Evolutionary Analysis and Structural Insights in Brain Type Cytochrome P450 /aromatase of Stinging Catfish, Heteropneustes Fossilis

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 27

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/283088400 

Evolutionary analysis and structural insights in Brain type Cytochrome P450 /Aromatase 
of Stinging catfish, Heteropneustes fossilis 
Article in Research journal of biotechnology · November 2015 
CITATIONS 0 
READS 308 
4 authors: 
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects: 
Pallipuram Jayasankar Central Institute of Freshwater Aquaculture 
156 PUBLICATIONS 790 CITATIONS 
SEE PROFILE 
All content following this page was uploaded by Kiran Rasal on 23 October 2015. 
The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. 
J.K. Sundaray Central Institute of Freshwater Aquaculture 
121 PUBLICATIONS 508 CITATIONS 
SEE PROFILE 
Pranati Swain Medgenome Labs 
44 PUBLICATIONS 73 CITATIONS 
SEE PROFILE 
Tribal Sub Plan View project 
Molecular and computational approach to delineate metabolic pathways for better carbohydrate utilization in Labeo species View 
project 
Kiran Rasal Central Institute of Freshwater Aquaculture 
23 PUBLICATIONS 65 CITATIONS 
SEE PROFILE 
 
Research Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (11) November (2015) 
Res. J. Biotech Evolutionary analysis and structural insights in Brain type Cytochrome P450/Aromatase of Stinging catfish, 
Heteropneustes fossilis Sundaray Jitendra Kumar, Rasal Kiran Dashrath*, Swain Pranati and Jayasankar Pallipuram Fish 
Genetics and Biotechnology Division, ICAR - Central Institute of Freshwater Aquaculture, Bhubaneswar 751 002, Odisha, 
INDIA *kirancife@gmail.com; Kiran.Rasal@icar.gov.in 

Abstract The brain type cytochrome p450 is the enzyme playing vital role in sexual 
differentiation as well as secondary sexual character development. To date, most of the studies 
on aromatase have focused on the expression pattern, promoter activity and function in sexual 
differentiation. As the computational algorithms/tools are being developed, they have 
revolutionized the way of study for in-depth analysis using existing nucleotide/protein sequence 
data. 
There  is  no  evidence  addressed  for  phylogenetic  analysis  for  investigating  conservation and 3D 
structure  of  aromatase  protein  in  the  Stinging  catfish.  The  stinging  catfish,  Heteropneustes 
fossilis is one of the important species in aquaculture sector. 
The  evolutionary  analysis  was  performed  using  Neighbor-joining  and  UPGMA  methods  using 
CLC  genomic  7.5.1  workbench  tool  followed  by  bootstrap  test  (100  replicates)  performed  to 
validate  the  phylogenetic  tree/cladogram.  We  have  generated 3D structure of aromatase protein 
of  stinging  catfish  using  homology  modelling  with  help  of  template  4KQ8  (54  %  identity)  using 
tool  Modeller  9.1  which  was  further  validated  using  SAVES  server  in  Procheck  and  Verify3D. 
The  Ramachandran  plot  depicted  that  89.4% residues lies in favored region followed by 9.7% in 
additional as well as allowed region and 0.9 % residues found to be in outlier region. 
In  order  to  understand  global  network  of  aromatase protein, we have used STRING 9.1 tool and 
speculated  that  this  protein  interacting with several other protein, strong association/interaction 
with 2 proteins such as estradiol 17 beta dehydrogenase3, 3- beta steroid –dehydrogenase-1 with 
0.988 and 0.979 confidence score respectively. In addition to this, we also investigated structural 
and  functional  consequences  of  SNPs  on  structure  of  aromatase  using  algorithms  like 
PANTHER,  PROVEAN  and  I-  Mutant  2.0.  We  revealed  impact  of  SNPs  on  the protein structure 
and its function using sequence- based tools. 
* Author for Correspondence 

Keywords:  Aromatase/Cytochrome  P450,  Homology  Modelling,  Non-synonymous  Single  Nucleotide 
Polymorphism (nsSNP). 
Introduction Despite the finding of Cytochrome P450/Aromatase about fifty years ago, there still remains 
importance in the field of scientific research and increasing evidence for a role of aromatase in the 
sexualization. The estrogen is important sex steroid playing major role in sex differentiation as well as 
development of secondary sexual character and its biological synthesis is facilitated through enzyme 
cytochrome P450 aromatase (CYP19) in almost all vertebrates 
1-3 

.  This  enzyme  responsible  for  the  conversion  of  androgens  to  estrogens  is  harnessed  for 
production of functional males in some teleost fishes 

such as Chinook salmon, Oncorhynchus tshawytscha 


;  Nile  tilapia,  Oreochromis  niloticus;  rainbow  trout, 


Oncorhynchus mykiss 

; Japanese flounder, Paralichthys olivaceus 


and zebrafish, Danio rerio 


. In case of mammals, it has been noted that this gene is having multiple promoters. 
9-11 

Interestingly,  teleost  fishes  have  two  aromatase  genes,  one  cyp19a1a (aromatase A) that is specific to the 


gonads  and  cyp19a1b  (aromatase  B)  due  to  genome  duplication  event  which  is  strongly  expressed in the 
brain 
12,13 

.  In  fishes,  two  genes  (Cyp19a1a  and  cyp19a1b)  have  been 


identified such as Oncorhynchus mykiss 
14 

, Intalurus punctatus 
15 

, Oreochromis niloticus 
16 

, Carassius auratus 
17 

, Danio rerio 
18-19 

, Cyprinus carpio 
20 

, Trichogaster trichopterus 
21 

, Monoperus albus 
22 

, Melanotaenia fluviatilis 
23 

and Plecoglossus altivelis 


24 


It  has  been  documented  that  teleost  fish  possesses  highest  level  of  brain  aromatase  (cyp19a1b)  activity 
compared to mammals 
12-25 

.  These  two  isoforms  possessed  different  tissue  specificities,  expression  patterns,  enzymatic 
activities  and  regulation  modes  as  evidenced  in  Zebrafish,  Eupropean  sebass,  Nile  tilapia, Common carp 
and Yellowtail clownfish, and Catfish half-smooth tongue sole respectively. 
4,20,26-30 

