Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Structures Steel
Structures Steel
b, the maximum deflection will occur in the left portion of the span, to which equation (¥) applies. Setting the derivative of this expression equal to zero gives, x= fare) _ (every _ [P06 3 3 3 at that point a horizontal tangent and hence the point of maximum deflection substituting this value P.b(? by"? 9/3. ELL of x into equation (v), we find, Yuu, Case “I if sts tin it bea = f= LED a i.e. at mid point b= L2 then P(L2)x{u (U2)? pp on Yow (8) See ABE (vi) A simply supported beam with UDL (Uniformly distributed load) A simply supported beam AB carries a uniformly distributed load (UDI, of intensity wianit length aver its whole span Las shown in figure. We want to develop the equation of the elastic curve and find the maximum deflection & at the middle of the span | ‘Taking co-ordinate axes x and y as shown, we have for the bending moment at any point x Baqg?09 429Chapter-5 Deflection of Beam SK Mondal’s Again Integrating both side we get wh ew xt Bly SE At Where A and B are integration constants. To evaluate these constants we have to use houndary. conditions, at x=0,y=0 gives B=0 cap DW, we at x= 12, SF=0 gives A=-57 ‘Therefore the equation of the elastic curve we 2EI = MTP arse a’ = agep LE 2b? +") ‘The maximum deflection at the mid-span, we have to put x = L/2 in the equation and obtain _ 5wL' 384E/ "And Maximum slope 0, =0, at the left end A and at the right end b is same putting x= 0 orx=L. a — recieve sie a (vii) A simply supported beam with triangular distributed load (GVL) gradually varied load. A simply supported beam carries a triangular distributed load (GVL) as shown in figure below, We have to find equation of elastic curve and find maximum deflection(3) In this (GVL) condition, we got Page 209 of 428Deflection of Beam SK Mondal's i) Ail) wil) eeliv) (v) Where A, B, C and D are integration constant. Boundary conditions atx=0, = My= y=o atx=L, .¥=0 gives Thorlo y=- MA [TU AOL +344} (nepeivesgn indicate downward defection) ” . dy Tofind maximum defection’, we have And it gives x= 0.519 L and maximum deflection (3)=0. ves (viii) A simply supported beam with a moment at mid-span A simply supported beam AB is acted upon by a couple M applied at an intermediate point distance ‘a’ from the equation of elastic curve and deflection at point where the moment acted. 7 Mi Ra we Considering equilibrium we get Ry=™ and Ry ‘Taking co-ordinate axes x and y as shown, we have for bending moment Indergin Oxse, Moll 5 Inineregon asst, M,=Meom So we obtain the difference equation for the elastieeaveDeflection of Beam SK Mondal’s for0; (a ) A Maximum defection (3) = % (F)G) : we ie (at free end) EI 31 (ii) A cantilever beam with a point load not at free end Pa? y, ‘Area of BM diagram (A)= LxaxPa =P pL, Therefore x Maximum slope(0) Pat Cat free end) L—4 eI Maximum deflection (3) = * EP ES) ve ~ EI *2e BM Diagram a {- 3) (at free end) (iii) A cantilever beam with UDL over its whole length ‘Area of BM diagram (A) +4 a) awe e Thorolore wt EI” Ge! Min afecton (= (e }: (i) 6 4 wit RE et tee end (iv) A simply supported beam with point load at mid-spam Maximum slope(9) (at free end) Page 2190428Chapter-5 Deflection of Beam SK Mondal's Area of shaded BM diagram. % PL_PL? M A PLP au} 2" 6 oh A "Therefore . The AL PL — Maximum slope(#) === === (at each ends) Maximum deflection (5) = BLM Diagram (v) A simply supported beam with UDL over its whole length Area of BM diagram (shaded) % (a)=2 (5 ()- we (" wiunitlength Ue) ae A ‘ b,x ‘Therefore emt. i wh Maximum siope(a)= A= (at cach ends) “ee iat EI” 24€1 Maximum deflection (6) (Se) El 3 Parabolic (at mid point) BM Diagram 9. Method of superposition Assumptions: + Structure should be linear + Slope of elastic line should be very small + The deflection of the beam should be small such that the effect due to the shaft or rotation of the line of action ofthe load is neglected Principle of Superposition: + Deformations of beams subjected to combinations of loadings may be obtained as the linear ‘combination of the deformations from the individual loadings + Procedure is facilitated by tables of solutions for common types of loadings and supports. Example: w For the beam and loading shown, determine the slope and deflection at point B. het wy wll Page 220 of 428Chapter-5 Deflection of Beam SK Mondal’s Superpose the deformations due to Loading Tand Loading IT as shown, ont Lonling It ies) —" Pia Paine Loading 1 ee, n, +—,__| o] Loading tt 7 a“ ow Colusa tn beam sezmeut CB, the beading moment is zero and te elastic cue i a staight ine, aha =(6ch 85 =(a); +a va=O2);+8)n 10. Conjugate beam method In the conjugate beam method, the length of the conjugate beam is the same as the length of the actual beam, the loading diagram (showing the loads acting) on the conjugate beam is simply the bending-moment diagram of the actual beam divided by the flexural rigidity EY of the actual beam, and the corresponding support condition for the conjugate beam is given by the rules as shown below. Corresponding support condition for the conjugate beam Page 210429Chapter-5 Deflection of Beam ‘SK Mondal's Existing support condition | Corresponding support condition of the actual beam for the conjugate beam Rule 1 | Fixed end Free end Rule 2 Fixed end | Rule 3 | Simple support at the end ‘Simple support atthe end Rule 4 Simple support nor at the end | Unsupported hinge Rule 5 | Unsupported hinge Simple support Conjugates of Common Types of Real Beams Conjugate beams for statically determinate Conjugate beams for _Statically real beams indeterminate real beams . coon Bo ” ae By the conjugate beam method, the slope and deflection of the actual beam can be found by using the following two rules: ‘The slope of the actual beam at any cross section is equal to the shearing force at the corresponding eross section of the conjugate beam, ‘The deflection of the actual beam at any point is equal to the bending moment of the conjugate beam at the corresponding point. Procedure for Analysis Construct the M/ ET diagram for the given (real) beam subjected to the specified (real) loading. Ifa combination of loading exists, you may use M-diagram by parts Determine the conjugate beam corresponding to the given real beam Apply the M/ EI diagram as the load on the conjugate beam as per sign convention Calculate the reactions at the supports of the conjugate beam by applying equations of equilibrium and conditions Determine the shears in the conjugate beam at locations where slopes is desired in the real beam, Veoas = Ore Determine the bending moments in the conjugate beam at locations where deflections is, desired in the real beam, Meow = yeu P0*77201428Chapter-5 Deflection of Beam SK Mondal’s ‘The method of double integration, method of superposition, moment-area theorems, and Castigliano’s theorem are all well established methods for finding deflections of beams, but they require that the boundary conditions of the beams be known or specified. If not, all of them become helpless. However, the conjugate beam method is able to proceed and yield a solution for the possible deflections of the beam based on the support conditions, rather than the boundary conditions, of the beams. (Acar at its free end. ver beam with a point load For Real Beam: At a section a distance ‘x’ from free end consider the forces to the left. Taking moments about the section gives (obviously to the left of the section) Ms = -P.x x (nogative sign means that the moment on the left hand side L of the portion is in the anticlockwise direction and is M,! therefore taken as negative according to the sign convention) x so that the maximum bending moment occurs at the fixed end ie. Mies =~ PE (at x= 1) M Diagram ]wiunit tength L ——_+| Considering equilibrium we get, My = “ and Reaction (Ry, Considering any cross-section XX which is ata distance of x from the fixed end At this point load (WY, Shear force (V,) = Ry ~atea of triangle ANM The shear force variation is parabolic. a st ra atx=0,V, atx=L,V, Bending moment (M,) Page 223 of 420Chapter-5 ‘SK Mondal's wg Wot wl 2 6L 3 ‘The bending moment variation is cubic ae ieMaximum BM. (Mya, Page 2240428Chapter-5 Deflection of Beam SK Mondal’s OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Beam Deflection GATE-1, A lean elastic beam of given flexural rigidity, EI, is loaded by a single force F era F as shown in figure. How many boundary conditions are necessary to determine the deflected centre line of the beam? position 5 4 Ms \ 3 @2 “in [GATE-1999] JUDE ULL GATE-1. Ans. (2) EISL=M. Since itis second order differential equation so we need two boundary conditions to solve it. GATE-2, A simply supported beam carrying a concentrated load W at mid-span deflects by 6 under the load. If the same beam carries the load W such that it is distributed uniformly over entire length and undergoes a deflection 6: at the mid span. The ratio 6: By is: [ES-1995; GATE-1994] (21 @) V2s1 ut @u2 (ty _ swe we -2, Ans. (d) 6,=-e-= and 6-12 = GATES Ame hte goer SU ge “gaae ‘Therefore 6: GATE-3. A simply supported laterally loaded beam was found to deflect more than a specified value, [GATE-2003] Which of the following measures will reduce the deflection? (a) Increase the area moment of inertia (b) _Inerease the span of the beam (©) Select a different material having lesser modulus of elasticity (@ Magnitude of the load to be increased we 4861 ‘To reduce, 6, increase the area moment of Inertia, GATE-8. Ans. (a) Maximum deflection (6) = Page 2280428Chapter-5 Deflection of Beam SK Mondal's Previous 20-Years IES Questions Double Integration Method IBS-1. Consider the following statements: [ES.2003] Ina cantilever subjected to a concentrated load at the free end 1. The bending stress is maximum at the free end 2. The maximum shear stress is constant along the length of the beam. 3. ‘The slope of the elastic curve is zero at the fixed end Which of these statements are correct? G@izands ty 2and 3 (1anas (@rana2 18S.1. Ans.) TES2, A cantilever of length L, moment of inertia T. Young's modulus E carries a Concentrated load W at the middie of its length. The slope of cantilever at the free end is: {1ES-2003) oe 4 we = @ Me tw ME ot @ HE DET ae SEI 16ET " 3) we 1ES-2. Ans. (¢) 9= 12). WE 2EI~ BEI IES8. The two cantilevers A and B. shown in the 5 figure have the same uniform croeescetion ed tn ‘mame meter ors Free end deflection of cantilever Ais 6. (WES-2000) ‘The value of mid- span deflection of the cantilever (a) $6 (28 (6 (a)26 Wer (WL), _ swe? 3E El Yea owL EI EI IES-4. A cantilever beam of reetangular cross-section is subjected to a load W at its free end. If the depth of the beam is doubled and the load is halved, the deflection of the free end as compared to original deflection will be: [TES-1999] (@) Halt (b) One-eighth (©) One-sixteenth, (@) Double WE _ WE x12 _ an SEI 3Eah’ Eah® 4W1 1 awe 2Ba(2h) 16” Bal? IES-8. Ans. (c) 2El IES-4. Ans. (¢) Deflectionin cantilever = If his doubled, and W is halved, New deflection = IES-5. A simply supported beam of constant flexural rigidity and length 2L carries a concentrated load 'P' at its mid-span and the deflection under the load isd. If a cantilever beam of the same flexural rigidity and length ‘L’ is subjected to load 'P' at its free end, then the deflection at the free end will be: [ES-1993] (a)38 (>) 5 pagezabflees (aseChapter-5 IES-5. Ans. (c) 6 forsimply supported beam: TES. IES.6, Ans. (d) When a B. Mis applied at the free end of cantilever, @="—" = TES. Deflection of Beam SK Mondal’s: W(2L) _ we 48EI — 6EI and deflection for Cantilever = 2 3ET ‘Two identical cantilevers are ~ P loaded as shown in the respective figures. If slope at t— L the free end of the cantilever in figure E is 8, the slope at free MRCS and of the cantilever in figure Figure F F will be: ES-1997] wie wre ©20 oe °3 2 O3 ML_(PLI2)L El EL When a cantilever is subjected toa single concentrated Toad at free end, then @ = = EL A cantilever beam ca) a load W uniformly distributed over its entire length. If the same load is placed at the free end of the same cantilever, then the ratio ‘of maximum deflection in the first case to that in the second ease will he: [LES-1996} (a) 388 was (oars @ss wes-7. Ans, gy HE BET IES-8. The given figure shows a p cantilever of span 'L’ subjected to ‘a concentrated load 'P! and a moment 'M' at the free end. Deflection at the free end is \r given by (1ES-1996] PL, Mt 1 ME, PL Otte YG spe @ 2EI 3EL 2EL * 3ET BEI" ET 2EI ” 48ET TES-8, Ans. (b) 1ES-9, For a cantilever beam of length 'L', flexural rigidity EI and loaded at its free ‘end by a concentrated load W, match List I with List Il and select the correct answer. UIES-1996] List List ‘A. Maximum bending moment 1 WI B. Strain energy 2. WPRET C. Maximum slope 3. WINSEL D. Maximum deflection 4. WHFIGEL Coes: A BC D AB Cc D @ 1 4 38 2 @® 1 4 2 8 @4 2 1 8 @ 4 38 1 2 TES-9, Ans. (b) 1Es.10. Maximum deflection of a capt yam of length ‘I carrying uniformly distributed load w por unit leit oe TIES. 2008}Chapter-5 Deflection of Beam ‘SK Mondal's, (@) wl ED, @) wi (AED) (wv (SED (@ wt 884 ED, [Where E = modulus of elasticity of beam material and I= moment of inertia of beam cross-section) IBS-10. Ans. (c) IES-11. A cantilever beam of length ‘I is subjected to a concentrated load P at a distance of US from the free end. What is the deflection of the free end of the beam? (ET is the flexural rigidity) [ES.2004] 2Pr 3Pr 14Pr 1sPr @) = w © @ S1zT 81EI SIET SILL IBS-11. Ans. (d) Moment Area method gives us IES.12, TES-12, Ans. (c) Reaction force on B and C is same 100/2 ave, 23 13)-(a°8) 6 EL mae ee “el*o"e"a1el Wat eI Alternatively Ygac= 100 kf and is simply supported at its ends by two cantilevers AB= 1 m long and 5 milong as shown in thefigure. = AG—O, The shear force at end A of the cantilever AB will be felms}—2 m —ste— 2m A (@) Zero ©) 40 kg (© 50ks @ 60kg [ES.1997] 50 kg. And we know that shear force is ‘same throughout its length and equal to load at freo ond. TES-13. Assertion (A): In a simply supported beam subjected to a concentrated load P at span, the elastic curve slope becomes zero under the load. [ES.2003] Reason (R): The deflection of the beam is maximum at mid-span. (@) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (@) Both Aand B are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (©) Aistrue but Ris false @ Ais false but R is true IBS-13. Ans. (a) IBS-14, At a certain section at a distance from one of the supports of « simply oct alas toa nde ar tsstag basing mucin fea ake eee ES 'W;, Mx and Vx respectively. If the intensity of loading is varying continuously along the length of the beam, then the invalid relation is: (LES-2000} Pi ¥ (2)Stope0, (=e (oq = (au, =4 IES-14. Ans. (a) Page 228 of 420Chapter-5 Deflection of Beam SK Mondal’s TES-15. ‘The bending moment equation, as a function of distance x measured from the left end, for a simply supported beam of span L m carrying a uniformly distributed load of intensity w Nim will be given by. [IES-1999] (a) Z(ux)yNm (8) “Ey Za)" Nm (c)M TES.15. Ans. (b) SZ (Lx) ~F(La)' Nm (a)M IES-16. A simply supported beam with width 'b' and depth ’d’ carries a central load W and undergoes deflection 8 at the centre. If the width and depth are interchanged, the deflection at the contre of the beam would attain the value 2 5 8 (TES-1997] ws offs ogo alge 1ES-16, Ans. (b) Deflection at center 3= WE. _Wh__ 48EI oe (DP 12 Insecond case, deflection =, aoe se ase( ane( OP 2 (12 1ES-17. A simply supported beam of rectangular section 4 cm by 6 cm carries a mid- span concentrated load such that the 6 cm side lies parallel to line of action of loading; deflection under the load is 8. If the beam is now supported with the 4 em side parallel to line of action of loading, the deflection under the load will be: [TES-1993] (a) 0.446 0675 156 (2.258 IES-17. Ans. (d) Use above explanation IES.18. A simply supported beam carrying a concentrated load W at mid-span deflect: by 6: under the load. If the same beam carries the load W such that it is distributed uniformly over entire length and undergoes a deflection 62 at the mid span. The ratio 5: 8: [TES-1995; GATE-1994] @2a oa 1 @uz Ww sag site el 48E & 384El TES.18. Ans. (a) 5, Moment Area Method IES.19. Match I with List-I and select the correct answer using the codes given below the Lists: [1ES-1997] List-l List-I AL Toughness 1. Moment area method B. Endurance strength 2. Hardness . Resistance to abrasion 8. Energy absorbed before fracture in ‘a tension test D. Deflection in a beam 4. Fatigue loading Cole: A BC D A BC D @ 4 3 1 2 @® 4 8 2 1 © 3 4 2 1 @ 38 4 1 2 IES-19. Ans. (c) page 22901426ion of Beam ‘S$ K Mondal's Chapter-5 Defle Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Slope and Deflection at a Section IAS-1. Which one of the following is represented by the area of the S.F diagram from ‘one end upto a given location on the beam? [AS-2004] (@) BM. at the location (b) Load at the location (©) Slope at the location (@) Deflection at the location TAS-1. Ans. (a) Double Integration Method TAS-2. Which one of the following is the correct statement? [AS-2007] itor eam 2 frites length amis canto (@) Free from any load (b) Subjected to a concentrated load at its free end (©) Subjected to an end moment _(d) Subjected to a udl over its whole span TAS-2. Ans. (e) udl or point load both vary with x. But if we apply Bending Moment (M) = const dM y Ww anat 9 w es posheadacad Yt t ¥ TASS. Ina cantilever beam, if the length is doubled while keeping the cross-section and the concentrated load acting at the free end the same, the deflection at the freo end will increase by TIAS-1996] (@) 2.6 times (@) Btimes (0 6 times (@) 8 times IAS-3. Ans. (d) I Conjugate Beam Method TAS-4. By conjugate beam method, the slope at any section of an actual beam is equal [1AS-2002] @ EI times the S.F. of the conjugate beam (b) El times the B.M. of the conjugate beam (©) SF. of conjugate beam (d) B.M. of the conjugate beam TAS-4. Ans. (c) TAS, 75 x 10 mt $120.5 m k— ——— E=200GPa Determine the stiffuess of the J] beam shown in the above figure a (@) 12 « 1000 Nim 1 (@) 10 * 10 Nim (©) 4 10 Nim (@8x109Nim [ES-2003] TAS-5, Ans, (c) Stifness means required load fog unit gefasmation, BMD of the given beam ab taeChapter-5 Deflection of Beam SK Mondal’s iW 2k. ‘ Loading diagram wi ) ‘The deflection at beam of conjugate beam ‘. the free end of the actual beam = HM of the at fixed point of conjugate poh Mca} L b+ (cen (e+ -98 3 *t2ei 2) tae) hs | zr 2x (200 x 10°) x(375x10-* Bet _ 2x(200%10%)x(975%10) 4 sye/m 3b 3x(0.5)" Page 231 of 420Chapter-5 ‘SK Mondal's Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question GATE-1999 Question: Consider the signboard mounting shown in figure below. The wind load acting perpendicular to the plane of the figure is F = 100 N. We wish to limit the deflection, due to bending, at point A of the hollow cylindrical pole of outer diameter 150 mm to 5 mm. Find the wall thiekness for the pole. [Assume E=2.0X 10" Nim‘) im Answer: — Given: P= 100 N; do= 150 mm, 0.15 my = 5 mm; E=2.0X 10" Nim? Thickness of pole, t ‘The system of signboard mounting can be considered as a cantilever loaded at A ie. W 100 N and also having anticlockwise moment of M= 100 x 1 = 100 Nm at the free end, Deflection of cantilever having concentrated load at the free end, ME ME “SET” 261 surg? 100%5" 10045 Bx2Z0x10" x1” 2x2.0x10"%1 1 100 «5° 100x 5° mt —100%5° , —100%8" | s gt7 107 lit But =2(e- ju ale-4) 5.417 «10° = = (0.18'— 64 or d.=0.141mor 141mm t= 150-141 ggg 2 2 Conventional Question IES-2003 Question: Find the slope and deflection at the free end of a cantilever beam of length 6m as loaded shown in figure below, using method of superposition. Evaluate their numerical value using B= 200 GPa, T= 1x10+m‘ and W=1KN. Page 2320428Chapter-5 Deflection of Beam SK Mondal’s: ‘Answer: We have to use superposition theory, pe ow weonsider A = PE (QW)x2 _ sw J__m jc §& «SEI SEI CET 0, = PL _ (3W).2" _ ow. 2Ei2EI ET . BW OW 4 32W Defiection at A due to this load\s,) = 8. + 8.082) =" + ex 4 = Ep consider: r 5, -2W)x4 _120W . 36. SET . 9, OW )x# _ 16H x f e2EI EL Se! Deflection at A due to this load(6,) & 5s gx(6-4y 28 3EI 3 cons w wxe_72W (id= 84 SEE A wxe?_18w 1 2E) El 1.0 (@)ox/on depends on the shape of cross-section My IBS-1. Ans. (d) Bending stress "MY, y and both depends on the ‘Shape of cross~ section so “A. depends on the shape of cross~ section IBS-2. If the area of cross-section of a circular section beam is made four times, keeping the loads, length, support conditions and material of the beam unchanged, then the qualities (List-D) will change through different factors (List-Il). Match the ListI with the List-II and select the correct answer using the code given below the Lists: [ES-2005] List Page 240 of datst-IT A. Maximum BM LsChapter-6 Bending Stress in Beam SK Mondal’s B, Deflection 21 C. Bending Stress 3. Us D. Section Modulus 4. 1n6 Codes A BC A B Cc »D @ 3 1 2 ® 2 4 38 4 © 3 4 2 @ 2 1 38 iameter will be double, A. Maximum BM will be unaffected IES-2, Ans. (b) 1B. deflection ratio #-(3) z=, (a) m(a/2) ©. Bending stress a 4 or Bending stress rat IES-3. Consider the following statements in ease of beams: [HES-2002] 1. Rate of change of shear force is equal to the rate of loading at a particular section 2. Rate of change of bending moment is equal to the shear force at a particular suction. 3. Maximum shear force in a beam occurs at a point where bending moment either zero or bending moment changes sign Which of the above statements are correct? (2) 1 alone () 2alone (land 2 (@1,2and3 IES-3. Ans. (c) TES4, Mate List below the Lis List I (State of Stress) List-Il (Kind of Loading) — List-II and select the correct answer using the code given [TES-2006] 1. Combined bending and torsion of circular A it ~ — 2. Torsion of circular shaft BS Load t 3. Thin cylinder subjected to internal Cc pressure 4, Tie har subjected to tensile force Codes A BC D A B oc D @ 2 1 8 4 @® 8 4 2 1 © 2 4 8 1 @ 8 1 2 Page 241 of 420Chapter-6 Bending Stress in Beam SK Mondal's Section Modulus TES5. Two beams of equal cross-sectional area are subjected to equal bending moment. If one beam has square cross-section and the other has cireular section, then [ES.1999] (@) Both beams will be equally strong () Circular section beam will be stronger (©) Square section beam will be stronger (@ The strength of the beam will depend on the nature of loading IES-5. Ans. (b) If D is diameter of circle anda’ the side of square section, fa ad 320 ar TES.6, A beam cross-section is used in two different orientations as shown in the given figure Bending moments applied to the beam in both eases are same. The }*—— 6 ——*| maximum bending stresses induced in cases (A) and (B) are related as: bye @o,=40, Wo, ‘for circular sectior o-2 @o,-2 ery a4 UES-1997] WES-6. Ans. (0) Zfor rectangular section io OS x 6 2B MnZ,0,-2y0, oF 24 TES-7, A horizontal beam with square cross-section Is simply supported with sides of the square horizontal and vertical and carries a distributed loading that produces maximum bending stress a in the beam. When the beam is placed one of the diagonals horizontal the maximum bending stress will be: [TES-1993] L @ bo © Vo (@) 20 v2 M TES-7. Ans. (@) Bending stress = “4 © ie Zz For rectangular eam with sides horizontal and vertical, = © For same section with diagonal horizontal, Z=—" “ 6v2 *. Ratio of two stresses = V2 TES-8. Which one of the following combinations of angles will carry the maximum load as a column? (ES-1994] Page 242 of 420Chapter-6 Bending Stress in Beam SK Mondal’s aE IES'8, Ans. (a) IES.9. Assertion (A): For structures steel I-beams preferred to other shapes. [IES-1992] Reason (R): In -beams a large portion of their cross-section is located far from the neutral axis. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (@) Both A and Rare individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (©) Ais true but Ris false (@) Ais false but Ris true IES-9, Ans. (a) Combined direct and bending stress IES.10. Assertion (A): A column subjected to eccentric Ioad will have its stress at centroid independent of the eccentricity. [TES-1994] Reason (R): Eecentric loads in columns produce torsion. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correet explanation of A (© Aistrue but Ris false (@ Ais false but Ris true IES-10. Ans. (c) A is true and Ris false IES-11. For the configuration of loading shown in the given figure, the stress in fibre AB is given by: [IES-1995] P_Pes a) PIA onsite za (Compressive (a) PIA (tensile) of aT. ir pr ) P_ Pes © (E45) (Compressive (PIA Compresive) 54 Pp Pp t e=1 x fx 1.1 10 ali a B (compressive), o, = =P (ensite) TES-11, Ans. (b) 0, = Page 243 0428Chapter-6 TES.12, 1es1a Ans nope sana cb=12 Nam’ “(1 68) Bending Stress in Beam ‘SK Mondal's A columm of square section t@ mm 40 p mm, fixed to the ground carries an # socatri Lia af 000 Naas the Figure If the stress developed along the edge (co te a Naming ha ‘nba slain eaige AB willbe: (a) -1.2 Nimm? (>) +1. N/mm* (© 108 Nim ? (08mm Apter D -- --|40mm B C- 40mm (IES-1999] 4 ~1600(°* 20 or £~ 02. sostressat 4p =—1600 (1, 1600 6 0.2) =-0.8 Nimm*(com) subjected to an eccentri at an eccentricity e. To avoid tensile stress in the short column, the ‘eccentricity ¢ should be less than or equal to: @ wiz ©) We © ws (@ wa el es b aul beh [ES.2001] TBS-18. Ans. (b) IES-14, A short column of external diameter D and internal diameter d carries an ‘eccentric load W. Toe greatest eccentricity which the load can have without producing tension on the cross-section of the column would be: [ES-1999] Ded Did Ded @ 8 ® 8d © 8D 8 (a) TES-14. Ans. (c) Page 24¢of 420Chapter-6 Bending Stress in Beam SK Mondal’s: Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Bending equation TAS-1. Consider the cantilever loaded as shown below: {IAS-2004] a w kNim bbeyd Cross-section of the cantilever What is the ratio of the maximum compressive to the maximum tensile stress? @ 10 (2.0 25 @a0 rass.ane cy ol esi, Mas = (2Batoerent (2) super TAS-2, A 0.2 mm thick tape goes over a frictionless pulley of 25 mm diameter. If E of the material is 100 GPa, then the maximum stress induced in the tape TAS 1994] () 100 MPa (©) 200 MPa (©) 400 MPa (@ 800 MPa 25 = mm=12.5x 10m 2 IAS-3, A pipe of external diameter $ em and internal diameter 2 cm and of length 4m is supported at its ends. Tt carries a point load of 65 N at its centre. The sectional modulus of the pipe 9@INHio"42 THAS-2002]Chapter-6 Bending Stress in Beam ‘SK Mondal's 652 65m 65m 5 65ns @) = = @ = a oun oom om Open TAS-8. Ans. (c) Section modulus(z) Se em TAS-4. A Cantilever beam of rectangular cross-section is Im deep and 0.6 m thick. If ‘the beam were to be 0.6 m deep and Im thick, then the beam would. [TAS-1999] (@) Be weakened 0.5 times () Be weakened 0.6 times (©) Bestrengthened 0.6 times (@ Have the same strength as the original beam because the cross:sectional area remains the same TAS-4. Ans. (b) IAS. A T-beam shown in the given figure is subjected to a bending moment such that plastic hinge forms. The distance of the neutral axis from D. inmm) (@) Zero @) 109 mm © 125mm @ 170 mm [AS.2001} TAS-5. Ans. (b) IAS-6. Assertion (A): I, T and channel sections are preferred for beams. __[LAS-2000] Reason(R): A beam cross-section should be such that the greatest possible ‘mount of area is as far away from the neutral axis as possible. (@) Both Aand R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (@) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (© Aistrue but Ris false (@__ Ais false but R is true IAS-6, Ans. (a) Because it will increase area moMOMCMH#ERia, ic. strength of the beam.Chapter-6 Bending Stress in Beam SK Mondal’s IAS7. If the T-beam cross-section shown in the given figure has bending stress of 30 MPa in the top fiber, then the stress in the bottom fiber would be (G is centroid) (a) Zero (b) 30 MPa ore (©) -80MPa (@) 50 Mpa [1AS-2000] As top fibre in tension so bottom fibre will be in compression, JAS-8, Assertion (A): A square section is more economical in bending than the circular [IAS-1999] Reason (R): The modulus of the square section is less than of circular section of same area of cross-section. Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A ‘Ais true but Ris false ‘Ais false but Ris true Strip IAS-9, A straight bimetallic strip of copper and steel is heated. It is free at ends. The strip, will: [1AS-2002] (a) Expand and remain straight (©) Will not expand but will bend (©) Will expand and bend also (@) Twist only TAS-9, Ans. (c) As expansion of copper will be more than steel Combined direct and beni 1AS-10. A short vertical column having a square crose-section is subjected to ‘an axial compressive force, centre of pressure of which | passes through point R as shown in the P above figure. Maximum compressive stress oceurs at point @ s mQ OR @P ig stress [1AS-2002] TAS-10. Ans. (a) As direct and bending both the stress is compressive here. TAS-11, A strut’s cross-sectional area A is subjected to load P a point S (h, k) as shown in the given figure. The stress at the point Q (x, y) is: [1AS-2000] Page 2470428Chapter-6 Bending Stress in Beam SK Mondal's TAS-11. Ans. (b) All stress are compressive, direct stress, (Gamat, 2, s 7 (compressive) and «= FEE (compressive) Page 248 of 428Chapter-6 Bending Stress in Beam SK Mondal’s: Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question IES-2008 Question: A Simply supported beam AB of span length 4 m supports a uniformly istributed load of intensity q = 4 kNim spread over the entire span and a concentrated load P = 2 kN placed at a distance of 1.5 m from left end A. The beam is constructed of a rectangular cross-section with width b = 10 em and depth d = 20 cm. Determine the maximum tensile and compressive stresses developed in the beam to bending. Answer: Ryt R= 2 #44.) Ryx4 + 2x(4-1.5) + (B4)x2 Ail) or R,= 9.25 KN, R,=18-R,= 8.75 KN ifO ae TES-6. _ A beam having rectangular cross-section is subjected to an external loading. ‘The average shear stress devEF9p2! d@to the external loading at a particularChapter-7 Shear Stress in Beam SK Mondal's cross-section is t,.. What is the maximum shear stress developed at the same cross-section due to the same loading? [ES.2009] = ©) ba 24, PT Ee Alli tS UB TB t 7 | fool Shear stress in a rectangular Shear stress in a circular beam, the beam, maximum shear stress, maximum shear stress, wt 2 IBS-6. Ans. (e) oF ets 44 nat = Bp 7 1-5 Femnae) ‘ Bop 7B Tense) axi¢ a TES7, ‘The transverse shear stress 9 p—— » —={ acting in a beam of rectangular cross-section, subjected to a UA... | > transverse shear load, is: tT (@) Variable with maxim at the , bottom of the beam | () Variable with maximum at the 4 y-}--4—-——--}-* - top of the beam (© Uniform (@) Variable with maximum on the neutral axis [1ES-1995, GATE-2008, TES-7, Ans (@) Tay TESS. A cantilever is loaded by a concentrated load P at the free end as shown. The shear stress in the element LMNOPQRS is under consideration. Which of the following figures represents the shear stress directions in the cantilever? [TES.2002] Page 250 of 420Chapter-7 s Shear Stress in Beam SK Mondal’s » IES-8. Ans. (@) IES-9, In [Section of a beam subjected to transverse shear force, the maximum shear stress is developed. (LES. 2008] (a) At the centre of the web (b) At the top edge of the top flange (6) At the bottom edge of the top flange (@ None of the above IES-9, Ans. (a) IES-10. The given igure (all, «= f+ 00 dimensions are in mm) shows an [Section of the beam. The Pp shear stress at point P (very close to the bottom of the Q flange) is 12 MPa. The stress at ee} point Q in the web (very close » 80} to the flange) is: nfo @ Indeterminable due to incomplete data ©) 60MPa (© 18MPa @ 12MPa ar k-——— 100 TIES-2001] TES-10. Ans. (b) IES-1. Assertion (A): In an [Section beam subjected to concentrated loads, the shearing force at any section of the beam is resisted mainly by the web portion. Reason (R): Average value of the shearing stress in the web is equal to the value of shearing stress in the flange. [HES-1995] (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (@) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correet explanation of A (©) Ais true but Ris false (@ Ais false but Ris true IES-11. Ans. (c) Shear stress distribution for different section IES-12, The shear stress distribution over a beam eross- section is shown in the figure above. The beam is of (a) Equal flange Section (b) Unequal flange Section (© Circular cross-section (@ Tseetion Page 251 of 420 [HES-2003] TES.12. Ans. (b)Chapter-7 Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Shear Stress Variation IAS-1. Consider the following statements: [AS.2007} ‘Two beams of identical cross-section but of different materials carry same bending moment at a particular section, then 1. The maximum bending stress at that section in the two beams will be 2. ‘The maximum shearing stress at that section in the two beams will be 8. Maximum bending stress at that section will depend upon the elastic modulus of the beam material. 4. Curvature of the beam having greater value of B will be larger. Which of the statements given above are correct? (@)tand2only — (b)1, Sand 4 ©4,2and3 (@2,3and4 TAS. Ans (a) Bending stress = M2 and shear stress (r) =/4? both of them doesnot depends I ‘on material of beam. IAS.2. In a loaded beam under bending [AS.2003] (@) Both the maximum normal and the maximum shear stresses occur at the skin fibres (@) Both the maximum normal and the maximum shear stresses occur the neutral axis (©) The maximum normal stress occurs at the skin fibres while the maximum shear stress occurs at the neutral axis @ The maximum normal stress occurs at the neutral axis while the maximum shear stress ooeurs at the skin fibres TAS.2. Ans. (e) Shear Stress Distribution {IE-v8) inten prt iin hur sre sre th ron section, Shear stress distribution for different section TAS-8. Select the correct shear stress diajrthaiem diagram for a square beam with a diagonal in a vertical position: TAS-2002]Chapter-7 Shear Stress in Beam SK Mondal’s « o ; = IAS3. Ans. (€) IAS-4, The distribution of shear stress of a eam is shown in the given figure. The cross-section of the beam is: [1AS-2000] @ 1 ® T © @Zs 4 IAS-4, Ans. (b) TAS.5. A channel-section of the beam shown in the given figure carries a uniformly distributed load. [TAS-2000] ws Nim Assertion (A): The line of action of the load passes through the centroid of the cross-section. The beam twists besides bending. Reason (R): Twisting occurs since the line of ai through the web of the beam. (a) Both A and R are individuaHygtiee ant is the correct explanation of A (@) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A ion of the load does not passChapter-7 Shear Stress in Beam ‘SK Mondal's © Aistrue but Ris false (@ Ais false but R is true IAS-5. Ans. (¢) Twisting occurs since the line of action of the load does not pass through the shear. Page 254 of 420Chapter-7 ‘Shear Stress in Beam ‘SK Mondal's Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question IES-2009 Q@ (@A cantilever of circular solid cross-section is fixed at one end and carries a concentrated load P at the free end. The diameter at the free end is 200 mm and increases uniformly to 400 mm at the fixed end over a length of 2 m. At what distance from the free end will the bending stresses in the cantilever be maximum? Also calculate the value of the maximum bending stress if the concentrated load P= 30 kN [15-Marks} Ans. Wenave 52M yl ‘Taking distance x from the free end we have M= 30x kNam = 30x x 10° Nm ) y= 100+ 3 (200-100) =100+50x mm = mt and 1= 3 Let d be the diameter at x from five end. 64 _x(2004+100x)! - 64 From equation (), we have e (100+50x) x10" 30x10" Gq (200+ 100%)" x10 260% (2001003)"* X10? sw Gi) 960s =P (2004100) * x10" For max o, <2 =0 10 x 960 a [=(-8)(100)(200 + 100%)" +1.(200+100)"] = -800x + 200 + 100: => [k= Im] Page 2680428Chapter-7 Shear Stress in Beam, ‘SK Mondal's SOkN ed ZO00m 2m) Hence maximum bending stress oceurs at the midway and from equation (i), maxiraum bending stress = 282 (1)(200+100)* x10"? * 2 = 26010 11.32 MPa (300) Conventional Question TES-2006 Question: A timber beam 15 em wide and 20 cm deep carries uniformly distributed load over a span of 4 mand is simply supported. It the permissible stresses are 30. Nim? longitudinally and 3. Nimm# transverse shear, calculate the maximum load which can be carried by the timber beam. Min NA\ 2gcm ant Answer: Moment of nesta ) = 2% = (018)<(020)" 2 2 om Distance of neutral axis from the tp surfice y = 22 =10em = 0.1m Weknow that Mia Soe a Ty T ‘Where maximum bending moment due to uniformly MOTof2 spans aay > Areas of free B.M.D. Sadi; Distance of free B.M.D. from the end supports, or outer supports (Aand ©) Bs. Suand 3: > are. sinking or settlements of support from their initial position. Page 271 of 420Chapter-8 Fixed and Continuous Beam Page-270 OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years IES Questions Overhanging Beam IBS-1. An overhanging beam ABC is supported at points A and B, as shown in the above figure. Find the maximum bending moment and the point where it occurs. [ES.2009] (@) 6 kN-mat the right support 2kN 6xN (©) 6 KN-mat the left support 4 ai (© 4.5 kN-mat the right support 2 @ 45 kNem at the midpoint im 1m between the supports : mn TRS.1. Ans. (a) Taking moment about A V2 (201) + (6x3) > 2M, =2+18 = Vp =10 KN Va + Vp = 2+6 = SKN V, = 8-10 =-2 kN ‘Maximum Bending Moment = GKN-m at the right support TES-2. A beam of length 4 I. is simply supported on two supports with equal overhangs of L on either sides and carries three equal loads, one each at free ends and the third at the mid-span. Which one of the following diagrams represents correct distribution of shearing foree on the beam? [ES.2004} ” oy © — @ ro —~ IBS-2. Ans. (d) Page 2720428Chapter-8 IES-3. Fixed and Continuous Beam Page-271 IP Pp x iP ro ; fen vd Ip2 PAI P ‘They use opposite sign conversions but for correct sign remember SF & BM of cantilever is Qive. A horizontal beam carrying uniformly distributed load is supported with equal *@ overhangs as shown in the given figure ‘The resultant bending moment at the mid-span shall be zero if afb is: [IES-2001] (ay a 213 1 @ys »—$—obreal TES:3. Ans. (c) Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Overhanging Beam 1Asa, TASA. Ans. (¢) R= R, = P+ 1As2, If the beam shown in the given figure is to have zero bending moment at its middle point, the overhang x should be: TTAS-2000] (o) wh /4P ©) wP OP (© wE ISP. @ wP /12P wl 2) Bending moment at mid point ( Seb Rah P(x 5 Oat = A beam carrying a uniformly distributed load rests on two supports 'b! apart with equal overhangs ‘a’ at each end. The ratio b/a for zero bending moment at mid-span is: (TAS-1997] 1 3 @> 1 ws @e 2 Page 2730428 2Chapter-8 Fixed and Continuous Beam Page-272 TAS-2. Ans. (d) @ —_Bysimilarity in the BM diagram a must be b/2 (By formula M ge “| Ogivesa=b2 2|4 TASS. A beam carries «uniformly disteibuted load and is supported with two equal overhangs as shown in figure 'A'. Which one of the following correctly shows ha bialig abet atsgeamn etna baat TAS 1994] Fig A fa) co 3 ) a ® = A IAS-3. Ans. (a) Page 2740f 429Chapter-8 Fixed and Continuous Beam Page-273 Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question IES-2006 Question: What are statically determinate and in determinate beams? Illustrate each case through examples. Beams for which reaction forces and internal forces can be found out from static Answer: equilibrium equations alone are ealled statically determinate Beam, Example: : R SOX, =O30Y, =0 and 7M =0 is sufficient to calculate R, & R, Beams for which reaction forces and internal forces cannot be found out from statle equilibrium equations alone are called statically indeterminate beat. ‘This type of ‘beam requites deformation equation in addition to stati equilibrium equations to solve for unknown forces Rxamiple: P P A. Ra 7 Ro Page 2750428Torsion Theory, at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) In machinery, the general term “shaft” refors to a momber, usually of circular crose- seetion, which supports gears, sprockets, wheels, rotors, ete,, and which is subjected to torsion and to transverse or axial loads aeting singly or in combination. + An “axle” is a rotating/non-rotating member that supports wheels, pulloys,... and carries no torque, © A“pindte" isa short shaft, Terms such as lineshafl, headshaft, stub shoft, transmission (@) 67.72 MPa GATE-1, Ans. (a) GATE-2, Maximum shear stress developed on the surface of a solid cireular shaft under pure torsion is 240 MPa. If the shaft diameter is doubled then the maximum. shear stress developed corresponding to the same torque will be: [GATE-2003] (@) 120 MPa (0) 60 MPa (©)30 MPa @ 15 MPa GATE-2, Ans. (¢) ¢= 31, 240 = 137 if diameter doubled d= 24, then «= GATE-3. A steel shaft A’ of diameter 'd! and length 'l is subjected to a torque ‘T” Another shaft 'B’ made of aluminium of the same diameter 'd’ and length 0.51 is also subjected to the same torque 'T’. The shear modulus of steel is 2.5 times the shear modulus of aluminium. The shear stress in the steel shaft is 100 MPa. The shear stress in the aluminium shaft, in MPa, [GATE-2000] oo oo ‘1 ai GATE 3 Ann (0) 25 ef tha same vie same GATE4, For aci Jar shaft of diameter d subjected to torque T, the maximum value of the shear stress is: IGATE-2006] 64T 32r 16T sr os 0) OF Om GATE-4. Ans. (e) Power Transmitted by Shaft GATES. ‘The diameter of shaft A is twice the diameter or shaft B and both are made of the same material. Assuming both the shafts to rotate at the same speed, the maximum power transmitted by Bis: THES-2001; GATE-1994] (@) The same as that of A (b) Halfof A (oe ot A (@ Va ot A 2a 461 md GATE-S. Ans. (¢) Power, P=Tx22% and or 60 a 16 Combined Bending and Torsion GATE-6, A solid shaft can resist a bending moment of 3.0 kNm and a twisting moment of 4.0 kNm together, then the maximum torque that can be applied is: [GATE-1996] (2) 7.0 kNm (6) 8.5 kn 202 0f420 (0)4.5 kN (@)5.0kNm GATE-6. Ans. (d) Equivalent torque (T,)= YE +1? = V3° +4? = SkNmChapter-9 Torsion SK Mondal's Comparison of Solid and Hollow Shafts GATE-7, The outside diameter of a hollow shaft is twice its inside diameter. The ratio of wcity to that of a solid shaft of the same material and the same outside diameter is: IGATE-1993; 1ES-2001] 15 3 l 1 a) ws @t @t 16 9 3 16 GATE. Ans. (a) T=S2eF of T= ris const T a J Unk R a{p_(O) 4 2D) er 20" Shafts in Series GATE-8. A torque of 10 Nm is transmitted through a stepped shaft as shown in figure. ‘The torsional stiffness of individual sections of lengths MN, NO and OP are 20 Nm/rad, 30 Nmv/rad and 60 Nuvrad respectively. The angular deflection between the ends Mand P of the shat i IGATE-2004] +5 (0) 0.5 rad (©) 10 rad (©)5.0rad (@) 100 rad GATE’. Ans. (b) We know that @= 7° or T =o (let k-= tional stiffness) Tau Te, Tor 10 10,10 Kw Kno n+ ho + Ap Orad ‘op 20°30” 60 Shafts in Parallel GATE-9, The two shafts AB and BC, of equal Iength and diameters d and 2d, are made of the same material. They are coupling 94 while the ends A and C are built-in L 5 (cantilevered). A twisting moment T is }-—_ —_.__—_ applied to the coupling. If Ta and Te A B Cc ind C, respectively, then IGATE-2005] a 0) Te=8 Ts (@ TAxi6 Te or ita. Tele Gh Golo Previous 20-Years IES Questions Torsion Equation TES, Consider the following statements: (TES. 2008] Maximum shear stress induced in g.poeg tggnsmitting shaft is 1. Directly proportional to torque being transmitted. 2 Inversely proportional to the cube of its diameter.Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondar's 1ES-1, IES, IES2, TES-3. IES, IES-4, TES. IES5. IES, IES, TES. IES. IES. IES, 3. Directly proportional to its polar moment of inertia, Which of the statements given above are correct? GL 2and3 @land3only (Zand only Land Zonly Tat 167 Ane (ay = TE HOT A solid shaft transmits a torque T. The allowable shearing stress is r. What is the diameter of the shaft? {18-2008} efit oP cog cot Ans. (a) Maximum shear stress developed on the surface of a solid circular shaft under pure torsion i= 240 MPa If the shaft diameter is doubled, then what is the Trainin shonr stress developed corresponding to the samme torque?’ [IES 2009] (a) 120MPa (b) 60 MPa (©) 30 MPa (@) 15 MPa Ans, (¢) Maximum shear stress = "2h = 240MPa=* ‘Maximum shear stress developed when diameter is doubled 16 118) + _ 240 ~ 16r__ 1/16T) _ + _ 240 _aompa x(2d) 8\ad') 8 8 The diameter of a shaft is increased from 30 mm to 60 mm, all other conditions its torque carrying capacity TTES-1995; 2004] G@) 2 times times © 8times @ 1 times Ans (¢) += 18 or T=2 for came material r= const. 16 B_(ay ey (a) “bo A circular shaft subjected to twisting ssocsent results in maxititin shear stress of 60 MPa. Then the maximum compressive stress in the material [IES-2003] (@) 30 MPa, (b) GO MPa. (©) 90 MPa (@ 20MPa Ans. (b) Tad or Angle of twist of a shaft of diameter ‘d’ is inversely proportional to [TES-2000] @d oe oa @at Ans. (@) {A solid circular shaft is subjected to pure torsion. The ratio of maximum shear to maxim normal stewne at any point would bet ES. @il ) 1:2 (oul w2s ‘Ans. (a) Shear stress = 167 and normal stress = 222 ad ad Ratio of shear stress and normal stress = 1:2 Assertion (A): In a composite shaft having two concentric shafts of different materials, the torque shared by cach shaft is directly proportional to its polar moment of inertia. [ES-1999] Reason (R): In a composite shaft having concentric shafts of different Is, the angle of twist for each shaft depends upon its polar moment of (@) Both Aand R are individually true and Ris the correct explanation of A () Both A and Rare individually true but Ris NOT the correct explanation of A (© Aistruebut Risfale Page 28501420 (@ Ais false but Ris trueChapter-9 Torsion SK Mondal’s TESS. Ans. (c) IES9. A shaft is subjected to torsion as shown. [ES-2002] Which of the following figures represents the shear stress on the element LMNOPQRS ? 8 ; @ IES9, Ans. (€) TES10. A round shaft of diameter ‘d’ andy Iength 'T fixed at both ends ‘A’ and c ‘BI is subjected to a twisting moment A B 'T at 'C’, at a distance of 1/4 from A (see figure). The torsional stresses in Me the parts AC and CB will be: @) Baval beivam (b) Inthe ratio 13 -— (© Inthe ratio 3-1 @) Indeterminate ES-19971 1 TES.10. Ans. (©) ret Hollow Circular Shafts TES-11, Onechalf length of 50 mm diameter stec! rod while the remaining half i r TES-11, Ans. (@) & ws hollow having a bore of 25 mm. The rod is subjected to equal and opposite torque at its ends. If the maximum shear stress in solid portion is t or, the maximum shear stress in the hollow portion is: [ES-2003] 15 16 @er wr @or 16 15 r sort tidy wd, ort y, Page 2960428Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondar's Ley (is) 2 1 Epa’) [-(3) | Power Transmitted by Shaft TES-12. In power transmission shafts, if the polar moment of inertia of a shaft is doubled, then what is the torque required to produce the same angle of twist? [ES-2006} (a) 1/4 of the original value (b) 172 of the original value (©) Same as the original value (@ Double the original value IBS-12, Ans. (4) T_Go_r Th FSP. Fo Q= Ze it disconst Ta J iis doubled then Tis also doubled IES-13, While transmitting the same power by a shaft, if its speed is doubled, what should be its new diameter if the maximum shear stress induced in the shaft sonnei? 11s-2006) 1 1 «) “Lotte original diameter 0) othe original diameter () 2 igi b) B igi © Zot the original diameter @ Lottie original diameter Qy TES-13. Ans. (4) Power (P) = torque(T) xangular speedo) ot 1 yt tPisconttat nT or P= (1/2) ate WT er) e(rI2) fe ad (ay «(3) proportional to: (1ES-2005] “eG ld 2eN 16T rod same nal ated ee of 6 IES-15. A shaft can safely transmit 90 kW while rotating at a given speed. If this shaft is replaced by a shaft of diameter double of the previous one and rotated at half the speed of the previous, the power that can be transmitted by the new shaft is: [ES-2002] (a) 90 kW (b) 180 kW (©) 360 kW (@ 720 kW, TES-15. Ans. (c) IES-16, The diameter of shaft A is twice the diameter or shaft B and both are made of the same material. Assuming both the shafts to rotate at the same speed, the maximum power transmitted by Bis: [ES-2001; GATE-1994), (@) The same as that of A () Half of A (6) U8 of A @ Ua of A 2eN 16T ad! FN and 1 ASE or T= Page 287 of 420 IES-16. Ans. (c) Power, P=Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondal’s IES-17, When a shaft transmits power through gears, the shaft experiences [IES-1997] (a) Torsional stresses alone () Bending stresees alone (© Constant bending and varying torsional stresses (@ _ Varying bending and constant torsional strosses TES-17. Ans. (d) Combined Bending and Torsion TES-18. The equivalent bending moment under combined action of bending moment M and torque ' is [IES-1996; 2008; IAS-1996] @ Mer © 3 [Mi] © 3[M+r] @ ier | TES-18. Ans. (b) TES.19. A solid circular shaft is subjected to a bending moment M and twisting moment ‘T. What is the equivalent twisting moment T. which will produce the same maximum shear stress as the above combination? ITES-1992; 2007] (@) Me+T @M+T © WweT (@M-T (ear IES20. A shaft is subjected to fluctuating loads for which the normal torque (I) and bending moment (M) are 1000 N-m and 500 N-m respectively. If the combined shock and fatigue factor for bending is 1.5 and combined shock and fatigue factor for torsion i TES.19, Ans. (c) T. 2, then the equivalent twisting moment for the shat i UES-1994] (a) 2000N-m. (b) 2050N-m (©) 2100N-m (@) 2136 Nem (1.5 300)° + (21000) = 2136Nm TES-21, A member is subjected to the combined action of bending moment 400 Nm and torque 300 Nm. What respectively are the equivalent bending moment and TES.20. Ans. (@) T,, equivalent torque? [TES-1994; 2004] (a) 450 Nm and 500 Nm (0) 900 Nm and 350 Nav (©) 900 Nm and 500 Nm (2) 400 Nm and 500 Nv TES-21. Ans. (a) Equivalent Bending Moment(M,) = 4508 MsVME=T? _ 400+ 400" +300" 2 2 Equivalent torque (T,) = VF 1 = J400" + 300 = 500Nm TES22, A shaft was initially subjected to bending moment and then was subjected to torsion. If the magnitude of bending moment is found to be the same as that of the torque, then the ratio of maximum bending stress to shear stress would be: [ES-1993] (0.25 0.50 20 @40 TES-29. Ans. (e) Use equivalent bending moment formula, 1 ease: Equivalent bending moment (M,) = M 264 ease: Equivalent bending momentttAge}280of42%-—— OsOer 7 2 2Chapter-9 IES-23. Torsion SK Mondar's A shaft is subjected to simultaneous action of a torque T, bending moment M and an axial thrust F. Which one of the following statements is correct for this situation? [ES-2004] (@) One extreme end of the vertical diametral fibre is subjected to maximum compressive stress only (©) The opposite extreme end of the vertical diametral fibre is subjected to tensile/compressive stress only (©) Every point on the surface of the shaft is subjected to maximum shear stress only (@) Axial longitudinal fibre of the shaft is subjected to compressive stress only IES.23. Ans. (a) IBS-24. TES-24, Ans. (d) Bending Moment, M IES.25. IBS-25, Ans. (a) o = 922) IES.26. For obtaining the maximum shear stress, induced in the shaft shown in the given figure, the torque should be equal to (@T — (b)WI+T ony (22) «@ {ur} ar] 2 ES.1999) wh 2 Wt of Shaft: Wer Unit Length —_g Gear 1) Poraue Acting 7) I We of Gear: W I | w+ Bending moment M and torque is applied on a solid circular shaft. If the maximum bending stress equals to maximum shear stress developed, them M is, ‘equal to: [ES-1992] (@) = (©) 2r @ 47 32M A circular shaft is subjected to the combined action of bending, twisting and direct axial loading. The maximum bending stress 6, maximum shearing force 3c and a uniform axial stress o{compressive) are produced. The maximum compressive normal stress produced in the shaft will be: [ES-1998] (@30 20 oo (@) Zero IBS-26, Ans. (a) Maximum normal stress = bending stress 0 + axial stress (0) = 20 1ES.27. We have to take maximum bending stress o is (compressive) Which one of the following statements is correct? Shafts used in heavy duty speed reducers are generally suubjectediten UES-2004) (@) Bending stress onlyChapter-9 Torsion SK Mondal’s (©) Shearing stress only (© Combined bending and shearing stresses (® Bending, shearing and axial thrust simultaneously TES.27. Ans. (e) Comparison of Solid and Hollow Shafts THS.28, The ratio of torque carrying capacity of a solid shaft to that of a hollow shaft is given by: [TES-2008] (a(t-K*) w(K" (Kt (@isks Whar K-=2L; D+ Inde meter of ll shal dD, Ot oer li shat, Shafter ithe ame uaa sou sed bane roto so ia t = £_& = Z(0s-0") 1,” be oF zOey! TES29, A hollow shaft of outer dia 40 mm and inner dia of 20 mm is to be replaced by a solid shaft to transmit the same torque at the same maximum stress. What should be the diameter of the solid shaft? UES 2007) (@) 30mm (&) 35 mam (©) 10% (60)! mm (@) 10% (20)! mm TES-29. Ans. (c) Section modules will be same ah sor 0-2) on at ao ad 2 2 or, d= (10) x60. or d= 104/60 mm IES-30, ‘The diameter of a solid shaft is D. The i shaft of same material and length are —~ spectively. What is the ratio of the weight of the hollow shaft to that of the solid shaft? (TS 2007] @ia wrs3 12 1s 4D) D £2 Ph ixpxe wes.so, Aus, (wy We 2 AA 33D ED xLxpx Z PXE TES31, What is the maximum torque transmitted by a hollow shaft of external radius R and internal radius r? THES-2006] Kipp? 2 (pte (Rt R ) 2(R-P) sf, 0 Z(Rt-r4 © A(R-r), ws OER )L El ye oF )f oa (Jf, = maximum shear stress in the shaft material) TES-31. Ans. (b) £=© of T 2 20) (R=), Enea eR R aR i TES-32. A hollow shaft of the same cross-£@etiA&\“@¥ea and material as that of a solid shaft transmits: [TES-2005]Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondar's (a) Same torque (b) Lesser torque (©) More torque (@ Cannot be predicted without more data TES-82, Ans. (e) B= 21 where n= Du Ts nvn?