Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Humanizing The Deities of Jazz: by Scott Jeppesen
Humanizing The Deities of Jazz: by Scott Jeppesen
I
am guilty. I have adorned the walls of my notables? Can my art ever be deemed wor-
home studio with framed images of John thy while residing under the shadow cast by context in which
Coltrane, Wayne Shorter, Charles Mingus,
Clifford Brown, and Miles Davis. Over my
such heroes? Sadly, it is not rare to encoun-
ter aspiring jazz musicians incapable of
jazz was created
computer desk, Art Kane’s famous photo- accepting compliments on performance due and continues to be
graph “A Great Day in Harlem” is promi- to a constant feeling of inadequacy due to
nently displayed like an altar to those I hold comparisons of their imposition. It is by no enjoyed.
most dear. Admiration for those who have accident that to this point I have avoided
contributed to your field is entirely reason- using the term people. These musical icons
able. However, particularly in the arts, we are in fact ordinary people. Brilliant, hard-
maintain an obsessive and almost religious working, and often flawed, lack of context
infatuation with our idols. Our admira- of their achievements have dehumanized
tion can be devastatingly heavy, crushing them to the extent that we view them as so
us under the weight of ambition and envy much more. Instantiation of context to their
while driven by the presence of the giants tales not only shows younger musicians that
of our art. How can one ever hope to achievement is the result of hard work and
gain membership in the fraternity of such dedication but can also lead them down a
NAfME is glad to offer one hour of professional development recognition to you for reading this article.
Please follow the link below and complete a short quiz to receive your certificate of completion.
http://bit.ly/DeitiesOfJazz
www.nafme.org 57
path of exploration and discovery in an musicians: Lester Young (“Prez”), Wil- considered by many to be the father
art form that is much deeper than the liam “Count” Basie, Benny Goodman of modern jazz, received extreme rev-
rabbit hole initially suggests. (“the King of Swing”), Paul Whiteman erence in the eyes of poets. “Humbled
(“the King of Jazz”), Thelonious Monk by Parker’s mythic legacy,” poets would
Always a Bigger Fish (“the High Priest”), Joe (“King”) Oliver, “praise him with embarrassingly hagi-
and Ella Fitzgerald (“the First Lady of ographic detail, equating him to Christ,
During the summer of 1997, I received Song”). While these nicknames were Buddha, and other gods and saints.”4
Joe Henderson’s phone number from a used during their lives, they only contrib- Throughout their lives and particu-
good friend. Henderson had long been ute further to posthumous deification. larly posthumously, these artists have
my hero, and I was thrilled at the pros- Edward (“Duke”) Ellington holds a become less and less human in our eyes.
pect of potentially studying with him. I well-deserved place in the jazz lineage.
dialed the number and listened to the Perhaps the most important composer Adding Context
ring. I found myself secretly hoping that in the history of jazz, Ellington had his
he would not answer—he did not. “This idols. Duke spent his early years idol- It is understandable that aspiring musi-
is Mr. J.—leave a message,” I heard. Both izing James P. Johnson. Ellington is cians view their idols with such admira-
deflated and relieved, I could not bring known to have spent countless hours tion. They are our idols because their
myself to leave a message. After all, why at a player piano allowing his fingers to music touches us in a way that others’
would Joe Henderson ever call me back? follow those of Johnson while perform- does not. Their influences combine
Several times I called, until one day as I ing “Carolina Shout.”2 within each of us to form unique individ-
was expecting to hear the usual message ual artistic styles.5 However, the music
prompt, he answered. While I am usu- created by our heroes was not done so
ally confident when speaking with oth- We can help establish a clearer in a vacuum but within a larger social
ers, I found myself stumbling over my historical picture by discussing and cultural context. By understanding
words. I was utterly starstruck. Hender- the roles that class, race, and the extramusical world in which they
son was kind and supportive. He coun- gender have played in the lived, we can better understand how
seled me not to be embarrassed about those influences have imprinted them-
development of jazz music.
being a fan of his playing and recounted selves on the musicians we revere.