Also,  interestingly,  teleost  fishes  are  known  for  showing  several  forms  of  natural 
hermaphroditism which was very rare in case of mammals. 
31-33 

Thus,  the mechanisms underlying gonadal sex determination and differentiation obviously differ in fish as 
compared to other vertebrates 
34-36 

.  In  our  earlier  investigation,  we  showed  expression  of  brain  type 
aromatase in male and female Wrasse, Pseudolabrus 
 
Research Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (11) November (2015) 
Res. J. Biotech 
sieboldin 
37 

. Although, the existence of two aromatase 


catfish such as theoretical isoelectric point 
(pI), molecular cyp19 genes was first evidenced in goldfish, Carassius 
weight and total number of positive and 
negative residues, auratus followed by in several other species. But some 
extinction coefficient, half-life, instability 
index, aliphatic interrogation is still remaining like sequence identity 
index and grand average hydrophathy 
(GRAVY) via among the diverse fish species, conserved region of 
submitting protein sequence in FASTA 
format. The expasy functional domains at the protein level, 3D structure of 
tool, SMART was used for motif, domain 
identification in protein and effect of mutation in the gene. 
aromatase protein of catfish (http://smart.embl- heidelberg.de/). Currently with the wide availability of 
sequence data in the form of nucleotide or protein level, we can gain previously 
Alignment and Phylogenetic study: In 
order to study the impossible insights into evolution of protein universe on 
comparison among different protein 
sequences, we have the domain, network and genome levels. Network level 
used global multiple sequence alignment 
program for studies allow us to understand the forces of evolution that 
analysis of aromatase protein sequences 
from different affect changes and conservation of protein networks. The 
fishes. The multiple sequence alignment 
(MSA) method is study of protein evolution had also become a key area of 
widely used for assessing sequence 
conservation and scientific research with discoveries such as the co-ordinated 
conservation of protein domains in protein. 
In this step, changes of key residues and substitution led to phenotype 
CLC genomic workbench 7.5.1 was used 
for multiple change 
38 

sequence alignment (MSA) analysis. Understanding phylogenetic relationship among different protein 
Alongside, the improvement in the computational 
sequences, we have seen the evolutionary 
analysis by algorithms/tools made roadmap for studying the 
depicting cladogram. The evolutionary 
analysis of genome/proteome at wide scale. In this study, although, 
aromatase protein among 31species was 
conducted using there is availability of aromatase sequences and its encoded 
CLC genomic workbench 7.5.1 using two 
different protein sequences in the database for stinging catfish but 
methods namely the UPMGA and 
Neighbor joining lack of species-specific structural information. This led to 
methods. The tree plots cladogram were 
constructed using absence of knowledge of protein network and evolution in 
CLC genomic workbench itself. fishes. In 
this study, we have retrieved protein sequences of stinging catfish used for comparative as well as 
Three dimensional structure generation 
using homology evolutionary analysis. We have predicted the three 
modeling and validation: In order to obtain 
homologous dimensional structure and its protein-interaction network. 
3D structure/template for Brain type 
Cytochrome We have also analyzed the effect of non-synonymous SNPs 
P450/Aromatase protein of Stinging 
catfish, BLASTp on protein structure using sequence-based computational 
(Basic local alignment) searches were 
performed against tools. 
protein databank. The 3D structure were retrieved from RCSB-PDB databank and used for homology 
modelling Material and Methods We have used different bioinformatics algorithms/tools for studying the 
aromatase protein of stinging catfish listed along with specified purpose. 
using Modeller9.1. The 3D structure of aromatase was visualized by PyMOL which is open source 
molecular visualization tool for interactive visualization and analysis of molecular structures 
(http://www.pymol.org/). The predicted model evaluation along with stereo-chemical Collection of Brain 
type cytochrome P450/Aromatase data: The UniProt is easily accessible database of protein sequence 
(http://www.uniprot.org/). The brain type aromatase P450 protein sequence of stinging catfish was 
retrieved from NCBI database with accession number (AID21724.1). Also, we have retrieved 31 species 
of fish 
quality assessment was carried out by using the SAVES (Structural Analysis and Verification Server) 
which is integrated server (http://nihserver.mbi.ucla.edu/SAVES/). The ProSA (Protein Structure 
Analysis) web server (https://prosa.services.came.sbg.ac.at/prosa) was used for refinement and validation 
of protein structure. The ProSA aromatase protein sequences along with their accession number and their 
source organisms were collected for multiple sequence alignment as well as for evolutionary 
was used for checking model structural quality with potential errors and program shows plot of its residue 
energies and Z-scores which determine overall quality of study (Table 1). 
model 
Physico-chemical  Characterization,  motif  analysis  of  Aromatase  P450: The various properties of proteins 
were  determined  and  characterized  from  the  protein  sequences.  Protparam 
(http://web.expasy.org/protoparam/)  is  expasy  tool  which  is  useful  for  computation  of  physical  and 
chemical  parameters of given protein based on sequence. We have calculated physico-chemical properties 
of Brain type Cytochrome P450/Aromatase sequence of stinging 

39 


Prediction  of  protein-protein  interaction  network  of  Brain  type  Cytochrome P450/Aromatase: We further 
predicted  the  gene  ontology  of  aromatase  for  biological,  molecular  functions  which  identified  using 
Uniprot  (http://www.uniprot.org/).  The  STRING  (Search  Tool  for  the  Retrieval  of  Interacting  Proteins) 
was  used  for  studying  the  protein-protein  interaction  network  of  the  Brain  type  Cytochrome 
P450/Aromatase via submitting Stinging 
 