=1 4, IES-38. The outside diameter of a hollow shaft is twice its inside diameter. The ratio of id shaft of the same material and the IGATE-1993; TES-2001] 1 1 > a es oF IES.83, IES-34, ‘Two hollow shafts of the same material have the same length and outside diameter. Shaft 1 has internal diameter equal to one-third of the outer diameter and shaft 2 has internal diameter equal to half of the outer diameter. If both the shafts are subjected to the same torque, the ratio of their twists 6, /O, will be equal to: ITES-1998] (@ 1681 (ser 1927 21ses6 ~_(d,/\ &{Y4) as TES. Ans. (@) Qoot- IES35. Maximum shear stress in a solid shaft of diameter D and length L twisted through an angle @ is x. A hollow shaft of same material and length having outside and inside diameters of D and D/2 respectively is also twisted through the same angle of twist 8. The value of maximum shear stress in the hollow shaft will be: [IES-1994; 1997] 1 8 4 “ b) = 2, d (a) 1s (b) $+ (4 (@r e535. Ans (@) TaS%02 or ¢2SR2 4 ots coats @ R and outer diameter seme in tth aoe eT Note ogi torque willbe diferent IES.26, A solid shaft of diameter 'D’ carries a twisting moment that develops maximum shear stress +. If the shaft is replaced by a hollow one of outside diameter 'D’ and inside diameter D/2, then the maximum shear stress will be: [IES-1994) (@) 1.067 v L148 4 (©) 1.3384 @2u it Tisconst ra + a IES.36. TES.87. A solid shaft of diameter 100 mupctingtls 1000 mm is subjected to a twisting moment 'T The maximum shear stress developed in the shaft is 60 Nimm*. A hole of 50 mm diameter is now drilled throughout the length of the shaft. ToChapter-9 Torsion SK Mondal’s develop a maximum shear stress of 60 Nimm* in the hollow shaft, the torque "T” must be reduced by: [ES-1998) on or oma ante rest. nn (op r,- 2-1 TMI, TIS Jord g—(d/2) T 16 L Reduction: 16 TES-38, Assertion (A): A hollow shaft will transmit a greater torque than a solid shaft of the same weight and same material. [ES-1994] Reason (R): The average shear stress in the hollow shaft is smaller than the average shear stress in the solid shai (a) Both A and R are individually true and Ris the correct explanation of A (b) Both A.and R are individually true but R'is NOT the correct explanation of A (6) Ais true but R is false @ Ais false but Ris true TES-88. Ans. (a) TES-89. A hollow shaft is subjected to torsion. The shear stress variation in the shaft slong the radius is given by: [ES-1996] follow shaft Parabolic (a) TES-39, Ans. (e) Shafts in Series TES-40, What is the total angle of twist of the stepped shaft subject to torque T 2g shown in figure given sbove? mK, 167, 387, @ 5 @ Oy 2 a (*r Gd" Gd" 647, [ES-2005] Shafts in Parallel IES-(1, For the two shafts connected in parallel, find which statement is true? (0) Torque in each shaft is the same [TES-1992] (b) Shear stress in each shaft is the same (©) Angle of twist of each shaft is the same (@ Torsional stiffness of each shaft is the same TES-41. Ans. (e) Page 2920428Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondar's IES-12, A circular section rod ABC is fixed at ends A and C. It is subjected to torque T at B, AB = BC=L and the polar moment of inertia of portions AB and BC are 2 Jand J respectively. If G is the modulus of rigidity, what is the angle of twist at point B? TES.2005} TL TL are S b @) © 56 o ( IBS-42, Ans. (a) A T c 2n, i B ee i 13 IES-43, A solid cireular rod AB of diameter D and length L is fixed at both ends. A torque T is applied at a section X such that AX = L/4 and BX = $L/4. What is the ‘maximum shear stress developed in the rod? TIES-2004] ler ir ar a os a oD D> oD TES-43, Ans. (b) A us 3u4 of T, = 97, or Ty = 3 toxdsT sar 03 IES-44, Two shafts are shown in e989 the above figure. These two shafts will be torsionally equivalent to each other if their (@) Polar moment of inertias are the same () Total angle of twists are the same (©) Lengths are the same (@ Strain energies ae the t1ns.1998) TES-14, Ans. (b) Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Torsion Equation IAS1, _Ansection. (A): In theory of tention, shearing strain inctwase radically sway from the longitudinal axis of thedyaze3 of 429, TIAS-2001] Boaton (R}: Plane tranaveree weetions belie loading remain plane after the torque is applied.Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondal’s (@) Both A and R are individually true and Ris the correct explanation of A (©) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (©) Ais true but R is false (@_ Ais false but Ris true TAS. Ans. (b) JAS-2, ‘The shear stress at a point in a shaft subjected to a torque is: AS-1995] (@) Directly proportional to the polar moment of inertia and to the distance of the point form the axis, () Directly proportional to the applied torque and inversely proportional to the polar moment of inertia, (©) Directly proportional to the applied torque and polar moment of inertia (@ inversely proportional to the applied torque and the polar moment of inertia T TAS.2. Ans. (b) OF R IAS.3, If two shafts of the same length, one of which is hollow, transmit equal torque and have equal maximum stress, then they should have equal. [AS-1994] (@) Polar moment of inertia (b) Polar modulus of section (6) Polar moment of inertia (@) Angle of twist 193 Ans 6) L= tt? & ra sans hs sme ple mt ction be same, Hollow Circular Shafts IAS4. A hollow circular shaft having outside diameter ‘D' and inside diameter ‘a’ subjected to a constant twisting moment 'T’ along its length. If the maximum. shear stress produced in the shaft is 0, then the twisting moment 'T’ is given by {1As-19901 wo, peak 8° Dp “pt 1.00.5 IAS4. Ans. (b) 5= = Ra) Torsional Rigidity IAS. Match List- with List-II and select the correct answer using the codes given helow the lists: [IAS-1996] List-I (Mechanical Properties) List-IT ( Characteristics) A. Torsional rigidity 1. Product of young’s modulus and second ‘moment of area about the plane of bending B. Modulus of resilience 2. Strain onorgy per unit volume ©. Bauschinger effect 3. Torque unit angle of twist D. Flexural rigidity 4. Lose of mechanical energy due to local yielding Codess A BC D A B Cc D @ 1 3 4 2 ® 8 2 4 21 @ 2 4 + 38 @ 8 1 4 2 IAS. Ans. (b) TAS, Assertion (A): Angle of twist per unit length of uniform diameter shaft depends upon its torsional rigidity. (AS-2004] Reason (R)The shafts are subjectga t oxiy, {i Bol A and ore sulidualy WoO ets art eplansion ot (Both Aand ave individually true but Ris NOT the correct explanation of AChapter-9 Torsion SK Mondar's (©) Ais true but Ris false (@) Ais false but Ris true IAS. Ans. (c) Combined Bending and Torsion 1AS-7, A shaft is subjected to a bending moment M = 400 N.m alld torque T = 300 Nam ‘The equivalent bending smmiment ie HAS-2003] @) 900. 0) 700 Nm (500 N.m (@s30Nm IAS-7. Ans. (d) Me MAAMENT AOE EO, au +300 450Nm 2 Comparison of Solid and Hollow Shafts TASS, A hollow shaft of length I is fixed at its both ends. It is subjected to torque T at a distance of £ from one end. What is the reaction torgue atthe other end of the shaft? [1As-2007] ot wet of @t OF "9 3 a TASS. Ans. (c) Bs T 1AS-9. A solid shaft of diameter d is replaced by a hollow shaft of the same material and length. The outside diameter of hollow shaft # while the inside diameter a is “. What is the ratio of the torsional stiffness of the hollow shaft to that of 3B 2 3 5 all) 0) LK zy 3 32 IAS.10, Two steel shafts, one solid of diameter D and the other hollow of outside diameter D and inside diameter D/2, are twisted to the same angle of twist per unit length. The ratio of maximum shear stress in solid shaft to that in the hollow shaft is: [AS-1998] te w Se ose @r 9 7 15 FES or 72 OR as outside diameter of shaft is D so ris 18.10, Ans. (@) T=£=S2 oy = SO ‘side diameter of both the shaft is D ‘same for both the cases. Page 2980428Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondal’s Shafts in Series IAS-11, Two shafts having the same length and material are joined in series. If the ratio of the diameter of the first shaft to that of the second shaft is 2, then the ratio of the angle of twist of the first shaft to that of the second shaft is: [IAS-1995; 2003] @i6 ws 4 @2 1AS.AL. Ans (a) Anglo of twist is proportional to 40 IAS.12, A circular shaft fixed at A has diameter D for half of its length and diameter Diz over the other half, What is the rotation of C relative of B if the rotation of B relative to A is 0.1 radian? [AS-1994] (0) 0.4 radian (6) 0.8 radian (©) 16 radian (8.2 radian A B ce > be 2 ole — 2 (1,L and C remaining same in both cases) or @=1.6 radian a1 @ay Shafts in Parallel TAS.18, A stepped solid circular shaft shown in the given figure is built-in at its ends and is subjected to a torque Ts at the shoulder section. The ratio of reactive torque T; and Ts at the ends is (Ji and Jz are polar moments of inertia): bes oe 1, ot n¢ > THAS-2001] 1AS-13, Ans. (e) or TAS.14, Steel shaft and brass shaft of same length and diameter are connected by a flange coupling. The assembly is rigidity held at its ends and is twisted by a torque through the coupling. Modulus of rigidity of steel is twice that of brass. If torque of the steel shaft is 500 Nm, then the value of the torque in brass shaft will be: TTAS-2007] (@250Nm 0) 354. Nm (0.500Nm (@ 708 Nm TAS4, Ans @) 0,=0,0r te Thy ork Ge. Z_a50Nm ai G. ri 2 TAS5. A steel shaft with bult-in ends is subjected to the action of a torque Mt applied st an intermediate cross-section ‘mu! ag shown in the given figure. [1AS-1997]Chapter-9 SK Mondar's Assertion (A): The magnitude of the twisting moment to which the portion BC is subjected is “4 a+b Reason(R): For geometric compatibility, angle of twist at 'mn' is the same for the portions AB and BC. (a) Both A and R are individually true and Ris the correct explanation of A (@) Both A and Rare individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (©) Aistrue but Ris false (@ Ais false but Ris true IAS-15, Ans. (a) 1AS-16, 1AS-16. Ans.(b) 0, = 8, oF A steel shaft of outside diameter 100 mm is solid over one half of its length and hollow over the other half. Inside diameter of hollow portion is 50 mm. The shaft if held rigidly at two ends and a pulley is mounted at its midsection ie., at ‘the junction of solid and hollow portions. The shaft is twisted by applying torque on the pulley. If the torque carried by the solid portion of the shaft is 16000kg-m, then the torque carried by the hollow portion of the shaft will be: [TAS-1997] (100° — 50° Ft00*) T Th Page 297 of 420Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondal’s Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question IES 2010 Q Ans. A hollow steel rod 200 mm long is to be used as torsional spring. The ratio of inside to outside diameter is 1: 2. The required stiffness of this spring is 100 Nam /degree. Determine the outside diameter of the rod. Value of G is 8x10" Nimm?. [10 Marks} Length of a hollow steel rod = 200mm Ratio of inside to outside diameter= 1: 2 Stiffness of torsional spring = 100 Nm /degree Rigidity of modulus (G) = 8x10" N J mm? Find outside diameter of rod :- We know that T_GO 729.578 N mlrad Where T = Torque 4 polar moment @ = twist angle in rad L ength of rod diag gpa x8 8104 10°N/m? 5729.578Nm J rad = xd} x15 02 32 5729.578x.2%32 _ “8x10 xnx15 93x10 m. 93mm. 9.93 19.86mm Ans. Conventional Question GATE - 1998 Question: Answer, A component used in the Mars pathfinder can be idealized as a circular bar clamped at its ends. The bar should withstand a torque of 1000 Nm The component is assembled on earth when the temperature is 30°C. Temperature on Mars at the site of landing is -70°C. The material of the bar has an allowable shear stress of 300 MPa and its young's modulus is 200 GPa. Design the diameter of the bar taking a factor of safety of 1.5 and assuming a coefficient of thermal expansion for the material of the bar as 12 x 10-4PC. Given: Page 2080428Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondar's 70°C; Targntie = 300MPA 12x10" °C Trax =1000Nm; te = 30°C; ty E=200GPa, FOS=15, « Diameter of the bar,D Change in length, dL = L « At, where L = original length. m. ‘Change in lengthat Mars = Lx1210* x[30-(-70)]=12*10"L meters Change in length _12«10“L ‘original length L ,, = axial stress = E xlinearstrain = 200 10° x12 «10° From maximum shear stress equation. we have Linear strain =12x107 2.4 10°N/m’ where, Tac 00MPa FOS 15 ‘Substituting the values, we get 4x10" = (eaey +(12x10°) or 181000 oa 16x1000 \* o0-( Son] =1.6x10° .03169 m=31.69 mm Conventional Question IES-2009 Q@ Ans, In a torsion test, the specimen is a hollow shaft with 50 mm external and 30 mm internal diameter. An applied torque of 1.6 kN-m is found to produce an angular twist of 0.4° measured on a length of 0.2 m of the shaft. The Young's modulus of elasticity obtained from a tensile test has been found to be 200 GPa, Find the values of Modulus of rigidity. Gi) Poisson's ratio. [10-Marks] We have T_t_Ge work ‘Where J = polar moment of inertia Rpt _at wl? -a‘) = 5 (50° -30') x10" 838x107 .6 KN ~m=1.6x10" Nom e= 04" 1=0.2m E=200 x 10° Nim* Ge L From equation (i) Page 299 of 428Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondal’s 3 Gxfoaxt saat__ 6*[*4* ih 1 5.338 x1077 0.2 x10" Ode xx 5.3981 =85.92 GPa We also have E G(l+y) 4: 200 = 2 x 85.92 (1+) 3 l+v=1.164 = v=0.164 2G Conventional Question IAS - 1996 Question: A solid circular uniformly tapered shaft of length T, with a small angle of taper is subjected to a torque T. The diameter at the two ends of the shaft are D and 1.2 D. Determine the error introduced of its angular twist for a given Jength is determined on the uniform mean diameter of the shaft. Answer: For shat of tapering’ section, we have =2TL[RE+RR, +Ri| _32TL(D? +DD, +0: 3Gr| RE 3Gz D:D; gate [(12) +12<1+(1" ee D,=D and D,=1.20] Sh (1.2) «(1 t 1 32m "se" 2.1065 Now, , or 2TL,[9(0-10)']_ gare, 3 327.» cao 3Gr | (Ly | 3Gz *(12)'D* 3620 Error= 20" _ 2 1065= 2.049 _ 9 0973 or 2.73% 2.1085 Conventional Question ESE-2008 Question: A hollow shaft and a solid shaft construction of the same material have the same length and the same outside radius. The inside radius of the hollow shaft is 0.6 times of the outside radius, Both the shafts are subjected to the same torque. @ What is the ratio of maximum shes solid shaft? Gi) What is the ratio of angle of twist in the hollow shaft to that of solid shaft? stress in the hollow shaft to that of Solution: Inside radius (r) ” Sor side R08 aNd T. =T =T ER gives ; For hollow shaft (r,) = — (R*—r') Give ane 0048Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondar's TR x ZR 2 and for solid shaft (7. 9, Therefore = pez os Conventional Question ESE-2006: Question: Two hollow shafts of same diameter are used to transmit same power. One shaft is rotating at 1000 rpm while the other at 1200 rpm. What will be the nature and magnitude of the stress on the surfaces of these shafts? Will it be the same in two cases of different? Justify your answer. Answer: We know power transmitted (P) = Torque (T) rotation speed (.) PD, nesinarenssey TEE Pe ‘Teofore 7 5 as P Dand date constant So the shaft rotating at 1000 xpm will experience greater stress then 1200 rpm shaft. Conventional Question ESE-2002 Question: A.5 em diameter solid shaft is welded to a flat plate by 1 em filled weld. What will be the maximum torque that the welded joint can sustain if the permissible shear stress in the weld material is not to exceed 8 kNiem*? Deduce the expression for the shear stress at the throat from the basic theory. Answer: Consider a cixeular shaft connected to a plate by means of a fillet joint as shown in figure. If the shat is subjected to a torque, shear stress develops in the weld. ‘Assuming that the weld thickness is very small compared to the diameter of the shaft, the maximum shear stress oceurs in the throat area. Thus, for a given torque ‘the maximum shear stress in the weld is Where = Torque applied. outer diameter of the shaft throat thickness lar moment of area of the throat Page 201 of 420Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondal’s [As t <<] then Tra Given & t=tem=0.1m =80MPa=80%10°N/ mi? 142kNm 2 Conventional Question ESE-2000 Question: Answer: The ratio of inside to outside diameter of a hollow shaft is 0.6, If there is a solid shaft with same torsional strength, what is the ratio of the outside diameter of hollow shaft to the diameter of the equivalent solid shat. Tet D=external diameter of hollow shaft So d=0.6D internal diameter of hollow shaft And D.=diameter of solid shaft From torsion equation (0.80)*) rx 32—______torhollow sha Se rornotiow snet =p! ane ret9.2 sp 58s coewomaanen A so? tye BD D4 (0.81) = 7 223 angi. 3 Conventional Question ESE-2001 Question: Answer: A cantilever tube of length 120 mm is subjected to an axial tension P= 9.0 kN, A torsional moment T = 72.0 Nm and a pending Load F = 1.75 KN at the free end. The material is aluminum alloy with an yield strength 276 MPa. Find the thickness of the tube limiting the outside diameter to 50 mm. so as to ensure a factor of safety of 4. Polar moment of inertia (J) =2aRt = a Page 2020428Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondal's TR_1_ 1D _ oF 2x72___ 18936 J 2s 5 aD t adit ex(0.050Fxt ain 9000 9000 _ 57296 A” xdt ~ x(0.060)t ft Direct stress (6, Md, Maximum bending stress (c, Es NZ, Me v=2) 1750%0.120%0.050.4 _ 106952 xx (0.080)°t t Total longitudinal stress («,) = 0, +0, = 184248 t Maximum principal stress Soy oe) 2 164248 ‘erzan), (908) 276 x10" 2 2 at 2t t 4 or,t=2.4x10"'m =2.4mm Conventional Question ESE-2000 & ESE 2001 Question: Answer: A hollow shaft of diameter ratio 3/8 required to transmit 600 kW at 110 rpm, the maximum torque being 20% greater than the mean. The shear stress is, not to exceed 63 MPa and the twist in a length of 3 m not to exceed 14 degrees. Determine the diameter of the shaft. Assume modulus of rigidity for the shaft material as 84 GN/m?. Let d= internal diameter of the hollow shaft ‘And D = external diameter of the hollow shaft (given) d= 3/8 D=0.375D Power (P= 600 kW, speed (N) =110 rpm, Shear stress(}= 63 MPa. Angle of twist (0 JP1.4*, Length (() =3m , modulus of rigidity (G)= 84GPa oN 60 60x P _ 60%(600%10") 2aN 2xnxt10 Tyg, = 12% T = 1252087 =62504 Nm First we consider that shear stress is not to exceed 63 MPa We know that, (P) =P. = [Tis average torque] or T= 52087Nm. ae iain EE orp aTh TD T 2r 62504%D or £[D* -(0375D)']= 32 2x(63x10°) or D=0.172Tm=172.Imm——~~{i) Second we consider angle of twist is not exceed 1.4” VIX tian Page 2030420Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondal’s G8 mavenanae tO sili : oh 0 62504 x3 axis 5 weir] or D=0.1755m =175.5mm— (ii) So both the condition will satisfy if greater of the two value is adopted 0 D=175.5 mm Conventional Question ESE-1997 Question: Determine the torsional stiffness of a hollow shaft of length L and having outside diameter equal to 1.5 times inside diameter d. The shear modulus of the material is G. Answer: — Quiside diameter (D) =1.5 4 ee ee Polar modulus of the shaft (J) = —(D* —d’ US 1 a= 5 )=Haas'—p We know that = 1 =? RoL Goa". (6 or =o On Bees Conventional Question AMIE-1996 Question: ‘The maximum normal stress and the maximum shear stress analysed for a shaft of 150 mm diameter under combined bending and torsion, were found to be 120 MN/m? and 80 MNim! respectively. Find the bending moment and torque to which the shaft is subjected. If the maximum shear stress be limited to 100 MNim#, find by how much the torque can be increased if the bending moment is kept constant. Answer: Given: dng, = 120MN/M*; Fg, = BOMN /m?:d = 150mm = 0.1m. Part-1: MT We know that for combined bending and torsion, we have the following expressions: le iF] ) ad and gy = 28 [AES ‘Substituting the given values in the above equations, we have es " Sia | -— ---(iv) aoe oar eT = B08FAO15) og o5_ Page 204 of 420 (v)Chapter-9 Torsion SK Mondal's ‘Substituting this values in equation 120-6 _ *(0.150") M=0.0265MNm_ [m+0.053] ‘Substituting for M in equation(v), we have ((0.0265)' +1" =0.053 or T=0.0459MNm Part i [pas = 100MN J?) Increase in torque Bending moment (M) to be kept cons tant = 0.0265MNm = 0.004391 or (0.0256)' vf feeeagossr) 16 T=0.0607 MNm The increased torque = 0.0807 - 0.0459 = 0.0148MNm. Conventional Question ESE-1996 Question: A solid shaft is to transmit 300 KW at 120 rpm. If the shear stress is not to exceed 100 MPa, Find the diameter of the shaft, What percent saving in weight would be obtained if this shaft were replaced by a hollow one whose internal diameter equals 0.6 of the external diameter, the length, material and maximum allowable shear stress being the same? Answer: Given P=300 kW, N= 120 rpm, 7=100 MPa, d,, =0.6D,, Diameter of solid shaft, Di ip , Welknow that P= 287 gy ggg = 22812047" yy 7293873 Nm 01000 601000 We know that 7 = 7 JOR or, D.= 0.1067 m =106.7mm Percentage saving in weight: Page 208 of 428Torsion SK Mondal’s (0.60,)* _ ps Dd, : D. 106.7 Dy ae = ° Yrr06) Vi-0.64 =111.8mm (228) 0.97 = 0.702 106.7 Percentage savings in weignta|i-¥e}. 100 = (1-0.702)*100 = 29.8% Page 206 of 428Page 207 of 428Thin Cylinder Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 1. Thin Rings Uniformly distributed loading (radial) may be due to either ‘+ Internal pressure or external pressure ‘© Centrifugal force as in the case of a rotating ring Case-I: Internal pressure or external pressure © s=ar Where q= Intensity of loading in kg/em of O* 1 =Mean contreline of radius ‘= circumferential tension or hoop’s tension (Radial loading ducted outward) * Unitstress, 0-5 = © aA © Circumferential strain, ¢, AE + Diametral strain, (¢, ) = Circumferential strain, (€, ) Case-I: Centrifugal foree wor? ‘+ Hoop's Tension, ¢ Where w = wt. per unit length of circumferential element @ = Angular velocity ‘+ Radial loading, © Hoop's stress, o = 2. Thin Walled Pressure Vessels For thin cylinders whose thickness may be considered small compared to their diameter. Inner dia of the cylinder (d,) wall thickness(t) >15 0r20 Page 2080428Chapter-10 Thin Cylinder ‘SK Mondat's 3. General Formula G42-2 RoR Ft Where 0) =Meridional stress at A o =Circumforential / Hoop's stress Intensity of internal gas pressure/ fluid pressure {t= Thickness of pressure vessel 4. Some cases: Gylindrical vessel a Scio eee 2 4 & Spherical vessel «<0, 22 lt 4t © Conical vessel /< _—e PYRE, oc) and ay i jh \. Notes: — ei * Volume 'V’ of the spherical shell, V- ma-(8y Design of thin cylindrical shells is based on hoop's stress 5. Volumetric Strain (Dilation) + mocap Ee, 6, 6 + Oylindrical pressure vessel a pr € Longitudinal strain = 2 — 2 — P" [241 * EME 2g 2d €,=Cireumferential strain Pr BM Edel 2A] : av pr pd ‘olumetrie Strain, me, 4+2e,=—P™ [5 dy] = ps4 omer Stn, =e, #Des= oS Al ISA) i.e. Volumetric strain,(<,) = longitudinal strain(<,) +2» circumferential strain (=, © Spherical vessels Page 2090 428Chapter-to Thin Cylinder SK Mondal's AV _y__3er 3-H Y ze Al 6. Thin cylindrical shell with hemispherical end Condition for no distortion at the junction of cylindrical and hemispherical portion ae Where, = wall thicknes ofelindricl portion Baw t= wal thickness of hemisphevieal portion 7. Alternative method Consider the equilibrium of forces in the z-direction acting on the part cylinder shown in figure. Force due to internal pressure p acting on area 7 D/A =p. # D#/4 Foree due to longitudinal stross sL. acting on area Dt o,2Dt Equating: p. #D24= 0,2 Dt pd _pr Oa Ot Now consider the equilibrium of forces in the x-direction acting on the sectioned cylinder shown in figure, It is assumed that the circumferential stress @, is constant through the thickness of the cylinder. Foree due to internal pressure p acting on area Dz= pDz Forve due to circumferential stress o, acting on area 2tz= o,2tz Equating: pDz=o, 212 pD _ pr at or Page 3100420Chapter-10 Thin Cylinder SK Mondal's OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Longitudinal stress GATE, ‘The maximum principal strain in a thin cylindrical tank, having a radius of 25 ‘em and wall thickness of 5 mm when subjected to an internal pressure of IMPa, is (taking Young's modulus as 200 GPa and Poisson's ratio as 0.2) [GATE-1998] (225 10" (225 (9225 104 @» GATE-1. Ans. (a) Circumferential or Hoop stress (0, nee 5OMPa Longitudinal nn (a) = = 26§Pa 0, =e ph SOHO gg, 251995 x40 EE” 200x107" 200%10 Maximum shear stress GATE2, A thin walled cylindrical vessel of well thickness, t and diameter d is fitted with gas to a gauge pressure of p. The maximum shear stress on the vessel wall will then be: IGATE-1999], (a) 2 (a : & wns. (@) 0, = GATE. Ans. () 0, = e Change in dimensions of a thin cylindrical shell due to an internal pressure Statement for Linked Answers and Questions 3 and 4 A cylindrical container of radius R = 1 m, wall thickness 1 mm is filled with water up to a depth of 2 m and suspended along its upper rim. The density of water is 1000 kg/m! and acceleration due to gravity is 10 mist. The self weight of the cylinder is negligible. The formula for hoop stress in a thin-walled cylinder ean be used at all points along the height of the cylindrical ae a IGATE-2008} GATE-S. The axial and circumferential stress (0,,,) experienced by the cylinder wall at mid-depth (1 mas shown) are (@) (10,10) MPa (0) (6,10) MPa (0005) MPa @G65Mra GATE. Ans. (a) Pressure (P)= hp ¢= 1100010 = 10 kPa Axial Stross (¢1,)=>07, x2aRt = pg x AR? L = PERL _1000%10 11 _ or 9, “11 _1oMPa t lo PR ees kira Circumferential Stress( o_)= ers)Chapter-10 Thin Cylinder SK Mondal’s GATE-4, If the Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio of the container material are 100 GPa and 0.3, respectively, the axial strain in the cylinder wall at mid-depth i (a) 2% 10 (6) 6x 105 (7 105 (@) 12x 108 109310 EE 00x10" 100x107 GATE-4. Ans. (©) &, =7x107 Previous 20-Years IES Questions Circumferential or hoop stress IES, Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer: [IES-2002] List List (2D Stress system loading) {Ratio of principal stresses) A. Thin cylinder under internal pressure 1.3.0 B. Thin sphere underinternal pressure 2.1L. ©. Shaft subjected to torsion a -10 4.20 Codes A BC A B ¢ @ 4 2 3 @® 1 38 2 © 4 3 2 @ 1 2 3 TES-1, Ans. (a) IES2. A thin cylinder of radius r and thickness t when subjected to an internal hydrostatic pressure P causes a radial displacement u, then the tangential strain caused is: TES-2002] du L du u 2u io (b) © a) st oF of ws TES.2, Ans. (e) IES-3. A thin cylindrical shell is subjected to internal pressure p. The Poisson's ratio of the material of the shell is 0.3. Due to internal pressure, the shell is subjected strain to TES-2001] (a) 0.425 2.25 (0225 @ 425 Ce -8. Ans, (d) Circumferential strain, €, = 22 — i= PE (g— TRS. Ans. (4) Cirvumforential strain, @, = FEF = FE (2- xm) Longitudinal strain, € TES4. A thin cylindrical shell of diameter d, length ‘T and thickne: tis subjected to an internal pressure p. What is the ratio of longitudinal strain to hoop strain in [TES-2004] 2m+2 @ Page 3120429Chapter-10 Thin Cylinder SK Mondar's IES‘. hoop stress (o, When a thin cylinder of diameter ‘d’ and thickness 't’ is pressurized with an internal pressure of 'p', (I/m = 11 is the Poisson's ratio and E is the modulus of clasticity), then [IES-1998] pel 1a f) The circumferential strain will be equal to 4 ® a ue \2 mi Sl") ) The longitudinal strain will be equal to P4{ ° et? EU lm (©The longitudinal stress will be equal to 2 (@) ‘The ratio of the longitudinal strain to circumferential strain will be equal to 2m-1 IES-5. Ans. (d) Ratio of longitudinal strain to circumferential strain IES, A thin cylinder contains fluid at a pressure of 500 Nim?, the internal diameter of the shell is 0.6 m and the tensile stress in the material is to be limited to 9000 \Nim#. The shell must have a minimum wall thickness of nearly TES.2000] @ 9mm © 1mm ©17 mm @21 mm TES-6. Ans. (c) IES-7, A thin cylinder with closed lids is subjected to internal pressure and supported at the ends as shown in figure. ‘The state of stress at point X is as represented in ox rr [ES-1999] @ | © | @ CAL AL [reste 7 +Chapter-10 Thin Cylinder SK Mondal’s TES-7. Ans. (a) Point 'X’ is subjected to circumferential and longitudinal stress, ie. tension on all ‘faces, but there i no shear stress because vessel is supported freely outside, TES. A thin cylinder with both ends closed is subjected to internal pressure p. The longitudinal stress at the surface has been calculated as oy, Maximum shear stress at the surface will be equal to: [TES-1999] (a)2o, (b) 150, (Jo, (4) 050, TESS. Ans. (€) Longitudinal stress =o, and hoop stress = 20, Max. shear stress =~! TES-9. A metal pipe of Im diameter contains a fluid having a pressure of 10 kgf/em*. If is 200 kgfiem?, then the thickness of the permissible tensile stress in the meta the metal required for making the pipe would be: (ES-1993] oem See am stm wes2.ans op sess = 2 gto oy aa TES.0. Circumferential stress in a cylindrical steel boiler shell under internal pressure is 80 MPa. Young's modulus of elasticity and Poisson's ratio are respectively 2 x 10% MPa and 0.28. The magnitude of cireumferential strain in the boiler shell will be: TIES-1999] at 10 3.84% 104 (4x 104 4.56 %10-+ TES-10, Ans. (a) Circumferential stra Le, -10,) Since circumferential stress 6, = 80 MPa and longitudinal stress 0 = 40 MPa ircumnferential strain = ———' [80 -0.28 40] 10° = 3.44 x10" 2x10 x10" TES.11. A penstock pipe of 10m diameter carries water under a pressure head of 100 m. If the wall thickness is 9 mm, what is the tensile stress in the pipe wall in MPa? ts 00 Where, P = pgH = 980000N/ m? Tonsie sess» 800000 4g a4st0TWint= S44 4M = 48 4aPa TES.12, A water main of 1 m diameter contains water at a pressure head of 100 metres. ‘The permissible tensile stress in the material of the water main is 25 MPa. What is the minimum thickness of the water main? (Take = 10 m/s"). TES: 2009] @) 10mm © 20mm (50mm @ 0mm TES-12. Ans. (b) Pressure in the main = pgh = 1000101000 = 10° N/mm* = 1000 KPa Hoop stress = «, = 24 Pp =.