Colgate Space Dentistry1

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

!

!
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Balwant Rai

Space Dentistry: Longer


Duration Manned Missions
Educational Objectives

Upon completion of this course, the participant will be able to:

1. Understand the possible effects of space environments on the oral cavity.

2. Possible dental emergencies during space missions.

3. Proposed dental emergency kit for space mission.


Abstract
Extraterrestrial environments can have a significant impact on the physiological and
psychological well-being of astronauts including oral health and the acclimatization of astronauts
to these conditions is of utmost importance. The new disciplines of aeronautical and space
dentistry are a specialized branches of dentistry which deal with the study of oro-dental factors
in aeronautical and extraterrestrial environments. Dental emergencies are real medical
emergencies during short and long term space missions and must be handled accordingly.

Since environments in space can have adverse effects on the oral cavity including oral health,
an aeronautical or space dentist has to be prepared to screen and select only those astronauts
with optimal oral health prior to a mission as well as make guidelines for the preparation of
dental emergency kits to deal with dental emergencies during missions. This article reviews the
possible effects of space environments on the oral cavity, dental emergencies during space
missions and the role of dental emergency kits.

Introduction
During Space missions such as Mars expeditions, international crews are involved in complex
activities over long periods of time in isolated, harsh and extreme environments. Extraterrestrial
environments have been found to affect human physiology causing bone loss, muscle atrophy,
cardiac dysrhythmias, altered orientation and psychological status of astronauts during both
short- and long-duration spaceflights.1, 2 Very few studies have been conducted to show the
effects of microgravity on the oral cavity.3-5 NASA and other space agencies have to date
reported only limited dental emergencies in space. Astronauts, however, are likely to encounter
more dental emergencies during long missions such as trips to Mars. For this reason, proper
protocols and dental kits are vital tools necessary to address dental emergencies should these
occur during long missions. This article addresses possible dental emergencies and the design
and component parts of an Emergency Dental Kit for space.

As mentioned earlier, the effect of long duration on oral cavity has only been studied in limited
fashion3-13. The following studies have been reported so far:

a) Skylab studies:5-6, 12-13 These studies highlight a significant increase among inflight
increments of dental plaque, calculus and gingival inflammation. Oral microflora such as
streptococci, Neisseria, lactobacilli, and enteric bacilli were significantly higher. Studies reported
the relative absence of intraoral changes that are hazardous to health and in other studies it has
been reported that higher levels of mycoplasma and cariogenic streptococci and decreased
counts of enteric bacilli, decreased saliva flow rates, and increased secretory Immunoglobulin A
and saliva lysozyme level were observed. Secretory IgA and salivary lysozyme elevations were
considered to be responsive to an endogenous or environmental microbial in influence.

b) JBR studies during simulated space mission environments:3-4, 7-11 Saliva based
biomarkers of periodontal diseases, dental caries and bone loss biomarkers were found to be
elevated in extreme and isolated environments. Wound healing is also significantly delayed
during space missions. Trigeminal sensations and taste sensation are significantly affected in
extreme conditions and during extravehicular activities in extreme conditions. Furthermore,
temporomandibular joint and facial pain is elevated in extreme conditions. A simulated isolated

environment increases plaque formation, and anaerobic and aerobic bacterial levels were
significantly increased.

The following oral-dental problems have been experienced and documented during space flight
by astronaut crews and related ground based studies3-11
• Barotrauma
• Periodontitis

• Dental caries

• Bone loss and fractures of the jaw bone

• Facial pain and numbness of teeth and oral cavity tissue


• Stones of the salivary duct and oral cancer
• Headache
• Rash, facial, recurrent inguinal

• Nasal congestion

• Acute maxillary sinusitis

Evidence based dental emergencies during long duration space missions: The evidence
required to hypothesize and estimate the probability of oral dental problems occurring during
space missions can be taken from several different sources.

Some of these include:

(a) Records of dental problems that were faced during previous space flights by crews as well
as other international partners;

(b) information on the medical conditions that occurred during short- and long-term Earth
expeditions i.e. simulated space flight missions (submarine, alpine, Arctic and Antarctic
expeditions, expeditions to other remote ground-based locations, etc.);

(c) General population studies addressing the age-related probabilities of different diseases
and incidence of trauma as well as injuries;

(d) Pre- and post-flight records of the health status and medical conditions of astronauts and
cosmonauts;

(e) JBR studies of Martian sol bed rest (simulated microgravity) {Investigator: Balwant Rai };

(f) Mars analog mission {Investigator: Balwant Rai };

(g) Pilot surveys i.e. the study of oral dental problems faced by crew members including
fighter pilots during long duration flights {Investigator : Balwant Rai}.


