— J Leading-Edge Motorsport Technology Since 1990
i iC Ly ae
Seer
‘August 2019 + Vol 29 No 8 + wwv.racecar-engineering.com * UK £5.95 - US $14.50
Uae
Why hypercars are the Peter Wright's vision for The inside story of how
answer for the FIA WEC a sustainable Formuta 1 Toyota conquered Le MansXRP ProPLUS
Reusable Hose Ends
The evolution in FLUID HORSEPOWER ™ pane! cao
De ed
ay of god rating be pane 8) but
See
en]
Log on to
www.xrp.com
anytime for catalog downloads,
‘new product updates
and tech ts. fe
US XRP, Inc. sales@xrp.com tel 562 861 4765 fax 562 861 5503
EU PROTEC FUEL SYSTEMS LTD. info@protecfuelpumps.com tel 44 (0) 121 572 6533
AUGUST 2019 woewrcecrenginesingcom 3ECR Engines Rely On
BGG
automotive joa ng produc
Seen eee ered
TOU Bae Lee Om ee ne
en RO een me R MLO sed
ee eee are
the Mobil 1 12 Hours of Sebring
in the DPI division of the IMSA
Tee nemere Toe
ARP fasteners provide strength and
CCIE WAM am eaten)
PRO OOK ec COM USECUL RS cutee Art ce
IVETE] 218° fasteners are
Ra ea ARP-bolts.com
. Be RD RRS ESRD ey
Pan beet te
Pee IY er rey re ten en err
STRAIGHT TALK — RICARDO DIVILA
Back to the drawing
boar
Our columnist offers some hard-won advice on how to go about designing a racecar
re ofthe things that do which ssi
ing with acing cris ging
ing anew problem, we
exploit the knowledge about the world acquited
utthe design buildand sofa, to quickly find an adequate solution that is
tart of the presentation
y 02s along the lines of
it but ean
sibilities that
This derives from compiling all the mistake e ied.
that Ihave commited 0 9 knowledge
busines andis
called experience, butt is realyoops Iw
rake this mistake again And belew
Grand designs
main conceps of design should cate tothe
sential rules:
1 There willbe acer init andit
your responsiblity to mitigate the
tokeepthemas
ample, kerbs area
af keeping diver inside the white
lines but you know they will dive over
renin search of faster lap time,
accordingly.
ou physics and mechani
ct innate; _Ukelheed ofthis srt of chasis abuse into your racecar design
and others
experience through tial ant f
he centuries stil the bs
ther domains,
perating method problem.
of allthe technologies you wil ap
you have leaned something new:The a complation of several treads of
ye you do not master, but do understand
tally and should have the coura
corollary is aso being able to cisprove something
you thought you knew.It shard to change:
nd butt needs a general spring ce
often, much ike ahard-sk
‘so, be open-minded, Technology ages
en.also there the application ofa
problem you simply don have, the
ing for a problem.
Engineers are the embodiment off itain broke,
itdoesnt have enough features
reason foradding feature
does creativity gen
decline with age? Well ge
more. tean be an advantag
lead to ignoring evidence that c
‘think we know: thas todo witha tension
Keep it simple
ein, The whole
faster simp
ind of thinking exploration and
Drivers havea habit of using kerbs and you will eed to factor the
Being realistic, every design's awed and
incomplete in ight of further knowledge but can
work ts valid
'5 Pyramids, ship, and spacecraft are examples
‘ofwhat a group of people can do when working
together Big complex projects that
do on thelr own Modern rein
nts roughly 80 per cent ofthe effects come
20 percent ofthe causes can atest it
ceflec; that lst one percents ery very expensive,
Mostindustril processes ae the:
hy they ae specials; sk them what
hey ecommend and vty. The prod
willbe better and you will have a
your knowledge base,
ven puting dimensions on your
drawing should cat
method ofthe specialist as
have todo the inputs But be
aging the fame of referenc
requires can introduc
evaluable time,
f courage to admitit not goin
uldand then putit out of smi
you taking anew tack or approach,
7 Group think can distort judgement. The
biggest cock ups ha
the desig office having a mistaken view
butas
hindsight flaws were ds
So,armed with some painfully acquited
precepts go out there and make your own
mistakes fill be fun. Some
Once you have invested a great deal of time, money and credibility into
any project it will take a lot of courage to admit it
is not going to workFull service testing and engineering facility spe
+ 487-post shaker vehicle testing + Data acquisition » Data analysis
+ Component performance & durability testing
Engineers and operators experienced in testing and developing vehicles from IndyCar and NASCAR to
OEMs and grassroots racers, From the earliest planning stages through validating results on the track,
Zeta can provide all of the resources and knowledge required
804-690-8979
www.ZetaPVT.com
SIDETRACK - MIKE BLANCHET
Spoil sports
Why top-level stewards need to learn to use a little bit of common sense
debacle wl noc have fade fom its controversial
postzace headlines by the time this columns
printed, Regardless ofthe ights and wrongs of
the incident (ifindeed there are any), Sebastian
Vettels more measured later comments about
his sllusionment concerning curent FI have
contained much which should belstened to, Most
important ofall they shouldbe acted upon The
FIA obsesion with safety and corectnessat all
costshas bacome an Ancint Mariner‘albatoss
circling over the sport. lam not signed-up to
‘the ules ae rules view rather respect the
time-erved opinion that rules are forthe (strict)
‘obedience of fools and the guidance of wise men.