how in his youth he “didn’t want to play Influences in jazz come from many
like Prez, he wanted to be Prez.” He places. From its early roots in slave spir-
recalled going so far as to don Lester’s I mentioned earlier the prominent ituals and work songs to the influence
trademark porkpie hat. It was stunning placement of “A Great Day in Harlem” of music from Cuba and South Amer-
to me to come to the realization that on my wall. This photo became a central ica and eventually classical music, jazz
even my hero understood the feeling of plot point of the 2004 film The Terminal, has thrived because of its vast array of
idolizing another and acted as though starring Tom Hanks. In the movie, Hanks sources. These sources exist in both cul-
wearing a hat would make them peers. plays an immigrant trapped in New tural and political forms. While single
In his autobiography, Miles Davis York’s John F. Kennedy airport termi- events may not cause the creation of
admits taking drugs at the age of twenty nal while attempting to visit a jazz club a new style, music or societal changes
because “the idea was going round that to obtain an autograph from one of the can positively reflect one another.6 For
to use heroin might make you play as participants in the photo—saxophon- example, while a music style may be
great as Bird.”1 Miles pursued poten- ist Benny Golson. Interviewed for John created independently of cultural hap-
tially devastating activities in his pur- Coltrane’s biography, Golson recalls, “I penings, that style may catch on or
suit of reaching the heights that Charlie told [Dizzy Gillespie] how John [Col- gain in popularity due to extramusical
Parker was already occupying. He, trane] and I came to get his autograph, factors. In addition to thoughtful con-
like so many others after him, did not and he laughed years later. We didn’t sideration between music and cultural
see Parker as another struggling musi- think we would come to know him and framing, we must also provide context
cian but something greater. This need actually play with him and record with for musical events that are non–style
to reach the point of our idols can be him. If somebody told us then, we’d be specific. Tracing the music through the
inspiring, debilitating, or both. falling down on the floor.”3 slave trade from the Ivory Coast, through
As his career developed, Miles Further deification exists outside the Caribbean and South America, and
became known as “the Prince of Dark- the minds of jazz musicians. Praise and into America is essential to see where
ness.” Nicknames in jazz are far from discussion by writers, filmmakers, and and how some of the early aspects of
rare. Many of these nicknames bestow audiences add to the power of the leg- jazz originated. Observing the effects of
an air of importance and dominance. ends surrounding many jazz greats. Jazz the closure of Storyville by the US gov-
We find these authoritative nicknames musicians often played central roles in ernment and its influence on the migra-
among many of our most revered the poetry of the era. Charlie Parker, tion of musicians from New Orleans to
www.nafme.org 59
their music: (1) recordings, (2) photos, understand better the role that different artist influenced by another? Why or
(3) videos, (4) autobiographies, and artists, or instruments, played in perfor- why not?
(5) additional online resources. mances. For example, the class could Perhaps even more poignant than
listen to Ella Fitzgerald’s 1947 recording the action shots are the shots of musi-
of “Lover Man.” Teachers can instruct cians being regular people. The quiet
Listen
students to pay particular attention to before going on stage. The smile, or lack
Technological advancements are never bassist Ray Brown’s performance, lead- thereof, on an artist’s face when inter-
without controversy. We now have the ing to a discussion about the role of a acting with members of their audience.
ability to listen to almost any recording bassist in a jazz ensemble and the ways Count Basie and his band playing base-
ever made through Internet streaming in which he constructed bass lines. ball outside their bus to kill time before
services. While these services still need Additionally, teachers can note that a show. Louis Armstrong as a child was
to figure out a way to get musicians shortly after the recording, Fitzgerald entirely unaware that he would some-
adequately compensated for their work, and Brown were married. day become a celebrity. Teachers should
they provide an incredible resource to Online listening also empowers encourage discussion of these photo-
aspiring musicians and educators. No teachers to use technology to add addi- graphs surrounding not only the musi-
discussion about a figure in jazz his- tional interactive possibilities to their cians but also the venues and audiences.
tory should occur without some time classes. Using Spotify, teachers can Teachers can help to shed further light
spent listening to the recordings. After share interactive music playlists with on the context by leading discussions
all, that is the reason we are studying their students. Students can freely add about photos of the main jazz hubs in
them in the first place! Teachers should tracks to the playlist from home and America: New Orleans, New York, and
use these services not only to explore come prepared to discuss the tracks in Chicago. Examining pictures of these cit-
the iconic recordings of the jazz canon class or through writing assignments. ies during the Great Depression inspires
but also broaden the number of artists questions; for example, how did the
studied. Increasing the number of art- Depression affect musicians during the
ists that students are exposed to helps
The Value of a Picture 1930s? Exploring images of Chicago dur-
to improve context because the students Online resources allow the opportunity ing the 1920s can lead to a discussion
are allowed to see what more musicians to put a face to the music. Accessing of how prohibition may have affected
were doing during that era. For example, such treasures as the William P. Gott- the evolution of jazz. Where was jazz
studying the music of Louis Armstrong is lieb Collection at the Library of Congress mostly performed during this era? How
an unquestionably important part of an gives access to thousands of photo- was Prohibition related to the women’s
education in jazz history. However, to graphs of jazz luminaries. The photos suffrage movement?
