Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hartley 2000
Hartley 2000
REVIEW
Paediatric airway stenosis: laryngotracheal reconstruction
or cricotracheal resection?
B.E.J. HARTLEY & R.T. COTTON
The Children's Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, OH, USA
Aetiology and incidence of laryngotracheal ment of the neonatal airway on intensive care units and the
stenosis incidence of subglottic stenosis has decreased. Figures of
1%ÿ8% are often quoted3,4 but if the very low birth weight
The introduction of prolonged endotracheal intubation for
infants (< 1.5 kg) are excluded the incidence is < 1%.5
premature neonates with immature lungs in the 1960s
caused a dramatic rise in the incidence of paediatric subglot- This reduction has been achieved by a number of measures.
tic stenosis. McDonald and Stocks1 reported a 20% tra- The replacement of red rubber endotracheal tubes with
cheostomy rate following prolonged intubation in 1965 and polyvinylchloride tubes made a large impact. The length of
Fearon et al.2 reported a 24% rate the following year. Since time of intubation is important but is only one factor. The
that time many advances have been made in the manage- use of too large a tube quickly leads to ischaemia ulceration
and subsequent stenosis. Poor ®xation of the tube is likely
Correspondence: Benjamin E.J. Hartley, The Royal National
Throat, Nose and Ear Hospital, Gray's Inn Road, London WC1X
to increase the subglottic trauma and the chance of stenosis.
8DA, UK. Nasotracheal intubation is preferred to orotracheal intuba-
tion as the tube is more securely ®xed and less likely to Early adult procedures for laryngotracheal
cause trauma to the subglottis. stenosis
Acquired subglottic stenosis due to endotracheal intuba-
In 1938 Negus8 described the technique of laryngo®ssure
tion is the predominant cause of subglottic stenosis that
and dermal grafting for scar tissue formation in adults. Sub-
requires surgery. Congenital subglottic stenosis is the second
glottic stenosis at that time was principally due to high tra-
commonest congenital laryngeal anomaly after laryngoma-
cheostomies performed as emergency procedures for
lacia.6 The diagnosis is suspected when subglottic stenosis is
in¯ammatory disease, principally diphtheria. In 1953 Rethi9
diagnosed in a child who has not been previously intubated
in Budapest reported splitting the cricoid ring anteriorly
and the cricoid is an abnormal shape, often elliptical.
and posteriorly for cicatrical stenosis of the larynx in adults.
In¯ammatory diseases such as Wegeners granulomatosis
A long-term rubber stent was left in for several months
may lead to subglottic stenosis although it is rare for this to
before the wound was closed. Rethi was working mainly
happen in children it may be seen in adolescents.
with adults who had sustained war injuries to the larynx.
Aboulker10 in 1966 introduced a stent which could be wired
into the tracheostomy tube and left in place for several
Classi®cation of subglottic stenosis months.
(Cincinnati, OH, USA). Ninety-three of these children The single stage laryngotracheal
(90%) had been decannulated. Sixty had been treated by reconstruction
laryngotracheoplasty and the remainder by costal cartilage
It became clear from the experience with the anterior cricoid
grafts or the modi®ed Rethi principle (cricoid split and
split that by using the endotracheal tube as a stent and as
stent). All these types of procedure were obtaining high suc-
an airway that laryngotracheal surgery could be performed
cess rates in terms of decannulation. The next step was the
without a tracheostomy. This development gave rise to the
introduction of cartilage grafts into the posterior cricoid
single stage laryngotracheal reconstruction.20,21 The tra-
lamina. This procedure also proved successful and a detailed
cheostomy was removed at the time of surgery and the
animal study demonstrated that posteriorly placed grafts
patient kept intubated for a period of up to 2 weeks post-
underwent signi®cantly less necrosis and absorption than
operatively. A recent review of 200 cases has demonstrated
anteriorly placed grafts.3 The combination of anterior and
an overall decannulation rate of 96%. This should be quali-
posterior grafts and even the addition of lateral cuts to form
®ed with the observation that 29% required re-intubation
the so-called four quadrant split15 meant that almost any
and 15% required a postoperative tracheostomy which was
subglottic stenosis could be managed surgically although
removed at a later stage in the majority of cases.22
not surprisingly surgery for the more severe stenosis was
less successful.16,17 High decannulation rates were being