Iffurther ammunition formy arguments
required Le Mans provided it Previous
‘outright ace winner NckTandy
had 10 take astop-and-go when his
Porsche GTE crossed the pit-exting
whiten byes than half atyre
width. Clas leading Pro-Am plot Ben
Keating sufered a similar penalty for
slighty wheel-spining his Ford Tout
‘of his pit. Had Tandy joined the ack
dangerously or Keating disappeared
up proad ina tyresmoking,
‘ishtaling departure, then fair enough.
‘One assumes that there ae safety
reasons behind these regulations, but
neither incident could possibly have
been described 2: creating ask noe
‘gaining an advantage.
Against the rules
These are only the examples sav: doubles there
vere mere To me sch petfogging bureaucracy
indicates tha stewards cannot be tstd wth
making ntelignt assessments of cases such as
these This cannot be so. Atel inte real word
we entrust the fate of people charged with rave
fences by sucha process governance of moor
‘acing more dc than this? The stead
roomisno place for lawyers administrators
unable to gasp that milseconds often decidea
chive’ actions. Itshoul be only for stewards ith
proven moor racing competence and experience.
Racing is tough compatiton, ater than atest
cies andteans adherence to every etal
ofthe le book The concept ofa warning for
minor ascrton but second stike and youie ou”
| hope that the Canadian GPfve-second penalty
‘Atthe Canadian Grand Prix the Ft stewards
should have been an epe dice forthe I
- Pit Equipment - Impellers - Mixing Valves - Connection Systems - Pneumatic Systems -
‘han eve-
anyone wo wants to entey, slong as they are
Scart components
But the ethos ofthe championship remained
‘the same proving ground forteams and
‘organisations wanting to get imolvedin electric
racing, and therehas beena tof interest in
particular from tuning companies. One of the
key things about this series isthat we wantitto
beaffordable inital because we were looking
at unvestes but now mainly because somany
small and medium sized companies haveshoun THe ERA series founder and technica decor itor Varswigenhovn pictured withthe Dome F11/EV monocoque
very seriousinteres'Vanswiigenhoven sys
‘One market that the series founders had
not considered was young dives, but almost
as soon as this ne initiative was announce
many were contacting them looking for dives
Formula is Geatlya sucess, and the divers
are well pad to acein it Vanswiigenhoven based around te same car, but one class would
says’Butforayoung driver theres nat relly _bealmedatengineers and companies the ther MSAMailee lal UL
anyoptiontoleamhowtoraceelecric ars, at rivers"Wewillhave wo lasses, thefistof ERE
‘Thereisjustelectric karting, and that’ really just themisthe Spor Class, where yourun our basic | EW HOS aero peueed 8) Dene Danpostes
low performancerental stuff and then there's package, and thatincudes battery and motor, | gwereain
Formula, afullon profesional championship, everycar willbe identical Vanswijgenhowen ‘Atelete, 120 she ms, 2k ia base ate
‘there wasnothingin the mile until we explains The second, which wil eventually be Supanson
‘came along Thatgave usthveediferentkey __thefasterlass.the Innovation Class Here we Doble wisone wi pustrodatne anpers ont and
customers fr the series young engineers have createdafairamountof technical fieedom, _ Tansmision
tuning businesses and young rivers Oncewe The eams willbe able to develop batteries, =
understood hat trealyhad an impact cnalot__motorsandthel own bodywerkuithin some AN a rap gt Sm
‘ofthings,interms of what the series wouldbe, _liitations which illstep the costs geting out ack ss tort 420m
not eastin tems of the car design cof control and alsokeep things sae war
twas then decided thatthe series would While the ful technical regulations have yet). Roun 62a
have wo classes acing together ontrack bath tobe nalsedit is xpacted tat there willbe a
eee
7 seed 7 SAUDIA * SAUDI
ony
ee
\\
aps
Discover innovation at
For race engineers and drivers hoping to workin Formula thee ar nol many opportunist lear about EV ecng The al-new ERA series nen fl is gap arrowprecision.com
vownraccarengesingcom AUGUST 2019INSIGHT - ELECTRIC RACING ACADEMY
maximum power level forthe motor or motrs)
and various safety requirements In tems of
the racecar much ofthe cre package hasto be
retained including the outboard suspension,
‘monocoque and front and rearimpact
structures and some body parts
‘We created that tobe aitebitofan
enginee’splayroune!Vanswigenhoven sys,
‘Geer novation Class entrant wll have to start
off with a basic kit of parts from the Spor Class
‘at They then have the option of developing
‘the flowing pars-batery, motor inverter and
cdver interface. We areloking at freeing up the
rear bodywork, sidepods and some other parts,
and weare aso considering making dampers
feeinthe Innovation Clas too,
‘But wehave toretainal he safety citcal
parts Vansnjgenhoven ads. thinkit vl
‘give young engineers alot to work o, and will
akohelp divers ean natonly how to dive an
‘ect carbut aso how to develop one. But we
are taking care to ensureit doesnot become
spending war. Torace inthe Sport Class you
simply have to buy carand enteritinto the
series but there are enough common pats that
