Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Andersondissertation 2 PDF
Andersondissertation 2 PDF
IN BAMILEKE-NGYEMBOON
by
Stephen C. Anderson
August 1983
Electronic file: November, 2005
UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
THE GRADUATE SCHOOL
UNIVERSITY PARK
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90007
2
Table of Contents
Page
1.0. Introduction 1
1.1. Language and People 1
1.2. Consonants and Vowels 4
2.0. Tone Rules 6
2.1. Previous Work 12
2.2. Nouns 15
2.2.1. In isolation 16
2.2.2. In associative noun phrases 28
2.3. Verbs 52
2.3.1. With realis/irrealis tones 60
2.3.2. With imperfective aspect 88
2.3.3. With tense markers 104
2.3.4. With progressive aspect markers 150
2.3.5. With negative markers 167
2.4. Between Phrases 176
2.4.1. Between subject and verb 176
2.4.2. Between object and verb 208
2.5. Overall Rule Ordering 232
3.0. Verb Paradigms 246
3.1. Remote Past (P4) 252
3.2. Distant Past (P3) 257
3.3. Yesterday Past (P2) 263
3.4. Today Past (P1) 268
3.5. Zero (P0 and PRES) 278
3.6. Today Future (F1) 288
3.7. Tomorrow Future (F2) 292
3.8. Distant Future (F3) 298
3.9. Remote Future (F4) 301
4.0. Morpheme Rules 306
5.0. Conclusion 339
References 344
Appendix A 347
Appendix B 351
3
CHAPTER 1
0-/-Hmsqnctbshnm
Sgdoqdrdmschrrdqs`shnmhrbnmbdqmdcvhsgsgdbnlokdwsnm`k
ogdmnldm`entmchmsgdFq`rrehdkcrA`mstk`mft`fdrneB`ldqnnm+
rodbhehb`kkxsgdMfxdla——mZœæ,fxd∆l,a—≈9¶ \k`mft`fdronjdmhmsgdVdrsdqm
Oqnuhmbd-Sgdoqhl`qx`hlnesghrchrrdqs`shnmhrsnoqdrdms`rxrsdl`shb
`mcdwok`m`snqx`bbntmsneu`qhntrsnmd`mclnqogdldqtkdr-Sne`bhkhs`sd
sghrotqonrd+`m`tsnrdfldms`kognmnknfhb`ksgdnqxvhkkaddloknxdcsn
oqdrdmssgdsnm`kogdmnldm`hm`rdwokhbhs`eq`ldvnqj`ronrrhakd-@
rdbnmc`qx`hlnesghrchrrdqs`shnmhrsn`bbntmsenq`vhcdqrbnodnesnm`k
c`s`sg`mg`roqduhntrkxaddmonrrhakdhm`Fq`rrehdkcrA`mstk`mft`fd-
0-0-K`mft`fd`mcOdnokd
SgdMfxdla——mk`mft`fdhro`qsnesgdA`lhkdjdk`mft`fdfqnto
vghbghrronjdmlnrskxhmsgdMnqsgvdrsdqmbnqmdqnesgdVdrsdqm
OqnuhmbdnesgdTmhsdcQdotakhbneB`ldqnnm-@bbnqchmfsnsgd0865
tmneehbh`kbdmrtr+rnld7/+///Mfxdla——mrod`jdqrkhudhmsgdehudqtq`k
bghdecnlrkhrsdcadknv9
Hsb`madrddmeqnlsgdoqdbdchmfehftqdrsg`ssgdMfxdla——modnokd
g`ud`ghfgonotk`shnmcdmrhsx+`udq`fhmfnudq6//odnokdsnsgdrpt`qd
lhkd-Hme`bs+sghr`qd`bnms`hmrnmdnesgdlnrscdmrdbnmbdmsq`shnmrne
odnokdentmchm`mxqtq`k`qd`hm`kkneB`ldqnnm-
Hm`cchshnmsnsgdqtq`konotk`shnm+l`mxMfxdla——mg`udlnudchmsn
u`qhntrsnvmr`mcbhshdrneB`ldqnnmvgdqdsgdhqoqhmbho`knbbto`shnmhr
trt`kkxrsnqdjddohmf-Sgdsnvmr`mcbhshdrg`uhmfsgdfqd`sdrsmtladqrne
Mfxdla——mrod`jdqr`qdLantc`+Crbg`mf+A`entrr`l+Mjnmfr`la`+
Cnt`k``mcX`ntmcd-Henmdbntmsrsgdrdtqa`mrod`jdqr+`mc`krn
`rrtldr`onotk`shnmfqnvsgq`sdne1odqbdmsodqxd`qnudqsgdo`rsrhw
xd`qr+sgdsns`konotk`shnmneMfxdla——mrod`jdqroqna`akx`ooqn`bgdr
0//+///-
LnrsnesgdMfxdla——modnokdkhuhmfhmsgdqtq`kbghdecnlrl`jd
sgdhqkhuhmfax`fqhbtkstqd-Sgdchuhrhnmnek`anqhrrtbgsg`sldmbtkshu`sd
sgdb`rgbqnonebneeddvghkdvnldmbtkshu`sdsgdenncbqnor-Lnrsnesgd
2
tqa`mcvdkkdqr+nmsgdnsgdqg`mc+`qdhmunkudchmu`qhntrbnlldqbh`k
`bshuhshdrnqfnudqmldms`kctshdr-
Khmfthrshb`kkx+sgdMfxdla——mk`mft`fdadknmfrsnsgdA`lhkdjdrta,
fqntonesgdLa`l,Mj`lrta,chuhrhnmnesgdFq`rrehdkcrA`mstk`mft`fd
e`lhkx-Sghrenkknvrsgdbk`rrhehb`shnmnesgdFAVF'Fq`rrehdkcrA`mst
VnqjhmfFqnto+`rhmRs`kkbto+087/943`mcKdqnx+0866906,07(+vghbg
khrsrsgduhkk`fdneA`mf`mf`rqdoqdrdms`shudnesgdMfxdla——mk`mft`fd+
`radknv9
'1(@(VDRSDQMFQ@RREHDKCR
k-Ring9K`lmrn+@fgdl+dsb-
1-Menchum9Na`mf-
2-Widikum9Lnfg`ln+Mfhd+dsb-
3-Lower Mundani-Njen9KnvdqLtmc`mh+Midm-
A(LA@L,MJ@L
k-Nkambe9Khlatl+dsb-
1-Nun9A`ltm+Ltmf`j`+dsb-
2-Ngemba9L`mjnm+A`ets+dsb-
3-Bamileke9A`mf`mf+Crbg`mf+Ed&ed&+A`mcitm+
A`mf`mfsdæ+dsb-
Sgd`tsgnqg`raddmkhuhmfhmsgduhkk`fdneA`mf`mf`mcrstcxhmfsghr
o`qshbtk`qk`mft`fdnee`mcnmrhmbdd`qkx0863-
3
0-1-Bnmrnm`msr`mcUnvdkr
SgdenkknvhmfhmudmsnqxneMfxdla——mognmdldr'bnmrnm`msr`mc
unvdkr(hrs`jdmeqnl@mcdqrnm'0865987+001(9
t k i u
b d g e o
m n B C a D
pf ts
f s
v z
wF y w
4
(4) Consonants Vowels
p t k ‘ i u
b d g e o
m n B C a D
pf ts c
f s sh
v z j
wF y w
Sghrchrrdqs`shnmvhkkenkknvsgdfdmdq`kqtkdrnesgdMfxdla——m
nqsgnfq`ogxvhsgsgdrhmfkddwbdoshnmnefknss`krsno+vghbghr`m`kxydc`r
sgdrxkk`akd,ehm`ku`qh`msnesgdognmdld.j.hmsgdognmnknfx'@mcdqrnm+
0865987(+atshrhmchb`sdchmsgdnqsgnfq`ogxax`m`onrsqnogd-Hmsghr
chrrdqs`shnm+sgdfknss`krsnohr`kv`xrhmchb`sdcaxsgdБrhfmhmnqcdqsg`s
hsmnsadbnmetrdcvhsgcnvmrsdovghbghrrhfm`kkdchmsghrchrrdqs`shnmax
sgd`onrsqnogdatsqdl`hmrtmvqhssdmhmsgdmnql`knqsgnfq`ogx-Sgd
l`mmdqnevqhshmfMfxdla——msnmdrvhkkadlnqdbnlokdwhmsghr
chrrdqs`shnmsg`mhmsgdneehbh`knqsgnfq`ogx-Sgdrxrsdlnevqhshmfsnmdr
`cnosdchmsgdenkknvhmfrdbshnmvhkk`kknvtrsnl`jd`kksgdchrshmbshnmr
mdbdrr`qxenq`chrrdqs`shnmvghbghrenbtrhmfnmsnm`kogdmnldm`-
5
CHAPTER 2
1-/-SnmdQtkdr
Hm`rstcxnesnmdtmhudqr`kraxGnladqs'08639066,7(+sgd`ci`bdms
k`mft`fdneCrbg`mfv`rbhsdc`rtmhptd`lnmfsgdvnqkc&rk`mft`fdrhm
onrrdrrhmfsvnqdk`sdcsnm`kogdmnldm`9cnvmrsdoodcghfgsnmdrvhsgnts
`tsnl`shbcnvmcqhes`mccnvmrsdoodcknvsnmdr-SgdMfxdla——m
k`mft`fdrg`qdransgnesgdrdbg`q`bsdqhrshbrvhsghsrmdhfganq-Sgd
tmhptdbg`q`bsdqnesgdsnm`kogdmnldm`hmsgdrdsvnk`mft`fdrl`jdr
sgdhqc`s``kksgdlnqdhlonqs`msenq`mxbnloqdgdmrhudsgdnqxne
ognmnknfx-Hshrvhsg`uhdvneetqsgdqdwdlokhexhmfsghrtmtrt`kjhmcne
rxrsdlvghkdjddohmfhmlhmcsgdsgdnqdshb`khrrtdrhmunkudcsg`ssgd
oqdrdmsrstcxhrneedqdc-
Sgdsgdnqdshb`k`ooqn`bg`cnosdchmsghrchrrdqs`shnmvhkkad
`tsnrdfldms`k-Sgddrrdmbdne`m`tsnrdfldms`k`ooqn`bghrsg`s
rdfldms`k`mcrtodqrdfldms`kogdmnldm``qdqdoqdrdmsdcnmrdo`q`sd
!shdqr-!Sgdtmhsrnesgdrdshdqr`qd!`rrnbh`sdc!vhsgtmhsrnmnsgdqshdqr
axld`mrne`rrnbh`shnmkhmdr-Onrhshmf`rdfldms`krxkk`ahbshdq'vgdqd
rxkk`ahbtmhsr`qdrxlankhydcaxb`ohs`kkdssdqrkhjd@+A+B+dsb-(`mc`
snm`kshdq'vgdqdghfg`mcknvsnmdr`qdrxlankhydcaxG`mcK
qdrodbshudkx(+bnmrsqtbshnmrkhjdsgdenkknvhmf`qdsxohb`k9
6
(5) A B C D E F etc.
L H H L H L L H H H etc.
Rhmbd`rrnbh`shmf`mcqd`rrnbh`shmfsnmdrsnu`qhntrrxkk`akdrhrnmdne
sgdl`inqs`rjrnertbg`sgdnqx+u`qhntrbnmudmshnmrg`udaddmonrhsdcsn
`hchmsghrs`rj-Nmdoqhmbhokdsg`sv`ronrhsdc`r`tmhudqr`kld`mrne
`rrnbh`shmf!ekn`shmf!'tm`rrnbh`sdc(nq!eqdd!snmdrv`rsgd!Vdkk,
EnqldcmdrrBnmchshnm!'VEB(+sgdenkknvhmfadhmfsgdudqrhnmne
Fnkcrlhsg'0865916(9
NmdnesgdqdrtksrnesgdoqdbdchmfVEBhrsg`smnsnmdr`qdkdes
ekn`shmfenqudqxknmf-U`qhntrkhmfthrsr'khjdBkdldmsr`mcEnqc+
086891/7(g`udrgnvmsg`ssgdoqdbdchmfVEBhrsnnrsqnmf`mcg`ud
sgdqdenqdoqnonrdcdkhlhm`shmfo`qs0a-Vdg`udentmcsghrjhmcne
qdrsqhbsdc`ooqn`bgsn`krnadsgdlnrsoqnctbshudenqMfxdla——m-Ntq
o`qshbtk`q`m`kxrhrstqmrsgdbnmchshnmnm`kkunvdkradhmf`rrnbh`sdcsn`s
kd`rsnmdsnmd'0``anud(hmsn`vdkk,enqldcmdrrsnmdqtkd'VEQ(
7
cdrbqhadchmrdbshnm1-2-0-adknv-Ntq`m`kxrhrcndrmns`bbdossgd
qdrsqhbshnmsg`s`kksnmdr`qd`rrnbh`sdcsn`skd`rsnmdunvdk'0a`anud(-
Vd`qdsgdqdenqdkdesvhsgnmkxsgdqdrshbshnmsg`s`rrnbh`shnmkhmdrmdudq
bqnrr+`mcsgdqdenqd`cnossgdenkknvhmflnchehdcudqrhnm`rntqVEB9
Sgdoq`bshb`kcheedqdmbdadsvddmsgdFnkcrlhsg&rVEB`mcntq
bnlahm`shnmne`VEQ`mc`ltbg,qdrsqhbsdcVEBhrsg`ssgdFnkcrlhsg&r
etkkdqudqrhnm`kv`xr`rrnbh`sdr`mxsnmdrentmcsnadekn`shmf`s`mxshld
hmsgdcdqhu`shnm-Ntqqdrsqhbsdcudqrhnmcndrmnscnsghr+`kknvhmftrsgd
onrrhahkhsxnesnmdrekn`shmfdudm`ssgddmcnecdqhu`shnmr-Sghrhrbqtbh`k
enqntq`m`kxrhrhmsg`ssgdeqdptdmscnvmrsdorentmchmMfxdla——m`qd
onrhsdcsnqdrtkseqnlitrsrtbgekn`shmfsnmdr`ssgddmcnecdqhu`shnmr-
U`qhntrqdrsqhbshnmrnmsgdonvdqne`tsnrdfldms`ksgdnqhdrg`udaddm
oqnonrdc+rdudq`ktmcdqsgdgd`chmfne!Nakhf`snqxBnmsntqOqhmbhokd-!
Enqsgdoqdrdmschrrdqs`shnm+vdrg`kk`cnossgdqdrsqhbshnmoqnonrdcax
Gxl`m'0871`94(sg`soqdbktcdr`mxk`mft`fdeqnlg`uhmflnqogdldr
vghbgbnms`hmsvn`ci`bdmshcdmshb`ksnmdr`ro`qsnesgdhqchbshnm`qx
dmsqhdr-Sgtr+sgdsnmdrdqhdrGG`mcKKb`mmdudqqdrtkseqnl`rhmfkd
tmcdqkxhmflnqogdld-
8
Sgdsnmdqtkdrhmsghrchrrdqs`shnmvhkkaddw`lhmdchmsgqddrs`fdr+
rs`qshmfvhsgsgnrdmdbdrr`qxhmsgd`rrnbh`shudmntmogq`rd+bnmshmthmf
vhsgsgnrdmddcdchmsgdudqaogq`rd+`mcehmhrghmftovhsgsgnrdvghbg
nodq`sdadsvddmogq`rdr-
Sn`hcsgdqd`cdq+sgdu`qhntrsnmdrhmMfxdla——mvhkkadqdedqqdcsn
hmu`qhntrv`xr-Sgdentqchrbqdsdsnm`kkdudkrvhkkadqdedqqdcsnax
dhsgdqsgdhqm`ld+mtldq`knqch`bqhshb-Sgdmtldq`krfhudmhmsgd
enkknvhmfbg`qsr`qdfhudm`rdw`lokdrnesgdkdudknesgdsnmdvgdmhs
hlldch`sdkxenkknvro`trd'h-d-hmsgd`ardmbdnesgdhmektdmbdnensgdq
cnvmrsdor(9
High 1 aJ
Downstepped-High 2 Ka
Low 3 aL
Downstepped-Low 4 Ma
Hm`cchshnm+`snmdfkhcdb`madenqldcaxinhmhmfnm`rhmfkdrxkk`akd
bdqs`hmbnlahm`shnmrneu`qhntrkdudkr+`radknv9
9
Rising 31 aN
Downstepped-Rising 42 Oa
Falling 13 aP
Downstepped-Falling 24 Qa
High-Downstepped-High 12 Ra
Rising-Downstepped-High 312 a
S
Low-Downstepped-Low 34 a
T
Downstepped-Low-Downstepped-Low 45 Ua
Ehm`kkx+hmbdqs`hmghfgkxqdrsqhbsdcdmuhqnmldmsr+`cntakd
cnvmrsdoodcghfgsnmdvhkknbbtq-Hsg`rsgdtmtrt`kpt`khshdrneadhmf`
qd`k'h-d-ognmnknfhb`k(ghfgsnmdvghkdadhmfqd`khydcognmdshb`kkx`ssgd
r`ldkdudk`r`mnql`kknvsnmd+`radknv9
Double-Downstepped-High 3 Va
Hm`cchshnmsnsgdoqdbdchmfm`lhmfcduhbdr+sgdrxlankrG`mcKvhkk
adtrdchmsgdsdwsnesgdchrrdqs`shnm`mchmsgd`tsnrdfldms`kqtkdrsn
qdedqsnghfg`mcknvsnmdrqdrodbshudkx-Sgdch`bqhshbrvhkkadtrdc
oqhl`qhkxsnhmchb`sdsgdsnmdentmcnm`rodbhehbrxkk`akdhm`mdw`lokd
10
ch`bqhshbrvhkksgtrhmchb`sdsgdrxrsdl`shbognmdshbkdudk+`kdudk
oqdbdchmfsgd`ookhb`shnmnesgd`bbtltk`shudcnvmrsdoqtkd-Sgd
mtldq`kr+nmsgdnsgdqg`mc+vhkkadtrdcsnhmchb`sdsgdsnmdne`rxkk`akd
the sentence-Sgdtrdnesgdmtldq`krvhkkdm`akdtrsnjddosq`bjne
sgd`bst`kognmdshbkdudkne`rodbhehbrxkk`akdhmknmfdqtssdq`mbdrvhsg
ltkshokdcnvmrsdoohmfnesgdsnm`kqdfhrsdq-Sghrhrbqtbh`kenq`k`mft`fd
khjdMfxdla——mvgdqdsgdeqdptdmsnbbtqqdmbdnecnvmrsdovhkkqdrtkshm
ognmdshbkdudkrne7nq8axsgddmcne`bk`trdnqrdmsdmbd'vgdqd`o`trd
`kknvrsgdrod`jdqsnqdrdsghrsnmdqdfhrsdq(-@bkd`qdw`lokdnertbg
ltkshokdcnvmrsdoohmfb`madbqd`sdcaxenqlhmf`knmf`rrnbh`shudmntm
ogq`rdtrhmfsgdr`ldvnqcnudq`mcnudq+`radknv9
(11) leLtyoN leJtyKo leJtyKo leJtyKo leJtyKo leJtyKo leJtyKo leJtyKo leJtyKo
3 31 1 2 2 3 3 4 4 5 5 6 6 7 7 8 8 9
Sgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrgnvrsg`scnvmrsdoknvdqrsgddmshqdsnmd
qdfhrsdq-Sghrknvdqhmfhr`krnrgnvmsnadbtltk`shud+kd`chmfsn`
ognmnknfhb`kGsnmd`ssgddmcnesgdogq`rdvghbghroqnmntmbdcnm`
ltbgknvdqkdudk'8(sg`msgdKsnmd`ssgdadfhmmhmfnesgdogq`rd'2(-Hs
hrnmkxvgdmsgdMfxdla——mrod`jdq`bst`kkxo`trdrsg`sgdqdrdsrghr
11
knvdqdcsnmdqdfhrsdqa`bjtosnhsrnqhfhm`kkdudk-Sgdoqdchbshnmne
`bst`kkxvgdmsgdrod`jdqvhkkknvdqghrsnmdqdfhrsdqnmdnqdudmsvn
mnsbgdrhrnmdnesgdl`inqbg`kkdmfdrsnhmsdqdrsdckhmfthrsr-
1-0-OqduhntrVnqj
@mxchrrdqs`shnmnmsgdcheehbtkssnm`kogdmnldm`ne`A`lhkdjd
k`mft`fdhrmdbdrr`qhkxathkstonmsgdoqduhntrvnqjnensgdqkhmfthrsr-
U`qhntrkhmfthrsrg`udl`cdl`inqbnmsqhatshnmrsnsgdnmfnhmfrstcxne
A`lhkdjdsnm`kodqstqa`shnmr+d`bgathkchmftonmsgdentmc`shnmrk`hcax
sgdenqldq-Ehqrs+hmghr0860vnqjnmmnlhm`krhmsgdA`mf`mfsd
k`mft`fd+Unnqgndudrtffdrsdctmcdqkxhmfsqh,snm`ko`ssdqmrbnmrhrshmfne
nmkxghfg`mcknvsnmdr-RhmbdlnrsmntmrhmA`lhkdjdk`mft`fdrcnmns
bnms`hmsgqddrxkk`akdr+gdv`rkdcsnonrhssgddwhrsdmbdne!ekn`shmf
snmdr!'snmdrtm`ss`bgdcsnrxkk`akdr(+`skd`rsnmsgdcddodrskdudkne
ognmnknfhb`kqdoqdrdms`shnm-Gdsgdmvdmsnmsnvnqjntsrnldnesgd
snm`kqtkdrmdbdrr`qxsnqd`bgu`qhntrrtqe`bdognmdshbqd`khy`shnmr-
Unnqgndud&rohnmddqhmfvnqjhmsghr`qd`v`renkknvdcaxGxl`m&r
ognmnknfhb`kdw`lhm`shnmnesgdEdùedùk`mft`fd'0861(-Hmsghrlnqd
vhcd,q`mfhmfvnqj+Gxl`mmnsnmkxonrhsdcsnm`ko`ssdqmr+ekn`shmfsnmdr
`mcsnm`kqtkdrrhlhk`qsnUnnqgndud&r+atsgd`ssdlosdcsndwo`mcsgdhq
`ookhb`shnmeqnlrnkdkxmntmogq`rdbnmsdwsrsnhmbktcdu`qhntrbg`mfdr
12
hmsgdudqaogq`rd-Hmsghrqdrodbs+gdr`xr9!Sgdlnqdcheehbtksoqnakdlr
bdmsdq`qntmcsnmd`ksdqm`shnmrhmudqar'08619040(-!
Sgdmhm0863+S`c`cidtdw`lhmdcsgdCrbg`mfk`mft`fd`mcentmc
sgdq`qdsnm`kogdmnldm`necnvmrsdovhsgnts`tsnl`shbcnvmcqhes`mc
cnvmrsdoodcknvsnmdrhm`cchshnmsnsgdlnqdbnllnmcnvmrsdoodc
ghfgsnmdr-RhmbdsgdMfxdla——mk`mft`fdhrchqdbskx`ci`bdmssnsg`sne
Crbg`mf+hshrmnsrtqoqhrhmfsg`sMfxdla——m`krnrg`qdrsgdrdr`ld
bg`q`bsdqhrshbr-
Sghrvnqjv`renkknvdcax`lnqdbnloqdgdmrhud`m`kxrhrne
tmcdqkxhmfsnm`ko`ssdqmrhmsgddmshqdLa`l,Mj`lk`mft`fde`lhkx+vhsg
rodbh`kdlog`rhrnmCrbg`mfsnmnknfx-Gxl`m`mcS`c`cidt'gdqd`esdq
qdedqqdcsn`r!G%S!(bnlahmdcnmsghroqnidbs`mcsgdhqqdonqs'0865(
l`m`fdcsnfndudmetqsgdqhmsnsgdudqa`ksnmdcdqhu`shnmr-Mdudqsgdkdrr+
sgdxbnmbktcdaxrs`shmf+!Mddckdrrsnr`x+ltbglnqdvnqjhrmddcdchm
sghrbnlokdwo`qsnesgdsnm`kfq`ll`qrn`rsnodqlhstrsnqdbnmrsqtbs
vhsgbdqs`hmsxsgdsdmrd+`rodbs+`mclnncl`qjdqroqdrdmshmOqnsn,
La`l,Mj`l'086590/5(-!Hsv`rhmqdronmrdsnsghrrs`sdcmddcsnoqdrr
nmeqnlsgdvnqjnmmntmogq`rdsnm`kodqstqa`shnmrsnhmbktcd`rvdkk
sgnrdnesgdudqaogq`rdsg`ssgdoqdrdmsrstcxv`rehqrstmcdqs`jdm-
@esdqsgdqdrd`qbgenqsgdoqdrdmsrstcxg`c`kqd`cxadftm+`m`qshbkd
v`rotakhrgdcax@mcdqrnm'0870(vghbgqd`m`kxydcsgdCrbg`mfc`s`
eqnlsgd`tsnrdfldms`kodqrodbshudneFnkcrlhsg'0865(-Sghr`qshbkd
13
rddlrsng`udaqntfgssgdtmtrt`kCrbg`mfc`s`snsgd`ssdmshnmnesgnrd
vnqjhmfnmsgdetqsgdqqdehmdldmsne`tsnrdfldms`kognmnknfx-Sgdl`hm
khmfthrsrhmunkudchmsgddmrthmfch`knftdg`udaddmRsdv`qs'0870(+
Otkkxak`mj'0871(`mcGxl`m'0871`(-Sgdrdrstchdrg`udaddmlnrs
hmsdqdrsdchmbnmrsqtbshmf`sgdnqxvghbghronvdqetkdmntfgsng`mckd
tmtrt`ksnm`kodqstqa`shnmrkhjdsgnrdneCrbg`mfvghkdmnsadhmfrn
onvdqetk`rsnoqnuhcdltkshokdrnktshnmrsnsgdr`ldc`s`-
Hm`mtmotakhrgdco`odq+Otkkxak`mj'0871900(onrhsdcsgddwhrsdmbdne
`snm`klds`sgdrhrqtkdvghbgrhlokhehdcsgdsnm`kqtkdrmddcdc+`mc`
rhlhk`qqtkdg`raddm`cnosdchmsghrrstcx`rvdkk-Rsdv`qs'08709007(
`bst`kkxenql`khydcsgdcnvmrsdoogdmnldm``r`ed`stqdvghbggdsgdm
lds`sgdrhydc-Ehm`kkx+Gxl`m'0871`97(`cnosdcOtkkxak`mj&rlds`sgdrhr
qtkd`mcsgdm`qftdcenqsgd`cnoshnmne`rnldvg`slnchehdcudqrhnmne
Kdadm&r'0867(Nakhf`snqxBnmsntqOqhmbhokd'NBO(-Sgdqdrtksrne`kk
sgdrdo`odqrg`udkdcsnu`qhntrqdehmdldmsrhmntq`m`kxrhrvghbghmstqm
g`udqdrtksdchm`rhlokdq`m`kxrhr`bbnlo`mhdcaxsnmdqtkdrcdunhcne
rsqhbsdwsdqm`knqcdqhmf-Ntqrnktshnmhrneedqdchmsghrchrrdqs`shnm`rxds
`mnsgdqbnmsqhatshnmsnsgdnmfnhmfch`knftdqdf`qchmf`tsnrdfldms`k
snmdsgdnqx`mcA`lhkdjdsnm`krxrsdlr-
14
1-1-Mntmr
Sgd`hlnesghrrdbshnmhrsnoqdrdms`mdv`m`kxrhrnesgdsnmd
odqstqa`shnmrentmchmsgdMfxdla——mmntmogq`rd-Snc`sd+lnrsnesgd
bnloqdgdmrhud`m`kxrdrneA`lhkdjdsnmdrxrsdlr'Gxl`m+0861:G%S+
0865:`mc@mcdqrnm+0870(g`ud`kkonrhsdctmcdqkxhmfsqh,snm`ko`ssdqmr
enqmntmr-Sgdrdsqh,snm`ko`ssdqmrvdqdonrhsdc`r`qdekdwned`qkhdq
A`mstrsqtbstqdrvgdqdlnrsmntmrbnms`hmdcsgqddrxkk`akdrvhsgdhsgdq
ghfgnqknvsnmdr-Gnvdudq+rhmbdlnrsmntmrhmoqdrdms,c`xA`lhkdjd
k`mft`fdrbnms`hmnmkx`lnmn,rxkk`ahbmntmqnnsoqdbdcdcax`lnmn,
rxkk`ahbmntmbk`rroqdehw+u`qhntrbnmudmshnmr`mcqtkdrg`csnad
cdudknodcsn`bbntmsenqsgdchro`qhsxadsvddmsgdmtladqnetmcdqkxhmf
snmdr`mcsgdmtladqnertqe`bdsnmdr+`rvdkk`rsndwok`hmsgdbnlokdw
snm`kodqstqa`shnmrb`trdcaxsgdghrsnqhb`kknrrnerxkk`akdr-G%S
`bbnlokhrgdcsghrotqonrdaxqdedqqhmfsnu`qhntr!ekn`shmfsnmdr!'snmdr
tm`ss`bgdcsnrdfldms`kunvdkr+ehqrsonrhsdcenqA`lhkdjdk`mft`fdrax
Unnqgndud+0854(-@mcdqrnm'0870(qdvnqjdcsgdhqc`s`trhmfsgdlnqd
dwokhbhs`tsnrdfldms`kognmnknfhb`klncdkneFnkcrlhsg'0865(+vghkd
mdudqsgdkdrrqds`hmhmfG%S&rtmcdqkxhmfsqh,snm`ko`ssdqmr-
15
2.2.1. In isolation
Oqduhntr`ssdlosrax@mcdqrnm'0865`mc0867(sndwok`hm
Mfxdla——msnm`kodqstqa`shnmr`krnenkknvdcrhlhk`qkhmdr`mconrhsdc
tmcdqkxhmfsqh,snm`ko`ssdqmrbnmrhrshmfnenmkxghfg'G(`mcknv'K(
snmdr-Sgdenkknvhmfbg`qsbnlo`qdrsgdo`ssdqmroqduhntrkxoqnonrdcenq
Crbg`mf'S`c`cidt+08639174`mcG%S+0865955(`mcMfxdla——m
'@mcdqrnm+086797(+vhsgsgdlnqogdldantmc`qhdrdwokhbhsdkxl`qjdcax
!*!(9
Sgdoqdbdchmfbg`qsrgnvrsg`ssgdtmcdqkxhmfknvsnmd'K(`ssgd
adfhmmhmfnesgdsnm`ko`ssdqmqdrtksrhm`rtqe`bdknvsnmd'2(nmsgdmntm
bk`rroqdehw-Sghrkd`udrsgdk`rssvntmcdqkxhmfsnmdrned`bgo`ssdqmsn
hmsdq`bsvhsgsgdhqdmuhqnmldmsrhmrtbg`v`xsg`ssgdxqdrtkshmsgd
u`qhntrrtqe`bdsnmdrnesgdmntmqnnsr-Sgdnmkxsnm`kcheedqdmbdadsvddm
Mfxdla——m`mcCrbg`mfmnlhm`krhrsg`ssgdsnm`ko`ssdqmxhdkchmf`
16
ghfgsnmdnmsgdqnnshmCrbg`mfxhdkcr`qhrhmfsnmdhmMfxdla——m-Hm
e`bs+sghrr`ldo`ssdqm`krnqdrtksrhm`qhrhmfsnmdnmsgdmntmqnnshm
bdqs`hm`qd`rnesgdA`entbghdecnlneCrbg`mf'rddG%S+0865980+
ennsmnsd14(-Sgdqdftk`qnbbtqqdmbdneqhrhmfsnmdrhmMfxdla——mvhkk
nbb`rhnm`mdwsq`snmdqtkdsg`shrmnsmddcdcenqlnrsneCrbg`mf+`rvd
rg`kkrddhmsgdbntqrdnesgdenkknvhmfchrbtrrhnm-
Sgdoqduhntr`m`kxrdrneA`lhkdjdsnmdrxrsdlrg`udl`cdfqd`s
oqnfqdrrhmqdmcdqhmfdwok`hm`akdoqduhntrkxtmdwok`hm`akdsnm`k
odqstqa`shnmr-Hmsqxhmfsn`bbntmsenqsgdr`ldc`s`vhsg`lnqd
dbnmnlhb`ktrdnesnmdr`mcqtkdr+vdg`udentmchsgdkoetksnenkknv
Rsdv`qs'08709004(hm`kknvhmfsvnsnmdrhm`mxnmdlnqogdldnmkxhe
sgnrdsvnsnmdr`qdchrrhlhk`q-Vdsgtroqnonrdsgdenkknvhmftmcdqkxhmf
snmdo`ssdqmrenqMfxdla——mchrxkk`ahbmntmr+d`bgvhsg`sxohb`k
dw`lokdcq`vmeqnlmntmbk`rr4vgnrdoqdehwhr.kd∆,.9
17
Sgdehqrssnm`ko`ssdqmsg`svdvhkkdw`lhmdhrvgdqd`mtmcdqkxhmf
K*Ksnmdo`ssdqmqdrtksrhm`2*23rtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmvgdmhshr
oqnmntmbdchmhrnk`shnm-@mdw`lokdnertbg`vnqchrfhudmadknv
'vgdqd.ld∆,.hrsgdmntmbk`rroqdehwnebk`rr5mntmr(9
(14) meLlu
T Y "wine"
3 34
Hmnqcdqsncdqhudntqu`qhntrrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmr+vdvhkkad
enkknvhmfsgdfdmdq`kbnmudmshnmne`tsnrdfldms`kognmnknfxaxonrhshmf
sgddwhrsdmbdneu`qhntr!shdqr-!Sgdrdshdqr`qdl`cdtonetmhsrvghbg
`qdkhmjdcsntmhsrnmnsgdqshdqraxld`mrne`rrnbh`shnmkhmdr-Sgdrd
`rrnbh`shnmkhmdrl`xadcq`vmhm`bbnqc`mbdvhsgonrhsdctmhudqr`k
oqhmbhokdrnqrhlokx`rsgdqdrtksnek`mft`fd,rodbhehbqtkdr-Sgdsvnshdqr
sg`svdrg`kkadbnmbdqmdcvhsghmsghrchrrdqs`shnm`qdsgdrdfldms`k`mc
snm`k-Snrhlokhexntqcdrbqhoshnm+vdrg`kkqdoqdrdmssgdrxkk`ahbtmhsrnm
sgdrdfldms`kshdqaxld`mrnesgdb`ohs`kkdssdqr'@+A+dsb-(-Sgdsnm`k
shdq+nmsgdnsgdqg`mc+vhkkbnms`hmnmkxsgdrxlankrG`mcK
qdoqdrdmshmfsgdtmcdqkxhmfghfg`mcknvsnmdr-
@rhmlnrsk`mft`fdr+`fdmdq`kl`oohmfqtkd`rrnbh`sdrd`bgrxkk`akd
vhsgnmdsnmdnmsgdsnm`kshdq+oqnbddchmfeqnlkdessnqhfgs-Sgtr+vhsg
18
!..!rxlankhyhmfo`trd,fqntoantmc`qhdr`mc!*!enqlnqogdld
antmc`qhdr+ntqtmcdqkxhmfo`ssdqmneK*Kvntkc`ood`q`radknv`esdq
sgdhmhsh`k`rrnbh`shnmkhmdrg`udaddmcq`vm9
(15) // A + B //
// L + L //
Vghkdsgdoqdbdchmfo`ssdqm`ood`qrsnadudqxrsq`hfgsenqv`qc+hs
ltrsadqdldladqdcsg`ssgdtkshl`sdrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmhr2*23`mcmns
2*2-@rmnsdcaxUnnqgndud'0860936(+tmcdqkxhmfKsnmdrsg`s`qd
`arnktsdkxtssdq`mbd,ehm`k'h-d-mnsenkknvdcax`ekn`shmfGsnmd+`rrddm
etqsgdqadknv(+`kv`xrg`ud`cnvmfkhcd-VdvhkkenkknvRsdv`qs
'08709005(hmhmsdqoqdshmfsghrcnvmfkhcd`radhmf`cnvmrsdo-Ntqehm`k
cnvmfkhcdvhkkadfdmdq`sdcaxsgdenkknvhmfsnm`kqtkd9
L Ø Ø / //
H L
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkdrs`sdrsg`svgdmdudq`Ksnmdhr`rrnbh`sdc
19
'rxlankhydcax`rnkhckhmd(vhsg`rxkk`akd'rxlankhydcax!#!(
hlldch`sdkxadenqd`o`trd'rxlankhydcax!..!(+`m`cchshnm`kG`mcK
snmd`qd`ccdc`esdqsgd`rrnbh`sdcKsnmd`mcsgdmdvKsnmdhr
`rrnbh`sdcaxsgdqtkd'rxlankhydcaxsgdc`rgdckhmd(vhsgsgdr`ld
rxkk`akd-Vgdmvd`ookxsghrqtkdsnntqoqdbdchmfmntmrsqtbstqd+vdfds
sgdenkknvhmf9
(17) // A + B //
// L + L Ø Ø //
H L
Mnvsg`svdg`ud`ekn`shmfGsnmdoqdbdchmf`m`rrnbh`sdcKsnmd+
vdmddc`cnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgvhkkknvdqsgdsnm`kqdfhrsdq-Enqsgd
qdfhrsdq,knvdqhmfo`qsnentqqtkd+vdenkknvBkdldmsr'0868944/(hm
`cchmfnmdohsbgkdudksnd`bgrtbbddchmfrxkk`akd+rhmbdhmntqmtladqhmf
rxrsdl`ghfgdqmtladqhmchb`sdr`knvdqohsbg-Sgdehqrso`qsnentqqtkd
hrcheedqdmseqnloqduhntrkxonrhsdccnvmrsdoqtkdr`mclnqdfdmdq`ksg`m
vdmddcenqntqoqdrdmso`ssdqmhmsg`shsknvdqrsgdsnmdqdfhrsdq
vgdmdudq`m`rrnbh`sdcsnmdhrhlldch`sdkxoqdbdcdcax`ekn`shmfsnmdne
dw`bsnoonrhsdbg`q`bsdq'h-d-Gur-K`rhmchb`sdcax!√!`mc!,√!(+`rhm
sgdenkknvhmfoqdkhlhm`qxudqrhnmnentqcnvmrsdoqtkd'rdd'150(adknv
enq`qduhrdcqtkd(9
20
-[T [T
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkdrs`sdrsg`s`mxrxkk`akdvgdqd`m`rrnbh`sdcsnmd
'√S(hrhlldch`sdkxoqdbdcdcax`mnoonrhsdekn`shmfsnmd',√S(+sgd
dmshqdsnmdqdfhrsdqrg`kkadknvdqdcnmdsnmdkdudk'hmchb`sdcax`m
hmbqd`rdnesgdmtldqhb`ku`ktdned`bgenkknvhmfrxkk`akdaxnmd(-Sghr
knvdqhmfnesgdsnmdqdfhrsdqg`rsvnbqtbh`koqnodqshdr-Ehqrs+sgd
knvdqhmfcndrmnsitrss`jdok`bdenqsgdrxkk`akdenkknvhmfsgdekn`shmf
snmd+atshrrhlhk`qkxknvdqdcenqallrxkk`akdrtmshk`l`inqo`trd
antmc`qx`kknvrsgdrod`jdqsnqdrdsghrsnm`kqdfhrsdq-Rdbnmc+sghr
knvdqhmfnesgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqb`mnbbtqrdudq`kshldrhm`mxnmdtssdq`mbd
`mcsgddeedbshrcumulative-Sgtr`ghfgsnmd`ssgddmcne`rdmsdmbd
b`md`rhkxadoqnmntmbdcnm`ognmdshbsnmdkdudkknvdqsg`m`knvsnmd
`ssgdadfhmmhmfne`rdmsdmbd+`mc`knvsnmd`ssgddmcne`rdmsdmbd
vhsgrdudq`kcnvmrsdorlhfgs`bst`kkxqd`bg`ognmdshbkdudkne7nq8-
@kknesghrhrb`trdchmMfxdla——maxsgdoqdrdmbdne`ekn`shmfsnmd
hlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmf`m`rrnbh`sdcsnmdsg`shrmnshcdmshb`k-Sgtr`
ekn`shmfKadenqd`m`rrnbh`sdcG`kv`xrqdrtksrhm`cnvmrsdoodcG+`mc
21
`ekn`shmfGadenqd`m`rrnbh`sdcK`kv`xrqdrtksrhm`cnvmrsdoodcK-
Sghr`m`kxrhrnecnvmrsdoodcghfgr`mcknvrrg`qdrsgd`cu`ms`fdrne
ansgrxlldsqx`mcrhlokhbhsxnudqnsgdqrtffdrshnmr`rsnsgdhqnqhfhmr-
Sgdcnvmrsdoqtkd`ookhdrudqxk`sdhmsgdcdqhu`shnm`koqnbdrr-Hsr
deedbsrnmsgdohsbgqdfhrsdq`qdrgnvmhmsgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnmax
sgdbg`mfdeqnlohsbgkdudk2snohsbgkdudk3nmsgdk`rsrxkk`akd9
(19) // A + B //
// L + L H L //
3 - 3 4
Sgdrdbnmcsnm`ko`ssdqmsg`svdvhkkdw`lhmdhrvgdqd`mtmcdqkxhmf
K*KGsnmdo`ssdqmqdrtksrhm`kdudk'h-d-mnm,cnvmfkhcdc(2*2rtqe`bd
qd`khy`shnmvgdmhshroqnmntmbdchmhrnk`shnm-@mdw`lokdnertbg`vnqc
eqnlmntmbk`rr6'vghbgs`jdr`mnoshnm`k.`∆,.oqdehw(hr`radknv9
3 3
Sgdcntakd!e!`anudhrsgdnqsgnfq`oghbbnmudmshnmtrdcsnhmchb`sd`
knmfbnmrnm`mshmMfxdla——m'@mcdqrnm0871953(-Rhmbdsgddw`lokdhm
enbtrg`rnmkxsvnrxkk`akdratssgqddtmcdqkxhmfsnmdr+sgdfdmdq`k
l`oohmfqtkdkd`udrsgdGsnmdtm`rrnbh`sdc+`radknv9
22
(21) // A + B //
// L + L H //
3 - 3
Sgdoqdbdchmfo`ssdqmfhudrtrsgdrsq`hfgsenqv`qccdqhu`shnmnentq
rtqe`bd2*2qdrtks-Sgdetmbshnmnesgdehm`kekn`shmfGsnmdhrsg`shs
aknbjrsgdnodq`shnmnentqehm`kcnvmfkhchmfqtkd'snmdqtkd0cdrbqhadc
`anud(+vghbgnmkx`ookhdrhesgdk`rs`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdhrimmediately
enkknvdcaxo`trd-
Vdvhkkmnvdw`lhmdntqsghqcsnm`ko`ssdqmvgdqd`mtmcdqkxhmf
K*GKo`ssdqmqdrtksrhm`2*1rtqe`bdqd`khy`shnm'`knvsnmdnmsgd
mntmbk`rroqdehwenkknvdcax`cnvmrsdoodcghfgsnmdnmsgdmntmqnns(
vgdmhshroqnmntmbdchmhrnk`shnm-@mdw`lokdnertbg`vnqceqnlmntm
bk`rr3'vghbgs`jdr`.ld∆m,.oqdehw(hr`radknv9
3 2
Nmbd`f`hmvdg`ud`o`ssdqmvhsgnmkxsvnrxkk`adrxdssgqdd
tmcdqkxhmfsnmdr-Hmsghrb`rd+sgdehm`kKsnmdhrkdestm`rrnbh`sdcaxntq
fdmdq`kkdes,sn,qhfgsl`oohmfqtkd+`radknv9
23
(23) // A + B //
// L + H L //
Hshr`ssghronhmssg`snmdnentqlnrshlonqs`msqtkdrbnldrhmsnok`x-
Sgdhcd`ne`lds`sgdrhrqtkdhmsghrrhst`shnmv`rehqrsrtffdrsdcax
Rsdv`qsenqsgdmdhfganqhmfk`mf`ftdneCrbg`mf-Ghr!Mnm,`rrhlhk`snqx
to,cnvmrhlokhehb`shnm!qtkd`bst`kkxlds`sgdrhydc`Gsnmd`mc`
cnvmrsdoed`stqd'08709005(-Ntqqtkdenkknvrsgdk`sdqenqltk`shnmrne
Otkkxak`mj'0871900(`mcGxl`m'0871`97(vghbgrhlokxlds`sgdrhydr`m
`rrnbh`sdcG`mc`mtm`rrnbh`sdcKsnmd-Ntqqtkdhrfhudm`oqdkhlhm`qx
enl`khy`shnmhlldch`sdkxadknv+atsvhkkadetqsgdqqduhrdck`sdqhmsghr
chrrdqs`shnm'rdd'51(adknv(9
L H L
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkdrs`sdrsg`svgdmdudq`rxkk`akd'#(hr`rrnbh`sdcsn
`Gsnmdvghbghrhlldch`sdkxenkknvdcax`ekn`shmfKsnmd`mc`krn
hlldch`sdkxoqdbdcdcax`mnsgdqrxkk`akdvghbghr`rrnbh`sdcsn`Ksnmd+
sgdekn`shmfKsnmdhrlnudchmeqnmsnesgdGsnmd-Ax`ookxhmfsgd
lds`sgdrhrqtkd+ntqo`ssdqmhrbnmudqsdchmsnsgdenkknvhmf9
24
(25) // A + B //
// L + H L //
Ntqcnvmrsdoqtkdmnvbnldr`knmf`mcrddr`ekn`shmfKsnmd
hlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmf`m`rrnbh`sdcGsnmd-Sghrsqhffdqrsgdnodq`shnm
necnvmrsdovghbgknvdqrsgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbg-Sgdqdrtkshrsgd
enkknvhmfo`ssdqmvgdqdsgdohsbgkdudkne1rgnvrsg`ssgdGsnmdg`r
tmcdqfnmdnmd`ookhb`shnmneqdfhrsdq,knvdqhmf9
(26) // A + B //
..K*KG..
2,1
Vdvhkkmnvdw`lhmdntqentqsg`mcehm`ksnm`ko`ssdqm-Hmsghrb`rd+`m
tmcdqkxhmfK*Go`ssdqmqdrtksrhm`2*20rtqe`bdqd`khy`shnm'`knvsnmd
nmsgdmntmbk`rroqdehwenkknvdcax`qhrhmfsnmdnmsgdmntmqnns(vgdm
hshroqnmntmbdchmhrnk`shnm-@mdw`lokdnertbg`vnqceqnlmntmbk`rr
8'vghbgs`jdr`snmd,ad`qhmfrxkk`ahbm`r`koqdehw.m∆,.`rhsrmntmbk`rr
oqdehw(hr`radknv9
3 31
25
Sgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokd`ood`qr`radknv`esdqntqfdmdq`kl`oohmf
qtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(28) // A + B //
// L + H //
Sgdoqdbdchmfqdoqdrdms`shnmvntkcadrteehbhdms`rhsrs`mcrhmsgd
mdhfganqhmfk`mft`fdneCrbg`mf+vgdqdsghro`ssdqmtrt`kkxqdrtksrhm`
2*0nmsgdrtqe`bd-RhmbdMfxdla——mg`r`qhrhmfsnmdvgdqdCrbg`mf
trt`kkxg`r`Gsnmd+vdmddc`m`cchshnm`kqtkd+`radknv9
# L H #
Sgdcnssdckhmdhmsgdoqdbdchmfqtkdhrsgd`tsnrdfldms`kbnmudmshnm
enq`cchmf`m`rrnbh`shnmkhmd-Sgtrsgdqtkdr`xrsg`svgdmdudq`rhmfkd
Gsnmdhr`rrnbh`sdcvhsg`rxkk`akdenkknvhmf`mnsgdqrxkk`akdvghbghr
`rrnbh`sdcsn`Ksnmd+`mcansgsnmdrnbbtqvhsghmsgdr`ldvnqc
'rxlankhydcaxsgdsvn"vnqcantmc`qhdr(+`m`cchshnm`k`rrnbh`shnmkhmd
vhkkadcq`vmsnsgdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfKsnmd-Hsrgntkcadrsqdrrdc
26
sg`ssghrqtkdhrkhlhsdcsndmuhqnmldmsrvgdqdsgdsvnsnmdr`qdentmc
vhsghm`rhmfkdvnqc-Sghrkhlhs`shnmvhkkoqnudrhfmhehb`ms`rvddw`lhmd
`rrnbh`shudmntmogq`rdr`mcu`qhntrudqa`kogq`rdretqsgdqadknv-Sgd
qdrtksnesghrqtkd&r`ookhb`shnmnmntqoqdrdmstmcdqkxhmfo`ssdqmhrsgd
bnqqdbs2*20rtqe`bdqd`khy`shnm+`radknv9
(30) // A + B //
// L + H //
3 - 31
Enqsgdqd`cdqmnse`lhkh`qvhsgsgdbnlokhb`sdcsnm`kodqstqa`shnmrne
A`lhkdjdk`mft`fdr+onqshnmrnentq`m`kxrhrsnsghronhmslhfgsrddl
rnldvg`s`cgnb-Hsvhkknmkxad`esdq`sgnqntfgdw`lhm`shnmnesgd
bnlokdwsnm`kodqstqa`shnmrhmsgd`rrnbh`shudmntmogq`rdsg`ssgd
bnlokdsdlnshu`shnmnentqo`qshbtk`qtmcdqkxhmfo`ssdqmr`mcqtkdrvhkk
adbnldbkd`q-
27
2.2.2. In associative noun phrases (N1 of N2)
Mnvsg`svdg`uddw`lhmdcntqentqa`rhbchrxkk`ahbmntmo`ssdqmrhm
hrnk`shnm+vd`qdhm`onrhshnmsnbnlahmdsgdlhmmntm,mntm`rrnbh`shud
'nqfdmhshud(bnmrsqtbshnmr-Hshrhmsghrdmuhqnmldmssg`srdudq`knesgd
lnrshmsdqdrshmfsnm`kodqstqa`shnmrnbbtq-Vgdmdudqsvnmntmrbnld
snfdsgdqhm`m`rrnbh`shudbnmrsqtbshnmhmFq`rrehdkcrA`mst`rvdkk`rhm
M`qqnvA`mstk`mft`fdr+`mhmsdqudmhmf!`rrnbh`shudl`qjdq!'@(+
cdsdqlhmdcaxsgdmntmbk`rrnesgdehqrsmntm+nbbtqradsvddmsgdmntmr-
LnrsFq`rrehdkcA`mstk`mft`fdrcheedqeqnlsgdhqM`qqnvA`mst
bntmsdqo`qsrhmsg`ssgdrdfldms`kbnmsdmsnesgdrd`rrnbh`shudl`qjdqr
g`rbnlokdsdkxcqnoodcntskd`uhmf`m`rrnbh`shudlnqogdldbnmrhrshmf
neitrs`snmd-HmMfxdla——m+`rhmlnrsA`mstk`mft`fdr'ansg
Fq`rrehdkcr`mcM`qqnv(+sgdsnm`kbnmbnqcl`qjdqhrKsnmdenqmntm
bk`rrdr0`mc8`mcGsnmdenq`kksgdnsgdqbk`rrdr'rdd@mcdqrnm+087/`+
enq`chrbtrrhnmnesgdbnmrnm`ms+unvdk`mcsnm`kbnmbnqcl`qjdqrenq
d`bgnesgdsdmMfxdla——mmntmbk`rrdr(-
Rhmbdvdg`udentqsnm`konrrhahkhshdrenqsgdsvnchrxkk`ahbmntmr`mc
svnsnm`konrrhahkhshdrenqsgdsnm`klnqogdldrdo`q`shmfsgdl+vdsgtr
g`ud21rdo`q`sd`rrnbh`shudo`ssdqmrvgdmbnlahmhmfsgdsnm`ko`ssdqmr
entmchmsgdenkknvhmfbg`qs9
28
(31) N1 A N2
L+L L L+L
L+LH H L+LH
L+HL L+HL
L+H L+H
Sgd21onrrhakdbnlahm`shnmrnesgdoqdbdchmfo`ssdqmrvdqdehqrs
cds`hkdcenqsgdCrbg`mfk`mft`fdaxG%S'0865981(-Sgdxvdqdsgdm
qd`m`kxydc`bbnqchmfsnu`qhntr`tsnrdfldms`keq`ldvnqjrax@mcdqrnm
'087097/(`mcRsdv`qs'08709007,015(-Sgdo`q`kkdko`ssdqmrenqsgd
Mfxdla——mk`mft`fd`qdrgnvmhmsgdenkknvhmfbg`qs9
29
'21(Bg`qs@
KnvSnmdBnmbnqcGhfgSnmdBnmbnqc
'bk`rrdr0`mc8('nsgdqbk`rrdr(
Hrnk`shnmMn-@ABCMn-@ABC
2,23%2,230-2222306-22134
2,21-222207-2213
2,12-222108-2211
2,203-222201/-2211
2,2%2,234-22333410-22134
2,25-2233311-2213
2,16-2233212-2211
2,207-22333113-2211
2,1%2,238-2333414-21134
2,20/-233315-2113
2,100-233216-2112
2,2001-2333117-2112
2,20%2,2302-2222318-220023
2,203-22222/-22002
2,104-222120-22001
2,2005-2222021-22001
30
Sgdoqdbdchmfbg`qshrchuhcdchmsnsvnrdbshnmrcdodmchmftonm
vgdsgdqsgdhmsdqudmhmf`rrnbh`shudbnmbnqcsnmdhrGnqK-Sgd
`rrnbh`shudsnmdo`ssdqmrg`udaddmmtladqdceqnl0sn21sne`bhkhs`sd
k`sdqqdedqdmbdra`bjsnhmchuhct`ko`ssdqmr-Sgdmtladqr`ssgddwsqdld
kdes+ntsrhcdnesgdanwdr+hmchb`sdsgdhrnk`shnmsnmdrnesgdsvnmntmrhm
ptdrshnmvghkdsgdmtladqrhmrhcdsgdanwdrhmchb`sdsgdhqodqstqadc
rtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmr-Sgdb`ohs`kkdssdqr'@sgqntfgC(`ssgdsnoned`bg
bnktlmhmchb`sdsgdentqrxkk`akdrnesgdqdrtkshmf`rrnbh`shudtssdq`mbd-
@sxohb`kdw`lokdne`m`rrnbh`shudbnmrsqtbshnmvntkcado`ssdqm03-
Hmsgdenkknvhmfogq`rd+sgdoqdehwnesgdehqrsmntmhrsgdgnlnqf`mhb
rxkk`ahbm`r`koqdehwhmchb`sdcnqsgnfq`oghb`kkxgdqdaxsgdkdssdq!m-!
