Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GST in India
GST in India
net/publication/305297217
CITATIONS READS
0 12,761
3 authors, including:
Mohamed Haneefa K
University of Calicut
78 PUBLICATIONS 152 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Mohamed Haneefa K on 14 July 2016.
Shyni K.G.
Research Scholar
Department of Library and Information Science
University of Calicut
Sujima A.P.
Librarian
KMCT Polytechnic College
NIT Campus P.O., Calicut-673601
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to investigate the use and services of Akshaya
Community Information Centres in Kerala. Structured questionnaires were
employed to collect data from a representative sample of 100 Akshaya Centre
Entrepreneurs in Malappuram district of Kerala. The study found that Akshaya
Centres are widely used for bill payments and a majority of the entrepreuneurs
provides various services at affordable rates. E-literacy programme is the main
attraction of the Akshaya that increased the status of Akshaya Centres. It is
revealed that the entrepreneurs are willing to diversify the Centres with more IT
related services. Demand for new services through the Centres showed the trust of
local community towards Akshaya Centres.
1. Introduction
Information and Communication Technology (ICT) can be effectively used by
developing countries to improve the quality of life of their people. Many programmes
have been launched so far worldwide to bridge the digital divide and to improve the
use of ICT by common man. Akshaya project is such a venture involved setting up of
thousands of Multi-purpose Community Technology Centers called Akshaya e-
Kendras across Kerala. It is a social and economic project focusing on various facts
of information and communication, e-learning, e-transactions and e-governance
610
Democratization of Information Using ICT (DEMICT) 2014
(Gomez and Gould, 2011). It is one of the early community based ICT initiatives by
Kerala IT Mission.
Akshaya project officially launched in 2002, by setting up more than 600 sites in
Malappuram district of Kerala, with the goal that one person in every family to be
computer literate in the district. After the first phase, Malappuram district is said to
be India’s first e-literate district. Akshaya marks the beginning of a drive to ‘Bridge
the Digital Divide’ by enabling thousands of ordinary citizens access relevant
information in the local language over the Internet. Akshaya was started with
creating the micro entrepreneur in each Panchayath. The micro entrepreneurs are
called Akshaya Centre Entrepreneurs (ACEs) or simply Akshaya entrepreneurs.
ACEs deliver services through which the population of the respective area benefits.
ACEs try to impart knowledge and try to educate the population. The entrepreneur is
the key to the success of the project.
The initial phase of the Akshaya was the ‘E- literacy phase’. This phase familiarized
people with the basics and the scope of IT and also ensures hands-on-skill in
operating a computer, using internet, etc. It is the largest e-literacy training project
worldwide. The second phase is the service delivery phase, offering a variety of
services like e-learning, e-commerce, advanced IT training, e-governance,
communications and specific community based services. Akshaya centers are able
to influence a wide range of development issues such as business and education
development to the extent to which information and communication is important to
individual users. Since control is within the government, Akshaya gets the credibility
of a government organization while at the delivery level there is a corporate
approach of welcoming every citizen with the friendly face.
In the history of the project, only two sets of services: the former e-literacy program
and the current array of e-governance application which constitute several G2C and
B2C services have been extended to all the telecenters within the project. The
remaining services offered in each telecenter largely depend on the supply choices
made by the single entrepreneur. Generally Akshaya centers provide various
services, courses and projects. Various services include e-payment, e-filing, e-
ticketing, Internet services, CSC, Janamythri police station, rural e-banking,
Industrial web portals, and data entry works. The courses included Intel learn
programme, Learn and Speak English, Medical Transcription, E-Vidya, IGNOU
Courses, DOEACC programme, C-DIT, Arabic Typing Tutor, Insight and Keltron
611
Democratization of Information Using ICT (DEMICT) 2014
Kuriyan, Ray and Toyama (2008) conducted a study on the challenges and tradeoffs
of implementing the Akshaya project and to analyze the business strategies of the
Akshaya entrepreneurs. The finding of the study revealed that market based
solutions; private enterprise and advanced technologies can increase the wellbeing
of the poor and concurrently increase the profits of the private sector. It is found that
poor are not the primary customers of ICT kiosks except for a one time, subsidized
Akshaya course. The main consumers are those in the middle class. It also showed
that broader political economy significantly influences the practices of technology
612
Democratization of Information Using ICT (DEMICT) 2014
It is evident from the review of literature that there is a need to study the use,
services and achievements of Akshaya. The present study is intented to find out the
use, services and achievements of Akshaya Community Information Centres in the
perspectives of the entrepreneurs. This study will be useful to find out answers to
questions associated with the project and suggest proper measures to overcome the
problems encountered with Akshaya Centers.