Research Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (11) November (2015) 
Res. J. Biotech 
catfish protein sequence (http://string- 
44 


db.org/newstring_cgi). 
Here, we depicted, grand average of hydropathicity (GRAVY) was -0.078 for aromatase of stinging 
catfish In silico mutagenesis study: To elucidate effect of SNPs 
which indicated that protein is hydrophilic 
in nature. on Aromatase protein structure, we have generated mutation using PyMoL tool. We have 
analyzed the effect of 
The Multiple Sequence Alignment (MSA) 
can give insight SNPs on structure of protein using sequence based tools 
into sequence conservation across several 
species and can such as PANTHER, PROVEAN and I-Mutant 2.0. The 
allow identification of those sections of the 
sequence, most functional impact of nsSNPs predicted was analyzed by 
critical to protein function PANTHER 
(Protein Analysis Througth Evolutionary Relationships; www.pantherdb.org/tools/csnp). This tool 
estimates the likelihood of a particular non-synonymous (amino-acid changing) coding SNP to cause a 
functional impact on the protein using Hidden Markov Models (HMM) based modeling and evolutionary 
relationship. It calculates the subPSEC (substitution position-specific evolutionary conservation) score 
based on an alignment of evolutionarily related proteins. 
PROVEAN  (Protein  Variation  Effect  Analyzer)  is  a  tool  which  predicts  impact  of  an  amino-acid 
substitution  or  indel  on  the  biological  function  of  a  protein  (http://provean.jcvi.org/index.php).  A  query 
sequence  was  provided  in  FASTA  format  and  score  prediction  based  on  default  threshold  -2.5.  Finally, 
I-Mutant2.0  (http://folding.biofold.org/cgi-bin/i-mutant2.0) is a Support Vector Machine -based server for 
the  automatic  prediction  of  protein  stability  changes upon single-site mutations. The RI value (Reliability 
Index)  is  computed  only  when  the  sign  of  the  stability  change  is  predicted  and  is  evaluated  from  the 
output  of  the  support  vector  machine.  The  input  FASTA  sequence  of  protein  along  with  the  residues 
change was provided for analysis of DDG value (Kcal/mol). 
Results and Discussion The current improvement in the field of bioinformatics has been facilitated to 
understand the global network of genes and their encoded protein. In this study, in order to get the 
evolutionary in-sights of brain type Cytochrome P450/aromatase of commercially important stinging 
catfish, H. fosilis, we have used several bioinformatics tools for analysis. After, retrieval of protein 
sequences, we first analyzed the physico-chemical parameter of aromatase protein of stinging catfish. The 
various characteristics were determined using ProtParam tool of the ExPASY proteomic server 

and contrary reveals hydrophobicity of the protein 
45 

.We  have  analyzed  the  MSA  among  31  species  of  fishes  using  retrieved 
aromatase  protein  sequences  using  CLC  genomic  workbench  7.5.1  (Figure  1).  Subsequently,  the 
phylogenetic  software  has  been  developed  such  as PhyML, RaxML, MEGA and Bayesian inference such 
as MrBayes for profiling proteins with respect to evolutionary study 
46-52 

.  In  our  study,  phylogenetic  tree  was  constructed  using  CLC 


genomic  workbench  7.5.1  using  UPGMA  method  which assumes constant rate of evolutionand Neighbor 
Joining  method,  well  suited  for  trees  with  varying  rates  of  evolution.  We  have  used  Kimura  protein 
algorithm which assumes equal amino acid frequency and equal substitution rates while analysis. 
The  earlier  study  demonstrated  that,  bootstrapping  method  generates  reliable  trees  using  re-sampling  the 
given dataset several times 
52-54 

.  We  revealed  that  aromatase  of  stinging  catfish  was  more  related  with  Ictarulus 
punctatus,Silurus  meridionalis  and  Tachysurus  fulvidraco  and  Clarias  spp.  while  distantly  related  with 
carps  (Figure  2a).  This  could  be  due  to  duplicated  gene  events  in  the  fishes  over  the  period  of time. The 
conserved  domains  of  the  Aromatase  were  the  I-helix  region,  the  Ozol’s  peptide  region,  the  aromatase- 
specific  region  and  the  heme-binding  region.  Overall,  this  analysis  strongly  indicates  that  aromatase  of 
stinging catfish is part of the aromatase evolutionary clade (Figure 2b). 
Further,  in  order  to  understand  structure  level  information  of  aromatase  protein  of  stinging  catfish,  we 
have  searched  template  PDB  structure  for  homology  modelling  using  BLASTp.  We  have  retrieved 
homologous  structure  4KQ8  with  54%  identity  and  performed  homology  modelling  using  Modeller9.13 
(Figure  3).  The  Modeller9.13  tool  is  highly  versatile  homology  modeling  tool  developed  by  sailab  and 
used in protein structure prediction 
55,56 

40 

.  We  speculated  that  molecular  weight  56657.2;  Theoretical  pI  7.98;  total  number  of  negatively 
charged residues (Asp + Glu) was 53; total number of positively 
The DOPE Score was -57782.65234 for generated model of aromatase. The generated 3D model of 
aromatase of charged residues (Arg + Lys) was 55. 
stinging catfish was validated using SAVES server and Ramachandran plot showed good quality of model 
with If the instability index of a given protein is < 40, it is predicted as stable while > 40 indicated as 
unstable protein 41-42 
.  In  this  work,  value  of  an  instability  index  of  aromataseprotein  was  44.55  which  indicated  unstable 
protein.  The  GRAVY  index  for  given proteins is calculated as the sum of the hydropathy values of all the 
aa divided by the number of residues in the protein sequence 
43 

. A GRAVY index > 0 indicates a protein is 


hydrophobic 
most  favored  region  89.9  %  with  other statistics described in tabular form (Table 2; Figure 4). The model 
possessed  85.02%  of  the  residues  had  an  averaged  3D-1D  score  >=  0.2  using  Verify3D  server  in  the 
SAVES  (Figure  5).The  Verify3D  determines  the  compatibility  of  3D  model  with  its  own  amino  acid 
sequence  by  allocating  a  structural-class  based  on  its  position  and  environment  (alpha,  beta,  loop,  polar, 
nonpolar etc.) and also comparing the results to the 
 
Research Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (11) November (2015) 
Res. J. Biotech 
good 3D structures. We have depicted our predicted structure having more than 80% residues in the 
averaged 3D-1D score which indicates good quality model. The ProSA analysis showed Z score value 
-1.995 which indicates good quality model. Protein-protein interaction 

investigation  is  a  wide-ranging  approach  to  know  the  organization  of  desire  proteome.  The  functional 
network  analysis  of  protein  will  be  helpful  for  drug  discovery,  to  understand  metabolic  pathways  and  to 
predict or develop genotype-phenotype associations 
57-58 


 
Research Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (11) November (2015) 
Res. J. Biotech 
Figure 1: Multiple sequence alignment of H. fossilis along with 30 fish species showing conserved 
amino acids with specified colors. The conserved Cystiene (C) residues are indicated by yellow color 

 
Research Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (11) November (2015) 
Res. J. Biotech 
Figure 2: Phylogenetic tree and cladogram of brain type cytochrome P450 aromatase of H. fossilis 
along with 30 fish species constructed by neighbor-joining method with bootstrap value 100 using 
CLC genomic workbench 7.5.1. 