= oF Pa (0) 4 20mm 20, 2x25x10° 50 Page 3140428Chapter-10 Thin Cylinder ‘SK Mondal's Longitudinal stress IES-13. Hoop stress and longitudinal stress in a boiler shell under internal pressure are 100 MN/m? and 50 MN/m? respectively. Young's modulus of elasticity and Poisson's ratio of the shell material are 200 GN/m? and 0.3 respectively. The hoop strain in boiler shell is: [ES-1995} (@) 0.425107 (60.5 x10" ©0585 «107 (a)0.75 «10° [100-0.3:50]= 0.425107 TES-13. Ans. (a) Hoopstrain zl 4 H0;) = 2001000 IES-14. In strain gauge dynamometers, the use of how many active gauge makes the dynamometer more effective? TIES 2007] (@) Four (0) Three (© Two (@ One IBS-14. Ans. (b) Volumetric strain TES-15, Circumferential and longitudinal strains in a cylindrical boiler under internal steam pressure are ¢, and ¢, respectively. Change in volume of the boiler cylinder per unit volume will be: [IES-1993; IAS 2003] (a) +28, (b)ee (c)26, +8, (det. TES-15, Ans, (c) Volumetric stream = 2 x circumferential strain + longitudinal strain TES.16. Tho volumetric strain in case of a thin cylindrical shell of diameter d thickness t, subjected to internal pressure p is: [IES-2003; IAS 1997] pd pd pd pd a) (3-2) ow PE (4-3 @ PA (say) Ph (A-sy © xe a) xe | “) © ve | i“) © 16 ) (Vere K = Modus of elasticity. n= Poisson's ratio forthe shell materia IES-16, Ans, (¢) Remember Spherical Vessel TES.17. For the same internal diameter, wall thickness, material and internal pressure, the ratio of maximum stress, induced in a thin cylindrical and in a thin spherical pressure vessel will be: [ES.2001] we wu oA (aa IES-17. Aus. (a) IES.18, From design point of view, spherical pressure vessels are preferred over cylindrical pressure vessels because they HES-19971 (a) Ave cost effective in fabrication () Have uniform higher ci (©) Uniform lower circumferential stress (@)_ Have a larger volume for the same quantity of material used TES-18. Ans. (4) cumferential stress Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Circumferential or hoop stress JAS-1. The ratio of circumferential stress to longitudinal stress in a thin cylinder subjected to internal hydrostatic pressure is: TAS 1994] @ir () 1 Page 31s0r429 (0) 2 @4 IAS-1, Ans. (e)Chapter-10 Thin Cylinder SK Mondal’s IAS2. A thin walled water pipe carries water under a pressure of 2 Nimm! and discharges water into a tank. Diameter of the pipe is 25 mm and thickness is 2-5 mm. What is the longitudinal stress induced in the pipe? AS-2007] @o )2.Nimmt (05 Nimm? @ 10 Nimm# TAS2. Ans. (€) = 2 = 28125 _ 5 Nim? 2x25 IAS. A thin cylindrical shell of mean diameter 750 mm and wall thickness 10 mm has 's ends rigidly closed by flat steel plates. The shell is subjected to internal fluid pressure of 10 Nimm? and an axial external pressure Pi. If the longitudinal stress in the shell is to be zero, what should be the approximate value of Pi? THAS-2007] (@) 8Nimm? (©) 9 Nimm? (© 10Némm? (@) 12 Nimm? we TAS.3. Ans. (c) Tensile longitudinal stross due to internal fhid pressuse (5) «= —S——4 2 @ * " (065 575010 tensile. Compressive longitudinal stress due to external pressure pi (0 De = ax ( ax is —* compressive. For zer0 longitudinal stress (6 9) .= (5 exT50=10 = TAS-4. Assertion (A): A thin cylindrical shell is subjected to internal fluid pressure that induces a 2-D stress state in the material along the longitudinal and circumferential directions. TAS-2000] Reason(R): The circumferential stress in the thin cylindrical shell is two times the magnitude of longitudinal stress. (@) Both A.and R are individually true and Ris the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R'is NOT the correct explanation of A (Ais true but R is false (@ Ais false but Ris true Pr u TAS-4. Ans. (b) For thin cell &, IAS.5, Match ListI (Terms used in thin cylinder stress analysis) with ListII (Mathematical expressions) and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: TAS-1998] List List A. Hoop stress 1. palit B. Maximum shear stress 2 pale €. Longitudinal stress 3 palo D. Cylinder thickness 4. pais Codess A BoC D A B Cc D @ 2 3 1 4 @ 2 8 4 4 O22 4 8 1 @ 2 4 1 8 TASS. Ans. (€) Longitudinal stress JAS-6. Assertion (A): For a thin cylinder under internal pressure, At least three strain gauges is needed to know the stref#@tdl€éiipletely at any point on the shell.Chapter-10 Thin Cylinder SK Mondar's Reason (R): If the principal stresses directions are not know, the minimum. number of strain gauges needed is three in a biaxial field. [148-2001] (@) Both A and Rare individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (@) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (©) Aistrue but Ris false (@ Ais false but Ris true TAS-6, Ans. (d) For thin cylinder, variation of radial strain ie zero, So only cireumferential and longitudinal strain has to measurer so only two strain gauges are needed. Maximum shear stress IAS7, The maximum shear stress is induced in a thin-walled cylindrical shell having an internal diameter 'D' and thickness't’ when subject to an internal pressure 'p' is equal to: [TAS-1996] G@) pDn ©) pret ppite (@ pis IAS-7, Ans, (d) Hoop stress(o,) a4. Volumetric strai 1AS-8, Circumferential and longitudinal strains in a cylindrical boiler under internal steam pressure are 6, and 6, respectively. Change in volume of the boiler cylinder per unit volume will be: [TES-1993; 1AS 2003] (ays, +26, (bye (©)26, +8, Weze, IAS-8. Ans. (c) Volumetric stream = 2 x circumferential strain + longitudinal strain. 1AS9, ‘The volumetric strain in case of a thin cylindrical shell of diameter d, thickness + subjected to internal pressure p is: [TES-2003; IAS 1997] @) Sry) PL (4-3 @ Pt (5-4 a) PE (4—syp @ FFG) OFE-3) OTE (-4H) MT A-5u) (Whore E = Modulus of elasticity, » = Poiscon's ratio for the sholl material) TAS.9. Ans. (c) Remember it IAS.10. A thin cylinder of diameter ‘d’ and thickne pressure 'p' the change in diameter is (where E ‘tis subjected to an internal the modulus of elasticity and pis the Poisson's ratio) [1AS-1998) @ ey w2Ha e 2 (@) ‘ME Hw) FE +H) © @ ME 2+ 4) TAS-10. Ans. (a) IAS-11. The percentage change in volume of a thin cylinder under internal pressure having hoop stress = 200 MPa, E = 200 GPa and Poisson's ratio = 0-25 is: TAS.2002] (@) 0.40 (030 © 025 020 Pr 1 TAS.11. Ans. (@) Hoop stress(¢,) 200x10°P, Page 317 0f428Chapter-10 Thin Cylinder SK Mondal’s Volumetric strain (e, Fi(S-4u) 440.28) =795 IAS-12, A round bar of length J, elastic modulus E and Poisson's ratio yt is subjected to an axial pull 'P", What would be the change in volume of the bar? {1AS-2007] PL Pl, Pl PL @ —_ PIC?) oF @— (-2E E E HE TAS-12. Ans. (b) pe{) EP 2, P +6, +6, = 22(1-24) =—(I-2, or 6, =6, +6, +6, = (I-24) = —(I-2n) PL Al= = (1-2) 26,0 TAS.13, Ifa block of material of length 25 em. breadth 10 em and height 5 em undergoes a volumetric strain of 1/5000, then change in volume will be: TAS-2000] (2) 0.50 em? (6) 0.20 em" (4) 0.75 em TAS.A3. Ans. (b) Volume change(6V) Volumetricstrain(s, ) Initial volume(V) 1 x25x10%5=0.2Sem" or (80) =6, x" (hes, 5000 Page 318 of 420Chapter-10 Thin Cylinder SK Mondar's Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question GATE-1996 Question: A thin cylinder of 100 mm internal diameter and 5 mm thickness is subjected to an internal pressure of 10 MPa and a torque of 2000 Nm. Calculate the magnitudes of the principal stresses. Answer: Given: d= 100 mm =0.1 m;t=5 mm = 0.005 m; 0.11 mp=10MPa, 10 x 10°Nim#; T= 2000 Nem pd _ 10x10" x0.1 4t 40.005 10x10" x0. 2t-2x0.005 ‘To find the shear stress, using Torsional equation, =d+2t= 142 0.005 = Longitudinal stress, 6, = 0, (0 10°N/ mi? = SOMN J m? Cireumforential stress, 0, =o, = 100MN Im? .we have R__TsR = 70000050008) 3 sayin? Zlo-t) — Z(o.1t-01) Principal stresses are: +o [ 50+100 (= 2 Wo 2 =75 34,75 = 109.75 and 40.25MN/m? c,, (Major principal stress) = 109.75MN/m?; (minor principal stress) = 40.25MN/m"; y + (24.147 Conventional Question IES-2008 Question: A thin cylindrical pressure vessel of inside radius ‘r’ and thickness of metal ‘t is subject to an internal fluid pressure p. What are the values of () Maximum normal stress! ii) Maximum shear stress? Anawer: —Cireumferontnl (Hoop) stross(, pr 2t Longitudinal stress (7) "Therefore (ii) Maximum shear stress, (7 wus) = Conventional Question IES-1996 Question: A thin cylindrical vessel of internal diameter d and thickness t is closed at both ends is subjected to an internal pressure P. How much would be the hoop and longitudinal stress Answer: For thineylinder we know that in the material? Page 3190428Chapter-10 Thin Cylinder SK Mondal’s Pd Heo iene sire (6,)= 22 ° )-% An ogi e(,)= 2 4 ‘Therefore 6, = 20, Conventional Question IES-2009 a Ans. Accylindrical shell has the following dimensi Length = 3m Inside diameter = 1m Internal pressure = 1.5 MPa Caleulate the change in dimensions of the shell and the maximum intensity of shear stress induced. Take E= 200 GPa and Poisson's ratio V=0.3. —_[15-Marks} We ean consider this as a thin eylinder, pd Hoop stresses, 6 or 2 Longitudinal stresses, 6, 1-8 2 =Pd "st Hence from the given data 1.51081 2x10x10~ =75 MPa _ 1.510" x1 4x10x10 Shear stres 0.75 x 10° oe =37.5x10° =37.5 MPa 8, Hoop strain 1 41 = 5 (01 - vor) = Pa (e_y) 4 1.5x108 x1 att (2-089) Taro w10 nao ( sx108 375210 (g 200% 10° = 0.31875 x10 aa d change in diameter, Ad = 1 « 0.31875 «107% m = 0.31875 mm ) 0.3) 8187 x10 Page 2200428Chapter-10 Thin Cylinder Logitudinal strain, 6 «= PA (20) 237.5% 10° 20010" 7.5%10% (1-2x0.3) Maasx10% 1 or Al =7.5x10 x3 25x10 m = 0.225mm_ => Change in length =: pd _ 1.5%10°x1 o= Pa, 15x10 x1 Bt 8x10x10 8.75 MPa 225 mm and maximum shear stress, Conventional Question IES-1998 Question: A thin eylinder with closed ends hi SK Mondar's an internal diameter of 50 mm and a wall thickness of 2.5 mm. It is subjected to an axial pull of 10 kN and a torque ‘of 500 Nm while under an internal pressure of 6 MN/m’ (® Determine the pri stress. «i Answer: Axial pull, P = 10 kN; T= 500 Nm; p () Principal stresses (o,.) in the tube and the maximum shear stres (tha pd P _ 6x10°x0.05 10x10" 4 dt 4x25x10" 7x0.05x2.5x10" = 3010" + 25.510" = 55.5% 10°N/m? 6x10" 0.05 1 pegs Oxo Principal stresses are: one(282) [rg ——9 Use Torsional equation, - “ ---(i) where J= (Dt a") = | (0.058) -(0.08)* ]=2.848«10-'m* jpal stresses in the tube and the maximum shear Represent the stress configuration on a square element taken in the load (J=polar moment of inertia) ‘Substituting the values in(i), we get Page 321 of 420Chapter-10 Thin Cylinder SK Mondal’s sor 2848x407 (0.05572) 500%(0.055/2) 49 09. 498 or 2.848x 107 Nin Now, substituting the various valaas in oqa,(), we bave (sees poms), =; 60x10 )Hes20c07 = 57.7510" + 48.33 x10° = 106.08MN/[m?,9.42MIN/m? Principal stresses are ‘7, = 106.08MN /m?; c, = 9.42MN/m* Masur sear ste gg = 2% = 10808842 «yg acre? (i) Stress configuration on a square element Po 2t y P Square (pd, P (Bt 3%) | lament at tam) x a 2t Page 3220 428Thick Cylinder Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 1. Thick cylinder Inner dia of the eylinder (4,) <15 020 wall thickness(t) 2. General Expression fs —— a ax : ~ Rl ye me WA re Sat ¢ «tee, @ (b) 3. Difference between the analysis of stresses in thin & thick cylinders + In thin cylinders, it is assumed that the tangential stress @, is uniformly distributed over the eylinder wall thickness, In thick eylinder, the tangential stress ¢, has the highest magnitude at the inner surface of the cylinder & gradually decreases towards the outer surface. ‘+ The radial stress @, is neglected in thin eylinders while it is of significant magnitude in case of thick eylinders. 4. Strain du dr + Radial strain, + Circumferential /Tangential strain. ¢,=“ + Awial strain, ©. Page 2230428Chapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondal’s 5. Stress © Axial stress, @, + Radia ireco, P + Circumferential Tangential stress, [ayaa P [Nota: Radial stress always compressive co its magnitude aliaye ~ive. ut in come books they B assume that compressive radial stress is positive and they use, 6, -Al 6. Boundary Conditions 8. Cylinders with internal pressure (p;) i.e. p, =0 (a) At the inner surface of the cylinder @ r= je, Git) 9) Tae (®) At the outer surface of the cylinder Page 2240f428Chapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondar's (©) Radial and circumferential stress distribution within the cylinder wall when only internal pressure acts. 9. Cylinders with External Pressure (p.) ie. p, =0 @ aw Gi) (6) At the outer surface of the eylinder @ ren «i Gi) (©) Distribution of radial and circumferential stresses within the cylinder wall when only external pressure acts Page 2280428Chapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondal’s 10. Lame's Equation [for Brittle Material, open or closed end] ‘There is a no of equations forthe design of thick cylinders. The choice of equation depends upon two parameters. + Cylinder Material (Whether brittle or ductile) + Condition of Cylinder ends (open or closed) When the material ofthe eylinder is brite, such as cast iron or cast steel, Lame's Equation is used to determine the wall thickness. Condition of eylinder ends may open or closed. It is based on maximum principal stress theory of failure. ‘There principal stresses at the inner surface of the eylinder are as follows: (i) (i) & (ii) Wo, =-p, +g, isthe criterion of design * Foran st [oP -| (Lame's Equation) 11. Clavarino's Equation [for cylinders with closed end & made of ductile material] When the material of a eylinder is ductile, such as mild steel or alloy steel, maximum strain theory of failure is used (St. Venant’s theory) is used. ‘Three principal stresses at the inner surface of the eylinder are as follows (i) (it) & (ii) Page 2260428Chapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondar's + Oro= , - Ma, +0). Where 0° fos +o isthe criterion of design los —200p, 5 Vo-+wep, =ntt ra er (Clavarion's Equation) 12. Birne's Equation [for cylinders with open end & made of ductile material] When the material ofa cylinder is ductile, such as mild steel or alloy steel, maximum strain theory of failure is used (St. Venant's theory) is used. © For ‘Three principal stresses at the inner surface of the eylinder are as follows (i) (i) & (ii) (o,=-2, (ao, (iio, =0 + o=0,-y0, where o= 2 +o isthe criterion of design ne fexd=wp, n Yo-U+u)p, 4 [oxd—wp, “We-d+np, age 27 of 420 © Forn=ntt | (Bimnie's Equation) 13. Barlow's equation: [for high pressure gas pipe brittle or ductile material]Chapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondal’s tor IGAIL exam 2004], %, Where o, =" for ductile material fos = 22 for brittle material fos 14. Compound Cylinder (A cylinder & A Jacket) When two cylindrical parts are assembled by shrinking or press-fitting, a contact pressure is created between the two parts. If the radii of the inner eylinder are a and e and that of the outer cylinder are (c- 5) and b, 6 being the radial interference the contact pressure is given ‘The inner diameter of the jacket is slightly smaller than the outer diameter of eylinder When the jacket is heated, it expands sufficiently to move over the eylinder ‘As the jacket cools, it tends to contract onto the inner eylinder, which induces residual compressive stress, ‘Thore is a shrinkage prossure 'P" between the cylinder and the jacket, ‘The pressure ‘P' tends to contract the cylinder and expand the jacket ‘The shrinkage pressure 'P" can be evaluated from the above equation for a given amount of interference 5 ‘The resultant stresses in a compound cylinder are found by supervision losing the 2- stresses 1 stresses due to shrink fit stresses due to internal pressure Derivation: Due to interference let us assume 8, of jacket and 6, crease in inner diameter jecrease in outer diameter of cylinder. so =(6,| +5,| i.e, without sign. Page 328 of 420Chapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondar's tangential strai ircumferential stress pib?+c?) ee) (radialstress) _ plc? +2%)} ‘And in similarway 3, =<. ¢ +h 7 — 16, |C (e-2) lo, =-p =e ee.,| (i) Here “ve signrepresents contraction ‘Adding (i) & (i) (6 — 0" fc? 20 += 16. Autofrettage Autofrettage is a process of pre-stressing the cylinder before using it in operation, We know that when the eylinder is subjected to internal pressure, the circumferential stress at the inner eurface limits the pressure carrying eapacity of the eylinder. In autofrettage pre-stressing develops a residual compressive stresses at the inner surface, When the cylinder is actually loaded in operation, the residual compressive stresses at the inner surface begin to decrease, become zero and finally become tensile as the pressure is gradually increased. ‘Thus autofrettage increases the pressure carrying capacity of the cylinder. 16. Rotating Disc ‘The radial & circumferential (tangential) stresses in a rotating dise of uniform thickness are given by Where R.= Internal radius R= External radiue lensity of the dise material @ = Angular speed Page 229 of 428 1 Poisson's ratio.Chapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondal’s ons 0 =(22*) poo] (254) po" -8"] Radial stress, 6, Page 330 of 420Chapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondal's OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Lame's theory GATE-1. A thick cylinder is subjected to an internal pressure of 60 MPa. If the hoop stress on the outer surface is 150 MPa, then the hoop stress on the internal surface [GATE-1996; TES-2001] (@) 105 MPa (&) 180 MPa (0210 MPa (@) 135 MPa GATE-1. Ans. (c)Ifinternal pressure = p. External pressure = zero Fi Circumferential or hoop stress (6 At p,=60MPa, 0, =150MPa and 150 = 60-_| oe Previous 20-Years IES Questions Thick cylinder IES-1, If a thick cylindrical shell is subjected to internal pressure, then hoop stress, radial stress and longitudinal stress at a point in the thickness will be: (a) Tensile, compressive and compressive respectively [IES-1999] ©) Allcompressive (© Alltensile (@)__ Tensile, compressive and tensile respectively TES-1, Ans. (@) Hoop stress ~ tensile, radial stress ~ compressive and longitudinal stress ~ tensile Distribution of radial and circumferential stresses within the cylinder wall when only external pressure acts Radial and cireumferential stress distribution within the eylinder wall when only internal pressure acts IES2, Where does the maximum hoop stress in a thick cylinder under external pressure occur? TES-2003] (@) At the outer surface () At the inner surface (©) At the mid-thickness (@) At the 2/8" outer radius Page 231 of 428Chapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondal’s TES-2. Ans. (b) Cireumforential or hoop stross = 0, IES3. —_ Ina thick cylinder pressurized from inside, the hoop stress is maximum at (a) The centre of the wall thickness () The outer radius [TES-1998] (©) The inner radius (@ Both the inner and the outer radii TES. Ans. (c) IES-4. Where does the maximum hoop stress in a thick cylinder under external pressure occur? TES-2008] (a) At the outer surface () At the inner surface (6) At the mid-thicknoss (@) At the 235 outer radius TES-4, Ans. (a) Maximum hoop stress in thick eylinder under external pressure occur at the outer surface. TES-5. A thick-walled hollow cylinder having outside and inside radii of 90 mm and 40 mm respectively is subjected to an external pressure of 800 MNim?, The maximum cireumferential stress in the cylinder will occur at a radius of [IES-1998] (40 mm (©) 60. mm (65 mm @ 90mm TESS. Ans. (a) IES. Ina thick cylinder, subjected to internal and external pressures, let ri and r be the internal and external radii respectively. Let u be the radial displacement of a material clement at radius r, 45 > r>r;. Identifying the cylinder axis as z axis, [ES-1996] (a) we We (© dulde (@) deo TES.6. Ans. (c) The strains e, and s may be given by the radial strain component é,, is Page 3320420Chapter-11 Thick Cylinder ‘SK Mondar's Roprosentation of radial and circumferential strain. Lame's theory IES-7. A thick cylinder is subjected to an internal pressure of 60 MPa. If the hoop stress on the outer surface is 150 MPa, then the hoop stress on the internal surface is: [GATE-1996; TES-2001) (a) 105 MPa (6) 180 MPa (©) 210 MPa (@) 135 MPa IBS-7, Ans. (¢) If internal pressure = pi External pressure = zero Circumferential or hoop stress (: At p,=60MPa, o,=150MPa and IES-8, A hollow pressure vessel is subject to internal pressure. [ES-2005} Consider the following statements: 1. Radial stress at inner radius is always zero. 2. Radial stress at outer radius is always zero. 3, The tangential stress is always higher than other stresses, 4. The tangential stress is always lower than other stresses. Which of the statements given above are correct? (@) and 3 (by Land 4 (© 2and3 (@2and 4 TES-8, Ans. (0) IES, A thick open ended cylinder as shown in the figure is made of a material with permissible normal and shear stresses 200 MPa and 100 MPa respectively. The ratio of permissible pressure based on the normal and shear stress is: [a= 10 em; da = 20 em) @ 95 oss ©15 4s {1ES-2002] IES-9, Ans. (b) Longitudinal and shear stress IES-10. A thick cylinder of internal radius and external radius a and b is subjected to internal pressure p as well as external pressure p. Which one of the following statements is correct? Page 33 of 420 TES.2004} ‘The magnitude of circumferential stress developed is: (@) Maximum at radius r=a (b) Maximum at radius r= bChapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondal’s (@) Maximum at radius r= Jab (@ Constant TES-10, Ans. (€) IES-11. Consider the following statements: [ES-2007] Ina thick walled cylindrical pressure vessel subjected to internal pressure, the Tangential and radial stresses are: 1. Minimum at outer side 2. Minimum at inner side 3. Maximum at inner side and both reduce to zero at outer wall 4, Maximum at inner wall but the radial stress reduces to zero at outer wall Which of the statements given above is/are correct? (@) Land 2 (b) Land 3 () Land 4 (@) 4only TES-11. Ans. (c) TES.12, Consider the following statements at given point in the case of thick cylinder subjected to fluid pressure: [ES-2006] Radial stress is compressive Hoop stress is tensile Hoop stress is compressive Longitudinal stress is tensile and it varies along the length Longitudinal stress is tensile and remains constant along the length of the eylinder Which of the statements given above are correct? (a) Only 1,2and4 (Only Sand4 (©) Only L2and5 —_(@) Only 1,3 and 5 IBS-12. Ans. (c) 3. For internal fluid pressure Hoop or circumferential stress is tensile 4. Longitudinal stress is tensile and remains constant along the length of the cylinder. IFS.13, A thick cylinder with internal diameter d and outside diameter 2d is subjected to internal pressure p. Then the maximum hoop stress developed in the cylinder is: [ES-2003] 5 @ w=, o> 2 » 3P 5P > TES-13. Ans. (c) In thick cylinder, maximum hoop stress Compound or shrunk cylinder TES-14, Autofrettage is a method of: [ES-1996; 2005; 2006) (@) Joining thick cylinders (®) Relieving stresces from thick eylinders (6) Pre-stressing thick eylinders (4 Increasing the life of thick eylinders TES-14, Ans. (e) TES.5. Match Li 1 with List-II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the Lists: [TES-2004] List List A. Wire winding 1. Hydrostatic stress B. Lame’s theory 2 Strengthening of thin eylindrical shell €. Solid sphere subjected to uniform pag softy s3prensthening of thick eylindrical shell pressure on the surface D. Autofrettage 4. Thick cylindersChapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondar's Coeds A BC D A B oc D @ 4 2 1 8 ® 4 2 8 1 @ 2 4 8 1 @ 2 4 1 38 TES-15. Ans. (a) TES-16. If the total radial interference between two cylinders forming a compound cylinder is 6 and Young's modulus of the materials of the cylinders is E, then the interface pressure developed at the interface between two cylinders of the same material and same length is: [TES-2005] (a) Directly proportional of E x 6 (b) Inversely proportional of E 6 {© Directly proportional of 2/8 {@) Inversely proportional of E18 TES-16. Ans. (a) p,|_ 20:(05-0) D: E | [(05-02) 05-07) Paes Atematively if E tthen P 7 andif 57 thenPt soP @ E6 Ds TES-17. A compound cylinder with inner radius 5 cm and outer radius 7 em is made by shrinking one cylinder on to the other cylinder. The junction radius is 6 em