achieved with a single procedure for grade 2 stenosis but Cricotracheal resection in children
lower rates for grades 3 and 4 and often multiple procedures
were being required. The logical approach to those children In adults resection of subglottic stenosis and end-to-end
with total stenosis was some form of resection of the steno- anastomosis was reported successfully by Conley in 1953.23
sis. Cricotracheal resection had become established in adults There was initial reluctance to introduce the procedure in
at this time but had not been applied to children. children based on concerns about the subglottic stenosis
commonly merging into the glottis or trachea3 and also con-
cerns about growth. In 1974 Gerwat and Bryce24 described
a modi®cation of Conley's operation performed on a 14-
year-old boy. Further descriptions of adult cricotracheal
Neonates with failed extubation: the anterior resection followed and it is now a well-established procedure
cricoid split procedure in the management of adult subglottic stenosis.25,26 The ®rst
Increasingly in the 1970s otolaryngologists were being series of successful cricotracheal resection in children was
involved in the neonatal care of children developing sub- published by Monnier in Switzerland in 199327 and this was
glottic stenosis. The principle management was to perform a followed by updates in 199828 and 1999.29 In this series 38
tracheostomy and wait and see if the subglottic stenosis children have been treated and 36 of these are without tra-
improved as the child grew. It was becoming clear that the cheostomy.
majority of children did not grow out of this problem and The early Cincinnati experience of 16 cases was published
also there was a signi®cant morbidity and mortality asso- in 1997, 15 of whom are without tracheostomy.30 In Cincin-
ciated with paediatric tracheostomy which could potentially nati we now have performed cricotracheal resection on 53
be avoided by laryngotracheal surgery. While giving a pre- children, 10 of whom are still with tracheostomy at the pre-
sentation at a paediatric ground rounds about subglottic sent time. Decannulation is anticipated in the majority of
stenosis a paediatrician suggested to Cotton that he split the these patients. Some important lessons have been learned
cricoid to facilitate extubation. It seemed the obvious solu- from this experience and these are discussed under operative
tion but was against current opinion at the time because technique.
splitting the cricoid during a high tracheostomy had been
the principle cause of subglottic stenosis for many years.
Indications for cricotracheal resection and
The operation was performed in 1977 and was successful.
laryngotracheal reconstruction in children
This patient is now 22 years old with a normal airway. In
1980, Cotton18 published the anterior cricoid split procedure In Cincinnati over 1000 paediatric laryngotracheal recon-
as an alternative to tracheostomy in the neonate who could structions have been performed and 53 cricotracheal resec-
not be successfully extubated. In 1988, 67 patients who had tions in children. Our practice is to perform cricotracheal
undergone this procedure were reported and 47 (70%) had resection on children who have severe laryngotracheal ste-
been successfully extubated.19 Currently this operation is nosis (severe grade 3 and grade 4) where there is an ade-
performed to avoid a tracheostomy in the majority of chil- quate margin of tissue between the stenosis and the vocal
dren with early subglottic stenosis who fail extubation and cords. At least 3 mm is recommended.31 It is the authors'
have no baseline oxygen requirement due to pulmonary dis- experience that stenosis involving or close to the vocal cords
ease. is preferably treated with laryngotracheal reconstruction
with cartilage grafts which can be placed higher than the incision is extended superiorly and inferiorly as required to
upper resection margin for CTR. identify the lumen and de®ne the stenotic area. In the case
LTR with cartilage graft placement remains the mainstay of grade 4 stenosis where no lumen is present a repeat endo-
of the surgical management of subglottic stenosis at this scopy is performed and then a small pair of artery forceps is
Institution for grade 2 and selected grade 3 stenosis. This is used to break through the stenosis into the laryngeal lumen.
a less extensive procedure than CTR as tracheal mobiliza- It is not usually necessary to divide the anterior commis-
tion is not required. In addition the placement of cartilage sure.
grafts has a precision that is not present with CTR. Anterior
stenosis can be accurately corrected with anterior grafts.