 
Research Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (11) November (2015) 
Res. J. Biotech 
Figure 3: The 3D structure of Aromatase protein of H. fossilis predicted using homology modelling 
started with Methionine and ended with glutamine (Showing helix, beta sheet and coils) 
Figure 4: Ramachandran Plot of Aromatase protein showing residues in most favored (red), 
additionally allowed (yellow), generously allowed (pale yellow) and disallowed regions (white) 
generated by PROCHECK. 

 
Research Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (11) November (2015) 
Res. J. Biotech 
Figure 5: The plot which indicates 85.02% of the residues had an averaged 3D-1D score >= 0.2 
using Verify 3D server. 
Figure 6: Interaction networks between Aromatase of H. fossilis and other proteins as predicted by 
STRING 

 
Research Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (11) November (2015) 
Res. J. Biotech 
Table 1 Retrieved amino acid sequences of brain type cytochrome P450 aromatase of fish species 
S.N. Name of Organisms Accession number 
1. Heteropneustes fossilis AID21724.1 2. Clarias fuscus AFB77217.1 3. Clarias gariepinus ADH29766.1 
4. Ictalurus punctatus AAL14612.1 5. Tachysurus fulvidraco AAU25806.2 6. Danio rerio AAV41033.1 7. 
Carassius auratus BAA23757.1 8. Gobiocypris rarus ADB44882.1 9. Cyprinus carpio ACB13198.1 10. 
Rutilus rutilus BAD91038.1 11. Pimephales prome CAC38767.1 12. Oncorhynchus mykiss CAG32835.1 
13. Amphiprion ocellaris BAP59135.1 14. Melanotaenia fluviatilis AED99847.1 15. Rhabdosargus sarba 
ABC70868.1 16. Scatophagus argus AFV47578.2 17. Micropogonias undulates AEL31294.1 18. 
Odontesthes bonariensis AAQ88434.2 19. Oreochromis mossambicus AAD31030.1 20. Oryzias 
melastigma AGN04323.1 21. Fundulus heteroclitus AAR97269.1 22. Kryptolebias marmoratus 
BAF03499.1 23 Sebastes schlegelii AGG53952.1 24. Larimichthys crocea ACO35042.1 25. Oreochromis 
niloticus AAO62626.1 26. Epinephelus coioides AAR97602.1 27. Kryptolebias marmoratus ABC68613.1 
28. Epinephelus akaara AAS58447.1 29. Poecilia vivipara AIN75487.1 30. Fundulus heteroclitus 
AAS76199.1 31. Oreochromis niloticus AAG49480.2 
Table 2 Ramachandran Plot statistics for predicted model of aromatase of H. fossilis 
No. of Residues Percentage 
Most favoured regions [A,B,L] 396 89.4% 
Additional allowed regions [a,b,l,p] 38 8.6% 
Generously allowed regions [~a,~b,~l,~p] 5 1.1% 
Disallowed regions [XX] 4 0.9% 
Non-glycine and non-proline residues 443 100.0% 
End-residues (excl. Gly and Pro) 2 
Glycine residues 29 
Proline residues 21 
Total number of residues 495 

 
Research Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (11) November (2015) 
Res. J. Biotech 
Table 3 Protein-protein interacting networks of aromatase of H. fossilis as determined by STRING 
tool 
cyp19a1b Cytochrome P450, family 19, 
subfamily A, polypeptide 1b (513 aa) 
Predicted Functional Partners: 
hsd17b3 Estradiol 17 beta-dehydrogenase 
3 (306 aa) 
10 
• • 0.988 
hsd3b1 3 beta-hydroxysteroid 
dehydrogenase 1 (374 aa) 
• • 0.979 
ugt1ab UDP glucuronosyltransferase 1 
family a, b (526 aa) 
• • • 0.975 
hsd17b1 Hydroxysteroid (17-beta) dehydrogenase 1 (293 aa) 
• 0.972 
LOC553532 LOC553532 protein Fragment 
(402 aa) 
• 0.965 
nr0b1 Nuclear receptor subfamily 0, 
group B, member 1 (264 aa) 
• 0.962 
zgc:172315 Hypothetical protein 
LOC792506 (527 aa) 
• • 0.953 
ENSDARG00000058845 Annotation not available (242 aa) • • 0.953 zgc:112490 Hypothetical protein 
LOC550352 (543 aa) 
• • 0.953 
zgc:112208 Hypothetical protein 
LOC550398 (252 aa) 
• • • 0.918 
Table 4 Impact analysis of SNPs in aromatase of H. fossilisusing PANTHER-cSNP, PROVEAN and 
I-Mutant2.0 
Amino acids change 
Protein position 
subPSEC score 

deleterious 

Prediction by PANTHER- cSNP 


PROVEAN score 
PROVEAN Prediction (Cutoff =- 2.5) 
I-mutant (DDG value) 
Stability Prediction 
Q/H 128 -2.6119 0.40418 Tolerated -1.299 Neutral -0.36 Decrease 
T/A 388 -3.04387 0.51096 Deleterious -3.772 Deleterious -0.50 Decrease 
R/G 371 -4.28368 0.78308 Deleterious -5.406 Deleterious -1.75 Decrease 
The  STRING  maps  revealed  aromatase  of  stinging  catfish  interacting  with  several  proteins (Table 3) but 
strong  association/interaction  was  with  2  proteins/enzymes  such  as  estradiol  17  beta  dehydrogenase  3, 
3-beta steroid – dehydrogenase-1, having 0.988 and 0.979 confidence score respectively (Figure 6). 
Moreover,  to  investigate  structural  and  functional  impact  of  SNPs  present  in  coding  region  of aromatase 
of stinging catfish, we have performed varied computational analysis. 
We  have  used  sequence-based  algorithms  such  as  PANTHER,  PROVEAN,  I-Mutant2.0  etc.  In  previous 
studies  also,  these  computational  tools  could  detect  non-  synonymous  mutations  and  proved  to be useful 
techniques in predicting the effect of nsSNPs on other proteins 
59-63 