ifa team wanted to step upto the Innovation
Chass then it would be totally achievable
Component
i imle l=) == 9
For Professional
Motorsport
THE BEST JUST GOT
BIGGER
With the clases and overall objective ofthe
series defined Venswijgenhoven had to finda
racecar to use But while the open whee! single
seater markets crowdedin Europe, there were
‘no obvious solutions for an electric powered
cardi se the pointin creating something
entirely from scratch, there are plenty of good
chassis out there 0 we looked around tsee
which one ogo for he says. We considered
intial opening it up tallow ny F3tub cr
horelogtedin hela 10 ens tobe used
but qui became cla that costs could get Manage the entire Se aera as
teal oof conto tat ay Sowe decided component lifecycle in one
that we would ave to goforaone-make
chassis and realistically that would have tobe
acurent Formula, F2-Ror Fa chassis We id
think bout the old DallaraSF14o Sift Super
Formulacas but that was over,
"We met with mst ofthe major European
manufacturers ofcourse buta chance meeting
lead us to Dome in Japan Vanswijgenhoven
ads. Mey alkeadyhad wo efferent Fa cas
‘acing, onein the JAF seties and onein the FIA
series anda Formula 3 Regional chasis under
development (see RCEV2GNE).The team there
really understood what we were tying to do
and boughtinto it and when we visited ther
facltyin Japan we were blown away they had
everthing we needed
(ne ofthe questions thatthe series had
totackle was whethertoutiiseaHaloon the
ETE by reaper nota tinastdornamees haf tyumioune sigur eheany = as www.gems.co.uk
vownraccarengesingcom AUGUST 2019 AUGUST 2019 wewracaareninengcon
clear intuitive system > 9 tri-colour shift lights
Drives improved reliability, better Sr A
performance and lower costs ee
(i
PraINSIGHT - ELECTRIC RACING ACADEMY
isnot mandatory outside of FA lasses. We
lap times are nt necessarily there Hert was er engineers who had fares including ct electronics allowing i .
byaineritvasabigstepandthe drives st developing puncture anda hybrid system faire cost
reportedthat the corwas much better temwasalso Toyota the win Porsche tok third victory on
Butthe euphoria wasnottoltforlong. _intaducedfothsseaton while Toyota _—_the bounce an then etd rom he dine
‘ioulortetntnccyeseeseying —nveicedcsupenson sndvnths—toleasenisneFomantpoganme E>
» AUGUST 2019LE MANS - TOYOTA
Seer
escent)
one ey
DST
Petree)
vwnracarengesingcom AUGUST 2019
CO ee ES
Seneca
ee ey
Incidemally Toyotas battery development
‘meant thatthe temperature operating window
as higher, and te compulsory air contoning
system was no longer required fr the battery
‘The batery therefore reverted to 8 more
traditional water-cooing system,
‘None asa manufacture forthe super
season which an fom Spain 2018 to Le Mans,
2019, Toyota had to find ways to race against
the privateers The tam acknowedged that t
‘Would have to give up performance toallow
theron hybrids to compete, and reduced its
‘maximum stntlength increased its weight
ane aso reduced the amount of fuel that it
Up to 100 display pages
G
Dorr
www.gems.co.uk
Think Automotive are
specialists in oil cooling
systems and all aspects of
vehicle plumbing. We are
the manufacturers and
distributors of Mocal® and
Laminova products.
Ous
We stock and distribute the finest automobile products,
such as ol coolers, hosing, hose fittings, filler caps, water
pumps, oll pumps, heater, gauges and more.
Buf
AUGUST 2019 wrsucecarengineeingcamGet the latest product
TECHNOLOGY - THE CONSULTANT
Anti-roll bars, pinion angles
and differing differentials
This month we're looking at how sway bar size affects handling, the
myths surrounding pinion angles, and road course versus oval diffs
P ) Leading-Edge Motorsport Technology Since 1990
developments, technical F
insight and performance , ! i L jae
analysis from the leading | im | § | Ly ri | y r)
motorsport technology en ime: =o
publication every month. a 3g aa enng
Le Mans 2019
MTree ery ei
*Unrivalled analysis
of major events
including Formula
One, the World Rally
Championship and
the World Endurance
Championship
* Detailed racecar design
and innovation
* Features from leading
industry engineers = Print or
and the latest product ——Twotattsvepowerlent —_Indyar ao igital
itinues its CFD
development ETO hint ribleer sues io waiepatens baie, ACCESS
DIGITAL EDITION ALSO AVAILABLE WORLDWIDE
ome eecletueneceut nec wre
p. x
Pres eee een eee al Tes 1
How does thesize ofthe sway
bar affect racecars? know you
‘canrun softer or harder
springs when you change the
boar size, but whyis that? And how doesit
affect the caster and camber?
‘Asway bar antl bar. isan
interconnectve spring almost
always inthe form of torsion
bat It connects front or ear
‘wheel pac nitssimples fortress only
‘oppositional motion ofthe two wheels: when
they movein the same direction, the bar just,
‘umsin its bushings and offers ne resistance;
when one goes upandthe other goes down,
‘that wists the bar anditressts the motion
The bar and the two springs both ress ol
Together they create the elastic component
‘ofthe roll esitance. The geometry ofthe
suspension genealy ls creates some roll
resistance. So, for a given amount fol
resistance, a silfer bar dictates softer springs.