and the junction pressure is 11 kgficm+, The maximum hoop stress developed in the inner cylinder is: [ES-1994] (a) 36 kgffem? compression lkgflem? tension (6) 72 kgtlem? compression kgflem? tension, IES-17. Ans. (¢) Thick Spherical Shell TES-18, The hemispherical end of a pressure vessel is fastened to the cylindrical portion of the pressure vessel with the help of gasket, bolts and lock nuts. The bolts are subjected to: 11ES-2003] G@) Tensile stress ¢b) Compressive stress (@) Shear stress (@) Bearing stress TES-18. Ans. (a) Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Longitudinal and shear stress JAS.1. A solid thick cylinder is subjected to an external hydrostatic pressure p. The state of stress in the material of the cylinder is represented as: [1AS-1995] Page 2380428Chapter-11 (ay o IAS-1. Ans. (e) Thick Cylinder P—} }e—P ” @ = SK Mondal’s —P Distribution of radial and circumferential stresses within the cylinder wall when only external pressure acts, Page 336 of 420Chapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondar's Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question IES-1997 The pressure within the cylinder of a hydrauli ‘Thickness of the eylinder: Using te equator, =p °% we have or Conventional Question IES-2010 Q A spherical shell of 150 mm internal diameter has to withstand an internal pressure of 30 MNim*, Calculate the thickness of the shell if the allowable stress is 80 MN/m. Assume the stress distribution in the shell to follow the law Bande, [10 Marks) F ‘Ans. Aspherical shellof 150 mm intornal diameter intraal pressure = 30 MPa. Aomable stress = 80 MINIs F canara, ax! At internal diameter () Page 227 of 428Chapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondal’s =-30N/mm* 2 ON /mm oe Bb (oy 80=a+ 75)" Soluing eq” (i) & (ii) 110x75" 130 3 At outer Radius (R) radial stress should be zero b 2b o=-a—2b z Sh AO TE 2b _ 2110%75" _713949.3077 a 130 3130 R=89.376mm There fore thickness of cylinder = (R -r) 14.376mm Conventional Question IES-1993 Question: A thick spherical vessel of inner ‘radius 150 mm is subjected to an internal pressure of 80 MPa. Calculate its wall thickness based upon the (@ Maximum principal stress theory, and Gi) Total strain energy theory. Poisson's ratio = 0.30, yield strength = 300 MPa Answer: Given’ f,= 180mm; p(z,)=80MPa=80.10°N/m?; 300MPa = 300%10°N/ m? Wall thickness t ())Maximum principal stress theory: (K2t)se ea or 8oxto*( +t ea or K2 1.314 or 314 We know that,c, 3001" ie 1.314 of r, =1, «1.914 =150 «1.314 =197.1mm Metal thickness, =197.1-150= 47.1mm Gi) Total strain energy theory Use a} +03 -— 10,0, <0; Page 38 of 420Chapter-11 Thick cyliner 8K Mondats ote LK +H) +(1-0)] way (0000 = 22(60107 [i (1+08)+(0-0)) . (ey or 300°(K? =1)° =2%80°(1.3K*+0.7) gives K = 1.86 or 0.59 itis clear that > 4 2K =1.964 or = 1,364 or F, = 1501.64 = 204.6 mm 104.6 - 150 = 54.6 mm Conventional Question ESE-2002 Question: Answer: What is the difference in the analysis of think tubes compared to that for thin tubes? State the basic equations describing stress distribution in a thick ‘tube. ‘The difference in the analysis of stressos in thin and thick cylinder: (Tn thin eylinder, it is assumed that the tangential stress is uniformly distributed over the eylinder wall thickness. In thick eylinder, the tangential stress has highest ‘magnitude at the inner surface of the cylinder and gradually decreases towards the outer surface. Gi) The radial stross is neglected in thin eylindors, while it is of significant magnitude in ease of thick eylinders. ‘Basie equation for describing stress distribution in thick tube is Lame’s equation, 8 8 o,=Z-A and o,=Z+A r r Conventional Question ESE-2006 Question: Answer: What is auto frettage? How does it help in increasing the pressure carrying capacity of a thick cylinder? Autofrettage is a process of pro-stressing the cylinder before using it in operation, We know that when the eylinder is subjected to internal pressure, the cireumferential stroas at the inner surface limits the pressure carrying capacity of the cylinder. In autofrettage pre-stressing develops a residual compressive stresses at the inner surface. When the eylinder is actually loaded in operation, the residual compressive stresses at the inner surface begin to decrease, become zero and finally become tensile fas the pressure is gradually increased. Thus autofrettage increases the pressure carrying capacity of the eylinder. Conventional Question ESE-2001 Question: When two cylindrical parts are assembled by shrinking or p contact pressure is created between the two parts, If the radii of the cylinder are a and c and that of the outer cylinder are (c- 6) and b, 6 being the radial interference the contact pressure is given by: B8|(6? —¢*)(¢* a") c| 2¢(b—a’) Where E is the Young's mod@lgscofathe= material, Can you outline the steps involved in developing this important design equChapter-11 Answer: Thick Cylinder SK Mondal’s CYLINDER JACKET) I oD GD | a = CYLINDER JACKET Rane 2b Due to interference let us assume 8, = increase in inner diameter of jacket and 8, = decrease in outer diameter of cylinder. so 6={5,| +[5,| i.e. without sign. Now 8, =€,¢ |e,= tangential strain] = Blo, -u0,|e |o,=circumferential stress| p(b*+c*) (e) \o,=-p(radialstress) cP +e pic? +2°) (-2) lo, =-p —~(ii) Here -ivesignrepresentscontraction Adding (i) & (i) |+p1- 2} _2o%(o*—a*) Ele _ FB|(b? -c* Ne" - 2°)] 2c*(b° — a") or P Prowgds40 ot 420Chapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondar's Conventional Question ESE-2003 Question: A steel rod of diameter 50 mm is forced into a bronze casing of outside diameter 90 mm, producing a tensile hoop stress of 30 MPa at the outside diameter of the easing. Find () The radial pressure between the rod and the casing Gi) The shrinkage allowance and Gil) The rise in temperature which would just eliminate the force ft. Assume the following material prope E.= 2x105 MPa, ji =0.25 , a, =1.2X10°/°C x10MPa, f4,=0.3, Jy, = 1.9107" C Answer: Pp Brénze casin Steel bod Bronze casing 9 ‘hee ls a ssinageprscre P beeen the sel oa he bono ening, The Prenoe inn toot tse anf xpd sh roe ang @) Consider Brouse casing, According ta Lames theory 2a whore a= 2= A =1|MPa=33.6MPa ‘Therefore the radial pressure between the rod and the casing is P= 33.6 MPa. Gi) The shrinkage allowance: Let 6 j= increase in inert diameter of bronze casing, 8 c=decrease in outer diameter of steel rod 1+ consider bronze casing: ‘Tangential stress at the inner surface(a,), 2 +A 2 ri nef)" ie Lar) 63.6MPa ee Page 341 of 420 AChapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondal’s and radial stress(o,), -33.6MPa longitudial stress(a,), Therefore tangential strain (3), = 2[o,),~wo.),] 1 1*10° 8, =(6), xd, = 7.968 x10 x 0.050= [63.6 +03 33.6] =7.368%10 .03684mm. 264 Consider steel rod: Circumferential stress (o,), and radial stress (¢,), 1 (xd, Ello. we). |xa, PA, y_y = -388%0.050 é, e 2x10" [1—0.3] = -0.0058amm [reduction] Total shrinkage =[6,|+[0,|=0.04272mm(iis diametral] = 0.02136mm [radial Gi) Let us temperature rise is (At) As a, >a, due to same temperature rise steel not will expand less than bronze casing, When their difference of expansion will be equal to the shrinkage then force fit will eliminate. d, xa, xAt=d, xa, x At = 0.04272 0.04272 _ 0.04272 t= To, a4] SOX[TOXIO = 122°C BAO] Conventional Question AMIE-1998 Question: A thick walled closed-end cylinder is made of an Al-alloy (E = 72 GPa, 0.33), has inside diameter of 200 mm and outside diameter of 800 mm. ‘The cylinder is subjected to internal fluid pressure of 150 MPa. Determine the principal stresses and maximum shear stress at a point on the inside surface of the cylinder. Also determine the increase in inside diameter due to fluid pressure. 200 Answer: Given: f,=—>~ = 100mm = 0.1m: = 150MPa = 150MN/m*; 33=" Principal stress and maximum shear stress: Using the condition in Lame’s equation: Substituting the values in the above equation we have Page 3420420Chapter-11 Thick Cylinder SK Mondal's b ape 8 _ From(iand(ii), weget a=10 and b=16 -(i) ‘The circumferential (or hoop) stress by Lame’s equation.is given by b pea r (0) 8 (=) = 0-1 4 +10=170MN/m? (tensile), and (out r=.) =0.4m= 25. +10 20MN /m (tensile) Principal stresses are 170 MN/m? and 20MN/m? (ena (en _ 170-20 Maximum shear stress, au: = 75MIN /m? Increase in inside diameter, 64, We know,longitudinal(or axial) stress, o, = Pit, = 190*(-1)_ sonan ym? Eo (04) (01) Circumferential (or hoop)strain at the inner radius.is given by ula, a) = ap Sag [170=10" +-0.33(160 - 10)x10"]= 0.003 or 0.003 = $4 654, = 0,003 0.1 = 0.003m or OPA? ot 420Spring Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 1. A spring is a mechanical device which is used for the efficient storage and release of energy. 2. Helical spring - stress equation Let us a close-coiled helical spring has coil diameter D, wire diameter d and number of turn n. The D spring material has a shearing modulus G. The spring index,C =. Ifa forve ‘P’ is exerted in both ends as shown. ‘Tho work done by the axial force 'P' is converted into strain energy and stored in the spring, average torque) (angular displacement) =149 2 TL From the figure we get, @ ==> PO Torque (N= length of wire (L)=1Dn Polar moment of neriauy= 2 Therefore us 420° Gal According to Castigliano's theorem, the displacement corresponding to force P is obtained by partially differentiating strain energy with respect to that foree, wu 8 fe oe 8PD'n ‘Therefore ‘ap dP| Ga" | Ga" 8PD'n Axial deflection | 6 = Spring stiffness or spring constant (I)Chapter-12 SK Mondar's ‘The torsional shear stress in the bar, 1, P__4P _8PD(0.5d) ‘The direct shear stress in the bar, near al) 4 oD oe Where k, =1+ 252 D is correction factor for direct shear stress. 3. WahI’s stress correction factor AC=1 9818). known ae Wah’ stress correction factor 4C-4 Where K -( Hore K = K:Ko; Where K, is correction factor for direct shear stress and Ke is correction factor for stress concentration du to curvature Note: When the spring is subjected to a static force, the effect of stress concentration is neglected Aue to eae yielding So we wil use, Fa, SD 4. Equivalent stiffness (keg) Spring in series (5, =, +3,) Spring in Parallel(5, =8,~3,) 4K, ms | x. pj —» WW K+K; Page 345 of 420Spring SK Mondal’s 4K, 5. Important note ‘* Lfa spring is cut into‘n’ equal lengths then spring constant of each new spring = nk When a closed coiled spring is subjected to an axial couple M then the rotation, 64MDn, Ed® 6. Laminated Leaf or Carriage Springs BPR 8Enbe 3PL # Maximum bending stress, Gy ==——> 2nbr Where P = load on spring L= total length between 2 points lickness of one plate. 7. Belleville Springs 455 6 2 CD [e+-ofe-g}re ] Where, E = Modulus of elasticity = Linear deflection H=Poisson’s Ratio Load, tor for Belleville spring Do= outside diamerer = Deflection required to flatten Belleville spring ‘+ Total stiffness of the springs k= stiffness per spring No of springs In a leaf spring ratio of stross between full length and graduated leaves = 1.5 Conical spring- For application requiring variable stiffness Belleville Springs -For application requiring high capacity springs into small space Page 246 of 420Chapter-12 Spring SK Mondal's OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Helical spring GATE-1, If the wire diameter of a closed coil helical spring subjected to compressive load is increased from 1 em to 2 em, other parameters remaining same, then deflection will decrease by a factor of: IGATE-2002] @) 16 8 4 @2 8PDN GATE-1. Ans. (a) 5="G oe GATE-2, A compression spring is made of music wire of 2 mm diameter having a shear strength and shear modulus of 800 MPa and 80 GPa respectively. The mean coil diameter is 20 mm, free length is 40 mm and the number of active coils is 10. If the mean coil diameter is reduced to 10 mm, the stiffness of the spring is IGATE-2008] (b) Decreased by 2 times (6) Increased by 2 times (@) Increased by 8 times GATE-2. Ans. (4) Spring constant (K) (2, (20) K, 10 GATE-S. Two helical tensile springs of the same material and also having identical mean coil diameter and weight, have wire diameters d and d/2. The ratio of their stiffness [GATE-2001] @. was (64 @ 128 P_Ga' a GATE-2, Ans. (¢) Spring constant (K) ‘Therefore ko 2 (©) Spring =a 7 GATE-4, A uniform stiff rod of length 300 mm vant and having a weight of 300 N is N pivoted at one end and connected t0 459 5 a spring at the other end. For keeping the rod vertical in a stable position the minimum value of Yn spring constant K needed is: @ (@) 300 Nim () 400Nim 150 m0 to (2) 1000 Nim Icare-2004 GATIEA, Ans, (Inlined it fo avery Tow angle, 40 For equilibrium taking moment about hinge! 1 aa) 0 ork- W300 _ w(t} aay t=0 ark 28 son GATE. A weighing machine consists of a 2 kg pan resting on spring. In this condition, with the pan resting on the spring, the length of the spring is 200 mm. When a mass of 20 kg is placed on the pan,,the length of the spring becomes 100 mm. For the spring, the un-deformed lett and the spring constant k (stiffness) are: IGATE-2005)Chapter-12 Spring SK Mondal’s @k = 1862 Nim (©) = 210 mm, k= 1960 Nim ob: 1960 Nim @) =200 mm, k= 2156 Nim GATE-5. Ans. (b) Initial length = Lm and stiffness = k Nim 2xg=k(|,-0.2) 2xg+20«g=k(l, -0.1) Just solve the above equations Springs in Series GATE.6, The deflection of a spring with 20 active turns under a load of 1000 N is 10 mm, ‘The spring is made into two pieces each of 10 active coils and placed in parallel under the same load. The deflection of this system is: IGATE-1995) G@) 20 mm () 10 mm 5mm @25mm GATE-6, Ans. (d) When a spring is cut into two, no, of coils gets halved. ffnoss of each hal gots doubled. Whon those are connected in parallel, stifnss = 2k + 2k = 4k ‘Therefore deflection wll be % times. Previous 20-Years IES Questions Helical spring TES, A helical coil spring with wire diameter ‘a’ and coil diameter 'D' is subjected to external load, A constant ratio of d and D has to be maintained, such that the extension of spring is independent of d and D. What is this ratio? —_(1ES-2008] (aot (eye? ot or ee 8PD'N Gat a TaFx> TESA, Ans. (a) 5 = a v-X(2) (6) “cer @U__ 8FD"N Gd IES-2. Assertion (A): Concentric cylindrical helical springs are used to have greater spring force in a limited space. HES.2006] Reason (R): Concentric helical springs are wound in opposite directions to prevent locking of coils under heavy dynamic loading. (a) Both Aand R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A () Both Aand R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (© Ais true but Ris false (@__ Ais false but Ris true TES-2, Ans. (b) IES-3. Assertion (A): Two concentric helical springs used to provide greater spring force are wound in opposite directions. TIES-1995; 1AS-20041 Reason (R): The winding in opposite directions in the case of helical springs prevents buckling. (a) Both Aand R are individually teR®082442the correct explanation of A () Both Aand R are individually true but K is NOT the correct explanation of AChapter-12 Spring SK Mondar's (©) Ais true but Ris false (@) Ais false but Ris true IES.8. Ans. (¢) It is for proventing locking not for buckling IES-4. Which one of the following statements is correct? _[IES-1996; 2007; IAS-1997] Ifa helical spring is halved in length, its spring stiffness (Oltemain came) Hae bowtie” rts TES. Ans () Sines of spin h)= S240 ko! anda IES-5. A body having weight of 1000 N is dropped from a height of 10 em over a close- coiled helical spring of stiffness 200 N/em. The resulting deflection of spring is nearly [ES-2001] (a) em (©) 16em (©)35em (@ 100 em 1594. Aan ) gto) = at IES-6. A close-coiled helical spring is made of 5 mm diameter wire coiled to 50 mm mean diameter. Maximum shear stress in the spring under the action of an axial force is 20 Nimm’, The maximum shear stress in a spring made of 3 mm diameter wire coiled to 30 mm mean diameter, under the action of the same force will be nearly [ES-2001] (2) 20 Nimm? (6) 83.3 Nimm? (©) 55.6 Nimm® (d) 92.6 Nimm® 1ES-6, Ans. (c) User =k, PO " aoe IES-7. A elosely-coiled helical spring is acted upon by an axial force. The max shear stress developed in the spring is 7. Half of the length of the spring off and the remaining spring is acted upon by the same axial force. The ‘maximum shear stress in the spring the new condition will be: UES-1995] @%r (7 zr @47 8PD TES-7. Ans. (b) User =k, “E> its independent of mamber of tara TES-8, The maximum shear stress occurs on the outermost fibers of a circular shaft under torsion, Ina close coiled helical spring, the maximum shear stress occurs on the TIES-1999] (@) Outermost fibres (b) Fibres at mean diameter _(¢) Innermost fibres () End coils IES-8, Ans. (c) IES-8. A helical spring has N turns of coil of diameter D, and a second spring, made of same wire diameter and of same material, has N/2 turns of coil of diameter 2D. If the stiffness of the first spring is k, then the stiffaess of the second spring will [ES-1999] (a) Wa (ee x (@) 4k Ga* Ga* k TES.9, Ans, (a) Stiffness (k) ‘econd spring, stiffness (k.) CARD 4 64(2a) a 1ES-10. A closed-coil helical spring is subjected to a torque about its axis. The spring wire would experience a TTES-1996; 1998] (@) Bending stress () Direct tensile stress of uniform intensity at its cross-section (©) Direct shear stress (@) Torsional shearing stress IES-10. Ans. (a) IES-11. Given that: TES-1996] d= diameter of spring, K = mean radius of coils, n = number of coils and G = igidity, the stiffness of the close-coiled helical spring subject to an axial load Wis equal to PapasanChapter-t2 Spring SK Mondal's oS Sf ann orn 32m Rn TRS.11. Ans. (@) TES.12, A closely coiled helical spring of 20 em mean diameter is having 25 coils of 2 em diameter rod. The modulus of rigidity of the material if 10° Niem?. What is the stiffness for the spring in Nem? (1ES-2004] (@) 50 (@) 100 (0250 (@) 500 Gat _10°(N/om')<2*(om*) BO" 820° (em) x25 TES-12. Ans. (b) Stiffness of sprin(k TES-13. Which one of the following expresses the stress factor K used for design of closed eoiled helical spring? TIES-2008] 4c—4 40-1 0515 40-4 0615 4c-1 @ oie © eee ont act Where C= spring index TES-13. Ans. (b) TES-14. In the calculation of induced shear stress in helical springs, the Wabl's correction factor is used to take care of [TES-1995; 1997] (a) Combined effeet of transverse shear stress and bending stresses in the wire. (b) Combined effect of hending stress and curvature of the wire. (©) Combined effect of transverse shear stress and curvature of the wire. (@ Combined effeet of torsional shear stress and transverse shear stress in the wire TES-14, Ans. (e) IFS.15. While calculating the stress induced in a closed coil heli spring, Wahl's factor must be considered to account for [ES-2002] (a) The curvature and stress concentration effect (8) Shock loading (©) Poor service conditions (@) Fatigue loading TES.A5. Ans. (a) IESG. Cracks in helical springs used in Railway carriages usually start on the inner side of the coil because of the fact that UES-1994] (a) Ttis subjected to the higher stress than the outer side, (b) Its subjected to a higher eyelic loading than the outer side (¢) It is more stretched than the outer side during the manufacturing process, (@ _Tthasa lower curvature than the outer side. TES-16. Ans. (a) IES.17, Two helical springs of the same material and of equal circular cross-section and length and number of turns, but having radii 20 mm and 40 mm, kept concentrically (smaller radius spring within the larger radius spring), are compressed between two parallel planes with a load P. The inner spring will carry a load equal to [TES-1994] are w2r8 ori ware Ww, R (2Y 1 W, W, IES-17. Ans. (a) — 2) ot =” sows ter or ORR (3) 8 gs TES.18, A length of mm diameter steel wire is coiled to a close coiled helie: having 8 coils of 75 mm mean diameter, and the spring has a stiffness K. If the same length of wire is coiled to 10 coils of 60 mm mean diameter, then the spring stiffness will be: UES-1993] @K ) 125K (156K @ 195K Ga* IES-18, Ans. (c) Stiffinessof spring (k Where G and d_issame OAR n Page 350 of 428Chapter-12 Spring SK Mondal's Theresore * ! 1 J k (RY(n @)(§) 156 RB) \m) \oo) Uo TES-19. A spring with 25 active coils cannot he accommodated within a given space. Hence 5 coils of the spring are cut. What is the stiffness of the new spring? Eicene aia uspa aes Gp anes he sage ang TS 2004) Coe eee ee paz tue tocol ering tes.18, ns. (sites of rng k)= SE oka! orks Bats TES-20. Wire diameter, mean coil diameter and number of turns of a closely-coiled steel spring are d, D and N respectively and stiffness of the spring is K. A second spring is made of same steel but with wire diameter, mean coil diameter and number of turns 2d, 2D and 2N respectively. The stiffness of the new spring is: TIBS-1998; 2001] @K 2K ouK @sK Gat TES.20. Ans. (a) stifess of spring (k) = FS TES-21, When two springs of equal lengths are arranged to form cluster springs which of the following statements are the: [ES-1992] 1, Angle of twist in both the springs will be equal 2. Deflection of both the springs will be equal 3, Load taken by each spring will be half the total load 4, Shear stress in each spring will be equal (@) Land 2only — (b) 2 and 3 only (©) Band 4only (@ 1, 2and 4 only IBS-21. Ans. (a) IES22, Consider the following statements: TES.2009] ‘When two springs of equal lengths are arranged to form a cluster spring 1. Angle of twist in both the springs will be equal 2. Deflection of both the springs will be equal 3. Load taken by each spring will be half the total load 4. Shear stress in each spring will be equal Which of the above statements is/are correct? (@) Land 2 () Band 4 (02 only @Aonly IES-22, Ans. (a) Same as (IES-1992] Page 351 of 420Chapter-12 SK Mondal’s Close-coiled helical spring with axial load IES-23. Under axial load, each section of a close-colled helical spring is subjected to (@) Tensile stress and shear stress due to load [ES-2003] (©) Compressive stress and shear stress due to torque (©) Tensile stress and shear stross due to torque (@) Torsional and direct shear stresses TES-23. Ans. (d) IES-24, When a weight of 100 N falls on a spring of stiffness 1 kN/m from a height of 2 1m, the deflection caused in the first fall is: [ES-2000] (a) Equal to 0.1m (b) Between 0.1 and 0.2 m (6) Equal t0 0.2 m (@ More than 0.2 m 1ES24, Ans. (d) use mg(h+ x) = a Subjected to 'A: TES25, A closed coil h | twist’ 1 spring of mean coil ameter 'D' and made from a wire of diameter 'd' is subjected to a torque 'T’ about the axis of the spring. What is the maximum stress developed in the spring wire? [ES-2008] 8T 16T 327 eat. oy oF oF Oe TES-25. Ans. (b) Springs in Series TES.26. When a helical compression spring is cut into two equal halves, the stiffness of each of the result in springs will be: [ES-2002; 1AS-2002] (@) Unaltered (©) Double (© One-half (€) One-fourth TRS-26. Ans. (b) Page 352 of 420 TES27, If a compression coil spring is cut into two equal parts and the parts are then used in parallel, the ratio of the spring rate to its initial value will be:[IES-1999]Chapter-12 Spring SK Mondar's Gt 2 4 (@ Indetorminable for want of sufficient data 1ES-27. Ans. (c) When a spring is cut into owo, no. of coils gets halved. Stiffness of each half gets doubled. When these are connected in parallel, stiffness = 2k + 2 Springs in Parallel TES28. The equivalent spring stiffuess for the system shown in the given figure (S is the spring stiffuess of each of the three springs ) 8i3 (©) 288 @s [TES-1997; IAS-2001], TES-28. Ans. (c) 2s IES29. Two coiled springs, each having stiffness K, are placed in parallel. The stiffness of the combination will bi [TES-2000] (ax (2x OF oy 18.29. Ans. (6) W= Oko IES-30, A mass is suspended at the bottom of two springs in series having stiffness 10 N/mm and 5 Nimm, The equivalent spring stiffness of the two springs is nearly [TES-2000] @)03 Nimm (0)3.3 Némm ©5Nom @ 15 Nom 1830. Ans. 6) 1=1 41 ors, =10 So t0ts SZ page asnctaenChapter-12 Spring SK Mondal’s TES31, Figure given above shows a spring- ‘mass system where the mass m is fixed in hetween two springs of stiffness S: and S:. What is the equivalent spring stiffness? (@) Sr () Sit Se (©) Gir Sofi Se @ Gr SiSs [TES-2005] TES31, Ans. (b) TES82, Two identical springs labelled as Land 2 are @ @ arranged in sories and subjected to force F we shown in the given Bgore Assume that each spring constant is K. The strain energy stored in spring 1 is: THES-2001] f of Pp a) 0 @ xR ) aK OR 16K 1 kx? /2=1xck,x{ | 12 and here total 2 2a" force Fis supported by both the spring 1 and 2 therefore key =k TES-52, Ans. (c) The strain energy stored per spring 1ES-33. What is the equivalent stiffness (ie. spring 7 constant) of the system shown in the given Saar ™ * 10 Coils ‘Nim (b) 16 Nimm K,=8N/mm @4Nimm @)6.8 Nim K, 3 5 Coils “ pes.1997) TES-83, Ans, (a) Stiffness Ki of 10 coils spring = 8 Nimm_ Stiffness Ke of 5 coils spring = 16 Nam ‘Though it looks like in series but they are in parallel combination. They are not subjected to same force. Equivalent stiffness (J) = ky + ke = 24 N/mm. Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Concentric cylindrical helical springs which are used to have greater spring force in a limited sjfaet%# #6%ind in opposite directions.Chapter-12 Spring SK Mondar's Reason (R): Winding in opposite directions prevents locking of the two coils in case of misalignment or buckling. [AS-1996} (@) Both A and Rare individually true and R is the correct explanation of A () Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (©) Aistrue but Ris false (@) Ais false but Ris true 1AS-1. Ans. (a) 1AS-2, An open-coiled helical spring of mean diameter D, number of coils N and wire diameter d is subjected to an axial force' P. The wire of the spring is subject to: [AS-1995] () direct shear only (b) combined shear and bending only (©) combined shear, bending and twisting (@) combined shear and twisting only TAS-2, Ans. (4) IAS, Assertion (A): Two concentric helical springs used to provide greater spring force are wound in opposite directions. (ES-1995; 1AS-2004) Reason (R): The winding in opposite directions in the case of helical springs prevents buckling. (@) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correet explanation of A (b) Both A and Rare individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (©) Aistrue but Ris false (@__ Ais false but Ris true IAS-3. Ans, (c) It is for preventing locking not for buckling. IAS-4, Which one of the following statements is correct? __{TES-1996; 2007; IAS-1997] Ifa helical spring is halved in length, its spring stiffaess (a) Remains same (6) Halves, (©) Doubles (@) Triples TAS-4, Ams. (¢) stiffness of sprin(k) = So 20 kod anyon TAS.5, A closed coil helical spring has 15 coils. If five coils of this spring are removed by cutting, the stiffuess of the modified spring will [AS-2004} (a) Increase to 2.5 times (b) Increase to 1.5 times (©) Reduce to 0.66 times. (@) Remain unaffected 185. Ans Ko wy IAS-6, A close-coiled helical spring has wire diameter 10 mm and spring index 5. If the spring contains 10 turns, then the length of the spring wire would be: [IAS-2000] (a) 100. mm () 157 mm (©) 500 mm (@ 1570 mm TAS. Ans, (€) = 2Dn=2(cd) n= 2%(5%10) «10 =1570mm IAS-7. Consider the following types of stresses: [AS-1996] 1. torsional shear 2. Transverse direct shear 3. Bending stress The stresses, that are produced in the wire of a close-coiled helical spring subjected to an axial load, would include (@) Land 3 (b) Land 2 (©)2and3 (@1,2and3 TAS-7. Ans. (b) IAS8. Two close-coiled springs are subjected to the same axial force. If the second spring has four times the coil diameter, double the wire diameter and double the number of coils of the first spring, then the ratio of deflection of the second spring to that of the first will be: TAS-1998] ws on o ve Page 355 of 420Chapter-12 Spring SK Mondal’s = 24 ln) e-2., oe? TASS. Ans. (a) 5 = TAS9. A block of weight 2 N falls from a height of Im on the top of a spring’ If the spring gets compressed by 0.1 m to bring the weight momentarily to rest, then the spring constant would be: TAS 2000] (a) 50 Nim (b) 100 Nim (©) 200N/m (4) 400Nim IAS.9. Ans. (d) Kinetic energy of block = potential energy of spring L Wh kx? or k= NJm=400N/m or Wh : 2 OF TAS10. The springs of a chest expander are 60 cm long when unstretched. Their stiffness is 10 N/mm. The work done in stretching them to 100 cm is: [TAS-1996] (a) 600 Nm () 800 Nm () 1000 Nm (@) 1600 Nm TAS-10. Ans. (b) ;00Nm TAS-11, A spring of stiffness 'k’ is extended from a displacement x: to a displacement xz the work done by the spring is: [1AS-1999] ) @ias >a! a Rae) SRC 2 1 2 at Oars? — @ zt TAS-11 An (Work done yeh spngin 2a’ Set TAS-12, A spring of stiffness 1000 Nim is stretched initially by 10 cm from the undeformed position. The work required to stretch it by another 10 em is: TIAS-1995] (@)5Nm ()7Nm @10Nm = @15Nm. TAS-12, Ans, (d) E +1000 {0.208 -0.10°) = 15Nm When a helical compression spring is cut into two equal halves, the stiffness of cach of the result in springs will be: (WES-2002; 1AS-2002] («) Unaltered (b) Double (€) One-halt (@) One-fourth TAS.13. Ans. (b) IAS.14. The length of the chest-expander spring when it is un-stretched, is 0.6 mand its stiffness is 10 Nimm. The work done in stretching it to 1m will be: [LAS-2001] (a) 800 J (b) 1600 J (@) 32005 (@) 6400 J TAS-14. Ans. (a) (10N S).0-06 2° Umm 10N Work done =2k.x <0 4m? = 800 Page 356 of 428Chapter-12 SK Mondar's Springs in Parallel Spring 1AS-15. The equivalent spring stiffness for the system shown in the given figure (S is the spring stiffuess of each of the three springs) is: @se sis (2818 @s [TES-1997; TAS-2001] 1sis.dns.(9 b= L+E ors, =25 ene a is Ss 2s Rigid bar Es s 1AS.16. ‘Two identical springs, each of stiffuess K, are assembled as shown in the given figure. The combined stiffness of the assembly i @ ke 2K OK @ ay 3, [AS-1998] IK. Due to applied force one spring will be under tension and TAS-16. Ans. (b) Eifective stiffnes another one under compression go total resistance force will double. Flat spiral Spring IAS.17. Mach List-I (Type of spring) with ListII (Application) and select the correct answer! [LAS-2000} List List-I A. Leaf/Helical springs 1. Automobiles/Railways coachers B. Spiral springs 2. Shearing machines ©. Belleville springs 3, Watches Codes: AB AB Cc @ 1 2 ® 1 3 2 oO 3 1 @ 2 8 1 1AS-17. Ans. (b) Page 257 of 428Chapter-12 Spring SK Mondal’s Semi-elliptical spring IAS-18. The ends of the leaves of a semi-elliptical leaf spring are made triangular in plain in order to: AS 1994) () Obtain variable | in each leaf (b) Permit each leaf to act asa overhanging beam (© Have variable bending moment in each leaf (@) Make Mil constant throughout the length ofthe leaf IAS-18, Ans. (@) The ends ofthe leaves of a semi-eliptical leaf spring are made rectangular in plan in order to make Mil constant throughout the longth of the leaf Page 2580428Chapter-12 Spring SK Mondar's Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Convent tional Question ESE-2008 Question: A close-coiled helical spring has coil diameter D, wire diameter d and number Answer: the spring, U=(average torque) (angular displacement) ty oho 1 From the figure we get, @ = PD Torque (7) Conven Q@ Ans. of turn n, The spring material has a shearing modulus G. Derive an expression for the stiffness k of the spring. "The work done by the axial force P is converted into strain energy and stored in length of wire (L)=1Dn Polar moment of Inertia(J)=™ 32 Therefore u= 4-2-0 Ge According to Castigliano's theorem, the displacement corresponding to force P is obtained by partially differentiating strain energy with respect to that force, tional Question ESE-2010 A stiff bar of negligible weight transfers a load P to a combination of three helical springs arranged in parallel as shown in the above figure. The springs are made up of the same material and out of rods of equal diameters. They are of same free length before loading. The number of coils in those three springs are 10, 12 and 15 respectively, while the mean coil diameters are in ratio of 1: 1.2: 14 respectively. Find the distance ‘x’ as shown in figure, such that the stiff har remains horizontal after the application of load P. [10 Marks} = ‘Same free length of spring before loadingChapter-12 Spring SK Mondal’s “The number of cols in the spring 1,2 and 3 is 10, 12 and 15 mean diameter of spring 1,2 and 3 in the ratioof 1: 1.214 Find out distance x+0 that rod remains horizontal after loading. Since the rod is rigid and remains horizontal after the Toad p is applied therefore the deflection of eaeh spring will be same 5,=8,=8)=8 (say) Spring are made of same material and out of the rods of equal diameter G,=G,=G,=G and d,=d,=d,=d Load in spring 1 Gas Gd's Gas GARIn, GAR} x10 G40R? Load in spring 2 Gis Gd G's ol) 2 G4xRin, G4x(1.2))x12R}1327.10R ‘@ Load in spring 3 Gal's cats __ ats 8) 8° GARIn, 64x(1.4)'x15R} 2634.2R} From eq® (1) & @) _ 640 1327.1 | P, =0.482P, from eq” (1) & (3) 640 P, =0.2430P, 1634.2 ‘Taking moment about the line of action P, P,xL+P,x2L=Px 0.4823 P,L.+0.2430 P, x2L= Px 4823 +0.486)P,L —eEeeeorvre (4) ¥ total load in the rod is P=P,+P, +P, P=P, +.4823P, +0.2430P, P=1.725 P, @) Equation (4) & (5) x=0.5613 L Conventional Question ESE-2008 Question: Answer: A close-coiled helical spring has coil diameter to wire diameter ratio of 6. The spring deflects 3 cm under an axial load of 500N and the maximum shear stress is not to exceed 300 MPa. Find the diameter and the length of the spring wire required. Shearing modulus of wire material = 80 GPa. P_ Gat Stifiness.K === am Page 36001428Chapter-12 Spring SK Mondar's 10°) x or, 500 _ (80 0°)xd 003° 8x6*xn or.d =3.6x10n———(i) For static loading correcting factor(k) 1405) -(+ c D ven c= = 6} (or gna ke| We know that (7: KPC [ a 5.252 10m = 5.252mm So D=cd=6%5.252mm=31.513mm From, equation (i) n=14.59 = 15 Now length of spring wire(L) =xDn =x x 31.513*15 mm =1.485 m Conventional Question ESE-2007 Question: Answer: A coil spring of stiffness ‘k’ is cut to two halves and these two springs are assembled in parallel to support a heavy machine. What is the combined stiffness provided by these two springs in the modified arrangement? When it cut to two halves stiffness of each half will be 2k. Springs in parallel Total load will be shared 0 ‘Total load = W+W ¥ iS or &K,, =8.(2k)+8.(2k) Conventional Question ESE-2001 Question: Answer: A helical spring B is placed je the coils of a second helical spring A having the same number of coils and free axial length and of same mate The two springs are compressed by an axial load of 210 N which is shared between them. The mean coil diameters of A and B are 90 mm and 60 mm and the wire diameters are 12 mm and 7 mm respectively. Calculate the load shared by individual springs and the maximum stress in each spring. i Gat ‘The stiffness of the spring (k) =. pring (k) = ay Here load shared the springs are arranged in paralle! Equivalent stifiness (k,)=K, +k,Chapter-t2 Spring SK Mondal's Load shared by spring'A'(F,) = K,xx= 7210-210 si fee] f +z) Load shared by spring'A'(F,)= K,, xx =(210—151)=59N 05)8PD adi For static load: 0.5 | 8x151x0.090 (7 Jpg, = flr} A = 21.362MPa (eas 2} xx(0.012)" = |g 25 | 8%59%0.060 _ 97 816 MPa "4 xx(0.007) Conventional Question AMIE-1997 Question: A close-coiled spring has mean diameter of 75 mm and spring constant of 90 N/m. It has 8 coils. What is the suitable diameter of the spring wire if maximum shear stress is not to exceed 250 MN/m:? Modulus of rigidity of the spring wire material is 80 GN/m?, What is the maximum axial load the spring can carry? Answer: Given D=75mm; r= 250MN/m?; G = 80GN/m? = Diameter of the spring wire, Torx (whereT =PxR) 16 We know, P0.0375 = (250%10")x a° ---(i) Also. P=ko or P= 80x10? x5 ---(ii) Using the relation: _8PD'n _ 8Px(0.075)' x8 _ wn P Gd Bont xg TSN TEMON Ge Substituting for 5 in equation(i), we get iP 80x10" «33.75 x10" geod ‘Maximum axial load the spring can earry P: From equation (i), we get Px 0.0375 =(250%10°) * 7g" (0.0128); P =2745.2N=2.7452kN 0128m or 12.8mm_ Page 2620428Page 3630420Theories of Column Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 4. Introduction Strut: A member of structure which carries an axial compressive Toad. Colum the strut is vertical itis known as column. A long, slender column becomes unstable when its axial compressive load reaches a value called the critical buckling load. Ifa beam element is under a compressive load and its length is an order of magnitude larger than either ofits other dimensions such a beam i called a columns Due to its size ite axial displacement is going to be very small compared to its lateral deflection called buckling. Buckling does not vary linearly with Toad it occurs suddenly and is therefore dangerous Slenderness Ratio: The ratio between the length and least radius of gyration Elastic Buekling: Buckling with no permanent deformation. Buler buckling is only valid for long, slender objects in the elastic region. For short columns a different set of equations must be used, 2. Which is the critical load? At this value the structure is in equilibrium regardless of the magnitude of the angle (provided it stays small) Critical load is the only load for which the structure will be in equilibrium in the disturbed position At this valuo, restoring effect of the moment in the spring matches the buckling effect of the axial load represents the boundary between the stable and unstable conditions. If the axial Toad is less than Pos the effect of the moment in the spring dominates and the structure returns to the vertical position after a small disturbance ~ stable condition. If the axial load is larger than Pos the effect of the axial force predominates and the structure buckles ~ unstable condition, Because of the large deflection caused by buckling, the least moment of inertia J can be Ake expressed as, Where: A is the eross sectional area and r is the radiue of gyration of the cross sectional area, Page 364 428Chapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondar's ‘© Note that the smallest radius of gyration of the column, ie. the least moment of inertia I should be taken in order to find the eritical stress, I/ k is called the slenderness ratio, it is a measure of the column's flexibility. 3. Euler’s Critical Load for Long Column Assumptions: (i) The column is perfectly straight and of uniform cross-section Gi) The material is homogenous and isotropic (ii) The material behaves elastically (iv) The load is perfectly axial and passes through the centroid of the column section, (0) The weight of the column is neglected. Euler's critical load, Where ¢.=Equivalent length of columa (1* mode of bending) 4. Remember the following table Both ends hinged/pinned rH oa oth ends fixed eel e 2 | Page 268 0428 One end fixed & other end free | ] wEL 2€ Wve aeChapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondal’s One end fixed & other end pinned | | ringed Jeast radius of gyration Slendemess Ratio = “= 6. Rankine's Crippling Load Rankine theory is applied to both ‘* Short strut /column (valid upto SR-40) ‘+ Long Column (Valid upto SR 120) nit oud Perl Grp slendemess ratio 5, Construction of cokurmn fare nes + Slenderness ratio (6, =entcalstessy- 4 = 9.4 vex) k where k' = Rankine constant os depefs 3A théfrial & end conditions zChapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondar's , = crushing stress + Forsteel columns for both ends fixed 25000 1 t = <1 fo one end fixed & other hinged 20< 12500 " k <100 7. Other formulas for crippling load (P) + Gordon's formula, As, ol + Johnson Straight line formula, b=a constant, d= least diameter or breadth of bar Po, 4r-c{%}| c= aconstant depending on material 4 inst parabolic emia 4 where the value of index b’ depends on the end conditions. «intemal p Ae.r=)- (ee) 209, PEL (4) 8. Eccentrically Loaded Columns + Secant formula Pie. Le Ee “y Sau =O] 14 Pe sec( e) }P we aL eae NEA 7 | {Where 6,,,=maximum compressive stress -———' P=load where, 6. = | Page 267 of 420Chapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondal’s A= Area of els Y_= Distance of the outermost fiber in compression from the NA Eccentricity of the load Equivalent length k= Radius of gyration =f E= Modulus of elasticity of the material M=PesSec| £. | P 2VEA Where M = Moment introduced ‘+ Prof, Perry’s Formula _P__Load “A clsarea P._Euler’s load eA els area e'= Versine at mid-length of column duc to initial curvature Becentricity of the load e=e't 120 {y= distance of outer most fiber in compression form the NA Radius of gyration If Oy, is allowed to go up to 6,(permssible stress) ‘+ Perry-Robertson Formula vanChapter-13 Theories of Column 9. ISI’s Formula for Columns and Struts For “=0 10 160 k . pe Lis 160 aso este) k 4E sg a rc a apes (=A hn OGL ihre Been ¢, = Guaranteed minimum yield stress = 2600 kg/em? for mild steel fos = factor of safety = 1.68 Slenderness ratio = or > 160 Page 3690 420 Modulus of elasticity = 2.045% 10° kg / cm? for mild steel SK Mondar'sChapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondal's OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Strength of Column GATE. The rod PQ of length L and with = flexural rigidity EI is hinged at both ends. For what minimum P force Fis it expected to buckle? ‘EL rt @* oy rel uv Z © z Z 45° \Q 4 F [GATE-2008] GATE. Ans, (b) Axial component ofthe force Fra=F Sin 45# We know for both end fixed column buckling load (P) & PEI and Fsin4S?=P or Equivalent Length GATE. The ratio of Euler's buckling loads of columns with the same parameters having (i) both ends fixed, and (ii) both ends hinged is: IGATE-1998; 2002; 1BS-2001] @2 wa 6 @s GATE-2, Ans. (b) Euler's buckling loads of eolumas (1) both ends sixea = 4! (2) both ends hinged Euler's Theory (For long column) GATES. A pin-ended column of length L, modulus of elasticity E and second moment of the cross-sectional area I is loaded centrically by a compressive load P. The critical buckling load (P..) is given by: IGATE-2006] @ p= p, == et @ * El f= GATE-8. Ans. (d) GATE, What is the expression forthe crippling load fora colum of length‘! with one tnd fixed and other end free? THES-2006; GATE-1998) 2H oy p=Z repeal @Chapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondar's GATE-t, Ans. (b) 21. The piston rad of diameter 20 mm and length 700 mm in a hydraulic cylinder is subjected to a compressive force af 10 KN due to the internal pressure. The end conditions for the rod may be assumed as guided at the piston end and hinged at the other end. The Young's modulus is 200 GPa. The factor of safely for the piston rod is (068 (©) 275 (0) 582 (6) 11,0 [GATE-2007] 21. Ans. (¢) Previous 20-Years IES Questions Classification of Column TES-1, A structural member subjected to an axial compressive force is called THES.2008] (a) Beam (b) Column (©) Frame (d) Strut TES.1, Ans. (d) A machine part subjected to an axial compressive fore is called a etrut, A strut may bo horizontal, inclined or even vertical, But n vertical strut is known as a column, pillar or stanchion. ‘The term column is applied to all such members except those in which failure would be by simple or pure compression, Columns can be categorized then as Long column with central loading Tntermediateclength columns with central Toading Columns with eccentric loading Struts or short colmmne with oscontris loading IES2. Which one of the following loadings is considered for design of axles? (@) Bending moment only ES-1995] (b) Twisting moment only (©) Combined bending moment and torsion (@) Combined action of hending moment, twisting moment and axial thrust IES-2. Ans. (a) Axle is a non-rotating member used for supporting rotating wheels etc. and do not ‘transmit any torque. Axle must resist forces applied laterally or transversely to their axes, Such members are called beams, Page 371 of 420Chapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondal’s TES3. The curve ABC is the Buler's curve for stability of column. The horizontal line DEF is the strength limit. With reference to this figure Match List-I with List- II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists List Lista egions) (Column specification) AR 1. Long, stable BR 2 Short ck Medium at oor . ae ES-1997] Codes: A B CD A B cD @ 2 4 3 1 @ 2 8 1 4 @r 2 4 8 @ 2 1 8 4 TES-3. Ans. (b) TES-4, Mach List-1 with List-II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: HIAS-1999] ‘List List-1 ‘A. Polar moment of inertia of section 1. Thin cylindrical shell B. Bucking 2 Torsion of shafts . Neutral axis 5. Columns 1D. Hoop stress 4. Bending of beams Codes AB OC) OD AB CD @ 3 2 4 0m 2 8 4 1 @8 2 4 1 @ 2 8 41 4 TES-4. Ans. (b) Strength of Column TES.5. " Slenderness ratio of a column is defined as the ratio of its length to its (a) Least radius of gyration (b) Least lateral dimension [ES-2003] (©) Maximum lateral dimension —_—_(q) Maximum radius of gyration TESS. Ans. (a) TES-6. Assertion (A: A long column of square cross section has greater buckling stability than a similar column of circular cross-section of same length, same material and same area of cross-section with same end conditions. Reason (R): A circular cross-section has a smaller second moment of area than a square cross-section of same area. [TES-1999, TES-1996] (a) Hoth A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (o) Ais true but Ris false (@ Ais false but Ris true TES-6. Ans. (a) Equivalent Length TES7. Four columns of same material and same length are of rectangular eross- section of same breadth b. The depth of the cross-section and the end conditions are, however different are given as follows: [ES-2004] Column, ‘Depth End conditions 1 065 Fixed-Fixed 2 sb Fixed-hinged 3 0b Hinged-Hinged 4 26d Fixed-Free Which of the above columns Euler buckling load maximum? (a) Column 1 (b) Columnrge 272 of 42de) Column 3 (@) Column 4 IES-7. Ans. (b)Chapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondar's TES-8. Match List-I (End conditions of columns) with List-IT (Equivalent length in terms of length of hinged-hinged column) and select the correct answer using the codes given below the Lists: TES-2000] List-I List-I A. Both ends hinged LL B. One end fixed and other end free a2 C. One end fixed and the other pin-pointed 3.2L D. Both ends fixed 42 Code: A BO OC) OD AB Cc oD @ 1 3 4 2 @ 1 8 2 4 O38 1 2 4 @ 3 1 4 2 IBS-8, Ans. (b) IES-9, The ratio of Euler's buckling loads of columns wi having (i) both ends fixed, and (ii) both ends hinged the same parameters [GATE-1998; 2002; 1ES-2001] 2 wa os @s IBS-9, Ans. (b) Euler's buckling loads of columns (1) both ends fixed = 4&1 (2) both ends hinged = = Euler's Theory (For long column) IES-10. What is the expression for the crippling load for a column of length T with one end fixed and other end free? [ES-2006; GATE-1994), 2x EL EL (@ P= oP cy IES-10. Ans. (b) © IES-11, Euler's formula gives 5 to 10% error in crippling load as compared to experimental results in practice because: [ES-1998} (a) Effect of direct stress is neglected () Pin joints are not free from friction (6) The assumptions made in using the formula are not met in practice (@) The material does not behave in an ideal elastic way in tension and compression IES-11, Ans. (0) TES-12, _ Buler's formula can be used for obtaining crippling load for a M.S. column with hhinged ends. satisfied? [(ES-2000) i i L i @5 k 8 ) 'e 18 @19 k 40 Oy 80 IES-12. Ans. (d) TES-13, If one end of a hinged column is made fixed and the other free, how much is the critical load compared to the original value? [ES-2008} a % 4 (©) Twice (4) Four times IES-13. Ans. (a) Critical Load for both ends hinged = 2 2E1/ [2 And Critieal Load for one end fixed, and other end free = “EAP IES-14. [fone end of a hinged column is made fixed and the other froe, how much is the critical load compared to the original value? [ES-2008] @% (©) Twice (@) Four times Page 3730428 IES-14. Ans. (a) Original load.Chapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondal’s When one end of hinged column is fixed and other free. New Le = 2L. New kad = 281-72 4 .oygnal vue (fay 44 IESL16, Match List with List and solct the correct anewor using the code given Micy asta Ts isch aureiansera Tine T cong Catummy Lise tt (tical bond) A Bathends hinged Leese Os Sea hand ras eo © Bochende ed sanaie 1 Ou sn iad id thor ot Wigs teen Codes nD a ot PP? wt & 2 2 O23 4 1 Of 3 2 4 TES-15. Ans. (b) TESAG. The ra of the compressive critical load for a long column fixed at both the ends and a column with one end fixed and the other end free is: {IES-1997] (1:2 (byt Ors (@ 1:16 TES-16. Ans. (d) Critical Load for one end fixed, and other end free is 721/472 and both ends fixed isd RUT? TES.17. The buckling load will be maximum for a column, if [TES-1993] (a) One end of the column is clamped and the other end is free (b) Both ends of the column are clamped (©) Both ends ofthe column are hinged (@__ One end of the column is hinged and the other end is free TES-17. Ans. (b) Buckling load of a column will be maximum when both ends are fixed TES.18, If diameter of a long column is reduced by 20%, the percentage of reduction in Euler buckling load is: UES-2001] aa ©) 36 19 (a59 eat rE) 4. (088) L059 TES.18. Ans. (@) P= “7 Peal oF Pood or TES.19. A long slender bar having uniform rectangular cross-section 'B x H' is acted upon by an axial compressive force. The sides B and H are parallel to x- and y- axes respectively. The ends of the bar are fixed such that they behave as pin- Jointed when the bar buckles in a plane normal to x-axis, and they behave as built-in when the bar buckles in a plane normal to y-axis. If load capacity in either mode of buckling is same, then the value of H/B will be: [LES-2000] @2 or 8 @ 6 es.19, Ans. (a) 2, ==! ana p, =4& Eas p, =P, then 1=a4l or BH = 43cHB° gg “SE oe ” 7242 IES20, The Euler's crippling load for a 2m long slender steel rod of uniform eross- section hinged at both the ends is 1 EN. The Euler's crippling load for 1 m long. steel rod of the same cross-section and hinged at both ends will be: [1ES-1998] (2) 0.25 kN (©) 0.5 KN (2KN (@ kN 1 TES-20, Ans, (d) For column with both ends hinged, P = If Tis halved, P will be 4 times. TES21. Ifo. and E denote the crushing stress and Young's modulus for the material of a column, then the Euler formula can be applied for determination of cripping Toad of a column made of this mate al ifits slenderness ratio is: (a) More than 2 fE To, P20° th) fess than JE 7a, TIES-2005]Chapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondar's covman x(2} cormon (2) o.) oO, wEl PEAK? fe) _ rE le og EM on efile or Bs Ta, TES-22. Four vertical columns of same material, height and weight have the same end conditions. Which cross-section will earry the maximum load? TES.2009] (a) Solid circular seetion (b) Thin hollow circular section (6) Solid square section (@) Lsection TES-22, Ans. (b) Rankine's Hypothesis for Struts/Columns TES-23, Rankine Gordon formula for buckling is valid for TES-1994] (a) Long column, () Short column () Short and long eoluma (@) Very long columa TES-23, Ans. (c) Prof. Perry's formula TES-24, Match ist with ListII and select the correct answer using the code given below the lists: [ES-2008} List-I (Formula/theoren/ method) List-II (Deals with topic) A. Clapeyron's theorem 1. Deflection of beam B. Maculay’s method. 2. Becentrically loaded column ©. Perry's formula 8. Riveted joints 4. Continuous beam Code: A BC A B oc @ 3 2 1 ® 4 1 2 @4 1 8 @ 2 4 3 TES-24. Ans. (b) Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Classification of Column IAS-1, Mach List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: [IAS-1999] List Listt ‘A Polar moment of inertia of section 1. Thin evlindrical shell B. Buckling 2. Torsion of shafts ©: Neutral axis 3. Columns . Hoop stress 4. Bending of beams Codes A BOO a ar) @ 3 2 1 4 @ 2 8 4 19 @ 3 2 1 @ 2 8 4. 