In  earlier  studies,  mutation  in  the  aromatase  gene  resulted  into  genetic  disorder,  also  on  bone 
mineralization and their effect on glucose as well as lipid metabolism 
64-69 

. In case of humans, MutCYP, bioinformatics online tools 


is available 
 
Research Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (11) November (2015) 
Res. J. Biotech 
to investigate or classify the effect of the missense mutation in the aromatase gene 
11 
network. This study has provided the clue to undertake 70 
. The experimental evidences also 
future in vivo experimental investigation 
for understanding reported site directed mutagenesis in aromatase gene at the 
the effect of mutation on biological as well 
as molecular p.Q123E, p.Q123H, p.T310S, p.T310C, p.R365K, 
level changes in aromatase activity due to 
mutation. p.R365A 
71 

.In  case  of  fishes,  polymorphism  in  a  portion  of  the  gene  regulatory  region  of  aromatase  gene 
was reported in the three strain of Nile tilapia 
72 

.  Thus,  in  case  of  fishes,  there  is  no  strong  evidence  regarding  whether 
mutation will affect sex change, behavior in fish and/or other genetic disorder. 
Acknowledgement The work was supported by the grant from Indian Council of Agricultural Research 
(ICAR), Ministry of Agriculture, and Government of India. 
In this study, we have created mutation in the three positions at the p.Q128H, p.T388A and p.R371G 
References 1. Simpson E. R. et al, Aromatase-a brief overview, Annl. Review of Physiology, 64, 93-127 
(2002) subsequently and analyzed the effect of that mutation using computational tools such as 
PANTHER, PROVEAN and I 
2. Uno T., Ishizuka M. and Itakura T., 
Cytochrome P450 (CYP) –Mutant 2.0 (Table 4). The I-Mutant 2.0 predicted all three mutations in 
aromatase as deleterious while PANTHER 
in fish, Environmental toxicology and pharmacology, 34(1), 1-13 (2012) predicted two mutations as 
deleterious except p.Q128H. The PROVEAN also categorizes the impact of nsSNPs on functional protein 
and this tool also classified two mutations as a deleterious except p.Q128H was neutral. 
3.  Wang  L.  et  al,  CYP19  gene  variant  confers  susceptibility  to  endometriosis-associated  infertility  in  Chinese  women, 
Experimental & molecular medicine, 46, e103 (2014) 

The significant difference in outputs of the algorithms may be attributed to utilization of different protein 
sequence 
4. Huang W., Zhou L., Li Z. and Gui J. F., Expression pattern, cellular localization and promoter activity analysis of ovarian 
alignment algorithms which was used to characterize the 
aromatase (Cyp19a1a) in protogynous hermaphrodite 
red-spotted variants. 

grouper, Molecular and cellular endocrinology, 307(1-2), 224-36 (2009) We postulated that effect of 
SNPs would be hampering on biological as well as molecular function of aromatase gene of stinging 
catfish. The blocking of aromatase activity resulted in the production of phenotypic males from females in 
birds 
73-74 

, reptiles 
75-76 

. In case of fishes, it is plausible that mutation in the aromatase led to 


several 
5.  Piferrer  F.  and  Donaldson  E.  M.,  Uptake  and  clearance  of  exogenous  estradiol-17beta  and  testosterone  during  the  early 
development  of  coho  salmon  (Oncorhynchus  kisutch),  including  eggs,  alevins and fry, Fish physiology and biochemistry, 13(3), 
219-32 (1994) 

problems like late puberty and regulations of gonadal sex 


6. Guiguen Y. et al, Involvement of estrogens in the 
process of differentiation or sex change. 
sex differentiation in two fish species: the rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and a tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus), 
Conclusion 

Molecular reproduction and development, 


54(2), 154-62 (1999) In conclusion, our computational study provided insights regarding comparative, 
evolutionary and structural level information of aromatase of stinging catfish H. fosslis. From 
protein-protein interactions network study, we have revealed that functional node 2 proteins/enzymes 
such as estradiol 17 beta dehydrogenase 3, 3-beta steroid – dehydrogenase-1, having 0.988 and 0.979 
confidence score, 
7.  Kitano  T.,  Takamune  K., Nagahama Y. and Abe S. I., Aromatase inhibitor and 17alpha-methyltestosterone cause sex- reversal 
from  genetical  females  to  phenotypic  males  and  suppression  of  P450  aromatase  gene  expression  in  Japanese  flounder 
(Paralichthys olivaceus), Molecular reproduction and development, 56(1), 1-5 (2000) 

were in aromatase protein of stinging catfish network. 


8. Uchida D., Yamashita M., Kitano T. and 
Iguchi T., An Moreover, protein-protein interaction pathway of this aromatase protein has helped us to 
understand the roles and associated proteins in various cellular pathways. We also generated 3D structure 
of aromatase protein using homology modelling and subsequent validation using 
aromatase  inhibitor  or  high  water  temperature  induce oocyte apoptosis and depletion of P450 aromatase activity in the gonads of 
genetic  female  zebrafish  during  sex-reversal,  Comparative  biochemistry  and  physiology  Part  A,  Molecular  &  integrative 
physiology, 137(1), 11-20 (2004) 

Ramachandran  plot.  In  addition,  we  investigated  the  impact  of  the three variant on aromatase in the form 
of energy calculation and evolutionary conserved residues. 
9.  Zhao  Y.,  Nichols  J.  E.,  Bulun  S.  E.,  Mendelson  C. R. and Simpson E. R., Aromatase P450 gene expression in human adipose 
tissue. Role of a Jak/STAT pathway in regulation of the 

The PANTHER, PROVEAN and I-Mutant2.0 algorithms 


adipose-specific promoter, The Journal of biological chemistry, 270(27), 16449-57 (1995) predicted that 
protein stability decreased due to two mutations (p.T388A and p.R371G). Thus, present work 
10. Yabusaki Y., Artificial P450/reductase 
fusion enzymes, what supported us to understand more about aromatase proteins of stinging catfish and 
their protein-protein interaction 
can we learn from their structures?, Biochimie, 77(7-8), 594-603 (1995) 
 