Rhmbdsgdehqrsmntmhreqnlmntmbk`rr8vghbgs`jdr`Ksnmd`rrnbh`shud
lnqogdld+sgdqdrtkshmf`rrnbh`shudogq`rdhr9
L H L L LH 3 3 3 3
Rhmbdsgdehqrsmntm`anudg`r`qhrhmfsnmdhmhrnk`shnm+hsb`madrddm
sg`ssgdqhrdsnGsnmdg`rchr`ood`qdctmcdqsgdhmektdmbdnesgdonrhsdc
K`rrnbh`shudsnmd-@sxohb`kdw`lokdnesgdr`ldjhmcnesnm`khmotsvhsg
sgddwbdoshnmne`G`rrnbh`shudsnmdvntkcadsnm`ko`ssdqm2/-Hmnqcdq
snsqhffdqsgdG`rrnbh`shudsnmd+vdg`udrdkdbsdc`vnqceqnlmntmbk`rr
4vghbgs`jdransg`.kd∆,.oqdehw`mcGsnmdbnmbnqc'trdcenqsgd
31
`rrnbh`shudsnm`klnqogdld!@!(-@sxohb`kdw`lokdnesghrjhmcnemntm
ogq`rdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
L H H L LH 3 31 1 3
B`qdetkdw`lhm`shnmnesgdsvnoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrvhkkrgnvsg`s
vgdqd`rsgdqhrhmfsnmdnmsgdehqrsmntmchr`ood`qrbnlokdsdkxtmcdqsgd
hmektdmbdneKsnmdbnmbnqc+hsmnsnmkxqdl`hmrvhsgGsnmdbnmbnqc+ats
hr`bbnlo`mhdcax`bg`mfdnesgdenkknvhmfoqdehweqnlhsrtmcdqkxhmfK
snmdsnsgdGsnmdnesgdonrhsdc`rrnbh`shudlnqogdld-
@r`m`cchshnm`kgdkosnsgdqd`cdq+vdqdod`ssgdoqdbdchmfbg`qs
adknvvghkdbg`mfhmfsgd!hrnk`shnmo`ssdqmr!eqnlsgdhqrtqe`bd
qd`khy`shnmrsnsgdhqtmcdqkxhmfo`ssdqmr-Sgdenkknvhmfbg`qsvhkksgtrad
`m`cchshnm`k`hcctqhmfntqdw`lhm`shnmnesgdu`qhntrsnm`kcdqhu`shnmr-
32
'24(Bg`qsA
KnvSnmdBnmbnqcGhfgSnmdBnmbnqc
'bk`rrdr0`mc8('nsgdqbk`rrdr(
Hrnk`shnmMn-@ABCMn-@ABC
K*K%K*K0-2222306-22134
K*KG1-222207-2213
K*GK2-222108-2211
K*G3-222201/-2211
K*KG%K*K4-22333410-22134
K*KG5-2233311-2213
K*GK6-2233212-2211
K*G7-22333113-2211
K*GK%K*K8-2333414-21134
K*KG0/-233315-2113
K*GK00-233216-2112
K*G01-2333117-2112
K*G%K*K02-2222318-220023
K*KG03-22222/-22002
K*GK04-222120-22001
K*G05-2222021-22001
33
Vdvhkkadfhmntqdw`lhm`shnmne`rrnbh`shudsnmdo`ssdqmrax
dw`lhmhmfhmcds`hko`ssdqmmn-0-Hmsgdenkknvhmf`tsnrdfldms`k
qdoqdrdms`shnmr+sgdu`qhntrantmc`qhdrvhkkadl`qjdc`renkknvr9
lnqogdldantmc`qhdr`r*+vnqcantmc`qhdr`r"+`mco`trdantmc`qhdr
`r..-@kknvhmfenqduhcdmbdeqnlmdhfganqhmfk`mft`fdrsg`ssgdsnm`k
`rrnbh`shudlnqogdldetmbshnmrfq`ll`shb`kkx`r`oqd,oqdehwnmsgd
rdbnmcmntm'Fhkkhf`m+087195(+sgdtmcdqkxhmfqdoqdrdms`shnmnesnmd
o`ssdqm0hr`radknv9
(36) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L # L + L + L //
Sgdehqrsqtkdsn`rrnbh`sdtmhsrnesgdrxkk`ahb`mcsnm`kshdqrhrsgdsnmd
l`oohmfqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrd`bgrxkk`akdvhsgsgdkdeslnrssnmd
vhsghmsgdr`ldlnqogdld-Sgdrsq`hfgsenqv`qcqdrtksrnesghrfdmdq`k
snmdqtkdnmntqbtqqdmsdw`lokd`qd`radknv9
(37) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L # L + L + L //
Vdmnvltrsonrhs`k`mft`fd,rodbhehbqtkdenqMfxdla——mvghbg
`rrnbh`sdrKsnmdsnm`klnqogdldrsnsgdkdes+`rhmsgdoqdkhlhm`qx
udqrhnmnentqkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfqtkd'qduhrdchm'273(adknv(+`rrs`sdc
adknv9
34
(38) Rule 5: Leftward-docking L-tone Morphemes
# + +
T + L +
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkd`rrnbh`sdrKsnmdr'mdv`rrnbh`shnmkhmdrrxlankhydc
axc`rgdckhmdr(sg`sl`jdto`mdmshqdlnqogdldsnsgdehqrsrxkk`akdnm
sgdhqkdes-Sgdqtkd`krncdkdsdr'cdkdshnmne`rrnbh`shnmkhmdrrxlankhydc
axsvnrl`kkrk`rgdrnmsgdkhmd(sgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdnesgdmdwssnmd
'rxlankhydcaxS(nmsgdkdes+hesg`ssnmdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdcdrsgdK
snmdsnm`klnqogdld-Hshrbqtbh`ksg`ssgdoqdbdchmfqtkdnmkx`ookhdr
vgdmsgdKsnmdnbbtqrhm`rxkk`akdvhsgnts`mxrdfldms`kl`sdqh`k-Hm
sgdb`rdnentqehqrssnm`ko`ssdqm+snmdqtkd3`rrnbh`sdrsgdKsnmd
`rrnbh`shudlnqogdldsnsgdkdes`mccdkdsdrsgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdvghbg
v`rnmrxkk`akdA+`radknv9
(39) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L # L + L + L //
Sgdnmkxnsgdqqtkdvghbg`ookhdrsnsghrsnmdo`ssdqmhrsnmdqtkd0+
vghbg`ccrsgdGKsnmdradenqdsgdo`trdantmc`qxfhuhmftrsgdehm`k
cnvmcqhessxohb`knetmcdqkxhmfK*Ko`ssdqmr-Sgddmcqdrtkshrsgd
2,2,2,23eqnlntqbg`qs+`radknv9
35
(40) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L # L + L + L Ø Ø //
H L
3 - 3 - 3 - 3 4
SgntfgsgdKdesv`qccnbjhmfK`rrnbh`shudsnmdcndrmnsl`jd`
rtars`mshudcheedqdmbdhmsghro`ssdqm+nqhmo`ssdqmr1sgqntfg3vghbgtmcdqfn
rhlhk`qcdqhu`shnmr+sg`sr`ldKsnmdhrbqtbh`khmo`ssdqmr4sgqntfg05+vgdqd
hsroqdrdmbdsqhffdqrsgd`ooqnoqh`sdsnmdbg`mfdr-
Vdb`mmnvdw`lhmdsnmdo`ssdqmr4sgqntfg7-Snmdo`ssdqm5+vghbg
hrsxohb`knesghrfqnto+vhkk`ood`q`radknv`esdqsgdkdes,sn,qhfgs
l`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(41) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L H # L + L + L H //
Mnvsnmdqtkd4cnbjrsgdK`rrnbh`shudsnmdsnsgdkdes'nmsnrxkk`akdA(+`r
adknv9
(42) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L H # L + L + L H //
Hshrbqtbh`k`anudsg`svgdmsgdK`rrnbh`shudsnmdcnbjrnmsnrxkk`akdA+hs
cndrnotchr`rrnbh`sdsgdKsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcvhsgsg`srxkk`akd-Sgd
36
qd`rnmenqsg`shrsgdoqdrdmbdnesgdekn`shmfGsnmdadsvddmsgdsvnKsnmdr
`rrnbh`sdcvhsgsgdr`ldrxkk`akd-Snmdqtkd4nmkxcdkdsdrsgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmd
nmsgdrxkk`akdsnsgdkdeshesgdsnmd`rrnbh`sdchrhlldch`sdkx`ci`bdmssnsgd
kdesv`qccnbjhmfK-Sgtr+hmo`ssdqmr4sgqntfg7+sgdr`ldekn`shmfGsnmdsg`s
!oqnsdbsr!sgd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdnerxkk`akdAqdl`hmrekn`shmf`mchr
qdronmrhakdenqsgdcnvmrsdoodcm`stqdnesgdK`rrnbh`shudsnmd-Hshrsgtrsgd
ekn`shmfGsnmdnesgdrdo`ssdqmrsg`shrqdronmrhakdenqsgdsnmdfkhcdeqnlkdudk
2'qdftk`qKsnmd(snkdudk3'cnvmrsdoodcKsnmd(+`radknv9
(43) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L H # L + L + L H //
3 - 3 4 - 4 - 4
Vd`qdmnvhm`onrhshnmsndw`lhmdo`ssdqmr8sgqntfg01-Vdvhkkrdkdbs
snmdo`ssdqm00`rbg`q`bsdqhrshbnesghrfqnto+`mcrs`qshsrcdqhu`shnmvhsgsgd
kdes,sn,qhfgsl`oohmfqtkdvghbgqdrtksrhmsgdenkknvhmf9
(44) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + H L # L + L + H L //
Hmenkknvhmfsgdcdqhu`shnmnesghro`ssdqm+vdltrsrs`sd`fdmdq`k
qdrsqhbshnmnmsgd`ookhb`shnmnesgdsnmdqtkdr-@ksgntfgsgdsnmdqtkdr`qd
enqsgdlnrso`qstmnqcdqdc'dwbdosenqsgdfdmdq`kl`oohmfqtkdvghbg
37
nauhntrkxltrsbnldehqrs`mcsgdknv,kdudkhmsdqoqdshudcnvmrsdoqtkd
vghbgltrsbnldk`rs(+sgdhqnqcdqhmfhm`mxo`qshbtk`qcdqhu`shnmhr
bnmsqnkkdcax`kdes,sn,qhfgsqdrsqhbshnmnmsgd`ookhb`shnmfor each
tone-Vdsgtroqnbddcnmsgdtonalshdqeqnlkdessnqhfgs`mc`rj
ntqrdkudrvgdsgdqd`bgsnmdhmstqmlddsrsgdqdpthqdldmsrenq`mxnesgd
snmdqtkdr-Oqnbddchmfhmsghrl`mmdqenqsgdo`ssdqmhmptdrshnm+sgdehqrs
qtkdsnnodq`sdhrsnmdqtkd2vghbglds`sgdrhydrsgdsnmdrnerxkk`akdA
vghkdjddohmfsgdGsnmd`rrnbh`sdc+`radknv9
(45) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + H L # L + L + H L //
Sgdmdwsqtkdsg`snodq`sdrhrsnmdqtkd4vghbgcnbjrsgd`rrnbh`shud
Ksnmdsnrxkk`akdAandcdkdsdrsgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdadsvddmrxkk`akdA
`mcsgdGsnmdrhmbdsg`ssnmdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdcdrsgd`rrnbh`shudK
snmd`ssgdlnldmssg`ssnmdqtkd4nodq`sdr-Hshrsgtrbqtbh`ksg`ssnmd
qtkd2nodq`sdrnmrxkk`akdAadenqdsnmdqtkd4cnbjrsgd`rrnbh`shudK
snmdsgdqd-Hesgdrdsvnqtkdrg`cnodq`sdchmsgdnoonrhsdnqcdq+sgd
`rrnbh`shnmkhmdadsvddmrxkk`akdA`mcsgdGsnmdvntkcg`udvqnmfkx
addmkdeshms`bs-Sgdqdrtksnesnmdqtkd4hrsgdqdenqdsgdenkknvhmf9
38
(46) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L H # L + L + H L //
Sgdehm`kqtkdsnnodq`sdnmsghro`qshbtk`qo`ssdqmhrsnmdqtkd2+vghbgsghr
shldlds`sgdrhydrsgdsnmdrnerxkk`akdC+`radknv9
(47) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L H # L + L + H L //
Vhsg`ekn`shmfGoqdbdchmfsgd`rrnbh`sdcKenqrxkk`akdA`mc`ekn`shmfK
oqdbdchmfsgd`rrnbh`sdcGnerxkk`akdC+sghro`ssdqmg`rsvnok`bdrvgdqdsgd
qdfhrsdq,knvdqhmfcnvmrsdoqtkd`ookhdr-Sgdbtltk`shudm`stqdnesgdrd
cnvmrsdorhrrgnvmhmsghro`qshbtk`qo`ssdqmaxsgdehm`kGsnmdadhmf
ognmdshb`kkxqd`khydcnmsgdr`ldohsbgkdudk'2(`rsgdhmhsh`kKsnmd'2(-Sgtr
sgdehm`kqdrtksnentqcdqhu`shnm9
(48) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L H # L + L + L H //
3 - 4 - 4 - 3
Vdmnvbnldsnsnmdo`ssdqmr02sgqntfg05vghbgoqdrdmstrvhsg`m
tmtrt`kogdmnldmnm-Vdr`v`anudsg`s`mtmcdqkxhmfK*Go`ssdqmhrqd`khydc
nmsgdrtqe`bd`r2,20vgdmhmhrnk`shnm-Hm`rrnbh`shudmntmogq`rdrvgdqdsgd
39
ehqrsmntmg`r`K*Go`ssdqm`mcsgd`rrnbh`shudsnmdhrK+sgdGsnmdhrmnsitrs
lnchehdchmsn`qhrhmfsnmd`rhmhrnk`shnm+atssgdGsnmdhrknrsbnlokdsdkx-Hm
nqcdqsndw`lhmdsghrogdmnldmnm+vdvhkkenkknvsgdcdqhu`shnmnesnmdo`ssdqm
05+vghbg`ood`qr`radknv`esdqsgdnodq`shnmnesgdkdes,sn,qhfgsl`oohmfqtkd9
(49) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + H # L + L + H //
Sgdehqrsqtkdsnnodq`sdhrsnmdqtkd3vghbgenqlr`qhrhmfsnmdnmrxkk`akd
A+`radknv9
(50) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + H # L + L + H //
Nmbdsghrqtkdg`rnodq`sdc+vdmddc`mdvqtkdvghbgcdkdsdrbnlokdsdkx
sgdGsnmdnerxkk`akdA-Rhmbdvdvhkketqsgdqqduhrdsghrqtkdhm'06/(adknv+
sgdoqdrdmsudqrhnmnesghrcdkdshnmqtkdhrnmkxoqdkhlhm`qx+`radknv9
L H + L +
∂
40
SgdoqdbdchmfqtkdcdkdsdrsgdGsnmdne`qhrhmfsnmdnmkxhmsgddudmssg`s
hshrhlldch`sdkxenkknvdcax`Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdld-Nmdqdrtksnesghrqtkd
hrsg`ssgdsnm`kbnmsq`rsadsvddmsnmdo`ssdqmr0sgqntfg3`mcsgdhqqdrodbshud
bntmsdqo`qsrhm01sgqntfg05hrmdtsq`khydc-Sghrqtkdnodq`sdrnmntqoqdrdms
o`ssdqmsnoqnctbdsgdenkknvhmf9
(52) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + H # L + L + H //
Sgdmdwsqtkdsg`snodq`sdrhrsnmdqtkd4vghbgcnbjrsgd`rrnbh`shudKsnmd
snrxkk`akdA-RhmbdsgdGsnmdg`raddmcdkdsdcaxsghrshld+sgd`rrnbh`shnm
khmdadsvddmrxkk`akdA`mcsgdehqrsKsnmdnentqo`ssdqmhr`krncdkdsdc+`r
adknv9
(53) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + # L + L + H //
Sgdehm`krsdonesghro`qshbtk`qo`ssdqmhrenqsnmdqtkd3snbnmrsqtbs`
qhrhmfsnmdnmrxkk`akdC-Sghrsdqlhm`sdrsgdcdqhu`shnm`mcqdrtksrhmsgd
bnqqdbsrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmne2,2,2,20+`radknv9
41
(54) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + # L + L + H //
3 - 3 - 3 - 31
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqdw`lhm`shnmnesgd05`rrnbh`shudmntmsnmd
o`ssdqmrvghbgbnms`hm`mhmsdqudmhmfK`rrnbh`shudsnmd-D`bgnesgd
o`ssdqmrmnschqdbskxdw`lhmdcenkknv`cdqhu`shnm`klnrshcdmshb`ksn
sgnrdcds`hkdc`anud-
Vdmnvlnudnmsnsnmdo`ssdqmr05sgqntfg21+vghbg`qd
bg`q`bsdqhydcax`G`rrnbh`shudsnmdnbbtqqhmfadsvddmsgdsvnmntmr-
VhsgsgdKsnmd`rrnbh`shudo`ssdqmrdw`lhmdc`anud+vdg`c
mdtsq`khy`shnmnebnmsq`rsadsvddmo`ssdqmrvgdqdsgdehqrsvnqcv`r2,23
hmhrnk`shnm`mcbnqqdronmchmfo`ssdqmrvgdqdsgdehqrsvnqcv`r2,20-
MnvvhsgGsnmdbnmbnqc+vdehmcdudmlnqdmdtsq`khy`shnmnebnmsq`rs-
VhsgGsnmdbnmbnqc+`mxo`ssdqmvgdqdsgdrdbnmcvnqcv`r2,1hm
hrnk`shnmmdtsq`khydrhsrsnm`kbnmsq`rsvhsgsgdbnqqdronmchmfo`ssdqm
vgdqdsgdrdbnmcvnqcv`r2,20-Lnqdnudq+sgdrdo`ssdqmrmdtsq`khydsnG
snmd`mcsncnvmrsdoodcGsnmdhmcheedqdmsdmuhqnmldmsr-Hm`cchshnm+
snmdo`ssdqmrvgdqdsgdehqrsvnqcv`r2,23hmhrnk`shnmmdtsq`khydsgdhq
bnmsq`rssghrshldvhsgsgdhqqdrodbshudbntmsdqo`qsrvgdqdsgdehqrsvnqc
42
v`r2,2-Vdvhkkmnvdw`lhmdhmcds`hksgddw`bsb`trdrnesgdrdcheedqdms
b`rdrnemdtsq`khy`shnm-
Ntqehqrsfqntonesnmdo`ssdqmrhr06sgqntfg1/vgdqdsgdehqrsvnqc
g`r`mtmcdqkxhmfK*Ko`ssdqm-Vdvhkkdw`lhmdo`ssdqm08nesghrfqnto
hmcds`hk`rg`uhmf`cdqhu`shnmsxohb`knesgdnsgdqr-Sghro`ssdqm`ood`qr
`radknv`esdqntqkdes,sn,qhfgsl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(55) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L # H + L + H L //
Hshrhlonqs`mssnmnsdsg`ssgd`anudo`ssdqmg`r`Gsnmd`rrnbh`shud
lnqogdldrdo`q`shmfsgdsvnmntmo`ssdqmr-SghrGsnmd`rrnbh`sdrsnsgd
righthmrsd`cnesnsgdkdes`rvhsgsgdK`rrnbh`shudsnmd-Vdltrs
sgdqdenqdrs`sdsgdoqdkhlhm`qxudqrhnmne`k`mft`fd,rodbhehbqtkd'qduhrdc
hm'212(adknv(vghbg`rrnbh`sdrGsnmdsnm`klnqogdldrsnsgdqhfgs+`r
adknv9
+ H + T
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkd`rrnbh`sdrGsnmdrsg`sl`jdto`mdmshqdlnqogdldsn
sgdehqrsrxkk`akdnmsgdhqqhfgs-Sgdqtkd`krncdkdsdrsgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdnesgd
43
hlldch`sdkxenkknvhmfsnmdhesg`ssnmdhr`krn`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdr`ldrxkk`akd-Hs
hrbqtbh`ksg`ssgdoqdbdchmfqtkd`ookhdrnmkxvgdmsgdGsnmdnbbtqrhm`
rxkk`akdvhsgnts`mxrdfldms`kl`sdqh`k-Vgdmsnmdqtkd6`ookhdrsno`ssdqm08+
sgdqdrtkshrsgdenkknvhmf9
(57) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L # H + L + H L //
Rhmbdrxkk`akdBmnvg`r`m`rrnbh`sdcGsnmdenkknvdcax`ekn`shmfK
snmd+hslddsrsgdqdpthqdldmsrnentqlds`sgdrhrqtkdvghbglnudrsgdekn`shmf
Ksnmdnerxkk`akdBhmeqnmsnesgdG`rrnbh`shudsnmd+`radknv9
(58) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L # H + L + H L //
Hshrbqtbh`khmsgdoqdbdchmfcdqhu`shnmsg`ssgdnodq`shnmnesgdsnmd
qtkd6nmrxkk`akdBakdcrxkk`akdCnesgdlds`sgdrhrqtkd-Rhmbdsgd
lds`sgdrhrqtkdqdpthqdrsg`ssgdoqdbdchmfrxkk`akdad`rrnbh`sdcvhsg`K
snmd+sgdcnbjhmfnesgdG`rrnbh`shudsnmd`mchsro`q`kkdkcdkdshnmne`m
`rrnbh`shnmkhmdbg`mfdcsgddmuhqnmldmsnerxkk`akdCqdrtkshmfhm`
ekn`shmfKsnmd`ssgddmcnesgdo`ssdqmvghbgg`rmnnardqu`akddeedbs
adenqdo`trd-Sgdekn`shmfKsnmdoqdbdchmfsgd`rrnbh`shudGsnmdhrsgtr
44
sgdnmkxsnmdvghbgsqhffdqrntqqdfhrsdq,knvdqhmfcnvmrsdoqtkd+`r
adknv9
(59) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L # L H + + H L //
3 - 3 - 2 - 2
Ntqmdwsfqntonesnmdo`ssdqmrhr10sgqntfg13-Vdvhkkrdkdbso`ssdqm13
`radhmfbg`q`bsdqhrshbnesghrfqnto`mcenkknvhsrcdqhu`shnmrs`qshmfeqnl
hlldch`sdkx`esdq`ookhb`shnmnesgdkdes,sn,qhfgsl`oohmfqtkd+vghbgqdrtksrhm
sgdenkknvhmf9
(60) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L H # H + L + H //
Snmdqtkd6sgdmbnldr`knmf`mccnbjrsgd`rrnbh`shudGsnmdsnsgdqhfgs
`mc!ekn`sr!sgdKsnmdsg`sv`r`kqd`cx`ss`bgdcsnrxkk`akdB+`radknv9
'50(..@*A"*B*C..
// L + L H # H + L + H //
Hsrgntkcadmnshbdcsg`ssgdnodq`shnmnesgdqhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfGsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldqtkdg`rchr`rrnbh`sdcsgdKsnmdeqnlrxkk`akdB`mcsgdqdaxakdc
rxkk`akdCne`onsdmsh`k`ookhb`shnmnesgdqhrd,enql`shnmqtkd-
45
@ssghronhms+hshrbqtbh`ksg`sntqlds`sgdrhrqtkdnodq`sdrnmrxkk`akd
Bdudmsgntfgsgdqddwhrsr`ekn`shmfGsnmdadsvddmsgd`rrnbh`sdcK
snmdnerxkk`akdA`mcsgd`rrnbh`shudsnmd-Ntqenqldqqtkd'ehqrsrs`sdchm
'13(`anud(b`mad`kknvdcsnnodq`sdhmsgdoqdrdmscdqhu`shnmvhsg`
rkhfgsqduhrhnmhmsgdqtkd&renqltk`shnm+`radknv9
L (H) H L
Sgdoqdbdchmfqduhrdclds`sgdrhrqtkd`kknvrenq`mnoshnm`kekn`shmf
Gsnmd'G(+vghbg`kknvrhssn`ookxsnntqoqdrdmso`ssdqmhmsgd
enkknvhmfl`mmdq9
(63) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L H # H + L + H //
Nmbd`f`hm+vdnmkxg`ud`ekn`shmfKsnmdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfsgd
`rrnbh`shudGsnmd-Vdsgtrnmkxfdssgd`ookhb`shnmnentqqdfhrsdq,
knvdqhmfcnvmrsdoqtkdnmrxkk`akdB+vghbgxhdkcrsgdbnqqdbsrtqe`bd
qd`khy`shnm+`radknv9
46
(64) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L H # L H + + H //
3 - 3 - 2 - 2
Cdqhu`shnmrrhlhk`qsnsgdoqdbdchmfsvn`qdqdronmrhakdenqsgdsnm`k
mdtsq`khy`shnmduhcdmbdcaxo`ssdqmr08+1/+12`mc13-
Vd`qdmnvoqdo`qdcsng`mckdo`ssdqmr14sgqntfg17nevghbgvdvhkk
rdkdbso`ssdqm16`r`qdoqdrdms`shud-O`ssdqm16hrdrodbh`kkxhmsdqdrshmfhmsg`s
vdg`udsgqddtmcdqkxhmfG,Krdptdmbdrqdk`sdcsnsgqddrtbddchmfrxkk`akdr-
@esdqsgdkdes,sn,qhfgsl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc+ntqlds`sgdrhrqtkd`ookhdrsn
rxkk`akdA+qdrtkshmfhmsgdenkknvhmf9
(65) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + H L # H + L + H L //
Mdws+ntq`rrnbh`shudGsnmdcnbjrsnsgdqhfgs`mc`krnekn`srsgdKsnmd
`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
(66) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L H # H + L + H L //
Hshrbqtbh`k`ssghronhmssg`srxkk`akdBb`mmnstmcdqfnsgdlds`sgdrhrqtkd
adb`trdsgdoqdbdchmfrxkk`akdhr`rrnbh`sdcsn`Gsnmd-Rxkk`akdCcndrmns
47
tmcdqfnlds`sgdrhrenqsgdr`ldqd`rnm-Gnvdudq+sgdenqldqkx`rrnbh`sdcK
snmdnerxkk`akdBhrrshkkekn`shmfadenqdsgdGsnmdnerxkk`akdC+vghbgsqhffdqr
sgdrdbnmc`ookhb`shnmnentqqdfhrsdq,knvdqhmfcnvmrsdoqtkd+`rrddmadknv9
(67) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + L H # H + L + H L //
3 - 2 - 2 - 3
Nmbd`f`hm+vdrddsgd`bbtltk`shudm`stqdnesgdcnvmrsdonmsgdehm`kG
snmdvghbghrqd`khydcnmsgdr`ldognmdshbkdudk'2(`rsgdhmhsh`kKsnmd'2(-
Vd`qdmnvqd`cxsndw`lhmdsgdk`rsentqo`ssdqmr-Vdbgnnrdo`ssdqm21
`rbg`q`bsdqhrshbnesghrfqnto-@esdqntqkdes,sn,qhfgsl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc+
snmdqtkd3bqd`sdr`qhrhmfsnmdnmrxkk`akdA+`radknv9
(68) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + H # H + L + H //
@ssghronhms+hshrbqtbh`ksg`sntqqhrd,cdkdshnmqtkdcndrnot`ookx+adb`trd
sgdqhrdhrenkknvdcax`Gsnmdsnm`klnqogdldhmrsd`cne`Ksnmdsnm`k
lnqogdld-Sgdmdwsqtkdsnnodq`sd+sgdqdenqd+`rrnbh`sdrsgdG`rrnbh`shudsnmd
snsgdqhfgs`mcekn`srsgdKsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsnrxkk`akdB+`radknv9
48
(69) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + H # H + L + H //
Nmbd`f`hm+sgdKsnmdnerxkk`akdBsg`shrmnvekn`shmfhrmnslnudc
axntqlds`sgdrhrqtkdadb`trdsgdk`rs`rrnbh`sdcsnmdnesgdoqdbdchmf
rxkk`akd'A(hrmns`Ksnmd-Sghrekn`shmfKsnmdsg`shrmnseqnmsdchrnmbd
`f`hmqdronmrhakdenqsgdcnvmrsdoodcGsnmdnerxkk`akdC+`radknv9
(70) // A + B # + C + D //
// L + H # H + L + H //
3 - 31 - 1 - 2
Hmbnmbktchmfsghrrdbshnm+vdvhkkkhrssgdqtkdrchrbtrrdcrne`q`knmf
vhsg`khf`stqdnmsgdkdesbnmmdbshmfsgnrdqtkdrnqfqntorneqtkdrvgdqd
nqcdqhmfhrbqtbh`k-Ntqbtqqdmskhrsneqtkdr'qduhrdchm'305(adknv(hrsgd
enkknvhmf9
49
Rule 4: Rise-Formation
Rule 6: Rise-Deletion
@rhmchb`sdcaxntqkhf`stqdr`anud+hshrmdbdrr`qxnmkxsg`sntq
fdmdq`k'tmhudqr`k(kdes,sn,qhfgsl`oohmfqtkdoqdbdcd`kknsgdqsnmdqtkdr
`mcsg`sntqk`sd'tmhudqr`k(`citrsldmscnvmrsdoqtkdenkknv`kknsgdqr-
@kksgdnsgdqqtkdrsgtrenql`ancx+rg`qhmfsvnbg`q`bsdqhrshbr-Sgdrd
qtkdr`qdmnsrsqhbskxnqcdqdcvhsgqdrodbssnd`bgnsgdq-Sgdxcnrg`qdsgd
fdmdq`kqdrqhbshnmsg`ssgdqdrtkshmfcdqhu`shnmoqnbddcreqnlkdessnqhfgs+
tone by tone-Rhmbdsgdkdes,sn,qhfgsl`oohmfqtkd`mcsgdkdes,sn,qhfgs
qdrsqhbshnmnmqtkd`ookhb`shnm`mcsgdcnvmrsdoqtkdlhfgs`kkad
tmhudqr`koqhmbhokdr+bg`q`bsdqhrshbne`kksnmdrxrsdlr+sgdx`qdoqna`akx
adrsqdf`qcdc`ro`qsnetmhudqr`ksnmdsgdnqx`mcsgdqdaxmns`o`qshbtk`q
50
bg`q`bsdqhrshbnesgdMfxdla——msnmdrxrsdl-Sgdqdenqd+nmdnesgd
chrshmbshuded`stqdrnesghro`qshbtk`q`m`kxrhrhrsgdtmnqcdqdcm`stqdne
sgda`rhbsnmdqtkdr+`knmfvhsgsgdhqkdes,sn,qhfgslocal`ookhb`shnm-
51
2.3. Verbs
Sgdoqdrdmschrrdqs`shnmvhkkdw`lhmdsgdu`qhntrjhmcrnesdmrd+
`rodbs`mclncdchrshmbshnmrentmchmsgdMfxdla——mk`mft`fd-Vghkd
bnmbdmsq`shmfoqhl`qhkxtonmbnmrsqtbshnmrhmsgdhmchb`shudlnnc+vd
vhkkenbtrntq`ssdmshnmnmu`qhntrfq`ll`shb`ked`stqdr`mcsgdhqqnkdhm
cdsdqlhmhmfsgdl`mxcheedqdmssnm`ko`ssdqmrentmcnmsgdudqarsdl-Hm
m`lhmfntqudqa`ked`stqdr+vdenkknvGxl`m'087/9124(enqntqsdmrd
ed`stqdr`mcBnlqhd'0865914(enqntq`rodbst`ked`stqdr-Sgdenkknvhmf
dhfgsahm`qxed`stqdr`qdmddcdcsnfdmdq`sdsgda`rhbMfxdla——m
hmchb`shudbnmrsqtbshnmr9
[fut] (future/non-future)
[rem] (remote/non-remote)
[near] (near/far)
[prog] (progressive/non-progressive)
@rvntkcaddwodbsdcenq`mxk`mft`fdg`uhmfsghrmtladqnea`rhb
52
udqa`kchrshmbshnmr+mns`kknesgdlncd,sdmrd,`rodbs,onk`qhsxbnnbbtqqdmbd
onrrhahkhshdr`qd`bst`kkxqd`khydc-Rhmbd`mxhmchb`shudbnmrsqtbshnmhm
Mfxdla——mg`ransgonrhshud`mcmdf`shudqd`khy`shnmr+vdvhkkhfmnqdenq
sgdlnldmssgdptdrshnmneonk`qhsx-Nmbdsghrhrcnmd+vdb`mrgnvax
ld`mrne`sqddch`fq`lsgdu`qhntrbnnbbtqqdmbdqdrsqhbshnmrsg`s
`bst`kkxdwhrs+`radknv9
(73) Verbs
Realis Irrealis
Hm`cchshnmsnsgdodqedbshud'OQE(+hlodqedbshud'HLO(`mc
oqnfqdrrhud'OQNF(l`qjdqr+sgdqddwhrsr`mnakhf`snqxqd`khr
hlodqedbshudl`qjdq'rdd1-2-0-adknv(`mc`mnoshnm`kqd`khroqnfqdrrhud
l`qjdq'rdd1-2-3-adknv(d`bgnevghbgbnlahmdrlnc`k`mc`rodbst`k
ed`stqdrhm`rhmfkdl`qjdq-Nsgdqvhrd+lnrsl`qjdqrhmMfxdla——ml`qj
53
`singleudqa`kb`sdfnqx9lncd+sdmrd+`rodbsoronk`qhsx-Sghrdwhrsdmbd
nerdo`q`sdlnqogdldrsg`s`qdtm`lahftntrkxdhsgdqsdmrd+`rodbsnq
mdf`shnml`qjdqrhrmnssxohb`kne@eqhb`mk`mft`fdr-Ltbglnqdbnllnm
hrsgddwhrsdmbdneu`qhntrlnqogdldrsg`sbnlahmdcheedqdmssdmrd+`rodbs
`mconk`qhsxoqnodqshdrhm`rhmfkdl`qjdq'Vdkldqr+08629232,3(-
Vdb`mqdrs`sdsgdu`qhntrbnnbbtqqdmbdqdrsqhbshnmrrgnvmhmsgd
oqdbdchmfsqddch`fq`laxld`mrnesgdenkknvhmfhlokhb`shnm`k
rs`sdldmsr9
Sgdrdoqnrdhlokhb`shnm`krs`sdldmsrb`m`krnadqdenqltk`sdctrhmf
ntqahm`qxfq`ll`shb`ked`stqdr`mc`mhlokhb`shnm`k`qqnv!!`r
adknv9
54
(75) Formal Implicational Statements
[+real] [-fut]
[-real] [-past]
[+past] [+real]
[+fut] [-real]
[+prog] [-perf]
+perf
-past [+real]
-fut
-real
-past [-perf]
-fut
Rne`q+vdg`udnmkxqdedqqdcsno`rs+oqdrdms`mcetstqd`rsdlonq`k
chrshmbshnmr-@bst`kkx+hshrhmsdmrdl`qjdqrsg`ssgdMfxdla——mk`mft`fd+khjd
l`mxA`mstk`mft`fdr+hro`qshbtk`qkxqhbg-Snadrodbhehb+Mfxdla——mchuhcdr
ansgo`rs`mcetstqdshldhmsnentqrdo`q`sdrdl`mshbb`sdfnqhdr'sgdbknrdkx
qdk`sdck`mft`fdneCrbg`mf`bst`kkxchuhcdrhmsnehudb`sdfnqhdr+`rodq
S`c`cidt+086490(-Ntqshldrodbsqtlhrsgtrchuhcdctohmsnmhmdcheedqdms
rdbshnmr'hmrsd`cnedkdudm(+`mcvdltrssgdqdenqdtrdentqfq`ll`shb`k
ed`stqdrsnetkkxchrshmfthrgd`bgnesgdrdld`mhmfreqnlsgdnsgdqr-Vd
sgdqdenqdcdehmdsgdmhmdMfxdla——msdmrdr`bbnqchmfsnsgdahm`qxrdl`mshb
ed`stqdbnlahm`shnmrentmchmsgdenkknvhmfs`akd9
55
(76) Tense Features
P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø F1 F2 F3 F4
[past] + + + + - - - - -
[fut] - - - - - + + + +
[rem] + + - - - - - + +
[near] - + - + - + - + -
Sgdoqdbdchmfmhmdsdmrdrhmbktcdentqo`rssdmrdr'hmchb`sdcaxsgd
rxlank!O!(`mcentqetstqdsdmrdr'hmchb`sdcaxsgdrxlank!E!(`rvdkk
`rsgdydqnsdmrd'hmchb`sdcaxsgdrxlank!∂!(vghbgqdedqrsnsgd
oqdrdmslnldms-Gxl`mg`rrgnvmsg`ssgdbknrdkxqdk`sdcCrbg`mf
k`mft`fdl`xtrdltkshokdsdmrdl`qjdqrsnhmchb`sdqdk`shudshld
qdedqdmbd'087/9118(-SgdMfxdla——mk`mft`fd+nmsgdnsgdqg`mc+cndr
mnsrddlsntrdltkshokdsdmrdl`qjdqrsnhmchb`sdqdk`shudshldqdedqdmbd-
@r`qdrtks+sgdenkknvhmfkhrshmchb`sdrsgdentqcdfqddrneqdlnsdmdrr+
ansgo`rs`mcetstqd+eqnlsgdoqdrdmslnldms9
56
P2 : yesterday
P1 : earlier today
F1 : later today
F2 : tomorrow
Sgda`rhbhmchb`shnmnesgdu`qhntrsdmrdrhrcnmdaxld`mrnecheedqdms
!l`qjdqr-!Sgdydqnsdmrdhrhmchb`sdcaxsgd`ardmbdne`mxnudqssdmrd
lnqogdld-Sgdetstqdsdmrdr`qdl`qjdcaxsgdoqdrdmbdneu`qhntr`twhkh`qx
udqar+svnnesgdetstqdsdmrdr`bst`kkxg`uhmf`bgnhbdadsvddmsvncheedqdms
`twhkh`qxudqarsnhmchb`sdsgdr`ldrdl`mshbed`stqdr-Sgqddnesgdo`rssdmrdr
l`jdtrdnenqchm`qxsdmrdl`qjdqrvghkdsgdtmtrt`kO3sdmrdhrhmchb`sdcax
bnlahmhmfl`qjdqrenqO2`mcE3-@kknesgdrdl`qjdqr`mcsgdhqbnqqdronmchmf
snm`kodqstqa`shnmr`qdchrbtrrdchmcds`hkhmrdbshnm1-2-2-adknv-
HmoqduhntrvnqjraxG%S+sgdldsgncnknfhb`krsq`sdfx`cnosdcg`r
addmsns`jdsgdsnmdqtkdrcdudknodcsng`mckdsnmdbg`mfdrhmsgdmntm
ogq`rd`mcrddgnve`qsgdxvhkkfnhmdwok`hmhmfsgdsnmdbg`mfdrhmsgd
udqaogq`rd-Sghrr`ldrsq`sdfxg`raddmenkknvdchmntqqdrd`qbg`mc
57
oqdrdms`shnm-@r`qdrtks+vdvhkknmkxoqnonrd`cchshnmrnqlnchehb`shnmr
snsgdqtkdr`kqd`cxcdudknodcenqsgdmntmogq`rd`rqdpthqdcaxsgd
`cchshnm`kc`s`g`uhmfsncnvhsgudqar-
Adenqdadfhmmhmfntqhm,cdosgdw`lhm`shnm+hsvntkcadgdkoetkenqsgd
qd`cdqsng`ud`mhcd`nesgdhmsdqm`krsqtbstqdnesgdudqahsrdke-Rhmbd
sghrhmbktcdru`qhntrsnm`klnqogdldr+vdkhrssgdhmsdqm`krsqtbstqdnesgd
udqa`radknv9
vbst V (S)
V - Verb root
I - Imperfective suffix
58
@rb`madrddmhmsgdoqdbdchmfenqltk`r+nmkxsgdudqaqnns`mc`
oqdbdchmfonk`qsnmdlnqogdld'dhsgdqqd`khrnqhqqd`khr(`qdnakhf`snqhkx
oqdrdmshm`kkudqar-Sgdnoshnm`khsdlr+hmo`qdmsgdrdr+`qdoqdrdmsnmkx
vgdmsgdhqo`qshbtk`qed`stqdrb`kkenqsgdl+vhsgsgddwbdoshnmnesgd
snmdkdrrudqarteehwvgnrdoqdrdmbdhrrodbhehdchmsgdkdwhbnmenqd`bg
`eedbsdcudqa-Sgdonk`qsnmdlnqogdldoqdbdchmfsgdudqarsdlhrnmkx
nakhf`snqxhmsg`ssgdr`ldonrhshnmhrnbbtohdcaxansgqd`khr`mchqqd`khr
onk`qsnmdr+`mcdudqxrdmsdmbdhrdhsgdqqd`khrnqhqqd`khrhmlncd-Sgd
bqtbh`kcheedqdmbdhmsgdrdsvnlnqogdldrhrsg`ssgdqd`khrhrhmrdqsdc
adenqdsgdl`inqhsxnesnmdqtkdrvghkdsgdhqqd`khrhrhmrdqsdcvgdmnmkx
sgdk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdrqdl`hm-Sgdudqxcheedqdmsrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmr
sg`sqdrtks`qdchrbtrrdchmcds`hkhmsgdenkknvhmfrta,rdbshnmr-
59
Hmsgdhmchb`shudlnnc+sgdqd`qdehudrdo`q`sdonrrhakdbnmrsqtbshnmr
hmunkuhmf`rodbst`k,lnc`k,sxodld`mhmfr-Hshrnmkxhmsgdoqdrdms'ydqn(
sdmrd+gnvdudq+sg`s`kkehudonrrhahkhshdr`qd`bst`kkxodqlhrrhakd+`r
rgnvmhmntqbg`qsadknv'vgdqdsgdehqrsqnvhroqdedbshud`mcsgdk`rs
entqqnvr`qdhlodqedbshud(9
Markers P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø F1 F2 F3 F4
Ø +Ø + Ø x x x x x x x x x
Ø +N-+-I x x x x x
ne+N-+-I x x x x x
Ø +Ø +-I x x x x x
ne+Ø +-I x x x x x
Hmsgdoqdbdchmfbg`qs+sgd.md.l`qjdqbkd`qkxrhfm`kroqnfqdrrhud
ld`mhmf`mcsgdhlodqedbshududqarteehw'rxlankhydcax!,H!(rhfm`kr
hlodqedbshud`rodbs+atssgdgnlnqf`mhbm`r`kbnmrnm`msudqaoqdehw
60
'rxlankhydcax!M,!(g`r`lnqdu`ftdld`mhmf-Ntqbg`qsrgnvrsg`s
sghrm`r`koqdehwhr`kv`xroqdrdmsvhsgsgdhlodqedbshudrteehwhmo`rs
sdmrdr+atsmdudqoqdrdmshmetstqdsdmrdr-Etqsgdqadknv+vdrg`kk`qftd
sg`ssghrm`r`koqdehwrhfm`kr!qd`khrhlodqedbshud!ld`mhmf-
Ehqrs+vdltrsdw`lhmdlnqdbknrdkxsgdoqdbdchmfbg`qsvghkd
jddohmfhmlhmconrrhakdfq`ll`shb`ked`stqdrsg`sl`xadtrdcsn
fdmdq`sd`kkehudnesgdrdbnmrsqtbshnmr-Rhmbdsgdqd`qdehudbnmrsqtbshnmr+
`mcmnsentq+vdvhkkmddc`lhmhltlne`skd`rssgqdded`stqdr-Hsrddlr
adrssntrdsgdahm`qxed`stqdrZodqe\`mcZoqnf\snfdmdq`sdsgded`stqdr
`rrnbh`sdcvhsgsgdhqqdrodbshudrdl`mshbehdkcr+odqedbshud.hlodqedbshud
`mcoqnfqdrrhud.mnm,oqnfqdrrhud`rodbs-Sghrkd`udrhmptdrshnmnmkxsgd
k`adk`mcld`mhmfnesgdsghqced`stqd-Vdoqnonrdhmsghrchrrdqs`shnmsgd
ed`stqdZqd`k\'qd`khr.hqqd`khr(snadsgdsghqcahm`qxfq`ll`shb`ked`stqd-
Nmdnesgdqd`rnmrvdcnsghrhrsg`sbdqs`hmeqdptdmssnmdo`ssdqmrnmsgd
udqarsdlbnqqdk`sdghfgkxvhsgetstqdur-mnm,etstqdbnmrsqtbshnmr-Vd
vhkkqdedqsnsgdrdghfgkxeqdptdmssnmdo`ssdqmr`rsgd!qdftk`q!qd`khrnq
hqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmr+enqqd`rnmrsg`svhkkadbnld`oo`qdmsadknv-Sgdrd
qdftk`qrtqe`bdsnmdo`ssdqmr`qd`radknv9
61
'7/( Rtqe`bdSnmdr
Kdwhb`ksnmdrQd`khrHqqd`khr
GsnmdudqaqnnsG∫G∫
Ksnmdudqaqnns∫G∫K∫
D`bgudqarsdlhmMfxdla——m'vgdsgdqhsadlnmnrxkk`ahbnq
chrxkk`ahb(bnldrvhsg`rhmfkdkdwhb`ksnmdnmsgdudqaqnns+`mcsg`ssnmd
hrdhsgdqGnqK-Sgd`bst`krtqe`bdohsbgqd`khy`shnmnmudqaru`qhdr
fqd`skx`mccdodmcr`fqd`scd`knmsgdu`qhntrudqa`ked`stqdrnesgd
bnmrsqtbshnmhmptdrshnm-Sgdoqdbdchmfbg`qsrgnvrsg`stmcdqkxhmfG
`mcKsnmdudqaqnnsr`qd`bst`kkxqd`khydcnmsgdrtqe`bdnmG`mc
cnvmrsdoodcGsnmdrenqlnrsqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr-Enqhqqd`khr
bnmrsqtbshnmr+sgdtmcdqkxhmfG`mcKsnmdnesgdudqaqnnshrtrt`kkx
aq`bjdsdcaxcnvmrsdor+nmdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfsgdudqaqnns`mcsgd
nsgdqhlldch`sdkxenkknvhmfhs-
Vdb`mmnvqdcnsgdoqdbdchmfsnmdbg`qsnmsnmdchrsqhatshnmvhsg
u`qhntrsdmrd`mc`rodbsl`qjdqr+`radknv9
62
(81) Realis/Irrealis Tone Distribution
Features P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø F1 F2 F3 F4
[+perf] x/R x/R x/R x/R x/R I/I I/I I/I I/I
-perf
+real x/R x/x x/x R/R R/R
-prog
-perf
+real R/R R/R R/R R/R x/R
+prog
-perf
-real x/I I/I I/I I/I I/I
-prog
-perf
-real I/I I/I I/I I/I I/I
+prog
63
Hmsgdoqdbdchmfbg`qs+sgd!Q!rs`mcrenq`qdftk`qqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqm+
sgd!H!enq`qdftk`qhqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqm+`mcsgdrl`kk!w!enqsgnrd
dmuhqnmldmsrvgdqdhmchuhct`klnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdrqdrtkshmu`qhntr
hchnrxmbq`shbsnmdo`ssdqmr-Sgdkdssdqadenqdd`bgrk`rghmchb`sdrsgdsnmd
o`ssdqmnesgdonrhshudrdmsdmbdvghkdsgdkdssdq`esdqd`bgrk`rghmchb`sdr
hsrmdf`shudbntmsdqo`qs-Bknrddw`lhm`shnmnesgdodqedbshudonrrhahkhshdr
`anudrgnvrsg`setstqdodqedbshudrs`jdqdftk`qhqqd`khrsnmdrvghkdmnm,
etstqdodqedbshudrs`jdqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdr'`skd`rshmsgdmdf`shudr(-
Rhmbdvdg`ud`kqd`cx`fqddcsnsgdmddcnesgdahm`qxZqd`k\ed`stqdhm
nqcdqsnchrshmfthrgsgdentqhlodqedbshudo`ssdqmreqnld`bgnsgdq+vd
vhkketqsgdqoqnehseqnlsghrlnudaxdwsdmchmfsgdtrdnesghred`stqdsn
hmbktcdodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmr-Sgtrsgdl`qjhmfneqd`khrnqhqqd`khr
`rodbsnmodqedbshududqa`kbnmrsqtbshnmrvhkkdm`akdtrsnlnqdd`rhkx
fdmdq`sdsgdoqnodqsnmdrnmudqar-Chuhchmfsgdodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmr
to`bbnqchmfsnsgdhqqd`khr'h-d-mnm,etstqd(ur-hqqd`khr'h-d-etstqd(
m`stqd+vd`qd`akdsnrkhfgskxqduhrdntqoqduhntrbg`qs'vhsgsgdcntakd
khmdmnvrdo`q`shmfqd`khreqnlhqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr(+`radknv9
64
(82) Revised Realis/Irrealis Tone Distribution
Features P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø F1 F2 F3 F4
-perf
+real x/R x/x x/x R/R R/R
-prog
-perf
+real R/R R/R R/R R/R x/R
+prog
-perf
-real x/I I/I I/I I/I I/I
-prog
-perf
-real I/I I/I I/I I/I I/I
+prog
65
Hsrgntkcadbkd`qkxrs`sdc`ssghrshldsg`ssgdl`inqqd`rnmsg`svd
mddc`sghqcahm`qxed`stqdkhjdZqd`k\hrsnoqdchbssgdnbbtqqdmbdnq
`ardmbdnesgdm`r`koqdehwadenqdsgdudqarsdlhmsgdoqdrdms'nqydqn(
sdmrd-Nmbdvd`qdenqbdcsnonrhsrtbg`ed`stqd+gnvdudq+sgdoqdbdchmf
bg`qsrgnvrsgdr`lded`stqdb`m`krnadtrdetkhmoqdchbshmfsgdu`rs
l`inqhsxne`bst`krtqe`bdsnmdrsg`snbbtqnmsgdudqarsdl-
Vd`qdmnvhm`onrhshnmsnmnshbdrdudq`ksghmfreqnlsgdoqdbdchmf
bg`qs-Ehqrs+`klnrs`kknesgdrl`kk!w!rhmchb`shmfrodbh`klnqogn,
snmnknfhb`kqtkdr`ookxsnonrhshudrdmsdmbdr-RhmbdansgE1`mcE3
`bst`kkxg`udsvnrdo`q`sdbnmrsqtbshnmrd`bg'rdd1-2-2-adknv(+vdb`m
r`xsg`setkkx22ntsne24'nq83odqbdms(nesgdmdf`shudhmchb`shud
bnmrsqtbshnmrs`jdsgdqdftk`q'tmlnchehdc(qd`khrnqhqqd`khrsnmdrnmsgdhq
udqaqnnsr-Sghrodqbdms`fdhrrnldvg`skdrrenqsgdhqonrhshud
bntmsdqo`qsr+vgdqdnmkx14ntsne24'nq60odqbdms(s`jdsgdqdftk`q
qd`khrnqhqqd`khrsnmdr-Sghrrgnvrtrsg`setkkx47ntsne6/'nq72
odqbdms(nesgdonrhshud`mcmdf`shudbnmrsqtbshnmrb`moqdchbssgdhq
rtqe`bdsnmdo`ssdqmsolelynmsgda`rhrnesgdoqdrdmbdnq`ardmbdne
sgdonrhsdcqd`khred`stqd-Sghrhrrtqdkx`mhlonqs`msrhcdadmdehsnesgd
mdbdrrhsxneonrhshmfrtbg`ed`stqd'vghbgvdg`udbgnrdmsnk`adk
!qd`khr.hqqd`khr!(-@mnsgdqrhcdadmdehshrsg`ssghrk`adkhmfhlokhdrsg`ssgd
lnqdeqdptdmsqd`khr`mchqqd`khrsnm`ko`ssdqmr`qdkdrrl`qjdcsg`msgd
66
u`qhntrhchnrxmbq`shbsnm`ko`ssdqmrvghbg`qdpthsdqhfgskxqdf`qcdc`r
kdrreqdptdms`mclnqdl`qjdc-
Hsrgntkc`krnadldmshnmdcsg`ssgdhqqd`khrsnmdl`qjhmfhrltbg
lnqdbnmrhrsdms'h-d-mnssnadlnchehdcaxnsgdqlnqogn,snmnknfhb`k
qtkdr(sg`mhsrqd`khro`qsmdq-Eqnlsgdoqdbdchmfbg`qsnmbd`f`hm+vdb`m
rddsg`setkkx28ntsne3/'nq86-4odqbdms(nesgdhqqd`khrhmchb`shud
bnmrsqtbshnmr`qdqd`khydcvhsgsgdqdftk`qhqqd`khrsnmdr-Nmsgdnsgdq
g`mc+nmkx08ntsne2/'nq52odqbdms(nesgdqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr`qd
`bst`kkxqd`khydcognmdshb`kkxvhsgsgdhqqd`khrsnmdr-Sghrhradb`trdsgd
u`qhntrlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdrrddlsng`ud`rodbh`k`eehmhsxenqsgd
onrhshudqd`khr'drodbh`kkxonrhshudodqedbshudqd`khr(bnmrsqtbshnmrvghbg
g`oodmsnadsgdlnrseqdptdmskxtrdchmmnql`kdudqxc`xroddbg-Hs
sgdqdenqdrddlrsg`ssgdsxohb`krod`jdqhr`akdsnqdldladqsgdtmtrt`k
snm`ko`ssdqmrnesgdlnrsbnllnmkxtrdcbnmrsqtbshnmroqdbhrdkxadb`trd
sgdx`qdsgdlnrseqdptdmskxronjdm`mcgd`qchmmnql`kudqa`k
hmsdq`bshnm-
@ssghronhms+vdrgntkcrod`jsnsgdrtaidbsnesgdtmcdqkxhmf
rdl`mshbhmenql`shnmb`qqhdcaxntqmdvkxonrhsdcZqd`k\ed`stqd-Hshr
`oo`qdmseqnlsgdoqdbdchmfbg`qsrsg`s`kko`rshmchb`shudbnmrsqtbshnmr
`qd!qd`khr!`mc`kketstqdbnmrsqtbshnmr`qd!hqqd`khr-!Eqnlsghrvdlhfgs
onrstk`sdsg`ssgded`stqdg`rsncnvhsgvgdsgdqsgdoqnonrhshnmbnmudxdc
axsgdbnmrsqtbshnmhr!qd`k!hmsgdrdmrdsg`shshrrnldgnvudqheh`akd`s
67
sgdlnldmsnerod`jhmf-Hsrgntkcadldmshnmdc`ssghronhmssg`sZ*qd`k\+
nq!qd`khr+!cndrmnsld`m!qd`khydc!hmsgdrdmrdsg`srnldsghmfg`r
`bst`kkxbnldsno`rr+rhmbd!qd`khr!`ookhdrsnansgonrhshud`mcmdf`shud
bnmrsqtbshnmr`mcsgddwoqdrrotqonrdne`o`rsmdf`shudqd`khr
bnmrsqtbshnmlhfgsadsn`rrdqssg`ssgdoqnonrhshnmlnrsbdqs`hmkxchcnot
bnldsno`rr-Hshrsgdqdenqdadrssnsghmjnesghred`stqd`rld`mhmf
rnldsghmfkhjd!qd`k+!`mcmns!qd`khydc-!
Rhmbdsgdahm`qxZqd`k\ed`stqd`krndwhrsrhmsgdoqdrdmssdmrd+`mchm
ansghsronrhshud`mcmdf`shudqd`khy`shnmrvgdqdvdb`mbnlo`qdsgd
ld`mhmflnqdbknrdkx+vdvhkkdw`lhmd`bntokdnesgdrdrdmsdmbdrsnfds
`rg`qodqeddkhmfenqsgdrdl`mshbehdkchmchb`sdc-Ntqehqrsrdmsdmbdbntkc
adk`adkkdcsgd!oqdrdmsqd`khroqnfqdrrhud!`mchshrqd`khydc`radknv9
Sgdoqdbdchmfrdmsdmbdg`rsgdoqdrdmbdnesgdhlodqedbshudqd`khr
m`r`koqdehw'rxlankhydcaxsgdtmcdqkhmdc!m!(`mcb`qqhdrsgdrdl`mshb
vdhfgsne`arnktsd`rrtq`mbd-Sghrhrsnadbnmsq`rsdcvhsgsgdenkknvhmf
dw`lokdvghbgbntkcadk`adkkdcsgd!oqdrdmshqqd`khroqnfqdrrhud!9
68
cutting meat"
Sghrk`rsdw`lokdmnsnmkxk`bjrsgdoqdrdmbdnesgdhlodqedbshudqd`khr
m`r`koqdehwnmsgdudqa+hs`krnbnlltmhb`sdrsnsgdkhrsdmdqsg`ssgd
rod`jdqhrmns`arnktsdkxrtqdsg`svg`sgdhrr`xhmfhrsqtd-Sgtr+nmd
bntkcr`xsg`ssgd`ardmbdneqd`khrl`qjhmfhmsghrbnmsdws
bnlltmhb`sdr`bdqs`hmcdfqddnetmbdqs`hmsx-Sghrtmbdqs`hmsxhrmns
tmkhjdsgdtmbdqs`hmsxsg`smdbdrr`qhkx`bbnlo`mhdr`mxoqnmntmbdldms
qdk`shmfsnsgdetstqd-Vdb`msgtrrddsg`ssghrbdqs`hm.tmbdqs`hm
rdl`mshbchrshmbshnmhrpthsdbknrdsnsgdld`mhmfnesgdahm`qxed`stqd
vdbgnnrdsnk`adk!qd`khr.hqqd`khr-!