gain a clear picture of jazz in the 1920s brilliantly capture musicians onstage, in Teachers can initiate a valuable les-
and 1930s, it is also necessary to explore practice, and candidly show them both son about race and class by examining
the music of Jelly Roll Morton, Kid Ory, professionally and personally. A simple photos of Harlem’s Cotton Club and
the Original Dixieland Jazz Band, Bes- search on Google Images will often the Savoy Ballroom. Only blocks apart,
sie Smith, and Jack Teagarden. Access return many valuable images of these the two clubs catered to different audi-
to a broader wealth of recorded history same artists. In addition to photos of ences. The Cotton Club, a segregated
facilitates this by providing the same musicians, using images that depict the establishment that featured bands such
collection of recordings to all teachers. cityscapes, clothing, clubs, dancing, and as Fletcher Henderson and Ellington,15
transportation of the time helps to paint attracted members of the upper class. In
a better picture of the environment that contrast, the Savoy had a “no discrimina-
Helping students learn why jazz framed the music and the artists. Pho- tion” policy, accepting members of all
happened helps foster greater tos portray musicians in situations rang- races, genders, and classes.16 How might
curiosity and the need to explore ing from the heat of live performance this distinction have affected the musi-
further . . . to candidly interacting with fans and cians that performed at each club?
colleagues. Performance photos can be
used by educators and students alike to
A Video Is Worth a Million
In addition to broadening the histori- examine instrument technique. Teach-
cal context of an artist study, educators ers may encourage their alto saxophone The next best thing to time travel,
can draw direct connections between students to compare and contrast the YouTube is full of videos taken of jazz
the records and performance prac- embouchures of Charlie Parker, Paul artists at work. It is increasingly easy
tices of their students. Teachers should Desmond, and Johnny Hodges. How to find videos of Charlie Parker, Duke
encourage their students to partake in may those differences have contributed Ellington, Miles Davis, and John Col-
directed and focused listening exercises. to their individual sounds? Is it possible trane performing live. Students can
Directed listening can help students to that any similarities found indicate one view and analyze the performances and
www.nafme.org 61
studies in improvisation, music literacy, 2. Terry Teachout, Duke (New York: tution/rare-footage-duke-ellington-high
composition, orchestration, arranging, Penguin, 2014), 97. lights-when-jazz-baseball-were-perfect-
3. Lewis Porter, John Coltrane: His Life and harmony-180950303/?no-ist.
and advanced technical skills on indi-
vidual instruments are all required to be Music (Ann Arbor: University of Michigan 12. Teachout, Duke, 25
Press, 1999), 36.
considered even moderately proficient. 13. Gene H. Anderson, The Original Hot Five
We spend exhaustive hours exploring the 4. Yusef Komunyakaa, Testimony: A Tribute
Recordings of Louis Armstrong (New
to Charlie Parker (Middletown, CT:
“how” and “what” aspects of jazz: chords, York: Pendragon, 2007), 155.
Wesleyan University Press), 61.
melodies, rhythms, substitutions. Some
5. Austin Kleon, Steal Like an Artist (New 14. Jeffrey E. Bush. “Bringing Music History
jazz musicians possess fanatical views of to Life,” Music Educators Journal, 86
York: Workman Publishing, 2012), 48.
jazz history. However, careful consider- (2000): 52
ations of the context in which history hap- 6. Brian Harker, “In Defense of Context
in Jazz History: A Response to Mark 15. Frank Tirro, Jazz: A History. 2nd ed.
pened allow us avenues to explore the
Gridley,” College Music Symposium 48 (New York: W. W. Norton & Company,
“why” aspect. Helping students learn why 1993), 221.