Research Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (11) November (2015) 
Res. J. Biotech 
11.  Tateishi  T.  et  al,  A  comparison  of  hepatic  cytochrome  P450  protein  expression  between  infancy  and  postinfancy,  Life 
sciences, 61(26), 2567-74 (1997) 
12.  Le  Page  Y.  et  al,  Aromatase,  brain  sexualization  and  plasticity:  the  fish  paradigm,  The  European  journal  of  neuroscience, 
32(12), 2105-15 (2010) 
13.  Diotel  N.  et  al,  Aromatase  in  the  brain  of  teleost  fish:  expression,  regulation  and  putative  functions,  Frontiers  in 
neuroendocrinology, 31(2), 172-92 (2010) 
14.  Tanaka  M.,  Telecky  T.  M.,  Fukada  S.,  Adachi  S.,  Chen  S.  and  Nagahama  Y.,  Cloning  and  sequence  analysis  of  the cDNA 
encoding  P-450  aromatase  (P450arom)  from  a  rainbow  trout  (Oncorhynchus  mykiss) ovary; relationship between the amount of 
P450arom mRNA and the production of oestradiol-17 beta in the ovary, Journal of molecular endocrinology, 8(1), 53-61 (1992) 
15.  Trant  J.  M.,  Isolation  and  characterization  of  the  cDNA  encoding  the  channel  catfish  (Ictalurus  punctatus)  form  of 
cytochrome P450arom, General and comparative endocrinology, 95(2), 155-68 (1994) 
16.  Chang  X.  T.,  Kobayashi  T.,  Kajiura  H.,  Nakamura  M.  and  Nagahama  Y.,  Isolation  and  characterization  of  the  cDNA 
encoding  the  tilapia  (Oreochromis  niloticus) cytochrome P450 aromatase (P450arom): changes in P450arom mRNA, protein and 
enzyme activity in ovarian follicles during oogenesis, Journal of molecular endocrinology, 18(1), 57-66 (1997) 
17.  Pasmanik  M.  and  Callard  G.  V.,  Changes  in  brain  aromatase  and  5  alpha-reductase  activities  correlate  significantly  with 
seasonal reproductive cycles in goldfish (Carassius auratus), Endocrinology, 122(4), 1349-56 (1988) 
18.  Chiang  E.  F.  et  al,  Characterization  of  duplicated  zebrafish  cyp19  genes, The Journal of experimental zoology, 290(7), 709- 
14 (2001) 
19.  Chiang  E.  F.,  Yan  Y.  L.,  Guiguen  Y.,  Postlethwait  J.  and  Chung  B.,  Two  Cyp19  (P450  aromatase)  genes  on  duplicated 
zebrafish chromosomes are expressed in ovary or brain, Molecular biology and evolution, 18(4), 542-50 (2001) 
20.  Barney  M.  L.,  Patil  J.  G.,  Gunasekera  R.  M. and Carter C. G., Distinct cytochrome P450 aromatase isoforms in the common 
carp  (Cyprinus  carpio):  sexual  dimorphism  and  onset  of  ontogenic  expression,  General  and comparative endocrinology, 156(3), 
499-508 (2008) 
21.  Ezagouri  M.,  Yom-Din  S.,  Goldberg  D.,  Jackson  K.,  Levavi-  Sivan  B.  and  Degani  G.,  Expression  of  the  two  cytochrome 
P450  aromatase  genes  in  the  male  and  female  blue  gourami  (Trichogaster  trichopterus)  during  the  reproductive  cycle,  General 
and comparative endocrinology, 159(2-3), 208-13 (2008) 
22.  Yu  J.  H.,  Tang  Y.  K.  and  Li  J.  L.,  Cloning,  structure,  and  expression  pattern  of  the  P-450  aromatase  gene  in  rice  field  eel 
(Monopterus albus), Biochemical genetics, 46(5-6), 267-80 (2008) 

12 
23.  Shanthanagouda  A.  H.,  Patil  J.  G.  and  Nugegoda  D.,  Effects  of  exposure  to  oestrogenic  compounds  on  aromatase  gene 
expression  are  gender  dependent  in  the  rainbowfish,  Melanotaenia  fluviatilis,  Comparative  biochemistry  and  physiology 
Toxicology & pharmacology : CBP, 157(2), 162-71 (2013) 
24.  Wang  J.  H.  et al, Cloning the Dmrt1 and DmrtA2 genes of ayu (Plecoglossus altivelis) and mapping their expression in adult, 
larval,  and  embryonic  stages,  Dong  wu  xue  yan  jiu  =  Zoological  research  /  "Dong  wu  xue  yan  jiu" bian ji wei yuan hui bian ji, 
35(2), 99-107 (2014) 
25.  Forlano  P.  M.,  Deitcher  D.  L.,  Myers  D.  A.  and  Bass  A.  H.,  Anatomical  distribution  and  cellular  basis  for  high  levels  of 
aromatase  activity  in  the  brain  of  teleost  fish:  aromatase  enzyme  and  mRNA  expression  identify  glia  as  source,  The  Journal of 
neuroscience, 21(22), 8943-55 (2001) 
26.  Kishida  M.  and  Callard  G.  V.,  Distinct  cytochrome  P450  aromatase  isoforms  in  zebrafish  (Danio rerio) brain and ovary are 
differentially programmed and estrogen regulated during early development, Endocrinology, 142(2), 740-50 (2001) 
27.  Blazquez  M.  and Piferrer F., Cloning, sequence analysis, tissue distribution, and sex-specific expression of the neural form of 
P450 aromatase in juvenile sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax), Molecular and cellular endocrinology, 219(1-2), 83-94 (2004) 
28.  Chang  X.,  Kobayashi  T.,  Senthilkumaran  B.,  Kobayashi-  Kajura  H.,  Sudhakumari  C.  C.  and  Nagahama  Y.,  Two  types  of 
aromatase  with  different  encoding  genes,  tissue  distribution  and  developmental  expression  in  Nile  tilapia  (Oreochromis 
niloticus), General and comparative endocrinology, 141(2), 101-15 (2005) 
29.  Kobayashi  Y.,  Horiguchi  R.,  Miura  S.  and  Nakamura  M., Sex- and tissue-specific expression of P450 aromatase (cyp19a1a) 
in  the  yellowtail  clownfish,  Amphiprion  clarkii,  Comparative  biochemistry  and  physiology  Part  A,  Molecular  &  integrative 
physiology, 155(2), 237-44 (2010) 
30.  Sridevi  P.,  Chaitanya  R. K., Dutta-Gupta A. and Senthilkumaran B., FTZ-F1 and FOXL2 up-regulate catfish brain aromatase 
gene transcription by specific binding to the promoter motifs, Biochimica et biophysica acta, 1819(1), 57-66 (2012) 
31.  Kitawaki  J.  et  al,  Immunohistochemical  localisation  of  aromatase  and  its  correlation  with  progesterone  receptors in ovarian 
epithelial tumours, Anti Cancer Research, 16(1), 91-7 (1996) 
32.  Baroiller  J.  F.,  D'Cotta  H.  and  Saillant  E.,  Environmental  effects  on  fish  sex  determination  and  differentiation,  Sexual 
development  :  genetics,  molecular  biology,  evolution,  endocrinology,  embryology,  and  pathology  of  sex  determination  and 
differentiation, 3(2-3), 118-35 (2009) 
33. Godwin J., Neuroendocrinology of sexual plasticity in teleost fishes, Frontiers in neuroendocrinology, 31(2), 203-16 (2010) 
34.  Ohta  K.  et  al,  Bidirectional  sex  change induced by sex steroid implantation in the hermaphrodite fish, Pseudolabrus sieboldi, 
Journal of experimental zoology Part A, Ecological genetics and physiology, 317(9), 552-60 (2012) 
 