Number of Dental Emergencies :

(a). Evidence can also be obtained from the Longitudinal Study of the Astronaut Health
database that is maintained at NASA Johnson Spaceflight Center (JSC). Two dental
emergencies occurred during March 14, 1995, through June 12, 19986.

(b). One dental emergency occurred during a Mars analog mission (Rai B 2009).

(c) Two dental emergencies occurred during JBR study of Martian sol study (Rai B, 2011).

Possible Dental emergencies during long duration space mission:6-11

The following dental emergencies are most likely to be faced during space missions:

(a) Barodontalgia

(b) Periodontitis

(c) Dental caries

(d) Bone loss and fractures of the jaw bone as well as a delay in wound healing

(e) Facial pain and numbness of teeth as well as oral cavity tissues

(f) Stones of the salivary duct

(g) Oral cancer

Dental Kit for Long Manned Missions


Dental emergencies have occurred only rarely in space flights during ISS missions and Moon
landings, however the frequency of occurrence during missions to Mars is likely to higher.

Dental problems can become a real medical emergency during these long duration missions.
Typically dental problems have arisen in about 5% or less of all recorded missions. As noted
earlier dental problems are now largely prevented by regular and complete preflight
examinations and preventive measures during crew training. Long duration space missions are
planned for travel to the Moon, Mars, and beyond and as the length of the mission increases the
likelihood of dental emergencies occurring in space flight naturally increases. Space crews live
and work as well as travel in a weightless, hyper gravity, zero gravity and a higher radiation-
level environment. The forces exerted on the human body in these environments produce
impact forces that can lead to tooth fracture and other significant injuries to the face and jaws.

There is also the possibility to observe cracked teeth, inflammation or infections of the tooth
pulp, temporo-mandibular disorders, periodontal abscesses, and dental caries as well as a
delay in wound healing during a long-duration flight(3-16). In order to allow for potential
emergencies specific dental instruments, materials and other important supplies should be
included in dental kit supplied to every space vehicle and space station (See Table1). The best
selection of analgesics and antibiotics appropriate for dental treatment and inclusion in the
dental kit for a space mission should be determined by a dental expert, i.e. a space dentist, with
experience in microgravity and radiation as well as in extraterrestrial environments. The detailed
formulation of a medical kit should be made in consultation with aero space medical physicians

who are also directly involved in the mission and mission planning. Physicians caring for
astronauts, mission specialists, or those in long course residency training should help maintain
and update the dental kit. This way they can provide a tool suitable for dental care in remote
settings if needed in the absence of a dentist.

Kit Design
The external case for the Dental Emergency Kit should be well designed for use on
extraterrestrial missions. This means that the casing should be lightweight, non-toxic, and also
meet relevant packaging criteria for the retention of the instruments under gravity-free, thermal
free conditions and should be resistant to the effects of extraterrestrial conditions. These
requirements also suggest an optimized strength-to-weight relationship. I selected a hard-shell-
foam core design (sandwich panel construction) for the packaging of the kit. The instruments
were embedded in form-fitted detents providing a slight interference fit, thereby solving the
problem of retention under weightlessness conditions.

Dental Training for Astronauts


Astronauts and mission specialists should be trained personally in emergency dental treatment
such as oral diagnosis, pain control methods, technologies for local dental anesthesia, dental
infection treatment, placement of temporary fillings, extraction of teeth, and bleeding control as
well as management of oral and maxillofacial trauma and injuries. In order to make sure that the
equipment will indeed provide the necessary dental assistance for the Astronauts adequate
training and testing needs to be done. In order to ensure that the crew were familiar with
appropriate use of the dental equipment and the introduction of unfamiliar technologies they
were provided with thorough training sessions that went on for 15 to 180 days. Outpatient based
procedures were discussed during the training programs. This process helped train the crew in
how to address problems as serious as the treatment of maxillary bone fractures and other
emergencies that are anticipated to be less serious than tooth removal. In addition to the
training programs a manual with diagrams of each procedure should, in all instances, be
provided on the space vehicle to serve as a guide for all crew members. This manual contains
detailed instructions on procedures, information on diagnosis, and images sourced from
personal radiographs of each astronaut to illustrate the oral structure for every astronaut on the
mission.