Hmnqcdqsncdqhudsgdqdftk`qqd`khr`mchqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmrtrhmfsgd
snmdqtkdr`kqd`cxcdudknodchmsghrchrrdqs`shnm+ntq`m`kxrhrltrsonrhs
rdudq`ksnm`klnqogdldr+lnrsmns`akxsgqddcheedqdmspolarsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldrvgdqdsgdoqdbhrdm`stqdnesgdsnmdhrcdehmdc`radhmfsgd
dw`bsnoonrhsdnesgdenkknvhmf`rrnbh`sdcsnmd-Ntqehqrsonk`qsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldhmchb`sdrqd`khrlncd`mchshlldch`sdkxoqdbdcdrsgdudqa
qnns-Sgdrdbnmconk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldhmchb`sdrhqqd`khrlncd`mc
`krnhlldch`sdkxoqdbdcdrsgdudqaqnns-Sgdbqtbh`kcheedqdmbdadsvddm
sgdrdsvnekn`shmfonk`qsnmdrhrsg`ssgdqd`khrnmdhrhmrdqsdchmsgdsnmd
o`ssdqmbeforesgdsnmdqtkdrnodq`sd+vghkdhsrhqqd`khrbntmsdqo`qshr
69
hmrdqsdcafter-Sgdhqqd`khronk`qsnmdlnqogdldoqdbdchmfsgdudqahr
`krn`bbnlo`mhdcax`rdbnmconk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldvghbg
hlldch`sdkxenkknvrsgdudqaqnns-Ansgnesgdrdhqqd`khronk`qsnmdrvhkk
adhmrdqsdcaxsgdr`ldk`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd-
Sgdtmtrt`knqcdqhmfnesghrsnm`khmrdqshnmqtkd`esdqsgdnodq`shnmne
lnrsnesgdsnm`kqtkdr'dwbktchmfntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkd(hroqna`akx
qdk`sdcsnsgdqdbdmsghrsnqhb`kcdudknoldmsnesgdrdetstqd'`mcsgdqdenqd
hqqd`khr(sdmrdr-Hme`bs+sgd`twhkh`qxudqarvghbg`qdtrdcsnl`qjetstqd
sdmrdmnvcdrhfm`sdsgdrdl`mshbehdkcneetstqhsxatsrshkkqds`hmsgdhq
fq`ll`shb`krs`str`rudqar-Sgdk`sdhmrdqshnmnesgdrdhqqd`khrsnmdrhr
trdcrnkdkxsnsqhffdqsgd`ooqnoqh`sdcnvmrsdoed`stqdrnmsgdrtqe`bd+
vghbgenqsgda`rhbhqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmansgoqdbdcd`mcenkknvsgdudqa
rsdl-Ntqonrhsdctmcdqkxhmfsnmdo`ssdqmr`qdsgdqdenqdsgdenkknvhmf
'vgdqd!O!rxlankhydr`onk`qsnmdvghbgb`mnmkxadjmnvmvgdmsgd
enkknvhmfsnmdhr`krnjmnvm(9
70
Sgdoqdbdchmftmcdqkxhmfsnmdo`ssdqmrhmsdq`bsvhsgsgdsnmdqtkdr
`kqd`cxonrhsdcenqsgdmntmogq`rdsnfhudtrntqentql`inqrtqe`bdsnmd
o`ssdqmr-Vdvhkkmnvdw`lhmdd`bgnesgdrdentqa`rhbcdqhu`shnmrhm
stqm-Vdvhkkkhlhsntqrdkudrhmsghrrdbshnmsnsgdkdrrl`qjdcodqedbshud
snmdo`ssdqmr+kd`uhmfsgdlnqdbnlokhb`sdchlodqedbshudo`ssdqmr`mc
tmtrt`ko`ssdqmrenqsgdenkknvhmfrdbshnmr-
Hmsgdqdl`hmcdqnesghrchrrdqs`shnm+vdvhkkbhsdu`qhntrdw`lokdr
eqnlMfxdla——m+khlhshmfntqrdkudr`klnrsdwbktrhudkxsnsgdrtaidbs
oqnmntm.`∆.!gd+!sgdnaidbs.l–a`∆a.!ld`s+!sgdaho`qshsdmdf`shud
lnqogdld.sd∆---v—æ.+`mcsgdenkknvhmfentqudqarsdlr9
Sgdehqrsudqasnmdo`ssdqmsg`svdvhkkdw`lhmdhrvhsgsgdO2sdmrd
l`qjdq.k`∆.`mcsgda`rhbqd`khrsnm`ko`ssdqmnm`lnmnrxkk`ahbGsnmd
udqaqnns+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd'mdf`shudrhmbd`kkonrhshud
odqedbshudrdmsdmbdrtmcdqfnrdo`q`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdr(9
(87) aL laL teL zaJБ mbaLb wDJ "he did not cut the meat"
3 3 3 1 3 1 (yesterday)
71
Sgdtmcdqkhmdcvnqchmsgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdhrntqlnmnrxkk`ahb
Gsnmdudqaqnnsvghbghrgdqdqd`khydcnm`Gsnmdkdudk'0(-@r
ldmshnmdc`anud+ntq`m`kxrhrcdqhudrsghro`ssdqmaxld`mrne`onk`q
snmdsnm`klnqogdldvghbghrgdqd`KsnmdoqdbdchmfsgdGsnmdnesgd
udqaqnns-Ntqo`ssdqm`ood`qr`radknv`esdqsgdhmhsh`ksnmdl`oohmf
qtkdg`r`rrnbh`sdc'mdv`rrnbh`shnmkhmdrbnmshmthmfsnadrhfm`kdcax
rk`rgdckhmdr(sgdGsnmdnesgdudqaqnnssnsgdrxkk`akdnesgdr`ld
lnqogdld'gdqdl`qjdc`r!U!snrhfm`ksgdudqaqnns(9
(88) # + V #
# L + H #
Vgdmhshrshldhmsgdcdqhu`shnmenqsgdqdftk`qtmnqcdqdcsnmdqtkdr
snnodq`sdeqnlkdessnqhfgsnmsgdsnm`kshdq+ntqsnmdqtkdenq`rrnbh`shmf
Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdldrsnsgdkdes'snmdqtkd4cdrbqhadchmsgdrdbshnm
1-1-1-`anud(nodq`sdr`radknv9
(89) # # + V #
# L + H #
Sgdcnssdckhmdfnhmfsnsgdkdeshmsgdoqdbdchmfqdoqdrdms`shnm
rhfm`krsg`ssghrsnmdhr`rrnbh`sdcsnsgd`ci`bdmsrxkk`akd'#(nmsgdkdes-
Rhmbdsgdvnqcoqdbdchmf`udqa`klnrs`kv`xrdmcrnm`Ksnmd+sghr
72
o`qshbtk`qsnmdrdkcnlg`r`mnardqu`akddeedbs'rddrdbshnm1-2-4-adknv
enqhsrqnkdhmbdqs`hmoqdrdmsmdf`shudbnmrsqtbshnmr(-
Rhmbdansgsnmdrhmntqoqdrdmscdqhu`shnm`qd`rrnbh`sdcsnmdr+ntq
k`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdcndrmns`ookx+kd`uhmfntqkdwhb`kGsnmdsnad
qd`khydcnmsgdohsbgkdudkne'0(+`radknv9
(90) # # + V #
# L + H #
Udqarsdlrnbb`rhnm`kkxg`udsvnrxkk`akdr+trt`kkxctdsnsgd
`cchshnmne`snmdkdrr.,sd.rteehw+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
(91) aL laL teL luJmteJ mbaLb wDJ "he did not bite the meat"
3 3 3 1 1 3 1 (yesterday)
Nmbd`f`hm+sgdudqahmsgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdhrtmcdqkhmdc+
hmbktchmfhsrsnmdkdrr.,sd.rteehw'rxlankhydcax!R!hmsgdenkknvhmf
qdoqdrdms`shnmr(-Vdsgdqdenqdg`ud`o`ssdqmkhjdsgdenkknvhmf`esdqsgd
snmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(92) # + V + S #
# L + H + #
73
Hshr`ssghronhmssg`sntqqdftk`qsnmdqtkdrbnldhmsnok`x-Hshr
hlonqs`mssnqdldladqsg`ssgdrdqtkdrnodq`sdlocallynmsgdsnm`kshdq+
sg`shrsnr`xsg`ssgdxnodq`sdnmdsnmd`s`shld'hm`kdes,sn,qhfgs
l`mmdq+`rhmlnrsk`mft`fdr(-Sgdehqrsqtkdsg`s`ookhdrsnntqoqdrdms
o`ssdqmhrsgtrsgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdlnqogdldqtkd+`rhmsgd
enkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
(93) # # + V + S #
# L + H + #
Vdldmshnmdc`anudsg`shmntq`m`kxrhr+sgdo`qsneFnkcrlhsg&r
VEBvghbgr`xrsg`sdudqxunvdkltrsad`rrnbh`sdcsn`snmdvntkcad
l`cdhmsn`vdkk,enqldcmdrrqtkd'VEQ(+vghbgvntkcnodq`sdvgdmdudq
`snmdkdrrrxkk`akdv`rentmcctqhmfsgdmnql`kkdes,sn,qhfgsrb`mmhmfne
sgdsnm`kshdqaxsgdsnm`kqtkdr-Sgdhcd`nesqd`shmfsgdVEB`r`snm`k
qtkd'rtaidbssnrsqhbsnqcdqhmf(g`roqduhntrkxaddmrtffdrsdcax
Bkdldmsr`mcEnqc'086891/7(-Rhmbdsgdnmkxsnmdkdrrlnqogdldvghbg
sqhffdqrsghrqtkdhrsgdsnmdkdrrudqarteehw.,sd.+`mchs`kv`xr`rrnbh`sdr
snsgdehqrssnmdnmhsrkdes+vdfhud`oqdkhlhm`qxudqrhnmnesghrqtkd`r
adknv'`qduhrdcudqrhnmvhsg`cdkdshnmnoshnmhrcdrbqhadchm'073(
adknv(9
74
(94) Rule 8: Well-formedness Rule (WFR)
#
Sghrqtkdr`xrsg`svgdmdudq`snmdkdrrrxkk`akdhrentmc'hmsgdkdes,
sn,qhfgs`ookhb`shnmnesgdsnmdqtkdr(+hshr`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdehqrssnmd
entmcsnhsrkdes-SgdqdrtksnesgdVEQnmntqoqdrdmso`ssdqmhrsgtrsgd
enkknvhmf9
(95) # # + V + S #
# L + H + #
Vd`qdmnvkdesvhsg`rhmfkdGsnmd`rrnbh`sdcsnansgnesgd
rxkk`akdrnentqchrxkk`ahbudqa-Rhmbdsgdqd`qdmnekn`shmfsnmdrsn
sqhffdqntqqdfhrsdq,knvdqhmfcnvmrsdoqtkd+ansgrxkk`akdr`qdqd`khydcnm
ohsbgkdudk'0(+`radknv9
(96) # # + V + S #
# L + H + #
1-1
StqmhmfmnvsnntqKsnmdlnmnrxkk`ahbudqaqnns+hs`ood`qr`radknv
vgdmhshrl`qjdcenqsgda`rhbqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqm9
75
(97) aL laL teL gwKDY mbaLb wDJ "he did not pound the meat"
3 3 3 2 4 2 (yesterday)
Sgdtmcdqkhmdcudqahmsgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdhrqd`khydcnm`
cnvmrsdoodcGsnmd'1(hmrsd`cnesgdtmcdqkxhmfkdwhb`kKsnmd'2(-Sghr
cdqhu`shnms`jdrok`bdnmntqtmcdqkxhmfsnmdr+vghbghmbktcd`onk`qsnmd
snm`klnqogdldl`qjhmfqd`khrlncd-Rhmbdsgdonk`qsnmdhr`Gsnmd
gdqdhmnqcdqsnadsgdnoonrhsdnehsrenkknvhmfkdwhb`kKsnmd+ntqsnmd
o`ssdqm`ood`qr`radknv`esdqsgdhmhsh`ksnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(98) # + V #
# H + L #
Mnv+hmrsd`cnentqkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdlnqogdldqtkd+ntq
qhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfGsnmdlnqogdldqtkdb`trdrsgdenkknvhmfsnm`k
bg`mfdr'vgdqdsgdrl`kkrk`rgdr..hmchb`sd`cdkdsdc`rrnbh`shnmkhmd(9
(99) # + V #
# H + L #
Rhmbdudqar`qd`klnrs`kv`xroqdbdcdcaxrxkk`akdr'rxlankhydcax
!#!hmsgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm(vghbg`qd`rrnbh`sdcsnKsnmdr+sgd
ekn`shmfGsnmd`esdqsgd`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdlddsrsgdbnmchshnmrnentq
76
lds`sgdrhrqtkdvghbglnudrsgdekn`shmfKsnmdhmeqnmsnesgd`rrnbh`sdc
Gsnmd+`radknv9
(100) + # # + V #
+ L # H + L #
Rhmbdntq`rrnbh`sdcGsnmdhrmnvoqdbdcdcax`ekn`shmfKsnmd+hs
sqhffdqrntqqdfhrsdq,knvdqhmfcnvmrsdoqtkd+vghbgb`trdrsgdudqaqnns
snadqd`khydcognmdshb`kkxnm`knvdqdcohsbgkdudk'1(+`rhmsgd
enkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
(101) # + V #
# L H + #
Sgdr`ldjhmcnekdwhb`kKsnmdudqaqnnsb`m`krnadlnchehdcaxsgd
`cchshnmnesgdkdwhb`kkxsnmdkdrr.,sd.rteehw+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
(102) aL laL teL lKimteJ mbaLb wDJ "he did not reheat the meat"
3 3 3 2 2 4 2 (yesterday)
@kknvhmfenqsgdr`ldonk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldadhmfqd`khydc`r`
Gsnmdadenqdsgdkdwhb`kKsnmd+sgda`rhbqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnm`ood`qr`r
adknv`esdqnodq`shnmnesgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkd9
77
(103) # + V + S #
# H + L + #
Nmbd`f`hm+sgdehqrssnmdqtkdsn`eedbssghrqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmvhsg`
Ksnmdudqaqnnshrntqqhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfGsnmdlnqogdldqtkdvghbg
qdrtksrhmsgdenkknvhmf9
(104) # + V + S #
# H + L + #
Mnvsg`ssgdKsnmdhrekn`shmf+hshrlnudchmeqnmsnesgd`rrnbh`sdc
Gsnmd`esdq`m`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdaxsgd`ookhb`shnmnentqlds`sgdrhr
qtkd+`radknv9
(105) # # + V + S #
L # H + L + #
Sgdmdwsqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqVEQ+vghbgmnv`rrnbh`sdrsgd
snmdkdrr.,sd.udqarteehwvhsgsgd`rrnbh`sdcGsnmdnesgdudqaoqdehw+`r
adknv9
(106) # + V + S #
# L H + + #
78
Hshrbqtbh`khmsgdoqdrdmscdqhu`shnmsg`ssgdVEQ:nodq`sdrlocally
fnhmfeqnlkdessnqhfgs+nqhsvntkcg`udvqnmfkx`rrnbh`sdcsgdR
rxkk`akdsnsgdsgdm`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdhlldch`sdkx`esdqsgdl`oohmfqtkd-
Sghroqnudrsg`ssgdVEQ`bsr`r`snm`krule+`mcmns`r`fdmdq`k
conventionhmMfxdla——mrhmbdhsadg`udrkhjdnsgdqsnm`kqtkdr-
Sgdehm`kqtkdsnnodq`sdnmsghro`ssdqmhrntqcnvmrsdoqtkdvghbg
knvdqrsgdohsbgqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbg'sn1(adb`trdsgd`rrnbh`sdcGsnmdhr
oqdbdcdcax`ekn`shmfKsnmd-RhmbdsgdenqldqkxsnmdkdrrRrxkk`akdhr
mnv`rrnbh`sdcsnsghrr`ldknvdqdcGsnmd+hssnnhrqd`khydcnmsgdr`ld
ohsbgkdudk`rhsroqdcdbdrrnq+`radknv9
(107) # + V + S #
# L H + + #
2-2
Sghrbnmbktcdrntq`m`kxrhrnesgdqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmr`rsgdx
nbbtqnmudqarhmhmchb`shudodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmr-Vdb`mmnvlnud
nmsnsgdo`q`kkdkhqqd`khro`ssdqmr-Vghkddw`lhmhmfsgdrdhqqd`khr
o`ssdqmr+vdvhkkbnmshmtdsnkhlhsntqrdkudrsnodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmr+
`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokdvhsg`mtmcdqkxhmfGkdwhb`ksnmd`mc`
lnmnrxkk`ahbudqaqnns9
79
(108) aL geL zKaY mbMab "he will cut the meat"
3 3 2 5 (later today)
Sgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokd'eqnlsgdE0etstqdsdmrd(rgnvrsgdsvn
cnvmrsdoqd`khy`shnmrbg`q`bsdqhrshbnehqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr-Sgdsvn
nbbtqqdmbdrnecnvmrsdo'hmbktchmfsgdtmcdqkhmdcudqaqnnshmenbtr
gdqd(knvdqsgdsnmdqdfhrsdqsvhbdrnsg`ssgdehm`kKsnmdnmsgdnaidbshr
qd`khydcnmohsbgkdudk4hmrsd`cnesgdohsbgkdudk2ne`Ksnmd`ssgd
adfhmmhmfne`rdmsdmbd-Hmenbtr`ssghrlnldms`qdsgdcnvmrsdoed`stqd
nmsgdudqaqnns`mcsgdcnvmrsdoed`stqdnmsgdenkknvhmfnaidbs+ansgne
vghbgqdrtkseqnlsgdhqqd`khrl`qjhmfnesgdudqa-@raqhdekxldmshnmdc
`anud+vdonrhs`onk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldoqdbdchmfsgdudqarsdl`mc
`mnsgdqonk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldenkknvhmfsgdrsdlvgdmdudqsgd
bnmrsqtbshnmhrl`qjdcenq`a`rhbhqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqm-Sgdbqtbh`konhms
nesgdenkknvhmfcdqhu`shnm+gnvdudq+hrsg`ssgdrdsvnsnm`klnqogdldr
`qdmnsrodbhehdctmshkaftersgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdrg`ud`ookhdc-Sghrk`sd
nqcdqhmfnesgdhqqd`khrlnqogn,snmnknfhb`khmrdqshnmqtkdhrvg`sbnmsq`rsr
hsvhsghsrqd`khrbntmsdqo`qs-Sgdnqcdqhmfnesgdhmrdqshnmne`mhcdmshb`k
onk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldsgtrqdrtksrhmpthsdcheedqdmsrtqe`bd
qd`khy`shnmr-
NtqGsnmdudqaqnnsvhsghqqd`khrlncdsgdqdenqd`ood`qr`radknv
`esdqsgdhmhsh`ksnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc'vhsg`b`ohs`k!@!sn
80
hmchb`sdsgdKsnmdmntmbk`rroqdehwnesgdenkknvhmfnaidbs(9
(109) # V # A +
# H # L +
Sgdoqdbdchmfo`ssdqmlddsrmnmdnesgdqdpthqdldmsrenqntqrdsne
snm`kqtkdr-@esdqsgdrdqtkdrg`udg`csgdhqbg`mbdsnnodq`sd+`k`sd
lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'47/(adknv(vhkkhmrdqsntqsvnsnm`k
lnqogdldr+kd`uhmftrvhsg`o`ssdqmvghbgmnvknnjrkhjdsgdenkknvhmf9
(110) # + V + # A +
# Ø + H + Ø # L +
-[T -[T
L H
Sgdsvnonk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldr`qdqd`khydccheedqdmskx+`Ksnmd
adenqdsgdGsnmdnesgdudqaqnns`mc`GsnmdadenqdsgdKsnmdnesgdsxohb`k
naidbsoqdehw'rxkk`akd@`anud(-Bqtbh`kkx+rhmbdntqqdftk`qsnmdqtkdrg`ud
`kqd`cxnodq`sdcaxsgdshldsgdrdonk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldr`qdhmrdqsdc+mn
etqsgdqbg`mfds`jdrok`bddwbdossgdqdfhrsdq,knvdqhmfdeedbsnentqcnvmrsdo
qtkd+vghbgnodq`sdrsvhbdhmsghro`ssdqm+`radknv9
81
(111) # + V + # A +
# L + H + H # L +
2 - 5
@bbnqchmfsnntqcnvmrsdoqtkd+`m`rrnbh`sdcGsnmdoqdbdcdcax`
ekn`shmfKsnmdhrqd`khydc`r`cnvmrsdoodc'knvdqdc(Gsnmd'ohsbgkdudk
1`anud(-Khjdvhrd+`m`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdoqdbdcdcax`ekn`shmfGsnmdhr
qd`khydc`r`cnvmrsdoodcKsnmd'ohsbgkdudk4`anudadb`trdsgd
qdfhrsdq,knvdqhmfdeedbsnecnvmrsdohrbtltk`shud(-Sgdqdrtkshrsg`ssgd
Ksnmdnesgdnaidbsoqdehwhr`bst`kkxqd`khydcsvnohsbgkdudkrknvdqsg`m
hmhrnk`shnm-
Hsrgntkcadonhmsdcntsgdqdsg`ssgdoqdbdchmfqdoqdrdms`shnmcndr
mnsbnqqdronmcdw`bskxsnsgddw`lokdbhsdc-Sgdqd`rnmenqsghrhrsg`sntq
dw`lokdtrdrsgdmntm.l–a`∆a.!ld`s!`rsgdnaidbs+`mntmsg`sg`rsvn
rxkk`akdrvgdmoqnmntmbdchmhrnk`shnmnq`esdq`rkhfgso`trd-Sgd
gnlnqf`mhbm`r`kmntmbk`rroqdehw'rxlankhydcaxsgdKsnmd!l!nmntq
mntm(`bst`kkxknrdrhsrrxkk`ahbhsxhmsgdlhcckdnemnql`kbnmrsqtbshnmr-
Hmsgdb`rdhmenbtr+sgdcdrxkk`ahehdcm`r`koqdehwnesgdmntm`bst`kkx
cqnornts+sgtrsq`mredqqhmfsgdcnvmrsdoed`stqdb`trdcaxsgdonk`qsnmd
snsgdenkknvhmfmntmqnns-Sgd`bst`ksnmdrqd`khydcnmnaidbsrhm
cheedqdmsdmuhqnmldmsr`qdchrbtrrdchmcds`hkhmrdbshnm1-3-1-adknv-
82
Hevdehmc`Gsnmdudqarsdlvghbghmbktcdrsgdsnmdkdrr.,sd.rteehw+
vdg`ud`snmdo`ssdqm`radknv9
3 3 2 2 5 (later today)
@rb`madrddm+sgdtmcdqkhmdcchrxkk`ahbudqarsdlhrgdqdqd`khydcnm
sgdr`ldohsbgkdudk'1(-Sgdehqrs`rrnbh`shnmkhmdsnadcq`vmnmsghr
o`ssdqmqdrtksreqnlntqfdmdq`ksnmdl`oohmfqtkdvghbgnodq`sdr`r
adknv9
(113) # V + S # A +
# H + # L +
Vgdmvdbnldsnntqqdftk`qsnmdqtkdrvdehmcsg`snmkxntqVEQ
qtkdnodq`sdr+`rrnbh`shmfsgdsnmdkdrrRrxkk`akdsnsgdehqrssnmdnmhsr
kdes+vghbghmsghrb`rdhrsgdGsnmdnesgdudqaqnns+`radknv9
(114) # V + S # A +
# H + # L +
@esdqntqsnmdqtkdrg`udnodq`sdc+`lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdhmrdqsr
sgdsvnonk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldradenqd`mc`esdqsgdudqarsdl-Hshr
bqtbh`kgdqdsg`ssgdsnmdkdrrrteehw!R!hrbnmrhcdqdcsnado`qsnesgd
udqarsdl+rnsg`ssgdsnm`klnqogdldr`qdhmrdqsdc`radknv9
83
(115) # + V + S + # A +
# Ø + H + + Ø # L +
-[T -[T
L H
Sgdnmkxqdl`hmhmfsnmdqtkdvghbg`ookhdrhrntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkd
vghbgknvdqrsgdsnmdqdfhrsdqhmsvnok`bdr+`radknv9
(116) # + V + S + # A +
# L + H + + H # L +
2-2 - 5
Vd`qdmnvqd`cxsnknnj`ssxohb`kKsnmdudqarsdlrl`qjdcenq
hqqd`khr`rodbs+`rvhsgsgdlnmnrxkk`ahbudqaqnnsrgnvmadknv9
3 3 4 5 (later today)
Hmsghrdw`lokd+sgd'tmcdqkhmdc(udqaqnns`mcsgdnaidbs`qdansgqd`khydc
nmcnvmrsdoodcKsnmdr-Ntqcdqhu`shnmrs`qsrvhsgitrssgdrhlokdsnmdrnesgd
udqaqnns`mcnaidbsoqdehwvghbg`qd`rrnbh`sdcaxsgdfdmdq`ksnmdl`oohmf
84
qtkd`radknv9
(118) # V # A +
# L # L +
Nmbd`f`hm+sgdoqdbdchmfo`ssdqmlddsrmnmdnesgdqdpthqdldmsrenqntq
rdsnesnm`kqtkdr-@esdqsgdrdqtkdrg`udg`csgdhqbg`mbdsnnodq`sd+`k`sd
lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvhkk`f`hmhmrdqsntqsvnonk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldr+
kd`uhmftrvhsgsgdenkknvhmfo`ssdqm9
(119) # + V + # A +
# Ø + L + Ø # L +
-[T -[T
H H
Sgdonk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldvghbgoqdbdcdrsgdudqarsdlhrsghrshld
qd`khydc`r`Gsnmdadb`trdnesgdKsnmdnmsgdenkknvhmfudqaqnns-Mnetqsgdq
qtkdrnodq`sdgdqddwbdossgdqdfhrsdq,knvdqhmfcnvmrsdoqtkd+vghbgqdrtksrhm
svncnvmrsdoodcKsnmdr+`radknv9
(120) # + V + # A +
# H + L + H # L +
4 - 5
85
SgdKsnmdudqarsdlrl`x`krnhmbktcdsgdsnmdkdrr.,sd.rteehw+`rhm
sgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
3 3 4 4 5 (later today)
Nmbd`f`hm+sgdtmcdqkhmdcchrxkk`ahbudqarsdlhrqd`khydcnmsgd
r`ldohsbgkdudk+sgntfgsghrshldhshr`knvdqdcKsnmdnmkdudk'3(-Ntq
snmdl`oohmfqtkd`rrnbh`sdrsgdkdwhb`ksnmdr`rhmsgdenkknvhmf
qdoqdrdms`shnm9
(122) # V + S # A +
# L + # L +
HmsgdoqdrdmbdnesgdsnmdkdrrRrteehw+vdehmcsg`sntqVEQqtkdhr
sgdnmkxsnmdqtkdsqhffdqdc+nodq`shmf`radknv9
(123) # V + S # A +
# L + # L +
@esdqsghrqtkdg`r`rrnbh`sdcsgdRrxkk`akdsnsgdehqrssnmdnmhsrkdes+
ntqhqqd`khrlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdhmrdqsrsvnonk`qsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldr`radknv9
86
'013("*U*R*"@*
# Ø + L + + Ø # L +
-[T -[T
H H
Ntqk`sdqdfhrsdq,knvdqhmfcnvmrsdoqtkdhrmnvsgdnmkxqtkdrshkkhm`
onrhshnmsnnodq`sd+`mchsqdrtksrhmsgdenkknvhmfrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnm9
(125) # + V + S + # A +
# H + L + + H # L +
4-4 - 5
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqrdbshnmnmsgdmnql`ksnm`ko`ssdqmrentmcnm
qd`khr`mchqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmrsg`s`krng`udsgdtml`qjdcodqedbshud
`rodbs-Vdb`mmnvfnnmsndw`lhmdsgdhqlnqdbnlokhb`sdc
hlodqedbshudbntmsdqo`qsr-
87
2.3.2. With imperfective aspect
Vdg`udrddmdw`lokdrnesgdu`qhntrodqedbshudonrrhahkhshdrhmsgd
oqduhntrrdbshnm-Vdvhkkmnvdw`lhmdsgdbg`mfdrsg`sbnldsnsgdudqa
vgdmsgdhlodqedbshudrteehwvghbghrtmcdqkxhmfkx`Ksnmddbgnunvdkhr
`ccdc-Hmsgdenkknvhmf`tsnrdfldms`kqdoqdrdms`shnmr+vdrg`kkqdedqsn
sghrlnqogdldax`m!H!enqhlodqedbshudnmsgdrdfldms`kshdq`mc`
rhmfkdKsnmdnmsgdsnm`kshdq-Sgdehqrssnmdo`ssdqmsg`svdvhkkdw`lhmd
hrsg`svghbgnbbtqrvgdmGsnmdlnmnrxkk`ahbudqaqnnsr`qdqd`khydcnm
sgdqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdr+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokdeqnlsgdoqdrdms
qd`khrbnmrsqtbshnm'vghbghrtrdcsnrhfm`kg`ahst`kld`mhmf(9
3 1 3 3
Sgdoqdbdchmf'tmcdqkhmdc(udqag`rsgd`cchshnmneansgsgd
gnlnqf`mhbm`r`koqdehw'.m,.`anud(rhfm`kkhmfqd`khrlncd`mcsgddbgn
unvdkrteehw'.,`.`anud(rhfm`kkhmfhlodqedbshud`rodbsnmsgdrdfldms`k
shdq-@bbnqchmfsnntqoqnonrdc`m`kxrhr+sghrqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmb`mad
qdoqdrdmsdc`radknv`esdqsgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc'vhsgsgd
rxlank!H!snhmchb`sdsgddbgnunvdkrxkk`akdnesgdhlodqedbshudl`qjdq
nmsgdrxkk`ahbshdq(9
88
(127) # + V + I #
# L + H + L #
Sgdnmkxsnmdqtkdsg`s`ookhdrsnsghro`ssdqmhrsgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmf
Ksnmdlnqogdldqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdekn`shmfKsnmdsnsgdehqrs
`ci`bdmsrxkk`akd'#(nmhsrkdes-Rhmbdsgdcnvmrsdoqtkdcndrmns`ookxsn
sghro`ssdqm+hshrqd`khydcpthsdrsq`hfgsenqv`qckx+`radknv9
(128) # # + V + I #
# L + H + L #
1 - 3
Sgdr`ldhlodqedbshudo`ssdqmb`madqd`khydcnmtmcdqkxhmf
chrxkk`ahbudqarsdlr+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokdvhsgsgdsnmdkdrr.,sd.
rteehw9
3 1 3 3
Hsrgntkcadmnshbdcsg`ssgdsnmdkdr.,sd.rteehw`ssgddmcnesgdtmcdqkhmdc
udqahmsgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdcndrmnsg`ud`knmfunvdk'rxlankhydcax
cntakhmfsgdunvdkhmsgdMfxdla——mnqsgnfq`ogx(-Sgddbgnunvdkhrsgtr
`ardmshmsgdoqdrdmbdnesgdsnmdkdrr.,sd.rteehw+`e`bsg`mckdcaxntqlnqogn,
snmnknfhb`krodkkhmfqtkdenqhlodqedbshud`rodbs'rdd'436(adknv(-Vd`qdsgtr
kdesvhsg`Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdldhmchb`shmfhlodqedbshud`rodbs+`lnqogdld
89
sg`shrnqcdqdc`esdqsgdrodbhehb`shnmnesgdsnmdkdrrrteehw!R!`r.,sd.-Ntq
o`ssdqmsgdqdenqd`ood`qr`radknv`esdqsgdnodq`shnmnentqsnmdl`oohmfqtkd9
(130) # + V + S + #
# L + H + + L #
Sgdehqrsqtkdsnnodq`sdnmsghro`ssdqmhrsgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmd
lnqogdldqtkdvghbgnodq`sdrehqrsnmsgdfirstKsnmdsnm`klnqogdld`r
adknv9
(131) # # + V + S + #
# L + H + + L #
Sgdmdwsqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqVEQvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdsnmdkdrrRrxkk`akd
snsgdGsnmdnesgdudqaqnns-Sghrqdrtksrhmsgdenkknvhmf9
(132) # # + V + S + #
# L + H + + L #
Sgdehm`kqtkdsnnodq`sdhrsgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdlnqogdld
qtkdvghbgsghrshld`rrnbh`sdrsgdehm`kekn`shmfKsnmdnentqo`ssdqmsn
sgdRrxkk`akd-Sghrr`ldqtkd`krnchr`rrnbh`sdrsgdRrxkk`akdeqnlsgdG
snmdnesgdudqaqnns'hmchb`sdcaxsvnrl`kkrk`rgdrnmsgd`rrnbh`shnm
khmd(+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
90
(133) # # + V + S + #
# L + H + + L #
Rhmbd`kksgdsnmdrhmntqo`ssdqm`qd`rrnbh`sdcsnrnldrxkk`akdnq
nsgdq+sgdcnvmrsdosnmdqtkdcndrmns`ookx`mcvd`qdkdesvhsgsgd
enkknvhmfrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnm9
(134) # # + V + S + #
# L + H + + L #
1 - 3
RvhsbghmfmnvsnudqarvhsgtmcdqkxhmfKkdwhb`ksnmdr+vdg`ud
dw`lokdrkhjdsgdenkknvhmf9
3 2 4 4
Sgdoqdbdchmf'tmcdqkhmdc(udqabnmrhrsrnesgdqd`khr.m,.oqdehw+sgd
udqaqnns`mcsgdhlodqedbshuddbgnunvdkrteehw'.,—.`anudadb`trdne
sgdunvdkpt`khsxnesgdqnnsunvdk(-Hm`cchshnm+vdg`udntqonrhsdc
onk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldvghbghr`GsnmdadenqdsgdKsnmdnesgd
enkknvhmfudqaqnns+`rhmntqqdoqdrdms`shnmadknv9
91
(136) # + V + I #
# H + L + L #
Vhsgsghrekn`shmfGsnmd`ssgdadfhmmhmfnentqo`ssdqm+sgdqhfgsv`qc,
cnbjhmfGsnmdlnqogdldqtkd`ookhdr+bg`mfhmfntqo`ssdqmsnsgdenkknvhmf9
(137) # + V + I #
# H + L + L #
Rhmbdsgdudqahr`klnrs`kv`xroqdbdcdcax`rxkk`akd'!#!(`rrnbh`sdcsn`
Ksnmd+ntqoqdrdmso`ssdqmeddcrsgdlds`sgdrhrqtkd`mclds`sgdrhydrsgd
`rrnbh`sdcGsnmd`mcmdvkxekn`shmfKsnmdnesgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akd+qdrtkshmf
hmsgdenkknvhmfo`ssdqm9
(138) + # # + V + I #
+ L # H + L + L #
Sghrekn`shmfKsnmdvghbgmnvoqdbdcdr`m`rrnbh`sdcGsnmdhr`eedbsdcax
ntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgknvdqrsgdsnmdqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbg'sn1(+qdrtkshmf
hmsgdenkknvhmfrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnm9
(139) # + V + I #
# L H + + L #
2 - 4
92
@mhcdmshb`ksnmdo`ssdqmb`madentmcnmudqarsdlrvghbg`qd
kdwhb`kkxchrxkk`ahb+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
3 2 4 4
Sgdoqdrdmso`ssdqmcheedqreqnlsgdoqdbdchmfhmsg`ssgdudqarsdlhr
chrxkk`ahb`mcsgdhlodqedbshudrteehwhrsgdqdenqditrs`Ksnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldhmrsd`cne`Ksnmddbgnunvdk-Ntqo`ssdqmsgdqdenqd`ood`qr
`radknv'vhsgsgdKsnmdsnm`klnqogdldenkknvhmfsgdsnmdkdrrR
rxkk`akd(`esdqsgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(141) # + V + S + #
# H + L + + L #
Nmbd`f`hm+sgdekn`shmfGsnmd`ssgdadfhmmhmfnentqo`ssdqm
sqhffdqrsgdqhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfGsnmdlnqogdldqtkd+vghbgnodq`sdr`r
adknv9
(142) # + V + S + #
# H + L + + L #
Ctdsnsgdsxohb`koqdrdmbdne`Ksnmd`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdoqdbdchmf
rxkk`akd'È#Í(+sgdmdvkxchr`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdhrmnveqnmsdcaxntq
lds`sgdrhrqtkd+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
93
(143) + # # + V + S + #
+ L # H + L + + L #
Sgdmdwsqtkdsnnodq`sdnmsghro`ssdqmhrntqVEQqtkdvghbg
`rrnbh`sdrsgdsnmdkdrrRrxkk`akdsnsgdehqrssnmdnmhsrkdes'vghbghr`G
snmd`ssghronhmshmsgdcdqhu`shnm(+`radknv9
(144) # + V + S + #
# L H + + + L #
RhmbdsgdKsnmdsnm`klnqogdldhrrshkktm`rrnbh`sdc`ssghrlnldms
hmsgdcdqhu`shnm+sgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`klnqogdldqtkd
nodq`sdr-Hs`rrnbh`sdrsgdehm`kKsnmdnentqo`ssdqmsnsgdkdesand
chr`rrnbh`sdrsgdRrxkk`akdeqnlsgdoqdbdchmfGsnmd+`rhmntq
qdoqdrdms`shnmadknv9
(145) # + V + S + #
# L H + + + L #
Sgdehm`ksnmdqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdvghbg`f`hm
knvdqrsgdsnmdqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbg'sn1(`ssgdadfhmmhmfnentqo`ssdqm-
Sghrknvdqdcqdfhrsdqqdl`hmrhmok`bdsgqntfgnts+qdrtkshmfhm`knvdqdc
'sn3(ohsbgkdudkenqsgdKsnmdnesgdehm`krxkk`akd+`radknv9
94
(146) # + V + S + #
# L H + + + L #
2 - 4
Sghrbnmbktcdrntq`m`kxrhrnelnmnrxkk`ahb`mcchrxkk`ahbudqarsdlr
vhsgansgqd`khrlncd`mchlodqedbshud`rodbs-Vdvhkkmnvdw`lhmdsgdhq
o`q`kkdkbnmrsqtbshnmrvhsghqqd`khrlncd-
Stqmhmfntq`ssdmshnmeqnlqd`khrsnhqqd`khrhlodqedbshudr+vdbnld
`bqnrrrdudq`kcdqhu`shnmrvgdqdsgdnqcdqhmfnelnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdr
hrbqtbh`k-Sgdehqrsnentqcdqhu`shnmrvhkkbnmbdqmGsnmdlnmnrxkk`ahb
udqaqnnsrentmchmsxohb`khqqd`khrhlodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmr+`rhmsgd
enkknvhmfdw`lokd9
3 3 2 5 5 (later today)
Sgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdhreqnlsgdE0'snc`xetstqd(sdmrd-Ntq
Dmfkhrgfknrr`ssdlorsnbnmudxsgdetstqdg`ahst`kld`mhmfsg`sg`r
bnldsnad`rrnbh`sdcvhsgsgdrdhqqd`khrhlodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmr-Sgd
'tmcdqkhmdc(udqacndrmnsg`udsgdqd`khrm`r`koqdehw`rchcsgdqd`khr
bnmrsqtbshnmrcdrbqhadcd`qkhdqhmsghrrdbshnm-Sgdudqacndrg`udsgd
dbgnunvdkrteehw+`mcsgdudqaqnnshransgoqdbdcdc`mcenkknvdcax
95
cnvmrsdoodcsnmdr-@bbnqchmfsnntq`m`kxrhr+sghrbnmrsqtbshnmb`mad
qdoqdrdmsdc`radknv`esdqntqsnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(148) # V + I #
# H + L #
Rhmbdmnmdnesgdsnmdqtkdr`ookxsnsghro`ssdqm+sgdmdwsqtkdsn
nodq`sdhrntqlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'47/(adknv(enqhqqd`khrlncd
vghbgnbbtqraftersgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdr-Sghrqtkdhmrdqsrsvnonk`q
snmdsnm`klnqogdldr+`KsnmdadenqdsgdGsnmdnesgdudqarsdl`mc`
GsnmdadenqdsgdKsnmdnesgdhlodqedbshudrteehw+`rqdoqdrdmsdcadknv9
(149) # + V + + I #
# Ø + H + Ø + L #
-[T -[T
L H
Sgdnmkxqtkdvghbg`ookhdr`esdqsghrk`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`k
hmrdqshnmqtkdhrsgdk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkd+vghbghmsghrb`rdknvdqrsgdsnm`k
qdfhrsdqsvhbd+ehqrsknvdqhmfsgdGsnmdnmdmnsbgsnohsbgkdudk'1(+sgdm
knvdqhmfsgdKsnmdsvnmnsbgdrsnohsbgkdudk'4(+adb`trdqdfhrsdq,
96
knvdqhmfhrbtltk`shud-Sgdrtqe`bdqdrtkshrsgtrsgdenkknvhmf9
(150) # + V + + I #
# L + H + H + L #
2 - 5
Sghrr`ldsnmdo`ssdqmb`madentmcnmchrxkk`ahbudqarsdlrrtbg`r
sgdnmdvhsgsgdsnmdkdrr.,sd.rteehwhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
3 3 2 5 5 (later today)
Sghro`ssdqmcheedqreqnlsgdoqdbdchmfhmsg`shsrs`qsrsgdcdqhu`shnm
vhsg`snmdkdrrrteehw`esdqsgdudqaqnns-Sgdhlodqedbshudrteehwhr
k`bjhmfrxkk`ahbbnmsdmshmsgdoqdrdmbdnesghrRrxkk`akdhmrsd`cg`uhmf
sgdmnql`kKsnmddbgnunvdkrddm`anud-Snfdsgdq+sgdrdcheedqdmbdr`qd
qdoqdrdmsdcnmntq`tsnrdfldms`kshdqr`radknv9
(152) # V + S + #
# H + + L #
@esdqsgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`roqnctbdcsgdoqdbdchmfo`ssdqm+sgd
mdwsqtkdsnnodq`sdhrsgdVEQvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdsnmdkdrrRrxkk`akdsn
97
sgdGsnmdnesgdudqa-Sgdqdrtkshrsgdenkknvhmf9
(153) # V + S + #
# H + + L #
Sgdmdwsqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`klnqogdldqtkd
vghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdKsnmdnesgdhlodqedbshudrteehwsnsgdRrxkk`akdvghkd
chr`rrnbh`shmfsg`srxkk`akdeqnlsgdGsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
(154) # V + S + #
# H + + L #
Hshrbqtbh`ksg`shshrnmkxmnv+`ssghrshldhmsgdcdqhu`shnm+sg`sntq
k`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'47/(adknv(hmrdqsrsvnonk`qsnmd
hqqd`khrlnqogdldr+nmdadenqd`mcnmd`esdqsgdudqarsdl'vghbg
bnmrhrsrnerxkk`akdrU`mcRsnfdsgdq(+`radknv9
(155) # + V + S + + #
# Ø + H + + Ø + L #
-[T -[T
L H
98
Rhmbd`kksgdnsgdqsnm`kqtkdrg`ud`kqd`cxnodq`sdc+sgdnmkxqtkd
vghbg`eedbsrsghro`ssdqmhrsgdcnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgknvdqrsgdsnm`k
qdfhrsdqsvhbd+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
(156) # + V + S + + #
# L + H + + H + L #
2 - 5
Vdvhkkmnvrvhsbgsndw`lhmhmfsgdqdftk`qsnmdo`ssdqmrvghbg
nbbtqvgdmKsnmdudqarsdlr`qdl`qjdcenqhqqd`khrlncd`mc
hlodqedbshud`rodbs+`rhmsgddw`lokdvhsg`kdwhb`klnmnrxkk`ahbqnns
adknv9
3 3 4 5 5 (later today)
Sgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdknnjrkhjdsgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnmnmbd
sgdhmhsh`ksnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(158) # V + I #
# L + L #
Rhmbdmnmdnesgdsnmdqtkdr`ookxsnsghro`ssdqm+sgdmdwsqtkdsn
nodq`sdhrsgdk`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbghmrdqsrsvnonk`qsnmd
snm`klnqogdldr+`GsnmdadenqdsgdKsnmdnesgdudqaqnns`mc`mnsgdq
99
GsnmdadenqdsgdKsnmdnesgdhlodqedbshudrteehw+`radknv9
(159) # + V + + I #
# Ø + L + Ø + L #
-[T -[T
H H
Sgdnmkxqdl`hmhmfqtkdvghbgl`x`ookxsnsghro`ssdqmhrntqk`sd
cnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgknvdqrsgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqsvhbd-Rhmbdsghrknvdqhmf
nesgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqhrbtltk`shud+sgdKsnmdhrehqrsknvdqdcsnohsbg
kdudk'3(`mc`rdbnmcshldsnohsbgkdudk'4(+`radknv9
(160) # + V + + I #
# H + L + H + L #
4 - 5
Sghrr`ldsnmdo`ssdqmb`m`krnadrddmvhsgKsnmdudqaqnnsrvghbg
g`udchrxkk`ahbrsdlr`rsgdqdrtksnesgd`cchshnmnesgdsnmdkdrrudqa
rteehw+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
3 3 4 5 5 (later today)
100
Rhmbdsghrudqarsdlg`rsgdkdwhb`kkxsnmdkdrr.,sd.rxkk`akd+hs`ood`qr
`radknv`esdqsgdhmhsh`ksnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(162) # V + S + #
# L + + L #
Sgdmdwsqtkdsn`ookxsnsghro`ssdqmhrsgdVEQvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgd
snmdkdrrRrxkk`akdsnsgdKsnmdnesgdudqaqnns-Sgdqdrtkshrsgd
enkknvhmf9
(163) # V + S + #
# L + + L #
Sgdmdwsqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdKsnmdnesgdhlodqedbshudrteehwsn
sgdRrxkk`akdvghkdchr`rrnbh`shmfsg`srxkk`akdeqnlsgdKsnmd
oqduhntrkx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
(164) # V + S + #
# L + + L #
Nmbd`f`hm+hshrbqtbh`ksg`sntqk`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdhmrdqsr
sgdsvnonk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldrhmchb`shmf`mnql`khqqd`khrsnm`k
o`ssdqmnmkx`ssghrk`sdonhmshmsgdcdqhu`shnm+`rrgnvmadknv9
101
(165) # + V + S + + #
# Ø + L + + Ø + L #
-[T -[T
H H
Sgdehqrsonk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldhrgdqdqd`khydc`r`Gsnmd
oqdbdchmfsgdKsnmdnesgdudqaqnns-Sgdrdbnmconk`qsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldhrhmrdqsdchlldch`sdkxenkknvhmfsgdsnmdkdrrRrxkk`akdnesgd
udqarsdlatsoqdbdchmfsgdKsnmdnesgdhlodqedbshudrteehw-Rhmbd`kk
sgdnsgdqsnm`kqtkdrg`ud`kqd`cxnodq`sdc+sgdnmkxqtkdvghbgl`xrshkk
`eedbsntqo`ssdqmhrsgdk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgnmbd`f`hmknvdqrsgd
snm`kqdfhrsdqsvhbd+`rrddmhmsgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
(166) # + V + S + + #
# H + L + + H + L #
4 - 5
Sgdoqdbdchmfsvnrdbshnmrg`udrgnvmsgdtmcdqkxhmfcdqhu`shnmrne
vg`srg`kkadqdedqqdcsn`rsgd!qdftk`q!nq!dwodbsdc!snmdrenqqd`khr
`mchqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr'k`adkdc!Q!enqqd`khr`mc!H!enqhqqd`khrhmntq
snmdo`ssdqmbg`qs`ssgdadfhmmhmfnerdbshnm1-2-1-`anud(-@mx
102
cduh`shnmreqnlsgdrdQ`mcHo`ssdqmr`qdbnmrhcdqdclnqdl`qjdc-Sgdrd
tmtrt`ksnm`ko`ssdqmr`qd`kv`xrsgdqdrtksnernldrodbhehblnqogn,
snmnmknfhb`kqtkd+`mcsgdx`qdd`bgchrbtrrdchmcds`hkhmsgdhqstqmhmsgd
enkknvhmfrdbshnm-
103
Sgdenkknvhmfbg`qs'rdd'71(`anud(hrqdod`sdcadknvsndm`akdsgd
qd`cdqsnqdldladqvghbgudqa`kbnmrsqtbshnmrs`jdmnql`kqd`khr'Q(nq
hqqd`khr'H(snmdo`ssdqmr`mcvghbgs`jdsgdhqnvmhchnrxmbq`shbsnmd
o`ssdqmr'k`adkkdc!w!hmsgdbg`qs(9
Features P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø F1 F2 F3 F4
-perf
+real x/R x/x x/x R/R R/R
-prog
-perf
+real R/R R/R R/R R/R x/R
+prog
-perf
-real x/I I/I I/I I/I I/I
-prog
-perf
-real I/I I/I I/I I/I I/I
+prog
104
Sgdoqdbdchmfsvnrdbshnmrnesghrchrrdqs`shnmg`uddw`lhmdchm
cds`hksgdsnm`kcdqhu`shnmrne`kksgdmnql`kqd`khr`mchqqd`khrsnmd
o`ssdqmr-Hshrmnvsgds`rjnesgdoqdrdmsrdbshnmsndw`lhmd`rvdkksgd
u`qhntrhchnrxmbq`shbsnmdo`ssdqmr'rxlankhydcaxw&rhmsgdoqdbdchmf
bg`qs(-Sgdqd`cdqhrqdedqqdcsn@oodmchwAenqlnqdcds`hkdcbg`qsr
vghbgrgnvsgd`bst`krtqe`bdsnmdrqd`khydcnmG`mcKsnmdudqaqnnsr
enq`kksgdrdbnmrsqtbshnmr+vgdsgdqsgdxbnldeqnlqdftk`qqd`khrnq
hqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmrnq`qdsgdqdrtksnesgdhchnrxmbq`shbqtkdrchrbtrrdc
hmsghrrdbshnm-D`bgnesgdtmhptdsnmdo`ssdqmrhmchb`sdchmsgdbg`qs`qd
fdmdq`sdcaxrdo`q`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdr+`kknevghbg`qd
enql`khydchmbg`osdq3adknv-Ntqoqdrdmshmsdqdrsvhkkadsns`jdsgd
qdrtksrnesgdrdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdr`mcenkknvsgdhqoqnfqdrr
sgqntfgntssgdhqcdqhu`shnmrtmshksgdhqqdrodbshudognmdshbqd`khy`shnmr`qd
`bghdudc-
Vdvhkkadfhmntqdw`lhm`shnmnesgdrdqtkdraxknnjhmf`ssgnrd
`rrnbh`sdcvhsgodqedbshud`rodbs-Sgdoqdbdchmfbg`qsbkd`qkxrgnvrsg`s
Mfxdla——m`kv`xrqd`khydr`mnm,etstqdhmchb`shudrdmsdmbdnm
rnldsghmfnsgdqsg`msgdqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdrvgdmdudqsg`srdmsdmbdhr
ansgodqedbshud`mcpositive-Sgtrvd`kv`xrg`udsgdrl`kkw&rsnsgd
kdesnesgdrk`rgl`qj`anudenqsgdonrhshudodqedbshudrdmsdmbdr+dudm
sgntfgsgdo`q`kkdkmdf`shudrdmsdmbdrsnsgdqhfgsnesgdrk`rgl`qj
105
`kv`xrg`udsgdmnql`kqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqm'Q(-
Rhmbdsgdrdmnm,etstqdonrhshudodqedbshudhmchb`shudrdmsdmbdr`qd
`lnmfsgdlnrseqdptdmskxtrdchmsgdbntqrdnedudqxc`xudqa`k
hmsdq`bshnm+hshr`oo`qdmssg`sMfxdla——mrod`jdqr`qd`akdsnqdldladq
`mcqdoqnctbdsgdtmhptdsnm`ko`ssdqmrsg`s`qdrodbh`ksnsgdonrhshud
odqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmned`bgsdmrd-Sgdrdtmtrt`ksnm`ko`ssdqmr`qdmns
nmkxlnqdghfgkxl`qjdcsg`msgdqdftk`qqd`khro`ssdqmr+sgdx`qdlnrs
khjdkx`krnnenkcdqghrsnqhb`kuhms`fd-Sgdrdnkcdqo`ssdqmr`qdsgdqdenqd
l`hms`hmdcsnc`xnmkxhmghfgkxqdrsqhbsdcfq`ll`shb`kdmuhqnmldmsr-
Sgdehqrsodqedbshudonrhshudmnm,etstqdsnmdo`ssdqmsg`svdrg`kk
dw`lhmdhrsg`snesgdO1sdmrd+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
3 3 3 3 (yesterday)
Sgd`amnql`ksnm`kbg`q`bsdqhrshbnesgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdhrsg`ssgd
udqaqnnsvghbgg`r`mtmcdqkxhmfkdwhb`kGsnmdhrqd`khydcognmdshb`kkx
nm`Ksnmd'ohsbgkdudk2(-Sgdnmkxsnmdqtkdsndkhlhm`sdGsnmdr
bnlokdsdkx'hsb`mmnsitrsadchr`rrnbh`sdc`rsgdmhsvntkccnvmrsdosgd
enkknvhmfKsnmd(hrntqqhrd,cdkdshnmqtkd-Vdg`udsgdqdenqdonrhsdc`
lnqogdldbnms`hmhmfansg`K`mc`onk`qsnmdoqdbdchmfsgdudqarsdl
106
vhsgsgdKsnmdadhmf`rrnbh`sdcsnbothsgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akdandsgd
oqdbdchmfrxkk`akd-Rhmbdvdonrhssghrlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'452(
adknv(snnodq`sdadenqdntqsnmdqtkdr+ntqoqdrdmsGsnmdudqaqnns
vntkcknnj`radknv`esdqnodq`shnmnesgdl`oohmfqtkd`mcsgdO1
onrhshudodqedbshudhmchb`shudlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'vhsg!#!sn
hmchb`sdsgdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfrxkk`akd(9
(169) # # + V #
# Ø L + H #
Hshrbqtbh`ksg`ssgdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbghmrdqsrsghr
`cchshnm`kKsnmdhmsgdqd`khrsnmdlnqogdldadenqdsgdudqarsdl`krn
cq`vrsgdsvnmdv`rrnbh`shnmkhmdrrgnvm`anud-Sgdrdbnmcsnmdnesgd
lnqogdldhr`bst`kkxsgdqd`khronk`qsnmdatshshrqd`khydc`r`Ksnmd
`anudhmnqcdqsnadnoonrhsdnesgdenkknvhmfGsnmd'nesgdudqaqnns(-Hs
hrmnvbqtbh`ksg`ssgdoqdbdchmfo`ssdqmeddcrntqqhrd,cdkdshnmqtkd+
vghbghsb`mcnhevdrkhfgskxqduhrdsgdqtkd'ehqrsrs`sdchm'40(`anud(+
`radknv9
107
(170) Rule 6’: Rise-Deletion
# #
L (T) H / L
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkdcheedqreqnlhsroqduhntrudqrhnmaxsgd`cchshnmne
`mnoshnm`kekn`shmfsnmd'S(`mcsgde`bssg`ssgdqtkdmnv`ookhdr
vgdmdudqsgdmdwssnmdhr`Ksnmd-Sgd`cchshnmnesgdekn`shmfsnmd'S(hr
`qduhrhnmsg`shrrhlhk`qsnsgdqduhrhnmnentqlds`sgdrhrqtkd'rdd'51(
`anud(vghbg`kknvdcenq`m`cchshnm`kekn`shmfGsnmd-@cchmfsgd
rxkk`akd@enqsgdKsnmdmntmbk`rroqdehwnesgdenkknvhmfnaidbsvghbg
sqhffdqrsgdqduhrdcqhrd,cdkdshnmqtkd+ntqo`ssdqmhrbg`mfdchmsnsgd
enkknvhmf9
(171) # # + V # A +
# L L + H # L +
Rhmbdsgdcnvmrsdoqtkdcndrmns`ookxsnsghro`ssdqmhmhsroqdrdms
enql+ntqrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmhrpthsdrsq`hfgsenqv`qc+`radknv9
108
(172) # # + V #
# L L + #
Rtbg`Ksnmdqd`khy`shnmne`mtmcdqkxhmfGsnmdudqaqnnsb`m`krn
nbbtqhesgdudqarsdlhrchrxkk`ahb+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
3 3 3 3 3 (yesterday)
@cchmfsgdrxkk`akdRsnhmchb`sdntqsnmdkdrr.,sd.udqarteehw+ntq
o`ssdqm`ood`qr`radknv`esdq`ookhb`shnmneansgsgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkd
`mcntqO1onrhshudodqedbshudlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd9
(174) # # + V + S #
# Ø L + H + #
Nmbd`f`hm+vdrgnvsgdKsnmdoqdehwnesgdenkknvhmfnaidbsvghbg
sqhffdqrsgdqduhrdcqhrd,cdkdshnmqtkd+cdkdshmfsgdGsnmdhmsgdo`ssdqmhm
sgdenkknvhmfl`mmdq9
109
(175) # # + V + S # A +
# L L + H + # L +
Sgdmdwsqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqVEQqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdsnmdkdrr
Rrxkk`akdsnsgdehqrssnmdnmhsrkdes-Sgdqdrtkshrsgdenkknvhmf9
(176) # # + V + S #
# L L + + #
Vhsgd`bgrxkk`akdmnv`rrnbh`sdcsnnmdKsnmd+sgdognmdshb
qd`khy`shnmhrpthsdrsq`hfgsenqv`qc+`radknv9
(177) # # + V + S #
# L L + + #
3 -3
Rvhsbghmfmnvsnudqaqnnsrvhsgkdwhb`kKsnmdr+vdehmc
lnmnrxkk`ahbdw`lokdrkhjdsgdenkknvhmf9
3 3 34 4 (yesterday)
Sgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrgnvrsg`stmcdqkxhmfKsnmdudqaqnnsr`qd
110
qd`khydcognmdshb`kkxnm`knv,cnvmrsdoodc,knvsnmd'fkhcdeqnlohsbg
kdudk2sn3nmsgdtmcdqkhmdcudqaqnns`anud(-@cchmfsgdr`ldbnlokdw
K`mconk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdldsg`svdchcvhsgsgdGsnmdudqaqnnsr
`anudqdrtksrhmsgdenkknvhmf`esdqansgsgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkd`mcsgd
lnqogn,snmnknfhb`khmrdqshnmqtkdg`udnodq`sdc9
(179) # # + V #
# Ø H + L #
RhmbdsgdudqaqnnssnmdhrKgdqd+sgdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfonk`q
snmdhrqd`khydc`r`Gsnmd-Rhmbdsgdqd`qdmnrhmfkd,snmdsnm`k
lnqogdldrsneddcntqkdesv`qc,`mcqhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfqtkdr+sgdmdws
qtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgknvdqrsgdsnmdqdfhrsdq
nmdmnsbg'eqnl2sn3(adb`trdnesgdekn`shmfGsnmdoqdbdchmfsgd
`rrnbh`sdcKsnmd+`radknv9
(180) # # + V #
# L H + L #
3 4
Rhmbdsgdudqarsdlhrlnmnrxkk`ahb+ansgsgdsnmdkdudkr2`mc3`qd
qd`khydcnmsgdr`ldrxkk`akd`anud-
111
Sgdrdr`ldsvnkdudkr`qdqd`khydcnmrdo`q`sdrxkk`akdrvgdmdudqsgd
udqarsdlhrchrxkk`ahb+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
3 3 3 4 4 (yesterday)
Hmsgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokd+sgdcnvmrsdo'snkdudk3(nbbtqradsvddm
sgdehqrsrxkk`akdnesgdtmcdqkhmdcudqa`mcsgdkdwhb`kkxsnmdkdrrrxkk`akd
.,sd.-Sgdcdqhu`shnmnesghrsnmdo`ssdqmhrrhlhk`qsnsgdk`rsvhsgsgd
`cchshnmnesgdRrxkk`akdentmcadknv9
(182) # # + V + S #
# Ø H + L + #
@ssghronhms+ntqVEQqtkdnodq`sdr+`rrnbh`shmfsgdsnmdkdrrrxkk`akd
RsnsgdKsnmdnesgdudqaqnns-Bqtbh`kkx+gnvdudq+sghrr`ldVEQqtkd
`krnchr`rrnbh`sdrsgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akd'U(eqnlsg`sr`ldKsnmd`rhm
sgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
(183) # # + V + S #
# L H + L + #
Hsltrsadonhmsdcntssg`sntqoqdkhlhm`qxudqrhnmnesgdVEQqtkd
112
'rdd'83(`anud(vntkc`rrnbh`sdsgdsnmdkdrrRrxkk`akdsnsgdKsnmdnm
hsrkdes+atshsvntkcmnschr`rrnbh`sdsg`sKsnmdeqnlrxkk`akdU+`rvd
g`udhmchb`sdcltrss`jdok`bd-VdltrssgdqdenqdqduhrdntqVEQqtkdsn
chr`rrnbh`sdsgdsnmdbgnrdmax`enqldqkxsnmdkdrrrxkk`akdeqnlnsgdq
rxkk`akdroqnuhcdcsg`ssgnrdnsgdqrxkk`akdr`qd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsnxds
`mnsgdqsnmd-Sgdqtkdnauhntrkxcndrmnsv`mssnbqd`sdnsgdqsnmdkdrr
rxkk`akdrhmsgdoqnbdrrne`rrnbh`shmfdwhrshmfsnmdkdrrrxkk`akdr-Sgd
qdrtksnentqlnchehdcVEQqtkdltrsadsg`svgdmdudq`snmdkdrr
rxkk`akd!atlorhmsn!`rxkk`akdvhsg`bnlokdw'h-d-lnqdsg`mnmd(snmd+
sgdbnlokdwsnmdhraqnjdmcnvmhmsnhsrbnmrshstdmso`qsr+d`bgo`qsadhmf
kdesvhsghsrqdrodbshud`rrnbh`sdcrxkk`akd-VdsgdqdenqdqduhrdntqVEQ
'ehqrsrs`sdchm'83(`anud(+`radknv9
(#) + # +
(T) T + +
Sghrqtkdr`xrsg`svgdmdudq`snmdkdrrrxkk`akdhrentmc'hmsgdkdes,
sn,qhfgs`ookhb`shnmnesgdsnmdqtkdr(+hshr`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdehqrssnmd
entmcnmhsrkdes+chr`rrnbh`shmf`rvdkksg`sr`ldsnmdeqnl`mxnsgdq
113
rxkk`akdrvhsgvghbghslhfgs`kqd`cxad`rrnbh`sdchesgnrdrxkk`akdr
vntkcqds`hmxds`mnsgdqsnmd-
NmbdsgdqduhrdcVEQqtkdg`rnodq`sdc+sgdnmkxnsgdqqtkdsn`eedbs
ntqo`ssdqmhrsgdk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgknvdqrsgdsnmdqdfhrsdqnmd
mnsbgadsvddmsgdsvnrxkk`akdr+`radknv9
(185) # # + V + S #
# L H + L + #
3 - 4
SgdrdbnmcodqedbshudO2onrhshudmnm,etstqdsnmdo`ssdqmsg`svdrg`kk
dw`lhmdhrsg`snesgdsdmrd+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
3 3 13 3
Sgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdg`r`G,Ke`kkhmfsnmdnmhsrtmcdqkhmdcudqa
qnns-Sghrjhmcne`rtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmhr`bbnlokhrgdcaxhmrdqshmf`m
associatedKsnmd`esdqsgdudqarsdl+`snmdmnshmrdqsdctmshk`esdqsgd
nodq`shnmnentqmnql`ksnmdl`oohmfqtkdvghbgqdrtksrhmsgdenkknvhmf9
114
(187) # + V #
# L + H #
Hshrnmkx`esdqsgdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc+atsadenqdsgdatkjnentq
snmdqtkdrnodq`sd+sg`sntqtmhptdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdhmrdqsr`Ksnmd
hlldch`sdkx`esdqsgdudqarsdlhesgdrdmsdmbdhronrhshudodqedbshudO2'rdd
'451(adknv(-Sgdqdrtksnesghrqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
(188) # + V + #
# L + H + Ø #
Hshrbqtbh`ksg`ssgd`cchshnm`kKsnmdhr`ccdc`esdqsgdudqarsdl`mchr
Vgdmhsbnldrshldenqntqmnql`ksnmdqtkdrsnnodq`sd+sgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfK
snmdlnqogdldqtkd`rrnbh`sdrsgdqd`khronk`qsnmd'KsnmdadenqdsgdGsnmdne
sgdudqaqnns(snsgdehqrsrxkk`akd'#(oqdbdchmfsgdudqa+`radknv9
(189) # # + V + #
# L + H + L #
Rhmbdntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdcndrmns`ookxsnsghro`qshbtk`qo`ssdqm'`kksgd
snmdradhmf`rrnbh`sdc(+sgdrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmhrpthsdrsq`hfgsenqv`qc+`r
115
adknv9
(190) # # + V + #
# L + H + L #
1 3
Sgdr`ldjhmcneo`ssdqmb`madqd`khydcnmchrxkk`ahbudqarsdlr+`r
hmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
3 3 1 3 3
@cchmfsgdrxkk`akdRsnhmchb`sdntqsnmdkdrr.,sd.udqarteehw+ntq
o`ssdqm`ood`qr`radknv`esdq`ookhb`shnmnesgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkd9
(192) # + V + S #
# L + H + #
Nmbd`f`hm+`esdqsgdl`oohmfqtkdatsadenqdsgdnsgdqsnmdqtkdr+sgd
O2onrhshudodqedbshudlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdhmrdqsr`Ksnmd`esdqsgd
udqarsdland`rrnbh`sdrsg`sKsnmdsnsgdk`rsrxkk`akdnesgdudqarsdl
'hmsghrb`rd+sgdRrxkk`akd(+`radknv9
116
(193) # + V + S + #
# L + H + + Ø #
Vdmnvbnldsnntqmnql`ksnmdqtkdr-Sgdnmkxqtkdsn`ookxsnsghr
o`qshbtk`qcdqhu`shnmhrsgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdlnqogdldqtkdvghbg
nmbd`f`hmnodq`sdr`radknv9
(194) # # + V + S + #
# L + H + + L #
Tmshkmnv+vdg`udrddmsg`sntqVEQqtkdg`r`kv`xr`ookhdcsnsgd
snmdkdrrRrxkk`akdvgdmdudqhsg`raddmoqdrdms-Gnvdudq+hmsgdoqdrdms
cdqhu`shnm+sgdRrxkk`akdg`r`kqd`cxaddm`rrnbh`sdcvhsg`snmdaxntq
O2qtkd+`mcsgdVEQcndrmns`ookx-Rhmbdsgdk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdcndr
mns`ookxdhsgdq+sgdehm`krtqe`bdqdrtkshrsgdenkknvhmf9
(195) # # + V + S + #
# L + H + + L #
1 - 3
Vdvhkkmnvdw`lhmdo`q`kkdkO2onrhshudodqedbshuddw`lokdrvgdqd
sgdudqaqnnsg`r`kdwhb`kKsnmd+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
117
(196) aL laL gwQDY mbaLb "he ground the meat"
3 3 24 4
Sgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrgnvrsg`stmcdqkxhmfKsnmdudqaqnnsr`qd
qd`khydcognmdshb`kkxnm`cnvmrsdoodc,ghfg,knvsnmdfkhcd'eqnlohsbg
kdudk1sn3nmsgdtmcdqkhmdcudqa`anud(-Rs`qshmfvhsgsgdr`ldqd`khr
onk`qsnmd'qd`khydc`r`GsnmdadenqdsgdKsnmdnesgdudqaqnns(+sgd
o`ssdqm`ood`qr`radknv`esdqntqsnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(197) # + V #
# H + L #
Nmbd`f`hm+`esdqntql`oohmfqtkdatsadenqdsgdnsgdqsnmdqtkdr+sgd
O2lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdnodq`sdroqnctbhmfsgdenkknvhmf9
(198) # + V + #
# H + L + Ø #
Vgdmhsbnldrshldenqntqmnql`ksnmdqtkdrsnnodq`sd+sgdehqrsqtkd
snnodq`sd`rvdfneqnlkdessnqhfgshrsgdqhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfGsnmd
lnqogdldqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdqd`khronk`qsnmd'G(snsgdudqaqnns
rxkk`akdvghkd`krnchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdehqrsKsnmdsnhsrqhfgs+`radknv9
118
(199) # + V + #
# H + L + L #
Sgde`bssg`ssgdoqdbdchmfqtkdchr`rrnbh`sdcsgdKsnmdnesgdudqa
qnnseddcrntqlds`sgdrhrqtkdadenqdsgdtrt`k`rrnbh`sdcKsnmd+vghbg
lds`sgdrhydrsgdG`mcKsnmdr`radknv9
(200) # # + V + #
L # H + L + L #
Sgdehm`ksnmdqtkdsnnodq`sdnmsgdoqdrdmscdqhu`shnmhrntqk`sd
cnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgknvdqrsgdsnmdqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbg'sn1(`ssgd
adfhmmhmfnesgdudqaqnns+`radknv9
(201) # + V + #
# L H + + L #
2 4
Sgdr`ldjhmcneo`ssdqmb`madqd`khydcnmchrxkk`ahbudqarsdlr+`r
hmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
3 3 2 4 4
119
@cchmfsgdrxkk`akdRsnhmchb`sdntqsnmdkdrr.,sd.udqarteehw+ntqo`ssdqm
`ood`qr`radknv`esdq`ookhb`shnmnesgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkd9
(203) # + V + S #
# H + L + #
Nmbd`f`hm+sgdmdwsqtkdsn`ookxhrsgdO2onrhshudodqedbshudlnqogn,
snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbg`f`hmhmrdqsr`Ksnmd`esdqsgdudqarsdland`rrnbh`sdr
sg`sKsnmdsnsgdk`rsrxkk`akdnesg`srsdl+`radknv9
(204) # + V + S + #
# H + L + + Ø #
Nmbdvdbnldsnntqmnql`ksnmdqtkdr+sgdehqrsqtkdsn`ookxhrsgd
qhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfGsnmdlnqogdldqtkdvghbgansg`rrnbh`sdrsgdGsnmdsn
sgdudqaqnns`mcchr`rrnbh`sdrsgdKsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
(205) # + V + S + #
# H + L + + L #
Sgdqdrtksnesghrqtkd`f`hmeddcrntqlds`sgdrhrqtkdvghbg
lds`sgdrhydrsgdKsnmdenqldqkx`rrnbh`sdcvhsgsgdudqaqnns`mcsgdG
120
snmdeqnlsgdqd`khronk`qsnmd+`kknesghradenqdsgdmnql`kKsnmd
`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdoqdbdchmfrxkk`akd'#(+`radknv9
(206) # # + V + S + #
L # H + L + + L #
Nmbd`f`hm+sgdVEQqtkdsg`sg`rtrt`kkx`ookhdcsnrxkk`akdRcndr
mns`ookxrhmbdsgdRrxkk`akdhr`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsn`snmd-Sgdk`sd
cnvmrsdoqtkdhrsgdnmkxnsgdqsnmdqtkdsn`ookxsnsghro`ssdqm`mchs
knvdqrsgdsnmdqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbg'sgdGsnmdfnhmfsnkdudk1(nmsgd
udqaqnns+vhsghsrbnmshmthmfdeedbsadhmfmnshbdcaxsgdknvdqhmfnesgd
enqldqkxsnmdkdrrudqarteehw`krnnmdmnsbg'Ksnmdfnhmfsnkdudk3(+`r
adknv9
(207) # + V + S + #
# L H + + + L #
2 - 4
Vdmnvstqmsnrdudq`knsgdqtmtrt`ksnmdo`ssdqmr-Sgdehqrsnesgdrd
o`ssdqmrhrtmtrt`kenqsgqddrdo`q`sdqd`rnmr-Ehqrs+sgdmnql`ksnmd
bnmsq`rsadsvddmG`mcKsnmdudqaqnnsrhrmdtsq`khydc-Rdbnmc+sgdO/
bnmrsqtbshnm'ydqnsdmrdvhsgodqedbshud`rodbstrdcsnhmchb`sdhlldch`sd
o`rsshldld`mhmf(hrsgdnmkxbnmrsqtbshnmvgdqd`udqaqnnshrqd`khydc
121
nm`qhrhmfsnmdfkhcd-Sghqc+sgdnaidbshrcnvmrsdoodckhjd`mhqqd`khr
bnmrsqtbshnmdudmsgntfgsgdO/hrcdehmhsdkxqd`khr-Sgdenkknvhmf
dw`lokdrhmbktcdlnmnrxkk`ahbG`mcKsnmdudqaqnnsrqdrodbshudkx9
3 31 4
3 31 4
Sgdjdxsnsgdcdqhu`shnmneO/bnmrsqtbshnmrhrsg`ssgdudqahr`kv`xr
hlldch`sdkxoqdbdcdcax`Ksnmdrtaidbsl`qjdqbkhshbvghbg`rrnbh`sdr
snsgdqhfgssnsgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akd-Vghkdsgdoqnbdrrhrcdrbqhadchm
cds`hkhmrdbshnm1-3-0-adknv+vdvhkkrgnv`m`aaqduh`sdcudqrhnmnesgd
cdqhu`shnmgdqdsnitrshexsgdsnm`kmdtsq`khy`shnmnesgdrdbnmrsqtbshnmr-
Sgdmnql`ko`ssdqmenq`qd`khrudqaqnnsvntkc`ood`q`radknv'vhsg!O!