‘Atagivenspeedina given turn the car
willhave an amount of lateral load transfer
determined almost entirely bys track width
andg height The front and rear wheel pars
have to absorb this load transfer, and they spit
itn proportion to theirrespectiv total elastic
and geometric oll esitances Assuming
equal tack width at both ends fone end of
the carhas 60 per cent of the roll resistance it
‘experiences 60 percent of the load transfer
So increasing therollesitance atone
lend ofthe car, whether with the ati-olba,
the springs or the geometry increases load
transfer at that end and decreases load transfer
atthe opposite end. Load transfer hurts lateral
acceleration capability (se bit), so increasing
rollesitance at one end ofthe car makes the
‘opposite end ofthe car stick beter.
‘The se ofthe bar dramaticaly affects its
stfoess The stiffness varies directly with the
fourth power ofthe diameter. it als varies
inversly wit the square of lever arm length,
inversely wit the square of lever arm end to.
‘contact patch motion rato, and inversely with
the fist power ofbar length
(On oval track cars, sometimes the ar and
its associated hardware can be markedly
asymmetial.In such cases the bar can create
(sve ato baron a Formula Ford 1600s asta by sing the veral ads on eer sie ang the bar
Increasing the roll resistance at one end of the
racecar makes the opposite end stick better
roll momentsin response to vertical forces
onthe ar. In extreme cases the barcan even
Pick the left front wheel up off the ground
‘when the front end ofthe cars pulled straight
down and the carisnotallowed toro
Changing the bac does notin itself change
camber o caster. Using a big ba/sft spring
setupon an oval rackar wil cause the front
end torun lower through the turns, and that
wil afect camber and caster nthat case, as
genera ule the car will require more static
postive camber ontheleft font, ess static
negative camber on the ight font, and ess
static asteron both font wheels
Some sayrollbars create more load transfer
than other means of resisting rll Tha'snot
trv, Rall esisance ha the same effect on load
transfer distsbution, no matter where it comes
from. The suspension hasto act through the
‘resto essa and iinescapably changes
theirloads in tect proportion to the ol
resisting moment generated
Another mythisthat atoll bars cannot or
should not be used wth beam axles They are
less needed with beam axles because these
can safely have mare geometric rolresitance
than independent suspensions andi some
classes in stock car racing they are prohibited
‘onthe ear axle, However they workjust fine
with beam axes, and are used with them very
succesfull onal sors of racecars and road
vehicles. They are particularly useful on road
racing cars with Iverearases in conjunction
with low roll centres, This combination reduces
torque wedge the change in diagonal
percentage that results fram driveshatt torque
acting through the suspension
Whatis pinion angle and how
doesitaffect a car? How would
youcaleulateitand around
what angle would be ideal?
Pinion anesthe side view
inclination ofthe ear axles
pinion shaft Horzontalis
.generaly taken as zero. Over the
years there has beena lat of mythology among
‘oval racers about pinion angle According to
Some, the cr puts power down better when
the pinion shaft has anose-down attitude,
AUGUST 2019 winaccarengineengcamTECHNOLOGY - THE CONSULTANT
"ANASCAR stock car ona oad course (Watkins Glen), Dero lockers are much ei ule to oval racing applatons
An abrupt increase in thrust from the outside wheel
adds oversteer and creates the ‘locker twitch’
Some others say having itnose-up does the
same thing do not subscribe to any ofthat
rmyset | actually think the main effec of
‘oddball pinion angles isto increase Uoint
fiction, reducing power tothe wheels and
‘giving theillusion of more traction,
‘There may also bea small tendency for
the driveshaft try tostraighten itself
‘outwhen tis eunning with ots of joint
angular, but fundamentally the driveshaft
is designed to transmit rotational force only.
Ikisnot an axle locating member.
For smoothest operation and good Uoint
le the usual recommendation isto have
‘the pinion shaft statically at the same side
view inclination asthe cank centerine, For
reduction cas this ill generally be around
four degrees nose-up.Thisis usually measured
with an angle finder on the companion ange
For best joint if, we want small joint
angulaty, butt quite zre. We want the
parts ta move enough so the needles inthe
‘cups dont Brine indent the surfaces they run
on, but that usualy nota problem.
How we adjust pinion angle depends on the
"ype of suspension. n some cases, we get
changesin the geometry of things that do
locate the axle when we change pinion angle,
and these wil aflect the handling
With track rms or leaf springs we can adjust
Pinion angle by changing the angle of the
armor springs with respect to the fame, or
\wecan change itwith shims or mounting pad
‘magifcations where the springs or arms
attach tothe carsanle- Changing the position
‘ofthe springs ortruckarms with respec tothe
frame changes ant-squat With lea springs it
nsoeca-engnesngcam AUGUST 2019
changes bump ster. Changing the angle of
the axle housing wit respect tothe springs or
armshas no such effect
‘Sometimes, particulary with Late Model
ir wack stock cars, a Panhard bar ataches to
thenose ofthe centre section The height of
this attachment point wll change I we aise or
lower the font ofthe centre section Lowering
itwalleduce rear geometrierol resistance. This
‘may add understeer, although notifthe car
comers wth the left rar suspension topped
‘outand the lft front wheel off the ground
regardless ofthis adjustment
(ne effect of changing pinion angle thats
often unrecognised isthatit also changes the
heightof theo filer plug onthe differen
Assuming we fillto the plug tataffects the
cillevel inthe dif. This is one reason that
otherwise identical dif when used in diferent
vehicles, willsometimes have diferent filer
pluglocations. Running too much ortoo litle
cilinthe unit adversely affects ts efficiency
and operating temperature.
