Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Maleic Acid
Maleic Acid
Maleic Acid
www.elsevier.com/locate/ces
Abstract
The hydrogenation of maleic acid was investigated using a bimetallic Ru–Re/C catalyst powder in a semi-batch stirred slurry reactor
with the main objective of developing a kinetic model that would provide reliable predictions of the observed reactant and product
distributions and selectivities. The combined e2ects of hydrogen pressure, catalyst loading and initial maleic acid (MAC) concentration
on the concentration vs. time pro4les were studied over the temperature range of 523–543 K. The direct hydrogenation of aqueous MAC
solutions with the Ru–Re/C catalyst powder showed that succinic acid (SAC), -butyrolactone (GBL) and tetrahydrofuran (THF) were
the major products while n-butanol (BuOH), methane and propane were the principal side products. The selectivities of GBL and THF
were found to be strongly dependent on the initial MAC concentration, H2 pressure, catalyst powder loading and reaction temperature.
Kinetic rate equations for the key steps in the reaction sequence were developed using the observed concentration vs. time pro4les as the
starting basis and the kinetic parameters were estimated using non-linear parameter estimation. The predictions of the semi batch slurry
reactor model were found to agree reasonably well with the experimental data. The kinetic data showed a strong substrate inhibition e2ect
for the consecutive reactions sequence with the extent of inhibition decreasing in the order of MAC ¿ SAC ¿ GBL. This observation
suggests that a high space-time yield to THF can be obtained in a slurry reactor with signi4cant liquid phase backmixing by the use of
elevated temperature and pressure and long slurry residence time. Implications for commercial implementation are also suggested.
? 2003 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Hydrogenation; Slurry reactor; Kinetics; Maleic acid; Ru–Re/C catalyst; Tetrahydrofuran
0009-2509/03/$ - see front matter ? 2003 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/S0009-2509(02)00588-2
628 R. V. Chaudhari et al. / Chemical Engineering Science 58 (2003) 627 – 632
MAC FAC carried out to study the product distribution and selectivity
behavior using the Ru–Re/C catalyst. The experiments were
performed using the semi-batch slurry reactor to observe
SAC concentration-time pro4les for a given set of initial condi-
tions. The e2ect of catalyst loading, H2 pressure, MAC con-
centration and temperature was investigated, the results of
PA GBL HBA which are discussed in the following sections.
BDO BuOH
PrOH MeOH 3.1. Preliminary experiments
THF Butane
Propane In order to obtain reliable kinetic parameter estima-
Methane tion, it is important to ensure that all the key products are
FAC Fumaricacid; PA Propionic acid, HBA Hydroxybutyraldehyde identi4ed. Also, the material balance based upon reactants
consumed and products formed should be satis4ed within
Fig. 2. Reaction pathway for hydrogenation of maleic anhydride. reasonable error limits for an assumed stoichiometry. Fi-
nally, to achieve consistent catalyst performance for the
(ca:50 rpm). After the desired temperature was attained, the kinetic study, the preactivation procedure had to be stan-
autoclave was quickly pressurized to the requisite pressure dardized. This was particularly important for Ru–Re/C
with H2 and the reaction was started by adjusting the ag- catalyst system since initial performance tests indicated that
itation speed to 900 rpm. The cumulative H2 consumption in-situ activation of the catalyst by treatment with H2 in a
was determined from the decrease in the hydrogen pressure batch slurry mode at 573 K and 13 MPa did not lead to re-
in the reservoir vessel as a function of time. The liquid sam- producible concentration vs time data. This procedure also
ples were withdrawn at speci4c time intervals and analyzed had a disadvantage since the preactivation was required be-
(see below) to determine the reactant and product concen- fore each kinetic run, which also led to inconsistent results.
trations. At the end of the reaction, the autoclave was cooled In another modi4ed procedure, the aqueous slurry of the
to room temperature and a gas sample was withdrawn for catalyst was pretreated with H2 at 523 K and 13 MPa for
analysis of the 4nal gas phase products. This gas phase anal- 1 h. The resulting activated catalyst was 4ltered, dried and
ysis was essential to ensure that the cracking of the products stored in dry conditions. This procedure was found to give
to hydrocarbons was negligible. Following this procedure, a catalyst, which produced consistent concentration vs time
the contents in the reactor were discharged and the liquid data. It was also noted that the catalyst did not deteriorate
samples analyzed for reactant and products. on storage since the activity of the catalyst was retained
even after a few weeks. The catalyst treated in this fashion
was used further for all studies.