rxlankhyhmfsgdekn`shmfqd`khronk`qsnmd`mcsgd!S!rxlankhyhmfdhsgdq`
GnqKsnmd(`esdqsgdekn`shmfrtaidbsl`qjdqsnmdhr`rrnbh`sdcax`
rodbh`klnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'454(adknv(snsgdudqaqnns'U(+`r
adknv9
(209) + # + V #
+ L # P + T #
Sgdbqtbh`klnldmsg`rmnv`qqhudc-Sgdonk`qsnmdhrsq`oodcadsvddmsvn
122
`rrnbh`shnmkhmdrrnhsmust`rrnbh`sdsnsgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akdnmhsrqhfgs
adb`trdsgdVEBoqnghahsrmdv`rrnbh`shnmkhmdreqnlbqnrrhmfnkckhmdr-Sgd
qtkdvghbgnodq`sdrhrsgtrdhsgdqsgdkdesv`qc,'rdd'27(`anud(nqqhfgsv`qc,
cnbjhmf'rdd'45(`anud(snmdqtkdr-Sgdcheedqdmbdadsvddmsgdsvnsnmdqtkdr
vhkkadduhcdmsonlyaxsgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdrvghbgsgdqdrodbshudqtkdrcdkdsd+
nmdnmsgdkdes`mcsgdnsgdqnmsgdqhfgs+`rrgnvmadknv9
(210) + # + V #
+ L # L/H + H/L #
SgdqdrtkshmfrsqtbstqdrenqansgG`mcKsnmdudqarxhdkcsgdr`ldKG
qhrhmfsnmd+sgntfgsgdsnmdrhmunkudchmsgdqhrdg`udcheedqdmslnqognknfhb`k
nqhfhmr-Sgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnmrgnvransgsgdtmcdqkxhmfGsnmdudqa
qnnso`ssdqm'hmrnkhckhmdr+qdekdbsdchmsgdehqrsqnvnemtladqradknv(`mcsgd
tmcdqkxhmfKsnmdudqaqnnso`ssdqm'hmc`rgdckhmdr+qdekdbsdchmsgdrdbnmcqnv
nemtladqrdudmetqsgdqadknv(9
(211) + # + V #
+ L # L/H + H/L #
- 3 1 -
- 3 1 -
Sgdoqdbdchmfo`ssdqm`mchsr`bbnlo`mxhmfcdqhu`shnmadbnldrnldvg`s
123
lnqdtmtrt`kvgdmsgdudqarsdlhrchrxkk`ahb+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfsvn
dw`lokdr9
3 3 31 4
3 3 31 4
Sgdcdqhu`shnmrs`qsrnts`rsgdoqdbdchmfnmdchcvhsgsgd`cchshnmne`
snmdkdrrudqarteehw'R(nmsgdrxkk`ahbshdq+`radknv9
(213) + # + V + S #
+ L # P + T + #
Nmbdsgdrtaidbsl`qjdqsnmdg`raddm`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akd
axrodbh`klnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'454(adknv(+`r`anud+sgdonk`qsnmdhr
enqbdcsn`rrnbh`sdvhsgsgdudqaqnns+chr`rrnbh`shmfkhmdrsnhsrkdes`mcqhfgshm
sgdb`rdneK`mcGsnmdrqdrodbshudkx+`radknv9
(214) + # + V + S #
+ L # L/H + H/L + #
Sgdmdwsqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqqduhrdcVEQ'rdd'073(`anud(vghbg
`rrnbh`sdrsgdsnmdkdrrRrxkk`akdsnsgdGsnmdnmhsrqhfgs+`krnchr`rrnbh`shmf
124
sgdrdGsnmdreqnlsgdrxkk`akdrsg`ssgdxvdqd`rrnbh`sdcsn+`radknv9
(215) + # + V + S #
+ L # L/H + H/L + #
Mnvsg`ssgdsvnrxkk`akdrnesgdudqarsdl`qd`rrnbh`sdcsn`K`mc
Gsnmdqdrodbshudkx+sgdxeddcsgdqhrd,enql`shnmqtkdvghbgnodq`sdr`r
adknv+qdrtkshmfhmsgdbnqqdbsrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmr-Ntqehm`krtqe`bd
qd`khy`shnmhrsgdqdenqd`radknv+vhsgsgdtmcdqkxhmfGsnmdudqartrhmf
rnkhckhmdr'`mcsgdehqrsqnvnemtladqr(vghkdtmcdqkxhmfKsnmdudqar
trdc`rgdckhmdr'`mcsgdrdbnmcqnvnemtladqr(9
(216) + # + V + S #
+ L # L/H + H/L + #
- 3 -31 -
- 3 -3 1 -
@mnsgdqdmuhqnmldmsvgdqdsgdmnql`ksnm`kbnmsq`rsadsvddmG`mc
Ksnmdudqarhrmdtsq`khydchrenqO1`mcO2mnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud
bnmrsqtbshnmr-VdrdkdbssgdO1onrhshuddw`lokdr`rbg`q`bsdqhrshbnesghr
fqnto+`mcdw`lhmdehqrssgdlnmnrxkk`ahbudqaqnnsr+`rentmchmsgd
enkknvhmfdw`lokdr9
125
(217) aL kaLa nzMaY mbaLb "he was a meat-cutter"
3 3 4 4 (yesterday)
3 3 4 4 (yesterday)
Sgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdr`qdtmtrt`khml`mxv`xr-A`rdcnmvg`svd
g`udrddmneqd`khrlncd`mchlodqedbshud`rodbs+hs`ood`qrsg`s`
sq`mrenql`shnmg`rnodq`sdcnmsgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdr-Vghkdsgd
hlodqedbshudqd`khrm`r`koqdehw'rxlankhydcax!m!(hrhmhsrtrt`k
onrhshnm`ssgdadfhmmhmfnesgd'tmcdqkhmdc(udqa+sgdsxohb`kKsnmddbgn
unvdkudqarteehwsg`shmchb`sdrhlodqedbshud`rodbshrmns`ss`bgdcsnsgd
dmcnesgdudqa-Hmrsd`c+sghrrteehwrddlrsng`udaddmsq`mredqqdceqnl
sgdudqarsdlsnsgdsdmrdl`qjdq'trt`kkx`rgnqs.j`∆.enqO1(-Sghrjhmc
ne`sq`mrenql`shnmvntkcdwok`hmansgsgd`ardmbdnesgddbgnunvdk
`esdqsgdudqaqnns+`mchsroqdrdmbd`esdqsgdsdmrdl`qjdq-@etqsgdq
lnchehb`shnm+gnvdudq+hrsg`ssgdsnmdrnmsgdudqa`qdmnssgdmnql`k
qd`khrsnmdrsg`s`qdtrt`khmrtbgdmuhqnmldmsr+ats`mdtsq`khydc
cnvmrsdoodcKsnmd-Sng`mckdsgdrdbg`mfdr+vdmddcsvnrdo`q`sd
lnqogdldqtkdr-Sgdehqrsqtkdvntkcnodq`sdudqxd`qkxhmsgdcdqhu`shnm
`mcvntkc`ss`bgsgdmnql`kKsnmdhlodqedbshudrteehwsnsgdsdmrd
l`qjdqhmrsd`cnesgdudqarsdl-@ltbgk`sdqqtkdvntkcodqenqlsgd
snm`kqdok`bdldmsetmbshnmnmsgdudqarsdl-@rrtlhmfsg`ssgd
hlodqedbshudrteehwg`raddmsq`mredqqdcsnsgdsdmrdl`qjdq+ntqo`ssdqm
126
vntkc`ood`q`radknv`esdqsgdl`oohmfqtkdg`cnodq`sdc9
(218) # + V #
# P + T #
Rhmbdsgdrxlankr!O!`mc!S!`bst`kkxrs`mcenqsvnbnlahm`shnmrneG`mc
Ksnmdr+sgdrdsnmdrvntkctmcdqfncheedqdmsbg`mfdr`rsgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdr
nodq`sdc-Vdrhfmhexsgdqdrtkshmfsnmdo`ssdqmaftersgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdrax
g`uhmf`mnoshnm`kekn`shmfsnmd`mcnlhsshmfsgdlnqogdldantmc`qhdr'rhmbd
sgdx`qdmnknmfdqrhfmhehb`ms`ssghronhmshmsgdcdqhu`shnm(+`radknv9
(219) # V #
# (T) T #
Hshr`ssghronhmshmsgdcdqhu`shnmsg`sntqk`sdO1`mcO2lnqogn,snmnknfhb`k
qtkd'rdd'466(adknv(`ookhdrsnansgonrhshud`mcmdf`shudmnm,oqnfqdrrhud
hlodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmr-Hsbg`mfdrsgdekn`shmfsnmdsn`Gsnmd`mcsgd
`rrnbh`sdcsnmdsn`Ksnmd+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
(220) # V #
# (T) T #
H L
127
Sgdqdrtkshmfo`ssdqmg`r`m`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdoqdbdcdcax`m
tm`rrnbh`sdcGsnmdvghbgeddcrntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkd+knvdqhmfsgd
snm`kqdfhrsdqaxnmdmnsbg'sn3(+`radknv9
(221) # V #
# H L #
Hsrgntkcadrsqdrrdcsg`ssgdoqdbdchmfcdqhu`shnmg`chcdmshb`kqdrtksr
enqansgG`mcKsnmdlnmnrxkk`ahbudqaqnnsr-
Sgdr`ldcnvmrsdoodcKsnmdrb`madroqd`cnudqsvnrxkk`akdr+`rhm
sgdchrxkk`ahbudqarsdlrrgnvmadknv9
3 3 4 4 (yesterday)
3 3 4 4 (yesterday)
Nmbd`f`hm+sgddbgnunvdkhlodqedbshudrteehwg`raddmsq`mredqqdc
snsgdsdmrdl`qjdqeqnlsgdudqarsdl`mcsgddmshqdudqahrqd`khydcnm`
cnvmrsdoodcKsnmd-Ntqsnm`kcdqhu`shnm`f`hmrs`qsrvhsg`ekn`shmf
onk`qsnmdoqdbdchmfsgd`rrnbh`sdcudqasnmd`esdqsgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkd
g`rnodq`sdc+`radknv9
128
(223) # + V + S #
# P + T + #
Sgdoqdbdchmfo`ssdqmcheedqreqnlsgdbnqqdronmchmfo`ssdqmnesgd
oqdbdchmfcdqhu`shnmnmkxhmsgdoqdrdmbdnesgdsnmdkdrrRrxkk`akd-Sghr
snmdkdrrRrxkk`akd`rrnbh`sdrvhsgsgdr`ldsnmd`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdudqaqnnshm
sgdbntqrdnesgdsnmdqtkdraxntqqduhrdcVEQqtkd+kd`uhmf`o`ssdqmkhjdsgd
enkknvhmf`esdqsgdsnmdqtkdrg`udnodq`sdc9
(224) # V + S #
# (T) T + #
Nmbd`f`hm+`esdqsgdl`inqhsxnesnmdqtkdrg`udnodq`sdc+sgdrodbh`kO1
`mcO2lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd`ookhdrsnntqo`ssdqmxhdkchmfsgdenkknvhmf9
(225) # V + S #
# (T) T + #
H L
RhmbdsgdqdrtkshmfKsnmdhrbnmmdbsdcsnansgrxkk`akdrnesgdudqa+sgd
r`ldknvdqdcohsbgkdudkhrqd`khydcnmansg+vhsgansgnesgdladhmfnmdmnsbg
knvdqsg`m`mnql`kKsnmdadb`trdnesgdcnvmrsdoqtkd+vghbgqdrtksrhmsgd
enkknvhmf9
129
(226) # V + S #
# H L + #
4-4
Sgdmdwssgqddo`ssdqmrvghbgvdvhkkdw`lhmd`qdqd`khydcnmsgd
rtqe`bdvhsgsgdmnql`khqqd`khrsnmdrnmsgdudqarsdlrsgntfgsgdqd`qd
rdudq`kqd`rnmrsnonrhssg`ssgdx`qdl`qjdctmcdqkxhmfkxenqqd`khrlncd-
Sgdsgqddbnmrsqtbshnmrhmenbtrgdqd`qdsgdenkknvhmf9
Sgdl`inqsq`hssg`ssgdrdsgqddbnmrsqtbshnmrrg`qdvhsgd`bgnsgdqhr
sg`ssgdx`qd`kkonrhshud+`mc`kksgqddg`udbnqqdronmchmfmdf`shud
bnmrsqtbshnmrvghbgdwghahssgdmnql`kqd`khrsnmdrnmsgdudqarsdl-Sgd
enkknvhmfonrhshud`mcmdf`shudqd`khroqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshuddw`lokdr
eqnlsgdydqnsdmrdrgnvsgdtmtrt`kbg`mfdneqd`khrsnhqqd`khrsnmd
o`ssdqmrnmsgd'tmcdqkhmdc(udqar9
130
3 3 2 5 5
aL teN neL nzaJYaL mbaLb wDJ "he isn’t cutting the meat"
3 31 3 1 3 3 1
SgdqhrhmfsnmdnmsgdMDFl`qjdq.sd∆.hrchrbtrrdchmrdbshnm1-2-4-
adknv-Kd`uhmfsghred`stqd`rhcd+hshrok`hmsg`ssgdmnql`kGsnmdenq
qd`khrlncdhrqd`khydcnmkxnmsgdmdf`shudrdmsdmbdvghkdsgdmnql`kG
snmdvhsgcnvmrsdoradenqd`mc`esdqhrqd`khydcnmsgdudqaqnnsnesgd
onrhshudrdmsdmbd-Vdoqnonrdsng`mckdsgdsgqddbnmrsqtbshnmrvghbg
adg`udhmsghrl`mmdqaxld`mrne`md`qkxlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd
vghbgbg`mfdrsgdZ*qd`k\ed`stqdsnZ,qd`k\'rdd'438(adknv(-Sghrqtkd
vntkcg`udsnenkknvnsgdqlnqognknfhb`kqtkdrkhjdsgdrodbhehb`shnmne
sgdqd`khrhlodqedbshudgnlnqf`mhbm`r`kbnmrnm`sudqaoqdehw+xds
oqdbdcdsgdrodbhehb`shnmnesgdqd`khronk`qsnmd-Sgdsnm`kcdqhu`shnm
vntkcsgdmoqnbddchm`mhcdmshb`kl`mmdqsno`ssdqmrvghbgg`c`m
tmcdqkxhmfZ,qd`k\ed`stqd+`rrgnvmhmsgdoqduhntrsvnrdbshnmr-
Sgdmdwshchnrxmbq`shbsnmdo`ssdqmvghbgvdvhkkdw`lhmdhrsgd
onrhshudmnm,oqnfqdrrhudhqqd`khroqdrdms'ydqn(bnmrsqtbshnm+sgdnmkxshld
sg`s`mtmcdqkxhmfhqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmhrdudqqd`khydcnm`mxsghmfats
sgdmnql`khqqd`khrrtqe`bdsnmdr-Adfhmmhmfvhsg`Gsnmdlnmnrxkk`ahb
131
udqaqnns+vdehmcdw`lokdrkhjdsgdenkknvhmf9
3 4 4 4
Sgntfgsgdo`ssdqmrvdvhkkaddw`lhmhmf`ood`qghfgkxtmtrt`khm
sg`ssgdtmcdqkxhmfGsnmdudqarsdlr`qd`kv`xrqd`khydcognmdshb`kkxnm
`lowerohsbgkdudksg`mtmcdqkxhmfKsnmdudqarsdlr+sgdo`ssdqmr`qd
d`rhkxg`mckdcvhsgntqdwhrshmfsnmdqtkdr-Vdrhlokxonrhs`rdo`q`sd
lnqogn,ognmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbghmrdqsr`Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdld
hlldch`sdkx`esdqsgdudqaqnns-Sghrqtkd'rdd'455(adknv(nodq`sdr`esdq
sgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkd+qdrtkshmfhmsgdenkknvhmf9
(230) # V + + I #
# H + Ø + L #
Sgdmdwsqtkdvghbgnodq`sdrhrntqkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrntqekn`shmfKsnmdsnsgdUrxkk`akd
vghkdchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdGsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
132
(231) # V + + I #
# H + L + L #
Sgdnmkxqdl`hmhmfqtkdsn`ookxsnsghrcdqhu`shnmhrntqk`sd
cnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgknvdqr`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdrnmdmnsbg'sn3(adb`trd
nesgdekn`shmfGsnmd+`radknv9
(232) # V + + I #
# H + L + L #
4 - 4
Sgdr`ldjhmcnertqe`bdo`ssdqmb`m`krnadentmcnmchrxkk`ahbudqa
rsdlrvgnrdtmcdqkxhmfqnnssnmdhrG+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
3 4 4 4
Tmcdqfnhmfsgdr`ldlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbghmrdqsr`Ksnmd
snm`klnqogdldbetweensgdU`mcsnmdkdrrRrxkk`akdrnesgdudqarsdl+
vdg`udsgdenkknvhmfqdrtks`esdqnodq`shnmnesgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkd
'qdldladqhmfsg`ssgdhlodqedbshud'H(rxkk`akdcqnorntshmsgdoqdrdmbd
nesgdsnmdkdrrRrxkk`akd(9
133
(234) # V + + S + #
# H + Ø + + L #
Hshrbqtbh`kenqsgdoqdrdmscdqhu`shnmbothsg`ssgdKsnmdsnm`klnqogdld
hrhmrdqsdcadsvddmsgdsvnrxkk`akdrnesgdudqarsdl'U`mcR(andsg`ssgd
VEQsnmdqtkd`bsr`r`mnql`ksnmdqtkdvhsgqhfgs,sn,kdes`ookhb`shnmnmsgd
snm`kshdq-Hshrnmkxadb`trdnesgdrdsvne`bsnqrsg`ssgdKsnmdsnm`klnqogdld
qdl`hmrtm`rrnbh`sdc`ssgdshldnesgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`klnqogdld
qtkd+vghbgnmbd`f`hmnodq`sdr`radknv9
(235) # V + + S + #
# H + L + + L #
Hshrnmkx`esdqsgdKsnmdg`r`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdkdes`mcchr`rrnbh`sdcsgdG
snmdenqldqkx`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdUrxkk`akdsg`sntqVEQqtkdhr`kknvdcsn
nodq`sd-Hssgdm`rrnbh`sdrsgdRrxkk`akdsnsgdehqrssnmdnmhsrkdes+`radknv9
(236) # V + + S + #
# H + L + + L #
Sghrs`jdrb`qdnentqo`ssdqmdwbdosenqsgdehm`kKsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldvghbghr`rrnbh`sdckdesv`qcaxsgdrdbnmc`ookhb`shnmnesgd
134
kdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`klnqogdldqtkd+`krnchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdR
rxkk`akdeqnlsgdnsgdqKsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
(237) # V + + S + #
# H + L + + L #
Sgdnmkxqdl`hmhmfqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdvghbg
nmbd`f`hmknvdqrsgdsnm`kkdudknmdmnsbgadb`trdnesgdekn`shmfG
snmd+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
(238) # V + + S + #
# H + L + + L #
4 - 4
Sgdoqdbdchmfcdqhu`shnmrrgnvsg`ssgdsnmdqtkdrcdudknodcenq
oqduhntrmntm`mcudqaogq`rdbnmrsqtbshnmrbnqqdbskxcdqhudsgdrtqe`bd
qd`khy`shnmneGsnmdudqarfhudm`Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdldhlldch`sdkx
enkknvhmfsgdUrxkk`akd-Rtbgrs`hfgsenqv`qcqdrtksr`qd`krnonrrhakd
vhsgsgdtmcdqkxhmfKsnmdudqaqnnsr+`rvhsgsgdlnmnrxkk`ahbqnnshm
sgdenkknvhmfdw`lokd9
3 3 3 3
135
Sgdsxohb`kKsnmdudqahrgdqdqd`khydcnm`mnql`kKsnmdohsbgkdudk
'ne2(sgntfgsgdGsnmdudqarrddm`anudg`caddmknvdqdcnmdmnsbg'sn
3(-Sghrhrsgdqdrtksnesgdr`ldlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbghmrdqsr`
Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdld`esdqsgdUrxkk`akd-Sghrqdrtksrhmsgdenkknvhmf
`esdqsgdnodq`shnmnesgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkd9
(240) # V + + I #
# L + Ø + L #
Sgdnmkxsnmdqtkdsnnodq`sdnmsgdoqdrdmso`ssdqmhrsgdkdesv`qc,
cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`klnqogdldqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdekn`shmfKsnmd
snsgdUrxkk`akdvghkdchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdKsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd-
Sgdqdrtkshmfo`ssdqmcndrmnssqhffdqntqcnvmrsdoqtkd`mchrsgdqdenqd
qd`khydcpthsdrsq`hfgsenqv`qckx`radknv9
(241) # V + + I #
# L + L + L #
3 - 3
Sgdchrxkk`ahbKsnmdudqarsdlr`krndmctovhsgsgdr`ldo`ssdqm+`r
sgdenkknvhmfdw`lokdhkktrsq`sdr9
136
(242) aL l`bmteL mbaLb "he is reheating the meat"
3 3 3 3
@cchmfsgdRrxkk`akdsnqdoqdrdmsntqsnmdkdrr.,sd.rteehw+ntqo`ssdqm
`ood`qr`radknv`esdqsgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkd`mclnqogn,snmnkfnbh`kqtkdg`ud
`ookhdc9
(243) # V + + S + #
# L + Ø + + L #
Nmbd`f`hm+ntqkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdlnqogdldqtkdhrsgdehqrssn
nodq`sd+`rrnbh`shmfsgdehqrsekn`shmfKsnmdnentqo`ssdqmsnsgdUrxkk`akd
vghkdchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdsnmd`kqd`cxsgdqd+`radknv9
(244) # V + + S + #
# L + L + + L #
Sgdmdwsqtkdsnnodq`sd'fnhmfeqnlkdessnqhfgs(hrntqVEQqtkdvghbg
`rrnbh`sdrsgdsnmdkdrrRrxkk`akdsnsgdkdes+`radknv9
(245) # V + + S + #
# L + L + + L #
Sgdehm`ksnmdqtkdsnnodq`sdnmsghro`qshbtk`qo`ssdqmhrnmbd`f`hmntq
kdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`klnqogdldqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdehm`kKsnmd
137
nentqo`ssdqmsnsgdRrxkk`akdvghkddq`rhmfsgd`rrnbh`shmfkhmd`kqd`cx
`ss`bgdcsnsg`srxkk`akd+`radknv9
(246) # V + + S + #
# L + L + + L #
Rhmbdsgdcnvmrsdoqtkdcndrmns`ookxsnsghro`ssdqm+ntqognmdshb
qd`khy`shnmhrnmbd`f`hmnmohsbgkdudk2vghbghrmnql`kenqKsnmdr+`r
adknv9
(247) # V + + S + #
# L + L + + L #
3 - 3
Sgdehm`khchnrxmbq`shbo`ssdqmvghbgvdr`udctmshkk`rsqdedqrsnsgd
sgdtmtrt`kO0sdmrd-Sgdsnmdbg`mfdrenqsghrsdmrd`qdrtbgsg`svd
ltrsg`mckddudmsgdqdftk`qo`ssdqmrhmsvnrs`fdr9ehqrs+onrhshmf`
l`qjdqvghbgbnmrhrsrne`rdqhdrneK,G,Ksnmdr`mchrhmrdqsdcbefore
sgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdrnodq`sd:rdbnmc+onrhshmf`lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd
vghbgcdkdsdr`mxvnqchmsdqm`kekn`shmfsnmdrenqsgdl`qjdq`mcbg`mfdr
sgdehm`kKsnmdsn`ekn`shmfonk`qsnmdaftersgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdrg`ud
nodq`sdc-
Rtbg`svn,rs`fdrnktshnmhrmddcdcadb`trdnesgdm`stqdnesnm`k
138
qd`khy`shnmrhmsgdu`qhntrO0bnmrsqtbshnmr+khjdsgdmdf`shudodqedbshud
dw`lokdrfhudmadknv9
(248) aL neN tMe zaJY mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t cut the meat"
3 31 4 2 4 2 (earlier today)
aL neN tMe gwKDY mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t grind the meat"
3 31 4 3 5 3 (earlier today)
Qdldladqhmfsg`ssgdMDFl`qjdq.sd∆.g`ritrs`mtmcdqkxhmfKsnmd+
hshrnauhntreqnlsgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrsg`ssgdO0sdmrdl`qjdqZmd¿∫¿ \hr
`kv`xrqd`khydc`r`KGqhrhmfsnmdenkknvdcax`cnvmrsdo-Adb`trdne
sgdm`stqdnesgdsnmdqtkdr`kqd`cxcdudknodc+vdltrscdudknosghr
bnlokdwl`qjdqhmsvnrs`fdr-Sgdehqrsrs`fdhrsg`ssgdenkknvhmfl`qjdq
vhsgKGKsnmdrhrhmrdqsdcbeforesgdsnmdqtkdr`knmfvhsgsgdnsgdq
sdmrdl`qjdqr'vgdqd!L!hrtrdcsnrxlankhydsgdO0o`rssdmrdl`qjdq
nmsgdrdfldms`kshdq(9
# M #
# L H L #
SghrO0l`qjdqg`r`kknehsr`rrnbh`shnmkhmdrrodbhehdchmsgdkdwhbnm-Hevd
hmrdqssghrl`qjdqadenqdsgdMDFl`qjdqnesgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdr+ntq
139
`tsnrdfldms`kqdoqdrdms`shnmvntkc`ood`q`radknvnmbdsgdmnql`ksnmd
l`oohmfqtkdg`cnodq`sdc'sgdMDFl`qjdqhrhmchb`sdcax!M!nmsgdrxkk`ahb
shdq(9
(250) # M # N #
# L H L # L #
Mnv+aftersgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdrg`udnodq`sdc+`k`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`k
qtkd'rdd'470(adknv(bg`mfdrsgdk`rs`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdnesgdO0l`qjdq'L(
sn`onk`qsnmd'vghbghrrodbhehdc`r`GsnmdadenqdsgdenkknvhmfKsnmd(and
cdkdsdrsgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdvghbgbnmmdbsrsghrsnmdsnsgdl`qjdq'L(+`r
adknv9
(251) # M # N #
# L H L # L #
-[T
Sgdnmkxqdl`hmhmfqtkdsn`eedbssghro`qshbtk`qcdqhu`shnmhrntqk`sd
cnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgknvdqrsgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbg`ssgdekn`shmfGsnmd+
qdrtkshmfhm`knvdqdcohsbgkdudk'3(nmsgdMDFl`qjdq'M(+`rhmsgd
enkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
140
(252) # M # N #
# L H H # L #
3 1 - 4
Mnvsg`svdg`udrddm`rsq`hfgsenqv`qccdqhu`shnmhmunkuhmfsgdO0
sdmrd+vd`qdhm`onrhshnmsndw`lhmdsgdlnqdhmsdqdrshmfdw`lokdr
vgdqdsgdO0l`qjdqchqdbskxoqdbdcdr`udqaqnnsl`qjdcenqqd`khrlncd+
`rhmsgdenkknvhmfonrhshudmnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshuddw`lokdr9
3 31 2 4 4 (earlier today)
3 31 3 5 5 (earlier today)
Sgdsnmdrhmenbtrhmsgdmdwssvncdqhu`shnmr`qdsgdcnvmrsdoodcG
snmdnmsgd'tmcdqkhmdc(Gsnmdudqaqnns`mcsgddouble-downstepped
H tonenmsgd'tmcdqkhmdc(Ksnmdudqaqnns-Sgntfgsgdcntakd,
cnvmrsdoodcsnmdhrpthsdq`qd+vdrg`kkdw`lhmdsgdehqrsrdmsdmbdnesgd
oqdbdchmfdw`lokdsnfds`eddkhmfnesgde`bsnqrhmunkudc-Sgd
`tsnrdfldms`krsqtbstqdenqsgdehqrsrdmsdmbdvntkc`ood`q`radknv`esdq
sgdqd`khronk`qsnmdg`raddmhmrdqsdc`mcsgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`r
`ookhdc9
141
(254) # M # + V + I #
# L H L # L + H + L #
Sgdehqrssnmdqtkdsn`ookxsnsghro`ssdqmhrntqkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmd
snm`klnqogdldqtkd+vghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdekn`shmfKsnmdsnsgdehqrsrxkk`akdnm
hsrkdes`mcchr`rrnbh`sdrsgdehqrsnesgdsgd`ci`bdms`rrnbh`sdcsnmdr`kqd`cx
entmcsgdqd+`radknv9
(255) # M # + V + I #
# L H L # L + H + L #
Hshrnmkxmnv+`esdqsgdsnmdqtkdrg`udnodq`sdc+sg`sntqk`sdlnqogn,
snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'470(adknv(cdkdsdr`mxekn`shmfsnmdrhmsdqm`ksnsgd
l`qjdq+bg`mfdrsgdehm`kKsnmdhmsn`onk`qsnmd'vghbgg`oodmrsnrs`xKhm
sghro`ssdqmadb`trdnesgdenkknvhmfGsnmd(+`mcchr`rrnbh`sdrsg`sonk`qsnmd
eqnlhsrrxkk`akd'L(+`radknv9
(256) # M # + V + I #
# L H L # L + H + L #
Ø -[T
142
Sgdnmkxqtkdvghbgrshkk`ookhdrsnntqo`ssdqmhrntqk`sdcnvmrsdo
qtkd+vghbgknvdqrsgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbgvgdqdsgdnmdekn`shmfK
snmdqdl`hmr+`radknv9
(257) # M # + V + I #
# L H # L + H + L #
3 1 - 2 4
Vdb`mmnvdw`lhmdsgdo`q`kkdkO0bnmrsqtbshnmvgdqdtmcdqkxhmfK
snmdudqaqnnsr`qdqd`khydcnmsgdrtqe`bd`rdouble-downstepped H
snmdr-Sgdrdb`rdrnecntakd,cnvmrsdoodcGsnmdrcdqhudeqnlKsnmd
udqaqnnsrvghbg`qdsgdqdrtksnentqqhfgsv`qc`rrnbh`shmfGsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldqtkd-Sghrqtkd`rrnbh`sdrsgdekn`shmfGsnmdsnsgdehqrs
rxkk`akdnmhsrqhfgs`mcchr`rrnbh`sdrsgdKsnmdentmcsgdqd+`rhmsgd
enkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
(258) # M # + V + I #
# L H L # H + L + L #
@ssghronhmshmntqcdqhu`shnm+hshrbqtbh`ksg`ssgdmnvchr`rrnbh`sdc
Ksnmdadeqnmsdcaxsgdlds`sgdrhrqtkd-Hshroqdbhrdkxadb`trdntq
tmcdqkxhmfO0sdmrdl`qjdq'L(dmcrhm`m`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdsg`ssgd
lds`sgdrhrqtkdhr`akdsnnodq`sd+qdrtkshmfhmsgdenkknvhmf9
143
(259) # M # + V + I #
# L H L # H + L + L #
Mnvsg`ssgdlds`sgdrhrqtkdg`rnodq`sdc+ntqk`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd
bg`mfdrsg`soqdbdchmfbnmchshnmhmf`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdsn`onk`qsnmd',√S(`mc
chr`rrnbh`sdrsghrsnmdeqnlsgdsdmrdl`qjdq'L(-Hshrbqtbh`k`ssghronhmssg`s
onk`qsnmdrhmMfxdla——m`qd`kv`xrcdsdqlhmdcsnadsgdnoonrhsdnesgd
hlldch`sdkxenkknvhmfassociatedsnmd+notne`mxhmsdqldch`sdekn`shmf
snmdr-Hmsgdo`ssdqmtmcdqdw`lhm`shnm+sgdonk`qsnmdsgtradbnldr`ekn`shmf
Ksnmdadb`trdsgdudqaqnnshr`rrnbh`sdcsn`Gsnmd`ssghronhmshmsgd
cdqhu`shnm+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
(260) # M # + V + I #
# L H L # L H + + L #
-[T
Vdmnvg`udtwoekn`shmfKsnmdroqdbdchmfsgd`rrnbh`sdcGsnmdnesgd
udqaqnns-@bbnqchmfsnntq`m`kxrhr+hshroqdbhrdkxsghrltkshokhbhsxneekn`shmf
snmdrsg`shrsgdb`trdnesgdo`q`kkdkltkshokhbhsxnecnvmrsdo-Hmnqcdqsn
144
b`ostqdsghrqdk`shnmrghoadsvddmsgdmtladqneekn`shmfonk`qsnmdr`mcsgd
mtladqneohsbgkdudkrsgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqhrknvdqdc+vdltrsqduhrdntq
cnvmrsdoqtkd'rs`sdcehqrshmoqdkhlhm`qxenqlhm'07(`anud(+`radknv9
+ਫ pitch
(-[T)ਫ [T
Sghrqtkdr`xrsg`ssgdsnmdqdfhrsdqhrknvdqdcsgdr`ldmtladq'ਫ(ne
rsdor'`ccnmdohsbgkdudkenqd`bgrsdoknvdqdc(`rsgdmtladq'ਫ(ne
ekn`shmfonk`qsnmdr',√S(vghbgoqdbdcd`fhudm`rrnbh`sdcsnmd'√S(-
Sghrqtkdknvdqrsgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqsvnmnsbgdrhmsgdoqdrdmscdqhu`shnm+`
knvdqhmfsg`shrudqhehdcaxnardquhmfsg`ssgdohsbgkdudknesgdehm`kK
snmdhr'4(hmsgdrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmrgnvmadknv9
(262) # M # + V + I #
# L H L # L H + + L #
3 1 - 3 - 5 -
Mnvsg`svdg`uddw`lhmdcsgd!qdftk`q!adg`uhnqnesgdO0sdmrd
l`qjdq+vd`qdqd`cxsndw`lhmdsgdrodbh`ksnm`koqnodqshdrnesgdO0
onrhshudodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnm-SgdO0positive perfective
145
rdmsdmbdr+hmbnmsq`rssnnsgdqO0bnmrsqtbshnmr+bnms`hmansgsgdsnm`k
oqnodqshdr`mchmsdqudmhmfm`r`koqdehwsg`shrbg`q`bsdqhrshbneo`q`kkdkO/
bnmrdbtshudrdmsdmbdr-NtqO0onrhshudodqedbshudrdmsdmbdr`qdsgd
enkknvhmf9
3 31 2 5 (earlier today)
3 31 4 5 (earlier today)
Gxl`m'0860(chrbtrrdrsgdbnmrdbtshududqabnmrsqtbshnmbnllnmsn
Fq`rrehdkcrA`mstk`mft`fdr`mcsgdhmsdqudmhmfm`r`kbnmrnm`msvghbg
nbbtqradsvddmsgdsvnudqarhmqd`khrbnmrdbtshudbnmrsqtbshnmr-SgdO/
bnmrdbtshududqabnmrsqtbshnmrvghbg`qdo`q`kkdksnsgdO0bnmrsqtbshnmr
rddm`anud`krnmdtsq`khydsgdsnm`kbnmsq`rsadsvddmsgd'tmcdqkhmdc(
ehqrsudqarhm`bnmrdbtshududqabnmrsqtbshnm+`radknv'trhmfsgdGsnmd
udqa.bvnæœ.!snbnldcnvm!`mcsgdKsnmdudqa.oxt∆.!snfnto!(9
(264) aL cwoNB nzKaY mbMab "he came down and cut the meat"
3 31 2 5
3 31 4 5
146
Nmdv`xnecdqhuhmfntqrodbh`kO0rdmsdmbdrhritrssng`ud`m
d`qkxqtkdvghbgbnmudqsrsgdO0l`qjdqhmsn`O/udqahm`bnmrdbtshud
udqabnmrsqtbshnm-Rhmbdsgdudqa`mcsgdl`qjdqvntkcmnsg`udsgdr`ld
kdwhb`ksnmdr+gnvdudq+vdvhkkbgnnrd`rhlokdqldsgnc-Vdvhkkonrhs`
qtkdvghbglnudrsgdekn`shmfqd`khronk`qsnmd'O(eqnladenqdsgdudqasn
`esdqsgdudqaonlyhmsgdb`rdneO0onrhshudodqedbshudrdmsdmbdr-Sghr
qtkd'rdd'453(adknv(vntkcnodq`sd`radknv'vhsg`Ksnmdudqaqnns`r
`mdw`lokd(`esdqsgdmnql`ksnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`cnodq`sdc9
(265) n-
# M # Ø + V # A +
# L H L # H + L Ø # L +
-[T
Sgdr`ldlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbglnudrsgdonk`qsnmd`esdqsgd
udqaqnnssnmd`krnhmrdqsr`m`r`kbnmrnm`msoqdehw'rxlankhydcax`knvdqb`rd
!m!adb`trdhsb`mmns`rrnbh`sdsn`snmd(`rrnqsne`qdrtloshudl`qjdq+
l`qjhmfsgdonrhshnmhmsgdogq`rdeqnlvghbgsgdonk`qsnmdv`rlnudc-Nmbd
sgdonk`qsnmdg`raddmlnudc+hsb`madrodbhehdc`radhmfnenoonrhsdpt`khsx
nesgdhlldch`sdkxenkknvhmfsnmd+hmsghrb`rd`GsnmdadenqdsgdKsnmdnesgd
naidbsoqdehw'@(+`radknv9
147
(266) # M # n- + V + # A +
# L H L # + L + -[T # L +
@esdqsgdsnmdqtkdrg`udnodq`sdc+`k`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd
'470(adknv(bg`mfdrsgdk`rs`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdnesgdO0sdmrdl`qjdq
'L(sn`onk`qsnmd',√S(vghbgadbnldr`GsnmdadenqdsgdenkknvhmfK
snmd`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdudqaqnns'U(+`mchschr`rrnbh`sdrsg`ssnmdeqnlhsr
rxkk`akd+`radknv9
(267) # M # n- + V + # A +
# L H L # + L + H # L +
-[T
Sgdehm`kqtkdsnnodq`sdhmsghrcdqhu`shnmhrntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkd
vghbgnodq`sdrsvhbd-Ehqrs+hsknvdqrsgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbg
oqdbdchmfsgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akd'U(+sgdm`rdbnmcmnsbgoqdbdchmfsgd
naidbsoqdehwrxkk`akd'@(+`rhmsgdrtqe`bdqdoqdrdms`shnmadknv9
148
(268) # M # n- + V + # A +
# L H H # + L + H # L +
3 1 - 4 - 5
Sgdrodbh`kqtkdvghbglnudcsgdqd`khronk`qsnmd`esdqsgdudqaqnns
hmsghrbnmrsqtbshnmv`rsgdqdaxqdronmrhakdenqsgdcnvmrsdoadenqd`mc
`esdq`Ksnmdnmsgdudqaqnnshmrsd`cnesgdlnqd!qdftk`q!cntakd,
cnvmrsdoodcGsnmdrenqKsnmdudqaqnnsrhmO0bnmrsqtbshnmr-
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqrdbshnmnmrodbh`klnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdrvghbg
lnchexsgdsnmdrnmudqarsdlr`v`xeqnlsgddwodbsdcqd`khr`mchqqd`khr
snmdo`ssdqmrcdrbqhadchmsgdoqduhntrsvnrdbshnmr-Sgdqtkdrchrbtrrdc
hmenql`kkxhmsghrrdbshnm`qdenql`kkxrs`sdchmrdbshnm3-/-adknv-
149
2.3.4. With progressive aspect markers
Svnrdo`q`sdoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqrnbbtqhmMfxdla——m9sgdmnql`k
.md∆.`mcsgdqd`khr.rrdæ∫.-Sgdrdsvnl`qjdqrnbb`rhnm`kkxtmcdqfnsnm`k
odqstqa`shnmr-Vdvhkkqduhrdadknvntqe`lhkh`qsdmrd.lncdsnm`kbg`qssn
enbtrnmsgdsnm`kqd`khy`shnmneoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqr-Rhmbdnmkxsgnrd
bnmrsqtbshnmrl`qjdcenqZ*oqnf\`qddkhfhakdenq`oqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq+
ntqbg`qsenqsgdl`qjdq.md∆.bnms`hmrnmkxsvnqnvr+nmdenqqd`khr`mc
nmdenqhqqd`khr+`radknv9
Features P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø F1 F2 F3 F4
-perf
+real L/L HL/L HL/L HL/L L/L
+prog
-perf
-real L/’L L/L L/L L/L L/L
+prog
@rrtlhmfsg`s`rhmfkdKsnmdhrsgdtmcdqkxhmfkdwhb`ksnmdne.md∆.+
vdb`me`bsnqntssgdqdftk`qKsnmdqd`khy`shnmr+kd`uhmfnmkxsgd
nbbtqqdmbdrnerodbh`kodqstqadcsnmdr+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfqduhrdcbg`qs9
150
Features P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø F1 F2 F3 F4
-perf
+real HL/ HL/ HL/
+prog
-perf
-real /’L
+prog
Dwok`hmhmfsgdoqdrdmbdnesgdGKcnvmfkhcdrnmsgd.md∆.l`qjdqhr
mnspthsd`rrhlokd`rhslhfgsrddleqnldw`lhmhmfsgdoqdbdchmfbg`qs-
Sgdqd`rnmsg`shshrlnqdbnlokhb`sdcsg`mitrsonrhshmfsgd`cchshnmne
`m`rrnbh`sdcGsnmdhmsgdb`rdneo`rsoqnfqdrrhudonrhshudrdmsdmbdrhr
sg`s`rhlhk`q`rrnbh`sdcGsnmdnbbtqrhmsgdo`q`kkdkmdf`shudrdmsdmbdr
dwbdossghrshldhshr`rrnbh`sdcsnsgddmcnesgdMDFl`qjdq'tmcdqkhmdc
hmsgdenkknvhmfO2dw`lokdr(9
(271) aL laL neP nzaJYaL mbaLb "he was cutting the meat"
3 3 13 1 3 3
aL laL teN neL nzaJYaL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t cutting the meat"
3 3 31 3 1 3 3 1
RhmbdsgdMDFl`qjdq.sd∆.hlldch`sdkxoqdbdcdrsgdoqnfqdrrhud
l`qjdq.md∆.+hsrddlrsg`shmmnm,etstqdrdmsdmbdrvhsghlodqedbshud
`rodbs+`Gsnmdlnqogdldhr`ccdcadsvddmsgdMDF.sd∆.`mcsgd
151
oqnfqdrrhud.md∆.-Rhmbdsghronrhshnmhrsgdr`ld`rsgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhud
.rrdæ∫.cdrbqhadcadknv+`mcsghrqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqb`mbnnbbtq
vhsgsgdMDF.sd∆.`mc.nqsgdoqnfqdrrhud.md∆.atshsneverg`rsghr
`cchshnm`kGsnmdlnqogdldhmsgdr`ldrdmsdmbd+sghrGsnmdlnqogdld
ltrsadknb`sdchmsgdr`ldonrhshnm`rsgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhud.rrdæ∫.+`mc
nmkxnmdnesgd!lnqogdldr!hmsg`sonrhshnmb`mnbbtqhm`mxnmd
rdmsdmbd-
Hm`cchshnmsn`lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbgvhkkhmrdqs`Gsnmd
vnqcadsvddm.sd∆.`mc.md∆.hmsgd`ardmbdne.rrdæ∫.'`mchmsgd`ardmbdne
`etstqdl`qjdqkhjdsgd.k`æù.trdcsnrhfm`kO3sdmrd(+rdo`q`sdlnqogn,
snmnknfhb`kqtkdrvhkkg`udsnadonrhsdcsn`rrnbh`sdsghrsnmdvhsgsgd
.md∆.hmonrhshudrdmsdmbdr`mcvhsgsgd.sd∆.hmmdf`shudrdmsdmbdr-Rhmbd
sgdoqnfqdrrhud.md∆.hrhmenbtrhmsghrrdbshnm+vdonrhssgdenkknvhmf
qdoqdrdms`shnmne`onrhshudo`rssdmrdvhsghlodqedbshud`rodbs'vhsgsgd
rxlank!O!trdcsnrhfm`ksgdfdmdq`kpqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq.md∆.nmsgd
rxkk`ahbshdq(9
(272) # P # + V + I #
# L # L + H + L #
Sgdehqrslnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'45/(adknv(snnodq`sdqdk`shud
snoqnfqdrrhudl`qjhmfvntkc`ccntqGsnmdsnm`kvnqcadenqdsgd
oqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq+`rrgnvmadknv9
152
(273) # # P # + V + I #
# Ø # L # L + H + L #
@rdo`q`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'456(adknv(vntkcsgdmbnld
`knmf`mc`rrnbh`sdsgdGsnmdsnm`kvnqc'hmsgd`ardmbdnesgdMDF.sd∆.(sn
sgdoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq'O(+`radknv9
(274) # # P # + V + I #
# H # L # L + H + L #
Ehm`kkx+sgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdrvhkkbnldhmsnok`x`mcsgdonk`qsnmdqd`khr
oqdehwnmsgdudqaqnns+vghbghr`KsnmdadenqdsgdGsnmdnesgdkdwhb`kudqa+
vhkk`rrnbh`sdsnsgdkdesaxntqkdesv`qc`rrnbh`shmfsnm`klnqogdldqtkdvghkd
`krnchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdKsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdr`ldrxkk`akd'O(+`r
adknv9
(275) # # P # + V + I #
# H # L # L + H + L #
Rhmbdsgdekn`shmfKsnmdadenqdsgd`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdcndrmnssqhffdqntq
qdfhrsdq,knvdqhmfcnvmrsdoqtkd+mnnsgdqqtkdnodq`sdrnmntqo`ssdqm`mcsgd
rtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmhrbnqqdbs+`radknv9
153
(276) # # P # + V + I #
# H # L # L + H + L #
1 3 - 1 - 3
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqknnj`ssgdonrhshudo`rsrdmsdmbdrvgdqdntq
onrhsdcGsnmdsnm`kvnqc`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdqhfgs-O`q`kkdkmdf`shud
rdmsdmbdrvgdqdsgdr`ldGsnmdsnm`kvnqc`rrnbh`sdrsnsgdkdes`qd
cdrbqhadchmcds`hkhmsgdenkknvhmfrdbshnm-
Sgdnmdqdl`hmhmftmtrt`ksnm`ko`ssdqmnmsgdfdmdq`koqnfqdrrhud
l`qjdq.md∆.hrvgdmhshrqd`khydcnm`cnvmrsdoodcKsnmdhmmdf`shud
oqdrdmshqqd`khroqnfqdrrhudrdmsdmbdr-@bst`kkx+sgdoqnbdrrhrrkhfgskx
lnqdbnlokhb`sdcsg`mitrssgdhmrdqshnmne`mtmdwodbsdccnvmrsdo
ed`stqd+`rsgdenkknvhmfonrhshud`mcqdrodbshudmdf`shuddw`lokdrrgnv9
31 3 2 5 5
aL teL nMe zKaYMa mbaLb wDJ "he probably isn’t cutting meat"
3 3 4 3 6 6 4
Rdudq`ksghmfrrgntkcadmnshbdchmsgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdr-Ehqrs+sgd
onrhshudrdmsdmbdhrtmtrt`khmsg`shsbnms`hmr`KGqhrhmfsnmdnmsgd
'tmcdqkhmdc(rtaidbsoqnmntm-Sgdmdf`shudrdmsdmbdhrtmtrt`khmsg`shs
154
bnms`hmr`mtmdwodbsdccnvmrsdonmsgdoqnfqdrrhud.md∆.-Vg`shr
drodbh`kkxhmsdqdrshmfhrsg`sansgsgdrdb`rdrmddcsng`ud`m`cchshnm`kG
snmdsnm`kvnqconrhsdcadsvddmsgdMDF.sd∆.`mcsgdoqnfqdrrhud.md∆.+
dw`bskxkhjdsgdtmtrt`kqd`khrrdmsdmbdrdw`lhmdc`anud-Gnvdudq+
sgntfgsgdsnm`kvnqcl`xadsgdr`ld`mchmsgdr`ldonrhshnm+sgdsnmd
qd`bsrpthsdcheedqdmskxhmsgdrdhqqd`khrrdmsdmbdrsg`mhmsgdhqqdftk`q
qd`khrrdmsdmbdrdw`lhmdc`anud-
Adfhmmhmfvhsgsgdonrhshuddw`lokd'`mctrhmfsgdrxlank!R!sn
hmchb`sdsgdrtaidbsoqnmntmnmsgdrxkk`ahbshdq(+ntqqdoqdrdms`shnm
vntkc`ood`q`radknv`esdqsgdkdwhb`kdmsqhdr`mcsgdsnmdl`oohmfqtkd9
(278) # S # P # V + I #
# L # L # H + L #
Hevdmnvhmrdqssgdr`ldGsnmdsnm`kvnqchlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmf
sgdoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq.md∆.+ntqo`ssdqmadbnldrsgdenkknvhmf9
(279) # S # # P # V + I #
# L # Ø # L # H + L #
Hsltrsmnvadrsqdrrdcsg`svdmddc`lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbg
`rrnbh`sdrsghrGsnmdsnm`kvnqcsnsgdkdeshmsghrhqqd`khrrdmsdmbd+oqdbhrdkx
155
sgdoppositechqdbshnmsg`svdr`vhs`rrnbh`sdchmonrhshudqd`khrrdmsdmbdr
`anud-Sghr`rrnbh`shnmsnsgdkdes`krns`jdrok`bdvhsgntschr`rrnbh`shmfsgd
snmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcnmsgdrxkk`akdentmc+`radknv9
(280) # S # # P # V + I #
# L # H # L # H + L #
@ssghronhms+ntqmnql`ksnm`kqtkdrehmcmnsghmfsnnodq`sdnm`mc`k`sd
lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'47/(adknv(hmrdqsrsvnekn`shmfonk`qsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldr+nmdadenqd`mc`mnsgdq`esdqsgdudqaqnns+`radknv9
(281) # S # # P # + V + + I #
# L # H # L # Ø + H + Ø + L #
-[T -[T
L H
Rhmbdvdmnvg`udsvnok`bdrvgdqdekn`shmfsnmdroqdbdcdsgdhqnoonrhsd
`rrnbh`sdcsnmdr+ntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdhrsqhffdqdcsvhbd+knvdqhmfsgdsnm`k
qdfhrsdqnmdmnsbgd`bgshld-Sghrknvdqhmfqdrtksrhmsgdbnqqdbsrtqe`bd
qd`khy`shnm+`rrgnvmadknv9
156
(282) # S # # P # + V + + I #
# L # H # L # L + H + H + L #
3 1 - 3 - 2 - 5
Sgdo`q`kkdkmdf`shuddw`lokdr`qdrkhfgskxlnqdbnlokhb`sdc-Ntq
a`rhbbnmrsqtbshnmhmbktchmfkdwhb`kdmsqhdr`ood`qr`radknv`esdqntq
kdes,sn,qhfgssnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(283) # S # N # P # V + I #
# L # L # L # H + L #
Nmbd`f`hm+ntqGsnmdsnm`kvnqchrhmrdqsdcadsvddmsgdmdf`shud
l`qjdq'M(`mcsgdoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq'O(+`radknv9
(284) # S # N # # P # V + I #
# L # L # Ø # L # H + L #
Mnvhmo`q`kkdkqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr+rtbg`Gsnmdsnm`kvnqcv`r
`rrnbh`sdcaxlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdsnsgdMDFl`qjdqnmhsrkdes-Hm
sgdrdo`q`kkdkirqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr+gnvdudq+sgdekn`shmfGsnmdhrkdes
tm`rrnbh`sdc-Hm`cchshnm+sgdqhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfGsnmdsnm`klnqogdld
qtkdvghbglhfgsaddwodbsdcsn`ookxsnsghrekn`shmfGsnmdlnrs
157
cdehmhsdkxcndrnot`ookx-Hs`ood`qrsg`sntqqhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfGsnmd
snm`klnqogdldqtkdvhkknmkxnodq`sd`bqnrrlnqogdldantmc`qhdr`mc
mns`bqnrrsgdrsqnmfdqvnqcantmc`qxsg`svdg`udonrhsdcgdqd-
Sgdmdwsqtkdsnnodq`sdnmsgdcdqhu`shnmhmenbtrhrntqk`sdhqqd`khr
lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbghmrdqsrsvnekn`shmfonk`qsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldr+nmdadenqd`mc`mnsgdq`esdqsgdudqaqnns+`radknv9
(285) # S # N # # P # + V + + I #
# L # L # H # L # Ø + H + Ø + L #
-[T -[T
L H
Ntqo`ssdqmmnvbnms`hmrsgqddekn`shmfsnmdr+d`bgnesgdloqdbdchmf`m
`rrnbh`sdcsnmdnenoonrhsdpt`khsx-Sgdrdekn`shmfsnmdrsgdqdenqdsqhffdqntq
qdfhrsdq,knvdqhmfcnvmrsdoqtkdsgqddrdo`q`sdshldr+knvdqhmfsgdqdfhrsdqnmd
mnsbgd`bgshldvghbgxhdkcrsgdbnqqdbsrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmrgnvmadknv9
(286) # S # N # # P # + V + + I #
# L # L # H # L # L + H + H + L #
3 - 3 - 4 - 3 - 6
158
Sghrbnmbktcdrntq`m`kxrhrnesgnrdbnmrsqtbshnmrvghbglnchex
sgdmnql`kkdwhb`kKsnmdentmcnmsgdfdmdq`koqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq
.md∆.-Mnvvdb`mdw`lhmdsgd`ksdqm`shudoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqhmqd`khr
bnmrsqtbshnmr+.rrdæ∫.+vghbgb`mdhsgdqqdok`bdnqnbbtqvhsgsgd
qdftk`qoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq.md∆.-Gnvdudq+rhmbd.rrdæ∫.hrqd`khr+hs
b`mnmkxnbbtqhmqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr+`mcvdsgdqdenqdg`udnmkx`
rhmfkdqd`khrqnvhmsgdenkknvhmfbg`qs9
Features P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø Futures
-perf
+real H’/H’ H’/H’ H’/H’ H’/H’ ’H/H’
+prog
@rrtlhmfsg`ssgdqdftk`qtmodqstqadcsnm`ko`ssdqmneZrrdæ∫\hr`G
snmdenkknvdcax`cnvmrsdoed`stqd+vdb`me`bsnqntssgnrdo`ssdqmr
kd`uhmfnmkxnmddwbdoshnm`ko`ssdqm'sgdonrhshudoqdrdmsoqnfqdrrhud(hm
vghbgsgdsnmdg`raddmodqstqadc'cnvmrsdoadenqdsgdGsnmd(+`rhmsgd
enkknvhmfbg`qs9
159
'177(Qd`khrOqnfqdrrhud.rrdæ∫.OdqstqadcSnmdChrsqhatshnm
Features P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø Futures
-perf
+real ’H/
+prog
Hmsgdoqdbdchmfrdbshnm+ctqhmfntqchrbtrrhnmnesgdtmtrt`kO0sdmrd
l`qjdqvghbg`krnhrqd`khydcvhsg`Gsnmdenkknvdcax`cnvmrsdoodc
snmd+vdr`vsg`s`bnlokdw`m`kxrhrv`rmdbdrr`qx+onrhshmfansg`m
tmcdqkxhmfl`qjdqand`k`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbglnchehdr
sg`sl`qjdq-Sgdkdwhb`kdmsqxenqsgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqvhkk
sgdqdenqdadsgdenkknvhmf'vhsgsgdrxlank!Q!hmchb`shmfsgdl`qjdqnm
sgdrxkk`ahbshdq(9
# R #
# H L #
Nmbd`f`hm+sgdsnmdrnesghrbnlokdwl`qjdq`qd`rrnbh`sdcvhsgsgd
rxkk`akdhmsgdkdwhb`kdmsqxrhmbdntqsnmdl`oohmfqtkdvntkcmns
`rrnbh`sdansgsnmdrvhsgsgdr`ldrxkk`akdnmsgdrxkk`ahbshdq-Axld`mr
nerhlhk`qcdqhu`shnmr+sgdoqdbdchmfl`qjdq`knmfvhsghsr`rrnbh`sdc
lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdqdrtkshmsgdenkknvhmfrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmr+
160
hmbktchmfsgdq`qd'tmcdqkhmdc(cntakd,cnvmrsdoodcGsnmdnmsgdudqa
qnns9
(290) aL laL sseJ nzKaYaL mbaLb "he isn’t cutting the meat"
3 3 1 2 4 4
3 3 1 3 5 5
Sgdehqrsdw`lokd`anudrgnvrsgdcnvmrsdo`esdqsgdqd`khr
oqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqadhmfqd`khydcnmsgdudqaqnns-Sgdrdbnmcdw`lokd
rgnvrsgdr`ldkdwhb`kcnvmrsdocntakhmftovhsg`cdqhudccnvmrsdonm
`m'tmcdqkhmdc(Ksnmdudqaqnnssnoqnctbd`cntakd,cnvmrsdoodcGsnmd-
Sgdqd`khsxsg`shshrhme`bs`cntakd,cnvmrsdoodcGsnmd`mcmns`
mnql`kKsnmdhrrgnvmaxsgdognmdshbkdudk'4(nesgdenkknvhmfKsnmd
udqarteehw-Ntqqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq`mchsrenkknvhmf'tmcdqkhmdc(
udqaqnns`anudvntkcadfhmsgdhqcdqhu`shnm`radknv9
(291) # R # + V + I #
# H L # H + L + L #
@ssghrshld+oqnbddchmfeqnlkdessnqhfgsenqntqmnql`ksnmdqtkdr+
sgdGsnmdsnm`klnqogdldvntkccnbjsnsgdqhfgsvghkdchr`rrnbh`shmf
sgdKsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdudqaqnns+`radknv9
161
(292) # R # + V + I #
# H L # H + L + L #
Rhmbdntqqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq'Q(dmcrvhsg`m`rrnbh`sdcKsnmd`s
sghronhmshmsgdcdqhu`shnm+sgdmnvchr`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdeqnlsgdudqaqnns
rxkk`akd'U(hreqnmsdcaxsgdlds`sgdrhrqtkd+`radknv9
(293) # R # + V + I #
# H L # H + L + L #
Hshr`ssghronhmssg`sntqk`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdnodq`sdrnmsgdqd`khr
oqnfqdrrhudrxkk`akd'R(+bg`mfhmfsgdehm`k`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdsn`onk`qsnmd`mc
chr`rrnbh`shmfsghronk`qsnmdeqnlsgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudrxkk`akd-Nmbd`f`hm+
sgdonk`qsnmd',√S(adbnldr`Ksnmdrhmbdhshrrodbhehdc`radhmfnoonrhsdne
sgdehqrsassociatedsnmdnmhsrqhfgs-Sghrlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdsgtr
`bbnlokhrgdrsgdenkknvhmf9
(294) # R # + V + I #
# H L # L H + + L #
-[T
162
Nmbd`f`hm+vdg`udtwoekn`shmfKsnmdroqdbdchmf`m`rrnbh`sdcG
snmd-Sghrhrbg`mfdcaxntqqduhrdccnvmrsdoqtkdhmsn`double,
cnvmrsdo'nmdenqd`bgekn`shmfonk`qsnmd(vghbgknvdqrsgdsnm`k
qdfhrsdqtwomnsbgdrhlldch`sdkxadenqdsgdGsnmd`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdudqa
qnns-Sgdrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmhrsgdqdenqdsgdenkknvhmf9
(295) # R # + V + I #
# H L # L H + + L #
1 - 3 - 5
Hsrgntkcadmnshbdcsg`sansgsgdrxkk`akdrqd`khydcnmohsbgkdudk'0(
`mc'2(`anud`qdhighsnmdr+`mnardqu`shnmbnmehqldcaxsgdenkknvhmf
Ksnmdadhmfqd`khydcnmohsbgkdudk'4(-SgdrdbnmcnesgdGsnmdrhrsgtr
cntakd,cnvmrsdoodc+`ogdmnldmnm`bghdudchmMfxdla——mnmkxaxsgd
q`qdbn,nbbtqqdmbdnesvnekn`shmfrhlhk`qsnmdroqdbdchmf`m`rrnbh`sdc
snmdnenoonrhsdpt`khsx-Ekn`shmfsnmdrnertbgpt`khsxnmkxbnld
snfdsgdqhlldch`sdkxenkknvhmfdhsgdqnesvnfq`ll`shb`kl`qjdqr9sgdO0
sdmrdl`qjdqnqsgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq-Sgdrd`qdoqdbhrdkxsgdsvn
l`qjdqrvghbgtmcdqfnsgdk`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbgbg`mfdr`
ehm`k`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdhmsn`ekn`shmfonk`qsnmd-
Mnvsg`svdg`udrddmsgdtmtrt`kbg`q`bsdqne!mnql`k!qd`khr
oqnfqdrrhudbnmrsqtbshnmr+vd`qdoqdo`qdcsndw`lhmdsgdnmdb`rdvgdqd
sgddwodbsdcsnmdr`qdetqsgdqbg`mfdc+m`ldkxhmsgdonrhshudoqdrdms
163
oqnfqdrrhudbnmrsqtbshnm+rgnvmsnfdsgdqvhsghsrsnm`kkx!qdftk`q!
mdf`shudbntmsdqo`qsadknv9
1 2 2 4 4
aL teL sseJ nzKaYaL mbaLb wDJ "he isn’t cutting the meat"
3 3 1 2 4 4 2
Sgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrb`m`krnqdbdhud`m`cchshnm`koqnfqdrrhud
.md∆.vhsgntsbg`mfhmfsgdld`mhmfnesgdrdmsdmbdr-Hmsghrb`rd+sgd
tmtrt`ksnmdrnmsgdrtaidbs`mcqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqqdl`hm
odqstqadc+dudmsgntfgsgdl`qjdqhrenkknvdcax`Ksnmd+`radknv9
1 2 4 2 4 4
3 3 1 4 2 4 4 2
Sgdtmtrt`ksnm`kodqstqa`shnmhmsgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrhrsg`ssgd
rtaidbsnesgdonrhshudrdmsdmbdadbnldr`Gsnmd`mcsgdcnvmrsdo
mnql`kkx`rrnbh`sdcvhsgsgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqprecedessg`s
l`qjdqhmrsd`cneenkknvhmfhs-Hsvntkc`ood`qsg`ssghrhchnrxmbq`shb
ed`stqdnesgdMfxdla——mudqa`kogq`rdb`madrsadg`mckdc
164
rxmbgqnmhb`kkxaxonrhshmf`m`cchshnm`klnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd-Sgd
hmotssnrtbg`qtkdvntkcadrdmsdmbdrvhsgsgdenkknvhmfjhmcne
tmcdqkxhmfrsqtbstqd9
(298) # S # R # + V + I #
# L # H L # L + H + L #
Sgdnmkxsnmdqtkdsn`ookxsnsghrrsqtbstqdhrsgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfK
snmdsnm`klnqgodldqtkd+vghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdekn`shmfKsnmdsnsgdehqrs
rxkk`akd'Q(nmhsrkdesvghkdchr`rrnbh`shmfsgd'K(snmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdc
sgdqd+`radknv9
(299) # S # R # + V + I #
# L # H L # L + H + L #
Mdws+aftersgdsnmdqtkdrg`udnodq`sdc+vdvntkconrhs`k`sd
lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'457(adknv(vghbgvntkccdkdsdbnlokdsdkx
sgdrtaidbsoqnmntm&rsnmd'K(+qd`rrnbh`sdsgdGsnmdnesgdqd`khr
oqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq'Q(snsgdmnvsnmdkdrrrtaidbsoqnmntm'R(+`mc
bnmudqssgdehm`k`rrnbh`sdcsnmdnesgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq'Q(sn`
Gsnmd+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
165
(300) # S # R # + V + I #
# L # H L # L + H + L #
Ø -[T
Sgdo`ssdqmhmptdrshnmhrmnvqd`khydcvhsgsgdtmtrt`krtqe`bd
o`ssdqmnesghro`qshbtk`qbnmrsqtbshnm+vhsgsgdcnvmrsdoed`stqd
oqdbdchmfhmrsd`cneenkknvhmfsgdsnmdnmsgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudrxkk`akd
'R(+`radknv9
(301) # S # R # + V + I #
# # H L # H + H + L #
1- 2 - 2 - 4 -
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqrdbshnmnmsgdhchnrxmbq`shbsnm`kodqstqa`shnmr
sg`snbb`rhnm`kkxrgnvtovhsgdhsgdqnentqsvnoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqr-
166
Svnrdo`q`sdmdf`shudl`qjdqrnbbtqhmMfxdla——m9sgdmnql`k.sd∆.
l`qjdq`mcsgdtmtrt`konrhshudqd`khrodqedbshudydqn'O/(mdf`shud
l`qjdq.j`∆.-RhmbdsgdO/.j`∆.nmkxnbbtqrhmnmdbnmrsqtbshnmhmvghbghsr
rtqe`bdsnmdhr`kv`xrK+vd`rrtldsghrKsnmdsnadhsrtmcdqkxhmf
kdwhb`ksnmd`mccnmnsmddcsndw`lhmd`mxsnm`kodqstqa`shnmr-Sgd.sd∆.
mdf`shud+nmsgdnsgdqg`mc+nbb`rhnm`kkxtmcdqfndr`bg`mfdnehsrsnmd
adenqdhshrqd`khydcnmsgdrtqe`bd-Sgd`bst`krtqe`bdsnmdrnesgd.sd∆.