‘Will you please explain the
differences between the
rear end differentials of
road course and circle (oval)
trackracecars and why they are each
designed the way they are?
Stock cars masty use Detroit
lockers. These ae not quite true
lfferential but they are use for
the same purpove:to drive two
‘output shafts froma common input shaft
whi allowing speed differences between the
output shafts. A tue diff maintains a designed
torque distribution between two output shafts
and ets their relative speed vary rely. Atrue
aitferential with imitd slip add some sort of
friction mechanism thatin some manner limits
how rely te relative speed can vary
Alackeisitferet it drives both output
salts atthe same speed ordinary but wil let
cone whee! overrun ifitreceives a bit of reverse
torque from its wheel. In most lockers ether
vwiheel can overun (but not both at once; there
issill engine power or engine braking tothe
slower wheel, Thismeans that there's not
fixed torque spl. stead the torque split
can ay freely but the speed split cannot, up
tothe point where the torque atone wheel
goes negative. Beyond that point, the slower
whe! gets essentially all the torque and the
fasterone has just enough reverse torque to
‘overcome light spring and unlock
When comerin, the outside whee!
‘overruns and the inside wheel drives This
holds tre uti the river applies enough
power to spinthe inside whee. Then the
nit locks and the drives then shared by
the two rear wheels in proportion tothe
action they have, Theceis an abruptincrease
inthrust fom the ouside wheel This adds
overseer, creating the locke witch
Thereisalsoa special version ofthis device
that isused only on oval tacks where only the
left whee! can overun. One might suppose
that thisis backwards Doesnt the right wheel
‘eed to overrun in alefhand comer? It
would except that these unitsare used with
‘enough tye stagger to make the right wheel
tur slower than the lft one ina left turn of
the radius tat trackhas So the outside wheel
www.WOODFORDTRAILERS.com
Woodford Trailers Limited
14 Great Central Way
Daventry + Woodford Halse
Northants * N11 3PZ
Telephone: 01327 263379
Email: sales@woodfordtrailers.com
AUGUST 2019 yowcecrengneeingcnmall TECHNOLOGY - EV COOLING
Eco telpaCnahsoo eco oP CASCADIA 26: MOTION
and no diferent toszingany system where we inverter canbe asmuchas20ftes per minute” arenow commercially availabe = a
hvebeengvenasetofboundaycondtensMarinsya‘Apkspontsthatyouwoudtw Thegeea pelo oolng emis 5 pee =
from the customer. We use these specific through the inverter ist, then through the the same for IC hybrid and electric powered Prof I M
Coumioutpcdeesndacrcnewthins mre ndimrsndbectotepumyso means bebat ae bomen ‘essional Motorsport
aiahtewcoecciouge! sieeihenacwWines peter Motors and Inverters
grometisoetberalcinpefomane, pena pele esi Steg wich eredeshet he ple UNLEASH YOUR CURRENT POTENTIAL
Asfor inverter cooing, wel that's open and an
s1ea of development for many custome fenoa TOOL nS
The soltionsiplerented depend hey
onthe manufatuersintegaton,butour nce coolant often wate has extracted the eat rom the et source, be tha the
experience wth igh complex vacuum engine, battery motor orinerte then owsino thereat though aes of hin
brand coll plates lps us withhese nelr tbe! inwren theses ional cited shaped ikea Propulsion systems from 50kW to 1MW and beyond
chalenges hat wespecalienis working iti ith li than tensed toh theta alan ati wich th
Inpanielwtheurctomerstoachievetie __sptesthshestothe oncoming and cooler a that fos tough the orf the adr
coolngrecuremerswtcomplesgeometic | _“Outubesate ether older exe tuber andsome have was thinas 2. Whee -the- in si
Sapestomamseperomance andminnse ous canbe as thins 6mm expan And Sct senor engineer a PUR-Once we Inverters, motors, off-the-shelf or custom, in single or dual packages
the paclaging spac required worked outthe speciation ofthe cre, we wil the tube and manufacture thea nto
Safety first ee eae Ui From the Dakar Rally to hill climb, drag-racing, endurance,
InFormalsftyhasremined the main Stackthe sandwich layers of ue andfn ontop ofeach oterto mest rei face area tha,
Dron fichastewos frei | ad in nl ist alt “ motorcycle, Formula E and Formula1
Category of eecticacing understandable efor the components are tacked and brazed together hey wl gothoughaclening
Thiseiplnsay the btery coved thon pres Fash they are washed reduce any contanation onthe component going int the
indirect cooking system using dielectric fu furnace, The coreis then faxed, which Supercars/Hypercars
‘0 avoid any potential leaks and consequent isa procedure where aflux and water intention nm)
short cicuts within the battery, despite the ‘mixtures applied tothe complete core. —
loveratesothetvansechoweve, ava —Tisthen eso powdertat MAUR near
and ghcolmiisusedtcolthe motorand_eneapsustesthe whole core proving a
inverter on te grounds thatashr cuit Alayerof protection etre braang, Pomme Le pee)
fromaleskcan bemvtigtedby opeingthe __Thssesental Because any oxygen RANT MTT
battery contactors Thetefore wit erent haters upinthe face through Ta rai
fhidswsedtocooithebateryandthe motors lhe theenvrnment or evaporated
and inverters the cooing stem onfybridand _romwaterthathas been ton the
tlecticrcearschanconiscftwosepante | caeuilinhttha basing proce
cheutsassthe case informa “Theis the basing procedure,
youhaveamoterandinvertrwhichare which cons of sever stages
usnga wate cold sterandyreguicion | astet reseed bt aise?