(2008): 158.
jazz happened helps foster greater curios-
ity and the need to explore further the vast 7. Nancy Brister, “Storyville and the Birth 16. Gioia, History of Jazz, 117.
lineage of jazz artists and styles.22 Find- of Jazz,” accessed February 12, 2016, 17. Cabin in the Sky, directed by Vincente
http://www.old-new-orleans.com/NO_ Minnelli (1943; Burbank, CA: Warner
ing out about where these musicians are
Storyville.html. Home Video, 2006), DVD.
from and who influenced them facilitates
humanizing these brilliant artists but also 8. Gunther Schuller, Early Jazz (New York: 18. Holly Farrington, “Narrating the
exposes students to new music within the Oxford University Press, 1968), 70. Jazz Life: Three Approaches to Jazz
jazz canon. Gaining this understanding 9. Ted Gioia, The History of Jazz (New York: Autobiography,” Popular Music and
fosters further curiosity and helps guide Oxford University Press, 2011), 66. Society 29 (2006): 376–77.
students to be more aware of their own Kindle edition. 19. Ibid., 377.
surroundings and how these can, in turn, 10. Dick Hyman, “Jazz Piano Roots:
20. Ibid., 380.
affect their artistic contributions. Thinking about the Lion,” Piano Today
29 (2009): 20–21. 21. Ibid., 383.
Notes 11. John Edward Hasse, “Rare Footage of 22. John Barron, “Lessons from the
Duke Ellington Highlights When Jazz Bandstand: Using Jazz as a Model for
1. Miles Davis and Quincy Troupe, Miles, and Baseball Were in Perfect Harmony,” a Constructivist Approach to Music
the Autobiography (London: Macmillan, accessed August 1, 2017, http://www Education,” Music Educators Journal 94
1997), 86. .smithsonianmag.com/smithsonian-insti (2007): 21.
Anderson, Gene H. The Original Hot Five Recordings of Louis Myers, Marc. Why Jazz Happened. Berkeley: University of
Armstrong. New York: Pendragon, 2007. California Press, 2013.
Berliner, Paul F. Thinking in Jazz: The Infinite Art of Improvisation. Porter, Lewis. John Coltrane: His Life and Music. Ann Arbor:
Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1994. University of Michigan Press, 1999.
Davis, Miles, and Quincy Troupe. Miles, the Autobiography. Schuller, Gunther. Early Jazz. New York: Oxford University Press,
London: Macmillan, 1997. 1968.
Gioia, Ted. The History of Jazz. New York: Oxford University Press, Schuller, Gunther. The Swing Era. New York: Oxford University
2011. Kindle edition. Press, 1989.
Harker, Brian. “In Defense of Context in Jazz History: A Response to Shapiro, Nat and Nat Hentoff. The Story of Jazz as Told by the Men
Mark Gridley.” College Music Symposium 48 (2008): 157–59. Who Made It: Talkin’ to Ya. New York: Dover Publications, Inc,
1955.
Kleon, Austin. Steal Like an Artist. New York: Workman Publishing,
2012. Teachout, Terry. Duke. New York: Penguin, 2014.
Komunyakaa, Yusef. Testimony: A Tribute to Charlie Parker. Tirro, Frank. Jazz: A History, 2d ed. New York: W. W. Norton & Co.,
Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press, 2002. 1993.
Barron, John. “Lessons from the Bandstand: Using Jazz as a Model for A History of Jazz Music. Great source of information organized by
a Constructivist Approach to Music Education.” Music Educators style and genre. Also includes links to historical information
Journal 94, no. 2 (2007): 18–21, http://search.proquest.com about rock and pop music history. http://www.scaruffi.com/
.libproxy2.usc.edu/docview/1109766?accountid=14749. history/jazz.html
Bush, Jeffrey E. “Bringing Music History to Life.” Music Educators The Jazz Education Network. Education network dedicated to
Journal 86, no. 6 (2000): 31, http://search.proquest.com building the jazz arts community. Contains great information
.libproxy2.usc .edu/docview/197184503?accountid=14749. on jazz education, history, and research. Sponsors annual Jazz
Education Network Conference. https://www.jazzednet.org/
Farrington, Holly E. “Narrating the Jazz Life: Three Approaches
to Jazz Autobiography.” Popular Music and Society 29, no. 3 Jazz History Online. Great collection of jazz history information.
(2006): 375–86. http://search.proquest.com.libproxy2.usc http://www.jazzhistoryonline.- com/
.edu/docview/208067907?accountid=14749.
LinkedJazz. Resource exploring connections between jazz
Hyman, Dick. “Jazz Piano Roots: Thinking about the Lion.” Piano musicians and other members of the jazz community. https://
Today 29, no. 1 (Winter 2009): 20–21. http://libproxy.usc.edu/ linkedjazz.org/
login?url=http://search.proquest.com.libproxy1.usc.edu/docview/
The Red Hot Jazz Archive. Great resource for important figures and
1469574?accountid=14749.
music in early jazz. http://www.redhotjazz.com/
www.nafme.org 63