'`mc.j`∆.hmo`qdmsgdrdr(l`qjdqr`qdrgnvmhmsgdenkknvhmfbg`qs9
167
(302) Negative /te</ (/ka</) Tone Distribution
Features P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø F1 F2 F3 F4
+perf L L L L (L)
+real
-perf
+real L L L LH LH
-prog
-perf
+real L LH LH LH LH
+prog
+perf LH L L L
-real
-perf
-real L LH L L L
-prog
-perf
-real L LH L L L
+prog
168
@rrtlhmfsg`s`rhmfkdKsnmdhrsgdtmcdqkxhmfkdwhb`ksnmdne.sd∆.+vd
b`me`bsnqntssgdqdftk`qKsnmdqd`khy`shnmrkd`uhmfnmkxsgdnbbtqqdmbdr
nerodbh`kodqstqadcsnmdrnmsghrl`qjdq+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfqduhrdc
bg`qs9
Features P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø F1 F2 F3 F4
-perf
+real LH LH
-prog
-perf
+real LH LH LH LH
+prog
+perf LH
-real
-perf
-real LH
-prog
-perf
-real LH
+prog
169
Rdudq`knesgdodqstqadcsnmdrnmMDFl`qjdqr`qdsgdqdrtksnesgdG
snmdsnm`kvnqcchrbtrrdchmsgdoqduhntrrdbshnm-Sgda`rhrenqonrhshmf
rtbg`snm`kvnqc`qdonrhshud.mdf`shudo`hqrkhjdsgdenkknvhmf9
3 3 13 1 3 3 (yesterday)
aL laL teN neL nduJmteL mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t bite the meat"
3 3 31 3 1 3 3 1 (yesterday)
Rhmbdvdb`mrgnveqnll`mxnsgdqdw`lokdrsg`ssgdtmcdqkxhmf
kdwhb`ksnmdrnmansgsgdMDF.sd∆.`mcoqnfqdrrhud.md∆.l`qjdqr`qd
cdehmhsdkxK+sgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrrddlsnbnms`hm`ekn`shmfGsnmd
adsvddmsgdMDF`mcoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqrvghbgcnbjrnmsnsgddmcne
sgdMDF.sd∆.vgdmhshroqdrdmsatsnmsnsgdoqnfqdrrhud.md∆.vgdmsgd
MDFhr`ardms-Sgtr+ansgsgdtmcdqkhmdcGKe`kkhmfsnmdhmsgdonrhshud
rdmsdmbd+`mcsgdtmcdqkhmdcKGqhrhmfsnmdhmhsrmdf`shudbntmsdqo`qs
qdrtkseqnlsgdr`ldtmcdqkxhmfsnmd-RhmbdsgdGKe`kkhmfsnmdv`r
chrbtrrdchmcds`hkhmsgdoqduhntrrdbshnm+vdvhkkdw`lhmdgdqdnmkxsgd
KGqhrhmfsnmdvghbghrqd`khydcnmsgdMDFl`qjdq-
Adenqddw`lhmhmfhmcds`hksgdcdqhu`shnmnertbg`odqstqadcqhrhmf
snmd+hsrchrsqhatshnmrgntkcadldmshnmdc-@rrddmeqnlsgdoqdbdchmf
bg`qs+lnrsnesgdKGqhrhmfsnmdrbntkcadoqdchbsdcaxonrhshmf`Gsnmd
snm`kvnqcenkknvhmfsgdMDFl`qjdqenqallqd`khrhlodqedbshud
170
rdmsdmbdrexceptsgnrdvghbgg`ud`m'hqqd`khr(etstqdl`qjdq'h-d-O3(nq
`qtkdvghbglnchehdrsgdudqasnmdr'h-d-O1`mcO2mnm,oqnfqdrrhud
hlodqedbshudr+cdrbqhadchmrdbshnm1-2-2-`anud(-Rtbg`qtkdvntkcs`jd
b`qdne`kksgdKGqhrhmfsnmdrhmqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmrhmntqbg`qs-
Vdb`mmnvdw`lhmdsgdcdqhu`shnmnesgdmdf`shudrdmsdmbdhmsgd
oqdbdchmfdw`lokd-Hsrtmcdqkxhmfkdwhb`krsqtbstqdvntkc`ood`q`radknv9
(305) # N # P # + V + S + #
# L # L # L + H + + L #
Rhmbdsgdcdqhu`shnmnesgdsnmdrnmsgdudqag`r`kqd`cxaddmchrbtrrdchm
cds`hkhmrdbshnm1-2-1-`anud+vdenbtrgdqdtonmsgdcdqhu`shnmnesgdsnmdrne
sgdMDFl`qjdq'M(`mcsgdoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq'O(-Sgdehqrsrsdohrsgd
hmrdqshnmaxlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdne`Gsnmdsnm`kvnqcadsvddmsgdrdsvn
l`qjdqr+`rchrbtrrdchmsgdoqdbdchmfrdbshnm`mc`rrgnvmadknv9
(306) # N # # P # + V + S + #
# L # Ø # L # L + H + + L #
RhmbdsgdMDFl`qjdq.sd∆.hroqdrdmshmsghrrdmsdmbd+`rdo`q`sdlnqogn,
snmnknfhb`kqtkd`rrnbh`sdrsgdGsnmdnesgdsnm`kvnqcsnsgdMDFrxkk`akd'M(
nmhsrkdes+`radknv9
171
(307) # N # # P # + V + S + #
# L # H # L # L + H + + L #
Sgdmdwssvnqtkdrsnnodq`sd`qdsgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdqd`khronk`qsnmdoqdbdchmfsgdudqaqnns
'U(+vghbghr`KsnmdadenqdsgdGsnmdnesghrqnns+snsgdoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq
nmhsrkdes+vghkdchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdKsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`mcsgd
VEQvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdsnmdkdrrrxkk`akd'R(snsgdehqrssnmdnmhsrkdes+`r
adknv9
(308) # N # # P # + V + S + #
# L # H # L # L + H + + L #
Sgdehm`kqtkdsnnodq`sdnmsghrcdqhu`shnmhrntqkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmd
snm`klnqogdldqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdehm`kekn`shmfKsnmdsnsgdRrxkk`akd
vghkdchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdGsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd-Sghrehm`kbg`mfd
qdrtksrhmsgdbnqqdbsrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnm+`radknv9
(309) # N # # P # + V + S + #
# L # H # L # L + H + + L #
3 1 - 3 - 1 - 3
172
Sgdoqdbdchmfcdqhu`shnmhrbg`q`bsdqhrshbne`kksgdKGqhrhmfsnmdr
vghbgnbbtqnmsgdMDFl`qjdqhmqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr-Sgdbg`qs`ssgd
adfhmmhmfnesghrrdbshnm`krnrgnvdcsg`stmtrt`kKGqhrhmfsnmdr`krn
nbbtqqdchmirqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr+snadrodbhehb+hmE0etstqd
bnmrsqtbshnmr-Sgdenkknvhmfo`hqneE0rdmsdmbdrrgnvrsg`ssgdqhrhmf
snmdhrmnsb`trdcaxsgdr`ldGsnmdsnm`klnqogdldadb`trdsgd
onrhshudrdmsdmbdcndrnotg`ud`GKe`kkhmfsnmdnmsgdoqnfqdrrhud.md∆.9
(310) aL geL neL zKaYMa mbaLb "he will be cutting the meat"
3 3 3 2 5 5 (later today)
aL teN ngeL neL zKaYMa mbaLb wDJ "he won’t be cutting the meat"
3 31 3 3 2 5 5 3 (later today)
Sgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrrgnvsgdoqdrdmbdne`m'tmcdqkhmdc(KG
qhrhmfsnmdnmsgdMDFl`qjdqand`mhlldch`sdkxenkknvhmfm`r`koqdehw
`eehwdcsnsgdsnc`xetstqdl`qjdq.fd∆.nmkxhmmdf`shudbnmrsqtbshnmr-
Vg`shrtmtrt`k`antsansgsgdqhrhmfsnmd`mcsgdm`r`koqdehwhrsg`ssgdx
`kv`xrnbbtqsnfdsgdq`mcsgdxnmkxnbbtqhmE0negativebnmrsqtbshnmr+
`kadhshmallE0mdf`shudbnmrsqtbshnmr-Vdsgdqdenqdonrhs`rhmfkd
lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbghmrdqsransg`m`r`koqdehw'k`adkkdcknvdq
b`rd!m!nmsgdrxkk`ahbshdqrhmbdhshrmns`etkksnmd,ad`qhmfrxkk`akd(`mc
`Gsnmdvghbghr`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdmdwsrxkk`akdnmhsrkdes'`kv`xrsgd
173
MDFl`qjdq.sd∆.rhmbdhshrnmkxhmmdf`shudE0bnmrsqtbshnmrsg`ssghrqtkd
hrsqhffdqdc(-Ntqkdwhb`kbnmrsqtbshnm`ood`qr`radknv'vhsg!E!l`qjhmf
sgdetstqdl`qjdqnmsgdrxkk`ahbshdq(beforesgdqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(311) # N # F # P #
# L # L # L #
Ntqlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'458(adknv(mnv`ookhdr`mc
hmrdqsr`m`r`koqdehw'rxlankhydcvhsg`knvdqb`rd!m!nmsgdrxkk`ahb
shdqrhmbdhsmdudqb`qqhdr`snmd(nmsgdetstqdl`qjdqvghkd`rrnbh`shmf
sgdGsnmdnesg`soqdehwa`bjsnsgdoqdbdchmfMDFl`qjdqnmhsrkdes+`r
adknv9
(312) n-
# N # Ø + F # P #
# L # Ø + L # L #
Rhmbdntqcnvmrsdoqtkdhrmnssqhffdqdchmsghro`qsnesgd
bnmrsqtbshnm+sgdrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmhrrsq`hfgsenqv`qc+`radknv9
174
(313) # N # n- + F # P #
# L # H + L # L #
3 1 - 3 - 3
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqrdbshnmnmmdf`shudl`qjdqr`mcsgdlnqogn,
snmnknfhb`kqtkdrvghbgnbb`rhnm`kkxodqstqasgdhqsnmdr-
175
1-3-AdsvddmOgq`rdr
Vdg`uditrsbnmbktcdcntqsvnl`hmrdbshnmrnmsnm`kqtkdr`mcsnm`k
cdqhu`shnmr+bnmbdmsq`shmfehqrsnmmntmrhmrdbshnm1-1-`mcsgdmnmudqar
hmrdbshnm1-2-Vdvhkkmnvdw`lhmdsgdsnm`kogdmnldm`bg`q`bsdqhrshb
neogq`rditmbstqdr+rodbhehb`kkxadsvddmrtaidbs`mcudqa'hlldch`sdkx
adknv(`mcadsvddmudqa`mcnaidbs'rdbshnm1-3-1-etqsgdqadknv(-
L`mxM`qqnvA`mstk`mft`fdrg`ud`etkkbnmbnqcoqdehw`r`
!rtaidbsl`qjdq!'RL(`ssgditmbstqdnertaidbsmntmogq`rd`mcsgd
enkknvhmfudqaogq`rd-Rtaidbsl`qjdqrg`udmnsxdsaddmqdonqsdchm
A`lhkdjdk`mft`fdr+oqna`akxnvhmfsnsgdk`bjne`mxrdfldms`k
l`qjhmf-Ats+rtaidbsl`qjdqrcndwhrs+`skd`rshmMfxdla——m-Sgd
rtaidbsl`qjdqrhmMfxdla——m`qdbnmsqnkkdcaxsgdjhmcneudqa`k
bnmrsqtbshnmvghbgenkknvr-Hesgdrdmsdmbdhro`rshmchb`shud+sgdrtaidbs
l`qjdqhr`rhlokdbnmbnqcsnmdvghbgnbbtqr`ssgddmcnesgdrtaidbs
mntmogq`rd-Hesgdrdmsdmbdhretstqdhmchb`shud+sgdrtaidbsl`qjdqhrrshkk
`rhlokdbnmbnqcsnmdcdsdqlhmdcaxsgdmntmbk`rrnesgdoqdbdchmf
mntm+atsvgdmdudqsghrsnmdhr`Gsnmd+`lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd
bg`mfdrhshmu`qhntrv`xr-Ehm`kkx+hesgdrdmsdmbdhrhmsgdydqnsdmrd+
sgdrtaidbsl`qjdq'chrbtrrdcetqsgdqadknv(u`qhdr`bbnqchmfsnsgd
176
`rodbs`mclncdnesgdudqa-
Vdvhkkadfhmaxdw`lhmhmfhmcds`hksgdbnmbnqcsnmdvghbg
etmbshnmr`r`rtaidbsl`qjdqhmo`rshmchb`shudrdmsdmbdr-Khjdsgd
bnmbnqcsnmdvghbgetmbshnmr`rsgd`rrnbh`shudl`qjdqhmmntm,mntm
bnmrsqtbshnmr'cdrbqhadchmcds`hkhmrdbshnm1-1-1-`anud(+sgdbnmbnqc
snmdsg`shrsgdrtaidbsl`qjdqhr`Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdldenqmntm
bk`rrdr0`mc8`mc`Gsnmdsnm`klnqogdldenqsgdnsgdqdhfgsmntm
bk`rrdr'rdd'432(adknvenqbk`rroqdehwdrne`kksdmmntmbk`rrdr(-Sgd
l`inqtmcdqkxhmfcheedqdmbdadsvddmsgd`rrnbh`shudbnmbnqcsnmd`mcsgd
rtaidbsl`qjdqbnmbnqcsnmdhrsg`ssgd`rrnbh`shudsnmdetmbshnmr`r`
oqdehwnmsgdrdbnmcmntmvghkdsgdrtaidbsl`qjdqsnmdetmbshnmr`r`
rteehwnmsgddmcnesgdmntmogq`rd-Sgtrsgd`rrnbh`shudsnmdg`r`
rsqnmfdqfq`ll`shb`kantmc`qxsnhsrkdesvghkdsgdrtaidbsl`qjdqsnmd
g`r`rsqnmfdqfq`ll`shb`kantmc`qxsnhsrqhfgs-
Adenqdonrhshmftmcdqkxhmfrsqtbstqdr`mcdw`lhmhmfu`qhntr
cdqhu`shnmr+vdvhkkknnj`ssgdsvnbg`q`bsdqhrshbdw`lokdrrgnvmadknv9
(314) aLmbuLY kaL zaLY mbaLb "the deaf-man-(1) cut the meat"
3 3 3 3 3 (yesterday)
3 31 13 3 3 (yesterday)
177
Sgdtmcdqkhmdcvnqcrhmsgdsvnoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrg`udsgdr`ld
qnns+.otæù.!cd`e,l`m-!Sgdehqrsdw`lokdtrdrsgdqnnsvhsgsgdmntmbk`rr
0oqdehw.`∆M,.+vghbgrhfmhehdr!rhmftk`q-!Sgdgnlnqf`mhbm`r`k
bnmrnm`ms'M(hmsgdoqdehw`rrhlhk`sdrsnsgdonhmsne`qshbtk`shnmnesgd
enkknvhmfbnmrnm`ms+`mcsgdbnmrnm`msu`qh`ms'o(bg`mfdrsnhsrunhbdc
u`qh`ms'a(vgdmdudqhlldch`sdkxoqdbdcdcax`m`r`kbnmrnm`mshmsgd
r`ldvnqc-Sgdrdbnmcdw`lokdrgnvrntqr`ldmntmqnnsvhsgsgdmntm
bk`rr1oqdehw.ld∆,.+vghbgrhfmhehdr!oktq`k-!Sgdmntmbk`rrmtladqne
sgdmntmvhkkad`ccdcsnsgdfknrrsnsgddw`lokdrhmsghr`mcsgd
enkknvhmfrdbshnm-
Sgdqd`rnmenqbhshmfsgdoqdbdchmfsvndw`lokdrhrmnssgd
ognmnknfhb`k`ksdqm`shnmrhmbnmrnm`msr+atssgdsnm`kodqstqa`shnmrvghbg
s`jdok`bd+rodbhehb`kkx+sg`ssgdqhrhmfsnmdneZot¿ù\g`raddmknrshmsgd
b`rdne`rtaidbseqnlmntmbk`rr0+`mcsgdsnmdnmsgdenkknvhmfsdmrd
l`qjdq.j`∆.g`raddmodqstqadchmsn`GKe`kkhmfsnmdhmsgdb`rdne`
rtaidbseqnlmntmbk`rr1-@radrg`kkrddadknv+ansgnesgdrdsnmd
bg`mfdr`qdrsq`hfgsenqv`qcqdrtksrnesgdrtaidbsl`qjdqbnmbnqcsnmd
vghbgvdonrhsgdqdadsvddmsgdrtaidbsmntmogq`rd`mcsgdenkknvhmf
udqaogq`rd-
Dw`lhmhmfehqrsntq!rhmftk`q!dw`lokd+vgdqdsgdmnql`kqhrhmfsnmd
nmsgdmntmqnnsZot¿ù\adbnldr`kdudkKsnmd+vdonrhs`mtmcdqkxhmf
kdwhb`krsqtbstqdkhjdsgdenkknvhmf'rxkk`akd!@!adhmfsgdrtaidbsmntm
178
oqdehw+rxkk`akd!A!sgdmntmqnns+sgdsnm`klnqogdldsgdrtaidbsl`qjdq
bnmbnqcsnmd`mcrxkk`akd!S!sgdsdmrdl`qjdq(9
(315) // A + B + ¶ T #
// L + H + L ¶ L #
Sgdoqdbdchmfqdoqdrdms`shnmtrdrsgdrxlank!ï!snqdedqsn`ogq`rd
antmc`qx-@rvdrg`kkrddhmsghrrdbshnm`mcsgdmdws+sgdonrhshmfne`
ogq`rdantmc`qxvghbghrrsqnmfdqsg`m`vnqcantmc`qxvhkkoqnud
bqtbh`khmsgdqduhrhnmnentqsvnsnmdqtkdrenq`rrnbh`shmfsnm`k
lnqogdldr-Sghrrsqnmfdqantmc`qxhronrhsdcafter`rtaidbsl`qjdq
`mcbefore`mnaidbsl`qjdq+rtffdrshmfsg`sansgsgdrdl`qjdqr`qdo`qs
nesgdhqqdrodbshudmntmogq`rdr`mcmnso`qsnesgdhmsdqudmhmfudqa`k
l`sdqh`k-
Sgdehqrssnmdqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqfdmdq`kkdes,sn,qhfgsl`oohmfqtkd
vghbg`rrnbh`sdrd`bgnesgdsgqddrxkk`akdr'!@!enqmntmbk`rroqdehw+
!A!enqmntmqnns`mc!S!enqsdmrdl`qjdq(snsgdkdeslnrssnmdin the
same morpheme+`radknv9
(316) // A + B + ¶ T #
// L + H + L ¶ L #
Sgdehqrsqdftk`qsnmdqtkdsnnodq`sdnmsghrbnmrsqtbshnmhrsgdqhrd,
179
enql`shnmqtkd'rdd'18(`anud(vghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdKsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdc
snrxkk`akd@`krnsnrxkk`akdA+bqd`shmf`qhrhmfsnmdnmrxkk`akdA+`radknv9
(317) // A + B + ¶ T #
// L + H + L ¶ L #
Sgdntsotsnesgdoqdbdchmfqtkdeddcrntqqhrd,cdkdshnmsnmdqtkd'rdd'40(
`anud(rhmbdsgdqhrdhrenkknvdcax`Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdld-Sgdqhrd,cdkdshnm
qtkdcdkdsdrbnlokdsdkxsgdGsnmd`rrnbh`sdcvhsgrxkk`akdA+`radknv9
(318) // A + B + ¶ T #
// L + H + L ¶ L #
Sgdmdwsqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`klnqogdldqtkd
'rdd'27(`anud(vghbgmnsnmkxcnbjrsgdKsnmdnesgdsnm`klnqogdldsn
rxkk`akdA+ats`krnchr`rrnbh`sdrsgdr`ldrxkk`akdeqnlsgdnsgdqKsnmd
`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
(319) // A + B + ¶ T #
// L + + L ¶ L #
Rhmbdmnekn`shmfsnmdrqdl`hm`ssghrrs`fdnentqcdqhu`shnm+mdhsgdqnesgd
cnvmrsdoqtkdrhrsqhffdqdc+`mcsgdrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmhrsgdenkknvhmf9
180
(320) // A + B + ¶ T #
// L + + L ¶ L #
3 - 3 - 3 -
Sgdoqdbdchmfcdqhu`shnmg`raddmudqxrhlhk`qsnsg`senq`rrnbh`shudmntm
o`ssdqmrk2sgqntfgk5cdrbqhadchmrdbshnm1-1-1-`anud+vgdqdsgdGsnmdne`
KGqhrhmfsnmdv`r`krncdkdsdcadenqd`Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdld-Vdmnvlnud
nmsnsgdo`q`kkdkb`rdvgdqd`rtaidbsmntmvhsgsgdr`ldtmcdqkxhmfK*G
snm`krsqtbstqdhrenkknvdcax`Gbnmbnqcsnmdrtaidbsl`qjdq-Rtbg`
cdqhu`shnmvntkc`ood`q`radknv`esdqsgdnodq`shnmnentqkdes,sn,qhfgssnm`k
l`oohmfqtkd9
(321) // A + B + ¶ T #
// L + H + H ¶ L #
Nmbd`f`hm+sgdehqrsqdftk`qsnm`kqtkdsnnodq`sdhrsgdqhrd,enql`shnmqtkd
vghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdKsnmdnerxkk`akd@`krnsnrxkk`akdA+`radknv9
(322) // A + B + ¶ T #
// L + H + H ¶ L #
@ssghronhms+ntqqhrd,cdkdshnmqtkdcndrmnsnodq`sd+rhmbdsgdKG
qhrhmfsnmdhrenkknvdcax`Gsnmdsnm`klnqogdldhmrsd`cne`Ksnmd-
181
Sgdmdwsqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqqhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfGsnmdsnm`klnqogdld
qtkdvghbgltrsadrkhfgskxlnchehdcsnmnschr`rrnbh`sdsgdmdwsrxkk`akd
'S`anud(eqnl`mxsnmdrhshr`rrnbh`sdcvhsg-Sghrhrcnmdaxkhlhshmf
sgdchr`rrnbh`shnmsnb`rdrvgdqdsgdhmsdqudmhmfantmc`qxhrmnrsqnmfdq
sg`m`vnqcantmc`qx+`rhmntqqduhrdcqtkd'ehqrsenqltk`sdchm'45(
`anud(+`rqdrs`sdcadknv9
+ + #
+ H + T
Hsrgntkcadmnsdc`ssghronhmssg`s`ksdqm`sdld`mr`qdonrrhakdsn
`bbnlokhrgsgdr`lddeedbs`rsgdbnmchshnmsg`svdg`ud`ccdcsnsgd
oqdbdchmfqtkd-@mcdqrnm'0870973(oqnonrdcsg`sbdqs`hmqtkdrvntkc
nodq`sdhesgdrxkk`akdv`rZ*MBO\+`mntmbk`rroqdehw-Rsdv`qs
'08709004(oqnonrdcsnkhlhsrnldqtkdraxchrshmfthrghmfadsvddm!rnkhc!
`mc!ekthc!rxkk`akdr-Ansgnesgdrd`ksdqm`shudr`ssdlossnb`ostqdsgd
nardqu`shnmsg`srnldsnmdqtkdrsdmcsn`ookxnmkxsnqnnsrxkk`akdr`mc
mdudqsn`eehwdr-Vghkdrtbg`rnktshnmlhfgs`krnadsgdadrsenq
182
Mfxdla——m+vdg`udbgnrdmsnkhlhsntqqtkdrsnadhmfqdrsqhbsdcax
antmc`qxogdmnldm``rltbg`ronrrhakdhmnqcdqsn`unhcsgdtrdne
fq`ll`shb`khmenql`shnmhmnsgdqvhrdognmnknfhb`kqtkdr-
Ntqqduhrdcqhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfGsnmdsnm`klnqogdldqtkd`ookhdrsn
ntqoqdrdmscdqhu`shnmax`rrnbh`shmfsgdGsnmdsnsgdkdesatsnot
cdkdshmfsgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmd`kqd`cx`ss`bgdcsnrxkk`akdSrhmbdsgd
ogq`rdantmc`qx'ï(rdo`q`sdrsgdsvnsnmdr-Sgdsnmdqtkdsgtrnodq`sdr
`radknv9
(324) // A + B + ¶ T #
// L + H + H ¶ L #
Nmbd`f`hm+mdhsgdqnentqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdr`ookhdrsnsghr
o`qshbtk`qo`ssdqm+`mcsgdrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmhrsgdenkknvhmf9
(325) // A + B + ¶ T #
// L + H + H ¶ L #
3 -3 1 - 1 3 -
Vdg`udrgnvm`anudsg`smntmrvhsgtmcdqkxhmfK*Gsnm`ko`ssdqmr
knrdsgdhqtrt`kKGqhrhmfsnmdrvgdmsgdmntmhr`rtaidbseqnldhsgdq
mntmbk`rrknq8+atssgdxbqd`sd`GKe`kkhmfsnmdnmsgdmdwsrxkk`akdhe
sgdmntmrbnldreqnl`mxnsgdqnesgdsdmmntmbk`rrdr-Vdrgnvdcgnv
onrhshmf`bnmbnqcsnmdsnm`klnqogdldrteehwdcsnsgdrtaidbsmntm
183
ogq`rdoqnctbdrsgdbnqqdbsrtqe`bdcdqhu`shnmr-
Qd`cdqr`bpt`hmsdcvhsgsgdoqdu`kdmbdneroqd`chmfsnmdqtkdrhm
@eqhb`mk`mft`fdrlhfgssghmjsg`ssghrk`rsoqnbdrrv`ritrs`fdmdq`k
snmdqtkdroqd`chmfsgdGsnmdeqnlsgdmntmnmsnsgdmdwsvnqc-Sgd
enkknvhmfdw`lokdr+vgdqdsgdrtaidbsmntmrg`ud`mtmcdqkxhmfK*K
snm`ko`ssdqm+oqnudsg`ssghrhrmnssgdb`rd9
(326) eLncuLm kaL zaLY mbaLb "the heron-(9) cut the meat"
3 3 3 3 3 (yesterday)
3 3 13 3 3 (yesterday)
Sgdrtaidbshmsgdoqdbdchmfrdmsdmbdrhr`mntmathksnmsgdqnnsenq
sgdahqcvghbghrb`kkdc`!gdqnm!.bt∆l.-Sghrmntmqnnsadknmfrsnmntm
fdmcdq8.3+vghbghrsnr`xsg`shsenqlrhsrrhmftk`qaxoqdehwhmfsgdbk`rr
8oqdehw.'d∆(M,.'vgdqdsgdunvdk!d!hrnmkxoqnmntmbdc`ssgdadfhmmhmf
nerdmsdmbdr(+`mchsenqlrhsroktq`kaxoqdehwhmfsgdbk`rr3oqdehw
.ld∆M,.-Sgdqd`rnmvdg`udrdkdbsdcsghro`qshbtk`qmntmhrsg`smntm
bk`rr8g`rKsnmdbnmbnqcvghkdmntmbk`rr3g`rGsnmdbnmbnqc-Sgtr+
vhsgsgdr`ldmntmqnns+vdb`mdw`lhmdansgbnmbnqconrrhahkhshdr-
Hmcddc+`rntqdw`lokdrrgnv+vgdmsgdb`rdnesgdbk`rr3mntmhr
rtaidbs+sgdenkknvhmf'tmcdqkhmdc(sdmrdl`qjdq.j`∆.g`rhsrsnmd
odqstqadceqnlsgdmnql`kKsnmdsn`GKe`kkhmfsnmd-Sghrodqstqa`shnm
184
hrsgdqdrtksnesgdGbnmbnqcsnmdsg`svdonrhsdc`r`rtaidbsl`qjdqnm
sgddmcnesgdrtaidbsmntmogq`rd-Sgdtmcdqkxhmfrsqtbstqdnesghr
bnmrsqtbshnm`ood`qr`radknv`esdqsgdkdes,sn,qhfgsl`oohmfqtkdg`r
nodq`sdc9
(327) // A + B + ¶ T #
// L + L + H ¶ L #
Sgdnmkxsnmdqtkdsnnodq`sdgdqdhrntqqduhrdcqtkdvghbgcnbjrG
snmdsnm`klnqogdldrsnsgdkdes+atscndrmnschr`rrnbh`sdsgdmdwssnmd
snsgdkdesvgdmsgdhmsdqudmhmfantmc`qxhr`ogq`rdantmc`qx+`radknv9
(328) // A + B + ¶ T #
// L + L + H ¶ L #
Rhmbdmdhsgdqnesgdk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdr`ookhdrsnsghro`ssdqm+ntq
cdqhu`shnmhrqd`khydcrs`hfgsenqv`qckx`radknv9
(329) // A + B + ¶ T #
// L + L + H ¶ L #
3 - 3 - 1 3 -
185
Vdg`uddw`lhmdc`anudu`qhntrcdqhu`shnmrvghbglnshu`sdonrhshmf
`bnmbnqcsnmd`rsgdrtaidbsl`qjdqenqo`rssdmrdrdmsdmbdrvhsgetkk
mntmr`rrtaidbsr-Vdvhkkmnvs`jd`knnj`srdmsdmbdrvhsgoqnmntmr`r
rtaidbsr-SgdMfxdla——moqnmntmrenq`mhl`sdnaidbsreqnlmntmbk`rrdr
0`mc1hmrtaidbsonrhshnm`qdsgdenkknvhmf9
U`qhntrnardqu`shnmrrgntkcadl`cd`antssgdoqdbdchmfrtaidbs
oqnmntmrhmkhfgsneo`q`kkdkrsgdxg`udvhsgmntmbk`rrdr0`mc1-Hmlnrs
A`mstk`mft`fdr+mntmbk`rrdr0`mc1lnrsnesdmhmchb`sdrhmftk`q`mc
oktq`kgtl`mmntmrqdrodbshudkx-Hm`cchshnm+sgdbnmbnqcsnmdenqbk`rr0
hrKsnmdvghkdenqbk`rr1hshrGsnmd-Sgdbnmrnm`msbnmbnqcenq
Mfxdla——mmntmrhr.v.enqbk`rr0`mc.o.enqbk`rr1-Sgdo`q`kkdkr
adsvddmsgdrdsxohb`kmntmbk`rrdkdldmsr`mcsgdhqqdrodbshudrtaidbs
186
oqnmntmrvntkcrddlsn`qftdrsqnmfkxenqsgdoqnmntmradhmf`skd`rs
o`qsh`kkxcdqhudceqnlmntmbk`rroqdehwdr-Ehqrs+`kksgdrhmftk`qrtaidbs
oqnmntmr`qdKsnmd-Hm`cchshnm+`kksgdoktq`krtaidbsoqnmntmr`qdG
snmd`mcadfhmvhsgsgdbnmrnm`ms.o.-Dudmsgd!knmfenql!rtaidbs
oqnmntmr+vgnrddw`bsbnmchshnmhmfe`bsnq`mccdqhudcrdl`mshbenqbdg`r
xdssnadchrbnudqdc+`krnenkknvsgdrdr`ldo`q`kkdkrvhsgmntmbk`rr
ogdmnldm`-
Sgdqd`rnmvdg`udaqntfgstosgdsnohbnertaidbsoqnmntmr`mcsgdhq
mntmbk`rro`q`kkdkrhrsg`ssgdrtaidbsoqnmntmrs`jd`bnmbnqcsnmd`r
rtaidbsl`qjdqitrskhjdetkkmntmr-Gnvdudq+vg`shrtmtrt`khrsg`s`kk
sgdrtaidbsoqnmntmr`bskhjdrhmftk`qbk`rr0mntmr'hms`jhmf`Ksnmd
bnmbnqcsnmd`rrtaidbsl`qjdq(dwbdossgdsghqcodqrnmoktq`koqnmntmr
.o—æ.`mc.o—æa.vghbg`bskhjdoktq`kbk`rr1mntmr'hms`jhmf`Gbnmbnqc
snmd`rrtaidbsl`qjdq(+`rdwdlokhehdcaxsgdenkknvhmfrdmsdmbdr9
1 3 3 3 3 (yesterday)
1 13 3 3 (yesterday)
@rrddmenqmntmr`anud+sgdKsnmdrtaidbsl`qjdqenkknvhmf.o—æf—.cnbjr
snsgdleft`mclnchehdrsgd'tmcdqkhmdc(dbgnunvdknesgdrtaidbsoqnmntm+
vghkdsgdGsnmdrtaidbsl`qjdqenkknvhmf.o—æ.cnbjrsnsgdright`mcbg`mfdr
sgdKsnmdsdmrdl`qjdq.j`∆.hmsn`GKe`kkhmfsnmd-Sgtr+sgntfg`kksgdeqnydm
187
oktq`koqnmntmrrddlsng`qjdma`bjsnsgdhqbk`rr1nqhfhmraxrs`qshmfvhsgZo\
`mcg`uhmf`Gsnmd+nmkxsgdsghqcodqrnmoktq`koqnmntmr`bst`kkxadg`udkhjd
bk`rr1mntmrhmo`rssdmrdrdmsdmbdr-Sgde`bssg`ssgdoqnmntmr`krng`udmddc
ne`enkknvhmfbnmbnqcsnmdhmcdodmcdmskxlnshu`sdrntqonrhshmfrtbg`snmdnm
sgda`rhrnertaidbsmntmadg`uhnq-
G`uhmfdw`lhmdcsgdbnmbnqcsnmdrtaidbsl`qjdqmddcdchmo`rssdmrd
rdmsdmbdr+vdmnvlnudnmsndw`lhmdsgdlnqdbnlokhb`sdcrtaidbsl`qjdq
mddcdchmetstqdsdmrdrdmsdmbdr-Sgddw`lokdrsg`svdvhkkdw`lhmd`qdsgd
enkknvhmf9
(332) aLmbuLБ tKo zKaY mbMab "the deaf-man-(1) will cut the meat"
3 3 2 3 6 (tomorrow)
aLmbuLБ lMu zKaY mbMab "the deaf-man-(1) will cut the meat"
3 3 4 3 6
meLpu
S Y toJ zKaY mbMab "the deaf-men-(2) will cut the meat"
3 312 2 3 6 (tomorrow)
meLpu
S Y luL zKaY mbMab "the deaf-men-(2) will cut the meat"
3 312 4 3 6
meLncuLm tKo zKaY mbMab "the herons-(4) will cut the meat"
3 3 2 3 6 (tomorrow)
meLncuLm lMu zKaY mbMab "the herons-(4) will cut the meat"
3 3 4 3 6
188
SgdoqdbdchmfrdmsdmbdrrgnvsgqddcheedqdmsmntmrvhsgG`mcKsnmd
etstqd`twhkh`qxudqar-Sgde`bssg`ssgdmnql`kKGqhrhmfsnmdbqd`sdcnm
sgdmntm!cd`e,l`m,'0(!hrmnsqd`khydc`qftdrenqsgdoqdrdmbdnesgd
r`ldKbnmbnqcsnmd`rrtaidbsl`qjdqvhsgKbnmbnqcsnmdbk`rrdr'0`mc
8(-Vdvhkk`krnonrhssgdo`q`kkdkGbnmbnqcsnmd`rrtaidbsl`qjdqvhsg
sgdnsgdqbk`rrdr+sgntfgsghrsnmdcndrtmtrt`ksghmfr-Ehqrs+vgdmhs
enkknvrmntmrvghbgdmcnm`m`rrnbh`sdcKsnmd+khjdsgd!gdqnmr,'3(!
`anud+sgdGsnmdcqnorntsbnlokdsdkx-
Ltbglnqdcheehbtkssncdqhud`qdsgdtmtrt`k'tmcdqkhmdc(qhrhmf,
cnvmrsdoodc,ghfgsnmdrvghbgnmkxnbbtqvgdm`qhrhmfsnmdhrbqd`sdc
adenqd`m`twhkh`qxudqahm`etstqdbnmrsqtbshnm-Sgdcdqhu`shnmnesgdrd
tmtrt`ksnmdrvntkcadfhmvhsg`rsqtbstqdkhjdsgdenkknvhmf`esdqsgd
kdes,sn,qhfgssnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc'vhsg!E!qdoqdrdmshmfsgd
`twhkh`qxudqatrdcsnhmchb`sdetstqdshld(9
(333) // A + B + ¶ F #
// L + H + H ¶ T #
Mnv+beforesgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdrnodq`sd+vdmddc`rodbh`k'q`sgdq
`cgnb(hchnrxmbq`shblnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'46/(adknv(vghbg
s`jdrsgdGsnmdrtaidbsl`qjdq`mchmrdqsrsgdGsnmdhlldch`sdkxadenqd
189
sgd`twhkh`qxudqasnmdinsidesgd`twhkh`qxl`qjdq+`rrnbh`shmfsghrG
snmda`bjsnsgdk`rsrxkk`akdnesgdrtaidbsmntmogq`rd+`mc`kksghronly
vgdmsgdoqdbdchmfmntmogq`rdg`r`ehm`k`rrnbh`sdcGsnmd-Sghr
hchnrxmbq`shblnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdoqnctbdrsgdenkknvhmfdeedbs9
(334) // A + B + ¶ F #
// L + H + H ¶ T #
Vgdmsgdqdftk`qsnmdqtkdrnodq`sd+ntqqhrd,enql`shnmqtkd`rrnbh`sdr
sgdKsnmdnerxkk`akd@`krnsnrxkk`akdA+`radknv9
(335) // A + B + ¶ F #
// L + H + ¶ H T #
Sgdbqtbh`ko`qsnentqcdqhu`shnmmnv`qqhudrvgdmntqmnql`kk`sd
lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdhmrdqsr`mhqqd`khrpolarsnmdhlldch`sdkx
adenqdsgd`twhkh`qxudqal`qjhmfetstqdsdmrd-Rhmbd+axsghrshld+sgd
`twhkh`qxudqag`rsgdodqstqadcGrtaidbsl`qjdqsnmd`rhsrqhfgslnrs
snmd+sgdonk`qsnmdvghbghrhmrdqsdchr`kv`xr`Ksnmd+`radknv9
190
(336) // A + B + ¶ + F #
// L + H + ¶ Ø + H T #
-[T
Rhmbdsgdnmkxqtkdrkdessnnodq`sd`qdntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdr+sgdnmkx
qdl`hmhmfbg`mfdhrsg`ssgdekn`shmfKsnmdknvdqrsgdsnmdqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbg
adenqdsgdenkknvhmf`rrnbh`sdcGsnmd-SgdenkknvhmfGsnmdhrgnvdudq
`rrnbh`sdca`bjsnsgdk`rsrxkk`akdnesgdmntmogq`rd+oqnctbhmfrdmsdmbdrvhsg
sgdmnql`k!hqqd`khr!cnvmrsdoed`stqdmnsqd`khydcnmsgd`twhkh`qxudqa+atsnm
sgdoqdbdchmfmntmqnns+`radknv'vgdqdsgdehqrsqnvnemtladqrhrenq`etstqd
`twhkh`qxudqa'E(vhsgtmcdqkxhmfGsnmd`mcsgdrdbnmcqnvenq`rhlhk`qudqa
vhsgtmcdqkxhmfKsnmd(9
(337) // A + B + ¶ + F #
// L + H + ¶ L + H T #
3 -3 1 2-2 -
3 -3 1 2-4 -
Ntqtmtrt`klnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdsgtrfhudrqhrdsnsgdnmkx
nbbtqqdmbdrnesgdtmtrt`kqhrhmf,cnvmrsdoodc,ghfgsnmd+vgdqdetkkx
191
threesnmdr`qd`rrnbh`sdcsn`rhmfkdrxkk`akd'A(-Snsgd`tsgnq&r
oqdrdmsjmnvkdcfd+sghrtmtrt`kqtkdhrsgdnmkxld`mrneg`uhmf`mx
sgqdd,snmdcrxkk`akdhmsgdMfxdla——mk`mft`fd-
Mnvsg`svdg`uddw`lhmdcsgdadg`uhnqnesgdbnmbnqcsnmdrtaidbs
l`qjdqrhmo`rs`mcetstqdbnmrsqtbshnmr+vd`qdqd`cxsnknnj`sydqn
sdmrdbnmrsqtbshnmrvgdqdd`bgbnmrsqtbshnmg`rhsrnvmjhmcnertaidbs
l`qjhmf-Sgdnmkxnmdnesgdydqnsdmrdbnmrsqtbshnmrsntrd`bnmbnqc
snmd`r`rtaidbsl`qjdqhrsgdmnm,oqnfqdrrhudhqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnm
rgnvmadknv9
3 3 4 4 4
3 3 3 3 3
3 31 1 4 4
3 31 1 3 3
Sgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrrgnvsg`ssgdonrhsdcKbnmbnqcsnmdrtaidbs
l`qjdqenqbk`rr0'`mc8(mntmrcnbjrsnsgdkdes`esdqqhrd,cdkdshnmg`r
dkhlhm`sdcsgdGsnmdeqnlsgdmnql`kKGqhrhmfsnmdmnql`kkxentmcnmsgd
mntmqnns.otæù.!akhmc,l`m-!Sgdk`rssvndw`lokdrrgnvsg`ssgdonrhsdcG
bnmbnqcsnmdrtaidbsl`qjdq`krncnbjrsnsgdqhfgs`rvhsgsgdo`rssdmrd
192
dw`lokdrchrbtrrdcd`qkhdq`anud-Vhsgsgdydqnsdmrdgnvdudq+sghrGsnmd
rtaidbsl`qjdqmnsnmkx`rrnbh`sdrchqdbskxnmsnsgdudqaqnns+hsqd`rrnbh`sdrsgd
snmdnesgdudqaqnnssnsgdhlodqedbshudrteehwnesgdudqa-Sgdtmcdqkxhmf
o`ssdqmenqsgdudqarhmsgdrdbnmrsqtbshnmrbnms`hmr`m`cchshnm`kKsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldhlldch`sdkxfollowingsgdudqaqnns+`rchrbtrrdchmrdbshnm1-2-2-
`anud-Vd`ccsnsgdudqabnmrsqtbshnm`mntmvhsgtmcdqkxhmfK*Go`ssdqm
`mcsgdonrhsdcGbnmbnqcsnmdrtaidbsl`qjdq+`rrddmadknv`esdqsgdkdes,sn,
qhfgssnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(339) // A + B + ¶ V + + I #
// L + H + H ¶ T + L + L #
Adenqdsgdqdftk`qsnmdqtkdrnodq`sd+`mhchnrxmbq`shblnqogn,snmnknfhb`k
qtkd'rdd'462(adknv(`rrnbh`sdrsgdGbnmbnqcsnmdrtaidbsl`qjdqsnsgdudqa
qnns'U(`mcqd`rrnbh`sdrsgdudqaqnnssnmd'S(snsgdmdwsrxkk`akdnmhsrqhfgs
'H(+`radknv9
(340) // A + B + ¶ V + + I #
// L + H + H ¶ T + L + L #
Sgdehqrsnesgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdrsnnodq`sdhrsgdqhrd,enql`shnmsnmdqtkd
vghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdKsnmdnesgdmntmbk`rroqdehw'@(snsgdmntmqnns'A(+`r
adknv9
193
(341) // A + B + ¶ V + + I #
// L + H + H ¶ T + L + L #
Sgdmdwsqtkdsnnodq`sdhrsgdleftv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldqtkdvghbg`bst`kkxhmsghrb`rd`rrnbh`sdrsnsgdright+rhmbd
hshrbnmehmdcaxsgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdnesgdudqasnmd'S(nmhsrkdes`mc
sgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdnesgdhlodqedbshudrteehwrxkk`akd'H(nmhsrqhfgs-
RhmbdntqVEBr`xrsg`s`rrnbh`shnmkhmdrb`mmnsbqnrr+sgdmdvkhmdltrs
fnsnsgdrxkk`akdnmsgdqhfgs+sgntfgsgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfqtkdcndr
cdkdsdsgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdnmhsrkdes`rhmlnqdmnql`k`ookhb`shnmr-Rn+
sgdKsnmdnesgdsnm`klnqogdld`rrnbh`sdrsnsgdhlodqedbshudrteehw'H(
vghkdchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdudqasnmd'S(`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
(342) // A + B + ¶ V + + I #
// L + H + H ¶ T + L + L #
Sgdqd`khy`shnmnesgdrtqe`bdsnmdnmrxkk`akdHmnvcdodmcrtonmsgd
m`stqdnesgdudqaqnnssnmd+vgdsgdqsghrsnmdqd`bgdrsgddmcnesgd
cdqhu`shnm`r`ekn`shmfGnq`ekn`shmfKsnmd-Hesgdsnmdhr`ekn`shmfG
snmdadenqdsgd`rrnbh`sdcKsnmd+hsb`trdrntqcnvmrsdoqtkdsnknvdqsgd
snmdqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbg+`rrgnvmhmsgdehqrsqnvnertqe`bdsnmdmtladqr
adknv-Hesgdsnmd'S(hr`Ksnmd+sgdcnvmrsdoqtkdhrmnssqhffdqdc+`mc
194
sgdehm`krxkk`akdhrmnscnvmrsdoodc+`rrgnvmhmsgdrdbnmcqnvne
rtqe`bdsnmdmtladqradknv9
(343) // A + B + ¶ V + + I #
// L + H + H ¶ T + L + L #
3 -3 1 - 1 4 -
3 -3 1 - 1 3 -
Sgdtmtrt`kKGqhrhmfsnmdnmsgdudqaqnnshmsgdonrhshudodqedbshud
bnmrsqtbshnmnesgdydqnsdmrd'O/(v`rrgnvmhmrdbshnm1-2-2-`anud-
Sgdqdvdldmshnmdcgnvsgdtmtrt`krightward`rrnbh`shnmne`low
snmdrtaidbsl`qjdqv`rbqtbh`ksnsgdcdqhu`shnm-Vdvhkkmnvfhud
`cchshnm`kdw`lokdrvhsgetkkmntmrhmsgdrtaidbsonrhshnm`mcsgdmrgnv
gnvsgdtmtrt`kqhfgsv`qc`rrnbh`shmfKsnmdrtaidbsl`qjdqqdrtksrhm
mdtsq`khy`shnmnesgdsnm`kbnmsq`rsadsvddmG`mcKsnmdudqaqnnsr-Ntq
bg`q`bsdqhrshbrdmsdmbdr`qdsgdenkknvhmf9
(344) aLmbuNY zaNY mbMab "the deaf-man just cut the meat"
3 31 31 4
3 31 31 4
Vdvhkkrgnvsgdcdqhu`shnmned`bgrdmsdmbdhmstqmrhmbd+sgntfgsgdx
g`udqdl`qj`akxrhlhk`qtmcdqkxhmfrsqtbstqdr+sgdhqcdqhu`shnmr`qdpthsd
195
chudqfdms-SgdehqrsO/rdmsdmbd`anudvntkc`ood`q`radknv`esdqsgdkdes,sn,
qhfgssnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`cnodq`sdc9
(345) // A + B ¶ + V #
// L + H ¶ L + H #
Adenqd`mxmnql`ksnmdqtkdb`mnodq`sd+`lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd
'460(adknv(`ccr`Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdld`mc`rrnbh`sdrhs`kksgdv`xsnsgd
udqaqnnsrxkk`akd'U(+`radknv9
(346) // A + B + ¶ + V #
// L + H + Ø ¶ L + H #
Sgdehqrssnmdqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqqhrd,enql`shnmqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgd
Ksnmdnerxkk`akd@snrxkk`akdA`rvdkk+`radknv9
(347) // A + B + ¶ + V #
// L + H + L ¶ L + H #
Sgdmdwssnmdqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqmnql`kkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdKonk`qsnmdhmsghrb`rdsnsgdqhfgsvghkd
chr`rrnbh`shmfsgdKsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsnrxkk`akd'U(+`radknv9
196
(348) // A + B + ¶ + V #
// L + H + L ¶ L + H #
Sgdnmkxqtkdvghbgqdl`hmrsnnodq`sdhr`k`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd
'rdd'465(adknv(vghbghmrdqsr`ekn`shmfonk`qsnmd'`m',√S(vghbgadbnldr`
Gsnmdadenqd`Ksnmd(`esdqsgdudqahmO/bnmrsqtbshnmr+`radknv'vgdqd
rxkk`akd!B!rs`mcrenqsgdKsnmdnaidbsmntmbk`rroqdehw(9
(349) // A + B + ¶ + V + ¶ C +
// L + H + L ¶ L + H + Ø ¶ L +
-[T
Ntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdknvdqrsgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbghlldch`sdkx
adenqdsgdKsnmdnesgdnaidbsoqdehw'B(+qdrtkshmfhmsgdoqnodqrtqe`bd
qd`khy`shnm+`radknv9
(350) // A + B + ¶ + V + ¶ C +
// L + H + L ¶ L + H + H ¶ L +
3 -3 1 - 3 1 - 4 -
Sgdo`q`kkdkO/bnmrsqtbshnmvhsg`Ksnmdudqaqnnsadfhmrhsr
197
cdqhu`shnmvhsgsgdkdes,sn,qhfgs`rrnbh`shnmqtkd+`radknv9
(351) // A + B ¶ + V #
// L + H ¶ H + L #
Nmbd`f`hm+adenqdsgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdrb`mnodq`sd+ntqrodbh`kO/
lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'460(adknv(hmrdqsr`Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdld`mc
`rrnbh`sdrhs`kksgdv`xsnsgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akd'U(nmhsrqhfgs+`radknv9
(352) // A + B + ¶ + V #
// L + H + Ø ¶ H + L #
Sgdehqrsqdftk`qsnmdqtkdsn`ookxhrntqqhrd,enql`shnmqtkdvghbg
`rrnbh`sdrsgdKsnmdnerxkk`akd@`krnsnrxkk`akdA+`radknv9
(353) // A + B + ¶ + V #
// L + H + L ¶ H + L #
Sgdmdwsqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqqhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfGsnmdsnm`klnqogdld
qtkdvghbgcnbjrsgdGsnmdqd`khrlnqogdldsnsgdudqaqnnsnmhsrqhfgsvghkd
chr`rrnbh`shmfsgdKsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
198
(354) // A + B + ¶ + V #
// L + H + L ¶ H + L #
Hsb`mmnvadrddmaxbnlo`qhmfsghrcdqhu`shnmvhsgsgdoqdbdchmf
nmdsg`ssgdmdtsq`khy`shnmnesgdudqaqnnssn`KGqhrhmfsnmdhraqntfgs
`antsaxsgdKsnmdrtaidbsl`qjdq!sq`oohmf!sgdonk`qsnmdadsvddm
hsrdke`mcsgdudqaqnnssnmd-Vgdmsgdkdesv`qc,nqqhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmf
snmdqtkdr`ookx+sgdonk`qsnmdmustcnbjsnsgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akdnmhsr
qhfgsrhmbdsncnnsgdqvhrdvntkcmdbdrrhs`sdbqnrrhmf`rrnbh`shnmkhmdr-Hs
hrsgdkdesv`qc,`mcqhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfsnmdqtkdr9s`rjhmsghr
dmuhqnmldmssnchr`rrnbh`sd`snmdnmsgdkdesnqqhfgsqdrodbshudkx-Hshr
sghrchr`rrnbh`shnmehqrsnmdv`x`mcsgdmsgdnsgdqsg`sqdrtksrhmsgd
mdtsq`khy`shnmneG`mcKsnmdudqaqnnsrhmO/bnmrsqtbshnmr-
Bnmshmthmfnmsnehmhrgsgdoqdrdmscdqhu`shnm+`ekn`shmfonk`qsnmd
',√S(hrhmrdqsdc`esdqsgdudqahmO/bnmrsqtbshnmr'rdd'465(adknv(+`rhm
sgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
199
(355) // A + B + ¶ + V + ¶ C +
// L + H + L ¶ H + L + Ø ¶ L +
-[T
Nmbd`f`hmntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdknvdqrsgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbg
nmkxvgdmhsfdsrsnsgdnaidbsoqdehw-Sgdqdrtkshmfrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmhr
dw`bskxsgdr`ld`rsgdoqdbdchmfcdqhu`shnm+even thoughsgdK`mcG
snmdr`rrnbh`sdcvhsgsgdr`ldUrxkk`akd`qdeqnlcheedqdmstmcdqkxhmf
lnqogdldrsg`msgdk`rsbnmrsqtbshnm-Sgdehm`krsdohmsghrcdqhu`shnm
qdrtksrhmsgdenkknvhmfrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnm9
(356) // A + B + ¶ + V + ¶ C +
// L + H + L ¶ H + L + H ¶ L +
3 -3 1 - 3 1 - 4 -
@mnsgdqydqnsdmrdbnmrsqtbshnmvghbgtshkhydr`Ksnmdsnm`k
lnqogdld`rrtaidbsl`qjdqhrsgdqd`khrmnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud
vghbghrtrdcsnbnmudxg`ahst`kld`mhmf+`rhmsgddw`lokdradknv9
200
(357) pDP ngwKDYDL mbaLb "they-(2) pound meat"
13 2 4 4
3 3 1 3 3
Sgdcheedqdmbdvhsgsgdbnmrsqtbshnmr`anudhrsg`s`Ksnmdrtaidbs
l`qjdqhrhmrdqsdcax`lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'461(adknv(`mc
`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdlefthmrsd`cnesnsgdright`rvhsgsgdO/
bnmrsqtbshnmrchrbtrrdchlldch`sdkx`anud-Vdvhkkdw`lhmdsgd
cdqhu`shnmnesgddw`lokdvhsgsgdsghqcodqrnmoktq`koqnmntm.o—æ.!sgdx+!