Research Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (11) November (2015) 
Res. J. Biotech 
35.  Nagahama  Y.,  Molecular  mechanisms  of  sex  determination  and  gonadal  sex  differentiation  in  fish,  Fish  physiology  and 
biochemistry, 31(2-3), 105-9 (2005) 
36.  Guiguen  Y.,  Fostier  A.,  Piferrer  F.  and  Chang  C.  F.,  Ovarian  aromatase  and  estrogens:  a  pivotal  role  for  gonadal  sex 
differentiation and sex change in fish, General and comparative endocrinology, 165(3), 352-66 (2010) 
37.  Sundaray J. K., Ohta K., Yamaguchi A., Kitano T. and Matsuyama M., Isolation, cloning, sequencing of brain type aromatase 
and its expression in male and female Wrasse, Pseudolabrus sieboldi, Fish physiology and biochemistry, 31(2-3), 137-41 (2005) 
38. Reeck G. R. et al, "Homology" in proteins and nucleic acids: a terminology muddle and a way out of it, Cell, 50(5), 667 
(1987) 
39.  Wiederstein  M.  and  Sippl  M.  J.,  ProSA-web:  interactive  web  service  for  the  recognition  of  errors  in  three-dimensional 
structures of proteins, Nucleic acids research, 35(Web Server issue), W407-10 (2007) 
40. Artimo P. et al, ExPASy: SIB bioinformatics resource portal, Nucleic acids research, 40(Web Server issue), W597-603 
(2012) 
41.  Guruprasad  K.,  Reddy  B.  V.  and  Pandit  M.  W.,  Correlation  between  stability  of  a  protein  and  its  dipeptide  composition:  a 
novel approach for predicting in vivo stability of a protein from its primary sequence, Protein engineering, 4(2), 155-61 (1990) 
42.  Sivakumar  S.,  Rajagopal  R.,  Venkatesh  G.  R.,  Srivastava  A.  and  Bhatnagar  R.  K.,  Knockdown  of  aminopeptidase-N  from 
Helicoverpa  armigera  larvae  and  in  transfected  Sf21  cells  by  RNA  interference  reveals  its  functional  interaction  with  Bacillus 
thuringiensis insecticidal protein Cry1Ac, The Journal of biological chemistry, 282(10), 7312-9 (2007) 
43.  Gasteiger  J.,  Chemoinformatics:  a  new  field  with  a  long  tradition,  Analytical  and  bioanalytical  chemistry,  384(1),  57-64 
(2006) 
44.  Kyte  J.  and  Doolittle  R.  F.,  A  simple  method  for  displaying  the  hydropathic  character  of  a  protein,  Journal  of  molecular 
biology, 157(1), 105-32 (1982) 
45. Wiseman R. L. and Kelly J. W., Evolving protein stability through genetic selection, Molecular cell, 36(5), 730-1 (2009) 
46. Eddy S. R., Profile hidden Markov models, Bioinformatics, 14(9), 755-63 (1998) 
47.  Coulson  R.  M.,  Hall  N.  and  Ouzounis  C.  A.,  Comparative  genomics of transcriptional control in the human malaria parasite 
Plasmodium falciparum, Genome Research, 14(8), 1548-54 (2004) 
48.  Fong  J.  H.,  Geer  L.  Y.,  Panchenko  A.  R.  and  Bryant  S.  H.,  Modeling  the  evolution  of  protein  domain  architectures  using 
maximum parsimony, Journal of molecular biology, 366(1), 307- 15 (2007) 