Recommendations for the Space and Aeronautical Dentist or Space


Oral Physician
a. Clinical examination19-21

1. Very standard dental or oral health guidelines have been established for the selection and
oral examination during pre-flight dental examination of astronauts to minimize the possibility of
dental emergencies during flight

2. Astronauts have to undergo a dental examination at least 6 months before launch

3. Any dental treatment required should be done 3 to 6 months before launch depending on the
types of treatment indicated.


4. Crew medical officers and crew dental officers should work together and discuss possible
dental emergencies during pre flight briefings.

b. Space Dentistry in the Dental Curriculum : I have proposed four types of training 19-21 :

1. an FAD (Fellowship of Aeronautic Dentistry) is to be awarded to students completing an


introductory course requiring 18 weeks of full-time study

2. a PGDAD (Postgraduate Diploma in Aeronautic Dentistry) is to be awarded to students


completing an advanced course requiring 36 weeks of full time study.

3. Masters in Space and Aeronautical Dentistry: is to be awarded to students completing a very


advanced course requiring 2 years of full time study.

4. PhD in Space and Aeronautical Dentistry: is to be awarded to students completing a highly


advanced course including a Ph.D thesis requiring 3 years of full time study.

CDE Programme and Journal Clubs: I have proposed this to different countries and dental
councils as well as dental credit awarding agencies to start a CDE programme . In addition this
has been proposed to Journal clubs.

Research and Development:19-21

It is of prime importance for aeronautical or space dentists to design and conduct studies in
simulated space flight environments i.e. simulated space missions, ground-based studies, in the
ISS as well as at the Mars simulated lab., in aeronautical and space dentistry. Different smart
technologies as well as oral health care products should be formulated and used to care for the
oral health of astronauts during space missions, in addition to normal populations.

Conclusion
A well designed dental kit with the right combination of medicines, instruments, supplies and
devices with accompanying training manual can provide an important tool to address
emergency dental problems should they arise in space. Treatment of dental problems in space
remains a very challenging area. NASA and other space agencies have explored and carried
out research on how to address unexpected dental emergencies in space. Accordingly much
more dental research must be performed in the planning of future for long duration crewed
missions in space. To address this possibility NASA, among other activities, has sponsored the
development of an emergency dental kit. This kit has been designed to contain instruments,
materials, and drugs that would operate in the weightlessness of space and be easy to use and/
or operate in space. Moreover, astronauts, prior to flights, have been systematically required to
visit the dentist’s chair before their flight in order to anticipate and hopefully prevent any possible
dental problems that might occur during their mission. This process has been successful for
short duration flights but more needs to be done to address the needs of manned personnel on
longer duration flights.

Acknowledgment
I am thankful to Dr. Paul D Slowey , Oasis Diagnostics® Corporation, [Vancouver WA USA] for
making English corrections and thoroughly reviewing this manuscript


References
1. Belakovski_ MS. The 6th International Congress "MEDICINE IN SPACE AND EXTREME
ENVIRONMENTS. Aviakosm Ekolog Med. 2015;49(3):61-7.

2. Clément GR, Bukley AP, Paloski WH. Artificial gravity as a countermeasure for mitigating
physiological deconditioning during long-duration space missions. Front Syst Neurosci. 2015 Jun
17;9:92. doi: 10.3389/fnsys.2015.00092. eCollection 2015.

3. Rai B, Kaur J, Foing BH. Evaluation by an aeronautic dentist on the adverse effects of a six-week
period of microgravity on the oral cavity. Int J Dent. 2011;2011:548068.

4. Rai B, Kaur J. The history and importance of aeronautic dentistry. J Oral Sci. 2011 ;53(2):143-6.

5. Brown LR, Fromme WJ, Handler SF, Wheatcroft MG, Johnston DA. Effect of Skylab missions on
clinical and microbiologic aspects of oral health. J Am Dent Assoc. 1976 ;93(2):357-63.

6. Stewart LH, Trunkey D, Rebagliati GS. Emergency medicine in space. J. Emerg. Med.2007; 32(1):
45–54

7. Rai B, Kaur J. Association between stress, sleep quality and temporomandibular joint dysfunction:
simulated Mars mission. Oman Med J. 2013 ;28(3):216-9.