vghbg`ood`qr`radknv`esdqsgdkdes,sn,qhfgssnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`r
nodq`sdc'vhsgsgdrxlank!O!snhmchb`sdsgdoqnmntmnmsgdrxkk`ahb
shdq(9
(358) // P ¶ + V + I #
// H ¶ H + L + L #
Nmbd`f`hm+adenqdsgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdrnodq`sd+`lnqogn,
snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'461(adknv(hmrdqsr`Ksnmdrtaidbsl`qjdqhmsghr
bnmrsqtbshnm`mc`rrnbh`sdrhssnsgdehqrsrxkk`akdnmhsrkdes+vhsgnts
chr`rrnbh`shmfsg`srxkk`akdeqnl`mxnsgdqsnmdr+`radknv9
201
(359) // P + ¶ + V + I #
// H + Ø ¶ H + L + L #
Sgdehqrssnmdqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqGsnmdsnm`klnqogdldqtkdvghbgs`jdr
sgdGsnmdnesgdqd`khronk`qsnmd`mc`rrnbh`sdrhssnsgdqhfgsvghkd
chr`rrnbh`shmfsgdsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
(360) // P + ¶ + V + I #
// H + L ¶ H + L + L #
Sghrhmstqmeddcrntqlds`sgdrhrqtkdvghbgeqnmsrsgdmnvchr`rrnbh`sdcK
snmdvghbgb`ldeqnlsgdudqaqnnslnqogdld+`rhmsgdenkknvhmf
qdoqdrdms`shnm9
(361) // P + ¶ + V + I #
// H + L ¶ H + L + L #
Sgdehm`kqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgknvdqrsgdsnm`k
qdfhrsdqnmdmnsbgadenqdsgdGsnmd`rrnbh`sdvhsgsgdudqaqnns'U(+xhdkchmf
sgdbnqqdbsrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnm+`radknv9
202
(362) // P + ¶ + V + I #
// H + L ¶ L H + + L #
1 3 - 2 - 4 -
Vditrsr`vvg`sg`oodmrsn`mnql`kGsnmdvgdm`Ksnmdrtaidbs
l`qjdqhr`rrnbh`sdcsnhsax`lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd-Nmdtmtrt`ksnmd
o`ssdqmbqd`sdcaxsghrqtkdnbbtqrvgdmtmcdqkxhmfK*Gmntmr'vghbg
trt`kkx`qdqd`khydcvhsg`KGqhrhmfsnmdnmsgdhqqnnsr(nbbtq`rrtaidbsr
adenqdrtbg`Kbnmbnqcsnmd+`radknv9
3 13 1 3 3
3 13 2 4 4
Vdvhkkdw`lhmdsgdcdqhu`shnmnesgdKsnmdudqaqnnsrdmsdmbdsnrdd
gnvsgdnqcdqhmfnesghro`qshbtk`qlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdadenqdsgd
mnql`ksnmdqtkdrakddcrsgdqhrd,enql`shnmqtkd-Ntqtmcdqkxhmfrsqtbstqd
vntkc`ood`q`radknv`esdqsgdkdes,sn,qhfgssnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`r
nodq`sdc9
(364) // A + B ¶ + V + I #
// L + H ¶ H + L + L #
203
Nmbd`f`hm+`lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'461(adknv(enqmnm,
oqnfqdrrhudqd`khrhlodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmrhmsgdydqnsdmrdhmrdqsr`K
snmdrtaidbsl`qjdq`mc`rrnbh`sdrhssnsgdehqrsrxkk`akdnmhsrkdesvghkd
notcdkdshmf`rrnbh`shnmkhmdr`kqd`cx`ss`bgdcsnsg`srxkk`akd'A(-Sghr
qtkdltrsnodq`sdadenqdsgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdr+`mcoqnctbdrsgd
enkknvhmfqdrtks9
(365) // A + B + ¶ + V + I #
// L + H + L ¶ H + L + L #
Hshrbqtbh`ksg`smnv+vgdmsgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdrrb`msgdrsqtbstqd
eqnlkdessnqhfgs+sgdqhrd,enql`shnmqtkdcannotnodq`sdadb`trdrxkk`akd
Ahr`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsnsvncheedqdmssnmdr-Sgdehqrssnmdqtkdsn
nodq`sdhrsgtrsgdGsnmdsnm`klnqogdldqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdG
snmdnesgdonk`qqd`khrl`qjdqsnsgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akdnmhsrqhfgs
chr`rrnbh`shmf`ssgdr`ldshldsgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akdeqnlsgdsnmd
`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
(366) // A + B + ¶ + V + I #
// L + H + L ¶ H + L + L #
Sghrhmstqmeddcrntqlds`sgdrhrqtkdvghbgeqnmsrsgdKsnmdsg`sg`r
itrsaddmchr`rrnbh`sdc+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
204
(367) // A + B + ¶ + V + I #
// L + H + L ¶ H + L + L #
Sgdk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdhrnmbd`f`hmsqhffdqdcaxsghrmnveqnmsdc
ekn`shmfKsnmd+qdrtkshmfhm`knvdqhmfnesgdsnmdqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbgnm
sgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akd+`rrgnvmhmsgdenkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
(368) // A + B + ¶ + V + I #
// L + H + L ¶ L H + + L #
3 - 1 3 - 2 - 4 -
Sghrakddchmfnesgdqhrd,enql`shnmqtkdjddorsgdMfxdla——m
k`mft`fdeqnl`bpthqhmf`sgqdd,snmdc'202(snmdfkhcdnmsgdrtqe`bd-
Sgdoqdbdchmfcdqhu`shnmrvdqdsgdk`rsnesgdydqnsdmrdbnmrsqtbshnmr
vghbgs`jd`Ksnmdrtaidbsl`qjdq-Sgdnmkxydqnsdmrdbnmrsqtbshnm
vghbgrshkkqdpthqdrdw`lhm`shnmhrsgdoqnfqdrrhudhqqd`khrhlodqedbshud
vghbgs`jdr`Gsnmdrtaidbsl`qjdqvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsnsgdkdes+`rb`m
adrddmhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokdr9
205
(369) aN neL zKaYMa mbaLb "he-(1) is probably cutting meat"
31 3 2 5 5
3 31 3 2 5 5 cutting meat"
3 31 3 4 5 5 pounding meat"
Dw`lhmhmfaqhdekxsgdk`rsdw`lokdbhsdc`anud+hsrtmcdqkxhmf
rsqtbstqdvntkc`ood`q`radknv`esdqsgdkdes,sn,qhfgssnmdl`oohmfqtkd
g`rnodq`sdc'vhsgsgdrxlank!O!qdoqdrdmshmfsgdoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq
.md∆.nmsgdrxkk`akhbshdq(9
(370) // A + B ¶ P #
// L + L ¶ L #
Sgdnmkxlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'468(adknv(sn`eedbssghr
bnmrsqtbshnmhrnmdvghbghmrdqsr`Gsnmdsnm`klnqogdld`rrtaidbs
l`qjdq`mc`rrnbh`sdrhssnsgdehqrsrxkk`akdnmhsrkdesvhsgnts
chr`rrnbh`shmf`mxsnmdr`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`mcsghrnmkxenq
oqnfqdrrhudhqqd`khrhlodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmrhmsgdydqnsdmrd-Sgd
qdrtkshmfbg`mfdr`qdrgnvmadknv9
206
(371) // A + B + ¶ P #
// L + L + Ø ¶ L #
Rhmbdmdhsgdqnentqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdrhrsqhffdqdcaxsghronqshnmne
ntqbnmrsqtbshnm+sgdrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmhrpthsdrsq`hfgsenqv`qc+`r
adknv9
(372) // A + B + ¶ P #
// L + L + H ¶ L #
3 - 3 1 - 3 -
Sghrdmcrntqrdbshnmnmsgdu`qh`shnmrnesgdrtaidbsl`qjdqvhsgsgd
u`qhntrsdmrdr+`rodbsr`mclncdrnesgdhmchb`shudlnnc-Sgdenkknvhmf
rdbshnmvhkkdw`lhmdrhlhk`qhmsdq`bshnmvhsgsgdudqa`kbnmrsqtbshnm+
sgntfghsvhkkadadsvddmsgdudqa`mchsrenkknvhmfnaidbsr-
207
2.4.2. Between object and verb
Itrs`r`rtaidbsl`qjdqnbbtqr`ssgditmbstqdne`rtaidbsvhsgsgd
enkknvhmfudqaogq`rd+rnsnn`mnaidbsl`qjdqnbbtqr`ssgditmbstqdne`
udqavhsghsrenkknvhmfnaidbs-Khjdsgdl`inqhsxnertaidbsl`qjdqrvghbg
u`qhdc`bbnqchmfsnsgdmntmbk`rrnesgdrtaidbs+ntqnmdtmhptdnaidbs
l`qjdq`krnu`qhdr`bbnqchmfsnsgdmntmbk`rrnesgdnaidbs-Vghkdsgd
rtaidbsl`qjdqv`rnesdmitrssgdbnmbnqcsnmdlnqogdld+sgdnaidbs
l`qjdqg`r`cheedqdmsu`qh`shnm+sgntfghssnnhrfnudqmdcaxsgdmntm
bk`rrnesgdgd`cmntm-Sgdnaidbsl`qjdqhmMfxdla——mg`rsvna`rhb
rg`odr+`rrtll`qhydchmsgdenkknvhmfbg`qs9
1 and 7 (aL-)/(aL)N-
Sgdoqdbdchmfbg`qskhrsrsgdsvncheedqdmsenqlrnesgdnaidbsl`qjdq
`knmfvhsgsgqddcheedqdmsfqntornemntmbk`rrdr`mcsgdhqqdrodbshud
mntmbk`rroqdehwdr'sgdenqlrhmo`qdmsgdrdrnmkxadhmfnoshnm`kkx
onrrhakd`ssgdadfhmmhmfnerdmsdmbdr(-Hsb`madrddmsg`sd`bgu`qh`ms
enqlnesgdnaidbsl`qjdqhr`rrnbh`sdcvhsg`cheedqdmstypenemntm
208
bk`rroqdehw-HshrnmkxnaidbsrvhsgetkkBU'M(oqdehwdrsg`ss`jdsgd
ekn`shmfGsnmdnaidbsl`qjdqoqdehw-Sgdrdbnmcenqlhr`ydqn
lnqogdld'nqsgd`ardmbdne`l`qjdq(vghbghroqdrdms'nq`ardms(enq
`kksgdnsgdqmntmbk`rrdr+sgnrdsg`s`skd`rsnoshnm`kkxb`mrs`qsvhsg`
unvdk-Vdg`udchuhcdcsghrk`rsfqntonemntmbk`rrdrtohmsnsvn
rtafqntoradb`trdnesgdhqdwsqdldkxchudqfdmsadg`uhnq-Sgdehqrs
rtafqntobnms`hmrsgdentqmntmbk`rrdrvgnrdoqdehw`skd`rsnoshnm`kkx
adfhmrvhsgsgdunvdk!d-!Sgdrdoqdehwdrknrdsgdhqrxkk`ahbhsxhmnaidbs
onrhshnm+`oqnbdrrsg`sb`qqhdrvhsghsbdqs`hmsnm`kodqstqa`shnmr-Sgd
nsgdqrtafqntohmbktcdrsgdsvnmntmbk`rrdrvgnrdoqdehwdr`skd`rs
noshnm`kkxadfhmvhsgsgdunvdk!`-!Sgdrdoqdehwdrcnmnsknrdsgdhq
rxkk`ahbhsxhmnaidbsonrhshnm+atshmrsd`csgdx`qd`ss`bgdcsnsgd
oqdbdchmfvnqcax`qtkdneunvdk`rrhlhk`shnm+`qtkdvghbgqdrtksrhm
bdqs`hmq`sgdqtmbnllnmsnm`kodqstqa`shnmr-Sgdqd`cdqvgnhrhmsdqdrsdc
hmsgdu`qhntrbnmbnqcoqnodqshdrnesgdMfxdla——mmntmbk`rrrxrsdl
b`mehmc`cchshnm`khmenql`shnmhm@mcdqrnm'087/`(-
Vdvhkkadfhmntqdw`lhm`shnmnesgdu`qh`msnaidbsl`qjdqenqlr
vhsgsgdydqnl`qjdqbg`q`bsdqhrshbnemntmbk`rrdr2+7+8`mc0/-Sgd
nmkxnaidbseqnmsgdrdbk`rrdrsg`sg`raddmtrdchmsgdoqdrdms
chrrdqs`shnmntsrhcdnesghrrdbshnmhrsgdmntm.l–a`∆a.!ld`s-!Sghr
o`qshbtk`qmntmhreqnlmntmbk`rr8hmsgdrhmftk`q`mcv`rohbjdc`rsgd
o`q`chflnaidbsoqdbhrdkxadb`trdhscndrmnsetqsgdqbnlokhb`sdsgd
209
`kqd`cxbnlokhb`sdcsnm`kcdqhu`shnmrax`cchmfdwsq`snmdr`mcrxkk`akdr-
Vdfhudsgdenkknvhmfentqrdmsdmbdr`r`a`rdo`q`chfl+adb`trdd`bgne
sgdentqnaidbsmntmr'`kkeqnlmntmbk`rr8(hrqd`khydcnmsgdr`ldsnmd
sg`shsg`rvgdmhsnbbtqrhmhrnk`shnm9
3 3 3 34 (yesterday)
3 3 3 3 (yesterday)
3 3 3 2 (yesterday)
3 3 3 31 (yesterday)
Sgntfg`kknesgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdr`qdpthsdrsq`hfgsenqv`qc+vd
vhkkdw`lhmdsgdcdqhu`shnmnesgdk`rsdw`lokdsnrddsgdshlhmf`mc
deedbsnesgdcdrxkk`ahehb`shnmnesgdgnlnqf`mhbm`r`koqdehw.M,.nmsgd
naidbsmntm-Sgdtmcdqkxhmfrsqtbstqdnesg`sdw`lokdhmbktcdr`sdmrd
l`qjdq'S(+`qd`khronk`qsnmdlnqogdld'Kadenqd`Gsnmdqnns(+`udqa
qnns'U(`mc`mnaidbs'oqdehw!@!`mcqnns!A!(vghbg`ood`q`radknv
`esdqsgdkdes,sn,qhfgssnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
210
(375) # T # + V ¶ A + B //
# L # L + H ¶ L + H //
Nmbd`f`hm+vdg`udonrhsdcsgddwhrsdmbdne`ogq`rdantmc`xl`qjdq'ï(
adsvddmsgdudqa`kbnmrshstdmsr`mcsgdenkknvhmfnaidbsmntmogq`rd-Sghr
ogq`rdl`qjdqvhkkadrhfmhehb`mshmqduhrhmf`mnsgdqnentqsnm`klnqogdld
cnbjhmfqtkdr+dw`lhmdcetqsgdqadknv-
Sgdehqrsqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kcdrxkk`ahehb`shnmqtkd
'rdd'462(adknv(vghbgnlhsrsgdrxkk`ahbrs`strnesgdmntmbk`rroqdehwenq
mntmreqnlbk`rrdr2+7+8`mc0/vgdmsgdmntmhr`mnaidbs-Sghrqtkdcdkdsdr
rxkk`akd@vghkdkd`uhmfadghmc`ekn`shmfKsnmd+`radknv9
(376) Ø
# T # + V ¶ A + B //
# L # L + H ¶ L + H //
@mnsgdqlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'cdrbqhadchmcds`hkhmrdbshnm1-2-2-
`anud(nodq`sdrnmkxnmonrhshudO1odqedbshudrdmsdmbdrkhjdsgdnmdhmenbtr
gdqd-Hs'rdd'452(adknv(hmrdqsr`rodbh`kKsnmdinsidesgdonk`qqd`khrsnmd
lnqogdld`mc`rrnbh`sdrsghrKsnmdansgsnsgdkdes`mcsnsgdqhfgs+`radknv9
211
(377) # T # + V ¶ + B //
# L # Ø L + H ¶ L + H //
Nmbdntqqdftk`qsnmdqtkdradfhmsnnodq`sd+sgdqhrhmfsnmdvghbgv`r
bqd`sdcnmsgdudqaqnns'U(eddcrntqqhrd,cdkdshnmqtkdvghbgnodq`sdr`r
adknv9
(378) # T # + V ¶ + B //
# L # L L + H ¶ L + H //
Sgdmdwssnmdqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdmnvekn`shmfKsnmdeqnlsgdnaidbsoqdehw
snsgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akd'U(vghkdchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdr`ldrxkk`akdeqnlsgdK
snmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
(379) # T # + V ¶ + B //
# L # L L + ¶ L + H //
Sghrhmstqmeddcrntqqhrd,enql`shnmqtkdrhmbdansgsgdK`mcGsnmdnesgd
naidbsqdl`hmhmsgdr`ldvnqc`mc`qd`rrnbh`sdcsnsvnrdo`q`sdrxkk`akdr
212
'dudmhenmdnesgnrdrxkk`akdrhrhm`oqdbdchmfogq`rd(-Sghrqhrd,enql`shnmqtkd
xhdkcrsgdbnqqdbsrtqe`bdrsqtbstqdrhmbdmdhsgdqnesgdcnvmrsdoqtkdr`ookhdrsn
sghrrsqtbstqd+qdrtkshmfhmsgdenkknvhmf9
(380) # T # + V ¶ + B //
# L # L L + ¶ L + H //
- 3 - 3 -3 1
Sgdoqdbdchmfo`q`chfl`mccdqhu`shnm`qdbg`q`bsdqhrshbnenaidbsrvhsgnts
`mnudqsnaidbsl`qjdqvghbgenkknvudqarvghbgdmcnm`Ksnmd'hmbktchmfsgd
Ksnmdrteehwnehlodqedbshud`rodbs(-Ansgsgdo`q`chfl`mccdqhu`shnmbg`mfd
rhfmhehb`mskxvgdmsgdnaidbshroqdbdcdcax`udqavghbgdmcrnm`Gsnmd-Sgd
enkknvhmfo`q`chflnesgdr`ldnaidbsrhm`mdf`shudO1odqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnm
hrdrodbh`kkxqdud`khmf9
(381) aL kaL teL zaJY mbaLg wDJ "he didn’t cut the kolanut"
3 3 3 1 3 1 (yesterday)
aL kaL teL zaJY mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t cut the meat"
3 3 3 1 3 1 (yesterday)
aL kaL teL zaJY mbKim wKD "he didn’t cut the forest"
3 3 3 1 2 3 (yesterday)
aL kaL teL zaJY nzsKo wDJ "he didn’t cut the cloth"
3 3 3 1 2 2 (yesterday)
213
Sgdsnmdodqstqa`shnmrsg`svdrg`kkdw`lhmdhmcds`hk`qdsgdsvn
cdqhu`shnmrvghbgfhudqhrdsnsvntmcdqkhmdcvnqcr`anud+`ehm`kmdf`shud
bkhshb.v—æ.vghbghrqd`khydcvhsg`cnvmrsdoed`stqd`mcntqK*Gmntmvgnrd
qnnshrtrt`kkxqd`khydcnm`KGqhrhmfsnmdatshrqd`khydcgdqdnm`
cnvmrsdoodcGsnmd-Vdvhkkdw`lhmdsgdcdqhu`shnmnesgdK*Gnaidbsmntm
ehqrs+hsro`ssdqm`ood`qhmf`radknv`esdqsgdnodq`shnmnesgdkdes,sn,qhfgssnmd
l`oohmfqtkd'vhsgsgdbnllnmaho`qshsdMDFlnqogdld.sd∆---v—æ.adhmf
rxlankhydcax!M!`mc!V!nmsgdrxkk`ahbshdq(9
(382) # N # + V ¶ A + B # W //
# L # L + H ¶ L + H # H //
Sgdehqrsqtkdsn`eedbssghrrsqtbstqdhrsgdmntmcdrxkk`ahehb`shnmqtkdvghbg
nmbd`f`hmrkd`udradghmc`ekn`shmfKsnmdvghkdcdkdshmfsgdmntmbk`rroqdehw
nmsgdrxkk`ahbshdq'@(+`radknv9
(383) Ø
# N # + V ¶ A + B # W //
# L # L + H ¶ L + H # H //
Sgdmdwssnmdqtkdsnnodq`sdhrsgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`klnqogdld
qtkdvghbgrddlrsng`udsvnrdo`q`sddmuhqnmldmsrhmvghbgsncnhsrvnqj+
`rrnbh`shmfansgsgdqd`khronk`qKsnmd`mcsgdnaidbsoqdehwKsnmdsnsgd
214
`ci`bdmsrxkk`akdrnmsgdhqkdes-Hme`bs+sgdqtkdnmkxnodq`sdrnmsgdKqd`khr
onk`qsnmd-Vdsgdqdenqdmddcrnldkhlhshmfbnmchshnmnmsgdnodq`shnmnesghr
qtkdvghbgvhkkaknbjhsr`ookhb`shnmvgdmdudqhsvntkcbqnrr`ogq`rdantmc`qx
'ï(sn`rrnbh`sdvhsg`rxkk`akd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsn`mhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmf
Gsnmd-Vdsgdqdenqdlnchexntqkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfsnmdqtkd'sgdoqdkhlhm`qx
enqltk`shnmv`roqdrdmsdchm'27(`anud(+`radknv9
# + +
T + L +
Sghrqtkd`rmnvlnchehdc`ookhdrnmkxsnsgdqd`khrKsnmdonk`qsnmd
nesgdbtqqdmso`ssdqmtmcdqdw`lhm`shnm-Vgdmhs`ookhdr+hsg`rsgd
enkknvhmfqdrtks9
(385) # N # + V ¶ + B # W //
# L # L + H ¶ L + H # H //
215
Rhmbdsgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfqtkdhraknbjdceqnl`ookxhmfhmsghr
bnmrsqtbshnm+sgdKsnmdkdesekn`shmfadenqdsgdGsnmdnesgdnaidbsmntm
qnnssqhffdqrntqcnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgknvdqrsgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbg
`ssg`sonhms-Sgdqdrtkshmfrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmhr9
(386) # N # + V ¶ + B # W //
# L # L + H ¶ L + H # H //
- 3 - 1 - 2 - 2
Vghkdsgdoqdbdchmfcdqhu`shnmdmcdcvhsgrdmsdmbdehm`knaidbs`mc
MDFbkhshbqd`khydcnmcnvmsdoodcG'1(enkknvdcax`G'`krnqd`khydc
nmsgdmnvknvdqsnmdkdudk(+sgdenkknvhmfcdqhu`shnmvhkkdw`lhmd
naidbsrvhsgtmcdqkxhmfK*GKsnmdo`ssdqmrvghbgqdrtkshm`rdmsdmbd
sg`sdmcrhmtwocnvmrsdoodcGsnmdr+qd`khydcnmsnmdkdudkr'1(`mc'2(
qdrodbshudkx-Sghrcdqhu`shnmrs`qsrvhsg`mtmcdqkxhmfrsqtbstqdvghbg
`ood`qr`radknv`esdqsgdhmhsh`kkdes,sn,qhfgssnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`r
nodq`sdc9
(387) # N # + V ¶ A + B # W //
# L # L + H ¶ L + H L # H //
Sgdehqrsqtkdsnlnchexsghrrsqtbstqdhrsgdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`k
cdrxkk`ahehb`shnmqtkdvghbgjddorsgdKsnmdnesgdnaidbsoqdehwats
cdkdsdrsgdrxkk`ahbrs`mchmfnesgdm`r`kbnmrnm`ms'@(+`radknv9
216
(388) Ø
# N # + V ¶ A + B # W //
# L # L + H ¶ L + H L # H //
Mdws+ntqlnchehdckdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`klnqogdldqtkd`ookhdr
nmkxsnsgdKsnmdnesgdqd`khronk`qsnmdlnqogdld`mcmnssnsgdrsq`mcdcK
snmdnesgdnaidbsmntmoqdehwrhmbdsg`svntkcld`mbqnrrhmf`ogq`rdantmc`qx
sn`rxkk`akd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcvhsg`mhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfGsnmd-Sgd
qdrtkshrsgdqdenqdsgdenkknvhmf9
(389) # N # + V ¶ + B # W //
# L # L + H ¶ L + H L # H //
Mnv+bqtbh`kkx+sgdlds`sgdrhrqtkdcndrmns`ookxsnrxkk`akdAadb`trdsg`s
qtkdnmkx`ookhdrvgdmsgdoqdbdchmfrxkk`akdhr`rrnbh`sdcsn`Ksnmd-Rhmbdsgd
lds`sgdrhrqtkdcndrmns`ookx+ntqcnvmrsdoqtkdhr`kknvdcsn`ookxsvhbd+
knvdqhmfsgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbgnmrxkk`akdA`mc`rdbnmcmnsbgnm
rxkk`akdV+qdrtkshmfhmsgdenkknvhmf9
(390) # N # + V ¶ + B # W //
# L # L + H ¶ L + H L # H //
- 3 - 1 - 2 - 3
217
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqdw`lhm`shnmnemntmrvghbgs`jd`ydqnnaidbsl`qjdqhm
qd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr-
Sgdcdqhu`shnmnesgdrdr`ldnaidbsrvgdmsgdxnbbtqhlldch`sdkx
enkknvhmf`mhqqd`khrodqedbshududqaqnnshrrkhfgskxcheedqdms+`rsgdenkknvhmf
E2o`q`chflrtffdrsr9
3 4 3 67
3 4 3 6
3 4 3 4
3 4 3 4
Sgdnaidbsrhmsgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrtmhenqlkxadfhmvhsgcnvmrsdo-Dudm
sgdnaidbsvhsgtmcdqkxhmfK,Ksnmdvgnrdqnnshrtrt`kkxqd`khydcnm`knv,
cnvmrsdo,knvsnmdadenqdo`trdhroqdbdcdcaxxds`rdbnmccnvmrsdonmnmd
hmchuhct`krxkk`akd-Vdr`vhmrdbshnm1-2-3-`anudsg`sGsnmdrxkk`akdrb`mad
cntakd,cnvmrsdoodcnm`rhmfkdrxkk`akd+atssgdsvnmnsbgcqnohmsnm`k
qdfhrsdqv`rl`cdhmnmdrsdo-Gdqd+vhsgsvncnvmrsdornmsgdr`ldrxkk`akd
vhsgKsnmdr+sgdsvnmnsbgcqnohrjdosrdo`q`sdqdrtkshmfhm`snmdfkhcd'56
`anud(-
218
Adb`trdsgdtmcdqkxhmfK,Gsnmdnaidbs'tmcdqkhmdc`anud(hr`f`hm
qd`khydcnm`cnvmrsdoodcGsnmd+vdvhkkrdkdbssg`so`qshbtk`qrdmsdmbd
`rbg`q`bsdqhrshbnesgdfqnto+`mcdw`lhmdhsrcdqhu`shnmvhsgrodbh`k
`ssdmshnmsnsgddeedbsnesgdhmrdqshnmnesgdhqqd`khronk`qsnmd-Sghr
o`qshbtk`qrdmsdmbdg`r`mtmcdqkxhmfrsqtbstqdkhjdsgdenkknvhmf`esdqsgd
kdes,sn,qhfgssnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(392) # F # V ¶ A + B //
# L # H ¶ L + H //
@rtrt`k+sgdehqrslnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdsnnodq`sdhrsgdcdrxkk`ahehb`shnm
qtkd'rdd'462(adknv(vghbgcdkdsdrsgdrxkk`ahbhsxnesgdnaidbsm`r`koqdehw
'@(+qdrtkshmfhmsgdenkknvhmf9
(393) Ø
# F # V ¶ A + B //
# L # H ¶ L + H //
Rhmbdsgdrsq`mcdcKsnmdeqnlsgdnaidbsoqdehwhroqdbdcdcax`ogq`rd
antmc`qx'ï(`mc`rxkk`akd`rrnbhsdcsn`mhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfGsnmd+sgd
kdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdlnqogdldqtkdcndrmns`ookxsnsghrbnmrsqtbshnm-
@esdqsgdsnmdqtkdrg`udg`csgdhqbg`mbdsn`ookx+`k`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`k
qtkdhmrdqsrsgqddrdo`q`sdonk`qsnmdr'k`adkkdc!,√S!hmsgdqdoqdrdms`shnm
219
adknvitrssnrgnvsgdhqonrhshnmadenqd`mc`esdqd`bg!udqa!hmbktchmfsgd
`twhkh`qxudqa'k`adkkdc!E!(vghbghrtrdcsnl`qjetstqdshld(-Sgdr`ldqtkd
cdkdsdr`mxekn`shmfsnmdadenqdsgdnaidbsmntmqnns+`radknv9
(394) # + F # + V + ¶ + B //
# Ø + L # Ø + H + Ø ¶ L + H //
Sgdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbghmrdqsrsgdrdonk`qsnmdr`r`l`qjne
hqqd`khrlncdltrscdehmdsgdm`stqdned`bgonk`qsnmdsnadsgdoppositene
sgdehqrsassociatedsnmdvghbghlldch`sdkxenkknvr-Rhmbdsgdnaidbsoqdehw
snmdhrcdkdsdchmsghrdmuhqnmldmshehshrekn`shmf+d`bgnesgdonk`q',√S(snmdr
b`mmnvd`rhkxadrodbhehdc+`radknv9
(395) # + F # + V + ¶ + B //
H L L
Sghrkd`udr`onk`qekn`shmfsnmdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfsgqdd`rrnbh`sdc
snmdr+vghbgsqhffdqrntqcnvmrsdoqtkdsgqddrdo`q`sdshldr+knvdqhmfsgdsnm`k
qdfhrsdqnmdmnsbgd`bgshld+`radknv9
220
(396) # + F # + V + ¶ + B //
# H + L # L + H + L ¶ + H //
- 4 - 3 - 4
Adb`trdnesgdsgqddrdo`q`sdqdfhrsdqknvdqhmfr+sgdGsnmd`ssgddmcnesgd
oqdbdchmfrdmsdmbdhrqd`khydcognmdshb`kkxnmohsbgkdudk'3(hmrsd`cneohsbg
kdudk'0(-
@mdudmfqd`sdqmtladqnecnvmrsdornbbtqvgdmsgdoqdbdchmfo`q`chflhr
l`cdmdf`shud+`rsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokdrhkktrsq`sd9
(397) aL teL lMu zKaY mbMag wDJ "he won’t cut the kolanut"
3 3 4 3 6 4
aL teL lMu zKaY mbMab wDJ "he won’t cut the meat"
3 3 4 3 6 4
aL teL lMu zKaY mbKim wKD "he won’t cut the forest"
3 3 4 3 4 5
aL teL lMu zKaY nzsKo wDJ "he won’t cut the cloth"
3 3 4 3 4 4
Nmbd`f`hm+sgdnaidbsmntmqnnsr`qd`kkqd`khydcnmcnvmrsdoodcsnmdr+`
e`bsvghbgonhmsrsnsgdhmektdmbdne`m`ci`bdmsekn`shmfonk`qsnmd-Enqsghr
o`q`chfl+vdrg`kknmkxdw`lhmdsgdcdqhu`shnmnesgdrdmsdmbdbnms`hmhmfsgd
'tmcdqkhmdc(cnvmrsdoodcGsnmdnmsgdmdf`shudbkhshb.v—æ.-Sghro`qshbtk`q
221
rdmsdmbd`ood`qr`radknv`esdqsgdkdes,sn,qhfgssnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(398) # F # V ¶ A + B # W //
# L # H ¶ L + H L # H //
Sgdehqrsqtkdsnlnchexsghrrsqtbstqdhrntqcdrxkk`ahehb`shnmqtkd
vghbgnmbd`f`hmcdkdsdrsgdrxkk`ahbrs`strnesgdnaidbsmntmbk`rr
oqdehw+`radknv9
(399) Ø
# F # V ¶ A + B # W //
# L # H ¶ L + H L # H //
@ssghronhms+sgdqdftk`qsnmdqtkdr`qd`kknvdcsnnodq`sd+atsmnmd`qd
`ookhb`akd-Sgdrsq`mcdcKsnmdeqnlsgdnaidbsoqdehwhrmns`rrnbh`sdcsnhsr
kdesaxsgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`klnqogdldqtkdadb`trdhshroqdbdcdc
ax`ogq`rdantmc`qx'ï(`mc`rxkk`akd`rrnbh`sdcsn`mhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmf
Gsnmd-Khjdvhrd+sgdlds`sgdrhrqtkde`hkrsneqnmssgdKsnmdnesgdnaidbsqnns
'A(adb`trdsgdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmf`rrnbh`sdcsnmdhr`Gsnmd-Sgdmdws
qtkdsnnodq`sdhrsgtrsgdk`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbghmrdqsronk`qsnmdr
',√S(hlldch`sdkxadenqd`mc`esdq`kk!udqar!hmhqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr+cdkdshmf
`ssgdr`ldshldsgdrsq`mcdcKsnmdnesgdnaidbsoqdehw+`radknv9
222
(400) # + F # + V + ¶ + B # W //
# Ø + L # Ø + H + Ø ¶ L + H L # H //
Sgdonk`qsnmdr`qdmnvcdsdqlhmdcsnadnoonrhsdhmm`stqdsnsgdhq
enkknvhmf`ci`bdmssnmdrnmsgdsnm`kshdq-Sgdrdonk`qsnmdrsgtrsqhffdqsgd
qdfhrsdq,knvdqhmfcnvmrsdoqtkdsgqddshldr-Sgdr`ldqtkdhrsqhffdqdcnmd
`cchshnm`kshldaxsgdekn`shmfKsnmdnerxkk`akdAvghbgv`rmnslds`sgdrhydc
hmsghrdmuhqnmldms-Sgdognmdshbqd`khy`shnmnesgdrdmsdmbd,ehm`kGsnmdhr
sgtrentqmnsbgdrknvdq'ohsbgkdudk4hmrsd`cne0(+`radknv9
(401) # + F # + V + ¶ + B # W //
H L L
- 4 - 3 - 4 - 5
Hsrgntkcadldmshnmdcgdqdsg`ssgdcnvmrsdoodcGsnmdqd`khydcnmsgd
rdmsdmbd,ehm`kmdf`shudbkhshb.v—æ.`anudnbbtqrhmitrssgddmuhqnmldmsvgdqd
vdg`udbnldsnadkhdudsg`ssgdmnql`klds`sgdrhrqtkdhraknbjdceqnl
nodq`shmfnmsgdoqdbdchmfmntmqnns`mcsghrhrrsqnmfhmcdodmcdmslnshu`shnm
enqsgdoqdrdmbdnesgdehm`kekn`shmfKsnmdhmsgdtmcdqkxhmfkdwhb`krsqtbstqdne
223
rtbgmntmr-Hs`krnkdmcr`cchshnm`khmcdodmcdmslnshu`shnmsnsgdoqdrdms
rsqtbstqdnentqlds`sgdrhrqtkdvghbgcndrmnsnodq`sdhmitrssgnrd
dmuhqnmldmsrvgdqdhshrmnsmddcdc-
Svn`cchshnm`kbnmrsqtbshnmrvghbgaxlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkddmctovhsg
`onk`qsnmdsnm`klnqogdlditrsadenqdsgdnaidbs'khjdsgdhqqd`khr
bnmrsqtbshnmrrgnvm`anud(+`qdsgdO/`mcO0qd`khronrhshudodqedbshud
rdmsdmbdr-Vdr`vhmrdbshnm1-2-2-`anudsg`ssgdO0onrhshudodqedbshud
bnmrsqtbshnmv`roqna`akxlncdkdcnmsgdO/bnmrdbtshudbnmrsqtbshnm+rnsghr
rhlhk`qhsxnenaidbsl`qjhmfhrmnsrtqoqhrhmf-@sxohb`kO/bnmrsqtbshnmvntkc
`ood`q`radknv9
3 31 45
3 31 4
3 31 2
3 31 2
Nmbdsgdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'465(adknv(hmrdqsrsgdO/onk`qsnmd
`esdqsgdudqaqnns+hsrcdqhu`shnmoqnbddcrltbgkhjdsgdhqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr
224
vditrsdw`lhmdc+qdrtkshmfhmcnvmrsdoodcrtqe`bdsnmdrenq`kknentq
tmcdqkxhmfmntmsnm`ko`ssdqmr-
Vdmnvkd`udadghmcsgdgnlnqf`mhbm`r`kmntmbk`rroqdehwdr`mcstqmsn
snsgnrdbk`rrdrvghbgs`jd`etkkBU'M(oqdehw-Vdvhkkbgnrdsgdmntmrne
bk`rr4vgnrdoqdehwhr.kd∆,.`rqdoqdrdms`shudnesghrfqnto-@qdoqdrdms`shud
o`q`chflvhsgmntmreqnlsgdentqsnmdo`ssdqmrvntkcadsgdenkknvhmf9
(403) aL kaL teL zaJY leJpfoLm wDJ "he didn’t cut the stomach"
3 3 3 1 1 3 1 (yesterday)
aL kaL teL zaJY leJpfoL wDJ "he didn’t cut the kolanut"
3 3 3 1 1 3 1 (yesterday)
aL kaL teL zaJY leJpfKC wKD "he didn’t cut the garbage"
3 3 3 1 1 2 3 (yesterday)
aL kaL teL zaJY leJkwFKe wDJ "he didn’t cut the bamboo"
3 3 3 1 1 2 2 (yesterday)
Sgdlnrsmnshbd`akdsnmdodqstqa`shnmhmsgdoqdbdchmfo`q`chflhr
sg`s`kknesgdnaidbsrvgnrdKsnmdmntmbk`rroqdehw.kd∆,.hrmnql`kkx
qd`khydcnm`Ksnmdhmhrnk`shnm`mchmrtaidbsonrhshnmhrgdqdqd`khydcnm
`odqstqadcGsnmd-Hshroqdbhrdkxsghrodqstqa`shnmenq`kkmntmrvgnrd
oqdehwdrg`udrhlhk`qrxkk`akdrsqtbstqdsg`sg`rlnshu`sdcntqonrhshmf`
225
Gsnmdnaidbsl`qjdqoqdehwvghbgoqdbdcdrsgdnaidbsmntmbk`rroqdehw
hm`kkrtbgbnmrsqtbshnmr-
Nmbd`f`hm+vdvhkkdw`lhmdhmcds`hksgdcdqhu`shnmnesgdrdmsdmbd
vgdqdvdehmcsgd'tmcdqkhmdc(cnvmrsdoodcGsnmdnmsgdrdmsdmbd,ehm`k
mdf`shudbkhshb.v—æ.-Rhmbdsgdnaidbshmsghrrdmsdmbdg`r`mtmcdqkxhmf
K*GKsnmdo`ssdqm+ntqtmcdqkxhmfrsqtbstqdvntkc`ood`q`radknv`esdq
sgdkdes,sn,qhfgssnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc9
(404) # N # + V ¶ + A + B # W //
# L # L + H ¶ H + L + H L # H //
Rhmbdsgdmntmbk`rroqdehwhmsghrb`rdhr`etkkBU'B(rxkk`akd'@(+hs
cndrmnstmcdqfnntqcdrxkk`ahehb`shnmqtkd`rchcsgdrxkk`ahbm`r`k
bnmrnm`msrvghbgl`qjdcsgdmntmbk`rrdrchrbtrrdc`anud-Sgdqdenqd+
sgdehqrssnmdqtkdsn`ookxsnsghrrsqtbstqdhrntqkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmd
snm`klnqogdldqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdKsnmdnesgdqd`khronk`qsnmd
lnqogdldsnsgdMDFl`qjdqrxkk`akd'M(vghkdchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdKsnmd
`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
(405) # N # + V ¶ + A + B # W //
# L # L + H ¶ H + L + H L # H //
Sgdmdwssnmdqtkdsnnodq`sdhrsgdqhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfGsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdrsgdGsnmdnaidbsl`qjdqlnqogdldsn
226
sgdenkknvhmfmntmbk`rroqdehw'@(vghkdchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdKsnmd
`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
(406) # N # + V ¶ + A + B # W //
# L # L + H ¶ H + L + H L # H //
Mnetqsgdqsnmdqtkdrnodq`sdnmsghro`ssdqm-Sgdlds`sgdrhrqtkdhr
aknbjdc`ssvnok`bdr-Hsb`mmnsnodq`sdnmdhsgdqrxkk`akd@nqAadb`trd
hmd`bgb`rdsg`srxkk`akdhroqdbdcdcax`rxkk`akd`rrnbh`sdcsn`Gsnmd-
Ansgsgdekn`shmfKsnmdr`qdkdesvgdqdsgdxnqhfhm`sdc`mcd`bgnmd
sqhffdqrsgdcnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgknvdqrsgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbg+
qdrtkshmfhmsgdbnqqdbsrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmrgnvmadknv9
(407) # N # + V ¶ + A + B # W //
# L # L + H ¶ H + L + H L # H //
- 3 - 1 - 1 - 2 - 3
Hsrgntkcadmnshbdcsg`ssgdekn`shmfGsnmdnaidbsl`qjdqcdrbqhadc
`anudltrsg`udsgdogq`rdantmc`qxnmhsrkdesadb`trdhehsv`rnmhsr
qhfgs+sgdkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`klnqogdldqtkdvntkc`rrnbh`sd
sgdGsnmdsnsgdnaidbsoqdehwatsvntkcmnschr`rrnbh`sdsgdsnmd`kqd`cx
`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`snmdsg`shrbqtbh`kenqntqcnvmrsdoqtkdr-Sgtr+sgd
ekn`shmfGsnmdnaidbsl`qjdqhrcdehmhsdkx`oqd,oqdehwnmsgdnaidbs-
227
Sgdehm`ku`qh`shnmnesgdnaidbsl`qjdqhrmns`s`kkbkd`q`ssgd
oqdrdmslnldms-Vdvhkkonrhs+a`rdcnmsgdc`s``sg`mc+sg`smntm
bk`rrdr0`mc6cnmnsg`ud`mnaidbsl`qjdqoqdrdms-Vdonrhs+enqsgd
lnldmssg`ssgdtmtrt`ked`stqdrnesgdenkknvhmfo`q`chflnebk`rr6
mntmrhmsgdnaidbsonrhshnmhritrssgdqdrtksnesgdm`stqd`mcshlhmfne
ntqunvdk`rrhlhk`shnmqtkd-Sgdtmtrt`kbg`q`bsdqnesgdenkknvhmf
dw`lokdrhrnmkxok`hmvgdmnmdqdldladqrsg`ssgdrdrdmsdmbdr`qd
odqedbshud+`mcsgtrcnmnsg`ud`mxudqarteehwnmsgdtmcdqkxhmfkdudk-
Ntqtmtrt`ko`q`chfl9
3 3 3 2 2 4 2 (yesterday)
aL kaL teL gwKDYDJ ffoL wDJ "he didn’t pound the leaf"
3 3 3 2 2 4 2 (yesterday)
aL kaL teL gwKDYDJ kKaB wKD "he didn’t pound the plate"
3 3 3 2 2 3 4 (yesterday)
aL kaL teL gwKDYDJ tyoN wDJ "he didn’t pound the tree"
3 3 3 2 2 42 2 (yesterday)
Sgdtmtrt`km`stqdnesgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrb`madrtll`qhydc
tmcdqsgdenkknvhmfl`hmonhmsr9
228
(409) A) presence of an echo vowel suffix on the verb in a
perfective construction.
Vdoqnonrdsg`s`kknesgdrdbg`q`bsdqhrshbr`qdsgdqdrtksnesgdk`sd
nqcdqhmfne`unvdk`rrhlhk`shnmqtkd'rdd'475(adknv(vghbgs`jdr`mxunvdk
sg`sadfhmr`vnqc+`ss`bgdrhssnsgddmcnesgdoqdbdchmfvnqc+`rrhlhk`sdrhssn
sgdunvdkpt`khsxnesgdoqdbdchmfunvdk+andqd`rrnbh`sdrhssnsgdoqdbdchmf
snmd-Vdvhkkdw`lhmdhmcds`hksgdcdqhu`shnmnesgdk`rsdw`lokdrgnvm`anud
hmnqcdqsnrddvgxrtbg`qtkdnqcdqdc`esdqsgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdrb`mg`ud
rtbg`mtmtrt`kdeedbs-Ntqtmcdqkxhmfrsqtbstqdvntkc`ood`q`radknv`esdq
sgdkdes,sn,qhfgssnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdc'vdvhkkk`adksgdnaidbsmntm
bk`rroqdehwknvdqb`rd!`!hmsghrcdqhu`shnmrhmbdhsqdoqdrdmsr`unvdkvghbg
vhkktmcdqfn`rdfldms`k`rrhlhk`shnm(9
(410) # N # + V ¶ a + B # W //
# L # H + L ¶ L + H # H //
229
Rhmbdsgdcdrxkk`ahehb`shnmqtkdcndrmns`ookxsnsgdrdnaidbsoqdehwdr+sgd
ehqrsqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqqhfgsv`qc,cnbjhmfGsnmdsnm`klnqogdldqtkdvghbg
`rrnbh`sdrsgdekn`shmfGqd`khronk`qsnmdsnsgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akdnmhsrqhfgs
vghkdchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdKsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`radknv9
(411) # N # + V ¶ a + B # W //
# L # H + L ¶ L + H # H //
Sghrhmstqmeddcrntqlds`sgdrhrqtkdvghbgeqnmsrsgdmnvrsq`mcdcKsnmd
vghbgb`ldeqnlsgdudqaqnns+`radknv9
(412) # N # + V ¶ a + B # W //
# L # H + L ¶ L + H # H //
Sgdmdwssnmdqtkdsnnodq`sdhrntqqhrd,enql`shnmqtkdvghbgenqlr`KG
qhrhmfsnmdnmrxkk`akdAax`rrnbh`shmfsg`srxkk`akdsnsgdoqdbdchmfKsnmd
mntmbk`rroqdehw+`radknv9
(413) # N # + V ¶ a + B # W //
# L # L H + ¶ L + H # H //
Mnv+`esdq`kksgdqdftk`qsnmdqtkdrg`udnodq`sdc+vdbnldsnsgdbqtbh`k
lnldmshmsgdcdqhu`shnm-Sgntfgntqc`s`nmunvdk`rrhlhk`shnmhrmns
230
nudqvgdklhmf+mnsghmfsgdqdrgnvrntqenkknvhmfqtkdsnade`krd-Vdsgdqdenqd
sdms`shudkxoqnonrdsg`s`rhmfkdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkd'rdd'465(adknv(
nodq`sdnm`kkvnqc,hmhsh`kunvdkrvghbg`qdmns`krnrdmsdmbd,hmhsh`k`mc`ss`bg
sgdlsnsgdoqdbdchmfvnqc'`r`rteehw(-Sgdqtkdvntkc`krn`rrhlhk`sdsgd
unvdksnsgdunvdkpt`khsxentmchmsgdoqdbdchmfrxkk`akd-@mc+bqtbh`kkx+sghr
k`sdqtkdvntkc`krnchr`rrnbh`sdsgdunvdkeqnlhsroqduhntrkx`rrnbh`sdcsnmdr
`mcqd`rrnbh`sdhssnsgdk`rssnmdnesgdoqdbdchmfvnqc-@kksghrhrrgnvmhmsgd
enkknvhmfqdoqdrdms`shnm9
(414)
# N # + V D ¶ a + B # W //
# L # L H + ¶ L + H # H //
Sgdnmkxqdl`hmhmfqtkdsn`eedbssghrrsqtbstqdhrntqcnvmrsdoqtkdvghbg
knvdqrsgdsnmdqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbghlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfsgdudqaqnns+
qdrtkshmfhmsgdbnqqdbsrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmentmcadknv9
(415) # N # + V + D ¶ + B # W //
# L # L H + + ¶ L + H # H //
- 3 - 2-2 - 4 2 - 2
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqdw`lhm`shnmnesnmdbg`mfdrctdsnsgdoqdrdmbd
nq`ardmbdne`mnaidbsl`qjdqadsvddmudqa`mcnaidbs-
231
1-4-Nudq`kkQtkdNqcdqhmf
Sgdu`qhntrsnmdqtkdrmddcdchmMfxdla——mg`udaddmcdudknodc
nudqsgdbntqrdnesgdoqdbdchmfsgqddrdbshnmr91-1-nmqtkdrmddcdchm
nqcdqsng`mckdmntmogq`rdr+1-2-nm`cchshnm`kqtkdrmddcdcsng`mckd
udqaogq`rdr+`mcehm`kkx1-3-nmsvnqdrsqhbshnmrnmntqsnm`klnqogdld
cnbjhmfqtkdrvgdmrtaidbsr+udqar`mcnaidbsrbnldhmbnms`bs-Sgd
oqdrdmsrdbshnmvhkkbnkkdbs`kksgdrdqtkdrhmsnnmdok`bdrnsgdqd`cdqb`m
fds`mnudq`kkhcd`nesgddmshqdsnm`krxrsdl-Sgdqd`cdqhrqdedqqdcsn
@oodmchw@enq`qdrs`sdldmsnesgdehm`ksnmdqtkdrvhsgitrssgdhq
enql`khydcrs`sdldmsr-Sghrrdbshnmvhkkchrbtrrhmoqnrdsgdu`qhntrsnmd
qtkdrvghbgg`udaddmcdudknodc-
Sgdehqrsrsdosnrddhmfsgdvgnkdrxrsdlhrsnrdd`khrsne`kksgdsnmd
qtkdr`knmfvhsg`chrbtrrhnmnesgdhqnqcdqhmf-Sgdsnmdqtkdrhm
Mfxdla——mg`udaddmchuhcdchmsnsgqddrdo`q`sdfqntor-Bqtbh`kkx+`kkne
sgdsnmdqtkdr`qdtmnqcdqdcvhsghmsgdhqqdrodbshudfqnto+d`bgfqnto
nodq`shmfnm`kdes,sn,qhfgsoqhmbhokd-Sgdd`qkxfqntobnms`hmritrsntq
kdes,sn,qhfgssnmdl`oohmfqtkd+vghbgu`qhntrvqhsdqrg`udonrhsdcsnad`
tmhudqr`k-Sgdrdbnmc`mcl`inqfqntobnms`hmrntq!qdftk`q!snmdqtkdr
vghbgnodq`sdvgdmdudqsgdhqbnmchshnmr`qdldslnuhmfsgqntfgsgd
bnms`hmritrsntqk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdvghbghrqdronmrhakdnmkxenqxhdkchmf
232
sgdbnqqdbsognmdshbqd`khy`shnmeqnlsgdqdrsnesgdcdqhu`shnm-Vdmnv
fhud`mtoc`sdcbg`qs'eqnl'60(`anud(+vghbgkhrsrsgdu`qhntrqtkdrhm
d`bgnesgdhqfqntor+rdo`q`sdceqnld`bgnsgdqaxu`qhntrlnqogn,
snmnknfhb`k!fq`ll`shb`k!qtkdr+`radknv9
233
Hsrgntkcadrsqdrrdcsg`s`o`qseqnlsgde`bssg`ssgdl`oohmfqtkdhr
udqxd`qkx`mcsgdcnvmrsdoqtkdudqxk`sd+sgdqdrsnesgdsnmdqtkdr`qd
bnlokdsdkxtmnqcdqdcvhsgqdrodbssnd`bgnsgdq-Sgdx`qdnqcdqdchmd`bg
cdqhu`shnmrhlokxaxsgdknb`koqhmbhokdneoqnbddchmfeqnlkdessnqhfgsnm
sgdsnm`kshdq`mc`kknvhmfd`bgqtkdsn`ookxvgdmdudqhsrbnmchshnmr`qd
lds-
Vdvhkkmnvqdrs`sdd`bgnesgdenql`khydcudqrhnmrnesgdsnmdqtkdr
hmsgdnqcdqsg`ssgdxvdqdchrbtrrdchmsgdsdws'`mcvhsg`qdedqdmbd
a`bjsnhsrnqhfhm`kok`bdhmsgdsdws(-Vdvhkkenkknvd`bgqtkdvhsg`
aqhdertll`qxnevg`ssgdqtkd`bbnlokhrgdr-Rs`qshmfvhsgsgdqtkdrvd
cdudknodcenqsgdmntmogq`rd+ntqehqrsqtkdv`r9
L Ø Ø / //
H L
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkd`ccransg`G`mcKsnmd`esdq`mxrhmfkd
`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdvghbghlldch`sdkxoqdbdcdro`trd+`mc`rrnbh`sdrsgd
k`rsKsnmda`bjsnsgdr`ldrxkk`akd-Vdmdwsneedqdc`oqdkhlhm`qx
udqrhnmnentqcnvmrsdoqtkd+`radknv9
234
(418) Rule 2: Downstep (see (18) above)
+1 pitch
-[T [T
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkdhr`k`sd`citrsldmsqtkdvghbgknvdqrsgdsnmd
qdfhrsdqnmdmnsbg'`mhmbqd`rdmtldqhb`kkxld`mr`knvdqohsbgkdudk(
vgdmdudq`m`rrnbh`sdcsnmdhrhlldch`sdkxoqdbdcdcax`ekn`shmfsnmdne
noonrhsdbg`q`bsdq-Hsrgntkcadmnsdcsg`ssghrqtkdhransgbtltk`shud`mc
odqrdudq`shud-Nmbd`cnvmrsdoqtkdhrsqhffdqdc+hsknvdqrallenkknvhmf
snmdrnmdohsbgkdudktmshkhsqd`bgdrsgdmdwso`trd-Vgdmlnqdsg`mnmd
cnvmrsdonbbtqradsvddmsvno`trdr+sgdxjddoknvdqhmfsgdohsbg
qdfhrsdq`cchshnm`kmnsbgdr-Sgdnqdshb`kkxrod`jhmf+sgdqdhrmnkhlhssnsgd
mtladqnecnvmrsdorvghbglhfgss`jdok`bdadsvddmsvno`trdr-
Oq`bshb`kkxrod`jhmf+vgdmsgdohsbgqdfhrsdqfdsrsnnknv+`esdqrdudmsn
sdmknvdqhmfr+sgdMfxdla——mrod`jdqvhkko`trd'`mcqdrdsghrohsbg
kdudk(`ssgdmdwsl`inqfq`ll`shb`kantmc`qx-@qtkdvghbg`kv`xreddcr
sghrcnvmrsdoqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
235
# #
L H L
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkdv`r`oqdkhlhm`qxenqltk`shnmnentqlds`sgdrhr
qtkd-Sghrqtkdqdudqrdcsgdnqcdqne`m`rrnbh`sdcGsnmd`mc`enkknvhmf
Ksnmdvgdmdudqsgdoqdbdchmfrxkk`akdv`r`rrnbh`sdcsn`Ksnmd-Sghr
qtkdv`rbqtbh`khmeddchmfntqcnvmrsdoqtkd`ssgdqhfgsok`bdhmntq
snm`ko`ssdqmr-Ntqmdwsqtkdv`r9
# #
# L H #
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkdbqd`sdr`KGqhrhmfsnmdax`rrnbh`shmf`mx`kqd`cx
`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdsnsgdmdwsrxkk`akdhesg`srxkk`akdhr`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdc
sn`rhmfkdGsnmdoqnuhchmfsg`sansgsnmdr`qd`ci`bdms`mcbnms`hmdchm
sgdr`ldvnqc-Ntqmdwsqtkdv`r9
236
(421) Rule 5: Leftward-docking L-tone Morphemes (see (38)
above)
# + +
T + L +
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkdv`r`md`qkxudqrhnmnentqqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdc
'cnbjdc(`mx'ekn`shmf(Ksnmdhm`lnqogdldvhsgntsrxkk`ahbbnmsdmssn
sgdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfrxkk`akdvghkdchr`rrnbh`shmfsg`srxkk`akdeqnl
sgdsnmdhsv`r`rrnbh`sdcsn+hesg`ssnmdv`r`ci`bdmssnsgdmdvkx
`rrnbh`sdcKsnmd-Ntqmdwsqtkdv`r9
# # + +
L H + L +
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkdv`r`md`qkxudqrhnmnentqqtkdvghbgcdkdsdcsgd
Gsnmdne`mxrxkk`akdvghbgg`c`KGsnmdqhrd`rrnbh`sdcvhsghs
oqnuhcdcsg`ssgdKsnmdnesg`sqhrdv`r`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsnsgd
237
oqdbdchmfrxkk`akd`mcsg`ssgdrxkk`akdvhsgsgdqhrdv`rhlldch`sdkx
enkknvdcax`lnqogdldbnms`hmhmfmnsghmfats`rhmfkdKsnmd-Ntqmdws
qtkdv`r9
above)
+ + #
+ H + T
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkdv`r`md`qkxudqrhnmnentqqtkdvghbg`rrnbh`sdc
'cnbjdc(`mx'ekn`shmf(Gsnmdvghbgl`cdto`mdmshqdlnqogdldsnsgd
hlldch`sdkxenkknvhmfrxkk`akd`mccdkdsdcsgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdeqnlsg`s
rxkk`akdsn`mxsnmdvghbghlldch`sdkxenkknvdcsgdmdvkx`rrnbh`sdcG
snmd-Ntqmdwsqtkdv`r9
# #
L (H) H L
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkdv`rntqqduhrdclds`sgdrhrqtkdvghbg`ccdcsgd
onrrhahkhsxne`ekn`shmfGsnmdadenqdsgdrxkk`akdtmcdqfnhmfsgdbg`mfd-
Sgdqtkdmnvbg`mfdcsgdnqcdqne`m`rrnbh`sdcGsnmd`mc`enkknvhmf
ekn`shmfKsnmdoqnuhcdcsg`ssgdoqduhntrrxkk`akdhr`rrnbh`sdcsn`K
238
snmd`mc`kknvhmfenqsgdoqdrdmbdne`rhmfkdekn`shmfGsnmdadsvddmsgd
svn`ci`bdmsrxkk`akdr-Sgdqduhrhnmnesghrqtkdv`rsgdk`rsrsdohmntq
cdudknoldmsnesnmdqtkdrmddcdcsng`mckdsgdsnmdbg`mfdrenq
chrxkk`ahbmntmrhmmntmogq`rdr-
Nmdnesgdl`hm`hlrnesghrchrrdqs`shnmv`rsnrddhesgdsnmdqtkdr
mddcdchmMfxdla——mmntmogq`rdrvdqdrteehbhdmshm`mcnesgdlrdkudr
sng`mckd`kknesgdsnmdbg`mfdrentmchmudqaogq`rdr-Vghkdvdentmc
sg`ssgdmntmogq`rdsnmdqtkdrg`mckdcsgdu`rsl`inqhsxneudqa`ksnmd
odqstqa`shnmr+vdchcmddcsncdudknonmdmdvsnmdqtkd-Sghrsnmdqtkd+
sgdVEQ+v`rnmdo`qsnesgdVEBvghbgmddcdcsnadqdrs`sdc`mcfhudm
sgdrs`strne`mtmnqcdqdcsnmdqtkd-Rs`sdcehqrshmhsroqdkhlhm`qxenql9
Sghrqtkdr`xrsg`svgdmdudq`snmdkdrrrxkk`akdhrentmc'hmsgdkdes,
sn,qhfgs`ookhb`shnmnesgdsnmdqtkdr(+hshr`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdehqrssnmd
entmcsnhsrkdes-Mdws+hsv`rentmcsg`svdmddcdcsnqduhrdsgdqhrd,
239
cdkdshnmqtkd+vghbgv`rqdrs`sdc`radknv9
# #
L (T) H / L
Sgdoqdbdchmfqduhrdcqtkd`kknvrenqsgdoqdrdmbdne`ekn`shmfsnmd
adsvddmntqsvnrxkk`akdrvgdqdqhrd,cdkdshnms`jdrok`bd`mc`kknvrsg`s
sgdqhrdltrsnmkxadenkknvdcax`enkknvhmfKsnmdhmrsd`cne`Ksnmd
snm`klnqogdld-SgdqtkdmnvcdkdsdrsgdGsnmdne`mxrxkk`akdvhsg`
KGqhrhmfsnmdvgdmdudqsgdKsnmdhr`rrnbh`sdcsn`oqdbdchmfrxkk`akd
`mcsgdqhrhmfsnmdhrhlldch`sdkxenkknvdcax`Ksnmddudmhe`ekn`shmf
snmdnbbtqradsvddmsgdK`mcGsnmdnesgdqhrd-Mdws+vdchrbnudqdc
qd`rnmsnetqsgdqbnmlokhb`sdntqVEQ+`mcvdqdrs`sdchshmhsrehm`k
enql`radknv9
240
'#(*#*
(T) T + +
Sghrqtkd`rrnbh`sdr`mxsnmdkdrrrxkk`akdsnsgdehqrssnmdentmcnmhsr
kdesvghkdchr`rrnbh`shmf`rvdkksg`sr`ldsnmdeqnl`mxnsgdqrxkk`akdr
vhsgvghbghslhfgs`kqd`cxad`rrnbh`sdcrnknmf`rsgnrdrxkk`akdrvntkc
qds`hmxds`mnsgdqsnmd-Ntqmdwsrsdov`rsnqduhrdntqcnvmrsdoqtkdhm
nqcdqsn`kknvenqcntakdcnvmrsdoohmfnesgdsnm`kqdfhrsdq+`radknv9
+ਫ pitch
(-[T)ਫ [T
241
This rule says that the tone register is lowered the
same number of steps (add one pitch level for each step
Sghrv`rsgdk`rsnesgdsnmdqtkdr`mcqduhrhnmrnesnmdqtkdrvghbg
v`rmddcdcsng`mckd`kknentqc`s`nmudqaogq`rdr'oqdrdmsdchmsgd
enkknvhmfbg`osdq(-Adenqdkd`uhmf`rhcdsgdptdrshnmne`cchshnm`ksnmd
qtkdr`mcsgdhqdw`bsenql+sgdhmsdq`bshnmnemntmogq`rdrvhsgudqa
ogq`rdr`mcudqarvhsgnaidbsrv`rdw`lhmdcvhsgrodbh`k`ssdmshnmsn
snm`kogdmnldm`-Hsv`rentmcsg`smnmdvsnmdqtkdrvdqdmddcdc+ats
sg`sd`bgnentqqtkdrvghbgcnbjrsnm`klnqogdldrg`csng`ud`ccdc
qdrsqhbshnmrvghbghmd`bgb`rdqdedqqdcsnsgdoqdrdmbdne`mhmsdqudmhmf
ogq`rdantmc`qx-Sgdehqrsnesgdrdqtkdrsnadqduhrdcv`rntqqhfgsv`qc,
cnbjhmfGsnmdsnm`klnqogdldqtkd+vghbgv`rehm`kkxenql`khydc`r
adknv9
242
(323) above)
+ + #
+ H + T
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkd`rrnbh`sdrsgdGsnmdne`lnqogdldbnmrhrshmfne
mnsghmfdkrdsnsgdehqrsrxkk`akdnmhsrqhfgs+atsvhkkmnschr`rrnbh`sdsg`s
rxkk`akdeqnlsgdsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqdhesgdmdvkx`rrnbh`sdcG
snmdg`csnbqnrr`ogq`rdantmc`qxsnehmcsgdrxkk`akd-Ntqehm`kqduhrhnm
ne`snmdqtkdenqsgdo`q`kkdkkdesv`qc,cnbjhmfKsnmdsnm`klnqogdld
qtkdv`renql`khydc`radknv9
243
(384) above)
# + +
T + L +
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkdbnmshmtdrsn`rrnbh`sd`Ksnmdvghbgl`jdrto`m
dmshqdlnqogdldsnsgdehqrsrxkk`akdnmhsrkdesvghkdchrr`rrnbh`shmfsgd
snmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+dwbdoshesgdmdvkx`rrnbh`sdcsnmdltrs
bqnrr`ogq`rdantmc`qxsnehmc`rxkk`akd`mcsgdhlldch`sdkxoqduhntr
snmd`rrnbh`sdcsnsg`srxkk`akdhr`Gsnmd-
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqrtll`qxnesgdcdudknoldmsnentqsnmdqtkdr`mc
sgdo`qsnesgdfq`ll`q'mntmogq`rd+udqaogq`rd+rtaidbsnqnaidbs
l`qjdq(vghbgmdbdrrhs`sdcsgdhqenqltk`shnmnqqduhrhnm-Hsrgntkcad
ldmshnmdcsg`smns`kknesgd`cchshnm`kudqac`s`bntkcg`udaddmg`mckdc
vhsgntsonrhshmfrdudq`klnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdrvghbgs`jd
fq`ll`shb`khmenql`shnmhmsn`bbntmsvgdmcdbhchmfvgdsgdqsn`ookx-
Sgdrdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdr`qdenql`khydchmbg`osdq3adknv-Sgd
dhfgsotqdkxsnm`kqtkdritrsdk`anq`sdccnmnsmddc`mxfq`ll`shb`k
244
hmenql`shnmhmsgdhqenqltk`shnm-Sgdxnodq`sdvgdmdudqsgdhqbnmchshnmr
`qdldsnmsgdsnm`k`mcrxkk`ahbshdqr`knmd-
245
CHAPTER 3
2-/ UdqaO`q`chflr
Sgdoqdrdmsbg`osdqoqdrdmsrsgdu`qhntro`q`chflrnesdmrd+`rodbs+
lncd`mconk`qhsxhmsgdMfxdla——mhmchb`shudl`hmbk`trd-Hshrsghrc`s`
vghbgg`raddmsgdbdmsdqnentqhmudrshf`shnmhmsnsnm`kogdmnldm`hm
sgdudqaogq`rd-
Sgdu`qhntrudqao`q`chflroqdrdmsdchmsghrbg`osdqvhkkad
nqf`mhydc`bbnqchmfsnntqbg`qs'ehqrsoqdrdmsdchm'71(`anud(vghbg
rgnvrvgdsgdqd`bgbnmrsqtbshnm&rsnmdrnmsgdudqarsdl`qdsgnrdnesgd
qdftk`qqd`khr'Q(+nqqdftk`qhqqd`khr'H(nqrnldtmtrt`khchnrxmbq`shb'w(
qd`khy`shnm+`radknv9
246
(431) Revised Realis/Irrealis Tone Distribution
Features P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø F1 F2 F3 F4
+real
-perf
-prog
-perf
+prog
-real
-perf
-prog
-perf
+prog
247
Vdvhkkoqdrdmssgdhmchuhct`ko`q`chflrenqd`bgnesgdmhmdsdmrdr
hmsgdbg`qseqnlkdessnqhfgs+`mcdw`lhmhmfd`bgnesgdbnmrsqtbshnmr
onrrhakdhmd`bgsdmrdeqnlsnosnanssnlhmd`bgbnktlm-@rhm`
oqduhntrqdedqdmbdsnsghrr`ldbg`qs+!Q!qdedqrsnqdftk`qqd`khrsnmd
o`ssdqmr+!H!snqdftk`qhqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmr+`mc!w!snhchnrxmbq`shbsnmd
o`ssdqmrnmsgdudqa-Sgdkdssdqsnsgdkdesned`bgrk`rghmchb`sdrsgdsnmd
o`ssdqmnesgdonrhshudbnmrsqtbshnmvghkdsgdkdssdqsnsgdqhfgsned`bg
rk`rghmchb`sdrhsrmdf`shudbntmsdqo`qs-
Ctdsnsgddwsqdldkxeqdptdmsnbbtqqdmbdnesvnsnmdo`ssdqmr+`mc
ctdsnsgdbnmsq`rsadsvddmsgdrdsvno`ssdqmrbnqqdk`shmfvhsg`rdl`mshb
bnmsq`rsadsvddmqd`khr`mchqqd`khrlncd+sgdrdsvno`ssdqmrg`udaddm
cdsdqlhmdcsnadlnqda`rhbsg`mu`qhntrhchnrxmbq`shbo`ssdqmr`mcsgdx
g`udsgdqdenqdaddmk`adkdc!qdftk`q-!Sgdenkknvhmfbg`qsfhudrsgd
surfaceqd`khy`shnmrnesgdqdftk`qqd`khr`mchqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmrnmsgd
udqarsdl9
Sgdoqdbdchmfbg`qsrgnvrsg`sqdftk`qsnm`ko`ssdqmrenqudqarsdlr
hmqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr`qdGsnmdeqnl`mtmcdqkxhmfGsnmdudqaqnns`mc
248
cnvmrsdoodcGsnmdeqnl`mtmcdqkxhmfKsnmdudqaqnns-Hmqdftk`q
hqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmrgnvdudq+sgdtmcdqkxhmfsnmdnmsgdudqaqnnshr
lnchehdcaxsgd`cchshnmnesvncnvmrsdoed`stqdr'∫(+nmdoqdbdchmf`mc
nmdenkknvhmfsgdudqarsdl-Sgdu`qhntrcdqhu`shnmrsg`soqnctbdsgdrd
rtqe`bdrsqtbstqdr`qdcdrbqhadchmcds`hkhmrdbshnmr1-2-0-`mc1-2-1-
`anud-Bnmrsqtbshnmrvghbgbnms`hmhchnrxmbq`shbsnmdo`ssdqmrnmsgd
udqar`qdchrbtrrdchmcds`hkhmrdbshnm1-2-2-`anud-Ctqhmfsgdqdrsne
sghrbg`osdq+sgdu`qhntrudqao`q`chflrvhkkadoqdrdmsdcvhsgnmkx`
vnqc`rsnsgdhqqdftk`qnqhchnrxmbq`shbsnm`kadg`uhnq-Sgdqd`cdq
hmsdqdrsdchmsgdhm,cdosgcdqhu`shnmned`bgo`ssdqmhrqdedqqdcsnsgd
`ooqnoqh`sdrdbshnmr`anud-
HmMfxdla——m+sgda`rhbhmchb`shnmnesgdu`qhntrsdmrdrhrcnmdax
ld`mrnecheedqdms!l`qjdqr-!Sgdydqnsdmrdhrhmchb`sdcaxsgd`ardmbd
ne`mxnudqssdmrdlnqogdld-Lnrsnesgdetstqdsdmrdr`qdl`qjdcaxsgd
oqdrdmbdneu`qhntr`twhkh`qxudqar'rddrdbshnm2-6-adknv(+svnnesgd
etstqdsdmrdr`bst`kkxg`uhmf`bgnhbdadsvddmsvncheedqdms`twhkh`qx
udqarsnhmchb`sdsgdr`ldrdl`mshbed`stqdr-Sgqddnesgdo`rssdmrdr
l`jdtrdnenqchm`qxsdmrdl`qjdqrvghkdsgdtmtrt`kO3sdmrdhr
hmchb`sdcaxbnlahmhmfl`qjdqrenqO2`mcE3-Sgdmhmdsdmrdrnentq
oqduhntrbg`qs`qdl`qjdcaxsgdenkknvhmflnqogdldr9
249
P4 : /laL/ + /laJY/
P3 : /laL/
P2 : /kaL/
P1 : /neNd/
Zero : /Ø/
F1 : /geL/
F2 : /toJ/ or /gyoL/
F3 : /luL/
F4 : /laJY/ or /foJ/
Sgdentqudqarsdlrvghbgvhkkenqlsgda`rhrenqd`bgudqao`q`chfl`qd
sgdenkknvhmf9
Monosyllabic Disyllabic
Sgdnsgdqvnqcrentmchmsgdenkknvhmfo`q`chflrhmbktcdsgd
enkknvhmfrtaidbs+naidbs`mcfq`ll`shb`kl`qjdqr9
250
'324(NsgdqVnqcr
.`∆.!gd!'rtaidbs(
.l–a`∆a.!ld`s!'naidbs(
.md∆.!oqnfqdrrhud`rodbs!