2.4. Analysis
Catalytic hydrogenation of MAC is a complex multistep
reaction so that determining the reaction scheme for a spe-
The analysis of the reactants and products was performed
ci4c catalyst system is necessary. Among the numerous re-
using both high-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC
actions possible, the isomerisation of MAC to fumaric acid
model HP 1050) and gas-liquid chromatography (GLC, HP
[FAC] is a non-catalytic reaction. Under reaction conditions
5840). Both MAC and SAC were analyzed by HPLC us-
isomerisation of MAC to FAC was observed, but no iso-
ing a lichrospher RP-18 column, with an overall length of
merisation was observed when FAC hydrogenation was in-
250 mm. HPLC grade water was used as the mobile phase
vestigated. Since, the rates of hydrogenation of both MAC
at a Now rate of 1 ml=min. The HPLC detector wavelength
and FAC to SAC were similar, the isomerisation of MAC
was set at = 206 cm−1 for SAC and 254 cm−1 for MAC.
to FAC was not considered in the kinetic analysis.
Other reaction products such as GBL, THF and n-BuOH
were analyzed on GLC on a 1=4 × 6 column packed with
80/100 mesh of 5%PEG 1500 on Chromosorb W-AW using 3.2. Product distributions and selectivity
a N2 carrier gas Now rate of 20 ml/min. The column was
temperature programmed from 60◦ C to 140◦ C at the rate A typical concentration pro4le observed in hydrogenation
of 45◦ C=min. of aqueous MAC is shown in Fig. 3. The principal products
formed were: succinic acid (SAC), -butyrolactone (GBL),
tetrahydrofuran (THF) and n-butanol (BuOH). These reac-
3. Results and discussions tion species accounted for more than 92% of the material
balance. Fumaric acid, butanediol and other products were
Hydrogenation of maleic acid proceeds through a series not observed with Ru–Re/C catalyst during hydrogenation.
of consecutive and parallel reactions as represented by the Under certain extreme conditions (e.g., initial concentration
reaction scheme shown in Fig. 2. Initial experiments were of MAC = 3:45 kmol=m3 , catalyst loading = 2 × 102 kg=m3
630 R. V. Chaudhari et al. / Chemical Engineering Science 58 (2003) 627 – 632
1.0 1.0 80
3
Concentration of Reactants / Products kmol/m
Predicted
70
GBL - 543K
MAC THF - 543K
0.8 SAC 0.8
GBL 60 GBL - 523K
THF THF - 523K
BuOH
Selectivity %
50
0.6 0.6
40
0.4 0.4 30
20
0.2 0.2
10
0.0 0.0
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 0 100 200 300 400 500 600
Time, min Time, min
Fig. 3. Concentration Time Pro4le for hydrogenation of MAC us- Fig. 5. Plot of selectivity as a function of time; E2ect of temperature. Re-
ing Ru–Re/C catalyst. Reaction conditions: temperature = 523 K; total action conditions: temperature=523 K; total pressure=13:91 MPa; MAC
pressure = 13:91 MPa; MAC concentration = 0:862 kmol=m3 ; catalyst concentration = 0:862 kmol=m3 ; liquid phase volume = 100 × 10−6 m3 .
loading = 50 kg=m3 ; liquid phase volume = 100 × 10−6 m3 .
The mass balance equations for the various reactant/product 1.0 1.0
3
Concentration of reactants / products,kmol/m
species in a semi-batch slurry reactor are given below: Predicted
MAC
dt THF
BuOH
0.6 0.6
dC2 r2
= r1 − ; (6)
dt 2 0.4 0.4
dC3 (r2 − r3 )
= ; (7)
dt 2 0.2 0.2
dC4 r3
= − r4 ; (8)
dt 2
0.0 0.0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600
Time, min
dC5
= r4 ; (9) Fig. 6. Concentration time pro4le for hydrogenation of MAC using
dt
Ru–Re/C catalyst. Reaction conditions: temperature = 503 K; total
pressure = 13:91 MPa; MAC concentration = 0:862 kmol=m3 ;
with initial conditions : t = 0; C1 = C0 ; C2 to C5 = 0: catalyst loading = 50 kg=m3 ; liquid phase volume = 100 × 10−6 m3 .
(10)
Table 1
Rate Parameters for Hydrogenation of MAC