13 
49.  Forslund  K.,  Henricson  A.,  Hollich  V.  and  Sonnhammer E. L., Domain tree-based analysis of protein architecture evolution, 
Molecular biology and evolution, 25(2), 254-64 (2008) 
50.  Stecher  G.,  Liu  L.,  Sanderford  M.,  Peterson  D.,  Tamura  K.  and  Kumar  S.,  MEGA-MD:  molecular  evolutionary  genetics 
analysis software with mutational diagnosis of amino acid variation, Bioinformatics, 30(9), 1305-7 (2014) 
51.  Kumar  S.,  Nei  M.,  Dudley  J.  and  Tamura  K.,  MEGA:  a  biologist-centric  software  for  evolutionary  analysis  of  DNA  and 
protein sequences, Briefings in bioinformatics, 9(4), 299-306 (2008) 
52.  Tamura  K.,  Dudley  J.,  Nei M. and Kumar S., MEGA4: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis (MEGA) software version 
4.0, Molecular biology and evolution, 24(8), 1596-9 (2007) 
53.  Kumar  S.,  Stecher  G.,  Peterson  D.  and  Tamura K., MEGA- CC: computing core of molecular evolutionary genetics analysis 
program for automated and iterative data analysis, Bioinformatics, 28(20), 2685-6 (2012) 
54.  Kumar  S.,  Tamura  K.  and  Nei  M.,  MEGA:  Molecular  Evolutionary  Genetics  Analysis  software  for  microcomputers, 
Computer applications in the biosciences : CABIOS, 10(2), 189- 91 (1994) 
55. Webb B. and Sali A., Protein structure modeling with MODELLER, Methods in molecular biology, 1137, 1-15 (2014) 
56.  Yang  Z.  et  al,  UCSF  Chimera,  MODELLER, and IMP: an integrated modeling system, Journal of structural biology, 179(3), 
269-78 (2012) 
57.  Wang  H.  Q.,  Zhu  H.  L.,  Cho  W.  C.,  Yip  T.  T.,  Ngan  R.  K.  and  Law  S.  C.,  Method  of  regulatory  network  that can explore 
protein regulations for disease classification, Artificial intelligence in medicine, 48(2-3), 119-27 (2010) 
58.  Hsia  C.  W.,  Ho  M.  Y.,  Shui  H.  A.,  Tsai  C. B. and Tseng M. J., Analysis of Dermal Papilla Cell Interactome Using STRING 
Database  to  Profile  the  ex  Vivo  Hair  Growth  Inhibition  Effect  of  a  Vinca  Alkaloid  Drug,  Colchicine,  International  journal  of 
molecular sciences, 16(2), 3579-98 (2015) 
59.  Alanazi  M.  et  al,  In  silico  analysis  of  single  nucleotide  polymorphism  (SNPs)  in  human  beta-globin  gene,  PloSOne,  6(10), 
e25876 (2011) 
60.  George  Priya  Doss  C.  and  Rajith  B.,  Computational  refinement  of  functional  single  nucleotide  polymorphisms  associated 
with ATM gene, PloSOne, 7(4), e34573 (2012) 
61.  Johnson  M.  M.,  Houck  J.  and  Chen C., Screening for deleterious nonsynonymous single-nucleotide polymorphisms in genes 
involved in steroid hormone metabolism and response, Cancer epidemiology, biomarkers & prevention, 14(5), 1326-9 (2005) 
62. Kamaraj B. and Purohit R., In silico screening and molecular dynamics simulation of disease-associated nsSNP in TYRP1 
gene 
 
Research Journal of Biotechnology Vol. 10 (11) November (2015) 
Res. J. Biotech 
and its structural consequences in OCA3, BioMed research international, 2013, Article ID 697051, 13 Pages (2013) 
63. Khan S. and Vihinen M., Performance of protein stability predictors, Human mutation, 31(6), 675-84 (2010) 
64.  Conte  F.  A.,  Grumbach  M.  M.,  Ito  Y.,  Fisher  C.  R.  and  Simpson  E.  R.,  A  syndrome  of  female  pseudohermaphrodism, 
hypergonadotropic  hypogonadism,  and  multicystic  ovaries  associated  with  missense  mutations  in  the  gene  encoding  aromatase 
(P450arom), The Journal of clinical endocrinology and metabolism, 78(6), 1287-92 (1994) 
65.  Bakker  J.,  Pierman  S.  and  Gonzalez-Martinez  D.,  Effects  of  aromatase  mutation  (ArKO)  on  the  sexual  differentiation  of 
kisspeptin  neuronal  numbers  and  their  activation  by  same  versus  opposite  sex  urinary  pheromones,  Hormones  and  behavior, 
57(4- 5), 390-5 (2010) 
66.  Herrmann  B.  L.  et  al,  Impact  of  estrogen  replacement  therapy  in  a  male  with  congenital  aromatase  deficiency  caused  by  a 
novel mutation in the CYP19 gene, The Journal of clinical endocrinology and metabolism, 87(12), 5476-84 (2002) 
67. Anthoni H. et al, The aromatase gene CYP19A1: several genetic and functional lines of evidence supporting a role in reading, 
speech and language, Behavior genetics, 42(4), 509-27 (2012) 
68.  Sudeep  K.,  Abraham  J.,  Seshadri  L.  and  Seshadri  M.  S.,  Aromatase  deficiency:  an  unusual  cause  for  primary  amenorrhea 
with virilization, The Journal of the Association of Physicians of India, 61(5), 340-3 (2013) 
69.  Gagliardi  L.,  Scott  H.  S.,  Feng  J.  and  Torpy D. J., A case of Aromatase deficiency due to a novel CYP19A1 mutation, BMC 
endocrine disorders, 14, 16 (2014) 

14 
70.  Fechter  K.  and  Porollo  A.,  MutaCYP:  Classification  of  missense  mutations  in  human  cytochromes  P450,  BMC  medical 
genomics, 7, 47 (2014) 
71.  Chen  S.  and  Zhou  D.,  Functional  domains  of  aromatase cytochrome P450 inferred from comparative analyses of amino acid 
sequences  and  substantiated  by  site-directed  mutagenesis  experiments,  The  Journal  of  biological  chemistry,  267(31),  22587-94 
(1992) 
72.  Rodrigues  A.  C.,  de  Oliveira  Monero  T.,  Frighetto  R.  T.  and  de  Almeida  E.  A.,  E2  potentializes  benzo(a)pyrene-induced 
hepatic  cytochrome  P450  enzyme  activities  in  Nile  tilapia  at  high  concentrations,  Environmental  science and pollution research 
international, 5, 1-8 (2014) 
73. Elbrecht A. and Smith R. G., Aromatase enzyme activity and sex determination in chickens, Science, 255(5043), 467-70 
(1992) 
74.  Hudson  Q.  J.,  Smith  C.  A.  and  Sinclair  A.  H., Aromatase inhibition reduces expression of FOXL2 in the embryonic chicken 
ovary, Developmental dynamics, 233(3), 1052-5 (2005) 
75.  Wibbels  T.  and  Crews  D.,  Putative  aromatase  inhibitor  induces  male  sex determination in a female unisexual lizard and in a 
turtle with temperature-dependent sex determination, The Journal of endocrinology, 141(2), 295-9 (1994) 
76.  Belaid  B.,  Richard-Mercier  N.,  Pieau  C.  and  Dorizzi  M.,  Sex  reversal  and  aromatase  in the European pond turtle: treatment 
with  letrozole  after  the  thermosensitive  period  for  sex  determination,  The  Journal  of  Experimental  Zoology,  290(5),  490-497 
(2001). 

(Received 20 
th 

March 2015, accepted 10 


th 

May 2015) 
View View publication publication stats stats 

You might also like