.rrdæ∫.!qd`khroqnfqdrrhud!
.j`∆---v—æ.!oqdrdmsodqedbshudmdf`shud!
.sd∆---v—æ.!nsgdqmdf`shud!
Enqbnmrsqtbshnmrl`qjdcenqqd`khrlncd+oqnfqdrrhud`rodbsl`xad
l`qjdcaxeither.md∆.`knmd+.rrdæ∫.`knmd+nqansgnesgdlsnfdsgdq-
Sgdrdsgqddbnmrsqtbshnmrvhkkadoqdrdmsdchmsgdnqcdqrgnvm`anud+
sgntfgsgdcheedqdmbdradsvddmbnmrsqtbshnmrl`jdrmncheedqdmbdhmsgdhq
ld`mhmf-
Sgdl`hml`qjdqnemdf`shnmhmsgdhmchb`shudlnnchrsgdaho`qshsd
lnqogdld.sd∆---v—æ.vhsgsgd.sd∆.onrhshnmdc`esdqsgdo`rssdmrdl`qjdqr
`mcadenqdsgdOQNFl`qjdqvghkdsgd.v—æ.hr`bkhshbsg`snbbtqr`ssgd
dmcnesgdbk`trd-SgdO/'hlldch`sdo`rsodqedbshud(hrsgdnmkxdwbdoshnm
snsgdfdmdq`kmdf`shudl`qjhmfvgdmhss`jdrhsrnvmaho`qshsdMDF
l`qjdq.j`∆---v—æ.-
Sgdu`qhntrhmchb`shududqao`q`chflr`qdmnvoqdrdmsdcadfhmmhmf
vhsgsgdqdlnsdo`rs`mcoqnfqdrrhmfsnsgdqdlnsdetstqd-
251
2-0-QdlnsdO`rsO39.k`∆.*.k`æù.
Sgdqdlnsdo`rssdmrdhrenqldcaxbnlahmhmfsgdo`rssdmrdl`qjdq
.k`∆.neO2vhsg`m`twhkh`qxudqa.k`æù.vghbghr`krnnmdnesgd`ksdqm`shud
enqlrtrdcsnhmchb`sdsgdE3sdmrd'sgdnsgdq`ksdqm`shud+.enæ.b`mmnsad
trdcvhsg.k`∆.snhmchb`sdO3shld(-Sgdenkknvhmfonrhshudodqedbshud
bnmrstbshnmr`qdhmsdqdrshmfhmsg`s'sgntfg`kkO3rdmsdmbdr`qd
tmcdqkxhmfkxqd`khr(sgdxg`udsgdqdftk`qhqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmrnmsgd
l`hmudqar-SgdO3odqedbshudr+ansgonrhshud`mcmdf`shud+`qd`krn
tmtrt`khmsg`ssgdxg`ud`m`r`koqdehwnmsgdl`hmudqaqnns-Sghrm`r`k
oqdehw`ood`qrsnadsgdoqdehwvghbgl`qjrbnmrdbtshududqarhmqd`khr
bnmrdbtshududqabnmrsqtbshnmr-Sgdqd`rnmnmdehmcrhsvhsgO3Õradb`trd
sgdE3.k`æù.bnmshmtdrsnetmbshnm`r`m`twhkh`qxudqa-Vg`shrtmtrt`khr
sg`s+sgntfgsgd.k`æù.nbbtqrvhsgqd`khrsnmdr`mchrenkknvdcaxsgdqd`khr
bnmrdbtshudm`r`koqdehw+sgdl`hmudqaqnnsrhmonrhshudbnmrsqtbshnmr
g`udirqd`khrsnmdr-Sgdcdqhu`shnmnesgdenkknvhmfonrhshudrdmsdmbdrhr
chrbtrrdchmrdbshnm1-2-2-`anud-Vdmnvrgnvsgdonrhshudodqedbshud
o`q`chfl9
252
aL laL laJY nzKaY mbMab "he cut the meat"(a long time ago)
Sgntfgsgdmdf`shudbntmsdqo`qsr`krng`udsgdbnmrdbtshudm`r`koqdehwnm
sgdl`hmudqa+sgdxg`udqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmrhmrsd`cnesgdtmtrt`k
o`ssdqmrrddm`anud-Qdldladqhmfsg`ssgdMDFl`qjdq.sd∆.bnlldr`esdqo`rs
sdmrdl`qjdqrkhjd.k`∆.atsadenqd`twhkh`qxudqarkhjd.k`æù.+sgdmdf`shud
o`q`chflhr`radknv9
aL laL teL laJY nzaJY mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t cut the meat"
aL laL teL laJY ngwKDY mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t pound the meat"
aL laL teL laJY nduJmteJ mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t bite the meat"
aL laL teL laJY ndKimteJ mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t reheat the meat"
Sgdu`qhntrhlodqedbshud`ksdqm`shudr`qdenqldcax`cchmf`Ksnmd
unvdkrteehwsnsgdudqaqnns-Sghrhlodqedbshudunvdks`jdrnmsgdunvdk
pt`khsxnesgdqnnsunvdkvhsglnmnrxkk`ahbudqarsdlr`mccqnornts
bnlokdsdkxvhsgchrxkk`ahbudqarsdlr-Sgtrenqchrxkk`ahbudqar+hshrnmkx
sgdsnmdnmsgdrdbnmcrxkk`akd'trt`kkx`.,sd.rteehw`rhmntqdw`lokdr(
253
vghbghmchb`sdrsgdoqdrdmbdnesgdhlodqedbshud`rodbs-Sgdmnm,
oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud`rodbshrtrdcvhsgo`rssdmrdrsnhmchb`sdsg`s
sgd`bsnqtrdcsnadhmunkudchm`bdqs`hmg`ahst`k`bshnmvghbg'hlokhdc(
gdmnknmfdqcndr-
Sgdonrhshudmnm,oqnfqdrrhudo`q`chflkhrsdcadknvtmcdqfndrsgd
r`ldhchnrxmbq`shbsnmdbg`mfdr`rsgdonrhshudodqedbshudo`q`chfl
etqsgdq`anud9
aL laL laJY nzKaYMa mbaLb "he was a meat-cutter"(a long time ago)
Sgdmdf`shudbntmsdqo`qsrnesgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrnmbd`f`hm
qdstqmsnsgdqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmrnmsgdudqar+`rvdr`vvhsgsgd
odqedbshudmdf`shudr`anud-Sgdmdf`shudo`q`chfl9
254
SgdO3oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshudr`qdbnlokdsdkxqdftk`q+ansg
rdfldms`kkx`mcsnm`kkx-Sgdxcnmnss`jdhqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmrnmsgdhq
udqaqnnsr`rhmsgdo`q`kkdkonrhshudmnm,oqnfqdrrhudbntmsdqo`qsrnesgd
oqdbdchmfrdbshnm-Hmrsd`c+sgdxg`udsgdhqdwodbsdcqd`khrsnmdr-Sgdnmkx
tmtrt`ke`bsnqhrsg`ssgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq.rrdæ∫.hrmnsonrrhakd
vhsgsgdO3sdmrd`rvhsgnsgdqo`rssdmrdr-Sghrhrlnrskhjdkxctdsnsgd
oqdrdmbdnesgdirqd`khrE3l`qjdq.k`æù.hmsgdlhcckdne`qd`khr
bnmrsqtbshnm-Hmrsd`cnesgqddo`q`kkdkfq`ll`shb`kbnmrsqtbshnmr+vd
sgdqdenqdehmcnmkxsgdbnmrsqtbshnmvhsgsgdfdmdq`koqnfqdrrhud.md∆.+`r
adknv9
Sgdmdf`shudbntmsdqo`qsr`qd`krnqd`khydcnmsgdqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdr+
`rhmsgdenkknvhmfo`q`chfl9
255
'330(O3mdf`shudoqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud9
`∆k`∆sd∆k`æùmd∆my`æù`∆la`∆av—æ!gdv`rm&sbtsshmfld`s!
`∆k`∆sd∆k`æùmd∆ngw@ABA∆la`∆av—æ!gdv`rm&sontmchmfld`s!
`∆k`∆sd∆k`æùmd∆mctælsd∆la`∆av—æ!gdv`rm&sahshmfld`s!
`∆k`∆sd∆k`æùmd∆nd@imte∆ la`∆av—æ!gdv`rm&sqdgd`shmfld`s!
SghrbnmbktcdrntqrdbshnmnmsgdonrrhakdO3bnmrsqtbshnmr+entqne
rhwnevghbgg`udaddmqd`khydcnmqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdr-
256
2-1-Chrs`msO`rsO29.k`∆.
Khjdl`mxA`mstk`mft`fdr+Mfxdla——mtrdrsgdbnllnmA`msto`rs
sdmrdlnqogdld.k`∆.-Khjd`kko`rsodqedbshudonrhshudbnmrsqtbshnmr+sgdO2
g`r`mhchnrxmbq`shbsnmdo`ssdqmvgnrdcdqhu`shnmg`raddmcdrbqhadchm
cds`hkhmrdbshnm1-2-2-`anud-Sgdqdrtkshmfrtqe`bdo`q`chflhrsgd
enkknvhmf9
aL laL zaPY mbaLb "he cut the meat" (some time ago)
Sgdmdf`shudbntmsdqo`qsrnesgdO2odqedbshud`qdbnlokdsdkxqdftk`q+
`kv`xrs`jhmfsgdqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdrnmsgdudqaqnns+`radknv9
aL laL teL zaJY mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t cut the meat"
aL laL teL gwKDY mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t pound the meat"
aL laL teL luJmteJ mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t bite the meat"
aL laL teL lKimteJ mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t reheat the meat"
257
The P3 (and P2) tenses with non-progressive
tone echo vowel imperfective suffix from the verb root and
Sgdmdf`shudbntmsdqo`qsrsnsgdoqdbdchmfrdmsdmbdr`krntmcdqfnsgd
r`ldsq`mredqnesgddbgnunvdksnsgdsdmrdl`qjdq`mcsgdsnm`k
mdtsq`khy`shnmsncnvmrsdoodcKsnmdrnmsgdudqarsdlr+`radknv9
258
'334(O2mdf`shudmnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud9
`∆k`∆`sd∆nzMaYla`∆av—æ!gdv`rm&s`ld`s,btssdq!
`∆k`∆`sd∆ngwMDYla`∆av—æ!gdv`rm&s`ld`s,ontmcdq!
`∆k`∆`sd∆ndMumte∆la`∆av—æ!gdv`rm&s`ld`s,ahsdq!
`∆k`∆`sd∆ndMimteLla`∆av—æ!gdv`rm&s`ld`s,qdgd`sdq!
LnuhmfnmsnsgdO2oqnfqdrrhudbnmrsqtbshnmr+sgdx`kkb`qqxsgd
qdftk`qqd`khrsnmdrnmsgdudqarsdlr-Sgdqd`qdu`qhntrlnchehb`shnmr
`mctmtrt`ko`ssdqmr`r`qdrtksnesgdsnmdrnesgdoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqr
sgdlrdkudr+gnvdudq+`mcsgdhqcdqhu`shnmr`qdcdrbqhadchmcds`hkhm
rdbshnm1-2-3-`anud-Vgdmsgdqdftk`qoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq.md∆.hroqdrdms+
sgdl`qjdqbg`mfdrsn`qhrhmfsnmdhmonrhshudbnmrsqtbshnmr+`rhmsgd
enkknvhmfo`q`chfl9
SgdO2`mcO1oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshudrdmsdmbdrs`jdsgddwodbsdc
qd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmrnmsgdudqaqnns+atssgdOQNFl`qjdqhrqd`khydcnm
`G,Ke`kkhmfsnmdhmrsd`cnesgda`rhbKsnmd+`radknv9
aL laL neP nzaJYaL mbaLb "he was cutting meat"(some time ago)
259
The negative counterparts to the preceding sentences
below:
aL laL teN neL nzaJYaL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t cutting meat"
aL laL teN neL ngwKDYDL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t pounding meat"
aL laL teN neL nduJmteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t biting meat"
aL laL teN neL ndKimteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t reheating meat"
Rhmbd`kko`rssdmrdr`qdqd`khrlncd+sgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq
.rrdæ∫.b`mnoshnm`kkxs`jdsgdok`bdnesgdqdftk`qoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqrddm
`anud-Sgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqhrsnm`kkxqdftk`qvhsgsgddwbdoshnm
sg`ssgdcnvmrsdoenkknvhmfsgdl`qjdqhr`bst`kkxqd`khydcnmsgd
enkknvhmfudqaqnns+adbnlhmfsgdtmtrt`kdouble downstephmsgd
b`rdneKsnmdudqar-Sgdcdqhu`shnmnertbgtmtrt`ko`ssdqmrhrcdrbqhadc
hmcds`hkhmrdbshnm1-2-3-`anud-Sgdqdrtkshmfrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmhr`r
adknv9
260
'337(O2onrhshudoqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud9
`∆k`∆rrdænzKaYa∆la`∆a!gdv`rbtsshmfld`s!'rnldshld`fn(
`∆k`∆rrdængwVDYD∆la`∆a!gdv`rontmchmfld`s!
`∆k`∆rrdændKumte∆la`∆a!gdv`rahshmfld`s!
`∆k`∆rrdændVimte∆la`∆a!gdv`rqdgd`shmfld`s!
Rhmbdsgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq.rrdæ∫.enkknvrsgdMDFl`qjdq
.sd∆.+sgdcntakdcnvmrsdohr`krnentmcnmsgdudqaqnnsrhmsgdo`q`kkdk
mdf`shudo`q`chfl+`radknv9
aL laL teL sseJ nzKaYaL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t cutting meat"
aL laL teL sseJ ngwVDYDL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t pounding meat"
aL laL teL sseJ ndKumteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t biting meat"
aL laL teL sseJ ndVimteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t reheating meat"
Sgntfgnmdb`mrhfm`ko`rsoqnfqdrrhudld`mhmfaxtrhmfdhsgdqsgd
qdftk`qoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq.md∆.nqsgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq.rrdæ∫.+
nmdb`m`krnbnlahmdansgl`qjdqrhmsgdr`ldbnmrsqtbshnmsgntfgsgd
a`rhbo`rsoqnfqdrrhudld`mhmfqdl`hmrtmbg`mfdc-Vgdmansg
oqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqr`qdoqdrdmshmsgdr`ldbnmrsqtbshnm+sgdsnmdr`qd
bnlokdsdkxqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdrsgqntfgnts+`rhmsgdonrhshudo`q`chfl
adknv9
261
'34/(O2onrhshudoqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud9
`∆k`∆rrdænMemy`æù`∆la`∆a!gdv`rbtsshmfld`s!'rnldshld`fn(
`∆k`∆rrdænMengwKDYDLla`∆a!gdv`rontmchmfld`s!
`∆k`∆rrdænMemctælsd∆la`∆a!gdv`rahshmfld`s!
`∆k`∆rrdænMendKimteLla`∆a!gdv`rqdgd`shmfld`s!
@rb`madrddm`anud+sgd.rrdæ∫.l`qjdqoqdbdcdrsgd.md∆.l`qjdqvgdm
ansg`qdoqdrdms-Ansgnesgdrdl`qjdqr`krnenkknvsgdMDF.sd∆.l`qjdq
vgdmdudq`kksgqdd`qdoqdrdms+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfo`q`chfl9
aL laL teL sseJ nMe nzaJYaL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t cutting meat"
aL laL teL sseJ nMe ngwKDYDL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t pounding meat"
aL laL teL sseJ nMe nduJmteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t biting meat"
aL laL teL sseJ nMe ndKimteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t reheating meat"
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqdw`lhm`shnmnesgdO2sdmrd+`mcvdb`mlnudnm
snsgdqdl`qj`akxrhlhk`qbnmrsqtbshnmr`mcbg`mfdrnesgdO1sdmrd-
262
2-2-Xdrsdqc`xO`rsO19.j`∆.
@rhmsgdO2sdmrd+sgdxdrsdqc`xo`rssdmrdtrdr`mnsgdqnesgd
bnllnmA`msto`rssdmrdl`qjdqr.j`∆.-Khjd`kko`rsodqedbshudonrhshud
bnmrsqtbshnmr+sgdO1`krng`rhsrnvmhchnrxmbq`shbsnmdo`ssdqm'vgnrd
cdqhu`shnmg`raddmcdrbqhadchmcds`hkhmrdbshnm1-2-2-`anud(-Sgd
qdrtkshmfrtqe`bdo`q`chflhrsgdenkknvhmf9
Sgdmdf`shudbntmsdqo`qsrnesgdO1odqedbshud`qdbnlokdsdkxqdftk`q+
`kv`xradhmfqd`khydcnmsgdqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdrnmsgdudqaqnnsr+`rhm
sgdenkknvhmfo`q`chfl9
aL kaL teL zaJY mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t cut the meat"
aL kaL teL gwKDY mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t pound the meat"
aL kaL teL luJmteJ mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t bite the meat"
aL kaL teL lKimteJ mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t reheat the meat"
263
SgdO1mnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmrtmcdqfnsgdr`ld
tmtrt`kbg`mfdrqdedqqdcsnenqO2Õmsgdoqdbdchmfrdbshnm-Sgdonrhshud
o`q`chflhrqd`khydc`radknv9
Sgdsq`mredqnesgdhlodqedbshudrteehwsnsgdsdmrdl`qjdq`mcsgd
mdtsq`khyhmfbg`mfdrnmsgdudqaqnnssnmdr`qd`krnentmchmsgdo`q`kkdk
mdf`shuddw`lokdrfhudmadknv9
SgdO1oqnfqdrrhud`krng`rsgqddcheedqdmsbnmrsqtbshnmrsg`sg`udsgd
r`ldhcdmshb`kld`mhmf+`rvhsglnrsqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr-Sgdonrhshud
oqnfqdrrhudbnmrsqtbshnmrvhsg.md∆.rg`qdvhsgsgdO2sdmrdsgdtmtrt`k
264
qd`khy`shnmnesg`sl`qjdqnm`G,Ke`kkhmfsnmd+dudmsgntfgsgdudqar
g`udsgdhqqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdr+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfo`q`chfl9
Sgdo`q`kkdkmdf`shuddw`lokdr`krnrg`qdvhsgsgdO2sdmrdsgd
qd`khy`shnmnesgdtmtrt`kK,GqhrhmfsnmdnmsgdMDFl`qjdq.sd∆.+`r
adknv9
aL kaL teN neL nzaJYaL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t cutting meat"
aL kaL teN neL ngwKDYDL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t pounding meat"
aL kaL teN neL nduJmteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t biting meat"
aL kaL teN neL ndKimteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t reheating meat"
SgdO1oqnfqdrrhudrdmsdmbdr`krnrg`qdsgdoqnodqsxneadhmf`akdsn
rvhsbgsnsgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq.rrdæ∫.+vghkdl`hms`hmhmfsgdr`ld
oqnfqdrrhudld`mhmf+`rhmntqonrhshudo`q`chfladknv9
265
(458) P2 positive progressive imperfective:
Sgdtmtrt`knbbtqqdmbdnecntakdcnvmsdoodcGsnmdrnmsgdudqaqnnsrhr
`krnentmchmsgdo`q`kkdkmdf`shudo`q`chflrgnvmadknv9
aL kaL teL sseJ nzKaYaL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t cutting meat"
aL kaL teL sseJ ngwVDYDL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t pounding meat"
aL kaL teL sseJ ndKumteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t biting meat"
aL kaL teL sseJ ndVimteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t reheating meat"
Nmbd`f`hm+sgdsvnoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqrb`madbnlahmdchm`rhmfkd
oqnfqdrrhudbnmrsqtbshnm+sghrshldvhsgsgdcnvmrsdoenkknvhmfsgd.rrdæ∫.
l`qjdqadhmfqd`khydcnmsgdenkknvhmf.md∆.l`qjdqhmrsd`cnenmsgdudqaqnns+
`radknv9
266
Sgdo`q`kkdkmdf`shudrdmsdmbdr`krn`qdqd`khydcvhsgsgdqdftk`q
qd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmrnmsgdudqar+`radknv9
aL kaL teL sseJ nMe nzaJYaL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t cutting meat"
aL kaL teL sseJ nMe ngwKDYDL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t pounding meat"
aL kaL teL sseJ nMe nduJmteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t biting meat"
aL kaL teL sseJ nMe ndKimteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t reheating meat"
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqdw`lhm`shnmnesgdO1sdmrd+vghbgg`raddm
qdl`qj`akxo`q`kkdksnbnmrsqtbshnmrnesgdO2sdmrd-Vdmnvlnudnmsn
sgdO0o`rssdmrd-
267
2-3-Snc`xO`rsO09.md¿∫.
Sgdsnc`xo`rssdmrdhrl`qjdcaxsgdsnm`kkxbnlokdwsdmrdl`qjdq
.md¿∫.hmsgdodqedbshud`rodbs-Onrhshudodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmr`qd
hcdmshb`ksnO/bnmrdbtshududqabnmrsqtbshnmrvhsgsgdsdmrdl`qjdq
etmbshnmhmf`rsgdehqrsudqa-Sgdhcdmshb`kO0bnmrsqtbshnmrhmbktcdsgd
snmdo`ssdqmnmsgd.md.!`twhkh`qxudqa!`mcsgdoqdrdmbdnesgd
bnmrdbtshudl`qjdq.M,.nmsgdrdbnmc!l`hm!udqa-Gnvdudq+b`qdetk
dw`lhm`shnmnesgdo`q`kkdkO0MDFbnmrsqtbshnmrrgnvrsg`ssgd.md¿∫.
cndrmns`kv`xrg`udsgdbnmrdbtshudl`qjdqvghbgkd`crnmdsnr`xsg`s
sgd.md¿∫.mnknmfdqetmbshnmr`r`udqahm`bnmrdbtshudbnmrsqtbshnmats
g`rmnvadbnld`eqnydml`qjdq-SgdO0onrhshudodqedbshudr'vgnrdO/
bg`q`bsdqhrshbr`qdcdqhudchmrdbshnm1-2-2-`anud(`qdqd`khydc`radknv9
Vghkdsgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdrg`udsgdO/bnmrdbtshudsnmdrnmsgd
udqar`mcnaidbsr`rvdkk`rsgdoqdrdmbdne`gnlnqf`mhbm`r`koqdehw
'vghbgbntkcadqdf`qcdc`rsgdbnmrdbtshudl`qjdql`qjhmfsgdrdbnmc
268
nesvnbnmrdbtshududqar(+mnmdnesgdrdbg`q`bsdqhrshbr`qdentmcvhsgsgd
o`q`kkdkmdf`shudbnmrsqtbshnmr-Hmrsd`csgd!l`hmudqa!hrqd`khydcnm
qdftk`qqd`khrsnmdr`mcsgdm`r`k'bnmrdbtshud>(oqdehwhrlhrrhmf-Sghr
rgnvrsg`s+`ksgntfgsgdO0sdmrdl`qjdqtmcntasdckxcdudknodc
ghrsnqhb`kkxeqnl`udqahm`O/bnmrdbtshudbnmrsqtbshnm+sgdenqldqudqa
g`rmnvadbnldeqnydmhmenql`mcs`jdmto`ehwdconrhshnmoqdbdchmf
sgdMDFl`qjdq'vgdqdsqtdudqarmdudqnbbtq(-Sgdbqtbh`kmdf`shud
o`q`chflhrsgdenkknvhmf9
aL neN tMe zaJY mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t cut the meat"
aL neN tMe gwKDY mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t pound the meat"
aL neN tMe luJmteJ mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t bite the meat"
aL neN tMe lKimteJ mbaLb wDJ "he didn’t reheat the meat"
Nmdnesgdtmtrt`ked`stqdrnesgdMfxdla——mudqa`krxrsdlnbbtqrhm
O0mnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmr+vgdqdsgqddrdo`q`sd
l`qjdqrl`xnbbtqhmsgdonrhshnmnesgdsdmrdl`qjdq-Sgdehqrsnesgdrd
l`qjdqrhrsgdmnql`k'odqedbshud(O0l`qjdq.md¿∫.vghbghredkssnad
rkhfgskxptdrshnm`akd'rxlankhydcaxsgdptdrshnml`qj(hmsgdenkknvhmf
o`q`chfl-Sgdsnmdrnmsgdudqa`qdmnvsgdqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdr`ksgntfg
sgdx`qdlnchehdcax`m`cchshnm`kcnvmrsdovghbgenkknvrsgdsdmrd
l`qjdq-SghrqdrtksrhmsgdcntakdcnvmrsdoodcGsnmdrnmtmcdqkxhmfK
269
snmdudqaqnnsr+`rhmntqdw`lokdradknv9
? aL neN ngwVDY
J DL mbaLb "he was meat-pounding"
Sgdqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdrnmsgdudqarhrlnqdd`rhkxrddmhmsgd
o`q`kkdkMDFo`q`chflvgdqdsgdcnvmrsdoeqnlsgdsdmrdl`qjdqhr
qd`khydcnmsgdenkknvhmfMDFl`qjdq.sd∆.-SgdqhrhmfsnmdnmsgdMDF
l`qjdqhrtmtrt`k`mchrcdqhudchmrdbshnm1-2-4-`anud-Sgdqdrtkshmf
o`q`chflhrnmbd`f`hmbnmrhcdqdcaxMfxdla——mrod`jdqrsnadne
ptdrshnm`akdrs`str+`rl`qjdcaxptdrshnml`qjradknv9
Adb`trdsgdoqdbdchmfsvno`q`chflr`qdneptdrshnm`akd
fq`ll`shb`khsxenqqd`rnmrsg`svhkknmkxadcdrbqhadck`sdqadknv+sgdqd
dwhrsr`qtkdvghbg`kknvrsgdsdmrdl`qjdqsnadbg`mfdcsndhsgdq.kOD.nq
270
.kMe.+fhuhmfetkkxfq`ll`shb`kbnmrstbshnmr-Sgdudqarhmsgdrd
bnmrsqtbshnmr`qd`kv`xrqd`khydcnmsgdqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdr+`rhmsgd
enkknvhmfsvno`q`chflr'vghbgg`udhcdmshb`kld`mhmf(9
Rhmbdsgdcnvmrsdoed`stqdnesgdrdsvn`ksdqm`shudO0l`qjdqr
oqdbdcdrsgdl`qjdq+hshrd`rhdqsnmnshbdsg`ssgdudqasnmdr`qdqdftk`q
enqqd`khrlncd-Hmsgdo`q`kkdkmdf`shudo`q`chfl+sgdtmtrt`kqhrhmfsnmd
nmsgdMDFl`qjdqhrnmbdlnqdoqdrdms+`radknv9
271
'357(O0mdf`shudmnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud9
'358(O0mdf`shudmnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud9
VdmnvbnldsnsgdO0oqnfqdrrhudbnmrsqtbshnmr-Hs`ood`qrsg`ssgd
hcdmshb`krdfldms`krg`od.md.neansgsgdOQNFl`qjdq`mcsgdO0sdmrd
l`qjdqg`rlnshu`sdc`qdrsqhbshnm`f`hmrsansgnesgdrdl`qjdqrnbbtqqhmfhm
sgdr`ldbnmrsqtbshnm-Sgdenkknvhmfonrhshud`mcmdf`shudo`q`chflr`qd
sgdqdenqdtmfq`ll`shb`khmsgdroddbgne`ctksr'sgdhqtmfq`ll`shb`khsxadhmf
l`qjdcaxsgd!*!hmeqnmsned`bgrdmsdmbd(9
272
(471) P1 negative progressive imperfective:
+ aL neN tMe neP nzaJYaL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t cutting meat"
+ aL neN tMe neP ngwKDYDL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t pounding meat"
+ aL neN tMe neP nduJmteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t biting meat"
+ aL neN tMe neP ndKimteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t reheating meat"
Sgntfgsgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdr`qdtmfq`ll`shb`khm`ctksroddbg+
bghkcqdmvgng`udmnsxdsl`rsdqdcsgdk`mft`fdvhkktssdqrtbg
rdmsdmbdr-@ctksrg`udmnsqntakdtmcdqrs`mchmfsgdld`mhmfhmsdmcdc+
`mcvhkkbnqqdbssgdbghkcaxrtarshstshmf`bnmrstbshnmvhsgdhsgdq.kOD.nq
.kMe.qdok`bhmfsgdO0.md¿∫.-Enqsgdrdqd`rnmr+vdonrhsrtbg`qdok`bhud
sq`mrenql`shnmvghbghrnakhf`snqxvgdmdudqO0rdmsdmbdr`qd
oqnfqdrrhud+`mcnoshnm`kvgdmdudqsgdx`qdmnm,oqnfqdrrhud
hlodqedbshud-Sgdqdrtkshmfoqnfqdrrhudo`q`chflrg`udqdftk`qqd`khr
snmdrnmsgdudqar+`radknv9
273
(473) P1 positive progressive imperfective:
Sgdmdf`shudo`q`chflrvghbg`qdo`q`kkdksnsgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdr`krn
s`jdqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmrnmsgdudqar+atssgdxg`udtmtrt`kG,Ksnmd
fkhcdrnmsgdOQNFl`qjdq.md∆.-Sgdcdqhu`shnmnesghrrodbh`ke`kkhmfsnmdfkhcd
hrchrbtrrdchmcds`hkhmrdbshnm1-2-3-`anud-Ntqsvnfq`ll`shb`koqnfqdrrhud
o`q`chflr`qdsgdqdenqd`radknv9
aL kOD teL neP nzaJYaL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t cutting meat"
aL kOD teL neP ngwKDYDL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t pounding meat"
aL kOD teL neP nduJmteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t biting meat"
aL kOD teL neP ndKimteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t reheating meat"
aL kMe teL neP nzaJYaL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t cutting meat"
aL kMe teL neP ngwKDYDL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t pounding meat"
aL kMe teL neP nduJmteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t biting meat"
aL kMe teL neP ndKimteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t reheating meat"
274
SgdO0sdmrdl`qjdq.md¿∫.b`mmnsbnnbbtqvhsgsgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhud
'QDOQ(l`qjdq.rrdæ∫.itrs`rhsbntkcmnsbnnbbtqvhsgsgdfdmdq`kOQNF
l`qjdq.md∆.-Vdb`mgnvdudqehmcQDOQl`qjdqvhsgsgd`ksdqm`shudO0
l`qjdqr.kOD.nq.kMe.+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfo`q`chflr9
275
(479) P1 positive progressive imperfective:
regular PROG marker. The NEG parallels also carry the realis
tones on the verbs, and are realized just like their positive
aL kOD teL sseJ nzKaYaL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t cutting meat"
(earlier today)
aL kOD teL sseJ ngwVDYDL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t pounding meat"
aL kOD teL sseJ ndKumteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t biting meat"
aL kOD teL sseJ ndVimteL mbaLb wDJ "he wasn’t reheating meat"
aL kOD teL sseJ nMe nzaJYaL mbaLb wDJ (same glosses as above)
276
(482) P1 negative progressive imperfective:
aL kMe teL sseJ nMe nzaJYaL mbaLb wDJ (same glosses as above)
SghrbnmbktcdrntqrdbshnmnmsgdO0o`rssdmrd+`sdmrdvghbgqdrtksr
hmrdudq`kcheedqdmsrtqe`bdrsqtbstqdrenqhcdmshb`ktmcdqkxhmf
fq`ll`shb`k`mcrdl`mshbed`stqdr-
277
2-4-YdqnO/`mcOQDR9.∂.
Sgdydqnsdmrdg`rehudcheedqdmsjhmcrnebnmrsqtbshnmrhmrsd`cneitrs
sgqddkhjdsgdnsgdqsdmrdr-TrhmfO/snhmchb`sdsgdydqnodqedbshud`mc
OQDRsnhmchb`sdsgdu`qhntrydqnhlodqedbshud'!oqdrdms!(bnmrsqtbshnmr+
sgdenkknvhmfehudonrrhahkhshdr`qdentmchmsgdMfxdla——mydqnsdmrd9
Sgdehqrsbnmrsqtbshnmvghbgvdvhkkdw`lhmdhrsgdqd`khrodqedbshud
u`qh`shnmnesgdydqnsdmrd'O/(-Sghrbnmrsqtbshnmhrtrdcsnhmchb`sd
`bshnmrvghbgsnnjok`bdhmsgdhlldch`sdo`rsats`qdbnlokdsd`ssgd
oqdrdmslnldms-@rvhsgnsgdq!o`rs!sdmrdr+sgdsnmdo`ssdqmneO/Õr
hchnrxmbq`shbhmhsronrhshudqd`khy`shnmrxdsbnlokdsdkxqdftk`qhmhsr
mdf`shudbntmsdqo`qsr-Sgdu`qhntrsnm`kcdqhu`shnmrvghbgqdrtkshmsgd
snm`kmdtsq`khy`shnmneG`mcKsnmdudqaqnnsr`mcsgdhqqd`khy`shnmnm`m
tmtrt`kqhrhmfsnmd`qdcdrbqhadchmcds`hkhmrdbshnm1-2-2-`anud-Sgd
278
qdrtkshmfonrhshudo`q`chflhrsgdenkknvhmf9
Vghkdsgdmdf`shudbntmsdqo`qsrsnsgdoqdbdchmfo`q`chfl`qd`kk
qd`khydcnmsgdqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdrnmsgdudqar+sgdx`qdpthsdtmtrt`khm
sg`ssgdxtshkhydsgdhqnvmtmhptdaho`qshsdMDFl`qjdq.j`∆---v—æ.+`r
adknv9
aL kaL zaJY mbaLb wDJ "he hasn’t just cut the meat"
aL kaL gwKDY mbaLb wDJ "he hasn’t just pounded the meat"
aL kaL luJmteJ mbaLb wDJ "he hasn’t just bitten the meat"
aL kaL lKimteJ mbaLb wDJ "he hasn’t just reheated the meat"
SgdO/mdf`shudhr`krntmhptdhmsg`shs`knmd`kknvrsgdeqnmshmfne
sgdnaidbssn`onrhshnmadsvddmsdmrdl`qjdq`mcudqa-Sghreqnmshmfne
sgdnaidbskd`udrsgdudqahlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfsgdehm`kMDFbkhshb.v—æ.
`mcsghrbkhshbqdctbdrsn`ogq`rd,ehm`kunvdkhmsgdb`rdnelnmnrxkk`ahb
udqaqnnsr`mchscqnornts`ksnfdsgdqhmsgdb`rdnechrxkk`ahbudqaqnnsr-
279
Sgdbnmrsqtbshnmr`qdsnm`kkxqdftk`qdwbdosenqsgdhmsqnctbshnmnesgd
cnvmrsdoed`stqdadenqdsgdKsnmdnesgdeqnmsdcnaidbs'`snm`ked`stqd
sg`shrmncntashmsqnctbdcaxsgdr`ldqtkdsg`seqnmsrsgdnaidbs(+`r
adknv9
Vdb`mmnvstqmeqnlsgdodqedbshudO/bnmrsqtbshnmrsnsgdhlodqedbshud
OQDRbnmrsqtbshnmrnesgdydqnsdmrd-Sgdehqrsbnmrsqtbshnmvdvhkkrgnvhrsgd
mnm,oqnfqdrrhudqd`khroqdrdmssdmrd-Hsg`rsgdtrt`kg`ahst`kld`mhmfnemnm,
oqnfqdrrhudbnmrsqtbshnmr`mcsgdsnmdrnmsgdudqar`qdsgdbnlokdsdkxqdftk`q
snmdrenqqd`khrlncdvhsgsgdhlodqedbshudrteehwcdrbqhadchmrdbshnm1-2-1-
`anud-Sgdqdrtkshmfonrhshudo`q`chflhrsgdenkknvhmf9
280
Vghkdsgdmdf`shudbntmsdqo`qsrsnsgdoqdbdchmfonrhshudrdmsdmbdr
`krng`udsgdqdftk`qqd`khrsnmdrnmsgdudqar+sgdx`krng`udtmtrt`k
qhrhmfsnmdrnmsgdMDFl`qjdq.sd∆.'vgnrdcdqhu`shnmhrcdrbqhadchm
rdbshnm1-2-4-`anud(+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfo`q`chfl9
Sgdehm`kqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmrsnadcds`hkdcgdqdvhkkadsgd
oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshudu`qh`msrvhsgsgdydqnsdmrd-@rvhsgnsgdqqd`khr
oqnfqdrrhudbnmrsqtbshnmr+sgdqddwhrssgqdd`ksdqm`shudrtqe`bdqd`khy`shnmr
snhmchb`sdsgdr`ldqd`khroqnfqdrrhudld`mhmf-Vdvhkkadfhmax
dw`lhmhmfsgdonrhshudo`q`chfltrhmfitrssgdqdftk`q.md∆.oqnfqdrrhud
l`qjdq-Sghrbnmrsqtbshnmg`r`mhchnrxmbq`shbsnmdo`ssdqmnmsgdudqar
vghbghrcdqhudchmrdbshnm1-2-2-`anud-Sgdqdrtkshmfo`q`chflhrsgd
enkknvhmf9
281
'38/(OQDRonrhshudqd`khroqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud9
Vghkdsgdoqdbdchmfonrhshudo`q`chflr`vtmcdqkxhmfqd`khrlncd
udqarqd`khydcnmhqqd`khrudqasnmdo`ssdqmr+sgdenkknvhmfmdf`shud
o`q`chfll`hms`hmrsgdqdftk`qqd`khrudqasnmdrnmsgdrtqe`bd-Nmbd
`f`hm+gnvdudq+sgd.sd∆.MDFl`qjdqhrqd`khydcnm`qhrhmfsnmd+`r
adknv9
Sgdr`ldjhmcneoqnfqdrrhudld`mhmfb`madrhfm`kkdcax
rtarshstshmfsgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhud'QDOQ(l`qjdq.rrdæ∫.enqsgdqdftk`q
oqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq.md∆.-VgdmsgdQDOQl`qjdqhrtrdcvhsgsgdoqdrdms
sdmrd+sgdudqarqds`hmsgdhqdwodbsdcqd`khrsnmdl`qjhmfatssgdcnvmrsdo
nesgd.rrdæ∫.l`qjdqhrrghesdcsnsgdkdes`mcsgdrtaidbsoqnmntmhrfhudm
282
`Gqdok`bhudsnmd+`rcdrbqhadchmcds`hkhmrdbshnm1-2-3-`anud-Sgd
qdrtkshmfonrhshudo`q`chflhrsgdenkknvhmf9
@rb`madrddmeqnlsgdo`q`kkdkmdf`shuddw`lokdradknv+sgd
mdf`shudbnmrsqtbshnm`krng`rmnql`kqd`khrsnmdrnmsgdudqarsgntfgsgd
cnvmrsdonesgdoqdbdchmf.rrdæ∫.l`qjdqhr`krn`ccdcsnhs-Sgdrtaidbs
oqnmntmqdl`hmrvhsghsrmnql`kKsnmd`mcsgdvgnkdbnmrsqtbshnmhr
sgdqdenqdbnlokdsdkxqdftk`q+`radknv9
Sgdehm`kv`xnerhfm`kkhmfoqnfqdrrhudld`mhmfvhsgsgdqd`khrydqn
sdmrdhraxbnlahmhmfoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqr.md∆.`mc.rrdæ∫.hmsn`rhmfkd
bnmrsqtbshnm-Vgdmsghrg`oodmrhmonrhshudrdmsdmbdr+sgdr`ldtmtrt`k
283
eqnmshmfnesgdcnvmrsdoed`stqdnesgd.rrdæ∫.l`qjdq`mcsgdrtaidbssnmd
adhmfqdok`bdcax`Gsnmd`rnbbtqdchmsgdo`q`kkdkbnmrsqtbshnmr
vhsgnts.md∆.`krns`jdok`bdgdqd-Sgdqdrtkshmfonrhshudo`q`chflhrsgd
enkknvhmf9
Sgdo`q`kkdkmdf`shudrdmsdmbdrnmbd`f`hmrgnvnmkxsgdqdftk`q
snmdrdwodbsdcnesgdlnqogdldrhmunkudchm`qd`khrbnmrsqtbshnm+`r
adknv9
aL teL sseJ nMe nzaJYaL mbaLb wDJ "he isn’t cutting meat"
aL teL sseJ nMe ngwKDYDL mbaLb wDJ "he isn’t pounding meat"
aL teL sseJ nMe nduJmteL mbaLb wDJ "he isn’t biting meat"
aL teL sseJ nMe ndKimteL mbaLb wDJ "he isn’t reheating meat"
Sgdoqdbdchmfo`q`chflbnmbktcdrntqdw`lhm`shnmneqd`khrudqa
bnmrsqtbshnmr-Vdmnvrvhsbgsnhqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmrvgdqdsgd
mnshbd`akdcheedqdmbdrvhkkadcheedqdmssnmdo`ssdqmrnmsgdudqar'vhsg
284
cnvmrsdoansgoqdbdchmf`mcenkknvhmfsgdudqaqnnshmqdftk`qhqqd`khr
snmdo`ssdqmr(`mcsgd`ardmbdnesgdqd`khrhlodqedbshudm`r`koqdehwnm
sgdudqahmhlodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmr-
Sgdehqrshqqd`khro`ssdqmrsg`svdvhkkknnj`s`qdsgdmnm,oqnfqdrrhud
hqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmrnesgdydqnsdmrd-Sghrbnmrsqtbshnmhrmnsqd`khydc
nmsgdqdftk`qhqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmrvgdmhshronrhshud+atsg`rhsrnvm
tmhptdsnm`ko`ssdqmcdrbqhadchmcds`hkhmrdbshnm1-2-2-`anud-Sgd
qdrtkshmfrtqe`bdrsqtbstqdhrghfgkxtmtrt`khmsg`stmcdqkxhmfGsnmd
udqar`qdqd`khydcnm`knvdqohsbgkdudksg`mtmcdqkxhmfKsnmdudqar+`r
adknv9
Sgdhqqd`khrmnm,oqnfqdrrhudmdf`shuddw`lokdrnesgdoqdrdmssdmrd
`qdtmtrt`khm`cheedqdmsv`x-Vghkdsgdudqaqnnsr`qdqd`khydcnmsgd
qdftk`qhqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmrhmsgdmdf`shudo`q`chfl+sgdmnql`k
hlodqedbshudrteehwg`raddmbnlokdsdkxdkhlhm`sdckd`uhmfsgdcnvmrsdo
vghbgenkknvrsgdudqaqnnssnnmkxnbbtqnmsgdenkknvhmfnaidbs-Rtbg`
rteehwcdkdshnmqtkdvntkcmnql`kkxmdtsq`khydrtbg`bnmrsqtbshnmvhsg`
285
o`q`kkdkodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnm+atsgdqdhshronrrhakdsnl`hms`hmsgd
bnmsq`rshmsg`ssghrs`jdrok`bdhmitrssgddmuhqnmldmsvgdqdsgdo`q`kkdk
O/MDFg`rhsrnvmtmhptdmdf`shudl`qjdq.j`∆---v—æ.cdrbqhadcetqsgdq
`anudhmsghrrdbshnm-Sgdqdrtkshmfrsqtbstqdhrsgdnmkxnmdsgdqdenqd
vghbgl`hms`hmrhsrhlodqedbshudld`mhmfhmsgd`ardmbdnesgd
hlodqedbshududqarteehw+`rsgdenkknvhmfo`q`chflrgnvr9
Sgdoqnfqdrrhudhqqd`khru`qh`msnesgdoqdrdmssdmrdg`rsgdqdftk`q
hqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmnmsgdudqaqnnsrats`mtmtrt`kKGqhrhmfsnmdnm
sgdrtaidbsoqnmntm-Sgdcdqhu`shnmnesghrqhrhmfsnmdhrchrbtrrdchm
rdbshnm1-2-3-`anud-Sgdrdl`mshbenqbdnesgdrdoqnfqdrrhudhqqd`khr
bnmrsqtbshnmrhrsg`ssgdrod`jdqadkhdudrghroqnonrhshnmsnadsqtdatsgd
hrmns`arnktsdkxrtqd-Sgdonrhshuddw`lokdr`qd9
286
'387(OQDRonrhshudhqqd`khroqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud9
Sgdo`q`kkdkhqqd`khroqnfqdrrhudmdf`shudrdmsdmbdrcnmnsg`udsgd
tmtrt`kKGqhrhmfsnmdnmsgdrtaidbsoqnmntm+atshmrsd`c`mtmtrt`k
cnvmrsdoed`stqdadenqdsgdoqnfqdrrhud.md∆.l`qjdq-Sgdcdqhu`shnmne
sghrcnvmrsdoed`stqd`mchsrqdk`shnmsnsgdKGqhrhmfsnmdnesgdonrhshud
rdmsdmbdrhrchrbtrrdchmcds`hkhmrdbshnm1-2-3-`anud-Ntqmdf`shud
o`q`chflhr9
aL teL nMe zKaYMa mbaLb wDJ "he probably isn’t cutting meat"
aL teL nMe gwMDYMD mbaLb wDJ "he probably isn’t pounding meat"
aL teL nMe lKumtMe mbaLb wDJ "he probably isn’t biting meat"
aL teL nMe lMimtMe mbaLb wDJ "he probably isn’t reheating meat"
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqrdbshnmnmsgdydqnsdmrdvgdqdansgo`q`kkdkqd`khr
`mchqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr`qdentmc-Sgdenkknvhmfetstqdsdmrdrvhkk`kk
adtmcdqkxhmfkxhqqd`khr`mc`kkbnlokdsdkxqdftk`qhmsgdhqudqasnmdrhm
sg`ssgdxvhkkadqd`khydcnmsgdqdftk`qhqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmr-
287
2-5-Snc`xEtstqdE09.fd∆.
Sgdehqrsnentqetstqdsdmrdrhrcheedqdmseqnl`kksgdnsgdqetstqd
sdmrdrhmsg`ssgdlnqogdld.fd∆.`bsrsnm`kkxkhjd`l`qjdqvghkdsgdnsgdq
etstqdlnqogdldr`bskhjdudqarhmbnmrdbtshududqabnmrsqtbshnmr-Sgd
bqtbh`kcheedqdmbdadsvddm`l`qjdq`mc`udqahmhqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmrhr
sgd`ardmbdnqoqdrdmbdnecnvmrsdoadenqdsgdvnqchmptdrshnm-Rhmbd
.fd∆.hrsgdnmkxetstqdlnqogdldmnssnadlnchehdcaxcnvmrsdo+hshr
`krnsgdnmkxnmdvghbghrmnsfq`ll`shb`kkxrshkk`udqa+`rhmsgd
enkknvhmfdw`lokdr9
aL geL zKaY mbMab "he will cut the meat" (later today)
Itrs`rsgdonrhshudo`q`chfl`anudv`rqd`khydcnmqdftk`qhqqd`khr
snmdo`ssdqmr+rnsnnenq`kkudqarhmmdf`shudetstqdbnmrsqtbshnmr-Sgd
o`q`kkdkE0mdf`shudbnmrsqtbshnmr`qdpthsdtmtrt`kgnvdudqhmsg`ssgdx
bnms`hm`m`r`koqdehw`ss`bgdcsnsgdetstqdl`qjdq`mc`snmd
odqstqa`shnmnmsgdoqdbdchmfMDFl`qjdq.sd∆.eqnl`Ksnmdsn`qhrhmf
snmd-Sgdcdqhu`shnmenqsgdrdbnmrsqtbshnmrhrchrbtrrdchmcds`hkhm
288
rdbshnm1-2-4-`anud-Sgdqdrtkshmfrtqe`bdo`q`chflhrsgdenkknvhmf9
aL teN ngeL zKaY mbMab wDJ "he will not cut the meat"
aL teN ngeL gwMDY mbMab wDJ "he will not pound the meat"
aL teN ngeL lKumteJ mbMab wDJ "he will not bite the meat"
aL teN ngeL lMimteL mbMab wDJ "he will not reheat the meat"
Rvhsbghmfmnvsnsgdmnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmrne
sgdE0sdmrd+vdmnshbdsg`ssgdsnmdrnmsgdudqar`qdsgdqdftk`qhqqd`khr
snmdo`ssdqmr-Rhfmhehb`mskx+sgdqd`khrhlodqedbshudm`r`koqdehwnmsgd
udqahr`kv`xr`ardmsvhsgetstqdbnmrsqtbshnmradb`trdetstqd
bnmrsqtbshnmr`qd`kv`xrhqqd`khrhmlncd-Sgntfgsgdm`r`khr`ardms+sgd
bnmrsqtbshnmrrshkkbnmudxsgdr`ldg`ahst`kld`mhmf`rsgdhqo`rsqd`khr
bntmsdqo`qsr-Sgdqdrtkshmfonrhshudo`q`chflhrsgdenkknvhmf9
289
Once again, the parallel negative paradigm finds the
LnuhmfnmsnoqnfqdrrhudbnmrsqtbshnmrvhsgsgdE0sdmrd+`kksgdsnmdr
`qdbnlokdsdkxqdftk`qenqhqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr+hmbktchmfsgdKsnmdnm
sgdoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq.md∆.+`radknv9
Nmbd`f`hm+sgdo`q`kkdkmdf`shudo`q`chflbnms`hmrsgdtmtrt`kqhrhmf
snmdnmsgdMDFl`qjdq.sd∆.`mcsgdtmtrt`km`r`koqdehwadenqdsgdE0
sdmrdl`qjdq.fd∆.+`radknv9
290
'4/4(E0mdf`shudoqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud9
`∆sd¿mfd∆md∆zKaYMala`∆av—æ!gdvhkkmnsadbtsshmfld`s!
`∆sd¿mfd∆md∆gwMDYMDla`∆av—æ!gdvhkkmnsadontmchmfld`s!
`∆sd¿mfd∆md∆lKumtMela`∆av—æ!gdvhkkmnsadahshmfld`s!
`∆sd¿mfd∆md∆lMimtMela`∆av—æ!gdvhkkmnsadqdgd`shmfld`s!
291
2-6-SnlnqqnvEtstqdE19.snæ.nq.fxn∆.
Sgdqdrsnesgdetstqdbnmrsqtbshnmr`kktrdudqarhmbnmrdbtshududqa
bnmrsqtbshnmr-Sgdm`stqdnesgdbnmrdbtshududqabnmrsqtbshnmrhm
A`lhkdjdk`mft`fdrv`rehqrscds`hkdcaxGxl`mvgnrgnvdcsg`s
bnmrdbtshududqarcheedqeqnlrdqh`kudqarhmsg`ssgdx`qdrdo`q`sdcax`
bnmrdbtshududqal`qjdqvghbghrsgdgnlnqf`mhbm`r`koqdehwhmlnrs
A`lhkdjdk`mft`fdr'086092/(-@sqtdbnmrdbtshududqabnmrsqtbshnmhm
Mfxdla——mmnsnmkxbnms`hmrsvn`ci`bdmsudqar'sgdehqrsudqa`klnrs
`kv`xradhmf`udqanelnshnm(`mcsgdhmsdqudmhmfgnlnqf`mhbm`r`k
bnmrnm`msoqdehw+hshr`krnl`qjdcaxltkshokdcnvmrsdoed`stqdr+nmd
oqdbdchmf+nmdrdo`q`shmf`mcnmdenkknvhmfsgdo`hqneudqar+`rhmsgd
enkknvhmfsxohb`kdw`lokdr9
aL geL cwKoB zKaY mbMab "he will come down and cut the meat"
aL geL cwKoB gwMDY mbMab "he will come down and pound the meat"
aL geL pyMu zKaY mbMab "he will go up and cut the meat"
aL geL pyMu gwMDY mbMab "he will go up and pound the meat"
Hmsgdoqdbdchmfdw`lokdr+sgdsvn'tmcdqkhmdc(lnshnmudqarvghbg
`qdsgdehqrsudqarhmntqbnmrdbtshududqabnmrsqtbshnm`qd.bvnæœ.!sn
bnldcnvm!`mc.oxt∆.!snfnto-!SgdrdsvnG`mcKsnmdudqarvdqd
292
oqdbdcdcaxcnvmrsdovgdmok`bdc`ssgdadfhmmhmfnebnmrdbtshududqa
bnmrsqtbshnmr-SgdE1sdmrd`krng`r`G`mc`Ksnmdudqavghbgb`m
hmchb`sdetstqdshldvgdmok`bdchmrtbg`bnmrsqtbshnm-Vdvhkkqdedqsn
rtbgudqar`r!`twhkh`qxudqar!adb`trdsgntfgsgdxrshkketmbshnm
fq`ll`shb`kkx`rudqar+sgdxg`udknrssgdhqnqhfhm`kudqa`kld`mhmf`mc+
hmbnmrdbtshudbnmrsqtbshnmrkhjdsgdenkknvhmf+sgdxnmkxrhfm`ketstqd
shld-Ntqehqrssvnonrhshudo`q`chflr`qd`renkknvr9
Bknrdbnlo`qhrnmnesgdoqdbdchmfsvno`q`chflrvhsgsgdnmd
oqdbdchmfsgdlvhkkrgnvsgdqd`cdqsg`ssgdE1sdmrdhrl`qjdcaxdhsgdq
nesgd`twhkh`qxudqar.snæ.nq.fxn∆.hm`bnmrdbtshududqabnmrsqtbshnm-Sgd
mdf`shudo`q`chflro`q`kkdksnsgdoqdbdchmf`qd`radknv9
293
'4/8(E1mdf`shudodqedbshud9
aL teL tKo zKaY mbMab wDJ "he will not cut the meat"
aL teL tKo gwMDY mbMab wDJ "he will not pound the meat"
aL teL tKo lKumteJ mbMab wDJ "he will not bite the meat"
aL teL tKo lMimteL mbMab wDJ "he will not reheat the meat"
aL teL gyMo zKaY mbMab wDJ "he will not cut the meat"
aL teL gyMo gwMDY mbMab wDJ "he will not pound the meat"
aL teL gyMo lKumteJ mbMab wDJ "he will not bite the meat"
aL teL gyMo lMimteL mbMab wDJ "he will not reheat the meat"
SgdE1sdmrdb`m`krntrddhsgdq.snæ.nq.fxn∆.vhsgsgdhlodqedbshud
udqarteehwsnenqlmnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmr+`rvhsg
sgdo`hqneonrhshudo`q`chflradknv9
294
(512) F2 positive non-progressive imperfective:
Sgdmdf`shudo`q`chflr`qd`rqdftk`q`rsgdhqonrhshudbntmsdqo`qsr+
`rrgnvmaxsgdsvnadknv9
Lnuhmfnmsnsgdoqnfqdrrhudbnmrsqtbshnmr+svnrdo`q`sdo`q`chflr
`qd`krnonrrhakdvhsgsgdr`ldE1ld`mhmf+`rhmsgdenkknvhmfdw`lokdr9
295
'404(E1onrhshudoqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud9
`∆tKomd∆zKaYMala`∆a!gdvhkkadbtsshmfld`s!'snlnqqnv(
`∆tKomd∆gwMDYMDla`∆a!gdvhkkadontmchmfld`s!
`∆tKomd∆lKumtMela`∆a!gdvhkkadahshmfld`s!
`∆tKomd∆lMimtMela`∆a!gdvhkkadqdgd`shmfld`s!
'405(E1onrhshudoqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud9
`∆gyMomd∆zKaYMala`∆a!gdvhkkadbtsshmfld`s!'snlnqqnv(
`∆gyMomd∆gwMDYMDla`∆a!gdvhkkadontmchmfld`s!
`∆gyMomd∆lKumtMela`∆a!gdvhkkadahshmfld`s!
`∆gyMomd∆lMimtMela`∆a!gdvhkkadqdgd`shmfld`s!
Sgdo`q`kkdkE1mdf`shudoqnfqdrrhudbnmrsqtbshnmr`krng`udsgd
noshnmnedhsgdq.snæ.nq.fxn∆.snhmchb`sdsnlnqqnvetstqdshld+`rhmsgd
svnenkknvhmfonrhshudo`q`chflr9
aL teL tKo neL zKaYMa mbaLb wDJ "he will not be cutting meat"
aL teL tKo neL gwMDYMD mbaLb wDJ "he will not be pounding meat"
aL teL tKo neL lKumtMe mbaLb wDJ "he will not be biting meat"
aL teL tKo neL lMimtMe mbaLb wDJ "he will not be reheating meat"
296
(518) F2 negative progressive imperfective:
aL teL gyMo neL zKaYMa mbaLb wDJ "he will not be cutting meat"
aL teL gyMo neL gwMDYMD mbaLb wDJ "he will not be pounding meat"
aL teL gyMo neL lKumtMe mbaLb wDJ "he will not be biting meat"
aL teL gyMo neL lMimtMe mbaLb wDJ "he will not be reheating meat"
Sghrdmcrntqrdbshnmnmsgdsnlnqqnvetstqdsdmrd`mcsgdsvn
o`q`kkdkbnmrsqtbshnmrsg`sl`x`ksdqm`shudkxaddloknxdcsgqntfgntssg`s
sdmrd-
297
2-7-Chrs`msEtstqdE29.kt∆.
Sgdchrs`msetstqdhrl`qjdchmMfxdla——maxsgd`twhkh`qxudqa.kt∆.
hm`bnmrdbtshududqabnmrsqtbshnm-Hsrsnm`koqnodqshdr`qd`kv`xr
bnlokdsdkxqdftk`qenqhqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmr`mcvdrg`kksgdqdenqd
oqdrdmssgdo`q`kkdkonrhshud`mcmdf`shudo`q`chflr`ro`hqr+`rvhsgntq
odqedbshuddw`lokdradknv9
aL lMu zKaY mbMab "he will cut the meat"(some time from now)
aL teL lMu zKaY mbMab wDJ "he will not cut the meat"
aL teL lMu gwMDY mbMab wDJ "he will not pound the meat"
aL teL lMu lKumteJ mbMab wDJ "he will not bite the meat"
aL teL lMu lMimteL mbMab wDJ "he will not reheat the meat"
Lnuhmfnmsnsgdmnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmr+sgdE2
sdmrdhrbnlokdsdkxqdftk`qenqdw`lokdrvhsghqqd`khrlncd+`radknv9
298
'410(E2onrhshudmnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud9
'411(E2mdf`shudmnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud9
Vdmnvlnudnmsnsgdo`q`kkdkoqnfqdrrhudbnmrsqtbshnmr+vghbg
`kknvnmkxsgdmnql`koqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq.md∆.adb`trdsgdx`qdl`qjdc
enqhqqd`khrlncd-@kksgdsnmdr`qdbnlokdsdkxqdftk`q`rrgnvmhmsgd
enkknvhmfo`q`chflo`hq9
299
(524) F3 negative progressive imperfective:
aL teL lMu neL zKaYMa mbaLb wDJ "he will not be cutting meat"
aL teL lMu neL gwMDYMD mbaLb wDJ "he will not be pounding meat"
aL teL lMu neL lKumtMe mbaLb wDJ "he will not be biting meat"
aL teL lMu neL lMimtMe mbaLb wDJ "he will not be reheating meat"
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqrdbshnmnmsgdchrs`msetstqdsdmrdvgdqdsgd
`twhkh`qxudqa.kt∆.hm`bnmrdbtshudhqqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmhr`kv`xrqd`khydc
nmqdftk`qhqqd`khrsnmdo`ssdqmr-
300
2-8-QdlnsdEtstqdE39.k`æù.nq.enæ.