3. Research Design
The universe of the study was Akshaya Center Entrepreneurs (ACEs) in
Malappuram district, Kerala. Structured questionnaires were used to collect data
from a representative sample of 100 ACEs in Malappuram District. The investigators
distributed the questionnaires during the days of training programmes conducted
jointly by Kerala State IT Mission and Akshaya District Project Office, Malappuram.
Out of 100 questionnaires distributed, 91 were duly filled in and returned back. All
the questions in the questionnaire were analyzed on the basis of formulated
objectives.
613
Democratization of Information Using ICT (DEMICT) 2014
Table 1
Purpose of Use of Akshaya Centers
Sl. Responses
Purposes
No. (n=91)
24
1 Educational purpose
(26.4%)
46
2 Bill payment
(50.5%)
23
3 Internet facility
(25.3%)
18
4 Computer training programmes
(19.8%)
20
5 All the above
(21.9%)
It is found that about half (50.5 per cent) of the entrepreneurs opined Akshaya
Centers are widely used for bill payment. A few (26.4 per cent) stated that Akshaya
Centers are used for educational purpose and another 25.3 per cent of the
entrepreneurs agreed that people use internet facility. A few (19.8 per cent) of the
entrepreneurs opined that people make use of computer training programmes also.
A few (21.9 per cent) of the entrepreneurs were of the opinion that people use the
centers for all the services including bill payment, educational purpose, internet
facility, and computer training programmes.
614
Democratization of Information Using ICT (DEMICT) 2014
Table 2
Popular Service Delivery Time
Sl. Responses
Time
No. (n=91)
72
1 Morning (Up to 12)
(79.1%)
13
2 Afternoon (12-4)
(14.3%)
13
3 Early evening (4-6)
(14.3%)
11
4 Evening (after 6)
(12.1%)
It is found that a majority (79.1 per cent) of the entrepreneurs opined that people
prefer morning (up to 12) to use the services. Similarly a very few (14.3 per cent) of
the entrepreneurs stated that afternoon (12-4) is the convenient time to users. Also a
very few (14.3 per cent) of the entrepreneurs opined that people use services in the
early evening (4-6). A very few (12.1 per cent) of the entrepreneurs said that people
prefer evening (after 6) to use the services.
615
Democratization of Information Using ICT (DEMICT) 2014
Table 3
Support from Various Sources
Table 4
Benefits to Entrepreneurs
Sl. Responses
Benefits
No. (n=91)
24
1 Status in the family increased
(26.4%)
59
2 Status in the community increased
(64.8%)
43
3 Business opportunity
(47.3%)
10
4 Opportunity for livelihood
(10.9%)
22
5 Financial gains
(24.2%)
54
6 Increased awareness of IT related services
(59.3%)
2
7 Others
(2.2%)
It is seen that a majority (64.8 per cent) of the entrepreneurs enjoy an increased
status in the community. Majority (59.3 per cent) of the entrepreneurs stated that
they can increase awareness of IT related services. About half (47.3 per cent) of the
entrepreneurs enjoy business or entrepreneurship aspect of the project. A few (26.4
616
Democratization of Information Using ICT (DEMICT) 2014
per cent) of the entrepreneurs satisfy with the increased status in the family. A few
(24.2 per cent) of the entrepreneurs get financial gains through Akshaya and a very
few (10.9 per cent) of the entrepreneurs consider it as an opportunity for livelihood.
Table 5
Benefits to Community
Sl. Responses
Benefits
No. (n=91)
18
1 Opportunity for women
(19.8%)
17
2 Employment for youth
(18.7%)
69
3 E-literary
(75.8%)
35
4 Others
(38.5%)
It is found that a majority (75.8 per cent) of the entrepreneurs consider e-literacy as
the main benefit to the community. A good number (38.5 per cent) of the
entrepreneurs’ indicated that community gain other benefits (certified e-learning
programme at an affordable rate, IT awareness among housewives, availability of
services from a nearest information center, provision of convenient and reliable e-
governance services at a low rate) from the centers. A few (19.8 per cent) of the
entrepreneurs think women get opportunity to come forward and express their
enormous talents in various aspects that remain untapped in them. A few (18.7 per
cent) of the entrepreneurs agree that youth get employment opportunities through
Akshaya.