8. Rai B, Kaur J. Periodontal status, salivary immunoglobulin, and microbial counts after short exposure
to an isolated environment. J Oral Sci. 2013;55(2):139-43.

9. Rai B, Kaur J, Foing BH. Wound healing and mucosal immunity during short Mars analog
environment mission: salivary biomarkers and its clinical implications. Eurasian J Med. 2012 ;44(2):
63-7.

10. Rai B, Kaur J, Catalina M, Anand SC, Jacobs R, Teughels W. Effect of simulated microgravity on
salivary and serum oxidants, antioxidants, and periodontal status. J Periodontol. 2011 ;82(10):
1478-82.

11. Rai B, Kaur J,Catalina M. Bone mineral density, bone mineral content, gingival crevicular fluid (matrix
metalloproteinases, cathepsin K, osteocalcin), and salivary and serum osteocalcin levels in human
mandible and alveolar bone under conditions of simulated microgravity. J Oral Sci.2010 ;52(3):
385-90.

12. Taylor GR. Recovery of medically important microorganisms from Apollo astronauts. Aerospace Med.
1974; 45: 824-828

13. Taylor GR, Kropp KD, Henney MR, Ekblad SS, Baky AA, Groves TO, Molina TC, Decelle JG,
Carmichael CF, Gehring NJ, Young EL, Shannon IL, Frome WJ, Funderburk NR . Microbial
Exchange: Experiment AR-002. ApolloSoyuz Test Project: Summary Science Report Vol I. Scientific
and Technical Information Office, National Aeronautics and Space Administration. 1977; 237-255.

14. Rai B, Kaur J. 18th IAA Humans in Space Symposium (2011). http://www.dsls.usra.edu/meetings/IAA/
pdf/2002.pdf


15. Rai B. Dental emergencies during space mission: Proposed models. J Appl Mech Eng. DOI:
10.4172/2168-9873.S1.002

16. Rai B. Salivary Proteome During Simulated Mars Analog Missions: Aeronautical (Space) Dentistry. J
Aeronaut Aerospace Eng 2014; 3:e124. doi: 10.4172/2168-9792.1000e124.

17. Rai B, Kaur J. Bone loss in dental implant during simulated microgravity: Salivary biomarkers in
Space dentistry (IAA-HIS-15-P14). 20th Humans in Space Symposium (HIS), pp.31

18. Rai B, Kaur J. Effects of Herbal mouth wash on Bone Metabolism in a simulated Microgravity
Environment (IAA-HIS-15-P16) . 20th Humans in Space Symposium (HIS).pp.31

19. Rai B. Aeronautic Dentistry: A New Specialized branch and its Curriculum Guidelines. Internet J Dent
Sci 2007;5:69-72

20. Rai B, Kaur J. The history and importance of aeronautic dentistry. J Oral Sci 2011;53:143-46.

21. Rai B. Effects of Microgravity on Teeth and Periodontium: Aeronautic Dentistry. Internet J Dent Sci
2007;5:4-6.


Table: 1 Dental Kit for Long Space Missions Including Mars Missions
( proposed by Dr. Balwant Rai )

Proposed Proposed Proposed Non- Other Proposed Proposed Devices


Medicines Instruments Medicinal Supplies Supplies

Analgesics Wooden plastic or Tooth paste and Gauze/sponge (2X Laser, LED
(in medical kit) smart instruments. mouth wash (non- in) (2 packs) technology for
foaming, anti-caries, dentistry
anticancer, anti-
inflammatory) 17-18

Anesthesia Carpule Front surface Instrument Anesthesia Anesthesia syringe


3% mepivacaine dental mouth mirror disinfection packet aspirating dental needle
HCl 4% articaine syringe
HCl with 1:100000
epinephrine

Extraction forceps Handheld light with Long gauge Examination gloves Extraction elevators
Antibiotics such as batteries
amoxicillin and
cloxacillin Others
such as 5%
amlexanox, non
alcoholic tooth
paste and mouth
wash, Antioxidants
and calcium
supplements,
melatonin, 0.05%
oxymetazoline and
0.5-1%
phenylephrine

Cavit-G, Dycal Excavator (small) Cotton rolls Periodontal scaler Set of elevators
(tubes and
apllicator)

Topical application Robotic or smart Dental floss and Arch wires and Explorer, Giggle
such as ibuprofen instruments tooth brush instruments for saw
and antibiotics tagging of arch wire

You might also like