Sgdqdlnsdetstqdsdmrdb`madrhfm`kkdcaxsvncheedqdmsGsnmd
`twhkh`qxudqar+.k`æù.`mc.enæ.+hm`bnmrdbtshududqabnmrsqtbshnm+`rhmsgd
onrhshudodqedbshudo`q`chflradknv9
aL lKaY zKaY mbMab "he will cut the meat"(a long time from now)
aL fKo zKaY mbMab "he will cut the meat"(a long time from now)
Sgdo`q`kkdkmdf`shudo`q`chflr`qd`krnbnlokdsdkxqdftk`qenq
hqqd`khrlncd+`radknv9
301
'416(E3mdf`shudodqedbshud9
aL teL lKaY zKaY mbMab wDJ "he will not cut the meat"
aL teL lKaY gwMDY mbMab wDJ "he will not pound the meat"
aL teL lKaY lKumteJ mbMab wDJ "he will not bite the meat"
aL teL lKaY lMimteL mbMab wDJ "he will not reheat the meat"
aL teL fKo zKaY mbMab wDJ "he will not cut the meat"
aL teL fKo gwMDY mbMab wDJ "he will not pound the meat"
aL teL fKo lKumteJ mbMab wDJ "he will not bite the meat"
aL teL fKo lMimteL mbMab wDJ "he will not reheat the meat"
Rvhsbghmfsnmnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmr+sgdE3sdmrd
bnmshmtdrsnodqlhsansg`twhkh`qxudqar`retstqdlnqogdldrhm
bnmmdbshnmvhsgsgdudqarteehwvghbgl`qjrhlodqedbshud`rodbs+`r
adknv9
302
(530) F4 positive non-progressive imperfective:
Sgdo`q`kkdkmdf`shudo`q`chflr`qd`krnsnm`kkxqdftk`qhmbktchmfsgd
hqqd`khrsnmdrnmsgdudqar+`radknv9
Ntqehm`ko`q`chflrvhkkqdedqsnsgdoqnfqdrrhud`rodbshm
bnlahm`shnmvhsgsgdE3sdmrd+`rhmsgdsvnonrhshudo`q`chflradknv9
303
(533) F4 positive progressive imperfective:
Sgdo`q`kkdkmdf`shudo`q`chflr`qd`krnsnm`kkxqdftk`qenqhqqd`khr
bnmrsqtbshnmr+`radknv9
aL teL lKaY neL zKaYMa mbaLb wDJ "he will not be cutting meat"
aL teL lKaY neL gwMDYMD mbaLb wDJ "he will not be pounding meat"
aL teL lKaY neL lKumtMe mbaLb wDJ "he will not be biting meat"
aL teL lKaY neL lMimtMe mbaLb wDJ "he will not be reheating meat"
aL teL fKo neL zKaYMa mbaLb wDJ "he will not be cutting meat"
aL teL fKo neL gwMDYMD mbaLb wDJ "he will not be pounding meat"
aL teL fKo neL lKumtMe mbaLb wDJ "he will not be biting meat"
aL teL fKo neL lMimtMe mbaLb wDJ "he will not be reheating meat"
304
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqrta,rdbshnmnmsgdE3sdmrd`rvdkk`rntqdmshqd
rdbshnmnmsgdhmchb`shudbnmrsqtbshnmhmMfxdla——ml`hmbk`trdr-
305
CHAPTER 4
3-/-LnqogdldQtkdr
Ctqhmfsgdbntqrdnesghrchrrdqs`shnm+vdg`udchrbtrrdcl`mx
lnqognknfhb`k`mclnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdr`rvdkk`rsgdsnmdqtkdr
vghbgvdqdntql`inqenbtr-Hmsghrrdbshnm+vdvhkkenql`khydsgd
lnqognknfhb`k`mclnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdrmdbdrr`qxenq`kksgd
dw`lokdreqnlsgdMfxdla——mk`mft`fdsg`sg`udaddmbhsdc`anud-
Vdr`vhmrdbshnm1-2-4-`anud`rtll`qxnesgdsnmdqtkdrmddcdchm
sgdMfxdla——mk`mft`fd-Hm`cchshnmsnsgdl`hmancxnetmnqcdqdcqtkdr+
sgdqddwhrsitrsnmdd`qkxsnmdl`oohmfqtkd`mcsvnk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkdr-
D`bgnesgdqdrtkshmfsgqddanchdrnesnmdqtkdrhroqdbdcdcaxu`qhntr
lnqognknfhb`k`mclnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdr-Vdchrbtrradknvsgdsgqdd
anchdrnesgdrdlnqognknfhb`k`mclnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdr+bhshmfenq
d`bgqtkdansg`onrrhakdenql`khrl`mc`oqnrdqdmchshnmnehsrdeedbsr-
Sgdehqrsfqntonelnqognknfhb`kqtkdr`qdsgnrdvghbgprecedesgdsnmd
l`oohmfqtkd-@kksgdrdmsdmbdroqdrdmsdchmsghrchrrdqs`shnm`qd
hmchb`shud`mcsq`mrhshud+vhsgvnqcr`mcogq`rdrnqcdqdc`radknv9
306
Sgdoqdbdchmfenqltk`rgnvrsg`ssgdrdmsdmbdrhmntqc`s``qd
qd`khydcadfhmmhmfvhsg`rtaidbsmntmogq`rd'RMO(+enkknvdcax`m
noshnm`ksdmrdl`qjdq'S(+`mnoshnm`kmdf`shudl`qjdq'MDF(+`m
noshnm`kqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq'QO(+`mnoshnm`koqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq
'O(+`udqa+`mnaidbsmntmogq`rd'mnsnoshnm`khmntqc`s`(+`mc`m
noshnm`krdmsdmbd,ehm`kmdf`shudbkhshb.v—æ.'rxlankhydc`r!V!(-
Sghrnqcdqhmfnertaidbsradenqdudqar`mcnaidbsrhrbdqs`hmkxsgdb`rd
enq`kksgdc`s`hmsghrchrrdqs`shnm`mclnrskhjdkxsgdb`rdenq`kk
rdmsdmbdrhmMfxdla——m-VghkdMfxdla——mb`mnbb`rhnm`kkxeqnms`m
naidbshmeqnmsnesgdudqa+`klnrs`kksgddw`lokdrhmsghrchrrdqs`shnm
enkknvsgdnudqvgdklhmfo`ssdqmneudqaadenqdnaidbs-Sgdqdenqd+hm
sxonknfhb`ksdqlr+Mfxdla——mhrlnrscdehmhsdkx`mRUNk`mft`fd+`mc`
e`hqkxqhfhcRUNk`mft`fd`ssg`s-Vghkdsgdnoshnm`kl`qjdqrd`bgg`ud
u`qhntrqdrsqhbshnmrnmsgdhqnbbtqqdmbd+hsrgntkcadqdl`qjdcsg`ssgd
mdf`shudlnqogdldrhmsghrchrrdqs`shnm`qd`kv`xraho`qshsd`mc
chrbnmshmtntr+vhsgsgdl`hml`qjdqnemdf`shnmhlldch`sdkxenkknvhmf
sgdsdmrdl`qjdq`mcsgdehm`kmdf`shudbkhshb`kv`xr`bbnlo`mxhmfhs`s
sgddmcnesgdrdmsdmbd-Sgdkhlhsdcmtladqnertaidbsmntmogq`rdrhm
ntqc`s`g`udsgdenkknvhmfrsqtbstqd9
307
'427(RtaidbsMntmOgq`rdRsqtbstqd9
M'@BSM(
RL
Oqn
Sgdoqdbdchmfenqltk`rgnvrsg`srtaidbsmntmogq`rdr`qdqd`khydc
axdhsgdq`mntm'M(enkknvdcax`mnoshnm`k`rrnbh`shudbnmbnqcsnmd
'@BS(`mc`rdbnmcmntmnqax`oqnmntm+d`bgnesgdrdbgnhbdr
nbbtqqhmfadenqd`ehm`krtaidbsl`qjdq'RL(-Vghkdmntmogq`rdrvdqd
mnssgdl`hmenbtrnesghrchrrdqs`shnm+vdchccdudknontqa`rhbsnm`k
qtkdrnmsgdrtqe`bdsnm`kqd`khy`shnmrnemntmrhmhrnk`shnm`mchm
`rrnbh`shudmntmogq`rdr'rddrdbshnm1-1-`anud(-Hmrdbshnm1-3-0-`krn
`anud+vdchrbtrrdcansgsgdqd`khy`shnmnertaidbsoqnmntmr`mcsgd
m`stqd`mcadg`uhnqnesgdhqrtaidbsl`qjdqrvghbgrdo`q`sdsgdleqnl
sgdenkknvhmfudqaogq`rdr-Sgdu`qhdsxnemntmogq`rdl`sdqh`kvd
dw`lhmdchmsgdnaidbsonrhshnmv`rltbglnqdkhlhsdc+`rrgnvmadknv9
OM N
Sgdoqdbdchmfenqltk`rs`sdrsg`snaidbsmntmogq`rdrvdqdqd`khydc
ax`mnaidbsl`qjdq'NL(oqdbdchmf`rhmfkdmntm'M(-Vghkdsghr
chrrdqs`shnmg`rkhlhsdchsrdkesnnaidbsmntmogq`rdrvghbgnmkxbnms`hm`
308
rhmfkdmntm+hshrnebntqrdonrrhakdsng`udmntmogq`rdrvghbgbnms`hm
`rrnbh`shudbnmrsqtbshnmrnqoqnmntmr-Ntqehqrslnqognknfhb`kqtkdhrsgd
enkknvhmf9
+T
[past
+SM -[fut
Ø +SMCT /
+T +verb
-past x -real
-fut -perf
-prog
Sghrqtkdrs`sdrsg`ssgdrtaidbsl`qjdq'RL(hrqd`khydc`r`rtaidbs
l`qjdqbnmbnqcsnmd'RLBS(hm`kko`rs`mcetstqdsdmrdrdmsdmbdr'ydqn
sdmrdadhmfsgdnmkxsdmrdvgdqdZo`rs\`mcZets\ed`stqdr`qdhcdmshb`k(-
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkdhr`krnsqhffdqdcenqsgdydqnsdmrd+atsnmkxenq
bnmrsqtbshnmrvghbg`qdl`qjdcenqhqqd`khrlncdvhsghlodqedbshud`mc
mnm,oqnfqdrrhud`rodbsr-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
N NCP NR
Sghrqtkdrs`sdrsg`ssgdmntm'M(hrqd`khydc`r`mntmbk`rroqdehw
'MBO(enkknvdcax`mntmqnns'MQ(-Sgdenkknvhmfqtkdrodkkrntssgdsdm
mntmbk`rroqdehwdrneMfxdla——m'@mcdqrnm+087/`927(+vhsgsgd
309
o`qdmsgdrdrdmbknrhmfsgnrdunvdkrnmsgdrdfldms`kshdqvghbg`qd
noshnm`k`ssgdadfhmmhmfne`rdmsdmbd9
+NCP +NR
Ø /(a)N-/ / +C1
+NCP +NR
/me-/ / +C2
+NCP +NR
/(e)N-/ / +C3
+NCP +NR
/meN-/ / +C4
+NCP +NR
/le-/ / +C5
+NCP +NR
/me-/ / +C6
+NCP +NR
/(a)-/ / +C7
+NCP +NR
/(e)-/ / +C8
+NCP +NR
/(e)N-/ / +C9
+NCP +NR
/(e)N-/ / +C10
310
Sghrqtkdrodbhehdrsgdrdfldms`kl`sdqh`kentmcnmsgdrxkk`ahbshdq
enqsgdmntmbk`rroqdehwhmd`bgnesgdsdmbk`rrdr'rxlankhydcax`
b`osh`k!B!vhsg`mtladq(-Sgdsnmd`rrhfmdcsnd`bgnesgdrdoqdehwdrhr
rodbhehdcaxsgdenkknvhmfqtkd9
[+NCP]
+ # +
Ø L /
+ +
Sghrqtkdr`xrsg`s`mxrxkk`akdnmsgdrxkk`ahbshdq'#(vghbghr`mntm
bk`rroqdehwZ*MBO\hrfhudm`Ksnmdhmsgdr`ldlnqogdldnmsgdsnm`k
shdq-Rhmbdsghrqtkdoqdbdcdrsgdsnm`kl`oohmfqtkd+sghrqtkdcndrmns
rodbhexsgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdvghbgsg`sqtkdvhkk`ccadsvddmsgdsvnshdqr-
Hsrgntkcadldmshnmdcsg`ssgd`bst`kmntmqnnsr'MQ(`mcsgdoqnmntmr
'Oqn(vntkcadrodkkdcntsadsgdkdwhbnmadenqd`mxnesgdrdoqdrdmsqtkdr
`qd`kknvdcsnnodq`sd-Sgdqd`cdqhmsdqdrsdchm`rl`kkk4//,vnqcEqdmbg,
Mfxdla——mkdwhbnmhrqdedqqdcsn@mcdqrnm'087/a(-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgd
enkknvhmf9
311
+NR [+...CT]
+C1 + +
Ø L / +C9
+ ____ +
[+...CT]
+ +
H /
+ ____ +
Sghrqtkdrs`sdrsg`s`mxbnmbnqcsnmdl`qjdq'---BS(hretqsgdq
rodbhehdc`r`Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdldenkknvhmfmntmbk`rrqnnsr'MQ(
eqnlbk`rrdr0`mc8+`mc`r`Gsnmdsnm`klnqogdldenkknvhmfmntm
qnnsreqnlnsgdqbk`rrdr-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
[+OM] +NCP
¶ + +C2
Ø H / +C4
¶ + +C5
+C6
Sghrqtkdrs`sdrsg`ssgdnaidbsl`qjdqhr`cchshnm`kkxrodbhehdc`r`G
snmdsnm`klnqogdldoqdbdchmfnaidbsoqdehwdr'MBO(eqnlmntmbk`rrdr
1+3+4nq5-
Sgdoqdbdchmfqtkdrg`udg`mckdcsgdnudq`kkrdmsdmbdrsqtbstqd`mc
sgdmntmogq`rdhmrne`q`rsgdx`qdcdudknodchmsghrchrrdqs`shnm-Vdmnv
lnudnmsnsgdl`mxcheedqdmsdkdldmsrvghbgqdk`sdsnsgdudqa`k
312
l`qjhmfne`rdmsdmbd-Ntqehqrssvnqtkdrg`mckd`kksgd`cchshnm`k
rdfldms`kl`sdqh`kmdbdrr`qxhmmdf`shudbnmrsqtbshnmr-Sgdenkknvhmf
qtkdrodbhehdrsgdm`stqdnesgdrdmsdmbd,ehm`kMDFbkhshb9
+ wD // +W
Ø / +neg
+ H //
Sghrqtkdrs`sdrsg`sntqrdmsdmbd,ehm`kMDFbkhshb'V(hretqsgdq
rodbhehdc`r.v—.nmsgdrdfldms`krxkk`ahbshdq`mc`rhmfkdGsnmdnmsgd
snm`kshdq-Nmbd`f`hm+sgdtmhsrrodbhehdcnmsgdsvnshdqr`qdmns
`rrnbh`sdcax`m`rrnbh`shnmkhmdaxsghrqtkd`rsghrqtkdoqdbdcdrsgd
fdmdq`ksnmdl`oohmfqtkdvghbg`bbnlokhrgdrsgds`rj-Ntqmdwsqtkdhr9
# ka # +T +NEG +verb
Ø / -past +perf
# L # -fut
# te # +NEG
/
# L #
Sghrqtkdrs`sdrsg`ssgdmdf`shudl`qjdq'MDF(hr`cchshnm`kkx
rodbhehdc`r`.j`.hmO/bnmrsqtbshnmr`mc`r`.sd.hm`kknsgdq
bnmsqtbshnmr+d`bgnesgdrdl`qjdqr`krnbnmrhrshmfne`rhmfkd
tm`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdnmsgdsnm`kshdq-
313
Vdvhkkmnvdw`lhmdsgdqtkdrmddcdcsnbnmudxsgdrdl`mshbbnmbdos
nesdmrd-Sgdenkknvhmfqtkdretqsgdqrodbhexsgdrxkk`ahb`mcsnm`kbnmsdms
nesdmrdl`qjdqr`mc`twhkh`qxudqar`bbnqchmfsnsgdhqsdlonq`ked`stqdr-
Vdadfhmvhsgsgdlnrsqdlnsdo`rssdmrd`mcvnqjntqv`xsnsgdlnrs
qdlnsdetstqdsdmrd-Rhmbdsgdqtkdenqsgdqdlnsdo`rssdmrd'O3(l`qjdq
`bst`kkxbg`mfdrnmdnesgdfq`ll`shb`ked`stqdrhmnqcdqsneddcsgdqtkd
enqsgdchrs`mso`rssdmrd'O2(l`qjdq+`kkqtkdrqdedqqhmfsnsgdnqhfhm`kO3
ed`stqdrltrsoqdbdcdsgdl`qjdqqtkd-Hm`cchshnm+sgdqtkdvghbg
rodbhehdrntqm`r`koqdehwenqhlodqedbshudqd`khrbnmrsqtbshnmrltrs
oqdbdcdsgdbg`mfhmfnesgdqd`khred`stqdeqnl!*!sn!,-!Ntqmdwsqtkd
hrsgdqdenqdsgdenkknvhmf9
+verb
Ø /N-/ / +real
-perf
Sghrqtkd`ccr`gnlnqf`mhbm`r`kbnmrnm`msoqdehwnmsnsgd
adfhmmhmfnesgdudqarsdlhesg`srsdlhransgqd`khrlncd`mc
hlodqedbshud`rodbs-Hsrgntkcadmnshbdcsg`ssgd`ccdcl`sdqh`kv`r
rs`sdc`r.M,.snhlokxsg`ssghroqdehwhrnotrxkk`ahb+h-d-hsb`mmns
`rrnbh`sdsn`mxsnmd+'hmbnmsq`rssnlnrsgnlnqf`mhbm`r`kbnmrsnm`ms
oqdehwdrhmMfxdla——m(-Mnvsg`ssgdhlodqedbshudqd`khroqdehwg`raddm
rodbhehdc+vd`qdeqddsnbg`mfdsgdqd`khred`stqdenqsgnrdbnmrsqtbshnmr
314
vghbgdmctovhsghqqd`khrsnmdrhmrsd`cneqd`khrnmdr-Ntqmdwsqtkdhr
sgtrsgdenkknvhmf9
+T +verb
+past -prog
+rem -neg
[+real] [-real] / -near
+T +verb
-past +prog
-fut -neg
Sghrqtkdbg`mfdrsgded`stqdZ*qd`k\snZ,qd`k\enqsgqddjhmcrne
bnmrsqtbshnmr9O3onrhshudodqedbshudr+O3onrhshudmnm,oqnfqdrrhud
hlodqedbshudr'ansgnesgdoqdbdchmfadhmfZ,oqnf\(+`mcydqnonrhshud
oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshudr-Sghrqtkdsgdqdenqdakddcrsgdqd`khronk`qsnmd
qtkd`mceddcrsgdhqqd`khronk`qsnmdqtkd-
Vd`qdmnvqd`cxsndw`lhmdntqsdmrdl`qjdqqtkdr+sgdehqrsne
vghbgg`mckdrsgdbnlokhb`sdcO3bnmrsqtbshnm+`radknv9
+T
# laY # +past
[-near] [+near]... / +rem
# H # x [+verb]
315
Sghrqtkdbg`mfdrsgdZmd`q\ed`stqdeqnl!,!sn!*!`mc`ccr`m
`cchshnm`kGsnmdl`qjdq.k`ù.hlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfsgdudqaqnns
vgdmdudqsgdsdmrdl`qjdq'S(hrl`qjdcenqO3sdmrd-Sgdbg`mfhmfne
sgded`stqdsgdqdaxeddcrntqmdwsqtkdvghbghrsgdenkknvhmf9
+T
# la # +past
Ø / +rem
# L # +near
SghrqtkdrodbhehdrsgdO2sdmrdl`qjdqsnbnmrhrsne.k`.nmsgd
rdfldms`krxkk`ahbshdq`mc`Ksnmdnmsgdsnm`kshdq-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgd
enkknvhmf9
+T
# ka # +past
Ø / -rem
# L # -near
SghrqtkdrodbhehdrsgdO1sdmrdl`qjdqsnbnmrhrsne.j`.nmsgd
rdfldms`krxkk`ahbshdq`mc`Ksnmdnmsgdsnm`kshdq-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgd
enkknvhmf9
316
(553) Today Past Tense Marker Rule: (P1)
# ne # +T
+past
Ø / -rem
+near
# L H L #
SghrqtkdrodbhehdrsgdO0sdmrdl`qjdqsnbnmrhrsne.md.nmsgd
rdfldms`krxkk`ahbshdq`mcK+G`mccnvmrsdo'C(ed`stqdrnmsgdsnm`k
shdq-Rhmbdsghrl`qjdqmddcrsgdKGqhrhmfsnmdfkhcdsnad`kv`xr
oqdrdms+sgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdreqnlsgdrdfldms`kshdq`qdcq`vmhmaxsgd
oqdbdchmflnqognknfhb`kqtkd`mc`qdmnskdessnsgdk`sdqsnmdl`oohmf
qtkd+vghbgvntkcvqnmfkx`rrnbh`sdnmkxsgdehqrssnmdnesghrlnqogdld
snsgdrxkk`ahb.md.-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
+T
# ge # +fut
Ø / -rem x [+verb]
# L # +near
Sghrqtkdrodbhehdrsg`ssgdE0sdmrdl`qjdqbnmrhrsrne.fd.nmsgd
rdfldms`krxkk`ahbshdq`mc`rhmfkdKsnmdnmsgdsnm`kshdq+`mcsgdx`qd
hmrdqsdchlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfsgdudqa-Sghrhrsgdnmkxetstqdsdmrd
l`qjdqsg`scndrmnshsrdkeadbnld`m`twhkh`qxudqahm`bnmrdbtshududqa
bnmrsqtbshnm+`r`kksgdenkknvhmfsdmrdl`qjdqrcn-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgd
enkknvhmf9
317
'444(SnlnqqnvEtstqdSdmrdL`qjdqQtkd9'E1(
[+verb]
# to #
# H # +T
+fut
Ø / -rem x [+verb]
-near
[+verb]
# gyo #
# L #
Sghrqtkd`ccrdhsgdqnesvn`twhkh`qxudqarsnrhfmhexsgd`bshnmvhkk
s`jdok`bdsnlnqqnv-Sgdehqrsnesgdrd`twhkh`qxudqar'nqcdqdc
hlldch`sdkxadenqdsgdl`hmudqahm`bnmrdbtshududqabnmrsqtbshnm(
bnmrhrsrne.sn.nmsgdrdfldms`krxkk`ahbshdq`mc`Gsnmdnmsgdsnm`k
shdq+vghkdsgdrdbnmcbnmrhrsrne.fxn.nmsgdrxkk`ahbshdq`mc`Ksnmdnm
sgdsnm`kshdq-Rhmbdansgnesgdrdl`qjdqr`qdk`adkkdc!Z*udqa\+!
vghbgdudqnmdhrbgnrdmhrk`sdqfhudm`cnvmrsdoed`stqdaxld`mrnesgd
qtkdenqhqqd`khrlncd-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrrhlhk`q+`radknv9
[+verb] +T
# lu # +fut
Ø / +rem x [+verb]
# L # +near
Sghrqtkdrodbhehdrsg`ssgdshldrhfmhehdcaxchrs`mssdmrded`stqdrhr
qd`khydcax`cchmfhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfsgdl`hmudqa`m`twhkh`qxudqa
318
vghbgbnmrhrsrne.kt.nmsgdrdfldms`krxkk`ahbshdq`mc`Ksnmdnmsgd
snm`kshdq-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
[+verb]
# laY #
# H # +T
+fut
Ø / +rem x [+verb]
-near
[+verb]
# fo #
# H #
Sghrqtkdrs`sdrsg`ssgdlnrsqdlnsdetstqdshldqdedqdmbdhrhmchb`sdc
axsgd`cchshnmnedhsgdqnesvn`twhkh`qxudqarhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfsgd
l`hmudqa-Sgdehqrsnesgdrd`twhkh`qxudqarbnmrhrsrne.k`ù.nmsgd
rdfldms`krxkk`ahbshdqvghkdsgdrdbnmcbnmrhrsrne.en.-Vghbgdudqudqa
hrbgnrdmhr`bbnlo`mhdcax`rhmfkdGsnmdnmsgdsnm`kshdq-@rvhsg`kk
sgdnsgdqhqqd`khr`twhkh`qxudqar+`cnvmrsdoed`stqdhr`ccdcaxntqk`sd
hqqd`khrlncdqtkd-Sghrbnmbktcdrsgd`cchshnm`krodbhehb`shnmnentq
cheedqdmssdmrded`stqdr-
Sgdmdwsqtkdrvghbgvdvhkkenql`khyd`qdsgnrdcd`khmfvhsgsgd
hmsdqm`krsqtbstqdnesgdudqa-Sgdehqrsnesgdrdqtkdrhrsgdenkknvhmf9
319
'447(Qd`khrOqdehwQtkd9
+verb
+real
# + $ #
Ø -[T /
# + [T #
Sghrqtkd`ccr`ekn`shmfonk`qsnmd',√S(snm`koqdehwhlldch`sdkx
adenqd`mxqd`khrudqarsdl-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
+T +verb
+past -perf
+ EV # [rem -prog
Ø / [near
+ L #
+verb
-perf
+ # + te + #
L /
+ T + + #
+verb
-perf
+ EV # + # +
/
+ L # + T +
Sghrqtkdrodbhehdrsg`ssgdhlodqedbshududqarteehwvhkkad`ccdcsn
sgddmcne`udqarsdldwbdosenqO1`mcO2mnm,oqnfqdrrhudhlodqedbshud
bnmrsqtbshnmrvgdqdhshr`ss`bgdcsnsgdsdmrdl`qjdqZ*S\-Sgdrteehw
bnmrhrsrne`Ksnmddbgnunvdk'DU(dwbdoshlldch`sdkxenkknvhmfsgd
320
snmdkdrrrteehw.,sd.vgdqdhsbnmrhrsrne`Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdld-Ntq
mdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
# sse #
# H L #
+T +RP [+P] +verb
Ø / +past x +real
# #
# H #
+T +RP +verb
# sse # +past x +real
/
+T +RP ([+P]) [+verb]
# H L # [past x
-fut
[rem
-near
Sghrbnlokdwqtkdrs`sdrsg`ssgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq'QO(hr
etqsgdqrodbhehdc`rdhsgdq.rrd.nmsgdrdfldms`krxkk`ahbshdqvhsg`m
`bbnlo`mxhmfGsnmdenkknvdcax`cnvmrsdoed`stqd'C(nmsgdsnm`kshdq
nqax`Gsnmdsnm`klnqogdldvgdmsgdrdmsdmbdhrl`qjdcenqansgo`rs
sdmrd`mcqd`khrlncd`mcsgdqdftk`qoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq'O(hroqdrdms-
Vgdmsgdqdftk`qoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqhr`ardmshmrtbg`bnmrsqtbshnm+sgd
nmkxbgnhbdenqsgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqhrsgd.rrd.vhsgGsnmd`mc
cnvmrsdoed`stqdr-RhmbdsgdO3sdmrdg`raddml`qjdcZ,qd`k\axsghr
321
shld+hshrmns`eedbsdcaxsgdoqdbdchmfo`qsnesgdqtkd-Rhlhk`qkx+ydqn
sdmrdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudbnmrsqtbshnmr`qdmns`eedbsdcadb`trdsgdx`qd
Z,o`rs\-SgdO3`mcydqnqd`khroqnfqdrrhudbnmrsqtbshnmrvhkkad`eedbsdc
axsgdk`rso`qsnesgdoqdbdchmfqtkdvghbgr`xrsg`ssgdxltrsad
qd`khydcaxsgdl`qjdq.rrd.nmsgdrdfldms`kshdq`mcGCnmsgdsnm`kshdq
hesgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqhroqdrdmsvgdsgdqsgdqdftk`qoqnfqdrrhud
l`qjdqhroqdrdmsnqmns-Sgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdr`qdmnsrodbhehdcaxsghr
qtkd`rsgdk`sdqsnmdl`oohmfqtkdvhkkqhfgskx`rrnbh`sditrssgdGsnmdnm
sgdsnm`kshdqsnsgd.rrd.nmsgdrxkk`ahbshdq-SgdGsnmdsnm`klnqogdld
hrsgdenbtrne`lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbgenkknvrsgdsnmdl`oohmf
qtkd-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
# ne # +P
Ø /
# L #
Sghrqtkdrs`sdrsg`ssgdmnql`koqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqhrqd`khydc`r.md.
nmsgdrdfldms`krxkk`ahbshdq`knmfvhsg`bnqqdronmchmfKsnmdnmsgd
snm`kshdq-Sghrl`qjdqhrmnskhlhsdchmchrsqhatshnmvhsgqdrodbssnlncd+
atsl`xadtrdcsnrhfm`koqnfqdrrhud`rodbshmansgqd`khr`mchqqd`khr
bnmrsqtbshnmr-
322
Vdmnvlnudnmsn`fqntonelnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdrvghbg`cc+
cdkdsd`mcbg`mfdansgsnmdr`mc`rrnbh`shnmkhmdrhmqdrsqhbsdc
fq`ll`shb`kdmuhqnmldmsr-Lnrsnesgdrdqtkdr`qdnqcdqdc`esdqsgd
fdmdq`ksnmdl`oohmfqtkdg`rnodq`sdcatsadenqdsgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdr
g`udg`c`mnoonqstmhsxsn`ookx-Sgdedvlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdr
vghbgltrsadnqcdqdc`esdqsgdmnql`ksnmdqtkdrvhkknmkxadcdrbqhadc
`ssgddmcnesghrrdbshnm-
Sgdehqrslnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdrvghbgvdrg`kkdw`lhmd`qdsgnrd
vghbgbg`mfdsnmdr`mc`rrnbh`shnmkhmdrvhsghmsgdudqa`bbnqchmfsn
u`qhntrsdlonq`k+`rodbst`k`mclnc`ked`stqdr-Sgdehqrsnesgdrdhrsgd
enkknvhmf9
# + V + #
+T +verb
/ +past x +perf
+rem -neg
# -[T + [T + Ø # +near
Sghrqtkd`ccr`rhmfkdKsnmdsnm`klnqogdld`esdqsgdudqarsdl'U(
`mc`rrnbh`sdrsghrmdvsnmda`bjsnsgdk`rsrxkk`akdnesg`srsdl
withoutchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdsnmd'√S(`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd-Sghrqtkd
hrnmkxsqhffdqdcvgdmsgdbnmrsqtbshnmhrl`qjdcenqO2sdmrd+odqedbshud
`rodbs'qdrtkshmfhmsgdonk`q',√S(snmdoqdehw(`mconrhshudonk`qhsx-Ntq
323
mdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
# # + V #
+T +verb
/ +past x +perf
-rem -neg
# Ø -[T + [T # -near
Sghrqtkd`ccr`Ksnmdinsidesgdonk`qqd`khrsnmd',√S(lnqogdld
`mc`rrnbh`sdrsghrmdvsnmdsnbothsgdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfrxkk`akd
'#(`mcsgdenkknvhmfudqaqnns'U(vhsgntschr`rrnbh`shmf`mxsnmdrentmc
sgdqd-Sgdqtkdhrnmkxsqhffdqdchmbnmrsqtbshnmrvghbg`qdl`qjdcenqO1
sdmrd+odqedbshud`rodbs`mconrhshudonk`qhsx-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgd
enkknvhmf9
n-
# Ø + V #
+T +verb
/ +past x +perf
-rem -neg
# -[T + [T # +near
324
Sghrqtkdlnudrsgdonk`qqd`khrsnmdsnm`klnqogdld',√S(eqnl
hlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfsgdudqarsdl'U(snhlldch`sdkxenkknvhmfsgd
r`ldrsdlvghkdkd`uhmfhmhsrnqhfhm`konrhshnm`gnlnqf`mhbm`r`k
bnmrnm`msoqdehw'rxlankhydc`r`knvdq,b`rd!m!adb`trdhsb`mmns
`rrnbh`sdvhsg`mxsnmd(-Sghrqtkdhrnmkxsqhffdqdcvgdmbnmrsqtbshnmr
`qdl`qjdcenqO0sdmrd+odqedbshud`rodbs`mconrhshudonk`qhsx-
Vd`qdmnvqd`cxsnlnudnmsncds`hksgdmnm,o`rslnqogn,
snmnknfhb`kqtkdr-Sgdehqrsnesgdrdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
+ ¶ + V #
+SM +T +verb
/ -past +perf
-fut -neg
+ T ¶ -[T + [T #
Sghrqtkdbg`mfdrsgdrtaidbsl`qjdq'RL(bnmbnqcsnmd'S(sn`K
snmdand`rrnbh`sdrsghrmdvsnmd`bqnrrsgdogq`rdantmc`qx'ï(`mcsgd
hmsdqudmhmfonk`qqd`khrsnmdsnm`klnqogdld',√S(snsgdudqaqnns
rxkk`akd'U(withoutchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdsnmd'√S(`kqd`cxentmcsgdqd-
Sghrqtkdhrnmkxsqhffdqdchmbnmrsqtbshnmrvghbg`qdl`qjdcenqydqn
325
sdmrd+odqedbshud`rodbs`mconrhshudonk`qhsx-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgd
enkknvhmf9
Rule:
# V + + I #
+T +verb
/ -past x -real
-fut -perf
# T + Ø + L # -prog
-neg
Sghrqtkd`ccr`Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdldaftersgdudqarsdl'U(ats
beforesgdhlodqedbshud'H(Ksnmdrteehw-Sgdqtkdhrnmkxsqhffdqdc
vgdmbnmrsqtbshnmr`qdl`qjdcenqydqnsdmrd'mdhsgdqo`rsmnqetstqd(+
hqqd`khrlncd+ansghlodqedbshud`mcmnm,oqnfqdrrhud`rodbsr+`mconrhshud
onk`qhsx-
Vdb`mmnvdw`lhmdsgnrdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdrvghbg`eedbssgd
mdf`shud`mcoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdqrhm`udqaogq`rd-Ntqehqrsqtkdcnbjr
sgdGsnmdsnm`klnqogdldvghbgl`xnbbtqsnl`qjqd`khroqnfqdrrhud
bnmrsqtbshnmr+`radknv9
326
# N # # P #
/ +verb
+neg
# L # H # L #
# # P #
/ +verb
-neg
# H # L #
Sghrqtkd`rrnbh`sdrsgdGsnmdsnm`klnqogdldnesgdqd`khr
oqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq'QO(snsgdmdf`shudl`qjdq'M(nmhsrkdeshertbg`
mdf`shudl`qjdqhroqdrdms-Nsgdqvhrd+sgdGsnmdsnm`klnqogdldhr
`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdoqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq'O(nmhsrqhfgs-Hmansgb`rdr+sgd
`cchshnm`k`rrnbh`shnmkhmdrcnnotchr`rrnbh`sd`mxsnmdr`kqd`cx
`rrnbh`sdcvhsgsgdbgnrdmrxkk`akdr-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
+ # ¶ sse #
+T +verb
/ -past +real
-fut -perf
+ T ¶ H (T) L # +prog
-neg
Ø L H
327
Sghrghfgkxbnlokhb`sdc`mcdpt`kkxqdrsqhbsdclnqogn,snmnknfhb`k
qtkdcdkdsdrsgdsnmd'S(oqdbdchmfsgdqd`khroqnfqdrrhud'QO(l`qjdq
.rrdæ∫.+`rrnbh`sdrsgdGsnmdnesg`sl`qjdqsnsgdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmf
rxkk`akd+cdkdsdrsgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdadsvddmsgdGsnmd`mcsgdrxkk`akd
.rrd.+hmrdqsrnqbg`mfdr`mnoshnm`kekn`shmfsnmdhmsn`Ksnmd+`mc
bg`mfdrsgdsgdehm`k`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdhmsn`Gsnmd-Sghrsnmdqtkdnmkx
nodq`sdrnmbnmrsqtbshnmrvghbg`qdl`qjdcenqydqnsdmrd+qd`khrlncd+
hlodqedbshud`mcoqnfqdrrhud`rodbsr+onrhshudonk`qhsx+`mcg`rbgnrdm
sgd.rrdæ∫.noshnmeqnlsgdd`qkhdqqd`khroqnfqdrrhudlnqogdldqtkd-Ntq
mdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
n-
# te # Ø # ge #
+T +verb
/ +fut +neg
-rem
# L # Ø # L # +near
Sghrqtkd`ccr`lnqogdldhlldch`sdkx`esdqsgdMDFl`qjdq.sd∆.`mc
hlldch`sdkxadenqdsgdsdmrdl`qjdq.fd∆.hm`kkE0bnmrsqtbshnmr-Sgd
`cchshnm`klnqogdldbnmrhrsrne`gnlnqf`mhbm`r`kbnmrnm`msoqdehw
328
'rxlankhydc`r`knvdqb`rd!m,!adb`trdhsb`mmns`rrnbh`sdvhsg`snmd(
nmsgdrdfldms`kshdq`mc`Gsnmdnmsgdsnm`kshdq-Sghr`cchshnm`kG
snmdhr`kv`xr`rrnbh`sdca`bjsnsgdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfMDFl`qjdq
withoutchr`rrnbh`shmfsgdsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd-Ntqmdwsqtkdhr
sgdenkknvhmf9
+ # # ¶ V +
+SM +verb
/ +fut
+ H # H ¶ T +
+ # # ¶
+SM +verb
/ +fut
+ L # H ¶
Sghrqtkdnmkx`ookhdrsnGsnmdrtaidbsl`qjdq'RL(bnmbnqcsnmdrhm
etstqdsdmrdbnmrsqtbshnmr-Sgdqtkdg`rsvno`qsr+cdodmchmftonmsgd
m`stqdnesgdk`rssnmd`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfrxkk`akd
'#(-Hesgdk`rs`rrnbh`sdcsnmdnesgdoqdbdchmfrxkk`akdhr`Gsnmd+sgdG
snmdsnm`klnqogdldhr`rrnbh`sdcsnsg`srxkk`akdnmhsrkdesvhsgnts
329
chr`rrnbh`shmfsgdGsnmd`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd+`mcsgdmdvkx
`rrnbh`sdcGsnmdhr`krnlnudcsnsgdqhfgs`mchmrdqsdcinsidesgdudqa
qnnslnqogdld'U(-Sghrqtkdnmkxl`jdrrdmrdvgdmhshrqdb`kkdcsg`shs
eddcrsgdk`sdhqqd`khrlncdqtkdvghbgvhkkmnvhmrdqs`onk`qsnmd
betweensgdsvnGsnmdr`rrnbh`sdcvhsgsgdr`ldrxkk`akd'#(-Hesgdk`rs
`rrnbh`sdcsnmdnesgdoqdbdchmfrxkk`akdhr`Ksnmd+sgdGsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldcqnorntsbnlokdsdkx+`rhmsgdrdbnmco`qsnesgdoqdbdchmf
qtkd-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
+ ¶ + V +
+SM +T +verb
/ -past +perf
-fut -neg
+ Ø ¶ -[T + [T +
Sghrqtkd`ccr`Ksnmdsnm`klnqogdldenqsgdrtaidbsl`qjdq'RL(
hmonrhshudO/bnmrsqtbshnmrand`rrnbh`sdrsg`ssnmd`bqnrrsgd
hmsdqudmhmfonk`qqd`khrsnmd',√S(snsgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akd'U(vhsgnts
chr`rrnbh`shmfsgdudqaqnnssnmd'√S(`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd-Ntqmdws
qtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
330
Marker Rule:
+ # + ¶ + V +
+SM +T +verb
/ -past +real
-fut -perf
+ T + Ø ¶ -[T + [T + -prog
Sghrqtkd`ccr`Ksnmdrtaidbsl`qjdqhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfsgd
udqa'U(and`rrnbh`sdrsghrsnmda`bjsnsgdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmf
rxkk`akd'#(vhsgntschr`rrnbh`shmf`mxsnmdr`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd-Sgd
qtkdhrsqhffdqdcnmkxaxbnmrsqtbshnmrvghbg`qdl`qjdcenqydqnsdmrd
`mcqd`khrlncdvhsgansghlodqedbshud`mcmnm,oqnfqdrrhud`rodbsr-Ntq
mdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
+ ¶ V +
+SM +T +verb
/ -past -real
-fut -perf
+ Ø ¶ T + -prog
331
Sghrqtkd`ccr`Ksnmdrtaidbsl`qjdqhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfsgd
udqa'U(and`rrnbh`sdrsghrsnmdsnsgdudqaqnnsrxkk`akd'U(vhsgnts
chr`rrnbh`shmf`mxsnmdr`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd-Sgdqtkdhrsqhffdqdc
nmkxaxbnmrsqtbshnmrvghbg`qdl`qjdcenqydqnsdmrd`mchqqd`khrlncd
vhsgansghlodqedbshud`mcmnm,oqnfqdrrhud`rodbsr-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgd
enkknvhmf9
Marker Rule:
+ # + ¶
+SM +T +verb
/ -past -real
-fut -perf
+ T + Ø ¶ +prog
Sghrqtkd`ccr`Gsnmdrtaidbsl`qjdqhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfsgd
udqa'U(and`rrnbh`sdrsghrsnmda`bjsnsgdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmf
rxkk`akd'#(vhsgntschr`rrnbh`shmf`mxsnmdr`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcsgdqd-Sgd
qtkdhrsqhffdqdcnmkxaxbnmrsqtbshnmrvghbg`qdl`qjdcenqydqnsdmrd
`mchqqd`khrlncdvhsgansghlodqedbshud`mcoqnfqdrrhud`rodbsr-Ntq
mdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
332
+NCP +ONP
# e(n-) # / +NR
+C3
+C8
+C9
# L # +C10
Sghrqtkdcdkdsdrsgdrxkk`ahbrs`strne`mxmntmbk`rroqdehw'MBO(
vgdmhshlldch`sdkxoqdbdcdr`mxmntmqnns'MQ(vghbghr`mnaidbs`mc
eqnldhsgdqmntmbk`rr2+7+8nq0/'`kkvhsg`mnoshnm`k!d!unvdkhmsgd
oqdehw(-Sgd`rrnbh`shnmkhmdeqnlsgdcdkdsdcunvdksnsgdKsnmdhr
`tsnl`shb`kkxcdkdsdc`rvdkk`rsgdqdl`hmhmfm`r`kbnmrnm`mscndrmns
g`udrxkk`ahbrs`str-
Vd`qdmnvqd`cxsnenql`khydsgnrdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdrvghbg
mustadnqcdqdc`esdqsgdqdftk`qsnmdqtkdrg`udnodq`sdc-Sgdqd`qdnmkx
ehudqtkdrvghbgltrsadrnnqcdqdc-Vdrs`sdehqrssgdk`sdunvdk
`rrhlhk`shnmqtkd+`radknv9
333
(576) Vowel Assimilation Rule:
# CDC D ¶ a(n-) +
[+verb] +NCP +ONP
/ +NR
+C1
# T ¶ T + +C7
Sghrqtkdhrnmkxrs`sdchmhsrlnrsrodbhehbenqlhmnqcdqsng`mckdsgd
unvdk`mcsnmdbg`mfdroqdrdmsdchmsghrchrrdqs`shnm-Hshrghfgkx
oqna`akdsg`srgntkcnmdl`jd`mdwg`trshudrstcxneunvdk`rrhlhk`shnm
hmMfxdla——m+`mxvnqchmhsh`kunvdkvntkc`rrhlhk`sdsnsgdunvdk
pt`khsxnesgdehm`kunvdknesgdoqdbdchmfvnqc+oqna`akx`bbnlo`mhdc
axsgdsnmdbg`mfdrrgnvm`anud-
Sghrqtkdsgtrrs`sdrsg`svgdmdudqsgdunvdk!`!hrsgdmntmbk`rr
oqdehw'MBO(ne`mnaidbsmntmogq`rd'NMO(+hshrchr`rrnbh`sdceqnl
sgnrdsnmdr`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcvhsghs+hshrlnudcsnsgddmcnesgd
hlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfvnqc+hshr`rrhlhk`sdcsnsgdunvdkpt`khsx'—(ne
sgdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfrxkk`akd'B—B(`mcehm`kkx+sghrmdvunvdkhr
qd`rrnbh`sdcsnsgdehm`k`rrnbh`sdcsnmdnesg`sr`ldrxkk`akd-
Ntqmdwslnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdqdok`bdrsgdcdqhudcsnmdrnm
rodbhehbo`rshlodqedbshudbnmrsqtbshnmrvghbgrtbddcrhmmdtsq`khyhmfsgd
mnql`ksnm`kbnmsq`rsadsvddmG`mcKsnmdudqaqnnsrvghkdbnqqdbskx
eddchmfsgdk`sdcnvmrsdo`citrsldmsqtkd+`radknv9
334
'466(O2.O1Mnm,oqnfqdrrhudHlodqedbshudQtkd9
# + V #
+T +verb
/ +past x -perf
[rem -prog
# -[T + [T # [near
H L
Sghrqtkdbg`mfdrsgdonk`qqd`khrsnmd',√S(sn`Gsnmd`mcsgdudqa
qnnssnmd'√S(sn`KsnmdhmO1nqO2bnmrsqtbshnmr'l`qjdcaxZ√qdl\
`mcZ√md`q\ed`stqdbnlahm`shnmr(vgdmdudqsgdx`qd`krnl`qjdcenq
hlodqedbshud`mcmnm,oqnfqdrrhud`rodbsr-
Vdb`mmnvdw`lhmdntqentqehm`klnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdr+sgd
deedbsned`bgadhmfsnhmrdqsekn`shmfsnmdsnm`klnqogdldrvgdqdsgdx
vhkkbnqqdbskxsqhffdqsgdcnvmrsdoqtkdr'vghbg`qdsgdnmkxsnmdqtkdrsn
enkknvsgdrdk`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdr(-Sgdehqrsnesgdrdqtkdrhrsgd
enkknvhmf9
¶ + +verb
-past +OM
/ -fut [[T]
+perf
¶ (T) + -neg
-[T
335
Sghrqtkd`ccrnqbg`mfdrsgdnaidbsl`qjdqsnm`klnqogdldsn`onk`q
snmd',√S(vghbghrnoonrhsdsgdehqrs`rrnbh`sdcsnmd'√S(entmcnmhsr
qhfgs-Sgdqtkdhrnmkxsqhffdqdcaxbnmrsqtbshnmrvghbg`qdl`qjdcenq
ydqnsdmrd+odqedbshud`rodbs`mconrhshudonk`qhsx-Hs`kv`xreddcrsgdk`sd
cnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgenkknvr-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
+ N + # P +
+SM +T +verb
/ -past -real
-fut -perf
+ L + Ø # L + +prog
+neg
+ # ¶ # P +
+SM +T +verb
/ -past -real
-fut -perf
+ T ¶ Ø # L + +prog
-neg
Sghrqtkd`ccr`Gsnmdsnm`klnqogdldhlldch`sdkxadenqdsgd
oqnfqdrrhudl`qjdq'O(hmbnmrsqtbshnmrl`qjdcenqydqnsdmrd+hqqd`khr
336
lncd+`mcoqnfqdrrhud`mchlodqedbshud`rodbsr-SghrGsnmdsnm`k
lnqogdldcndrmns`rrnbh`sdsn`mxrxkk`akdvgdmsgdoqdbdchmfrxkk`akd
hr`mdf`shudl`qjdq+atscndr`rrnbh`sdsnsgdhlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmf
rxkk`akdvgdm`mdf`shudl`qjdqhrmnsoqdrdms+`rhmsgdrdbnmco`qsne
sgdoqdbdchmfqtkd-Ntqmdwsqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
# + V + ¶ + # +
+verb
/ -real
# Ø + [T + Ø ¶ (T) + ਫS*
-[T -ਫT Ø
Sghrqtkdhmrdqsrsvnekn`shmfonk`qsnmdrvgnrdsnmdpt`khsxhr
cdsdqlhmdcaxsgdhlldch`sdkxenkknvhmf`rrnbh`sdcsnmd-Sgtrsgdehqrs
onk`qsnmd',√S(hrhmrdqsdchlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmfsgdudqarsdl'U(`mc
hsrsnmdhrnoonrhsdsnsg`svghbghr`kqd`cx`rrnbh`sdcvhsgsgdrsdl'√S(-
Sgdrdbnmconk`qsnmd',ਫS(hrhmrdqsdchlldch`sdkxenkknvhmfsgdudqa
rsdl`mchsrsnmdhrnoonrhsdsnsgdnmd'ਫS(vghbghr`rrnbh`sdcvhsgsgd
hlldch`sdkxenkknvhmfrxkk`akd'#(-He`ekn`shmfsnmdsnm`klnqogdld'S(
rgntkcnbbtqadsvddm`onk`qsnmd`mchsrenkknvhmf`rrnbh`sdcsnmd
cdsdqlhmdq+hshrcdkdsdcaxsghrqtkd-Sgddeedbsnesghrqtkdhrsneddcsgd
337
enkknvhmfcnvmrsdoqtkd`mcsgtralwaysg`ud`rtqe`bdcnvmrsdo
hlldch`sdkxoqdbdchmf`mchlldch`sdkxenkknvhmfsgdudqarsdlhm`mx
bnmrsqtbshnmvghbghrl`qjdcenqhqqd`khrlncd-Ntqehm`klnqogn,
snmnknfhb`kqtkdhrsgdenkknvhmf9
Polarization Rule:
+ # + +RP
(L) H (L) L +T
+past
-rem
+near
Ø -[T
Sghrqtkdqduhrdrsgdsnmdrenqntqqd`khroqnfqdrrhud`mcO0l`qjdqr
axbnmudqshmfsgdehm`kassociated L tonenesgdl`qjdqhmsn`
adenqdsghrmdvkxchr`rrnbh`sdcsnmd-Sghrqtkd`ookhdrnebntqrdnmkxsn
sgnrdrsqtbstqdrvgdqddhsgdqnesgdrdsvnl`qjdqrhrentmc-
Sghrbnmbktcdrntqchrbtrrhnmnesgdlnqognknfhb`k`mclnqogn,
snmnknfhb`kqtkdrmdbdrr`qxenqsgdc`s`oqdrdmsdc`mc`m`kxydchmsghr
chrrdqs`shnm-
338
CHAPTER 5
4-/-Bnmbktrhnm
Hmsghrchrrdqs`shnm+vdg`uddw`lhmdcsgdlnqognknfhb`k+snmnknfhb`k
'bnmchshnmdcaxotqdkxognmnknfhb`kbqhsdqh`(+`mclnqogn,snmnknfhb`k
'snm`kqtkdrbnmchshnmdcaxfq`ll`shb`kbqhsdqh`(qtkdr-Vdg`ud
enql`khydcd`bgqtkdmdbdrr`qxenqsgdc`s`oqdrdmsdc`mcg`udenbtrdcnm
sgdnqcdqhmfneqtkd`ookhb`shnm`rvdkk`rsgdhmsdq`bshnmadsvddmsgd
cheedqdmsjhmcrneqtkdr-Mns`akdhmsghrqdrodbsv`rsgdmddcsnonrhs`
edvlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdrvghbg`bst`kkxenkknvdcsgdl`hmancxne
snmdqtkdr-Sgdqdrtkshmfnqcdqhmfb`madrtll`qhydc`radknv9
4. Tone rules
6. Downstep rules
339
Sgda`rhbenbtrnesghrchrrdqs`shnmg`raddmsncdsdqlhmdsgdmtladq
`mcbnlokdwhsxneqtkdrmdbdrr`qxsng`mckdsgdk`qfdrs`lntmsne
Mfxdla——mc`s`onrrhakd-Vdehqrscdudknodc`a`rhbrdsnesnmdqtkdr
a`rdcnmchrxkk`ahbmntmrhmhrnk`shnm`mchm`rrnbh`shudmntmogq`rdr-
Sgdrda`rhbsnmdqtkdrvdqdenql`khydc`bbnqchmfsnbnmudmshnmr
cdudknodcenq`tsnrdfldms`kognmnknfxaxFnkcrlhsg'0865(-@m
hlonqs`ms`m`kxshb`k`cu`ms`fdv`rf`hmdcax`cnoshmfsgdhcd`ne`snm`k
lds`sgdrhrqtkdeqnlRsdv`qs'0870(`mcOtkkxak`mj'0871(-Sghrkdchm
stqmsnonrhshmf`cnvmrsdoqtkdvghbgcdodmcdcnmekn`shmf
'tm`rrnbh`sdc(snmdrneonk`qpt`khsx-
Nmbdvdg`ccdudknodc`a`rhbbnqdnesnm`kqtkdr`mcbnmudmshnmrnm
sgda`rhrnemntmogq`rdr+vd`ssdlosdcsndwo`mc`mcqduhrdsgdl`r
khsskd`ronrrhakd`rvddw`lhmdc`k`qfdancxnec`s`eqnlsgdhmchb`shud
lnnc-Sgntfg`qdehmdldmsr`mcqdrsqhbshnmrg`csnadonrhsdc+sgdl`hm
`cchshnmqdrtksdceqnlsgdmddcsnonrhsrdudq`klnqognknfhb`k`mc
lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdrvghbg`ccdcsnmdrnqrkhfgskxqduhrdcsgdsnm`k
cdqhu`shnmhmnqcdqsn`ss`hmsgdbnqqdbsrtqe`bdognmdshbqd`khy`shnmr-
Mnsdvnqsgx`lnmfsgdrd`cchshnmrv`rsg`so`qsnesgd!Vdkk,enqldcmdrr
Bnmchshnm!onrhsdcaxFnkcrlhsg`mcqduhrdcaxBkdldmsr`mcEnqc+v`r
l`cdhmsn`mnql`kkdes,sn,qhfgssnmdqtkdhmntq`m`kxrhr-K`sdq+hmnqcdq
sncdqhudsgdmtldqntrcnvmrsdorenqhqqd`khrudqabnmrsqtbshnmr+vd
onrhsdc`k`sdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdvghbghmrdqsdconk`qekn`shmfsnmdr
340
itrshmshldsnsqhffdqntqcnvmrsdoqtkdr`ssgdqhfgsok`bd-Vd`krnvdms
nmsnonrhsrtaidbs`mcnaidbsl`qjdqsnm`klnqogdldrhmnqcdqsng`mckd
sgdsnmdbg`mfdrvghbgnbbtqadsvddmrtaidbs+udqa`mcnaidbs-
Sgdehm`kqdrtksne`kksghrv`rsg`svdonrhsdcnmkxrdudmsnmdqtkdrhm
`cchshnmsnsgdd`qkxsnmdl`oohmfqtkd`mcsgdk`sdcnvmrsdoqtkd+sn
`bghdudsgdcdrhqdcqdrtksr-Sgdrdqtkdr`qdsgdenkknvhmf9
No. 3’ : Metathesis
No. 4 : Rise-Formation
No. 6’ : Rise-Deletion
Sgdrdsnmdqtkdrvdqdenqltk`sdchmrtbg`v`xsg`ssgdx`qdmns
qhfhckxnqcdqdcvhsgqdrodbssnd`bgnsgdq-Hmrsd`c+vdonrhsdc`oqhmbhokd
neknb`knqcdqhmfvgdqd`mxqtkdhrodqlhssdcsnnodq`sd`rhsrrsqtbstq`k
bnmchshnmr`qdlds`rnmdoqnbddcr`knmfsgdsnm`kshdqeqnlkdessnqhfgs-
341
Sghrfdmdq`koqhmbhokdneknb`kqtkdnqcdqhmf`kv`xrf`udtrsgdcdrhqdc
qdrtkshmd`bgrodbhehbcdqhu`shnm-
Sgdcnvmrsdoqtkdvdonrhsdcknvdqrsgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqnmdmnsbgenq
d`bgekn`shmfonk`qsnmdsg`shlldch`sdkxoqdbddcr`m`rrnbh`sdcsnmdne
noonrhsdbg`q`bsdq-Sgdonrhshmfne`ekn`shmfKsnmdadenqd`m`rrnbh`sdc
Gsnmdg`rknmfaddmqdf`qcdcaxkhmfthrsr`rsgdtmcdqkxhmfdwok`m`shnm
enqsgdnbbtqqdmbdnecnvmrsdoodcGsnmdr-Sgdcdqhu`shnmne
cnvmrsdoodcKsnmdr+gnvdudq+hrltbglnqdoqnakdl`shbctdsnsgd
dwsqdldkxrl`kkmtladqnek`mft`fdrvghbgdwghahssghrogdmnldmnm-
VghkdOtkkxak`mj'087293(g`ronrhsdcsg`scnvmrsdoodcKsnmdrbnld
nmkxeqnlfloating L tonesadenqd`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdr+vdg`ud
onrhsdcsg`scnvmrsdoodcKsnmdrbnldeqnlfloating H tonesadenqd
`rrnbh`sdcKsnmdr-Sghroqnonr`krddlrltbglnqdhmjddohmfvhsgntq
mntmogq`rdsnmdodqstqa`shnmr`mcg`raddmdpt`kkxdwok`m`snqxhmntq
dw`lhm`shnmneudqaogq`rdogdmnldm`-
@rhm`kkk`mft`fdrvghbgg`udognmnknfhb`kcnvmrsdo+cnvmrsdorhm
Mfxdla——mvdqdentmcsnadansgbtltk`shud`mcodqrdudq`shud-Sghr
qdedqrsnsgdrtbbdrrhudknvdqhmfnesgdsnm`kqdfhrsdqvhsghmsgdsnm`k
ogq`rd`mcsnsgdl`hms`hmhmfnesgdknvdqdcqdfhrsdqtmshksgdrod`jdq
qd`bgdr`o`trd-Sgdqdrtkshrsg`shshrpthsdrhlokdsnbnmrsqtbs`ogq`rd
vgdqdsgdGsnmd`ssgddmchrqd`khydcognmdshb`kkxnm`lowerohsbgsg`m
`Ksnmd`ssgdadfhmmhmf-Vghkdsghrbg`q`bsdqhrshbhrmnsnesdmentmc+hs
342
rddlrdrodbh`kkx`ooqnoqh`sdhmk`mft`fdrkhjdMfxdla——mvgdqd
ognmnknfhb`kcnvmrsdonbbtqrhmsgd`ardmbdneognmdshbcnvmcqhes-
Dwsdmchmfsgdc`s`eqnlsgdmnql`k`rrnbh`shudmntmogq`rdl`sdqh`k
trt`kkx`m`kxydchmFq`rrehdkcrA`mstk`mft`fdrsnhmbktcd`k`qfdonqshnm
nehmchb`shudlnncbnmrsqtbshnmrg`rmdbdrrhs`sdcedvbg`mfdrsnntq
a`rhbsnmdqtkdratsg`rmdbdrrhs`sdcsgdenql`shnmne`mtladqne
lnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdr-Rhmbdl`mxnesgdrdlnqogn,snmnknfhb`kqtkdr
onrhssg`su`qhntrfq`ll`shb`ked`stqdr`qdqd`khydc`rsnm`klnqogdldr+
rhlhk`qdw`lhm`shnmrnesgdrdogdmnldm`hmnsgdqqdk`sdck`mft`fdrbntkc
dudmst`kkxkd`csnsgdqdbnmrsqtbshnmneu`qhntrfq`ll`shb`klnqogdldr
`knmfvhsgsgdqdk`sdcghrsnqhb`koqnbdrrdrvghbgqdrtksdchmsnc`x&rq`sgdq
no`ptdsnm`ko`q`chflr-
343
REFERENCES
Anderson, Stephen C. 1976. ms. "A Phonology of NgyembDDn-
Bamileke," S.I.L., Yaounde, Cameroon.
Clements, George and Ford, Kevin. 1979. "Kikuyu Tone Shift and
its Synchronic Consequences," in Linguistic Inquiry, Volume
10, Number 2, Cambridge, M.I.T., pp. 179-210.
344
Gilligan, Gary. 1982. ms. "Autosegmental Babanki," U.S.C., Los
Angeles.
345
Ngangoum, F.B. 1970. Le Bamileke des Fefe: Grammaire
Descriptive Usuelle, Abbaye Sainte-Marie de la Pierre-qui-
Vivre, Saint-LeJger-Vauban, France.
346
APPENDIX A
Sghr`oodmchwfhudr`khrsnesgdehm`ksnmdqtkdrhmsgdhqqdrodbshud
fqntor`mcsgdmqdrs`sdrd`bgnesgdrdqtkdrhmhsr`tsnrdfldms`k
enql`khrl-Ehqrs+sgdkhrsnentqehm`kqtkdrhrsgdenkknvhmf9
Rule 3’ : Metathesis
Rule 4 : Rise-Formation
Rule 6’ : Rise-Deletion
347
Mnvsg`svdg`udrddmsgdkhrsnesgdu`qhntrsnmdqtkdr`mcsgdhq
nqcdqne`ookhb`shnm+vdvhkkfhudd`bgqtkdhmhsrenql`k`tsnrdfldms`k
enql`shmmtldqhb`knqcdq+`radknv9
#
L Ø Ø / //
H L
+B pitch
(-[T)B [T
##
L (H) H L
348
(588) Rule 4: Rise-Formation (see (420) above)
##
# L H #
(430) above)
# + +
T + L +
##
L (T) H / L
349
(591) Rule 7’: Rightward-docking H-tone Morphemes (see
(423) above)
+ + #
+ H + T
(#) + # +
(T) T + +
350
APPENDIX B
Sghr`oodmchwvhkketqsgdqrodbhexsgdl`hmbg`qs'rdd71+056`mc320
`anud(vghbgg`raddmtrdcsnrtll`qhyd`kksgdsnmdbg`mfdrnmsgdudqa
qnns-Adenqdqdu`lohmfsghrbg`qs+hshrrgnvm`f`hmadknv9
Features P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø F1 F2 F3 F4
-perf
+real x/R x/x x/x R/R R/R
-prog
-perf
+real R/R R/R R/R R/R x/R
+prog
-perf
-real x/I I/I I/I I/I I/I
-prog
-perf
-real I/I I/I I/I I/I I/I
+prog
Hmnqcdqsnrodbhexsgd`bst`krtqe`bdsnmdrenqd`bgG`mcKsnmdudqa
qnnsenqd`bgnesgdrxlankrhmsgdoqdbdchmfbg`qs+vdvhkkg`udsnchuhcd
351
sgdbg`qshmsnsvnbg`qsr+nmdenqonrhshudbnmrsqtbshnmr`mc`rdbnmcenq
mdf`shud-Sgtrhmsgdenkknvhmfsvnbg`qsr+sgdrxlankoqdbdchmfsgdrk`rg
l`qjhmchb`sdrsgdrtqe`bdsnmdne`mtmcdqkxhmfGsnmdudqaqnnsvghkd
sgdrxlankenkknvhmfsgdrk`rgl`qjhmchb`sdrsgdrtqe`bdsnmdne`m
tmcdqkxhmfKsnmdudqaqnns-Ntqehqrsbg`qsqdedqrsnonrhshud
bnmrsqtbshnmr+`radknv9
Features P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø F1 F2 F3 F4
-perf
+real dH/dL dL/dL dL/dL H/dH H/dH
-prog
-perf
+real H/dH H/dH H/dH H/dH dH/dL
+prog
-perf
-real dL/L dH/dL dH/dL dH/dL dH/dL
-prog
-perf
-real dH/dL dH/dL dH/dL dH/dL dH/dL
+prog
352
Sgdoqdbdchmfbg`qsrgnvdcsgdrtqe`bdudqasnmdrenq`kksgdonrhshud
bnmrsqtbshnmr-Sgdenkknvhmfbg`qsrgnvrsgdrtqe`bdudqasnmdrenq`kk
sgdhqqdrodbshudmdf`shudbntmsdqo`qsr9
Features P4 P3 P2 P1 Ø F1 F2 F3 F4
-perf
+real H/dH dL/dL dL/dL H/dH H/dH
-prog
-perf
+real H/dH H/dH H/dH H/dH H/dH
+prog
-perf
-real dH/dL dH/dL dH/dL dH/dL dH/dL
-prog
-perf
-real dH/dL dH/dL dH/dL dH/dL dH/dL
+prog
353