youneed tows dlecticfuid onthe baton, _Scttays‘Depending onthe se and Aspen of Rew range et KR a sOU0OT
Jouhavenechoicebuttosptthe systems’ massofthe core each wireatferenty_ vlped by waFinevn arse PR,
Marinsays'Whatve a seeninthe pasts becuse ots thermalietia so we veto
thatyoutendtofow more fuidtroughthe _pckabespote recto gtthatcoreupto the ital braze temperate: .
bateysoasarestyouneedadifeentpump. _ Thebrazng process stars of witha dying stage to ensure that any ofthe remaing fx ‘
‘overdo presets Duh” sbewn ede Tematfal there model fam 00 ees PROPELLING INNOVATION in ELECTRIC PROPULSION
flyer the ater cooing cra Depanding onthe cor concn either the tubes eis wil have an adtonalacrfical
Forthemotorandvertecoolngcicut _lyerwhichly makesup anal portion ofthe total mater hchness. PES | wcascanianorion.com
thereat several schoo of thought onthe “Thesacrifiialcading ners slighty lowering pinthan the parent mater ee
insteffectveconiguatonTypealy ning _sowhanthe furnace ast to theca temperate the cladding layer lly est
‘to make a cooling circuit with a very high heat and it will start to use capillary action to work towards any joints in the core itself; Scott a een LAA
tranfercoefcentoftenrezutsinalatofback explains Those ae the jit between the fran th tbe andl the joint between the
presure onthe motor whichmakesitdifiat ender lateandthe tue. tlcete alt in those its and once the part drops below
tocool bot the motor and theinverrin thecal braze temperate itil oii. Therefore weend up with one piece uit
SeiesThecombined pressure losislicyto_whichiscompltel sealed without any aks
86 wnsacear-angnosingcom AUGUST 2019mill TECHNOLOGY - CHASSIS SIMULATION
Playing with dyno mights
While dyno results should be treated with some caution, when
they’re combined with simulation data it all adds up to one
very powerful set-up tool, argues Racecar’s maths guru
By DANNY NOWLAN
ne ofthe most disturbing trends
have sen over the ast couple of
years has ben the emerging view
that dyn results whether they're
for engine tyre or aerodynamics, might be afox
sent from God Almighty himsel
Thisis particularly apparent with ecent
‘graduate engineers uta supsngly effects
alotof enor engineers as wel ste principal
‘of ChassisSim one ofmy main activites i getting
‘correlation on a daly basis and thisputs mein
unique position to discus this After al have to
deal wth the fallout from this every day
Tobegin dynos whether they be engine,
‘tyre or aero ~are primary comparative too,
Dont get me wrong, they wil ge you a good
idea on where the absolute numbers ae but
they arenever the nal wor. leant this ist
hand when worked foran aftermarket engine
management compary. We used to derive alt
‘of amusement atthe keyboard warriors who
‘would oloatinly pos thr dyno resus. Butif
yout involved inthe engine tuning game you
recognise very quickly that the absolute results
‘ofan engine dyno wl vary. tl depend on
your ambient conditions and how lang the
‘engine/carhas been onthe dyna, becauseit
gets eal warm real quick This doesrt mean the
rumbers you get from the dyno are bad. Asa
‘comparative too they are lant, and having
been involved inthe experince of tuning
engines on the road, know that once you tune
‘ona dyno you wil never go back
‘eth hisis al wel and good for the
engine what about tyes and aero? Wel frst.
fal hate to bust alot of engineers bubbles
here, but wind tunnel esuts arent the panacea
that everyone seems to thinkthey are.
Tounderstandthis you need to knora tle
bit about how wind tunnels work and what you
are trying to model in them. As canbe seen in
the picture above, the wind tunnel hasa certain
‘oss sectional atea and you have ascale model
corinthiscasea carin there, andiealy a oling
‘oad. The ist problem comes with blockage
elects that wl effec the low aound the mode
‘orcar Thanks to Bemoul’ equation we know
‘the alrspeed wll increase around the cr Also,
‘when modeling in subsonic flow you match
the Reynolds numbers and in supersonic ow
yyoumatch the Mach number The problem with
racecar aerodynamics is that thanks to thecars
proximity tothe ground we have high subsonich
‘tansonic flow coming together There are
‘certain things we can do to mitigate this and as
_acomparative tol and something tohep get
you int the bal parka wind tunnels invaluable,
However to claim twillgive you absolute
numbers to within one to two per cents foolish,
Irthiswas the case why mould FI teams employ
‘engineers tovalidate their ontrack ero?