4 IAS-1, Ans. (b) Strength of Column IAS2, Assertion (A): A Iong column of square cross-section has greater buckling stability than that of a column of circular cross-section of same length, same sane ond conditions and same area of cross-section. TIAS-1998] Reason (B) The second momen of prog af column of clreular eroseeection is Smaller than hat ofa colunm of Sates Seon section having the same are {@) Both And Rare individually te and Ri the correct explanation of AChapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondal’s (b) Both A and R are individually true but Ris NOT the correct explanation of A (©) Ais true but Ris false (@ Ais false but Ris true TAS-2. Ans. (a) IAS.3. Which one of the following pairs is not correctly matched? THAS-2003] (a) Slenderness ratio: ‘The ratio of length of the column to the least radius of gyration (b) Buckling factor: ‘The ratio of maximum load to the permissible axial load on the ‘column (©) Short column A column for which slenderness ratio < 32 (@ Strut A member of a structure in any position and carrying an axial compressive load TAS.8. Ans. (b) Buckling factor: The ratio of equivalent length of the column to the least radius of evration, Equivalent Length IAS-4. A column of length ‘I’ is fixed at its both ends. The equivalent length of the column is: TAS-1995] @2t @)05T wz @!r IAS-4. Ans. (b) TAS.5. Which one of the following statements is correct? [TAS-2000] (a) Euler's formula holds good only for short columns (©) A short column is one which has the ratio ofits Iength to least radius of gyration groater than 100 (© Acolumn with both ends fixed has minimum equivalent or effective length (@) The equivalent length of a column with one end fixed and other end hinged is half of'its actual length, TAS-5. Ans. (c) A column with both ends fixed has minimum equivalent effective length (/2) Euler's Theory (For long column) TAS-6. For which one of the following columns, Euler buckling load =. jv bl, (a) Column with both hinged ends TTAS-1999; 2004] (b) Column with one end fixed and other end free (©) Column with both ends fixed (@ Column with one end fixed and other hinged TAS-6. Ans. (c) IAS7. Assertion (A): Buckling of long columns causes plastic deformation. [LAS-2001] Reason (R): In a buckled colunm, the stresses do not exceed the yield stress, (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (©) Ais true but Ris false (@ Ais false but Ris true TAS 1. Ans. (d) And Critical Load for one end fixed, and other end free = 7 EVP IAS8, Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the code given helow the Lists: [IES-1995; 2007; IAS-1997] List-I (Long Column) List-1I (Critieal Load) ‘A. Both ends hinged Page 376 of ag HEL/AM B. Ono ond fixed, and other end free 24 2B TEChapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondar's C. Hoth ends fixed 3.2 EYE D. One end fixed, and other end hinged 4 EWE Code: A BC D A B Cc D @m 2 1 4 8 M4 1 2 8 @®2 38 4 1 @4 3 2 1 TAS-8, Ans. (b) Page 37 of 420Chapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondal’s Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question ESE-2001, ESE 2000 Question: Differentiate between strut and column. What is the general expression used for determining of their critical load? Answer: Strut: A member of structure which earries an axial compressive Lond. Column: Ifthe strut is vertical itis known as column, Compressive force For strut failure due to compression or 0, " ‘ ‘Area Ifo, > 0,- it fails, WEL Euler's formula for calumn(P.) Conventional Question ESE-2009 @ ‘Two long columns are made of identical lengths ‘’ and flexural rigidities ‘EV’. Column 1 is hinged at both ends whereas for column 2 one end is fixed and the other end is free. (Write the expression for Euler's buckling load for column 1. (ii) What is the ratio of Euler’s buckling load of column 1 to that column 2? [2 Marks] Ans. op 4 PEL, » WEL, “ppt Pen gg (right) Forcolumnl, both end hinged| La aw» ai P, Conventional Question ESE-2010 Q The piston rod of diameter 20 mm and length 700 mm in a hydraulic cylinder is subjected to a compressive force of 10 KN due to internal pressure. The piston end of the rod is guided along the cylinder and the other end of the rod is hinged at the cross-head. The modulus of elasticity for piston rod material is 200 GPa. Estimate the factor of safety taken for the piston rod design. [2 Marks} WEL Phy a AE other end is hinged) Pe=Buler Crippling load Compressive load, P, =o, xArea = 10 kN 2? 200310") x(n0.020" /64) (considering one end of the column is fixed and Euler's load, P, = ae = 63.278 KN Euler's load Compressiveload 63.27 Page 3780428Chapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondar's Conventional Question ESE-1999 Question: State the limitation of Euler's formula for calculating critical load on columns Answer: Assumptions: @ The column is perfectly straight and of uniform cross-section (i) The material is homogenous and isotropie (Gi) The material behaves elastically (iv) The load is perfectly axial and passes through the centroid ofthe column section (8) The weight ofthe column is neglected, Conventional Question ESE-2007 Question: What is the value of Buler's buckling load for an axially loaded pin-ended (hinged at both ends) strut of length 'T and flexural rigidity EI’? What would he order of Euler's buckling load carrying capacity of a similar strut but fixed at both ends in terms of the load carrying eapacity of the earlier one? Answer: From Euler's buckling load formula, wEl Critical load (P,) = "> Equivalent length (¢,. for both end hinged = {% for both end fixed. So for both end hinged (P.)s., a REI 4x°El and for both fixed (P.)eer we Conventional Question ESE-1996 Question: Euler's critical load for a column with both ends hinged is found as 40 kN. What would be the change in the critical load if both ends are fixed? Answer: We know that Euler's eritical laod, El Pra [Where E = modulus of elasticity, I = least moment of inertia ¢, = equivalent length } For both end hinged (£. [And For both end fixed (€)= ¢/2 (Peaer doen 1OkN(Given) and (Pee er 4x TEx 40 = 160K Conventional Question ESE-1999 Question: A hollow cast iron column of 300 mm external diameter and 220 mm internal ‘diameter is used as a column 4 m long with both ends hinged. Determine the safe compressive load the column can carry without buckling using Euler's formula and Renkine's formula E=0.7%105Nimms, FOS = 4, Rankine constant (a) = 1/1600 Crushing Stress (0) = 567 Nimm* Anawer: Given outer diameter of colunin (D) = 300 m Inner diameter ofthe column (2) = 220 mm ‘Length of the column (£) = 4m End conditions is both ends hinged. Therefore equivalent length (0) Yield crushing stress (6, )= 567 MPa = 567%106 Nim? 1/1600 aap eae Nimo 0.3m, 22m, Rankine constant (a) 109 NimtChapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondat’s Momentofinertia() = = (D* ~4*) = 2 [0.3 0.22] = 2.626% 10~m* a2) aa 7 ree fos os +027 _ occa Area(a) = (0? - 0°) = 5 (0.3? - baz) = 0.03267 m? (0) Euler's buckling load, Pa. Pag = REL _ F A(TO%10") (2.62610) _ 49 944 q 4 Safe load = Fase — 122 _ 3.05 yy tos 4 (iRankine's buckling load, Pranin oA __ (867%10*) 0.03267 Panne = 024 = EDIE JSODSIST = 8.59 MN anaes 1600 {0.093 2.148MPa tral P, Safe load = Fesstn=, safe loa 3 Conventional Question ESE-2008 Question: Answer: ‘A both ends hinged cast iron hollow cylindrical column 3 m in length has a itical buckling load of P kN. When the column is fixed at both the ends, its critical buckling load raise by 300 kN more. If ratio of external diameter to internal diameter is 1.25 and E= 100 GPa determine the external diameter of column. “ For both end fixed column +300: ny Dividing (ji) by (i) we get +300 4 of P=100kN Moment of inertia of a hollow cylinder c/s is Pe we 64 (10010*)3® x x x100x10° (D* -d* ual orb* —d' 1.857710 Page 380 of 428Chapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondar's D D iven © = 4.25 ord =P oven g 1255 or ot} -( 4] = 1.857710 125 or D=0.0749 m = 74.9 mm Conventional Question AMIE-1996 Question: A piston rod of steam engine 80 em long in subjected to a maximum load of 60 KN. Determine the diameter of the rod using Rankine’s formula with permissible compressive stress of 100 Nimm*. Take constant in Rankine’s formula as [for hinged ends. The rod may be assumed pa 1 sa ially fixed with length coefficient of 0-6. Answer: Given: |=80 om = 800mm ;P = 60KN=60x10°N, a, 1 7600 JOON / mm’, a= =.—- for hinged ends; length coefficient = 0.6 To find diameter of the rod, d: Use Rankine’s formula ala 5 * 7600 E 74 | Solving the above equation we gt the value of a Nota: Unit of d comos out from the equation will ba mm as we put the equivalent length in mim. or d=3323mm Conventional Question ESE-2005 Question: A hollow cylinder CI column, 3 m long its internal and external diameters as 80 mm and 100 mm respectively. Calculate the safe load using Rankine formula: (i) Both ends are hinged and (ii) Both ends are fixed. ‘Take crushing strength of material as 600 V/ mn", Rankine constant 1/1600 and factor of safety = 3. = .1'—0.08" Fy (0-1 — 0.08") Answer: Moment of Inertia (| 2.89810 m* Page 381 of 420Chapter-t3 Theories of Column SK Mondal’s Area(A) = ©(0.4° -0.08") = 2.827410? 2.898%4 Radius of gyration (k) = /+ = | 208% 10 — lus of gyration 2.8274x10 A 0.032m Presee= —S°7 i [C= equivalent length] ital +a{ (600 x10*) x(2.8274x10-*) @ ar ae ee m for both end hinged] 14f— |] 3 +{;e00) local =2.61026kN Safe load (P)=Pexue — 26126 _ 57 ook FOS 3 (ii) For both end fixed, ¢, = 5m (600x10°) (2.8274 x10") rane 5 =714.8KN wot (os%s] 1600 “|0.032 Pressing _ 714.8 Safe load (P)="ete. = TES = 238.27 KN Conventional Question AMIE-1997 Question: A slender column is built-in at one end and an eccentric load is applied at the free end. Working from the first principles find the expression for the maximum length of column such that the deflection of the free end does not exceed the eccentricity of loading. Answer: Above figure shows a slender column of length ‘T. The column is built in at one end B and eccentric load P is applied at the free end A. Let y be the deflection at any section XX distant x from the fixed end B. Let 5 be the deflection at A. ‘The bending moment at the section XX is given by Page 2820428Chapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondar's 2 pore =| Elgg Plo +e-y) @ ay dy PPO. EISY py =P(s+ Py Pos, get Py=P(S+8) oF Cat ey=E(F+e) ‘The solution to the above differential equation is roe lecafe ier. 0 Where C, and C, are the constants. At the end B, and y=0 C, cos 0+C, sind+(5 +e) (s+e) Differentiating equation (i) we get 6, /P fe poe os EF) ax yer (Ver |* Cres [Yer Again,at the fixed end B, or gy when x=0,22 1x Oa P iF o=(6+e) 4 «040, [F coso o G0 At the free end AX= y= ‘Substituting for x and y in equation (i), we have Coren | (e+e) liste Tt is mentioned in the problem that the deflection of the free end does not exceed the eccentricity. It means that 6=e ‘Substituting this value in equation (ii), we have cx | tat a ore 2 Conventional Question ESE-2005 Question: A long strut AB of longth '¢' is of uniform section throughout. A thrust P is applied at the ends eccentrically on the same side of the centre line with eccentricity at the end B twice than that at the end A. Show that the maximum bending moment occurs at a distance x from the end A, oskt 4 [P sink wel Page 383.0428Chapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondal’s Anawer: Let at a distance 'x from end A deflection of the [P given am CX ofthis differential oquation y= Acos kx+ B sin kx, Where A & B constant, Tris elearat x=0, y Andat x=, y=2e e=A. i) 2e=Acosk(+Bsinkc or B=|2—2008Kr sink? 2e—ecoské = ecoskx + |P2— 2 COSKL sin py ¥ +P sinks | Where bending moment is maximum, the deflection will be maximum so = 0 yy 2e-ecoski} p _ = ek indo +k PPE cos kx =0 or tankx = 2—CO8KE sinke Conventional Question ESE-1996 Question: The link of a mechanism is subjected to axial compressive force. It has solid circular cross-section with diameter 9 mm and length 200 mm, The two ends of the link are hinged. It is made of steel having yield strength = 400 N/mm? and elastic modulus = 200 kN/imm®. Calculate the critical load that the link can carry. Use Johnon's equation. Answer: According to Johnson's equation », =6, A= Hear A=; 2 _63.62mm* ee | least radius of gyration (k ory == 255mm fF) For both end hinged n=1 | 400 20 Pa 40036362 — oo aos 28] 15262KN Conventional Question GATE-1995 Question: Find the shortest length of a hinggd-etogksplumn having a rectangular cross- section 600 mm x 100 mm, for which the elastie Euler formula applies. TakeChapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondar's yield strength and modulus of elasticity value for steel as 250 MPa and 200 GPa respectively. Answer: Given: Cross-section, (= bx d) = 600 mm x 100 mm = 0.6 m x 0.1 m=0.06 m#; Yul wagh= © 2509 = 204 = 200 GPa 2010°H a Length of the column, L : Leastareamomentof inertia, = 4 = 95*0.1 _ 5 -19-¢m* 2 12 1 _ 5x10 Also, 8.33310" m? A” 06x04 [- [= AK? (where A= area of cross-section, k = radius of gyration)] From Euler's formula for column, we have FEI _ «El Te For bothendhinged type of column, t= L Crushing load, —P, or or or ‘Substituting the value, we get ® x 200 x10” x 0,0008333 & 25010" L=2565m Conventional Question GATE-1993 Question: Determine the temperature rise necessary to induce buckling in a Im long circular rod of diameter 40 mm shown in the Figure below. Assume the rod to be pinned at its ends and the coefficient of thermal expansion as20x10" /° C Assume uniform heating of the bar. 40mm dia. rod Answer: —_Letusassumethe buckling load be'P’. Page 2880428Chapter-13 Theories of Column SK Mondal’s éL=L.x.at, Where At is the temperature rise. or Also, ——— (where L, =equivalentlength) or [QL,=L Forbothendhinged] or eh x LALx Fan ‘Substituting the values, we get x= x(0,040)" — 84 2 49.38°C (1° «3 x(0.040)* «20107 So the rod will buckle when the temperature rises more than 49.35°C. Temperature rise af Page 386 of 428Strain Energy Method Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 4. Resilience (U) ? + Resilience is an ability of a material to absorb energy when elastically deformed and to return it when unloaded. Arcana 6) + The strain energy stored in a specimen when stained within the elastic Limit is known aa resilience, a S_xVolume| or 2E 2. Proof Resilience + Maximum strain energy stored at elastic limit. ie, the strain energy stored in the body upto clastic limit. ‘+ This is the property of the material that enables it to resist shock and impact by storing energy. The measure of proof resilience is the strain energy absorbed per unit volume. 3. Modulus of Resilience (u) ‘The proof resilience per unit volume is known as modulus of resilience. If 6 is the stress due to ‘gradually applied load, then or 4. Application eae eeeneaaene ‘Strain energy becomes smaller & smaller as the cross sectional area of bar is increased over more & more ofits length ie. AT, UL 5. Toughness + This is the property which enables a material to be twisted, bont or stretched under impact Toad or high stress before rupture. Te 889° B@\Aldered to be the ability of the material toChapter-14 Strain Energy Method SK Mondal’s absorb energy in the plastic zone. The measure of toughness is the amount of energy absorbed after being stressed upto the point of fracture. + Toughness is an ability to absorb energy in the plastic range, ‘+ The ability to withstand occasional stresses above the yield stress without fracture ‘© Toughness = strength + ductility ‘+ The materials with higher modulus of toughness are used to make components and structures that will he exposed to sudden and impact loads. Modulus of Toughness 2 ° +The ability of unit volume of material eae to absorb energy in the plastic range. Set ---7 «The amount of work per mit value wai that the material can withstand without failure. © The area under the entire stress strain ® & diagram is called modulus of toughness, which is a measure of energy that ean u=xu3) be absorbed by the unit volume of material due to impact loading before it fractures. 6. Strain energy in shear and torsion ‘© Strain energy per unit volume. (u,) Tr ri bu =a] + Total Strain Energy (U) for a Shaft in Torsion ¢ i . or © Cases *Solid shaft U, =" x77 L UG ‘Hollow shaft, U, Page 388 of 420Chapter-14 Strain Energy Method SK Mondar's Thin walled tube, U, = 4G xslt where 5= Length of mean centre line saa} -2 =) Rda (R= Radius) ds * Conical spring, Us oar J Reda: (R varies with ) 3( PL ‘Cantilever beam with load 'p' at end, U, = “ Wah seiy (aa) Helical spring , U, = a " (:L=2aRn) 7. Strain energy in bending. Me i + Angle subtended by are, 0= J a © Strain energy stored in beam, © Cantilever beam with a end load P, Us (© Simply supported with a load P at centre, U, + Important Note © For pure bending Mis constant along the length 'L + on Mt El we ifMisknown = 2 curvature IL isknown + Us © For non-uniform bending Strain enorgy in shear is neglected Strain enorgy in bending is only considered. 8. Castiglione’s theorem Page 389 of 428Strain Energy Method SK Mondal’s Lp ay (Me El) *\ ep © Strain energy, stored due to direct stress in 3 coordinates u=Z1Ley-2Lse,] © Ifo, =0, =4,,in case of equal stress in 3 direction then 307 e i U=Felt-2il= 57 (volume strain energy) Page 390 of 428Chapter-14 Strain Energy Method SK Mondar's OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Strain Energy or Resilience GATE-1, The strain energy stored in the beam with flexural rigidity EI and loaded as shown in the figure is: IGATE-2008} are 3EI is IGATE-1993] (a) py) Ft 3H ET GATE-2, Ans, (b) We may do it taking average PY) PL PL Strain energy = Average foree x displacement = (> " “ ° (er 3EI GET 1 Alternative method: In a funny way you may use Castiglione’s theorem, 6= "=. Then Iternative met Wy way you may tial P PL. OP Partially integrating with respect to P we Ej UP Partially integrating with respect to P we get Page 291 of 428Chapt strain Energy Method SK Mondas GATE-3. The stress-strain behaviour of a 1 sat aiee i teed ae Tailicnes tnd toughaves, Mewes, tre reapectvely fe hot ie (a) 28% 108, 7 () 28 % 108, 48 108 () 14 x 10%, 90 x 10" (@ 76x :10' 0.008 00 Stra (maven IGATE-2000) our: A Mss Wass ee Np OLN = $0.004.<70.10° =14<10° Noi! 14107040" s(0012-0004)- (9012-0004 120-70) Nm’ 00st! Nett same bar is then used as a cantilever beam and subjected to all end load P. The ratio of the strain energies, stored in the bar in the second case to that stored in the first cast IGATE-1998] @i6 (b) 400 (© 1000 (a) 2500 a GATE-4, Ans. (d) U,= wal al 2 ja U= Ge Fray Aza eel ( 2 u, a a uy ae ats Toughness GATE-5, The total area under the stress-strain curve of a mild steel specimen tested up to failure under tension is a measure of IGATE-2002) (a) Ductiity(b) Ultimate strength © Stiffness (@) Toughness GATE-5. Ans. d) Previous 20-Years IES Questions Strain Energy or Resilience TES.1. What is the strain energy stored in a body of volume V with stress ¢ due to gradually applied load? [TES-2006] ok cE a a) SF ) © @) F oF 5 © @ Where, E = Modulus of elastic 1a TRS. Ans. (2) Strain Energy =5.5xV TES-2. A bar having length L and uniform cross-section with area A is subjected to hoth tensile force P and torque ApekéAérigothe shear modulus and E is the Young's modulus, the intornal strain energy stored in the bar is: [IES-2003]Chapter-14 Strain Energy Method SK Mondar's @ r'L. PL 2G) 2AE A, 1 1 1, PL1,,.7L TES. Ans. J pselrg tp Phy lp Te (©) Internal strain energy = 5P5+570= P+ 5T oe TES, Strain energy stored in a body of volume V subjected to uniform st (1ES-2002] @sEIV wevv own @ eae TES-3. Ans. (d) TES-4, A ber of length L and of uniform cross-sectional area A and secondd moment of area 1’ is subjected to a pull P. If Young's modulus of elasticity of the bar tmatorial is E, the expression for strain energy svored in the bar will be T1ES-1999] P Pl PI PL —— (b)—— (d) DAE OE OcE OnE TES-4, Ans, (a) Strain energy = +x stress x stain x volume=4x{ ?)f? 4) (an) = PE 2 2\4 AE. 2AE IES5. Which one of the following gives the correct expression for strain energy stored in a beam of length L and of uniform cross-section having moment of inertia T and subjected to constant bending moment M? [ES-1997] ML ML ML N a) by (e) = (ay Oe eR OF (Vom TESS. Ans, (@) IES-6, A steel specimen 150 mm’ in cross-section stretches by 0:05 mm over a 50 mm gauge length under an axial load of 20 kN. What is the strain energy stored in the specimen? (Take E = 200 GPa) [TES-2009] (a) 0.75 N-m (b) 1.00 N-m (©) 1.50 Nm (@) 3.00N-m TES-6, Ans. (a) Strain Energy stored in the specimen se(P) PAL __(30000)’ «50x10 AE)” 2AE ~ 2150x107 x200%10° =0.75N-m IES-7, What is the expression for the strain energy due to bending of a cantilever beam (length L. modulus of elasticity E and moment of inertial)? —_[TES-2009] PE PL Pe PL (ay a FE oft @ § SET 6EI 4ér A8ET LPN af pa TES-7, Ans, () Strain Bnorgy Stored = (PALM. P(X Y . PL V2 “zea,” eet TES, The property by which an amount of energy is absorbed by a material without plastic deformation, is called: {LES-2000) {@) Toughness (B) Impact strength (© Dustility (@) Resilience TES, Ans. (@) IES-9, 30 C 8 steel has its yield strength of 400 Nimm and modulus of elasticity of 2 10° MPa. Assuming the material to obey Hooke's law up to yielding, what is its proof resilience? [LES-2006] () 08 Nimm? (6)0.4 Nim? (©)06 Nimm? (0:7 Nimm*? 1 @? _ 1, (400) ER g eta JAN mm TES.9, Ans, (b) Proof resilience (R,Chapter-14 Strain Energy Method SK Mondal’s Toughness TES-10. Toughness for mild steel under uni-axial tensile loading is given by the shaded portion of the stress-strain diagram as shown in [1ES-2003] fa) () ° ~™ © Fracture 7 = TES.10, An&. (d) Toughness of material is the total area under stress-strain curve, Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Strain Energy or Resilience IAS-1. Total strain energy stored in a simply supported beam of span, ‘L’ and flexural ty ‘El ‘subjected to a concentrated load W" at the centre is equal to: TAS-1995] wee Ww wee ) yy WE © a © (OE © CoE © S6BI : beede # 1 Pre WER TAS-L. Ans. (6) Strain energy = [MS «25 f Mie 1S (WRY ay 2 tostnincmna = Papa? [ere] Owe tortie method tna fnny wap yn may wo Castine hone, 8 20 = ap ow ~48ET We know that for simply supported beam in concentrated Ioad at mid span. au. ou _ wet pw? ‘Then = «ua fou LAW partially integrating with ap a ~ ager = J = | aug mosis starve was respect to Wwe got U= ™ fee O6EI TAS.2, If the cross-section of a member is subjected to a uniform shear stress of intensity ‘q’ then the strain energy stored per unit volume is equal to (G = modulus of rigidity). [AS-1994] (a) 2926 2G (a2 2G @G2q@ IAS2. Ans. (c) TAS8. The strain energy stored in the beam with flexural rigidity ET and loaded as shown in the figure is: IGATE-2008] Page 294 0f428Chapter-14 Strain Energy Method SK Mondal's P P e+ 2 Ww Pe re ae are (ay PE ) o © Er SEI Og ET eMed TAS. Ans. (e © ‘ zy Meds ie 5p Cae +fege- Peet Je SEI IAS-4, Which one of the following statements is correct? {1As-2004) ‘The work done in stretching an elastic string varies (G0 Ab tha square ofthe extension (@) As the square rot of tha extansion (© Linearly withthe extension (@) As the cube root of the extension ete _ slo TAS, Ans. (a) 2 = 3 : Toughness JAS. Match List with ListIl and select the correct answer using the cades given below the lis TAS-1996] List (Mechanical properties) Listll (Meaning of properties) A. Ductile 1. Resistance to indentation B. Hardnese 2 Ability to abvorb onorgy during plastic ©: Malleability doformstion D. Toughness 3, Peroontage of elongation 4 Ability tobe rolled into flat product Codes A RB CD AR CD @ 1 4 8 2 @ 8 2 4 2 ® 2 8 4 1 @ 3 1 4 2 @ IAS6, Match List (Material properties) with List (Technical definition/requirement) and select the correct answer using the codes below the lists [AS-1999] List-I1 1, Pereontage of elongation B. Toughnoss 2. Resistance to indentation C. Mallenbility 3. Ability to absorb energy during plastic deformation D, Ductility 4. Ability to be rolled into plates Codes A BC D AB C oD @ 3 2 1 4 @ 2 8 4 1 ® 2 4 3 1 @ 1 8 4 2 (o) IAS7, A truck weighing 150 KN and travelling at 2m/sec impacts which a buffer spring which compresses 1.25em per 10 KN. The maximum compression of the oping ie Page 05 of 420 TAS-1995]Chapter-14 Strain Energy Method SK Mondal’s (2) 20,00 em () 22.85 em (©) 27.66 em 150KN TORRENT (@) 30.00 em 0. TAS 7. Ans. (c) Kinetic energy of the truck = strain energy of the spring 02") Jinv? = te? orx = | = Soar) 2 2 k 101000 “0.0125 = 0.2766m = 27.66em Page 396 of 428Chapter-14 Strain Energy Method SK Mondar's Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question IES 2009 a Ans. A close coiled helical spring made of wire diameter d has mean coil radius R, number of turns n and modulus of rigidity G. The spring is subjected to an axial compression W. () Write the expression for the stiffness of the spring. @) What is the magnitude of the maximum shear stress induced in the spring wire neglecting the curvature effect? [2 Marks] W_ Ga! (1 Spring stiffness, K= = TS swD (2) Maximum shear stress, xa? Conventional Question IES 2010 a Ans. A semicircular steel ring of mean radius 300 mm is suspended vertically with the top end fixed as shown in the above figure and carries a vertical load of 200 Nat the lowest point Calculate the vertical deflection of the lower end if the ring is of rectangular cross- section 20 mm thick and 30 mm wide, Value of Elastic modulus is2x10° N/mm, Influence of circumferential and shearing forces may be neglected. [10 Marks} 3 Pe. ap Toad applied, Mean Radius, R istic modules, E = 210° Nimm? Inertia of moment of eross — section ba® b=20mm > Influence of circumferential and shearing force are noglected strain energy at the section, Page 297 of 428Chapter-14 Strain Energy Method SK Mondal’s TM'RdO » R for 210 ‘ Ver a M=FxRsin@ = Mersino au _fERteint@ 4g _, ERY wr aER? __2x200x(300)" 2EL 2x2%10° «45000 14107 mm. Conventional Question GATE-1996 Question: Answer: A simply supported beam is subjected to a single force P at a distance b from one of the supports. Obtain the expression for the deflection under the load using Castigliano’s theorem. How do you calculate deflection at the mid-point of the beam? Let load P acts at a distance b from the support B, and I. be the total length of the beam. Reaction tA, R="? and Reaction at A, 2 Pe —a Se A cc 8 L Pb Pa iL - Strain energy stored by beam AB, U= Strain energy stored by AC (U 10) + strain energy stored by BC U ns) “(2 ea (Pa) de _ Piva, Pita! he BET ‘OT GEILE L _Pibia® Piva? _ P*( fea 0 >6, Then 9, -¢, ‘+ Failure by slip (yielding) occurs when the maximum shearing stress, 1,., exceeds the yield stress z,a8 determined in a uniaxial tension test, ‘+ This theory gives satisfactory result for ductile material. Ls ee y Failure surface according to maximum shear stress theory 4, Strain Energy Theory (Haigh’s Theory) ‘The theory associated with Haigh ‘This cheory is based on the assumption that strains are recoverable up to the elastie limit, and the energy absorbed by the material at failure up to this point is a single valued function independent of the stress aystom causing it. The strain energy per unit volume eausing failure is equal to the strain energy atthe elastic limit in simple tension, 1 g, = ho? +02 +02 -2u(a,0, +040, +050,) |= Uns e[ai +0f +03 -2u (a0, +0,0, + 0,04)]= 5 0} +0} +03 ~2u (00. + 0405 +0,0,)= 07 For 3D- stress bP FeR=2jaey=e2 — For 2D-stross 5. Shear Strain Energy Theory (Distor Theory or Von-Misses Theory)-Ductil Von-Mises Criterion: n Energy Theory or Mises-Henky Material © Also known as the Maximum Energy of Distortion erterion + Based on a more complex view ofthe role SFORAPRALPal stress differences,Chapter-15 Theories of Failure SK Mondar's ‘© In simple terms, the von Mises criterion considers the diameters of all three Mohr’s circles as contributing to the characterization of yield onset in isotropic materials. ‘+ When the criterion is applied, its relationship to the uniaxial tensile yield strength is: n¥ +(0,—24) +(0,—,) = 205 + Fora state of plane stress (04 =0) of -0,0, +0 =07 + It is often convenient to express this as an equivalent stress, @« | 7 re llevan +004 rs) + (05 ora, 9,2 +, - 0, + (0, -oF +005, +73, +75) 1 #le. «in ralaing he ire theory we wid eralized Honk’ wr anionic stra s0 the theory given is only applicable to those materials but it can be generalized to aninirnie mater ‘= The von Mises theory is a little Tess conservative than the Tresca theory but in most eases there is little difference in their predictions of failure, Most experimental results tend to fall ‘on or between these two theories, + Tegives very good result in ductile material. oo Mines 6. Maximum Prin According to this theory al Strain Theory (St. Venant Theory) jelding will occur when the maximum prineipal strain just exceeds the train at the tentile yield peintin either simple taion or wonmpresdion. Fes anid ex dro maximum and sxinimum principal strains corresponding to; and o, a the Limiting case 1 4=2(,-v0;) — al2le: zlr-v2) eile} 2=2@-v) [6/216] This give Ex, =0)-v0 =t0y Ee) =0)-vo, Page 403 of 420Chapter-15 ‘Theories of Failure SK Mondal’s Yield surface corresponding to maximum principal strain theory 7. Mohr’s theory- Brittle Material Mohr's Theory Mobr's theory is used to predict the fracture of a material having different properties in tension and compression. Criterion makes use of Mohs circle In Mohr's circle, we note that. depends on o, or 7 = /(o). Note the vertical line PC represents states of stress on planes with same o but differing 7, which means the weakest plane is the one with maximum 7, point P. Points on the outer circlo are tho weakest planes. On these planes the maximum and ‘minimam principal stresses are sufficient to decide whether or not failure will cur. Experiments are done on a given material to determine the states of stress that result in failure, Each state defines a Mohr’s circle. If the data are obtained from simple tension, simple compression, and pure shear, the three resulting circles are adequate to construct an envelope (AB & A'B) Mobr's envelope thus represents the locus of all possible failure states, ie Plo.t) Failure envelope Higher shear stresses are to the left of origin, since most brittle materials have higher strength in compression 8. Comparison A-comparison among the different failure theories can be made by superposing the yield surfaces as shown in figure Page 404 of 420Chapter-15 Theories of Failure SK Mondar's Page 408 of 428Chapter-tS Theories of Failure SK Mondal’s OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Maximum Shear stress or Stress Difference Theory GATE-1, Match 4 correct pairs between list I and Li ions IGATE-19941 II for the que: List List-II (a) Hooke's law 1. Planetary motion (b) St. Venant’s law 2. Conservation Energy (©) Kepler's laws. 3. Elasticity (@) Tresca's eriterion 4. Plasticity (©) Coulomb's laws, 5. Fracture (9 Griffith's law 6. Inertia GATE-L, Ans. (a) -3, (3-1, (@)-5, (€)-2 Venant's law: Maximum principal strain theory GATE-2, Which theory of failure will you use for aluminium components under steady loading? IGATE-1999] (a) Principal stress theory () Principal strain theory (©) Strain energy theory (@) Maximum shear stress theory GATE-2, Ans. (d) Aluminium is a ductile material so use maximum shear stress theory Shear Strain Energy Theory (Distortion energy theory) GATE-8. According to Von-Mises' distortion energy theory, the distortion energy under three dimensional stress state is represented by IGATE-2006] 1 @ xgl0f +93 +03-a(e,0; +0302 +0403] 1-2) oa [oF +0} +03 +(0,02 +0307 +9;03)| Lovie 2a 8. to) Sof +08 +08 (aya, +030; +0395)] ll o2eo2+a? @ (2% +03 +03 - Wo,02 -0;02 +0495)] GATES. Ans. (@) =0,)° +(a2-03)' +(0-0,)'} Where E = 2G(1+ 1) simplifyand getresult GATE-4. 