Similarly posterior stenosis can be accurately corrected with UPPER RESECTION MARGIN
posterior grafts and slit shaped lateral stenosis can be
widened with anterior and posterior grafts. The upper resection margin is then de®ned. The incision is
extended laterally along the lower border of the thyroid car-
tilage towards the cricothyroid joint. Anterior to the joint
Operative technique (and therefore clear of the recurrent laryngeal nerves) the
The operative technique for laryngotracheal reconstruction incision turns inferiorly and the cricoid cartilage is divide
has been well described32 and will not be described here. vertically on both sides. Posteriorly the incision is continued
Here we describe the technique for cricotracheal resection as along the inferior border of the cricoid lamina to complete
used by the authors. the upper resection margin. The resulting superior end com-
prises the thyroid cartilage anteriorly and the cricoid lamina
posteriorly. The two being joined by the cricothyroid joints.
PREPARATION The inner surface of the cricoid lamina is covered with the
Immediately before the procedure a repeat rigid endoscopy subglottic scar. This is excised leaving an edge of healthy
is performed to con®rm the exact nature and position of the mucosa superiorly below the arytenoids. Later the posterior
stenosis. An oesophageal bougie is inserted to help de®ne ¯ap of membranous trachea will be sutured to this. To
the position of the oesophagus during the later tracheal reduce the prominence of the cartilage posteriorly a drill is
mobilization. The neck is extended initially but when the used (4 mm cutting then diamond burr) to thin the cricoid
anastomosis is performed the neck is returned to the anato- lamina. The thyroid cartilage is split anteriorly in the mid-
mical position to reduce tension. Usually a tracheostomy is line. This will accept the V-shaped notch in the lower seg-
present and an oral RAE tube is cut short and placed in the ment when the anastomosis is formed (Figs 2 and 3).
stoma to allow ventilation. A large size is chosen to reduce
the intraoperative air leak once the airway is opened. If a
single stage procedure is planned then an oral endotracheal
tube is placed initially. Local anaesthetic with adrenaline is
in®ltrated into the area around the tracheostomy.
EXPOSURE
achieve decannulation and with enough time and a large imminent. Further surgery is planned on two of the others
enough number of procedures high decannulation rates can who remain cannulated and one patient was lost to follow-
be achieved in the majority of cohorts of children. up but is presumed to still be tracheostomy dependent.
Despite this, decannulation rates for patients with severe Although one might expect higher decannulation rates for
(grade 3 and 4 subglottic stenosis) remains a broad and grade 3 than grade 4 patients undergoing CTR, the grade 3
easily understandable measure of success. Furthermore in stenosis patients include a number of patients where the ste-
the published literature it is usually the only outcome mea- nosis was close to the vocal cords or who had partial laryn-
sure available. geal atresia and these have done less well.
There is so far no published comparison of LTR and
CTR in matched patients. It has been suggested that CTR is
better than LTR based on published decannulation rates in
Conclusions
dierent Institutions.29 Comparison of decannulation rates
in dierent Institutions in a retrospective manner may be A surgeon facing the problem of a child with subglottic ste-
misleading. The spectrum of disease at any given Institution nosis now has a wide range of surgical options. The proce-
will vary enormously dependent on referral pattern. In addi- dure must be tailored to the anatomy of the stenosis. Both
tion the indications for surgery and surgical technique will LTR and CTR have achieved high decannulation rates.
vary between Institutions. There is no published data comparing dierent surgical
techniques in matched patients. A retrospective review of
patients with grade 4 stenosis in this Institution suggests
GRADE 4 STENOSIS
that a similar proportion are decannulated with CTR and
In this institution airway reconstruction surgery has been LTR and the CTR patients are less likely to require a sec-
performed on 64 children with grade 4 stenosis.32 The surgi- ond open procedure to achieve decannulation. CTR is the
cal technique has evolved over three decades and a large preferred option for grade 4 and severe grade 3 stenosis that
number of the early patients were treated with division of are clear of the vocal cords. LTR as a less extensive proce-
the stenosis and stenting. The principle surgical options are dure is preferred for grade 2 and less severe grade 3 stenosis.
now between CTR and LTR with anterior and posterior Stenosis close to the vocal cords remains a challenge.
