. Laragh JH: The renin system and four lines of hyper-
18. Knowler We. Bennett PH, Ballintine EJ: Increased in- tension research. Hypertension 20:267-279, 1992
cidence of retinopathy in diabetics with elevated blood pres- 35. Kirchheim H, Ehmke H, Hackenthal E, Lowe W,
sure. N Eng) J Med 302:645-648, 1980 Persson P: Autoregulation of renal blood flow, glomerular
19. Bidani AK, Schwartz MM, Lewis EJ: Renal autoreg- filtration rate and renin release in conscious dogs. Eur J Physiol
ulation and vulnerability to hypertensive injury in remnant 410:441-449, 1987
kidney. Am J PhysioI252:FI003-FI008, 1987 36. Weidmann P, Beretta-Piccoli C, Steffen F, Blumberg
20. Hostetter RH, Olson JH, Rennke HG, Venkatachalan A, Reubi FC: Hypertension in terminal renal failure. Kidney
MA, Brenner BM: Hyperfiltration in remnant nephrons: A Int 9:294-301, 1976
potentially adverse response to renal ablation. Am J Physiol 37. Vertes V, Cangiano JI, Berman LB, Gould N: Hyper-
241:F85-F93, 1981 tension in end-stage renal disease. N Eng) J Med 280:978-
21. Guyton AC: Renal function curve: A key to under- 981, 1969
standing the pathogenesis of hypertension. Hypertension 10: 38. Katholi RE, Wintemitz SR, Oparil S: Decrease in pe-
1-6, 1987 ripheral sympathetic nervous system activity following renal
22. Beretta-Piccoli C, Weidmann P, de Chatel R, Reubi denervation or unclipping in the one-kidney, one clip Gold-
F: Hypertension associated with early stage kidney disease: blatt hypertensive rat. J Clin Invest 69:55-62, 1982
Complementary roles of circulating renin, the body sodium 39. Rascher W, SchOmig A, Kreye VA, Ritz E: Diminished
volume state and duration of hypertension. Am J Med 61: vascular response to noradrenaline in experimental chronic
739-747, 1976 uremia. Kidney Int 21:20-27, 1982
23. Schmid M, Mann JFE, Stein G, Herter M, Nussberger 40. Schohn D, Weidmann P, Jahn H, Beretta-Piccoli C:
J, Klingbeil A, Ritz E: Natriuresis-pressure relationship in Norepinephrine-related mechanism in hypertension accom-
polycystic kidney disease. J Hypertens 8:227-283, 1990
panying renal failure. Kidney Int 28:814-821, 1985
24. Lever AF, Beretta-Piccoli C, Brown JJ, Davies DL,
41. McGrath BP, Tilden DJ, Bune A: Autonomic blockade
Fraser R, Robertson JIS: Sodium and potassium in essential
and the Valsalva maneuver in patients on maintenance HD.
hypertension. BMJ 283:463-468, 1981
Kidney Int 12:294-303, 1977
25. Campese VM, Romoff MS, Levitan D, Sag)ikes Y,
42. Victor RG, Scherer U, Fouad-Terazi F, Jacobsen TN,
Friedler RM, Massry SG: Abnormal relationship between so-
Toto RD: Reversible sympathetic activation in patients with
dium intake and sympathetic nervous system activity in salt-
chronic renal failure: A vasoconstrictor reflex arising in the
sensitive patients with essential hypertension. Kidney Int 21:
failing kidney? Circulation 82:3-10, 1990
371-378,1982
43. Vallance P, Leone A, Calver A, Collier J, Moncada S:
26. De Wardener HE, MacGregor GA: The natriuretic
hormone and essential hypertension. Lancet I: 1450-1454, Accumulation of an endogenous inhibitor of nitric oxide syn-
1982 thesis in chronic renal failure. Lancet 339:572-575, 1992
27. Valvo E, Gammaro L, Tessitore N: Hypertension of 44. Charra B, Calemard E, Ruffet M: Survival as an index
polycystic kidney disease: Mechanisms and hemodynamic al- of adequacy of dialysis. Kidney Int 41:1286-1291,1992
terations. Am J NephroI5:176-18I, 1985 45. Muirhead EE: Antihypertensive functions of the kidney.
28. Nash MDA: Hypertension in polycystic kidney disease Hypertension 2:444-464, 1980
without renal failure. Arch Intern Med 137:1571-1575, 1977 46. Karlstrom G, Amman V, Bergstrom G, Muirhead EE,
29. Chapman AB, Johnson A, Gabow PA, Schrier RW: Rudenstam J, Gothberg G: Renal and circulatory effects of
The renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system and autosomal medullolipin I, as studied in the in vivo cross-circulated isolated
dominant polycystic kidney disease. N Eng) J Med 323: 1091- kidney and intact Wistar-Kyoto rat. Acta Physiol Scand 137:
1096, 1990 521-5~3, 1989
30. Harrap SB, Davies DL, Macnicol AN, Watson ML: 47. Karlstrom G, Amman V, Folkow B, Gothberg G: Ac-
Renal, cardiovascular and hormonal characteristics of young tivation of the humoral antihypertensive system of the kidney.
adults with autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease. Hypertension 11:597-601, 1988
Kidney Int 40:510-508, 1991 48. Grollman A, Muirhead EE, VanattaJ: Role of the kid-
31. Klingbeil A, Schmid M, Ritz E, Nussberger J, Mann ney in pathogenesis of hypertension as determined by a study
J: Plasma Angiotensin II und Angiotensin II-Rezeptorregu- of the effects of bilateral nephrectomy and other experimental
lation bei Patienten mit adulten Zystennieren. Nieren Hoch- procedures in the blood pressure of the dog. Am J Physiol
druckkrankheiten 21:395, 1992 (abstr) 157:21-30, 1949
32. Zeier M, Fehrenbach P, Geberth S, Mohring K, Wal- 49. Kuster G, Ritz E: Analgesic abuse and hypertension.
dherr R, Ritz E: Renal histology in polycystic kidney disease Lancet 2: 1105-1106, 1989