617
Democratization of Information Using ICT (DEMICT) 2014
Table 6
Advantages of Akshaya
Sl. Responses
Advantages
No. (n=91)
Time reduction in delivery of 47
1
services (51.6%)
30
2 Lack of harassment
(32.9%)
54
3 Akshaya is too near
(59.3%)
40
4 Convenient and reliable services
(43.9%)
39
5 More freely available services
(42.9%)
Transparency in delivery of 28
6
services (30.8%)
67
7 Less service charge
(73.6%)
2
8 Others
(2.2%)
It is revealed that a majority (73.6 per cent) of the entrepreneurs consider availability
of services at a cheaper rate is the main advantage of Akshaya services. A majority
(59.3 per cent) of the entrepreneurs think availability of the services from nearest
place is the advantage. About half (51.6 per cent) of the entrepreneurs stated that
time reduction in service delivery is the main advantage of Akshaya. A good number
(43.9 per cent) of the entrepreneurs think availability of convenient and reliable
service is the advantage of Akshaya. A good number (42.9 per cent) of the
entrepreneurs stated use of freely available services is the advantage of Akshaya
Centers.
A good number (32.9 per cent) of the entrepreneurs consider lack of harassment as
the advantage of Akshaya use. A good number (30.8 per cent) of the entrepreneurs
said transparency in service delivery is the main advantage. A very few (2.2 per
618
Democratization of Information Using ICT (DEMICT) 2014
cent) of the entrepreneurs stated that there are some other advantages. For
example, ‘being a government supporting center’ is the main advantage of Akshaya
service use.
The table depicts that most (96.7 per cent) of the entrepreneurs provide e-payment
services. A large majority of the entrepreneurs provided e-literacy programme (89
per cent) and E-Vidya Course (87.9 per cent). Majority of the entrepreneurs provide
e- filing (63.7 per cent), e-ticketing (61.5 per cent), e-Krishi (78 per cent), Learn and
Speak English (63.7 per cent), Online Application of Ration Card (79.1 per cent),
registration of BPL families under Health Insurance Scheme (67 per cent) and
Collection of Subscription amount of NRK Welfare fund (58.2 per cent).
Table 7
Akshaya Services
Sl. Responses
Name of Service
No. (n=91)
1 E-Literacy 81(89%)
2 E-Payment 88(96.7%)
3 E-Filing 58(63.7%)
4 E-Ticketing 56(61.5%)
5 SPARK 31(34.1%)
6 E-Krishi 71(78%)
7 Ente Gramam 34(37.4%)
8 Intel learning 55(60.4%)
9 Learn and Speak English 58(63.7%)
10 Medical Transcription 15(16.5%)
11 E-Vidya 80(87.9%)
Online Application of
12 72(79.1%)
ration card
Registration of BPL
13 families under Health 61(67%)
Insurance scheme
Collection of Subscription
14 amount of NRK welfare 53(58.2%)
Fund
619
Democratization of Information Using ICT (DEMICT) 2014
A good number of the entrepreneurs provide Ente Gramam project (37.4 per cent),
and SPARK (34.1 per cent). A few (16.5 per cent) of the entrepreneurs provide
Medical Transcription Course.
Table 8
Problems of Akshaya Centers
Sl. Responses
Problems
No. (n=91)
26
1 Lack of infrastructure facilities
(28.6%)
Lack of awareness of people about Akshaya 43
2
services (47.3%)
Lack of training programs from authoritative 15
3
bodies (16.5%)
66
4 Financial problems
(72.5%)
19
5 Lack of trained staff
(20.9%)
17
6 Other problems
(18.7%)
It is seen that a majority (72.5 per cent) of the entrepreneurs indicated that financial
problem affect the functioning of Akshaya Centers. About half (47.3 per cent) of the
entrepreneurs reported that lack of awareness about the Akshaya services among
people is another problem. A few (28.6 per cent) of the entrepreneurs opined that
the lack of infrastructure facilities in the Centers is another factor adversely affecting
the success of the project. A few (16.5 per cent) of the entrepreneurs felt difficulties
due to the lack of training programmes from authoritative bodies.