costal cartilage grafts. At the present time we have per-
formed CTR on 12 patients with grade 4 stenosis. Ten of
these have been decannulated (83%) and two have T-tubes References
in situ. One is likely to be decannulated within the next 6
months. Two patients required further open surgery to 1 MCDONALD I.H. & STOCKS J.G. (1965) Prolonged nasotra-
cheal intubation-a review of its development in a paediatric hos-
achieve decannulation (17%). LTR with anterior and pos-
pital. Br. J. Anaesthesia 37, 161±173
terior grafts has been performed on 16 patients patients 2 FEARON B., MCDONALD R.E., SMITH C. et al. (1966) Airway
with grade 4 stenosis, 13 of whom have been decannulated problems in children following prolonged endotracheal intuba-
(81%). Six patients (46%) required further surgery to obtain tion. Ann. Otol. Rhinol. Laryngol. 75, 975±986
this. Based on this retrospective data for patients with 3 COTTON R.T. (1991) The problem of paediatric laryngotracheal
stenosis: a clinical and experimental study on the ecacy of
matched stenosis grade at a single Institution at the current
autogenous cartilaginous grafts placed between the vertically
time the decannulation rates for grade 4 subglottic stenosis divided halves of the posterior lamina of the cricoid cartilage.
for CTR and LTR are equivalent, but the LTR patients are Laryngoscope 101 (Suppl.)
more likely to require a second open procedure to achieve 4 QUINEY R.E., SPENCER M.G., BAILEY C.M. et al. (1986)
decannulation. Management of subglottic stenosis: experience from two centers.
Arch. Dis Childhood 61, 686±690
5 RATNER I. & WHITFIELD J. (1983) Acquired subglottic stenosis
GRADE 3 STENOSIS in the very low birth weight infant. Am. J. Dis. Child 137, 40±43
6 HOLINGER L.D., LUSK R.P. & GREEN C.G. (1997). Paediatric
Grade 3 subglottic stenosis includes a wide range of Laryngology and Bronchoesophagology. Lippincott-Raven Pub-
patients. At one end of the spectrum some children with a lishers, Philadelphia
7 MYER C.M., O'CONNOR D.M. & COTTON R.T. (1994) Pro-
7% stenosis manage without a tracheostomy. Also included posed grading system for subglottic stenosis based on endotra-
in the category of grade 3 stenosis would be a child with cheal tube sizes. Ann. Otol. Rhinol. Laryngol. 103, 319±323
99% stenosis with a pinhole airway. The latter is clearly a 8 NEGUS V.E. (1938) Treatment of chronic stenosis of the larynx
greater surgical challenge. The decannulation rate for grade with special reference to skin grafting. Ann. Otol. Rhinol. Laryn-
3 stenosis treated with CTR after one procedure at this gol. 47, 891±901
9 RETHI A. (1953) An operation for cicatricial stenosis of the lar-
institution for patients with 1-year follow-up is 82% (28 of
ynx. J. Laryngol. Otol. 70, 283±296
34 patients).33 A second operation (anterior cartilage graft) 10 ABOULKER P. (1966) Modi®cations apportees a l'intervention
has been performed on one patient and decannulation is de Rethi. Ann. Otolaryngol. (Paris) 83, 98±901
11 GRAHNE B. (1981) Operative treatment of severe traumatic 24 GERWAT J. & BRYCE D.P. (1975) The management of subglot-
chronic laryngeal stenosis in infants up to 3 years old. Acta Oto- tic laryngeal stenosis by resection and direct anastomosis. Lar-
laryngol. (Stockh.) 72, 134±137 yngoscope 89, 940±957
12 FEARON B. & COTTON R.T. (1972) Surgical correction of sub- 25 PEARSON F.G., COOPER J.D., NELELMS J.M. et al. (1975) Pri-
glottic stenosis of the larynx, preliminary report of an experi- mary tracheal anastomosis after resection of the cricoid cartilage
mental surgical technique. Ann. Otol. Rhinol. Laryngol. 81, 508± with preservation of the recurrent laryngeal nerves. J. Thorac.