1 section of a component is in a bi-axial state of stres# with the two principal stresses being 360 MPa and 140 MPa, The ‘maximum working stress according to Distortion Energy Theory is: IGATE-1997] (@) 220 MPa () 110 MPa (314 MPa (@) 330 MPa GATE-4. Ans, (¢) According to distortion energy theory if maximum stress (0) then or = 960* + 140* 360.140 ora, =314 MPa Page 40s of 428Theories of Failure Previous 20-Years IES Questions Chapter-15 SK Mondar's Maximum Principal Stress Theory MES-1, Match List (Theory of Failure) with List-ll (Predicted Ratio of Shear Strew to Dinect Stross at Vield Condition for Steel Speclmen) and select the correct answer using the code given below the Lists: [ES-2006] ict Listtt 1 Mximam shear sro theory Lio Maximum dtrtion entre Choory Losi . Masinam prised set theory howe D.Macimom prncpa stain fear 050 Code Be a Be bp @ 7 2 4 3 @ 4 3 1 3 o 1 i 2 @® t 24 TES-1. Ans. (d) 1ES.2, From a tension test, the yield strength of atcel is found to be 200 Nim. Using taster of eafety o€ und applying sax-innin principal stress theory of falas, the permissible stress in the steel shaft subjected to torque will be: _ [TES-2000] ON WET Ninae 860. Nima 100 Nim 1ES-2, Ans (@) For pute shear r=, TES2, A cirowlar solid shaft iv subjected to a bending moment of 400 kN and « {wisting moment of 200 LNew On the basis of the muriommn principal stress theory. the direct stress no and according to the maximum shenr stress theory, the shear stress is r. The ratio of r is: [LES-2000} 1 3 9 u 5 3 (02 Oe esa, Ans (0) 0= 29 (Ma dAPaT?) and r= 18 (iP) a _MsVMaT _ 44 eee 8 Therefore Z t WMT eae 5 TES-4. A transmission shaft subjected to bending loads must be designed on the basis of, [ES-1996} (a) Maximum normal stress theory (b) Maximum shear stress theory (©) Maximum normal stress and maximum shear stress theories (@) Fatigue strongth IBS-4. Ans. (a) TES.5. Design of shafts made of brittle materials is based on [ES-1993] (a) Guest's thoory (b) Rankine’s thoory (@) St. Venant’s theory (d) Von Mises theory TES.5. Ans. (b) Rankine's theory or maximum principle stress theory is most commonly used for brittle materials, Maximum Shear stress or Stress Difference Theory IES.6, Which one of the following figures represents the maximum shear stress theory or Tresea eriterion? IES-1999] @ Sem (6) oy, ov, age set AS ly (a) 21Chapter-15 ‘Theories of Failure SK Mondal’s TES-6. Ans. (b) TES7. According to the maximum shear stress theory of failure, permis [ES-1998: ISRO-2008] wr wT oF @ar IES-7. Ans. (d) Given r= s “F Principalstresses for only this shear stress are oe +r maximum principal stress theory of failure gives, 16(2T) maxfe,.a,]= 0, = ae TESS. Permissible bending moment ii ‘cular shaft under pure bending is M according to maximum principal stress theory of failure. According to maximum shear stress theory of failure, the permissible bending moment in the same shaft is [IES-1995] (@ 12M. o)M @v2M @ 2M 1858.ans. 0) 0-28 (Wea SP) and c= 18 AF =P) pur r=0 ae ad 32M 32M 46M oy _ (nd?) _ 16M and r “SS ThereforeM' =M ne 2” 2 ae ae TES-9. A rod having cross-sectional area 100 x 10°* m* is subjected to a tensile load. Based on the Tresca failure criterion, if the uniaxial yield stress of the material is 200 MPa, the failure load is: UES-2001] (@) 10KN (b) 20 kN (©) 100 kN (@) 200 kN TES-9. Ans. (b) Tresca failure criterion is maximum shear stress theory. Po ‘Weknowthat,r = OFF = 5R =e OF P A IFS.10. A cold roller steel shaft is designed on the basis of maximum shear stress theory. The principal stresses induced at its critical section are 60 MPa and - 60 MPa respectively. If the yield stress for the shaft material is 360 MPa, the factor of safety of the design is: [ES-2002] @2 3 4 @6 TES.10, Ans. (b) IES.11, A shaft is subjected to a maximum bending stress of 80 Nimm! and maximum shearing stress equal to 30 N/mm* at a particular section. If the yield point in tension of the material is 280 N/mm, and the maximum shear stress theory of failure is used, then the factor of safety obtained will be: TIES-1994] @25 28 (a0 @ss TRS. Ans.) Masimu hearse =f SON/mm? ¢, According to maximum shear stress theory,r = 2. 2a 2 2x50 TES12, For a two-dimensional state stress (a, > 0,0) > 0,0, <0) the designed values are mort conservative ifwhich one ofthe following failure theorla were used? ties 9) (a)Aasimum principal strain theory () Maxam distortion ener theory (O)Marimam heer sts theor” py, Magjoam prince res Yaory TES-12. Ans. (c) Peo staChapter-15 Theories of Failure SK Mondar's ‘Maxinnm principal strain theory ‘Maxinum shear stress theory ‘Maxinuum principal stress theory Graphical comparison of different failure theories Above diagram shows that ¢;>0,0, Tresea ‘Maximum principal stress theory > Rankine ‘Maximum principal strain theory > St. Venant ‘Maximum shear strain energy theory > Mises Henky IES-15. The maximum distortion energy theory of failure is suitable to predict the failure of which one of the following types of materi [ES-2004} (@) Brittle materiale (b) Ductile materials (¢) Plastics (@) Composite materials IBS-15. Ans. (b) IES.16. If 9, is the yield strength of a particular material, then the distortion energy theory is expressed as [TES-1994] (@) (o,-0;)' +(0;-0,) +(a,-0, & (6) -03 +03) -24o\0, + 0,0, +00) (0 (0-2, +(a,-5)' +(a-@ @ (1-2n)(0, +0, +0,)' =2(1+2) TES-16. Ans. (a) IES-17. Ifa shaft made from ductile material is twisting moments, calculations based on which one of the following failure theories would give the most conservative value? HES-1996] (a) Maximum principal stress theory (b) Maximum shear stress theory (@ Maximum strain energy theory (@) Maximum distortion energy theory TES-17. Ans. (b) Page 409 of 428Chapter-15 Theories of Failure SK Mondal’s ‘Maxinnm principal strain theory | anim distortion eneray theory v Maxum shear stress theory ‘Maxinum principal stress theory “ ge Maximum Principal Strain Theory TES.18. Match List-I (Failure theories) with List-II (Figures representing boundaries of these theories) and select the correct answer using the codes given below the Lists: TES-1997] List List-1 A Maximum principal stress 2 theory 1 e; LE B. Maximum shear stress theory a _ C. Maximum. octahedral stress theory D. Maximum shear strain energy theory 3 Code: A BoC D Bc D @ 2 1 8 4 4 3 1 © 4 2 3 @ 11 TES-18. Ans. (d) Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Maximum Principal Stress Theory TAS. For 0, #0, and os = 0, what is the physical boundary for Rankine failure theory? [AS-2004] (a) Arectangle —_ (b) Anellipse (©) Asquare (@)A parabola Page 4100428Chapter-15 Theories of Failure SK Mondar's TAS-1. Ans. (c) Rankine failure theory or ‘Maximum principle stress theory Shear Strain Energy Theory (Distortion energy theory) IAS2, Consider the following statements: TAs.20071 1. Experiments have shown that the distortion-energy theory gives an accurate prediction about failure of a ductile component than any other theory of failure. 2 According to the distortion-energy theory, the yield strength in shear is less than the yield strength in tension. Which of the statements given above is/are correct? (a) Lonly (b) 2 only (©) Both 1 and 2 (@ Neither 1 nor 2 °, 1AS2. Ans. (e) 1, = iB IAS3. Consider the following statements: [AS-2003} 1. Distortion-energy theory is in better agreement for predicting the failure of ductile materials. 2, Maximum normal stress theory gives good predi brittle materials. 3. Module of elasticity in tension and compression are assumed to be different stress analysis of curved beams. Which of these statements islare correct? =0.5770, m for the failure of (a) 1, 2and3 () Land 2 (©) Boaly @ Lands TAS-8, Ans. (b) IAS-4. Which one of the following graphs represents Mises yield criterion? [JAS- 1996] @ 3) IAS-4, Ans. (@) Maximum Principal Strain Theory TAS.5. Given that the principal stresses o>, >, and o: is the elastic limit stress in simple tension; which one of the following must be satisfied such that the clastic failure does not occur in accordance with the maximum principal strain theory? TIAS-2004] @ Ze. Page 411 of 428Chapter-15 ‘Theories of Failure SK Mondal’s @ S>( Bp Bey OE ETE HE JAS.5. Ans. (b) Strain at yield point>principal strain Page 4120428Chapter-15 Theories of Failure ‘SK Mondal's Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question ESE-2010 @ Ans. 0 Gi) ai, ww) The stress state at a point in a body 6, =60N/mm* & o, =-36N/ mm’ If the allowable stress for the material in simple tension or compression is 100 Nimm¥ calculate the value of factor of safety with each of the following criteria for failure (@ Max Stress Criteria Gi) Max Shear Stross Criteria Gi) Max strain criteria Gv) Max Distortion energy eriteria [10 Marks] plane with ‘The stress at a point in a body is plane ¢,=60 N/mm? a, = -36 N/mm? Allowable stress for the material in simple tension or compression is 100, Nim? Find out factor of safety for Maximum stress Criteria : - In this failure point occurs when max principal stress teaches the limiting strength of material ‘Therefore. Let F'S factor of safety ¢ (allowable) * FS Ans. ‘Maximum Shear stress criteria : - According to this failure point occurs at a point in a ‘member when maximum shear stress reaches to shear at yield point 100 N/mm* _ 8-5 6036 98 48 N/m FS=1.042 Ans. Maximum Strain Criteria ! - In this failure point occurs at a point in a member when ‘maximum strain in a bi ~ axial stress system reaches the limiting value of strain (.e strain at yield point) of tot —3y0,0, ={ Telbmatte i a a ( FOS J FOS=1.27 (u=0.3assume) ‘Maximum Distortion energy criteria !~ In this failure point oceurs at a point in a ‘member when distortion strain energy per unit volume in a bi—axial system reaches the limiting distortion strain energy at the of yield Page 413 of 420Chapter-15 67 +63-9, x0, 60° + (36)" ~»60%-96-( ‘Theories of Failure SK Mondal’s FS=119 Conventional Question ESE-2006 Question: Answer: A mild steel shaft of 0 mm diameter is subjected to a beading moment of 1.5 Nm and torque T. If the yield point of steel in tension is 210 MPa, find the maximum value of the torque without causing yielding of the shaft material according to @ Maximum principal stress theory Gi) Maximum shear stress theory. 32M We know that, Maximum bending stress (c,) 167 aa? and Maximum shear stress (7) Principal stresses are given by a, fa), 18 — Oya = Sh [3] + = [weer] (i) According to Maximum principal stress theory Maximum principal sress=Maximum stress at elastic limit ( or a2 a oF] =2t0x0" oe 1915004 SOFT |= 210.108 (0.050) or T = 3332 Nm = 3.332 KNm (i) According to Maximum shear stress theory a=, _9, or, 0 = on, 2 SSF = 210510" or, T= 2086 m= 2086 kn Conventional Question ESE-2005 Question: Answer: Illustrate the graphical comparison of following theories of failures for two- dimensional stress system: @ Maximum normal stress theory Gi) Maximum shear stress theory (iii) Distortion energy theory Page 414 01429Chapter-15 Theories of Failure SK Mondar's (+ Maximum distortion energy theory Maximum shear stress theory ‘Maximum principal stress theory Conventional Question ESE-2004 Question Answer: Conv Question: Answer: State the Von- Mises's theory. Also give the naturally expression. ‘According to this theory yielding woul! cecur when total distortion energy absorbed ‘er unit aime’ Yue bpplid loads excoous the dtoriia eaargy charted per wait olume at th teil yield point. The fire criterion ia (,~2)' + (02-3) +(03—8,)" = 20% [symbols has usual meaning] tional Question ESE-2002 Derive an expression for the distortion energy per unit volume for a body subjected to a uniform stress state, given by the ,and, with the third principal stress 0, being zero. According to this theory yielding would occur when total distortion energy absorbed per unit volume due to applied loads exceeds the distortion energy absorbed per unit volume at the tensile yield point. Total strain energy Er and strain energy for volume change By can be given as Ee $(o8, +28 +058) and Ey = 20, ‘Substituting strains in terms of stresses the distortion energy can be given as 20+v) Ey= Er Ey = “EM (o,240,' +05"—o40)-0:0~050)) At ths tonal yield point, =o, 0: = 01= 0 which pres 2d+v. B, 209? “! 6E ‘The failure criterion is thus obtained by equating Fa and Fa, , which gives 2 2 2 (o,-62)' +(0,-03)° +(03-0) =20, Ina 2D situation ifo 0, the criterion reduces to 6 +6," — 0,5, =6,” Conventional Question GATE-1996 Question: Answer: ‘A cube of 5mm side is loaded as shown in figure below. (Determine the principal stresses 0,,0;,03- (ii) Will the cube yield if the yield strength of the mater Von-Mises theory. aguante Yield strength of the material o_ = 70 MPa = 7 5 70 MPa? Use (0 MNim? or 70 Nimm?Chapter-15 ‘Theories of Failure SK Mondal’s 1000N *—5 mm —1 ()Principal stress 0, [us = 60+ (20) +(32) =97.74, 22.26 97.74Nimm*, or 97.74 MPa and a, =22.96N/mm? or 22.96 MPa oy = 0, =20Nimm? or 22 MPa (ii) Will the cube yieldornot? According to Von-Mises yield criteria, yielding will occur if (oon) +(02-05)' +(05 04)" 220% Now — (a,~0,) +(0;-03) +(0.-04)° (97.74 ~ 22.96) + (22.96 -20}' + (20-97.74)* 1745.8 -(i) and, 203, = 2x(70)' = 9800 —(ii) Since 11745.8 > 9800 so yielding will occur. Conventional Question GATE-1995 Question: A thin-walled circular tube of walll thickness t and mean radius r is subjected to an axial load P and torque T in a combined tension-torsion experiment. (@) Determine the state of stress existing in the tube in terms of P and T. ii) Using Von-Mises - Henky failure criteria show that failure takes place oF £37 =04, where o, is the yield stress in uniaxial tension, @ and 7 are respectively the axial and torsional stresses in the tube. when Answer: — Mean radius of the tul Wall thickness of the tub Axial load = P, and aso Neen Page 416 of 420 (The state of stress in the tube:Chapter-15 Theories of Failure SK Mondar's ‘Duo to axial load, the axial stress in the tube ox Due to torque, shear stress, Tr Tr J 2st {r +t} 2 » The state of stress in the tube is, o, Gi) Von Mises-Henky failure in tension for 2-dimensional stress is =0i +03 -a0 Conventional Question GATE-1994 Question: Find the maximum principal stress developed in a cylindrical shaft. 8 em in diameter and subjected to a bending moment of 2.5 kNm and a twisting moment of 42 kNm. If the yield stress of the shaft material is 300 MPa. Determine the factor of safety of the shaft according to the maximum shearing stress theory of failure. Answer: Given: d= 8 cm = 0,08 m; M= 2.5 kN =300 MPa = 300 MNim? Equivalent torque, T, = VM? +T? = (2.5) + (4.2) =4.888kNm Maximum shear stress developed in the shaft, AGT _ 16% 4.88810" ad x(0.08)" 300 = 1604MNI? = 2500 Nm; T= 4.2 kNm = 4200 Nm Css (ye x10°* MNim? = 48.62MNim? Permissible shear stress Face of sey = 250,285Chapter-15 Theories of Failure SK Mondal’s Page 418 0f428Page 419 of 420Riveted and Welded Joint Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) Types of Rivets FIGURE DESCRIPTION > LARGE BUTTON HEAD a NARROW BUTTON HEAD <= NARROW BUTTON HEAD BUTTON HEAD WITH SPLINED SHANK ES LARGE BUTTON HEAD =s- CCOUNTERSUNK HEAD = FLATHEAD THIN NARROW BUTTON HEAD, SEMITUBULAR COUNTERSUNK FLAT HEAD, SEMITUBLLAR, FLAT HEAD, SEMITUBULAR Page 4200f428Chapter-16 Riveted and Welded Joint SK Mondar's FLATHEAD SEMITUBULAR, SHOULDER FLAT HEAD, TUBULAR, FLAT HEAD, TUBULAR, FLAT HEAD THREADED, TUBULAR, DouTy FLAT HEAD, CLOSED END, ‘THREADED TUBULAR HEXAGON FIGURE DESCRIPTION HEXAGON THREADED FLAT HEAD HEXAGON CLOSE END THREADED FLAT HEAD RIVETS ‘THREADED HEXAGON FOR ‘AUTOMATED ASSEMBLY ‘SQUARE THREADED FLAT HEAD Peuuo BUTTON HEAD, TAPING Page 421 of 420Chapter-16 Riveted and Welded Joint SK Mondal’s OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Failure of riveted joint GATE-1, Bolts in the flanged end of pressure vessel are usually pre-tonsioned Indicate which of the following statements is NOT TRUE? IGATE-1999] (a) Prestensioning helps to seal the pressure vessel (b) Pre-tensioning increases the fatigue life of the bolts (©) Pro-tensioning reduces the maximum tensile stress in the bolts (@ Pre-tensioning helps to reduce the effect of pressure pulsations in the pressure vessel GATE-L, Ans. (e) Statement for Linked Answers and Questions Q2 and Q3 A steel bar of 10 x 50 mm is cantilevered with two M12 bolts (P and Q) to support a static load of 4 KN as shown in the figure. 100:_400 100) — « 17m Gf ie) LT 4kN GATE-2, The primary and secondary shear loads on bolt P, respectively, are: IGATE-2008] (8) 2kN, 20 kN (B)20 kN, 2kN (© 20kN 08 () OkN, 20 kN GATE-2. Ans, (a) Primary (Direct) Shear load = ay =2kN GATE. The resultant stress on bolt P is closest to IGATE-2008] (9) 182 MPa (8) 159 MPa (© 178MPa (0) 195 MPa GATE-s. Ans. (b) GATE-4, A bolted joint is shown below. The maximum shear stress, in MPa, in the bolts at A and B, respectively ar IGATE-2007] Page 422 0f 429Chapter-16 Riveted and Welded Joint SK Mondar's 3 holes of M10 x 1.75 mm bolts — {all dimensions in the figure are in mm) @) 202.6, (6) 425.5, 242.6 ©4258, 425 (@) 242.6, 2126 GATE-4, Ans. (a) GATE-5. A bracket (shown in figure) is rigidly mounted on wall using four rivets. Each rivet is 6 mm in diameter and has an effective length of 12mm. [GATE-2010] je— 32 —sfe— 32 —5} be 12- 14 — 401412 1 Direct shear stress (in MPa) in the most heavily loaded rivet is: (aaa ss 176 @a52 GATE-5. Ans. (b) 1000, F_ 250 Fa =250N and = =8.8MPa Efficiency of a riveted joint GATE-6, If the ratio of the diameter of rivet hole to the pitch of rivets is 0.25, then the tearing efficiency of the joint is: [GATE-1996] (a) 0.50 (b) 0.75 (©) 0.25 (@) 0.87, GATE-6. Ans. (b) Page 4230428Chapter-16 Riveted and Welded Joint SK Mondal’s GATE-7. 4 _., f, «150 MPa p 7 028 P-d wee (QD) = 75% A manufacturer of rivets claims that the failure load in shear of his product is 500 + 25 N. This specification implies that IGATE-1992] (a) No rivet is weaker than 475 N and stronger than 525 N (b) The standard deviation of strength of random sample of rivets is 25 N (©) There is an equal probability of failure strength to be either 475 Nor 525 N (@ There is approximately two-tone chance that the strength of a rivet lies between (75N to.525.N GATE-7. Ans, (a) Previous 20-Years IES Questions Failure of riveted joint TEs. TES. Ans. (b) IEs2, An eccentrically loaded riveted joint is shown with 4 rivets at P, Q, Rand 5. Which of ‘the rivets are the most loaded? (a) P and Q () Qand R (Rand (@ Sand P [ES-2002] A riveted joint has been designed to support an eccentric load P. The load generates value of F; equal to 4 KN and Fs equal to 3 KN. The cross-sectional area of each rivet is 500 mm Consider the following statements: 1. The stress in the rivet is 10 N/mm* 2. The value of eccentricity L is 100 mm 3. The value of load P is 6 kN 4. The resultant force in each rivet is 6 KN Which of these statements are correct? (a) Vand 2 (b)2and 3 (3 and 4 (@) Land 3 ES-2003] TES.2. Ans. (€) Page 424 0f 429Chapter-16 Riveted and Welded Joint SK Mondar's IES3, P=2F,=2x3=6KN Fy Pp and PL= Fl + Fl=2 FI or 6L = 2x 41 = 81 L_& or 255 16 Resultant force on rivet, R=/F, = ¥(4) +3) +2x4x3cos0 =5kN ¢. Shearstresson rivet, R__ 5x10 =10 Nimm? plates of joint through a pin an shown in. the given figure is 200 MPa, then the width w will be @) 15mm 0) 18 mm (920mm @ 25mm [TES-1999] IBS-3, Ans. (a) (w ~ 10) x 2 x 10%% 200 x 10*= 2000 N; or w= 15 mm. IES-4, For the bracket bolted as shown in the figure, the bolts will develop (a) Primary tensile stresses and secondary shear stresses (b) Primary shear stresses and secondary shear stresses (© Primary shear stresses and secondary tensile strosses (@ Primary tensile stresses and secondary compressive stresses [ES-2000] IBS-4, Ans. (a) TESS. Assertion (A): In pre-loaded bolted joints, there is a tendeney for failure to ‘occur in the gross plate section rather than through holes. [TES-2000] Reason (R): The effect of pre-loading is to create sufficient friction between the assembled parts so that no slippage occurs. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually tgue but Ris NOT the correct explanation of A. (© Aistrne but Ris false Page 425 01 428 (@) Ais false but Ris trueChapter-16 Riveted and Welded Joint SK Mondal’s TES-5. Ans. (a) IES6. ‘Two rigid plates are clamped by means of bolt and nut with an initial force N. After tightening, a separating force P (P < N) is applied to the lower plate, which in turn acts on nut, The tension in the bolt after this is: [ES-1996} (+P) NP) oP @n IES-6. Ans. (a) Efficiency of a riveted joint TES7. Which one of the following structural joints with 10 rivets and same size of plate and material will be the most efficient? [ES-1994] IES-7. Ans. (b) IES-8. ‘The most efficient riveted joint possible is one which would be as strong in tension, shear and bearing as the original plates to be joined. But this can never be achieved beeause: [1ES-1993] (a) Rivets cannot be made with the same material (b) Rivets are weak in compression (@) There should be at least one hole in the plate redueing its strength (@ Clearance is present between the plate and the rivet TES-8. Ans. (c) Riveted joint can't be as strong as original plates, because there should be at least ‘one hole in the plate redueing its strength. Advantages and disadvantages of welded joints IES-9, Assertion (A): In a boiler shell with riveted construction, the longitudinal seam is, jointed by butt joint. [ES-2001] Reason (R): A butt joint is stronger than a lap joint in a riveted construction. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (©) Ais true but R is false (@) Ais false but R is true TES-9. Ans. (c) Page 426 0f428Chapter-16 Riveted and Welded Joint SK Monda's Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Failure of riveted joint 1AS-1, Two identical planks of Pitch distance wood are connected by 20cm bolts at a pitch distance of 20 em The beam is subjected to a bending See gala ae fiom ee eae tone J (a) Zero () 0.1 kN aaa Sorin Boks je msse0n IAS-1. Ans. (a) TAS-2. with List-II and select the correct answer using the code given below the Lists: {LAS-2007] Sint "aca (Sites Lenton) cent teleasen Lenses) Seta Sete bce ring under ait ad zener Sa nr ee eee 5 a nee aoe 2 SP we FF FS O33 4 7 84 t 3 3 IAS-2. Ans. (c) Page 427 of 428Chapter-16 Riveted and Welded Joint SK Mondar's Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question GATE-1994 Quest Answer: ‘The longitudinal joint of a thin cylindrical pressure vessel, 6 m internal diameter and 16 mm plate thickness, is double riveted lap point with no staggering between the rows. The rivets are of 20 mm nominal (diameter with a pitch of 72 mm, What is the efficiency of the joint and what would be the safe pressure inside the vessel? Allowable stresses for the plate and rivet materials are; 145 MNim? in shear and 230 MN/m? in bearing. Take rivet hole diameter as 1.5 mm more than the rivet diameter. Given; Diameter of rivet = 20 mm Diameter the pressure vest, Thickness ofthe plate, t= 16 mm ‘Type of the joint: Double riveted lap joint Allowable stresses ISMN Im"; 1 =120MN Imn":o, = 280.MN/ m* 72-(2«215)]_ 16 Strength of plate in tearing/piteh, R =| —E**9)), 18 45 ‘ath ot teh [ 1000 |" 1000 = 0.06728 MN = (20) trength of rivert in tearinglpiteh,2, = 2x" x «120 " oe 1 (eos) = 0.0754 MN 20 16 Strength of plate in erushing/piteh,2, =2{ 2. 18 \..230 ‘ath ot wich R, (seas 1000. = 0.1472 MN From the above three modes of failure it can be seen that the weakest element is the plate as it will have tear failure at 0.06728 MNipitch load itself, Stresses acting on the plate for an inside pressure of pN/m? is shown in figure. pd px6 * Hoop stress = 22 - _P*6 __ 87.55 ° 2 2x(0.016) " 6 Longitudinal stress —P*6_soa75p “4 45(0.016) " ‘Maximum principal stress acting on the plate only (e187 p)as there is no choar stross, or 1875p s 9.06728 _—_ (0.016) (ors) [ 1000 or 50.7733 MN /m* or 0.7733 MPa 28.1429 nowt 0.0678 4688 pea, ~ (0.072) (0.016) x11Chapter-18 Riveted and Welded Joint SK Mondar's Conventional Question GATE-1995 Question: Answer: Determine the shaft diameter and bolt size for a marine flange-coupling transmitting 3.75 MW at 150 r.p.m. The allowable shear stress in the shaft and bolts may be taken as 50 MPa. The number of bolts may be taken as 10 and bolt pitch circle diameter as 1.6 times the shaft diameter. Given, P= 3.75MW; N= 150r-p.m; 125 =50MPa; | n=10, D,=16D Shaft diameter, D pa2eN? 60 Also, or 238732 = 50 «10° x pt 6 29879216 D=[238782x16) _ 928m or 290 mm. (Gass) Bolt sized, Bolt pitch citvle diameter, D, =1.6D 6x0.29=0.464m Now oe sae7a2~10<£d «50.40? . dy #00512 m or 512mm Page 429 of 428