620
Democratization of Information Using ICT (DEMICT) 2014
Table 9
Provision of Additional Services from Akshaya Centers
Sl. Responses
Additional Services
No. (n=91)
52
1 Data entry jobs for Panchayath
(57.1%)
60
2 Computer training programs
(65.9%)
22
3 Xerox facility
(24.2%)
30
4 Financial support from other sources
(32.9%)
It is found that a majority (65.9 per cent) of the entrepreneurs prefer to provide
computer training programmes other than Akshaya services. Majority (57.1 per cent)
of the entrepreneurs do data entry jobs for the local Panchayath to get financial
benefits. A good number (32.9 per cent) of the entrepreneurs get financial support
from other sources. A few (24.2 per cent) of the entrepreneurs do Xerography to run
the Akshaya Centers.
Table 10
Future Plans for Akshaya Centers
Sl. Responses
Future Plans
No. (n=91)
Continue with
1 25 (27.5%)
same facilities
Diversify with more 62
2
IT related services (68.1%)
4
3 Close the center
(4.4%)
621
Democratization of Information Using ICT (DEMICT) 2014
It is revealed that a majority (68.1 per cent) of the entrepreneurs decided to diversify
the entrepreneurship with more IT related services. A few (27.5 per cent) of the
entrepreneurs hope to continue with the available infrastructure facilities. Only four
(4.4 per cent) of the entrepreneurs actually admit the closing down of their Akshaya
Centers.
622
Democratization of Information Using ICT (DEMICT) 2014
Lack of financial support is the main threat to the sustainability of Akshaya Centers.
So, government should implement special funding mechanism to meet the economic
problems of Akshaya Centers and Government officials must be closely involved in
the effective functioning of the Akshaya Centers. Identification of the right
entrepreneur is one of the important aspects in the success of the Akshaya Centres.
Entrepreneurs can be rated on the basis of profit generated by them from Akshaya
and the role played by them in spreading awareness of Akshaya in their allotted
areas. This can motivate the entrepreneurs to increase the participation of
community, thereby increasing the utilization of Akshaya services.
The efficient utilization of the information through ICT can create comprehensive
wealth for nation and improve existing quality of rural life. So, more Akshaya
Centers should be opened in villages and services made more widely available to
help in the socio-economic transformation of the poor villages. Akshaya officials
should conduct regular meetings with the entrepreneurs to discuss common
problems encountered and solutions must be chalked out. This will encourage the
entrepreneurs continue to run the Centers rather than closing down them. Since
Akshaya Centers directly link with public, thereby result in social development and
empowerment. So, these Centers are in need of support from all concerned sources
for its smooth functioning. Support and cooperation from both the State and local
623
Democratization of Information Using ICT (DEMICT) 2014
self government or Panchayath have to be improved, and then only these Centers
can improve its performance in all levels.
References
1. Gomez, Ricardo & Gould, Elizebeth (2011). The cool factor of public access to
ICT user’s perceptions of trust in libraries, telecentres and cyber cafes in
developing countries. Information Technology and People. 23(3), 247-264.
2. Gopakumar, Kiran, & Rajalekshmi (2007). E-Governance services through
Telecenters: The Role of Human intermediary and Issues of Trust. Information
Technologies and International Development 4(1) 19-35. Web. 22 Mar. 2011.
3. International Development Research Centre. Assessment of Akshaya project
from a Gender perspective. New Delhi: Institute of Social Studies Trust, MIMAP
Gender Network Project, Phase III. JCC @ UGC-INFONET. Web. 12 Jan.
2011.
4. Kuriyan, Renee, Isha Ray, & Kentaro Toyama (2008). Information and
Communication Technologies for development: the bottom of the pyramid
model in Practice. The Information Society 24(2), 93-104. JCC @ UGC-
INFONET. Web. 26 Jan. 2011.
5. Madon, Shirin (2005). Governance Lessons from the Experience of Telecenters
in Kerala. European Journal of Information Systems 14(4), 401-416. JCC @
UGC-INFONET. Web. 5 Feb. 2011
6. Masiero, Silvia (2011). Financial vs Social Sustainability of Telecenters: Mutual
Exclusion or Mutual Reinforcement. EJISDC 45(3) 1-23. Web. 12 Mar. 2011
7. Pal, Joyojeet (2009). If the state provided free computer literacy, would it find
takers: evidence and propositions from the Akshaya project in India. Inf Syst
Front 11. 105-116. JCC @ UGC-INFONET. Web. 12 Jan. 2011.
8. Sharma, Arvind K (2008). Information Environment in Rural India: Impediments
to Free flow of Information. Library Herald 46(1), 5-12.
9. Akshaya retrieved at <www.akshaya.kerela.gov.in> accessed on 10/01/2014.
624