513 Cardiovasc. Surg. 70, 806±816
13 EVANS J.N.G. & TODD G.B. (1974) Laryngo-tracheoplasty. J. 26 GRILLO H.C., MATHIESON D.J. & WAYNE J.C. (1982) Laryn-
Laryngol. Otol. 88, 589±597 gotracheal resection and reconstruction for subglottic stenosis.
14 COTTON R.T. & EVANS J.N.G. (1981) Laryngotracheal recon- Ann. Thorac. Surg. 53, 54±63
struction in children: 5-year follow-up. Ann. Otol. 90, 516±520 27 MONNIER P., SAVARY M. & CHAPUIS G. (1993) Partial crico-
15 COTTON R.T., MORTELLITI A. & MYER C.M. (1992) Four tracheal resection with primary tracheal anastomosis for sub-
quadrant cricoid cartilage division in laryngotracheal recon- glottic stenosis in infants and children. Laryngoscope 103, 1273±
struction. Arch. Otolaryngol. Head Neck Surg. 118, 1023±1027 1283
16 COTTON R.T., GRAY S.D. & MILLER R.P. (1989) Update of 28 MONNIER P., LANG F. & SAVARY M. (1998) Partial cricotra-
the Cincinnati experience in paediatric laryngotracheal recon- cheal resection for severe paediatric subglottic stenosis: update
struction. Laryngoscope 99, 1111±1116 of the Lausanne experience. Ann. Otol. Rhinol. Laryngol. 107,
17 OCHI J.W., EVANS J.N.G. & BAILEY C.M. (1992) Paediatric 961±968
airway reconstruction at Great Ormond street: a 10-year review. 29 MONNIER P., LANG F. & SAVARY M. (1999) Cricotracheal
1. Laryngotracheoplasty and laryngotracheal reconstruction. resection for severe paediatric subglottic stenosis. Int. J. Pediatr.
Ann. Otol. Rhinol. Laryngol. 101, 465±468 Otorhinolaryngol. 49 (Suppl.), S283±S286
18 COTTON R.T. & SEID A.B. (1980) Management of the extuba- 30 STERN Y., GERBER G.E., WALNER D.L. et al. (1997) Partial
tion problem in the premature child-anterior cricoid split as an cricotracheal resection with primary anstomosis in the paediatric
alternative to tracheostomy. Ann. Otol. 89, 508±511 age group. Ann. Otol. Rhinol. Laryngol. 106, 891±896
19 COTTON R.T., MYER C.M., BRATCHER G.O. et al. (1988) 31 WALNER D.L., STERN Y. & COTTON R.T. (1999) Margins of
Anterior cricoid split 1977±1987: evolution of a technique. Arch. partial cricotracheal resection in children. Laryngoscope 109,
Otolaryngol. Head Neck Surg. 114, 1300±1302 1607±1610
20 SEID A.B., PRANSKY S.M. & KEARNS D.B. (1991) One stage 32 COTTON R.T. & MYER C.M. (1998). Practical Paediatric Oto-
laryngotracheoplasty. Arch. Otolaryngol. Head Neck Surg. 117, laryngology. Lippincott-Raven Publishers, Philadelphia
408±410 33 GUSTAFSON L.M., HARTLEY B.E.J. & COTTON R.T. (2000)
21 COTTON R.T., MYER C.M., O'CONNOR D.M. et al. (1995) Pae- The management of total (grade 4) subglottic stenosis in chil-
diatric laryngotracheal reconstruction with cartilage grafts and dren. Presented at The American Broncho Esophageal Associa-
endotracheal tube stenting. Laryngoscope 105, 818±821. tion meeting in Orlando, FL, May 2000.
22 GUSTAVSON M.G., HARTLEY B.E.J., LIU J.H. et al. (2000) 34 RUTTER M.R., HARTLEY B.E.J. & COTTON R.T. (2000) Crico-
Single stage laryngotracheal reconstruction in children a review tracheal resection in children. Presented at the American Society
of 200 cases. Otolaryngol. Head Neck Surg. in press for Paediatric Otolaryngology meeting in Orlando, FL, May
23 CONLEY J.J. (1953) Reconstruction of the subglottic air pas- 2000.
sage. Ann. Otol. Rhinol. Laryngol. 62, 477±495