Taking on fluid
sit now CFDs ioimmatre to give
you an aroma thatiswihin ve er cet!
the absolute velues The cod bssnumeta
procsing powers spy not there where
(isworth ts waghtingotisin png ou
undesiandwhathe ow sutures as el
asilstating the pitch sensi
Butthere awesome xcptons. At acate
Inpont. Toman ToalsimUSAdo great
‘ork wl Andrew iat om AME
‘ero Butthey areexcepional at wath do
Rob Lewis Ray Letoand Andrew Brillant and
their respective teams have been doing this
forsolong they have an instinctive felfor the
numbers, while they have fallen in love with
thei oun publicity ether.
The next thing to seus istyre testrig
results and what you get from Pacejka results,
because tissomething weneed tohave 2
serious chat about had five dolls fom every
Formula tudent/FSAE team that thinks that
Pacejka result from tyre test gests ae thelast
word on tyre performance then | would have
retired avery longtime ago as avery wealthy
‘man. The thing they are wrong. One ofthe
worst kept secrets ishow unreliable Pacejta
results actualy are Figure 1 isaPaceka result
fram aigh downforce category was involed
in, which a particularly egregious example of
Something going pear shaped
Dueto confidentiality cant say where
thiscame from and have hadto blockout
the scalings but what thi tye model shows is
thatas yu apply laa the peakslip angle wil
Increase significantly So what this means for
vehicle performance’ you would have to be
applying 10 degres of tering lock Given ny
Dynos will certainly give you a very good idea on where the
absolute numbers are but they are never the final word
188 wsacecatengresingcam AUGUST 2019
customers atthe time where reporting about
‘wot three degree of tering through high
speed comers an the racecars were gluedto
the trackthey gured out eally quickly that
‘these results lefa lot tobe desired,
‘The eason these results can go wrong is
‘down totwo factors and the ist of theses the
inadequacies ofthe Paceka mode self This
«ould be anartlein its ov ight. The other
reasonisthat tre test machines are very hard
essed todeal with the thermal conditions you
willencounter onthe ace track Thisis motto
say they are bad onthe contrary they are very
useulanda a asin point would jump at
thechanceto use the Sova Motion igin Alton,
Virginia inthe US, for instance Asa comparative
‘ool they are very useful and have their pace.
However you alvayshave to treat tyre test
results sa rough stating point ony
Dyno sore
Nowat ths pointin the game know afew of
you reading this wl be iting the rev inite
suffering from extreme cognitive cssonance, But
‘alm down forthe way you deal with this is
actually quite simple, and | wl break this down
‘rom the easiest method tothe hardest.
Fist, dealing with the engine isactaly
very simple, because of al the measurements
were looting at thisis actually very close. What
you do hereis fix the engine power and use your
lap time simulation tools ike Chass, to tune
the engineeficency and global A values. In
Table’ there are some ugh rules of thumb
thathave worked fr us ove the years
Do treat these as rough rules ofthumb,
‘though. You typically employ tis when your end
of staightisa +-delta of 20kmvh. Once you are
‘down under thislimit you tuneby scaling the
CRE ee ny
Lateral force (N)
Normal force (N)
Slipangle (Rad)
nee ed
Transmission type
‘Open wheelerprototype
GTear/mid-engine
ring canfront engine
total QA map or in Chassis speak you play
with the C,Aon therear wing. The gal here
Istomatch the speed at the end of the fastest
straight. This ilusteated in Figure 2
InFigure2 actuals coloured data and
simlatedis black. You play with the maximum
CAvalues until you are within 05to tanh This
Figure 2: Matching the speed at the end of the fastest straight
and thats representative environment
Net taken thelsts dealing wth
downforce. your wind tunnelis any good
itwillgive you very good baseline on pitch
eh see
———— =
|s good enough. Artis pointinthe game sty
speaking you may not have an absolute value
bbutyou have something much more powerul,
&
AUGUST 2019 wonnaecrengnesingcon 99TECHNOLOGY - CHASSIS SIMULATION
sensitivity. Your st pot of cll. hen istoscale
the global A and apply 2glbal aero offset.
‘The great thing about Chasissim isthatifyou
clickon the rear wing by adjusting the Cand
aero balance offset valves then ths willbe done
for you.The goal here is tomatch the damper
postions front and ear atthe end ofthe longest
straight. Thisislustratedin Figure 3.
‘Again actuals coloured and simulateds
black. The ist channels speed the seconds
steering, The tied trace the fron pitch which
istheaveraged leftand ight front dampers,
and the last races the rear pitch, which isthe
averaged lft and ght reat dampers Allyou
are doing i playing withthe global A and
aero balance to match up the fastest end of
‘straight condition You can also do this with
ther lap time o track epay simulation. At this
stage ofthe game it doesnt matter.
The next step inthe process sto refine
the pitch sensitivity map. This is actual rally
simple and as much a would ike to take the
ence engpetngcom AUGUST 2019
EQUATION 1
Trip =ky(l—ky “F,)F
Were:
Tyo =o hs 0)
il eter fon
top el oe ith nt
dente
creditor ths haveto give ito a colleague of
min. JP Sarin, ho came up ith the idea of
sing the Chasssim track repay to compare
simulated to actual datas shown in Figure 4,
Here youneed tolook t where the dampers
don'tmatch up Then look at what the simulated
rie heights are and that ls you what you need
Parameter Value |
2 |
sestN) |
toadjustin the aeromap inthis case what this
telngusis that we need to decease the CAin
thisateaandincrease forward aero balance.
The ast thing we need totalkabout ishow to
ea withthe tyres and to this we needto cap
a technique ve discussed before, which involves
tyre modeling frm scratch To recap, we are
sing the form ofthe traction crc radius that
isshownin Equation 1, and some typical values
forthisae shown in Table2.
What sally seul about thisis that any
'yre canbe broken down into a peak oad and
DOCKING
ea
Ea en TELE Wg
¢
Cen aa
ET EY <<
ras EUR
ASS CDs
PEM pac
Peete
Prete
Cee
Dre eye Soy
oO ReeeCglet
+44(0) 1327 858011
Ps ecu acy
OM
‘Welding Standards
Unit 15 Siverstone Circuit’
Silverstone, Northants
NNI26T, United Kingdom
Ren Rod crane erro earn
in motorsport transmissions covering rebuilds,
PUSeiecro on ates agcetonl
types of gearboxes and axles.
Supporting teamsin the Worid Endurance Championship,
pteoey Cie neeeeeats
tas
Eee ee cee aes
Eien natant as wellas input
erates
MJTech Limited
peer
cs a
ee ee
eee ort)
eee od
eNeeeet ey ss
te sero oo a)
>: www.m-)-tech.com + @ MJ Tech Limited.
Racing
Development
GO eee
Re eee arsenate
@ecraneeane KRONE, EEG:
Pitstop products, and Is supplier to most works Le Mans but also
‘many pivate teams! Hope to hear fom you soon.
~ =
oOo o>
AUGUST 2019 yowacecrengneeingcmnTECHNOLOGY - CHASSIS SIMULATION
cabernet
= she HA ee Mn nici 4 pet me
nly addition to ths fyouare sing something The bottomline is that awel-alibrateddatalog
ke Chassis, isthatfortransient simulation _villalway hae the final word
you add 20 per cent scaling font and rea, In closing, while engine, wind tunnel and
because you need that offset the bumps. tyre testi results are valuable points of
_ Tosumup.whatwehavedonehere suse reference they are never the final word on the
both dyno results and data together Inthecase numbers you apply othe acecar T subscribe
ofengine and aero we tookourenginedyno_tothisvewisnaively optimistic at best and
and wind tunnel essa ourbaseline We then downright dangerous at worst But you
sed the data to ine tune the resis use these numbers asa start point and cross
Lastly, with the tyre results because tyre reference this withthe data usin the methods
testrigresutstendtobelessrelablewe had wehave discussed then they wll become a
force asilustatedin Figures (where, isthe _tobealitleceativehere. However asalways vty powerful ool that will provide you with
load atvhich thetyregeneratesitsmaximum everythings crosreferenced backtothedata. _amodelthat srepresetatve,
force). There are two ingredients tothe magic
sauce that makesal this work AS canbe seen
from Figure 6, the fist method is youneed to
determine the peak load of the traction cirle - eee om
‘adius You cn do this by runing a track replay
simulation or 2 ough cut time simulation,
‘ether using ChasssSim or something sito
determine what the tye lands look ke during
‘the lap Thisislstrated in Figure
Allyouthen need todo isto take the peak
‘yreloods and add 1000 200kg and this gives
you your peak load For Formula Student cars,
which ate so mach ightes,add50 to 100k
‘The final piece ofthe purses figuring out the
intial co-efficient offction.Allyou are doing
isa stat force balance oragivencuvatue,
Speed and setup. Then you change the k tems
or initia co-efficient of fiction tomatch the
corner speeds The eally grat thing about this
isitcanbe combined nan Excel spreadsheet
suchas the one illustrated in Figure 7.
(Once youhavealthisyouhaveatyremodel | #f
you can putinto your simulation package.The + #Astem ACR!
venue engpetngcom AUGUST 2019
0 ee
DISCOVER
NEW TECHNOLOGY.
ES
BUSINESS.
P14 1a
Ua PD
UT
ca)
Se VR ee eRe Lee Cell (c}
SU amie eas TM eee
Miya Ra AZ Le
PCS CO SCL LL Learn more at pri2019.comlll BUSINESS - PEOPLE
Interview —- Hugh Chambers
At your service
The CEO of Motorsport UK explains how the recent shake-up in the national
governing body in Britain amounts to much more than just a name change
By MIKE BRESLIN
‘The very clear
evidence is that
unless we make
‘some changes
the future of
motorsport, not just
in this country but
| think worldwide,
is threatened’
betes. an expression Hugh Chambers kes to use to